Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu you so today's development I'm going to be go infancy towards adulthood next Thursday we'll talk about development after infancy to adulthood and over age and it's amazing think about babies and how do they get going and how two scientists discover from babies and young children how their minds are fundamentally different than adults and how your mind was fundamentally different than it is as an adult and so and then the last thing will be a dangerous experiment where my wife will come over with my two-year-old in my four-year-old and we'll try to do a developmental demonstration in front of you but I should warn you that live children uh have their own will so we'll see how that goes okay all right so one thing that people are struck by babies is that babies are cute okay and it's not just it's not yeah it is thought to be not just fun but kind of maybe a really important biological thing we talked about motherese before singsong talked to babies that helped them to learn language there's something about adults finding babies cute that makes them want to help babies okay parents and Friends I mean the cuteness is thought to be kind of an evolutionary you know reward for dealing with a baby so and then people have said well what is it it's a little bit different about a baby's face than an adult they have rounder heads they have foreheads that protrude more towards their sloped back more they have larger eyes proportionately smaller jaw bones proportionally and people use the term neoteny to describe this kind of infant proportions or properties of faces which are universal and of course a lot of people discover this in advertising or cartoons and so here's an interesting example of how Mickey Mouse has over the years from the original version of Mickey Mouse to the current super cute super tested super Disney a version of Mickey Mouse has become increasingly neo tonight and how much the cartoonists literally know that or just have kept saying you know what makes a cuter and cuter and cuter and ended up with a lot of the same proportions in Mickey else's face that make infants so cute and desirable you know we don't really know but but the world kind of feels this even adult research is a little funny line of research that says adults who look more baby-faced okay get treated a little bit different socially so I so here's a Leonardo DiCaprio and baby-faced adults and experiments are perceived as just by their faces as more naive more honest more helpless more kind more warm and more you know just people think this is going to be a nice warm person okay guessing from faces they're using the cues of neoteny other studies have found that people who are baby-faced are statistically more likely to be found innocent in cases of intentional wrongdoing okay so the whether whether they're trying to prove that somebody on purpose try to do something bad you go not that cute little person right but there's no difference if it's if it's cases involved negligence something we should have didn't something because we know babies aren't super responsible for how they behave right okay so it's kind of like defense on the on the on the and they're less likely to receive votes in elections okay so people we have won't even tell you this but people have done all kinds of analyses of faces that win elections in the US and around the world and there's two dimensions that people look for what looks like somebody's empathetic and what looks like somebody's competent alright so you want babies when it's fun but when you have to figure out how to balance the budget you know that doesn't seem like a baby task all right so it's kind of funny uh you know a lot of voters you know go by instinct as well as by sort of facts or stated values so in the development of infants into into adults the classic debates about how our mind grasps the world have played out yet again in a powerful way you know the nature nurture debate what's in our genes and gets us going what's acquired from the environment philosophers is that knowledge starts with innate or genetic or more evolved capacities other ones who've emphasized that we pick it up from the world empirically as measuring scientists serving so for example Aristotle wrote that nothing in the there's nothing in the select which was not first in the census that's the empirical view right it's out there in the world and you solve it and starting with a blank slate and in fact the behaviorists of course we're believed in this with a vengeance in psychology so Watson row give me a dozen healthy infants well-formed and my own specified world to bring them up and I'll guarantee to take any of them one at random and train him to become any type of specialist I might select a doctor lawyer artist merchant chief and yes even beggarman and thief that it's all the environment and a blank slate and who really knows but infants are born with some incredible things we'll talk about them today one of them is this experiment from Andy meltzoff which is this that it seems like within moments of birth infants are equipped with a desire to imitate adults a desire to imitate right and why people have been really impressed by this is if you have that in your genes and in your nature it's a good way to learn about the world is to imitate people you see around you right it's kind of a driving principle I'll imitate their language their social mores right okay so here's what here's what meltzoff did sticks out his tongue opens his mouth purses his lips and here's the infant one day old or a couple days old tongue out mouth open lips pursed okay now I should warn you about one thing these are the greatest hits' pieces of that research people debate about how perfectly this happens all right so I was frustrated with my infant came home and I did all the stuff and she would not instantly do everything she was supposed to do all right it's a statistical thing because you know when you see these pictures they're showing you the best moments they have to defend that it happens above chance statistically but it's not like every expression you make they copy you okay and that's why there's still some debate about exactly what's going on but they definitely on average imitate an adult within a day or two of birth for completely arbitrary as far as we think expressions so it's a very powerful mechanism for learning that appears to be in place because there's two ways we could imagine right genetically programmed learning one is that you know the content of it already but in other ways that you just have stuff that makes you a learner right so being an imitator is a general way to make you a learner without being very specific to the content so we talked a little bit about this already but you know psychologists are unbelievably brilliant I think I'm really blown away about how they can figure out what an infant knows and doesn't know or a young child knows or doesn't know and they do this indirectly by things like looking time and well you've seen this I'll give you an example or two and you'll see some more examples as a measure of what the baby knows or the young child knows and of course if they look longer at something it could be because they prefer it and also if it's a base on a memory task something like you saw something you see it again that would tell you there's some sort of discrimination they can tell things apart based on memory and then sometimes people will push this memory thing with habituation or familiarize ation so if you show something to a baby over and over and over again they get sort of tired of it and at that moment they'll change the stimulus and they'll see whether the baby gets newly attentive now if it's something that the baby doesn't grasp they won't get newly attentive you know nothing's changed in their mind if it's something the baby understands then you know they'll say wow something interesting is happening and they'll look longer so here's an example of you know baby getting bored because they're showing something over and over and something new okay that's the kind of things that people measure and they you know we're doing it loosely here they measure it pretty carefully I should tell you the people who do this kind of research they'll film it they'll show two unbiased people like you may be judges okay to say how long is the baby looking where is looking you don't know where the what the babies should be looking at or not so researchers take care to make it not just you know that you're convinced in your heart of hearts they're looking more they film it they show to people who don't know what's going on they try to make it a blind procedure in many ways the better research so how do we know things so even a very young infants look selectively at novel objects if something's new even at one day if you show them checker boards with different sized squares same size same size same size wait a couple of seconds smaller squares they look more that shows you they saw the difference in the squares they even remember somehow in their mind the difference between the squares because when you switch it start looking more something interesting has happened based on perception and memory another thing that we've mentioned I'll just remind you is that infants are almost from birth seem to love to control or provoke their environment so we already mentioned to you that 20 months old prefer a mobile that responds to their bodily movements they like things that they control if they take a two-month-old and they put a string on their wrist by which they can control a showing of Sesame Street you know they kind of like that and if you stops tesa me seat they can show anger on their face hey you know I was in charge here who has a remote control now right and four and five months old a little bit older I remain angry when the video comes back on because that's not what they wanted they wanted to control the presentation of the video right so infants said this apparent craving and to explore and feel like they have some control over their environment at an age when they don't control a lot because of their limited physical capacity in the first three or four months infants explore the world a lot by their mouths that's what people worry about to not leave around things like that they will put into their mouth and swallow that are dangerous okay because their visual and auditory systems and their system with their hand are slowly developing by five or six months around the world they start to explore with their hands and their eyes around them as their motor system gets more mature as your visual system gets great gains acuity and we already know that infants use social cues to guide exploration one of the big changes has happened in the last ten years I'd say in infant studies or child studies has been a lot of appreciation about the intersection between cognition and social interaction there used to be like two different worlds the people who studied language you know they would have algorithms and formulas about the language and then the social people who studied how babies were cute or something right but there's been more and more thought that a deep thing in us that helps cognition grow is the social relations that an infant is drawn to parents and caretakers so for example a six-month-old if their mother let's say roles or pounds a ball they tend to copy that in to imitate that action they follow the eyes of a person joint attention you know the windows the eyes are the windows on the soul we know eyes mean a lot where are people putting their ten what are they paying attention to infants pick up on this very early on and they if somebody looks over there they look over there if you look at them they know that your attention is focused on them and sometimes people will say you know because psychologists left to test everything is it just the way the head is turning so if you put a you know cover somebody's head they don't follow it anymore they know it has to be the eyes you know reflecting where the mind is putting his attention all right it's not the head direction it's the eyes here's something infants who are a little bit better at following eyes either maturing faster or something also learn language faster they get words faster and syntax faster it's as if part of that social interaction is helping to drive the language learning so that's how these social things and language things interact very substantially and we already said that a 12 month old will stop at a visual cliff but if the mother smiles there they go okay so constant learning that mixes in the cognitive and the social now the epic name in developmental psychology is Jean Piaget because prior to him roughly speaking in the science of child development people just thought children were sort of boring and dumb okay yeah it's like like they need a lot of attention you know please you know finish MIT so we can talk with you intelligently okay all right so so just people were not that interested you know partly as the world was different in so many ways there was no practically no formal psychology experimentation or thought about what really children's mental lives were like and Piaget I have a wrong year there 1886 developed the Kahn he himself was a child prodigy trained in biology very early interesting weather categories are in her heads or in the world tried poetry worked with Binet on intelligence testing became interested in patterns of errors than successes you'll see that in many ways what he discovered about how a child mind is different than yours fundamentally is based on the patterns of their errors and he said there's two basic things going on it's a huge idea one is a simulation that you incorporate new knowledge into existing cognitive structures it's basically ways you think about the world and new knowledge is added that's important but he thought the dramatic thing that happens in infancy and childhood is what he call adaptation that the fundamental ways in which you understand the world are shifted through development to accommodate new evidence so there's a wonderful book if you come across they called the scientist in the crib okay but it's kind of a pun it's written by scientists to study infants but the idea is that in a sense every infant is kind of his or her own scientist as you were probing the world and discovering the physical and social laws of the world okay because they don't know them coming in and they're going to pick up a lot of them and they're going to probe them you know but fail to publish the results okay so so he postulated that there was these big stages what he called the sensorimotor age zero to two where the world is one of what you see and the physical actions and there's not much representation of ideas or lasting thoughts and we'll see some examples of these between two and seven you start to be able to keep a thought in your mind you still have an egocentric perspective you see the world from your view but not appreciating the views of somebody else you start to use language a lot of flimsy a discussion about fantasy and reality I can tell you with my own daughter who you will meet she's still working out whether fairies really exist or not okay and this was chaotic as we went to some skating show where there was a where Tinkerbell was a human dancing and that totally made this situation very complicated right cuz you could tell a car okay alright so she's still working on that concrete you know as you get seven to eleven organized logical thought still concrete as opposed to sort of abstract and then you move to more adult-like cognition which we'll talk about next week so the idea is from birth to two years you know you would love to have an infinite just tell you what do I think the world is really like they have very modest language of course right so they can't tell you what they see so the thought is they have fleeting disconnected sensory impressions and motor reactions it's all at what do I see how am i responding that that their focus of thought is centered on actions not things or intentions and I'll show you that in a very concrete way there's no distinction there in mind between things that are stable in the world and transient events no distinction between themselves and the world around them it's all just one big sort of mush until they get to some more they can have abstract representations that separate these things out so so let's talk about object permanence that so I'm going to show you that you have object permanence just simply by saying here's my pointer I need a volunteer this is so easy that you will not feel scared I prom is it all right thank you very much so you see this where do you think it is now okay yeah if I was a really cool teacher who did magic you know it would be gone all right so uh but yes and you know it's there that's object permanence okay all right if you can if you turn your head you believe it's probably still there okay but now knowing that's going beyond the fundamentals of perception that's your knowledge and representing in your head there's something I don't see but I know it's there that is not available to a zero to two-year-old so for example if they see a rattle they feel a rattle but now if you if they look away or if you just put a sheet of paper in front of it I'll show you a couple of examples they behave as if the rattle no longer exists just like I did in front of you if you just cover it up it's gone as if it doesn't exist because their mind cannot represent what they do not see right in front of them so out of sight out of existence so you can show them a toy they love and until about eight months once you could do this and they go they start crying a protest but they won't reach for it even when it's easily within the reach out of sight out of mind it doesn't exist they can't represent in their mind what they don't see and then there's another one out you'll see I'll show you'll see a film of this but let me tell you this is this shows you about actions versus other things so imagine you hide a toy under one location the child searches there finds it you hide it again in the same location you know you encourage a child to search they find it they do it two or three times now in front of the child you take that same object that you've shown them like this several times it grabbed several times and you simply in front of them pick it up and put it over here and they're viewing everything in full view just like you did okay what do they do when it's there champ turn to grab they grab here the wrong place the place where they grab before because what's in their mind is the action they did not the object as an independent thing they can put in their mind as that makes answer and I'll show you I'll show you several pieces of this so it's called the aid not be effect I put this eh-eh-eh-eh in the front full of you put it over here and they reach over here to get it so this is this idea that they're in their head is not the toy their head is representing the thing on the right that reached for because they don't represent ideas of things they represent actions that they've done so here's object permanence here's a child you know sees a toy they like you put up in front of them this thing and tragically it's disappeared okay it's gone out of existence in the world and some people have done some sort of niors imaging suggesting the kids who sort of get past the stage are developing some frontal maturation but I think the most compelling things are the videos or the kids themselves so let me show you another film again very cleverly that Rene buyer Jean has been one of the leaders in this field very cleverly showing you what infants are grasp and don't grasp not only the brilliance of these experiments I mean really but you know these infants are really trying to figure out the world and coming up with hypotheses that you know they're confirming and then when they're broken down right there they're upset what's going on so let's move on to age two to seven especially in the early years of a pre operational stage and one of the coolest things I will try this and see how it goes with with with some girls in a few minutes is this idea so if you see two glasses filled with equal amounts of liquid and you pour one over into the thinner taller glass see which will have more water in it a or C the same all right thank you okay but not if your two-year-old or a four-year-old so it's called conservation of liquid so it's kind of fascinating isn't that it's kind of amazing and you know it's all if you do this with a three-year-old Garrett is virtually guaranteed building this I mean all of you did it all over the world and in some sense as far as you can guess you know all throughout our species history so brilliant ways of showing the babies and or young children really see a little bit of a different world you know that than you and I do okay as adults so conversation of it so here's another really uh I think you know very powerful area of research which is taking perspectives from the view that other people have thoughts and feelings besides yourself and how you interact with them so so this is and people call this idea theory of mind the idea that you understand that other people out there have their own thoughts their own feelings distinct from yours and in the most challenging case they can even be false beliefs you could personally have wrong information in their head and truly believe it even when you know it's wrong because you as an adult realize that thoughts are one thing and sort of physical reality is another thing all right but that's not what children think they think is there's just one reality that's why at the very youngest stage they think if they cover their eyes right that you don't know where they are because they think there's one physical reality only and they're you know they don't realize it's another perspective besides their own so here's a very clever experiment showing you that at three months children code the word in terms of actions and by six to nine month they begin to understand intentions that people out there animals too but we'll just focus on people have intentions and goals in their head so here's what the experiment they do using this habituation a person there's a two pedestals here and a person reaches again and again for a ball so now what do you believe the intention is to reach for the ball okay you see it ten times the babies losing interest now comes their shocker right to get the baby crying or laughing or drooling get the baby's attention that you can measure by how they respond and in some conditions you know something goes down and when it goes back up the person reaches but now they reach four they take the same reach for the left pedestal but it's a teddy bear or in another case they reach for the ball and the opposite side who depending on their age sees these two different changes in the scenario as startling the three-month olds are startled when the person reaches for the same object okay the three months old because they're in their mind the only thing that was really happening was reached for the left reach for the left reach for the left and now you're reaching for the right the action changed because the action is independent of intention it's just what happened what happened what happened and they're shocked when the person goes for the ball over here by six to nine month they're shocked relatively speaking when the person reaches for the same action but now the goal is different grabbing the teddy bear it's as if they understand the intention of the person was to get the ball and these children think the only thing that's happening is physical action physical action physical action so a very clever experiment by this habituation and looking time to shoot it at three months all you see is actions and by six and nine months you start to grasp that people have intentions in their head above and beyond their actions that govern their actions so to make it really sort of tricky there's this very clever experimental that makes then we'll try it in a few minutes this way this so-called sally-ann problem because it's been so widely cited and discussed so you sell you tell a child this story imagine there's two girls here Sally or Anne and Sally takes a ball and puts a boat in this basket below and then she leaves the room and who's a little bit of a troublemaker takes the ball out of here and puts it into this box and closes the box here's the big question when Sally comes back in and looks for this ball where will she look and a three-year-old says in the box now she was out of the room there's no way for her to look that's in the box but for the three-year-old there's not thoughts and reality there's just kind of reality does that make sense the three-year-old can't entertain the idea that sally has in her head wrong knowledge of where this ball is that she couldn't have known and she's going to act on the knowledge that's in her head that's the content of her mind the three old says there's one reality the balls over here I know it everybody knows that what else is there to even think about that makes it but the typical five-year-old will say you know Sally will look in the wrong place she'll look in the basket because that I'm sure look yeah in the wrong place where compared to where the ball is now because she believes it's there she has the wrong idea in her head that ideas can be independent of physical observable things in the world this is a universal finding man I'm going to change my settings sorry your handout has this in practically every country where this test is a three-year-olds don't have a theory of mind five-year-olds do turns out and you could take it yes the older sibling you have the younger you become getting a good theory of mind what's your get nobody really knows what the answer is but what's your guests the more siblings you have we're older than you the younger by some number of months people tend to show that they have they can understand that people have all kinds of thoughts and beliefs in their head what's your guess yeah they were cured by their sibling so no but but but on top of that the intuition is and we don't really know this is hard to brew you know they're living in a world because they have older siblings who do unkind things to them who have superior powers over them physically they're much more socially you know have to figure out what's going on to survive happily and make their way in the world right you know that the big five-year-old is like he or she is like dominant you know and the two-year-old is like trying to steer around like what is that five-year-old think how will I not get into trouble with that five-year-old and my mother and my right you know that a younger sibling is more social pressures to figure out what's going on and steer your way around and not get in trouble with your older siblings I'll just say welcome back to autism I'll just say a word about this now you hear a lot about it the current guess is that it's approximately one out of every 140 children a shocking increase in numbers to what people believed it was many years ago mysteriously there's many more boys than girls with autism estimates are four to one or ten to one range all it's hard to know for sure we'll talk more about that but autism is defined by three things a sort of weakness our deficit in social interaction children with autism have are adults a difficulty in social interaction in communication and they have lots of repetitive behaviors that are can be difficult to help interactions with others and when people test theory of mind and children with autism is typically delayed by five or six years on average for those children who can take the test at all they have a very slowly developing very delayed theory of mind and understanding what's in the content of the thoughts of other people and that's considered one of those sort of biggest challenges is how they relate to other people understanding what the other person's thinking and feeling okay so just for a couple minutes I'm going to show you a video then we're going to try it so the biggest challenges to Piaget have been this idea that there's these distinct stages of thought that your mind shifts literally how its constructed and understands the world and that people have thought the process is much more continuous than Piaget had suggested and here's one compelling example of that kind so this is the a not be experiment there's a food to food Wells and something of interest to this infant the seven-month-old looks at the toy here it gets covered up and in the toy this is well this is sorry something was placed in B & B B it's it's one of the two wells he continues to look at B when both are covered he knows the toys over there and the toy has been placed over and over again an a all right so he gets at a not b air he has the action and even though he sees the toys placed there it's covered up he's looking where the toy is when it's time to reach he goes to this well so this is the 8th of the error a part of his mind that guides action is stuck and guides the what he reaches for right but obviously another part of his mind knows perfectly well where the toy is right so it's not as if it's all of one or all of the other his mind is representing that there's a toy down there but the part of his brain or mind that guides his action is still stuck at this early developmental stages if he were to ages right one guiding where his eyes goes and one guiding the ultimate action of or his hands goes and as he gets a little older his eyes and hands will go in the same place okay last couple of things about how infants are mathematicians because of course we focused on language or social thought but you know the ideas of counting and ultimately arithmetic or math also come out of a children's minds and the very clever experiment and I'll show you two of them that shows even at six months infants are starting to prepare themselves to become mathematicians and here's how they begin the counting they're shown this place of three objects or two objects and then they hear two sounds like boom boom and where do they look they tend to look at the one with two objects so this is pretty impressive they're counting the two they're relating something and sound to something in sight that's arbitrarily related but it shares the numerosity right and if they get boom boom boom three boom sounds then they go okay now I like to display with three things they understand in some level tunas and three nos and so you start to have the basis of having numbers and not only that Karen Wynn at Yale has shown quite cleverly not only do infants have numbers they can do a little bit of subtraction in addition so here's the experiment she does she places an object in a case the screen comes up now comes a second object and the hand leaves okay the screen drops and there are two one plus one equals two and the infant is okay no big deal but the screen drops and there's one the infant to startle that looks longer and they can do it the other way around they can do subtraction as well okay so they you know one plus one equals two and if there's one left by the trickery of the kind you saw earlier they're disturbed that the addition is not occurred correctly or the subtraction is not occurred correctly and there's kind of a debate this is less lied about and here's the core idea though the which is this that our minds afford us by evolution counting up to about four objects in the world and many animals do that as well that's sort of you know has to develop a little bit but we have a lot running in us so that the infants can do because of course if you show seven if you give 77 booms they don't look for the display with 77 versus 78 okay or they can't do that okay so they can operate in the world of one two three or one two four and then they discovered there's been a series of studies in tribes that are relatively isolated in different parts of the world where they had in their language they only have words for one two and three and everything after that is really described as many or a whole lot they don't have words for five and up there's no word in their language okay because they've never needed it apparently okay in the world they live in so they go to them and they have them do little counting tasks and as soon as they get beyond about four they get very inaccurate it's as if the mind naturally can represent about four things in the object world four things in the counting world maybe because of that and after that everything is a cultural invention of higher level mathematics it builds off one to four but you don't have it unless your culture teaches it to you or your culture invents it so and there's been brain imaging studies too suggesting that counting one two four is very different in the brain then exact mathematics beyond the number four or five that's all culturally learned and invented builds based on a certain innate one to four capacity