Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu so I I in some ways I won't be able to uh compete with live demonstrations of children from last week uh but I will try to uh talk about adult development and we will really sweep through uh your minds and brains from when you were not yet born until you're going to be in your 90s okay so so uh here's your life uh from the beginning to to uh to the end uh uh you know viewed in different ways and we'll touch on a number of different topics so you know this uh question of people have talked for long time about this the development that one goes throughout one's life what walks on four legs in the morning two legs in the afternoon and three legs in the evening you know the answer to this right people right they're crawling they're standing up and then you get to my age and we need an extra little prop to move around successfully right and so uh sort of thinking about this that different things matter to people at different ages that there's different priorities different uh ways of thought Eric Ericson has often given credit for trying to artic articulate that and we'll just walk through it for a moment where he said oh at different ages in infancy Early Childhood through school adolescence young adulthood you know people are dealing with different kinds of issues and different developmental tasks in front of them that your life is a constant development not maybe as dramatic as infancy where we saw last time that children really see the world differently uh but there's different challenges in front of you at all ages and so you know infancy you're deciding who can you trust who can you love is it a good world right uh and then the the drama of uh potty training Independence you know how much are you becoming a free agent in the world um early School you start to interact with other children and and play and make friendships and think about social groups uh you know later in school as you're becoming more advanced in terms of what you're learning in school and more complex in terms of the social networks that you're developing uh the much discussed and we'll come back to this at the end period of a high anxiety and drama of um adolescence uh uh then uh you know the something about young adulthood you may have heard recently people have been speculating that what used to be the beginning of young adulthood culturally at least in the US and maybe Europe and uh industrialized parts of the world that whereas the 20s used to be considered a decade of adulthood there's now theories floating around or Impressions floating around the 20s are the new adolescence okay what do you guys think you know everybody says oh my 20s I'm going to discover this I'm going to discover that but when I get to 30 that's When We're Playing for Keeps is that is that is that is that what do you what is that yeah well and probably it's because you live longer on average or you count on living longer and you do on average live longer right for a person who's counting on Living to 90 which many of you are sort of another decade of finding your way your 20s seems reasonable right in a world where people didn't live nearly as long didn't have as many options you know time you finish college it's well you know or many people didn't go to college just roll up your sleeves and get to adulthood so uh there's been all these uh sort of magazine discussions that are the 20s the new teens okay uh in terms of whether people feel they have responsibilities they have to execute as a young adult uh and then and this is a little bit timed also from you know a little bit anachronistic because you know then having family although I think you know we're much more thinking about that's not necessarily the root for everybody uh at all uh and then old age where you give other people lots of advice okay uh so we're talk about brain development from infancy to Young adulthood uh uh uh cognitive stability and decline in adulthood we've talked a little bit about that talk a bit more uh alterations and hemispheric specialization that come with aging uh a bunch of remarkable results about exercise in the brain all of us want as we get older or just even when you're younger maybe just a pill you pop and you're ready to go right that would be the best uh it turns out there's remarkable evidence about what e physical exercise does for the brain I'll share that with you especially regards to aging but at all ages ideas about how as you get older your social and emotional goals will tend to change a little bit about rewards and a little bit about back to adolescence and some reth thoughts about what's going on in the Adolescent mind and brain so we know there's one thing about the brain that's stunning uh and challenging to grasp and empowers us to be humans it's its complexity huge number of neurons fantastic number of connections among the neurons uh so this just phenomenal complexity that all starts right with a single cell and how does the brain become this dramatically complex organ and how does it organize in the right way to let you be an effective learner an effective partner in your family and so on um so start with the idea of neurogenesis a magical word the neurons being born uh and they have to make this make this craw this a huge path for the size of a neuron from the ventricular surface The ventricle the fluid field space to get to uh the place you're going to be in the brain it's a huge Adventure per neuron um cells dividing there the earliest neurons are are existing about the second embryonic week so that's when you began to produce your neurons in your brain uh by the seventh embryonic week so you're just to months of pregnancy you're producing 500,000 an estimated 500,000 neurons a minute we said a neuron is kind of like a moderate computer except unlike iPhones it can't keep track of where you're going all the time right but we said it's a it's a moderate computer uh so um uh 500,000 of those every minute I mean it's staggering right that it all works out is staggering um Peak uh uh by the 18th week you most made all the neurons you're ever going to make for the rest of your life except in two brain regions and there's a big debate in the last decade but about another brain region I'll share those with you but people have been taught for many many many years in medical school and college and graduate school that all the neurons you get are by the 18th week so hang on to them through healthy living and wise Behavior right because you have what you have right so don't lose them but we'll talk about that you lose a vast majority of them anyway naturally uh I still recommend Healthy Living uh because you know perhaps from other courses that the brain does this wild thing that it excessively overproduces by Massive scales the number of neurons and the connections among the neurons and then through use it uh gets rid of neurons and gets rid of connections among neurons right exactly the opposite way if you built a building if you build a building what do you do you construct every bit of it you need and you're done what you don't do is say I need a twostory building so I'm going to do a 40 story building or a 90 story building and then knock off the stories as they're not needed you say well that's wild why would I do that right but the brain brilliantly makes many more neurons and many more connections on Epic scales and then only uses the ones that seem to be useful for the functions of the brain um and so for that reason uh the number of uh the the density of the neurons in the brain is much higher in a two-year-old than in you where it was much higher when you were two than it is now okay so a 2-year-old they have 55% more uh grain matter density in the frontal lobe than than adult even at age five even at age seven they're 10% more so you're constant from a peak of around uh before birth you're constantly shedding neurons and their connections and keeping the ones that seem to be effective somehow now for many years people have said is there neurogenesis in the adult brain is everything you get before you're born and that's pretty Prett much it uh and there's many reasons to be interested in that one is just how does the brain work how do people work the second is for diseases like Alzheimer's disease Parkinson's disease and other diseases we would love to replace neurons that have died to help people do better so can the brain make new neurons past uh uh before birth uh there's compelling evidence in animals and some indirect evidence and people too that neurogenesis does consider continue into adulthood in the the olfactory bulb and in a particular part I'll come back to this at the hippocampus a small part of the hippoc campus called the Dente gyus everybody's in pretty much agreement on this for the moment which is kind of interesting why those two areas amongst all the areas in the brain what makes them different that they can produce neurons all throughout your life uh and then about a decade ago Elizabeth Gula Princeton said oh you know when I do the right kind of experiment I see new neurons in the prefrontal cortex of monkeys of you know infrahuman primates that was a giant Revolution because they said wait a minute maybe if you know monkeys are doing it people might be doing it making neurons throughout their life we just didn't know that it's not so easy to measure okay if you think about it they kind of experiment to know for certain if a human is making a new neuron is not so easy because brain Imaging is very far from the single neuron level and even if we saw a neuron how could we tell it's new so uh and then there's you know Pascal Rak a big developmental researcher yel said that what she really thought what she really saw was glea the GAA are the other neuron other cells in the brain not the neurons they support uh the neurons everybody agrees that you make glea all through your life all right there's no debate about that but glea are not the stuff of thoughts and feelings neurons are so what's you know what do what do we understand about that whole story here's an unbelievable experiment I think or it's only not an experiment but it's it's a measurement uh so here you know uh published in 2006 as one approach to asking do adults make new neurons and so the nuclear bomb tests that occurred during the Cold War sent a carbon 14 into the atmosphere from 1955 to 1963 until there was an international testband treaty and then these decreased and stopped but there's a lot of nuclear bomb testing in the late 50s and 60s that released carbon 14 into the atmosphere and that integrates with DNA and forms a date Mark for the cell of a birth okay so this is not an experiment we would want to do again which have you know atmospheric nuclear testing and having nuclear stuff floating around in the atmosphere right but I'll tell you the bottom line then I'll show you how they figured this out uh what they figured out is looking at people who died uh a few years ago uh that non neuronal cells are generated that was found before gal cells are made throughout your lifetime as the inference from the finding but neurons are not generated in adult neocortex the commentary in shrio said no new neurons for you okay okay not quite true we know these two little areas in the brain do it but not in most of the brain and they also looked at something called uh uh bird U brdu which is another way to take a brain If you have it uh that you can and it marks newly synthesized DNA so if you have the brain directly to measure you have a couple measures of newly synthesized DNA which will be the marker of new neurons so here's a fantastically interesting thing they took people who were born in different times took postmortem samples and measured the CD 14 relative to what was expected the line here is relative to what was expected uh by the amount of carbon in the atmosphere okay so that's and here's what they found if they look for somebody born after 1963 they have in their neurons exactly the amount that you would expect if they made all their neurons around around here uh and the the decrease here didn't affect the neurons at all the glea are here which is kind of an average of here and the rest of life so if you aage the average age of the Gia it was about the average age of the life of the person the carbon was being picked up in the DNA because it's being made it's being kept and being made but the neurons all look like one value the value that has to do with when you're born all right so it's not changing uh the number of neurons that are showing the carbon 14 as if whatever you got a birth that's it on the other hand here's somebody born before 1963 uh having essentially zero carbon that's being showing up in their neuronal DNA and having again the expected average gal DNA as if glea kept going so this is fantastic this is looking at the carbon 14 in the DNA of neurons and GAA and people who have passed away and saying the Carbon 14 dating looks like neurons you get them all before you're born that's it glea you keep making and they can look at it more directly by looking at this uh uh thing that shows you recent DNA again showing you impressively that glea keep making nuia with new DNA but not neurons so the current conclusion of the field as far as anybody can tell is no new neurons for you except in your Dente gyrus and old factory bul um now here's something fantastic though it appears that exercise I'll just show you one example in animals and humans there's other thing exercise will pump up the number of new neurons you make in the Dente gyrus of the hippocampus and we know the hippocampus is important for memory so that's not a bad place to make new neurons so you know that going to exercise you know will strengthen you in various ways but you never realized unless you follow this line of work that when you exercise you're enhancing the number of new neurons that you're producing in your Dent Jus so here's two here's a couple ways people have approached this so one way is to measure cerebral blood volume how much blood is in the dentate and I'm going to show you evidence that mice that are allowed to exercise push up the blood volume and that that seems to go with direct evidence of neurogenesis you can do that in the animals you can look at sacrificed animals and then in humans some indirect evidence uh that exercise is again pushing up the blood volume in the Dage and pushing up a little bit memory abilities that go with that part of the brain we can't go in and measure neurons uh in the humans so here are mice who exercised or didn't exercise they measure the blood volume here in red is the dentate part of the hippocampus you can see it's the hottest spot for blood volume volume uh and it's the only Spar that responds to to exercise so they had some mice not get to exercise some M get to exercise uh the blood volume increases within the hippocampus selectively in a small component of the hippocampus the Dente Jaris exercises pushing up the blood volume now that's not direct evidence about what's happening at the cellular level but they can sacrifice these animals and show you that uh if they look at this binding that goes with new neurons with new DNA uh that's pushed up in the exercise animals here's the statistics you know here's the picture okay so in the animals they can relate directly or correlate directly more blood volume and more new neurons being going with more physical exercise in humans they can measure the blood volume and so they had some people do more exercise some people less exercise against a Dente gyrus selectively that showed an increase in blood volume in humans and now they give them a memory test and it's not overwhelming but at least in some cases the people who did exercising who pushed up their blood volume also pushed up a little bit their memory performance so in humans it has to be more indirect but all the data align with the idea that exercise is pushing up neuronal Genesis creation of new neurons in one of the two regions that everybody agrees we make new neurons the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus so but cells have to go incredible distances of the cellular size neurons have to travel to the intend location migration occurs over many months including uh eight months postnatally here's this neuron following its little path to where it's going to go uh uh these gleo tracks following molecular cues as to their ultimate Target location to get organized its initial destination and function are predetermined at the start of migration people can measure things in these that tell you where this is going to end up it's programmed in these cells uh that unless there's something that blocks them uh that they know where they're going to go and make up different parts of the brain um and then they form synaps right the part of where information is scent from one neuron to another um it occurs throughout the brain uh but at different rates in different areas so very early you see it in spinal cord uh very late you see it in higher cortical areas like prefrontal cortex at the peak growth there's an estimate these are all you know gross estimates that there may be you may be forming 1.8 million synapses per second it's stunning right 1.8 million synapses per second and do you know how many molecules are in average synapse by krent estimations a thousand there's a thousand different molecules in a synapse for it to do what it has to do multiply that times 1.8 million per second it's spectacular biology um and then they keep getting more and more until two years and then you start to lose them by by by age 16 you'll have lost a lot of them and so that people have this idea we mentioned before that pruning and selection that we overgrow the number of neurons number of connections uh what stays is activity dependent or this use it or lose it neural Darwinism here's something amazing there's an estimate and you know that we lose 20 billion synapses per day through adolescence you know and that's not a bad thing okay that's not the worst behaving adolescence doing the worst things they can do that's the brain uh you know getting rid of connections that aren't useful it's an incredibly interesting way to construct a powerful brain is to get everybody you build way overb build right and then eliminate the ones that aren't powerfully useful and another thing another marker of of of development is myelination that's the growth of the fatty sheath that surrounds uh neurons that are extending distances it insulates them and accelerates their signal it looks like white matter in the postmortem brain um what happens through adolesence here's age four to 22 is that white matter goes up and gray matter goes down so quite interestingly the the total brain size from about s six to about 20 young adulthood most of you stays about the same the total brain size what you're doing is you're getting rid of gray matter and you're enhancing white matter you're getting rid of the neurons that are nonproductive and the synapses that are non-productive and you're increasing the strength with which different parts of the brain can communicate with one another through the white matter and so here's the kinds of pictures of of this growth and some some of the parts of the brain that mature latest by these kinds of measures of getting rid of the overgrowth are in prefrontal cortex and we've talked about that before so people are interested in in in always in thinking about developmental issues and the biology of them and here's a kind of a stunning finding um and uh we don't know exactly how it would relate to humans but I thought it'd be interesting to share with you and think about this just a little bit so the title of the paper in science was good memories of bad events in infancy so we know from before and just every common sense that fear is important for the survival right so we studed the amydala which seems essential for learning what's to be feared because what's to be feared is what injures you or worst case could kill you uh so the amdal is essential for learn fear and we know that one example of fear conditioning that depends on the amigdala would be a neutral stimulus like an odor you know an odor that's not particularly good or bad just an odor and then a shock that makes it an aversive stimulus so you pair them through conditioning odor shock odor shock so the odor predicts a shock now they looked at Young rats uh uh and looked at attach M and here's what they find kind of remarkably up to postnatal Day N for these rats uh if they expose to the odors and the shocks here's what they do they know through pairings odor shock odor shock odor shock right here comes the odor here comes the shock they still approach the odors that's what's in this graph up to nine days the rats the mice sorry who uh are still approaching this odor even though it will lead to a shock but on the 10th day just one day later it completely reverses and they avoid the odors that predict the shock a complete reversal so they keep going to the odors with the shock and on the 10th day the the pups stop going there um and what they also find is this if they look at uh metabolic activity in the amydala for the nine day old it's the same for the odor and the shock or a neutral odor it's not selective to what's to be feared and the 10day old here's a big response in the for the odor that predicts the shock for the fearful learning to know what's scary and injurious and dangerous uh so how do people think about this well this is an animal experiment up to nine days we can't really know how it relates to people um but the speculation was this and maybe there's something to it on a different scale on people why would an animal approach something injurious up to the amydala seems to get more mature and then avoid what's injurious why would that happen in such a predictable evolutionary determined you know way and the hypothesis is this that if you're a very helpless newborn you have to go to uh uh things no matter what okay because you're so dependent on things in your environment to survive but at some moment you mature enough uh that you say no thank you if it's going to be shocking and painful I'm going to avoid it okay you become kind of independent in that sense in in a concrete sense and so the author said well so could it be helpful for new bord to know what no matter what approach a caregiver you know not not respond to things that are negative because you need the care because you're so dependent and now this is super speculatively a thing that's been noted is that even in families where there's unfortunate tremendous abuse for a young child the Abus victims so commonly remain powerfully loyal to their parents is this kind of a mechanism that mixes up attachment and fear all right especially when you're young and can't separate them out so well so it's a huge leap from the mice to the people but it's a mechanism that we can understand might be involved in how attachment and fear can have unusual relationships with one another all right you you can't avoid reading in the newspapers or seeing on on on your computer screen discussions about the deficit and older people like me demanding a lot of Medical Care that's paid for by the wages you're G to get in a couple years right okay I mean that's how I look at it okay so all right I mean I'm you know all right so you are entering a world we're all entering a world where the changing ages the demography of our society is spectacular Japan is ahead of us in this a little bit the rest of the world is following and China is going to be unbelievable when it happens on scale but the United States right now okay right now and here's why for most of human history the average life expectancy was up to 20 years old that's why you had to be an adult right because a 20 go like who knows how much time I have right better do my adult things right and it wasn't that people some people lived for a long time this is really interesting it wasn't that everybody perished by 30 it was that some people lived to 60 70 80 uh 90 but many people fell ill to many diseases that are now readily cured so the average age was 20 1800s it became the 30s it's you know just a couple hundred years ago in all of human history by 2000 the average first in the US lived till 77 uh by 2010 78 so we're having a spectacular growth in the proportion of humans in our society who are living a long long time which is a wonderful thing right okay but it's radically changing the world we live in and the world for those people who are older as well so for example 100y old people there's 50,000 of them in the US which is triple what there was time ago and it's expected to be a million people in the US who are 100 years and older by 2050 which is in your lifetime okay a million people in the US alone who will be a hundred or older um and maybe 50% of girls born in 2000 will live for a century all right spectacular changes are occurring right this moment okay the baby boom generation huge numbers of us are approaching you know retirement and the kind of medical support that gets heavier when you get older on average huge number numbers of us um how is it changing one way it's changing is it me families often have and you might hear this issue of families feeling their sandwich generation they're taking care of their children and their elderly and you can bet if you have parents who are living to 120 you're doing that okay all right uh uh giant effects on education pension work financial markets I mean these are epic societal effects so you're hearing the discussion now about how the us is going to deal with this uh so there used to be kind of an old model and this even this is not that old this is from the mid1 1950s you know where you your job was to uh you know go to college uh have a career have a mage take care of a kid retire at 65 and put your feet up on the desk right but all of a sudden if everybody's living not everybody but huge numbers of people are living till SE 70 80 90 100 many in pretty good health not everybody we wish for but many in pretty good health that's a fantastically different thing 65 is no longer the retirement moment and you're glad you made it 65 is something like the halfway point of your potential work life right 20 to 60 60 to 100 you know something like this right okay I me it's an unbelievable change you cannot overestimate how it's changing the world around you and how it will affect the economics and politics of the world that the rest of us will be in and you for many years uh there's about 10% of the population over 65 now in 20 years one out of every four people will be over 65 by current estimates right so we're going to elect whatever President we want okay right and older people go vote a lot more than younger people you can change that but that's how it is uh so let's talk about adult development uh uh I can tell you that if you compare adult development uh very little is understood from 20 to 80 almost all the research is taking something like college students and something like 80y olds and comparing them so this is pretty much minimal information is available about everything between 20 and 80 but we'll look at what we can and one of the things we'll talk about for a moment is uh the two kinds of studies we can look at for development this could be about infants but we're going to talk about adults uh crosssectional versus longitudinal so cross-sectional is I look at you as 20 year olds I look at eight some 80y olds in the Boston Community compare them that's very different than looking at you at 20 and seeing you at 80 right because that's much more controlled that's you with everything that's special and particular about you at 20 and 80 when you go get people who are 20 year olds from one place and 80y old from another a cross-sectional study uh uh that's going to um you know have all the differences that go with those coal Hearts so uh what are the what do we see in these kinds of things sorry um so here's here's some measures you've seen this kind of system before for things like working memory speed of processing long-term memory here's people in their 20s people in their 80s a ski slope of uh decline here's things like knowledge of vocabulary and that stays more stady the crystallized fluid distinction you've already heard about before so what are the strengths and limitations of crosssectional versus longitudinal studies so for cross-sectional studies they're fast if you're a scientist like a graduate student who has to do a PhD thesis in a May six or seven years okay you can go to an experiment with 20- year olds and 80 year olds and have a conclusion if you're a graduate student who would have to test this class at 20 and come back to you in 60 years from now and see how you're doing all right it's going to be slow progress okay so that's why the overwhelming amount of evidence is cross-sectional uh the problem with it is cohort effects we discussed for example that IQ scores go up year by year throughout the world so you're not really comparing equal things in terms of educational opportunities nutrition uh exposure to information on the internet a 20-year-old and an 80-year-old have lived through different worlds uh so it's all mixed up in the measurements not just age it's different world worlds that people have lived in longitudinal studies are are painfully slow they're more accurate because you're looking at change within a person you're holding all the world things constant you have one other weird thing which is you get practice effects if you test somebody in the same test not 60 years apart you don't get much but maybe three or four years apart you take a test twice you get better at it so that's a problem with longitudinal effects where you retest somebody so there's been a few studies I've looked at relatively short-term longitudinal and cross-sectional data um and here's the ski slope on the values of fluid intelligence things and it's just made a bit milder by a longitudinal design but not dramatically different so it's not the case that longitudinal studies that people used to think oh these longitudinal studies are overestimating that especially if you're older you like that thought you know it's a messed up study approach but unfortunately cross-sectional ones just diminish the difference a little bit so um people have said though there's an interesting trade-off what's the trade-off then I'll ask you for a moment between most of you are like 18 to 22 you know I'll bracket it 17 to 25 right most of you is that fair okay okay what advantage do you have versus somebody in their mid-50s like me and what disadvantage do you have in some Global sense oh that was that was painful yes the answer was you guys are physically able okay all right that that would be true you there's there's not many Olympian sprinters who are in their mid-50s right okay uh so how about in terms of cognitive things so we just said for Speed of mental processing it's good to be 20 and then you 30 year olds are a little slower 40 year olds a little slower 50 60 70 okay every decade a little bit slower for Speed of mental processing but there's one thing that's an advantage with time for cognition what's the advantage sorry experience experience thank you oh yes okay yes you get to you over time you learn stuff especially stuff that you're you know you're exposed to a lot right so time is a trade-off between within adulthood you lose some speeded capacities you gain some specific knowledge or experience and so they looked at studies like these air traffic controllers in Canada and this is very relevant because people are constantly thinking about what especially now air air traffic controllers are in the news more than they want to be right you right you've seen them they're unfortunately they're napping they're playing movies some of them I'm sure it's a tiny minority but worrisome if you're a member of the flying public okay so here's another question what age should you tell somebody well I think you know we don't need you to be an air controller anymore because you're not with it enough for us to feel safe right um so people are probing this all the time so uh air you know so here the average retirement age in the US is 55 and Canada 65 is one more correct than the other and so here's what they found when they looked at air trffic controllers uh age influenced processing speed but not task performance so what we're thinking is but older people aren't better but they're not worse maybe there's a trade-off between speed and experience and it kind of evens out until some age where it will no longer even out 118 Pilots 40 to 69 they would took place in flight simulators tested three times across three years a longitudinal design and a flight simulator the older Pilots would worse the first time they did it now some time is passing but then they outperformed the younger pilots in years two and three that is once they had some experience with the new situation they could apply presumably their prior experience but the very first time they did it when they have to use their fluid intelligence to figure out what's going on they were worse so you can see some trade-offs between raw processing speed and flexibility that goes with young adulthood and some degree of knowledge and expertise that's gained over time and so trade-offs on these things uh how about in memory declarative memory that we've talked about everyday memory I'll show you in a moment there's mild steady uh decline in healthy aging severe and Alzheimer's implicit memory we talked about that you know can be more steady across ages but let me focus on explicit memory or declarative memory um we're going to figure out what's why the projector is washing these things out so much but uh here's a slide that you don't have to see very much to know long-term memories performance is going down you know quite sharply year by year as you get older uh but here is something that was a huge surprise from brain Imaging a huge surprise and the thing that if you didn't have brain Imaging you wouldn't even conceive that it could have existed so many Studies have done brain Imaging as people performed various kinds of tasks memory tasks in this case with young adults and older adults and what they found unexpectedly was this uh that young adults would uh uh typically activate one side of the prefrontal cortex typically in regards to whether it was verbal or spatial so here's young adults mostly on on one side mostly on one side uh mostly on one side mostly on one side healthy older adults in good health characteristically turned on both sides of the brain as they were performing these memory tasks so you wouldn't have known that if you didn't have Imaging because who could have thought about that right so then there was a little bit of a debate in the field where the fact that adults were turning on both sides of their hemispheres whereas adults were just pick one or just using one was that a good thing or a bad thing so people said well it's a bad thing because maybe as you get older you lose your specializations and you're using the wrong stuff okay it's as if I need my physics book and I'm going to grab my chemistry book well just grab your physics book right okay right just grab the run right thing why you why are you getting other stuff that's not relevant and could mess you up or slow you down so some people said you're sort of losing the specialization of peak young adulthood you're leaking brain activity in the wrong places it's yet another sad sign of getting older here's an alternative one well you get older but maybe you get some compensatory mechanisms you realize at some level in your brain that you can't do what you could when you were 20 and you make up for that by somehow using two sides of your brain instead of one does that make so that would be a good thing right so how would you decide that how would you decide whether using the two sides of your brain when you're an older adult is a helpful thing part of the solution to keeping your your cognition going or is it part of the problem of losing long-term memor abilities as you get older they're declining how would you decide that there's kind of an easy answer sorry you what yes well yeah should we split you this is a suggestion we should take older people split their brains and see how they're doing yeah right well older people are their long-term memory is not that bad they're yeah so here's here was here was the approach seems reasonable they say amongst older people some people do better and worse in terms of the memory does better memory with go with using two sides or one side right and what was found here's one example here's young people using one side of their frontal cortex as they perform a memory task here's older people whose memory was not so good here's older people whose memory was good and here's a similar finding so the suggestion was that older people who used both frontal cortices were actually doing better they were having less of and effective age on cognition so the answer seems to be it's a good thing and if you're older you somehow compensate for some of the decrease in long-term ability by applying more neural systems to support your performance okay so now what are some factors that I mean older adults are really interested you you are not about 30 years you might be but older adults are really interested in you know what can I do to keep myself going since I'm going to live to be 80 90 or 100 with any just just a little bit of luck how can I keep my quality of life high in terms of cognition and mental abilities so one thing that people I found is that on average higher education is correlated with and there's many inter interpretations of this uh better cognitive abilities and less likelihood of getting Alzheimer's or getting Alzheimer's if you're going to get it at an older age um so that's kind of interesting that's a go good to go to college good to keep being educated in some sense it doesn't have to be formal but formal education correlates with that um now here was a surprise and now you tell me what it is so how would that work how would sitting there and listening to me really carefully right now give you an extra decade of cognitive ability when you're 80 okay all right now I got your attention so I how would that work biologically like you know is education kind of going in your brain and saying you know we're we're knocking all these things in and keeping them here and we're not going to let you have any injury when you're 40 or 50 how does that work okay so I'm going to tell you one more piece of information which is this and you tell me you think uh so the other thing that that we know is there's evidence that once you get the diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease then the higher the more educated you are the faster you decline and I don't think the story is all done yet because people are complicated but this is this is the current evidence so how do you interpret that so here's the interpretation the interpretation is more education gives you more mental tools what people will call cognitive Reserve you have more things going for you like maybe the ability to use two hemispheres that will protect you as something like some brain injury happens over time like an Alzheimer's disease or other causes of slow or or diminished cognition in old age that will help you you have more tools with which to keep operating successfully but once Alzheimer's disease becom severe enough in the brain that those tools are no longer available to you then the more educated you are the more you plummet because you know everything is done so we now know something and I'll just say about Alzheimer's disease and this is compelling evidence for this starts in your brain um about 15 years before you get the diagnosis about and and it could be more than that that's how far we can track it back by brain Imaging so if if an adult is diagnosed with Alzheimer's at 70 somewhere around 55 something has started uh that will you know ultimately be injury enough to be lead to dementi Alzheimer's disease um and that's why there's such a big emphasis on early identification because it's very hard to treat a brain that's had a lot of injury you want to you want to catch the people at 55 or 60 so we also know that lifelong cognitive activity is good conscientious we we talked about that and here again comes exercise okay um so uh so they took a study this is this is now a random assignment study finally a full-on experiment where they took Rel they took sedentary people people were not exercising over 60 and assigned them to two groups uh an aerobic training group who was did the walking and swimming so some real exercise and a non- aerobic group who did toning and stretching so they were they thought they were special they were active but they weren't doing the aerobic exercise uh and and they didn't do it a phenomenal amount of time an hour a day a few times a week for months it's not a brutal exercise schedule uh what happens it's kind of amazing what happen these are healthy people but not very active what's shown here the red bars are the cognitive performances after the after the exercise of the healthy older people and blue bars are the people who did the stretching and toning not the aerobic exercise so very substantial gains in cognitive abilities from a few months of moderate exercise and in the brain both by functional MRI and by structural MRI and gray matter and white matter physically measurable changes in the brain for the group that did the aerobic exercise a couple times a week you know uh for a few months compared to the group that did the sedentary ex the Le less active exercises that's amazing brain changes uh cognition changes uh again not no pill you can pop uh and you're making new neurons in your Dent gyrus to boot right so it's kind of you know all of us want the easy out but exercise is the most compelling story uh uh for keeping your brain optimized that we know now here's a remarkable thing so exercise we kind of get actually if you think about it we don't know the mechanism at all okay I mean you know you're running around like this now how is that pushing up your neurons in your brain but here's something very psychological that's kind of stunning and the first I almost didn't believe it when I read it but there's been a few other studies that have supported this we often think well exercise is something like real attitudes even in a psychology of course attitudes are just kind of they're just attitudes okay so look at this and then you you can think about this so they looked in a longitudinal study of 400 people over 400 uh in the Baltimore longitudinal study of aging they started under 50 but they've kept going with them they gave them a questionnaire on attitudes about aging so they said are older people for example more absent minded or less intelligent and some people are you know say oh oh my gosh older people are very absent minded they're very less intelligent other people think it's just a milder thing people vary in their estimates of how severe these changes are in old age then they measured something very concrete and real the number of cardio vascular events uh like stroke or heart attack over the next 38 years okay so this is a real physical measurement this is an attitude how powerful is an attitude well it's kind of stunning unbelievably powerful in some ways we don't know if it's the attitude or something correlated but here's the uh percent with cardio Strokes or heart attacks here's the people who had negative age stereotypes and here's the people who had positive age stereotypes so one always has to be worried about this a chicken and egg issue you know maybe if you've had a lot of strokes and heart attacks you're not so optimistic about your old age right but they were measuring these things uh at the beginning they were very similar so they weren't starting out with different health problems so something about attitudes seems to chip in to the most core aspects of physical health but none of us understand the mechanism yes a lot to do with that's a good so the question is how about family history it could be mixed into that yese y that's a very good point then it's not just attitudes right or it could be not attitudes at all okay that's uh so here and here's a concept that regardless of your age but age is the one of the most powerful uh story pieces of the story when your time is limited people focus on social goals related to emotional meaning and emotional satisfaction and less related to knowledge acquisition that depending on the moment of your life on average you know when you're an adolescence and you're in college and graduate school and you're beginning your residency or becoming a you know Junior partner in a law firm you're in an age of huge uh information acquisition what you want to know is what do I need to know to do something important significant valuable in my life right right you're sitting here acquiring knowledge colleges you know four years of acquiring knowledge in terms of classrooms and Majors right you guys do other things too but the number one mission is acquire that knowledge uh now when you get older you know you don't really want so much information anymore and maybe what you're much more interested in is how you regulate your feelings how how positive can you make your life not by being adventurous taking risks and all this kind of stuff but by finding a way towards happiness and I'm going to show you a bunch of research that suggest that young adulthood is full about acquisition of information through Adventure uh an old age you regulate your em that you're you switch on average you're Focus to regulate your emotions in positive ways and so sometimes people will call that wisdom although you could you could just say it's different things for different ages are desirable and part of support came from the following result which has been found many many many times but it was kind of stunning when it was first reported so this is where where people were asked how happy are you are you satisfied with your life so here's younger adults 18 to to 50 basically about half of them said they're very satisfied but it zooms up uh if you're older how many people are satisfied with a standard of living 40 if you're younger 60 if you're older frequency of depression for example never uh let's let's pick uh often higher for younger people uh more frequent thoughts about suicide by every measure you can make if we give you a questionnaire like this on average for 20 year olds or 30 year olds you report more unhappiness okay than older people on average of course it varies okay but that's kind of a surprise maybe or not okay and that's everybody has found that not not a surprise I mean just because they report something doesn't mean that's the way it is ah well we'll come back to this again yes just because you say you're happier doesn't mean you're happier yeah we don't have a better way than that though okay we can't say oh you think you're happy but you'd be so happy if you were a celac you know you'd be just so happy I you know this is one of the measures you know I'm I I'm a brain measurer so I like objective the measures uh I think if a person tells you they're happy they probably are there there are certain moments I know when people tell you well we'll see who knows I agree with you it's a concern um so here's the thought that motivation and goals are set by temporal context that time is perceived as limited uh and all this will come that the older you get the more you focus on positive things in the world and what makes you happy as a thought is to focus on positive things and ignore the negative so how true might this be experimentally so they had students this is really washed out capture these uh special moments the same ad and this one says capture so capture the special moments and this one says uh capture the unexplored world so if you're an information Seeker which is better the unexplored world or the special moments which is better unexplored world right you're a 20-year-old unexplored is awesome right young people prefer this ad older people prefer the special moments and special moments we emotionally satisfying right okay here's another one they show you uh pictures of a positive and a negative expression it flashes away and there's a DOT left and you simply put if the dot appears on the right you push your right hand button button if the dot appears on the left you push the left hand button it's simply pushing to a dot but the dot is in the place where you just saw either a negative or a neutral face and what they find is for younger people they're about as fast whether the dot appears where the neutral or negative face was they don't really care for the older people they're much faster if the dot appears where the positive phase had just been as if their attention was locked to the positive face oh the dot appears there I'm ready to go lock to the positive face of the dot appears here and go whoa whoa whoa you shift your attention and that takes extra time so you're locked to the positive when you see a positive and a negative face here's another one where you're asked um given positive and negative car options things that are good or bad about a car this line goes up this line goes down younger people focus more on the negative options relative to older people who focus more on the positive options here's another one you show pictures of happy scenes or neutral scenes or negative scenes this is a graveyard uh young people's uh uh memory for positive negative and neutral things they remember emotional things better let's go to the older people look at this line way up here that's memory for the positive scenes and here's the negative scenes do you see the focus on the positivity and the sort of lack of interest in the negative stuff right for young people equally interesting if it's positive or negative for older people much more interesting and sticking in your memory if it's positive and not sticking in your memory if it's negative um so one of the big questions is is this simply about getting older and I'm going to ask you to think back if I can to your last days in high school your last days in high school for those last days and I'm sure it will vary depending on your experience and different ways were you primarily interested in getting that last little bit of information about us history or calculus I mean you might have been that could be the critical bit of information that will make College work out or or did you have a sudden and this kind of embarrassing year 16 17 18 enhanced sense of nostalgia oh this is the last time that the three of us or the six of us or the eight of us or the two of us will be together then we're spreading across the world to go to different colleges nobody had that feeling okay it's kind of embarrassing when you're 18 because you're not supposed to say that kind of stuff right and it will happen to you at the end of college for most of you most of the time I remember senior year crept up on us in college and we started colleg and oh my gosh this is the last year we're together and seemed very emotionally important okay all right so age or time so if is a simply age or as a time so they did experiments where they asked people are you focusing on you know adventure and content are you focusing on emotion and satisfaction when you're about to move from one city to another people wanted to spend time with people they really cared about and they were not interested in getting new information more two more sort of tragic studies if people are near death and they ask this question of course time with people not acquiring information but here's another one inner city gangs study in Los Angeles Inner City gangs that involved in violence much more interested in time with people than in information and you know partly that goes with what is viewed from the outside you know sometimes as kind of the insane loyalty that inner city gag members have for one another it's because they're so focused given their situation on this relations with the other people in their group compared to everything that's rational about a safe you know growing up right okay so it's not and tragically you know if you ask member City gangs how long they think they'll live they often tell you not very long I'm counting on not living very long right so it's not whether you're 20 or 60 or 80 it's how long you sense time is in front of you um a temporal Horizon so here's one study where uh uh I had a hand in where we took older and younger people and put them inside MRI and showed them positive neutral and negative pictures here's a couple different points when they said how intense is this picture look at younger people positive neutral and the negative are really intense look at this goes down so the older people as they see the pictures experiened by their own report the negative pictures is being less intense all right they're they're sort of downplaying the negative and if we ask their memory here's younger people positive and negative things neutral things same for positive and negative look at older people much more focused in memory retaining in memory the positive and not so much the negative and if we look in their amydala which we know is a structure That's essential for how emotion modulates the formation of memory here's young people here's a positive picture here's a negative picture here's a neutral picture so emotion counts positive and negative count about the same look at older people here's positive and here's negative okay so this partly addresses the question like for some people like are older people pretending they're positive well it doesn't look like that right this is the amydala as they're looking at it I mean I don't know if they amydala pretend to look at the positive right so here's the good news for you what will happen as you get older on average is that for whatever reason happens and we don't really know why you will focus more and more on the positive things in your life and you'll feel better for that on average so that's a kind of quiet satisfaction oh I'm focusing on the positive that's the Zen satisfaction let's talk about fantastic satisfaction the reward system right when you really really want to do something because it's really wonder it's going to feel so wonderful the reward system so let me tell you a little bit about what we understand about that uh it involves dopamine is a critical neurotransmitter starts in the vental segmental area of your brain stem and that projects to something called the nucleus accumbens an inferior portion of the basil ganglia and this is reward Central if you love something from Opera to Chocolate to video games this turns on every experiment that people have ever done uh shows in humans if something really turns you on this area really gets turned on all right I mean what's more powerful for us than what we find deeply emotionally rewarding this is that reward system um and the dopamine runs from there uh there but and look at how cells response I'm going to show you an example from monkeys where we could look at single cells and uh and then brain Imaging back to people so here's the experiment with monkeys and there's there's a message in this that's both biologically true and I think compelling about human life all right so uh so biologically true the science they compelling about life is a is a story right so here's the experiment the monkey sits there and gets various cues different visual things that tell them what's coming up Let's Pretend This is a cue that something wonderful is coming up highly desired food right so they they recording electrically while the animal sees this there's waiting for it what we can call the anticipation period and now here comes the reward and here's something sort of deep I think about reward and learning and people and things like this so here's the neurons firing this is a a this is a sum of the neurons firing in the vental segmental area so right now they're just sitting there whoops here comes the reward here's our and boom dopamine is released okay the dopaminergic cells are firing a crazy they're getting food they really want we're thrilled we're hungry and we're getting something delicious not much more rewarding than can happen when you're really hungry okay now they predict the arrival with with the cue that you saw a meaningless uh stimulus and look what happens when do these neurons fire not for the food arriving but for the visual signal that predicts the food will come what's delicious for the brain is the anticipation of something that's rewarding and this morning when I was thinking about this lecture I was thinking in my life almost always you might tell us think about experiences you've had that you've looked forward to and almost the most delicious part you might say is the anticipation of something delightful often the event itself is more mixed and and post climatic anti-climatic than you would have thought is that is that fair okay I mean I think there's nothing better than like I'm anticipating something wonderful and the event can be wonderful but often it's a little more complicated right that anticipation is like pure joy because your dopaminergic system is firing freely away um uh and it protests also so you get the visual signal that oh the reward is coming up okay um here it is here comes the food the The food doesn't come look at the silence these cells are protesting you know because they didn't get what they expected to get okay right so it's very compelling that the reward in you occurs not even so much for the reward itself but the anticipation of the reward is where it's biologically occurring when you can anticipate and counting it correctly so in humans it's harder to deliver not impossible food in the scanner so that a very simple thing is done for reward which is offering people money so in a given trial in the scanner you might see a meaningless cue like this but you learn that this box predicts that at the end of this trial you do many trials you're going to get a dollar another one might be 10 cents another one they might take away a dollar okay so this is like a good one to get like I'm gonna get a dollar just sitting here I'm gonna get a dollar okay it's not huge it's not the biggest reward in the world but it's something for like just laying in a scanner doing nothing um and here's what happens your nucleus accumbent gets activated this where where dopamine flows from the vental tental area when you anticipate a reward this is not this is not when the reward comes this is when you're anticipating the reward um and here's another picture uh and it's most it's most powerful for when people anticipate a gain a reward and less responsive when people anticipate a loss so it's about gains then the same system projects to the inferior parts of your frontal lobe so now we're moving into the neocortex and that part of the brain seems to respond most powerfully if you get the reward so this is really interesting a part of your brain that responds to the anticipation the dopaminergic reward system and then another part of the brain that responds not whether you anticipated but sometimes they trick you and they say we're going to give you a dollar and they go oops we're not giving it to you okay this part of the brain seems to register the receipt of the reward or not so a separation in the brain between the anticipation of reward and the response to whether you get the reward or not um older people uh when they look at these kinds of similar reward paradigms they respond uh they're less responsive to potential loss but equally responsive to potential gain as young adults so that's exactly responding to positive things and showing less of a response to potential negative things so let's switch to adolescence we're going to focus on adolesence now mostly for the next 10 minutes uh pretty you know you just got through that okay so let's reflect back for last couple years and they make the experiments because they want to put children into it a little bit more Vivid here's Pirates here's not much reward here's some reward here's a lot of reward okay in the scanner and your children or adolescents or young adults and they look in the nucleus accumbent this a reward region and look who's firing like crazy adolescents okay teenagers um but they're not firing like crazy in the frontal cortex so this is very speculative uh uh and these are partly just wide stories but one hypothesis is this and we're going to say in a minute more about this adolesence uh uh is a really interesting period because it's not only when you're deciding like who you are in the world in many ways independently it's also worrisomely for parents grandparents cousins siblings the period in life when people are most likely to put themselves at Great risk and one version of that is that the subcortical reward areas are developing way faster than the cortical areas that control and regulate your behavior okay so you this goes with the stereotype which is probably as unfair as any other stereotype of the out of- control teenager right okay but imagine if it were true that your award system is very turned up for and your cortical control system were not yet caught up to the adult level well that would make you a little bit more likely to do adventuresome things right uh because there re is powerful and the control of your thoughts about how to approach that or reject that reward are less powerful so uh uh so here's some things to think about and people worry about for adolescence um 40% of adult alcoholics report having initial alcoholism between 15 and 19 between 16 and 20 both sexes have at least twice are twice as likely between accidents than drivers between 20 and 50 Twice The Accidental rate adolescent more likely to engage in impulsive sexual behavior multiple Partners uh annually 3 million adolescence contracted sexual transmitted diseases so lots of things that are risky behaviors occur with high frequency in a demonstrable way on average among adolescents okay uh young kids don't drive yet 20 year olds are a bit more mature on their driving uh so um part of this is again attitudinal here's here's a question that people were asked about future perspectives they were asked I would rather save my money for a rainy day then spend it on something fun right now okay uh in your 20s a little bit uh but you know when you're 11 but you know 11 to is that I mean that's growing that you'll keep the dollar but you know the younger you are in your teenage years the more like who wants the wait let's do it now okay so uh moving from something fun to something experimental um let's put together a couple last themes so here's a thing we did before several times in this class creating false memories and you remember the way that they create false memories in the laboratory is they pick a word they don't present to you like sweet then they ask many students to say what words go with that word like sour or candy or sugar they present you this list and then they test you for this word that was not presented and people often imagine incorrectly that they heard or saw this word right we've done that a couple of times it's a way to show theuser memories and the way we understand it is basically this your memory your mind mostly thinks about the essence of things not the details of things the essence of things was everything is sweet the the details were the specific words in the list okay so let's look at uh older adults versus younger adults 80y olds versus 20 year olds and exactly this experiment older adults have many more false memories and they perform less well so here's here to a scary extent the healthy seven-year-olds here's their real memories here's their false memories it's dead even okay here's young people having lots of false memories but not as many as older people and having more correct memories so older adults have more false memories because they're encoding the gist a lot but they're losing the specifics does that make sense okay then you're really vulnerable to a false memory children you might think well what do they know right children have less false memories than you do you would have had less false memories at age five than you would right now now which is kind of amazing if you didn't do the experiment you'd imagine children would be totally confused they got a big list of words with sweet on the list I don't know yeah sure right okay no a 5-year-old does better than a seven does better than 11y old does better than a 20y old why why do a 5-year-old have less false memories in their circumstances well we understand that to be the price of having a mind that understands a lot of gist as you become older you understand what's important what counts it's not the little details it's the big Concepts right so here's an example of for example how well people can relate words across uh sentences and that grows from six to n and that's what we want you don't want to read word word word you want to say what's the point of the sentence right okay that process of saying I don't care about the detail I care about the concept the gist of the concept it's like the chess players you shed the specific details to gain the overall knowledge Advantage but the 5-year-old is not making the big picture they're just getting the little details so they're less prone for the illusory memories um and you can't see that but this is just showing that when it comes to organizing memories you see that uh develop across uh childhood okay last couple things because when I heard this a few years at AG go conference I was so surprised by these findings I've been around long enough I don't get as surprised as often as I used to but it's kind of really interesting and it's a total twist and you can you can make a judgment call about how to interpret it but here's the experiments and the data so again we have this picture that everybody likes because it fits with the stereotype right uh uh which is the teenager a of control their dopamine is going up there and they're sending you know let's go have let's do a lot of inappropriate things because it'll be rewarding okay I know everybody's against it but you know all right so that's a stereotype and probably there's something true about that I mean literally in the brain Imaging it looks somewhat true uh but let's think about this one for a moment so you're going to be good at this if line a these are lines is longer than b and line B is longer than line C is a longer than C yes all right okay this is MIT right all right um now an answer this question truly think about it for a moment person a is a friend with person B so let's pretend you're a person B and you're friend with a and you're also friend with C are A and C likely to be friends let's think it is it let's think about this is it is it mathematically transitive like this one no let's think about it for a moment in your experience through life on average are your friends mostly kind of going to like each other kind of not all the time but kind of yeah because probably because if they like you if one person likes you another person likes you you share interest you share background to a certain extent in a loose statistical way it's not definitive like this so let's take a look what happens when you ask these two questions grades one through four okay these kids are just making mistakes right and they're getting smarter but look at this one go up just like that so we could we can say this is a growth in logical ability this is a growth in your everyday sense that I hang out with a certain kind of person maybe they like football maybe they like you know skating you know maybe they like psychology right but that's the group I tend to hang out with and like on average you know if I have a friend it's because we share some interest or style of of being and if I have another friend we probably share that too so more than chance you know they might like each other okay uh so so this is idea that you know there you can separate out what you might call Purely logical analysis of things versus a sense a growth of social experience basically so last three slides or so um you remember this from a bit back from a prior exam where we said there's a framing cistica verse for gains you're people are risk averse for gains but they're risk taking for losses so if we said here's PR prr we did this before if program a is adopted 200 people are saved and six and and uh or here's 400 people will die out of 600 that's the same statement but because this is stated as a as a gain people usually like this because this is stated as a loss people usually don't like this adults are risk averse for gains and they're risk-taking for losses if something looks like a loss roll the dice something looks like it's going to work out go with it even though numerically these are identical turns out that that attitude uh you can't see this I can tell you um uh is uh not present in preschoolers or second graders preschoolers or second graders when you give them these kinds of problems they don't show the asymmetry for losses and gains that's something that happens over time and it's not a logical one logically you should be that so in that weird sense the preschooler is more logical than you and I more logical than you and I okay because there's no reason to be statistically different for losses and gains that's purely an attitudinal emotional uh perspective first of all you can hear the information seeking let's check it out that's kind of interesting Swimming with Sharks that's kind of you know that's kind of right I mean I I assure you 70 year- olds are not going to go hey that could be kind of interesting they're going like no terrible idea don't do it yeah doesn't were they ask like a group collectively yes you see some pure influence right yeah and that doesn't happen with adolesence right right so anyway so everybody play you know when they do this they go oh my gosh these are these teenagers are going to go do all these things and get horrible sexual diseases and drive why they should are impaired and you know that's just the beginning of their weekend okay all right because they're not going to follow all the advice that we gave them for years and years and years and years at home and in school uh so here's the flip on this and just think about it for a moment uh and it's it's complicated Swimming with Sharks the adults say don't tell you don't have to tell me anymore it's a bad idea the gist is Shar sharks bad okay I don't even need to hear any the rest of the story adolescence start to weigh the factors we'd be safer in a group there a dark or night outside right you know how how shallow is the water right there and you could say well it's kind of ridiculous but it's not totally ridiculous because when we talk about danger those are the kinds some of the things you might start to think about so uh having you know so by this analysis um having unprotected sex adults you know bad bad bad okay I mean really bad I mean right adolescence well let's think about this uh you know let's what what's the gain well you know we hear that sex is highly pleasurable uh what's the loss all these things everybody's telling us what's the odds purely statistically that for a single sexual experience you will have the pleasure of sex but you will end up with a terrible disease what's the odds for one outing what do you think here's the complexity some people are arguing that adolescence are actually more accurate in their assessment of risk they're not wise in their choice okay do you understand the point okay but they're actually doing the calculation whereas adults just go sharks bad sexually transmitted diseases avoid okay because we're you're not parsing through the exact odds and circumstances the trade-offs between exploration and pleasure and responsibility and safety you just have the gist the line that's it that's my wisdom you know that I've gotten sharks bad sexual transmitted disease bad okay that's it uh uh and these teenagers are kind of curiously thinking about what are the factors you could say it's not the best analysis but you could say it's almost more rational just like the older adults will make more gist errors in memory will be more emotional in their avoidance of risk right okay so so it's very complicated it's not just dopamine flushing it's also in the brain right it's also something about how risk is perceived under at different ages and what information is available to you all right thanks very much