Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu so we've become to top it up that I think you know feels like including what almost the chorus technology might be about which is personality why are something easy person person why we like something why did you around us behave finally supportively or loyalty or whatever so what can we understand our personality scientifically so how do psychologists I study in some systematic fashion some key concepts so finding our traits States and contexts traits I'll come to these and then finally some brain correlates personality so I love this quote because I think it's a about individuality which says every person is in certain respects like all other people and we think that's true there's something deeply similar among all humans also about psychology also about our brains like some other people that is there's dimensions of individuality or like some other people like if we're a male or a female if we're this age of that age this culture or that culture like math or don't like math you know like vanilla ice cream or don't like ice cream right and then finally we come down to the unique set of things that make you you and that's that that's very hard to study the unique things that make you you but the second level dimensions of individuality we can study in personality is obviously a big one that we feel in our own lives and around us so you know this is the old original Star Trek alright like many programs or in TV series it plays out really is in part as you go from galaxy to galaxy and then struggle with various uh opponent civilizations but uh it almost always comes down to a personality thing right the Captain Kirk who's has to be aggressive and charge in there and do something very emotional Spock who's the pure rational machine and a Koi who represents a sort of humane touch as opposed to the rational thought and somewhere in between as the man who has to pick the action to command the ship right so it's all every show plays out with I'm asking him to be human right and who asking him to be rational and him you know killing somebody who's troublemaking right okay so so what do we mean by personality a set of behavioral emotional and cognitive tendencies that people display over time when we talk about personality right we really mean something that we think is consistent in ourselves and other people's that somebody is shy somebody's helpful somebody's rude and across situations not just one place one time but pretty regularly and that varies across people that distinguishes them from one to another something that's kind of you know there's some similarities but people vary in this and so when people think about this they think in three categories as it conceptualize that one is traits by trait we mean something that that's in you that's constant across situations and times and but we also think of it as a continuum so for example if we talk about introversion extroversion or outgoingness and shyness it's not that everybody's one or the other along that path from being extremely shy to extremely outgoing many of us are somewhere in between and then we can talk about states how we are temporarily you know how do we feel excited afraid that kinds of stuff and then situations were in because they're specific at times and places and that influences we get we're fearful we're happy we're looking forward to something we're not looking forward to something so these are different pieces that might end up in how we feel inside and how we act on the world so here's a very funny thing because it's a very different line of research than practically anything else that's out there very active because we're so curious about personality here's how people have basically approached it not everybody but the sort of the mainline scientific perspective they looked in the dictionary and originally in the 1930s for this line of work and they said let's look at all the adjectives in the dictionary that we think might describe personality in some sense so here's you know they would look up they found nearly 18,000 words in the dictionaries that seem to be adjectives for describing people and something that might be about personality whether you're affable or amiable congenial convivial cordial friendly genial sociable welcoming these are all synonyms right right they don't mean roughly this roughly the same thing we think but they found it you know you know 18,000 terms are because we think a lot about other people and talk a lot of other people and other people are interesting to us and as I said we're not going to study you know 18,000 dimensions of personality especially when lots of them overlap like this so what we're going to do is see are there some underlying traits a manageable set of personality traits or dimensions that many of these 18,000 adjectives sort of boiled down to so manageable set of personally dimensions so how do people measure personality in some way and for those of us who like to measure things by behavior you do a test or you push a button or we measure your brain personality research is always funny because the bulk of it these people's self-report about themselves and about the last thing most of us in psychology trust these people's reports about themselves ok so what we think is for many reasons that we can talk about a little bit what we think is you know that that people when they fill out a piece of paper describing themselves they start to have all kinds of thoughts like okay I'm not going but compared to who I'm you know I might do I want to fill this out like I really like to think about myself or how I think I really am or and I sometimes this way and sometimes that way which is the right answer okay so all these things bother us as researchers but we don't have a more direct path towards personality so we can interview people about you know their personality we can observe I'll talk about some studies that involve observation but by far the dominant mode of collecting somewhat quantitative data of our personality our questionnaires of the kind you just got handed out to you thank you teller and the most famous one of all which you have in your hands is this so-called Big Five personality dimensions there's many other aspects of personality we'll talk about that but this is the most famous one and it was derived in some sense objectively and empirically from factor analysis like this what they said is we have this huge number of terms but many of them are either very similar to one another or when we call Antiqua they're sort of opposites so for example if a person's rude are we also likely to think of them as kind now you could have something you know there's many movies of the rude senior citizen who turns out to be you know have a heart of gold underneath right every year we we have all kinds of but in general if you say this person's rude usually doesn't go and they're so kind right we think of them as sort of opposites in personality if somebody's dependable or carefree now maybe you know somebody's both dependable and carefree but we tend to think carefully people are not so dependable they can be delightful right dependable people but now rude you can be dependable and rude or dependable and polite right okay so you get a feeling of that so they had people fill out tons of pieces of paper saying how do they feel these factors describe them and they started with this huge universe of terms and then they try to boil it down and boil it down and boil it down by looking at all this doesn't show up very well this as well correlations you have the notes so you can guess without being able to see you can guess let's pick two things if I pick the adjectives carefree and dependable kind of go together and not go together doesn't tend to go together and people describing themselves how about hard-working and dependable kind of goes together okay see how so they they said we can take a lot of these adjectives and say piles in them going one area we'll just pick a few words to describe that dimension piles of them go in another area and they boil it down basically to two by factor analysis and they end up with five big factors in this most widely used one so here's two of them and here comes a big thing they have the factor which is basically just mathematically a set of adjectives that travel together that are highly correlated when people describe themselves alright and are somewhat anti-correlated or uncorrelated with the other dimensions that's purely empirical now though they have the set of adjectives like carefree or dependable not hard-working okay or hard-working and now they have to say what's the label I'm going to put on the dimension of human personality there's no science for that that's judgment but five of them get fixed and once these got fixed they've become the terminology of the field all right so they said we're going to call one conscientiousness those are people who say they're not carefree they are dependable and they are hard-working does that make sense or somebody's agreeable that's one of the other big five separate five is somebody says I'm pretty compliant I'm pretty kind and I'm seldom rude so I'm going to give you a minute to try this you can fill it out fully so your piece of paper that you have is a version of this test it's the real thing one side tells you how to score it don't look at that okay the other side at the bottom the other side so just try a few items for fun if you feel like it and you can fill it out later and score yourself or print it out from the notes and score your friends respond use it responsibly the knowledge or yeah and and you could just have an intuition of what does it mean because it's almost all personality research almost all of it does exactly what you're doing now which is gives you a piece of paper and have you describe yourself to yourself I'll give you a minute just to get a feeling for you it I think it's kind of fun and the feeling you get like add some people worry about stuff like who are you comparing yourself to if you're outgoing compared to who you know compared to Robin Williams okay maybe not so much sure you know compared to your roommate maybe yes right so all these questions like you know where do you get these number from how do you come to these answers and so on people worry about polishing your image oh yes I'm always polite you know I'm nearly perfect when I'm asked to describe myself okay to the extent that people did that it wouldn't work right because everybody would look perfect all the time so so these big five are OSHA are openness conscientiousness extraversion agreeableness and neuroticism and for memorizing for tests Oshin is the acronym okay these were the ones that have come out as as five separable dimensions that seem to cover a tremendous amount of individual descriptions of human personality and are widely used in research so here's your big five inventory here's the other on the backside how to score it if you feel like figuring out what this test would say about yourself okay you could be honest with your scoring because you write is we're not going to collect it it's just you describing you to yourself if you're curious and now I'm going to go on and you know you're more than welcome to finish it whenever you want it's thus yours to keep and here's how we would score it where you would score it you know it tells you in the bottom what to do so a person who for conscientiousness and we'll come back to this is a really interesting measure and if you rate yourself as somebody who does a thorough job as a reliable worker persevere until the task is finished does things efficiently and makes plans and follows through with them the higher you rate yourself on those this makes sense you're more conscientious right the less you say that you're you're somewhat careless you tend to be disorganized you tend to be lazy and you're easily distracted well those are negative things for that dimensions that make sense okay so you have to watch when you score at which are the positive in which are the negative as you square them up which hit a plus or a minus and they try to make it either way so that if you constantly say yes you know you're not going to score anything that makes sense even to yourself okay anyway so here's the big questions right okay all this sort of research behind of this factor analysis you want to know two things are they stable do they really describe a person across situations in time that's what we mean by personality and second do they protect behaviors and life outcomes is there something about them that goes with things that we care about variably across people so where people have looked at this over some number of years it correlates 0.5 to 0.7 across 30 or 40 years of life height and sex to think about it correlates point-four so it's again height and sex is kind of it people will pick that to think about on average men tend to be taller than women but lots of women are taller than lots of individual men okay so it's stronger relationship across time it's more stable than what you'd predict by height and sex and here's something really interesting they tested people across seven years with in childhood with in young adulthood within the 30s or even 50 to 70 age range and here's something kind of striking if you test people twice across seven years starting from you know infancy as best you can or questions about them because they can't fill out forms to adulthood the striking thing is that the older you get the more consistent you become across a seven year period the older you get the more consistent you become so how might you interpret that there's a couple different ways you could think about that the older you become the more consistent you become in describing your personality let's pretend your descriptions are accurate the more consistent your personality is how do you think about the expect that is that what you expect something opposite yeah yeah so there's two ways to describe getting older yeah yeah so like me yeah I get set in my ways right yes okay sorry go or I'll say the other way we discovered the ways that we really like okay I'm again yeah my friend Robert Sapolsky at Stanford who writes fantastic books and was a fantastic lecturer had an essay where he said he noticed it is you know late 40s or 50s that the people is working lab that they were playing irritating music I was just bothering him when they were playing the music and it was music you know the people of your generation listened to okay I said why is it irritating because you know he played his when he played the Beatles or whatever they were irritating to his parents okay so what's what's going on and he said oh and so he did a little informal study to talk to people different ages and people in restaurants and stuff like they said at what age do people seem to stop wanting to do new things and get stuck in their ways or find what they like and stick with it and there's no one answer in the cito but he found a tremendous number of people by about 30 to 35 that's their music they like sushi or they don't like sushi you know they kind of they have their set of stuff that they have going for them or they don't like and you know so you could say they get stuck in the ways you could say they discover what they like and stick with it you know and here's an age more of exploration and variability who knows okay but it's kind of interesting the older you get the more consistent you get and you know this is this flexibility it's just chaos you know you could look at it either way there's no real answer okay what people have looked at these scores and asked whether things like do they vary with age and gender so for example these broken lines are sorry neuroticism which is a funny label it really means neuroticism is the bad side of its stability is the good side of it you could also say to stable could be boring and inert you could real able these things pretty much but you know on average you know women scores a little bit less stable than men a little bit more outgoing a little bit by age you gets a few trends this will not surprise you actually so for a for sorry neuroticism against stability that darkness ISM decreases with age people get more stable and get more conscientious as they get older you kind of expect that you people get more used to their habits and more stuck in their ways that we would call stability okay so so let's ask for people who score high or low on these measures what do they go with so for these five fundamental personality measures so people who score highly on the neuroticism scale again these labels are tricky but that means ranging from very stable and emotional sense to very labile they pay more attention to threaten the environment more stressed when given a surprise math test have a higher divorce rate more susceptible to depression and anxiety at the very very very highest scores of neuroticism it's a big risk for for depression and anxiety and one of the deep questions always is to what extent are what we call psychiatric labels extremes of personality or something beyond personality this is a much deeper issue than you think we'll come back to it in psychiatry because you know some people say there's no such thing for example a social anxiety disorder that's a recent invention for what people used to call shyness all right I don't think that's right mostly okay but this debate goes on because it's there's not a sharp boundary between being a little shy and so shy that you don't leave your house to meet people I mean that's kind of an extreme but most people you know or they're not it's not one person is here and the next person's here there's people all along a continuum where you draw the line it is a challenging issue highly extroverted people versus highly introverted that sort of shyness are not going this this will be a big surprise highly extroverted people by these personality measures attend more parties they're more popular they're identified as leaders in college they live with and work with more people they're less disturbed by sudden loud sounds or intense stimuli you can do experiments you know in a laboratory and get these differences this will none of these are surprising they're just telling you there's something correct about these personality measures highly agreeable people are more willing to lend money have higher high school grades and a fewer arrests as adults but the cool thing is not I mean you're not surprised with the fact that they fill out a questionnaire you know sitting at a desk like you do predicts to some decent extent over the population whether they'll go to jail or not that's kind of interesting more openness to experience you're more likely to major in the humanities not awesome okay change careers in midlife perform better and job training programs and play a musical instrument alright but these are massive statistical things you know because kind of conversely well you know there's very interesting relations between musicality and sort of math and science backgrounds so that seems to go against this so these are big averages maybe I think in some ways the most interesting one for for practical reasons has turned out to be conscientiousness and that's like doing what you're supposed to do more sexually faithful to spouses higher job rating smoke less drink less drive more safely live longer less risk for Alzheimer's disease spectacularly less risk okay and also play a musical instrument I wonder for this yeah yeah no matter what okay but I'm so the Alzheimer's disease is kind of interesting because I you know what we think is happening and we don't really know is this so you may know there's basically one gene now more recently a couple other genes identify this significant risk genes for Alzheimer's but the one powerful well identifying so called the so called April II gene and that is a significant risk gene if you have to to version two if your homologous for that you have a higher risk for Alzheimer's but that best known best characterized gene is a far smaller risk factor mathematically you know than being low country interest and we don't know what that really means right what's your guess and nobody knows this is just an empirical finding and it's been replicated a number of times what's your guess so conscientious people do what they're supposed to well all the things that you're supposed to in the morning get up and do they do them pretty well right you know right you know make your bed do your laundry regularly brush your teeth regularly have your medical appointments regularly you know eat well exercise approp all the things that everybody tells you is good for you conscientious people are more likely to do yeah it's something like that yeah a pipeline analogy if you keep flushing it regularly instead of clogging it up with bad things that are bad for you wherever I mean we don't really in the end there has to be a biological mechanism and the other has to be but maybe it's a lifetime of doing healthy things and they add up enough day-in day-out month in month out year in year out that they somehow in some way either fend off Alzheimer's disease or diminish its expression for much longer is that sound okay but it's it's very it's a very compelling finding all right so then there's always a fun question for our personality and there'll be one big surprise here I think what one I'll tell you this is our surprise Otteman was reminding me that this lecture there's a parents visiting weekend which is not today right but a few years ago I gave this lecture on that and I came to a conclusion that parents will find impossible untrue and you know very disturbing all right get ready all right here we go so again we're always curious our personalities you know whether we're outgoing or not agreeable or not open or not how much of that is in our genes at birth how much is that in our environment in terms of parental influence of sibling influence of school and so on so the usual way to this until we know the true biology of this our estimates from twin studies and children reared apart and reared separately so let me start with the twin studies so these are identical twins in green versus dizygotic or fraternal twins shared environment some shared genes the difference about this is thought to be an estimate of heritage of pure genetic heritability and so you get a pretty good one extraversion and openness the most maybe but it definitely a genetic contribution to personality that's that's the evidence from twin studies and it's even impressive if you do not self-report questionnaires but behaviors that people describe activities they do time spent watching television number of childhood accidents tendency for marriage and divorce religious attitudes your balance between work and leisure you know how much do you want to be at work all the time or leisure or what the ah to be 0.5 that's about half heritable estimated happiness will come back to happiness ratings the way people rate happiness it turns out is if you do a 1 to 7 scale that's the field ok 7 means happy all the time one means miserable all the time you know that's the way happy news research is done in the last lecture we'll talk about what people think people do need to do to be happy but that would they use that but but one thing we know is that people tend to have happiness set points you may know this amongst your friends or yourselves that is an average a person will be like very happy or moderately happy or pretty grumbly most of the time ok something happens in their lives that's really good or bad they'll move a little bit but they'll slide right back to it right there's nothing that are worse about one or the other but it's just people tend to be pretty sad and the estimates from twin studies are about half of your chronic sense of happiness day in day out it comes from genes is the estimate from okay so that's a big piece but here's the kind of stunning thing and in the next couple of slides I tell you let me tell you the bottom line and tell you the evidence yes the empirical evidence could support a position that parents and family environments have zero influence on your personality then the question is what is the environmental influence okay because we know it's not all genetic but wherever it's been looked at carefully parents and home environments appear to have by you know as far as I can see nearly zero influence on your personality now this is the thing that drives parents crazy because as a parent I can tell you from the moment they're born or even months before children are born to the moment you're you're no longer around to take care of your children you want them you know to develop the right kind of you know be a happy person a good person hopefully something about conscientiousness to do well in life right I mean and you're doing every little thing to encourage that the comments you make the schools you send them to the activities you encourage them to do you want them to have a personality that will be happy for them and good for them thriving right I said to be told that whatever you do doesn't matter it's kind of a big shock and we don't really know the depth of this and it sounds like it's ridiculous but I can tell you the empirical evidence kind of supports it okay so for example for the twin studies it makes no difference at all for personality dimensions whether twins are raised together or raised apart okay so they're in different families or the same family doesn't make a difference all the heritability brings me exactly the same so you know where are the environmental factors coming from we believe there's environmental factors but we can't spot them and what's fascinating about these things is that we as human beings and this is just an example now always want to understand who we are is some sort of willful response to our environments so here are two identical twins reared apart ah and they're both super neat okay all right and here's and neither one of them tells you well you know it's in my genes what else were they going to do I mean none of us mostly think that you know outside of some you know dire circumstances of diseases we mostly think ah yeah it's my choice this morning whether I'm gonna make my bed or not it's my choice if I do laundry this year or not right yeah but the other 50% comes from things like diet or other things in the environment it could it what's much in shock is but even that tends to go by families some right you know some families just say you know here's here's a new year's worth of potato chips good luck alright another family's going oh my gosh you didn't need carrots all month long you know this is right I'm even that tends to be on average somewhat environmental right both by Economic Opportunity part of the world you're in parental attitudes right yeah but I agree with you it's gotta be something and maybe we just don't have the whole story right but here's two twins telling you why each of them is very neat okay we the first one is my mother when I was growing up this is you know one household of one twin she always kept a house perfectly ordered I learned from her what else could I do okay as I had a model when my parent she was neat on neat here's the other twin who's also very neat the reason is quite simple I'm reacting to my mother who was a complete slob okay so it's the complete opposite stories I'm modeling my parents I'm rebelling against my parents here but you know that they they're identical twins and they end up in the same place yeah you that's another interpretation this is a good question you know I'm pretending the explanations had nothing to do with anything and you're saying maybe this is personality think somebody who chooses to model their parent versus somebody chooses to rebel against or parent maybe that's the personality dimension right it could be would be it's just neatness you know twins who aren't neat tend to go the same way in twins who neat tend to go the same way about 50% of the effect is in the genes that I don't know I'm not saying there are things aren't there it's a bit of a mystery it's a bit of a shock or so here's here's a couple more things biological non twin siblings okay so these are siblings but they're not twins are far more similar to one another than adoptive siblings okay that's okay that's the genetics right okay because the adopted child is into the family but here's a shocking one four personality children are no more similar to an adoptive sibling than two too thin our two randomly selected children so in a household if you have an adopt a child and a biological child in that household of sharing the same environment they are no more similar one to the other than two random children in the world okay where is the effect of the environment where is the parental effect on the two children in terms of personality so so people have mounted this arguments so let me pick another one you put up your hand if you want to I'll put up my hand how many people grew up in a household where one or more parents spoke you know in a noticeable accent I mean I did let's let's try this room okay how many of you who have your hand up keep your hand up did you keep your parents accent where's the environment okay okay and your critical moments of language development right you were hearing that accent where is the environment and you could say well yeah but there are other people speaking other things yeah but then zero parental influence on the way in which you produce your language so there's a lot of different things to think as we move from language to personality but it's turned out to be surprisingly hard on some dimensions to show an influence of parental environment on child development especially personality yeah oh yes it's worse than that this is a very good question it's not only that they have adoptive parents if they have another kid in the house there's another kid in the house they probably go to the same if they go to church or synagogue or right or anything like that you know same school same state you know same influence of whoever's you know the NAT NBA basketball champion yeah I mean the whole list and it all seems to be quick you can't identify anything in that yeah yeah so who diet would influence that who knows is that sweat okay well so let me let me let me separate it from one moment I think it's some level of analysis all environmental influences education parenting everything will have a biological counterpart in your body and in your brain right because the environment has to affect you by how it changes your body or brain sorry after you're born ya know it could be added in there's things that we would methylation there's there's post there's a lot yeah it could be all those things but we who's driving that okay you know who's what's we're so so that it's not you know my bet is that we'll discover stuff about this that we don't grasp yet there's a it's not the answer is not going to be parenting makes no difference okay or environments make no different or schools make no difference for personality but we just don't know how to think about that yes is the best guess because it's just hard to believe yeah yeah iq personality there is a moderate conscientiousness especially but that makes sense on average you know and we certainly know people who are very smart and very sloppy okay so it's but on average the more conscientious you are like you go to school you do your homework that kinds of stuff there is there is a positive correlation so so there's all kinds of one questions whether how much personality is fixing your environment so how much is the way you are from the moment you're born driving actually the way the teacher responds to you in school the way the parent responds to you and so that's why your personality is already driving your actual environment right that mean so because we could say while you're in school but really how does that you know do you like the teacher - not like the teacher do you like the parent you go you know you follow them do you oppose them you know maybe those kinds of things are happening sometimes people think that you know that this kind of that your personality is driving the way your environment responds to you it might be done by sibling contrast so you may have this experience that um it parents and other people and siblings yourself often think a fair bit how they are similar or dissimilar for their own sibling and they might overdo it okay so the parent has two kids one kids like one percent more outgoing and they go that's the outgoing one okay you know you know one kid plays five percent more time on the piano they go oh she's the real musician and because he plays two more baseball games a year either athlete or side and then it starts to snowball that way okay or all right parent identification could kids who identify with one parent or and the other again by their predispositions you know serves be driving the way the parents interact with them in a way that's again driven by the personality the personalities from the first moment for one reason or another this drug is molding the environment around it and carrying the environmental effect as well so one of the giant fights in all of psychology is this and there's not going to be an answer I'll just say the debate and to the core of this question of why do we do the things we do so personality just psychologists will say it's these things we just discussed it's our predispositions to like things and not like other things in a general way our personality social psychologists and we'll spend two lectures in just a few weeks on so psychology say people are all kind of the same it's all about the social situation we're in probably you know it's like when these nature-nurture things probably something about the situation something about who you are but let me tell you how some of this debate has played out so a famous study that went against the idea of a personality being constant across situations and time came from Walter Mischel and they looked at conscientiousness and they said okay some kids score high or low or medium on conscientiousness now let's look at nineteen specific behaviors in their life not their report of how they are or the parent support of how they are but things they do that we can measure how often do they make their bed how often do they go to class like they should how often do they complete their homework assignments how often do they you know have good class notes when they leave classes so things you can check yes or no and they said gee what we notice is somebody tends to be pretty consistent about whether they make their bed or not every morning not perfect but pretty consistent but that same person may or may not be so good at completing homework assignments okay and that and that person is very consistent on completing Homa science may or may not be so good on having neat class notes so that it's not that people aren't consistent but it's far more specific about what they're consistent about than a big personality dimension that covers a range of things that ought to go together so he said this situation ISM you behave in a certain way in a certain situation it's not like you have a personality that moves from situation to situation and predicts the same route behavior and here's another example of how they follow kids in a summer camp and here's different behaviors from one child in another child so this is a child who when a peer approaches how however a verbally aggressive they are and so aggression is high this way these are different situations and you can see for one child they're aggressive in this situation when they deal with an adult and in this situation the other this other child is aggressive what he or she deals with a peer so if you were to say there's an aggressive thing about people they're aggressive or they're not well this person's aggressive would appear and this person is aggressive specifically with an adult so is aggressiveness a personality thing or situation by situation by situation in the movies you see all the time if you watch The Sopranos or many movies it's not uncommon to had the crime figure be really kind of nice with his family and really brutal with a competing criminal gang right have you seen that yeah and that's you know the kind of nice at home and then they go shoot people in two seconds notice right yeah if they're fighting about something so you see that kind of an idea another thing that people have looked at thats related to personalities temperament it's a little bit so it's an innate biologically based propensity to engage in certain style behavior is broader than a trait I'll describe one that's been well studied but people like it because they think it's observable so with traits it's hard to just look at you and say you're extroverted or you're conscientious you know I could follow you around all day maybe have an estimate but sorry but here they like temperaments are um broader than traits and you can see in terms of people's sociability emotional emotionality and activity level you can just follow them and see them behave in certain ways so let's think about the temperament of shyness so the way these studies were done at Harvard was that some babies even at six weeks are more reactive to make sudden noises they're more fussy about 20% of children could be that way they make a noise or something and they cry they get disturbed they're unhappy and so he called those children hi reactive or inhibited babies those two terms for the same idea versus low reactive once who are very disturbed by the environment and once they were like you know no big deal okay and the ones who were inhibited babies cried more they were distressed more they showed more activity faster heart rates higher levels of cortisol and they even have they could measure this in some cases faster heart rates in the womb even before they were born okay their hearts were racing right so all it is that one last little thing and the idea that maybe their sympathetic nervous system is easily aroused seeks less arousing situations and it's inhibited because they're already internally so aroused they want calm so there's going to be a surprise in the story but as we go in terms of thinking about shyness and you can measure these at 2 months or 4 months with the very simple little things you do with babies to see how they respond to some noise and to a decent extent it predicts shyness and later childhood in adulthood about a quarter of the children who look pretty inhibited aren't shy but about 75% who look pretty inhibited end up shy so that's a pretty good prediction from a two-month-old to a young adults about 75% of these children who look pretty shy at two months and of course they're not shy in a group that is responding to noises right end up being kind of shy as adults and they studied these four until age 21 and again and start with several outcomes specifically things like let's pick one mmm crime how often get in crime children who are well controlled don't get so much into crime children who had 21 had poor control at age three are more likely to get into trouble so as if these temperament factors in early early childhood already risk factors for doing better or worse in the world another one that people enjoy studying this is more sensation-seeking you know the bungee jumpers the people who like to parachute the kinds of people the people who enjoy the thrill of activities novel high stimulation situations statistically they have more fun probably in some ways they're more likely to dive they're more likely to drive fast or more likely to have drug and alcohol use and more likely to send flame emails listen to punk music and have driving accidents so it's an interesting mix of you know enjoyment in trouble right and there's some evidence they have lower levels of something in the blood that may be a measure of something that lets dopamine last longer in the synapse in your brain dopamine is the reward neurotransmitter so you could imagine that I'm you know if reward hangs around longer maybe you're more drawn towards instantly rewarding things another sort of I think did a 2-dimensional classification of personality again one dimension that they focused on was this in tribution two extraversion or stable to unstable this is neuroticism or introversion extroversion in the big five but there's some interesting turns this here's the interesting turn I mentioned it let me tell you one more time because when you it's counterintuitive it's the opposite of what you think in terms of what people have found so we think of extroverts as people you know go to parties are very talkative very outgoing run around and have a you know social time and introverts is more likely to be shy quiet withdrawn right there's the definitions of the words but what people have found in a variety of studies this is that extroverts di when people are less easily aroused so it's as if they seek stimulation it's as if their internal arousal is low and they want things that are stimulating an environment to push up their internal arousal right introverts are the opposite around introverts are aroused already and it's as if they seek environments that are quiet so their arousal is not pushed above some level of discomfort so intuitively you might think extroverts are more aroused internally because it is your first but the thought is that extroverts are actually seeking arousal okay because they're a little lower inside introverts already feeling pretty aroused so they don't need more bungee jumping they're already there they're already feeling like they're bungee jumping okay so and they're all seeking the sort of optimal level of arousal so for example extroverts do better in noisy settings they can take the extra stuff they don't mind it right introverts are more sensitive to pain and they salivate more to lemon juice they're already kind of revved up okay is Authority internally so here's one advantage in the course but and this is almost as practical constantly of private you could think about this for your own test taking a three-way interaction okay is this three factors at all interact with one another in performance and it involves situation and personality so here we go so the three factors aren't whether you're introverted or extroverted whether you're taking a test a GRE kind of a test in the morning or the afternoon and whether you drank a cup of coffee before the test or not three different things floating around and here's what people have found in several times in experiments when you're taking a test here's the upshot of these studies if you're introverted and the test is in the morning test is in the evening or late afternoon or evening drink coffee if you're outgoing drink coffee in the morning now I'll tell you the logic of this okay all right so here's the idea many studies have shown and you may know this if you think about people you know yourself on average introverts are most aroused in the morning they tend to be get up early in the morning and get their day going people maybe because they didn't party deep into the previous night okay so I mean there's a lot of cause and effect it's really hard to plot in all of this okay but introverts are more aroused in the morning and less in the evening it's the average the kind of people are get up early in the morning go do their stuff and the evening they want to you know mellow down and maybe not go to sleep so late extroverts are more aroused in the evening and less in the morning then this is on average and this has been found a number of times so again you can imagine if you're taking a test if you're under aroused you could use the coffee to perk you up if you're over aroused the coffee is going to make you jittery and push you over so depending on the time of day you're going to be one state or the other depending on kind of person all you have does that make sense of these three things come together like that in the famous yerkes-dodson law of performance which is this and this is you know observed in many years here's arousal how aroused you are super aroused super nervous shaky so are so sleepy you you're about to crash out somewhere in the middle usually goes with best performance okay because this is too much and this is too little you know that if you're too nervous you don't tend to perform well if you're too kind of out of it you don't perform well somewhere in the middle is just right so here's extroverts you know for example in the morning they're pretty low on this they could use some coffee to move to optimal here's introverts in the morning they're ready ready to go I'm ready to go we're ready to go the last thing is more coffee - oh now um you know I hope it's not a bubble test right because my hands are shaking okay so uh so three things the kind of personal IR the time of day and you know whether you're drinking coffee helps you to move to this middle position or not does that make sense okay so that's three different factors sort of adding up to to optimize performance or not okay lastly I've had to talk a little bit about some things we know about brain correlates of personality and in some areas these brain things are more informative at a broad level because sometimes people will say well personally out it's all this checkbox' tough is it even relevant to anything biological now if it's relevant to behavior it's relevant to biology right behavior is biology or biology is behavior right is it we're not going to get one relative to the other but still until recently people couldn't measure this so these are pictures of not of brain functions of a task turning on will see pictures of those in a moment this is measurement of brain structure measurement of brain structure and specifically thickness of cortex so what you're seeing as a statistic here which is the more extroverted you are the thicker your cortex is here the more conscientious the thicker your cortex here the more neurotic the thicker your cortex here and so on so it's not we don't understand these deeply but we do see you know physically measurable correlates of these personality dimensions so that's physical brain structure let's talk about some function thing this is a slide you saw before that in the amygdala the more emotionally intense something is the more the response the more neutral it is too less the response here's a pot you know positive happy picture right I'm going to show you a neutral picture that I'm going to show you now the bad picture don't look if you don't want to see it again so when you saw before close your eyes for a moment bad picture okay here we go now you can all look okay so people are introverted or extroverted so you know extroverts are sociable talkative introverts are on average more reserved or quiet extroverts report more positive experiences more susceptible to positives and mood induction lots of evidence for some differences among them so imagine a study where you show people positive and negative slides again you know people will say well if I'm you know on a diet this is really negative or something or but you know but I don't you know you have people rate them but on average these are negative and herbage these are positive you measure their personality and here's what you find in the amygdala the more extroverted they are the more their amygdala response to positive things the more introverted they are the more response to negative things so here's exactly what we mean by personality serve instantiated in one example and it's not the only symbol what do we mean by personality we mean there's a constant situation pretend a party you go to you know a party deep in my memory remember parties I went to the music is playing and there's sticky beer on the floor and you know there's people you know and a lot of people you don't know right so who walks in the door and thinks this is awesome the extrovert right who walks in the door and things collide in my friend dragged me do this I could be doing something good like chess at home right okay yeah okay so now identical situation different but that's true of so many things and preferences as life that's almost what we mean by personality right who likes what situations people activities so for extraversion here's the amygdala going a positive things will be they notice sort of speaking they're in their amygdala the positivity of the environment they're drawn to things for the cpo here's the introverts going Danger Danger okay everybody see the same set of slides but people are drawn to the positive or the negative aspects of this and you could say it's one better the worse will no avoiding dangerous thinks is a good idea you know enjoying positive thinks is a good idea not one is not better than the other they're just different you're tuned to different rewards in life and this is one example of that how about a smiling face who thinks a smiling face is an invitation to go over and meet somebody new the introvert of the extrovert help me on this okay who think is modeling faces pressure do I go over are they smiling at me right or I'm gonna go over and another nun that gonna like me exist they like me now right I mean I should tell you I I was quite only in my teaching mode do I appear extroverted okay but I definitely was an introvert in high school in college so if I make fun of introverts I'm making fun of myself so here's a response to a fearful faces and we talked about that before response in the amygdala regardless of personality but now when we talk about the response in the amygdala for happy faces big response if you're extroverted little response if you're introverted because a happy face is like compelling cool wonderful for the extrovert ah not as not as enticing for the introvert okay so again the way we might imagine how do individual differences in personality play out they play out that some things are beguiling wonderful and other things not so much and the pending on your personality that can vary so these are the children who were studied from ages of two and four months who were shy in temperament and they compared them to the uninhibited inhibited in orange sari and they compared them to the most uninhibited they take the extremes but it's a very rare thing when you have a behavioral assessment of a child in their infancy and then you bring image them about twenty years later when they're grown up so now you're making this out twenty years of your life story and again in the amygdala what they find is this if you look at the people who are uninhibited the either here's a novel face they see for the first time in the scanner or a face they see many times and there's not much difference for the people who are inhibited you see a much bigger amygdala response to the novel face well this is exactly what you might intuitively think shyness would be about if you're a shy person you know somebody well I think a lot of shyness disappears but where shyness shows the most is a face that you don't know a new person you haven't met and maybe you're not so comfortable with them yet so it's exactly the pattern you might expect that it doesn't matter too much for an extrovert a new face a familiar face from the made familiar in the experiment not somebody you really know it doesn't make much of a difference for the person who's inhibited much more responds to the face they see for the first time only as opposed to a face they've grown familiar with a couple more examples along this line here's another scale there's an infinite number of them the spielberger state and trade anxiety so state and trait right so they ask you this is just a reminder of that how do you feel right now that would be your state right now do I feel at ease do I feel upset and in general how do you feel at ease or upset so this is day-in day-out this is right now we're going to focus on the trait how you tell it how you say you feel the day-in day-out and now they're going to show you faces of people who are shown in full view or who are shown in a subliminal masked version where a fear of neutral face is followed by another face this is the critical phase so you see a face that you see pretty well or you see a face that's presented under circumstances where you can't tell what the face was okay and first they say what happens if we show you the regular face that you see perfectly well it makes much of a difference here's the amygdala response to a fearful face you've seen this now multiple times but kind of interesting you get a smaller response to the amygdala and it's driven by how anxious you report yourself to be on a regular basis so the interpretation is this if you see a fearful face you louts a fearful face I know it's a fearful face we're all the same if you subliminally present it you have an unknown source of danger what we intuitively imagine anxiety is is feeling danger or threat in your environment more than is helpful more than is comfortable okay and you don't even know exactly why it's not entirely rational when you're anxious in that way and so what happens is the more anxious you are the more these subliminal phases drive an amygdala response and you don't have control over that because you don't know what happened because it was subliminally presented does that make sense okay when it's clear everybody knows what to do it's just a face I'm not that scary but what it's an unknown source of a bit of unease the more chronically anxious you are the more the brain is responding or we might say the bigger the brain response is the basis perhaps of the chronic unease so we talked also before about the amygdala being important for recognizing fearful expressions and and then I want to two last examples how about genetic influences so we we know genes are a big part of the story but how big a part of the story so again we talked about single nucleotide polymorphisms common genetic variants and here's one that involves a serotonin transporter in the amygdala there's a short or long allele you can so you know when it will have two of these all of us the short allele is weakly correlated with anxiety traits all this genetic stuff is pretty weak at the moment for reasons that are not well understood I'm only presenting you ones that have been at least replicated once but there's practically every genetic example I'm going to show you there's been non confirmations as well we don't know why this is the genes are just so far away from complex human behaviors is probably the answer but what has been replicated a number of times is this if they show you fearful faces and you have the short allele the one that's slightly associate with anxiety this is the difference between people with the long goalie on the shorter leave a much more powerful response to fearful faces if you have the shorter allele so a single gene can be correlated with a more potent response to a sort of threat stimulus and again that goes with their sense of anxiety and when we might call a a less-than-desirable response to threat in the environment so here's the last two slides and I but it's it's the dream we all have in understanding people and actually all animals on the face of this planet but people most of all if you're curious about people which is what is the interaction between the genes were born with and the life we lead and how does that end up with us being us all right and it's incredibly hard to study that because everybody says in biology and neuroscience we know it's a gene by experience interaction that you know the genes will make you good strong in some circumstances and vulnerable and others but it's very hard to specify that the genes have been hard to identify and we can't put people into experiments we can't say you know what's like two identical twins and we'll put one into some horrible household full of stress and horribleness and went into a delightful household and then see them at 20 and see what happened okay we're just not allowed to do that right so we can't experiment on the environment and we don't the genes are poorly understood very poorly understood in relation to two basic human behaviors but there's a study from Casspi that you know is a glimpse of where we think the field might be going but I'm going to warn you that this has not always been replicated it's somewhat rough it's been replicated some times but not other times so it's a warrant as an asterisk but it's it's still a finding that's really quite striking if it turns out to be roughly correct so again this is this polymorphism of the same gene that's associated with anxiety and what they did in a very large sample in New Zealand was catalogue stressful life events ages 21 to 26 job how you do it whether you have a job or not your salary decent housing terrible housing good health bad health happy relationships no relations it's terrible relationships people are filling out forms telling you about the stresses in their life and then they also have information about childhood maltreatment some of these children it's very sadly when they were younger we're treated very poorly they were abused in some way or another we're in very terrible circumstances and some not so they're going to look at stressful events in childhood and adulthood and sort them out by the allele the individuals have the gene version and what they find is enough showing a graph in a moment more depression and suicidality in response to stressful events given them if you have the short version of the allele the short version we just said is the one that seems to drive a bigger anxiety response to fearful faces in the amygdala okay so it seems first pass to be a gene that's associated with responding in a more anxious way to environmental stress threat and bad things so here's a couple of graphs I'll just do a couple with you here's the probability of major depression if you've had no maltreatment as a child if you've probably had some or you've had documented horrible maltreatment as a child and what you can see if you have the long version this is this lines here the long version of this allele no difference it's as if it's as if if you happen to be born in a biological lottery that we all participate in at birth with these version of these genes and maybe many other genes that are part of the story list they just measure this one that it doesn't matter how people whether you live in a nice supportive environment or a brutalizing horrible one your probability of depression is about the same it's a protective gene for stresses of life that are visited upon you if you have the office of the short version look the worse the environment you double your chances of depression it's as if you're born with a gene that if you're given a terrible environment this is exactly interaction right then you're very susceptible to that and you see the same thing you know the same rough pattern all of them that the individuals who have this version of the gene seem to be relatively imper to environmental stressors the ones born with this version of the gene are terribly so you know if this person is born with this version of the gene but happens to be a nice supportive household no problem right okay but if they happen to be born into a household where they experience sadly severe maltreatment big problem and so this is exactly what we imagine if we understood any depth what people are about and they you know the genetic potentiation is you're born with what's easy for you or hard for you by genes and the world you're handed as an infant not under your control but the environment you're given supportive or threatening right how those two things play out and it sort of duet you know putting you making you safe or putting you at risk you know that's exactly what we've done would deeply understand the biology and the psychology of human life so this is a kind of thought he gets a lot of attention because if we had it exactly right which we don't yet we would understand something really deep about people and vulnerability and environments you

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 16 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011