Transcript

The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseWare at ocw.mit.edu. Sometimes psychologists like to talk about two aspects of our mind, the hot and the cool, okay? So, the cool parts we've been talking about recently, um, thinking parts like language, thought, things related to intelligence, problem-solving, you know, the rational aspects of of the human mind. And today we're going to focus on, you know, maybe the hottest of the hot, uh, the emotions that we feel and that, you know, sort of color our lives in terms of intensity and arousal and what matters to us.

Um, and so we'll talk a little bit about uh, just very briefly about a thumbnail history of the study of emotion, the scientific study of emotion, ideas about how to define it, uh, a few models of emotion, how emotion might work, some big questions about things is emotion universal? Uh, does go correlate to a bodily feelings? Why do we have emotion? And then things about the brain basis of emotions. So, we have a huge number of words, by one count, you know, about 550 words that describe, uh, the feelings we have, the emotions we have. Uh, and we have, you know, there's a lot of overlap conceptually among them, but we have so many words because we think that, we feel that from our daily lives, the feelings and emotions that we have are such a big part of our human existence, right?

How we relate to other people, uh, we feel when we're by ourselves. Emotions are just a big, big part of how we uh, go about our lives. Um, and uh, they're readily apparent to us everywhere we look on the faces of others, uh, positive emotions, negative emotions, fearful emotions. You see them around you all the time. So, uh, in psychology, a lot of sort of ideas about formulating the field go back to William James, who worked at Harvard, who articulated in many ways, uh, in language that's still relevant to this day, the basic ideas, the basic things about being a human, uh, that one wants to understand out of a psychology.

And as he wrote about emotion this way, if you can conceive of yourself suddenly stripped of all the emotion which which our world now inspires you, no one portion of the universe would have more important characteristics beyond another. And the whole character of its things and series and events would be without significance, character, expression, or perspective, right? That what we fear, what we desire, what we, uh, enjoy, all the, you know, what we find disgusting, we'll talk a little bit about disgust today, that all those things, uh, you know, tell us what's important and whether it's to be avoided or approached, enjoyed or loathed.

Um, and so, you know, people have thought about emotions, uh, you could pick a million different cultural directions. Here's a picture from Greek philosophy, but you could pick practically every culture around the world. You can't, right, be a human and not think about the feelings you have. Um, but kind of strikingly, in terms of research, uh, for a very, very long time compared to language or thinking or many topics, uh, people, uh, sort of didn't study emotion cuz it seemed hard to study scientifically. And it's still harder to study scientifically in many ways, I think, than than than than cognition, but there's been tremendous progress in bringing scientific approaches to understanding something about emotions in you and I.

Um, and, you know, like many things, it was reinvigorated around the Renaissance and the mystery of Mona Lisa's smile. Um, and now there's entire journals and conferences and organizations of scientific psychology devoted to study emotion. It's a big part of our lives, you would think in the study of the human mind and brain and be a big endeavor, and it is now, but that wouldn't have been true even 20 years ago. So, how might we, uh, define emotion just to sort of have some boundaries? So, we could say that emotions are biologically based responses to situations that are seen as personally relevant.

They are shaped by learning and usually involve changes in peripheral physiology, you know, your hands are trembling or things like that, your heart is pounding, expressive behavior, how you the intonation with which you speak, uh, the, uh, facial expression that you have or see in others, and subjective experience, you know, the emotions you have go with what you feel is going on inside you. Researchers try to distinguish between moods and emotions. And talk about moods as diffuse, long-lasting emotional states, you know, when you're in a funk or a positive mood over, you know, days, weeks, months.

Uh, that's not what we're going to talk about today. That's interesting and important also. We're going to talk about emotions, which are very punctate, immediate responses to situations, uh, to a specific thing or a specific stress or a specific uh, element of your environment, an immediate, strong response. And within that, one more distinction has turned out to be useful for for thinking about emotions between two dimensions, uh, arousal or you could call it intensity, and valence. So, arousal means things that are exciting, intense, if they're high arousal, or calm or lethargic, if they're low arousal.

Valence refers to whether it's a positive thing that makes you elated or or contented, negative, sad or gloomy. Um, and you can already see, for example, take take positive valence. Elated is high arousal, right? Contented, ah, that's low arousal, right? They're both positive, but they're kind of different. Um, so it's calm versus lethargic. Being calm can be sometimes good. Feeling really slow, really lethargic, right? Also it's low arousal, but it's usually not a desirable low arousal. And so people think that they can take basically these two dimensions, valence and arousal, and use it as a useful way to say something like calm is here, it's it's a little bit positive and it's it's low on on the arousal dimension.

Excited is up here, it's positive valence. And that different thing, gloomy, right, is is negative and it's it's fairly intense feeling as opposed to merely lethargic. So, that these two dimensions can cover a big sense of the life of emotions, uh, that inhabit us. And a huge question and one that's brutally hard to satisfy in some deep scientific way, of course, is is it restricted to humans? So, if you hang around pets and animals in various circumstances, you can't help but feel they have emotions. It's just very hard for us to ask them to fill out questionnaires telling us their emotions. So, you know, here's a a chimp that has lost its mother recently.

Uh, there's a dog going out for good all night. Here's an armadillo going, "Wee!" right? Looks looks pretty aroused. So, so, you know, we don't know how much of this in some cases is us reading human feelings into their expressions, how much of that is them feeling the same as we do. There's a lot of sense that obviously that many, uh, species have feelings as well as humans. We'll focus just on humans today. Um, and the other thing that's important is the shape by learning. What that means is many different things, but for example, they can vary in, uh, cultural from one culture to another in certain ways.

Um, and here's one example of a, you know, a movie that's bringing tears to everybody's eyes except this person who finds it utterly hilarious, okay? All right. And I if you work in emotion research, I could tell you you you get that. We show, you know, I worked a little bit in that. Um, you know, you you show some really horrible pictures, everybody goes, "Oh, horrible, horrible, horrible." And somebody else starts laughing. It's like horror movies. Have you been around horror movies where some people are really, you know, really scared out of their seats and very worried about the characters and other people think it's all pretty funny.

So, that's, you know, your perspective. So, it's not an automatic uh, response to certain many situations. So, how have people thought about, you know, the emotion you feel when a bear jumps out of your closet unexpectedly, right? Okay. Um, so here's the logical one. Okay, common sense, bear is scary, right? You feel fearful, that's your subjective experience, and your body starts to do things like your heart starts to pump, you your, uh, sweat glands start to sweat because you go, "This is dangerous, this is scary, here comes my body." That would be the intuitive Interestingly, you can all reverse the order and find some things that are better explained that way.

So, this is it's sometimes nice, sometimes people will say, "Oh my gosh, everything in psychology is so obvious." For some reason they always say my grandmother would have known it. I don't know why they picked that example. You know, show us something that science only can tell you, okay? So, here's a here's a very clever reversal from William James and and and also Lang. We they reversed it. They said that first comes the bodily response to the situation, and second comes your mind interpreting your body's primary response. The exact opposite order of why we feel as we do. He says, "We feel sorry because we cry, angry because we strike, afraid because we tremble, and not that we strike, cry, or tremble because we are sorry, angry, or fearful." See, it's exact opposite.

Here says, "First comes an emotion that's shaking your body in some way, and then comes your mind saying, "Aha, I'm afraid." You know, pretty fast, or I'm I'm happy or whatever. So, here's some examples cuz you could think, okay, yeah, you can cleverly reverse them, but is there any science to suggest that in some cases that relationship does reverse? So, here's what people did. I'll show you a picture of this. They said, "How can peripheral bodily events, things on sort of the edge of our bodies, influence the emotions we feel inside?" So, they would have people do things like hold a pencil tightly between their teeth and look at that pencil.

They're not told to smile, they're just told to keep that pencil there. And what does that look like? A smile, right? Okay. You've tricked the person's face into smiling and they don't even know that necessarily. They're thinking this is a weird psychology experiment about how long can you hold a pencil in your mouth? Although they're going to know something more in a moment. Um or between the lips, hold that pencil. Now, does this person look happy? No, a little bit not happy, right? Okay. All right. Okay. Uh and then you have them watch a funny movie that most people find funny. Uh and they rate how much they like it.

And the person who had uh this one rates it as more enjoyable than the person holding the pencil this way. As if already having the muscles in your face moved into a position that typically signals happiness or laughter, makes you feel happy inside and the funny movie, you know, is is even funnier. Being in a somewhat, you know, neutral to negative position makes that same funny movie seem less funny. You're interpreting the face you where your muscles are that normally go with one emotion or another and that's driving your internal final emotion about how you feel about the movie. Was there a question?

Well, does one require more concentration? So, you'd have to work That's an excellent question because we always like to say, "Oh, it's this thing." You know, what if this is a harder thing like that? And so, one would have to hope and I have to admit I don't know. Uh you know, that they controlled for things like that in some way. If you read the research paper, you'd want to be That's an excellent question. You know, if this is just harder work, then maybe you're less paying less attention to the movie just hanging on to that pencil. I I I don't know. And I I have to hope they did a good job and that's an excellent question.

We're Um and here's you know, other ones where again where they're trying to get the face to go smiley or go frowny. Uh and then they just ask them, "How do you feel?" And this person will say will rate themselves as feeling happier than this person as they answer on a piece of paper in front of them. Again, they're trying to say, you know, if I can move your peripheral facial expressions into uh your muscles into expressions, the feelings will follow from the expressions. Uh you can also do something else which is you can tell people. So, Paul Ekman, his name will come up a lot today. He's done a fantastic amount of the key research in this, uh making emotions into a research topic in many ways.

Uh What he developed is a way that he said, "I'm going to describe objectively which muscles are in which position for each of six fundamental emotional expressions." We'll come back to those. So, he you know, he would tell a person, "Raise your eyebrows and pull them together. Raise your upper eyelids. Now, stretch your lips horizontally back towards your ears." So, what he's giving this person step by step is directions that move the muscles into an into an expression of fear by the time you end up there. The participant usually doesn't know that cuz it's so weird, okay? You're moving your mouth, you're moving your it's just so weird, right?

But then they can do these kinds of experiments and, you know, these people will report a fearful movie as being more fearful than somebody who just gets to sit there or has or whose muscles are moved into a happy position. So, you know, all of a sudden you got all these peripheral things being interpreted by your mind as a signal for what emotion you have or enhancing it anyway. And then because any strong theory is usually turns out to be not nearly complicated enough, you get the wishy-washy middle but probably covers more of the truth, you know, which is both things are going on. Both you're having a subjective cognitive interpretation of your environment and a bodily response maybe more in parallel than one driving the other.

So, again, how can peripheral bodily events influence emotions? So, one idea that's floated around and probably true in there is that the perception or thought, your your mental interpretation of your emotion, tells you the type of emotion, okay? So, if if a bear jumps out, you know, you can say, "Okay, I know something's pretty intense and I can tell you right away it's bad." Okay? All right. But if something wonderful jumps out of your closet unexpectedly, uh then uh you know, there you go, "Oh my gosh, I can't believe, you know, that Lindsay Lohan is visiting me and I didn't even know it." And so, then um if that considered a good visit, uh you know, that you know, that that that would influence the again the interpretation, but that the intensity might come from the bodily parts.

How intense it is might be signaled from that. So, here's a couple ways that people have explored this. So, um here's a study from years ago from uh Schachter where he injected people with adrenaline. So, adrenaline is the uh neurohormone that goes with high arousal. It raises your heart rate uh or a placebo. So, he's directly taking the chemical that we normally produce under high arousal conditions. And the first question you might ask is and you might be curious about it if somebody gave you a shot of adrenaline, you know, what would you happen? Would you like jump out of your seat and run laps around the room?

What what did you do? And surprisingly all by itself not very much. People said they feel a bit jittery like if you've had maybe a little too much coffee or Red Bull is that the current Okay. Uh you know, see that little jittery feeling, but they're not like jumping it up and, you know, doing jumping jacks and one-armed push-ups and stuff like that. They're not having Okay. Now, having had the placebo or the adrenaline injected into you and you don't know that, it's uh they they show you an emotion eliciting They'll show you a movie like a horror movie. And the people who had the adrenaline will feel report more fear when they see the horror movie, more anger when they get insulted.

That's a fun experiment when you insult them, you know, they I'm sure the IRB had to be pretty careful. Uh more laughter for a comedy. So, the adrenaline seemed to amplify the intensity of the emotion, but the emotion was driven by the situation. Does that make sense? Okay. But here's something quite interesting about humans which is that if you told them, "We've given you adrenaline and it usually amplifies stuff," then it disappeared. Once the person knew that, they could discount that in their mind. So, it's not like adrenaline is your master, okay? And that I must have a twice as big a response.

Once you knew that was in the picture, then people the ratings went back to placebo. Okay. So, it's not that biology is destiny, but under normal circumstances it seems like the adrenaline accentuates the intensity. So, that would go with this possibility that peripheral stuff drives the intensity, peripherally injected adrenaline, um and and our minds' interpretation drives the content. Here's a sort of fun slightly sexist experiment um uh that in the end I think explains the following phenomenon. When you see a famous movie stars go into movie set on set or whatever they call it, you incredibly often hear about romances occurring between the leads, right?

And there's debates about whether it's just a press agent selling their movie or whatever, but you hear that all the time, right? Okay, so I'm going to tell you why that happens when it really happens. Okay. I can't really tell you that, but I can tell you a experiment that might touch on that, right? So, here's the experiment. Uh this was done by Dutton and Aron in North Vancouver, Canada and they did the experiment in an area where there were two bridges uh not not in right right next to each other, pretty near each other. One was a flimsy suspension bridge, 5 ft wide, swaying and wobbling 320 ft over jagged boulders and river rapids, right?

So, you have to imagine Indiana Jones, right? Okay. And like you come to this bridge and you go, "I don't know, you know, you know, okay." The other one upstream, same river, same Canadian district, there's a steady low broad bridge. No problem at all, right? You could drive your car over that, no problem. All right, two bridges over the same waters, one seeming scary, one not. That's what Then what they did is in the middle of each bridge they place an attractive, in this case female, confederate. Somebody should Maybe somebody's done the reverse gender experiment. I don't know that. This is um anyway.

And as men walk across the bridge, they ask them to fill out a questionnaire. Does it you know, some boring questionnaire. And they casually mention that if that person as they finish the questionnaire has more questions, he can call the woman providing the questionnaire at home and she provides him her home number. Okay? And the measure that they have is how many phone calls go from the male subjects to the female experimenter at home, okay? And they're betting that it's not really scientific curiosity that's driving a lot of the phone calling, all But here's what they actually find. More males will call that female at home use if they were on the dangerous bridge than on the safe bridge.

That's the actual finding. And the interpretation is this. The dangerous bridge because of the true feeling of danger produces high arousal, increased adrenaline, and that's misinterpreted or what if you want to call it that by the male because he thinks now he's super attracted to that woman because of the swaying bridge, okay? So, another reason to take your if somebody you want to win over of, you know, whatever whatever the gender situation is, you know, a really scary roller coaster ride, is highly recommended together with that warm beverage that as long as it doesn't spill on you, right?

I mean, I'm giving I'm making you too powerful to control people, right? Uh but uh you know, that that that again the arousal of the bridge has been misinterpreted by that person as as an intense attraction to that woman. And you could imagine making movies are probably high arousal exciting situations and that would promote romantic relations in in high intense situations that might not otherwise occur. Yeah. They had to randomly assign them to one bridge or the other. You would hope, you know, you would I can tell you this about a bunch of other experiments sort of like this this is the most what you could call ecological, silly, or sexist you could figure.

And but they all go with this idea that if you're in a high arousal situation, you sort of move over that arousal into whatever seems to be whatever it is you're encoding. Does that make sense? Okay. And in this case because you're creating an interaction between a man and a woman, it's promoting the probability of a sense of romance in the male. Is that okay? Uh uh uh uh But it could be any situation. It's the arousal will make it If it's something bad, it can make you feel worse about it. Uh totally excellent question. You're asking awesome questions. You know, now this is because you know I have to assume and this is I should know this but I don't that that they weren't Yeah, because if you had male self-selecting, you know, you had the some males running to the dangerous bridge drawn to danger and others saying, "Oh, please give me a safe road." Okay?

You know, is that the real difference? So you have to presume they did something to control that. Yeah, excellent question. Um Uh but but so the current view is, you know, something like that there's two factors that there's both there's a bodily response that happens pretty fast, pretty automatically, pretty unconsciously. There's a lot of interpretation and the combination of that bodily response and the interpretation leads you finally to the subjective experience you have. And probably works differently for different emotions and things are complicated. I'll just say but the order you know, we're pretty far from this first guess in terms of the fact that peripheral things can have very powerful effects on how you interpret situations.

The intensity with which your interpretations and the intensity itself can change the behavior that follows the situation. So three questions in the field are are emotions universal? Are they in you from when you're born? Are they same for people around the world? Do they have unique physiological signatures? Could we define if we knew your heart rate, if we knew your you know, your pulse and so on, could we know what emotional state you're in? And then speculations as to why we have emotions at all. What's the use of having emotions? So brilliant as he is in so many ways in many ways this dialogue began in modern times with Charles Darwin who knows that animals had very striking facial expressions as we saw before and that made him think about the evolution of facial expressions.

Uh this was one of his drawings of a of a cat. Uh-huh. So here's infants having early displays of emotions and so people have been very joy, disgust, surprise, sadness, anger, fear. So people have been very impressed that very early on infants are having the full array of expressions. Of course, they might see them you know, from moments from their birth. They have people around them but it's very early. That's almost for sure. A really interesting line of research I'll show an example has been looking at emotional expressions, emotional facial expressions in people who are born deaf or born blind.

So they never hear intonation, they never see a facial expression, right? They can't learn it from their environments. So there there are there are sort of a natural window into are these inborn in us or do we learn it from people around us? So here's an experiment where they took spontaneous facial expressions of emotion in athletes from both the Olympics and the Paralympics. And they looked especially at congenitally blind people who were born blind, never saw a face and sighted athletes. And they looked at the expressions after winning or losing an Olympic level match. Before I show you this, you may know the story.

You know, what are the what happens after an Olympic event? Somebody wins and where do they go? Do they go You know this podium thing? The gold medal winner's up here and the silver's here and the bronze is here. They've also done studies. This is just a side note saying, "Who looks the happiest in those pictures?" The bronze medal winner. Who looks the saddest in those pictures? The silver, right? Cuz the bronze medal winner's going "Thank goodness I came in third place. I'm in the podium. I have an Olympic medal. If I was fourth place, fourth through infinity gets the same Olympic medal, right?" Okay.

The silver medalist, what's he or she thinking? On average, "Man, if I had just you know, one more fractions of a millisecond, I could be the gold medalist, right?" Okay. So it's kind of an interesting thing of you know, when we consider things satisfactory or not. But now let's turn turn back to this question. So here's two people who just lost Olympic medal matches. And your question is, which is the sighted person and which is the blind person? And to the extent it's hard to be certain, that would be a big suggestion that these expressions are inborn in us because a person who's never seen a sad expression still has a sad expression.

And the answer is uh that's the blind athlete and that's the sighted athlete. So it's pretty convincing I think that these are we're born with this set of expressions as a core entity of of being human. Even though we're born with that, you know, we live in different cultures, in very different cultures around the world and even within countries and across countries. And so how how universal are these sorts of things? And there's lots of evidence of a degree of influence of cultures even with around this core universality. Um So does a smile mean friendship to everyone? And again Ekman and Izard studied made a big study in which they argued that as far as they can tell in looking around at facial expressions there's six basic emotional expressions that signal feelings.

Happiness, sadness, fear, anger, surprise, or disgust. These are all you know, people who are trained to try to make the perfect expression of those things. Okay? They look kind of weird by themselves, right? They look kind of weird. You don't see a neutral one here. Maybe we'll see a neutral one later. Neutral is kind of weird cuz you go, "Well, it's neutral." But I can tell you a totally neutral face looking at you is can be kind of creepy, right? You know, cuz if you interact with somebody and like they have no expression at all, that's a little disturbing, right? So cuz normally we're you know, but these these these are ones that are pretty universally recognized.

Um but not completely. So let's take Westerners, people from the United States or Europe. You know, we're not perfect at that even with these posed pictures. This is how often people came up with the correct labels. Pretty often, not perfect. So there's a lot of mystery at the edges of this. But here's how people came up from non-Western cultures for the same Western faces. Well above chance but you know, not the same as Westerners looking at Western expressions. And that it would reverse if if if Westerners had to look at non-Western expressions. So there's definitely a degree of cultural influences on the recognition of these expressions as well.

It's partly innate and universal and there's there's a cultural overlay as well. Um this is a joke. Shoot. You got not only the wrong planet but you got the wrong solar system. I mean a wrong planet I can understand but a wrong solar system. And you can tell with just a little information that this is a sheepish smile of embarrassment and this is a little bit of the body expression of you know, a little bit of irksomeness, right? Irked. Okay. But here you know, here's a an isolated preliterate tribe in New Guinea and that smile looks like the smile of any kid you ever saw. Um That's sadness. This sadness of any kid you ever saw.

There's a little bit of a disgust, right? Um Um and so people have built up a model something like there's things in the environment that happen that drive some sort of a facial affect program. Your your muscles in your face move to express a six or so or different kinds of feelings. Uh cultural rules about what what should you show, what should you not show in different cultures. Some faces expressions are more appreciated than others and finally all of that moves into the facial expression you make. So now second question we ask. So we see we think to a first approximation emotions at least as far as we can tell are pretty universal but there's cultural and learned ex uh pieces as well.

Do emotions have unique physiological signatures? Could we tell from your physiology what you're feeling? And there was a lot of hope that this would work cuz we intuitively emotions differ from one another. We our body feels different as we go from one emotion to another. Um And we use language words like she got hot and bothered, you make my blood boil, he's just letting off steam. All these are you know, there's a different physiology go with different feelings. And so people hoped they could make decision trees like this. Let's measure your heart rate, higher or low. Well, if it's high, then we get your skin temperature and then we can tell if you're angry or fear or sad.

Then you could make a decision tree by looking at peripheral measures of physiology but it never worked. Yeah, it was it's never been strongly discriminating. People have not been able to have a you know, physiological fingerprint for the emotion that you feel that's reasonably accurate. It's Yeah. So what are they counting as something that they could go in that tree? For instance, could they measure a chemical concentration in place? It's possible. Yeah, here's a very good question. Here they're measuring peripheral physiology or autonomic systems, skin temperature, heart rate. Could there be other things like chemicals, right?

So um I'd say yes but we just don't know them well enough, right? Or could you have brain measures that ultimately would be sophisticated enough? I can tell you the brain measures are not that good at that now. Okay. But could they be someday? Yes. So yes, it's the specific measures that we have. You know, a really deep question will be at some level, you know, when you're fearful and I'm fearful, how identical will those be, right? Depending on our cultural background, depending on situations we've experienced. You know, we can both say we can both agree we're scared of something but it could be pretty different, right?

Okay. Um So it's a really deep question, right? When you know, in the end how close are these things from one person to another? Now at least as speculative as why we have emotions. And you know, sometimes obviously it's helped Sometimes people think it's intrapersonal functions within us. We're organizing ourselves. What's our basic feeling? Are we basically happy or sad about something or fearful of something? Um so that we use that feeling as a source of information to sort of pull ourselves to say like this is basically where I'm at. It's a source of information for me. And they can tell me what behavior makes sense to do in this context.

And then from one person to another interpersonally, what does that person feel? What am I signaling to that person? So, um here's an experiment and I'll show you just a brief YouTube video on this cuz this thing is really cute. But it's almost a life and death experiment, although no infants was harmed in the making of this experiment, okay? So, so what they do is this is a visual cliff. So, they have a uh infant is put on this, a very tiny baby. Here it's plexi-hard plexiglass. There is no danger to the baby. Okay? But uh there is a drop here and a drop here. Now, as the baby approaches this, you know, they're not used to the idea of plexiglass.

Even you and I would be pretty worried about that I think if it was on a larger scale, right? We want to be pretty sure about the strength of that plexiglass. But to the infants' eyes, they're approaching what they call a visual cliff. On the other side, I'll show you the film in a moment. I is a mother. And the mother can either be showing a positive expression or a negative expression. And look what happens to the infants in this perilous situation where they see a drop, you know, that's, you know, pretty big, okay? And how much they trust their mother's expression to know what to do. So, if the mother is looking happy like it's okay, this is going to be great, we're having a lot of fun, three-quarters of the time the infant goes for it.

If the mother looks scary, never. Okay? They're making kind of a dangerous decision entirely on the facial expression of the mother and their trust that the mother knows the right thing to do and is giving them the right advice. So, it's it's I mean, you know, sometimes, you know, everything psychology can just seem like, oh, it's just another thing. But facial expressions are an unbelievable powerful way that we communicate with one another. Um So, uh here's an extremely clever experiment from Adam Anderson and I you know, who who happened to be a post-doctoral fellow in my lab, but he did this completely independently.

Which is this Here's the question. So, okay, we have some different expressions and you could say, well, are they completely random as to what the actual expression is? We haven't even asked this. You know, like, why does a smile go one way and a frown go the way? Does it mean anything? Or are they just arbitrary signals of different emotions that have evolved over time? And he's almost the first person I know who even asked this question. I mean, and he looked at two emotions um that we'll come back to in just a little bit. Fear and disgust, okay? Uh and he he thought, well, look, it's kind of interesting what fear and disgust do.

For example, fear, your eyes get bigger. Disgust, think about it, something really Think about like something really stinky, okay? You know, you close your eyes, you sort of scrunch up your nose. Here, look at this, right? And he looked at what he looked at and measured how airflow patterns and different things happen when you go into those expressions, okay? Non-arbitrary properties of an expression, right? And then he did psychological expressions. He got people to get into these expressions and he found that if they were in a fearful expression, that they would feel like they had a wider field of view.

Uh and if it's disgust, a smaller. Now, think about this for a moment. When it's fearful, do you want to feel like you want to know what's going on around you? Right? Or do you want to think to sit back and think about, you know, stuff? Or do you want to say like, uh-oh, right? Where do I run? What's going on? When you go into some disgusting situation and you you know, do you want to really look around a lot? Or are you kind of happy to find some way out of it, right? Okay? Same thing with your nose. Um here's the air velocity that's passing through your nose when you're fearful and when you're disgusted.

Now, you don't you don't even think about that and you're like, who's thinking like, I'm controlling my air velocity, right? But why do you think you might want to really sample your environment when you feel danger? Visually and all in an olfactory way. Why do you think you might want to sample it? Well, you want to know what's going on. You want the information as fast as possible. Do I run? Do I duck? What do I do? Do I fight, flee? You know, what do I do? I have moments to decide cuz I'm in danger, right? If you're if you're in a disgust situation, are you interested typically in exploring the olfactory environment in as much detail as you can?

Right? Okay? Usually not, right? Okay, so it's kind of interesting. So, the very first time I know this very clever ask, do Where do these expressions come from? Um well, maybe they tend to a certain extent to exaggerate or diminish forms of sensory input that are relevant for the emotion. Um So, for the last little bit I'm going to talk about for a little while here what we know about the brain basis of some emotions. So, we already talked about the idea that the amygdala plays a special role in fear and I'll show you a couple different ways in which that's true. So, this is uh just sitting in front of the hippocampus, one on the left and one on the right, the core elements of your limbic system.

Um here's is viewed from the side, the amygdala. Um uh here's here's the actual amygdala from a postmortem brain. And there's another whole level of analysis that animal researchers do that we can't touch today, which is the amygdala itself is made out of bundles of neurons called nuclei, very distinct ones that have different roles, different inputs, different outputs. And in animal research where you can selectively in, you know, influence one or the other, you can see they have quite different specific roles. In humans, we don't have that precision of control, so we sort of have have some clump average statements about the amygdala, but really we're mixing together a few functions.

So, you already saw this picture that animals that mice or rats that have an amygdala removed lose the fear they ought to have of a cat. Um In primate studies, they found that if they have amygdala lesions, the loss of threat appreciation impairs social fitness. The animals that don't know what they ought to be afraid of get into big trouble. Uh they they lose their their position in dominance hierarchies. You may know primate groups tend to have dominant hierarchies, the sort of alpha male and so on. They slide down that. Um uh if they lesion the dominant male, the alpha male, the male who wins all the fights and controls the group, the animal that animal fall down the hierarchy and become subordinate.

Um and in the wild, they've shown that if they do lesions and return the animal to a social situation, they get rejected by the other animals because the other animals feel there's something weird about the animals and they're often isolated and they get to early death because the other animals are not helping them or supporting them. So, you know, very important for learning what's dangerous. Here's an experiment with rhesus monkeys lesioned at 2 weeks as infants, returned to their mothers and tested at 8 weeks. And here's an example of something. So, this is if you show an animal a novel object and this is how often they respond to it.

Young animals will will often not explore it because they go, well, I don't know, that could be dangerous, right? They're They're waiting for their mother's expression, right? Here's the other animals with the amygdala lesions, they'll explore it. In a sense, they're fearless. But that's probably not, you know, an ideal thing to do when you're an infant exploring the world. Um or they'll put food near food only or food next to a play snake. Okay, snakes are dangerous for monkeys. They usually don't want to figure out at this age, you know, is it a play monkey? Is it a play snake or a real snake?

They just say, I don't really need to eat that, okay? So, everybody likes the food, put the snake next to it and the control animals go, no, I don't think so, right? Basically, the amygdala ones, you know, what's for dinner, right? And the answer is if it's a real snake, you're for dinner, right? Okay, so they lose the fear of things they ought to have fear of. If they have this they lose the things fear of unknown things, fear of things they ought to be afraid of. So, the amygdala plays this really important role. Fear sometimes is maybe the best understood emotion in terms of brain processes and maybe the most studied partly cuz we've had some success in understanding what's going on and partly because fear is the maybe the emotion that's most people think is closest to survival.

You fear what kills you, you fear what pains you. That's a very powerful emotion for survival and safety. Um and you can do fear conditioning. We talked about conditioning before in, you know, all species from humans to primates, other mammals, fruit flies. You can do all of them have to a first approximation similar fear conditioning. It's as if, you know, if you're alive, you have to fear things that are scary and dangerous. Um so, people have done fear conditioning experiments and now you know this very well. You know, you met your tone that's not scary at first. If you put it with something that you don't like like a foot shock, you get fearful to the tone.

And what people have discovered kind of remarkably is that you can make lesions in many parts of the brain and you don't affect that learned fearfulness to the tone. Uh but if you make a damage in the part of the amygdala, you abolish that learning. These animals fail to learn the signal of something that is coming up to be painful and dangerous. Uh and you can even make large lesions in the cortex, that doesn't affect anything. And these animals with the amygdala lesions, they have an intact unconditioned response. When they get the shock, they jump like the other animals. They don't like it.

Okay, it's not that they can't feel pain. They can't learn that the tone predicts the painful stimulus. They can't learn the warning signal of danger. Um there's very few patients with amygdala injuries only, but there's a few. So, here's a patient SM who's been studied by Damasio and his colleagues. Uh this is where the amygdala ought to be. It's a developmental disorder where this is calcified very early in development. It's not an adult lesion, but it seems to be fairly amygdala specific. And people have done a couple of experiments with these patients to and it's it's sort of guided our understanding of what the amygdala does in you and I.

So, here's one example where they did conditioning. Again, in this case they didn't use shocks, they used a super loud boat horn, okay? That's pretty noxious to people. People don't like it. Uh and they preceded that with something gentle that warned you it was coming. So, uh here's here's the initial response and then now and then and then here's the important thing. With humans, of course you can well, let me just say they they'll manage they they managed a skin response to have a galvanic skin response uh to the bad tones. So, here's the conditioned stimulus uh uh uh you know, the response to the um to the uh boat horns in the conditioning uh that what predicts the boat horns.

Here's the part here's the response to the to the baseline. And here's the performance of patients with amnesia uh who have the amygdala spare or controls, I'm sorry, who both can tell you they're responding selectively to the scary tones and also remember perfectly well. When you at the end of the testing you session, go what went on? And they say, oh yeah, well well when I got one signal I got a horrible boat horn and when I heard the other signal I got nothing, okay? It's easy, right? Okay. You do that for half an hour. One you get one visual signal that means boat horn coming up, one visual signal nothing coming up.

If you have patients who have amygdala lesions, that galvanic skin response doesn't happen even though they tell you perfectly well afterwards what happened. So, they know just like everybody else that they got a certain signal that went with a noxious boat horn. But their body is not learning that association. If a person has hippocampal damage, their body learns that association, but they don't remember it afterwards consciously. So, you can you can separate the two kinds of learning, a hippocampal dependent learning of the facts of the session and an amygdala dependent learning which is a bodily response to learning that something is dangerous and unpleasant.

Now, we often learn things like the visual cliff without having to have a boat horn and practice, right? If somebody tells you that something is dangerous or you figure out that something is dangerous, you don't have to go through a terrible experience to pretty much decide you're not going to do it. So, here's an experiment um that was uh aimed at showing you that. So, what people were shown there's a funny human subjects wrinkle to this, I'll just tell you. This occurred at Yale. Where they had a a blue square came on. That means safe, you can just relax, nothing bad's going to happen. But when the yellow square comes on, get ready you might get a somewhat unpleasant shock, okay?

But they never give them a shock. So, there's no you're not learning that way. You're just you just factually learn that something is safe and something is dangerous. And here's the amygdala response to the scary one, to a neutral situation, and to the one where you know, ah, I'm safe, okay? So, you never got the shock. You never got the shock. You were just told about the shock. You didn't have to get it, but you're human, you can figure this out and your amygdala is going, you know, I can just figure out that's dangerous, that's baseline, and that's not that's the absence of danger, positive safety, okay?

Uh and the Yale IRB, hilariously I think, uh said that, oh, but you're deceiving the people cuz you tell them they're going to might get a shock and they never got a shock, so you have to give them one shock at the end of the experiment, so there's a So, dutifully the experimenters gave them one shock after the experiment was over, so they were honest because during the experiment as they measured the brain activation in the amygdala responding to the threat of pain without any pain being associated, right? We're smart, we can learn something is dangerous just by thinking it through and it engages the same part of the brain that learns by actual painful experience.

Now, how about memory? So, here's the way this ex- this study was done. Uh People viewed a slide story with an emotional middle section. So, an example would be this. Parents are home having breakfast with a kid, you know, uh uh parents go to work, kid walks to school. Kind of tragically, but these are all slides again, nobody was injured. Uh child is hit by a car. Something high arousing happens in the middle of the story. Everybody runs to the hospital, the kid is okay. When people ask a week later or something like that, I think three weeks a week later, um tell me about the stories I told you last week.

There's a number of stories. People have best memory for the part where something highly arousing happened like the child was hit by a car. That makes sense, right? Kid having breakfast, huh? You know, kid okay, huh? Car accident with a kid, you're aroused and you remember that better. So, emotion is amplifying memory. The patients with the amygdala lesions don't have that memory bump based on emotion. Emotion is not enhancing their memory. And you can imagine that there's a pretty good reason for emotions to enhance memory, right? If something is fearful, delightful, horribly disgusting, those are all good reasons to remember, you know, let's do that again if it's great, let's avoid that if it's terrible, right?

Okay? I mean, it's a good idea for emotions to drive memory formation and in your brain and mine, it appears the amygdala has this role of transforming emotions into memories. Um Now, we also talked about six facial expressions and I showed you this before. The same patients have trouble in recognizing fearful facial expression. So, kind of the amygdala in so many different ways, learning uh memory, perception of faces seems to play this huge role in fear. And kind of interestingly um because you might have the intuition and this, you know, a lot of this came from Freud. Um you know, that a lot of our emotions are happening kind of under our conscious awareness, okay?

We almost discover them after like, why am I angry at this person or why am I so happy? We have to think it through almost. Uh if you show subliminal fearful faces versus happy faces subliminally presented so people can't tell you what the face expression was, still they turn on the amygdala. So, unconscious perception of a fearful face engages the amygdala. You don't have to go through consciousness. Cortical blindness, we talked about that earlier in the course where you're blind in one visual field, and yet individual patients, a couple of them with cortical blindness, if they were shown a fearful stimulus in the cortically blind field, still turned on in the cortically blind field, the amygdala uh for a fearful face versus a happy face.

Which indicates that a non-conscious subcortical pathway that doesn't intersect with uh conscious thought or cortex is sending information from your eyes to your amygdala, okay? A different pathway. Um and people have speculated that, you know, maybe again because fear is survival and danger, we might have a super highway of information that sends dangerous information immediately to your amygdala. It doesn't wait for you to think a lot, so to speak, in your cortex. Boom, you know. Yeah, danger danger danger even before you process the rest of the situation. So, we talked about fear and the threat in the amygdala.

Just to say a word about disgust. People think that maybe a a reason, you know, there's many reasons things we can be disgusted at or about, but that maybe in terms of evolution, it might have been a pretty good signal for contaminated food, food that makes you sick, right? Things to avoid that makes you sick. And it turns out another part of the brain called the insula is um pretty important for that. So, here's the amygdala left and right. Here's the insula that you have left and right in purple outlined in purple. And again, just like with the amygdala, patients with uh uh uh lesions of the insula don't recognize facial expressions and imaging wise if you see a disgusted face, that turns on that part of the brain as well.

So, those are two those are the best understood brain pieces of emotion by far. So, now those are patient things, so let me turn for a moment now lastly to a few imaging studies of typical people in in some topics on emotion. So, here's the terrible pictures from 9/11 um the horror of the moment and and we always imagine we'll remember and we've already talked a little bit about this in flashbulb memories, emotionally things correctly for a long time. The horror of that moment the king went on, I shall never forget. This is Lewis Carroll through the looking glass. You will though, the queen said if you don't make a memorandum of it.

And now you know that Lewis Carroll was talking about the amygdala, right? You didn't know that before, but you know that now because if the amygdala isn't there, the emotional intensity doesn't make the memory more permanent or more powerful. Um so, Larry Cahill uh UC Irvine did the first brain study on this topic. And what he did is he showed people uh uh students while they were getting PET scanning, positron emission tomography, um uh films, short films that were either powerfully emotional or neutral. And then he brought them back three weeks later and he here's what he found. The more activation there was in the amygdala, each square here is a different person, the more they remembered the emotional stuff.

But it didn't matter for neutral things. So, the amygdala seems unimportant for neutral information, but the more it was engaged, the more they remembered emotional information. So, this is sort of evidence in the typical human mind of the relationship between the amygdala and emotional memories. So, here's an experiment uh actually that we did um at Stanford where we show people stimuli that were either neutral, somewhat negative. And I'm going to show you something that's very negative. If you don't want to look, close your eyes for a moment. Close your eyes, here we go. Very negative. Okay.

Sorry. All right. Uh It turns out if we don't show you something that negative, it's hard to get your brain pumped up. This is uh it doesn't have to be all these that sad, but it has to be pretty intense. Okay. So, we show you things like this, and we record your brain response for each of those. Um and here's what we do. We ask you to tell us how bad is this. So, the baby picture was bad, right? Okay. For most people. Um we wait 3 weeks, pretty long time, and then we test your memory uh for the scenes from before. Okay, we test your memory 3 weeks later, pretty long time. And here's what we see it.

Two things. Um so, one in the left amygdala in this study, uh here's what you rated as terrible, pretty bad, somewhat bad, and neutral. So, the amygdala is responding to your subjective sense of terribleness. Now, you know, uh we're really looking at arousal and negativity. We didn't see positive We didn't look at positive ones. I can tell you in other studies uh and here's a trick in research. I'm going to tell you now, I only have a couple more slides, but I'm going to tell you a little bit about insider things on imaging just so you could you understand imaging is as human and fallible a form of research as anything, which you might suspect anyway, right?

So, uh So, uh you know, so you know, we we we we we show these things uh and we we got these responses. Okay. So, that's going with your subjective sense of how bad uh films are. And then when we tested people's memory, um what we also found was that memory was best when we got the biggest amygdala response. So, that's That's just like you heard before, okay? So, that all seemed fine. The line ones you know, lined up with the prior result. Um but here was the slight surprise and a thing that followed. Um and they still get cited fairly often. It's It's the research that I've been affiliated with that gets still cited most often in the newspapers and magazines.

So, um anyway. So, this was the study you saw before, and the thing I didn't emphasize to you was that this was in the right amygdala in the right hemisphere. Doesn't really matter, it just happened to be that. Our study at Stanford was in the left hemisphere. This is where we were getting the emotion memory responses. And so, we were we were very deep scientists, okay? And we said, "What could be going on? You know, why is Larry Cahill at uh UC Irvine getting it in the left amygdala? The more active it is, the more you would remember emotional information. And why are we getting it in the right Was he getting in the right amygdala and we're getting in the left amygdala?

Okay. Um so, we we took a piece of paper, we wrote down the different things that people had found. Oh, the story I was going to tell you is about Stefan Hamann's study. So, Stefan Hamann at Emory did a study where he said, "Okay, all this amygdala response to negative things, does it also respond to positive things?" That's a good question, right? And the answer is yes. But it turns out in many experiments it doesn't look that way because you saw, for those of you who looked at horrible-looking baby picture, what would be an equal positive powerful picture? Let's try this one. Everybody agrees it's cute when there's little children around a birthday cake.

Okay? Smile, I see smiles, right? All right. All right. Powerful? Unless it's your kid, maybe. Powerful image? Powerful as the face of the infant? No, okay. So, it's very hard to get It's really interesting thing. It's very hard to get positive stimuli that are as potent as negative stimuli. It's just You can get a million negative stimuli from the internet, and it's very hard to get very positive ones. Okay. Having said that, we said, "Let's let's think about the negative ones for the moment." So, you know, we our studies were fMRI, PET, PET. Ours were all with women, and these were all with men.

And you could go, "Well, why did that happen? Okay, it's good that it's half women and half men, you know, because these were positron emission tomography. These uh that involves injecting radioactive stuff into people to do that kind of imaging, and many uh IRBs say, "Well, let's not have women do it because they could be unknowingly pregnant. They could be, and we shouldn't be giving radioactive stuff just for an experiment." Okay? You could have debates about that, but that's what the thought you know, why not let the men get their radioactive stuff. Okay, we we don't really need them. All right.

Uh so, that And then so when we did the study, we said, "Well, these are all with men, it seems in fairness we should do with women, too." You know, we we just thought it seemed fair kind of, you know, we didn't have any big thought about that. And um you know, and and again, we were getting left amygdala and they were getting right amygdala. Pictures or films, different you know, and this caught our eye that we had done studies with women, we were getting left amygdala, they did it with men with right amygdala. So, deep scientists that we were, Larry Cahill said, "I'll test you know, men and women." And we said, "We'll test men and women." And here's what we found.

And these are averages, but one critical thing what that we discovered, we didn't know this is that to the extent And these are averages, of course these are averages. Uh uh that you compare men and women on average, women have better memory for emotional life events, faster production of autobiographical to memories to cues, more accurate in dating memories. So, these dating studies are pretty useful because you never know how accurate a person is when they have a memory for something. What they do in the dating studies is they have people who are dating keep diaries, for example, in the fall semester, okay?

And presumably those are reasonably accurate, they're filling them in every day. And then, you know, things happen over the holidays, and some people remain dating and some don't, right? So, you go back to them in March, and you go, "In your fall, when the two of you were going out, you know, tell us about what you did in November, and you know, and they can say who's more accurate, okay? And they have almost a virtual record because they have the responses that the men and the women put down that day. And on average, these are averages, the women were more accurate. And wives score higher than husbands on vividness of memories of first date, last vacation, recent argument.

Okay, so these are all averages, there's lots of overlap, but on average it's that way. And so, Larry Cahill went and did this thing, and sure enough, again, as he found before for men, the more they turn on the right amygdala, the more certain they were to remember negative films. And for women, the more they turn on the left amygdala, the more certain they would remember negative films. On average. Now, a thing to know is, on average again, uh when you have people rate the kinds of pictures we use, how do you think was your Here it is, and this is one example where your stereotype guesses probably play out for the averages.

Um who rates this as more scary or who says it's more scary, men or women? Okay. So, what? Positive or negative? I just I said it's for positive or negative. So, here's women not finding this a particularly on average, and there's a range of responses, not finding this particularly a positive picture. Here's men going, "Pretty cool, you know, where did What division did that come from?" Okay. So, you know, people are always asking like uh you know, what does this really mean? Are men just knowing they have to do this or whatever? The question you're Who knows? Okay, there's no answer to this about whether it's social things or biology.

It's probably certainly social things are a big part of the story. Um when we have people rate the pictures in the scanner, here's the women rating Here's the worst pictures. And look at the men, they're less willing to rate these pictures as bad. Again, psychologists, you know, who see these data say, "Well, maybe the men think you're never supposed to rate them as bad cuz you know, cuz we're tough guys and nothing's so bad, right?" I mean, I don't know, who knows, okay? But these are just the ratings. Um Now, if we look at the activation of men and women on the left as they rate them, the worse they rate it, the more intense they find it, the more they turn on their left amygdala.

So, at the moment they're rating them, men and women look very similar. But when we relate it to their memory, two things happened. First, the women did have superior memory to the men. These were Stanford undergraduates, probably not that dissimilar on average to people in this room. And quite strikingly, as you saw it, activation in the right hemisphere predicted memory in men and left hemisphere for women. So, I know there's been a lot a lot of right and left. But here's the Here we think was the message, and you know, the it's kind of stood the test of time a little bit on average. So, uh what you see here is the part of the left amygdala turn on for women as they're rating it, more intense, the more active, uh in relation to whether they form a long-term memory, the more active, the more likely they'll remember it, and kind of the physical overlap of the two.

In men, more active on in in that amygdala on the left during the rating, but doesn't seem to be involved in memory formation. Um in the hippocampus, again, overlap, overlap, overlap, no apparent overlap in the men. So, what happens literally in the brain, I mean, literally as far as we can measure it, in women on average, there was more overlap between the parts of the brain brain engaged as you evaluate something, and the parts of the brain that make the memory of that. And in men is on average it was as if here's my emotional rating on the right, and here's what I'm going to remember on the left.

Kind of a separation of those processes in the most simple sense. Now, here's a huge question. Does this brain imaging study, you know, tell us anything about whether this is in the genes of boys and girls as they're born, or a consequence of socialization, or both? It's incredibly intuitive for people to think that if you see it in the brain, it's hardwired and genetic, or hormonal, or something. Okay? Brain imaging data never tells you that. It never tells you that. It just tells you by this age, this is what's going on. And you don't have to know much psychology to know that we're all hugely influenced uh to varying degrees, but we're all hugely influenced by social influences on what it is to be a male or female in our families, in our cultures, in our societies.

Whether something's in your genes or in your culture, it shows up in your brain, right? Okay. And we can't tell those two things apart. You know, is this anything to do with how we're born? Is this anything to do with how Hollywood pitches, you know, uh movies that are about video game battles versus flick What is it? Chick flicks? Is you know, and how you know, and they're how they're pitching that and trying to tell us we're supposed to like something, you know? Who knows? We can't tell if it's social or genetic at all.

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 15 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011