Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu so when we talked about learning we said that you know everything we know comes from learning except that which is given to us by our genes our knowledge of how to walk around in the world to read to think to talk to feel the values we have the hopes we have the fears we have they're all learned through experience and then we talk about another approach to thinking about how we learn things through memory and today I'm going to talk about what we understand to be the brain organization of human memory and Oliver Sacks in the chapter and the lost Mariner chapter 2 talks about one of the two major kinds of amnesia the loss of memory due to a brain disorder of brain injury but he has a very nice language from Liesman yell talking about memory you have begun to lose your memory if only in bits and pieces to realize that memory is what makes our life life without memories no life at all our memories our coherence our reason our feeling even our action without it we are nothing I can only wait for the final amnesia the one that erases an entire life as I did my mother's right so our memories of our lives what we've done you know where we've been what mattered to us that's a huge piece of who we are and he runs into a patient who has who came into the hospital early 1975 with a note saying helpless demented confused and disoriented he had a perty had what we call clinically korsakoff's syndrome see these are individuals who have a severe alcoholism for many years and a subset of those people develop a severe memory disorder like this man he's 49 years old he tells sachs about his life details of his life going into World War two that he worked on a submarine and so on and it says Sachs has a full an interesting life remember visually in detail but for some reason his memory stopped around World War two then he asked him what year is it remember the years 1975 and he says it's 1945 what do you mean we've won the war FDR Franklin Delano Roosevelt is dead Truman's at the helm these are great times ahead and Jimmy how old would you be he stopped he said well I guess I'm 19 that would have been his age you know 20 years ago right 30 years ago so you know he's stuck in time he thinks it's historically a while ago he has two completely wrong age and sex takes out a mirror and throws the denim and says what do you you know what happened and he gets he says Jesus Christ what's going on what happened is this a nightmare my craziest as a joke such as if he's lost the last 30 years of his life and he's living as if it were 30 years ago and then when he walks back in he's hardly recognized Sachs is hardly recognized by the person on intelligence he shows excellent ability but his memory is very quickly he forgets things what is this I asked him rubbing a photo in the magazine I was holding it's the moon no it's not if it's a picture of the Earth taken from the moon I mean don't forget 1945 nobody imagined that we would be sending up people to the moon right and taking pictures from the moon of the earth you're used to it is nothing to you no it's not it's a picture taken for the moon doc you're kidding somebody would have to get a camera up there naturally hell you're joking how would you know that so he has um you know he's has lost the last 30 years of his life for all practical purposes despite normal intelligence and normal thought so we're going to talk more about how this occurs in patients and other patients and and more generally how the brain supports you ability to learn things so here's this remarkable brain right and in one sense you could say it's almost all there to absorb things in life right yeah you know you have very small insects that can do a lot with the genes are given we have big brains to sort of learn the life we lead and I'm going to come back at the end to this metaphor with the idea that in many ways your brain as you sit there right now or any healthy brain is kind of like a symphony orchestra that has many specialized instruments for learning different kinds of things and you feel like a unified whole and you are and these instruments interact with each other but just like a symphony orchestra you know together they make a sound so imagine you're a Martian who lands outside of Symphony Hall and you hear a symphony playing is something beautiful well that sounds really interesting if you're a Martian on the outside of the Symphony Hall how many instruments are you guessing how many things you might you guess they are making that sound would you have any idea one big one two big ones fifty you would be very hard to guess and it's only been in the last 20 years or so that we had some real clarification on the instruments of learning in our brains so I'm going to talk about three things today and Tara great amnesia the loss of the ability to form new memories retrograde amnesia the loss of memories you already had an idea of memory systems this idea that each of us is has a symphony of learning instruments in our brain that empowers us to learn different kinds of things so integrity shows again the inability to remember new information and people mostly talk about two kinds but as you see there most of life okay not all of it we'll talk about that but a lot of it such as events you experience or facts you encounter so think about this all the events you've remembered from your entire life all the facts you've ever learned in school at home on the computer that's a huge amount of what you know and a patient like we just described with patients I'll describe in a moment lose the ability to remember any event from the day they become a music or remember much in the way of new information of any kind in terms of facts of the world so in what sense is memory in the brain distributer localized in what sense is in one place or many places and this has been a sort of a central debate as in all of neuroscience but in memory too and Karl Lashley a sort of giant of neuroscience or just to t-stops away at Harvard so this it's not possible to demonstrate the isolated localization of a memory trace anywhere in the nervous system the Engram is represented throughout the brain the engrams kind of a magic word in memory in the brain the Engram is the thing in you that changes in your brain that is the stuff of a memory if you learn today that there's you know more terrible news in Japan with the nuclear reactors and you remember that because it matters to you because you care about the people in that there's a physical change in your brain that is the memory if you remember what I'm saying now for more than a few moments that is a physical change your brain so all of us in earth sciences are amazed by that how can we physically change the brain to be the biological record of a memory that we can keep and use in the future and the Engram Carl Ashley said is represented throughout the brain is spread throughout the brain here's why he thought that so he was working with rats and they ran a maze right and you saw how quickly you learned the maze to go from start to finish to get the food if you're if you're a rat and here's what he found and it the results won't amaze you to start with ok so what he did is he made this is number of errors during learning so it's good to be low and this is how much neocortex they took out ranging from 10% to 80% and he said he discovered the more neocortex you took out the worst learner you were now if it didn't happen in some broad sense we'd say well what part is of us is learning it right you take out more brain you're less of a good reader right 10% out 10% bad memory 50% of brain out 50% of bad memory 9 80 percent of the brain out 80% bad memory right right ok that makes sense but what he was really impressed by is it didn't seem to him to matter where he took the brain out of the rat it just didn't matter it's just the percent that he took out whatever percent he took out is how bad a learner you were and we'll come back to that but that's why I said it must be spread everywhere because wherever I take out brain part of the memory is weakened or disappears and sometimes people call that mass action for a distributed memory that spread throughout the brain in this math ways this we were just spread all over the place and a single clinical case and I'll spend a few moments on him for two reasons it is the historical case that turned this around and I have a particular perspective on this because when I was a graduate student I did a lot of work with the single patient whose case turned around our understanding of the mammalian brain and memory ok so as I start to talk about and this is one I can't tell you what Phineas Gage was really like beyond what I read or gay or Broca's patients from the 1900s I can tell you what HM the man were about to talk about was like as I spent many many hours with him two blocks from here when I was a graduate student in Suzanne Corkins lab so the structure we'll focus on is something called the hippocampus it looks sort of big in the picture and it's about the size of about two-thirds of your thumb one on the left and one on the right in the in size or the medial part of the temporal lobes pretty small percentage of the brain and you can see it uh you know it's located here here to sort of drawn-out and here's the story of this man he died a couple years ago there's lots of plays and movies and books in the works okay I can also tell you that when I was a graduate student here my fellow graduate students would say tell us who HM what does his initials really stand for as if it really mattered particularly here but I felt privileged to have the secret knowledge of what his name was when he died they published it everybody knows now so my secret is out but um our RC crews that would he was born in 1926 at age 16 hit his first major epileptic seizure that by age 27 he was having many many seizures a day you can have petit mal seizures where you tune out from the world you can have grand mal seizures that lead to physical convulsions by age 27 the medications were not helping him in 1953 very much that were available and he was just sitting in his house just waiting for the next seizure basically that was his life he was a man of normal intelligence and sort of fairly typical average background nothing remarkable and in order to treat the epilepsy William Scoville the surger surgeon receptive or took out surgically the tissue here's his cartoon of what he took out the hippocampus also the amygdala just in front of it also tissue that surrounds it and the reason he took it out is the single most likely place where epileptic seizures start is the hippocampus it's kind of a signal in many ways that the hippocampus does something very dangerous its operating in a some sort of fast speed lane of neurobiology it's a very sensitive part of the brain for a lack of oxygen for diseases we'll talk about Alzheimer's disease it's a very vulnerable part of the brain but it does something magical and essential for memory and so he couldn't locate where the seizures were starting very well from him in ways they typically do so they said okay he has all these seizures we don't know what to do let's take out the left and the right hippocampus in the surrounding tissue and in terms of seizure control was pretty successful he had to stay on medications from that day till he till a few years ago when he passed away but he had very very few seizures compared to before that so was medically very successful in terms of seizure control it had a giant side effect from that day to the pro till a couple years ago HM never formed a new memory for any event or for all practical purposes for any fact that he was exposed to ever again despite his normal intelligence and his uh otherwise intact abilities so they took an mr of HM it took a long time to decide they could even take a mr picture of HM because they were very worried that if you put him in an mr scanner this magnetic fields right and often they put in clips after surgery regularly they put in clips after the surgery to keep the vessels from bleeding and they weren't sure what the clips were made of for a while and so they said well we can't put him in because we could move the clips and kill him which would be bad so right so they said it was dangerous and they did a huge detective process of going to the factory that made them and talking to the people who build it before they decided took like ten years of research to decide that the clips were not metal and they could take an mr and even here here's a top of the brain normal person here's the hippocampus the small structure in you pretty small it's removed in him but you can see he's got a lot of brain left except for these removed structures but what happened was he had such a fantastic impairment and learning new information that got the label of a global amnesia global amnesia it didn't matter that what tests were hard like remembering stuff or multiple-choice he failed practically every standard test of memory you'd ever give a person or if it's words or nonsense syllables faces cliques mazes public events assassinations of presidents Wars going to the moon whatever you know whatever you think of as famous he he didn't know they happen at all personal events the death of his own parents if you asked him how his parents were doing he would say something like I haven't seen them for a while he would not know they had passed away so no matter how publicly famous something was no matter how personally important it was that knowledge he could remember for a few seconds and we'll talk about that more but it would drift away completely within seconds no matter how often he heard it no matter how personally important it was and you could say what does he say his experience is like so Brenda Milner the neuropsychologist to the lot of the critical original research with him describing his case said that he said everyday is alone in itself whatever joy I've had and whatever sorrow I've had I mean it sounds very poetic and it's true except that for HM his memory lasts seconds so he doesn't remember any day okay since 1950 or something so I think his experience is more like this right now I'm wondering have I done or said anything on this you see at this moment everything looks clear to me his mind is clear he's smart but what happened just before what happened a minute ago or two minutes ago or five minutes ago that's what worries me it's like waking from her dream I just don't remember all right so he you know when we worked with him here a few blocks from here he would know who I was he would know why he was here he was an extremely pleasant and wonderful research participant a piece of that was he was very nice and very pleasant a piece of that was he didn't know time was passing so if any of you are involved in experiments as participants sometimes people you know they enjoy the experiment for about five minutes but not for the next 55 okay so we're getting a lot of measurements to get a good measurement you know for HM it was never an hour-long experiment it was always a min and a half experiment so you have to be very careful you know not to abuse that situation as a researcher so here's his name Henry mOLAISON here's his uh pictures from his youth and from this but you see how we had a complete reversal all of a sudden the removal of just two small regions the left and the right hippocampus in the brain stopped the creation or formation of new memories altogether in any practical way so that shows you that memories not spread throughout the brain and the sort of undifferentiated mass action way but that particular parts of the brain play very particular roles in how memories are formed and hippocampus plays a huge role in that can't see it so they had they had a big project where they brought him from the nursing home in Connecticut where he was they drove him by ambulance to Massachusetts General Hospital they overnight did an like something like an 8-hour MRI scan on him to have the world's most detail MRI scan you practically have on anybody and then they removed his brain and send it to a laboratory in San Diego where they took his brain and they sliced it into many many many incredibly thin slices that they're going to post on the web okay at on the web for quite a while was the slicing of his brain he consented to this it's you know all he really is all this research effort and finally his brain is a you know gift to research and understanding the brain and memory you so let me tell you a couple of experiments salts from him and then you might think of questions you have about what a man like this is like okay so we've talked about last time about that if you give a list of words to people and you try to yourself that people remember the first words best the primacy effect a long-term memory effect that's not affected by adding a few seconds of delay and a recency effect superior memory for the last few words to the list that's strongly affected by adding in just ten seconds of delay from the last word until you recall and this is done with other music patients and not hmm a similar disorder you can see that their memory is worse overall there's a dark line but they have some benefit from the beginning of the list and but it's small it's not the same as the controls but they're completely normal completely normal for the last two or three words so this is what we mean by impaired long-term memory and spared short-term memory but the short-term memory is just moments but it's not just an impression you have you know it's a scientific experiment you can do here's a note we did this last time we said if you read digits to people and ask them to repeat them back aloud that we have a limited short-term memory of seven plus or minus two people get to about seven or eight typically so there's a sort of mean test that's given to look at something so here's what they do imagine that you do this test and you were correct for two digits correct for three repeating them back after you heard them four five six seven you did well and then you made mistakes at eight okay which would be very typical for a human right they find so this is your span they're four seven that's how much you can hold and short-term memory it varies a little bit from person to person and now they're going to do all the rest of the experiment at one beyond your span right one beyond what you can do one beyond what your short-term memory right with here's a limit of your short-term memory let's add one thing and one thing that we know helps memory is repetition it's not the best way to learn things but it is a powerful way to learn things so now they give the entire experiment with eight digits at a time for this person one beyond what you could report so they give you this and they give you this but they give you one boost which is every third one is the same sequence over and over again so some you've here once and once only and one you hear over and over again is that okay now what would happens if you think if you hear eight digits over and over again what would happen you know this in your own life your social security number telephone numbers things what happens can you learn eight digits if you do it over yeah it wouldn't be easy but you can you get you get it right with repetition so here's what happens in typical people here's the repetition here's how well they do for the non repeated Super span ones they never get that good because they basically can't do that occasionally they get lucky but mostly not but the ones that they repeat they get better and better so repetition is another way to break the bounds of short-term memory and register something and long-term memory but in HM they did this for hundreds of trials and he never got better at the repeated series so you could do endless repetition with him or it could be personally important he wouldn't remember it so let me add one more piece to the story that's if I talk to you and say here that you just tell that back to me that's an auditory verbal experiments their words and you're hearing them you can also test short-term memory and long-term memory using a visual spatial test of blocks so you're seeing what the examiner sees with numbers on the back of each of these the person taking the test just sees these blocks as black boxes without any number you need that because you have a piece of paper with numbers on it that tell you what to tap okay so when you give this test you you might see five seven eight and you would tap with your hand five seven eight and the person would tap that back alright I can tell you it made me pretty nervous when I gave this test if a person had a long one because I'd have to read the numbers practice it and I'd be desperately trying to get eight in my head which I could barely do maybe because I could tap eight back right so as well as if a person was good right and then we do the same thing say if you can do eight we'll test you at nine and repeat them and here's two findings and then let's talk about HM for a moment so one finding is on now in patience now we're going to switch one thing a little bit HM had the left and the right hippocampus removed in these patients they had either the left or the right moved either to the left or the right so here's what happens for normal controls for the numbers that are beyond their span not too good low performance but they benefit from repetition here's what happens for the patients with left hippocampal removals for the auditory-verbal things for the digits good at short-term sorry let me get this right um right so they're good for immediate memory for this stuff but they're terrible at developing a long-term memory over here it is verbal but the patients with the right temporal ones are just fine for spatial things is exactly the opposite the group that's really impaired are the patients with a large right hippocampal of removal and the people with a left hippocampus who just fine so we have two separations in the brain for learning things in the medial temporal lobes neither the left nor the right are involved in short-term memory short-term memory lasting only seconds the left is important for verbal long-term memories and the right is important for long-term spatial memories which is very consistent with what we know about left and right hemispheres for verbal and spatial knowledge so let me say we're going to learn more about how we think about the organization of memory and we'll come back to this chart so we're talking here so far about what people call declarative or explicit memory you study some material you get tested on it what did you study and people sometimes make a difference between two kinds of things so episodic memory might be if I ask you okay I needs a volunteer in your seat it's really easy this one okay thanks sir I saw some people getting ready to go but you well okay I'll start okay what did you have for breakfast this morning and you don't have to answer honestly if it's embarrassing you can just give us a standard I'm not looking to make yet cereal how are you young Syrian yogurt - excellent healthy answers okay so I'm so now I'm going to ask you if I gotta ask you first how many feet in a yard excellent great okay so and I'm gonna ask you when and where did you learn that okay and you might go yeah you made you have a you might go I don't know I just learned it right or if I ask a capital of France Paris excellent answer and when when was the shocking moment when this was revealed to you when you say I'll never trust the world again you know yes who knows right so what you're learning is episodic memories memory for specific events like what I did last night what I had for breakfast specific time in place semantic memories what we could call generic memory we know lots of things about the world but we might not know when or where we learned it looks that okay so that's a distinction psychologists find useful to think about so how about an HM we've said he can't remember digits or faces or things like that how about generic memory so here's an experiment that I was involved in where we said because there were some debates about this at the time so we gave HM a multiple-choice test where we saw words or phrases that entered the language after the onset of Zim neva okay so we thought he wouldn't learn - but we didn't know for sure from just everyday experience and by the way I should tell you he watched tons of television okay what is experience that was like watching televisions and interesting questions you should be thinking about questions you want to ask about HM in a moment so I'll come back to that but look at so he has four choices for the word amniocentesis including the correct one buddy picks an infectious inflammatory disease of the intended apartheid in front of him is the correct answer two other answers and he picks the separation of young cows that have not yet given birth to calves both people people cater bon-voyage parties which is completely the wrong spirit brainwash the food that surrounds them Bayes the brain granola portable keyboard wind instrument software expensive clothing made of a soft world fabric what's going on with him are these like crazy weird answers or how would you what do you what do we think is going on with him why is he picking these the other one is right in front of him what's he doing yeah he's he's doing what teachers teach you in school what take apart the word into its parts right he so he goes soft where soft clothes that you wear I mean but what does that mean he's missed in every sense the advent of computers and software in the world okay the idea the concept the words it's as if it didn't exist because in 1953 all those software existed it wasn't a very popular concept right most people didn't know about the concept of that 1953 the way we looked at these we looked at these were not words that work in the dictionary in the 1950s so um so now what would you like to know about a man like HM yeah right so you're saying he wouldn't remember something two days ago but you're talking with him what's that like right so let me give you one experimental thing and then extrude so one experiment they did is they left him with something like six numbers okay well within the span and said remember these numbers then it could be you know 1 2 3 4 5 cell that wouldn't work so well yeah 2 4 6 8 9 2 4 6 8 9 - they leave the room for 15 minutes they come back in he's a excellent subject is going to 4 6 8 9 - 4 69 - what would numbers 2 4 6 and they go that's excellent you know it was there any trick you did to do that or did you just think up what were the numbers okay what as soon as a thought is out of his forefront of his mind it's gone okay so yeah he would he would not recognize us if we spent many hours with him a striking thing which which was amazing at first and then sometimes some if you worked with him and he was a delightful guy um was that he would tell you a story from his past and he didn't have a huge array of stories because they were all from you know a long time ago and he would tell you like about a gun collection he had and he would tell you he had three guns and this property in that property he'd finish the story and if you just stayed quiet for a moment he would forget that he told you the story but it would be vaguely on his mind because he just told it to you and he would say to you hey did I tell you about my gun collection and he would tell you almost we're getting the same story you just wait a moment he forgot that he told you the story but it's kind of slightly on his mind because he just told you it and he goes hey did I tell you my good he could tell you this as until you could bear it no longer okay all right so it was kind of amazing how short his short-term memory was you know without this part of the brain it's just a few seconds his conversations were ok but I would you know I would call them pretty shallow I don't know how to put it you you you you know when you talk with somebody and you're on the phone and they're doing something else and you can tell you know for him was a little bit like that so he was so good social convention he would smile he would chat with you but if it's before you're talking about dependent and remembering something from three sentences ago in any detail gone ok just seconds unless he's practicing at practicing or practicing without doing anything else yeah that capability to learn procedurally yes we're going to come to that so the question is that he ever learned that he had other kinds of learning that were amazingly completely normal in him procedural memory you're absolutely right and we'll come to that just in about 20 minutes okay exactly right and if I don't answer that well make me do that again okay well yeah yeah yeah really good question was he able to remember that he couldn't remember things yes he knew he had a bad memory so now the question is in what sense do you know he had a bad memory like I know there's I can't draw very well okay uh amongst many other things I can't do very well so uh but uh you know if you talk to him he'd say yeah I don't have a good memory but you look he's looking at you and he's going like I don't know where I am who you are or what I'm doing everything is vague for many many years I must have bad memory like you were too like a science fiction movie you woke up you didn't know who you were where you were what you were doing and you can't remember anything except from the most distant past news go something is not good with my memory right but you're smart so you would know that what I don't know is if you woke him up at 2 a.m.

and you said hm yeah how's your memory I don't know if he go well I'm a famous and music of course is terrible right you know I I don't know if he knew it as a fact like we might know about what we're good at not good at what he just knew it by constantly being aware that he didn't know anything he ought to know via memory does that make sense is that yeah anything else about yeah Langley is a very interesting informed consent you know yeah so technically he was conserved by the state once his family had passed away um but you know his intelligence was fine so he had to be a little bit careful to do it right but you could tell him we're going to experiment we're gonna test your memory for words is that okay with you and he'd say yes of course if you had to meet a 12 page document by the time we got to page 12 but you could talk him through it his intelligence was fine you could worry about the edges if there you know so I think the investigators you know felt an extra ethical thing also not to ask him to do anything that a person might say no to he was a wonderful participant but there was an extra responsibility for the reason your sign yeah easily happy all the time excellent question he was a very sort of mellow yeah yeah well you could think for a moment where the heaven no memory would make you happy or sad so he's he couldn't hold a job he couldn't sustain a human relation because he would never know he met you before uh so those are things we often think is pretty big in our happiness the kind of the work we do in some broad sense and the people we relate to right and those were all gone for him on the other hand he didn't exactly realize that he didn't realize he didn't work he didn't realize he didn't have relations he might be expected to have cuz he'd forget that as bad as fast as he could think about it so uh so hi he was kind of a very I would say mild happy person so there's three possibilities that crossed my head and scientifically we can never figure them out one of them is um you know maybe just he was that way I mean some people are just mellow and happy right they don't have without amnesia okay second possibility is he had removed also the amygdala we'll talk about that later in the course that's a structure that's pretty important for some aspects of emotion and feeling said that could have been relevant the third one is but this is kind of getting to your question which is intuitively I feel like this again this is not science but just a feeling that what makes us mostly sort of happy or sad for me it's mostly relatively recent things that were went well or didn't go well or things you know things I'm sad about recently and things on my horizon things I'm worried about or thinks I'm looking forward to is that good and you guys might be different but I don't get that worked up these days about second grade all right I mean at the time I'm sure I was pretty emotional about so-so so if you think about him you know he doesn't remember anything kind of recent that was good or bad he doesn't remember anything coming up that's interesting or threatening or risky or unpleasant so he lives in this constant now we know people tell you live in the moment nobody could have lived more in the moment than he did okay it's impossible to live more in the moment when the only the previous moment you can consult is from 30 40 years ago okay so yeah he was pretty happy in a pretty Pleasant guy you know essentially I don't think most of us want that life although he's probably happier than many people who have all their memories right one thing he's the opposite of just to remind you is as we talked about it now but just to make it clear he's the opposite of television amnesia what happens in soap opera and murder movies when somebody gets bonked a comedy shows when they get bumped on the head television Tunisia they forget who they are and where they came from right and then they marry the worst enemy or something like this to make the story go forward right that's television I mean but after after that they're kind of fine right they're kind of operating but it's just forgot where they come okay that we never see after brain injuries we never see a person who forgets who they are but gets around find in the world hm is the opposite he remembers stuff from his from before but he can't learn new things opposite of TV amnesia right is that okay um any other questions about HM yeah yes and let me talk a little bit about that if I don't answer that let me know so let me talk about this this is sort of touches on this loss of already known information okay if I don't answer you well make me just put your hand up again okay so how do we - it's easy to test learning new things because you can give somebody something in the laboratory you see if they learn it knowing things they should have known from before is much harder different people know different things right in the past so here's how they test it and here's the thing that people have discovered which is people are pretty unknowledgeable about mostly about faces of people who are famous at the time they were famous but if you're like 20 you don't know people who are famous before you were born mostly there's some fake sections okay so but so they take faces from different decades and they show you them and they ask you do you know who this is so do you know who this is this is Lindbergh Frank Sinatra Bob Hope is that name even ring a bell I know this is this is totally however old you are is totally how you do on this test Lyndon Baines Johnson President I States after Kennedy Douglas MacArthur the general this seemed like Richard Nixon McCarthy light as in McCarthyism go to my ear Elvis okay okay now if you pretend you became a music you became a music pretend you're old enough to become a music in 1990 this is if your feeling would you know this face if you're in 1990 let's make 1980 let's make it simple 1980 no okay would you know this face no no no okay but you know them now okay so that tells you that you can put names to decade faces two decades roughly and you know 1980 only Barack Obama's family knew Barack Obama's face right now we all did said okay so temporally limited retrograde amnesia so this is how well you do higher is better and decades right so in 1960 here's hm so here's faces that were famous in the 20s 30s and 40s before he became a music and he's pretty normal these are public faces and then he's terrible for the 50s and 60s after his Denisha so his memory for faces from the past is pretty normal his memory for faces from the onset of the news forward is terrible okay does that answer your question reasonably okay um yeah but here's another really weird thing that people have observed in many cases which is kind of hard to understand but but it's been observed in many cases so here's a another patient he was a bus driver in Washington DC he moved to work in a drugstore in Boston than a mattress Factory in Boston then he was hospitalized at the Boston VA in November 1965 with a huge hematoma and the right term people probably big bleeding and he was pretty aphasic and stuporous he couldn't answer questions in a month he's digit span and short-term memory returns he states the date as approximately something like September 1965 he is a severe and terribly in Asia for example he fails to learn the names of the nurses he sees every day but when asked this is what the striking thing he says targeting me when asked where do you live he says I live in Washington with certainty as if he lost all these memories from before by March he starts to learn the nurses name he's recovering his memory capacity he couldn't remember that he moved to Boston but he doesn't fight the idea that he lives in Boston then he remembers he worked at a drugstore then he remembers that he worked in a mattress Factory and by the time he's discharged it's only the last 24 hours before he went to the hospital he's lost so two things there's a coupling between the interrogate amnesia and the retrograde amnesia he can't learn new things but he lost old things and as the interrogator amnesia resolves the retrograde amnesia resolves in some sense in temporal order it's really odd it's been observed many times so so there is some link between what the hippocampus does and memory for the past now it's in some ways that's really hard to study these things in detail in a patient like HM but in some other patients give us another perspective although every one of these examples is not quite perfect here's patients who undergo treatment for depression with electroconvulsive therapy and appropriately in movies like One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest you know wrongly used electroconvulsive therapy is wrong for some patients with severe depression who failed to respond to medications and who have suicidal ideation literally attempt to take their lives or talked a lot about it in a believable way to family and physician electroconvulsive therapy can be very helpful it's a hard choice to make in a complicated one here's what happens patients typically go and it varies but they go in for the electroconvulsive therapy and nowadays has done typically only the right hemisphere in this study done some years ago around 1972 it was bilateral they put electrodes on both sides of the brain they pass current and they induce a seizure and a remark and they do that on something like every second day for about ten days it's a very you know aggressive form of treatment certainly but for some patients the depression just lifts and they're no longer talking about taking their lives so for some people it seems to work when other things don't during the course of the treatment these patients develop an and Terra great amnesia they become HM like while they're in the hospital to become HM like they can't learn new things they forget the nurses you can test them formally and so Larry squirter did the following experiment with these consultations so we don't know that it's the hippocampus that's the critical thing in these patients but it look a lot like HM and we know that the hippocampus has a low seizure threshold that's why it occurs so often as the locus of epilepsy so what they did is they took television shows now this is another world and you can possibly imagine I grew up in a world where there were basically three television stations and you're feeling sad for me already and so everybody knew what was on those three television stations or and but they took shows that weren't very successful that we're on for one season only okay so they weren't super popular but a lot of people saw them and there were only three television station networks and stations so when they did they tested them on these events or other things like that before they had ECT so this is their knowledge before they had a CT of course they remember recent things 1971 better than stuff from years ago okay like it we all do but the striking thing is when these patients got ECT during the course of their aneasha the only lost memory for TV shows from the last two years they didn't lose this memory these are the very same patients the very same patients before they got ECT and while they're getting ECT they lose memory only for the last two years of TV shows and not all the other ones or same thing you can do with famous public events so this is what people call a temporally limited retrograde amnesia it goes back for some years of knowledge you already had and here's the amazing thing when these patients go home the memory largely comes back and so does their knowledge of the TV shows it's as if it's in their brain they don't have access to it for the last two years of information but it's still sitting there and they regained that access to more examples on this so here's an example because with humans is always tough so they did the same thing with monkeys with monkeys they could do you know create a surgical lesion like HM and train them on material they knew exactly what they learned here they had the surgery either two four eight or twelve or eight sixteen weeks and you can see the monkeys with the hippocampal damage we're performing poorly if they learn the material two or four weeks ago but not you know eight or sixteen weeks ago again a temporally limited Retro greater than usual so we're getting the idea that the hippocampus is important not only for forming new memories but and this is kind of wild it's still important for you to remember stuff from a week ago a month ago and a couple years ago and it takes years for your memory to become independent or what people call consolidated so that it no longer depends upon the hippocampus all right so the campus both is required to form a new memory and it seems like it's necessary to remember that memory you know from months to years before that memory becomes independent of the campus so right now in you it's as if you had a neuro chemistry team finishing your memories you know from the end of eighth grade okay we're done we're moving on in ninth grade okay because it takes years for your hippocampus to no longer be required to get those memories that you acquired years ago and the same thing they did these famous faces like the ones I showed you before so they said to be somewhat older people here activation in the 1990s if they were looking at famous faces and the experiment was done in the nineteen nineteen ninety so recent faces if a campus or not but not for the 80s 70s or 60s or 50s or 40s again is if the hippocampus were required to retrieve memories that's in the rest of your brain for some time period but then after much time passes it's no longer required this summarizes those things so now Tyler if we could do the film so we're gonna show you a music patient most in these equations are like this man very intelligent very verbal not dramatic but with terribly impaired memory you so last part of the talk is I'd like to talk to said back this idea of memory systems of procedural memory the idea that you're a symphony of the neural systems that learn different things so your brain is like the University right are going to chemistry department biology department cognitive science or economics in you are multiple very specialized learning circuits that are good for learning different things so the idea of a memory system a particular part of brain that has a particular nning process and a key concept of that is so probably been talking about with people with normally calm memory explicit or direct testing you know what did you study what year is that you're asked directly to do something but another way to show memory and learning is through changes in performance with practice so people will sometimes call the first kind declarative memory where you directly have conscious memory about facts and that business you know that you know something like that something occurred and then the other kind we'll talk about now procedural memory accessible only through performance and knowing how now with these kinds of skill learning or procedural memory we see how people get better when they practice getting better is a change in your behavior that's learned and a change in your brain that performs the superior performance so here's the experiments and that was the original one friend emitted with HM where you have to trace a star in a mirror you see your hand in the mirror but you don't have direct move your hand if any of you have done something like this for some odds-and-ends reason anybody for sometimes do I see a hand no okay it's surprisingly hard the horizontals and verticals are pretty easy the diagonals as you move your hand you go oh it's no problem I just reverse everything and you see your hand just drift the wrong way okay and you go okay no no no I just have to you know go 45 degrees different but I could do it and if you're controlling your hand but then you move again and it still goes the wrong way and so at first you make lots of mistakes we understand this because you have such automaticity between what you see and how you move all the time - the mirror verse you have to overcome that automatic relationship so first you make a lot of mistakes and move slowly you practice you get better here's the remarkable thing with age so here's hm each of these dots is you know the next time he does it consecutively he gets better from do get over and over again that's not a shock here's a shock he comes to the next day he he keeps to learning he had and he gets better comes in day three he keeps learning now for him a day is like infinity okay for memory when he comes in the room he says what do I do with this you go what we did it the last two days don't you know he said no I have no idea have you done this before no you can give him multiple choice of different things he might have done he'll pick the wrong thing when you come in on day three and you're this good you're pretty proud in fact vain okay you're going like I can do this I'm awesome you know this let me add it right okay because you know that you did it you know how good you are through practice he has no idea but his learning is entirely normal not just better than you think just as good as you so a memory system in his brain a different one in the hippocampus has recapped that memory uses that memory and the amazing thing is means that that's also true in you as far as we understand these things okay when you learn a physical or mental skill a lot of it is learned in a way that has nothing to do with your memory that you learn the skill it's all by doing and it doesn't depend on the hippocampus and some years later I sort of did this again a little bit here's his performance first second third day a week later two weeks later and a year later complete retention for a man who can forget within moments a year later a skill he forgets that he did it ever within moments so another kind of task that people do same idea motor school you can lose is called roadway pursuit there's a disk like this that revolves around a platter that turns pretty fast your job is to maintain contact between this is sort of sad before video games right this is about as interesting as 1940s games got okay it is whizzed around and you're Janna is fast enough that it's not easy to do and a first-year hand goes off it but with practice you get really good at revolving with the rotating disc and um-hm and patients like him learn that very well another motor skill so who's bad at learning this which part of the brain is your instrument for learning skills through practice so our best evidence comes from patients with a very difficult disease called Huntington's disease that's genetic rare disease it's onset is in 30s or 40s these patients get severe motor problems and movement problems then over time cognitive ones and psychiatric ones there's no treatment for it so this is the caudate withering away and a patients with Huntington's disease compared to a healthy person's postmortem or if you look at an MRI here's your basal ganglia here's the withered away basal ganglion the patients with Huntington's disease and there's a brief Tyler there's a brief video of a patient with early stage Huntington's disease you so it's not the most of your problem they have but when they do one of these motor kinds of tasks here's normal typical people learning a motor task getting better on it's good to be high on this graph here's the patients with Huntington's disease showing no learning at all and this is a test and these efficiently learn normally so very convincing and you could say well they have a motor problem they're not going to get a motor skill so one thing they do is they make the platter or the turn very slowly so at the beginning they're doing just as well and they still so no learning at all so there's a lot of other evidence sparked by this this it just shows that the basal ganglia is an instrument that's essential for us to learn physical or motor skills perceptual skills in a variety of cognitive skills as well things where we practice practice practice to become excellent basal ganglia is doing a lot of that work for you the last kind of learning I'll talk to you about and the last disease is a sort of odder form of learning called repetition priming it's a change in performance because of something you did recently and if I give you a concrete example it will feel better so here's one of many examples imagine you study a list of words like stamp landmark speed clock you study a list of words like these I can give you an explicit or declarative memory test what words did you see you'd recall them or which were did you see that we need multiple-choice that's regular memory we know depends on the hippocampus I can also give you a weird test like this which says tell me the first where do you think of that starts with sta now if you have good memory you'll go do you want me to give you stamp ok is that the point you go no no no they go Gian thing you want to know some weird things I'm going to think of an ego no no no just tell me the first word you think of ok and you can give many answers that are all perfectly fine it can give stall stands staccato star right many s da words either pick and all them are fine that's all you have to do but if you saw stamp one particular completion of this about 10 minutes ago you're biased or prime to come up with that word not all the time but much more than by chance a recent experiences biases you to be and here's the remarkable thing when you do this experiment with hm if you just had the list of words and you wait about 20 seconds here's you recall now you're not surprised that we call from a healthy persons about seven words right you try that yourself hm sadly is no score because he always goes like what list okay so no recall multiple-choice recognition where there are three choices here's typical people hmm about chance the probability above chance that you give stamp as the completion to sta if you saw stamp if I showed you star probably you could start the specific word you saw ten minutes ago perfectly the same in HMS normal control subjects is just as influenced by that word he thought ten minutes ago as you are to give you that answer okay so this got people very excited because they said now we can experimentally scientifically study something that Freud talked about as a very vague idea the cognitive unconscious he's not conscious that he saw a list of words ten minutes ago but it's making him choose to behave in a certain way now now you have both things in you as far as we understand it you can both remember you saw the word list but if you switch your thinking a little bit your behavior a little bit the unconscious system gets into the driver's seat right because the people with good memory we're giving stamped often but no more or less than hm so unconscious so what part of the brain does this kind of memory and our insight to that comes from Alzheimer's disease so these is HMS kind of amnesia extremely rare Huntington's quite rare Alzheimer's is tragically calm in fact what they went to East Boston the area near Logan and knocked on doors at people's homes okay not people in nursing homes at home and they estimated and there's debates about this I could back and forth but about half the people over 85 who answered the door qualified for diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease about half okay over 85 there's debates about this Justin Bates about whether all of us would get it if we live long enough you know but as American society gets older as us baby boomers all move into our you know 60s 70s and 80s there's going to be a heck of a lot of people around with Alzheimer's disease and severe if you use some of you probably have experienced this with grandparents that nothing else it's a very devastating disorder for the patient for the spouse or family it's a very challenging disorder so what is Alzheimer's disease well behaviorally it's an insidious and progressive dementia dementia means unlike hm it's many losses of abilities unlike hm-hm had a surgery one day boom that was it Alzheimer starts very slowly gets worse and worse over time the biggest problem early on is memory the most common problem but over time language thinking concentration spatial thinking sometimes mood and personality all of these get altered over time in the brain when you look at the changes you see that the changes occur especially in the hippocampal region so that that's why the memory problem is like HM and also in some other parts of the cortex but not so much for example in basal ganglia that we just spoke about as important for procedural memory here's a control brain and an equal age Alzheimer's brain the reason why these gyri does this all site widen is because of widespread neuronal shrinkage or death and what's happening inside the brain with the most important post mortem there's sort of neurofibrillary tangles and plaques that are associated with the disease these are tangles are something about the cells that have died the plaques are thought to be maybe part of the process that leads to the disorder but there's debate about that to this day and if you look on post mortem where the tangles are those tangles up here you can see their most dense in the hippocampus or near the hippocampus like hm and so that's why we think so many patients with Alzheimer's have an HM like memory problem and then more problems after that so here's a healthy person top of the brain here's the left and right at the campus eighty one-year-old and here an 80 year old Alzheimer's patient the hippocampus is withered away both sides of the brain bilaterally so one more brain perspective on this this is a SPECT scan that just shows you where there's blood flow and metabolism top of the brain bottom of the brain here's the insides of the temporal lobes and healthy elderly adults look how much worse but this is HM he looks pretty good right you have to look really hard to see that the hippocampus is missing because I said a small structure and not here's an early stage Alzheimer's patient lots of the tissue is there a lot of you know it's not functioning because there's so much damage here's the medial temporal lobe but also cortical areas that are compromised okay again not the biggest problem but in terms of thinking about different parts of the brain and what parts of memory they do so here's a hm so these on these occasions including HM Alzheimer's patients and Greene and controls so recall the list where words were on the list explicit memory bad in the two patient crews recognition pretty poor word stem completion the kind of thing that we said is completely normal in HM that's impaired in Alzheimer's disease so we think that kind of priming depends on the neocortex the part of the brain that's also injured in Alzheimer's because we know it doesn't depend on the hippocampus because the patient's wood hippocampus only damaged you're fine so we end up with a picture like this and of something on memory system for explicit or declarative memory from patients with amnesia we know it depends on the medial temporal lobe left verbal right spatial for skill learning anything you practice many times to get better at we know from Huntington's disease that depends on the basal ganglia four kinds of priming recent experience altering something about brain organization Alzheimer's disease we know from that that it's likely mediated by the neocortex these are from patient studies but imaging studies are very well aligned with these things so we think it's true not only of patients you in terms of the instruments of your brain so now we have not only episodic memory and semantic memory we talked about procedural memory but talk about priming I didn't talk about conditioning today but we've talked about that before so I have two more slides to Anam conceptually so in what sense was Karl Lashley right or wrong when he said memories all over the brain here's how we think about it now we think he was right that all of your brain is learning practically all of your brain is plastic it changes with experience but different parts of your brain are learning different things the basal ganglia is learning how to be skilled at something the neocortex how to gain knowledge and shift your representation of knowledge like in priming the medial temporal lobe and the left of learning verbal facts the right is nonverbal factor spatial effects so all of your brain is learning that is learning different things and in that sense we end up with this metaphor that you know just like there's a string section right in a percussion section or something like that in you there's all these different instruments that are highly tuned to the way they're organized to learn all the different things you learn they're all pretty useful instruments to have and without these patients and then the imaging studies we wouldn't have known that you'd be like the Martian one instruments thousand instruments what we know there's multiple ones and we know pretty much which structures are essential for them Thanks you

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 11 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011