Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu so let's talk about uh memory today and the fragile power of memory if memory didn't work we wouldn't remember anything we wouldn't learn anything so we know it has to work reasonably uh but it has a number of fragile aspects we'll talk about where of course we forget things uh but on top of that it turns out there's ways in which our memories get less accurate and distorted are are not actual records of our experience but rather our interpretations or our memory of our memory and we'll talk about experiments that reveal that so to a large extent we'll talk about what do we know from scientific research about why we remember some of our lives and why we forget so many other things that we experience uh and and a version of the way that people sometimes think about it is in what sense is memory like a camera that every experience you have is stored in your mind somewhere we all have the experience perhaps that something will remind you of something you haven't thought about for days weeks or years right and you go oh well it must be all stored there I just need the right cue or the right path to get that memory uh so that's one version of memory everything is in US recorded sometimes we can get to it sometimes we can't another version is the way to think about your memory it's kind of like a punch bowl you put in some milk and then you put in some orange juice and swirl it around and then you put in some Coca-Cola and swirl around and it's not a desirable drink that you have in your bowl but you can no more get the specific milk or the specific orange juice or the specific Coke because they're all mixed together and his memory more like that that as life goes on things get mixed in and the raw memory is never recoverable from the mixture of subsequent experiences thoughts and feelings so uh we'll bring the same perspective a little bit bottom up memory might be you know really the video camera if we had it an actual recording of what we hear what we see what we experience out there in the world top down processes are the mental uh things we have in our mindset let us interpret what's out there um uh Concepts expectations also turns out you'll see that subsequent experiences go back and change memories from prior times and which of these things the bottom up original experience or the top- down interpretation grows over time to constitute your memory so we can have a very simple model of memory uh a flash for a moment we I'll give you an example of how people test this of sensory memory very tiny moments only short-term memory that you can rehearse in some cases somebody tells you number and you can repeat it over and over again you have that capacity and then long-term memory things that last uh for a long time you can Define these things many different ways when we talk about the brain organization of human memory we'll say that short-term memory is probably lasts seconds and everything after that is long-term memory now of course if you just experience something you remember it better if it's a week a month a year five years from now most likely less better right so time passes but we think almost all of that is in the context of long memory capacities of your mind so here's the kind of experiment I won't really we we'll do a couple exercises at your seat but this I'm just going to give you a feeling because you have to this would require millisecond timing to do correctly but the way they approached this sensory memory the flash of memory the just you know capturing for a moment what's out there it's something like this so imagine your job is to report back the letters that you see okay yeah you're getting a number of them okay all right uh so that method would be you just did what's called the whole report method tell me everything you saw um they they did uh another approach which is present letters and then right just just as it disappeared they we get a tone a high medium or low tone and that would tell them which row to report the top row the middle row or the bottom row depending on the tone they heard just after the flashh immediately after the flesh does that make sense okay it's gone but the tone is was telling you which one to report and the Striking finding on this was this if they showed you 12 letters like you just saw and said tell me everything you see people could give you about four letters back maybe you had that experience about four letters accurately if they gave you the letters they flashed them then you got the tone for one row only you got about three letters correct now this is interesting the letters are gone but it's kind of like as if the photograph of your memory is fading but if you put your attention somewhere you can still pull it back but just a little bit of it so okay because here you get four out of 12 here you get three out of 12 almost the same because your attention can zoom in on that fading mental image of what you just saw um so this much is sensed but attention only selects a little bit to be remembered okay so that's his very first moment of memory but uh you know one of the more impressive lines of research is the next moment shortterm memory keeping in mind something in your mind briefly and when the most striking aspects of human short-term memory is is limited in how much it can hold and across a tremendous range of materials words letters shapes tones and so on you can hold approximately seven plus or minus two chunks of information limited short-term memory um so uh now I need somebody who's willing at their chair to do something you will have to uh I'm going to read to you numbers and ask you to repeat them back but your eyes will need to be closed and it'll be fairly challenging all right thank you very much all right okay uh close your eyes and here we go ready keep your eyes closed until repeat after me 61 rep you say when I'm done I'm sorry yeah ready 6194 repeat 6194 right ready 37852 repeat 37852 ready ready 965 283 repeat 965 283 great ready 426 9851 repeat 426 9851 very good ready 816 37249 repeat 81 6742 okay perfect I'll I'll C your eyes thank you very much so you did terrific uh you did uh you got four right five right six right seven right eight right you got a mostly right you just reverse one or two okay seven plus or minus two doesn't matter how smart you are how advanced you are uh uh there used to be some confusions about this because they would say kids in different countries have different limits okay and they say all our country is smarter than your country okay and people or our educational system is better than your educational system it turned out that all of that got equated around the world if you count it up the number of syllables that are in the digits the real unit of memory here are syllables okay so in English it's is mostly most of the numbers are one syllable one two 3 four five six are all one syllable seven gets two right eight is one syllable nine is one syllable in some other languages the words that go with the digits are two syllables and the real unit is so so countries that have two syllables they had lower spans because not because they were Dumber or had a worse education system it's because the real unit is number of because you're hearing it it's language okay is that right okay so around the world it's a fundamental capacity of the human mind is that you're limited to this kinds of stuff so how do we get around that you why are we not always barely able to do anything okay uh with very small amounts of information it's just a constraint of our minds uh it's because background prior knowledge things you know before you have to learn something has a very powerful effect it allows you for the information to be retained in memory but it has a double edge sword which is kind of a theme in mday as much as it helps you remember things it can fool you into misremembering things and let me give you a concrete example so you can have put you can put chess displays in front of people who are either beginning chess players have played for a while or are Masters and this is they're not going to play they're going to look at it the pieces will be swep to the side and then they have to put all the pieces back out of memory into the same location where they just saw it they know that's going to happen right so it's a memory test here's the pieces take a look The Examiner sweeps the pieces to the side and you put them back as well as you can you see it it gets swept to the side you reproduce it from memory what you just saw and here's the performance uh of uh Master players and beginner players in this case so people who have played a lot of Chess and people who played very little chess it's better to be high the number of correct pieces um and here's there's two kinds of displays in one kind of display is what we call the normal displays those are ones that could really have happened in a game they were kind of reasonable configurations of pieces the random displays are pieces all over the place in a configuration that you're not likely to see in a real game of chess equal number of pieces and look what happens the best performance are Master players who see a real normal chess configuration here are the players who are beginners and look at the worst performance is the Chess Masters who see a random setup so what do you guess is happening yeah a lot memorized games and positions so they're used to seeing those patterns and when they see a random configuration they can't recreate it as right so that people who play chess a lot have a lot of configurations in their mind background knowledge they use that background knowledge of what a chess array means somebody's in trouble somebody's winning you know something interesting is happening in this corner that knowledge helps them escape the boundaries of seven plus or minus two uh and they do a lot better than the beginners for whom it doesn't mean much it's just a bunch of stuff out there hard to remember but what happens here when the pieces are random the Chess Masters are making mistakes because they're putting the pieces into places they ought to be rather than the places they perversely were randomly located okay if you're chest player you know you don't like that random board right doesn't feel right uh and so but they're trying to be accurate but now they're misplacing their memory for what they actually saw with their mental model of what ought to be out there okay now the players who are not so good they don't you don't see much of a difference between these lines it doesn't make they don't understand when it's random they don't understand when it's organized it's just a bunch of pieces is that okay so the double edge of background knowledge background knowledge lets you escape the pounds of limited short-term memory but at a cost of sometimes substituting in for the actual experience you had okay so we'll try this organize and people use the word chunking is the cap way in which you use your background knowledge to get big pieces of information stored that are better than you'd think from short-term memory limits so here's a quick one ready oh I need I need a volunteer actually not too bad wow tough volunteer day you're mad at me about the exam okay thank all okay ready what were the letters okay how about this ones all right you see it same letters it's just that now you see the chunks and you can map them onto long-term memory more easily okay plus I showed it longer okay anybody else want to try something like this thank you okay ready here we go ready showing that what letters do you see ready okay now I'm going to let your background knowledge Triumph ready all right same letters right but you can use your back it's the same letters the others okay you don't believe me same letters all it is this this one no your background knowledge is useless your knowledge of words your knowledge of the alphabet useless same information in a sense same number of letters same identity of letters but now your background knowledge is powerful okay um okay I need somebody else one more volunteer when you s thank you ready I'm going to show you a sentence this is meant to be hard the first one don't worry about it okay here we go can you tell me what what they were that's pretty good okay let me let me let me show you another equal number of words ready go okay what where is it walking around while yeah you would do better okay I know it's hard to pull these things off well anyway so 13 words you know people would do pretty miserably this although you did very well uh a lot better at this because again you can use your background knowledge of what does a sentence mean what's the organ syntax all your background knowledge can be applied again the power of background knowledge is immense I can tell you that if you go work somewhere or if you working in a lab now or if you're working in any wor you know you might be impressed by people who are older than you and what they know and what they can learn and pick up it's background knowledge background knowledge background knowledge okay uh it lets you quickly understand an idea because you can interpret it from prior ideas you know quickly read a paper because you slot it into prior things you know background knowledge is incredibly powerful to let you discover the signal and get a lot of the specific information and any kind of information out there so um oh Tyler I left with you this time sorry so we're going to do a quick memory test you will do it at your own seat your it's voluntary but I will ask you to share some of a little bit of information but this is for everybody now not for one person to be put on the spot um so what I'm going to do is read you a list of words uh wait till the end and when I say when I say recall write down the words from your memory okay so I'll wait for a moment if you get a pencil or pen or something okay I see a few people still getting stuff okay all right ready here comes the word so just listen don't write that would be too easy right I'll say recall and then write them down here we go mailbox sardine shotgun peacock credit detail flicker Airline spinach clarinet recall okay here are the answers okay um as you look at this list put your hand up if you got all 10 nine eight 7 6 5 4 3 2 thank you all right so now think about this for a moment uh we said seven plus or minus two when the words are presented uh in a random unorganized list like this you're pretty much back to short-term memory and limits in many senses not completely but in many ways so if you were to tell a person on the street I mean I have to say two things about you guys which is certainly true and complimentary okay you're at your most of you uh if you're somewhere between 18 and 25 you're at your Peak memory capacity for the rest of your life you will never do better you will never do better for rote learning than you are right now there's a ton of research that shows that you will never do better for rote learning then about 18 to 25 okay after that it's downhill okay uh you get other benefits you know salaries go up a little bit you get Authority that's a nice one um but rope memory you're you're at the top not only are you at the top but you know you are an incredibly selected academically achieving group right you're MIT undergraduates right you're in incredibly selected to be the topof the top in many senses for learning between 18 to 25 as far as MIT can possibly figure this out right okay you are our hope for the future right if you guys can't fix global warming you know we're in trouble all right so so you can't get 10 words come on we have big problems to solve right it's a capacity of the human mind that we just can't do about more than this right it's just amazing how limited rot memory is without other things but there's a little bit more that we can tell how many of you got mailbox and sardine Fair number of hands okay how many of you got spinach and clarinet the last two words Fair number hands how many of you got credit and detail way fewer hands and that's what happens under a well controlled experiment so this is correct high is correct this is uh what order the word was in the first word you heard say the fifth this was this experiment is 15 words you can see that people are you know here's their performance two things are noteworthy people do best for the first couple of words and sometimes they do best for the last couple of words so here's three delays these delays are 0o seconds what we did you get the list you immediately write them down and recall them verbally that's zero you know immediate or I wait 10 seconds and then say now recall or I wait a half minute and say now Recall now for memory for the first two items what's called a Primacy effect it doesn't matter and all three conditions those are the best two remembered words on average for most of the experiment okay um and people think that's a signature of long-term memory you can get those one or two words and then you start to get overwhelmed okay in long-term memory here you only get the boost for the last couple of words if there's zero second delay if there's 10 seconds or 30 seconds delay no boost so people interpret this recency effect Superior memory for the last couple of words is a signature of short-term memory that lasts only seconds and so with a simple experiment you can see long-term memory influences short-term memory influences and short-term is very shortterm it's just seconds um now ebbing house is one of the founders of experimental studies of memory and he was heroic I mean he uh he would just train himself he used nonsense syllables because he wanted to get rid of a lot of background stuff rope memory and he would learn thousands of these and then test himself and score himself honestly okay he did he did the bulk of the work on himself and he discovered something that's pretty simple but that's uh uh has had a huge effect so how well do you do since you learned something all in long-term memory if you're tested immediately 100% if it's a small list and you studied a lot 20 minutes later an hour later nine hours later you can see the Steep forgetting up until about 10 hours and then it sort of hangs in there a forgetting curve of long-term memory that we you know immediately afterwards we're pretty good then there's a lot of forgetting in 20 minutes and for a day and then things hang in there this this this you this this shaped ASM totic um um curve of forgetting okay now here's another mission for you you need a pencil or just your fingers will work fine either way um you're going to see a list of words some will be in uppercase some will be uh in lower case capital letters uppercase okay your job as you see them from top to bottom is tap your left hand for each word that's in the capital letter and your right hand for each word that's a lowercase letter is that okay so if the first word is capital you tap left the second word is lowercase you tap right and you just tap tap tap until you get to the bottom and then it will go you ready you ready to help me out here we go thank you very much here we go excellent all right what were the words okay you might be impressed that even though they were right in front of you and even though you were looking whether they were upper and lower case so you really saw them uh if you don't think if you don't bring the relevant background knowledge to remembering it which is the meaning of words most of the time uh our memory is pretty hideous okay all right let's try another one now the trick is gone a little bit so we're going to do you know just a little bit of a setup but I can tell you it's scientifically true okay so now it's the same idea you're going see words but think about you're going to read the word if it's a living thing like a dog tap the left hand if it's a non-living thing like a chair the right hand ready you did awesome thanks here we go okay does it feel like you would remember the words better okay does it feel like you would what okay so here's what we did the first list is you thought about the appearance of the word in memory that's called shallow encoding just if it's upper lower case and typically that leads to pretty poor memory if you think about the meaning of the word we think that's optim optimizes memory people call it deep encoding and it leads to better memory and In a well-controlled experiment now here we had a certain order and you knew there was a trick but if you have a well-controlled experiment here's what you find if you just think about the appearance of the word uh here's how well you do pretty low for if you see the word once or twice and if we look over here at the meaning of the word you can see one thought about the meaning of the word is better than two presentations thinking about the appearance and two thoughts about the meaning of the word and your memory is really excellent Yeah question so if you're think about get confused by the upper case verus lower case and the living versus non- Liv was it confusing to do one than the other it was a little bit right yeah is that supposed to make you remember it better if you have to think that hard uh no usually well the if it to the extent it draws you to think of the question is is the confusion of doing the two different tasks help you out so roughly speaking the answer is to the extent it draws your attention more to the word yes to the extent you're sitting there going okay was it uppercase or was it living and this is is weirding me out it's going to hurt you because your mind is filled with those thoughts not looking at what's in front of you is that okay yeah so but we can do you know in these demonstrations it's they're a they're a little uh cloie um here's a fun one the effective context so that this is how they did the experiment you could do it different ways but this is a fun one they actually went in in in the United Kingdom to the Shoreline and they people put on those old style driving diving helmets you know the old big helmets and you go under the water with the big hose in front of you to your air source and they had them learn word lists like you were looking at word lists on the land or underwater underwat they're hearing the okay and then they were tested for those on the land or in the water and here's the core message was you do better remembering information if you're tested in the same situation in which you learned it so what we see here is if you uh here's the words learned underwater you're better if you're tested underwater instead of going on the land if you learn learn the word under land you're better off if you're test of the land than if you go underwater the context in which you learn something helps you right being studying in the water underwater and tested underwater you do better than studying underwater and going on land or vice versa being in the same room same time of day uh all those things help you a little bit to bring a memory back because those are parts of the memory is the context in which you experience it another approach that people have taken this is about organization they'll present a set of words like this ask people to try to remember them pretty big list you know but if you take the same words and do that same words people remember a lot better because there's a organization that helps you your your background knowledge of what is a career what is housework what is a food all contribute to helping your memory for these items be better um so let's think about forgetting some we know something from last year we forgot it there's at least two ideas that people have said what's the core reason we forget things one of them is like passive well i't used it for a while you know uh you know it's just not available anymore because time has passed not been used not available that's passive forgetting the other way to think about why we forget is not that it's a passive loss of knowledge but that experiences you have after that moment when you learn something will go back and write over and muddy and confuse your memory for the original event it's active interference of subsequent experience it's not passive withering other stuff is getting in your head that's writing over and modifying the original memory and the original memory is never there again um and one and people have talked about it in two different directions that you can think about this one of them is what they call proactive interference where things from before mess up your learning on something or retroactive interference you already have the memory and now new things mess you up and right over the the memory so memory is threatened by what came before the experience or what happens after the experience in the way that it interferes uh with accuracy of memory so here's a fun experiment just two subjects but there's a lot of other studies that looked at this this the original demonstration um where people had to remember syllables and they T they taught them the syllables just before they went to sleep or as they woke up and then in each case they were tested for example uh some number of hours later let's say eight hour hours later and their idea in the study and there's one wrinkle Al I'll mention now that we know things their idea was look when you go to sleep there's no retroactive interference because you're not learning anything else you're not experiencing you're not talking you're not reading so when you wake up in the morning nothing has messed up your memory from when you just went to sleep does that make sense if you study in the morning now you go and you have your day you go to classes you talk to people you read things all those new experiences can go back and mess up the memory you acquire to start with so in both cases you get the memory to start with but in one case you're sleeping for 8 hours it's not messed up in the other case you're out in the world lots of new things are happening they're retroactively messing up the memory and I'll answer let me just let me just thing uh and you can see the people who did who slept after they learned when they woke up did a lot better than the people who walked around during the day and that's thought to be one of then a huge line of research saying that one of the reasons that memories become unavailable to us is not simply passive withering but active other mental experiences that block right over and change the original memory question yeah so if you study in the night and then go to sleep does this having those memories hanging around in your brain strengthen them because you're going to wake up and do step in yeah so now there's the second thing we now know the question is is there something good about going to sleep after studying and the answer is uh there's a lot of evidence now uh in animals and and increasingly in humans that sleep is a period that can fixes memories uh from the prior day and if you if you don't get the right kind of sleep or something like that those memories from the prior day don't don't seem to get as well fixed into long-term memory so this is mixing those two issues these people have two advantages now we think one advantage they have is they're not having new experiences during the night that are messing up the memory they got okay and they're having this consolidation period during sleep uh people have long studied like what's the use of sleep okay besides making you not sleepy and uh uh uh uh one of the most fascinating things is and there's just more and more evidence for this is that it's a period where because our brain is kind of quiet in many ways it seems to work a lot on fixing memories from that day into a better long-term unit is that okay so there people have two advantages by our current understanding so that's retroactive interference let me give you an example of proactive interference um and here's how they study it we won't try it but let me give you an example they they they uh would have you hear three words like banana peach and apple they're all related then they have you count allowed from 138 backward by sevens for a few moments okay they say what were the words and you give what you can then they give you Plum apricot and lime count backwards by sevens melon lemong gra you can see all these are from the same category and then they switch the category so we said typically background knowledge helps but here's a way it can get weirdly not helpful so here's the performance of you know healthy young people doing this so this is percent correct good is high the first list they really good okay occasionally they forget one of the three words but look what's happening as they go along for this the second list and the third list they're getting worse and worse that's proactive interference the experience in the first list is messing you up to learn the new information on the second list and most of the errors people make are substitutions they go Plum apricot Apple okay by the third list they're going melon lime Apple okay because you see what's happening because they're related because they're related now you're getting confused it's a sec if I just if I heard the word great recently was that in the first group I'm not reporting that one right now was in the one before that or the one I'm supposed to report right now the relations among them mess you up because it's hard to tell when you heard them and they're all related and just to convince you that it's true because you might say well maybe you're just getting tired you know like list and list and Counting then they give you a new list and look what happens if it's fruits still fruits you're still stuck but if it's another list like vegetables flowers and meats or professions very different your memory zooms right back up because all the interference you had here about fruits is no longer relevant for learning a set of professions and it's kind of graded right we think of flowers is more related to fruits kind of uh and professions as very unrelated you know doctor lawyer programmer right the more unrelated it is the more your memory gos right back to where it was because a proactive interference is no longer happening another um thing that researchers have focused on is you know as we read things or and and what what do we uh focus on so here's an example where they read people's sentences read they actually saw sentor read them and then they tested them and either for the meaning or for the style of the sentence now usually when we read stuff we're focused on the meaning not the style right I mean style we might notice it but usually just what am I reading what's the point um now if they were warned that they would be tested if they weren't unwarned they read the sentence then you're tested much better for meaning than for style because we automatically go for meaning that's what we go for when we read by and large when we think about poetry or something that might be different but reading typical test what's the meaning we strip away almost the the style we want to get to the content but people are flex and they're terrible if they're asked about the style the specific organization of the sentence the word by word organization but of course if they focus on it they can do a lot better so this is just saying we naturally go for gist and meaning and we try to throw away a lot of the specific particular like the way the sentence was organized the style of the writing um okay so now I'd like to do a demonstration uh that will work better for something others but here we go right um uh uh so uh here we go I'm going to read you a list of words and then I'm going to um ask you for a couple different words and ask you if they were on the list okay here we go ready door glass pain shade ledge sill house open curtain frame view Breeze sash screen Sutter okay was the word glass on okay was the word potato on the list was the word shade on the list was the word uh car on the list was the word window on the list okay how many people said window come on put your hands up you come I he a lot of window you hear a lot of yes all right you're not helping me out here okay smart undergraduates like you the peak of your memory about half the time say yes to window you saw this demonstration before or you heard it before uh the way they compose these lists is uh they ask students to say what's the first word you think of that goes with door the second word and the first word that goes with door the most common one they'll put over here will okay that's a trick word The Lure word and then these are other words that people think kind of goes with the word door so if you hear this list and then either you're tested for did you hear the word window or see the word window it doesn't matter whether you see it or hear it about half the time undergraduates will say uh yes I heard it or saw it because they're getting the gist of the list this is all about Door and Window stuff right so when the word window appears they have a false or illusory memory the rate of false or illusory memories goes up with age as well when you're uh for every decade that will pass you'll add a few more of those okay uh uh but uh even even undergraduates typically about half the time they'll falsely recall they heard the word window again the idea is here's this double-edged sword oh you go it's about words that go with doors and windows so when you get that's the gist that's the main idea when you get the word window you falsely believe that you saw it or heard it so that's the way that people try in the laboratory to um to for to create false memories that are experimentally testable we'll talk about real life ones just in a moment so we said you know all these things make it feel like memory is more the punch bow metaphor than the camera right because it's all switched together the proactive stuff the interpretation the retroactive changes that are created in memory uh are all altering the memory uh based on the interpretation or based on subsequent experience um so let me stop for one moment uh to tell you okay so memory is shaky wouldn't it be cool to have truly photographic memory I mean that would be awesome as a student right would wouldn't be bad in life there's only been one well-described case of a person who seems to have truly photographic memory hear various stories uh most of the people who you know are things like memory performers or there's memory Olympics and things like that they train the heck out of themselves to use different methods that can enhance your memory and they can do amazing things but it's all hard work okay it's all hard work as far as we understand it but here's a guy who was different studied by Thea a psychologist in Russia about a hundred years ago so this is a guy who was a reporter at a newspaper and he would go out uh and come back and you know type up the report of what he had seen at some event for the newspaper and the editor noticed that this guy never took notes okay he came back and he just started typing and the editor said you got to take notes because you won't know exactly what happened who said what exactly you know you'll make mistakes the guy said no I'm always perfect the other said okay you know I'm we're going to teach you a lesson about this to just to show you and he said okay he got some material and he said everybody come around he's going to embarrass the guy right I'm going to read you something you tell me every word I said he read him some you know some J and the guy repeated every word perfectly this guy truly had photographic memory and kind of interestingly when they said wow you have photographic memory he didn't go yes I'm awesome I'm a superhero right he said doesn't everybody all right he didn't he was not he was not aware that most of us don't remember every single thing that we study easily and for the rest of our lives so uh he would be presented you know rows of digits like these studi them for three minutes and he could recall them um uh uh days weeks and months later perfectly you could you know okay truly this is almost the only case we have well described and well analyzed uh so it's really rare um uh he he would say when he was had to think back of a particular list oh tell me the one from you know last year or tell me the one from two years ago he would have to think where he was and reinstate you know so in his Mind's Eye he would see the room or hear the voice of the person reading it to him um uh but you know even 15 years later Perfect Memory for list like this wouldn't you like to have that you know right now I wouldn't mind it either okay um uh he also was th athetic that is when he had things in one modality it triggered perception-like experiences in another modality he could change his resting pulse uh from 70 to 100 uh he could uh change his temperature by two degrees by force of will he's an unusual person okay all right I mean you know we would we we would love to discover another person like this on the place of the planet we have not seen another one well well documented probably there is but you know they're sitting somewhere in some Village remembering everything perfectly going I thought you all remembered everything perfectly uh so you could think wow that's awesome nice superpower to have um said but uh he was not a happy person this is kind of interesting question because he he complained that when somebody spoke to him like a family member what would happen was he would be flooded by a word with some memory for some list or some event last week last month or 10 years years ago okay his family members said they you're not listening to me yeah because every word or thing you know triggered back brought back a flood of memory um he got so miserable that things in his environment would trigger perfect floods of memory into his mind and this is truly like a novel uh that he would at one point in order to get rid of memories and this did did not work he wrote them down in a piece of paper and threw them into a fire thinking somehow that would work okay it didn't work so this is one of these you know uh Twilight Zone Oh Henry depending you know kinds of stories right uh where you think it's awesome to have photographic like memory but in fact it seems to have uh blocked in many ways his development as a person he became once he realized he was so uh had such a rare memory he became a professional memory performer uh and then all kinds of jobs and finally retreated into Countryside kind of unhappy treating people with herbs uh with his wife and son okay so he did not have a happy awesome life now I don't know if in this in this world he would do better because you could get on TV shows and become a celebrity or something if you could do this right uh but um uh uh so so what what's the problem with photographic like memory do you think why is it that we kind of wish we had it at certain moments but what's the drawback well the drawback seems to be imagine if you had in your head a photograph of everything you would have so much stuff okay that you wouldn't be analyzing it for the basic point of what it's about so we just said the risk of analyzing things for their basic Point their basic gist is that uh we want to get the bottom message and we give up a lot of the particulars it's not like a photograph you know it's like a very small abstract or a note about a photograph that's in your mind but that's a very powerful way to approach the world because then all your background knowledge is instantly available to help you interpret what's going on because you're using lots of connections and very few pars okay too many particulars are all as burdensome as probably having too many generalities let me talk a minute about flashball memories so this is a kind of funny thing we might have you might have the experience uh in your own life of very Salient moments big moments in your life with your family other things you're doing in your life where you say I'll never forget this moment because just everything is so vivid for me what people call flash bulb in the old days with FL still flash bulbs uh so you know we can never know how accurate your flash bulb memory is right you go I'll never forget when I got into MIT the moment because I was wearing the my lucky socks and it was sunny outside and you might be right or you might be wrong okay so there's a slightly gruesome um research Enterprise uh which takes public events that are very emotional for people so some of them will be very historical for you some are in your lifetime John F Kennedy's assassination uh the Challenger blowing up uh as a high school teacher was you know going up to be the first High School teacher to do that the OJ Simpson verdict you guys are too how were you even lie for the no sorry I can tell you that got an unbelievable amount of interest because I'm from Buffalo that's where O.J Simpson play football so I had a particular uh you know it was like everything you wanted in a in a in a TV show I mean some tragically two people died because OJ SS a super famous football player that huge debates about whether he had murdered his wife and and another person in a house and there was an exact moment when they said get everybody get on your TVs you know here comes the verdict okay um or the 911 attack uh uh so here's this funny research business what people do is they go and as soon as these horrible things happen they ask people to write down where were you what were you doing how did you learn about it what were your feelings what were the feelings in people around you and what did you do in the next hour okay they can't you can't be prepared for this other than wait for something horrible everybody says I'll never forget where I was when 911 happened or things like that people feel that way and they certainly remember that day more and some sense than a typical quiet day okay but here's what they do if they test them on their own answers you know so that you gave the information just a little bit after presumably it's roughly correct if you're tested a year later yes you remember that day better than other days that's but it's full of errors it's full of errors and people are way overconfident they say I know where I was and and a year later and you know I know I was with my friend and you say but what a year ago you wrote down you were by yourself oops okay but I'm pretty sure I was wearing you know my ring coat and you go oops you wrote down you know you were wearing a sweater you go oops okay so your memory is way higher but it's full of inaccuracies even though people are sure it's not they're sure that's not inaccurate okay and that's that's the way uh so the next horrible public event that happens there'll be a bunch of memory researchers running around and myl were saying where were you what were you doing what were you feeling because we need that to be able to verify whether your memory for emotionally intense experience is accurate or not and how how long it lasts um okay so couple experiments in the video um so here's eyewitness testimony there's nothing more dramatic in court right uh on the TV shows or in real life if you have to be around these things where the person says you know who was the person who murdered your neighbor and you go that's the woman that's the man right jur is look on you okay right okay so how accurate is eyewitness testimony I mean of course it has to be somewhat accurate we're not living in a crazy world where people people are randomly imagining things right but how accurate is it really because uh so here's a kind of an experiment they did uh this is work from Elizabeth lus who's a leader in this area she would have people just see slides this is before computers basically uh where a sports car would come to an intersection would turn and would hit a pedestrian in the slides so it's not the drama of really seeing it you know it's a stage thing and there would be either a yield sign or a stop sign uh just before the car turns that you would clearly see and let's PR you were in a condition where you saw the yield sign then afterwards they would say did another car pass the red datson while it was stopped at the yield sign that's consistent the word yield or did another car pass the datson while it was stopped at the stop sign see you slipped in the word stopped right uh or neutral you don't see anything and now you say which slide did you see okay you show them the actual slide with a stop sign or a yield sign you saw the yield line but here's what happens if you saw the yield sign and you and you uh uh have shown this yield on you do pretty well consistent but look what happens if you saw the yield sign you got the question did you see a stop sign and now you're tested which what did you actually see you're pretty much wrong you're pretty much saying I saw a stop sign that's retroactive interference you saw the yield sign you were asked about a stop sign and now you believe you saw a stop sign that's why it's so important how police or other people interrogate Witnesses right CU if they saw if they slip in certain words people will have a hard time going back to their original memory they'll have a memory that's a mixture of the original experience and the questions asked about that experience um so people said oh that's just a laboratory experiment in real life that wouldn't happen so they did this experiment uh uh Jim a graduate student reminded his younger brother Chris that they lost Chris in a mall when Chris was five uh and an and an older tallish man brought him back so that would be a pretty traumatic thing for a 5-year-old to be lost in them all and have an old man take you back right okay all right certainly for the parents are going where's the kid where's the kid so two days later Chris says the the younger kid um yeah now yeah I was with you guys for a second and then I went over to look at the toy store the KB story and then we got lost I was looking around I thought uh oh I'm in trouble now you know and then I thought I was never going to see my family again I was really scared you know and this old man I think he was wearing a blue flannel came up to me he was kind of old he was kind of bald he had a ring of Chris Chris was never lost he was never this Jim the graduate student mean to his younger brother but for good science reasons told him this slight story he didn't give him any of these details he just said remember when you were five years old you got lost in the mall and the old tall man brought you back but what's happening is you know our memories of when we're kids are pretty vague you know Chris is sort of mixing in some real things that happened and the story and he's fabricating you know for no he's not trying to get away with anything he's just creating this false memory so um and they said oh no we want even more life life likee than that so here's the experiment they did they had 120 students see an ad uh for Bugs Bunny at Disneyland to evaluate the ad so you're you're brought into a room you say we want to Market test whether this is a good ad uh uh for Disneyland and then they said you know and when then then these are and then and all all these people had been to Disneyland some years ago as kids in real life okay then they said you know by the way we're thinking about Bugs Bunny when you were there did you meet him did you shake his hand uh uh now what's the big trick about Bugs Bunny Disneyland I saw some Smiles right away he's Bugs Bunny is one of the few cartoon characters in many kids know that's not a Disney character okay and by law cannot be found at Disneyland or Disney World right but one out of three college students remembered seeing Bugs Bunny at Disney World or Disneyland when they were a kid after they had just seen some promotional material showing Bugs Bunny you know shaking hands right they sort of forgot you know because they had been there they don't remember stuff okay bugs money sure okay right right so again how potent is this way that we mix up new information with the original experience so we can't tell apart the original memory from the mixed up new relevant information I mean this would not have worked of course if they show you King Kong right you got there's no way Su King Kong it has to be slightly credible a yield stop but it but it just but it's a pretty big difference in some cases so here's one example in real life uh this is a real case in dark October night a woman hitchhiker picks up on Pacific Highway south of Seattle a hitchhiker turns into an isolated rope uh the man brutally rapes her and leaves her by the side of the Roe 24 hours later she looks at an array of photos and she picks out a man who is convicted because she says that's the man who brutally raped me a few months later another man is arrested for a series of rapes she sees his picture in the newspaper and she realizes oops sadly this is the man who attacked and raped me okay he's released from jail uh because uh he's by then he's lost his money his job his fiance his reputation he sends four years pursuing a lawsuit he dies 11 days prior to the trial 10 months later his estate gets 2.8 million because the police weren't very careful how they did the photo lineup it turns out if you look at the photo lineup his was the slightly out liar picture of the six pictures okay so the woman went for that guy so when she's accusing in court she's not trying to lie what's she mixing up her memory for the photo array versus her memory for the original event those two have gotten Blended in the punch bowl of her memory does that make sense perfectly with good intention uh uh and and you know there's 880,000 trials you're estimated that rely on eyewitness testimony and many many of those are mistaken it's just human nature to mistake them especially because trials are not boom one minute later there lots of discussion lots of dis uh you know interviews with policemen or prosecutors or lawyers lots of things happen from the original crime moment until that moment in court every discussion and thought and feeling you have from the original experience Blends in with the original experience and it can be hard to pull those apart um here's another sort of weird example uh a woman at home in Australia she's brutally raped in her home she identifies Donald Thompson now you'll see why this is a bit ironic weird story a renowned Australian psychologist who studies eyewitness memory problems okay it turns out he was on television at the moment uh that she was being raped and obviously she's in a very disturbed difficult moment and so she conflates the face on the TV with the face of the actual horrible perpetrator okay so he has a good Alibi he's on TV somewhere okay but you know in a perfectly good way I she's trying to be correct these things get jumbled together um so you're going to see in one minute a film of uh Susan n so here this is an amazing story eight-year-old girl uh well sorry you'll see the film of VI Franklin but she Susan n was an 8-year-old girl who was missing and found murdered in October 31 1969 TW uh see 20 years later Eileen Franklin you'll see her remembers that her remembers that her father uh murdered Susan Mason testifies against him and he's found guilty and he goes to jail he's been subsequently released because she says I was with him when he murdered my little friend but she doesn't remember it continuously she remembers it because a therapist has had her think about her past and all of a sudden what she feels like was a repressed memory comes back so we're going to show Tyler a movie about this topic it's it's your next paper topic what's the status of memory so this let's separate two things because it's really important cases where um women or men more often women uh remember being uh uh abused sexually abused you know and they remember it all the way through they may not like to think about it but they remember it all the way through that's that's not what we're talking about now what we're talking about are the the rarer cases where a man or a woman says I haven't thought about this I feel like I've repressed this for 20 or 30 or 40 years uh and now more often than not because of I'm working with maybe a psychologist or a clinical psychologist to help me with problems I have more you know I recover my repressed memory and it's a brutal thing because you can imagine on the one hand you have a say a young woman accusing her father or uncle or father let's say of doing something that we think is a you know terrible which is sexually abusing her the biggest you know failure of trust you can have in a father uh the biggest VI you know huge violation so he's horrible if she's right but if her memory is inaccurate what's more horrible than an innocent man being accused by his own daughter of of sexually abusing her because her memory is incorrect so we'll we we'll show you two films briefly and then we'll yeah so the father went to jail um so here's here's the lawyers who were defending the father wanted to tell the is the following thing which you know every account you read is accurate uh that when that everything that she described about the death of that girl Susan n every detail she described was in the newspaper accounts of the time and that no detail that she provided uh was you know verifiable and different than newspapers had reported at the time does that so so you know one of the things that people like to do investigators is have the person know something that wasn't publicly released and everything that she spoke about in regards to the little girl's murder Susan n's was publicly available information that had been on television or in newspapers and the the judge originally ruled that the jurors could not be told that uh and then later on uh they retried the Father the jurors were told that and the father was let go from jail um so there was this huge pendulum swing because originally as these repressed memory cases were brought up people said well why would the woman lie about such a horrible thing it's so horrible of course she must be telling the truth and of course the father must be lying to protect himself but now especially in the context of repressed memories again very different than continuing Memories the ones that recovered after decades there's a suspicion that some of them might be inaccurate uh and that some some psychologists working with some patients might be having patients think about possible sources of their difficulty and these memories get falsely constructed and the hard part and the part that you'll write your paper about is knowing which is which right because it's heart rening right you know it's heart-rending to have a woman who was abused be not believed uh it's heart-rending for a father who was not an abuser to be accused to being an abuser and it's incredibly hard to have direct evidence about who's telling the truth and who's not um in these kinds of cases that are so far from when the crime occurred uh and you know or might have occurred and you know where there's uh such a long period of non-d discussion about it because it's been repressed for decades so you look at that it's a big test it takes you into course in case you into clinical uh complexities of people

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 10 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011