Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu okay good afternoon so in the last couple of weeks we've gone through some you know some of the major human capacities that you have and I have and most people have most of them right which are the ability to see the world around us to attend to what's important to learn lessons from life to remember things while we sometimes forget things and today we're going to talk about another huge dimension of human experience of the human mind of the human brain language the ability to talk to one another you know I can talk you can listen and vice versa to read to communicate in the ways that are so remarkable our love our life is flooded with language right that we hear that we read and so on so when psychologists try to sort of divide up language into study of all components they talk about comprehension understanding what somebody says to you when you're an infant or now as an adult or reading text or producing speech which you can do with your mouth by speaking or you learn to write so you can both comprehend and produce language both visually and orally and a thing that has you know greatly enamored linguists to figure out is how a language that we speak is endlessly generative I'm not sure you can actually calculate out how many sentences we could possibly produce but just for fun people have done stuff and they said it would take a hundred trillion years to memorize all the sentences we can produce I'm not sure that's exactly the right number but it's a lot right because we can say a lot of different sentences and understand what a person saying it's a incredibly generative system for communication one person to another so when people in psychology think about different aspects of language levels of language they often divided it something like this phonology is the sounds of language that we hear that we acquire as infants that we use to speak to one another syntax grammar and by this this isn't like school grammar or not you know get the sentence right it's just regret the understanding of the organization of words and how that changes the meaning of the sentence syntax semantics what are the words mean what are the groups of words mean pragmatics and we'll talk about each of these a little bit sometimes you know a person is sarcastic so they go you go that was an awesome yes sir lecture yesterday in psychology somebody could say that in 100 trillion years and uh and you go yeah yeah right okay so that's the pragmatics versus us semantics then of course it's not just sentences there's we have whole discussions and another aspect of language we'll just touch on a little bit today is their emotional comprehension and production the tone somebody speaks in the tone you produce are also informative so as many aspects of language we'll start with so the base most basic or phonology so phonemes are the words that people used to describe two building blocks of speech sounds so boy versus toy are differ by one phonemes phonemes are the building blocks of the sounds of language human use about a hundred phonemes across languages but any given language only uses a subset and this has really interesting consequences of course a language could only exist in the world if you could understand those phonemes you know phonemes that are understandable I'm going to be part of anybody's language but different languages through for historical reasons have ended up using different subsets of phonemes and we'll come back to that when we're babies for about the first six months of our lives were Universal learners we know all the phonemes and respond to all of them as we become native language speakers and listeners we become only good at the ones that are used in our language and our ability to even recognize the ones that are not in our language disappears you can get it back some but the older the you are you never get it back fully so we're universal learners at birth but we become enslaved to the language that we are native speakers of and listen to within months of birth English is about forty-five so it's meant more than a number of letters we have and sometimes people get confused a little bit letters or phonemes they're not so you know hot and cold have the Oh hot and the O sound and cold are different sounds same letter so there's many more phonemes even in English when they say it's about forty five depending on dialects you can have a couple more a couple less so again we're born to use all of them we use them or lose something we don't entirely lose it but we can we're never as good if we try to learn a distinction once we become older than that humans understand speech at an incredible rate the typical fast talking is about 180 words a minute 14 phonemes a second and a continuous speech stream but people can go up to 250 words we're incredibly fast language processors incredibly fast language processors so how do we roughly conceptualize in the most simple way you know what we have to do to to get to a word that we hear to get to its meaning well coup stick information comes to the ear those are you know wave forms physical things arriving at our ears we sort of in some way figure out how those correspond to phonemes and then map that in some way to words that have meanings in the world and the reason why machine's understanding what you say is shockingly hard to do a good job on is for the following reason there's a huge difference between a word by the time your mind understands what it is and the nature of the signal that arrived at your ear so we talked a lot about that in terms of the retina and vision right you have this very impoverished stuff that arrives on your retina and then the whole rest of your brain you know millions and millions of neurons and synapses reconstruct what's out there from a very impoverished retinal input and the same thing happens in audition what gets to your ear is incredibly impoverished and the rest of your brain has to brilliantly reconstruct what it heard and assign it to meaning and so part of the challenge of your mind and brain to do that is this this is a representation of something like the physical signal that arrives at your ear and you could say well here's one word here's another word what's the problem okay but this is all the signal that arrives that you're weird for the word captain so here's the see all this stuff for the a a period of long silence that sets up the P okay turns out I'll convince you of this in a moment that our speech is full with in words of silent breaks that are incredibly informed and alter our perception of what's physically going on then the little T is long stuff for the AI this long stuff for the N so the physical signal to your ear you know barely resembles what seems like a single unit captain right and where is that pause when person doesn't say cap or doesn't say cut one two three pertain right okay but I mean but the pause is happening and it's incredibly informative as I'll show you so that that's the incredible thing your your your auditory system your language system has to reconstruct the sound into phonemes into words it's not obvious from the physics physical signal in the year it's not even that a physical signal at the ear gives you much information at the outset about whether you're hearing one word or two words or three words so here is what and do you mean as one big blend where is du where's you words you mean and why does what look so separate and these three words what do you mean you know get all garbled together and you have to unpack them by your brain in mind here's another example John said that the dog snapped at them the dog snapped here's what's coming roughly to your ear taken from spoken speech and here again notice that the boundaries that you can see here the gaps of silence occur you know not very related to the boundaries between the words that your mind ultimately understands so here's the word the dog here's s4 snapped here's a good pause but that's the pause between the P sound and the T sound I mean that looks like a good word boundary to a machine that's a very good word boundary okay it's not a word boundary for you you know snapped as one word and here comes at ad is kind of blended into the T right so there's this physical signal it doesn't even give you breaks where words separate from one another it's kind of a continuous mix of breaks and silences so here's to convince you that a silence carries incredible information in it let's see make sure I have the volume okay so I'm going to play you this this is the physical signal to your ear the word say say okay then they yeah okay alright I always work as how there's an expert in this and I'm almost like please Tyler don't embarrass me when I'm wrong okay I you don't have this pressure out there but the teaching assistants are all experts in something or another and then they know more often than I do in that topic and we hit their topic in the course I'm looking over there nervously okay so so here's say now they're going to take this thing and just separate this you know just just in the way you do a physical signal computer just separate in time they're just going to add a little bit of time and what do you hear say the T sound that makes is simply adding silence here to produce that now that's what you hear all the time it's not a random choice but isn't amazing that silence is as ultimately informative for your mind as actual language sounds themselves and now all this is happening on the order of thousands of a second and bits of information that's bad enough here's another amazingly tough thing so people like to compare consonants that have a lot of similarities but some interesting differences ba and does it's really comparing B versus deeds throwing on the a just to have a vowel sound so here again is a representation of what's coming to your ear notice that all the difference between the B and the D these two consonants all the physical differences occurring in 40 thousandths of a second 40,000 so the second is all the physical difference that you get as you hear these two things forty thousands of a second and yet you know you can hear the word bad and you're not going bad dab if you're one of those thousands of the seconds right and now that you'd be another word in other word in a sentence that's why they people use the word speech stream and we think of it as a speech torrent right phonemes phonemes phonemes breaks all garbled together and your mind has to go back and constantly instantly and brilliantly figure out what you heard so let me give you another example because part of the challenge of this our phonemes occur in the context of words and sentences so make sure I have good volume on this okay so let's do this first one good what was that what okay here's the same thing and a person is going to say this now all by yourself you got that right okay very saw the three little pigs in the corridor okay but here's the amazing thing the first sound you heard I'll replay it they took the word little and they cut it out from the last sentence you heard when little is said all by itself what you comes to your ear is literally the first thing you heard not this because when you say a word in isolation little people say it differently but we almost never talk like that we almost always have a sentence and it turns out the way we say things and therefore the way you hear things is hugely influenced by what comes before it and what comes after it nevermind things like the speed at which different people talk the accent that talk or the loudness of the background conversation okay but just simply the fact that you're going to say little by itself and how does that work it's amazing right listen again if you heard little all by itself and it's exactly the same physical signal it's not so good okay let me try that again that's exactly the same physical signal exactly the same physical signal as the three bill days in the court are the what you hear easily as little as exactly that words in isolation and this is a great demonstration if you hear a word cut out the reason why it sounds like nothing is your mind is already preparing how to interpret that given what you heard just before it and also a little bit what you hear just after it okay your mind is constantly fixing up things because it knows what's going on what's going into it what's coming out is not because it just simply hears the word itself if we lived in a world where people just do one word every half an hour you know we could do this in a world where we're talking to each other and sentences all the time we have to do this here's another example of our brilliant auditory system for hearing these kinds of things so again these are representations of how this physical signal Arizer your ear hears the word bet be boat and bird they all start with the same B sound that's easy right but look what it came to your ear look at this signal this signal this signal look at this one how different does this look it's different because what follows the bird influences how this is said but you can see that you trends you translate both of these into the B sound pretty easily now look at these words these all start with D look at how bet and debt look almost identical we said it's only 40 milliseconds difference 40 thousands of a second difference of physical ignorant through your ear but you can tell the word bet versus debt look at that word D how different it looks from word to word so your mind is constantly figuring out what you're hearing the problem of invariance and it's constantly coming to you in incredibly variable ways okay all right so one of the tools we have and an amazing human capacity is what's called categorical perception so we have all this huge range of physical sounds that can come to our ear and kind of brilliantly and you don't even think about it I mean none of you go around bragging about your categorical perception abilities right like when you go to spring break right and you maybe some of you will go home or you'll see friends and you won't go you know I have categorical perception I try to be modest about it you know but it's it's an amazing human talent and essential because what it does is this we hear this huge range of sounds depending on accents what comes before what comes after and we have to decide that's a B and we're going to do is take this huge range of things and just go boom it's a B or a D and that's all there is to it so here's the way they do it so categorical perception sounds can vary continuously we showed you some of this continuity they in this experiment on purpose they're going to vary sounds in a very continuous physical way but in our heads for ba and DA here in our heads all the stuff that's over here even though they're very different one from the other at a physical specific level we'll say ba I'm done with it we're going to put it into one category for interpretation and you're gonna have a pretty sharp boundary here and everything over here all these physical Ignis you're going to call pas and so you're not going to spend a lot of time going that was a one third ba two thirds pas probability if we couldn't do that right because you couldn't get through a word number - sentence you're going to instantly group huge numbers of things that are specific different from one another into two categories that need to be separated so here's the kind of experiment they do I'll just give you the feeling of it here's what they're varying okay in constant units constant units you know every stimuli is here is different but every time you hear ba and the constant going to vary something about its physical property you always call it a B and then something happens in about 20 milliseconds of information and boom you always call it a P okay so change change change change change in the physical signal you call it one category a little bit more change boom it's the other category and you keep changing but for you it's always a perfectly good P even those every one of those are different alright so it's an amazing fundamental capacity to take a huge you know for all practical purposes an infinite variety of inputs and say it's a B or a P if that's the world I'm working in syntax that's another way in which we understand things the way that words are organizing order so we could say the model embrace the designer and the photo photographer mentioned somebody sank to this but then they complete the sentence the model embraced the designer and the photographer laughed okay so people who study syntax really are interested in what happens in your mind as you hear the model embrace the designer and the photograph photographer and some big group hug is going on right and then all of a sudden you get this word laughed and all you've does it rearranged the elements in your mind that's what syntax is letting you do to say oh the meaning is really quite different okay there's only one hub going on and one person laughing at them right but the meaning it overtime is somebody talks to you set up your thinking this boom because you understand syntax you understand what happened semantics are kind is more straightforward we usually think about them they're the meaning of words or sentences morphemes and we can understand semantics even when the sentence is nonsense colorless green ideas sleep furiously is a famous example we can understand semantics even in bad grammatical sentences right fastly eat dinner or ball games start soon you know your your fifth-grade teacher would be up in arms to hear that but you understand you know eat now go see the ball game right okay so we get through a lot of stuff to get semantics and we can see interactions I stole this example from Ted Gibson because it took me like 20 minutes to figure out what the sentence means you're probably faster than I am you are you K funk I'm going to the old man we're where's the missing words or yeah the old man the boats okay so you know this is how you have to parse up the sense it's not always obvious people who study language love these things where people are all confused most of our lives we don't go through that much confusion but there's some fun ones sort of like the visual illusions to point out how meaning and syntax can interact as you figure out things here's another example Jay Leno talked about sex with Lyndsey lon okay now wait a minute did I miss an excellent episode of Jay Leno or or you know was she on the show and talking about safety and saying I'd rather not talk about my recent conviction I'd rather talk about something less controversial okay so um so somatic all these things are constantly interacting in your mind is kind of amazing when you think about that right we said phonology is amazing some six syntax boom they're all happening in you and none of you are sitting there going just a phonology please don't ask me to semantics you know we just admit terms right brilliant so one of the ways that people try to convince themselves that these things are separable and gives a little bit more insight as evoked response potentials those are these things that you can measure on infants or adults that measure electrical activity in milliseconds and the speed of language processing surface electrodes that give you an index of hundreds of a few hundred thousand neurons and this is an example you saw before actually earlier in the course the so called n 400 so n means whether the wave is going up or down negative or positive 400 means it occurs about 400 milliseconds about half a second after the relevant event so here's this uh you know let's see he it was his first day at work as the baseline he spread the warm bread with socks oh my gosh socks semantically bad and here comes the n400 okay and the controlled condition is you throw up this unexpected wear shoes that's weird but not semantically and you get it quite a different response so here's an N 400 it seems to Sippy about semantic expectation or congruence how about if you mess up syntax the spoiled child throw the toys on the box and uh you know then you get a response at about 600 milliseconds to syntactic and congruity so people this is just more evidence that in the brain meaning or semantics and syntax or something about word order are processed somewhat differently in time and place pragmatics is kind of fun it's practical understanding right the old joke do you know what time it is and the person says yes they're messing with your sense of pragmatics that you're you know two negatives make a positive saying oh yeah yeah I've heard that one before earlier in the lecture now here's something kind of interesting again which is remarkable and if you didn't do the experiment you could know that our mind is like this because you wouldn't do things like this except because it sounds too ridiculous but your mind does it all the time so we're going to think about the word bugs and I have to set you up a little bit with paradigms you've heard before but just remind you of these things so one thing we one kind of task that psychologists like to use to think about how people process words is a lexical decision tasks all you're deciding is whether a word is a wheel word or a nonsense word okay so dr.
is real poplar is not spy as a real word this spelling is not a real word okay so a real word not a real word we also talked about one other idea really in the course that if prior to processing a word like doctor you get an unrelated word or a related word you process doctor faster if you had a related word before its semantic priming the ideas about nurse overlap a lot with the ideas about doctor and seeing this word before makes you process this word faster so you need those two things in mind what was the person doing is it a real word or not and you're going to mess with what's in their mind before that related or unrelated and here's the experiment so you would hear over headphones something like this as an example rumor has it that for years the government building had been plagued with problems now here's the critical sentence the man was not surprised when he found several spiders roaches and other bugs in the corner of his room so there's two senses of the word at least two meanings of the word bug right the insect you don't want in your soup at or the microphone that somebody slipped into your room to listen what's going on two different meanings for the word bug this is obviously about the insect so the person is hearing this over headphones and on a computer monitor in front of them after they hear the word bugs here they see for a lexical decision the word ant which is related to this meeting or spy which is related to the other meaning that's not relevant for here or so which is the control condition we'll ignore that okay that's just a control condition I'll ignore that remote so you're making a lexical decision now on the related meaning or the unrelated meaning and here's what they find if it's the related meeting and you only have about a half second from when they came on to when you had to do this task so you saw the word bug and here comes this you're you're faster but if you get the unrelated meaning within a half a second of processing the word you're also faster what this means is your mind has done exactly what you would think it wouldn't do your mind has looked up in your brain and in your knowledge of vocabulary every meaning of the word even the sentence is clearly setting you up for the word the insect meaning isn't every meaning of your word is turned on and available to you your mind does the opposite of what you might think you might think well I know let's look at the sentence you know I know once I get spiders roaches and bugs by here you know you're in the insect world not in the world of spies right okay but your mind even then looks up every possible word because it's cheaper for the mind to look up every word than to start to decide what the reappropriation other-- a second and a half you're only fast for the selected meaning and now you're slowed down for the one that's not context relevant so your mind looks up everything all the time every every meaning of every word you know every time that word pops up it seems like your mind looks up every meaning and then the rest of your mind selects out the one that's relevant and shuts down the ones that are not but you wouldn't think that you'd think maybe I'll just get the one I need I'm not going to get everything it's like I'm not gonna put all my clothes on walk outside and take off everything that's not relevant for the weather right all right that seems like a really like a you know inefficient way to get dressed right but that's not the way your mind is your mind it's cheaper and more efficient to look up every meaning every time and then pick the right one it's more efficient and that's how people do it so people use this word exhaustive lexical access I look up every meaning of the word and then I'll pick out the correct one another another interesting aspect of sort of that could be brought into pragmatics and we'll talk a little bit more about this later in the course but emotional intonation and it turns out where's almost all language processes are left dominant as we've talked about many times in the course one stream of ass processing language both visual and auditory is right hemisphere dependent and that's emotional intonation and that brings us to our reading for today from Oliver Sacks and I have to say I think Oliver Sacks is a phenomenal author but there's always been the sense of like hamat some of these stories are just a bit too true to be you know just a bit cute or whatever it is and so for years I taught for this story and I believe it's likely true but I thought well it's just a little cute and then came an experiment that showed is it's not only cute but it's exactly correct okay so for this you appreciate this a bit more if you if you know a couple things about Ronald Reagan who was president in the 1980s so what do you guys know about Ronald Reagan what party was okay there you go was he considered a good communicator yes he was considered hey you know you can have all kinds of views and around Regas leagues the public said he's an awesome communicator if I Barack Obama said he would like to communicate like Ronald Reagan all right whether that's to get Republican votes or not you know as here's your judgment but uh but he was considered an excellent communicator was he considered by and large to be an extremely analytic thinker might have been I don't know him but not so much now part of this is the prejudice or not these from California and he was an actor before he became a you know president and a governor president he also had some degree of well he ultimately had Alzheimer's disease his question about late in his administration whether he was already working his way towards that so anyway complicated things but he was master communicator but not necessarily you know the Barack Obama Bill Clinton Jimmy Carter version of analytic power is a general perception you never know whether these are right or wrong but for the person but in this story listening to the president's speech are patients with aphasia that Oliver Sacks described and is getting laughter as they're watching his speech and what happens is some of the people with the left hemisphere lesions they have a language problem we see a video of that pretty shortly they're laughing because they sort of think he's that he's uh that he's the way he's talking his facial expressions they find hilarious okay now why do they find it hilarious they're not they have a damage to the parts of the brain that help them understand the content of his message on the left hemisphere and here's what here's where the sax thinks is going on the feelings I have which all of us who work closely with the physics have is that they can you cannot lie to an aphasic he cannot grasp your words and so be deceived by them but what he grasps he grabs with infallible precision namely the expression that goes with the words that total spontaneous involuntary expresses this which can never be simulated or faked or words alone or words alone can hide all sometimes too easily so you know when you give up very public speech especially under tough circumstances the president sometimes have to do you know we sometimes things are the tension between exactly what they're saying and exactly what they're thinking okay and what they feel they need to say and exactly what they know behinds behind the scenes and so the idea is that these are faces were feet where they were saying you know this guy obviously doesn't mean what he's saying look at his face look at his tone I don't know what he's saying but it's hilarious how he's masking his face and speaking in a funny tone to tell something he truly doesn't believe okay that's their interpretation and yet he has an opposite patient a patient with a right hemisphere lesion we said that's the side of the hemisphere that seems important for facial expressions and emotional intonation and she complains about the logic of the case he's making as if having normally we talked to somebody's both left hemispheres getting the content analyzing the content right hemispheres something about the intonation true or not true whether they are their eyes like this and they can't even face us as they tell us something they know is false okay so but these patients may be because they have one channel of information knocked out because of injury to become hyper sensitive to the other one all right so I thought well that sounds fantastically you know interesting but you know is that really true so here in Boston they did a study with a large number of patients that's the superior identification of people who are lying to you they had they had made video clips and audio clips of people who are lying to you if they had a left hemisphere lesion so this is a paper so here's the two examples so they have an example let's pick this one we're both you see you see just a facial expression of a person talking the voice is turned down your job is to decide whether a person is lying or not okay and some videos are lying some videos they're not so how would you do well I don't know how you would do but I can tell you how a group of Harvard undergraduates did 50% is chance and here's how they did okay that was one of their control groups and in fact for studies like this they brought in many many kinds of people to ask whether anybody is better everybody's pretty much terrible at directly telling whether a lie is going on now these are video clips of people you don't know in circumstances you don't know that could matter but everybody is terrible at that policemen are terrible FBI agents are terrible the only group that seems to be above chance and not much above it our Secret Service agents okay so if you're a friend with a Secret Service agent and you wanted to see them you know keep in mind that they seem to be above chance or not awesome they're above chance but Luke was doing better than everybody patients were the left hemisphere lesions and the interpretation is all the content of the lie is gone all they see is your expression or your expression and intonation and because that's all they have to go on they can tell more when you have the discomfort of lying than a person who's partly persuaded by hearing the message you're sending as you talk so I thought this was an overly cute example but it turns out to be exactly replicable in a full study any question about that okay so let's talk a little bit about the brain basis of language we've talked a little bit about you know we know that if you have damage here you have Broca's aphasia on the left hemisphere trouble producing language damage here Wernicke's aphasia trouble comprehending language to a first approximation and and there's a lot of research that has made this much more complicated but to a first approximation the lesions are in frontal cortex or temporal cortex the speech in these patients are what's called non fluent or telegraphic they get single words out but have a hard time anything like a sentence can be very frustrating for these patients Wernicke's patients seem much happier you'll see a film in a moment their speech is fluent but it's amazingly empty of content okay these patients have trouble producing speech for their comprehension is decent these patients produce speech pretty well but their comprehension so they're sort of mirror opposites and let's see what I want yes so in this field a frequent incredibly frequently used picture to study aphasia is this specific picture it's called the cookie theft picture why it's become widely used I'm not exactly sure but once it's widely used enough that everybody uses it okay so they'll put a picture like this in front of the fit of an individual and they'll ask them to describe what's going on is to elicit production and you know you would say something like you know here's you know there's two kids the kids down a stool oh they're gonna fall over because you know they're falling off the cookie jar and the mother sort of not paying attention her mind must be somewhere else because she's letting the water splish-splash here right that's what you'd say something like that okay so let's see what patients with aphasia say and other examples of their difficulty with language yeah the writing tends to go pretty much with their spoken language okay that's a really good question about so the question is what would the writing be like it very much parallels their spoken language yeah sorry okay so this week very good question cannot could not fluent aphasics learn sign language to bypass in a sense their problem right so I'm about to answer that in a moment right on the next slide not directly that but the implication of that right okay because the important thing is so let me show you this thing let me come back the question is you know could you train an aphasic to use sign language to get around because or her language problem right if it's a speech problem so people have studied a sign language as a language for many reasons but a huge one is this because I'm going to interpret your question the way I need to and then you can tell me if I did it right for from your perspective versus in what sense is language equal speech right because could could you communicate linguistically like but just switch to your hands if for some reason and the answer is that at the level of the problem of these patients they could not do it because they're these kinds of patients the problem isn't really speech there are people who can't forgive problems with the motor apparatus to move their mouth that does exist their problem is in language processes that produce your speech intent okay or language processes that extract meaning from sounds and those language processes that produce what you want to say that comprehend what you hear or read those are the same ones that are utilized as far as we understand whether you're producing language in the typical vocal way or in the less typical but well studied way of sign language that makes it okay so you can't get around it because it's a language problem so both by brain imaging evidence for example here are patients who use sign language turning on Broca's area and Wernicke's area on tasks that are about comprehension and productions the same areas whether it's using your hands for sign language or using your mouth to talk or your ear to hear further they've been really fun studies where they took deaf infants and have shown and it's not easy to show up but I think most people are convinced that they babble with their hands the same way babies make little sounds to get themselves going we'll talk more about infants in a moment infants who grow up in an environment where they only learn sign language bable with their hands because speech you know language is not about your mouth talking it's about ideas that you can communicate by your production or comprehension by your hand over your mouth so language is separable from speech because even without speech you communicate in very much the same way in terms of sign language by many studies yeah like an action words since either against or that they also couldn't like it magic words are like cupen the people with the Broca's area I don't think so III you know we talked to us before that I may not be understanding your question exactly but that in many ways imagining something is the same part of the brain that does it when we imagine a face we turn on the parts of our brain that sees I think when you imagine if you if you sit I do this sometimes I say here's what I'm going to say to that person in my head okay and I practice that little speech that's this part of the brain pretty much running okay just another this is a last little step of moving your mouth but that's from the discussion we're having now that's kind of a superficial thing of moving your mouth okay that's not speech planning speech thinking speech intentions those are a core process for production for comprehension and I think imagined stuff this is exactly the same way right is that okay yeah yeah how what is your thinking yeah it's a good question is if there are so that if they have this troubles with score language ideas abilities what's the thinking light I can just tell you that it's a sort of a classic debate for humans how deeply language equals thought but language now and in a sense of speech okay it's just one of those things that people debate a lot because it depends what you mean by these things in many different ways but but if language means something like comprehending ideas in the world it's hard to get around that for thinking about it it means planning actions in the world that changed the world around you and communicating that it's hard to to do to not have that capacity for thinking in that way right so it's at this level not whether use your hands or your mouth it's very hard to separate out what you might call thought and what you might call language but keep in mind that these patients that we see you know it's not like they lost all of language at all so even though the Broca's aphasic cross child producing language he's produces some and he comprehends it pretty well so it's not like these patients have lost all of their language circuitry and therefore don't have thought available right they have a lot of language left in their head and a lot of thought left in their mind is that okay um so one interesting thing that people have wondered where a brain imaging gives us evidence that we couldn't have imagined you know 15 years ago is this so you had if you have damage let's say here's a patient with damage to the left frontal area and they get better because they've had a stroke here or an injury here they get better a question that people have wondered is do they get better by sort of somehow recovering ability and the part of the brain that got injured or do they get better because they use an entirely different pathway in their brain now until brain imaging you couldn't begin to touch that question but now we have some evidence then I'll make it just but so here's an example of a patient who has damaged here they have him do a task that in healthy people turns on exactly that place and when he does it he can do it okay and where does he do it in his right hemisphere so this patient seems to switch which hemisphere he uses for language it takes time and training to recover that but it seems like he's found an alter pathway to produce the language somehow turns out that the more people have studied these things are more complicated it gets maybe just diversity of people the diversity of injuries or whatever so it doesn't always work this way but often it seems like when people have better recovery from a large injury to the speaking left hemisphere they find a way somehow through practice and training to get the right hemisphere to take over some of those responsibilities okay language acquisition so one of the most amazing things about infants right is they go from zero to speech in just a couple of years and go through an unbelievable training and the program of development so what happens in two or three months they perceive all the phonemes they notice this change in phonemes by six months they start to ignore distinctions among sounds that are not used in their language and was other language sounds they start to babble that's getting there in some way getting their speech ready to go by eight months they start to identify single words in a speech stream in a year they're back there babbling becomes more adult-like sounding but about a little bit after that they get up to about fifty words in understanding so comprehension always goes ahead of production you know children understand words before they could speak them but then the lagging here comes a speech telegraphic speech short sentences at two years and then you know finally pretty complete speech in many ways by nine so it's a long long process learning you know ten thousand words estimated by the age of six is a spectacular learning curve when they do experiments on infants where they measure things like preference or learning by sucking rates and a nipple because they can't talk they're trying to figure out what is the infant hearing within two hours of birth they suck with more enthusiasm to their mother voice over another voice these are infants this is their first visit to their mother and half you have to sign up to do this experiment you know that now they might have heard their mother's voice in a certain way in the womb right so this it's not the but they already have picked up by three-day-old they prefer language to many other sounds like music now we come to love music but that's not the urgent business of the infant okay by four days old they start to notice and says between languages this is amazing right there the the rate of learning is fantastic and by two months they can tell the Baga distinction you know subtle distinctions forty milliseconds information and then they develop a continuingly strong preference for the sounds of their native language now some years ago people debated endlessly this left hemisphere specialization for languages is fantastically essential and striking in humans does that grow over time or is it in your mind and brain at birth okay and the evidence is pretty compelling from many sources but here's maybe the most here's fMRI on two-day-old infants you might ask how do they instruct the infant's to lie still in the scanner and participate in the experiment and the answer is at two days old infants mostly just lay there and don't do much okay all right I mean you know I said I mean they don't they don't do much and he's a lot going on their mind but they don't have much physical apparatus to do much say you could swaddle them very warmly you just lay you know you put them on a cradle into the fMRI scanner their parents have signed up they you know for them and you can play them sounds where they just lay there and do nothing they can't push buttons they can't do stuff but you can see what's happening inside their brain and at two days old here's the left hemisphere response to language compared to the right so it's there as you know instantly we believe it's been there actually in the womb as the child's been developing though this left hemisphere genetically set up dominance for language and almost everybody fMRI just for those of you who yeah you get again we can start doing it at about age five but from about three months to age five it's incredibly hard to do children in a scanner but the first couple of days it's not so hard now a really interesting a line of research has talked about motherese have you heard this term so how do how do grown-ups even college students talk to babies you talk to babies just like you talk to everybody else No cute baby baby baby you know what everybody looks like an idiot right okay alright and you can just think okay that's just people being idiots around babies but it turns out there's been beautiful beautiful studies to show that what you spontaneously do this and you know I do you and I don't take motherese or father ease courses right what we do spontaneously is that way of elongating sounds the intonations we give our incredibly perfect to help the baby learn language we're exactly doing what they can understand okay and that at that again must be virtually in our genes I think it's you know we hear it around so it's not zero but the short pauses careful enunciation exaggerated intonation baby view that's you can do an experiments where you take language and you get rid of those and the babies are like they don't know what's going on they're not interested you put them back in boom those are perfect for the baby okay that's amazing not only how babies are ready to go but how adults who talk with them are ready to go I mean it's just amazing okay it's you know none of us will ever be as good a teacher in a classroom as all of you will be with a baby anytime you talk with them right it's just amazing so there's beautiful experiments that show that every time you tinker with the way that mothers spontaneously or parents spontaneously talked to infants you make it worse less interesting and less informative for the infant so now let's talk about a more formal experiment to sort of these are they sort of the classic experiment that nailed home this message that at Birth were Universal under standards of all sounds in the world as the years go along we become only good at the sounds that are relevant that are part of our own language a famous example you know in the u.s.
it's a difficult difficulty for Japanese native speakers for the r.l distinction but every language has some distinctions that doesn't make and they're really hard when you get older so here's the idea in English we make a distinction between ba and DA and by 10 to 12 months and infants can make that distinction and certainly adults can that's categorical deception that we talked about that kind of division between Banda but their sounds that occur in other language so was shown here and you're going to hear some of you may know Hindi sounds and it'll be different experience for you when I every year when I first hear this clip I'm about to show you I think something's wrong because they say the infant's going to tell the difference between da and da and I go well how they going to I can't do that okay that's because there really are different sounds they're hearing but in English they're not different sounds and so it all sounds the same to me I'm the longer universal learner you know haven't been since quite a while okay so here we go understand always by the brilliance of the infant you know researchers like this who somehow pretty convincingly in most cases you know really tell you what the infant is knows or pays attention to our thanks and pretty compelling ways even though they can't tell you themselves um so so one thing that's come up in the u.s.
I mean the whole world is a kid you know becoming evermore bilingual and trilingual there used to be some concerns less now and I'll tell you you don't have to worry about it whether it's bad to learn to language that once when you're a kid and some parents worry about this right you're going to be all messed up because you're going to blend them all up and not do well in school and so there's been quite a bit of research actually asking tracking and asking whether there's any downside it is huge upsides to knowing two or three languages are there any downsides in terms of language development and the objective evidence is pretty compelling that for babbling for first words for first picture four pairs of words at a Sun things at two months that there's really no cost so they followed in Canada for example children who grew up learning English and French English and ASL French and for English only everybody does the same pretty much there's no cost okay compared to the huge gain sometimes some kids will get a little mixed up they'll actually mix up languages because they'll just get mixed them up when they're pretty young but there's no developmental delay or milestones or negative consequences there's only the benefit of having you know two or three languages that you could speak so the evidence is overwhelming empirically that there's no cost for learning more than one language at a time when you're an infant um one thing there is a cost a little bit if you're a boy okay so unknown why this happens I mean that I don't things any deep science about it but everybody has observed that for example number of new words understood during the first two years of life that girls on average outperform boys and language acquisition early on and then things get you know closer pretty much but the rate of learning on girls and averages is faster than boys nobody I think understands the specific basis of that so people talk about critical periods in language acquisition you know and what are fragile or resilient aspects of language where language is that aspects of learning languages seem very dependent on the age you are which are independent so phonology including the production of the language sounds seems very fragile easy when you're young harder when you're older grammar is also age sensitive making subtle grammatical distinctions learning about meaning or vocabulary you're perfectly fine when you're an adult that doesn't seem to show something like a sensitive period and here's one famous study that you know that established some of these things they looked at what age people arrive to different countries from different countries to the US that started learning English that people didn't know English before and then they had them do they're all adults now and they had to do quickly grammatical judgments and what they found is if you came to the US when you were born in the US you came to the age three to seven you know you were very good at doing this but the later you came here eight to ten years of age 11 to 15 17 to 39 your ability to make these vast subtle of grammatical judgments you know just went down even though you've been here in many cases for many years you're very smart accents are like that right people come to the US at a certain point in their development they're very skilled in English and big vocabulary but the accent never disappears that's another thing in the terms of language production that has this fragile developmental early period so the last thing I'll do and then show you a movie for about eight minutes you know one of the sort of we get these occasional sort of horrible experiments it's not even an experiment of nature which is an experiment of horrible human behavior and the most famous one in language development which had a huge impact on the field at the time is as a child Genie I'll show you see her in a movie clip in a moment they discovered her a lock in a root room in a house from age 20 months approximately until they discovered her at 13 she was she almost spoke to no one so the people taking care of her locked her in a closet basically and do not talk with her or she had no language interactions until they she was discovered and rescued and then they performed research for years saying what could she could she learn things what could she not learn she got single words for example but she never got particularly good at grammar so either syntax you know sort of brutal way to test the idea that what's acquirable later in life and what if you don't learn it early in life it's been possible to acquire fully so all in would this will do this for like five minutes or seven minutes got there its summarized in your book it's you know everybody knows about it because this is a study couldn't do epically in a million years right he would never do which is if you deprive a child you the critical period of language exposure and she never got lots of aspects of language going she got okay and you know a minimal vocabulary grew in other ways but many of the things that come from a language perspective she never got machine miss secretary so that's a bit of a sad story obviously but have a good Spring Break been a refreshing spring break and I'll see you ten days you you