Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu um so it's a beautiful recording okay so uh to get started um question from last time so Barton covered for me last time I I fled I was out of town um I was at a math conference it was pretty surreal questions yes about the exam yes absolutely so um the exam uh is as you all know on Thursday uh weekend so on Tuesday we will have a lecture the material Tuesday will not be covered uh on the exam the exam will be a review of everything through today's lecture including the problem set which for some technical reason I don't know why it didn't get posted but it should be up after lecture today um the exam will be a a combination of short questions and uh computations uh it will not focus on an enormous number of computations it will focus more on conceptual things but there will be a few calculations uh on the exam um and I will post some practice problems uh over the next couple of days um have a problem you you do have a problem due Tuesday and that is part of your preparation for the exam here's a basic strategy for exams for this class anything that's on a problem set is fair game anything that's not covered on a problem set is not going to be fair game if you haven't seen a problem on it broadly construed then then you won't you know I won't test you on a topic you haven't done problems on before um but I will take problems and ideas that you've studied before and spin them slightly differently to make you think through them in real time on the exam Okay so the purpose from my point of view the purpose of these exams is not to give you a grade I don't care about the grade the purpose of these exams is to give you feedback on your understanding okay it's very easy to slip through quantum mechanics and think like oh yeah I totally I got this this is fine but it's uh it's not always uh it's not always an accurate read so that's the point um did that answer your question okay other questions exam yeah uh about the harmonic oscillator actually EXC um when we solve it Tuesday using the series method yes um so there are two solutions techn right the even solution and the odd term solution good so did boundary conditions Force the other one to be completely zero like the coefficient in front of it so like there's like an a zero term which determines all the other ones yes um but there there's like an a zero term and an A1 term for the evens and odds so did the other one just have to be zero this is a really good question so this is an excellent question let me ask the question slightly differently and tell me if this is the same question when we wrote down our differential equation so last time we did the harmonic oscillator and uh Barton gave you the Brute Force strategy for the harmonic oscillator we want to find the energy igen states because that's what we do to solve the the star equation and to we turn that into a differential equation and we solve this differential equation by doing an ASM totic analysis and then a series expansion right now this is a second order differential equation everyone agree with that it's a second order differential equation however uh in our series expansion we ended up with uh one integration constant not two how does that work how can it be that there was only one integration constant not two it's a second order differential equation right is this your question okay and this is an excellent question because it must be two true that there are two solutions it cannot be that there is just one solution it's a second order differential equation there existence and uniqueness theorems which tell us there are two integration constants okay so how can it possibly be that there was only one well some we did something rather subtle in that series expansion in order to for that series expansion there was a critical moment which I'm not going to go through but you can come to my office hours again but just look through the notes there's an important moment in the notes when we say aha these terms matter but what we did is we suppressed a singular solution there's a solution of that differential equation which is not well behaved which is not smooth and in particular which diverges okay and we already did from the ASM totic analysis we already fixed that the ASM totic Behavior was exponentially falling but there's a second solution which is exponentially growing so what we did remember how we did this this story we took our wave function and we said okay look we're going to pull off we're going to first do ASM totic analysis an ASM totic analysis tells us that either we have exponentially growing or exponentially shrinking Solutions let's pick the exponentially shrinking Solutions so s e is equal to eus x 2 a^ 2^ 2 times some I don't remember what Bon called it I'll call it U of X so um so we've extracted because we know that ASM totically it takes this form well it could also take the other form it could be e to the plus which would be bad not normalizable we've extracted that then we write down the differential equation for U and then we solve that differential equation by series analysis yeah however if this is if I have a second or differential equation for fi this change of variables doesn't change the fact that it's a second order differential equation for you right there's still two solutions for you one of those Solutions will be the solution of the equation that has this ASM totic form but the other solution will be one that has an e to the plus x^2 over a^2 so that it cancels off this leading factor and gives me the exponentially growing solution everyone cool with that so in that series analysis there's a sort of a subtle moment where you impose that you have a the convergent solution so the answer of why did we get a first order relation is that we we very carefully um although it may not have been totally obvious but um when doing this calculation one carefully chooses the convergent solution that doesn't uh have this this function blowing up so as to overwhelm the envelope did that answer your question great okay it's a very good question this is an important subtlety that comes up all over the place when you do ASM totic analysis um I speak for my heart it it's an important thing the research that I'm doing right now getting these sorts of of uh subtleties right is is it can be very confusing it's important to think carefully through them so it's a very good question other questions before we move on okay so um I'm going to erase this because it's not directly germine but it is great okay so so one of the lessons of this Brute Force analysis was that we constructed the Spectrum I.E the set of energy igen values allowed for the harmonic oscillator the quantum Quantum harmonic oscillator and we constructed the wave functions we constructed the wave functions by solving the differential equation through ASM totic analysis which gave us the gaussian envelope and series expansion which gave us the pooms and then there's some normalization coefficient and then we got the energy values by asking when does this series expansion converge when does it in fact truncate terminate so that we can write down an answer um and that was what gave us these discrete values but fine we can see that it would be discret values we're cool with that in fact Barton went through the discussion of the node theorem and and the lack of of uh of of um degeneracy in one-dimensional quantum mechanics so it's reasonable that we'd get a bunch of discreet energy igen values as we've talked about now for two lectures however there's a surprise here which is that these aren't just discreet they're evenly spaced we get a tower starting with the lowest possible energy corresponding to a sorry e zero starting with the lowest possible energy uh which is greater than zero uh and a corresponding ground state wave function and then we have a whole bunch of other states F1 f 2 53 54 labeled by their energies where the energies are evenly spaced yeah they needed to be discreet because these are bound States but evenly spaced is a surprise so why are they evenly spaced anyone based on last lectures analysis yeah you don't have a good answer to that from last lecture's analysis one of the one of the Mysteries that comes out of the Brute Force analysis when you take a differential equation you just beat the you know crap out of it with a stick by solving it with differential equ strategies like this you don't necessarily get uh some of the more subtle structure one of the goals of today's lecture is going to be to explain why we get this structure why just from the physics or the problem the underling physics should you know that the system is going to have evenly space Dion values what's the structure and secondly I want to show you a way of repeating this calculation without doing the Brute Force analysis that reveals some of that more fine grained structure of the problem and this is going to turn out to be uh one of the canonical Moves In in the analysis of quantum mechanical systems so from quantum mechanics to Quantum field Theory this is a basic series of of logical moves um what I'm going to do today also has uh an independent life in mathematics um uh in algebra uh and that will be something you'll study in more detail on 805 but I would encourage you to ask your recitation instructors uh about it or me in office hours okay so our goal is to understand that even spacing and also to rederive these results without the sort of brutal uh direct assault methods we used last time so what I'm going to tell you about today is something called the operator method it usually goes under the name of the operator method um okay so to get us started let's go back to look at the energy operator for um for the harmonic oor which is what at the end of the day we want to solve 2 M plus M Omega 2 upon 2 x^2 right and this is the operator that we want to whose Z values we want to construct whose Z functions we want to construct before we do anything else we should do dimensional analysis first thing you do when you look at a problem is do some dimensional analysis identify the s scales and make things to the degree possible dimensionless your life will be better so what are the parameters we have available to us we have uh H because it's quantum mechanics we have M because we have a particle of mass m we have omega because this potential has a characteristic frequency Omega what other parameters do we have available to us well we have C that's available to us but is it relevant No it should no if you get an answer that depends on the speed of light you've made some horrible mistake right so not there what about the number of students in 804 no there are an infinite number of parameters that don't matter to this problem what you want to know is when you do dimensional analysis what parameters matter for the problem what parameters could possibly appear in the answer and that's it there are no other parameters in this problem yeah so that's the full set of parameters available to us this has dimensions of momentum times length this has momentum dimensions of mass and this has dimensions of one Upon a Time and so what characteristic scales can we build using these three parameters well this is a momentum times a a length if we multiply by a mass that's momentum time mass time x which is almost momentum again we need a velocity not a position but we have one over time so if we take H bar time M Omega so that's PX * m/ T that has units of momentum squared okay and similarly this is momentum which is X which is length mass over time I can divide by mass divide by frequency or multiply by time so H bar upon M Omega uh and this is going to have units of length squared okay and with a little bit of foresight from factors of two I'm going to Define we use these to Define two length scales X knot is equal to uh H bar oh I want to be careful to get my coefficients yeah I always put the two in the wrong place so 2 H bar upon M Omega square root and I'm going to Define p is equal to squ < TK of 2 H time M Omega okay so here's my claim my claim is at the end of the day the Salient length scales for this problem should be integers or dimensionless numbers times this length scale and saling momentum scale should be this scale okay just from dimensional analysis so if someone at this point says what do you think is the typical scale what is the typical size uh of the ground state wave function the typical um length scale over which the wave function is not zero well that can't possibly be the size of manhan it's not the signs of a proton there's only one link scale s to the system it should be of Order X knot always start with dimensional analysis always okay so with that we can rewrite this energy oh sorry and there's one last energy uh we we can write an energy thing with energy um which is equal to H Omega an this times times uh a frequency gives us um uh an energy okay so we can rewrite this this energy operator as H Omega times p^2 over P so this has units of energy so everything in here must be dimensionless and it turns out to be p^2 over p^ S Plus X operator squar over x^ squ so that that's convenient so this has nothing to do with the operator method this is just being reasonable okay quick note thing to note uh X knot time P KN is just the M omegas cancel so we get < tk2 H bar s to H bar okay so little tricks like that are useful to keep track of as you go okay so we're interested in this operator we're interested in this energy operator and it has a nice form it's a sum of squares and when you see the sum of squares a very tempting thing to do is to factor it so for example if I have two classical numbers c^2 plus d^2 the mathematician in me screams out to write C minus ID time C plus ID I have factored this and that's usually a step in the right direction and is this true well yes it's true c^2 plus d^2 and the cross terms cancel okay that's great four complex numbers or four C numbers now is this true for operators can I do this for operators here we have the energy operator as a sum of squares well let's try it I'd like to write that in terms of X and P so what about WR is um is so what about writing the quantity um x minus i p over X over P operator time X over X Plus IP over P KN okay so we can compute this this is easy so the first term gives us the X squ over x^ squ that last term gives us the I's cancel we get p squ over P Squared but then there are cross terms we have an x p and an minus PX with an overall I so plus I * x p uh over x * P so x * P however is 2 H bar so that's over 2 H bar okay and then we have the other term minus PX same thing so I can write that as the commutator XP minus PX everyone cool with that unfortunately this is not what we wanted we wanted just p^2 plus x^2 and what we got instead was P S Plus x s close plus a commutator happily this commutator is simple what's the commutator of X with P yeah exactly Commit This to Memory okay this is this is your friend okay so this is just IH bar so this is equal to ditto plus ditto Plus ihar the I whoops uh somewhere I got a minus sign where did I get my minus sign wrong x with IP oh no good this is good okay so x with p is I so we get an IH bar no no I really did screw up the sign how did I screw up the sign oh no I didn't wait oh of course no no no good good good good sorry sorry trust your calculation not your memory okay so the calculation gave us this so what does this give us we give us IH bar so plus but the I bar * I is going to give me a minus and the H bar is going to cancel because I've got an H bar from here and an H bar in the denominator minus 12 so this quantity is equal to the quantity we wanted minus 12 and what is the quantity we wanted X squ plus p^ squ this guy so putting that all together we can write that the energy operator which was equal to um uh H bar Omega times the quantity we wanted right is equal to well the quantity we wanted is this quantity plus 12 H bar Omega times um I'll write this as uh X over X Plus i p over p x over X oops over xot minus uh Plus i p over P hat hat hat plus2 every go with that so it almost worked we can almost Factor so at this point it's tempting to say well that isn't really much an improvement you've just made it uglier but consider the following and just trust me on this one that this is not a stupid thing to do oops that's a stupid symbol to write though so let's define an operator called a which is equal to X over xot uh plus I P over p and an operator which I will call a dagger is that a dagger I see before me um X sorry over x minus i p over P KN um uh Hamlet quotes are harder um so this is a dagger um and we can now write the energy operator for the harmonic oscillator is equal to H Omega time a dagger a plus 12 everyone cool with that now this should look suggestive you should say aha this looks like each part mea something plus2 that sure looks familiar from our Brute Force calculation but okay that familiar it is not an answer to the question uh meanwhile you should say something like this look this looks kind of like the complex conjugate of this guy right because we you know there's an i and you change a sign of the I but what is a complex conjugate of an operator what does that mean an operator is like take a vector rotate what is a complex conjugation of that I don't I mean I don't know so we have to Define that okay so I'm now going to start with this a quick math aside and morally this is about what is the complex conjugate of an operator but before I move on questions okay so here's a mathematical uh series of of facts and claims so given so I claim the following given any linear operator uh we can build there's a natural way to build without making any additional assumptions or any additional ingredients we can build another operator OD dagger hat hat in the following way consider um the inner product of f with G or the the bracket of f with G so integral DX of f complex conjugate G okay now consider the the the function we're taking here is actually the operator we have on G I'm going to Define my op so is a perfectly good thing what this expression says is take your function G act on it with the operator o multiply by F complex conjugate take the integral this is what we would have done if we had taken the inner product of f with the state we get by or the function we get by taking o and acting on the function G so now here's the thing what we want just in a side what we want to do is Define a new operator and here's how I'm going to Define it I'm Define it by choosing how it acts I'm going to tell you exactly how it acts and then we'll Define the operator so this operator o with a dagger called the ad joint is defined in the following way this is whatever operator you need such that the integral uh gives you such that the following is true integral DX uh o on F complex conjugate G okay so this is the definition of this dagger action the adjoint action okay so o dagger is the adjoint and sometimes it's called the herian adjoint uh all occasionally say Hermes occasionally not with no particular uh or order to it um so what does this mean this means that the whatever o OD dagger is it's that operator that when acting on G and then taking the inter prodct with f gives me the same answer as taking my original operator and acting on F and taking the in product with G cool so we know how if we know what our operator o is the challenge now is going to be to figure out what must this OD dagger operator be such that this expression is true that's going to be my definition of the Adent cool so I'm going to do a bunch of examples I'm going to walk through this okay so the mathematical definition is that an operator o defined in this fashion is the herian ad joint of O Okay so that's the mathematical definition well that's our version of the mathematical definition I just came back from a math conference so I'm particularly chased at the moment to be careful um Okay so here so let's do some quick examples example one uh what's the suppose uh C is a complex number I claim a number is also an operator it acts by multiplication the number seven is an operator because it takes a vector and it gives you seven times that Vector okay so this uh this number is a particularly simple kind of operator uh and what C joint okay well we can do that that's easy so C adjoint is going to be defined in the following way it's integral DX uh F star of c adjoint g is equal to the integral DX of C on F complex conjugate time G but what is this well C is just a number so when we take its complex conjugate we can just pull it out so this is equal to the integral DX C complex conjugate fstar G but I'm now going to rewrite this using the awesome power of reordering multiplication as C star G and I'm going to put parentheses around this because it seems like fun so now we have this nice expression the integral DX of f c adint g is equal to the integral DX of f c star g c complex conjugate G but notice that this must be true for all F it's true for all because I made no assumption about what f and g are true for for all f and g and therefore the adjoint of a complex number is its complex conjugate okay and this is the basic strategy for determining the complex the adjoint of any operator we're going to play this exactly this sort of game we'll put the adjoint in here we'll use the definition of the adjoint and then we'll do whatever minations are necessary to rewrite this as some operator acting on the first Factor cool questions okay let's do it for a more interesting operator so by the way uh to check at home and I think this might be on your problem set um but I don't remember if it's on or not so if it's not check this for yourself check that the adjoint of the adjoint is equal to the operator itself that's an easy thing to check okay so next example what is the adjoint of the operator derived with respect to X consider the operator which is just derivative with respect to X and I want to know what is the adint of this Beast okay so how do we do this same logic as before whatever the operator is it's defined in the following way integral DX F complex conjugate on DX dagger on G this is equal to the integral DX of are you on time good um integral DX of um DX F complex conjugate on G now what we want is we want to turn this into an expression where the operator is acting on G just our familiar operator DDX so how do I get the DDX oh by the way I so how do I get the DDX over here I need to do two things first what's the complex con of the derivative respect to X of a complex function and my D has indigestion um so this is integral DX derivative with respect to X of f complex conjugate G and now I can I want this operator I want derivative acting on G that's the definition right because I want to know what is this operator and so I'm going to do integration by parts so this is equal to the integral DX when I integrate by Parts I get an F complex conjugate and then a overall minus sign from the integration by parts minus F complex conjugate DX G did I was I telling you the truth or did I lie to you okay keep thinking about that and this is equal to well the integral of DX F complex conjugate of minus the derivative respect to X acting on G everyone cool with that but if you look at these equalities DX adint acting on G is equal is the same as minus DX acting on G so this tells me that the adint of DX is equal to minus DX yeah are you assuming that your surface terms vanish thank you I lied to you so I assumed in this that my Surface terms vanished I did a variation by parts and that that leaves me with a total derivative right and that total derivative gives me a boundary term remember how integration by parts Works integration by parts says the integral of a uh dxb is equal to the integral of well a dxb can be written as um derivative respect to X of a uh minus um so uh minus B uh derivative with respect to X of a right because this is a prime B plus b prime a here we have a prime so we just subtract off the appropriate term but this is a total derivative so it only gives us a boundary term so this integral is equal to can move the integral minus the integral over here the integral and the derivative because an integral is nothing but an anti-derivative the integral and the derivative cancel leaving us with a boundary terms and in this case it's from our boundaries which are plus INF or sorry minus infinity to plus infinity minus infinity and plus infinity now this tells us something very important and I'm not going to speak about this in detail but I encourage the recitation instructors who might happen to be here to think to mention this in recitation um and I encourage you all to think about it when I if I ask you what is the adjoint of the derivative operator acting on the space of functions which are normalizable so that they vanish at Infinity what is the adjoint of the derivative operator acting on the space of functions which is normalizable at Infinity we just derive the answer because we assumed that these surface terms vanished right because our wave functions f and g vanish at Infinity they're normalizable however if I had asked you a slightly different question if I had asked you what's the adint of the derivative operator acting on a different set of functions the set of functions that don't necessarily vanish at Infinity including sinusoids that go off to infinity and don't vanish is this the correct answer no this would not be the correct answer because they're boundary terms so the point I'm making here first off we're always in physics we're always going to be talking about normalizable Beast so at the end of the day the physical objects we care about are in a room they are not off Infinity so everything is going to be normal ible that is how the world Works however you've got to be careful in making these sorts of arguments and realize that when I ask you what is the derivative what is the adint of this operator I need to I need to uh say something more precise I need to say what's the adint of the derivative uh acting when this operator is understood as acting on some particular set of functions acting on normalizable functions good so anyway I'll leave that aside as a something to ponder okay but with that technical detail aside as long as we're talking about normalizable functions so these boundary terms from the integration by parts cancel the ad joint to the derivative operator is minus the derivative operator cool okay let's do another example um and where do I want to do this yeah I'll do it here so another example actually no ow I will do it here okay so we got another example which is three uh what's the adjoint of the position operator okay take two minutes do this on a piece of paper in front of you I'm not going to call on you so you can raise your hand if you okay um chat with the person next to you I mean chat about physics right just not what's your uh okay how come because it seems parsimonious yeah I it's good intuition explain explain okay so how do we go about doing this we go about solving this problem by using the definition of the adjoint so what is X adjoint it's that operator such that the following is true such that the integral DX of um of f complex conjugate with X dagger acting on G is equal to the integral DX of what I get by taking the complex conjugate of taking X and acting on F and then integrating this against G but now we can use the action of X and say that this is equal to the integral DX of x f complex conjugate G but here's the nice thing what is the complex conjugate of X time a complex function of F X is real right positions are real so that's just x a complex conjugate of f so that was the essential move there and now we can rewrite this as equal the integral of f complex conjugate XG and now eyeballing this x dagger is that operator which acts by acting by multiplying with X Little X therefore the adjoint of the operator X is equal to the same operator X is equal to its own adjoint Okay cool so we've just learned a couple of really nice things so the first is um we're want to do this yeah good so we've learned a couple of nice things and I want to encode them in the following definition definition an operator which I will call O whose adjoint is equal to O So an operator whose adjoint is equal to itself is called is Hermes okay so an operator which is equal to its own Adine is called herian and so I want to note a couple of nice examples of that so note um a an a a number a number which is herian is what real right an operator we found an operator which is equal to its own ad joint X dagger is equal to X and what can you say about the igen values of this operator they're real we use that in the proof actually so this is real I will call an operator real if it's herian and here's a fact a mathematical fact which is that any operator which is herian has all real I values so this is really I I'll se it as a but it's just a fact for us um o has all oh good has all real IG values okay yeah uh is it if and only no it's not if it's um uh uh let's see um so if you have all real igen values um it does not imply that you're herion however if you have all real I values and you can be diagonalized it does imply so let me give you an example so consider the following uh operator um rotations we've done this many times rotation in real threedimensional space of a vector around the vertical axis okay it has one IG Vector right which is the vertical vector and the IG value is is one so it's real right but that's not enough to make it herian because there's another fact that we haven't got to yet with herian operators which is going to tell us that a herian operator has as many igen vectors as there are dimensions in the space okay IE that the IG vectors form a basis but there's only one IG Vector for this guy even though we're in a threedimensional vector space so this operator Rotation by an angle Theta is not herian even though it does have its only I value is in fact real okay so it's not only if if you are herian your I values are all real and you'll prove this on a problem set yeah if you're herian are your um are your Ion functions normal uh uh not necessarily but they can be made normal we'll talk about this in more detail later okay so if that's so let's do a quick check um last example and I'm not actually going to go through this in detail um but what about P what about momentum operator first off do you think the momentum is real it sure would be nice right because it's it's Ting values are the observable values of momentum and so its I Val should all be real does that make it herian not necessarily but let's check so what is the the adjoint of P well this actually we can do very easily and I'm not going to go through an elaborate argument I'm just going to not the following p is equal to um H bar upon I or sorry I upon yeah H bar upon I uh DDX right and this is an operator and this is an operator so what's the adjoint of this operator well this under an adjoint gets a minus sign right it's itself up to a minus sign so is the derivative herian no it's in fact what we call anti herian its adjoint is minus itself okay what about I what's its adjoint minus I sweet so this has an Adent picks up a minus this has an adject pi picks up a minus the minus is cancel p adjoint is p so p is in fact teration okay and here's a stronger physical fact so now we've seen that each of the operators we built uh is is X and P each of the operators that we've we've looked at so far is uh herian those that correspond to physical observables uh here's a physical fact all the observables you measure with sticks are real and the corresponding statement is that all operators corresponding to uh observables all operators must be herian so to um to the postulate that says observables are represented by operators should be adjoined the word heran observables are represented in quantum mechanics by herian operators which are operators that have a number of nice properties including they have all real igen values cool okay questions yeah so if it has to be herian and not just have like real IG values does that mean the IG values always need to form some kind of bases yeah the IG vectors will yeah yeah we're going to so so this is connected to the fact we've already seen if you take an arbitrary wave function you can expand it in states with definite momentum right as a superp position you can also expand it as a as a set of in a set of states of definite energy or of definite position anytime you have a herian operator it's ve its igen vectors suffice to to expand any function okay they provide a basis for representing any function okay so that was the that's the end of the mathematical assign let's get back to this physical point so we've defined this operator a and this other operator a dagger and here's my question first is a Herm no it's at that's hermion that's hermion but there's an I that I will pick up a minus sign when we do the complex conjugation um oh look so sure was fortuitous that I called this a dagger since this is equal to a dagger yeah okay so this is the adjoint of a so this tells you immediately tells you something interesting X and P are both observables does a correspond to an observable is it a is it herian we every observable is associated to a herian operator this is not herian so a does not represent an observable operator okay and I have I will post notes on the web page which give us a somewhat lengthy discussion or might be in one of the solutions somewhat lengthy discussion of what it means for a and a dagger to not be observable we you'll you'll get more discussion of that there so meanwhile if a is non observable it's not herian does it have real igen values well here's an important thing I said if your Hermes and all the I values are real if you're not heran that doesn't tell you you can't have any real igen values it just says that I haven't guaranteed for you that all the igen values are real okay so what we will Discover at towards the end of the course when we talk about something called coherent States is that in fact a does have a nice set of igen vectors they're very nice they're great we use them for lasers okay they're very useful and they're called coherent States but their IG vectors or their IG values are not in general real they're generically complex numbers okay so are they things you can measure not directly um there related to things you can measure though in some pretty nice ways okay so why are we bothering with these guys if they're not observable you know yeah yeah good excellent that's really good so two things about it so one thing is um this form for the energy operator is particularly simple we see the one half this looks suggestive from before but it it makes it obvious that e is herian and that may not be obvious to you guys so just check so something here's something that you'll show on the problem set um AB adint is equal to B adint A adint the order matters these are operators and so if we take the adint of this what's this going to give us well we change the order so it's going to be a dagger and then we take the dagger of both of them a a dagger so this is self this is self adjoint or herian so that's good of course we already knew that because we could have written in terms of X and P but this is somehow simpler and it in particular emphasizes the form of the capitulates the form of the energy values so indeed the form why else would we care about a dagger okay now this is a good moment here's the second reason so the first reason you care is the sort of structural similarity and and and the fact that it's sort of nicely hermi in a different way here's the key thing key okay a and a dagger satisfy the simplest commutation relation in the world well the second simplest the simplest is that it's zero on the right hand side but the simplest not trivial computation relation a with a dagger is equal to so what is a dagger equal to well we just take the definition let's put this in so this is uh x uh over X knot uh plus I P over p uh comma uh X over x minus i p over P hat hat hat hat bracket bracket good so here there going to be four uh there going to be four terms there's x commutator x what is that what is the commutator of an operator with itself zero because remember the definition of the commutator is uh a uh B is a minus b a so a with a is equal to a a minus a a and I mean you have no options there that's zero so x with X is zero p with p is zero so the only terms that matter are the cross terms we have an X with p and notice that's going to be times a minus I with p and X knot and then we have another term which is p with X which is i p over X knot so you change the order and you change the sign but if you change the order of a commutator you change the side so we can put them both in the same order well let me just write this out so this is I over x p so this guy minus I over X x p but x p is equal to 2 H bar as we checked before uh this was x with p uh and then the second term was uh um plus I again over x p which is 2 H bar uh p with X this x with p is equal to IH bar so the H bar cancels the I gives me a plus one and and P with X gives me minus I bar so the H bar and the minus I gives me a plus one well that's nice this is equal to one so plus 12 uh therefore a with a dagger is equal to one as advertised that is about as simple as a get notice a couple of other commutators that follow from this a diager with a is equal to minus one we just Chang the order and that's just an overall minus sign and a with a is what zero a dger with a dger good okay so we are now going to use we are now going to use this commutation relation to totally crush the problem into submission it's going to be weeping before us like the Romans in front of the vizago it's going to be dramatic okay so let's let's check so let's combine the the two things so we had the first thing is that the form is simple the second is that the commutator is simple let's combine these together and really milk the system for what it's got and to do that I need two more commutators okay and the lesson of this series of machinations it's very tempting to look at this and be like why are you doing this and the reason is I want to encourage you to to I want to encourage you to see the power of these commutation relations they're telling you a tremendous amount about the system so we're going through and doing some relatively simple calculations we're just Computing commutators we're following our noes and we're going to derive something awesome so bear so don't just bear with it learn from this that there's something very useful and Powerful about commutation relations you'll see that at the end but I want you to hold on to the slight awkwardness right now that it's not totally obvious beforehand where this is going so what is e with a well that's easy it's the H bar Omega a diager a uh plus one2 so the one/ half what's one/ half commutator with an operator zero because any number commutes with an operator 1/ half operator is operator one2 it's just a constant the that term is gone so the only thing that's left over is H bar Omega a DI a with a now the H bar Omega is just a constant it's going to pull out no matter which term we're looking at so I can write I can just pull that factor out okay so this is equal to H bar Omega times a d a a minus a a dger a but this is equal to H bar Omega well that's a dagger a a a a dagger a we can just pull out the A on the right um a dagger a minus a a dagger a but that's equal to H bar Omega well a dagger with a is equal to a diager with a minus one is equal to minus H Omega and we have this a left over a so e with a is equal to minus a well that's interesting now the second commutator I'm not going to do it e with a dagger is going to be equal to well it's just eyeball what's going to happen this going to be uh a dagger so we're going to have a dagger a dagger minus a dagger a dagger a so we're going have an a dagger in front and then a dagger so all we're going to get is a sign and it's going to be a dagger plus a dagger I should have written that in the center okay everyone cool with that yeah oh shoot thank you ah H bar Omega thank you we would have misruled the Galaxy so uh uh okay good other questions okay you don't notice you haven't noticed yet but we just won we just totally solved the problem and here's why once you see this anytime you see this anytime you see this commut wow I'm far anytime you see this commutator an operator with an a is equal to plus a times some constant anytime you see this cheer okay and here's why yeah right exactly now you know um so so here's why here's why you should cheer because you no longer have to solve any problems you no longer have to solve any differential equations you can simply write down the problem and let's see that you can just write down the answer so suppose suppose we already happen to have access know here in my sleeve I have access to an igen function of the energy operator e on f e is equal to e f e suppose I have this guy cool check this out consider a new state s which is equal to a do I which do I want to do first it doesn't really matter but let's do a consider s is equal to a on f e okay consider what can you say about this state well it's the state you get by taking this wave function and acting with a not terribly Illuminating however e on S is equal to what maybe this has some nice property underacting with e this is equal to e on a with f e now this is tantalizing because at this point it's very look that e it really wants to hit this F right it just really wants to there's an e it wants to pull out it'll be great the problem is that not there there's an A in the way and so at this point we add zero okay this is a very powerful technique this is equal to E A minus a oops e plus a e okay F okay but that has a nice expression this is equal to E A minus AE that's the commutator of e with a uh plus a well what's E acting on f e well actually let me just leave this as AE so what have we done here before we actually act fight what we've done is something called commuting an operator through so what do I mean by commuting an operator through if we have an operator a and an operator B and an and a state F and I want a to act on F I can always write this as this is equal to um the commutator of a with B plus ba acting on F so this lets me act a on F directly without B but I have to know what the commutator of these two operators is so if I know what the commutator is I can do this I can simplify this is called when one does this when one takes a and replaces it by the commutator of a with B plus ba changing the order the the phrase that one uses is I have commuted a through b okay and commuting operators through each other is an extraordinarily useful tool useful technique now let's see why so here what's the commutator of e with a oh we just did that it's minus H Omega a and what's a e on f e what's E on f e e right exactly uh plus uh e uh a on fi and now we're cooking with gas because this is equal to H minus H bar Omega a plus E A I'm going to pull out this common factor of e of a okay so if I pull out that common factor of a plus e a f e and now I'm going to just slightly write this instead of e or minus H bar Omega plus e I'm going write this as e minus H bar Omega I just literally changing the order of the algebra e minus H Omega and what is a e s that was the original state we started with s well that's cool if I have a state with energy e and I act on it with the operator a I get a new state Sai which is also an IG state of the energy operator but with a slightly different energy IG value the igen value is now decreased by H bar Omega cool and that is what we wanted let's explore the consequences of this so if we have a state with with I value e we have f e such that e on f e is equal to e f e then the state a f e has I value as energy I value e minus H bar Omega so I could call S uh uh I could just call this F sub e minus H Omega it's an igen value igen function of the energy operator the value e minus H Omega agreed do I know that this is in fact properly normalized no because 12 times it would also be a perfectly good igen function of the energy operator so this is proportional to the properly normalized guy with some at the moment unknown constant coefficient normalization everyone cool with that so now let's think about what this tells us this tells us if we have a state f e which I will denote its energy by this level then if I act on it with a f e I get another state where the energy instead of being e is equal to eus H bar Omega so this distance in energy is H bar Omega cool let me do it again let's act a on F by exactly the same argument if I make S is equal to a on a f a s f i get another state again separated by H bar Omega e minus 2 H Omega Turtles all the way down everyone cool with that let's do a slightly different calcul so okay but before we do that so I want to give a a name okay a does something really cool when you take the state f e that has definite energy e it's an energy function and you act on it with a what happens it lowers the energy by H bar Omega so I'm going to call a the lowering operator because what it does is it takes a state with f e with energy value e to a state with energy eus H Omega and I can just keep doing this as many times as I like and I build a tower yes you the ground state ah very good question we hold on to that for a second we'll come back to that in just a second okay so this seems to build for me a ladder downwards everyone cool with that but we could have done the same thing with a dagger and how does a story change what happens if we take a dagger instead of a well let's go through every step here so this is going to be e on a dagger and now we have e a dagger a dagger e a dagger what's e with a dagger a dagger e with a dagger is equal to same thing but with a plus and again s same thing because the a dagger factors out yeah so we go down by acting with a we go up by acting with a dagger and again the spacing is H bar Omega and we go up by acting with a dagger again so a and a dagger a and a dagger are called the raising and lowering operators a dagger the raising operator a dagger f e plus h bar Omega Okay so what that lets us do is build a tower of States an infinite Tower of States we're given a state we can walk up this ladder with the raising operator and we can walk down it by the lowering operator so now I ask you the question why is this ladder evenly spaced there's one equation on the board that you can point to well I guess two technically there are two equations on the board that you could point to that suffice to immediately answer the question why is the power of energy states evenly spaced what is that equation yeah those commutators these commutators are all we needed we didn't need to know anything else we didn't even need to know what the potential was right if I just told you there's an energy operator e and there's an operator a that you can build out of the observables of the system such that you have this computation relation what do you immediately know you immediately know that you get a tower of operators because you can act with a and raise the energy by a finite amount which is the coefficient of that a in the commutator yeah this didn't have to be the quantum mechanics of the harmonic oscillator at this point we just needed this commutator relation e with a e with a dagger and one of the totally awesome things is how often this shows up if you take a bunch of electrons and you put them in a magnetic field okay bunch of electrons magnetic very strong magnetic field what you discover is the quantum mechanics of those guys has nothing to do with a harmonic oscillator on the face of it magnetic field it's Laurent Force law the whole thing what you discover is there's an operator which isn't usually called a but you know it depends on which book you use it's n or M or L there's an operator that commutes with the energy operator in precisely this fashion which tells you that the energy ion States live in a ladder they're called Lando levels this turns out to be very useful any of you who are doing a urop in a lab that has you know graphine or any material really with the magnetic field then this matters so this commutator encodes an enormous amount of the structure of the energy IG values and the trick for us was showing that we could write the harmonic oscillator energy operator in terms of operators that commute in this fashion yeah so what we're going to run into this structure over and over again this operator commutes with this one to the same operator times a constant that tells you you have a ladder we're going to run into that over and over again when we talk about about land levels if we get there when we talk about angular momentum we'll get the same thing when we talk about the harmonic oscillator we'll get the same thing all sorry the the hydrogen uh system we'll get the same thing okay so second question does this ladder extend infinitely up yeah why not can it extend infinitely down why well okay people are saying ground state well we know that from The Brute Force calculation but without the Brute Force calculation can this ladder extend infinitely down you can't go under the minimum brilliant okay good and as you'll prove on the problem set you can't make the energy arbitrarily negative but let me make that let me make that sharp I don't want to I don't want to appeal to something we haven't proved proven uh let me show you that concretely the energy expectation value in some state in any state right the energy expectation value can be written as the integral of f complex conjugate let's say in the state f i com conjugate e f but I can write this as the integral and let's say DX integral DX um let's just put in uh what the energy operator looks like so slda we can take the 4 a transform right the ca of P p^2 upon 2 m oops DP for the F for the kinetic energy term plus the integral and now I'm using the harmonic conator plus the integral DX of s of x Norm squ Norm s uh M Omega 2 upon 2x^2 okay little bit of a quick move there doing the 4A transform for the momentum term and not doing the 4 transform but it's okay they're separate integrals I can do this and The crucial thing here is this is positive definite this is positive definite positive definite positive definite all these terms are strictly positive this must be greater than or equal to zero it can never be negative yeah so what that tells us is there must be a minimum e there must be an a minimum energy and I will call it minimum e not okay we can't lower the tower forever so what is that how is this possible how is it possible that look on the one hand if we want if we have a state we can always build a lower energy state by acting with the lowering operator a and yet this is telling me that I can't there must be a last one where I can't lower it anymore so what reaches out of the chalkboard and stops me from acting with a again how can it possibly be true that a always lowers the I function but there's a least one that can't be lowered any further N normalizable is a good guess very good guess not not the case because at this point we from this argument we don't even use wave functions uh that would be bad yes exactly so that would be bad but that doesn't what I mean that's just saying that there's an inconsistency here so I'm going to come back to your your answer non-normalizable it's correct but in a sneaky way here's the way it's not it's Sneaky consider a state a on fi let's say this is the lowest State okay the lowest possible state it must be true that the resulting state is not F minus H bar Omega there can't be any such State and how can that be that can be if true if it's zero so if the lowering operator acts on some State and gives me zero well okay that's a that's a an igen state but it's a stupid IG state it doesn't it's not normalizable it can't be used to describe any real physical object because where is it well it's nowhere the probability density to find it anywhere is nowhere nothing zero so the way that this this Tower terminates is by having a last state which we'll call pH Z such that lowering it gives me zero not the state called zero which I would call this but actually the function zero which is not normalizable which is not a good State okay so there's a minimum e not and associated with that is a lowest energy I State called the ground state now can the energy get arbitrarily large sure that's a positive definite thing and this could get as large as you like so there's no problem with the energy I values getting arbitrarily large we can just keep raising and raising and raising I mention that because later on in the semester we will find a system with exactly that commutation relation precisely that commutation relation where there will be a minimum and a maximum okay so the commutation relation is a good start but it doesn't tell you anything we have to add in some Physics like the energy operator bounded below for the harmonic oscillator questions at this point yeah so you so you basically have shown that this ladder has to exist particular energy IEM say that I can kind of construct a letter how do I know that I can't like construct other intersec letters yeah that's an excellent question so when I remember vividly when I saw this lecture in 143a and that question plagued me and foolishly I didn't ask it um so here's the question the question is look you found a bunch of States how do you know that's all of them okay how do you know that's all of them so let's think through that that's a very good question I'm not going to worry about normalization but there's a discussion of normalization in the notes um how do I know that's all of them so yeah that's a little bit tricky so let's think through it imagine it's not all of them in particular what would that mean in order for there to be more States than the ones that we've written down there must be states that are not on that Tower and how can we Poss wow this thing is totally falling apart how do we do that how is that possible so there are two ways to do it there are two ways to do it so here's my tower of States okay there's my Tower of states and I'll call this one 5 Z okay and so I raise with a dagger and I lower with a so how could it be that I miss some states well there are two ways to do it one is there could be extra states that are in between right so let's say that there's one extra State that's in between these two okay just imagine that's true if there is such a state by that commutation relation there must be another Tower right so there must be this State and there must be this state and there must be this state and there must be this state yeah okay so so that's good so far but what happens well a on this guy gave me zero right so a on F not was zero and this is going to be some fi Tilda um knot suppose that this Tower ends okay and now you have you have to ask the question can there be two different states with two different energies with a can there be two different states that are annihilated by a not well let's check what must be true of any state annihilated by a well let's write the energy operator uh acting on that state what's the energy of that state energy on 5 Z is equal to H Omega this is a very good question so let's let's go through it so it's equal to H bar Omega time a diag A plus 12 on f z okay but what can you say about this well a annihilates F0 it gives us zero so in addition to a being called the lowering operator it's also called the annihilation operator I don't know we're brutal in warlike species um so this is equal to H this term kills again with the kills um and gives me a one half left over one half H bar Omega 5 Z so the ground state any state any state annihilated by a must have the same energy yeah the only way you can be annihilated by a is if your energy is this cool so what does it tell you about this second ladder of hidden states that we missed it's got to be degenerate right it's got to have the same energies yeah I drew that really badly didn't I those are evenly spaced um so so it's got to be degenerate however Barton proved for you the node theorem last time right he gave you my uh spread argument for the for the node theorem in particular one of the consequences of that is that in a system with boun stat in a system with a potential that goes up you can never have degeneracies in one dimension we're not going to prove that carefully in in here but it's it's relatively easy to prove in fact if you come to my office hours I'll prove it for you it takes three minutes but I don't want to set up the math right now so um how many people know with the Ron skin if I say wrong that's awesome okay so I leave it to you as an exercise to use the Ron skin to show that there cannot be degeneracies in one dimension which is cool um anyway so um the Ronin for the differential equation which is the energy value equation so there can be no degeneracies in one-dimensional potentials with bound States so what we've just shown is that the only way that there can be extra states that we missed is if there's a tower with exactly identical energies all the way up but if they have exactly identical energy that means there's degenerate but we can prove that there can't be degeneracies in 1D so can there be an extra Tower States we missed no can we have missed any states no those are all the states there are and we've done it without ever solving a differential equation just by using that commutation relation now at this point it's very tempting to say like that was just sort of Magical Mystery stuff but what we really did last time was very honest we wrote down a differential equation we found the solution and we got the wave functions so you know Professor Adams you just monkeyed around at the chalkboard with commutators for a while but what are the damn wave functions right so we already have the answer this is really quite nice last time we solved that differential equation right and we had to solve that differential equation many many times different levels and but now we have a very nice thing we can do what's true of the ground state well the ground state is annihilated by the lowering operator so that means that a acting on f z of X is equal to zero but a has a nice expression which oh unfortunately I erased sorry about that so um a has a nice expression a is equal to X xot Plus i p over P right and so if you write that out and multiply by uh some appropriate constants um this differential this becomes the following differenti equation well the x is just multiplied by X and the p is take a derivative with respect to X multipli by H bar upon I and multiplying by I over H bar to get that equation this gives us DX plus p over um H uh X knot whoops P KN sorry that shouldn't be an I that should be p P good um X on F0 is equal to Z and you solved this last time when you did the ASM totic analysis right this is actually a ridiculously easy equation it's a first order differential equation there's one normalization or there's one integration constant that's going to be the overall normalization and so the form is completely fixed first order differential equation so what's the solution of this guy it's a gaan and what's the width of that gaan we look at p H bar x p over H bar well we know that P time xot is twice H right so if I multiply by X on the top and bottom get two H bar the H bars cancel so this gives me 2 upon x^ squ okay remember I said it would be useful to remember that P KN time xot is 2 H bar it's useful um so it gives us this and so the result is that F not is equal to up to an overall normalization coefficient e to the minus x^2 over X not squ solid okay so there we've solved that differential equation it's the easiest second easiest differential equation it's a first order differential equation with a linear term rather than a constant we get a gaussian and now now that we've got this guy look do you remember the third hermit polinomial because you know if you want we know that the the third excited state is given by H3 times this uh gaussian right do you remember it off the top of your head here's how you solve what it is how do we get 53 first of how do we get 51 how do we get the next state in the ladder how do we get the wave function raising operator but what is the raising operator oh it's the differential operator I take with okay but if I had a dagger it's just going to change the sign here so now how do I get F1 F1 is equal to up to some normalization okay DX minus 2x^ 2 x 5 Z cool so now do I have to solve a differential equation to get the higher States no I take derivatives and multiply by constants okay so to get the Herm third Herm polinomial what do you do you do this three times this is actually an extremely efficient way it's related to something called a generating functional extremely efficient way to write down the hermet pols they're the things that you get by acting on this with this operator as many times as you want that is a nice formal definition of the Herm pooms the upshot of all of this is the following the upshot of of all this is that we've derived we've derived that without ever solving the differential equation the Spectrum just from that commutation relation just from that commutation relation I cannot emphasize this strongly enough just from the commutation relation EA is minus a time a constant and EA dagger is a dagger times a constant we derive that the the energy ion States come in a tower you can move along this Tower by raising with a raising operator lowering with the lowering operator you can construct the ground state by building that simple op wave function which is annihilated by the lowering operator you can build all the other states by raising them which is just taking derivatives instead of solving differential equations which is hard and all of this came from this commutation relation and since we are going to see this over and over again and you will see this depending on how far you take physics you will see this in 05 you will see this in 06 you will see this in Quantum field Theory this shows up everywhere it's absolutely at the core of how we organize the degrees of freedom uh this structure is something you should see and declare Victory upon seeing you should see this and immediately say I know the answer and I can write it down okay in the next lecture we're going to do a review which is going to introduce a slightly more formal presentation of all of these ideas that's not going to be material covered on the exam but it's going to help you with the exam which will be on Thursday see you Tuesday

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lecture 9: Operator Methods for the Harmonic Oscillator