Transcript

The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT Open Courseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT Open Courseware at ocw.mit.edu. Today we begin with a harmonic oscillator. And uh before getting to the harmonic oscillator, I want to touch on a few concepts that have been mentioned in class and just elaborate on them. Is this the issue of nodes and uh how solutions look at and uh why solutions have more and more nodes, why the ground state has no nodes, um this kind of stuff.

So um So these are just a collection of remarks and a argument for for you to understand a little more intuitively why these properties uh hold. Uh So, one first thing I want to uh mention is if you have a a Schrödinger equation for an energy eigenstate, Schrödinger dinger equation for an energy eigenstate, eigenstate, you have an equation of the form um minus h squared over 2 m d second dx squared psi of x plus v of x psi of x equal e times psi of x. Now, the issue with this equation is that um you're trying to solve for two things at the same time. Um if you're looking at what we call bound states, now what is a bound state?

A bound state is something that is not extended all that much. So, a bound state will be a wave function that goes to zero as the absolute value of x goes to infinity. So, it's a probability function that certainly doesn't extend all the way to infinity. It just collapses. It's normalizable. So, these are bound states and you're looking for bound states of this equation and your difficulty is that you don't know psi and you don't know e either. So, you have to solve a problem in which uh if you were thinking, oh, this is just a plain differential equation, give me the value of e, we know the potential, just calculate it.

That's not the way it works in quantum mechanics because you need to have normalizable solutions. So, at the end of the day, as will be very clear today, this e gets fixed. You cannot get arbitrary values of e's. So, I want to make a couple of remarks about this equation is that there's this thing that can't happen. If v of x, certainly if v of x is a smooth potential, potential, then if you observe that the wave function vanishes at some point and the derivative of the wave function vanishes at that same point, these two things imply that psi of x is identically zero. And therefore, it means that you really are not interested in that.

That's not a solution of the Schrödinger equation. Psi equals zero is obviously solves this, but it's not interesting. Doesn't represent a particle. So, what I claim here is that if it happens to be that you're solving a Schrödinger problem with some potential that is smooth, you can take derivatives of it, and then you encounter that the wave function vanishes at some point and its slope vanishes at that same point, then the wave function vanishes completely. So, you cannot have a wave function, a psi of x, that does the following, comes down here and it becomes an inflection point and goes down.

This is not allowed. If the wave function vanishes at some point, then the wave function is going to do this. It's going to hit at an angle because you cannot have that the wave function is zero and its derivative zero at the same point. And the reason is simple. I'm not going to prove it now here. It is that you have a second-order differential equation and a second-order differential equation is completely determined by knowing the function at the point and the derivative at the point. And if both are zero, it's like the most trivial kind of initial condition. The only solution consistent with this is psi equals zero everywhere.

So, this can't happen. And it's something good for you to remember. If you have to do a plot of a wave function, you should never have this. So, this is what we call the node in a wave function. It's an place where the wave function vanishes and the derivative of the wave function better not vanish at that point. Now, um there's another So, this is one claim that it's not hard to prove, but uh we just don't try to do it. And there's another claim that I want you to be aware of that in for bound states, states, in one dimension, in the kind of thing that we're doing now for in one dimension, no degeneracy is possible.

What do I mean by that? You will never find two bound states of a potential that are different and have the same energy. It's just absolutely impossible. It's a very wonderful result, but also I'm not going to prove it here. Maybe it will be given as an exercise later in the course and uh it's discussed in 8.05 as well. But that's another statement that is very important. There's no degeneracy. Now, you've looked at um this simple potential, the square well, infinite one. And how does it look? You have x going from zero to a and uh the potential is zero from zero to a, is infinite otherwise, and the particle is bound to stay inside the two walls of this potential.

So, in here we've plotted the potential as a function of x. Here is x. And the wave functions are things that you know already. Yes? Is it true if you have two wells next to each other that there's still no degeneracy if there's an infinite an infinite barrier? If if there's two wells and there's an infinite barrier between them, it's like having two universes. So, it's not really a one-dimensional problem. If If you have an infinite barrier, it's like two worlds that can't talk to each other. So, yes, then you would have degeneracy. This is like saying you can have a here one atom of hydrogen or something in one energy level here, another one.

They don't talk to each other. They're degenerate states. But in general, we're talking about normal potentials that are preferably smooth. Most of these things are true even if they're not smooth, but uh it's a little more delicate. But certainly, two potentials that are separated by an infinite barrier is not part of what we really want to consider. Okay, so these wave functions start with n equals 0, 1, 2, 3, and psi n's of x are square root of 2 over a sin n plus 1 pi x over a. Things that you've seen already. And uh e n's, the energies, are ever growing as a function of the integer n that characterizes them 2 m a squared.

And the thing that you notice is that the psi zero has technically no nodes. That is to say, you know, these wave functions have to vanish at the end because the potential becomes infinite, which means the particle really can't go through. The wave function has to be continuous. There cannot be any wave function to the left, so it has to vanish here. These things don't count as nodes. It is like a bound state has to vanish at infinity. And that's not what we count a node. A node is somewhere in the middle of the range of X where the wave function vanishes. So, this is the ground state. This is psi zero has no nodes.

Psi one would be something like that. Has one node. And try the next ones. They have more and more nodes. So, psi n has n nodes. And the interesting thing is that this result actually is true for extremely general potentials. You don't have to just do the square well to see that the ground state has no nodes. The first excited state has one node and so on and so forth. It's true in general. Now, let me This is a actually a very nice result, but it's difficult to prove. In fact, it's pretty hard to prove. And uh So, there is a nice argument, not 100% rigorous, but fairly nice and really physical, that I'm going to present to you why this result is true.

So, let's try to do that. So, here is the general case. I'm going to take a smooth V of X that will be of this kind. The potential Here is X. And this potential is going to be like that. Smooth all over. And um and I will actually have it that it actually goes to infinity as X goes to infinity. Many of these things are really not necessary, but uh but it simplifies our life. Okay. So, here is a result that is known to be true. This, if this thing grows to infinity, the potential never stops growing, you get infinite number of bound states at fixed energies. One energy, two energy, three energy.

Infinite number of bound states. Number of bound states. States. That's a fact. I will not try to prove it. We'll do it for the harmonic oscillator. We'll see those infinite number of states. But here, we can't prove it easily. Nevertheless, what I want to argue for you is that these states, as the first one, will have no nodes. The sec- the second state, the first excited state, will have one node. The next will have two nodes, three nodes, four nodes. We want to understand what is this issue of the nodes. Okay, so that's it's an You're not trying to prove everything, but we're trying to prove or understand something that is very important.

So, how do we prove this? Or how do we understand that the nodes uh so, there will be infinite number of bound states, psi zero, psi one, psi two up to psi n, and it goes on. And psi n has n nodes. All right. So, what I'm going to do in order to understand this is I'm going to produce what we will call screened potentials. Screened potentials. I'm going to select the lowest point of the potential here for convenience, and I'm going to call it X equals zero. Is the lowest point. And the screened potential it will have a parameter A. Is a potential which is equal to V of X if the absolute value of X is less than A, and it's infinity if the absolute value of X is greater than A.

So, I come here and I want to see this is this potential V of X. What is the screened potential for some A? Well, um I wanted color chalk, but I don't have it. Um I go mark A here, minus A. Here are the points between X and A. X absolute value of X less than A. Throughout this region, the potent- the screened potential is the potential that you have. Nevertheless, for the rest, it's infinite. So, the screened potential is this thing. Is infinite there, and it's here this thing. So, it's a just some potential. You take a like a screen, and you just see one part of the potential and let it go to infinity.

So, that's a screened potential. So, now what I'm going to do is I'm going to try to argue that you could try to find the bound states of the screened potential, and as you remove the screen you will find, as you let A goes to infinity, you will find the bound states of your original potential. It's reasonable that that's true, because as you remove the screen, you're letting more of the potential be exposed and more of the potential be exposed, and the wave functions eventually die. So, as the time that you're very far away, you affect the wave functions less and less. So, um so, that's the argument.

We're going to try to argue that we're going to look at the bound states of the screened potentials, and see what happened what do they tell us about the bound state of the original potential. So, for this, I'm going to begin with a screened potential in which A goes to zero, and say it's say that A is equal to epsilon, very small. So, what potential do I have? A very tiny potential here. From epsilon to minus epsilon. Now, I chose the original point down here to be the minimum. So, this actually the bottom part of the potential is really flat. And if you take epsilon going to zero well, the potential might do this, but really at the bottom for sufficiently small epsilon, this is an infinite square well with size two epsilon.

You know, I chose the minimum so that you don't get something like this. If it would be a point with a slope, this would be an ugly thing. So, let's choose the minimum, and we have the screened potential here, and that's it. Now, look what we do. We say, all right, here there is a ground state. Very tiny. Goes like that. Vanishes here. Vanishes there. And has no nodes. Very tiny, you know, the two zeros are very close to each other. And now I'm going to try to increase the the value of the screen. A. So, suppose we've increased the screen and uh now the potential is here. And now we have a finite screen.

Here is the potential. And I look at the wave function, how it looks. Here is psi zero. This ground state one, psi zero. Well, uh since this thing in here the potential becomes infinite, the wave function still must vanish here and still must vanish here. Now, just for your imagination, think of this at this stage, it still more or less looks like this. Maybe. Now, I'm going to ask, as I increase can I produce a node? And look what's going to happen. So, suppose I've, you know, it might happen that as you increase, suddenly you produce a node. So, here is what I'm saying here. I'm going to show it here.

Suppose up to this point, there is no node, but then when I double it, when I increase it to twice the size, when I go to screen potential like that, suddenly there is a node in the middle. So, if there is a node in the middle, one thing that could have happened is that you have this. And now look what must have happened then. As I stretch this, this slope must have been going down and down and down until it flips to the other side to produce a node here. It could have happened on this side, but it's the same. So, the argument is just done with this side. To produce a node, you could have done somehow the slope here must have changed sign.

But for that to happen continuously, at some point, the slope must have been zero. But you cannot have a zero on zero slope. So, this thing can't flip. Can't Can't do this. Another thing that could have happened is that when we are here already, maybe the wave function looks like that. It doesn't flip at the edges, but produces something like that. But the only way this can happen continuously, and this potential is changing continuously, is for this thing, at some intermediate stage, as you keep stretching the screen, this sort of starts to produce an a depression here, and at some point to get here, it has to do this.

But it can't do this either. Cannot vanish and have derivative like that. So, actually, as you stretch the screen, there's no way to produce a node. This That property forbids it. So, by the time you go and take the screen to infinity, this wave function has no nodes. Okay. So, that proves it that the ground state has no nodes. Um you know, you could call this a physicist proof. Um which means uh in uh not in a pejorative way. It means that it's reasonable. It's intuitive. And a mathematician working hard could make it rigorous. Um uh Uh a bad physics proof is one that is a little sloppy, and no mathematician could fix it and make it work.

Uh So, I think this is a good physics proof uh in that sense. It probably you can construct a real proof or a based on this, a very precise proof. Now, look at excited state. Suppose you take now here the screen very little, and now consider the third excited state, psi three. Uh this is I'm sorry. We'll call it psi two because it has two nodes. Now, um well, maybe I should do psi one. Let's go slow. Psi one. One node. Same thing. As you increase it, there's no way to create another node continuously because again, you have to flip at the edges, or you have to depress in the middle. So, this one will evolve to a wave function that will have one node in the whole big potential.

Now, is that state Does that state have more energy than the ground state? Well, uh it certainly begins with a small screen with more energy because in the square well, psi one has more energy. And that energy should be clear that it's not going to go below the energy of the ground state. Why? Because if it went below the energy of the ground state slowly, at some point, for some value of the screen, it would have the same energy as the ground state. But no degeneracy is possible in one-dimensional problem. So, that can't happen. Cannot have that. So, it will always stay a little higher. And therefore, with one node, you will be a little higher energy.

With two nodes, will be higher and higher. And And that's it. This That's the argument. Uh We've argued by this continuous deformation process that this potential not only has these bound states, but this is n nodes, and E n is greater than E n prime for n greater than n prime. So, the more nodes, the more energy. Pretty nice result, and that's really all I wanted to say about this problems. Are there any questions? Any Okay. So, what we do now is the harmonic oscillator. That's going to keep us busy for the rest of today's lecture. Uh It's a very interesting problem, and it's a most famous quantum mechanics problem, in a sense, because it's um happens to be useful in many, many applications.

If you have any potential So, what is the characteristic of the harmonic oscillator? Harmonic oscillator. Oscillator. Well, the energy operator is P squared over 2M. Plus we write 1/2 M omega squared X squared. Where omega is this omega that you always think of a angular velocity or angular frequency. It's more like angular frequency. Omega has units of 1 over time. It's actually 2 pi over the period of an oscillation. And this you know from classical mechanics. If you have a harmonic oscillator of this form, yeah, it actually oscillates with uh this frequency. And E is the energy operator. This is the energy of the oscillator.

So, what defines a oscillator is something in which the potential energy, this term, is V of X. V of X is quadratic in X. That is a harmonic oscillator. Then you arrange the constants to make sense. This has units of energy because this has units of uh length squared, 1 over time squared. Length over time is like velocity squared times mass is kinetic energy. So, this term has the units of energy. And you're good with that. And why is this useful? Because actually, in any sort of arbitrary potential, rather general potential, at least, whenever you have a minimum, where the derivative vanishes, then the second derivative need not vanish.

And then it's it's a good approximation to think of the potential at the minimum as a quadratic potential. It fits the potential nicely over a good region. And therefore, when you have two molecules with a bond or something oscillating, there is a potential that has a minimum at the equilibrium position. And the oscillations are governed by some harmonic oscillator. When you have photons in space-time traveling, there is a set of harmonic oscillators that correspond to photons. Uh many, many applications. Endless amount of applications for the harmonic oscillator. So, we really want to understand this system quantum mechanically.

And what does that mean? Is that we really want to calculate uh and solve the Schrödinger equation. This is our first step in understanding this system. There's going to be a lot of work to be done even once we have the solutions of the Schrödinger equation. But the first thing is to figure out what are the energy eigen states or the solutions of the Schrödinger equation for this problem. So, um notice that here in this problem, there's an energy quantity. Remember, when you have a Hamiltonian like that, and people say, "Well, so what is the ground state energy?" Well, have to find the ground state wave function.

Have to do things. Give me an hour. I'll find it, and all that. But if you want an approximate value, dimensional analysis will do it. Roughly, what is it going to be? Well, with these constants, how do you produce an energy? Well, you remember what uh Einstein did. And you know that H bar omega is has units of energy. So that's an energy associated with this Lagrangian. Energy like quantity. And we expect that that energy is going to be the relevant energy. And in fact, we'll find that the ground state energy is just one half of that. There's another quantity that may be interested. How about the length?

How do you construct a length from these quantities? Well, you can start doing M omega H bar and put powers and struggle. I hate doing that. Uh I always try to find some way of doing it and avoiding that thing. So I know that energies go like H over H squared over M uh length squared. So I'm going to call the length a quantity A. So M A squared that has units of energy. And you should remember that because energy is P squared over 2 M and P by uh the Broglie is H bar over some lambda. So H bar squared lambda squared and M here, that's units of energy. So that's a length. On the other hand, we have another way to construct an energy is with this thing M omega squared length squared.

So that's also M omega squared A squared. That's another energy. So from this equation, I find that A over four A to the fourth is H squared over M squared omega squared. And it's a little complicated. So A squared is H bar over M omega. So that's a length. Um length squared. I don't want to take the square root. We can leave it for a moment there. But that's important because that's a length scale. And if somebody would ask you, in the ground state, how far is this particle oscillating? You would say, probably about A. Square root of this would be the natural answer. And uh probably about right.

So uh okay. Energy and units is very important to begin your analysis. So what is the Schrödinger equation? The Schrödinger equation for this thing is going to be a for minus H squared over 2 M D second psi D X squared plus the potential 1/2 M omega squared X squared psi is equal E psi. And the big problem is I don't know psi and I don't know E. Now there's so many elegant ways of solving the harmonic oscillator. Um you will see those next lecture. Alan Adams will be back here, but we all have to go through once in your life through the direct uninspired method of solving it. Uh because most of the times when you'll have a new problem you will not come up with a beautiful elegant method to avoid solving a differential equation.

You will have to struggle with a differential equation. So today we struggle with a differential equation. We're going to just do it. And I'm going to do it slow enough and in detail enough that I hope you follow everything. I'll just keep a couple of things, but it will be one-line computations that I will skip. So this equation is some sort of fairly difficult thing and it's complicated and made fairly unpleasant by the presence of all these constants. What kind of equation is that with all these constants? They shouldn't be there all these constants, in fact. So this is the first step, cleaning up the equation.

We have to clean it up. Why? Because, you know, the nice functions in life like Y double prime is equal to minus Y have no units. The derivatives create no units. Y has the same units of that and the solution is sine of X, where X must have no units because you cannot find the sine of 1 cm. Um so this thing we should have the same thing here. No units anywhere. So how can we do that? This is a absolutely necessary first step. If you're going to be carrying all these constants, you'll get nowhere. So we have to clean it up. Um so what I'm going to try to see is that look, here is psi, psi, and psi.

So suppose I do the following thing that I will clean up the right-hand side by dividing by something with units of energy. So I'm going to do it the following way. Uh I'm going to divide all by 1 over H bar omega. And this two and I I'm going to multiply by two. So multiply and I'm sorry, not divide all by multiply by two over H bar omega. So what do I achieve with that first step? I achieve that these twos disappear. Well, that's not too bad. Not that great either, I think. But in the right-hand side, this has units of energy and the right-hand side will not have units of energy. So what do we get here?

So we get minus the H becomes an H alone over the M disappears. So M omega D second psi D X squared the one half disappears. So M omega over H bar X squared psi equals 2 E over H bar omega psi. Uh it looks actually quite better already. Should agree with that. That looks a lot nicer. Now I can use a name for this. I want to call this the dimensionless value of the energy. So a calligraphic E. It has no units. It's telling me if I find some energy that that energy really is this number, this pure number is how many times bigger is E with respect to H omega over two. So I'll write this now as E psi.

And look what I have. I have no units here. And I have a psi and I have a psi, but things have worked out already. Look, the same factor here H over M omega is upside down here. And this factor has units of length squared. Length squared times D D length squared has no units. And here is one over length squared. One over length squared times length squared. So things have worked out. And we can now simply say X is going to be equal to A U, a new variable. This is going to be your new variable for your differential equation. In which A is this thing. And then this differential equation um probably I'll go here.

Really has cleaned up perfectly well. Oops. So how does it look now? Well, uh it's all gone actually because if you have X equal A U D D X by chain rule is 1 over A D D U. And two derivatives with respect to X is 1 over A squared D second D U squared. And this thing is A squared. So actually you cancel this factor. And when I write X equals to A U, you get an A squared times this and A squared times this is one. So, your differential equation has become minus d second psi d u squared where u is a dimensionless quantity because this has units of length, this has units of length, no units here. You know units, so minus d second d u squared plus u squared psi is equal to e psi.

Much nicer. This is an equation we can think about without being distracted by this endless amount of little trivialities. So, but still, you know, we haven't solved it and uh how are we going to solve this equation? So, let's again think of what should happen. Somehow it should happen that these e's get fixed and there's some solutions just for some values of e's. It's not obvious at this stage how that is going to happen. Yes. Um here, for example, let's let me do this. This term. H bar over m omega is minus from that equation a squared. But d d x squared is 1 over a squared d d u squared. So, the a squared cancels.

And here x is equal a squared times u, so again cancels. Okay. So, uh So, what is the problem here? The problem is that most likely what's going to go wrong is that this solution for arbitrary values of e's is going to diverge at infinity and you're never going to be able to normalize it. So, let's try to understand how the solution looks as we go to infinity. So, this is the first thing you should do with an equation like that. How does the solution look as u goes to infinity? Now, we may not be able to solve it exactly in that case either, but we're going to gain insight into what's happening.

So, here it is. What when u goes to infinity, this term, whatever psi is, this term is much bigger than that because we're presumably working with some fixed energy that we still don't know what it is, but it's a fixed number and for u sufficiently large, this is going to dominate. So, the equation that we're trying to solve as u goes to infinity, the equation sort of becomes psi double prime. Prime is for two derivatives. Is equal to u squared psi. Okay. So, how do we get an idea of what solves this? It's not all that obvious. It's certainly not a power of u because when you differentiate a power of u, you lower the degree rather than increase the degree.

So, what function increases degree as you differentiate? It's not a trivial function. Um cannot be a polynomial. If it would be even a polynomial, if you take two derivatives, it cannot be equal to x squared times a polynomial. It's sort of upside down. So, if you think about it for a little while, you don't have an exact solution, but you would imagine that something like this would do it, an e to the u squared. Because an e to the u squared, when you differentiate with respect to u, you produce a u down when you take one derivative. When you take another derivative, well, it's more complicated, but one term you will produce another u down.

So, that probably is quite good. So, let's try that. Let's try to see if we have something like that. So, I will try something. Um So, I'll set I'll try try psi equals to um I'm going to try the following thing. E to the alpha u squared over two where alpha is a number. I don't know how much it is. Alpha is some number. Now, I could try this alone, but I actually want to emphasize to you that uh if this is the behavior near infinity, uh it won't make any difference if you put here, for example, something that u to the power k. It will will also be roughly a solution. So, let's uh see that. So, for that I have to differentiate.

And um let's see what we get. So, so we're trying to see how the function behaves far, far away. You might say, "Look, uh probably that alpha should be negative, uh but let's see what the equation tells us before we we put anything in there." So, if I do psi prime, you would get what? You would get one term that would be alpha u times this u to the k e to the alpha u squared over two where I differentiated the exponential. I differentiated the exponential. And then you would get a term where you differentiate the power, so you get k u to the k minus one e to the alpha u squared over two. If you take a second derivative, well, I can differentiate the exponential again, so I will get alpha u now squared because each derivative of this exponent produces a a factor of alpha u u to the k e to the alpha u squared over two.

And a couple more terms that they all have less powers of u because this term has u to the k plus already has u to the k plus one and this has u to the k minus one. They differ by two powers of u. So, for illustration, please, if you want, do it. Three lines. You should skip three lines in your notebook if you are taking notes and get the following. No point in me doing this algebra here. alpha u squared over two because actually, you know, it's not all that important over alpha one over u squared plus k k minus one over alpha squared one over u to the fourth. That's all you get. But this is look.

This is alpha squared u squared times psi times these things one plus two k plus one over alpha one over u squared. So, when u goes to infinity, your solution works because these things are negligible, so you get a number times u squared. That is the equation you're trying to solve up there. And therefore, you get that equation if alpha squared is equal to one. And that means really that alpha can be plus minus one. And roughly, this solution near infinity probably there's two solutions. Um this is a second order differential equation, so even near infinity, there should be two solutions. So, we expect as as u goes to infinity, psi of u will be some constant a times u to the k times e to the minus u squared over two.

That's for alpha equal minus one. Plus b u to the k e to the plus u squared over two. And what is k? Well, we don't know what is k. It seems to work for all k. That's may seem a little confusing now, but uh don't worry. We'll we'll we'll see other things happening here very soon. So, look at what has happened. We've identified that most likely your wave function is going to look like this at infinity. So, we're going to want this part not to be present. So, presumably we're going to want a solution that just has this because this is normalizable. The integral of any power times a Gaussian convergent.

So, this can be normalized. The Gaussian falls so fast that any power can be integrated against a Gaussian. Any power, however big, doesn't grow big enough to compensate a Gaussian. It's impossible to compensate a Gaussian. So, uh So, we hope for this. Hope for this. But, we want to translate what we've learned into some technical advantage in solving the differential equation because after all, we wanted insight how it looks far away, but uh you know, we want to solve the differential equation. So, how can we use this insight we now have to simplify the solution of the differential equation? The idea is to change variables a little bit.

So, write psi of U to be equal to H of U. That's times e to the minus U squared over two. Now, you can say, "Why? What are you doing? Are you making an approximation now that this is what is going to look far away? Or what what what are you putting there?" And I'm not making any approximation. I'm just saying whatever psi is, it can always be written in this way. Why? Because if you have a psi of U, you can write it as psi of U over e to the minus uh U squared over two times e to the U minus U squared over two. Very trivially, this can always be done as long as we say that H is arbitrary. There's nothing No constraint here.

I have not assumed anything. Nothing. I'm just hoping that I have a differential equation for psi that because this is a very clever factor, the differential equation for H will be simpler. Because part of the dependence it has been taken over. So, maybe H, for example, could be now a polynomial solution. Because this part has been taken care of. So, the hope is that by writing this this equation for it will become an equation for H of U, and that equation will be simpler. So, will it be simpler? Well, uh here again, uh this is not difficult. You're supposed to plug into equation one. This is equation one.

Plug into one. To one. I won't do it. It's three lines of algebra to plug into one and calculate the equation for H of U. You should do it. It's the kind of thing that one should do at least once. And uh So, please do it. It's uh three, four lines. Uh it's not long. But, I'll just write the answer. So, by the time you substitute, of course, the e to the minus U squared over two is going to cancel from everywhere. It's very easy here. You just need to take two derivatives. So, it becomes a second-order differential equation. And indeed, it becomes a tractable differential equation. The second H the U squared minus two U the H D U plus E minus one H equals zero.

Okay. That is our equation now. So, now we face the problem of finally solving this equation. So, before we start, maybe there are some questions of what we've done so far. Let's see. Any Any questions? Yes. You have a right there. You don't uh it'll be this equation is linear. So, if we just like say we have e to the minus U squared over two, and you you would stuff in that U to the K. I'm sorry. It's here, this thing? Yeah. Yeah. You didn't just power series what's going on at zero with those U to the K terms instead of a bunch of them? No. Uh this is the behavior as U goes to infinity. So, I actually don't know that the function near zero is going to behave like U to the K.

We really don't know. Yeah, it it suggests to you that maybe uh the solution is going to be near zero U to the K times some polynomial or something like that, but it's not that because this analysis was just done at infinity. So, we really have no information still what's going on near zero. Other questions? Yes. So, is K some arbitrary number or is it an integer? Um at this moment, actually, it doesn't matter. Is that right? So, um doesn't matter. The analysis that we did here suggested uh could be anything. That's why I just didn't put it into H of U. I didn't put it because it would be strange to put here a a U to the K.

I wouldn't know what to make of it. So, at this moment, the best thing to say is we don't know what it is, and maybe we'll understand it, and we will in a few seconds. We sort of see what's going on. Okay. So, how does one solve this equation? Um Well, it's it's not a trivial equation again, um but it can be solved by polynomials, and we'll see that. But, the way we solve this equation is by a power series expansion. Now, you could do it by hand first, and you know, I did it when I was preparing the lecture yesterday. Uh I said, "I'm going to just write H equals um H of U equal a constant A0 plus A1U plus A2U squared plus A3U cubed.

And uh I plugged it in here. And I just did the first few terms and tried to see what happened. And I found after a little thinking that A2 is determined by A0, and the A3 is determined by A1. Once you substitute, it's not obvious when you look at this, but that happens. So, uh you know, when you face a problem like that, don't go high power to begin with. Just try a simple series and see what happens, and you see a little pattern, and then you can do a more sophisticated analysis. So, what would be the more sophisticated analysis? To write H of U equal the sum from J equals zero to infinity AJ U to the J.

Then, if you take a derivative, but cuz we're going to need the derivative, uh D H D U would be the sum from J equals zero to infinity um J times AJ U to the J minus one. You would say, "That doesn't look very good because um for J equals zero, you have one over U, and that's crazy." But, indeed, for J equals zero, the J here multiplies it and makes it zero. So, this is okay. Now, the term that we actually need is minus two U D H D U. So, here minus two U D H D U would be equal to the sum from J equals zero to infinity, and I'll have minus two J AJ U to the J. The U makes this J minus one J, and the constant went there.

So, here is so far H. Here is this other term that we're going to need for the differential equation. And then there's the last term that we're going to need for the differential equation. So, I'm going to go here. So, what do we get for this last term? We'll have to take a second derivative. So, we'll take um h prime was there, so the second h d u squared will be the sum from j equals 0 of j times j minus 1 a j u to the j minus 2. Now, you have to rewrite this in order to make it tractable. You want everything to have like u to the j's. You don't want actually to have u to the j minus 2. So, the first thing that you notice is that this sum actually begins with 2.

Because for 0 and 1, it vanishes. So, I can write j times j minus 1 a j u to the j minus 2. Like that. And then, I can say let j be equal to j prime plus 2. And if j is Look, j begins with 2 in this sum. So, if j is j prime plus 2, j prime will begin with 0. So, we've shifted the sum, so it's j prime equals 0 to infinity. And whenever I have a j, I must put j prime plus 2. So, j prime plus 2 j prime plus 1 a j prime plus 2 u to the j prime. Wherever I had j, I put j prime plus 2. And finally, you say j or j prime is the same name, so let's call it j. j equals 0 j plus 2 j plus 1 a j plus 2 u j.

Okay. So, we got the series expansion of everything. So, we just plug into the differential equation. So, where is the differential equation? It's here. So, I'll plug it in. Let's see what we get. We'll get sum from j equals 0 to infinity. Let's see, the second derivative is here. j times j plus 2 times j plus 1 times j plus 1 a j plus 2 um u j. So, I'll put it here. u j. Good, that's the second derivative term. Now, this one. It's easy, minus 2 j a j and the u j is there. So, minus 2 j a j. Last term is just e minus 1. Because this is the function this times a j as well. That's h. And look, this whole thing must be 0.

So, what you learn is that this coefficient must be 0 for every value of j. Now, it's possible to Here is a j and a j, so it's actually one single thing. Let me write it here. j plus 2 times j plus 1 a j plus 2 minus 2 j plus um 1 minus e a j u j. I think I got it right. Yes. And this is the same sum. And now, okay, it's a lot of work, but we're getting there. Um This must be 0. So, actually that solves for a j plus 2 in terms of a j. What I had told you that you can notice in 2 minutes if you try it a little that a 2 seems to be determined by a 0 and a 3 seems to be determined by a 2. So, this is saying that a j plus 2 is given by 2 j plus 1 minus e over j plus 2 j plus 1 a j.

A very nice recursion relation. So, indeed, if you put the value of a 0 it will determine for you a 2, a 4, a 6, a 8, a all the even ones. If you put a value for a 1 it will determine for you a 3, a 5. So, a solution is determined by you telling me how much is a 0 and telling me how much is a 1. Two constants, two numbers. That's what you expect from a second order differential equation. The value of the function at the point, the derivative at the point. In fact, you're looking at a 0 and a 1 as the two constants that will determine a solution. And this is the value of h at the at 0. This is the derivative of h at 0.

So, um we can now write um the following for uh following facts about the solution that we have found. So, what do we know? That uh solutions fixed by giving a 0 and a 1. That correspond to the value of the function at 0 and the derivative of the function at 0. And this gives one solution. Once you fix a 0, you get a 2, a 4. And this is an even solution because it has only even powers. And then from a 1, you fix a 3, a 5. All the odd ones, it's an odd solution. Okay. Well, we solved the differential equation, which is really in a sense bad because we were expecting that we can only solve it for some values of the energy.

Moreover, uh well, you have a 0, you get a 2, a 4, a 6, a 8. This will go on forever and not terminate. And then it will be an infinite polynomial that grows up and doesn't ever decline, which is sort of contradictory with the idea that we had before that near infinity the function was going to be some power, some fixed power times this exponential. So, um this is what we're looking for, this h function now. And it doesn't look like a fixed power. It looks like it goes forever. So, let's see um what happens uh eventually when the coefficients, the value of the j index is large. For large j a j plus 2 is roughly equal to for large a, whatever the energy is sufficiently large.

The most important here is the 2 j here, the j and the j, so you get 2 over j a j. So, roughly for large j, it behaves like that. And now you have to ask yourself the question. If you have a power series expansion whose coefficients behave like that, how badly is it at infinity? How bad is it? You know, it's a power series expansion because uh your h was all these coefficients. And And suppose they behave like that. They grow in that way or decay in this way because they're decaying. Is this a solution that's going to blow up or is it not going to blow up? And here comes an important thing. Uh This is pretty bad behavior, actually.

It's pretty awful behavior. So, let's see that. Um That's pretty bad. So, um How do we see that? Well, uh you could do it in different ways, depending whether you want to derive that this is a bad behavior or or guess it. Um I'm going to guess uh something. So, I'm going to look at how does e to the u squared behaves as a power series? Well, you know, as a power series, exponential is 1 over n u squared to the n. Here is n factorial, n equals 0 to infinity. Now, these two ends, uh u to the two n, these are all even powers. So, um I'm going to change letters here, and I'm going to work with J from 0 2 4 over the evens, so I will write u to the J here.

And that is correct, because you'll produce u to the zero, u to the two, u to the fourth, these things. And J is really 2 n, so here you will have 1 over J over 2 factorial. Now, you might say, "J over 2, isn't it a fraction?" No, it's not a fraction, because J is even, so this is a nice factorial. Now, this is the coefficient c j u to the J. And let's see how these coefficients vary. So, this c j is 1 over J over 2 factorial. What is c j plus 2 over c j? Which is the analog of this thing. Well, this would be 1 over J plus 2 over 2 factorial. And here is up there, so J over 2 factorial. Well, this has one more factor in the denominator than the numerator.

So, this is roughly 1 over J over 2 plus 1, the last value of this. This integer is just one bigger than that. Now, if J is large, this is roughly 1 over J over 2, which is 2 over J. Oh, exactly that stuff. So, it's pretty bad. If this series goes on forever, it will diverge like e to the u squared. And your h will be like e to the u squared with e to the minus u squared over 2 is going to be like e to the plus u squared over 2. It's going to go and behave like this one. So, it's going to do exactly the wrong thing. If this series doesn't terminate, we have not succeeded. But happily, the series may terminate, because the J's are integers.

So, maybe for some energies that are integers, it terminates, and that's the solution. The only way to get a solution is if the series terminates. The only way it can terminate is that the E is some odd number over here. And that will solve the thing. So, we actually need to do this. This chose the energy. You found why it's quantized. So, let's do it, then. We're really done with this, in a sense. Uh this is the most important point of the lecture is that the series must terminate. Otherwise, it will blow up horrendously. If it terminates, it's a polynomial, and everything is good. So, to terminate, you can choose 2 J plus 1 minus E to be zero.

This will make a j plus 2 equal to zero. And your solution, your h of u will begin, you know, a j will be the last one that is non-zero, so it will be a j times u to the J. And it will go down, like uh a j minus 2 u to the j minus 2. It will go down in steps of two, because this recursion is always by steps of two. So, that's it. That's going to be the solution, where these coefficients are going to be fixed by the recursion relation, and we have this. Now, most people here call J equal n. So, let's call it n. And then we have 2 n plus 1 minus E equals zero, and h of u would be a n u to the n plus all these things.

That's the h. The full solution is h times e to the minus u squared over 2, as we will see. But recall what E was. E here is 2 n plus 1. But E was the true energy divided by h omega over 2. That was long ago. It's gone. Long gone. So, what has What have you found, therefore? Um that the energy that we'll call E N n n n The energy of the nth solution is going to be h omega over 2 2 n plus 1. So, it's actually h omega, and people write n plus 1/2, very famous result. The nth level of the harmonic oscillator has this energy. And moreover, these objects, people choose this co- You see, the constants are related by steps of two.

So, just like you could start with a zero or a one and go up, you can go down. People call these functions Hermite functions, and they fix the notation so that this a n is 2 to the n. They like it. It's a nice normalization. So, actually, h of u n is what we call the Hermite function of u sub n, and it goes like 2 to the n u to the n plus order u to the n minus 2 plus n minus 4, and goes on and on and on like that. Um Okay, a couple things and we're done. Um Just for reference, the Hermite polynomial, if you're interested in it, is the one that solves this equation, and the Hermite sub n corresponds to E sub n, which is um 2 n plus 1.

So, the Hermite solution from that equation is that the Hermite polynomial satisfies uh this minus 2 u d h n d u plus 2 n, because E N is 2 n plus 1. So, it's 2 n h n equals zero. That's the equation for the Hermite polynomial. An interesting thing to know. Um Actually, if you want to generate efficiently the Hermite polynomials, there's something called the generating function. E to the minus z squared plus 2 z u, if you expand it in a power series of z, it actually gives you n equals 0 to infinity. If it's a power series of z, it will be some z to the n's. You can put a factor here n, and here is the h n of u.

So, you can use your Mathematica program and expand this in powers of z, collect the various powers of u that appear with z to the n, and that's h n. It's the most efficient way of generating h n. And moreover, if you want to play in mathematics, you can show that such definition of h n satisfies this equation. So, it produces the solution. So, what have we found? Our end result is the following. Uh let me finish with that here. We had this potential. And the first energy level is called E0 and has energy H omega over two. The next energy is E1. It has three halves H omega. Next one is E2, five halves H omega.

This polynomial is nth degree polynomial, so it has n zeros, therefore n nodes. So, this wave functions will have the right number of nodes. E0, the psi zero will have no nodes. When you have psi zero, the Hn becomes a number for n equals zero, and the whole solution is the exponential of u squared over two. The whole solution, in fact, is, as we wrote, psi n Hn of u e to the minus u squared over two. In plain English, if you use an x, it would be Hn. U was x over that constant A we had. And you have minus x squared over 2a squared. Those are your eigen functions. These are the solutions. Discrete spectrum, evenly spaced, the nicest spectrum possible.

All the nodes are there. You will solve this in a more clever way next time. See you.