Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu hi everyone I'm in a very good mood today I nothing to do with the class but I'm having a baby so so that's kind of exciting so if I just start giggling you'll know why and then six months if I just weeping it on the ground you'll also know why so so today we're gonna do two things the first is we're going I'm gonna give you well the first is review a little bit of practice for the exam we're gonna have on Thursday let me tell you a little bit more about the exam the exam by the way has been rescheduled to be in six one twenty not in Walker gym so it's gonna be the usual place we're not moving and the reason is I'm changing the format on this exam in part to make it a little less of a burden to everyone but also in part because I've been struggling with the question of how to make the exam most useful the purpose of an exam like this is not to get get grades for you guys although that's an incidental by-product the purpose is to give you some feedback on how you're doing how you're command of the material has evolved and also to to help you sort of learn some of the things that you might not have mastered so the way the exam is gonna be structured it's gonna be about 50 minutes of short answer questions a couple of very short computations but mostly short answer questions on paper you'll hand those back and then we'll go over those questions in class afterwards okay so it's a relatively low pressure exam and it's mostly conceptual it will cover everything we've done through this last problem set today's the to the degree that we get to the lecture part of today after questions today's lecture will not be directly covered however it will be a fair game for the next midterm which would be more of a traditional midterm and that's coming in April so the structure of today is I'm going to give you a whole bunch of clicker questions so make sure you've got your clickers out and those clicker questions are going to give you a sense for the level and scope of the exam the exam will be a little harder than the clicker questions but not a whole lot and the difference is just that it's going to be on paper in front of you instead of you know clicker and thus that gives you a little more room to do calculations on a piece of paper short short calculations and then after that we'll we'll come on to some in some sense of a review but also an introduction to the Drakh bra ket notation that many of our textbooks use but that we haven't introduced in lecture so far okay any questions before you get started 41 other questions I think there will probably not be a practice exam because of the shift in format today will basically be your practice exam okay if I can get my work together and get you guys a practice exam of the right format then maybe but it wouldn't even be all that useful is the problem so watch what happens today yep I will post the questions from today on the website yes I can tell you that but it's not gonna be a time trial okay you're not gonna be racing to get the you know it will because it to my mind part of the reason to or to design the exam this way is that it's testing your conceptual understanding which is the important thing so yeah it will be the questions alright so let's get started with the clicker part of today so do do we're on channel 41 okay so consider this eigenvalue equation two derivatives on f it's constant times f of X how many of these are eigen functions with the corresponding eigenvalue okay I've got about 10 seconds let's go ahead and put in your clicks okay and so your whoops oh sorry that just cleared your responses unfortunately the durian they're saved in memory just clear them off my screen so the response is here we go that didn't work Wow it just totally disappeared how did that happen wow that's so weird oh no that didn't work let's try this where did it go ah there it is whoa this is all very confusing okay this one so that that was your response B and C 63 and 38% so let's go back to this so quickly discuss this with your neighbor okay and now go ahead and click in your new answers if you you can keep talking that's fine okay another five seconds awesome okay that's it so the answer is B and 99% of y'all got that I suspect someone didn't click okay good next question so I want insight to our two solutions of the Schrodinger equation is the sum of the two of them with coefficients a and B also a solution of the Schrodinger equation oh and I forgot to start the clicky thingy so click now oh yeah it is supposed to say psi 2 it says B Saito on the next sorry it's a Sai 1 plus psi 1 it should say Sai 1 plus psi 2 thank you yeah with the same potential yeah yeah Wow yeah so you know Einstein said God didn't play dice and let me paraphrase that is God doesn't mess with you and clicker question yeah okay and and you guys have effectively universally that the answer is a yes the superposition principle okay next question is going to be for answer here we go consider an infinite square well with with a and compared to the infinite square well with with a the ground state of a finite well is lower higher same energy or undetermined okay you've got ten seconds so continue thinking through this five seconds okay and you mostly got it but have a quick chat with the person next to you all right let's try again it's such a good technique um I read another five seconds to put in your answer four three two one okay and you virtually all got it right they lower energy and let's just think about this intuitively intuitively the the gradient of the potential is a force right so in the second case you've got less force cramming the particle inside the box so it's being squeezed less tightly more physically you see that there was an evanescent tail on the outside what that tells you is the wave flux you didn't have to go to zero at the end it just had to get small and match on to a dying exponential right that's from the qualitative analysis of wave functions but meanwhile what that tells you is it has to curve less inside in order to have to get to zero it just has to get to a small value where matches to the decaying exponential so if the curvature is less than the energy is less cool okay next question or so any questions on that okay good time zero wavefunction infinite well with a is this sine squared with the normalization what's the wave function at a subsequent time T and will remind you that you have solved the problem of the infinite square well and you know what the energies the eigenenergies and eigenfunctions are of the energy operators energy operator in the infinite square well so remember back to what those are all right and you have five seconds okay we are at about 50/50 correct so chat with the person next to you all right and now any moments go ahead and vote again good five more seconds and then put in your final vote okay that's it for now so what's the answer D is the answer but a lot of people so it's in doubt so who wants to give an explanation for why it's D excellent excellent really okay so I'm gonna restate that that was exactly correct in every step so the first thing is that wave function at time 0 sine squared of X is not an eigenfunction of the energy operator for the system in fact we computed the eigenfunctions for the energy operator in the infinite square well and their signs where they get a zero at the ends on the other hand any function with which satisfying the boundary conditions normalizable hits zero at the boundaries is a superposition of energy eigenfunctions and we can use that to determine the time evolution we take that superposition and and add on a phase e to the minus IET upon h-bar for each of the energy eigenfunctions and in Part D we express that wave function as a superposition with the coefficient cn determined from the overlap of our original function and the energy eigenfunctions everyone cool that so this is literally just a transcription of one of our postulates ok questions if you have any questions at all ask them this is the time to ask yeah exactly so the way you get CN is by saying look I have my wave function Phi of X is equal to sum over n CN Phi n of X where these fans are energy eigenfunctions e Phi n is equal to e n Phi n right of X and we also know that the integral of Phi n complex conjugate Phi M is equal to Delta MN right this is the statement that they're orthogonal and properly normalized we also write this as equal to Phi n Phi M and we can use this to determine the CNS the CN is equal to the inner product of Phi n with our wave function this is equal to the integral DX Phi star Phi n star sign which is equal to the integral DX Phi n star sum over m of C M by M but this sum over m of C M can be pulled out because this is just an integral over a sum of terms which is the same as a sum over m cm integral Phi n complex conjugate to Phi M and that's Delta MN which is 0 unless n is equal to M because these guys are orthogonal and properly normalized so this is zero unless n is equal to M so in this sum the only term that contributes is when M is equal to n this is equal to CN so CN is given by the overlap of our wave function with the corresponding eigen function this allows us to take our function a known function for example sine squared and express the coefficients in terms of an overlap of our wave function sine squared with the wave functions sign and that's exactly the expression you see below CN is equal to the integral of sine squared our wave function and sine which is the energy eigenfunction cool other questions okay great next problem come to me a computer I can't it should be written in Python okay I'm good yeah eigenstates Phi n which we usually call sign but there it is form an orthonormal set meaning integral of Phi M star Phi n is Delta MN what is the value of integral Siam against the sum CN Phi n okay you got five seconds give you a little extra time because people are clicking away okay you now have seven seconds because time is nonlinear okay so quickly discuss because there's still some ambiguity here all right you have 10 seconds to modify your clicks click alright yes and the answer is C excellent okay good right because in fact we just did that okay that one happened on the actual exam so here's the next question let the Hamiltonian on a dagger u n equals y n plus H Omega that should be an H bar a dagger u n what can you say about a dagger u n here what we should probably say what can one say you know possible okay what could one say here the assumption just to say it out loud the assumption is that UN is an eigenfunction of the energy operator H with eigenvalue en okay you've got five seconds all right we are at 5050 so discuss amongst yourselves yes all right you have okay go ahead and enter again enter your modified guesses and you have ten seconds to do so wow this is a lot better okay this is great so this is one of those really satisfying moments it's improved but there's still some real doubt here so I would like to get one person to argue for B and one person to argue for C's who who wants to volunteer for each of those which one you want who's gonna argue for be someone's gonna argue for me come on I'm not gonna argue for you I'm not gonna argue for C either that defeat surprised me I have to see this all the time so who's gonna intervene okay you argue for me who's gonna argue for C all right yeah that worked out well great beat are you for me you can do it so I guess I can do this so originally I just kind of didn't read the question and I thought since you're acting the ladder operator on the I can say that you get a proportionality constant sign some eigenstate so that's why that's not the best argument imaginable for B but we'll take it we'll take it so you can thank you so I yeah when I put someone in an impossible position to see and that fantastic that's exactly right so let me walk through that let me say that out loud so from the first line it is clear that the object a UN is an eigenfunction of the energy operator right and it's got egg in value en plus h Omega so it is a stationary States an eigenfunction of the energy it is not the same one because it has a different eigen value so if what it means to be the same energy eigenstate as it has the same eigen value it has a different energy eigenvalue it is a different state and they're orthogonal we proved this before two states with different energy orthogonal so they don't even not only are they not the same they don't even have any overlap okay so it is a stationary state but it's not proportional with the state UN it's an important one okay questions about that one before we move on to the next if it were proportional to the state UN then it would be some constant times UN that's what we mean by saying it's proportional but then if we acted on it with the energy operator what would the eigenvalue be so let me say this again suppose I have a state UN which I know that if I act with the energy operator on it or this is sometimes called H UN is equal to en un okay if I act with e on alpha UN where alpha is a constant what is this equal to alpha en un right so the eigenvalue is the same it's en right because they can't divide through by L so so if you have the same state meaning proportional to it then will have the same eigen value but this manifestly has a different eigen value cool awesome okay other questions yeah ah good okay so H is another name so some books use H and some books use E and the reason goes back to classical mechanics there's a there's an object called the Hamiltonian which it's sort of like saying I don't know it's like saying look bread and bond are the same thing but they evoke different things right you say bread and you think like Dixie and you say Ben and you think you know the me of some gorgeous baguette right okay it has a different feel it has a different feel so this invokes different things a particular to a classical mechanic the Hamiltonian is the generator of time translations now we don't usually that wasn't the classic way of thinking about the energy operator in you know say Newton's time okay but it is how we think about energy now so that's just this is just terminology for anyone who didn't get that sorry about that this is something that we've run across before but I should emphasize so when you hear people say the Hamiltonian that means the energy operator the reason I say energy operator rather than saying Hamiltonian which is the more common thing in the lingua franca of quantum mechanics because I want to impress upon you guys that it's just energy it is the energy it's nothing else it's not some strange beast it's just energy okay other questions bread other questions okay for next question which of these graphs shows the curvature of the wave function in a classically allowed region okay five seconds left all right fantastic and the answer is a because the curvature has to be towards the axis in a classically allowed reason the wave function is sinusoidal it's oscillatory alright and oops and the partner of that question is what about in the classically disallowed region okay five seconds okay awesome and basically everyone got this be great questions all right oh yeah sorry nope no that's a very good question so C and D I should say I should let me be a little more precise but it's a very reasonable question so let me give you an answer suppose you saw a wave function that had the curvature structure of C it was curved oscillatory over there and curved exponential over there on the right what would you say about the potential relative to the energy sagan yeah good so on one side were allowed and on the other side were disallowed so if you saw a wave function that had that curvature structure you'd immediately know that it was in the loud region on the left but then on the right it was disallowed classically just because it had curvature away from the axis that cool so that's something you if you saw a wave function so for example you might say well look you never get a wave function that does this and and that's not true right you could do that so this would be classically disallowed because it's curvature down this would be classically loud so the potential for example if this is the energy the potential could be do do okay so a potential like this could lead to a wave function like this that cool okay so it's a very good question I'm sorry I should have seen what you were asking more immediately okay other questions is following up on that anything okay cool no one ever asked that question before and I just want to emphasize that you guys should just ask questions when you don't when you're confused by something someone else is gonna be confused by it I wouldn't even necessarily know that the question is a meaningful question I get questions I've never heard before all the time in this class just don't hesitate to ask it's always a good idea okay next one wave function Phi has been expressed as a sum over energy eigenfunctions UN compared to the original wave function as a function of X a set of coefficients C 1 dot dot contains more or less same information or cannot be determined or depends all right 5 seconds all right and the answer is same information good questions okay good some of these you've seen before F and G are wave functions and C is a constant then the inner product C F with G is equal to click away ten seconds all right okay you've got about five seconds still a lot of fluctuations here wow I'm surprised by this one all right uh yeah question let's come back the previous one I have to redo this sir thanks but remind me to after we move on okay so discuss because about a third of you got this one wrong so discuss all right so go ahead and put in your answers again good all right another five seconds great okay and the answer is good get that complex conjugation right little things like that can cause you an infinite amount of trouble especially as you'll notice on the problem set when you're computing time dependence of expectation values getting that complex conjugation right is essential because you need to see interference terms and without the complex conjugation you will not get the right interference terms okay question oh yeah it's question from previous problem thank you the norm squared gives you the probabilities but if you know the coefficient so good this is a good question so let me rephrase the question so the question is look in the previous question we said look our wave function Phi of X is some function which we could draw right so I could represent this in two ways I could have there draw it or I could represent it as equal the sum over n of C n Phi n where Phi n are the known energy eigenfunctions right and the question is did the CN contain the same information so that's that was a question and the point that's being asked about here is a very good question the question is look we know what the C NS mean what the C ends mean is the probability that you measure the energy given that the state is signed the probability usually measure the energy B n is equal to norm CN squared right and so the CNS tell you about probabilities they don't tell you what the state is they just tell you what probability is that you'll measure a particular energy is that right so how can it contain the same information and the there are two important things to say about this first off this is of course true and this does give you the probability and the probability comes from the norm squared so the co if the phase of CN doesn't particularly matter for that however the claim that I can expand this function at in in a basis of the energy eigenfunctions in a basis of other functions is this statement if I know these CNS then I take C 1 multiplied by Phi 1 C 2 multiplied by Phi Q add them all back up and they get nothing other than this original function okay so if I know the C ends I can just construct that original function explicitly so this can't contain any more or any less information than the list of C NS as long as I know what basis I'm talking about okay so here's the disturbing thing about that when we say the wave function is the state of the system it contains all knowledge you could possibly have access to and not just knowledge that you could have access to it contains all of the information of the state and then we look at this and say well look it doesn't give us something deterministic because of something probabilistic it tells us the probability distribution for measuring the various different energies what does that immediately tell you since they're equivalent information this guy tells you nothing more than the probabilities I'm imagining it doesn't tell you what energies you'll measure it tells you the probabilities with which you will measure energies so they're the same thing it's a very it's a very good question and I think the way to take the sort of discomfort that that I don't know about you that causes me is just to read that as saying look the wave function is giving you probabilistic information about measurements excellent excellent okay so let me turn this around let me phrase it slightly different tell me if this is getting at the same point if I gave you a list of numbers one fourteen twelve does that tell you what function I'm talking about no I have to tell you that there are the expansion coefficients in say sine waves of a particular wavelength or energy eigenfunctions in some particular energy operator if I just give you a list of numbers it doesn't tell you what function is I have to give you a list of numbers and I have to tell you what basis I'm talking about if you have the wave function you don't need to know what basis you're talking about the wave function is basis independent right it's just a function in a few minutes I'm gonna come back and subvert what I just said but so the wave function is just what the wave function is and if I give you a list of numbers they're only equivalent when you also know the wave function so in order for these two things to be equivalent it's important that you know what basis you're talking about in particular it's important that you know the energy eigenfunctions is that is that getting it what what's the distinction you're making okay think more about it and and and and when when the question becomes more sharp ask okay other questions yeah you know the end are we supposed to do yeah yeah usually I I've I try on problem sets and exams to make that distinction clear but that will generally be assumed other questions all right I'm gonna come back to this but well I'm gonna come back to this when we finish with the clicker questions okay the next question in the simple harmonic oscillator the eigenvalues as we've just derived twice are en is h-bar n Rho Omega times n plus 1/2 for an integer N and a measurement of energy will always observe one of these values that's from postulate four three three what can we say about the expectation value of the energy in some arbitrary state okay this one isn't tricky but it's not trivial so think carefully about it all right you have five seconds enter your your best guess all right and you are at complete chance I think we've just put you through a hardness box so so discuss and okay go ahead and start put in your modified response all right another five seconds or so okay click okay you're still there's still a lot of disagreement here so let's see so who would like to argue for C would like to argue for D go ahead excellent excellent okay so let me let me restate that so the statement if I'm following your logic thank you so the same uniform your logic goes something like this look if we had the wave function which was Phi sub n times some phase some ridiculous phase let's say the phase is one if we had the wave functions Phi sub n what will the expectation value of the energy operator be in this state en right because it's the energy it's the sum over all possible ends of en times the probability that we measure en by definition but this is equal to sum over N of en times the expansion coefficient of our wave function in the energy eigenstate basis C N squared now what's the what's the expansion coefficient in our energy eigenbasis here it's one for a particular value of n and zero for everything else right so what will our answer be it will be zero for everything except one for a particular value yen corresponding to little n I should really call this mm so you know dummy variables that were summing over don't matter so for this particular case the expectation value of E is equal to en everyone call that so it certainly can be en but is this the only way to get in no so for example suppose we have Alpha Phi n or v 1 Phi 1 plus beta Phi 3 okay what will the answer be now first off in order to make this normalizable what is beta have to be it needs to be square of 1 minus alpha norm squared right just so that they sum to 1 1 norm squared so what I want to plot now the expectation value of the energy as a function of alpha when alpha is zero what is the expectation value of the energy III when alpha is 1 which it can't be anything greater than well if alpha is 1 what is the expectation value of the energy e1 and how does the expectation value of the energy vary between these two as a function of alpha well it's smooth right and in particular it's in particular it's quadratic because goes like the square of these coefficients so it's something smooth that does this and have slope zero at the end ok and somewhere in between it will hit e to but there is not only is this not equal to two it doesn't even contain e2 as an element of the superposition right so this is a counter example to see every cool this is an important point now if I let the system if I know that at some moment in time the energy expectation value is this value corresponding say to some particular alpha and I let the system evolve in time how does that expectation value evolving time how does the expectation value of the energy change over time it doesn't the expectation value of energy is always time independent yeah does the expectation value of position change over time in general yes when does it not change over time in a stationary state right so this is exactly what this is working through this is what's on your previous problem set as well as on your current problem set yeah is this anything like conservation of energy excellent it sort of sounds like that will make a sharp version of that later so you should have that tinkling in the back of your head is like oh look we have a time independent potential energy is conserved that sounds kind of like the expectation value is constant but we need to make that more precise and we'll find a precise version of that statement later in the semester but it's a very good intuition to have other questions okay so the answer is D and you guys were about 4/5 on that at the end but that was not right okay next one this is a three step question we have observable a and B with eigen States i1 its IQ and phi1 and phi2 of a and b and eigen values a1 a2 and b1 b2 the eigen states are related in this linear fashion I measure observable a and get the value a 1 what's the state immediately after that measurement what is the wave function alright five seconds to one-click ways okay great so there's pretty strong agreement among y'all that the answer is a and that is indeed the answer okay questions okay good so a slightly less obvious one immediately after this measurement of a the observable B is measured what's the probability that B 1 is found well there's some amazing initial transients there I could use this that could use the first couple of seconds as a random number generator move around okay that's it and and there's actually a third of you disagree with the correct answer so I'm gonna invite you to chat with each other all right go ahead and update your answers good okay five more seconds one second okay nice excellent you guys went from about 65 percent to 90 percent so that was great the answer is e it's the norm squared of the coefficient of the the eigen value or eigen function corresponding to be one in the original state which was silent okay now imagine on the other hand that the grad student doing the measurement failed to in fact measure the observer will be it was a bad day but instead measure day again what's the probability that the second measurement will yield a one trust me on this one there's so many ways you know they read the package wrong you know they did the wrong measurement sorry thank you thank you thank you no no very good question he accidentally measured thee instead of a are you need a MBA into the be actually live today and see how easy it is to make that mistake the accidentally measured a instead of B I preached that was intentional okay so and we get a almost total unanimity the answer is B yes question great question let's just assume it's instantaneous maybe sloppy but he's very quick okay next question a system is in a state which is a linear superposition of N equals 1 and N equals 2 energy eigenstates bla what's the probability that measurement of the energy will yield the first energy eigenvalue another 5 seconds 5 great you guys totally agree that the answer is C ok great ok that's it that's it for that clicker questions for today um so here's the thing I want to emphasize the first is that these were totally conceptual they did not involve any computations and yet and yet they're they're not trivial some of them were really not some of them got you know 50 percent consistently across the class so it's not just the calculations that are hard just thinking through the the basic premises the basic postulates is really essential at this point it's more important than the computation yeah I will post these I will post these ok any questions remaining from after this little oh shoot you know I missed out on a whole opportunity um I'll do it next time whoo any other questions before we move on to the lecture part oh you totally have to wait and you totally have to wait okay any any other questions yeah well that's a very good question so the question is can you ever have a potential function that is odd so for example so let me you're actually asking two questions and let me disentangle them so one question is can I have an energy and then a potential function which is odd in and linear right so it just ramps all the way down so does that seem physical is the energy bounded from below no okay well that's not a terribly good criterion because it's not bounded from below for the Coulomb potential either all right but in the case of the Coulomb potential it's not bounded from below in a little tiny region right not you know in a huge swath so we're gonna need a better definition of this but the short answer to this one is no this is not good okay on the other hand it's not the oddness that's bad it's that the energy is continuing to be unbounded from below and here's what here so let me be more precise than saying it's not happy what is it what's important for an observable what's important for an observable the operator corresponding to an observable in quantum mechanics what property must that operator have it has to be hermitian right and empty oh that implies real eigenvalues it implies that there's a basis of its eigenfunctions all these nice things what we will find is that the Coulomb potential the hydrogen potential gives us a nice hermitian energy operator will prove that the energy operator self the joint on a problem set however this guy will not okay so we're gonna have a one that is not bounded from below and so while it's there's a sense in which its hermitian there's not a good sense in which it's it's got problems so but that's a more technical detail however there's a second part of your question which is you could have been asking a look can you have a potential that's odd but literally decide the diverging it and infinity so for example cuz you have a potential that does this so that it's odd but it it's bounded and that's fine nothing wrong with that so odd isn't the problem the problem is certain ways of diverging yeah so later does that mean so what would happen in the case where you did have some kind of linear potentially get a uniform electric field and something was moving is that like just is it is the problem that that potential technically isn't like a physical potential because it doesn't go away or well how would you ever build a linear potential right so the question here is looks I know how to build a linear potential turn on a uniform electric field and the electric field is a gradient to the electrostatic potential so that means the electrostatic potential is linear and the potential energy of a charged particle with charge Q in an electrostatic potential is Q times the electrostatic potential so the potential energy for that charged particle is a linear function so how do I build such thing well I take two capacitor plates and I dump some charge on this one in the opposite charge on this guy and I build up a linear potential well yeah exactly so that's the problem so can I build make this linear over an arbitrarily large domain no I need an arbitrarily large amount of charge and I need to push them apart from each other arbitrarily far which takes an arbitrarily large amount of work that's not terribly physical right your arms are only so big right so so at the end of the day we're always going to discover that the pathologies that show up in a potential like is like the Hamiltonian is not self adjoint and compactly supported space of complex supported l2 continuous functions then okay that's that's going to always be some mathematical version of your arms are only so big you cannot build an infinitely large apparatus like this so yes you're exactly right it is not physical is it a mathematical problem one could analyze yes one could write a dissertation on the celerity structure of these differential equations but that dissertation would never be read by a physicist other questions yeah yes excellent question no no so here's what you can do suppose I have a bunch of energy eigenstates I have some potential at some crease this is the potential it's a crazy potential right and it has some definite energy eigenvalues as we've shown in 1d we don't her as I've mentioned and proved in office hours we can't find degenerate eigen functions in a one dimensional potential so they're just they're not degenerate their space to find a distance part four four states for wave functions that converge it to zero at infinity for a bound States so I could always construct an operator which I will simply define in this way a and just for flourish I will put a dagger on it which does the following a dagger is the is defined as the operator that map's Phi n to Phi M and plus one right so what's the rule it takes this state to this state this state to this state this state to this a and since we can extend since these are a basis then that tells us how this acts on an arbitrary function because it acts on the superposition as acting on each term so we can define it in this way but here's the question what does it mean for the raising operator to be the raising operator it wasn't that it lifted the raise the operator that's not what started out the whole machinery where the raising operator got its juice was from this commutation relation a dagger with E was equal to H bar Omega a dagger right so can we build an operator a dagger that raises States and commutes with the energy operator in this fashion no that depends on the energy operator this is not a general property this is not always something we can do okay if we could then that energy operator would have evenly spaced energy eigenfunctions on the other hand it's not like it's never useful so consider the following example and I think this was on your promise up in our number so let me just say it consider the what if we write um a dagger a is equal to n right then the commutation relation for this so the energy operator for the harmonic oscillator was equal to H bar Omega n plus 1/2 right that's what we derived last time if we drive define a dagger a is n then commutator of n with a dagger is a dagger and the commutator of n with a is equal to minus a suppose the Hamiltonian or suppose the energy operator sorry the French suppose the energy operator is is equal to H bar Omega n plus and cubed okay does the raising operator commute with the energy operator to give you a dagger again no because it's going to give you a commutes to give you an a dagger and commutes with this guy to give you well a constant times n squared a dagger which is a slightly funny Beast so this doesn't have the same commutation relations on the other hand we know how to build the eigenfunctions of the ennop rater because they live in a tower by this algebra by this commutator relation they live in a tower so I can build the eigenfunctions of n and then I can take those eigenfunctions of n act on them with E and we'll discover that they're also eigen functions of e because yakking on them is just n and then cube backing on the eigenfunctions of n and then so they're high interest so the states with definite n are still eigenfunctions of the energy operator but they're not evenly spaced now can every potential be written in terms of this n operator so I leave that to you as an exercise the answer is no try it yeah exactly so if there's there's always something that you can formally define in this fashion it's not always useful to you because it doesn't always commute with the energy operator in some nice way right so now you can ask are there think properties that are nice about this well there's something called the super symmetric method in 1d quantum mechanics but that's sort of beyond the scope come to my office hours and ask me this question again this is a miracle of the harmonic oscillator other questions yeah to construct the ground state we use a condition that a five zero is zero yes did we like so how did we call them did we demand that on physical grounds that it had to be zero yes we did so excellent question so the question is this when we constructed using the operator method for the harmonic oscillator when we constructed the ground state we said the ground state by zero is that state which is annihilated by the lowering operator AFI zero is equal to zero so where did that come from why were we fortunate enough for physical reasons for mathematical reasons what was it what was the reason so this was room this was very important so let's go through it slowly so remember the step that came immediately before this step immediately before this step we said look the expectation value of energy can always be written as a strictly positive thing it's equal to the integral and you should derive this for yourself I didn't derive it but this is a good thing to derive for yourself it takes only a couple of steps integral over all momentum of sigh tilde of P before ei transformed norm squared this is the probability that you have given the state sign this is the probability density that you have momentum P P squared upon 2m plus the integral of DX Phi of X norm squared M Omega squared upon 2 x squared right it's the probability that you're at position x given the wave function X movements the value of the potential now this is a strictly positive quantity as is this strictly positive as is this that is a plus this quantity must always be greater than or equal to zero correct however we derive from the operator relations that if we take a wave function Phi sub n sorry Phi sub E and we act on it with the lowering operator a this defines a new state which up to some Malaysian is is an eigenfunction of the energy operator with energy e minus h-bar Omega and we show this by showing that the energy eigenfunction acting on this gives exactly this coefficient times this back it's an eigenfunction we just showed explicit it's an eigenfunction so this suggests that if you have a state with energy e you can also build a state with energy e minus h-bar Omega and thus we can repeat a minus 2 H bar Omega and it's Turtles all the way down the problem is for any finite value of e eventually this tower will get negative here zero but the energy expectation value cannot be less than zero it's got to be strictly greater than zero but if we were in this energy eigenstate and we measured the expectation value of energy this is the value we would get which would be negative oops that's a 2 so something is amiss how can this possibly make sense and the answer we came up with was well look it's inescapable that acting was a on Phi gives us something that's an eigenfunction of the energy it's possible that this I can that this function happens to be the zero function non zero energy just zero not a function is zero normalizable no the integral of zero squared is zero no coefficient times that is a finite number is one so the only way so what must happen is it must be true that at some point we can't lower anymore but we can always act with a so we can always try to lower the only out is if when we lower one particular guy which I will call Phi zero the only out is if we try to lower Phi zero we don't get another state which we assumed we did here we don't get another state instead we just get zero we get no state not energy zero zero the function is 0 identically vanishing this does not describe the configuration of a particle probability of it being anywhere is zero that's bad so in order for the tower to end in order for the energy to be bounded from below as the potential is we need that there's a lowest state in the tower that answer your question great yeah very good question you're gonna show this on the problem set if you haven't already I thought you did but maybe not um the energy eigenfunctions for the energy eigenfunctions cannot wait for for potentials with only bound states can always be expressed as purely real or a purely imaginary you can always decompose them in terms of purely real and purely imaginary proving that will be a problem on one of your problem sets but for the moment let me just say that yes you can always show that the the energy eigenfunctions and for 1d potential can always be expressed as purely real loop I need that bound state condition as we'll see later in the course yeah hu make it sorry no no no this sorry no good good good so what this says is given some state with energy e when we lower we get h-bar Omega less that doesn't tell you what he is good other questions yeah expand on that slowly if you get this zero function that doesn't actually correspond to any energy eigenvalue current little on zero Cranky's say any correct zero the function zero is an eigenfunction of every operator but it's a stupid eigenfunction of every operator in particular it has nothing to do with the states we're interested in we are interested in normalizable states right and that is an auto normalizable state you can't multiply by any finite coefficient and get one when you square integrate it okay yep one last question well you we need to add more words that so the question is does that mean that the that the only particle that could really have zero energy is some imaginary particle that doesn't exist first off imaginary particles may exist and we just haven't seen them I mean right okay so so I need to say two things about this so there's a technical complaint I need to make about your question which is a very fair question but I need to make it all the same and the second is a more physical answer so the technical complaint is what do you mean by zero energy do you ever measure an energy directly and you measure energy differences right so relative to what we have to decide relative to what so for example in the harmonic oscillator what we mean when we say that grad student energy is nonzero is if we draw the potential and we call the minimum of the potential is zero classically a zero then what we discover is that the energy of the quantum mechanical ground state is one-half H bar Omega right above zero so is there any state of the harmonic oscillator with energy zero no okay now if we have a free particle is there is there a configuration with energy zero wow that's an interesting question so what are the ground what are the eigenstates e to the ikx okay when the energy is zero so and the energy is because it's just P squared upon 2m which is H bar squared K squared upon 2m the energy is H bar squared K squared upon 2m for a free particle no potential and by zeroing the asymptotic energy u equals zero can you have a state with energy zero this one's a little subtle because if we take the energy zero what must K be zero okay great so what's the wave function constant is that normalizable not so much so can you build a wave packet with energy zero carica sorry let me not say that can you put a single particle in a state with energy zero no that would not seem to be possible because that would be non-normalizable state well you say we deal with these Exponential's all the time we know how to deal with that we don't use a single wave plane wave we use a wave packet with some width right so I can build a wave packet with you know some average width but will that average width ever have expectation value of K equals zero no because we'll always have contributions from K naught equals zero so that it's localized so that it spatially localized so can you build a normalizable state with energies here which is an eigenfunction of the energy theorem no not in this case either so there's the technical complaint that you need to talk about what you mean relative to what that was about your question and the second of can you ever have an energy eigenstate which is that the minimum of the potential and that's also zero that's also no you'll actually prove that on a later problem set okay so um with all that said we now have a mirror that's awesome 15 minutes for a 14 page lecture so can I do this fast no I'm kidding um I won't do that to you so I want to just instead of going through so this was not directly relevant for the exam and it's also um yeah this can come a little bit later so let me let me just do a couple let me show you a couple of quick things so the notes are posted online look at them I'll go over them again in the future what do I want to do so I want to introduce to you two ideas one is direct notation and this is harkening back to basics of vector spaces and the second is i want to tell you something about what the commutator means so first off let me ask you guys a question now I can use I have one more clicker question for you all right y'all ready everyone up with ya okay everyone everyone up with the clickers okay here is a question when you go ahead and start clicking now Sigma is the uncertainty sorry Sigma is young certainty this is awesome I swear the clicks are going in beat with the music okay so at the moment so let me give you three more seconds one two three okay this is awesome you guys are totally at chance you have even probability distribution across the three so this is good because we haven't actually introduced this idea yet in a you know four so let me quickly talk you through this okay so yeah we've it off so so let me quickly quickly talk you through this and this is important this is going to give you some intuition for what on what uncertainty means and it's also going to give you some intuition for what the commutator means okay so this is a little more experience a little more practice with operators and we'll pick up on the direct notation and everything I think next time because I just want to get through this physics so consider two operators a and B so a and B are my two operators they have hats he has a top hat so we have you've got to make this stuff a little more lighthearted so we have two operators a and B and I want to ask is it possible for there to be a function by little a little B which is simultaneously an eigenfunction of a and an eigenfunction of B so now we're just this is a pure math question given two operators a and B can you build a function which is simultaneously an eigenfunction of a and an eigenfunction of b I will call this Phi baby yo why not okay so Phi sub a B has this property a on Phi a B is equal to a Phi B why not and B on Phi a B is a little beyond Phi B you can't stop me I have now created this OP this object what from the existence of this state what can you deduce about the operators a and B and if you've already seen this before that's cheating so don't raise your hand but if you haven't seen this before just think through what what what does this tell you about the operators a and B great that's a nice guess I like that guess so so let's check okay so what would it mean for the commutator of a and B to be 0 so if so a B is some so this is equal to a B minus B a and what the commutator does is it takes two operators and it gives you a new operator called bracket a B sometimes it's useful to call it C for commutator so it gives you a new operator giving two operators you build a new operator and saying that this so good and suppose now that we have a common eigen function of a and B what does it tell you well let's take the commutator a B and let's take it and act on five sub a B on this common eigenstate so what is this equal to this is equal to a B minus B a 5e which I can write as a B by B minus B a 5e by linearity by addition really okay but be acting on Phi B gives me by hypothesis little B Phi V and then a acting on a constant times Phi B gives me a little a times that constant okay - now here a acting on Phi B gives me a little a Phi B and then B acting are constant times Phi B gives me a little B and now I can join these together this is equal to good a B little a B minus B a Phi B but little a and little B our numbers if you take seven times five and five times seven and you subtract them what do you get zero so in order for a and B to share a single eigenfunction phi a be what must be true of their commutator it must have a nonzero kernel exactly it must the commutator must annihilate that particular function that common eigenfunction okay does it tell you that it kills every eigenfunction no but it must at the very least annihilate the shared eigenfunction true consider two operators of the following form consider two operators who commutator a b is equal to the identity times a constant okay do these operators share any common eigenfunctions they can't because the commutator the identity doesn't annihilate any wave functions any functions nothing is 0 when acted upon by the identity that's the definition of the identity right the identity takes any function gives it that function back cool do a and B share any common eigenfunctions now let's think about what that means in terms of what single with that term but what that means in terms of observables observables are represented by operators what are the eigen function what is the meaning of the eigenfunctions of those operators it corresponds to the state with a definite value of that observable and the value is the corresponding eigen function I can value yeah so the eigen function of an operator of an observable operator is a possible state with a definite value of that operator if I tell you that I have a state which is an energy eigenfunction then that means it is a state with a definite value of the energy if I measure that under general exactly what I will get cool if these are two observables that a and B are two observables and their commutator is proportional to the identity is it possible that there is a state with a definite value of a and a definite value of B simultaneously no because I stay with the definite value of an a would be an eigenfunction of a the state with the definite value of B would be a eigenfunction of B and there are no common States no common eigenfunctions of a and B because the commutator never kills a state and it has no zeros what is the commutator of X and P commit this memory IH bar now when we write a H bar this is not really an opera that's a number what's the operator the identity are there any states which are simultaneously eigenfunctions of X the operator X intimate and eigenfunctions of P are there any states that have a definite position and a definite momentum simultaneously is that because we're ignorant are we ignorant yes okay good so it is not it is because the kinds of things that position and momentum are forbid the existence of a state with a definite value of x and with a definite value of P simultaneously there's veter here and we're there nor pose nor neither okay so this tells us something very lovely this tells us that if we're in a state with a definite value of X what must be true of our uncertainty in the value of P it can't be zero because if it were zero for uncertainty in the knowledge P were zero that would mean we're in a P I can say we would have a definite value of P so if Delta X is zero Delta P cannot be zero for sure now how big does it have to be could it be arbitrarily small so here's a commutation relation you will prove the following relation later on in the course but I want to tell you now because I want to give you some intuition for what the commutator is what it means what the physics of it is if I take two operators a and B with which have a commutator which is a constant times the identity then the uncertainty in any state a sasai of a times the uncertainty in a States I the same States I of B must be greater than or equal to one-half the absolute value of the expectation value of the commutator that's an amazing set of symbols of a with B okay square root I gotta take a squirt thank you so the easier way through these are file let's see a B let's just make sure I'm getting this right I'm commentator of a and B it's oh no no there's no square root sorry why are you messing with me expectation value of a and B Delta a delta P H bar um yes good okay so in particular this expectation value should be taken with the states I sorry late and I'm tired sorry and this should be taken in the states I okay so we compute the commutator we take the expectation value in our state we take the norm multiplied by 1/2 and this is the bound this is the claim so let's check this in the case of X and P and we'll derive this using just math this will come from just linear algebra so let's check this in the case of X in P and X and P what's the expectation so what's the expectation value in a state sigh of I h-bar times the operator one saw its IH bar IH bar great so what happens over here what do we get for Delta X into the states I times Delta P in the state's I whoops in the states I P this must be greater than or equal to 1/2 times the act of the absolute value of the expectation value of the commutator but the expectation value of the commutator is IH bar and the norm of that is just H bar this is the uncertainty relation so given some uncertainty in Delta X this tells us how much Delta P is now how does this right-hand side depend on the weight and sigh well it turns out it doesn't right it's explicitly independent of the particular wavefunction we're interested in for any wave function mm-hmm for any wave function whatsoever the uncertainty in X times the uncertainty in P must be greater than or equal to 1/2 H bar and this is a consequence of the commutation and more importantly the failure of X and P to commute because the ability to commute and get 0 is necessary for there to be common eigenstates now imagine in this case a and B are that a and B that in fact do share a common eigenstate so let's take compute the expectation value R the uncertainty of a in the state Phi so maybe by some baby Phi baby vise baby and what is this equal to well what's the commutator acting on the state Phi sub a B 0 so this is greater than or equal to 0 and in fact you can just check by going through the proof of this that is just equal to 0 so what's the uncertainty of a well we know it's in the state with definite value of a it's 0 uncertainty and B in the state what's the uncertainty 0 we know that it's in an eigenstate of B so 0 is indeed greater than or equal to 0 so it satisfies the uncertainty relation commuting is telling you about the possibility of the state having definite values of both operators simultaneously and this is going to turn out to be enormously valuable when we talk about angular momentum which is coming in a couple of weeks ok see you guys on Thursday here for the midterm you