Transcript
The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseware at ocw.mit.edu. So, today I want to talk with you about how it is that we can do research of a scientific kind for something as complex as human behavior. You know, as opposed to things that you measure out in space or test tubes or under microscopes. People are are are complex organisms, right? And and so to do research on them to understand human nature, how the mind works, how the brain supports it is a challenging story.
So, usual thing is an experiment. You have a group of participants and we'll talk about that. But, in the reading for today, and I know first first time we've done this, so you may not have read it, but if you have, that'd be great, is a kind of another thread of the kind of of way that people are studied, which is dramatic individual stories, case studies, single stories that are illustrative of something that we think are broader principles. And and a lot of our biggest discoveries, and we'll come to that later in the course, have been made on very unusual single individuals who turn out to have a lesson that's pretty broad, for for example, for the organization of the human brain.
So, in in the Oliver Sacks book, there's a story about Donald, and um what did Donald do that got him in big trouble? Yeah, he murdered his girlfriend while he was on PCP. He's in a psychiatric hospital. Um They try hypnosis to help him remember it. He says he doesn't remember it. Many of you may know that an astounding number of criminals under under interrogation tell you they don't remember anything about the episode involved, right? It's So people are suspicious at first for many reasons because these are easy things to say is I don't remember what happened and then you can't catch yourself in a lie or any complexity, right?
Because you don't remember what happened. And sometimes you don't remember and sometimes you do. But in this case they try hypnosis, that doesn't help. He's in there there for 4 years and then he knows conceptually that he murdered his girlfriend and he says I'm not fit for society. He knows it's a terrible thing he did, but it's kind of like an intellectual knowledge, right? It's not it's not a feeling, it's not a memory. And then he has he goes biking and something happens which is he gets hit by a car. And so so there's what appears to be a drug-induced amnesia of the original murderous episode.
He gets hit by a car, he has a severe head injury, he's in a coma for 2 weeks. He has left-sided weakness as he comes out of it which means the biggest injury was in the right side of his brain. Weakness and numbness and he has frontal lobe contusions. He has injury and bleeding around the frontal lobes, the cortex that sits in the front of the brain. But now a remarkable thing happens. It's as if two you know, two insults, two wrongs made a right. The first wrong being the PCP, the second wrong being the accident and now what happens? He remembers in vivid and florid detail the horror that he actually committed this murder.
It's as if two insults to the brain, one drug-induced, one a focal injury repressed the memory and then un-repressed the memory. And one of the first things they have to do is discover whether he really has this memory or he just thinks he has this memory. And how do they figure out to their satisfaction whether it's a really recovered memory or a fabrication of his mind. Right, that's really important. He remembers details of the murder that are not publicly available that were not in the information that was given to him. That's a really huge issue in these kinds of memories. So this is a really recovered memory, not a inadvertently fabricated memory.
Uh and they discover he has a deep seizure activity in his limbic structures, the parts of his brain that are involved in emotion are having a seizures. So she in epilepsy, neurons are firing for no good reason. Uh and that's part of his disorder. They give him medications to help with that. Uh but here's the question for you for a moment to think about it. And it's now such a common question because our society's moving that way that it's on many TV shows. I see it like every couple of weeks there's a Law & Order episode that has something like this, which is the more you know about the biology that underlies that really criminal terrible behavior, should that be a cause for understanding it or or not?
Okay, so in this case, he took the drugs, he killed a person, you think he's pretty responsible. Uh but how about somebody who killed somebody and it turns out in this such a case, a man with no history grown man with no history of criminal activity of any kind shoved his wife out of a high window to her death in the course of a standard argument. All right? Then they discover that he has a big tumor growing in the basal part of his frontal cortex. Now, is the man responsible for what he did? It's a really interesting question, right? Uh and the more we understand about the neuroscience of our brains, what makes us do things, what lets us control impulses, what makes us murderous.
There's a guy Kent Kiehl, University of Mexico, he's driving around in a big van with an MRI scanner and he goes from penitentiary to penitentiary and he images the brains of serial murderers, of psychopathic murderers, okay? And he's getting things that are pretty systematically different about their brains. And the question is, you know, what does that mean? Does that mean those people were prone to do it for reasons of their early environment or genes or some incident that happened. If that's the case, do you forgive them differently? Should we have a more different moral code or legal code as we discover the brain basis for some of these things?
Or is that irrelevant? What counts is the action. So, this is kind of thing you could think about, maybe discuss in your section some. The more we understand about the human brain, the more we'll understand about behaviors that we find terrible. And what does that mean about legal and moral decisions about how to punish those or think about those? So, that's coming in your lifetime. Because there's steady progress on this and understand how to think about that is a really big question. So, I'm going to talk with you today about research in psychology. And a funny thing about psychology, and I'll come back to this, is everybody is an amateur psychologist.
They have to be. If you deal with people, you're an amateur psychologist. Moreover, we live in a world with Oprah Winfrey and Dr. Phil, right? So, in case you're only an amateur one, you hear all kinds of stuff, newspaper, internet, magazines, everywhere you go, friends will tell you stuff about psychologists have found this or psychologists have found that, right? So, you have your own intuitions to deal with people in everyday life. Uh and um here's a kind of a sentence from Time magazine, you know, that you know, drives psychologists crazy if you take it seriously. So, here's a here's this literal sentence.
Almost half of children of divorces enter adulthood as worried, underachieving, self-deprecating, and sometimes angry young men and women. Okay. So, that sounds kind of like a psychological study of some kind, kind of, right? You know, somebody who wants to argue about the importance of divorce and breakdown of the family. This is the kind of thing. So, let's think about this for a moment. Almost half of children of divorce enter adulthood as worried. Are you guys worried about global warming? A little? Are you worried about peace in the Middle East and how that influences the Middle East and the US?
A little? Are you worried about an economy that may not have jobs waiting for you? A little? Okay. Who's not worried a little a little bit of the time? So, almost So, it doesn't even tell you what that half of children in the world, for example, are who uh come from families without divorce, right? Cuz that's the only relevant question. It's not are people worried about stuff, underachieving compared to what? How would you prove somebody's underachieving? Scientifically, okay? I mean, we most of you probably have had days where you've underachieved and days where you've achieved pretty well. But how would you measure and prove that?
Self-deprecating. Well, sometimes we think it's actually kind of nice if a person's modest, okay? What's the What's the difference between modest and self-deprecation? And I like this one. Sometimes angry young men and women, right? I mean, I mean, you know, I mean, it's Are you sometimes angry about something or another, okay? And if you are, does that tell us that society is breaking down and your parents did something bad that you're sometimes I mean, who as a human being is not sometimes angry? So, here's a kind of psychology-sounding sentence on a serious topic, which is, you know, what is divorce, consequences of divorces in families, and you know, should we be thinking about things that encourage uh uh uh marriages to stay stable and things like that.
Uh but there's really no information at all. Right? Uh uh so, from a from a researcher science perspective, so I'm going to talk about a little bit just reminding you what science is. We're a university, obviously, that is thinks about science and does science all the time. Uh remind you of what an experiment is, a very brief history of psychology experimentation, and then walk you through a few experiments that I find kind of interesting um and then some topics related to psychology. So, let me start with this. How do you know what is true? How do you know what is true? That you take to be true.
What is the answer? Everyone's looking all like, "How do I know? Please tell me." Okay. Uh well, when people try to analyze this, and you can think about it for your own self, uh one of them is authority. Parents, teachers, textbooks, scientists, professors and courses, we tell you this is the truth, right? And if you remember the truth correctly, you get an A. So, you know, authority is a huge source. I mean, right? It would be costly to go around and come up with your own idea about everything. 12 inches in a foot? I'm not taking that piece of information without sca- right? I mean, you'd have to You couldn't live your life without kind of believing a lot of stuff, but you know, you don't want to believe everything, right?
You just cuz you hear it. Repetition or tenacity. You hear something often enough and people tend to believe stuff. A priori, what's reasonably think things through just by thought. What's possible, rational, and so on. And you know, then maybe a fourth brand of knowledge too, something is scientific analysis, where we have hypotheses and we test them in some version of experiments or or at least correlations among data. Now, there's another view which is kind of that uh whatever we think makes something science is what the scientific community decides as a community is true, right? Roughly speaking, that is if the mainstay of faculty at places like MIT and Stanford and Harvard and so on and around the world at universities tell you this is, you know, how science works, you go, "Okay, that's how science works." And I remember some years ago there was a there was a a lot of excitement about a satirical article written by a scientist where he said, "Oh, this is all just societal authority.
The scientists tell you what's true just cuz they believe in it just like, you know, sports writer says the Celtics are the best." You don't really think that the sports writer knows scientifically the Celtics are the best, right? Okay. So, you know, so he wrote a paper saying that gravity is simply a consensus among scientists and a particular view they're foisting on society, okay? But none none of us would want to really go up there and jump out the window going, "Well, gravity is, you know, one person's opinion and then here's my opinion, right?" Okay. So, so but it's kind of interesting because, you know, for those of you who go to medical school, for example, you learn lots of procedures and so on that the medical community believes is true where where not much scientific evidence behind it, but they have to use it every day.
So, you know, you're used to hearing about the scientific method. It applies to psychology in many ways, just like it applies to chemistry, physics, or biology. Uh we have to test things that are falsifiable. We have to deal in probabilities of outcomes uh in terms of statistics in some sense. Uh the kinds of data we can have are descriptive or correlative or experimental. I'll talk about those in a moment. We are always trying to disprove the null hypothesis. The statistically, as you know, which we can't prove that something is true, but we can prove that it's not true. Uh and then finally, uh like all fields of science, uh the most exciting today's most exciting breakthroughs are tomorrow's uh things that have to be apologized for and rediscovered, right?
Okay? I mean, what makes something breaking science is not that it's known with certainty. What's known with certainty is what's in your textbook, kind of. Uh what makes something breaking science is it moves the field forward. So, what's the difference between the cutting edge and the bleeding edge is a very close call. Uh so, here's a cartoon that says uh it's he's constantly proving his experiments wrong, okay? And the guy's kind of glum looking over he's proving the null hypothesis to be correct. Uh now, that's sort of funny uh uh for scientists, uh but it's a uh sort of funny in the sense that no, we don't really go around going, "I hope, you know, with all my heart for this research project I've worked on for the last 5 years that it will prove the null hypothesis, right?
There's no difference between things I'm studying." Uh in fact, scientists, like all humans, have a agendas and hopes and and uh like everybody else. Uh so, they observe, hypothesize, experiment, assess data. It doesn't always go perfectly, right? Uh And the last thing I want to say is I'm going to emphasize today a scientific approach to the human mind and behavior, but of course, there's many other paths of knowledge for important things in our life, religion, philosophy, arts, and so on. There's many things that science cannot address, and I don't want to pretend that it does. You know, that's not a problem too much when you think about chemistry.
It's kind of an interesting problem when you think about psychology because when we think about happiness or values or things like that, those topics cut across psychology and things like religion, philosophy, and topics like that. So, what makes something an experiment is you have to have sort of two things conceptually, especially. The dependent variable, what you measure, the outcome, and the independent variable, what you vary. Once you have those things in an experiment, you're kind of an experiment uh in in a broad sense. So, in psychology, it took a long time. It wasn't till the 1800s that people had kind of an approach to doing experiments in psychology and figuring out, for example, how to use the simple measurement of time to measure how long a mental operation lasts in your mind.
So, that's pretty cool. If you were to come to a fifth grader and say, "How would you measure not a you know a a brick or a stone, but how long a thought takes?" Uh you'd say, "Well, that'd be pretty hard." But, it turns out it's not as hard uh in in a simple way. So, Wilhelm Wundt who big figure in psychology, first textbook in psychology, first laboratory in psychology, did the following test of mental chronometry, simply measuring how long it takes you to do things. So, he would wait he would show you a light and you'd simply press the button and that would take about 20 a fifth of a second.
And then he would say, "Instead, let's you do this. If the light turns on and it's red, uh you push one button and if it's green, you push another." So, his idea was the motor system to push the button is about the same. The time to observe the light is about the same, but the difference between these two is how long it takes to make a choice. How long it takes to make a choice. And that difference, when he subtracts them, took about a tenth of a second by that measurement. So, all of a sudden, you could start to measure in an objective sense uh how long a mental operation takes in your mind. Uh then psychology went a lot of different directions.
A famous one uh from Titchener, who worked with Wundt, uh developed the psychology department at Cornell, was introspection. Look inside yourself and think very carefully when you think about a topic, how do I think about it? That lost its way as a scientific method. The trouble is, you know, one person thinks one way and one person thinks another way, and you can't really settle it, right? So, it's a introspection about your thoughts is a private process. It's not a public measure that you can exchange among scientists, like time or measurements. But we still introspect a lot when we think about psychology, whether it feels right to us, what are the questions to ask.
It's sort of just being human. You can't help but introspect about psychology topics. In the US, there was a sort of a huge response to to introspection as being too loose too loosey-goosey. One famous name in this is John Watson. He said the mind is unobservable. So, we can only study behavior, things that people do. Actions they take, their mouth moves, their hand buttons presses, and then we identify what in the environment influences those behaviors. The principles of the mind should be similar between animals and humans, and that the only thing a responsible experimental scientist can do is relate environmental factors to actions.
And so, there's a stimulus, and you can control the stimulus as a scientist. There's a response, you measure the response, and that's your psychology experiment. And then the 1980s became the cognitive revolution. Partly, this path led to not after a while to not very interesting science. That was the biggest problem. And people said, "No, we can make inferences about the mind as it translates what it hears or sees into what a person does." So, ideas of representations or knowledge in the mind or in the brain later on, and how that translates what's out there and how you act upon it. So, um I'll remind you a couple more things and we'll get to specifics.
So, correlations are you can only get in an experiment, right? Where you have an independent variable. Sorry. Correlations you can look at all the time. Experiments only experiments allows us to infer causation. So let's let's pick an example that when I read it struck me as slightly relevant. So age of parent and risk for disease in a child. So you're most of you are young enough that you're not too worried about this yet and you have no reason to be but for those of us who are in my generation and some generations back many people are postponing childbirth. As they do their careers and complete different tasks and they're getting older and parents are getting older and older and they're only they only seem old they are old.
Okay. So It's true it's the case statistically that the older the the mother is the higher the risk of Down syndrome. So the statistics are for mothers age 20 to 24 it's very rare to have Down syndrome and the number goes up dramatically if the mother is age over age 42. So this is simply observation and measurement but it's something a lot of women giving birth in their 30s and 40s are thinking about and worrying about and so it's a thing on their mind. Up until relatively recently men said oh it's too bad for those women but we're no problem for us here. So you're the the movie star right who's 90 years old and marries a 20-year-old actress right?
You know that that kind of model that you see all the time in the news because it doesn't matter how old the guy is. Well it turns out you know it does matter and here's some data for that. So here's the probability of developing schizophrenia a disease that's only that's typically diagnosed in a person's late adolescence or 20s depending on the age of the father and you can see the father is less than 25 it's one out of 141. If the father is in his 50s it becomes one out of 50 a dramatic growth in the likelihood of an offspring child having schizophrenia depending on the age of the father. Okay so now there's a correlation between age and whether a child expresses schizophrenia.
So, let's guess about the possible causes of that. I can tell you it's unknown, but let's even begin to guess about it. Let me ask you to guess about it. Yeah. Yeah, bad sperm, right? Okay. In some for some reason in some way and sperm that leads more likely to be risk for schizophrenia. So, that's a good that's that's your first intuition and that may turn out to be right. Problematic, something problematic about the sperm from the male. Uh Here here's another one though and this is shows you, you know, um uh you know, the challenges with correlation research on something even so important as this, which is how about an alternative which is who marries later in life?
Okay, you know, you know, maybe the desirable men are plucked off the market on average in large statistics by age 30 or something. And a bunch of us and I'm a late marrier, you know, limp to find some woman around the world who will accept us, okay? And finally out of pity some woman says, "Okay, you drag yourself into your 50s and I'll I'll take you." You know, so right because it's not random probably. And this is we're averaging over many people, but it's not random probably who marries at 25 and given society and who marries at 50. It's not random. It could be big differences among okay? And how could we tell that difference?
Maybe it's nothing to do with the sperm. Maybe it's something to do with the something about the genes and environment that goes with marrying, you know, being a parent in your 50s versus being a parent in your 20s. Completely different explanations. Someday maybe we'll know, but we don't know now, all right? So, this is the limits of correlations and you know, could be both could be true, neither could be a third story all together. So, that was about me. My My becoming a parent late in life and marrying late in life. Let's talk about you, all right? So, let's talk about the level of stress you have and how empathetic you are.
On average, your college generation relative to ones 5 or 10 or 20 years ago. So, let's ask that question. Why would people want to know such a thing? Well, you might want to understand, you know, what what pressures are we putting young people under as they go through grade school and high school and college. You know, what's what's the world like? Is it pretty much the same? Is it pretty much changing? Uh you know, Now, how would we figure that out? How would we begin to measure that? It's a very simple question. Are you more stressed than people 10 years ago at MIT? On average across the country?
And are you more or less empathetic towards other people? How might one answer that kind of a question? Yeah. For the stress part, we know a little bit about hormones to the extent that we can measure hormone levels to see whether they're too stressed. That would be a very interesting path. It's a tough research path, but you're right. It's some If we had some biological signature of stress, that would be good one. But let's let's ask this question. Let's say I measured everybody in here and got your average stress hormone or something like that. Now, what's my answer about whether 10 years ago people were more or less stressed?
Yeah. You could look at suicide rates. You That's would be an outcome. Yeah, that would be a sadly an extreme outcome of of of stress of a kind. But there's a lot of things that go on. Okay, so so so we have to worry about two things. One thing we don't know One thing we know is Let me ask you another one. You You could compare your level of stress to people who are 10 years older than you or 20 years older than you. What do you think about that? No. Yeah. Uh uh yeah. Um it would actually be more accurate if you measured, you know, if you want to know for a college student specifically, you'd have to get a baseline and do self stress from somewhere like from your work.
If Yeah, because maybe people are 20 or maybe people who are 30 or 40 are more stressed for other reasons because they have more bills and mortgages to pay or or less stressed for other reasons or whatever, right? Maybe it's not about the generation you're in. Maybe it's about being a person with more responsibilities at 40, right? Okay. So, here's for some things you get some luck and um you have it in your hand. So, here's uh an emotional health questionnaire where students across the country for the last 25 years have been given the identical questionnaire. It's a questionnaire, it's not a biology measure, about their self-reported measure of stress.
Okay. And this was in the New York Times just a few weeks ago. It's you guys, on average across the country, US college students are at all-time high level of self-reported stress. All right. Uh sorry about that. Yeah, yeah. So, so so now it's not the perfect measurement in every way, but it's the same questionnaire to college students year in year out. By self-report, people say, "I feel more stressed." You can also see that there's a difference uh between men and women. Women on average report on average report feeling more stressed. Um and it may be relevant that on average, for example, there's a higher rate of depression among women than men.
There's a much higher rate of autism among men than women. Uh so, it's not it's not a it's it's you know, being one sex or the other is not a gift certificate, you right, of avoiding mental health challenges. But uh you know, so you're more stressed than ever, okay? Good luck. We're We'll try to do the best we can in this course to not worry that way worse. But you know, it's something to think about. I I you know, I got a call the other day from somebody said there's a lot of curiosity about whether the shift from book learning and book reading to internet worlds and Twitter and Facebook worlds are fundamentally changing how people think.
And that sounds kind of possible, okay? And there are people who give amazingly entertaining lectures about these things. Uh scientifically, it's unbelievably hard to imagine how we would ever answer that. So, when I get occasional phone call like, you know, what What do neuroscientists know about that? What could they know about it? You know, is that an even an answerable question? If I take you now and say, well, you've probably done more Facebook than a 50-year-old and compare you to a 50-year-old on some other thing, is that going to answer the question of how you think about ideas given the world you live in versus the world a 50-year-old lived in?
No. So, there's just a lot of huge deep things about changes in the world that we can't even begin to get at. Sometimes we get lucky and people have been giving some particular measures for some time. Empathy uh by self-report. And now, you if this you don't I wouldn't fill it out now, but you can take a look just to get a feeling at your at your leisure. This is the questionnaire they used for self-reported empathy. It's self-report. Uh 40% lower today than 20 years ago. You know, so on average, you guys literally in college on average by these measures are more stressed and less empathetic towards others, okay?
And those Sorry. Okay. So, and those things This is not an individual. This is an average, right? So, to to the levels that society operates, things are going on and moving for some reason. Um By the way, I can tell you that when I'm stressed, I have less room to be empathetic, okay? So, maybe these things are related. If you're feeling stressed, your first thought is not, how can I help others? But like, how can I just get through the day? Okay? So, uh these these these things might be related. So, let's turn a little bit to experimentation. Um So, uh and some of the challenges of relating psychology to real-world policies that are meant to make the world better or safer in some way.
So, there's a famous uh broken window theory from the political scientist James Wilson and criminologist George Kelling. And their idea was this, that especially in neighborhoods that are not immaculately kept, or to say it the other way, where there's a lot of damage around you, things like broken windows is the phrase they used, that this promotes in people who live in that community or work around that community a sense that, you know, the the rules don't count. Anybody can do anything. And then it fosters the growth of petty crimes. And once you do a petty crime, you're more vulnerable or willing to do a major crime.
A slippery slope, okay? Um and in fact, uh uh there Rudy Giuliani and Commissioner Bill Bratton employed this. They asked the police to write lots of tickets and make lots of sort of minor arrests for things where people weren't upkeeping the environment or they were they were littering or things like that. And this is a huge debate cuz in a police department, you can only do so much. So, if they put if they have a person working on jaywalking and littering, that's a person not working on, you know, major crime rings, okay? So, they make it to try to make a choice where they think they can make communities safer in the most effective way.
And the crimes went way down in New York. In most cities now, you don't hear crime discussed as a big topic nationally. In some local areas, like in Boston, some specific areas, you do. You know, I I I don't really think in the State of the Union there was a word about crime that I can remember a week ago, okay? It's not a big national topic. In some local places, it is a big topic, but not nationally. So, you don't know some years ago when people said New York City was a horrible place to go cuz there was so much crime that you'd walk out from your airplane and get mugged before you made it to your taxi.
Now, it it was, you know, it was like the whole country was saying big cities were just crime, you know, crime-ridden and dangerous. They do this policy, things get better, right? So, everyone says, "Hmm, that sounds pretty good." But, of course, it's not an experiment, it's a real-life policy. And then people had these kind of, you know, incredibly clever reinterpretations of why crime went down. So, the the the most, you know, the most of the wildest one was was in Freakonomics, was discussed in the uh which said, "Well, abortion was legalized in 1973. That gave women who didn't have access to legal abortions uh the ability to uh have them.
That the children in on average in these communities that had at least access to safe and legal abortions would be poor, unstable, addicted addiction-ridden communities statistically." Uh and that so that if you imagine the reduced abortion rate in poor areas could, when you count out the number of of of possible criminals in those areas, uh account for the reduction in crime all by itself. A completely different interpretation that has nothing to do with the policy. It just said, "We're going to have a demographic shift which will have a weird, unexpected consequence of lowering the crime rate because it's the finding that uh young men in particular are most likely to engage in violent criminal activity.
It's not a all rule, but a statistical average." Or uh there was a big crack epidemic that crack epidemic that reduced or lots of states put in laws that put people into jail for much higher, longer periods, much more severe penalties uh with new drug laws. So, it's very hard to know if the policy that was initiated really worked or whether it completely other things were happening uh that moved the crime rates. Uh and here's some very, you know, sort of perverse or or or or or other explanations. So, that left the question is, is Broken Windows even a good idea? Just because, you know, a Harvard, and we know Harvard is always right, but just because a Harvard psychologist says pretty interestingly, that sounds right to me, is that even a right idea?
Okay. So, let's take a step back. Can we test that experimentally? So, here's the experiment. Um And the idea is again that when people observe that others violate a social norm or legitimate rule, are they more likely to violate? If you see people around you breaking rules, are you more likely to do it? Uh And you could say, "It seems like it is, but let's let's let's do the science." So, here's an independent measure. I'll show you the environment. And the dependent measure is the number of people who perform a violation. Now, you can't go getting people murdering each other and stuff for an experiment, but you can do this.
And this is You can have two conditions. So, in the top condition, do you ever go back to your car or bike? Usually it's cars, I think. And they put leaflets in your car. And now, what are you going to do? You're running away. They're leaving a leaflet on your windshield wiper. Uh so, they they put it out and they either had a wall like this, which was clean. There's a sign that says no graffiti. And they put on those white pieces of paper onto the bikes. Or they put a lot of graffiti on the wall. Okay? And people came out from their classes. They went in their classes. They They parked their bike.
They ran into class. They came out and they got all these white leaflets. And what they did is watched. And they said, "How many people put the leaflet away? And how many people crumpled it up and threw it right on the ground? Okay? So, you We don't know what they're going to do with the leaflets. If they put it away, but we could hope they're going to throw it out. One thing we know for sure, if you crumple it up and throw it on the ground, it's littering and and not a good social norm. And sure enough, uh a third of the people littered uh if the wall had no graffiti, but it more than doubled if the wall had graffiti.
So, that's a small thing. That's not a broken-down complicated neighborhood. But just at that moment as you roar out of class, you get that piece of paper on your bike, and you see like, "Wow, this is a pretty crummy place. People are breaking the rules all the time." Twice as likely to throw a piece of paper on the ground. So, that shows that people very easily are influenced by very mild perceptions of whether people are following rules or not. And will be their better selves or their worse selves depending on that sense of, you know, are all rules on or are all rules off? And it's a a good bet they're not thinking about it, right?
They're not thinking they're sitting there, "Okay, here's a you know, here's littering, you know, not as bad as killing somebody or here's litter. Here's the wall where there's 30% graffiti." I mean, nobody does that. They have an emotion quick response, but their their their environment makes a difference in that regard. So, an important thing about um um uh studies are this. So, let me tell you about this one. Here's a study that took at a drug that was supposed to lower mortality from coronary artery disease. So, those who took the drug, 80% or more cuz people follow whether you take the drug.
If you don't take the drug, of course, the drug won't work. I had a 15% mortality rate within 5 years. Those who took the drug less than 80% had a 25% mortality. So, you'd say, "Well, 10% better chance of living uh for 5 years. That's worth it, right?" Um the nice thing is they had a placebo and there was no difference whatsoever between those who took the active drug and those who took the placebo. The differences between was those who followed the instructions to take the pill and those who didn't. So, what does that mean? How do you interpret that? It's not the drug. Yeah. If you the stress of not following the directions means it's not working for you.
It It could be that. It could be the stress. Uh it could be that. It But let me make a guess. There's no scientific answer to this. People who tend not to follow instructions, are they mostly stressed by not following instructions? No. Mostly the intuition is they're blowing it off. They're like, "Yeah, that's the instructions, but I got things to do and places to go, right?" Uh but you could be right. Um So, anyway, the idea is what what you pick up it are people who try to take care of themselves. They have a They have a health condition and the people who are following the pill instruction are probably also doing the best they can in terms of exercise, diet, all the things they could do to maximize their health, right?
Okay? And they're taking their placebo or they're taking the drug. They don't know, right? But they're doing everything they can. And the people who are off stuff, they're the ones who are doing all the things that aren't healthy, including not even taking your pills. I mean, if you don't even take your pills, right? I mean, exercises work, diet is work, popping a pill that's been handed to you uh uh that you're told might help you is is probably not that much work. So, you know, it's it's it's what's called self-selection bias, that you stand out if you tend to take care of yourself or not. Um Okay.
So, when we run experiments at universities uh uh that involve people, a huge issue for us is the idea is this, that we randomly recruit people, and we'll come back to this in a moment. Then we randomly assign them to one condition or another, for example, the placebo condition or the drug condition. We randomly assign them to the messy wall or the clean wall. We discover something uh and then we try to generalize it as far as we can to people as a whole. We discovered something fundamental about how humans work. Generalizable principles of human mind and behavior. So, what really happens in the world?
And, you know, it's always a year between sort of the best possible world and the world we actually live in. Um so, is it really Who really Is it really random who participates in research studies that you uh in psychology departments where a lot of the research gets done? Is it really random? No. Okay. Uh So, who volunteers? Have any of you volunteered to be a subject in an experiment anywhere? Yeah. Yeah, okay. So, but it's not random, you know, it's some people who they they they either need to make a few bucks or they're very curious about psychology or they have a friend who's in psychology or, you know, it's not random.
And in fact, population-wide, people have just said that psychology could be described as weird research for the following reason, that the vast majority of the findings you'll read about everywhere, including in your textbook, but everywhere, are from nations that are Westernized, educated, industrialized, and relatively rich uh democracies. Okay? The vast majority are between 17 and 25. They're undergraduates or graduate students who participate in research. Uh it's been estimated if you're a US college student, you're 4,000 times more likely to show up in a scientifically reported experiment than if you're a person anywhere else on the planet, okay?
A 4,000 times. Because why? Because it's changing a little bit, but for many, many years, you know, the huge amount of research happened in the US at universities. Pretty much at better universities, pretty much at highly selected students. All right? So, that's and then we never publish that. We never say MIT students did the following things. People say, "Yeah, the MIT students, you know, cuz then we're going to get a different report from Stanford or from UMass or from Michigan or Texas." We say, "No, humans did an experiment and humans are like this, okay?" So, uh and that could make us, you know, it's just something to think about as you see studies and stuff like that.
And people are more and more sensitized to that as more and more of the world gets somewhat the industrializes, uh there's more and more research around the world, but still the vast majority of findings are you guys, okay? Um Now, that's just to start with who's in the subject pool or the participant pool. How normal are you when you do an experiment? And I would say, "Are you like yourself or are you doing weird stuff?" And people use this idea that you're really weird when you do an experiment in another sense, cuz you're like you don't know what's going on, you're following instructions, you know?
So, they do experiments to show how ridiculously people behave when they're doing an experiment like they would never do it. So, they they ask them to fill come in and they say, "Would you fill out 200 sheets of paper filled with random digits, add them pairwise, and just I'll come back in a few hours?" Now, if a friend asks you to do that, add random digits for a couple hours, you would say, like, "Uh no, thank you. I've got about 8 million better things to do than that, right?" I could multiply random digits to start with or So, uh but people will do it for hours because they're in this weird like I'm in this, you know, I got that's the instruction and that's what my mission is.
Or even more ridiculously, they pick up a card after each page, they've added all these numbers, you know, for no good reason, and the instruction tells them, "When you've done the page, tear the page up into 32 pieces." And here's the next page. Okay, the next page. It's obviously fruitless and pointless, ridiculously so, but because you're in an experiment and somebody told you to do that, right? You just keep barreling forward. So, you know, how much are we are who we are when we do experiments versus people following weird instructions? And we'll come back to that in some serious context. That's the subjects.
How about experimenters? Experimenters are never objective. We try to be as scientists as objective as we can. We're never, you know, we believe certain hypotheses, we have certain goals. We recognize results that would be super exciting. We recognize results that would be boring. Okay. We're we're humans, too. We want to do stuff that matters. We want to do stuff that people reward us for. I mean, it's just human. So, here's a here's a lowest case example of how once you're an experimenter, you produce your own results. And believe me, it's much more when your result matters for things like your your career advancement or your your status in the field.
So, students were told that rats were either maze bright or maze dull. They were told that these rats were bred to be smart learners or not so smart. The rats were all just random rats, okay? It's a fake story to undergraduates. Uh then they had them on a test on a maze, and they said, "In for your laboratory exercise, write down how quickly the the rat runs the maze, okay?" And amazingly, the the the smart rats did way better than the dull rats. Okay? Now, these are not students trying to become famous or have a career. They're handing in an assignment, okay? Uh and how did that happen? Well, they went back, and it wasn't that anybody faked it or anything like that, but when they looked at films or discuss stuff with kids uh students in the course, every little thing that the students did uh that moved the data in little tiny tiny ways always favored finding the maze bright rats being brilliant maze runners.
So, for example, you know, they would put the rat If you've ever run a rat in a maze Does anybody run a rat in a maze? Yeah, is it easy? If you If you pick them up and put them in the maze, that's how they don't more automated now. Is it physically easy? Are rats like, "Please, I'm show me the starting line. I'm ready to go." No, what are they like? Help me out here if you guys have done this. Are they kind of Are they kind of really at And they don't like to be handled that much, really. No, even ones in there and they're like they're just fighting and these are undergraduates who have hardly ever touched a rat.
Okay, they're like, "Please, you know, don't attack me or something." So, they're they're holding it up like that and the rat's fighting back and because it's really uncomfortable, the rat's really unhappy and the student's like, "Really, you know, it's a you know, so what happens is and and then they plunk the rat down and they go, "Oh my gosh, it's facing the wrong direction." And it's a smart one. Wait, let's start start stop the clock. Let's get him, you know, but if it's a dull one facing the wrong direction, it's okay, it's a dull one. Let the maze run. So, lots of little things. Are you sure you wrote this down?
Was it 12 seconds or 11? I guess it was 11. Oh, because it's a smart one. Okay. So, completely innocently, completely innocently as far as we understand, they made the result to match up with what the expectation was. And it's not just that and if you know this example, you know, cognitive psychologists have studied a phenomenon like this. So, try this at your desk. Each card has a letter on one side and a number on the other side. Your job is to figure out what's the smallest number of cards you have to pick up to discover if this rule is right. If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other side.
So, think about this for a moment. If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has to have an even number on the other side. What's the smallest number of cards you can pick up to test that hypothesis? So, here's what's people have found. The correct answer is E and 7. Uh and about 10% of people on average come up with that. Many, many more people see pick E alone or E and 6. Why? Well, everybody gets that you have to look at E because it's an even number, right? So, you flip E over and if that one turns out to have it's a vowel, if it has a odd number that the rule the hypothesis is wrong, right?
That's Everybody gets E should check E. Uh pretty much everybody gets that uh J is irrelevant cuz it's a consonant. Okay. Now comes the interesting 6 and 7. Uh because it's because of the sentence is talking about a vowel and an even number, sometimes people feel like I got to check the even number. Right? But it doesn't say anything about even numbers couldn't go with con- consonants. It doesn't even It doesn't tell you anything. That's not a That's not part of the hypothesis. So, you don't you don't But you But if you flipped over number seven and you discovered a vowel, you'd violate the rule.
So, what happens is they're tempted to go for things that feel like they confirm the question. And it feels like E confirms it, and it feels like 6 confirms it. Right? And it's it's what's called confirmatory bias, that when you look at stuff, if you see what you think confirms it, uh then you tend to go for that, even when there's evidence in front of you that could contradict your expectation. Okay. So, now I'm going to give you a practical day uh uh a practical suggestion for how to win somebody over if you have a brewing romantic interest in that person, all right? All right. So, finally we get practical, right?
Everything was like I don't know if you go I'm not running rats, you know, I'm not taking uh all right all right uh and I think it's very interesting cuz I cuz I cuz I think, you know, when we think about how people make decisions in their lives, we tend to think intuitively about big decisions. You know, like what's my career going to be, uh where do I go to college? We think those are the big decisions, but a huge amount of life is little decisions. Moment-to-moment, if somebody asks you for something, do you say yes or no? Somebody walks up to you at party, do they they they want to talk with you?
Do you feel like talking or not feel like talking? You know, maybe you talk with them and it's a lifetime friend or romantic partner or whatever. So, little I think we make constantly little decisions that turn out to have big effects in our lives. So, here's some evidence about things like that uh that that influence that. And this is uh work done at Yale. So, we describe people as warm or we can define them as cold or aloof, right? And we could think those words are kind of arbitrary. And most of us, if you met somebody at a party, would you rather hang out with somebody who's warm or cold? Warm.
Okay, okay. All right. Just Just checking that we're Okay. Uh now, sometimes um uh uh there's an idea of embodied cognition, and here's what it is. We can't really know uh how warm or cold that person is or even that's even an an abstract idea, but we know we're comfortable when it's we're kind of warm, and we know we're not comfortable physically inside us when we're kind of cold. So, there's an idea that when we think about other people's feelings, other people's thoughts, or abstract things in the world, we base them on physical experiences that we have inside. Okay? There is a more direct link between what we know inside us, and we use that to interpret the world out there.
Embodied cognition. Really, your body is the vehicle for understanding things out there. So, here's Here's the experiment. It's really clever. Um there's two temperature conditions. So, what happens is you go into a building, and the uh examiner, an undergraduate usually or graduate student, meets the subject in the lobby, and she's carrying or he's carrying a cup of coffee. Sometimes it's hot coffee, sometimes it's cold coffee. Um a clipboard, two textbooks. Okay? So, you can imagine it's a setup, right? Person's walking there juggling with the coffee, the textbook or all the clipboard or And he says, "On the elevator," he says, "Could you just hold my cup while I write down your name on my list of subjects in the experiment?" Okay, it's very innocent, right?
Uh on the elevator, and so you hold the cup of coffee, which half the people get a hot cup, half the people get a cold cup. Then you read a description of a person. It's just a paragraph, and you have to rate whether you find the person described as warm or cold. And if you had the warm cup of coffee, you're more likely to describe that person as a warm kind of a person. Okay? Now, these subjects have no idea. They held a cup of coffee. They probably didn't even think whether it was warm or cold. But something in their body that got warmed up to the least degree possible, right? That thought is still in their head.
So, when they read the description, they go, "Oh, this seems like a warm person." Or if it was a cold cup of coffee, uh they say, "Oh, this seems like a cold aloof kind of person as far as I can tell." All right? That little bit of difference. So, here's the lesson just so you got it. If you want to take somebody uh because you have a possible uh friendship or romantic interest in that person, are you better off going out for a warm cup of coffee or giving them a cold glass of beer? For that first impression, scientific research shows it's a warm something warm uh will work. Uh It's not that powerful.
You're not going to be able to control the world, okay? Uh uh uh But, you know what what it says is when we're in ambiguous situations, ambiguous situations, we first meet somebody, we don't really know them. Little things can start us off on one path or can start us off on another path. Surprisingly little things. Um Now, then they have to worry about a confound. Can you imagine a confound here? Think of the rats. Who knows if the cup is cold or hot besides the person holding it? The examiner, right? Okay? Now, maybe the examiner doesn't try to do this, but maybe the examiner, no matter what, says, "Oh, we're in the warm condition and I'm smiling and this is going to be nice.
I'm helping this person feel good, you know?" And here's the aloof condition and I'm giving them the and we're all going to be miserable, you know? And the examiner knows it because they know if they have a hot or cold cup of coffee. So, maybe the person's not vibing to the coffee. They're vibing to the expression or feeling or sentiment of the examiner, right? Who who understands what's going on. So, they do one more experiment where they give Have you seen these hot and icy therapeutic packs that you can make hot or cold? Okay. Now, somebody else makes it hot or cold. The experimenter has no idea of it was hot or cold.
So, it's what we call double blind. The person doesn't know it's relevant, the experimenter. Uh they rate the pad and now this is this moves a little bit. They either get uh after this thing is over, they're told it's a product evaluation of the pad, but they either got a hot pad or a cold pad. And they could either choose to uh one of two rewards, a Snapple beverage or a dollar gift certificate, whichever you like better. Okay, you had one two little things you could do. But, here's the big decision. Do you get it for yourself or we can send it for you to a friend. We can send them the Snapple or the certificate.
If the people got a cold pad, 75% of the time they say, "Please give it to me right now. I'll take it." If they had a warm pad, uh 46% of the you know, the majority of the time they actually send it to their friend. That pad difference moved, you know, quite substantially the likelihood that you take it for yourself or you give it away. Quite substantially, right? If you're a charity trying to get people to donate or you want to get help from somebody, a 75 you know, 25% success rate is a lot worse than a 54% rate, right? It's a doubling. A doubling of whether you keep it for yourself or you're generous to your friend.
Just that cup of coffee. Or it's just that that therapeutic pad. Uh I'm going to do two more and then go to the beer. How about money? When you think about money, I don't mean traumatic things about money. Just a little bit about money. How does it influence how you relate to other people? Okay, here's the experiment. Uh the idea is that money on average, when you just think a little bit about it and I'll show you how ridiculously little they think about it. Uh uh they think that their hypothesis that money makes you think about self-reliance. You earn your money, you have your bank account, you know, uh uh compared to situations where you're not thinking about money.
So, here's here's what they did. They had people come in in three conditions. They either and they had to unscramble sentences. You have no idea what's going on, right? You got a sentence like cold it desk outside is, which you would make into a good sentence. Or high a salary desk paying. Okay, so you just make this you scramble these words around, but the money condition has a word like salary in it. Or you get the neutral sentences that have no money reference and you see Monopoly money in the corner of the room. Okay, so we're not talking like people just send you your tuition bill, okay, or whatever or they or you just found out, you know, that your your your there's something terrible happened financially or you won the lottery.
It's Monopoly money, okay? It's just like the idea of money in the or okay. Uh And then they give you a task to do and the experimenter as he or she leaves the room they say, "It's a pretty hard task. You may want some help. So, just come and get me. I'm glad to help you. Not a problem." So, what happens? Here's the probability of getting help uh and it's incredibly more for the control groups that got that did the sentences without money and way less not only for the people who unscrambled the sentence with the word salary, but also way less if they saw Monopoly money in the corner. The mere idea of money, not money given to you, not financial trauma or financial gain, the mere idea of money makes you less willing to get up and get help.
So, the positive it makes you more self-reliant. The negative is people were less willing to help somebody. So, now the end is the examiner comes in and says, "You know, I'm an undergraduate like you. I've got huge pressure to get this paper in. Can you help me code Can you help me score up a few sheets, okay?" Uh people were twice as much willing to help if they just did the neutral things than if they unscrambled the money sentences or saw the Monopoly money in the corner of the room. Cuz just that thought about money goes like, "Man, okay, self-reliance. We're all in it for ourselves, okay?
You know, I've got my money, you've got your money, you know, good luck." You know, we're all we're all we're all you know, we're okay? Self-reliance can be a good thing, but it doesn't necessarily go with helping people very much also. Yeah. On the other rotation, do you feel that like because of the Monopoly money and do you feel suspicious of why the money is even there or not? and that's why we're not going to help. It could Yeah, the Monopoly money I I I agree with you. Maybe that's why they also had the one where you just get the scrambled sentences. Okay. I agree with you. These are all you know, you could think there's many many ways to think about this.
Um okay, the last example of this kind I want to show you is dating behavior. All right. Uh and the way again an experiment can can challenge various ideas. So, uh and this is specifically about dating between men and women. And the story uh to the extent it's been studied would be a little bit different if you're dating uh within a sex. So, for dating between men and women, who is more selective in their dating choices do you think? Who's more willing to date widely or a lot or less, you know, What's your thought? If you have to generalize about men and women on average in your No, okay. Thank you.
Okay. So, uh and and and evolutionary psychologist and I love evolutionary psychology, but it drives me crazy, too. Okay. Evolutionary psychologist will go, "Well, because, you know, by evolutionary theory, men have to go and make as many offspring as they can to keep their genes going. Women have to be more selective. It takes 9 months to bear a baby. It takes 9 seconds uh to do the male part, right?" Okay. Uh estimated uh Okay. So, uh So, you know, so this might or might not be true. It's kind of fun. We all laugh about it. All of it's fine. It's kind of amusing to sort of think about, you know, if we So, uh but uh how would we actually know if this is vaguely true on average?
How would we actually know if men for dating behavior are more How would we even on Is that true? Is that Is that a, you know, bad myth that bad rap or whatever? Yeah. Dating websites? Yeah, thank you very much. So, there's an entire uh research enterprise out there now that uses online dating sites, which of course it's only in the last 20 years or something, you know, that they've existed, I think. So, uh it wasn't before. And the other one that's been a a treasure trove of data is speed dating environments, okay? Where you can observe things and measure things. And those studies have shown, for example, that online dating, on average, men are 1 and 1/2 times more likely to send email offerings, you know, dates to a woman than the other way around, compared to women.
And in speed dating, too, um uh men are more likely to indicate they would be happy to date a person they met uh than women. So, there's objective evidence that this is true on average in the society at this time. Um And so, everybody goes, "Oh, yeah, this shows the evolutionary psychology." Evolutionary psychology is actually crazy, cuz on the one hand, it's certainly the case that our minds and brains evolved through evolution, okay? So, there's something about the history we went through as a species that matters for who we are now. That's got to be the case. On the other hand, it was a different world before internet dating and speed dating, right?
I mean, it's hard to know how those things line up exactly. So, here's the fun thing. It turns out that on average in speed dating, uh a typical speed dating event will have like 4 minutes, right? So, you typically have women sitting at desks. Is it almost always they set it up that way. And the men are sitting in chairs in front of the desk, and they meet and they talk for 4 minutes. The bell rings, the men jump up, and they shift over one station, right? And then what happens is, for each time you meet a person, you fill out a card that says yes or no, I'd be willing to have a date with the person.
And if you have two yeses from the man and the woman, uh the speed dating organizer exchanges the information so they can make direct contact. Does that Does that sound okay? All right. And men make more yes responses, and it turns out this doesn't have to be this way, but almost from my reading, that almost every speed dating thing has the men rotating around. Okay? And the women sitting there waiting for the men to rotate around. So, let's just ask this question, what happens if the women rotate? Which almost never happens, but they did this experimentally. They said, "For half of the speed dating sessions, the men will be sitting at the table, and the women will stand up and move a chair over every 4 minutes.
Bell rings, so the women are moving and rotating. And here's the here's the results. Uh basically, what's showing on the left are when the men rotate, the standard condition. Uh the first one is romantic desire. Men feel more romantic desire on average for the partner they sit with. They feel that more chemistry is happening with the person they sit with. And the on the bottom left corner, uh they also um are more likely to to give a yes response, I would like a date with this person. Okay? But reverse the roles, have the women rotating, and look at these bars. There's no difference at all. You completely wipe out the male-female difference in self-reported romantic desire, per person self-reported uh chemistry they think is happening, and the yes-no responses that I would have a date with.
You completely eliminate it when the women are rotating. It's flat even. So, what what what do you That's the That's the result. What do you What does it suggest? What happened to the evolutionary psychology? It disappeared just by having the women rotate around the room. It suggests, and we don't know this with certainty, but there are people who are following this up who are interested in this. It suggests that there's something about getting up and approaching that person, your body going, "Here I come." Okay? I'm I'm not sitting in my chair, hanging out, you know, it's like we're you know, here I come.
That makes a person energized, feel more romantic, feel more chemistry is happening, and more likely to ask on a date. And it doesn't matter whether you're a man or a woman at all. Okay? It's the getting up and that physical approach, just you're more invested, you're more out there. Who knows what it is. Completely eliminates what everybody had said is an ancient, inevitable evolutionary difference between men and women. And this isn't to say there might not be some of those streaks in us, who knows? But speed dating is not showing that, okay? All you got to do is have the women rotate and you completely eliminate what's thought to be a some hardwired biological difference on this dimension.
Now, talking about that, when we do experiments like this that look at sort of fun fun things like dating around a uh thing or age difference between a 5-year-old and a 20-year-old or 20-year-old and 80-year-old, cultures, there's lots of experiments that compare say Western cultures versus uh uh Eastern Asian cultures, we'll talk about that later in the course in terms of behaviors, genes, whether you have one gene or another. All those things um are those independent variables? No. We can't assign you randomly to be a man or a woman, young or old, to come from the United States or Japan or China, or to have this gene or that gene.
It's not that we couldn't do stuff. You know, in some monstrous world, but but not ethically and it's never going to happen, right? So, uh so whenever you have science that talks about differences between men and women or young and old or cultures or genes, it's not really a completely independent manipulation. We can't assign you randomly. And so it means everything in the world about what it means to be a man or a woman, a 20-year-old or an 80-year-old, come from this continent or that continent, have this gene or that gene. Those are not things we can freely manipulate and you have to be extra cautious in interpreting those kinds of studies because we can't randomly assign you to condition.
We just can't. Okay, and we I didn't talk about um the fact that we up until this moment we made every conclusion a complete generality about human nature, and people are different one from the other, individual differences, we'll talk about that later in the course, too. So, for the last couple of minutes I want to talk about this. Folk psychology, you know, everybody has ideas about psychology. So, if you have this piece of paper, if you would zoom through it, ideas about people in psychology, and just where there is some scientific evidence If you just zoom down and mark yes or no. On average do opposites attract?
On average does familiarity breed contempt? On average more people present an emergency are you are you more likely to get some help? On average are there such things as visual learners and verbal learners and if they got the right kind of instruction that would help them in school? Is hypnosis baloney? Does subliminal advertising work? You know when things are presented so you don't see them below conscious does it help you buy something? Does playing Mozart to an infant boost their intelligent Mozart effect? Is old age on average associated with dissatisfaction? If you're unsure of your answer when taking a test I'm going to tell you the the science about this.
It's best to stick with your first hunch. Practically every website tells you that. Have you heard that many times? Okay, I'm going to tell you what the actual evidence is about that and how they get that in a moment. Ulcers are caused primarily by stress. A positive attitude can stave off cancer. Raising children similarly leads to similarities in their adult personalities, you know, um Low self-esteem is a major cause of psychological problems. People's responses on the inkblot tests tell us a lot about their personalities. Interviews help identify those most likely to succeed in medical school.
Okay. I'll give you a minute. Okay. A bunch of these will come back to the course. The answer for all these is this and there's evidence to it all. So let me let me tell you about four of them for for 10 minutes, okay? One of the ones you might want to know most about is the changing your initial hunch answer. Okay, how do you know that? So the people have gone back over test scores and look where people crossed out an answer or erased an answer. That's the best source of evidence they have in large samples and people are twice as likely to give a better the correct answer than to move to a wrong answer.
That's the empirical evidence, okay? So so it's a fantastically interesting disconnect uh that you see so many places and teachers advise you go with your first hunch when you're unsure. The empirical evidence is you're much more likely to be correct when you go with your best final answer, okay? All right. I mean, of course, you're get you're not sure, so you're going to miss a fair bit, but you're twice as likely to come out with the correct answer when you go with your best possible answer. Uh so, that people who crossed out their answers or erased their answers, they were twice as likely to move to a good answer than leave behind a good answer.
Yeah. Yeah, that's an excellent question. We don't know. They could have gone like five times back and forth. We're assumption has been on average uh that that, you know, people will go once back and forth, but you're right. But But ask yourself the other question, too. What's the evidence ever that going with your hunches, and nobody's been able to show that, okay? So, where there's evidence is all in favor of best answer, and nobody's shown evidence that hunch is the best way to go empirically. That doesn't mean that sometimes it doesn't happen, but on average, that's the way that it goes. But your question your point is excellent.
Okay. So, I How about Rorschach test? Every psychology program, clinical psychologist in the country is required to learn how to administer and evaluate a Rorschach. You know this. So, this obviously shows obviously it shows some sort of horrible sex act between animals and No, that No, it's a Yeah. Yeah, you you know these kinds of tests you're supposed to read it and then examiner listens to you and they figure out something, right? Okay. You know, there's been about 10,000 publications about this. There's no evidence that there's anything uh predictive or correct about this test. None, zero, none, okay?
People argue it, people give it, you know? People have to learn how to give this test. Uh so, this is a disconnect that happens a lot between clinical stuff and experimental work. I mean, those you know, researchers don't can't grasp why people still give this. Um medical school interviews. Those of you who will apply to medical school um uh will um get interviews. You get interviews for jobs. You get interviews for all kinds of things in your life. What's the evidence that interviews are any good for anything? How could you know whether interviews are good for anything? It And a company interviews you, a university interviews you.
How would you even decide whether So, I can tell you the social psychologists have shown repeatedly that interviews are cesspools for discrimination because people tend to like people who are like them. Okay? You know, oh, you went to MIT? You know, yeah, course nine, yeah. You know, then you go, oh man, this is going to be good, right? Right? Or I went to Caltech. We didn't like MIT people. We thought they were a little bit snobby or something. And you go, oh, that's not going to be so good. Okay. So, so you know, social psychologists have shown if you just vary information and in practice interviews, people tend to people tend to like people who are like them.
By background, by appearance, and so on. On average, they try not to. They try to be fair, but okay. So, we know that. But how about me Okay. So, here's what Yale Here's what they did. Yale compared students who were accepted or rejected on the basis of an interview. So, they were all had scores that got them to the interview. And then they then they looked at them where they went in pairs or larger than pairs to other medical schools. So, let's say you got accepted by Yale and you were accepted or rejected on the interview, but you ended up as two students at Penn or two students at Michigan.
Okay? You're sitting next to each other. Right? One of you was accepted by interview at Yale, one of whom you was not. Who does better at that other place? They're dead even. The interview added nothing for predicting grade point average or completion of medical school. Here's one more example. University of Texas uh enlarged in the midst of their um at Houston in the midst of their interviews uh it enlarged uh from 150 to 200 students. They had interviewed uh 800. The 150 who came were among their top ones. They interviewed them, they liked them, they came. And then they had and then all of a sudden because the state legislature said, "We're by law mandating you take 50 more." They took 50 more who didn't do so well in the interview.
Okay? Uh those 50 more performed identically to the ones who got in with a successful interview. They couldn't find a difference between them. Now, there's at least one thing you might think the interview might have done but we don't know. But that's But people What do you think it might have done? So, these The outcome was your grades in medical school and your likelihood of completing medical school. What else could an interview have been relevant for? Maybe maybe maybe something about bedside manner or how you relate to people. Maybe maybe maybe, but there's no evidence that's true, okay? Now, you Now, you're starting to grasp at straws.
So, there's no evidence that interview processes make any difference anywhere, but everybody does interviews all the ways because we always think we're kind of good judges of human nature or something. So, interviews uh it's very hard to tell that they ever do anything. So, here's my last thing. Self-esteem. You cannot watch, you know, Oprah or Dr. Phil without some discussion of self-esteem at some moment. Um and it sounds good to everybody. I mean, nobody would wish for you as a parent or friend for you to have low self-esteem. And in fact, higher self-esteem is correlated with higher initiative and persistence, happiness, and emotional resilience, and also unfortunately with people who are narcissistic and bullies, okay?
On average, isn't that And how they measure it just so you know, because this is a problem, too. Like, how do you measure it? You have the There's several scales, but the most widely used scale is this Rosenberg scale. So, you have that, too, if you want to try it out on yourself, okay? Okay, self-report. Uh And when they reviewed 15,000 studies some years ago, they could find no evidence that higher self-esteem leads to better things. It all seemed the other way around. That like doing better at things led to higher self-esteem, okay? They could never find that pushing your self-esteem up doesn't.
Having said that, I can tell you as a parent of two young kids, or if you have friends and you care about them and you know this, we like to praise people to build up their self-esteem, right? We tell you, "You're awesome. You know, someday you'll go to MIT. I know you will, okay? You're a wonderful person and you're smart and you're beautiful." And you know, parents want their children, and teachers, too, to grow up and thrive and build up that self-esteem. So, how can And And the easiest way to do that is praise, right? Just telling your your kid how awesome he or she is, or your young person you know, simply how awesome he or she is.
Get their self-esteem up. So, the last little thing I'm going to tell you, and then we'll be done with about 3 minutes, is uh work from Carol Dweck that shows you how dangerous it is to uh to and counterproductive it is to have um uh you know, praise where you don't think through its relation to people. And in one sentence, we'll talk about are you going to succeed in life by your effort or by your talents? You know, what's a bigger question than that? Wherever you get to in your life, it's going to be based on your effort or your talent or both. I'll just have a sentence about that now, but But, here's the experiment she did with fifth graders.
She had them perform a pretty hard task. And afterwards, uh randomly, they were either praised for their intelligence. So, a person said to them, "You, fifth grader, you are so smart. I can't believe how great you did on that." And fifth grader, "Okay." All right. Or, they were praised for their hard work. "This shows a lot of hard work, okay?" Different kid. And some kids got no praise at all. Uh in this experiment, okay? Now, then they get an a task that's even a little bit harder. How does the different kind of praise influence things? So, here was the finding. If you were praised for your intelligence, you did worse on the second test.
If you were praised for your hard work, you did better. If nobody said anything, your performance didn't change. And the idea is this. You know, you understand, praise for your intelligence, you did worse on a hard task. Praise for your effort, you did better. And here's the idea, that if we praise people for their intelligence to build up their self-esteem, they start to care more more how their performance reflects on them than the performance itself. Because if I if you're trying to prove that you're an intelligent person, you care less you just people the students who get that kind of a praise for their intelligence, they persist less in a difficult task.
They say it's they they don't enjoy challenges. Why? They just want to ace everything to keep proving they're smart. Okay? Uh the kids who get praised for effort, they're kind of like, "Okay, I'm going to make some mistakes, but I'm just going to keep going cuz with effort I can do things sometimes." And it turns out that it makes a remarkable thing. And so Dweck, we'll come back to this, talks about you can have view your intelligence as a trait, I have only so much, or as a growth, the more harder I work, the smarter I get, but I have to do the hard work to get there, okay? And we live in a society that often goes by fixed traits.
American Idol, the harder to work, the better you sing, or who has the talent is discovered? Who has the talent is discovered, right? Okay? Right? Uh because the idea is you know you're you're a certain amount of musical talent, and now the judges show and you break into the world and you're a famous singer, right? Um uh so ask yourself this, uh uh when you are good at what you do, is it because something in your genes and environment made you good at or is it cuz you tried really hard? So uh Malcolm Gladwell has this statement that's floating around and gets a lot of attention that anybody can become great at anything if they work on it for 10,000 hours.
So how much of your success in the past, currently, in the future is going to be based on your effort and how much is it going to be based on your talents? And how would we know that? And we're a very talent-oriented society. Uh uh uh and it seems like the more we encourage effort, maybe the more people might flourish. So we talked about how psychology and science, experiments, brief history of psychology experimentation, uh some issues in experimentation, and then some psychological topics, and some practical information for being generous and kind, and winning friends rapidly. Okay, thanks very much.
Yeah.