Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu last time we discussed how people can approach psychological issues in terms of uh experiments and and at least correlations in some cases or causal studies through experiments and we discovered that if you think about money what happens on average you become s less more self-reliant less willing to help right okay we discovered that if you just change the way that men and women uh uh approach each other at a dating event you change their internal feelings and their external behaviors simply by who's approaching what uh who's approaching who so you know we learned all kinds of things that you might or might not have known unless you did the experiment uh and but for all these things that are our mental lives our thoughts our feelings you are all supported by our brains and so for me personally as a neuroscientist I've always thought that you know the brain is one of the three amazing things out there in the natural world which is the origins of the universe the uh uh origin of life right the brains that allow us to think and feel Perce and remember uh you know really everything that we do comes comes from that okay so uh here's this device and I want to share with you just this phrase that people sometimes use which is that your mind is what your brain does that your mind is what your brain does okay and so the readings from Oliver Sachs for today kind of remind you of that so there are two women who have um uh uh have seizures of various kinds and what happens in them so one is Mrs OC 88-year old woman and what starts to happen to her what's she starts to hear songs uh and so so powerfully not just when you have a little you know song in your head that it's hard for her to hear conversations right for her a conversation like we're having now it's as if the music stayed on really loud it turns out she's having temporal loes seizures the temporal loes are the parts of the brain that are terribly important for hearing uh so music is something that we hear um and it's and she has a right temporal lobe inunction she's had an injury in the right temporal lobe music for most of us is is more dependent on right hemisphere processes than the left so that makes it unusual um and she and how does she feel about the whole process uh Mis so so what's generating the songs though what's generating the songs that she hears yeah her memory her brain right because in epilepsy what's happening neurons are firing when neurons fire in organized patterns those are memories desires physical actions thoughts when they're firing For No Good Reason like an epilepsy because of some brain difficulty they just start firing but the neurons that happen to be firing will drive certain mental processes that they normally support in this case the neurons that are firing away are ones that are involved in memory for songss and perception for songs and when they fire it's as if you heard the song itself because when you hear my voice or when you hear a song you're never hearing the song You're always hearing what your neurons are interpreting the sound that comes to your ear your mind is what your brain does in that sense in you a very CR Central way if you had an injury in that part of the brain you could be cortically deaf and never hear a sound even though all the information came to your ear so without your brain uh you know interpreting the environment you wouldn't know what it is but if your brain starts to fire on its own that's just as good a signal as if you heard a song itself because that is the stuff of hearing songs so she had she enjoyed it actually she declined taking anti-convulsant medications because she felt it was a portal to her past right she could the songs that she heard were ones that reminded her of her life and were kind of pleasant to hear it was like being in a Non-Stop highlight film of her life okay or highlight uh MP3 okay so now an opposite response to a similar phenomenon comes from a Mrs om in her 80s she hears songs but she also Hears A lot of ringing and hissing okay it's not limited to the song itself she doesn't mention any of this for how long four years she's hearing ringing hissing songs she knows because her mind is fine that they're coming from nowhere but inside her head but she doesn't tell anybody that's a huge burden right uh and and why doesn't she tell them yeah especially you know if you're in your 80s and you're going around saying you know I'm hearing things right people go okay we're you know putting you in the old age home right you're out of it okay uh so so you know she doesn't want to give up her Freedom uh and so uh and and she gets a short playlist just three songs and hears them over and over and over again you may have the experience that some songs you hear you know for a while you like them more and then you get tired of them okay if you had only three all the time every day in a bad version that was hissing and ringing you'd get pretty tired of the songs too um that stops by anti-convulsive medications and medications that stops the seizure stop the songs uh uh and so uh it's uh it's a sort of a beautiful story with two opposite you know emotional responses for how your mind is what your brain does now from this the fact that songs are played back as if you had pulled out you know songs from your computer or or or or M shelf somewhere you know you might think that the brain retains these records perfectly throughout life and epilepsy will just sort them we'll come back to that later on and say that in very much we don't think memory is that way but we do remember songs that that are important for us uh and if our brain just starts firing in the same place where we store those songs we hear them just as real as your cortex hears it when it hears the actual song itself okay because that's the place where you hear it so uh this is the kind of evidence that in at least in some sense your mind is what your brain does and so here's this amazing brain it's about about you know two to three pounds right but every thought and feeling you'll ever have every physical movement every desire every uh thing that you're proud of or ashamed of that crosses your mind will be supported by this this structure um so I'm going to talk a little bit about the neurons just a little bit about the neurons that compose the brain and a little bit about a quick tour to the gross organization of the brain we'll come back to many of these structures as they're relevant to different things like memory or emotion or personality later in the course talk a little bit about the Enterprise of trying to say which parts of our brain support which parts of our mind uh uh missteps about that uh famous cases about that that have turned out to have roughly the right message and then a little bit more we'll focus on hemispheric specialization the thing in humans where our left hemisphere and our right hemisphere are uh uh organized to accomplish different things to support different mental functions and the surprise from split brain or cheroy patients that these different mental uh lives that support on different parts of the brain that they can live in isolation they don't even know they're there one to the other so let me rephrase this as you sit there uh uh you have in the thought is you might have independent parts of your mind supported by independent parts of your brain and uh at any one moment your Consciousness might be in one part and then it might move to another and just like there's all these people in this room your brain might be all these things having their own independent thinking lives okay they have to interact a lot but how much might there be independent modules in your brain that are doing their own thing and now you're thinking about music and those turn on and that's where your Consciousness is now you're thinking about history now you're thinking about dinner tonight and different parts of your brain turn on and that's where in your Consciousness is moving from one part of your brain to the other but the other parts keep going okay so we'll see how how plausible is that uh uh so it took a long time for people to decide that the uh the brain actually is the stuff of the mind uh you know smart philosophers like Plato said uh well the it's the part of the body that's closest to the heavens that's where the gods might reside so that's a good place to have your mind and that's where your brain is okay a sort of GPS approach to locating uh where the Mind might be Aristotle said wait a minute it's the warm and active heart the heart was very impressive on postmortem examination of people who passed away that houses the mind and that it cools uh and there's an inner brain so the brain was kind of a radiator that would sort of cool stuff off to keep the heart in optimal and even now we talk about people having a big heart right a cold heart a warm heart we still talk about human uh uh personality or character in terms of heart uh Galen said that the brain was surrounded there's ventricles in the middle of the brain that have fluid cerebral spinal fluid and he hypothesized that the brain was the packing material okay that protects that fluid hang on to that fluid that's all your stuff we're going to cram a lot of stuff around it right like the bubble pack that comes in the boxes okay uh and of course now we know it's the opposite way around the mind is in the and the physical the the dense part of the brain not that and then you know ideas from decart the pineal body is one of the very few structures it's in the midline of the brain uh that doesn't have a thing on the left and a thing on the right and so he thought maybe that's where things get unified uh uh uh in the whole brain it all comes together as as as a place that runs the whole brain and that's a wrong idea but people were trying to figure out what was going on um in modern Neuroscience there's many levels of analysis of the brain so uh if you go to any Neuroscience program like Department of brain and cognitive science you'll actually see scientists who study things like molecules and synapses molecular neurobiology how neurons work how neurons form networks little organizations of things that solve problems at a higher level Maps systems and the Brain as a whole in this course we mostly have to operate at this level that's the place where it's easy for us to relate in some ways parts of the Mind as we understand it of human nature as we understand it and physical parts of the brain it's very hard for us to get that to molecules at the moment but that's you know lots of neurosciences working to connect these things at different levels and I can't resist talking for one second to about the fact that we know our brains were not designed from scratch you know you are not humans 3.0 or 98.0 right uh everything in Us in some way evolved from other uh species that were similar to us and far enough back dissimilar to us so there's lots of speculations about you know how it is that we balance parts of the brain that are ancient in The evolutionary roots that are more recent in the Revolutionary basis and what that means about us another sense in which we're comprised of multiple Society of brain systems uh in between our ears so we know the the the neurons the the cells in the brain are Gia support cells and neurons that a neuron and I know you all know all this oh let me say a word about notes uh so we we sent Tyler all right uh uh PDFs of the lecture notes from the first two lectures and the third one just recently starting tomorrow we'll send you the PDF of each lecture but the latest by the night before the lecture so you'll be able to print it out or um uh or look it on the computer okay but a neurons have a Soma or a cell body those are make up the gray matter when we look at the brain they have an axon that can be covered with myelin that makes the white matter the dendrite is the the extensions of the neurons that have the input to the to the neuron we know that neurons communicate by neurotransmitters across synapses Junctions between different parts of neurons uh when you have a collection of cell bodies people call it a nucleus when you have a collection of axons they call it a tract it's just just vocabulary and stuff and you know this from other courses just reminding you about them and then you get these unbelievably startling kinds of numbers which are always huge estimates but they show you how amazing your brain is okay uh and how hard it is for us to deeply understand um uh how the brain works I mean we understand incredibly more than we did 10 years ago 20 years ago 30 years ago we're incredibly far from understanding how your brain accomplishes the amazing things it accomplishes so it has about a 100 billion neurons it has about a 100 trillion synapses connections among neurons and dendrites if you were to lay out uh the very thin melinated axons in your brain just the big axons that get milein it's estimated that you have 62,000 miles of ax s okay that's pretty good right now you really want to wear helmets when you go uh skateboarding or anything right uh and about a 100,000 miles of dendrites in each of you all right so this is why the brain is amazing and hard it's fantastic in its complexity um an average uh neuron may have up to 15,000 connections a thousand synapses uh and and uh to a thousand neurons people there's different ways of thinking about the computational power of a neuron but they estimate that these might have each one uh the computational power of something like a medium-sized computer so it's not the best uh uh computer but you've got a 100 billion of them okay now that's the easy part to 100 billion neurons in computers in your head the hard part is to get them all working together efficiently and you're not sitting around going you know computer 33 get up to speed here we you know we have to something's wrong here right you don't even think about them you just go about your business the time for information to go from neuron to neuron is pretty slow low compared to fast computers pretty fast for biology 10 milliseconds and and everybody thinks the secret of the brain whatever it will turn out to be in many ways is that you can run a fantastic number of computations simultaneously and collaboratively but we don't have a deep understanding of how that all plays out so here's a cartoon of of this amazing axon the cell body and the dendrites to get inputs to it the axon that's the output signal of a typical neuron neurons can have these beautiful arborizations tree likee properties of neurons have all kinds of different shapes and different parts of the brain presumably reflecting their different missions what they have to accomplish uh an incredibly complicated cellular uh Factory inside all of them you know is producing uh different things and this I'm this is a big overview this is not for you to learn a specific fact and this here's an actual neuron that's injected in the Fantastic uh tree of connections it makes with other neurons to accomplish its Mission here's a cartoon of a synapse of places where neur transmitter is a signal from one axon to one uh dendrite for example here's an actual picture of here's a package of vesicles that control that have the neurotransmitters in them making a connection or synapse onto a dendroid and you just have a fantastic number of these and you're sitting in you right now an unbelievable amount of stuff that's going on releasing them cleaning them away so they don't hang around too long building you want to get ready to go it's just an unbelievable story per neuron uh never mind the whole of them so now we take a step back to the brain as a whole here's the front of the brain top of the brain back of the brain I'm going to say a word about the cerebellum which we'll talk very little about in this course the cellular organization of the cerebellum is so consistent that people estimate that half of all the cortical neurons in the brain are in cerebellum and if you see the cerebell size is small you know not that large it's because it's packed so tightly and it's so consistent in this organization that people thought that's the first part of the brain will crack because the organiz is so clear that you know we'll be able to figure out what it's Computing and how it does it and it's turned out to be about as mysterious a structure as any okay I can't tell you the number of debates about what people we know it's involved in motor control but in many other things as well the wiring diagram knowing it what's connected to who turns out to be only a tiny step in understanding how a part of the brain does what it does uh so here's this mysterious cerebel um and then uh you know here's a basil ganglia that we know is involved in movement uh Parkinson's disease affects it Huntington's disease affects it uh it's also involved in learning habits of all kind uh it's also involved in the reward systems of the brain what do we found delightful and important what do we uh want to do because the reward system is is turned on we'll come back to that later on and then the lyic system the part of the brain that's involved in emotion and memory uh uh migdol and hippocampus will come back to that if you don't have this structure intact you can't form new memories ever again we'll talk about patients like that um and then we'll come to the smarts of the brain the cerebral cortex uh four loes frontal parietal occipital and temporal you have one four on the left and four on the right these loes are comprised of Gyro that's the part of the brain that sticks out and then there's a sort of indentation where it Dives deep uh into a sulkus comes back up it's the next gyrus Dives deep into the next sulcus a huge sulcus is called a Fisher here's a syvan Fisher that separates the temporal and and frontal cores and one of the reasons people have speculated about why do we have a thing like that why do we have you know these waves of ayrus going up and then plunging Into the Depths then coming back up like this again and plunging in you know from from uh sulkus to sulcus and nobody really knows but there's kind of a speculation that's that's fun and plausible uh so we have one thing we know is that um bigger cortices are good not so much one person to another but across species your smarts are in your cores language higher level thought and so on so on the whole a species that has bigger cores has a lot of opportunities for thought and and Social Development and so on uh so you could imagine having babies with heads you know this big uh and they'd be really smart okay maybe uh but what would be the problem what would be the big problem think about it not from your perspective uh perhaps if most of you are you know adult sort of teenagers or or young 20s or something like that most of you uh so you don't remember your birth experience directly right all right but who remembers your birth experience pretty well your parents okay all right it's your mother especially okay it's it's giving birth is a pretty painful specific challenging process okay so if a head big this came out you know it would be incommensurate with the birth canal that the mother can afford it's already pretty challenging with your head as big as it is when it comes out okay that's a challenge of birth it's not getting the arms and legs out it's the head that's too big okay so now we have a problem that the mother's birth canal is only so big we want as much brain and smartness in our species and in ourselves as possible so how are we going to get a lot of neocortex in there we're going to fold it okay a lot of neocortex in there but a smaller uh uh volume to get out through the birth canal and that's thought to be why the brain has this elaborate uh plunging from sulcus to sulcus and the this sort of convolved uh physical structure and if we think about the brain um we can think about things that go into our brains about the outer world so when you see Vision enters through this area or when you he it enters here when you touch or when you move your body these are the motor cortical neurons so these are sort of major inputs a major output that's in blue that's the areas that are devoted to specific perception or modalities or sensories uh and then we have y in yellow here that are the areas that are sort of closely tied to one modality uh but already they're interpreting what's going on and then you have areas in pink here that are sort of not tied to any modality and are are are devoted to what we might call abstract thought and you can see the prefrontal cortex the front of the cortex that's in front of the motor cortex is a huge swath like that we'll come back to that we think it's terribly important for thinking problem solving and many aspects of you know the highest human uh mentation now we're a huge believer in the end that form follows function in the brain and if we understood the correct relationship between Form and Function we'd be very far and and a neuroanatomist name name broadman made the following heroic effort what he did is he sectioned brains into lots of thin slices and he followed them through a microscope and every time the brain tissue changed the neurons looked different he would change the number of the area Okay so he started in something like area one and the neurons look pretty similar and he's moving moving moving and then all a sudden they start to look different the neurons and that becomes you know something like area three moving moving area four moving moving area six so every time the neurons looked different to his eye it gets a new number the idea being when the neurons look different they have a different job to do and that part of the brain does something different and there's lots of debates about the best way to do this or different interpretations but something like this holds true in a striking way the cellular organization of the brain reflects in some way what that part of the brain is accomplishing what part of your mind it supports and then we have simplified color pictures of this uh uh and and we'll come back to neuroimaging next time but it's turned out to be have a second life uh in neuroimaging because when scientists across the world want to compare their neuroimaging results they'll talk about well I got activation in area 46 or I got it in area 21 it's become a nomenclature for the organization of the human brain that allows you to integrate all kinds of Imaging data about the human species and here's a view from the inside of the brain and here's a structure called the Corpus kosum that we'll come back to in the next few minutes okay so um how much are functions localized or distributed how much is like you have a specific thing your mind does and it's in one place in the brain versus it's spread over a range and this idea of how much things are distributed or localized for mental functions of the brain has been a source of huge uh debate uh and I'll show you a misstep and then we'll show you some things where we think we have it more correctly okay the mrep is a phology and uh the most famous name in this is is uh from Gul sphe is another one and in the 19th century this the 1800s uh uh uh this area the phenology took hold a lot and there's a sort of a Freudian story if you want to call that of Gaul which is that apparently when he was a student uh he was very he viewed himself as a very uh effortful and fidia student who you know took all the notes you're supposed to take and worked very hard for exams and did everything he were supposed to do but shock of shocks some students did better than he did and he looked around the classroom and he said like who are these students doing better than I am because I'm trying as hard as I can and some students are doing better and he said hey you know one thing I notice about these students is they all seem to have big foreheads okay right now I don't know how accurate he was scientifically but apparently this was a emotionally transformative moment for Gaul and you'll see in what way this ended up uh guiding His science um so G and Spur time were actually uh uh you know good neuron anatomists they described lots of things about the brain that were correct that were kind of unknown at the time uh for example the paramal tracks the tracks that move from your motor cortex say on your left to control your right hand or on your right to control your left hand they describe those very well but here's here's where they got kind of funny they said okay we can describe the physical organization of the brain but now let's say which part of the brain do which part of the mind and in a way that we now consider a bit willy-nilly uh they began to assign different mental processes to different parts of the brain and the way they did it was they said I'm going to look at somebody and let's pretend somebody you know is very combative what they began to not figure was this well maybe the part of the brain that's involved in being combative the more combative you are the more you have of it so if I feel your skull above the part of the brain that I think is goes with being combative if if you have a big rise there if I feel your head and most of our heads are a little bumpy okay uh you know the person who really combative is going to have a lot of to bump there and and the person who's very Meek we'll have none okay so does that make sense they have these little categories as they just thought about people and they developed this idea uh uh uh that um uh you know they could find where where cautiousness was or precociousness or secretiveness right if you have a big bump there okay let me show you this picture here's a device you would step into that would you know Springs go down and they would go up and they would say where do you have the high bumps and where do you have the low bumps okay now all of this is wrong uh uh because there you know it's it's it's it's it's it's a naive way and and not a scientific way to do it weirdly enough look at what they put below the eye language okay now that's a weird place to put it and we what they saw was a soldier who had a wound that went through his eye into his brain uh and they said okay well he has he's he had trouble producing language and they said well that's where language is well that's language is not below your eye okay but but but evident but but they didn't realize that the wound went up into what something called broker are we'll talk about that in a couple minutes and so uh well they were they they weren't that wrong they just didn't think through where the end of the injury was okay all the other ones we completely dismiss these days uh but we have to worry about naive ways in which we link the M Life of the mind to the stuff of the brain and they did a control experiment the famous uh physiologist mendi preserved with veneration the brain of llas is a big name in history of chemistry spim had the natural wish to see the brain spurzheim was the phrenologist to test the science of the phrenologist mendi showed him instead the brain of an imbecile spurzheim who had already worked up his enthusiasm admired the brain of the imil as he would have admired that of Laos okay so this is the control test I give you a brain of somebody who's not a genius in chemistry and you go oh my gosh this chemistry part of the brain is unbelievable okay and this is the old idea we talked about that you you know if you have an idea you believe in as a scientist you will always find positive evidence for it okay uh Everywhere You Look Back to the brain and let's talk about this part the lower part of the orbital frontal cortex it sits right above your eyes it sort of your eyes would be something like here um and we know something about uh what that part of the brain does from the famous case of Phineas gauge so uh he he was involved in railroad construction in Vermont and that involved explos loading rocks to level the area so they could put in train tracks they would drill a hole put in some fuse put in a powder and they would use a tamping iron to push down uh the sand and powder so there would be a big explosion to flatten the Rock and uh at age 25 in 1848 he a mind who was described as well balanced energetic and persistent he was the ideal employee you know resourceful hardworking he was made a foreman a leader uh he was the most efficient and capable in the group and on September 13th 1848 something big happened and iron uh there was a miscommunication an iron that was 3' 7 in in length I'll show you a picture in a moment because if even if you've heard the story until you see a picture of it you can't grasp how big this was compared to a human being uh there was a miscommunication the explosion went off early he was directly over it the rod flew up went through his head all the way through his head and it had the power to land 30 yards away after you know exploding up into the air and by March of that year of the next year he was back at work not too long a vacation you know recovery period for for that big a thing going through your head but his personality had fundamentally changed so here's his a cast of his actual head and his skull that's here's where it shot up through here and out this hole um here's the actual Rod compared to that okay so if you haven't seen this you can underestimate uh uh the amazingness of this thing and at time at the time he was famous not for the reason we now think of him he was just a riple or not you know story believe it or not story of that a human survived it at all okay uh so uh Antonio deasio sort of attempted to reconstruct by computer you know wear this Rod shot up through here and out into 30 yards away right they're that big compared to him um and the amazing thing described by a physician who worked with him at the time is the equilibri between his intellectual facility faculties and animal propensity seem to have destroyed he is fitful irreverent indulging at times in the grossest profanity little deference for his fellows impatient of restraint conflicting with his desires at times pertinaciously obstinate capricious and vacillating devising many plans of future operations which are no sooner arranged than they are abandoned in turn for others appearing more feasible exactly the opposite of who he was before he was a responsible efficient leader and now he's a totally irresponsible person doing all kinds of things that make no sense a child in intellectual capacity he has the animal passions of a strong man so he completely changed who he was in this regard his mind was so radically changed that his friends and acquaintances that he was no longer gauge so here's a physical insult to the brain that changes the character of a person that changes what we would think of as a moral judgments of when is it right to tell the truth of having plans and being a responsible trustworthy person completely changed by this uh injury now uh one interpretation is this part of the brain is essential for making moral judgments and have being of good good character what would be another interpretation of why he might have changed just common sense uh besides that this part of the brain does that we want to not be the phrenologists okay uh so the most one you know the most first thought is this part of the brain supports what we think of as moral reasoning and character um well what else could you imagine might have happened yeah his go and was upet about it yeah yeah I I'll make up you know you know something like that but you know a more psychological and different interpretation let me try this one he real you know he was getting ready for the future you know I'll be a foreman today and then next week I'll be Executive Vice President and I'll be associate executive president and you know you and rod goes through his head and he goes wait a minute life is short he can end at any moment why not just do what I want to do all the time because uh you know I the next Rod could come who knows when right all right and I had all all these plans and I was promising people things next week that I delivered on but you know that's a sucker's life you know because your life can end like that so you know forget all the stuff about just enjoy the moment that's a possible thing okay you see movies like that where people are told you have so long to live and they change right uh what what would you want to convince yourself that it wasn't something like that which is not an unreasonable interpretation what you would want to see at a minimum is that if you have brain injuries other other places in the brain you don't see that and if you have other people with brain injuries in the same part of the brain you see that consistently at a minimum you want to say it's not just a big brain injury but it's consistently a brain injury in this part of the brain that leads to this kind of behavior and for at least this example that's true other patients with similar injuries behave similarly people with very very big injuries elsewhere in the brain don't behave similarly so that's there's a lot of Reason in the end for us to believe that this part of the brain is essential for something that we consider almost metaphysical character has this incredibly physical dependence and here's relatively recently just a few years ago they discovered a picture that think of a kind of Phineas gauge himself um here's the rod uh here's the injury to his eye his eye is damaged okay so one more example and then we'll switch to the Swit brains Paul broka uh and you know brok's area in the brain here's Paul broka here's the here's a a brain of a patient named Mr Tan let me say a word about the story so in France a number of people observing patients with injuries had talked about that the left side of the brain is important for speech until then there had not been much ideas that the left and right were fundamentally different uh so there so there's there's always sort of a background before the discovery and there's a talk in 1861 which describes a man who lost his speech but understood everything said to him he couldn't produce speech he could understand speech his intelligence is still unimpaired his speech is gone and then broka heard that talk and he went back and five days later a patient named lebour who who had lost his speech he could only say two things tan and he could swear like crazy okay uh and our current thought about that is uh swearing that's uh emotional and intuitive not the one where you think okay I'm going to swear now to scare somebody but the one you stub your toe in the middle of night and you really let out a curse we think that's guided like an animal Cry by the basil ganglia okay those those heartfelt really emotional uh cursing is not really language it's actually the same cry in animal makes on injury okay and uses some of the same neural circuitry but you know for higher level cortical stuff the only word he could say was tan he died in 1871 they looked at his brain and they found this change in the left frontal cortex and we now call that brokas aasia the inability to speak despite the presence of you can your mouth can move and you can understand language pretty well we'll come back to that so we talk about brokas area and then wori that brokas area is important for production and and here's the kind of damage uh and we'll come back to brokop fasal later in the course so this is a big hint there something different between the right and left hemispheres uh now in what percentage of people is language especially speech production predominantly in the left and our best answer for that come from something called a water test so this is a test given to patients who are undergoing neurosurgery for something like epilepsy sometimes for tumors and they want to know with you for for you personally with great certainty which hemisphere is the eloquent or speaking hemisphere because they want to remove more tissue if they're away from your language areas and less tissue if they're near near your language areas maybe they won't even do a certain surgery if they're too much in the middle of your language areas because in many cases it's so frustrating for people to lose their ability to speak their thoughts okay that they'd rather have the seizures for epilepsy then be unable to speak so Physicians and neurosurgeons are very worried about that so what they give they give you a test where they put in a drug called sodium amatol they inject it into your femural or cored artery it feeds up and the way that the vasculature is between the two hemispheres it mostly shuts down the operation of one hemisphere if you're injected in this feral artery it'll mostly shut down your left in this one it will mostly shut down your right and while the patient has one hemisphere turned off and they know this because for example let's say they shut down this hemisphere with the injection you're waving your arm falls down because your motor system can no longer control your arm you're blind in this field we'll talk about that many of the mental processes done by this half of the brain are shut down and then they'll test you like crazy to see if you can talk they say what are the days of the week what's your name you know name these pictures okay until the drug wears off and then you come back two days later or a day later and they'll inject the other side and they'll know with near certainty in you which is the side of your brain that does the speaking and best estimates are that something like 90% to 99% of people speak from their left even left-handers mostly speak from the left hemisphere uh because these are patients with epilepsy we're not quite sure how they generalize to everybody we wouldn't do this with typical people because these kinds of tests are invasive and a bit risky uh but our best estimates are that if you're right-handed it's almost certain you speak from your left hemisphere and if you're left-handed about 80% of left-handed people also speak from the left hemisphere okay so it doesn't go by handedness which makes handedness a bit more of a mystery so now switch from Gray matter discussions to white matter uh in the middle of your brain is something called the Corpus colossum here it's viewed from the middle if it cut the brain this way 200 million melinated fibers that connect the similar areas from the left and the right this is what Hooks up the left and right hemisphere from spot to spot uh here it is connecting uh and this is from the side view so it's a huge white matter area Corpus kosum and people noticed it because it was so striking but they couldn't figure out what it does and it kind of started to figure a little bit in philosophical debates would a divided brain if you cut the brain down the middle would it read to separate stores of mood predisposition knowledge and memory that is if your two halves of your brain were divided from one another would you be sort of two people okay now we're not going to do that to you right uh but the fascinating thing is okay are you two people to start with who talk to one another sometimes across your Corpus kosum okay um and William dgal said well the unity of Consciousness does not depend on the UN Unity of the nervous system and he volunteered for chomy but to cut this Corpus Clum Ericson noted in 1940 that epileptic seizures would become generalized convulsions often in animal models if you uh if the seizure began here it would spread to the corresponding part of of the opposite side of the brain and become a much word seizure so they got the idea that if they caught their Corpus kosum and patients with severe epilepsy who did not respond to medications that maybe that would make the seizures less severe does that make sense because you wouldn't transmit the seizure from the left to the right or the right to the left uh uh but you know people were sort of almost making jokes about the Corpus kosum because they couldn't figure out what it does they said the Corpus colom is hardly connected with psychological functions at all is for transmitting seizure activity from one hemisphere to the other that's kind of a mology joke okay to or Carl Ashley at Harvard to keep hemispheres from collapsing into one another I mean you do have to have structure and you know to keep things collapsing right so now I need to tell you word for the next couple minutes for this to make sense about how your visual system is organized um so here's the world out there and if you're looking straight ahead everything to the left people call the left visual field everything to the right people call the right visual field and we'll look at this more uh next week a little bit but weirdly your eyes are not set up to that way you could think this eye looks you know at this half and this eye looks at that half the way it's set up each eye looks at both Fields okay each eye looks at both fields and then the neurons that leave the eye get organized here in the optic kaym so by the time they move out towards the brain everything in the opposite half of the world is reflected so everything that's in the right visual field starts in your brain in the left hemisphere everything that's in the left visual field starts in your brain in the right hemisphere does that make sense okay so the first part of your smart neocortex that knows what's out there is you're looking at a face a word a anything the right occipital cortex notice is what's on the left and the left occipital cortex notice is on the right things are so seemlessly integrated in the brain that you don't ever have that feeling right you almost never have like we're getting bad signals on the left right I mean you if you didn't have a course like this you wouldn't know that exists and you could wonder why on Earth is it like that is it just to torture students and confuse them about Fields eyes and brains right uh and people debate about some evolutionary history behind this but it's a great big mystery why we don't organize things much more simply and just go all the way this way quite the opposite we have in the left posterior areas that's where we see the right half of the world and then things get integrated is that okay and keep in mind also that our left hemisphere moves our right hand and our right hemisphere moves our left hand so at least that's the same story right opposite hemisphere controlling seeing the opposite field controlling the opposite hand so imagine these kinds of patients um who uh had the surgery that divided the corpus colossum uh for um uh treatment of epilepsy let me tell you a couple things clinically it was pretty rarely done there weren't that many of them it's pretty rarely done nowadays first second uh the first thing that people noticed was it didn't have much an effect on the patients it's a fascinating story nobody noticed anything okay uh for for for decades because they didn't have the right questions to ask okay so it was these patients are not like astounding patients I can't believe when I see them right they seem pretty much like the same that they were I'll show you a video in a couple minutes of two of them okay um they're not they're not looking unusual in most ways but when people figured out what to ask of them they saw remarkable things they saw two minds in one head and here's how they saw that uh if they showed them a picture let's say of a spoon and a picture of a cup simultaneously in the two Fields they would be up briefly and go but not but it's easy for you to say I saw a spoon and I saw a cup they would say what did you see and the person would say a cup and that would be it okay what did you see a cup because the information in the right visual field goes into uh the left hemisphere that's the speaking hemisphere so the left hemisphere says I saw a cup the right hemisphere saw this perfectly well it's typically not the speaking hemisphere so that information is locked in the right Hemisphere and is doesn't have access to the speaking part of the brain in the left hemisphere so each hemisphere had its own experience and only the left hemisphere could speak you would integrate this information instantly via the Corpus kosum okay or anybody else but each hemisphere only knew what it saw and and so here's another example which not only that each hemisphere only knows what it knows but it's completely ignorant that the other one knows anything okay it's as if if the two of you are sitting next to each other okay uh uh and don't know each other are not passing notes or Tweeting or whatever uh uh you know it's as if like you know do you know exactly what the person next to you is thinking well you might you know no not necessarily right okay so uh that's exactly what it is like like you're in one person in their brain in their skull so they would show them a square in the left visual field and a triangle in the right visual field you would say I saw a square I saw a triangle what do you want uh here's what happens if they're asked to say say what did you see and then behind a board draw what you saw okay the board is there so so it's not confusing them um so here's what they say what did you see I saw a triangle because it's in a right field it goes into the visual area in the left hemisphere that's a speaking hemisphere but if they're drawing with their left hand what do they draw the square because the right hemisphere it's saw a square so the left hand is drawing it draws a square so simultaneously that will say a triangle and the hand behind the board will draw a square and the patient is not bothered in the least because each hemisphere only knows knows what it knows the reason they have the board there is if they didn't have the board there then the left hemisphere would see you drawing a square and you go like why am I drawing a square I saw a triangle and the person would be weirded out does that make sense okay all right okay so so but here's the thing the amazing thing is both of them have a lot of smarts by themselves and they're completely unaware of what the other hemisphere knows again the idea is you the hemispheres are talking all the time but at lots of moments different parts of your brain might be knowing different things and we have a lot of belief for that but this is the most striking demonstration so here's a patient who was asked to read you know say what he saw and pick it up one instruction read what you see and pick it up with your left hand so he sees the word ring in the speaking hemisphere he says ring his left hemisphere sees the word key has enough language to read that and it picks up the key behind the board right and it never says I saw two things or anything like that uh in most cases so um let me let me stop here and let's do can we do the first video so you're going to see an example of a patient named Vicki who's going to be tested uh by Mike ganiga you're going to see two videos with Mike ganiga when he was younger when he was older he did a lot of the work with these split brain patients plus Alan Alda for Mash will visit Mike anagon the second so one of the really interesting things is these flip braid patients have given us a sort of chance to ask in you and I uh what are some different ways in which the right Hemisphere and left hemisphere are their own minds and what are the things they seem to care about uh and that are useful so here's one example from Jerry Levy it's a very clever experiment she would show in the left or right visual field something like this and then say in free view which of these two things is more similar and on purpose it's ambiguous okay on purpose you could say well this is more similar because it has a similar shape or appearance this is more similar because I use a spoon and a fork to eat a piece of cake right and if this was seen by the left hemisphere people would pick by function if this was seen by the right hemisphere the patients would pick by appearance okay so uh it's the idea is that the left and this is the power of having two hemispheres in parallel figuring out what's going on one for is figuring out what's the information I need about shape and things like that in the world and what's the information I need about function and because you have two semi-independent brains in you you're constantly figuring out Form and Function and then using whatever you need to use to solve the problem in front of you does that make sense okay so here's another nice one here's scissors projected into left visual field the right hemisphere that would pick the spoon and the fork because the crossing shape is resembling that in the right visual field left hemisphere people would pick the needle and thread because that's functionally goes with scissors so your mind is seeing the same thing but in one case it's tuned in the left hemisphere to functions and the right hemisphere to appearance so these are just notes for you uh going over what I said so they talked about you know would you have two different consciousnesses in you it's hard really to tell uh they did one experiment with Vicki where they would present a nude picture in the left visual field unexpectedly this was a long time ago was a shocking thing um and the patient would blush and giggle when asked to explain why you're blushing and giggling was that's very safe patient she would all she could say is oh doctor you have some machine okay she knows something funny happened and inappropriate she can't tell you she doesn't the language in the hemisphere that saw it and so she gives this other kind of description another kind of a favorite one is the dresses one there was one patient who went back to work and his father's grocery store and this could be frustrating early on after his treatment he would put stock things on to a Shelf with one hand and remove it with the other you can imagine that would be a slow a slow work day uh these kinds of weird behaviors pretty much clear up within weeks okay after that you have to test to see the difference another one they presented the instructions walk across the room to the left visual field right hemisphere person gets up walks across the room that person's ask why did you walk across the room person doesn't know why because they're speaking hemisphere didn't see it and they they'll say something like I was thirsty so interestingly they fill in motivations okay they don't say I don't don't know why or have a split brain you know what do you expect right I mean I mean they're they're being tested for that right you know but they seem like they want to fill in some other explanation and I'll show you why another example for that and social psychologists have said because they like this uh uh they said you know this is an example that people are desperate rationalizers for ourselves we'll come back to this is social psychology you know you can think about whether it's true for yourself or not that when you know things are contradictory we don't say oh things are contradictory we say well here's why okay why as we explain our own behavior that we have to rationalize our own behavior um so here's the example uh uh here's the picture so here's one a split brain patient and he's shown um he's shown uh these pictures uh uh in in in in the visual field pairs of pictures in visual fields and he he supposed to pick two of them in free Vision that related to what he sees okay so let me say here's the picture that he sees boom this goes up and goes away now both hands go and pick something related to what the person just saw okay so this is shown briefly it disappears this hand um Let me let me do this right this the chicken went to this part of the brain that controls this hand so the claw goes to the to the rooster okay this hemisphere saw a snowy scene controls his hand and it goes for the shovel so now they're going to make the patient confront the weirdness of what he just did okay his his hands went out each hemisphere points to what it saw and again his answer could be I'm in an experiment you're constantly tricking me I know that okay basically they know that they're in an experiment uh uh but his answer is I saw a claw that's a speaking hemisphere I picked the chicken okay that's fine left hemisphere is speaking right now and then you have to clean out the chicken shed with a shovel okay you understand he's he's he's creating a story to make his behavior seem coherent all right uh uh rather than just saying you know you know I'm an experimental subject and that's why you're testing me okay here's the last thing I want to show then I'm for two minutes and I'm going to show you a film that touches on this psychologists are interested in understanding also uh uh in what way we see the forests and the trees you know you see the bumper stickers you know think globally act locally let's talk about global and local or parts and holes so the hole here is H and the locals are s does that make sense it's it's a way to operationalizing experiment looking at the hole versus looking or looking at the forest versus the Trees of ess's okay okay here the ho is a c and the local elements are O's um and there's a paint painter who did beautiful pictures you'll see more another example but he made whole faces out of vegetable Parts okay do you see that every part here of this face if you look at a piece by piece as a different vegetable okay or fruit all right so it's a sort of play on this thing and you'll see in the movie that way he made the whole face out of the parts of this but here's uh here's what what pray patients do and I'll show you something else in a moment they're asked shortly after surgery to copy this it's right in front of them all the time there's no one field it's right in front of all time just copy what's right in front of you if they do it with their left hand right hemisphere you see that you get the forest but not the trees here's the trees and they don't look that good honestly but still there's some some wiish thing there uh copy this it's right in front of you if it's a left hand you get the forest but not the parts if it's the right hand you get the parts but not the forest does that make sense it's as if each hemisphere is one hemisphere the left hemisphere is seeing the parts and the right hemisphere is seeing the whole so that's awesome because you don't have to be Global or local your mind is simultaneously figuring out the local parts and the global parts and then you can use whatever is the useful information your mind because you know you have multiple brains in you it's sort of figuring out what it needs to do last uh I'll show you and then we'll do one more video uh here are patients who have lesions injuries after stroke okay it's the same idea though so here's what they have to copy it's right in front of them just copy it exactly that's all they have to do if the patient has damage on the right so he loses his sense of uh of of wholeness you see there's lots of Z's that's the parts perceived by the intact left hemisphere but the right hemisphere is not giving very much information about the hole the very here's another patient with left hemisphere damage that person fails to appreciate the parts but gets the hole here same thing down here a patient with right hemisphere damage appreciates the parts in the intact left hemisphere but doesn't appreciate the hole in the injured right hemisphere conversely here's the injured left hemisphere that patient copies the hole the right hemisphere gets it left hemisphere is missing the parts okay it the amazing thing it's right in front of them They're copying it but if your injury if your brain is injured it no longer appreciates that a whole exists or that a part exists okay it's as if it wasn't there uh so that's how how much our mind is what our brain does in this regard and so if we do the last video you'll see that again any questions I want you saw so I I would say you know neurons are unbelievable we can't even begin to figure out your brain at the neuron level we're so far from that uh the big message from this last part besides hemispheric specialization is that your your brain and we'll show this over and over again in this course is a society of semi-independent brains doing their own thing sharing information as needed uh and the more we study the brain the more we understand how many parts of you there are that are semi independent and autonomous okay thanks

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 3 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011