Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu so today we're going to talk about attention and you know sometimes we talk about patients who are like very unusual and the next lecture we will do that we'll talk about spectacular disorders of attention but today we're going to talk about attention as it typically occurs in you sitting here right now I'm want to convince you that in addition to slips of attention that can occur as you get older also how you attend to the world around you is weirder than you think okay in a broad sense I hope to convince you that's happening all the time right now as you go back to your room as you walk to the next class or your room how you attend to what's around you in the world is weirder than you think okay so what is attention what do we mean by attending to things so William James was a psychologist at Harvard who in many ways articulated concepts in psychology that till this day turn out to be sort of beautiful ways to talk about them in an everyday sense everybody knows what attention is is that taking possession by the mind in clear and vivid form of one out of what seems like several simultaneous objects or trains of thought it applies withdrawal of some things in order to deal with other so a big idea there is we can pay attention to some things and there's a lot of things around us and so we have to pick where we focus our attention a little bit like if you have a budget if you have some money what do you spend your money on and what do you not spend your money on so we're going to talk about attention it's kind of similar to the idea of awareness what are you aware of or what are you conscious of and two themes across the talk will be we often intend to more than we realize and I'll show you very specific and you know evidence for that but we often attend to things less than we realized all the time and here's roughly to the outline we're seeing attention you know what you pay attention to is kind of a gatekeeper to what you perceive and what you know attention is very limited we can only do process one thing at a time and because of that we miss a lot around us all the time there are unconscious processes to pick up information so sometimes things that we don't notice do influence us and attention can be viewed as kind of a dialogue between two things between things in the world that capture your attention if somebody throws a ball at you something dramatic happens you hear a scary sound that captures your attention we talk about that as bottom-up processing it's it impinges on you it forces you to attend to it because it's dangerous it's moving it's unusual and then top-down things what's your goal what do you do what are you paying attention to what do you care about what are you up to people call that top-down processing so things that are the environment drives in to your attention because they're so dramatic bottom-up things that you're looking for thinking about you know are useful for your purposes top-down there's tremendous evidence that we encode a very small fraction of what's around us in a very specific way so we go listen estimate with me how often a day on average since you've been about five or six or seven and you've been allowed to have any money in your possession at all do you think you've held or seen a penny okay so we all know the horror when you're headed in for cents and change all right that's for pennies right there okay so you know well we'll make an estimate right pretend from age 5 to 20 even handling change so maybe you've encountered three pennies a day okay it's reasonable okay you don't have to be just in the right ballpark you know there's 365 days a year skip it 15 years right just do the multiplication you end up with about sixteen thousand three hundred eighty penny experiences okay all right so we all know that as you head towards midterms it's gonna be hard to study a lot of stuff quickly but if somebody said to you if you study something approximately 17,000 times okay you think well up that one I'm gonna get okay so let's ask the question there's a Lincoln penny face to the left or the right is there anything above his head or below has said is there anything on the penny to the left or to the right and how about the other side and how many of you was 17 approximately 17,000 or certainly many thousands of visual experiences with a penny would that you know something that means a lot to you on the correctness of the answer to these five fundamental questions okay all right this is good teamwork okay all right so let's make it multiple choice that's better right your rescue making me feel better because of the foul-ups and I appreciate that this is the actual what it looks like okay so what do you think it means that 17,000 exposures to a penny don't leave in you a reasonably accurate memory of the main things you see in a penny how could that happen and it happens to everybody in fact when they do experiments you know here's people's drawings okay don't feel bad if you didn't know it I mean it's psychology you know half the people don't even think that the version that you show them if you ask them is plausibly correct you show them the correct answer they go no please forgive me yeah that can't be right okay so here's one thing if we don't attend to something very specifically we can see it you know a tremendous number of times and it leaves no impression on our mind or no memory for of it right now why is that in an everyday sense we don't know in a deep science sense but what do you think that point of it is why don't you know what a penny looks like because it's not important somebody said yeah because it's close enough to see that Browns smallish thing and you don't need the rest of any information to hand the money back and forth right so what you attend to what you decide is important makes an incredible difference and nothing else makes up for it you know 17,000 exposures don't make up for for what a penny looks like you so after you it was research at MIT that used this method of simultaneously processing two messages in the two ears the shadowed message the one you're copying and the second message the one that you try to pick up but it's hard to do so they asked in the ear that you're not paying attention to what can you pick up here's what you can pick up if a voice is present now you just imagine it's silence versus somebody talking that you can notice if the voice changes from a man to a woman okay if it changes from a man to a woman you can pick that up in the unattended ear the one you're not paying attention to or if the voice goes a person is talking also goes earn you notice that okay here's what you don't notice anything about the content I mean that's what you experience it you can switch the language of the message you can go from English to Spanish or Italian a person won't notice that it changed you can change the you can also change the weather it's typical speech or backward nonsense speech which sounds very weird okay you don't notice that either so you notice a few things but there's a lot of other things you don't notice at all um now you may have all had the experience of the cocktail pot what's called a cocktail party phenomenon do you know you do know what that is have you ever been you know talking with people you're at a party you're at some events or something like that and somebody mentions your name you're especially a first name of you know your name that's what maybe you last thing where's food and then all of a sudden you notice a conversation around you and it's almost hard to pay attention to the person you're talking to because the first one over there it's just that your name and you wonder what they're saying about you now here's a really interesting paradox how did you not notice that other conversation which you didn't that's like the shadowing task oh yeah I'm talking to one person there's some hubbub over here I don't know what they're talking about right all of a sudden they say you're my name and I noticed what they're talking about well how did that happen I wasn't paying attention to it I don't know anything about it but my name bounced out in my mind and drew my attention to it so it's kind of a paradox right I'm not paying attention but somehow I pick up my name and so we'll talk a little bit more about this but people have looked at this very experimentally so here's how they approached it again here a sentence in one year the man approached the bank that's the one the repeating and in the other here they would hear one of two different words in the unattended ear they're not getting much out of that they would hear the word money or River so now the bank could be interpreted as he went to the bank to deposit your paycheck or you went to the bank to have a picnic by the river right two different meanings of the word bank are suggested by the word you hear in the ear that you're not processing information and then they people tell you well tell me what's the sentences you just heard kind of and people are primed to give the interpretation of the sentence that goes with the word that suggested the year they weren't listening to okay so something in their mind and brain heard enough of that to influence what they're interpreting and the good in the attended ear here's another example they're shadowing they're paying attention and repeating aloud an essay in one ear and in the other ear they hear something that's like the word like a word taxi fare and they pick words that are spelled two different ways homonyms so the word FA re or FA a are now if you were typically if I asked you to write down the word fare and spell it correctly you might say well which one do you want or something like that but if I didn't tell you anything most people would put down the word FAI are most of the time it's a more common word but what they found is this they finished the experiment I shadowed one thing they had a word like taxi fare in the unattended ear and they said well did you notice you got that word well if you listen to it you remembered you heard taxi fare but if you were shadowed you pretty much you very rarely remembered that you heard it say it's not consciously available to you that you heard it because you were so busy in the other ear and in your mind listen to hear but if you asked to spell the word how often do you come up with the rare spelling because of what you heard in your ear it's exactly the same so part of your mind heard that word thought about that phrase taxi fare and when somebody says to you write down the word fare your mind got moved to think about the alternative spellings the unconscious processing of that content has influenced you an experimentally verifiable way so what this shows if you go back to the cocktail party effect which is the everyday kind of version of this is that weirdly enough some kinds of things that we don't pay attention to have such a property that in a machine like reflexive way our mind and brain processes it to some extent anyway and then there's something curious that we don't understand deeply which is somehow if it's your name it's going like I'm hearing my name I'm hearing my name pay attention over here okay that's that's like deep psychological computational theory right and somehow you pull it out because it's triggered your mind enough because it's so because our names are so important to us yeah okay tell me against the phenomenon where if you notice the word good so tell me again sir comes in you what yeah it's very much delight to the same thing the question was you know something pops in your head a word and then you look back and go wait a minute I just read that I wasn't even thinking about it or something right I did you know somebody said it or it's on a sign but it yes yes that's something some experience you're not paying much attention to tips your mind to think a certain way and all the sudden you're thinking that way and you don't know what tip your mind that way that's very similar yeah you so again the message here is how you know as you're walking around in the world there's a very few things that you're very specifically really aware of and many things can change on you in these examples okay so you know and one of the reasons this is just a thought you know that you could be by being selective into attention you can focus on what you want to focus on it's not only up you know a weakness it's a strength so you could pick out the message in red or you could pick out the message in blue where you attend this as it helps you select information that's relevant but here's two more works an example is I just almost all the examples I just showed you where from Dan Simon's who's then really beautiful work in this way made it very available to there so here's to YouTube ones you sometimes people sometimes people have said okay you know these are cute laboratory things who are having people counting but the real world is different okay when I'm out of the classroom and I'm out of the laboratory the real world you kind of notice a lot more because you're it's real people real situations so this is one more example that's a beautiful example of this you so do you think it would have worked if the replacement person was like very different if we wouldn't a man or a woman or if a very tall or person versus a person not earlier no but what does that mean why does it work for this one and why and why would it it means that that means that in the person's head they have a very rough picture of who they're talking to is that makes sense there's a lot of room for a replacement not total room but a very rough picture but it's right in front of them okay now you've seen this thing so I won't do it as a demonstration now where people simply read the words the red orange brown and that's easy because you you're a very automatic reader if you're a typical adult you read about 250 words a minute okay zoom zoom zoom but if you have the name the color of the print when the print is contradicted by the word right so you're reading the word red printed in green but your job is to say green that naming of the print when the word is not matching the color of the print slows people down they make mistakes they're slower and that's because there's a big lesson in this it's great to get automatic at things that's how we're skilled at things speaking driving everything physical we don't even think about how we walk right the price of automaticity being really skilled and reflexive as you lose control right you lose control so you do not want it you don't want to think about what that word says but you can't help it now let me touch one more thing how many people think and just be honest in your seat that hypnosis is kind of baloney okay all right a lot of you this is MIT right okay so I'm gonna tell you that I don't think I think a lot of hypnosis the kinds of things were you know if I learned how to hypnotize people then they can all vote for me or something like that right that's not good that's doesn't work and people who are serious about hypnosis will tell you that hypnosis is in the person it's not in the Hypnotizer it's in the person it's not in the Hypnotizer and it turns out that in ways that are not well understood there are some people are highly hypnotizable and some people who are not okay so this is why I think we were suspicious because if we're not we're going like well they must be faking it or pretending or whatever but let me let me tell you what they did and let me see if this convinces you at all as an experiment so they told people sometimes to read those words where it's confusing because you're reading the color of the print and the word is contradictory it slows you down okay they told them imagine those characters our characters in a foreign language that you do not know with the content of the word mess you up for the color of the print no right because if it's a language you don't know it's just stuff and you can just name the okay and they ask them to imagine that now here's what happened for people who are low hypnotizability you can give people questionnaires and they're pretty good at these kinds of measures because they you know they're slowed down by about a tenth of a second per word when the information is contradictory and when they're asked to imagine it's a foreign language it's about the same they're low hypnotizables you can tell them imagine it's a print you don't know it doesn't matter okay here's the high hypnotizable also slow down but when they imagine it's a print in a foreign language they don't know not slow down at all okay so that's behavior that's evidence you know okay and we don't think you can fake it because how would you fake it but here in case you were still worried about that here's the brain imaging evidence from just that people with high hypnosis the high hypnotizable people here's what you see here turned on is the part of our brain areas are turned on when you have to do the difficult task or it's contradictory versus the easy task okay all this area you see turned on and the anterior cingulate and especially which is an area that we know is involved with things are contradictory or paradoxical people are sorting it out look what happens to that when these individuals are imagining it's a foreign text it's pretty much gone okay so I I'm as skeptical as anybody about behavioral claims I really am I think hypnosis is real for some people and very powerful for some people and for other people it doesn't work at all I happen to be in the low hypnotizable category okay but I think there's I'm you know I'm as skeptical as anybody but I think there are people who can do remarkable things by hypnotic suggestion but it's in them it's not in the a person who hypnotizes you so to speak can help you a little bit but it's in you whether you have that approach to control of your thoughts or not okay so let's go back to to a test so I'm gonna we're gonna plug in again of us there's two ideas that there's things that top-down and bottom-up processes and and different things ways that you can attend to the world so I'm gonna ask you to consult your own intuitions for the following thing I'm gonna show you things on the thing on the displays on the monitor and your job is simply to answer in your own mind as quickly as you possibly can maybe just if you want to do it aloud let's just say yes or no aloud okay if you're going to do it as quickly as you can whether you see a red X sometimes there's a red X sometimes not so ready no okay sorry that's just that's my get ready no great see MIT is easy sorry get ready red X or not great ready no okay Thank You Ida right ready right X or not whoa you guys are amazing now look how many places you have to look to find it but it didn't feel that way or did it seem to what they call it pop out it's just obvious it's just there okay so imagine I gave you this this task I said go into this room and please get a particular book and you go into the room and there's one book there and you picked it up would that be easy yeah you go into a room and you go my gosh there's hundreds of books in this room would that be easy now here are many many more things to find the red X but your mind instantly easily trivially finds it right okay so now let's try another version of this yes okay get ready all right slower harder okay some disagreement okay all right so let me show you data under well controlled conditions and here's the concept people think that in many ways when we look out in the world there's features things like simple things shape or color those are the two we're looking at here but in order to combine those two no the same thing out there has this shape and this color to glue together features we have to have attention and so when the display look like this a single feature redness helps you okay a singer feature redness helps you don't have to worry about the shape now you have to worry about the shape and the color to decide the red X worse yet alright now you it's it's a slower harder process and when people do this here's exactly what they find if it's just a feature by shape or by color and that alone will tell you the answer you can have one thing a few things and many things and boom your mind instantly discovers it instantly this is how long it takes you to do it but if you have to combine two things together the shape and the color and the very same thing combine those things you need the glue of attention and the more things that are out there they're more your mind has to search search search search until it finally finds it it has to look around and look around and look around to find the answer so some kinds of things in the world we notice without attention features we can look everywhere at once in the display that's how we're so fast things just pop out and the flat slope is the mathematically right it doesn't matter how many things are out there boom you get it right away other things where we have to glue together two features require us our attention to do the glueing things that are together we have to search spot spot spot see really we don't feel the intuition of pop out and we have a steep slope in search ok now I need somebody from the chair who's pretty confident in their math but it's it's it's a little bit harder than before but I'll tell you you don't have to go into triple digits oh yeah I owe you one okay I'll come back to you if there's one more I can't remember sir okay okay ready you can see some numbers and I want you to add them and tell me what they are and I'm going to be pretty fast is that okay desaad achtung yes okay all right ready yes ready' yes' ready' yes' ready' yes now what would the letters become sorry it's a trick it would have been mean sir very interesting okay now you can go all that was a trick how reasonable is that well let me make the argument that in order to add the 5 and the 8 you had to look at the letters you had to look at the letters in the middle okay but because your mind is not attuned to that it's as if they weren't there almost you know something's there right okay it's right in front of you it doesn't seem that hard but again if your mind is tuned to something the other stuff gets fuzzy and okay and you got the R right somewhere okay let me ask one more color one more question do you know that colors the letters were no that's that and in fact you don't so so thanks very much for we're going to do that so again we just said to bind shape and color we need the glue of attention we're not attending to the middle letters they seem irrelevant you and though the right in front of us even though we have to walk through them in our minds eye to move from one number to the other they're like I don't care right boom you move to the other side so it's not just seeing something it's attending to something that really matters and on top of that you need a lot of attention if you do glue together the shape and the color that requires a lot of focus what does this mean in everyday life okay and everyday life we're probably walking around constantly having free-floating features around us and things we're not paying attention to you know right now I'm probably seeing like a yellow computer over there and I'm seeing you know some blue fire extinguisher sign over there all right now why am I not freaked out by that and why are you not freaked out by that and why is it almost certain because if you're not attending to things you're constantly having free-floating features that are incorrect colors and shapes are just floating around you why are we not disturbed by that because we're not attending it to start with okay because it's like you didn't notice the letters were there but then you're not bothered they're just refloating information you're not paying attention to start with but that's what's happening in your mind all the time and these experiments demonstrated empirically indirectly there's also interesting temporal constraints so let me tell you I'll describe this experiment cuz it's too hard to cool off here so there's a phenomenon called the attentional blink is that what's weird about these things right I mean why is our minds like this and you know you can speculate in that but it's really well documented we attend to a small percentage of what's around us and we need a lot of resources to know something well or learn something well so here's another example what they see where participants see is letters presented very quickly one after the other e LH their job is to report any numbers that they sees go you go boom um um um um what were the numbers okay pretty fast but humanly possible the interesting question is what's the time gap between the two numbers that you see there's usually two numbers we'll call this one the first one top time one is the second one time two what's the gap between them and how does that influence whether you're likely to report them so here's here's what's called the attentional blink and a slightly scary graph but I'll tell you okay and let me tell you what it's like the metaphor and then let me show you the result the metaphor is this your mind moment to moment to moment it's kind of like if you you can imagine you're next to a stream a big stream with a lot of fish zooming by you have a fish net you dip into the stream you'll catch something at that moment but if a fish comes by just as you pull the your fish net out will you catch that one no okay so here's what happens that here's the time between the the computer between the presentation if there's approximately three numbers between them you know a couple hundred milliseconds you're almost a chance for the possibility of reporting the second digit it's sort of like the fish you can't catch because you just took your net out except it's not it's your mind it's not a physical limitation so here's what it's like so this is perfect performance this is chance performance if it immediately follows one number immediately follows the next number you're going to get both and the way to think about that is it's kind of like the fishnet again right you just put it in your fishnet you got one fish and if you're lucky while you're kind of pulling it out the next fish that swims in there you got two right okay now your fish nets out and if something else comes and something else comes and something else comes you're pretty bad at recognizing it was there at all a little bit of time comes back and you put your fish in it back in and you're catching everything again about a half second but how we understand that your mind works like that for spotting the digits that it has to take a break there's a part of your mind that's getting the digits and once it's gotten a digit for the next couple of hundred milliseconds it's not gonna have room to pay attention to the following digits how weird is that okay it's because our mind has these all these kind of limitations on what we perceive in the environment here's another sort of fun example of that okay so here's it here's a task one of these dots are going to one dot is going to blink and your job is to keep your eye on that dot you know when they fake to keep your eye on the ball keep your eye on the dot and when it stops moving notice which is the one you've been keeping your eye on so the first one's gonna be easy but it'll give you a feeling and then you'll see the answer given to you ready so people call this object tracking okay here we go see the one blinking now let's try one thing moving but even faster you so now stretch let's start tracking before things last example you so here's a graph with a high level of performance how people do so two things matter and you might have felt that how many you're viewing the number of targets and under many circumstances people seem to be able to do about three to four but also the speed matters - you might have felt that this both things contribute there's a lot of interest in this three to four limit that people seem to have four things that they track three to four items and there's a lot of work at Harvard actually in developmental psychology and related and we just say a word about that to you there's a thought that pretty young when you're a kid you get to about this three to four things that our minds naturally contract about notice or keep a count of about three to four things in the world and so people who study for example a math in the way that humans perform it think that we have in us in our brains approximately two systems that are physically different and culturally different one of them being and there's lots of debates about this I should tell you this but one of them being something like accurate counting up to about three or four and then cultures that don't have a organized system of math the next answer is many you've heard this right it's like one two three maybe four and then a lot now we don't stop counting at four but we might if we were in a true state of nature and we didn't have an organized system of math and weren't taught that and how it relates to our language abilities so there's a lot of debate about the exactness of this but there's something fascinating about this idea that our minds can have about four units of information kept in mind kept active that we can track and that lots of things in the world you know reflect that limitation including for example exact counting and without the cultural invention of mathematics we would count one two three four Lots okay but there's debates about this because exactly how you measure it can influence how you think about it now can attention be trained could you be trained to have much more attention so in many ways we don't think you can but in some ways you can and part of this has come out of this ironic line of research about things that are supposed to be bad for us some of them might be okay for us video games okay if you know if you're in my general people are going oh boy those video games are messing up all these kids and it's isn't that what you guys think no okay okay so definitely at Rochester has done a series of studies showing that if you play certain kinds of video games you actually do expand your attentional capacity through practice on those games because they make you practice a lot so here's what she did she took people who didn't have experience playing video games and now we're specifically talking about first-person shooter video games okay and had them do 30 hours of practice okay and she looked at their ability to do multiple object tracking of the kind you just saw those dots move whizzing around okay before and after so the games as you know are very different but they involve keeping tracks of lots of things happening at once and here's what she found that these people who you know played 30 hours these were people who are not gamers beforehand you know got better at performing these tasks of keeping track of multiple objects of all things a group that's super interested in that is the military and why do you think that is okay there was just a paper published recently if that if they take a brain image of your brain that can predict how good a gamer you'll become if you haven't been a gamer before okay these are adults okay if you have bigger basal ganglia you'll become a better gamer in the next week all right if we're starting from scratch the military is interested cuz you may know this at an increasing amount of warfare is video game-like which is a kind of a haunting thing because there's real people really being killed okay but do you know that the whole thing with the drones have you followed this and some of you okay so in the US has had a lot of success and there's a lot of debates about the ethics of this and sending in unmanned small airplanes into the Middle East and using that to kill opponents all right the person sitting in Washington DC or somewhere else is watching kind of like a video game when they make that decision about whether that's somebody to be attacked all right so a lot of operations now are computer based and they're kind of like a video game at one level they're real life hard decisions at another level so video games you know they're becoming more and more as you can sense a part of real-world decisions and controls if you play Tetris because it doesn't require that kind of fast thought stuff you don't get any benefit there could be other benefits but not this one all right so it's very it's not just video games it's the mental processes that are practiced in the video games that give you certain talents or not the abilities you didn't have before okay the last experiment I tell you is this so everything we've talked about now except a little bit about the stuff in the second year when you're shadowing has been about has been about this idea that we you know don't pay you don't pay much attention to what's around us we don't get much in our mind compared to what we think we would even if it's right in front of us if you notice is all over the place even if we've seen a penny 17,000 times but there are some studies that have shown something pretty interesting also which is you know reveal something very paradoxical about the human mind that we can sometimes know things without seeing or and people call that subliminal perception so how these experiment works as this and let me show you one example behaviorally I'm gonna show you one brain example so here's what happens let's pretend you have to read words aloud and we measure to the millisecond how fast to read the word if I show you this word and I show you this word and I measure how quickly you read the word doctor you're slower then if you read the worse the word nurse and then you read the word doctor okay because these two are related and something in your mind gets warmed up when you see this it doesn't get warmed up in a relevant way when you see this where does that make sense okay you see one word and you read the next one if they're related semantically or conceptually by meaning you're faster for the second one okay that's easy it's not too surprising the clever discovery was this what they do is they do something called they present to these words under what they call masked conditions on the computer monitor you get something busy like a row of X's for ten milliseconds only ten thousandth of a second the word appears and then there's a bunch of X's again so it's like a flash of X's okay and people they create situations and I'll show you this again in a moment they create situations where people say I'm not sure anything was there I certainly don't know what it is you have to be there and you have to convince yourself as a scientist that you've done that all right and then they have you read the word doctor in full view and in these circumstances where people cannot tell you that they saw a word and they certainly can't tell you what the word was you still get faster so they don't know that they saw church or nurse but something in their mind picks it up and what's picked up in the mind under the subliminal presentation changes the behavior when you have an overt act of behavior reading the next word aloud so this is you know in hardcore empirical evidence that your mind is able to pick up stuff at the level of meaning so think about the paradox you think when I read a word I see it and then I understand its meaning right here it's flashed in such a way that you don't feel like you see it but you extract its meaning anyway then we know that because it makes you read the next word faster only if they're related in meaning so your mind is subliminally primed now some years ago people used to worry that advertisers could do this really cleverly and make you go do stuff the famous examples historically can they make you buy popcorn which is now since it's 48 dollars right it's harder to do but can they make you buy popcorn you know the movie theater you know or or you know can they make you buy a Ford or a Chevrolet or something like that with the right subliminal message and that kinds of stuff every experiment that's been done to ask whether subliminal messages of this kind would make you get up and go do something like buy a car you know or change what country you live in or something it never works okay it never works okay nobody's ever been able to show the debt in any experimental condition which doesn't prevent some companies from selling these products to store owners or thinking they're getting their their sales up right but there's been never any evidence that these kinds of subliminal presentations make people do something big and complicated like get up and go buy popcorn or choose one product over another people have never been able to show that under controlled experiments but they have been able to show these kinds of changes in behaviors at last the moments that last a moment so what's happening in your brain so this is the last experiment again they're presenting these things that you know in the same place in the computer monitor all these things to keep fill your eyes and then they present a word for either twenty nine milliseconds that pretended either very briefly or in full view okay so here's visible you have because they remove the confusing visual information just before and after it here people don't report seeing it and scientifically it's really important to you just say oh people didn't see it but it's really important in our field to say we're so convinced and why are we so convinced because we say was there any word present because sometimes there's a word present and sometimes there isn't just is there a word present if you could see the word because these things were a little bit away in time and you couldn't see it you almost always got it if it was visible you almost never got it it was here right you almost never said there was a word presence um and and uh could you name it yes if you saw it like this you couldn't name it if it was presented brief it was surrounded by this visual stuff that makes it hard to see if they give you a memory test for it if you saw it fully you in full view you got it if it was hidden like this you didn't and finally they give you forced choice they say did you see the word note or did you see the word coat choose between the two people are still a chance fifty-fifty okay so the I mean feel out there really pushing people to say really did you see anything do you know what it wasn't in there completely a chance they don't remember anything they can't even tell if a word was there but we know it influences their mind and now let me show you what we know of how it influences your brain so what's shown here in green are parts of your brain that respond when a word is shown that you can see and what's shown here in red are the parts of your brain that respond for that subliminally presented word the word that's presented but you can't tell that any word was there never mind what word it was so first you can see there's a lot more brain response for the visible than the mast or subliminal word that makes a lot of sense you see something you think about it you know it happened but you can measure what's happening in the brain it's very small take this spot here's the response if it's in full view here's a tiny tiny tiny tiny response when it's presented in that minimalist way but it's measurable and it's present and we know that it's enough for you to figure out unconsciously what the meaning of that word was so then you know we enter with this paradox which is on the one hand you know we live in a world where we only notice a small fraction of what's around us what we focus our attention to because we have limited attentional capacity on the other hand there are channels of information that sneak into your mind that probably influence you only for a few moments in the unattended ear and the cocktail party you're actually picking up that conversation because if they say your name you'll get it here here's an example of where your brain is responding to a word you cannot identify or know that it was presented and those things can slightly move your behavior around but not in a science fiction or marketing dream that they could make you go do something really big okay that's never been shown and people have tried to show that so attention is really weirder than you think right you don't notice a lot of stuff but a few things you don't think are influencing you are influencing you here in there all the time thanks very much