Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu last time we talked about attention and the idea that attention has got some properties we're very limited in what we can focus on uh we we attend to less than we might guess in our environment on the other hand there are channels of information that sneak into US unconsciously or with minimal attention and that experimental research has kind of shown us what requires our focused attention to be noticed and what can sneak in through uh Pathways s things like features in our environment and so I want to talk to you today about two uh kinds of spectacular disorders of attention and and and and higher level Vision uh and insights that give us into the brain bases of attention and again the message is how much we construct by the rules of our mind and brain the environment that we see around us so we'll talk about blind sight that's a great name the paradoxical state that people are cortically blind but they kind of perceive some things we'll talk about that what is it what do we know about it's a brain basis what system of unconscious perception might occur you know be in our brains uh in these patients is their only visual system uh in you and I it's something in us and we don't know exactly what it's doing relative to our conscious visual system but we have the same brain system available to us and then neglect what it is it's brain basis and how it teaches us again how we construct the world around us to know what space we're in and what's around us um so a reminder and I think you know this well by now that the world out there divided into a left and right visual field as we look forward in the middle that the information from the left visual field goes through your brain and ends up shown in the right primary visual cortex from the right visual field into your left primary visual cortex uh but there's one other pathway we haven't talked about very much which goes to your a structure called The Superior calculus it's part of your midbrain and it's what the system we think gives rise to the possibility of sensation without perception that phrase sensation without perception is a good one to describe blind sight and we'll describe it in a moment so from your retina where all Vision has to go through uh a little bit of information a small number of fibers go to a part of your brain that controls your pupilary reflexes you know what makes your pupil get wider or smaller to see uh 90% of the fibers coming you know nerve fibers that that come from your eye and go through the latog geniculate uh uh are through the major system that you heard about from Melissa that connect to your primary visual cortex and then there's one other small visual pathway from Tina to this Superior ccul sometimes called the techn pulva or system so it's a small pathway from your eyes in terms of the number of f nerve fibers and so people said well can we say what's not done by the major visual pathway that goes from from the eye to the cortex What's Done by this other small pathway and one of the ways I looked at originally all the way back in 1881 was to create in dogs by lateral occipital lesions so now they're cortically blind they're not retinally blind they're cortically blind it's in the cortex and what can these animals do and they were very impressed although these animals didn't recognize many things they could steer their way around their environment they wouldn't bump into things if you had a blindfold on or if you were retinally blind and weren't given any opportunity to know your environment you would bump into things right but these animals seem to steer their way around things pretty well um and they can do some other very simple tasks even even though they they ought to have been seeing nothing so this is a suggestion in animals that there's something in the brains of primates that gives you some information that doesn't go through your conscious cortex and then uh a number of patient studies uh in patients with naturally occurring injuries have really shown us given us a chance to experiment on them in a human and relate them to Human Experience so here's a patient who had a large injury a large bleed um in the right visual cortex so because of this this patient this man was blind in the left visual field this field was fine this field was blind cortically blind um and the way that people figure out in what way are you blind what parts of the world do you see and do you not see is they'll put you in front of a computer monitor and they'll turn on lights in various locations and they'll create a map like this which shows you where you respond when a light comes on and where you don't do it so your job basically you just look in the middle and you say push a button when a light comes on so you're waiting and light comes on somewhere on the monitor so with this picture is showing you so the person could respond when the lights came on anywhere on the left side but never responded never said a light came on on the right side people call this perimetry it's it's it's it's a standard neurological test of visual difficulty here's a person whose injury harms only a quadrant of their visual thing so they never respond when a light turns on in that quarter of the world out there but the other three quarters they respond to so that's a way of testing what do you do you're not asking them anything sophisticated just did a light come on is that okay so for this patient here's the mapping this patient was fine in the right visual field this is one eye this is the other eye and terrible with a few spots a little bit better because lesions occurring naturally in people are seldom perfect lesions but you can see that all this area that's dark are areas that when a light came on in the left visual field this man never responded that anything had turned on there's nothing simpler right than light turning on and off he did not experience anything turning on in that way in the left half of the world so um uh uh but they noticed as they gave this test that even he was saying I don't see anything nothing's happening that when they flashed something in that blind cortically blind field he would sort of move his eyes in that direction all right as if something in his mind and brain felt something had happened not only something happened roughly where it happened but that information was not available to his conscious mind he's never pushing a button that he says he saw it he always says nothing I'm waiting for something to come on and then if it comes on his a good field he responds does that make sense okay so but something seemed to do it and what they found then it was better than chance in the left visual field he about things like if they put on a bigger patch of light he could tell if you got a gave him a short line or a long line now he would never say I see the line you would have to make him make a guess so the you know when you read the papers it's something like I don't see anything I don't see anything well you must guess is it a short line or a long line I don't there's no basis for me to guess it'll be a completely random guess but you know you must guess okay short or long and then if the lines are far enough apart in size he's almost 100% 97% accurate okay if he's forced to guess but he never has the experience that he sees a line he's just forced to guess and told that it's two lines or he can judge things like is it is it a circle or a cross is it an X or an O but he can't do something like a square versus a rectangle it's very limited subjectively he always feels he sees nothing if he's given two choices he's for some things he can make the correct choice if he's forced to make a guess um and there's another there's other sophisticated ways again to show that even though he's unconscious of anything in his blind field something in his mind and brain is processing information there so here they had a thing where he pushed a button when a light came on this is his good field and it takes him on average 359 millisecond okay now they do the same thing this is his good field but they put on at the same time a light in his blind field and when they do that his time goes up by about a tenth of a second as if the distraction in the blind field was slightly distracting him from making that button press so another objective way of demonstrating that some information is being processed in the blind field even though he never says he feels like something's happening there um so here's an one more patient and the last one I I'll show you of this kind who uh had the unfortunate uh occurrence of having two strokes one in the left occipital cortex and one in the right occipital cortex uh about um 36 days apart okay so now he was blind in both Fields by the time he had had both of his Strokes so he had a very unlucky person here in dark is the missing cortex that is died away um now always the problems with humans is uh the injuries are are not controlled and and precise and so here's two examples one one in in monkeys an incredibly clever experiment to get a monkey to tell you what he or she is thinking about okay and then one with infants as well human infants I how do you get a monkey to talk to you about their subjective experience right the Striking thing about blindsight is the person is saying I see nothing I see nothing I see nothing even as he walks past obstacles with precision and carefulness right uh so here what they did is they took monkeys and made unilateral lesions in them one there's a control monkey and three where they surgically removed you know as precisely as they could the left occipital visual cortex and the Corpus colossum that connects to the left and the right and the first task and I'll show you in a moment was to touch a light when it comes on and the second half is the clever design to get the monkey to tell you what he or G sub he or she subjectively feels is going on so here's the here's here's the video they would make of the monkey and in one case here's the light coming on so the monkeys had left removal so this is The Blind Side here's These Bars show you how often they Point correctly to a light going on and under this circumstance forced to point forced to point uh here's the control animal animal and you can see that the animals Who blind in in this field do almost perfectly when they're forced to point they pick almost perfectly which stimulus comes on in the blind field okay now let's they add one one more thing to the experiment they have a number of lights on on on the uh good side here is a response that they can push to signal I saw nothing and if they truly saw nothing they get the juice reward you know for which they're working for okay but there's a light that can come on here in the Brad fields on the right side now what happens here's the control monkey doing perfectly well for lights on this side lights on this side and when nothing is happening pushing this bar to signal that nothing is happening sometimes no light comes on so now the monkeyy allowed to say I see nothing by pushing this big panel up here if nothing seems to have turned on but look what happens to the monkeys with the with the cortical uh lesions on the left when this light comes on they almost never say they saw it they almost always push I saw nothing when they're allowed to say I saw nothing by the response then even though this thing that you know they can see because you see here they're responding perfectly well over here but when they're allowed to sort of consciously respond what they see then these black bars are all the way down they almost never indicate they saw something they almost always pick the response I saw nothing okay so the monkeyy is telling you what is subject objective experiences which is like the humans with the cortical lesions they're reporting they see nothing okay even though um some part of their brain can pick it up how about in humans well so sometimes humans children infants uh for medical reasons have to have hemispherectomies in the first year these are unfortunate infants who have a severe brain injury severe epilepsy and is considered better to help them by removing an entire hemisphere than to let to have the severity of the epilepsy they're having so a R cases have very unfortunate infants uh and in these infants who got this for purely medical reasons to make their lives uh better they also did an experiment to show you something not only about uh I think get what happens in our conscious visual system but how that system grows in infancy so uh and and the growth of a conscious cortical visual system so here's what they did um infants this young because they're in their first year can't even point and you can't tell them to point right so again you have to be clever experimentally and what they did is they watched where their eyes moved and recorded that information and that was the behavior sometimes they would have a a fixation they would always have a fixation you're looking in the middle and then something would come on on this side or this side in the blind field or in the intact field okay um and they would see how often with their eyes move to a stimulus in their good field which they expected all the time but how often would it move to the stimulus in the blind field the eye moved movement then they had a competition condition where you have a dot in the middle and that fixation dot would stay on while a box appeared here or here so the only sense the only difference between these two is there's a dot in the middle that can compete for what you look at that makes okay it's very it's not a big competition it's just a boring dot that stays on but there's a big consequence so here's how often they move their eyes to the Target in the non-competition condition the dot goes on it goes off and the Box comes on in your good field or your bad field and all these bars are up at the top and practically every trial at 8 weeks 10 weeks and 12 weeks of age the infant moves his or her eyes to the stimulus whether it's in the blind field or the good field so something in their mind and brain is letting them identify something and move their eyes to the good field much like we talked about before for for the adults now in the competition condition you can already see it's not quite the same if there's a DOT on and the box comes on their blind field they don't always make it to the box that dot is sort of capturing their conscious cortical attention and diminishing the likelihood they notice the box coming on in the blind field and as the weeks pass from 8 to 10 to 12 just a month of development look what happens this bar goes from a little lower a lot lower near zero that is from 8 to 12 weeks what it looks like is happening is that as the cortical system matures and the infants Consciousness is growing in some sense um now it's no longer tending to process the information in the blind field if there's competition right because the growth of that Consciousness uh in the cortex is suppressing unconscious the the ability of the infant to communicate with unconscious systems or be guided by unconscious systems in the brain so the cool thing is the implication of this is all of us have uh you know this calicular system in us uh it's a visual system that's been around Long through Evolution uh all of us have this massive conscious uh uh genicular the one that goes into your cortex system and that dominates this other system and so you know we only see it revealed uh in these patients as as guiding Behavior but you know who knows what it really does in us okay because it's sort of quietly sitting there we don't have conscious access to it and who knows how much is guiding our behavior and it's very hard to figure that out um but but is definitely sort of disappearing from our conscious life uh within the first couple of months of our development so now I'm going to switch to uh the second major disorder we'll talk about um attention and neglect and go through uh anosia spectacular version of that disorder uh some about how it's behaviorally measured its brain basis uh and then a few more analyses but in the book there's a very nice uh chapter about these patients now patients with blindsight are extremely rare you have to have exactly the right kind of engine you know to have to damage a lot of your occipital CeX uh uh and those kinds of injuries rarely occur on that scale um attention and neglect what I'm about to describe to you if any of you become Physicians or work in hospital settings you guarant to see guaranteed to see this a lot okay a lot it's very very common um uh for patients who have had things like stroke or brain injuries of some kind or and a pretty typical example is from Oliver sax most of the sax cases are pretty rare prosia pretty rare neglect incredibly common in the hospital award in neurology service so here he talks about a woman an intelligent woman in her 60s massive stroke affecting deeper inner Beck bushes of a right cerebral hemisphere good intelligence and humor and what happens to her when they bring her her dessert or coffee on her tray in the hospital yeah she complains that she's not getting enough food because is only eating food on the right half of her plate okay the left half of the plate it's as if it weren't present for her when they say but Mrs S it is right there on the left she seems not to understand what they say and does not look to the left if her head is gently turned so the dessert comes into sight in the preserved right half of her field she says oh there it is it wasn't there before you understand you know it's is if the left half of the plate did not exist and if they swivel her head and now that left half of her plate is in her right field okay now she goes oh my gosh who snuck that on my plate and now I can finish my meal okay and it's not just that she also only puts on uh makeup on half her face looking in her mirror which can lead to comical you know uh uh Impressions okay so it's not she not she ignores the left half of her world and it's not just that it isn't there it's as if it couldn't be there it's as if like what are you talking about there's a left half of something you know I see everything okay so we'll talk a little about this and understand more of it coming up so neglect means is a failure to resport respond or report to something uh that's opposite to the lesion contralateral means opposite to the lesion that can't be accounted for by Simple Things these patients don't have primary visual problems they not they understand language they're paying attention they're the ones who deny the left half of their body uh they dress on one side they eat from one side of the plate and they also have something that I'll show you in a moment the example of because it's it comes back a couple times and this sounds fancy but it's simple there's Extinction to double Sim ous stimulation seen in the late stages so uh here's what the neurologist does and you'll see at least one neurologist doing this in a film clip coming up and and they do this all the time in the hospital they'll wiggle little fingers they'll try to get in the middle of the patient this isn't carefully control it's done on the bedside they'll wiggle one side and say do you see anything moving or the other side and sometimes they wiggle both and the typical respon and neglect is is is already fascinating so past the earliest stages of the disorder they'll notice a thing on the left side that's their from their perspective that's their neglected side they'll notice it on the right side that's their good side okay they're noticing this fingure wiggling they're noticing that figure wiggling but when the physician Wiggles both fingers at the same time uh then the the patient will only notice the one on the good side it's as if this is extinguished because this one grabs your attention okay and you know they could see it by itself so uh it's only when it's both sides then it's distinguished and we'll come back to that so it's kind of interesting it's not that their mind can't see it but when there's competition in the two fields which reminds you a little bit of the blindsight then their mind can't see it so a strong a fascinating and rare piece of this but again not not very rare is something called anosognosia where they not only have the neglect uh that I just described but they have um they deny any problem at all so typically these are patients with big right lesions uh 5% of neglect cases and uh a very fascinating neuroscientist you may have read some of his stuff it's he's a very creative mind uh rash Shandra UCSD uh did some semi experiments with some of these patients uh so these are patients with right-sided lesions um so they have weakness or non-use of their left hand and so here's his dialogue with them can you use your right hand and that patient's hand is fine yes can you use your left hand yes and the patient can't use her left hand hand are your hands equally strong yes can you point to my nose with your right hand and she does her right hand is fine can you point to my nose with your left hand the paralyzed left hand it's a left hand because there's a right hemisphere stroke does not move at all are you pointing to my nose yes can you clearly see it pointing yes it's about two inches from your nose can you clap of course I can clap and here's what she does you know okay are you clapping yes I'm clapping okay she can't move her left side but in every way in this patient reports she seems to deny in a deep sense uh that there's any problem in her performance or any weakness of any kind so uh he he wanted to do a couple little experiments to to show that um uh uh that uh you know that it's not just that they're saying it but they'll follow all the way through so imagine uh that you had injured your your left arm was in a cast and somebody asked you I'm going to give you two choices I'm going to give you $5 to screw in a light bulb your left arm is in a cast now or $10 to tie your shoelaces which would you take the light bulb right because it's going to be hard to uh tie your shoelaces with one arm out of action this person is the same way she's had a stroke her left arm is not functioning she should definitely take the uh you know definitely take the light bulb she takes the shoelaces and it's when the physician Rand describes as she sits there with one hand trying to flop the laces together together making no progress at all okay he says finally he has to end the exercise he can't take it anymore she she'll just keep going you know until right so so it so she's in she just doesn't process that her left side of her body is not working and then he does another experiment more impressive um I can use one of these I think okay uh so imagine um uh uh this was a tray of cocktail glasses full of water let's say to a very brim imagine there's three here and three six things right you could you're right at the top and you're like you're just hoping that the person bring it to you doesn't spill it on you and the person brings it over to you um uh actually filled with water and asks a patient to hold the tray okay can I pick on you for one second imagine you had only uh uh uh H how would you how would you hold a tray if one arm was unavailable for you okay I'm ringing this over okay it's like yeah the water's like very exciting there water yes okay all right uh how would you head if two hands were available to you okay thank you okay right you could it's easy for you to imagine how you would hold it they walk over to the patient with all stuff they hand it to her and what does the patient do she puts out her right hand on the right side and the whole thing Falls over all right they're trying to demonstrate that that you know it goes all the way through this person really believes there's not a problem and they can be dowed in water for a moment and I'm sure dried appropriately uh and still deny that there's any problem at all um now one thing they can do and this is kind of a weird line of research but there's a number of papers that show this is if they put and I'm not recommending you do this at home because actually it's guess worse than it sounds like uh that they take a syringe with cold water and they put it into the left ear the images here the patient's AR starts to move they get nagus and they ask them if they feel how do they feel and then she says my ear is very cold but other than that I'm fine okay so she now she but they've sort of given her a little bit of a shock in the left ear and now he does the interesting experiment uh do you feel okay she says her ear is cold can you use your hands at this moment when they've sort of done something in the left ear that sort of wakes up the opposite right hemisphere I can use my right arm but not my left arm I want to move it but it doesn't move this happens just in a moment from the cold syring in a whose arm is this holding up the paralyzed arm it's mine of course can you use it no it's paralyzed like what kind of doctor do I have right it's paralyzed of course now here's something really fun uh in a Sherlock holmesian sense how long has your arm been paralyzed that it start just now because what he's asking is does she have a memory somewhere in her mind of her entire experience or does she say it's just started write down I don't know how this happened it's just not working and she says it's been paralyzed for several days now about 90 minutes later when they redo this she's back to just how she was so they can temporarily alleviate this uh by this irrigation to the ear um so this the denial of of sort of the left half of your body this denial that you have any disorder whatsoever is a very striking thing in most patients it clears up this is not you saw pictures of from Melissa you saw movies of patients with object disorders those don't clear up balent syndrome spatial disorders those don't clear up uh uh this anosognosia patients grow out of as somehow their brains recover over time um but again it shows you how much attention is constructed right because they have the stuff to represent their arm their disease that's all in their mind and brain uh but the state they're in because of the brain injury uh lets them not construct that reality so now I'm going to show you measures of neglect this is your list just for your notes but it's sort of fun just to look at the examples so here's a patient with these patients are typically have right-sided lesions so the neglect is to the left half of the world and here's a patient going to the bathroom as if all you can do is make right turns okay instead of going this way as if the world weren't there to proceed on the left here's another task that happens every day in a hospital they're given the physician has drawn these lines and says cross out the lines it's not perfect the patient does that one but look at they cross out all these lines and they the left half ones are mostly left uncrossed it's as if they weren't there um here's a what's called a cancellation task there's lots of letters here and their job is to cross out all the A's um now let me start with a neglect you see over here this whole area nothing is circled or crossed out and you could say well what would happen if instead of neglect you were like one of those Blind Side patients you had a big lesion in the cortex and you were blind on one side what would you do there well it's easy for those patients because what they do is they don't see part of the world but what do they do they turn their head okay just like you would do right they turn their head okay they don't see it but they know they don't see it and they turn their head and a patient who's blind on one side lost in the visual field gets all the line say all you have to do if you're blind on one side is turn your head okay it's not that hard uh in a PR IAL sense but if you don't imagine the left half of the world exists where would you turn your head to and that's what these NE patients don't imagine the left half of the world exists so here's a example of a patient reading a text they're handed this text the broken the slash lines here are where this patient seems to think the left side of the page stops okay so they're overcoming everything they know about how a sentence should be and reading this passage the patient says had to pass the windows whom good morning message for the ground his with all his and he bottle thank you very much okay it's right in front of him uh but you know the left half of the page is is just not present for this person's mind here is a person copying a flower the psychologist or neurologist draws this flower has a flower ready to go drawing and says copy everything you see it's not that always totally perfect exactly how it works but you could see you know there's a lot of the left side of this flower missing right in front front of them uh here a very simple one too copy everything you see here and what they see is these three things up here they're job is to copy everything down here they have all the time they want left side is neglected and all they copy is the triangle that's all they draw and the the tester will always say are you done are you sure you're done the person says I'm sure I'm done thank you very much sometimes they do something remarkable they're shown a scene like this here's four trees in a house in the middle and you can see this patient is sort of you know starts over here and say oh there's a tree over here draw us this oh there's a house over here and they jump from location to location every time their attention lands they draw the right half of it okay it's always as if the left piece we missing and again this idea how constructed this is um here's two more examples and the clock thing we'll talk a fair bit about here's a patient writing to dictation the first sentence they sort of stay but now it's as if they were running out of room on the page it's like the reading but it's writing okay the left half of the page doesn't exist clocks are used a lot in this line because it's kind of impressive and we'll come back in a couple different versions about this but look at that they were asked to draw the time on a clock and it's as if they could draw the time on the right side their good side but as if the left half of the clock didn't exist here's another patient um asked to draw the time and you you see almost what seems like a uh um uh struggle in the patient right they start on the right side and then here they're running out of space they got a cramp in that 10 their mind knows it goes to 12 right but there's no space to put it in and so you put them in in a sense in a sense of conflict um and that's the top version the bottom they were given numbers uh uh one at a time they were given it tells you here 12 and six so they put those in the right spots Here Comes 11 already 11 is like uh oh right you know uh and then and then they get you know four nine you know nine is not going to make it in 10 you know they know it has to come after you can see that you put them actually kind of in a in a struggle between what they know the something about where the numbers ought to go but the impossibility of the left half existing but now here's something and we'll come back to this in a few minutes uh what happens if you just give them a piece of paper and say write down one o'clock and then you take that piece of paper away right down two o'clock take that piece of paper away then look six seven eight nine 10 those are not bad right if they just do one of them the very same patient who had to crowd everything on the right is quite comfortable putting a pretty good 9 10 and 11 okay if it's just one of them we'll come back to in a little bit to experiments that sort of help understand what's going on uh in this ex because we don't all want a scientist to say wow this is unbelievable and amazing right we like to say something more about how the mind is doing this um and what part of the brain is important and kind of impressively here's a patient with eyes open mostly crowding on the right got that 10 on the left uh but doing a better job when their eyes are closed they miss the di alt together their eyes are closed but they actually do the same patient does a better job right okay so how does that work um and one more thing to mention is that neglect AC occurs across modalities that is when these patients have neglect I focused on the visual but these patients also uh uh don't do very well if they're doing things like reaching for things it's not just Vision it's pretty much everything in the left half of the world and you can do these kinds of things which again show but not only the neglect but the constructed psychological nature of the neglect it's not it varies in ways that are interesting so they're given a line like this and say Mark the exact middle you would draw something here do I draw here because they're going to neglect that part of the line then they say read the a so you're they so draw the person's attention and now draw it and they get better then they're asked to Mark the middle not too good Mark the middle but you see the difference here the a is present or the B is present and if the B is present and sort of pulls them over here if the a is present sort of pulls their attention over here they put their hand at the middle and say now please mark the middle their hand goes over here for the middle but if they start them all the way over here their hand will only go this far so as you see all these different movements it's telling you that the mind is kind of interpreting what the world is out there you could if you pull a little bit the person to the left they notice a little bit more of the left um where is the injury and uh so almost everywhere you read uh in still in neurology books to this day that it's in the parietal cortex um but in the last few years people have mostly come to this idea that the IM image the damage tends to be in the temporal lobe and what happens when the temperal lobe is injured it sort of knocks off the balance of attention in the left and right parietal cortex and uh the sort of something about the activity in the r parial CeX goes way down that's paying attention to the left half of the world and as patients recover from this the balance come back and that's actually been measured Now by B iming that as their attention comes back clinically and it doesn't patients uh then the the balance between the two parial cores get reestablished so even though people thought the sight of damage was here the interpretation is usually here in the temporal lobe but the consequence of that is reduced activity in this part of the brain even if it's not physically injured so the Fantastic thing is think about this for a second in order to ignore the left half of a flower the left half of a design the left half of a page the left half of a clock what do you have to know where the left and right are it's not as if his eyes were closed if your eyes were closed you wouldn't know where left and right are on a page right he has to represent in his mind what is left and right reasonably accurately and then he extinguishes awareness that anything on the left could exist but part of his mind has to know what is left for that to work right otherwise the digits would be all over the piece of paper not even on the paper you know he centers on the paper he centers on the circle right centering means I know what's left in other words that's the center and then boom the left disappears as a place that could exist so these are all tasks in front of you uh there's been some incredibly you know Sherlock Holmes like clever experiments asking whether you also neglect your imagination not what's in front of you but your imagination so here's the way they did it uh have any of you been in Milan there's okay it's like a central cathedral in part of town right there a big okay deal um and so he took millanes patients people who lived in Milan their whole Lives who had Strokes in the right hemisphere Hood neglect and he asked him to imagine the pza Del Duo the the major Church there looking at it from one side of the square or from entering from the opposite side of the square is that okay right um and then I'll show you the other experiment but here's the idea they said imagine that you're entering the square uh this direction um so that the church is behind you or this Direction so the church is in front of you so you're entering the Square from one side or from the other side now the square that you've been to many times that you know very well tell me everything that's in the Square as you imagine it entering from one side and here's what the patient reports they're imagining coming out facing the church and they report uh uh uh these kinds of things uh from this side if that's only on the right side they're ignoring the thing so they say there's a cafe there's a bookstore or whatever else there is here that's everything that's in the Square everything that's in the Square that's shown in red everything that's in the Square they wait just moments and they say now imagine instead you were coming out from the church right opposite view of the square tell me everything that's in the square and here's what they tell you the items that are in blue and they don't tell you the items they just told you the locations they just told you circled in Red so they're sitting there imagining in their square and then they will ignore everything on their left whatever is their subjective left and you know they know it because all they have to do is Imagine they're the opposite side of the square and then they report it okay does that make sense they're ignoring the left half of what they imagine the square looks like one they've been to many times um and here's another patient doing exactly the same thing uh imagine you're coming out of the church what's in the Square well here's some specific places I know that's it that's it wait a minute imagine you come this way into the square facing the church what do you what's what what's everything in the square and they only report the things uh on this side okay so they're ignore yeah no they never do that's an excellent question they just answered a moment ago one side right why don't they tell you I just told you this stuff on the other side because it's as if it couldn't exist right I mean it's it's a little bit analogous to the patient whose arm isn't moving and you go you know do you have any problem they go no I don't have any problem it's as if the couldn't be a problem you know like what are you talking about right so it overcomes all their knowledge and all their intelligence it's you know it's as if I force you to guess in detail what's in the back of the room if something new is there and you go there's no way there's I can't see in the eyes I have no eyes in the back of my head you know that's what it's sort of like that it's as if the left half couldn't exist the contradiction they could note right just a moment ago I told you the other one they don't notice it because something about this neglect swallows up all your judgments if it's not as it's it's beautifully phrased you know by some neurologists is it's as if the left half could not exist at the whenever you're thinking left it doesn't exist and ironically you have to think left for that to work right you know what I mean that's that's that's the amazing thing you have to go I'm in the middle there's a left there's a right now the left doesn't exist and it couldn't exist and any every hint I get that it does exist like that you know there's food on that side or uh you know the pages usually go all the way here and makes the sentences make sense it all disappears on you because it couldn't possibly exist and the neat thing about that is you know it's striking neurologically but that means in our own heads as we go around we're constructing the world this way you know building up two two sides of our brain that are gluing together a picture of the world around us and these patients lose that glue on one side of their brain is that okay here's another version it's sort of less flashy a bit but it's the same idea now neglect can't get small enough okay if you make something very tiny they you don't ignore the left side but once he gets tiny enough you can't do it so they took advantage of that and they showed cloud-like stimulus of these but they didn't show them like this they only had a slit so you you only saw the cloud a bit at a time and You' see one cloud and then you'd see another Cloud perhaps you'd see this Cloud go by and then you see this Cloud go by and your job was to say were they identical clouds or not and if they were not identical on which side do they differ so because your all your visual experiences through this slit which is too small small for neglect to happen what you do is you create in your mind's eye what does that whole cloud look like as it passed through the slit in your mind's eye and then you see another one and you put that up in your mind's eye and you compare these two things that are in your imagination in your mind's eyes and what happens is if these two things differ on the left side the patients rarely can make that distinction okay it's not because they can't see it it's always in that narrow slit but once they put the pieces together they put it up in their mind the left half disappears on them uh in their mind's eyes so um here's an experimental approach to think about what might be going wrong in these patients so they used a very simple task which is when a light comes on you push a button that's all the task is any light comes on you push a button and sometimes they'll put an arrow and then and sometimes you have no information the light comes on on the left or the right and sometimes they'll put on an arrow in the middle that will warn you whether the light is like likely to come on on the left or the right so sometimes you have neutral things you get across in the middle then the light light comes on you know if to say left and right you just push a button when one of those goes on sometimes he gets an errow that's called valid that 80% of the time if it's pointing this way uh it will turn out on that side 80% it will turn out on this side so 80% of time is honest and 20% of the time is dishonest so here's what it looks like you're looking here on a computer display uh that thing disappears and then either an X is here or here and you push a button that's all or light comes on you just push a button okay that's all it came on on the left or the right I push a button when an arrow appears 80% of the time it's warning you where that light will appear 20% it's dishonest and it appears on the opposite side so you will know how good an experimental psychologist you are right now if I ask you which condition do you think you're the fastest to push the button when you have an arrow that's truly telling you where the light will come on an arrow that's misleading you or the x that tells you nothing which do you think you'll be fastest where the arrow is pointing right like here's the answer over here okay thank you very much all right which do you think you'll be slowest on the dishonest Arrow right the arrow says look over here look over here and you're looking over there oh no it came on the other side you lied to me okay all right and the x is in the middle and here's the data I it's a very simple experiment right how fast are you this is reaction time just to push a button when it comes on here's the neutral condition in the middle you're a little bit faster if it's uh an honest Arrow you're a little bit slower if it's a dishonest misleading Arrow so now you do this exact experiment um and I'll show you the data and then I'll simplify it for you okay uh with patients who um have right-sided damage left side of neglect and you can see as you look at these lines that the arrow can be honest or dishonest and it can be in the left or right side now if you were always bad on the on the neglected side you go well that's not a big surprise but here's a surprise patients were only bad the the times were way up here only when they had a dishonest arrow that sent them into their good side that's when they were really bad so let's take a look at this again so here's the bad side here's the good side when an arrow comes on that's honest good when an arrow comes on that's an honest Arrow this way uh they do fine that's their bad field but they do fine tiny bit slower but just a tiny bit Arrow comes on that moves them into their bad field but it's really the lightest on here they do fine but if an arrow sends them into their good field then they're really really slow to get back here so posers argue that when you move your attention in the world you have three steps you have to do you have to disengage your attention from where you're paying attention just logically I'm paying attention here right now I'm going to pay attention over here I have to pull myself up from here move my attention over here and then Focus here so disengage you know get out from where you are move to where you need to go and land and focus what you want to do and the only condition where they're bad is where they have to get their attention out of the good field as if once they're in that good field once their mind is landed in that good field they're in quick sand and it's going to be really hard to get their attention to move into the bad field so think about this clocks are perfect for this because when you draw a clock mostly think about this intuitively if I was to ask you to draw the numbers on a clock you start with a 12 typically then what's the next one you would draw one because that's how we're taught to do clocks disaster if you have neglect you know you're in the good field right now the left half of the clock has disappeared on you and you got it because the clock has made you land your attention on the good field and now you can't pull out of it okay but what happened if you only have to draw 8:00 your attention never got moved into the good field it's just starting from middle so to speak and this this very same patient can draw the 8 o'clock or 10 o'clock pretty well does that make sense because they never got stuck in the good field they only moved into the bad field they can move into the bad field and and so uh so and if their eyes are closed that's better they get less stuck and now we understand this thing why is it these patients if both fingers are moving because once they is drawn into the good field it's as if the bad field disappeared on them but if they only get stimulated uh in the bad field right side here then uh they're okay because they never paid that much attention to the good field so they can't so this is a nice experiment it shows you what is the problem the problem is once you're paying attention to the good field the normal healthy field it's so powerful compared to the weakened representation here that you never leave it because it just seems like everything um now here's a here's a here's a clever one again this shows you how much of attention is created by our minds uh uh uh as opposed to just simply defined by the environment so what if you show a display to somebody with neglect and then rotate the display right in front of them okay uh so initially the neglect is going to be on the left side but imagine the thing is turning over like this right in front of them will the neglect travel with the initial assignment so this is from Marlin burn a very clever experiment they have to pay attention as the light comes on here or here but what they do is while the experiment's going on right in front of you it slowly rotates over to here and sure enough then the light comes on sure enough the neglect now moves into the good field because once you've assigned left and right you know this is left so okay you turn it over that's still really left okay the but think how weird that is the mind is deciding that in an absolute sense this thing is on the right but the mind said this is the leftward one and you can flip it over but you're not tricking me you know I know it's on the left and I'm considering it the leftward one right the mind is deciding what counts as left and right not the world um and what other kinds of processes you know information is being processed uh that's not reaching uh a tensional level so here's a cute experiment they would say to these patients uh you know any difference between these two things no but if you had to live in one of these houses which one do you think you'd live well I don't know they're pretty much the same why would I pick one well pick one okay they go Ah that's a little better place to live if I have to pick one you know which vase do you want I don't know they look the same right you have to pick pick this one okay which glass to drink from uh have to pick pick this one so they don't consciously are not aware of what's going on here when there's information to the opposite side to draw their attention but something in their mind somewhere is picking up information so the last question then I'll show you the final video is this what kind of information is picked up in the neglected field as you decide some part of your mind to neglect it so imagine if I showed you uh two forks versus a fork in a spoon okay um in order for that to make a difference whether you report both are present so again if you have a right sided lesion you might tend not to report this fork or not to report this key if you just don't report either one okay left is left and you're bad at reporting that when there's something competing in the good field right your attention gets drawn here hard to disengage but if it makes a difference what this thing is that means right that your mind kind of knows what it is and your mind is saying you know uh well if it's a key that's a different enough that I can still pay attention to it but if it's another Fork well those are really similar and now my mind is really sucked into this Fork but in order for that to make a difference does it make do you see that you have to know somewhere in your mind what's different than the left okay for that to affect your performance so now we'll see a video of of of a patient the last one this is a neurologist Bob Rafel and uh a patient you know it's a hugely nice thing of the patients most of all but also the Physicians to make these tapes available for teaching purpose so so you understand just just review for one moment and we're done that when the same object came up did he pretty much noticed the one on the bad side and the right side for him no right same object he almost always said it's one if they're different objects he typically reported slightly sluggishly the one on his bad side that means part of his mind has to know what the object is so that he ignores it if it's identical and he reports it if it's different well you have to know what it is to base your answer on that yet the logic of neglect is that if they're identical then he's going to ignore the one that he's spotted on the left in part of his mind but squat washed from his awareness in the other side okay thanks very much

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 8 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011