Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu all right so today's task is going to be to outline some of the basic experimental facts that we will both have to deal with and that our aim should be to understand and model through the rest of the course um physics uh doesn't tell you some abstract truth about why the universe is the way it is physics gives you models to understand how things work and predict what will happen next and what we will be aiming to do is develop models that give us some intuition for the phenomena and allow us to make predictions and these are going to be the experimental facts I would like to both explain develop an intuition for and be able to predict uh consequences of so we'll start off with um so let me just outline them so first fact atoms exist I'll go over some of the arguments for that Randomness definitely present in the world Atomic Spectra are discreet and structured we have a photoelectric effect which I'll describe in some detail um electrons uh do some funny things in particular electron defraction and six and Fin finally um Bells inequality uh something that we will come back to at the very end of the class uh which I like to think of as a sort of a frame for the entirety of 804 okay so good we'll stick with this for the moment so everyone in here knows that atoms are made of electrons and nuclei in particular um you know that electrons exist because you've seen a cathode ray tube I used to be able to say you've seen a t but you all have flat panel TV so this is useless so cathod ray tube is a gun that shoots electrons at a phosphorescent screen and every time the electron hits the screen it induces a little phosphorescence a little glow and that's how you see on a CRT um and so as was ply uh stated um Long Ago by a very famous physicist if you can spray them they exist it's pretty good argument um there's there's a better argument for the existence of electrons which is that we can actually see them individually and this is one of the most famous images in high energy physics it's from an experiment called Gargamel which was a 30 30 cubic meter uh tank of liquid Freon pulsing just at its vapor pressure 60 times a second and what this image is is apart from all the Schmutz you're watching a trail of bubbles in this depressurizing fron that wants to create bubbles but you have to nucleate Bubbles what you're seeing there in that central line that goes up and then curls around is a single electron that was nailed by a neutrino incident from a beam at CERN where currently the LHC is running and this experiment revealed two things first to us it will reveal that you can see individual electrons and by studying the images of them moving through fluids and leaving a disturbing wake of bubbles behind them we can study their their properties in some considerable detail the second thing it taught us is something that we're not going to talk about in detail uh is that it's possible for neutrino to hit an electron and that process is called a weak neutral current for sort of stupid historical reasons um it's actually a really good name uh uh and that was awesome and surprising and so this picture is both a monument to the technology of the experiment but also to the physics of weak neutral currents and electrons they exist if you can discover neutrinos by watching them okay secondly nuclei we know that nuclei exists because you can shoot alpha particles which come from radioactive decay at atoms and you have your atom which is some you know sort of vague thing and I'm gonna make the atom I'm gonna find the atom by making a sheet of atoms maybe a foil very thin foil of stuff and then I'm going to shoot very high energy alpha particles incident at this probably everyone has heard of this experiment it was done by Rutherford and guer and Marsden in particular his I guess students at the time or postto I don't recall um and you shoot these alpha particles in and if you think of these guys as some sort of jellyish lump then maybe they'll they'll deflect a little bit but if you shoot you know a bullet through Jello it just sort of maybe it gets deflected a little bit but Jello I mean come on and the thing that was shocking is you shoot these alpha particles in and every once in a while they bounce back at 100 you know 180 160 degrees butf likened this to uh to uh rolling a bowling ball uh against a piece of paper and having it bounce back uh kind of surprising and the explanation here that people eventually came up upon is that atoms are mostly uh zero density except they have very very high density cores which are many times smaller than the size of the atom uh but where most of the mass is Con concentrated and as a consequence most of the inertia and so we know that atoms have substructure and the picture we have is that well if you scrape this pile of metal you can pull off the electrons leaving behind nuclei which have positive charge because you've stra scraped off the electrons that have negative charge so we have a picture from these experiments that there are electrons and there are nuclei which I'll just write n as plus um which uh which are the constituents of atoms now this leads to a very natural picture of what an atom is if you're a 19th century physicist or even early 20th century physicist it's very natural to say aha well if I know if I have a positive charge and I have a negative charge then they attract each other with a 1 / R minus q1 Q2 sorry q1 Q2 over R potential this is just like gravity right the the Earth and and the sun are attracted with an inverse R potential this leads to klarian orbits and uh so maybe an atom is just some sort of orbiting uh classical uh combination of of an electron and nucleus positively charged nucleus the problem with this picture as you explore in detail in your first problem on the problem set is that it doesn't work what happens when you accelerate a charge it radiates yeah exactly so if it's radiating it's got a lose energy it's dumping energy into the out of the system so it's got to fall lower into the potential Falls lower it speeds up it radiates more because it's accelerating more to stay in a circular orbit radiates more that means it has to fall further down so on the problem say you're going to calculate how long that takes and it's not very long and so the fact that we persist for more than a few Pico seconds tells you that it's not that this is not a correct picture of of a of an atom okay so in classical mechanics atoms could not exist and yet atoms exist so we have to explain that that's going to be our first challenge okay now interestingly gerer who was this uh this collaborator of Rutherford Young Junior collaborator of Rutherford um went on uh to develop a really neat instrument so suppose you want to see radiation we do this all the time I'm looking at you and I'm seeing radiation seeing light but I'm not seeing ultra high energy radiation I'm seeing energy radiation in the op electromagnetic waves in the optical Spectrum meanwhile I'm also not seeing alpha particles so what guer wanted was a way to detect without using your eyes radiation that's you know hard to see so the way he did this is he he took a capacitor and he filled the surrounded the capacitor with some noble gas it doesn't interact there's no it's very hard to ionize and uh if you crank up the potential across his capacitor plate high enough what do you get a spark right you all know this if you crank up a capacitor eventually breaks down because a dialectric in between breaks down you get a spontaneous sparking so what he's what he figured was look if I take a capacitor plane and I charge it up but not quite to break down just a good potential and another charge particle comes flying through like an alpha particle which carries charge plus two that positive charge will disturb things and will add extra field effectively and lead to the nucleation of a spark so the presence of a spark when this potential is not strong enough to induce a spark spontaneously indicates the passage of a Charged particle Guyer worked later with um Marson Mueller Mueller I guess um uh heck I don't even remember and uh and developed this into a device now known as the Giger counter um and so you've probably all seen simul or seen uh or heard um guer counters going off in movies right they go ping ping ping ping ping ping ping ping ping ping ping right they bounce off randomly this is an extremely important lesson which is tantum out to the lesson of our second experiment yesterday the 50/50 when we didn't expect it the white electrons into the hardness box then into a color box again come out 50/50 not 100% and they come out in a way that's unpredictable we have no ability to our knowledge and more than our knowledge we'll come back to that with B andil we have no ability to predict which electron will come out of that third box White or black right similarly with a Geer counter you hear that atoms Decay but they Decay randomly the radiation comes out of a pile of radioactive material totally at random we know the probabilistic description of that we're going to develop that but we don't know exactly when and that's a really powerful example both of those experiments are powerful examples of Randomness and so we're going to have to incorporate that into our laws of physics into our model of quantum phenomena as well questions I usually have a Geer counter the point which is totally awesome um so I'll I'll try to produce the Geer counter demo later but the person with the Geer counter turns out to have left the continent made it a little challenging um uh okay um it's just sort of since we're at MIT an interesting side note um this strategy of so-called hard scattering of taking some object and sending it at very high velocity at some other object and looking for the rare events when they bounce off at some large angle so-called hard scattering which is you know used to detect dense cores of objects um it didn't stop with Rutherford people didn't just give up at that point similar experiments in the 60s and 70s which were conducted at slack um were uh involved not uh alpha particles incident on atoms but individual electrons incident on protons so not shooting into the nucleus but shooting and looking for the effect of hitting individual protons inside the nucleus and through this process it was discovered uh that in fact so this was done in the 60s and 70s that in fact the proton itself is also not a fundamental particle the proton is itself composite um and in particular it's made out of uh eventually people understood that it's made out of morally speaking I'm going to put this in quotation marks asked me about it in office hours three corks which are some particles and the the reason we you know all this tells you is that it's some object we've given it the name cork but indeed there are three point- like particles that in some sense make up a prot done it's actually much more complicated than that but these corks among other things have very strange properties like they have fractional charge and um this was discovered by a large group of people um uh in particular uh led by Kendall and Freedman and also Richard Taylor Kendall and Freedman were at MIT uh Richard Taylor was at Stanford uh and in 1990 they shared the Nobel Prize uh for the discovery of the the ponic structure of the nucleons um so these sorts of techniques that people have been using for a very long time continue to be useful and awesome in particular uh the experiment the experimental version of this that's currently going on that I particularly love is something called The relativistic Heavy ion collider uh which is going on at Brookhaven so here what you're doing is you take two protons and you blow them into each other okay at ultra high energy two protons Collide them and see what happens and that's what happens okay you get massive shrapnel coming flying out so instead of having a simple thing where one of the protons just bounces back because there's some hardcore instead what happens is just just trapnel everywhere right so you might think well how do we interpret that at all how do you make sense out of you know 14,000 particles coming out of two protons bouncing into each other how does that make any sense and the answer turns out to be kind of awesome and so this touches on my research so I want to uh make a quick comment on it just for color um the answer turns out to be really interesting first off uh the interior constituents of protons interact very strongly with each other but at the brief moment when protons collide with each other what you actually form is not uh a point like quk and another Point like quk in fact protons aren't made out of point- like quirks at all protons are big bags with quirks and gluons and all sorts of particles fluctuating in and out of existence in a complicated fashion and what you actually get is amazingly a liquid for a brief brief moment of time the parts of those protons that overlap think of them as two spheres and they overlap in some sort of almond shaped region the parts of those protons that overlap form a liquid at ultra high temperature and ultra high density it's Rel it's called the Rick Fireball or the cour Glon plasma although it's not actually a plasma but it's a liquid like water and what I mean by saying it's a liquid like water if you push it it spreads in waves and like water it's dissipative those waves dissipate but it's a really funny bit of liquid imagine you take your cup of coffee you drink it you're drinking your coffee as I want to do and uh it cools down over time this is very frustrating so you pour in a little bit of hot coffee now when you pour in that hot coffee the system is out of equilibrium it hasn't thermalized so what you want is you want to wait for all of the system to to wait until it's come to equilibrium so you don't get a you know Swig of hot or Swig of cold you want some sort of goldilox in in between so you can ask how long does it take for for this coffee to come to thermal equilibrium well it takes a while you know a few seconds a few minutes depending on exactly how you mess with it but let me ask you a quick question how does that time scale compare to the time it takes for light to cross your mug slower much much much slower right by orders of magnitude um for this liquid that's formed in the ultra high energy Collision of two protons the time it takes for the system which starts out crazy out of equilibrium with all sorts of quirks here and gluons there and stuff flying about the time it takes for it to equilib to come to thermal equilibrium is a order the time it takes for light to cross the little puddle of liquid this is a crazy liquid it's called a Quantum liquid it has all sorts of wonderful properties and the best thing about it to my mind is that it's very well modeled by black holes which is a totally separate issue but it's a fun example so um so from these sorts of collisions from SE these sorts of collisions we know a great deal about the existence of atoms uh and and Randomness as you can see that's a fairly random story okay so moving on to more 804 things um back to atoms so let's look at specifics of I'm not kidding they really are related to black holes like I get paid for this so so here's a nice fact so let's let's get to Atomic Spectra so to to study Atomic Spectra here's the experiment I want to run the experiment I want to run starts out with a uh you know some sort of power plant and out of the power plant come two wires right uh and I'm going to run these wires across a spark gap uh you know a piece of metal here and a piece of metal here and put them inside uh a container which has some gas like H2 or neon or whatever you want but some simple gas inside here so I've got uh electric potential established across it again we don't want so much potential that it Sparks um but we do want to excite the H2 so you know we can even make it spark it doesn't really matter too much the important thing is that we're going to excite the hydrogen and in exciting the hydrogen the excited hydrogen is going to send out light and I'm going to take this light doesn't do that light goes in straight lines so uh we we take the light um and uh and I'm going to shine this on a prism something I was taught to do by Newton and um metaphorically speaking and look at the image of this light uh having passed through the uh the prism and what you find is you find a very distinct set of of patterns you do not get a continuous band in fact what you get I'm going to have a hard time drawing this so let me draw it down here um I'm not going to draw the intensity of the light incident on this screen on this piece of paper people really used to use pieces of paper for this which is kind of awesome as a function of the wavelength and I'll measure it in angstroms okay and what you discover is here's around a thousand angstroms you get a bunch of lines get these spikes and they start to spread out okay and then there aren't so many and then at around 3,000 you get another set and then at around 10,000 you get another set okay this is around 10,000 and here's the interesting thing about these so the discovery of these lines these These are named after a guy named Lyman these are lemon lman these are named after a guy named um shoot would um Balmer thank you Steve Balmer right Balmer uh and these are passion like passion fruit um so everyone needs a pneumonic okay um so uh uh so you know these these people identify these lines and and and explain various things about them but here's an interesting fact if you replace this nuclear power plant with a coal plant makes no difference if you replace this Prism by a different prism it makes no difference to where the lines are if you uh if you change this mechanism of exciting the hydrogen it makes no difference as long as it's hydrogen as long as it's hydrogen in here you get the same lines maybe with different intensities depending on exactly how you do the experiment but you got the same position of the lines okay and that's a really striking thing now if you use a different chemical a different gas in here like neon you got a very different set of lines and a very different effective color out that when you eyeball this thing so um so Balmer incidentally um and I think this is actually why he got blamed for the particular series although I don't know the history bomber noticed by being depending on which biography you read very clever or very obsessed that these guys uh this particular set could be wavelengths if you wrote their wavelength and label them by an integer n where n ran from three to any positive integer above three uh could be written as 36 so this is pure numerology 3646 angstroms uh times the function n^2 over n^2 minus 4 where n is equal to three four dot dot dot integer okay and it turns out that if you just plug in these integers you get a pretty good approximation to this series of lines this is a hall tradition a phenomenological fit to some data where did it come from it came from his creative or obsessed mind so this was balber and this is specifically for hydrogen gas H2 okay so ridberg and Ritz RNR uh said well actually we can do one better now that they realize that this is true they looked at the whole sequence and they found a really neat little expression which is that one over the wavelength is equal to a single constant parameter not just for all these but for all of them one single numerical uh coefficient Time 1 m^ 2us 1 n^ 2 N is an integer greater than zero and greater than particular than M and if you plug in any value of N and any value of M for sufficiently reasonable I mean you you know put in 10 million and you're just not going to see it because it's way out there but if you put in or rather in here um if you um if you put in um if you put in any value of N and M um you will get one of these lines so again why you know as it's said who ordered that okay so this is experimental result three that we're going to have to deal with when you look at atoms and you look at the Spectre of light coming off of them their Spectre are discreet but they're not just stupidly discreet they're discreet with real structure something that begs for an explanation no this is obviously more than numerology because it explains with one tunable coefficient a tremendous number of of spectral lines and there's a different and crucially these both work specifically for hydrogen for different atoms you need a totally different formula but again there's always some formula that Nails those spectral lines Why questions okay um so speaking of speaking of atomic Spectra oops I went one two4 here's a different experiment so people notice the following thing people notice that if you take a piece of metal and you shine light at it you know by taking the Sun or better yet you know these days we'd use a laser but you shine light on this piece of metal uh something that is done all the time in condensed matter Labs it's a very useful Technique we really do use lasers not the Sun but still continuous to be useful effect to this day you shine light on a piece of metal and every once in a while what happens is electrons come flying off and the more light and the the stronger the light you shine uh you see uh changes in the way that electrons bounce off so we'd like to measure that I'd like to make that precise and this was done in A really lovely experiment here's the experiment the basic idea of the experiment is I want to check to see as I change the features of the light the intensity the frequency whatever I want to see how that changes the properties of the electrons that bounce off now one obvious way one obvious feature of an electron that flew off a piece of metal is how fast is it going how much energy does it have what's its kinetic energy so I'd like to build an experiment that measures the kinetic energy of an electron that's been excited through this photoelectric effect through emission after Shining Light on a piece of metal cool so I want to build that experiment so here's how that experiment goes well if this if this electron comes flying off with some kinetic energy and I want to measure that kinetic energy imagine the following circuit okay first off imagine I just take um uh I just take a second piece of metal over here and I'm I'm going to put a little current meter here an ameter and here's what here's what this circuit does when I shine light on this piece of metal we'll put a screen to protect the other piece of metal the electrons come flying off they get over here and uh now I've got a bunch of extra electrons over here and I'm missing electrons over here so this is negative this is positive and the electrons will now flow along this wire back here to neutralize the system the more light I shine the more electrons will go through the circuit and as a consequence there will be a current running through this current meter that cool to everyone okay so we haven't yet measured the kinetic energy though how do we measure the kinetic energy I want to know how much energy with how much energy were these electrons ejected well I can do that by the following clever trick I'm going to put now a voltage source here which I can tune the voltage of okay with a voltage V now what that's going to do is set up a potential difference across these and the energy in that is the charge times the potential difference so I know that the potential difference it takes so the amount of energy it takes to overcome this potential difference is Q * V that cool so now imagine I send in an electron I send in light and and it leads an electron to jump across and it has kinetic energy K well if the kinetic energy is less than this will it get across not so much it'll just fall back but if the kinetic energy is greater than the energy it takes to cross it'll cross and induce a current yeah so as a so the the upshot is that as a function of the voltage what I should see is that um there's some critical minimum voltage and depending on how you set up the sign the sign could be either way but there's some critical minimal voltage where for Less voltage the uh the uh electron doesn't get across and for any greater voltage um the or sorry for any closer to zero voltage the electron has enough kinetic energy to get across uh and so the current should increase so there's a critical voltage V critical where the current running through the system it runs to zero okay you make it harder for the electrons by making the voltage in magnitude even larger you make it harder for the electrons to get across none will get across make it a little easier more and more will get across and the current will go up cool okay so what you want to do to measure this kinetic energy is you want to measure the critical voltage at which the current goes to zero so now the question is what do we expect to see and remember the things we can tune in this experiment are the intensity of the light which is like e^2 plus B2 and we can tune the frequency of the light we can vary that now does the total energy does the frequency show up in the total energy of a classic electromagnetic wave no if it's an electromagnetic wave it it it cancels out you just get the total total uh intensity which is the square of the field um so this is just like a harmonic oscillator the energy is is um uh is in the amplitude the frequency of the oscillator doesn't matter you push the swing harder it gets more kinetic energy it's got more energy okay um so so what do we expect to see as we vary for example the intensity so here's a natural guess if you if you take so you can think about the light here as getting a person literally like get the person next to you to take a bat and hit a piece of metal right if they hit it really lightly they're probably not going to excite electrons with a lot of energy they just whack the heck out of it then you wouldn't be too surprising if you get much more energy in the particles that come flying off hit it hard enough things are just going to shrapnel and disintegrate so the the expectation here is the following that if you have a more intense beam then you should get more um the electrons coming off should be more energetic because you're hitting them harder and remember that the potential which I will call v0 the stopping voltage or sorry v0 the stopping voltage so therefore V 0 should be greater in magnitude so this anticipates that the way this curve should look as we vary uh int the current as a function of v if we have a low voltage uh sorry if we have a low intensity beam it shouldn't take too much uh potential to to impede the motion right but if we have a so this is a low intensity be but if we have a high intensity beam it should take a really large voltage to impede the electric Flow Electric current because high intensity beam you're just whacking those electrons really hard and they're coming off with a lot of kinetic energy so this is high intensity everyone down with that intuition this is what you get from Maxwell's Electro is what you'd expect and in particular as we vary so this is our predictions in particular as we vary so this is one two uh with greater intensity and the second prediction is that um V KN should be independent of frequency because the energy density in electromagnetic wave is independent of the frequency it just depends on the amplitude and I will use new to den know the frequency okay so those are the predictions that come from 802 and 803 but this is 804 and here's what the experimental results actually look like so here's the intensity here's the potential and if we look at high potential it turns out if we look sorry if we look at intermediate potentials it's true that the high intensity leads to a larger current and the low intensity leads to a lower current but here's the funny thing that happens as you go down to the critical voltage their critical voltages are the same V not what that tells you is that the kinetic energy kicked out electric the kinetic energy of an electron kicked out of this piece of metal by the light is independent of how intense that beam is no matter how intense that beam is no matter how strong the light you shine on the material the electrons all come out with the same energy this should be like you know taking a a baseball and and hitting it with a really powerful you know swing or a really weak swing and seeing that the electron dribbles away with the same amount of energy this is very counterintuitive but so more surprisingly so V is actually independent of intensity but here's the real shocker vot varies linearly in the frequency what does change vot is changing the frequency of the light that's incident that means that if you take an incredibly diffuse light incredibly diffuse light you can barely see it of a very high frequency then it takes a lot of energy to impede the the electrons that come popping off the electrons that come popping off have a large energy but if you take a low frequency light with extremely high intensity then those electrons are really easy to stop powerful beam but low frequency it's easy to stop those electrons weak little tiny Beam at high frequency very hard to stop the electrons that do come off so this is very counterintuitive and it doesn't fit at all with the maxwan picture questions about that so this led Einstein to uh to make a prediction uh that this was his 1905 result um one of his many totally breathtaking papers of that year and he didn't really propose a model or a detailed theoretical understanding of this but he he proposed a very simple idea and he said you know look if you want to fit this if you want to fit this experiment with um some simple equations here's the way to explain it um I claim I hear means Einstein not me I claim that light comes in packets or chunks with definite energy and the energy is linearly proportional to the frequency energy is equal to something times new and we'll call the coefficient H okay the intensity of light or the amplitude squared the intensity is like the number of packets so if you have a more intense Beam at the same frequency the energy of each individual chunk of light is the same there are just a lot more chunks flying around and so to explain the photoelectric effect Einstein observed the following look he said the electrons are stuck onto the metal and it takes some work to pull them off so now what's the kinetic energy of an electron that comes flying off well the whoops K3 Barton might have a laugh about that one uh kinetic K not three um so the kinetic energy of an electron that comes flying off well it's the energy deposited by the photon the chunk of of light H new but we have to subtract off the work it took minus the work to uh extract the electron from the material you can think of this as how much energy does it take to suck it off the surface okay and the consequence of this is that the kinetic energy uh of an electron uh should be look if H new is too small if the if the frequency is too low then the kinetic energy would be negative but that doesn't make any sense you can't have negative kinetic energy it's a strictly positive quantity so it just doesn't work until you have a critical value where the frequency time H this coefficient is equal to the work it takes to extract and after that the kinetic energy Rises with a frequency with a slope equal to H and that fits the data like a chain okay so no matter let's think about what this is saying again no matter what you do if your light is very low frequency and you you know pick some definite piece of metal that has a def very definite work function very different amount of energy it takes to extract an electron from the surface no matter how intense your beam if the frequency is insufficiently high no electrons come off none right so it turns out none is a little over statement because what you can have is two Photon processes where two chunks hit one electron at the right just at the same time roughly speaking at the same time and they have twice the energy but you can imagine that the probability of two photons hitting one electron at the same time is pretty low so the intensity has to be preposterously high and you see those sorts of multiphoton effects but as long as we're not talking about insanely High intensities uh this is an absolutely fantastic uh probe of the of the physics now there's a whole long subsequent story in the development of quantum mechanics about this particular effect and it turns out the photoelectric effect is a little more complicated than this but the story line is a very useful one for organizing your understanding of uh of the uh of the photoelectric effect and in particular this relation that Einstein proposed out of the blue with no other basis no one else had ever seen uh this sort of statement that the electrons or that the energy of of light of a beam of light um should be made up of uh some number of chunks Each of which has a definite minimum amount of energy so you can take what you've learned from 02 and 03 and extract a little bit more information out of this so here's something you learned from 02 in 802 you learn that the energy of an electromagnetic wave is equal to c times the momentum carried by that wave whoops O2 and in 803 you should have learned that the wavelength of an electromagnetic wave times the uh frequency is equal to the speed of light see and we just had Einstein tell us or declare without you know further Evidence just saying look this fits uh that the energy of a chunk of light should be H times the frequency so if you combine these together you get another nice relation that's similar to this one which says that the momentum of a chunk of light is equal to H over Lambda okay so these are two enormously influential expressions uh which come out of this argument from the photoelectric effect from Einstein and they're going to be uh their legacy will be with us throughout the rest of the semester now this coefficient has a name uh and it was named after plunk it's called plunk constant and the reason that it's called planks constant has nothing to do with the photoelectric effect it was first this this idea uh that the that a electromagnetic wave that light has an energy which is linearly proportional to its intensity squared none of that but just linearly proportional to the frequency first came up in an analysis of black body radiation by plun and you'll you'll go through this in some detail in 8044 later in the semester so I'm not going to dwell in it at length now but I do want to give you a little bit of perspective on it so plunk ran across this idea that e is equal to H new um uh through the through the process of trying to fit an experimental curve there was a theory of how much energy should be uh in should be emitted by an object that's hot and glowing as a function of frequency and that theory turned out to be in total disagreement with experiment spectacular disagreement the curve for the theory went up the curve for the experiment went down they were totally different so plonc set about writing down a function that described the data literally curve fitting that's all he was doing and this is the the the depths of desperation to which he was led he curvefitting he's an adult he shouldn't be doing this but he was curve fitting and so he fits the curve and in order to get it to fit the only thing that he can get to work even vaguely well is if he puts in this calculation of H new he says well maybe when I sum over all the possible energies I should restrict the energies which proportional to the frequency and it was forced on him because it fit from the function it's just functional analysis hated it hated it he completely hated it uh he was really frustrated by this it fit perfectly he became very famous he was already famous but he became ridiculously famous just totally loathed this idea okay so it's now become a Cornerstone of quantum mechanics but he wasn't so happy about it and to give you a sense for how bold and Punchy this paper by Einstein was that said look seriously seriously guys equals H new um here's what plun had to say when he wrote a letter of recommendation to get Einstein into the Prussian Academy of Sciences in 1917 or 1913 so he said there is hardly one among the great problems in physics to which Einstein has not made an important contribution that he may sometimes have missed the Target in his speculations as in his hypothesis of photons cannot really be held too much against him it's not possible to introduce new ideas without occasionally taking a risk Einstein who subsequently went on to develop special relativity and general relativity and prove the existence of atoms and the best measurement of avagadro's constant subsequently got the Nobel Prize not for avagadro Consin not for proving the existence of atoms not for relativity but for photons because of guys like Punk right this is crazy so this this was a pretty bold idea and here to get a sense for why let me leave that up because it's just sort of fun to see these guys scowling and smiling on the there's incidentally there's a there's a great book about um Einstein's years in Berlin by um Tom levenson who's a professor here um a great writer and and a sort of historian of science um you should take a class from him which is really great uh but but I encourage you to read this book it talks about why plon is not looking so pleased right there um among many other things um it's a great story so let's step back for a second why was plonc so upset by this and why was in fact everyone so flustered by this idea that it led to uh you know the best prize you can give a physicist you know apart from a happy home and you know I've got that one that's the one that matters to me um so uh uh so why why is this so surprising and the answer is really simple we know that it's false we know empirically we've known for 200 and some years that that light is a wave empirically this isn't like people like oh I think it'd be nice if it was a wave it's a wave so how do we know that so this goes back to the double slit experiment from Young um Young performance of this was in 1803 uh intimations of it come much earlier uh but this is really where it gets nailed to the wall um and um here's the experiment so how many people in here have not seen a double slit experiment described yeah exactly okay so so I'm just going to quickly remind you of how this goes so we have a source for waves we let the waves get big until they're basically plane waves and then we take a barrier and we poke two slits in it and these plane waves induce they act like sources at the slits and we get new and you get Crest and troughs and you look at some distant screen and you look at the pattern and the pattern you get has a maximum but then it falls off and it has these Wiggles these interference fringes and these interference fringes are of course extremely important and what's going on here is that the waves sometimes add in so the amplitude of the wave the height of the wave sometimes adds constructively and sometimes destructively so that sometimes you get twice the height and sometimes you get nothing okay so just because it's fun to see this here's Young's actual diagram from his original uh note on the double slit experiment so he's like this is so A and B are the slits and CDE and F are the of uh on the screen the distance screen um do by hand it's pretty good um so so we've known for a very long time uh that that light because of the double set experiment light is clearly a wave it behaves like a wave what are the senses in which it behaves like a wave there are two important senses here the first is answered by the question question where did the wave hit the screen okay so where did when we send in a wave you know I I drop a stone one big pulsive wave comes out it splits into you know it leads to New Waves being instigated here and the interfere where did that wave hit the screen anyone yeah exactly it didn't hit this wave at at the screen at anyone spot some amplitude shows up everywhere the wave is a distributed object it does not exist at one spot and it's by virtue of the fact that it is not a localized object it is not a point-like object that it can interfere with itself right the wave is a big large phenomena in a in a liquid in a in you know some thing so it's sort of essential that it's uh that it's not a localized object so not localized the answer is not localized and let's contrast this with what happens if you take this double slit experiment and you do it with you know I don't know take who um Tim Wakefield let's give some love to that guy so baseball player and have him throw baseballs at uh at a screen with two slits in it okay and he's got pretty good he's he's got terrible accuracy actually um so every once in a while he'll make it through the slit so um so let's let's imagine first blocking off one he's a knuckle baller right so uh every once a while uh it goes the baseball will go through the lit and let's think about what happens so let's cover one slit and what we expect to happen is well it'll go through more or less straight but sometimes it'll scrape the edge and it'll go off to the side and sometimes it'll come over here but if you take a whole bunch of baseballs and so any one baseball where does it hit some spot right one spot not distributed one spot and as a consequence you know one goes here one goes there one goes there and now uh there's you know there's nothing like interference effects but what happens is as it sort of doesn't yeah you get some distribution if you look at where they all hit yeah every cool with that and if we had covered over this slot slit and let the base balls go through this one same thing would have happened now if we leave them both open what happens is sometimes it goes here sometimes it goes here so now it's pretty useful that we've got a knuckle baller and what you actually get is the prob the Total distribution looks like this it's the sum of the two but at any given time any one baseball you say ah the baseball either went through the top slit and more or less goes up here or it went through the bottom slit and more or less goes down here right so for chunks for so this is for waves for chunks or localized particles they are localized and as a consequence we get no interference okay so for waves they are not localized and we do get interference yes interference okay so on your problem set you're going to deal with some calculations involving these interference effects and I'm going to uh I'm going to brush over them anyway the point of the point of of these um of the double slit experiment is that whatever else you want to say about baseballs or anything else light as we've learned since 1803 in Young's double slit experiment light behaves like a wave it is not localized it hits the screen over its entire extent and as a consequence we get interference the amplitud add the intensity is the square of the amplitude if the int if the intensities add so sorry if the amplitudes add amplitude total is equal to A1 Plus A2 the intensity which is the square of a1+ A2 squared has interference terms the cross terms from this Square okay so whoops where am I um so light from this point of view is an electromagnetic wave it interferes with itself it's made of chunks and I I can't help but think about it this way this is literally the metaphor I use in my head um light is creamy and smooth like a wave um uh chunks are very different uh but here's the funny thing light is both smooth like a wave it is also chunky it is super chunky as we have learned from the photoelectric effect okay um so light is both at once so it's the best of both worlds right it's you know everyone will be satisfied or unless you're not from the US in which case this is deeply disturbing um so of course the original Super chunk is a band um so uh so we've learned now from Young that light is a wave we've learned from the photoelectric effect that light is a bunch of chunks okay both experimental results are are true so uh how does that work well we're going to have to deal with that but enough about light if this is true of light if light depending on what experiment you and how you do the experiment sometimes it seems like it's a wave sometimes it seems like it's a chunk or particle which is true which is the better description so it's actually worthwhile to not think about light all the time let's think about something more General um let's stick to electrons so as we saw from yesterday's uh lecture you probably want to be a little bit wary when thinking about individual electrons things could be a little bit different than your classical intuition um but here's a crucial thing before doing anything else we can just think what which which one of these two is more likely to describe electrons well well electrons are localized when you throw an electron at a CRT it does not hit the whole CRT with a wavy distribution when you take a single electron you throw it at a CRT it goes ping and there's a little glowing spot electrons are localized and we know that localized things don't lead to interference right some guys at Hitachi really good scientist and Engineers developed some really awesome technology a couple of decades ago and they were trying to figure out a good way to demonstrate their technology and they decided that you know what would be really awesome this thought experiment that people always talk about that's never been done really well of send an electron through a two slit experiment in this case it was like 10 slits effectively was a grading send an electron a bunch of electrons one at a time throw the electron wait throw the electron waight like our french guy with the boat so do this experiment with our techology and let's see what happens okay and this this really is one of my favorite uh this is one of Let's see how do I close these screens aha okay this is going to take a little bit of and it's broken oh no oh oh that's so sad yeah come on oh I'm just GNA let yeah right uh let's see if we can we'll get part of the way I don't want to destroy it so um so what they actually did is they said look let's we want to see what happens we want to actually do this experiment because we're so awesome at Hitachi research Labs let's do it so here's what they did and I'm going to turn off the lights um great okay and um and I set this to some music because I like it okay here's what's happening one at a time individual photons so they look pretty localized there's not a whole lot of structure and now they're going to start speeding it up this is 100 times the actual speed yeah so those guys who know what they're doing um let's there we go so um I think I don't know of a more Vivid example of electron interference in that one it's totally obvious you see individual electrons they run through the apparatus you wait they run through the apparatus you wait one at a time single electron like a baseball being pitched through two slits and what you see is an interference effect but you don't see the interference effect like you do from light in from waves on the sea you see the interference effect by looking at the cumulative stacking up of all the electrons as they hit look at where all the electrons hit one at a time so is an electron behaving like a wave in aond p no no does a wave in a pond hit at a spot no it's a distributed Beast you okay yes it interferes but it's not localized well is it behaving like a baseball well it's localized but on when I look at a whole bunch of electrons they do that they seem to interfere but there's only one electron going through at a time so in some sense it's interfering with itself how does that work is an electron a wave does an electron uh hit at many spots at once no so is an electron a wave no is an electron a baseball no it's an electron okay so this is something you're going to have to deal with that every once in a while we every once in while we have these wonderful moments where it's useful to think about an electron as behaving in a wavelike sense sometimes it's useful to think about it as behaving in a particle likee sense but it is not a particle like you normally conceive of a baseball and it is not a wave like you normally conceive of a wave on the surface of a pond it's an electron let's see if we get oh uh so uh yeah so um I like to think about this like an elephant uh you know if you're closing your eyes and you walk up to an elephant you might think like I've got a snake and I've got a tree trunk and you know there's a fan over here um and you wouldn't know like maybe it's a wave maybe it's a particle I can't really tell but if you could just see the thing the way it is not through the preconceived sort of Notions you have you it's an elephant yes that is the STA Center so uh look everything has to happen sometime right so so Heisenberg it's often it's often people often give the false impression in popular books on physics so I want to subvert this that the ear in the early days of quantum mechanics the early people like Bourne and Oppenheimer and and uh and and and Heisenberg who invented quantum mechanics um they were really tortured about you know is an electron is a wave it's a wave particle duality it's both and this is one of the best subversions of that sort of siless that I know of so what Heisenberg says the two mental pictures which experiments lead us to form the one of particles the other of waves are both incomplete and have only the validity of analogies which which are accurate only limiting cases the apparent Duality arises in the limitation of our language okay and then he goes on to say look you developed your intuition by throwing rocks and you know swimming and duh that's not going to be very good for atoms so um I this will be posted it's really wonderful his whole lecture is is really the lectures are really quite lovely um and that's by the way that's him in the middle there poly all the way on the right um I guess they were pleased um okay so so that's the Hitachi thing so um so now let's pick up on this though let's pick up on this and think about what happens I want to think in a little more detail about this Hitachi experiment and I want to think about it in the Contex of a simple two slit experiment so here here's our source of electrons it's a it's a you know literally a gun an electron gun and it's firing off electrons and here's our barrier and it has two slits in it okay and we know that any individual electron hits at some spot right but when we take many of them we get an interference effect we get interference fringes and so the number that hit at a given spot fill up construct this this distribution so here's the question I want to ask when I take a single electron I shoot one electron at a time through this experiment one electron he could go through the top slate it could go through the bottom slate while it's inside the apparatus which path does it take good so did it take the top path how do you know good let's block the bottom okay to for force it to go through the top slit so we'll block the bottom slit now the only electrons that make it through go through the top slit okay half of them don't make it through but those that do make it through give you this distribution no interference but I didn't tell you these are hundreds of thousands of kilometers apart the person who threw in the electron didn't know whether there was a barrier here the electron how could it possibly know whether there was a barrier here if it went through the top this is exactly like our boxes right it's exactly like our boxes did it go through an electron when the when the slits are both open and we know that Ensemble average it will give us an interference effect did the electron inside the apparatus go through the top path no did it go through the bottom path did it go through both because we always see one electron did it go through neither it is in a of having gone through the top and the bottom of being along the top path and being along the bottom path this is a classic example of the two box experiment okay so I want to tie that together um so let's Nuance this just a little bit though because it's going to have an interesting implication for Gravity so here's the Nuance I want to pull on this one let's cheat okay suppose I want to I want to measure which slit the electron actually did go through how might I do that well you know I could do the coar thing I've been doing I could block it and just catch the catch electrons that go through in that spot but that's a little heavy-handed probably I can do something a little more delicate and so here's more delicate thing I want to do I want to build a detector okay that uses very very very weak light extremely weak light to detect whether the particle went through here or here and the way I can do that is I can sort of shine light through and uh and I just want to I'm going to you know bounce so here's my my source of light and I'll be able to tell whether the electron went through this slit or went through this slit cool so imagine I did that so obviously I don't want to use some giant huge ultra high energy laser because it would just blast the thing out of the way it would destroy the experience I want to use something very diffuse very low energy very low intensity you know electromagnetic wave and the idea here is that okay it's true that when I bounce this light off an electron let's say it bounces off an electron here uh it's it's true it's going to you know impart some momentum and the electron's going to change scor but if it's really really weak low energy light then it's going to you know it's going to deflect it only a little tiny bit so it will change the pattern I get over here but it'll change it in some relatively minor way because I've just thrown in very very low energy uh light yeah that make sense so this is the experiment I want to do this experiment doesn't work why no it's it's true that you know it turns out that those are correlated fact but here's the problem uh I can run this experiment without anyone actually knowing what happens until you know long afterwards so knowing doesn't seem to play any role it it turns out to be it's very tempting often to say no but it it turns out that it's really not about what you know it's really just about the experiment you're doing so what principle that we've already run into today makes it impossible to make this work I want to shine really low energy really fuse light through and have it scatter weakly yeah yeah exactly that's exactly right so when I say really low energy light I don't I really can't mean because we've already done this experiment I cannot possibly mean low intensity because intensity doesn't control the energy imparted by the light right the thing that controls the energy imparted by a collision of the light with the electron is the frequency the energy in a chunk of light is proportional to the frequency so now if I want to make the the effect the energy or the momentum similarly the momentum where did it go remember the momentum goes like H over Lambda if I want to make the energy really low I need to make the frequency really low if I want to make the momentum really low I need to make the wavelength what really big right so in order to make the momentum imparted by this Photon really low I need to make the wavelength really long but now here's the problem if I make the wavelength really long so if I use a really long wavelength wave like this long wavelength are you ever going to be able to tell which slit it went through no because it you know particle could have been anywhere could have scattered this light if it was here if it was here if it was here right in order to measure where the electron is to some reasonable Precision so for example to this sort of wavelength I need to be able to send in light with a wavelength that's comparable to comparable to the scale that I want to measure okay and it turns out that if you run through and just do the calculation suppose I send in and this is done in the books in I think all all four but this is done in the books on the reading list um if you send in a a wave with with a short enough wavelength to be able to distinguish between these two slits which slit did it go through the momentum that it imparts precisely wases washes out is just enough to wash out the interference effect and break up these fringes so you don't see interference effects it's not about what you know it's about the particulate nature of light and the fact that the momentum of a chunk of light goes like H over Lambda okay but this tells you something really interesting did I have to use light to do this measurement I could have sent in anything right I didn't have to bounce light off these things I could have bounced off you know gravitational waves so if I had a gravitational wave detector so uh Matt works on on gravitational wave detectors and so um I didn't tell you this but Matt gave me a pretty killer gravitational wave detector and it's you know here it is there's my awesome gravitation wave detector and I'm now going to build Supernova okay and they're creating on this black hole it's going to create giant gravitational waves and I'm going to use those gravitational waves and detect them with the super Advanced ligo and I'm going to detect which slit it went through but gravitational waves those aren't photons so I really can make a low intensity gravitational wave and then I can tell which slit it went through without destroying the interference effect right that would be awesome what does that tell you about gravitational waves they must come in chunks right in order for this all to fit together logically you need all the interactions that you could scatter off this to satisfy these quantization properties that the energy is proportional to the frequency now the the line I just gave you as a heuristic and making it precise is one of the great challenges of sort of modern contemporary high energy physics of dealing with the quantum mechanics and gravity together but this gives you a strong uh a strong picture of of why we need to treat all forces and all interactions Quantum mechanically in order for the world to be consistent okay um good okay questions at this point okay um so oh I forgot about this one so um uh there there are actually two more so I want to just quickly show you uh well okay so this is a gorgeous experiment so remember I told you the story of the guy with the boat and the opaque wall and it turns out that's a cheat it turns out that the um that this opaque screen uh doesn't actually give you uh Quantum mechanically uh isolated photons um they're still in a in a very important way classical so this experiment was done um uh truly with a source that gives you Quantum mechanically isolated single photons one at a time so this is the analog of the Hitachi experiment um and it was done by this pretty awesome Japanese group uh some number of years ago um and I just want to emphasize that it gives you exactly the same effects we see that photons this is this should look essentially identical to what we saw at the end of the Hitachi video and that's because it's exactly the same physics it's a grading with something like 10 slits and uh individual particles going through one at a time and hitting the screen and going Bing so what you see is the light going Bing on a CCD uh it's a pretty spectacular uh experiment okay so so let's get back to electrons I want another probe of whether electrons are really waves or not so this other experiment again you're going to study this on your problem set this other experiment was done by a couple of characters named Davidson and germer and um in this experiment what they did is they took a crystal and a crystal is just a lattice of regularly uh local located uh ions like diamond or something yeah is what sorry exactly the same um you mean for different electrons yeah well they can be different if the initial conditions are different but they could be if if the initial conditions are the same then the probabilities are identical yeah so every electron behaves identically to every other electron in that sense is that what you you were asking yeah ah sure oh absolutely so so the the the issue there is just a technological one of trying to build a beam that's perfectly columnated and that's just not doable so there's always some dispersion in your beam so in practice it's very hard to make them identical but in principle they could be if you were infinitely powerful as a experimentalist again I was banned from a lab so it's not me um so so here's our Crystal you can think of this as diamond or nickel or whatever I think they actually use nickel but I don't remember exactly um and they sent in a beam of electrons so they sent in a beam of electrons and what they discover is that um if you send in uh uh these electrons and watch how they scatter at various different angles um I'm going to call the angle here of scattering Theta what they discover is that the intensity excuse me the intensity of the reflected beam as a function of theta shows interference effects and in particular they gave a whole calculation for this which I'm not going to go through right now because it's not terribly germine for us um you're going to go through it on your problem set so that'll be good and it's a perfect thing for your recitation instructors to go through um but the important thing is the upshot so if the distance between these Crystal planes is L um or sorry D let me call it D so if the distance between the crystal planes is d um what they discover is that the interference effects that they observed these Maxima and Minima uh are consistent with the um uh with the wavelength of light or sorry with the with the electrons behaving as if they were waves with a definite wavelength with the wavelength Lambda being equal to uh um some integer n over 2D sin Theta okay so they this is the data that they these are the data they actually saw data R plural um these are the data they actually saw and they infer from this that the electrons are behaving as if they were wav likee with this wavelength now what they actually see are individual individual electrons hitting one by one although in their experiment they couldn't resolve individual electrons but that is what they see and so in particular putting plugging all of this back into the experiment you you send in the the electrons with some energy which corresponds to some definite momentum this leads us back to the same expression as before that the momentum is equal to H Lambda with this Lambda Associated so it turns out that this is correct so the electrons defract off the crystal as if they have a momentum which comes uh with a definite uh wavelength corresponding to its moment so that's experimental result oh I forgot to check off four that's experimental result five that electrons defract we already saw the electron defraction um so something to to uh to emphasize is that so these experiences we've described them we done with photons and with electrons but um you could imagine doing the experiment with soccer balls this is of course hard Quantum effects for macroscopic objects are usually insignificantly small however this experiment was done with Bucky Balls which are the same shape as soccer balls in some sense but they're huge they're gigantic objects and so here here's the experiment in which this was actually done um so uh the these these guys are just totally amazing so this is zelinger lab um and it doesn't look like all I mean it looks kind of you know it's it's hideous right I mean to a theorist it's like come on you've got to be kidding that that's um but here's the the the here's what a theorist is happy about um you know because it looks simple um we really love lying to ourselves about that so here's an oven we're going to cook up uh some Bucky Balls and emit them with some definite known thermal energy um known to to some accuracy we're going to column them by sending them through a single slit and then we're going to send them through a defraction grading which again is just a whole bunch of slits and then we're going to image them using photo ionization and see where they uh where they pop through so here is the horizontal position this way along the the uh the grading and this is the number that come through this is literally one by one counts because they're going bing bing bing as the C60 molecule goes through so without the grading you just get a peak but with the grading you get these side bands you get interference fringes so these guys again they're going through one by one a single bucky ball 60 carbons going through one by one is interfering with itself this is a gigantic object by any sort of uh comparison to uh single electrons um and we're seeing these interference fringes so this is a pretty CH to force experiment but I just want to emphasize that if you could do this with you know your neighbor it would work you just have to isolate the system well enough and that's a technological challenge but not an in principle one um okay and yeah good okay so um one last we have we have one last experimental fact to deal with and this is Bell's inequality and this is my favorite one so bills inequality for many years uh languished in obscurity until someone realized that it could actually be done uh beautifully in an experiment it led to a very concrete experiment that they could actually do and that they wanted to do and we now think of it as a enormously influential idea uh uh which which Nails the coffin closed for classical mechanics and it starts with a very simple question I claim that the following inequality is true the number of undergraduate of the number of people in the room who are undergraduates which I'll denote as and not blonde which I will denote it as Barb so undergraduates who are not blond actually let me write this out in English it's going to be easier number who are undergrads and not blonde plus the number of people in the room who are blonde but not from Massachusetts is strictly great than or equal to the number of people in the room who are undergraduates and not from Massachusetts I claim that this is true I haven't checked in this room but I claim this let's check how many people are undergraduates who are not blonde this is going to jeez okay that's yeah so lot okay how many people are blonde but not from Massachusetts okay uh uh a smattering oh God this is this is actually going to be terrible um uh uh uh uh uh uh shoot uh this is a really large class okay um small um and how many people are uh undergraduates are not from Massachusetts yeah this is oh God this county is going to be so let's I'm going to do this just so I can do the counting with the first two rows here okay my life is going to be easier this way so how many people in the first two rows uh in the center section are undergraduates but not not blonde okay 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 we could dispute some of those but we'll we'll take it for the moment so 14 um I me you're probably all undergraduates so um blonde and not from Massachusetts one awesome undergraduates not from Massachusetts 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 equality okay so so that that and so you might say well look you should have been nervous there uh you know and admittedly sometimes there's experimental error but uh but but I I want to convince you that I should never ever ever be nervous about this moment in 804 and the reason is the following I want to prove this for you and the way I'm going to prove it is slightly more General in more generality I want to prove to you that the number of if I have a set or soor the number of people who are undergraduates and not blonde which I'll write as B bar plus the number who are blonde but not for Massachusetts is greater than or equal to the number that are undergraduates and not from Massachusetts so how do I prove this well if you're an undergraduate and not blonde you may or you may not be from massachusett so this is equal to the number of undergraduates who are not blonde and are from Massachusetts plus the number of undergraduates who are not blonde and are not from Massachusetts it could hardly be otherwise you either are or you are not from Massachusetts not the sort of thing I normally see in a physics so um so this is so similar the number of people who are blonde and not from Massachusetts number of people who are blonde who are so if you're blonde and not from Massachusetts you may or may not be an undergraduate so this is the number of people who are undergraduates blonde and not from Massachusetts plus the number of people who are not undergraduates are blonde oops are blonde and are not from Massachusetts and on the right hand side so adding these two together gives us plus and plus on the right hand side the number of people who are undergraduates and not from Massachusetts well each one could be either blonde or not blonde so this is equal to the number that are undergraduates blonde and not from Massachusetts plus the number that that are undergraduates not blonde and not for Massachusetts agreed I am now going to use the awesome power of and so this is what we want to prove I'm now going to use the awesome power of subtraction and note that ubm bar ubm bar these guys cancel and U Bar Bar M Bar U Bar Bar M Bar these guys canceled and we're left with the following proposition the number of undergraduates who are not blonde but are from Massachusetts plus the number of undergrad of not undergraduates who are blonde but not from Massachusetts must be greater than or equal to zero can you have a number of people in a room satisfying some condition be less than zero can minus three of you be blonde undergraduates not from Massachusetts not so much this is a strictly positive number because it's enumerative it's counting problem how many are undergraduates not BL and from Massachusetts yeah everyone cool with that so it could hardly have been otherwise it had to work out like this and here's the more general statement the more general statement is that the number of people or the number of elements of any set where each element in that set has binary properties a b and c a or not a b or not b c or not C satisfies the following inequality number who are a but not B plus the number who are B but not C is greater than or equal to the number who are a but not C and this is exactly the same argument and this inequality which is a topology really is called Bell's inequality and it's obviously true what did I use to derive this logic and integers right I mean that's Bedrock stuff here's the problem I didn't mention this last time but in fact electrons have a third property in addition to electrons have a third property in addition to uh hardness and color the third property is called Whimsy and you can either be Whimsical or not Whimsical and every electron when measured is either Whimsical or not Whimsical you never have a boring electron you never have a ambiguous electron always Whimsical or not Whimsical so we have hardness we have color we have Whimsy okay and I can perform the following experiment from a set of electrons I can measure the number that are hard uh but um hard and uh not black and whims plus the number that are black uh but not Whimsical and I can measure the number that are hard and not Whimsical okay and I want to just open up the case a little bit and tell you that the hardness here really is the angular momentum of the electron along the xaxis color is the angular momentum of the electron along the y- AIS and Whimsy is the angular momentum of the electron along the z-axis these are things I can measure because I can measure angular momenta so I can perform this experiment with electrons and it needn't be satisfied in particular we will show that the number of electrons just to be very precise the number of electrons in a given set which are have positive angular momentum along the uh x-axis and down along the y- AIS plus up along the y- axis and down along the z-axis is less than the number that are up actually let me do this in a very particular way up uh zero down at Theta up at Theta down at 2 Theta is greater than the number that are up at zero and down at Theta now here's the thing 2 Theta you can't at the moment understand what this equation means but if I just tell you that these are three binary properties of the electron okay and that it violates this inequality there is something deeply troubling about this result Bell's inequality which we count which we proved trivially using integers using logic is false in quantum mechanics and it's not just false in quantum mechanics we will at the end of the course derive the the quantum mechanical prediction for this result and show that it leads to a predicted violation of bells inequality this experiment has been done and the real world violates Bell's inequality logic and integers and adding probabilities as we have done is misguided and our job which we will begin with the next lecture is to find a better way to add probabilities than classically and that will be quantum mechanics see you on Tuesday