Transcript
the following content is provided under a creative commons license your support will help mit opencourseware continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of mit courses visit mit open courseware at ocw.mit.edu so today before we get uh into the meat of today's lecture um matt has very kindly professor evans has uh very kindly uh agreed to uh do an experiment yeah so for those of y'all who are who are in recitations both he and martin talked about polarization uh in wrestling last week and matt will pick it up from there so uh back to the ancient past this was a week ago we had our hyper-intelligent monkeys that were sorting things that all seemed very theoretical and in recitation i said things about polarizers and said look if we use polarizers we can do exactly the same thing as these monkeys we just need to you know set up a little polarization experiment and the results are identical you can use one to figure out the other but i didn't have this or nice polarizers or anything to give a demo so so here we go what i'm going to show you is that if we start with uh something polarized here with all white and that's right now i have all vertical polarization here and if i just put on this other box there which is going to be another polarizer if i put it the same way this is all of our white electrons coming through all white see it doesn't really do much and if i look at the black output over here of the second color sorting box that's the same as turning my polarizer 90 degrees so nothing comes out black so this is our if we remove this guy from the middle you have just exactly what you'd expect you sort here you have white and you get all white out great everyone thought that was easy we all had that figured out this box got thrown in the center here and and it became sort of confusing because you thought well they were white so i'm going to throw my box in the middle here that's this guy 45 degrees then if i throw this guy on the end again the idea was well they were all white here so maybe this guy identified the soft ones from the white ones and now we have white and soft and they should still all be white right so i put this guy on up here they should all come out but sort of don't and you say well are they black well no they're not really black either there's some sort of strange combination of the two right so that's that's this experiment done in polarizers but let me just play the polarizer trick a little bit because it's fun so this is if i say vertical polarization and then how many of them come out horizontal so here i'm saying white and how many of them come out black that's the analogy right the answer is none of them and strangely if i take this thing which seems to just attenuate this is our middle box here and i just stuff it in between them i can get something to come out even though i still have cross polarizers on the side so you can see the middle region is now brighter and you can still see the dark corners there of the cross polarizers and as i turn this guy around i can make that better or worse the maximum is somewhere right there and it goes off again so this is a way of understanding our electron sorting hyper-intelligent monkeys in terms of polarizations and here it's just a vector projected on another vector projecting another vector something everybody knows how to do so here's the polarization analogy of this dan garlic experiment all right awesome so the the polarization analogy for uh for interference effects in quantum mechanics is a canonical one uh in uh the text of quantum mechanics so you'll find lots of books talking about this it's a very useful analogy and i encourage you to read more about it we won't talk about it a whole lot more but it's a useful one all right before i get going any questions from last lecture last lecture was pretty much self-contained it was experimental results no nothing all right um the one thing that uh that i i want to add to the last lecture the one last experimental observations i glossed over something um it's kind of important which is the following so we started off by saying look uh we know that if i have a a ray of light it's a wave it's a electromagnetic wave and it has some wavelength lambda and uh and yet the um the photoelectric effect tells us that in addition to having a wavelength lambda the energy it has a frequency as well a frequency in time and the photoelectric effect suggested that the energy is proportional to the frequency and we wrote this as h nu and h bar is equal to h upon 2 pi and omega is equal to 2 pi nu okay so this is just the angular frequency rather than the number per time frequency and h bar is the reduced plunk constant so i'll typically write h bar omega rather than h nu because these two pies will just cause us endless pain if we don't use the bar um anyway so to an electromagnetic wave we have a wavelength and a frequency and the photoelectric effect led us to predict that the energy is linearly proportional to the frequency with linear proportionality coefficient h bar plunk's constant and the momentum is equal to h upon lambda whoops h upon lambda also known as see i'm going to write this as h bar k which is equal to h upon lambda where here again h bar is h upon 2 pi and so k is equal to pi upon lambda so k is called the wave number and you should have seen this in nato 4803 so these are our basic relations for uh for light we know that light as an electromagnetic wave has a frequency and a wavelength or a wave number and inverse wavelength uh and the claim of the photoelectric effect is that the energy and the momentum of that light are thus quantized that light comes in chunks so it has a wave-like aspect and it also has properties that are more familiar from particles now early on shortly after einstein proposed this a young french physicist named de broy said well look okay this is true of light light has both wave-like and particle-like properties um why is it just light the world would be much more parsimonious if this relation were true not just of light but also of all particles i am thus conjecturing with no evidence whatsoever that um in fact this relation holds not just for light but for any object any object with momentum uh p has associated to a wavelength or a wave number uh which is p upon h bar every object that has energy e has associated with it a wave with wave with frequency omega to those electrons that we send through the davis and germa experiment apparatus which are sent in with definite energy there must be a frequency associated with an omega and a wavelength lambda associated with it and what we saw from the davis and german experiment was experimental confirmation of that prediction that electrons have both particulate and wave-like features simultaneously so these relations are called the de bruy relations or de broglie i leave it up to you to decide how to pronounce that uh and those relations are going to play an important role for us in the next few lectures i just want to give them a name and a little context this is a good example of parsimony and elegance theoretical elegance leading you to an idea that turns out to be true of the world now that's a dangerous strategy for finding truth right boy wouldn't it be nice if right wouldn't it be nice if you know we didn't have to pay taxes but we also had medicare um but but of course you know so that's not a terribly useful uh uh guide all the time but sometimes it really does lead you in the right direction this is a great example of physical intuition wildly divorced from experiment pushing you in the right direction i'm making it sound a little more shocking than well it was shocking it was just shocking okay um so with that said let me introduce the the moves for the next few lectures for the next several lectures here's what we're going to do i am not going to give you experimental motivation i've given you experimental motivation i'm going to give you a set of rules okay a set of postulates these are going to be the rules of quantum mechanics and what quantum mechanics is for us is a set of rules to allow us to make predictions about the world okay and these rules will be awesome if their predictions are good and if their predictions are bad these rules will suck right we will avoid bad rules to the degree possible i'm going to give you what we've learned over the past you know 100 years wow of developing quantum mechanics um that is amazing um wow okay yeah over the past 100 years of developing quantum mechanics um and i'm going to give them to you as a series of postulates and then we're going to work through the consequences and then we're going to spend the rest of the semester studying examples to develop an understanding for what the rules of quantum mechanics are giving you okay so we're just going to scrap classical mechanics and start over from scratch so let me do that and to begin let me start with the definition of a system and to understand that definition i want to start with classical mechanics as a guide so in classical mechanics let's think about the easiest classical system you can just a single particle sitting somewhere in classical mechanics of a single particle how do you specify the configuration or the state just different word for the same thing how do you specify the configuration or state of the system a specified position momentum exactly so in classical mechanics if you want to completely specify the configuration system you all you have to do is give me x and p for my particle and you if you tell me this i know everything if you know these numbers you know everything in particular what i mean by saying you know everything is that if there's anything else you want to measure the energy for example the energy is just some function of the position and momentum and if you know the position of the momentum you can unambiguously calculate the energy similarly the angular momentum which is a vector you can calculate if you know x and p which is just you know r cross p okay so this gives you complete knowledge of the system there's nothing more to know if you know that data now there are certainly still questions that you can't answer given knowledge of x and p okay for example are there 14 invisible monkeys standing behind me i'm here i'm not moving are there 14 invisible monkeys standing behind me you can't answer that it's a stupid question right okay let me give you another example the electron is x and p some position is it happy right so there are still questions you can't answer the point is complete knowledge of the system to answer any physically observable question any question that could be meaningfully turned into an experiment the answer is contained in knowing the state of the system cool okay but this can't possibly be true in quantum mechanics because as you saw in the problem set and as we've discussed previously there's an uncertainty relation which says that your knowledge or your uncertainty rather in the position of a particle quantum mechanically uh and i'm not going to say quantum mechanically i'm just going to say the real world okay so in the real world your the our uncertainty in the position of our point like object and our uncertainty in the momentum is always greater than or roughly equal to uh something that's proportional to planck's constant okay you can't be arbitrarily confident of the position and of the momentum simultaneously you work through a good example of this on the problem set we saw this in the two-slit experiment and the interference of electrons this is something we're gonna have to deal with so as a consequence you can't possibly specify the position and the momentum with confidence of a system you can't do it okay this was a myth it was a good approximation turned out to be false so the first thing we need is to specify the state the configuration of a system so what specifies the configuration of a system and so this brings us to the first postulate the configuration or state of a system and here i'm again just for simplicity i'm going to talk about a single object of a quantum object is completely specified completely specified by a single function a wave function which i will denote generally psi of x which is a complex function okay the state of a quantum object is completely specified once you know the wave function of the system which is a function of position i'm going to let me emphasize that this is a first pass at the position what we're going to do is go through the first the basic posits of quantum mechanics then we'll go through them again and give them a little more generality and then we'll go through them again and give them full generality that last pass is 805.
okay so let me give you some examples let me just draw some characteristic wave functions okay and these are going to turn out to be useful for us yeah good so for example consider the following function so here is zero and we're plotting as a function of x and i'm plotting the real part of psi of x okay so first consider a very narrowly supported function it's basically zero everywhere except it has some particular spot at what i'll call x1 okay here's another wave function zero it's basically zero except for some special spot at x2 okay and again i'm plotting the real part of psi and i'm plotting the real part of psi because a psi is a complex function at every point it specifies a complex number and b i can't draw complex numbers so to keep my head from exploding i'm just plotting the real part of the wave function but you should never forget that the wave function is complex so for the moment i'm going to assume that the imaginary part is zero i'm just going to draw the real parts so let me draw a couple more examples what else could be a good wave function well those are fine what about again we want a function of x and i'm going to draw the real part okay and another one so this is going to be a perfectly good wave function okay and let me draw three more two more so what else could be a reasonable wave function well this is harder than you'd think oh god okay so that's that's that could be the wave function i don't know and that is actually my signature my wife calls it a little gift um okay so so here's the deal um size is a complex function psi also needs to not be a stupid function okay so you have to ask me look could it be any function any arbitrary function so this is gonna be a job for us we're gonna have to define what it means to be a not stupid function well this is a completely reasonable function it's you know fine this is a reasonable function another reasonable function reasonable that's a little weird but it's you know it's not horrible um that's stupid right that is a so we're going to give you a we're going to have to come up with a good definition of of what not stupid means so fine these are all functions one of them is multi-valued and that looks a little worrying but they're all functions so here's the problem what does it mean so postulate two the meaning of the wave function is that the probability that upon measurement the object is found at the position x is equal to the norm squared of psi of x okay if you know the system is described by the wave function psi and you want to look at point x you want to know with what probability will i find the particle there the answer is psi squared notice that this is a complex number but absolute value squared or norm squared of a complex number is always a real non-negative number and that's important because we want our probabilities to be real non-negative numbers it could be zero right it could be zero chance of something it can't be negative seven chance okay incidentally there also can't be probability two right so that means that the total probability had better be normalized so let me just say this in words though first so p which is the norm squared of psi determines the probability and in particular the probability density that the object in state psi in the state given by the wave function psi of x uh will be found at x okay so there's the second postula so in particular when i say it's a probability density what i mean is the probability that it is found between the position x and x plus dx is equal to p of x dx okay which is equal to psi of x squared dx okay does that make sense so the probability that it's found in this infinitesimal interval is equal to this density times dx or psi squared dx now again we need it's crucial that the wave function is in fact properly normalized because if i say look something could either be here it could be here what's the what's the sum of the probability that's here plus a probability that is here it had better be one right or there's some other possibility so probabilities have to sum to one total probability that you find something somewhere must be one so what that tells you is that total probability which is equal to the integral over all possible values of x so if i sum over all possible values of x p of x uh all values should be equal to one and we can write this as integral dx over all values of x and i write all here rather than putting minus infinity to infinity because some systems will be defined from one to minus one some systems will be defined from minus infinity to infinity all just means integrate over all possible values hold on one sec of psi squared squared for yep to understand probability uh i'm not going to probability density is going to have just one argument and total probability is going to be have an interval as an argument okay so they're distinct and this is just a notation i like other questions okay um just as a side note what are the dimensions of the wave function so everyone think about this one for a second all right what are dimensions awesome yes it's one over length dimensions of psi are one over root length and the way to see that is that this should be equal to one it's a total probability this is an infinitesimal length so this has dimensions of length this has no dimension so the set must have dimensions of one over length and so psi itself of x must have dimensions of one over root length now something i want to emphasize i'm going to emphasize over and over in this class is dimensional analysis you need to become comfortable with dimensional analysis it's absolutely essential okay it's essential for two reasons first off it's essential because i'm going to be merciless in taking off points if you do write down a dimensionally false thing if you write down something on a problem center an exam that's like a length is equal to a velocity not good but the second thing is forget the fact that i'm going to take off points dimensional analysis is an incredibly powerful tool for you you can check something that you've just calculated and even better yet sometimes you can just avoid a calculation entirely by doing a dimensional analysis and seeing that there's only one possible way to build something of dimension's length in your system so we'll do that over and over again but this is a question i want you guys to start asking yourselves at every step along the way of a calculation what are the dimensions of all the objects in my system something smells like smoke um okay so with that said if that's the meaning of the wave function what physically can we take away what physically can we take away from knowing these wave functions well if this is the wave function let's draw the probability distribution what's the probability distribution p of x and the probability distribution here is really very simple it's again zero squared is still zero so it's still just a big spike at x1 and this one is a big spike at x2 okay everyone called that so what is what is what do you know when i tell you that this is the wave function describing your system you know that with great confidence you will find the particle be sitting at x1 if you look right so what this is telling you is you expect x is roughly x1 and our uncertainty in x is small everyone called that similarly here you see that the position is likely to be x2 and your uncertainty in your measurement your confidence in your prediction is another way to say it is quite uh quite good so your uncertainty is small now what about these guys well now it's norm squared i need to tell you what the wavefunction is here the wavefunction that i want and so here's zero the wavefunction is e to the i k one x and here the wave function is equal to e to the i k 2 x and remember i'm drawing the real part because you know of practical limitations so the real part is just a sinusoid or in fact a cosine and similarly here the real part is a cosine and i really should put zero in the appropriate place but that worked out well okay good so now now the question is what's the probability distribution p of x associated to these wave functions so what's the norm squared of minus e to the ikx if i have a complex number if i have a complex number uh a phase e to the i alpha and i take its norms squared what do i get one right so remember complex numbers if we have a complex number alpha or sorry if we have a complex number beta then beta squared is by definition beta complex conjugate times beta so e to the i alpha if the complex conjugate is e to the minus i alpha e to the i alpha times e to the minus psi alpha they cancel out that's one okay so if this is the wave function what's the probability distribution well it's one it's independent of x right so from this we've learned two important things the first is this is not properly normalized that's not so key but the most important thing is if this is our wave function and we subsequently measure the position of the particle we look at it we say ah there's the particle where are we likely to find it yeah it could be anywhere right so what what's the value of x you expect typical x i have no idea no information whatsoever none but and correspondingly what is our uncertainty in the position of x that we will measure it's very large exactly now in order to tell you it's actually infinite i need to stretch this off and tell you that it's actually constant off to infinity and my arms aren't that long so i'll just say large similarly here if our wave function is e to the ik2 x here k2 is larger the wavelength is shorter what's the probability distribution it's again constant right so if this is zero zero so again x we have no idea and our uncertainty in the x is large and in fact it's very large everyone call that questions what about these guys okay this is the the real challenge okay so if this is our wave function and let's just say that it's it's real hard as it is to believe that then what's our probability distribution well it's something like i don't know it's something you get the point okay so where is uh so if this is our probability distribution where are we likely to find the particle well now it's a little more difficult right because we're unlikely to find it here well it's reasonably likely to find here unlikely here reasonably likely unlikely like you know it's a mess so where is this i'm not really sure what's our uncertainty well our uncertainty is not infinite right because okay my name ends at some point so this is going to go to zero didn't go to zero so whatever else we know we know it's in this region so it's you know it's not infinite it's it's you know not small we'll say but it's not arbitrarily it's not uh it's not tiny oh sorry it's not gigantic that's what i meant it's not our uncertainty is not gigantic uh not gigantic but it's still pretty non-trivial because we i know i can say with some confidence that's more likely to be here than here but i really don't know which of those peaks it's going to be found right okay now what about this guy what's the probability distribution well now you see why this is a stupid wave function because it's multiply valued it has multiple different values at every value of x so what's the probability well might be it's root two maybe it's one over root three i'm really not sure right so this tells us an important lesson this is stupid and what i mean by stupid is uh it is multiple valued so the wave function we've just learned a lesson should be single valued okay and we will explore some more on your problem set which will be posted immediately after lecture there are problems that walk you through a variety of other potential pathologies of the wave function uh and guide you to some more intuition for example the wave function really needs to be continuous as well you'll see why all right questions at this point okay so these look like pretty useful wave function because they correspond to the particle being at some definite spot and i for example at a reasonably definite spot um these two wave functions they'll look pretty much useless because they give us no information whatsoever about what the position is everyone agree with that except remember the de broglie relations the debris relations say that associated to a particle is also some wave and the momentum of that particle is determined by the wavelength it's inversely related to the wavelength proportional to the wave number and the energy is proportional to the frequency now look at those wave functions those wave functions give us no position information whatsoever but they have very definite wavelengths those are periodic functions with definite wavelengths in particular this guy has a wavelength of from here to here yeah it has a wave number k k1 so that tells us that if we measure the momentum of this particle we can be pretty confident because it has a reasonably well defined wavelength corresponding to some wave number k 2 pi upon the wavelength it has some momentum and if we measured it we should be pretty confident that the momentum will be h bar k1 you ever agree with that looks like a sine wave and de bruy tells us that if you have a wave with wavelength lambda that corresponds to a particle having momentum p now how confident can we be in that estimation of the momentum well if i tell you it's e to the ikx that's exactly a periodic function with wavelength lambda 2 pi upon k so how confident are we pretty confident so our uncertainty in the position or in the momentum is tiny ever agree similarly for this wave again we have a wavelength it's a periodic function but the wavelength is much shorter if the wavelength is much shorter then k is much larger the momentum is much larger so the momentum we expect to measure which is roughly h bar k 2 is going to be much larger what about our uncertainty again it's a perfect periodic function so our uncertainty momentum is small everyone cool with that and that comes again from the de bruy relations so good so questions at this point you guys are real quiet today all right no questions yeah so is so delta p is zero basically it's pretty small now again i can't you know i haven't drawn this off to infinity but if it's exactly e to the ikx then yeah it turns out to be zero now an important thing so let me rephrase your questions slightly so the question was is delta p zero is it really zero so here's the problem for us right now we don't have a definition of delta p okay so what is the definition of delta p i haven't given you one so here when i've said delta p is small what i mean is intuitively just by eyeball our confidence and that momentum is pretty good using the debris relations i have not given you a definition and that will be part of my job over the next couple of lectures very good question yeah so like how would you encode noise in that function just have different wavelengths as you go along awesome so for example this does it have a definite wavelength not so much so um uh ask hold that question and wait until you see the next examples that i put on this board and if that doesn't answer your question ask it again because it's a very important question okay when you talk about like a photon which is like a given well you always say like a photon has a certain frequency doesn't that mean that it must be a wave because you have to like fix the wave number k awesome question does every wave packet of light that hits your eye does it always have a single unique frequency no you can take multiple frequency sources and superpose them an interesting choice of words i used there right so the question is does since you know what light has some wavelength does every you know chunk of light have a definite this is the question roughly yeah so and the answer is light doesn't always have a single you can have light coming at you that has many different wavelengths and put it in a prism and break it up into its various components right so you can have a superposition of different frequencies of light we'll see the same effect happening for us okay so again debray made these where did the there we go uh de bruy made this conjecture that e is h bar omega and p is h bar k um this was verified in the davidson grammar experiment that we ran but here one of the things that's sort of latent in this is what he means is look associated to every particle with energy e and momentum p is a is a plane wave of the form e to the i kx minus omega t okay and this properly in three dimensions should be k dot x but at this point this is an important simplification for the rest of 804 we are going to be doing one dimensional or for the rest of 804 until otherwise specified we are going to be doing one-dimensional quantum mechanics so i'm going to remove arrow marks and dot products there's going to be one spatial dimension and one time dimension we're always going to have just one time dimension but sometimes we'll have more spatial dimension but it's going to be a while till we get there so for now we're just going to have kx so this is a general plane wave and what de bruy really was saying is that somehow associated to the particle with energy e and momentum p should be some wave a plane wave with wave number k and frequency omega and that's the wave function associated to it the thing is not every wave function is a plane wave some wave functions are well localized some of them are just complicated morasses some of them are just a mess okay so now is the most important postulate in quantum mechanics i remember vividly vividly when um so when i took the analog of this class it was called uh physics 143a at harvard and the uh the professor at this point said i know him well now he's a friend he said this is what quantum mechanics is all about and i was so psyched and they told me and it was like that's ridiculous seriously that's what quantum mechanics is all about so i always thought this is some weird thing where like old physicists go crazy but it turns out i'm really gonna i'm gonna say exactly the same thing this is the most important thing in all of quantum mechanics it is all contained in the following proposition everything the two slit experiments the tube the box experiments all the cool stuff in quantum mechanics all the strange and counter-intuitive stuff comes directly from the next postulate so here it is i love this three put a star on it given two possible wave functions or states i'll say configurations of a quantum system i wish there was like right of the valkyries you know playing in the background so um of a quantum system corresponding to two distinct wave functions okay f with an upper ns is going to be my notation for functions uh because i have to write it a lot psi one and psi two and i'll say of x of x the system is down the system can also be in a superposition of side one and side two where alph and beta are complex numbers given any two possible configurations of the system there is also an allowed configuration of the system corresponding to being in an arbitrary superposition of them if an electron can be hard and it can be soft it can also be in an arbitrary superposition of being hard and soft and what i mean by that is that hard corresponds to some particular wave function soft will correspond to some particular wave function and a superposition corresponds to a different wave function which is a linear combination of them yeah okay that's a very good question so a and b alpha and beta are some complex numbers subjects to the normalization condition so indeed this wave function should be properly normalized at the end now let me step back for a second there's an alternate way to phrase the probability distribution here which goes like this and i'm going to put it here the alternate statement of the probability distribution is that the probability density at x is equal to psi of x norm squared divided by the integral over all x dx of psi squared okay so notice that if we properly normalize the wave function this denominator is equal to one but if we haven't properly normalized and so it's not there right then it's equivalent but if we haven't properly normalized it then this probability distribution is automatically properly normalized because this is a constant when we integrate the top that's equal to the bottom it integrates to one cool so i prefer personally in thinking about this for the first pass to just require that we always be careful to choose some normalization that won't always be easy and so sometimes it's useful to forget about normalizing and just to find the probability just probability distribution that way is that cool okay this is the beating soul of quantum mechanics everything in quantum mechanics is in here everything in quantum mechanics is forced on us from these few principles uh and a couple of requirements of matching to reality yeah when you do this like linear two-way yes can you get like interference yes excellent so the question is when you have a sum of two wave functions can you get some sort of interference effect and the answer is absolutely and that's exactly what we're going to do next so in particular let me look at a particular pair of superpositions so let's swap these boards around the parallelism is a little more obvious okay so let's scrap these rather silly wave functions and come up with something that's a little more interesting so instead of using those as characteristic wave functions i want to build superpositions so in particular i want to start by taking an arbitrary these both these wave functions is a simple interpretation this corresponds to a particle being here this corresponds to a particle being here i want to take a superposition of them so here's my superposition okay oops let's try that again good and my superposition so here's zero and here's x1 and here's x2 my superposition is going to be some amount times the first one plus some amount times the second one there's a superposition similarly i could have taken the superposition of the two functions on the second chalkboard and again i'm taking a superposition of the complex e to the ik one x and e to the ik two x and then taking the real part okay so that's a particular superposition particularly linear combination so now let's go back to this this was a particle that was here this was a particle that was there when we take the superposition what is the probability distribution where is this particle well there's some amplitude that it's here and there's some amplitude that it's here there's rather more amplitude that it's over here but there's still some probability that it's over here right where am i going to find the particle i'm not so sure anymore it's either going to be here or here but i'm not positive and it's more likely to be here than it is to be here but not a whole lot more so where am i going to find the particle well now we have to define this where i'm going to find the particle look if i did this experiment a whole bunch of times it'd be over here more than it would be over here so the average will be somewhere around here it'll be in between the two so x is somewhere in between that's where we expect to find it on average okay what's our uncertainty in the position well it's not that small anymore it's now you know of order x1 minus x2 you ever agree with that bless you now what about this guy well does this thing have a period does it have a single wavelength sorry no this is like light that comes at you from the sun it has many wavelengths in this case it has just two i've added those two together so this is a plane wave which is psi is e to the ik 1x plus e to the ik 2x okay so in fact it has two wavelengths associated with it lambda 1 and lambda 2.
and so the probability distribution now if we take the norm squared of this the probability distribution now which is the norm squared of this guy is no longer constant but there's an interference term and let's just see how that works out let me be very explicit about this note that the probability in our superposition of psi one plus psi two which i'll call e to the ik one x plus e to the ik two x the probability is equal to the norm squared of the wave function which is the superposition psi one plus beta psi 2 which is equal to alpha squared psi 1 squared plus beta squared psi 2 squared plus alpha star whoops psi one star actually let me write this over here plus alpha star psi one star uh beta cy2 plus alpha psi 1 beta star psi 2 star where star means complex conjugation but notice that this is equal to that first term is alpha squared times the first probability or the probability of this thing of alpha psi one so this is equal to probability one this term beta squared psi two squared is the probability that the second thing happens but these terms can't be understood in terms of the probabilities of psi one or the probability of psi two alone they're interference terms so the superposition principle together with the interpretation of the probability as the norm squared of the wave function gives us a correction to the classical addition of probabilities which is these interference terms everyone happy with that now here's something very important to keep in mind these things are norm squares of complex numbers that means they're real but in particular they're non-negative so these two are both real and non-negative but what about this this is not the norm squared of anything however this is its complex conjugate when you take something in this complex conjugate you add them together you get something that's necessarily real but it's not necessarily positive so this is a funny thing the probability that something happens if we add together two configurations if we super pose two configurations has positive probability terms but it's also got terms that don't have a definite sign that could be negative it's always real and you can check that this quantity is always greater than or equal to zero it's never negative the total quantity so remember bell's inequality that we talked about bell's inequality said look the probability of one thing happening if we have the probability of one thing happening being p1 and probability the other thing happening being p2 the probability of both things happening is just p1 plus p2 and here we see that in quantum mechanics probabilities don't add that way the wave functions add and the probability is the norm squared of the wave function the wave functions add not the probabilities and that is what underlies all of the interference effects we've seen and it's going to be the heart of the rest of quantum mechanics so you're probably all going in your head more or less like i was when i took into a quantum like yeah but i mean it's just you know you're adding complex numbers but trust me on this one this is where it's all starting okay so let's go back to this similarly let's look at this example we've taken the norm squared and now we have an interference effect and now our probability distribution instead of being totally trivial and containing no information our probability distribution now contains some information about the position of the object it's likely to be here it is unlikely to be here likely and unlikely we now have some position information we don't have enough to say where it is but x is obvious you have some information okay now our uncertainty is still gigantic delta x is still huge you know but okay we just added together two plane waves um yeah excellent this was the real part of the wave function right and the wave function is a complex quantity when you take e to the ik one let me do this on the chalkboard when we take e to the ik one x plus e to the i k two x let me write this slightly differently e to the i a plus e to the i b and take its norm squared okay so this is equal to i'm going to write this in a slightly more suggestive way the norm squared of e to the i a times 1 plus e to the i b minus a okay norm squared oops parentheses squared so first off the norm squared of a product of things is the product of the norm squareds so i can do that and this overall phase the norm squared of a phase is just one so that's just one so now we have the norm squared of one plus a complex number okay and so this is the the north square of 1 is going to give me 1.
the normal square of the complex number is going to give me 1 and the cross terms are going to give me the real part twice the real part of e to the i b minus a which is going to be equal to cosine of b minus a okay and so what you see here is you have a single frequency in the superposition cool okay so again here oh so good so our uncertainty is large so let's look at this second example in a little more detail um by superposing two states with wavelength lambda 1 and lambda 2 or k1 and k2 wow with uh right with wavelengths land1 and lambda2 we got something that okay it's still not well localized we don't know where the particle is going to be but it's better localized than it was before right what happens if we superpose with three wavelengths or four or more so for that i want to pull out a mathematica package you guys should all have seen fourier analysis in um you should all see in free analysis in 1803 but just in case i'm putting on the web page um on the stellar page a notebook that walks you through the basics of fourier analysis in mathematica you should all be fluent in mathematica if you're not you should probably oops come up to speed on it that's not what we wanted um let's try that again there we go oh that's awesome or by awesome i mean not it's coming okay good okay i'm not even gonna mess with the screens after last time um so doo doo um so i'm not gonna go through the the details of this package but what this does is walk you through um the um walk you through the superposition of um of wave packets so here i'm looking at the probability distribution coming from summing up a bunch of plane waves with some definite frequency so here it's just one okay that's one wave so first we have let me make this bigger yes stupid mathematical tricks so here we have the wave function and here we have the probability distribution the norm squared okay and um it's sort of badly normalized here so that's for a single wave and as you see it the probability distribution is constant and that's not zero that's 0.15 it's just i arbitrarily normalized this so let's add two plane waves and now what you see is the same effect as we had here you see a slightly more localized wave function now you have a little bit of structure in the probability distribution so there's the structure in the probability distribution we have a little more information about where the particle is more likely to be here than it is to be here let's add one more and as we keep adding more and more plane waves to our superposition the wave function and the probability distribution associated with it become more and more well localized yeah until as we go to very high numbers of plane waves that we're superposing we get an extremely narrow probability distribution and wave function for that matter extremely corresponding to a particle that's very likely to be here and unlikely to be anywhere else everyone called that what's the expense what what have we lost in the process well we know with great confidence now that the particle will be found here upon observation but what will its momentum be yeah now it's a superposition of a whole bunch of different momenta so if it's a superposition of a whole bunch of different momenta you know that here this is like superposition of a whole bunch of different positions right light could be here likely to be here likely to be here likely to be here what's our knowledge of its position it's not very good similarly now that we have superposed many different momenta with comparable strength in fact here they were all with unit strength we now have no information about what the momentum is anymore it could be anything in that superposition so now we're you know now we're seeing quite sharply the uncertainty relation and here it is go back to the so the uncertainty relation is now pretty clear from these guys oops that didn't work good so the uncertainty relation is oh and i'm going to leave it alone this is enough for the fourier analysis but that fourier package is available with extensive commentary uh on the seller web page yeah now is that sharp definition in the position caused by the interference between all those waves all that that's exactly what it is precisely precisely it's precisely the interference between the different momentum modes that leads to certainty in the position that's exactly right yeah exactly here we are so in in this example we have no idea what the position is we're quite confident of the momentum here we have no idea what the position is but we have great confidence in the momentum similarly here we have less perfect confidence of the position and here we have less perfect confidence in the momentum it would be nice to be able to estimate what our uncertainty is in the momentum here and what our uncertainty is in the position here so we're gonna have to do that that's gonna be one of our next tasks okay other questions yeah you said you know obviously if we do it a bunch of times we'll have more in the next two than a nice one yes the average it will never physically be yeah that's right so because it's a probability distribution it won't be exactly at that point but it'll be nearby okay so in order to be more precise and so for example for this what's our here's a quick question how well do you know the position of this particle pretty well right but how old do you know it's momentum well so we'd all like to see not very but tell me why why is your uncertainty in the momentum of the particle large yeah but that's a cheat because we haven't actually proved heisenberg's uncertainty principle it's just something we're inheriting i believe it too but i want a better argument because i believe all sorts of crazy stuff so um i really do so uh uh black holes fluids i mean look don't get me started yeah yeah excellent okay we'll get to that in just one sec so before taking a fourier transform which is an excellent so the answer was what just take a fourier transform it's going to give you some information we're going to do that in just a moment but before we do 48 transform just intuitively why would de bruy look at this and say no that doesn't have a definite momentum yeah there's no wavelength right it's not periodic by any stretch of the imagination it doesn't look like a thing with a definite wavelength and de bruy said look if you have a definite wavelength then you have a definite momentum and if you have a definite momentum you have a definite wavelength this is not a wave with a definite wavelength so it is not corresponding to the wave function for a particle with a definite momentum so our momentum is unknown so this is large and similarly here our uncertainty in the momentum is large okay so to do better than this we need to introduce the fourier transform and i want to do that now so you've all seen the you should all have seen 48 series in 803 now we're going to do the fourier transform and i'm going to introduce this to you in 804 conventions in the following way and the theorem says the fung we're not going to prove it by any stretch imagination but the theorem says any function f x that is sufficiently well behaved it shouldn't be discontinuous it shouldn't be singular any reasonably well-behaved non-stupid function f x can be built by enough plane waves of the form e to the ikx enough may be infinite so f of x any function f of x can be expressed as 1 over root 2 pi and this root 2 pi is a choice of normalization everyone has their own conventions and these are the ones we'll be using in 804 throughout minus infinity to infinity dk f tilde of k e to the ikx so here what we're doing is we're summing or summing over plane waves of the form e to the ikx these are modes with a definite wavelength 2 pi upon k f tilde oh sorry f tilde of k is telling us the amplitude of the wave with wavelength lambda or wave number k and we sum over all possible values and the claim is any function can be expressed as a superposition of plane waves in this form cool and this is for functions which are non-periodic on the real line rather than periodic functions on the interval which is what you should have seen in 803.
now conveniently if you know f tilde of k you can compute f of x by doing a sum but suppose you know f of x and you want to determine what the coefficients are the expansion coefficients that's the inverse fourier transform and the statement for that is that f tilde of k is equal to one over root two pi integral from minus infinity to infinity dx f of x e to the minus i kx okay and that's sometimes referred to as the inverse fourier transform and here's something absolutely essential f tilde of k the fourier transform coefficients of f of x are completely equivalent if you know f of x you can determine f tilde of k and if you know f tilde of k you can determine f of x by just doing a sum by just adding them up okay so now here's the physical version of this oh i can't slide that up the physical version of this i'm not going to put here oh no i'm not i'm going to put that down here so the physical version of this is that any wave function good any wave function psi of x can be expressed as the superposition in the form psi of x is equal to 1 over root 2 pi integral from minus infinity to infinity dk psi tilde of k e to the ikx of states or wave functions with a definite momentum p is equal to h bar k okay and so now it's useful to sketch the fourier transforms of each of these functions so in fact we want this up here so there is erasers carnage down there um so here we have the function and its probability distribution now i want to draw the fourier transforms of these guys so here's scitilde of k a function of a different variable than of x but nonetheless it's illuminating to draw them next to each other and again i'm drawing the real part and here x2 had i had my brothers about me i would have put x to a larger value ah good so it's further off to the right there huh and similarly i'm so loath to erase the superposition principle uh but fortunately i'm not there yet um let's look at the for a transform of these guys before we transform this guy is now oops this is k psi tilde of k well that's something with a definite value of k and it's fourier transform this is zero there's k one and for this guy zero k2 and now if we look at the fourier transforms of these guys see this way i don't have to erase the superposition principle the fourier transforms of these guys and the fourier transform of this guy okay so note that there's a sort of pleasing symmetry here if your wave function is well localized corresponding to a reasonably well defined position then your fourier transform is not well localized corresponding to not having a definite momentum on the other hand if you have definite momentum your position is not well defined but the fourier transform has a single peak the fourier transform has a single peak at the value of k corresponding to the momentum of your wave of your wave function everyone cool with that so here's a question sorry there was a reason yeah are we going to learn uh in this class how to determine the fourier transforms of these non-student functions yes that will be your homework on your homework is an extensive list of functions for you to compute fourier transforms of um and um and that will be the job of problem sets and recitation um so for a series and computing yeah you know what's coming um so 4a series are assumed to have been covered for everyone in 803 um and 1803 uh in some linear combination thereof um and fourier transforms i couldn't help it so 4k transforms um uh uh our our slight in beginning of the space up for a uh series because we're not looking at periodic functions yeah so um when we're doing like a fourier transform of a wave function we're basically writing as a continuous set of like different uh waves can we write it as a discrete set so like use a fourier series absolutely so however what is true of a fourier series when you when you use a discrete set of momentum which are linear it must be periodic function exactly so the question is do you always have to here what we've done is we've said look we're writing our wave function our arbitrary wave function as a super as a continuous superposition of a continuous value of of possible momentum this is absolutely correct it's exactly what we're doing however that's kind of annoying because continuous maybe you just want like one momentum and two months and three momenta what if you want a discrete series so the screen is fine but if you make that discrete series integer related to each other which is what you do with fourier series you force the function f of x to be periodic and we don't want that in general because life isn't periodic thank goodness right i mean there's like one film in which it but so um it's a good movie um so no so that's the essential difference between fourier series and fourier transforms fourier transforms are continuous in k and do not assume periodicity of the function other questions yeah so basically the fourier transform of precisely precisely correct so let's let me say that again so the question was so a fourier transform effectively associates a magnitude and a phase for each possible wave vector and that's exactly right so here there's some amplitude and phase this is a complex number because this is a complex function there's some complex number which is an amplitude and a phase associated to every possible momentum going into the superposition that amplitude may be zero there may be no contribution for a large number of momenta or maybe insignificantly small but it is indeed doing precisely that is associated an amplitude in a phase for every uh every plane wave with every different value of momentum and you can compute before you know for out before panicking um you can compute uh precisely what that amplitude and phase is by using the inverse fourier transform right so there's no magic here you just you calculate it you know you can use your calculator literally um i hate that word um okay uh so now here's a natural question oh uh so if this is the the fourier transform of our wave function this wavefunction we already knew that this wavefunction corresponded to having a definite from debre we know that it has a definite momentum right we also see that its fourier transform looks like this so that leads to a reasonable guess what do you think the probability distribution p of k is probability density the probability density to find the momentum to have wave vector k h bar k yeah that's a pretty reasonable guess so here's just we're totally pulling this out of the dark psi of k norm squared okay well let's see if that works so psi of k norm squared for this is going to give us a nice well localized function similarly psi of k for this guy and so that makes a lot of sense it's exactly what we expected right definite value of p with very small uncertainty similarly here definite value of p with very small uncertainty rock on however let's look at this guy what is the expected value of p if this is the fourier transform well remember we have to take the norm squared and psi of k was e to the i kx1 the fourier transform you will do much problem you do much practice on taking fourier transforms on the problem set where did my eraser go there it is farewell principle one so what is norm squared of psi tilde look like well just like before the norm squared is constant because the norm squared of a phase is constant and again the norm squared so this is psi tilde of k norm squared we believe we're conjecturing this is p of k you will prove this relation on your problem set you'll prove that it falls from what we've said before uh and similarly this is constant e to the ik x2 okay so now we have no knowledge of the momenta so that also fits the momentum is we have no idea and uncertainty is large and the momentum is we have no idea and the uncertainty is large so in all of these cases we see that we satisfy quite nicely the uncertainty relation small position momentum large momentum uncertainty large position uncertainty we can have we're allowed to have small momentum uncertainty and here it's a little more complicated we have a little bit of knowledge of the position and we have a little bit of knowledge of momenta we have a little bit of knowledge of position and we have a little bit of knowledge in the momenta so we'll walk through examples with superposition like this on the problem set okay last questions before we get going okay so i have one two two things to do before we're done the first is after lecture ends i have clickers and anyone who wants to borrow clickers you're welcome to to come down and pick them up in a first come first serve basis um uh i will start using the clickers in the next lecture so if you don't already have one get one now but the second thing is don't get started yet i have a demo to do and last time i told you this is awesome it's like having experimentals for a day last time i told you that one of the experimental facts of life is light of life one of the experimental facts of lice one of the experimental facts of life is that uh uh there is uncertainty in the world and that there is probability that there are there are unlikely events that happen with some probability some finding probability and a good example of the randomness of the real world involves radiation so hopefully you can hear this apparently i'm not very radioactive you'd be surprised at the things that are radioactive nope got a little tick okay this is a plate sold at an amish county fair it's called uh vaseline ware and it's made of local clays it's got uranium in it okay but even more exciting and i just you know i want to emphasize you know exactly when something goes click it sounds pretty random and it's actually a better random number generator than anything you'll find in you know mathematica or c in fact in some for some purposes the decay of radioactive isotopes is used as the perfect random number generator because it really is totally random as far as anyone can tell but here's my favorite people used to eat off these see you next time