Transcript
The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseware at ocw.mit.edu. Okay, so let me just quickly remind you of what we've done what we did last time. Um So, unfortunately, today is going to be a little bit um of what I wanted to do this time and a little bit of what I would have wanted to have been done in recitation yesterday because all recitations were canceled. So, today is going to include a few steps along the way um that I skipped over last time.
Okay, so to review from last time we talked about central potentials, the energy operator had a radial derivative term, an angular momentum term, and a potential term. So, this would be true regardless of whether we were central or not, but if we have a central potential where this only depends on the magnitude of the radius vector, then we can use separation of variables and write an energy eigenstate as a radial part, which we will sneakily pull out a factor of one over the radius um as we saw last time that was particularly convenient. It took care of this R and made everything nice and simple.
So, uh a radial part times a spherical harmonic. The reason we use a spherical harmonic is that none of neither of these two terms depend on the angular coordinates. The angular momentum we know what its eigen functions are, so if we use a spherical harmonic, the angular momentum becomes just a constant. And having separated in this form and pulling out that sneaky factor of one over R, the energy eigenvalue equation reduces to a simple 1D effective energy eigenvalue equation with a simple dr squared um and an effective potential where the effective potential is the original central potential plus an angular momentum term, often referred to as the angular momentum barrier.
Um where which is proportional to, you know, as Matt says, uh as Professor Evans says, uh in 804 one is forced to say h bar squared upon 2m repeatedly, and he pointed out that it would be much more efficient if I would just come up with a simple variable for saying it or or or sound. So, I will attempt to henceforth call it So, So, the effective potential is L L plus one upon R squared plus the central part of the potential. Props to Professor Evans. Um and this is true in general for a central potential. The last thing we notice of this is that since the energy eigenvalue equation has been reduced to this form, which depends on L but is independent of M.
M appears nowhere here. The energy can't possibly depend the energy can't possibly depend on uh M, although it can depend on L. It's just E of L, and thus for every different value of M, I will get the same energy. Fixed L, different M. And there are how many values of M for a fixed L? 12 plus one. So, the the degeneracy degeneracy of E L is 2L plus one. Right? That's general for any central potential that only requires spherical symmetry. Okay. So, then we studied the example of the Coulomb potential where the potential is minus e squared upon R. And we solved or I quickly reviewed the solution of the um of the energy eigenvalue equation.
Um yeah, okay, let me write it that way. Where R of uh what I will call uh in in place of E, I will simply write n, R n L of um sorry, is equal to uh e to the minus R over 2 R naught. Um uh n times R over R naught to the L plus one times some simple function V sub n L of R over R naught. With the energy n L M being equal to E naught uh or I should say E Rydberg in our notation last time upon n squared minus bound state. So, let's talk about this quickly. This term, the the fact that it goes exponentially falls exponentially at large distances came from um the asymptotic analysis uh at R goes to infinity.
And this is just saying it's a bound state. The probability density falls off exponentially as we go out to large radius. Yeah? This term came from the asymptotic analysis near R goes to zero. And near R goes to zero, the only term that matters is in V effective, this is one upon R, this is one over R squared, so this gets large more rapidly. This term is important and that L L plus one gave us R to the L plus one. We worked in dimensionless variables rho, and here I replaced rho with R over R naught where R naught was the characteristic scale we computed last time. And finally, this function V sub n L satisfied it had it was again satisfying the um energy eigenvalue equation, but having pulled out these factors such that asymptotically it's regular.
So, this function must be regular, smooth, no divergences, no poles um as uh R goes to infinity and to zero. Okay? And then we solved this by series expansion. And from termination of the series expansion, we got that the energy we got a relationship between the energy and L and M, and in particular, the relationship um this came from termination of the series just like it did for the harmonic oscillator. And the termination of the series gave us that the energy was equal to minus a constant over n squared. Okay? With one additional condition, which was that n had to be greater than L. n had to be an integer greater than L, and L of course has to be greater than or equal to zero.
So, let me just quickly tell you how this arises because this is an important fact about hydrogen, which I want you to understand. So, the way that arises is we do we we got the energy from a series expansion for this remaining function of R, V n L of R. And that series expansion started out by saying let V be of the form a sum over J of um A sub J uh R over R naught the dimensionless variable rho uh to the J to the Jth power, so it's a power series. And when we plug this whole form together with this series expansion into that differential equation, we get a just like we did before for harmonic oscillator, we get a a set of relations between the various coefficients in that series, and we solve that by saying A sub J plus one by deriving a recursion relation is equal to A sub J times uh two square root of epsilon times uh ooh, I'm going to be careful J plus L plus one Okay, J plus L plus one, yes, good, minus one upon uh J plus one J plus 2L plus two.
Okay. So, okay, fine, we get this recursion relation, looks absolutely awful, but it tells you that if you know A zero, say is a constant, one sec. If you know A zero is a constant which is not zero, right? If it's zero, then they're all zero, then this function is identically zero because A J plus one is A J times some constant. So, this had better not vanish, A sub zero. So, if the first term, the constant term doesn't vanish, which is good, it tells us V doesn't vanish, so we've already learned something. If V doesn't vanish um identically at the origin, then we can determine A one from A zero by multiplying by this.
J is zero in this, and L is whatever number we fixed from Y L M. And so on, we can deduce all the higher A sub L's. It's a series expansion, and this is the this is the recursion relation for it. However, note the following thing. As A as J gets large, so as we go out to higher and higher orders in the series, as we go to higher and higher order in the series, then J is much larger than whatever a fixed number L is and much larger than whatever fixed number two is. So, this asymptotes to A J times roughly two epsilon J upon J plus one J. At very large J, this just goes to two epsilon over J. Now, let's think about what that means.
If I have that A J plus one uh is roughly equal to A J times root epsilon times two over J plus uh plus one, I guess. Then this tells me that every time I increase J, I get a factor of J plus one and another factor of two to the epsilon. This tells me that A sub J is equal to A sub naught times two root epsilon to the J over J factorial. But those are the expansion coefficients of an exponential. Right? Quantity to the n over n factorial. But that's bad because if this series is the exponential series with argument two root epsilon, then this uh then this series becomes e to the 2 root epsilon r over r naught.
But that's bad because that would exactly swamp this term. Right? That would defeat the asymptotic analysis we did at the beginning. If this term is if v is growing so large twice as rapidly as this is diverging or is is going to zero, then the net is diverging at infinity. That's bad. So in order for this to describe for the series expansion to describe a good function that really does vanish at infinity, we need that this doesn't happen. So it must be true that j doesn't get large enough that the exponential in v overwhelms the decaying exponential from the asymptotic analysis. Everyone cool with that?
So it has to terminate. But if it terminates, let's look at the coefficient here. If it terminates, this says that 2 root epsilon uh times j plus and if it terminates sorry, if it terminates, that says that there's some j maximum. Well, let me write it over here. If it terminates, that means there's some value of j such that a j plus 1 is zero. But if a j plus 1 is zero, how can that possibly be? It must be if that for that maximum value of of j, the numerator vanishes. Specifically for that maximum value of j. Yeah? But what's the condition for that numerator to vanish for a specific value of j?
I'll call j sub m or j max the maximum value such that a sub j max plus 1 vanishes. So j plus l plus 1 must be equal to 1. Or said differently, epsilon, which is the energy in units of e naught, must be equal to 1 over 4 j max plus l plus 1 quantity squared. Cool? So that means that our solutions are states psi are now labeled by three integers. They're labeled by l and by m from the spherical harmonic, but they're also labeled by the value of j max. Yeah? And j max can be any number from zero to infinity. Right? Strictly it shouldn't be infinite, but any any finite number, any countable any integer.
Because eventually the series terminates at j max. So it's labeled by these three numbers and the energy is equal to of l m j max is equal to e naught minus over 4 and this e naught over 4 we already saw was e Rydberg 13.6 eV uh times what value? Well, here's the energy in units of e naught j m plus l plus 1 quantity squared. Where l is greater than or equal to zero, j sub m is greater than equal to zero and 1 is 1. Right? But this is sort of cumbersome. We can just as well call this quantity n, where n is greater than l as an integer. It can't be equal to l, but it could be 1 greater than l or any greater integer.
Is that cool? So instead of labeling it by j m the the point at which it terminates, the series terminates, we'll label it by n and you can deduce what j m is by subtracting off l for l plus 1 from n. That tells you where the series terminates. Notice that this tells you something nice. This power series for v, if n is equal to l plus 1, has how many terms in it? So don't say it out loud, just think about it for a second. If n is equal to l plus 1, how many terms are there that are non-vanishing in the power series? I won't call on you, but raise your hand when you have an answer. What's the value of j max if n is equal to l plus 1?
So what term is the first one to vanish in the series? Okay, so how many terms are non-vanishing? Yeah, just the one, just the first term. So when n or when l is as large as it can possibly be, when l is equal to n minus 1, v is a constant function. It's just constant. When l is 1 less, when l is n minus 1 or n is l plus 2, then v has two terms in it, a constant and a linear. So the greater the difference between l and n, the more terms there are in the series. Okay? Cool. So anyway, this leads to this form of the energy. But as is usually the case, this sort of a brute force analysis doesn't give us a whole lot of insight into why we get the qualitative features we do.
In particular, the qualitative feature that stands out most obviously to me, I don't know about you guys, is the fact that the degeneracy is now much much larger. In particular, we know from basic principles of a central potential as we just reviewed, that anytime a potential is symmetrically invariant, symmetrically symmetric, it is spherically symmetric, symmetrically symmetric. Anything Anything the potential is spherically symmetric, rotationally invariant, then there must be a degeneracy of 2 l plus 1 for every energy eigenstate. There must be, right? That l can be zero, but if there's any angular momentum, then that degeneracy must be 2 l plus 1.
But this is much more degenerate. Right? This is much more degenerate. And in fact, how degenerate is it? Well, the total degeneracy is Well, for for any given e n, the degeneracy is equal to Well, what are the possible values of l? So we have the sum We have a state for every We have some state for every different value of l. For l could be equal to zero and it can go up to n minus 1. Right? Because again, n is some integer which could vanish l plus 1. So this smallest this can be is zero. So n can be l plus 1 or anything greater. I.e., l can go up to n minus 1, but it can't be any greater. Then for every value of l, there is um a state m.
There's value of m which could be minus l all the way up to l in integer steps. So how many states are there? Well, there's one state for every value of n l and m. So it's this sum. The sum on m from minus l to l is 2 l plus 1, so this is the sum n minus 1 l equals zero of 2 l plus 1. And this is equal to kind of beautifully n squared. Just arithmetic series. So we have this huge degeneracy, which is much larger than 2 l plus 1. It's a sum over 2 l plus 1 from l is zero to n minus 1. Where is this degeneracy coming from? Why? Okay? So classically, or quantum mechanically, we know the following.
We've learned the following and I hope it's under your fingernails at this point, that when you see a degeneracy, you should expect that degeneracy to follow from some symmetry. There's some symmetry of the system that is leading to a degeneracy by virtue of the fact that the generators of that symmetry, for example for rotation that's angular momentum, commute with the energy. And when you have an operator that commutes with the energy operator, as we've seen, you can generally construct new states given a single energy eigenstate by acting suitably with that operator. Yeah? So we should expect there to be some new symmetry.
But it's very hard to see what symmetry. I mean, this is hydrogen, it's a central potential, it's just some stupid central potential. What's so special about the hydrogen system as opposed to, for example, the harmonic oscillator, which hopefully you will see in recitation at some point. Um the harmonic oscillator in three dimensions has degeneracy 2 l plus 1. It's a central potential. It has to have degeneracy 2 l plus 1, but not n squared. Where did that come from? What's so special about the Kepler problem? So there must be some symmetry, but it's not obvious what it is. But now let's use a a a note from classical mechanics.
Noether's theorem tells us when we have a symmetry we have a conserved quantity. We also saw this in the quantum mechanical version for expectation values, we have a conserved quantity. And in quantum mechanics, having a conserved quantity means that the energy commutes with some quantity. Because that controls the time evolution of the expectation value. So there must be some quantity, which I've written by an x question mark, that commutes with the energy operator specifically in the case of the harmonic oscillator. So what is that quantity? So actually this quantity in classical mechanics was studied uh because the same thing is true in the Kepler case.
In the Kepler case, the orbits uh close and they have they're simple ellipses and they have all sorts of nice properties that beg for an explanation in terms of symmetry and it was pointed out by a number of people, Laplace, Runge, Lenz, various people, that and this is often called the Runge-Lenz vector, but I think you could blame it on any number of people. Um that there's a vector that in classical mechanics for the Kepler problem or for the Coulomb problem is conserved. And that quantity is p cross l, momentum cross angular momentum, minus m squared uh sorry, m e squared uh and let me write m sub electron.
It's the mass rather than the quantum number little m. e squared uh r vector. So, turns out this quantity is classically conserved, and if you make a quantum operator out of it, then e with a is equal to zero. Hat hat. Okay. It's enormously non-obvious. If it's obvious to you, you are a freak. Okay? It's really, really not obvious. You can go through and do the calculation, and you know, when I say, you know, really not obvious, I mean, well, I'll show you what I mean in just a second. So, you can go through and do the calculation classically, is this quantity conserved in the Kepler problem using Newton's law?
And the answer is yes, it's amazing. Quantum mechanically, you can do the same thing, although I'm going to warn you for anyone who has the chutzpah to try, cuz I encourage you to, but it's it takes a little bit of brawn. Um, think about this operator for a second. Does this classical quantity have an obvious interpretation as a quantum operator? No, because L is r cross p. But now we have p r p, there's an ordering ambiguity. So, you have to decide which order do you put that p and that r and the other p and you p p r r p r p r r, right? You can write out which components you mean here. For example, you mean for the z component of a, you're going to get p x l y and l y p x, but within that, how do you order the p's and the r's?
Because l y contains p x. And it or sorry, and in particular, it contains x. So, there's an ordering ambiguity. So, just be a little bit careful about this as a quantum mechanical operator if you do play with this. Um, but if you do it and you're thoughtful about it, it's pretty easy to see that well, it can be computed and checked that in fact, the commutator vanishes. So, at this point, it's tempting to say, "Aha, there's an extra conserved quantity, we declare victory." The problem is, this didn't give us a symmetry. This just told us there's a conserved quantity. What's the symmetry behind this?
What's the symmetry that ensures that this is a conserved quantity? It's obviously not rotations, it's something else. And so, there are many answers to this question. One answer involves an explicit expression for in phase space, the change of variables d x, and this is a a variation that depends on I'll write this as f of x and p. Okay? So, there's a little vector parameter, and it the change of the of the physical coordinates depends on both the coordinates and the momenta. This is a slightly strange thing because it's like a change of variables where the position gets mapped into some non-linear function of the positions and momenta.
That's a little bit weird, but you can do this. But I don't find that a terribly satisfying answer. And here's the answer I find most satisfying. It's not terribly useful for our present purposes, but you're going to run into this again in 805 when you do what's called the operator method for the Coulomb potential, and it turns out to be an enormously useful machine. We're not going to use it in 804, but I want to advertise it for you. I want to give you a description though that isn't the description you're going to get in 805. The description is the following. 1935, guy named Fock, crazy guy, amazing, amazing physicist, played a huge role in the development of quantum field theory.
I'm not exactly sure why he was thinking about this problem, but he's, you know, he was. And this was a very sort of Soviet thing to do at the time, I guess, to be hardcore and mathematical. So, so off he was going computing things, and he observed the following fact. How he observed this again, crazy long story. He observed the following fact. If you take the Kepler problem and you work in momentum space, so write everything in terms of the momenta, it turns out that the Kepler problem or he referred to it as a Kepler problem, but I'll refer to it as the Coulomb problem, the Coulomb problem in 3D, three spatial dimensions, this is really crazy, is exactly equivalent, there's a change of variables, it's kind of complicated, it's just a projection, it turns out, is exactly equivalent to the problem of a free particle in, wait for it, four dimensions, constrained to the surface of a sphere.
To a three sphere in the four dimensions. So, you take a three sphere in four dimensions, you take a marble, you kick it, and but make sure that it's stuck to the sphere, it will move in perfect circles, right? So, obviously, it's moving on a sphere, it's just going to move in great circles. Okay, that's nice and simple. What's the symmetry group of that system? Well, the sphere is invariant under any rotation in four dimensions. Aha! SO4. There is a four there's a symmetry SO4, a special orthogonal transformation. Special means it doesn't change the length, orthogonal means it it's a rotation.
So, it's orthogonal rotations in four dimensions, and so now you can this should sound familiar because the angular momentum group angular momentum in 3D is SO3. It's rotations that don't change the length in three dimensions. Okay? How many elements does this have? How, you know, how many conserved quantities go along with this? Well, how many conserved quantities go along with rotations in three dimensions? What's conserved by virtue of rotational invariance in three dimensions? Angular momentum. How many components of angular momentum are there? Three. Great. There are three. So, it turns out that if you calculate in SO4, how many conserved quantities are there?
There are six. And when you do this mapping back down from the free particle in 4D into the Coulomb problem in 3D, three of them are the L's, and the other three of them are this A vector. Comes out spot on. So, what it's telling you is that the spectrum of hydrogen, or at least the spectrum, I shouldn't say of hydrogen, the spectrum of the Coulomb system has an enhanced symmetry. It's the symmetry group of rotations in four dimensions. Why? I don't know, it's just kind of awesome, but that's I think that's about the best that can be said. It just it's true. So, for certain very special potentials, we find that this sort of thing happens, and it happens in other systems, too.
You discover that there are accidental symmetries in your system. It should they shouldn't be referred to as accidental symmetries, they're enormously non-trivial functions of the rest of the system, and we're going to break the symmetry in a minute, and you'll see why we shouldn't refer to it as accidental. But in any case, the answer to the question, why do we have this giant degeneracy in the Coulomb problem, why is it n squared rather than 12 + 1, is that there is a there's an enhanced symmetry group. There's more symmetry than you would have thought, and there's a conserved quantity associated with it, and that conserved quantity corresponds quantum mechanically to an operator that commutes with the with the with the energy operator.
Okay? Yeah. Indeed. Indeed. Excellent. What is it What do I mean in classical mechanics for a quantity to be to be conserved? I mean that the time rate of change of that quantity under the classical dynamics, under classical evolution, is preserved. Right? So, what's the quantum mechanical version of that? So, the quantum mechanical version of that is well, can we say that d d t of some operator uh or of some observable A is zero? Does this make sense? No, cuz this isn't I mean, it turns out in in the language we've been using in in the Schrödinger evolution description that we've been using, this doesn't really make sense cuz A is an operator.
That's not a quantity. The quantity is something you measure. So, what do you measure? Do you measure the operator? In a state, you measure its expectation values. You might measure its eigen values if you but the more general thing is it's it's expectation values. So, this is something that depends on time because the wave function depends on time, psi of t. Okay? So, to say the best we can do to say something is conserved is to say d d t of A is zero. But we we've seen what the condition is for the expectation value to not change in time. In general, for any operator A, the time rate of change of its expectation value is given by the commutator of e with A.
I can't do the symbols, good. Okay? So, in particular, if this commutator vanishes, if the commutator vanishes, equals zero, this is equal to um Sorry? Well, the wave function could be time varying, and I'm going to assume for the moment that the energy operator and the A operator are not themselves explicitly time dependent. Yeah, that's an important assumption. So, let me just assume for simplicity that neither the energy nor the operator A that I'm looking at are explicitly time dependent. Like it shouldn't be like x + t p. That would be annoying. So, let me assume that that's not the case.
You you do have to deal with that sometimes. For example, if you are dealing with a system that changes in time, where there like there's a background magnetic field or something like that that changes in time. But modulo that sort of detail. And also, there's an i h part, so where do the i h bars go? Do the units make sense here? A A, good. E and d d t, whoops. So, where do the units Where do the i h bars go? Well, they can go on either side, but you have to tell me if they go up or down. What is the Schrödinger equation? So, there's Yeah, exactly, i h bar. Good. Okay. Good. So, we need an I Hbar.
Ah, good. Okay. Man. Um okay. This spring has got to us all. Um so, now in the in the case that E with A is zero, imagine we have an operator A that commutes with zero, then ddt of the expectation value of A in any state is equal to zero. And that's what I'll call conserved. So, classically to be a conserved quantity means that it's time independent. Quantum mechanically to be a conserved quantity means that it commutes with the energy. Now, coming back to the question, the question was, look for angular momentum, there are only two numbers you can know at any moment in time. You can't know three.
You can know the total angular momentum, little L, and you can know the angular momentum in a particular direction, which we'd conventionally call Z, little M. Right? But, you can't know some other angular momentum, like the angular momentum in the X direction simultaneously. So, what does it mean to say that there are three conserved quantities? I can't know three conserved quantity at the same time. They They're not even well defined at some moment in time. The answer is there are three operators, Lx and Ly and Lz, all of which, which I will simply write as L vector, all of which commute with E.
So, while it's true that I can't take that the system doesn't that systems don't have definite values of Lx, Ly, and Lz simultaneously, nonetheless, Lx, Ly, and Lz all commute with the energy operator. And as a consequence, their time expectation values are all zero in a central potential. All right. So, the time derivatives of their expectation values are all zero in a central potential. They're all constant in a central potential. Yeah. You You mean one over R? Yeah, one over R. Okay. So, so the question is, um look, if you don't have one over R, do you get extra special things that happen for other potentials that aren't one over R, but something else?
It's not quite the unique case. So, okay. So, the question is, look, uh this is It's a very good question, though. So, the the question is this. This is a great question. Look, there's something peculiar about one over R classically, the the orbits close. Right? You get ellipses. You don't get processing ellipses. That That's what you get if you have an anharmonic, if you have a you know, extra one over R to the sixth term or something, small correction to the one over R law. Which we do in the real solar system, right? It's a many-body system instead of a two-body system. So, our orbit doesn't close.
It's closed, but So, um so, that's special. And here we see that there's an enhanced symmetry. Are these things related to each other? So, the answer is almost in the following sense. For the harmonic oscillator, we also have it closed, but there isn't a Runge-Lenz vector. Okay? However, the orbits close. So, there's something special about that one, too. Is there a conserved quantity there? And it turns out that the answer to that is yes, there's an enhanced symmetry there as well. But, it's not it's not like this. It doesn't lead to this gigantic degeneracy. There's just extra structure that's nice about the harmonic oscillator.
But, for the harmonic oscillator, of course, it also closes, right? It's It's not this orbit, this. So, um so, there's a nice structure there, but it's a it it's not quite so simple. Um Okay. Yeah. One last question. Yeah. Yeah, it's not unrelated. I don't know how to make that connection sharp, but the the thing I can say sharply So, the question is, look, is that is that conserved quantity somehow related to the fact that there's equal time and equal equal area swept out in equal time at all points in the orbit? Which is a true thing about the Kepler problem. And that's a good observation. I don't know how to make that connection, but it is true in the following sense, that both of those facts are guaranteed by the fact closed orbits with a particular ratio.
Um and that is indeed can be blamed on the conservation of the Runge-Lenz vector. I don't know how to make that connection direct and explicit, but indeed it is. It's a That's a fun question. I'll I'll have to think about that. That's a good one. It's one of the one of the totally awesome things about teaching 804 is that every single time someone asks a question I've never even thought of before. Forget never answered, like never even thought of. Never thought of that. It's a great question. Um Okay. So, everyone cool with the degeneracy? We have this gigantic degeneracy. So, knowing what the degeneracy is or where it's coming from, at least more or less, uh is is, you know, progress.
But, what we'd really if you really understand why something is conserved, then you can break that conservation. You can break that degeneracy. So, here's my question. Is it possible? Can we or indeed must we Can we break or lift this degeneracy? So, first let me tell you what those words mean. So, we have this gigantic degeneracy of the uh Whoops. This guy. Uh I erased it. Okay, we have this gigantic gigantic degeneracy of the Oh, there it is. Up at the top. N squared of the Coulomb potential. Um can we break that degeneracy or lift it? So, what do I mean by lift a degeneracy? What do you mean by lift a degeneracy is the following.
Suppose I have a system that's degenerate. So, it's got two energy eigenstates with the same energy eigenvalue. So, this is energy. Then, if I can kick the system in some way or modify it or bend it such that the energy levels are no longer degenerate degenerate, one state has been lifted above the other. And so, we use the word to lift a degeneracy. Now, you can see that they're two different states by measuring the energies. Is that cool? It's also said to split a degeneracy or to break a degeneracy. So, these are just words. So, can we break or lift this degeneracy? Okay? So, sure. How do we break a degeneracy?
How do we lift a degeneracy? We need to break the symmetry. Okay? So, if we don't have the symmetry, we won't get the degeneracy. We've seen this before. So, first off, let's think about symmetries that What are the two symmetries that we want? Well, we got this degeneracy of 2L + 1 from spherical symmetry. And we got this extra degeneracy of N squared from conservation of the Runge-Lenz vector. And conservation of the Runge-Lenz vector came from the fact that we had exactly the Coulomb system. So, anything that isn't exactly the Coulomb system, but is still rotationally invariant, should still have the 2L + 1 degeneracy, but not the N squared degeneracy.
Cool? Like the harmonic oscillator, for example. So, let's change the system. Let's find a small correction to the system uh that leaves it mostly the Coulomb problem, but with some small correction. So, um what comes to mind? So, one good way to think about a uh physical natural way to break this degeneracy, to break the symmetry, is to think about a real system that's described by the Coulomb potential. So, the system that we usually talk about is hydrogen. Hydrogen is it's a proton. It's got a plus charge. You've got an electron, and it's attracted with a minus E squared upon R. Okay. So, in hydrogen, uh is this the energy operator for hydrogen?
Is this a good description of the energy operator for hydrogen? Well, it's a good start. But, it's not exactly right for a bunch of reasons. And in fact, on your first problem set, when you computed the time it takes for hydrogen classically to decay from the classical hydro Bohr radius or from the classical uh well, from the from the Bohr radius, um one of the things you discovered is that the electron starts out being non-relativistic, but very rapidly becomes relativistic. Right? Rapidly is like 10 to the minus 15 seconds. This is a non-relativistic P squared upon 2M kinetic energy. That's probably not a perfect approximation.
So, let's ask. So, the first example, example one, is going to be relativistic corrections. Now, will relativistic corrections break rotational symmetry? They can't, right? Because relativity doesn't say this is the Z direction. In fact, it does quite the opposite. Relativity, among other things, says, don't get too hung up on what's the Z direction. But, relativistic corrections will not break the symmetry. So, if we include relativistic relativistic corrections uh to the kinetic energy, this will will change E. Change the energy operator, but it will preserve the rotational symmetry. E with L is equal to zero.
So, we won't break the rotational symmetry, and so we'll preserve the 2L + 1. So, let's check to see that this is true. Okay? So, to check to see that this is true, let's actually estimate out the uh the correction to the energy due to the first non-trivial relativistic effect in the atom. The first non-trivial relativistic effect can be calculated in the following way. What's the kinetic energy in special relativity of a particle of mass M? So, that's easy. It's The total energy is the square root of uh P squared C Sorry. M squared C to the fourth plus P squared C squared minus MC squared. That's the rest energy.
That's the total energy. So, this is the kinetic energy. But, this is equal to Well, if we pull out a factor of M squared C squared, this is M squared Oh, sorry. M C squared times square root of one plus P squared over MC M squared C squared minus one. And now, if we Taylor expand this guy, cuz if the velocity or if the momentum is small compared to MC squared or MC, I should say. If the momentum is small compared to mc which is morally speaking at low velocities, the velocity is small compared to c, then this is one plus a small number and we can tailor expand this to get one plus one half a small number and the ones will cancel giving us only one half.
So, this is going to be equal to one half that small number p squared over mc squared times m Sorry, m squared c squared times mc squared upstairs giving us the first term which is p squared upon 2m. That's the familiar classical kinetic energy. Rock on. What's the next correction? The next correction is the next term from this Taylor series which is going to involve this quantity squared so it's going to be p to the fourth over m to the fourth c to the fourth times mc to the fourth. The coefficient is a minus 1/8 so we get minus p to the fourth over eight m cubed c squared. And that's down by a factor of m squared c squared from this guy and a p squared upstairs.
Which is what you'd get. P squared m squared over c squared. Okay? So, the correction to the kinetic energy for given momentum p is to correct it down by a p to the fourth term. Everyone cool with that? Yeah. Because in Because you, like Schrödinger, did problem set one and problem set one said, "If you have an electron at the Bohr radius classically its velocity is about a 400th of the speed of light. 200th Something It's It's small. It's a couple of order of magnitude smaller than the speed of light. So, that number that ratio there is one upon 200 or 400, I don't remember, squared. That's a very small number so that's a reasonable approximation to make.
Because what is the typical That's an excellent question. So, why am I talking about it as if the electron is sitting at that radius? And the answer is, well, look. What is the average momentum? What is the average value of p squared in Let's say the ground state of the hydrogen atom. What's the average value of p? What What must be the average value of p in the ground state of the hydrogen atom? Zero on two grounds. First off, p is a vector and the ground state of hydrogen rotationally invariant doesn't break anything. Second, it's not going anywhere, right? It's a bound state so it's just sitting there.
It's an It's got a average momentum zero. Carried momentum, it would be cruising. So, it's got to have momentum zero. Okay, fine. But what's the average momentum squared? What's the average of p squared? Well, we can actually do out that calculation and you're going to have to do that calculation on the problem set. And it's a small number and it's in fact almost exactly what you'd guess classically from the Bohr radius. So, you have to know the h bar to to compute the Bohr radius in the first place. So, the answer is to the to the best of anyone's ability to define what's the momentum or the typical scale of momentum.
That typical scale of momentum for the electron in the ground state of hydrogen is extraordinarily small compared to the speed of light by factors of 100 or 200 or 400, I don't remember exactly. Does that answer your question? Yeah. It's a very good question. Okay. So, So, here's the kinetic energy and another way to say By the way, another way to say that this approximation must be good is that we already computed ignoring the relativistic correction, we computed the ground state energy and it was 13.6 eV which is pretty good since the binding energy of hydrogen is about 13.6 eV. So, apparently that was a good approximation.
And you might be disgusted by answer analysis like that, but that's what physics is. Right? You write down some stupid cockamamie model that you know is wrong, but if it does a good job of fitting the data, you declare triumph and you call Stockholm. Okay. So Well, okay. It depends on the problem you've just solved approximately. So Okay. So So, here's the first correction. And now So, what this told us is therefore the energy of hydrogen or at least a better model of hydrogen, I'll call it hydrogen tilde is equal to e Coulomb minus p to the fourth over eight Oops, that's an eight. m cubed c to the fourth.
Oh, squared. Okay. Wow, that's a deformed eight. Let's try that again. Much better. Um Okay. So This, however, we know is small compared to the kinetic energy because 13.6 is pretty close to 13.6. You notice I didn't include the rest of the significant digits. So, this must be in the insignificant digits. So, this must be small. So, here's what I want to ask. We know that the energy of the Coulomb problem nlm uh is equal to e naught squared minus e naught squared over n squared independent of l and m what's the energy in this toy model of hydrogen that includes the first relativistic correction?
Okay? nlm Well, to answer that question we have to resolve the Schrödinger or the energy eigenvalue equation, right? We have to refine the energy eigenstates and we have to solve that. And this is now going to be a much worse problem because it's going to involve a p to the fourth term which is going to involve four derivatives. That sounds a horrible. Right? Can anyone think of a better way to just approximate estimate the magnitude and the value of the leading correction from this quantity? Yeah. Um some variation on take an eigenvalue, plug it in, see what the error is, correct for that error, plug it in again.
That's a very That's that There's an iterative method for doing that. That's a very good guess, but there's an even easier way to estimate it. But that's an excellent That's something we will call perturbation theory when we do this in 805 and doing that systematically is exactly the right answer. However, I wanted you to do the just leading part of that. Yeah. Oh, dimensional analysis would be awesome. That's fantastic. So, um So, how would Brilliant. So, how would you compute p? Okay. So, we didn't calculate p. So, you could do it dimensional analysis and get a p because you have an e, you have an l, you can probably do it.
But here's the problem with that though. This is the correct first answer to any question of this kind. Correct first answer is plug in dimensional analysis and get an estimate for the order of magnitude. But we want more than the order of magnitude here. We're interested in splitting the degeneracy due to this interaction. So, what that means is we want to see that different values of l lead to different energies. What we care about is the l dependence that comes out of this correction. And we're not going to be able to get the l dependence from dimensional analysis because l is an integer, it is dimensionless.
Yeah? So, that will give you the correct magnitude and that is the first thing you do. What's the second thing you do? Yeah. I'm just sticking in the expectation value of p to the fourth. Excellent. Let's just stick in the expectation value of p to the fourth. That's not exactly the right thing to do, but if this is small, uh it's probably pretty reasonable. And what you'll find when you do it systematically using perturbation theory as was pointed out earlier, we can take the entire system, the entire energy eigenvalue equation, we can think of this 1 over m cubed c squared We can think of that as a small number and we can do perturbation theory in that small number.
We can tailor expand everything in that small number. And when you tailor expand the exact equation, what you discover is the leading term in that Taylor expansion is the expectation value of p to the fourth over 8m cubed c squared. Okay? So, this is a fantastic guess. Okay, good. So, let's compute it. So, e hydrogen is going to be equal to e nlm which I'm just going to write as minus e naught squared over n squared. Oh, sorry. I don't know why I wrote squared. It's just e naught. If we're the energy If the energy we call the energy squared. At that point every respectable physicist goes out and asks themselves, "Okay, so um So, what what is the correct answer here?" So, it's It's this quantity minus So, this is making it more tightly bound.
Notice the sign. Cuz p to the fourth is strictly positive. P is real. So, minus e naught over m squared and if you go out and you do this expectation value which I really should have put on the problem set. Oh, I still can. It hasn't been posted yet. So, it'll be posted this afternoon, but I won't cuz I I won't. It's It's It's It's not that bad actually. Matt, what do you think? We'll We'll discuss this afterwards. Okay, so um which may or may not appear on your problem set. Um So, if you go out and you do this calculation, what you find is the correction is e n squared so e naught squared over n to the fourth.
This time it really is n to the fourth. And now you have to worry about dimensional analysis. This is two energies, we want one energy divided by Wait for it. mc squared cuz it's a relativistic correction. That shouldn't be too surprising. times the quantity 4n over and here's where life gets awesome l plus one half minus three. See, you laugh but I feel delighted by this for so many reasons. So, one is that's beautiful. What a crazy combination of symbols. But the second and more important one is Look, it has an l in it. And the l is downstairs, right? That's That's good. It has more leverage that way.
But so, we've got we've got this l appearing. So, now the energy depends on l. Good. We've broken the degeneracy. Different values of l give different energies. Yeah? So, let's do that graphically. Um So In particular In particular, what this tells us is is that now um while the Coulomb potential the Coulomb energy commuted with the Runge-Lenz vector it must be true that the energy of this model of hydrogen which includes the first relativistic correction does not commute with the Runge-Lenz vector. And indeed, if you check this, which is effortful but not intellectually difficult, um indeed it doesn't vanish.
And the failure of this conservation equation, the failure of this commutation relation to vanish tells us that it's possible for the system to not be degenerate. And lo and behold, it is not degenerate. Okay? Yeah. Um I just want to clarify something that So, did you say before that the actual first term in the quantum relativity just includes substituting the non-relativistic field of four? Yes. No, sorry. Yeah, yeah, I should have said that. There are other things that are important for relativity that we'll come to in a little bit, but this is if you just look at the kinetic energy, this is the first non-trivial comp- correction.
Yeah. Uh we still have the 2L + 1 We still have the 2L + 1 degeneracy, exactly. Because does this correction violate rotational invariance? No, that's P squared. That's a scalar under rotations. It's just a number, not a vector. So, but E still commutes with uh with L. Right? And you see that because this is independent of little M. Right? This is the mass of the electron. So, this is independent of the quantum number little M. It only depends on the quantum number little L. So, indeed, it is still degenerate. So, let's go through this and see the degeneracy explicitly. And let me do that by drawing you the following diagram.
So, um what happens if we have the uh E1 or E- E1, which is the ground state. It has some energy which is negative, which is minus E0. Right? And when we include this first correction, what does it do? Well, it decreases it by some amount. Okay? Everyone cool with that? It doesn't change the number. It doesn't split any degeneracy because ground state there was only one ground state in the first place because L had to be zero when N is one. L has to be one less than N or smaller. And if N is one, L has to be zero or it can't be smaller than zero, it's zero. There's just the one state with degeneracy 2 0 + 1, which is one.
Okay, so that's fine. It just changes the ground state by some amount. Let's consider the second excited level. So, in the second excited level, we have the states and let me name this slightly differently. So, this has energy minus E0. The ground state had L equals zero and M equals zero. Whoops. M equals zero. It had to. For the second excited state, N equals two, how many states are there? Two squared is four. So, there are four states, two, three, four. And what are their values of L and M? Well, if N is two, L can be either zero or one. If it's zero, then M has to be zero. If it's one, M could be one or it could be zero or it could be minus one.
Yeah? So, this again is L M L M L M. So, those are the four states with energy E2 in the hydrogen atom. And now, when we ask what are the energies of these three states when we include this so-called fine structure, what is this going to do? Well, the ground state is going to get pushed down by some amount. Okay? I should draw this differently to make it more vivid. Okay. This gets pushed down by some amount with some value of L. L here is zero. But for these three states, which all have the same value of little L, one, the denominator is larger. So, the amount by which it gets pushed down is less.
So, these three states get pushed down less but the same amount as each other. That cool? So, these three states degeneracy is three and this state degeneracy is one. Now, notice that 1 + 3 is equal to four. is equal to N squared. So, these states split into multiplets, groups of states which have to have the same energy by rotational invariance. If they have L equals one, there must be three states with the same energy. There must be. And states with L equals zero, there's just the one state. Is that cool? And if we did the same thing for E3, let's just think about what would happen. So, here we have I'm just going to write the L.
I'm not going to include the M. We have the L equals zero state times one. We have the L equals one state times three. And we have the L equals two state. And how many states are there in the L equals two state? times five. Good. And again, this gets pushed down to some value. This gets pushed down to some value. And this gets pushed down to some value. Where this is one, three, and five. And again, these add up to nine, which is three squared. So, the degeneracy So, by turning on the relativistic corrections, we break this degeneracy. We lift the degeneracy. You break the symmetry. You lift the degeneracy.
Cool? Now, unfortunately, this isn't one we can control by turning a dial in a lab. No experiment that I can do in the lab will change the value of the speed of light or the Well, actually, there are experiments that will change the value of the speed of light. If you work in medium, right? If you work in medium, the effective speed of light is different. So, that's going to change relativistic effects. So, that's interesting. That tells you you can actually vary this continuously if you can vary continuously the index of refraction of the ambient system. I invite you to think about how you might do that experimentally cuz it's a fun Bless you.
It's a fun question. Um Okay, um however, what I'd really like is something where Professor Evan in his lab can actually turn a dial and uh change the spectrum in a way that explicitly breaks the symmetry. Meanwhile, I also want an example that breaks the rotational invariance. I want to break the 2L + 1 states up into 2L + 1 states with different energies. I want to make them depend on the angular momentum in some direction. What must I do in order to lift that degeneracy? Fantastic. If you add a magnetic field, why is that going to break the degeneracy? Yeah. Give me an answer that depends on on not on your knowledge of chemistry, but give me an answer that depends on symmetries.
Why does turning on a magnetic field have the potential to split the degeneracy of the 2L + 1 states? Thank you, exactly. You have no rotational symmetry, exactly. So, that's pretty good. So, let's break the 2L + 1 by breaking rotational symmetry. And there are many ways we could break rotational symmetry. We could turn on electric field. We could break turn on magnetic field. We could, you know, I don't know, put a shovel in the room. But anything that breaks rotational symmetry will do it, but a very convenient way is to do it with a magnetic field. Magnetic field is particularly beautiful. So, this is This effect is now called the Zeeman effect.
Um I believe it was Faraday. I don't know. It's some some one of the classic like electromagnetists of the 19th century attempted to look at the spectral lines coming off glowing gas and see if they changed by turning on an electric or magnetic field. Turns out to be a tricky experiment to do because you need to have a very well-controlled magnetic field. Otherwise, what you get is just a bunch of schmutz. So, to get a clean spectrum, you have to have a very uniform magnetic field, which is not trivial. It has to be time independent. So, Zeeman um at the very end of the 19th century, um in fact, this experiment was done, I believe, in '96.
Um So, I think the the paper came out in '97. Um but the the experiment was done in '96. Zeeman did this experiment. He said, "Look, if I turn on a magnetic field next to a hot glowing gas and look at the spectrum that comes off, anything happen?" To it? Why would you think that anything Well, why would you think that anything might happen? And the answer to this one is is really quite nice. Look, if we compute the energy, the energy is going to be equal to the Coulomb energy plus a correction, which is the following. If you think of the atom as an electron carrying some angular momentum in the presence of the proton, right?
If you think of the electron as an as a the thing carrying some angular momentum and with a charge, if it has a charge and an angular momentum, it's going to have a magnetic moment, mu. And the magnetic moment is going to be equal to um the current of the charge times the area swept out divided by C cuz we work with sensible units. Um and this is equal to um minus for the case of the atom E L over Well, man, I really made this too small. Um Let me write it here. Uh minus mu, the magnetic moment of the system dotted into the magnetic field that you turn on in the background. So, this is a background magnetic field.
I am turning on an electromagnet, which induces magnetic field in some known direction with some known magnitude. Okay? So, my dial is with the magnitude of that B field. I can make it larger. I can make it small. And it's in a known direction. And the point is our electron carries some because it's orbiting, because it carries some angular momentum, it and it carries some charge, has some magnetic moment. So, it behaves like a little bar magnet. And that bar magnet wants to anti-align with the background magnetic field that I've turned on. So, there's an energy penalty to not being aligned. This is the usual dipole-dipole interaction from a dipole potential from electrostatics.
Okay. And mu here is equal to minus E over 2mc angular momentum. Okay. So, this can be computed from a simple model of the atom. Uh whatever. It's easy to compute. So, um this is slightly annoying because B is in some arbitrary direction. Let's just simplify our life and say that it's equal to E Coulomb uh minus mu B. And I want to turn on a magnetic field of known amplitude in a known direction. Let's call it the Z direction. So, this is mu Z. Okay. But this mu Z, that's just mu Z is LZ * - E over 2 MC. So, this is going to be plus E over 2 MC BZ. And I'm going to put this all together BZ LZ.
Everyone cool with that? And so, where this is coming from again is just the angular momentum is telling you the velocity. The velocity is telling you the current. And then the area is the radius. So, that's what's giving you the radius and the um and the angular momentum. Okay. So, this is our if our our um our energy what does this tell you about the energy eigenvalues? Yeah, they depend on M, right? And do we have to solve the energy eigenvalue equation again? No, because our energy eigenfunctions of EC are proportional to YLM. So, they're already eigenfunctions of LZ. Everyone cool with that?
So, when you take this beast and I act on the wave the wave functions I erased, but on the one upon little R capital R sub NL Y sub LM. When I act on the YLMs, this is just going to give me h bar M. Right? So, this is just a constant when acting on the Coulomb energy eigenfunctions. So, this is a much easier problem that we don't even have to make any approximations. We can just say exactly energy Zeeman is equal to minus E naught upon n squared NLM plus E h bar upon 2 MC BZ, the background magnetic field. And this is the M of electron mass times uh little M. And I'm going to write little M sub L just to distinguish little M sub L from M sub E.
Cool? So, when we turn on the prediction here is that when we turn on the magnetic field all is Zeeman our energy levels will get split according to the different values of M. Now, if instead of working with the pure Coulomb system, if we were in fact a little clever and we'd already noticed that there's a fine structure because they already knew that there was a fine structure at this point. They could see the the the different spectra in lines coming off of hot gas. So, it's just an experimental fact you can't turn off the fine structure. This is going to be equal to E NLM of our correction to the hydrogen atom with the fine structure corrected.
So, the L equals one states and the L equals zero states were split. Let's focus for example on E2. So, these guys have a different energy. The L equals one guys have a different energy than the L equals one the L equals zero guys. What is this predicted going to happen? If I look at my spectral line. So, what this predicts is the following. It says that look, if you have some spectrum that looks like this. So, here's this is as a function of wavelength. Um this is as a function of wavelength and um I'm looking literally at the what comes off a prism. Right? I'm looking at the spectral lines. And I'll have a line here and these are going to be the L equals zero states.
This is N equals two. L equals zero states and then there's the L equals one states. This is with zero magnetic field B is equal BZ equals zero. If we turn on a magnetic field BZ not equal to zero what should we see? Well, what happens to this state? Nothing. It's the same thing because the M is strictly zero, so it's the same value. And this guy, what happens to it? The M equals zero state is the same. But then it breaks up as everyone said, it breaks up into three lines that are equally spaced. Yeah? It breaks up into three lines because one of them has M which is plus one, one of them has M which is zero, and one is M is minus one.
So, the energies will increase or decrease. Let's say this is frequency. So, we get this splitting. And another way to draw this is as a function of B, let's draw the energy levels. So, there's the one, there's the zero. And this stays constant. And these guys one is constant, one increases, and one decreases. Everyone cool with that? When you start getting to strong magnetic fields, weird things happen like these guys cross and all sorts of subtle things can happen. But let's ignore the strong magnetic field case and just focus on this. So, we see that these guys split. So, this is what the short the Schrödinger theory which came in 19 or the the full story would predict.
It it came a little bit after this, but um well, this experiment was done in '96. So, there's actually kind of an entertaining story about people trying to explain this effect classically. And you say, "Well, look, could have some angular momentum in the Z direction, some angular momentum in the X direction, some angular momentum in the Y direction. The part that has angular momentum in the X direction doesn't do anything. And or the in the Z direction isn't doing anything. Part with the X and part with Y can have different polar." There's a whole classical song and dance. It's crazy. It doesn't make any sense.
But that's cuz they were trying to do classical mechanics to do quantum mechanics, which doesn't work. So, I'm not even going to bother explaining what they were thinking. But anyway, so people came up with a sort of classical crutch to say, "Well, that's not totally insane." So, this is what Zeeman got for example by looking at hydrogen. But he did more than just look at hydrogen. Um I can't remember exactly. I think he did it with sodium. Matt, do you remember? Sodium? I think he did sodium and iron. But anyway, um but here's the funny thing that he got with sodium and iron. So, this is a different experiment.
Same exactly the same setup, but he was looking at spectral lines in sodium. And the spectral lines in sodium did a very similar thing. There were some where one went to one. And there were others where one went to Why did we have three here? Just as a quick reminder, why did we have three states here? Cuz you have three states for L equals one, right? This one state went to one, two, three, four states. With none of them in the middle. And in fact, it's worse than that because they didn't go to equally spaced states in general. In general, they did something slightly funny and the beautiful plot in his paper looks like this.
There are four states. And as you take the magnetic field to zero, these four states all coalesce exactly to this one state. So, this one line is representing four different states. And this already included the the um the fine structure. So, we know that this is all a single value of L. But that apparently has four states. That should worry you. What does that tell you about L? What does L have to be in order to have four states in your tower? Half integer. In particular, what value? Three halves. Crap. We already know that these wave functions are described by the YLMs, right? We solved that problem.
We explicitly solved it. Here's the exact answer. It's the YLMs. But we've observed experimentally that L has to be three halves. But if L is three halves, YLM is equal to zero because it's equal to minus itself. This is bad. This is zero. So, this effect is called the Zeeman effect and this effect is called the anomalous Zeeman effect. Which is strange for two reasons. The first reason it's strange is they showed up in the same paper. And the second thing is okay, you call it the Zeeman effect cuz there's some guy named Zeeman. Is there some guy named anomalous Zeeman? It's a very strange name.
Anyway, so this was called the anomalous Zeeman effect despite appearing in the same paper because it's weird. It was deeply disconcerting to people. We now just call it the Zeeman effect although it we have the bad habit for entertainment value of referring to it still as the anomalous Zeeman effect. I'm not the only one responsible for that bad habit. Um I'm going to point out that at the end of this paper, it's totally awesome paper by the way. It's very readable. It's short. Um he says, I was looking at it last night. Zeeman says, quote "Possibly this observed the observed phenomenon will be regarded as nothing of any consequence." Okay.
So, a few years later Pauli says the following. So, Pauli says this actually in a also this is also totally lovely in science um from 1946. Pauli was uh in the US during the war. After the war, he was at the Institute for Advanced Study. At the Institute for Advanced Study, he got while he was there he got the Nobel Prize. And he gave a little uh for the exclusion principle which we're about to get to. And he gave a little spiel and it's written up in in this uh edition of science. And he says, quote "A colleague who met me strolling rather aimlessly in the beautiful streets of Copenhagen said to me in a friendly manner 'You look very unhappy.' To uh whereupon I responded fiercely, 'How can one look happy when he is thinking about the anomalous Zeeman effect?'" Okay.
So, this troubled people. Yeah. Yeah, he found all sorts of crazy states. So, this isn't the only example, it's just the only one I'm going to draw. But indeed, you can find five-halved states. You can find states with six. Oh, I didn't draw all the states. The spectrum is complicated and messy cuz it's sodium. So, there's a whole There's all sorts of crap. So, I'm just not drawing. I'm just focusing on a specific set of spectral lines. Good. Um maybe the best way to draw that is Okay. Okay. So, um this was really troubling. So, um but let's put this on pause for the moment. And we'll come back to it in just a second.
So, meanwhile, there's something else that's sort of annoying about this system. We've got the Coulomb potential. And the Coulomb potential has the following beautiful property the degeneracy of any energy state uh is equal to uh n squared. Meanwhile, various people were fond of observing the fact that um that the that the number of states, which I will in an abusive of language called the degeneracy, of the level n in the periodic table is equal to Well, the first one there's two and then there's eight and then there's six 18. 18. So, 2 6 or 2 8 8 18, that's uh almost 2 n squared. Right? 2 4 8 9 18.
Cool, maybe there's a relationship, right? And meanwhile, it's very tempting to think that there's a relationship because imagine you have four electrons. If you have four electrons, what do you do? Well, you put an electron here and then you can put an electron here or you can put an electron another electron here. You can also put another electron here and here or you can put them in any combination. Two here, you can put two here, two here, one one. You can do all sorts of stuff, right? But if for the moment if for the moment you imagine that electrons have this funny property. Imagine for the moment the electrons have the property they can't be in the same state at once.
Then if you have four electrons, I don't know why. I'm desperate. I'm thinking about the anomalous Zeeman effect among other things. I have nothing better to do. So, just for fun, let's imagine if I put an electron here, I can't put another one. So, if I have a two-electron atom, the second one goes in one of these, a three-electron atom, a four-electron atom. And these guys are all related to each other cuz they live in the same energy level, but they have different L values. So, they'll have slightly different properties. That suggests that the two that the 1s the 1 L equals zero state should be different from the three L equals one states chemically.
But wait, there aren't groupings of two and or one and three, they're groupings of two and six. Ah. Two. Well, so Pauli staring at this in 90 in uh '25 said the following. He said, "Look, I'm going to conjecture two things. The first is that no two electrons can live in the same state. Inhabit the same quantum state. That doesn't give us the periodic table, though. It gives us half of the periodic table. There are twice as many states as you think in hydrogen as you think. And you might think that I'm being facetious that he said something a little more, you know, sophisticated, but he really didn't.
What he said is, "I posit the existence of an additional quantum number which the electron can have, which takes one of two values." Which translated says, "There are twice as many states as you think." Okay? So, that's exactly what he said. So, this is called the Pauli exclusion principle. And now this does a totally spectacular thing. And you've probably all seen this in high school chemistry or even college chemistry. Now, what first electron goes here, second electron goes here cuz there are twice as many states as you think, but I can't put another state in there cuz there's as many as you can have.
Uh one can go here and you can put up to six in here. And that's it. So, the E2 states, the n squared, which is 4 * 2 states, are somehow related to each other naturally. And this gives you the structure of the periodic table. In fact, an awful lot of chemistry follows directly from this. So, this is the Pauli exclusion principle. However, it's a little bit disappointing because while this is whatever, some ridiculous rule about we're doing quantum mechanics and all they're all ridiculous rules. Um on the other hand, this one is just stupid, right? This is just like, "Look, it wouldn't it be nice?" So, in '25 a couple guys, really interesting characters, um uh named uh Goudsmit and um Uhlenbeck.
So, Uhlenbeck um uh wow, we're really low on time. Okay, so um I'll just tell you this and then I'll get to the last of it later. Um so, Goudsmit and Uhlenbeck, who were young kind of naive, they said, "Look, we've got two effects here. One effect is the anomalous Zeeman effect and there's this weird fact that states have the wrong total angular momentum. And we have this second thing that there are twice as many states for an electron as you think in uh in the Coulomb potential. How can these two things uh fit together naturally? Well, here's a guess. Suppose that the angular momentum that we calculated when we did the estimate of the uh of the uh uh of the breaking due to the Zeeman effect.
Suppose that angular momentum was not the right angular momentum. Maybe there's more angular momentum in the system. There's angular momentum in the system from the electron orbiting around, but maybe like a little tiny Earth, the electron itself can can have some intrinsic angular momentum. It turns out Pauli had this idea before. In fact, Kramers had suggested this to him who was a very young guy at the time. Um and Pauli said, "You're a blithering idiot cuz if you calculate how small an electron has to be in order to fit all the other things we know and you figure out how fast it has to rotate to explain the anomalous Zeeman effect, it surface would have to moving faster than the speed of light.
That's ridiculous. Leave my office." So, then Uhlenbeck and Gold and Goudsmit um uh I don't know how to spell Goudsmit. G O U D. Anyway, these two guys write a paper and say, "Aha, well, we can explain this, but let's just not assume that the stupid thing is rotating. Let's just say an electron has some intrinsic angular momentum. I don't know. Why not? Well, have some Electrons have intrinsic angular momentum. And if you assume that electrons have an intrinsic angular momentum, which I'll call uh uh uh s for the moment. So, then the total angular momentum J is equal to L, it's orbital angular momentum, plus some intrinsic angular momentum, which I don't remember what symbol they use, but we'll call it for the moment s, where this has the property that s squared uh for an electron is equal to uh uh sorry, uh the principal quantum number, which I will call little s, is equal to 1/2.
So, m sub s is equal to plus or minus 1/2. Okay? So, this is like the L equals 1/2 state, but it's not L, it's something intrinsic. Has nothing to do with anything rotating. It's just a fact about electrons. Suppose electrons have a little bit of spin. Then what you discover is if you have the L equals one state and the electron has spin 1/2, what's the total angular momentum? 3/2. Right? So, what do you get? You get quadruplets like that. So, this turns out to explain if you include a small relativistic effect it this turns out to explain the anomalous Zeeman effect bang on. Meanwhile, there was an experiment done in 1922, which was the Stern-Gerlach experiment, which people discovered that Nick Stern-Gerlach No, people discovered that nickel, when sent through a magnetic field gradient, bent into one of two different spots.
Never three. Never zero. Always two. How could that be? Electron spin. That wasn't realized until 1929 that the connection was there. So, these guys came up with this ridiculous postulate. This was Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit. And let me just quickly um U H L E N B E C uh K. So, Uhlenbeck, an amazing amazing scientist, also the father of um of the mathematician Uhlenbeck, and she was a total badass and has inspired awful lot of physics. Um Karen Uhlenbeck, who's at UT. Um so, this is a pretty interesting and prolific guy, but he was also prolific in the following way. He was uh he ran a program at the Rad Lab at MIT during World War II.
And Goudsmit worked with him. And when they were finishing up, when the war was ending, Goudsmit became the scientific advisor to something called Project Alsos. Project Alsos was a project where the military went to the conquered territories in Germany to catch the German atomic scientists and bring them to a place called Farm Hall in England where they listened to them eavesdropped on eavesdropped on them. Heisenberg, all the good guys, you know, um uh well, bad guys. Well, depends on you know, all the great physicists in the German territory at the time who were deeply complicated people. Um and they they listened to them in something called the Farm Hall transcripts are the transcripts of those recordings.
Uh they were written up in a book called the Epsilon Project, which is totally breathtakingly awesome. And Goudsmit wrote a book called Alsos about this process of hunting down the German scientists. So, Goudsmit, G O U D S M I T I think. Um and he wrote a book called Alsos, which I hardly recommend to you because it's like a combination adventure story and beautiful bit of physics history. Um so, these guys both had and they were both at MIT right during the World Wars. There's a nice connection here. So, these guys, fascinating characters, and they came up with this idea of some intrinsic angular momentum.
Pauli then calls it spin. He gives it the name and he develops a mathematical theory of spin. And that mathematical theory of spin will lead to quantum field theory, relativistic quantum mechanics, and it will eventually lead to quantum computation, which is going to be the topic of the last week of our course. So, what we've done so far is we've explained the the discreteness of atomic spectra and we've explained the structure of the of the periodic table. What we haven't done is we haven't explained why atoms form molecules or solids. And we also haven't explained what spin is it at all. Those are going to be the topics of the next 3 weeks.
See you next time.