Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu all right so uh for the next for the next six lectures including today uh we're going to finish off um the course with uh the application of everything we've studied so far to a couple of ideas the first being the existence of solids why we have solids and why we have conductivity in solids which is you know basic properties of materials in particular the story I want you guys to leave the course with is an understanding of why diamonds are transparent and why copper isn't um which you know is sort of a crude fact about the world but we can explain it from first principles which is pretty awesome um the second is we're going to come back to this idea of Spin and of half integral angular momentum this intrinsic angular momentum of the electron and we're going to use that to motivate a couple of ideas first off we're going to tie back to Bell's inequality from the very beginning and then we're going to do a little bit on Quantum computation that'll be the last two lectures so um before I get started though with today two things um first I'm going to ask for questions but the second is uh I got some really good questions about hydrogen so I want to wrap up with one last comment on hydrogen um because it's it's entertaining um but before I get started on that questions uh about everything up till now yeah it absolutely is okay so the question is this is a very very good question the question is look um if you look on Wikipedia about uh seriously if you this is a rational thing to do if you look at Wikipedia to to learn something about hydrogen um what you discover is everything that we've talked about including the fine structure including the zamon effect but you see that there are a couple of other effects so one effect for example is uh when you look at the zamon effect a little more carefully than we did there's a second term in the zamon effect which is uh an an sort of induced Magnetic Moment so even when the angular momentum uh is is uh is is small or even zero there's still a contribution to um to the energy from the mag an externally imposed magnetic field um so there are lots of other Corrections one of them in particular is something called spin orbit coupling and um so the form of and so the question was look what is that and and can do we know enough to explain what spin orbit coupling is so let me give you a very short answer to that question so we know that if we write down the energy operator for uh for our system we have the energy operator so the full the full energy operator for hydrogen I'll say um is the energy operator for kulum plus a bunch of Correction so for example we had the relativistic correction plus a term that was a coefficient time p and this is on your problem set um and this came from relativistic corrections I shouldn't call this C I'll call it beta maybe um some coefficient um and there are a whole bunch of other contributions for example there's the term we studied that contributed to the zount effect if there's an external magnetic field there's a b do uh uh magnetic d a magnetic um moment of the system and if the electron is uh in a state with finite angular momentum the Magnetic Moment is some dimensionful coefficient which we usually called the Bor Magneton because whatever we like the guy uh times the angular momentum okay but there can be additional contributions there there are a whole bunch of additional terms in this uh in the true potential for hydrogen one of them takes the following form it's a it's a constant plus maybe I'll call it Kappa times spin dotted into the angular momentum uh of the electron of the the uh electron bound to the hydrogen system so where this comes from is a sort of beautiful story so first off could it be there sure this is some this is a term that could exist with some coefficient why not um uh it turns out that you can derive its existence from a study of the relativistic uh version of the hydrogen equation of the hydrogen system we're not going to study that in any detail in 804 but the basic and what this does uh is totally amenable to to 804 level analysis this is just saying that when you have uh some orbital angular momentum and when you have some spin angular momentum both of those correspond to angular momentum of an object that carries charge and so it's not unreasonable that there's going to be some interaction between the two where the magnetic moments those two magnetic moments are you know either want to be aligned or anti-aligned depending on the sign of this coefficient however we haven't talked about spin in any great detail yet we're going to do that last week of the course so I'm going to defer talking about this in any detail we're only going to discuss it briefly at the end um for a couple of weeks but absolutely this sort of these additional couplings are important for hydrogen and they're also things we can you can study at at this level at 804 level I should also emphasize that there are a whole bunch of other Corrections there are lots of there are lots of terms I mean one set of terms an infinite number of terms are the further subleading relativistic Corrections of kinetic energy right and there are a whole bunch of other Corrections so I'm I'm going to leave those out for the moment but um I I want to emphasize to everyone that we're building models of hydrogen and they're all approximations yeah yes there there is so um so on the problem set um you're asked to estimate the the correction to the energy we actually I wrote down the answer in lecture the other day you're asked asked to uh compute the uh in particular the dependence but to estimate the magnitude or to estimate the value of the shift in the energy I values uh uh to hydrogen from the first relativistic correction this P to the fourth correction and for I I expect that this will be covered in your recitation in some detail but um there the question was are there is there a trick to make this a little easier I'm not going to there there are a couple of good physical arguments which I'm not going to tell you but there are nice ways to do this but but at the end of the day you do not want to end up doing the following computation you don't want to take the expectation value of P to 4th and write this as the some integral of s complex conjugate uh derivative to the 4th s if you do if you attempt to do this integral you will weep okay this is not the way you want to do it and here's what you want to do and I'm not going to tell you how to get here but you want to reduce the calculation of this expectation value to the calculation of the expectation value of one over r and of 1 R 2 okay and it turns out that if you know these expectation values that entirely suffices to compute the expectation value of P to 4th if you take into account the fact that the energy functions uh satisfy the original energy value equation so P ^2 upon 2 M plus v of X or V of R is equal to E when acting on that on those wave functions so for computing these guys you could try to do this Brute Force not unrelated to the to problem I believe two on ridberg atoms on the problem set um but there are actually sneakier ways to do these uh to do these expectation values as well um and um I I will leave that to you but let me yeah but let me emphasize that uh you can do a direct Brute Force calculation but you don't need to and I would encourage you to try to find an efficient uh indirect way to do these calculations that it's your question okay um anything else before we get yeah uh does adding time um it well it depends on what the how you introduce the time dependence so the yes yeah absolutely uh what's the reason for the question one of the problems on the problem set remind me which problem this is I don't remember oh oh oh sorry I really like that problem um the let me rephrase your question in the following way is it intrinsically non- herian to have time dependence in a system so no you can have a so what does heran mean physically what what does it mean for the energy to be herian for example what it means for the energy operator to be herian is that time Evolution which is represented by the oper so let me phrase it this way so if we know that the energy operator form what is that telling us well it tells us a lot of things it tells us the energy values are real that's that's good so e diag is equal to e but it tells us something else remember that the Shing equation is that um I DT on S is equal to e on S and we use this to argue that um the general solution for to the straight equation can be written in the following elegant way s of T is equal to e to the minus I uh upon H bar uh t e uh on side zero right where this was the evolution operator U subt yeah and this is a unitary operator and the way to see it's unitary goes back to the exam the way to see it's unitary is this is e to the I herian operator T is a real number H is a real number so so this is e to the I uh herian operator and anything of the form e to the I herian operator is UN it's adint is inverse what that tells you is that since this is unary it preserves the magnitude or the norm of the wave function so probability is conserved what would it mean for the energy operator to be not herian what would mean a lot of things one thing it would mean is that the energy I values are no longer real that's a little weird but the much more troubling thing is that the energy would no longer be or sorry the probability would no longer be conserved the the evolution operator which is the solution to the straing equation would no longer be unary operator and the probability the norm of the wave function would no longer be conserved so the question at the end of the the last question in problem four is really asking in the system you're thinking about is probability conserved okay and that's the question that you should be asking yourself when you finish up problem four good yeah when we solve the dist equation in that way um does this solution come from the fact that istion or that is time independent oh absolutely absolutely so um so here I was just focusing on the hermeticity and I was assuming in solving this I'm assuming that the energy is time independent if the energy is not time independent then this is not the right answer as as you're pointing out so in fact you have to do an integral and you have to time order things and it's a complicated story um but this is not the solution but even if we have a Time independent system if the energy operator is not heran this is not unary so indeed you're absolutely right that if the energy operator is time dependent the story is more complicated than just this but we already see the problem that's Salient for problem four at this stage with a Time independent operator yeah my parles yeah yes comp yeah that's well I guess it's sort of a matter of taste um uh so what these I would say that they're the same thing in the following sense suppose I have complex energy values well I know that if I have a stationary State then that stationary State as a function of time uh is equal to the stationary State at time Z times e so this is just an energy function rather than uh okay is e to minus I the energy time T over H bar or this is the energy I can value right now imagine e is complex so if e sorry First Imagine e is real that's not hard to imagine because it's usually the case and if if that's true what happens to the norm what happens to the way function as we evolved through time it rotates by phase now if e is complex imagine e is of the form uh e uh exactly let e be complex so e is going to be e real uh minus I uh uh gamma some imaginary piece yeah so what that's going to give me is an e to the minus gamma t Okay so and and that's a decaying thing that when you take its Norm squared gives you a decaying envelope over time it's going to give you an exponential decay right this is going to be equal to eus i e real uh T over H bar uh time e to the minus gamma T over H uh 5 and when we take the norm Square the phase goes away but this doesn't so having loss of probability is having a complex energy I value yeah why are we talking about I guess like time independent operator if there's an electromagnetic field and stuff is clearly going on between like the atom and the electromagnetic field this is a very good question and that actually leads me into the thing I wanted to talk about first so I got a bunch of questions thanks for that question I got a bunch of questions over the past few days about um the the Magnetic Moment of the hydrogen system H and what a strange idea that is so let me talk about that for a second and when I'm done with this little Spiel tell me if I've answered your question okay um let's just leave this up okay so in particular let's think about this term for the moment what this term came from last time was we said look we turn on an external magnetic field you know someone turns on a switch and current runs through electromagnet and we get a uniform magnetic field in our fiducial volume where we're doing the experiment and the electron system has uh if it carries some angular momentum it also has a charge angular momentum charge that means it's got a magnetic moment that's how much Magnetic Moment uh so this is saying that the Magnetic Moment of the electron bound to the with angular momentum uh wants to uh anti-align with the magnetic field or align in this case cuz I put the wrong sign um um but here's something really upsetting about that so what he just said sounds crazy if you think about it in the following way take an electron in the Kum system straight up Kum take an electron the coolum system put it in say the ground state lowest energy State okay uh is is it moving this is problem four in some right so is it is it moving the expectation value of position doesn't change in time it's a stationary State expectation value of nothing changes in time right okay fine but it's the ground state that carries zero angular momentum that's not so upsetting go to the first excited state with angular momentum the nals 2 lals 1 m equals 1 State okay so it's got as much angular momentum in LZ as possible is that thing moving yeah it's not moving at all and yet we're saying there's a current associated with it an electric current and that electric current is inducing a Magnetic Moment all right hand rule uh maybe via BOS of art if you want to be fancy and that Magnetic Moment you know little current Loop is uh leading to this interaction the zon's interaction yeah we know that it's true because the experiments show the zamon spitting so it is definitely true that there is a Magnetic Moment of this thing but it's not moving how can that be so how can there be a current if nothing is moving what's the expectation value of the momentum yeah zero yeah but first of all the world isn't classical you can't use classical intuition okay true second of all even if you have like let's suppose you have a a uniform ring of classical charge yes and set it spinning yes that ring is as a ring not moving but there's still a current Associated so you're saying that the electron is a ring it might sense to think of it that if you I like this no this is good it's wrong but it's good and the reason the reason it's good is that you're really pushing your assumptions to try to figure out how the experimental data can possibly match and you're saying look we have to just reject our intuition our intuition is clearly leading us astray and I like that that's correct so what we're going to do in the next few minutes is work through that and try to find the best way to to to phrase that your your your strategy is the correct one so let me let me rephrase that slightly look um if you have a classical uh distribution of charge that distribution of charge could be a stationary distribution right a distribution which as a distribution of charge doesn't change in time but each individual charge in that distribution is itself moving the problem here is that we just have the one electron if you ever look you will find the electron at a spot but what you're really saying is look it's it's a mistake to think about the electron having a definite position in the first place you just shouldn't think about that the best you can say is it has some probability of being in any spot so let's work with that let's take that idea and let's push it let's see how far we can take this idea that the electron has some probability do so suppose we have an electron in a stationary state of the colum potential the stationary states are labeled by three integers n l and m and we've written their wave functions there of course an infinite number of ways to write in different notation there are an infinite number of fonts one could use for the normalization constant one/ r r n l of L or sorry of of little r y LM of theta and F right and I'm going to rewrite this I'm going to expand this out slightly this is n 1/ r r of r n l uh and Y LM remember was of the form uh p uh L of cosine Theta time e to the i m f everyone cool with that so I just wrote the spherical harmonic as a polinomial in cosine Theta s an exponential in M5 yeah where the one R come from on the one over R was um so most people call capital r the whole thing but this is the pulling out the one over R to simplify the radial wave equation and the reason I prefer writing it this way is just that this guy satisfies a simple One D Shing your equation um that was a thing that we called U of R and then I confused the hell out of everyone by calling three different things on the board U which was sort of unnecessary so this is the thing that this is the artist previously known as you um the dude can sing okay um so so the first question I want to ask is so this is a stationary State uh is the electron moving no not in any conventional sense if you compute the expectation value of the position and you take its time derivative uh this is zero we could do this either by calculating it or just by observing that it's a stationary State non principle uh it it can't change in time okay so this guy is not moving in in any conventional sense okay um so why is there an electric current why do we get the zamon Magnetic Moment the Bor Magneton so as was pointed out look this is quantum mechanics it's not classical mechanics and um in quantum mechanics the electron isn't isn't at any point rather there's some probability density and the probability density that we find the electron at some point R is s squ nlm of r squared okay familiar beast and meanwhile a wonderful thing about the probability distribution in Quant mechanics that we've already discussed here is that it's conserved the time derivative of of the probability density of R remember this is a density not a probability time depend the time rate of change of the probability uh distribution is minus the gradient or sorry the gradient the Divergence of the probability current where the probability current J is equal to H bar over uh the the uh Mass which I'm going to call the mass mu oh gee I don't want to I'm going to call the mass capital M okay that's the mass of the electron um which a little strange because it's a very small quantity but anyway H over capital M uh of the imaginary part of s complex conjugant gradient s okay and you showed on a problem set long ago that this is true if J takes this form by virtue of the shinger equation okay now we usually write this imaginary 1 over 2 I * s gradient or S star gradient s minus s gradient s star but that's equal to the imaginary part of the first term okay thing I want to emphasize is the imaginary part so we have this current in our system the position expectation value is time independent and indeed it's a stationary state so beyond the position expectation to value of being time independent the probability dens density itself is time independent because the wave function evolves by an overall phase and the probability density is the norm Square so the phase goes away so in our situ in our system in an electron in this state in the potential the time rate of change of the potential of the probability density let me actually do this over here so in the stationary State s LM the time rate of change of the density is zero and this tells us by the conservation equation that the Divergence of the current is also zero does that tell us that the current is zero right so what's the current well we've written everything here in spherical coordinates and the uh gradient the current is given in terms of the gradient operator so let's um let me remind you quickly of what the gradient operator is in spherical coordinates it has three components a radial component a a Theta component and then a fi component okay and the radial Co the radial part is just Dr R the Theta component is 1 / r d Theta and the FI around the equator component is equal to 1 / R sin Theta D5 everyone call that so what's J well J is going to have a component J uh in the radial Direction the current in the radial Direction and intuitively what should that be is there stuff going out or in shouldn't be it's uh hydrogen right it nothing it's not doing this so this should be zero and we can just quickly see that this is H bar upon M imaginary part of well this is the r component it's going to be the derivative in the radial Direction but the derivative in the radial direction is going to be real right the derivative in the ra radial direction is going to be real so when we take the norm squared we don't pick up anything we pick up an overall coefficient it's going to be strictly real the phase e to the IM5 cancels out because this is the complex conjugate so the imaginary part of this thing is going to be zero Okay so R is zero and similarly uh J Theta p is a real function when we take a derivative we get a real function and then when we multiply by its complex conjugate again the phase cancels out we just get a whole bunch of real stuff whose imaginary piece is zero so J F J Theta is zero but JF is the cool one in my head I was just thinking J5 but um uh good okay at least someone got that um so um so JF uh however is not going to be zero for the following reasons so what is it equal to it's equal to H bar upon M the mass m uh times the imaginary part of well s star which is you know s complex conjugate uh and then the gradient with respect to F the F component is 1 R sin Theta and then deriva with respect to but the Der respect to five pulls down a I am oh look times s which is equal to H upon M times Well s Norm squar that's real s^ squ 1 / R sin Theta that's real so I can pull that out and we are left with um imaginary part of I which is just m which is not zero and in particular it's proportional to hm everyone see that so what this is saying is that the current the probability current for an electron in the stationary State s nlm of the coolum potential is equal to uh Norm s^ squ over m r sin Theta H Bar M in the F Direction e unit Vector cool so nothing is moving but there's a current what is moving what is the thing of whose current of whom this is the current the probability density the probability density is rotating so what this is telling us is that it's true the system is stationary but I want to now I'm looking down at the the equatorial plane okay so this plot is going to be looking down on the equatorial plane uh of hydrogen here's the origin the center of the potential and what the is telling us I'm going to draw these vectors they're in the EI Direction okay but their magnitude falls off with 1 / R and the norm square of the wave function which also is falling off exponentially and it goes to zero at the origin as R the L + 1 and M must be at least uh must be no bigger than l so in order for M to be non zero L must be non zero which means this must go like R to the something greater than m + 1 so the RS cancel out we have it that it vanishes so the contribution vanishes at the origin is small near the origin is largest at some radius and then falls off again so the magnitude of the arrow here is meant to indicate the magnitude of the flux so what we see is that we have a dist probability distribution where the probability as a distribution is time independent uh right the probability distribution is in fact time independent but there's a current which is a persistent stationary current everyone cool with that so if I ask you where is the particle well the probability density tells you that and if I ask you what's the current the electric current minus E * J okay at a point and this is really the current density and the probability current density now what is the consequence of the of the statement that the probability is not the probability density itself is not changing in time it's that that there's zero Divergence of this current and indeed there is zero Divergence every little bit going into a spot is matched by some equivalent amount going out there's zero Divergence cool and so we see and so we see that um that while it's true that nothing is moving it is also true that there is a non-trivial electric current and when you use the bosar law to sum up the contributions from each little bit of this current what you get is right hand rule a magnetic field a magnetic moment and following nothing but the BOS of law and using what you know about the wave functions um this gives us that the Magnetic Moment uh is equal to the bore Magneton B * m z okay everyone cool with that yeah yeah um well here's one way to say it there are two let me let me rephrase that question let me give you let me tell you a different question to ask and then let's think about the answers to that question and I and I hope that will answer your question if it doesn't ask it again so here's the question I would suggest that you ask or that someone ask I'll ask it um and I just totally lost my train of thought that's totally what was the question I wanted you to ask wow that's amazing I completely just in the blink of an eye totally lost my train of ah yes um so here it was crucial in this calculation that the current was given by the imaginary part of the gradient and as you showed in a problem set a while back um anytime you have a wave function which is real anytime you have a wave function which is real then the uh current will vanish here it was crucial in order to get a nonvanishing current it was crucial that the wave function was not real it had a phase right but you also showed on a problem set that you can always take your energy functions for bounce States you can always take energy functions and make them real you can always construct a basis of energy functions which are strictly real sorry in one dimension right yeah well also what what did you use for that proof just use linear combinations the yeah you just use the energy I value equation hermeticity and uh linear the linearity of the energy op and that's perfectly true in any number of Dimensions so that sounds crazy so first off why do we have a not real energy igen function can we construct purely real energy IG functions if we can those energy igen functions would appear to have no current so they would have no Magnetic Moment how do these fit together can you construct energy igen functions that are pure real for this system for the coolant potential let me give you a hint in 1D for a free particle what are the energy functions 1D e to the IX right that's not real but there's another igen function e to the minus IX and if you take the sum of those you get e to the IX plus e to the minus IX and let divide by two for fun and that gives you cosine of KX that's real but there's a second one which is s of KX which is also real now you can take linear combinations of them with I and get the exponentials back but let's just take the real part right now do those carry any momentum what's the momentum expectation value for cosine of KX zero because you get a contribution from plus K and one from minus K they exactly cancel now look at this solution can you construct a real energy igen function of the coolant potential how great let's take this and its complex conjugate so what would that be well if we take this s n LM and its complex conjugate well what is its complex conjugate these are real that just gives me a minus so that's the state plus s n l minus M which is also an allow state with the same energy by rotational invariance and this is thus the state s NL and it doesn't have a definite LZ angular momentum right so I'll just call it SC sub NL you know unhappy face um it is not an LZ function but it is an energy function and I could also have built a minus with you know divide by 2 I for fun I could have built the sign or the cosine of five one of which showed up on your exam so I can find a basis of these states s and cosine instead of e to the i and e to the minus IM and those would have been perfectly and in those situations what would the current have been if I put the system in this stationary State what would the current have been identically zero however that wouldn't be a state with a definite angular momentum so it wouldn't be surprising that it has zero current it's got some contribution it's a superposition of having some angular momentum and having the opposite angular momentum and the expectation value the expected value is zero I can also study states with a definite value of the angular mum those are not real there's nothing wrong with that I could have constructed states which don't have a definite angular momentum but are real but instead I want to work with states that have a definite angular momentum that cool so there's no tension there's no contradiction it's just that if we're interested in finding states that have a definite energy and a definite LZ angular momentum that is not going to be a real function and nothing tells us that it has to be and when you have a non-rib LZ when you have a non-trivial angular momentum just like a classical particle with non-trivial angular momentum that has charge we find that there's a current and thus a magnetic moment so the important thing was having a definite nonzero momentum or in this case angular momentum to give us the current yeah questions about this yeah using the same logic it kind of looks like we're taking a Charged particle and moving it around in a circle like or we have a distribution we're spinning it yeah we spend the distribtion of charge we're accelerating the Char particles in it yes individually yes accelerate them theyit radiation yes hyd ATS don't emit radiation yes how does that work that sounds a lot like problem four on your problems head problem ah okay well um um that's a great question and you should think about it how do I how could I say you read my mind yes struggling with this is exact to the point of one of the problems on your problem set and ask me that again after the problem set has been turned in and I'll give you a happy disquisition on it but I want you to struggle with it because it's it's a hard and interesting question yeah so um I don't think this answers my question necessarily about the radiation because so um analogously like to classical enm this would be the magnetostatic case where you just have a radiation you have like quickly oscillating fields and the transition times are really small and like the frequencies of the really fast so I still don't know that's the same so this question is unfortunately a linear combination of a of a really good independent question and that question so ask me after lecture and I'll talk to you about the part that's linearly independent thing okay I'm I'm on thin ice here okay um anything else where we dispense with hydrogen okay the the question that um the the question that you all keep coming to about the um well problem four on the I think it's problem four on the on the problem set maybe it's problem too um uh it involves almost no computation but it's the most intellectually challenging problem on the exam on the problem set so take it seriously even though it's like calculation free okay yeah yeah yeah it so the the um it's not by symmetry because there isn't a symmetry the proton is 2,000 times heavier than the electron but um the so um so the let me make sure I'm understanding your question your question is um we found that the electron is in uh is in Bound states in the colon potential but in hydrogen you have two particles you have an electron you have a proton so uh is the electron in that state and the proton is just free and cruising on its own thing that's exactly the topic of the next 45 minutes okay good question so um with with that Insight um uh let me we turned now to the question of identical particles or multiple particles okay so we're done with Kum for the moment pretty much for the rest of the course so I want to move on to the following question suppose I have a system we've spent a lot of time thinking about a particle in a potential I would like to think about multiple particles for a minute okay and neat things happen for multiple particles that don't happen for indiv ual isolated particles so let's think about what those let's think about the physics of multiple particles so in particular classically In classical mechanics if I have two particles what is the information I have to specify to specify the state I have to specify the position of the first particle uh X X1 and its momentum P1 and then the position of the second particle X2 and P2 I'm going to Omit vectors over everything but everything is in the appropriate number of Dimensions So In classical Mech or in quantum mechanics the state of the system is specified by a wave function which is a function of the positions or the the degrees of freedom let's say X1 and X2 um and x uh one and X2 and P1 and P2 are promoted to operators representing these observables right and the wave function is a function of now let me just quickly tell you what this notation means what this notation means is X1 is some number like seven and the quantity in the first spot this means that the first particle indicated by the first slot is at X1 and the second particle is at X2 okay so whenever I write a wave function what I mean is this is the probability amplitude the the thing whose Norm square is a probability to find the first particle at this value and the second particle that value so the one and two label the points not the particles the particle is labeled by the position inside this wave function everyone cool with that okay so that's just a notation so the quantum mechanical description of two particles is a wave function of both positions and operators representing the position and the coordinates um of um guess I can do this um the positions and the coordinates of the particles so and the probability actually let's go ahead and finish up here and the probability uh density to find uh the first particle oops first at X1 and the second at X2 is just the norm squared of the amplitude sx1 X2 squ just as usual that's the probability density all right everyone cool with that and what are X um one X2 commutator what is this commutator can you know the position of the first particle and the position of the second particle simultaneously sure I'm here you're there okay zero and um X1 with P1 just work in one dimension for the moment is equal to I bar and the same would have been true of X2 with P2 and what about uh X1 with P2 zero these are independent quantities okay so it's more or less as you'd expect so just to be explicit about this let's do an example two free particles okay so what's the energy operator well the energy operator is equal to p^2 upon 2 m for the first particle one plus P ^2 2 upon 2 M2 second particle its mass is M2 the first particle has mass M1 and the system is free so uh this is plus zero yeah yeah okay so the the question is um x1x2 commutator equals zero is that true uh even if there are forces between the particles so what are the forces between particles what are they going to contribute to yeah the potential and that's going to show up in the energy operator so that will certainly matter and it will change what the energy I values are but it won't tell you what can or can't be measured it won't tell you what properties the system can have or not good yeah me the we we'll we'll talk about things like that in a minute no that this is this is um does do the computation relations care what state you're in they relations amongst operators so they're independent of the state always okay yeah for the two free particles are we assuming that they're not charged particles yeah I'm assuming that there are no interactions whatsoever just totally free particles potential is zero V of X1 X2 equals z yeah so they're not charged they're just totally uninteresting no interactions no forces no potential okay so we know how to solve this problem because we can use separation s of X1 comma X2 is can be written as well we know what the solutions of p1^ 2 upon 2 m uh is equal to e r so we can write this as Kai of X1 and actually uh I'm going to call the the positions of these guys A and B because the subscripts are just terribly misleading so the first point is called a the second point is called B so uh uh A and B and this is p uh p uh P1 and P2 the momento the two guys uh Kai of a and F of B so all I'm doing here is I'm using separation okay p a PB so here instead of calling them the positions X1 and X2 I'm going to call them A and B just because it's going to be easier to write and make things clear so here I'm using separation and um then p1^ s or pa^ S upon 2 m on Kai of a is equal to uh EA Kai a and ditto for B this tells us that Kai of a is equal to e to the some coefficient C uh e to the i k a every Rec that a is just replacing X1 so it's just the position so this is just saying that the solution to a free single free particle is a plane wave and because this is just the sum of the momenta squares we can separate the equation and the same thing obtains for S so similarly for fi ditto fi of B is equal to the e to the i k sub b b and I'll call this Cas sub a to distinguish them so the wave functions a basis for for the uh wave functions for two particles s of a b with energy e is equal to e to the I Ka a plus KB B where um e is equal to h bar^ 2 upon 2 m k sub a 2 plus K sub b^ 2 yeah for a system of two free particles is every wave function of the form uh K Kai of a * 5 of B if you have a system that's separable is every wave function is every solution itself separated no because we can have arbitrary superpositions of forms of of this type right so we could have superpositions of plane waves as long as the energies of each plane wave in the superposition are equal to e the total energy equal E I can just superpose them and I still have an energy I function everyone cool with that okay so nothing shocking here but I did this example so that we'd have the notation of Kai uh and fi for the two states okay so now let me come to this question of uh what what about the proton well suppose I have a system now with um which is not a free particle it's two particles A and B and E is equal to PA a^ 2 over 2 ma a plus pb^ 2 upon 2 MB plus a potential that depends only on at a minus B okay so this is for example what happens in the cool potential when you include the proton having a finite Mass instead of being infinitely massive and stuck still so now we can do exactly the same thing we did In classical mechanics when you have a potential that only depends on the distance between two things I can reorganize degrees of freedom into the um Center of mass position R is equal to um 1/ ma+ MB of ma uh a plus uh MB B so that's the center of mass motion and the relative uh distance is equal to uh uh one over whoops I don't need that uh a minus B okay and then if you do this and you write out the energy operator e is equal to minus h s upon 2 m or to capital M total mass uh Dr r s plusus h bar^ 2/ 2 mu D little R 2 uh plus v of R okay so this is exactly what happens in classical mechanics you work in terms of the center of mass coordinate and the relative coordinate the relative coordinate becomes effectively an independent degree of Freedom with a potential which is the central potential and the center of mass coordinate is a free particle so if we have our proton and our electron and they're attracted to each other by Kum there's a center of mass motion and then they do together whatever they do together all the potential every cool that the only difference is that the mass in the potential is not the mass of the electron but it's the geometric mean mu is equal to M MB over ma plus MB okay now for a proton and an electron um if ma is the proton and MB is the electron then this is proton electron over proton plus electron but proton is about 2,000 times the mass of the electron so this is basically the mass of the proton and they factor out so the effective uh reduced mass is roughly equal to the electron Mass Corrections of a part in a thousand okay so to answer your question is the proton also in some complicated state describe it well in fact neither the electron nor the proton are described by the coolant potential but the Rel relative position the relative radial distance between them is controlled by the coolum potential and the center of mass degree of freedom is a free particle does that make sense okay good okay so so much for so much for that example the free particle and the central potential here's the much more interesting that happens when we have multiple particles yeah you exp oh yeah sorry this is the I just meant the gradient with respect to R so if R is a vector this is the gradient with respect to R norm squar and this is the gradient with respect to the the relative coordinate so for example um uh this is um if if we're in one dimension so that this is strictly one dimensional then this is just derivative with respect to r squared and this is derivative with respect to little r squared just the gradient squared did that answer your question yeah what about in well then it's the gradient operator the the thing that takes a function gives you a vector which is the the the directional derivative uh of that yeah exactly the r Direction sorry a subtraction where minus H squ upon 2 m d r 2 minus H S 2 mu D this okay so that's those are SE not multip yeah they're not multiplied right this this it's just the sum so the energy is kinetic energy of the relative of the center of mass kinetic energy of the relative degree of freedom and then potential energy yeah is exactly what happens in in class mechanics yeah this one M it's the total mass ma plus MB and this one is the reduced mass m MB upon ma plus MB okay so here's a cool thing that happens with multiple particles that didn't happen previously suppose we have identical particles so in particular imagine I have two billiard balls so I have two billiard balls and I shoot I send one in from one side and I send the other in from the other side and then they Collide and there's some horrible chaos that happens and one goes flying out to this position a and the other goes flying out to this position B okay now here's my question which ball went to a and which ball went to B well if we did this experiment that would be be easy to answer CU we could paint a little you know one on this one and a little two on this one and they'd go flying out uh and then at the end when you catch the ball at a and you catch the ball at B you can grab them and look at them and say aha this one in my left hand which I got from a has one on it this one has two on it and I'm done right the other way we could have uh observed which ball went where is we could have taken a high-speed film of this and watched frame by frame and said aha particle one particle one particle one particle one particle 2 two two two two right we could have just followed the paths and we we haven't done anything to the experiment we just took a film we haven't messed with it we don't change the results of the experiment we just watch right perfectly doable classically Quantum mechanically is this doable no because first off if you watch carefully along and figure out with did it go through this slit did it go through that slit you know you change the results 100% white versus 50/50 right if you go back to the boxes um and meanwhile if they're truly identical particles like electrons there's no way to paint anything on the damn particle they're just electrons and they're completely as far as anyone's ever been able to tell completely and utterly identical they cannot be distinguished in any way whatsoever so you can't do the thing where you grab the one from a and grab the one from B and say ah this one had the one on it they're indistinguishable yeah we're going to come to the poly Exclusion Principle hold on to that hold on to that question we're going to come we're going to get there okay so um so we we can't in if we have truly identical particles what we mean by that is there's no way to run this experiment and determine which particle ended up which of these two particles went to a and which went to B everyone cool with that they're identical and what I want to understand is what are the consequences so the first and basic consequence of this is that the probability that the first particle ends up at a and the second particle ends up at B must be equal to the probability um that the first particle ends up at B and the second particle ends up at a because you can't tell which is which if you can't tell it must be that those probabilities are equal because if they weren't equal you effectively have skewed the result and they're not they're distinguishable these are totally IND so the probability that the first particle ends up at a second at B must be equal to the probability the first particle ends up at B and second ends up at a because you cannot tell the difference this is what it means to be identical that equal sign is what I mean by saying I have identical particles cool so let's find out what the consequences of this are Define the following operator and Dave Morrison if you're watching uh this is the viros p uh so I'm going to call this operator scripty p sub12 is the operator so it's got a little hat on it one more fence uh which takes the first particle uh to the to and the second particle and swaps them okay so and I guess I don't even need the one two this P operator swaps particle one and particle two so for example it takes a probability of a to B uh to probability of B to a but more importantly this swapping operation takes the wave function the amplitude of a and b and it swaps a and b s of ba now it's clear that the probability or that the swapping operation does nothing to the probability because the fact that they're identical particles means that these are equal to each other so it hasn't changed the answer but just because the probabilities are equal to each other does that tell you that the wave function is invariant under swapping the particles no it doesn't have to be invariant the the important thing is that the norm squared of s so in principle this could be equal to some phase e to the i f subab or let me call it Theta subab uh s of ab and if this was the the case if there was a phase that we got here when we take the norm squared the probability Remains the Same okay on the other hand we know something else we know that if we take the we take the wave function S A and we swap it and then we swap it again what do we get a B but that means this is equal to e to the 2 I th AB so swapping twice had better give me one so this had better be equal to one let me write this slightly differently this is e to the I Theta squar is equal to one so what must be true of e to the I Theta of our phase it's a number that squares to one so it could be one of two values it could be one or could be minus one that's it so what that tells us is a uh so that tells us that P whoops script p on S B is equal to plus or minus s ba oh sorry AB another way to say this is just that so another way to say this is that p^2 acting on S is just s again so the igen values of P have to be plus or minus one here they are so um in fact this is let me phrase this in a little more correct way um this tells us that the igen values of p r plus orus one yeah yes good okay so let's let's check this quickly so the question is how can it be minus one how can that that doesn't that would seem to violate our calculation so what this is saying is that um if we know if we take p on uh let's say p on S of a let's say let's let s um be uh an igen function of P okay so if s is an igen function of p with igen value minus one then this p on S is equal to minus s yeah now the probability is equal to s^ squ and so p on S or sorry p on S squ is equal to um uh uh minus s squar we take each s it goes to minus s this is just equal to S squ yeah I who asked the question sorry right okay so it leaves the norm squared invariant so even so it's okay to have a minus one I value under P because that doesn't change the probability distribution the probability distribution is left in however if we take p^2 on S that's equal to p on p on S it's equal to p on minus s which is equal to minus minus s which is equal to S okay so and this is the statement that the square acts as the identity did that answer your question okay okay um a little why we need on to go back to I me it preserve the probability regard we had two good why did p^ s have to be the identity because what is p doing P takes two particles and it swaps them and if it swaps them again what do you get the original configuration right if you by swapping if by P you mean the thing that swaps those particles then doing it twice is like not doing anything at all now you can define a different quantity which isn't this swapping operation which does this twice and gives you something else that's perfectly reasonable but I'm going to be interested in the operator which is just Swap and if you do it twice you get back to the identity okay cool okay yeah yes uh well what what does it do with right so at given any configuration at any moment in time right pick your wave function pick your state for example two particles here what the script DP operator with the swapping operator does it just swaps them so it swaps the position of one and the position of the other right exactly and that and you do that at some moment in time you do that to a state so in that experiment what I mean there's no there's no answer to the question you know does p swap them before or does it swap them after it's up to you you could apply the P operator anytime you want cool okay yeah yeah that sounds reasonable sounds yeah this is disconcerting that's exactly right so that's an excellent observation let me rephrase that slightly so here's the observation that she's making it's exactly correct and it's where we're going to get in a few minutes um so the observation is this look imagine I take two electrons which for the moment we'll just call identical particles so we take two identical particles put one in my right hand one in my left hand and I just hold them there and I wait for a while a while later is it the same electron in my right hand I don't know they're identical I can't tell they're completely identical and so if you think about this like you do some like weak scattering if you did some weak scattering process between these where you you know you take them very far apart very slowly moving along but they're very far away so the electrostatic interaction is very small and so they repel each other just a little bit if this system is in fact identical and if the wave function is let's say for the moment we'll talk about whether this is correct or not if the wave function is invariant under swapping the particles let's just imagine that it's invariant under swapping the particles then then there are two things that could have happened the particles could have done this or there's also a contribution where they do this which kind of hurts um and uh in order for the system to be symmetric you have to have both contributions so let's come to that but indeed it's as if there's some additional interaction some additional correlations and that's exactly what we want to study so let's get to that very good observation so what I'd like to do is make that precise so there are two kinds of particles or three kinds of particles I should say in the world uh from this point of view the first kind of particle are distinguishable particles suppose I have two particles one with the mass m and one with the mass 2,000 M say just to pick randomly number right those are distinguishable because you can weigh them so you can tell which one is the heavy one which one is the light one and you know you can tell cool so there are distinguishable particles and if we have distinguishable particles I'll call s subd for distinguishable then it's okay to have uh the following thing s distinguishable first particle is the amplitude for the first particle to be at a and the amplitude for the second particle to be a b could be Kai of a some function of a and fi of B this is not invariant under a goes to B Because under a goes to B it becomes Kai of B some function of b f of a some different function of a that's distinct but it doesn't matter they're distinguishable so that's perfectly fine it's not true P of ab is not equal to P of ba but that's okay because they're distinguishable everyone cool with that yeah exactly so P of ab this is by definition equal to Norm square of S D um and I should say d d uh Norm square of SD of ab uh squared which is equal to Norm square of Kai of a 5 b squared whereas this guy would have been Kai of b f of a norm squ and since those are just some stupid functions I haven't told you what they are just some random functions then they're just different probability distributions so on the other hand if we have indistinguishable wave functions then um uh s indistinguishable um we need that s squ of ab R squ is equal to S of ba squ and this is not of that form okay so we have two possibilities I'll write this as s plus minus if I know that one of the particles is in the state described by Kai and the other particle is in theate state described by fi this would be an example of a wave function with that property however it's not invariant under swapping A and B so how can I make it invariant under swapping A and B well I could do the following 1un two2 Kai of a 5 of B and if I want to make it invariant I could add plus uh Kai of B 5 a and now if I swap A and B here this becomes Kai of b f a but that's exactly this term this becomes K of a f b that's this term so we just swapped them yeah but we don't need the wave function to be invariant under swapping we just need it to be invariant under up to a sign so the other option is to have a minus sign here and this gives us that the swapping operation P acting on S plus minus of ab is equal to plusus S of a okay and the plus is generally called the symmetric and the minus the anti- symmetric combination okay so distinguishable particles can just be in some random state but there are constraints on what states what combinations of states are allowed for indistinguishable particles if you can't tell the difference between two indistinguishable particles and you know one is in the state Kai and the other is in the state fi this cannot be the wave function it must be either kaii Plus kaii in this fashion or minus everyone cool that yeah I have a question meity me yes good so what does probability means is what's the probability that if that upon observation the system I find the first particle to be at a and the second particle to be a b right and I I can check that by saying like look I catch the first particle I catch the second particle uh is this a no okay then that gives zero to the probability distribution I do that a billion times and I build up statistics and I find that you know a fourth of one out of four times uh I'll find a particle the first particle or I'll find a particle at a one out of four times I'll find a particle at and the probability that I find the first particle at a and the second particle at B is1 say okay what you can't do if they're identical is you can't say which particle you caught at a this is saying a particle at a or a particle at B right but it's but whether this is the same or not of probability that I find a particle at B and the the first particle B and second particle at a if you can't tell the difference then they're just a particle at a and a particle at B okay okay so what does this give us so this gives us a couple of nice facts so imagine that's an exciting sound so this gives us a couple of nice facts uh with which we can find awesomeness in the world the first is the following if you have identical particles then the energy can't depend on the order if you have identical particles and they're truly identical you swap them then the energy will be the same if it wasn't the same then they're distinguishable by figuring out what the energy is so in order that they're identical it must be true that if you swap the particles and then compute the energy this should be the same as what you get if you first compute the energy and then swap them which is to say that the commutator of e with the swapping operator p is zero okay but what that tells you is that the expectation value of P doesn't change in time in particular if it's some initial state state if you initially p on S is equal to plus s at Time Zero then s then P at s uh P SI is equal to plus s for all for all future times P of T is equal to plus s of t Okay so if you have two identical particles and the wave function is invariant under swapping them at some moment in time then it will always be invariant under swapping them it's a persistent property of particles that their wave function is invariance under swapping them yeah yeah have urani one of heavier isotope and during the time that you're like holding them in your hand of them decay the same yeah that's always this tells you something this is a very good question so the question is look suppose I have an excited iope uranium that's distinguishable from the from some other isotope of uranium I wait for a while and then this thing decays down to the St it won't Decay to the stable isotope of uranium but whatever it decays down to we can imagine this a universe in which it did it decays down to a a stable State and uh well I mean uranium is never stable but anyway you you get the idea um and so and at which which point they're indistinguishable this sounds bad because now the wave function should be invariant uh but it started out not being invariant what's the problem in this argument the system has changed in particular something went flying out so this is actually kind of a nice way to argue that oh there must have been something else the full the wave function describes a full system but if something leaves then it's not the same system anymore and the wave function isn't describing the same degrees of freedom something left but suppose we keep track of that one we still can't exactly then well then there's some additional constraint right it must be invariant under swapping that but it must but the wave function also knows about that extra bit that went flying off and so the whole wave function has to be invariant under swapping The Identical Parts but not invariant under SWAT under you know the invariance is not just those two things they they're correlated with the thing that went flying away so another way to think about this is Imagine two different uh hydrogen atoms here I've got hydrogen atom it's an electron and a proton and here's a deterior derium atom it's a an electron bound to a proton and a neutron glued together deuteron so um are the electrons identical yeah they're totally identical so is the wave function invariant does the wave function or the probability distribution have to be invariant under swapping the electrons yes they're identical so the probability distribution must be invariant under swapping the electrons however is it identical under swapping the hydrogen with the duum no no so it's invariant under swapping The Identical parts and not the not identical Parts cool okay so so this tells us that there are two kinds of part particles they're persistent um or sorry there there are three kinds of particles and these properties are persistent the first kind of particle uh sets of particles are distinguishable particles if you have two particles which are distinguishable then you're done they're distinguishable nothing else to say two you can have identical particles with the property that if you take p on S AB uh sorry p on S if you swap the particles this is equal to plus s and then you have um so identical uh with plus and you have three identical particles where if you swap the particles you get a minus sign on s these particles are called we have a name for particles of this kind bons these are called Fons my ta did a bad thing to me when I was taking quantum mechanics and said just imagine them as little tiny fmes so just take a picture of fmy in your head and imagine Little P and and this is cruel because I can't help it every time someone in a seminar is like blah blah blah F me and I'm like damn damn it little fmy um it's really quite annoying um so now you have it too great um um so what are the consequences what are the consequences of the fact that there are two kinds of particles in the universe uh these Fons and um and bons this has a really lovely Consequence the first is suppose we have a uh a suppose we have two Fons okay examples of Fons are electrons suppose we have a wave function for two Fons the first might what's the probability amplitude that the first is at a and the second is at B well it's this s of ab and the statement that it's a firan is the statement that this is equal to minus s of ba if we swap the positions of the two particles we must pick up a minus sign this tells us in particular that the probability amplitude for the first particle would be at a and the second particle to be at a is equal to minus itself because upon swapping the particles we get minus s of AA so the probability amplitude to find two Fons at the same place is equal to zero two Fons cannot occupy the same state this was the poly Exclusion Principle which we needed to get the periodic table po two if we have so this is firion if we have bons s bosons s of ab let me write this out so um s firon or boson so firion is going to be with a minus and boson is going to be with a plus is equal to suppose I have two particles 1/ < tk2 and one particle is in the state Kai and the other particles in the state fi but in order to be fironic or bosonic in order for this to be invariant under swapping A and B we have to have a plus or a minus uh Kai of B 5 a okay and here immediately see this poly principle at work if I could take the fironic example with a minus sign then s evaluated at AA must be K A F at B minus kayet B fi at a but if a is B this is K A F A minus K A F A that's zero but let's think about the bosonic case if we have a bosonic field or if we have a sorry if we have a bosonic uh identical particles then s b at a with a for a firon it zero but s b of the amplitude to be at two uh at um at uh the same place is equal to well if B is a then these two terms are identical we have a plus this is root2 Kai at a f at a which is greater than what you might have naively guessed which would have been just K fa for bans they really like being next to each other they really like being in the same place and this will eventually lead to lasers so for from this simple statistical property under swapping picking up a minus sign we get the poly principle which gave us the periodic table and is going to give us in the next lecture bands in solids and conductivity from the same principle but with a plus and the Persistence of this sign from the Persistence of the statistics from the fact that we have two identical bons we get that they like to be in the same spot and we'll get lasers and Bose Einstein condensates and next time we'll pick up with Fons in a periodic potential and we'll study solids and gets a diamond