# Lec 35 | MIT 7.012 Introduction to Biology, Fall 2004

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGeBSiXoSoA
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/xGeBSiXoSoA

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 9:53 — Chapter 2 (9:53)
- 19:51 — Chapter 3 (19:51)
- 27:33 — Chapter 4 (27:33)
- 36:36 — Chapter 5 (36:36)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** I actually would like to take this occasion to uh praise and thank the TAs. Uh we've been teaching this course for about a dozen years and we've had some really excellent um uh groups of TAS, but this year's crop is is really offscale really outstanding and I uh we're all very grateful.

**[0:22]:** You you know their names. Uh I won't go through them all. Um but uh the fact of the matter is these TAs uh teach this course because they're told to teach the course and at the same time they're doing all their thesis research. So they end up spending about 168 hours a week on various kinds of work. So uh it's not a natural thing for them to spend an enormous amount of time as they have been this year really uh just offscale extraordinarily good. Here they are. Winston, Susan, Michelle, Sarah, Sarah, Divia, Jim, Sydney, Yasmine, and Cha. So, thank you all. Uh, at the same time, I'd also like to thank Claudet Gardell, who is who runs this thing. This is a large undertaking, believe it or not, with almost 350 students enrolled, but it's moved uh seamlessly and without any problems this year for which uh many of us are very grateful.

**[1:17]:** So, thank you, Rodet. Uh I I'm going to spend today uh trying to broadcast into the future, forecast into the future, I should say, about uh where all of what we've talked about this semester is taking us. Uh where is it going to get us in terms of uh where we're going to be 10 or 20 years from now and what you're going to be in the middle of 10 or 20 years from now as you begin to move as it will happen surely as day follows night into midlife. Imagine that when you're 35 or 40, this will happen. Uh, and in order to do so, I want to just go back 125 years or so to give you a feeling for what the history of biology has been like, some of it since uh, the end of the 19th century, just to give you a little flavor for what can happen to biology if things aren't done right.

**[2:06]:** Charles Darwin had a cousin named uh, Francis Galton. He was kned by the uh queen called Sir Francis Gton and he was an early pioneer in statistics and he coined the term eugenics and u as you may know eugenics is simply the the uh science of trying to use genetics to breed better um livestock, better plants uh and ultimately maybe to breed better human beings. And uh we humans have been doing eugenics on on plants and livestocks for at least 10,000 years. That is to say, we've been uh continually been selecting out the best of a breed as the progenitors of the next generation of the breed. And in that way, corn, which was originally this large when it was grown uh 5,000 years ago in Mexico, the cobbs have now become this large and and quite tasty. And all of that is through uh selective breeding.

**[3:04]:** Um but in the be in the last half of the 19th century inspired by Darwin and subsequently by Mendle's work on um on mandelian genetics a whole science of eugenics grew up in this country um which included not only the improvement in the quality of livestock and plants but also improvements in the gene pool of humanity. There was a strong conviction that genes uh were directly responsible for all kinds of physical traits as well as mental and psychological traits. There was a strong belief that some races were superior and other races were inferior because of genetic uh gifts or genetic deficits and this included as well within races however one defined them different ethnic groups. There was a firm belief that science could ultimately solve a lot of social problems including um urban violence, labor unrest, manic depression, schizophrenia and even mental retardation. And uh the eugenicists as they came to be known came to believe that the problems of the world alcoholism, poverty, prostitution, criminality, feeble-mindedness, chess playing ability, tendency to commit industrial sabotage that was big in the beginning of the

**[4:25]:** 20th century when the unions were coming into power. They were all associated with one or another rather penetrant mandelian alil. a well-known um geneticist named Davenport who subsequently was associated with an unnamed university upav studied uh various um ethnic groups and races and concluded that on the basis of genetics the Germans ranked highest in qualities such as leadership, humor, generosity, sympathy and loyalty, Italians and Irish ranked lowest in most of these traits. He was lucky he survived in this town since together Italians and Irish I think encompass 70% of the population. British were lowest in two of the traits. I Irish were highest in suspiciousness. Jews were highest in obtrusiveness and obtrusiveness, whatever that is. And all of these things were said to be genetically templated. And so uh at the beginning of World War I, IQ tests were first instituted uh in this country during the draft in order to determine who was genetically fit to serve and who was below standard.

**[5:34]:** And using IQ tests which were implemented in in great numbers and throughout the society in the 1920s a well-known geneticist named uh Goddard discovered that 80% of of Jewish Hungarian and Polish immigrants as well as Italian and Russ Russian immigrants were mentally defective or feeble-minded and that these traits these mental defects in 80% of these groups were transmitted as regularly and as surely as the color of hair or eyes. I'm not telling I'm not making up fairy tales now. I'm telling you what's happened in our history. Um in the 1920s there was a eugenics record office in this country which existed for the next 20 years. An American eugenics society which had 1,200 people. And uh JH Kellogg of Battle Creek M you know how he made his money don't you? Corn flakes. Um he founded a uh a race betterment uh association uh which whose intent was to better the gene pool of the American population through uh selective breeding.

**[6:42]:** In by 1928 there were 376 college courses taught across this country in the on the subject of eugenics I i.e. how to improve the human race by um beginning to breed more fit individuals. And so when the Nazis came to power, as they did in 1933 in Germany, uh they had much to draw from. In fact, most of their scientific rationale to the extent they had any didn't come from Germany. It came from eugenicists in the United States. And uh so they began to uh look amongst their society for people who were useless eaters i.e. they consumed food but didn't produce. They lived lives not worth living. The elderly, the chronic poor, the crippled and the misfits. And they began um involuntary sterilization. So people who were regarded as genetically less fit were uh sterilized. Uh by the time the Nazis finished their uh 12 years in power, uh 400 thou 400,000 people had been sterilized in Germany because for one or another reason uh they were regarded as somehow defective.

**[7:53]:** Um and uh as the war the second world war grew um made resources more uh tight uh they just did something much simpler. they just euthanized people. They just killed them. Uh if they were regarded as in one way or another genetically defective. In fact, my father had had a first cousin who around 1936 or so was was gassed because he had a bad stuttering defect. Uh so this is all things that really happened to people. As a consequence of all of this eugenics, uh by 1924, an immigration act was passed which severely circumscribed uh the amount of people immigrating into this country uh because they the the immigrants were widely viewed as diluting and contaminating the American gene pool. And this probably well this undoubtedly had a devastating effect on this country which we'll never really be able to know because the truth of the matter is that to the extent we have economic and um and scientific robustness

**[8:54]:** in this country it has come for the last century year after year generation after generation from the immigrants who come to this country not people who were here three four five generations it's the immigrants who brought in the new ideas the energy uh the power and I venture to say that if I were to ask what fraction of you you are first generation Americans it number would be pretty high right but uh in 1924 that was at for a while stopped simply because uh people coming into the country were viewed as genetically less than acceptable. Uh by 1940 30 states had had compulsory sterilization laws in this country i.e. people who were deemed to be genetically uh less gifted were sterilized against their will. Uh 60,000 of those sterilizations were performed in this country. Um and um the eugenics movement gained more and more adherence.

**[9:53]:** What shut it off ultimately was uh what happened in uh World War II where six million Jews were killed along with probably five or six million Slavs and other uh races who were deemed and and gypsies. There were probably half million gypsies killed by the Nazis. Different groups of people who were deemed to be genetically uh less deserving of living and genetically less likely to be productive and useful human beings. And were it not for World War II, it's pro it's quite plausible that the eugenics movement would have continued to grow and that today when we talk about genetics, much of it would be referred to a belief that somehow we can determine people's uh phenotype and genotype and that we can predict how useful or useless they're going to be on the basis of our insights into genetics. And this ideology of genetic determinism, I say it it it had a a great decline Um this is the phrase we use genetic determinism i.e.

**[10:55]:** to say that individuals who are uh an individual's life course is strongly dictated by his or her genome his or her alals. You heard a lot about the alals uh last time time from Eric. Um but genetic determinism is once again coming to the forefront. Why? Because now for the first time we actually have a science of human genetics when all of this other stuff was going on 50 and 100 years ago. It was all pseudocience. It was all made up. No one had the vaguest idea what uh genes were pe were present in people's DNA. They didn't even know about DNA. They didn't really know about most mandelian traits being passed in human populations. and they had no way of knowing in the vast majority of cases whether a certain person's phenotype was or was not dictated by um genotype. So is this notion of a strong genotype phenotype connection totally nonsense?

**[11:53]:** Well, I'll give you an example of where you might begin to think it isn't. And it comes from studies of identical twins who were separated at birth and brought up in different families. So these identical twins obviously have an identical genotype. So, here's a famous story that I like to refer to. There was a chance meeting in 1979 between a steel worker named Jim uh Lewis and a clerical worker named Jim Springer. They were both uh lived in Ohio. They were uh uh separated at birth at five weeks after birth and they were raised 80 miles apart in different towns in Ohio. And at the age of 39, they discovered themselves through some chance meeting. They discovered each other. Well, they both had dark hair. They both stood 6' tall and they both weighed 180 lbs. That's not so surprising. They both spoke with the same inflections, which they clearly had not yet learned to speak with when they were 5 weeks old.

**[12:45]:** They walked with the same gate. They made the same gestures. They both loved stock car racings. They both hated baseball. They both married women named women named Linda. Both of they were both divorced. And in their second marriages, both of them married women named Betty. They both drove uh Chevrolets. They drank Miller Lightite. They both chain smoked Salems. They vacationed on the same half mile of beach in Florida. They both had elevated blood pressure, severe migraines. Both had undergone vasectomies. They both bit their nails. And their heart rates, their brain waves, and their IQs were so similar that you couldn't tell whether it was the same person or two separate people being studied. Now, what do you begin to think about that? Well, that's an extreme case. Uh the fact is most identical twins raised apart uh do have quite a bit of divergence in uh their in their phenotype in the way they um they grow up.

**[13:41]:** But it begins to plant in your mind the notion that maybe many aspects of the way we think and act actually have a strong genetic template in them. Um and uh one can begin to uh study uh identical twins and ask things about especially those who are separated at birth and not use such extreme anecdotes like the one I just used. And one begins to find that there's an impressive list of attributes that can only be explained by there being a strong genetic determinant uh in in them. And these traits include being alienated from people around one, extroverted, being a traditionalist, looking at in con looking backwards in terms of one's customs, leadership, career choice, risk aversion, attention deficit disorder, religious conviction, uh, and vulnerability to stress. Heritability, it turns out, if you study identical twins, is about I'm sorry, happiness, if you study identical twins, is about 80% heritable, it turns out, uh, and depends little on one's wealth, achievement, or marital status.

**[14:48]:** But 80% of it, if you study identical twins, seem to have a genetic template. And you'll say, well, that's all very satisfying, but it begins to be a little unsettling because it begins to cause each of us to ask, are we really who we think we are? Are we just kind of cassette recorders who were playing out the program that was stuffed into us when the sperm hit the egg that led to each of our appearing on on the the face of the planet? Um, to what extent are we individuals or to to what extent are we simply manifestations of genotype? And to what extent do we have free will? It's kind of an interesting question. Now, people like Eric, I'm not pointing an accusing finger. People like Eric have begun to refine the science of genetics. So, it really is a science. And so, restriction fragment polymorphisms, snips, haplletype analysis are now uncovering a staggering array of human traits.

**[15:45]:** I believe that the number of human traits that have now been localized to specific genes, most of these are disease genes, exceeds 2,000 is is my recollection. And there are only 21,000 um 22,000 genes in the human genome. And the pace with which genes and genotype and phenotype will be linked to one another is going to increase if if nothing else. Many of the traits that one thinks about in terms of human beings are obviously polygenic. They're not single strong mandelian alals with strong penetrance. They represent the confluence, the collaboration of multiple alals that are conspiring to create one or another phenotype. And these polygenic traits or even polygenic diseases have traditionally resisted uh analysis because mathematically they're so complex to dissect out to dissect out the contributing genes which together uh as a cohort create a genotype. But as Eric told you last time, people like you who are great software developers will one day begin to figure out how one can take extraordinarily complex data sets and and begin to associate specific chromosomeal regions and ultimately

**[16:54]:** genes with uh specific genetic sequences that contribute to a polygenic trait. Uh I think at one time Eric spent uh it's about three or four years ago he worked with people at um uh at Cornell studying a the polygenic trait of ripening in tomatoes. It's a polygenic trait like probably chess playing ability in human beings and was able to localize um ripening rate of tomatoes to five or six distinct genetic regions in the chromosomes of the tomato plant. But that's only a harbinger of what could come. So let's imagine now again I'm not blaming Eric for this. I'm just telling you he's the one he more than anyone else almost on the planet is the person who is leading the charge to refine and strengthen these extraordinarily powerful tools that enable us to discern uh how our genome creates us the way we are. So but let's imagine and but he is he's not going to be the one who applies these tools.

**[17:53]:** They'll be applied all over the planet. There are geneticists everywhere who are interested in looking about diff at how different aspects of human phenotype including disease phenotype are governed by the alals by the snips by the polymorphisms that we carry and obviously by the genes and proteins that we make. So let's begin to imagine let's put ourselves fast forward 10 years and begin to imagine where this is going to take us. We will we already know about a a very substantial number of genes that determine the risk of different kinds of cancer i.e. there's at least 15 different cancer syndromes that people have which have been associated with spec specific genetic lossi. I talked briefly about retininoblastoma which is a rare one but even common um commonly occurring cancers will soon be connected with specific alals in the genome and the risk of getting them in one's lifetime will uh be relatively

**[18:51]:** accurately predictable might take another decade but it will happen manic depressiveness some people have great swings in mood two or three% of the population doesn't wake up happy every morning um and that is also I believe going to heal to specific genetic uh analyses and association with um certain genes. There's already a a a suggestion that the D4 dopamine receptor which is involved in what in receiving one of the neurotransmitters in the brain may uh have a polymorphism that's connected with manic depressiveness. Uh there will be uh probably alals which which are connected with in some way uh novelty or or adventure seeking. Um there are going to be alals that are associated with anxiety probably if probably maybe connected with the serotonin uh transporter uh in the brain. Cardiac disease susceptibility is already mapped out in a number of traits in the most extreme cases.

**[19:51]:** But cardiac disease is very frequent in this population and there undoubtedly will be alles that are discovered that determine whether one has a higher risk or low risk of getting heart disease of getting atherosclerosis and whether or not one can go to McDonald's every day uh and eat big macs with impunity. Can one do that or not? Some people probably can. Some people can eat as much salt as they want. It doesn't give them high blood pressure. Other people can't. We still don't really understand that. Uh schizophrenia is probably also very strongly genetically templated. Not totally, but very strongly. Susceptibility to rheumatoid arthritis probably also has a strong genetic component. Difficulty or ease with which you solve math problems probably also will one day be associated with a certain number of genetic lossi. Um how many difficulty in learning languages? There's already a um a trait that was discovered in a family in the Netherlands, I believe, and they had a very specific grammatical defect in the way that they assembled the syntax of sentences.

**[20:55]:** Um associated with a certain alil of a certain gene. Difficulty in just adding rows of numbers may also be associated with certain combinations of alals. Now, you will say, well, it's impossible. It's inconceivable that these different aspects of cognitive function can be associated with a small number of genes. But let me tell you something else. We talked a week ago about the evolution of humanity over the last couple hundred thousand years. And the pace, the pace with which the human brain has evolved over the last half million years and more recently the last 200,000 years has been so frighteningly rapid that that that evolution of cognitive function and perception in different ways can only have happened through the actions of a small number of genes. If one needed to have dozens of genes change in concert in order to acquire the penetrating minds that we now have and which our ancestors 500,000 years didn't have.

**[21:59]:** The evolution could not have taken uh could not have occurred so quickly. And for that reason alone, one begins to suspect that the genetic differences between people who live 500,000 years ago visav their cognitive function and ours are not so large. And therefore a rather small number of genes may have been responsible for conferring on us the powerful minds which we now um which most of us uh I didn't say anything um which most of us now possess. Um so where's this going to take us? What are the consequences of this? Let's imagine a time 10 or 20 years down the road when we can do some kind of snip analysis on one of these chips that are that have been developed uh in California and here and various places and we can begin to ma measure the alilic diversity uh in in a child a newborn child's DNA or even prenatally if you want.

**[22:59]:** So, uh, what are you going to do? Um, if you begin to find on a on a chip of a child's DNA that this kid is likely to be very good in languages, probably has going to have poor math skills, will be a rather anxious and obsessive person, um, will have difficulty associating with his or her peers, uh, and is likely to come down with heart disease at the age of 45. What's how is that going to affect your relationship to that person that that child? And will you give that child a different kind of education than a newborn who has snips which indicate that without doubt they're going to get 1600s on their morning boards and their shoeins for admission to MIT? How are you going to treat those kids the same? Are you going to treat them differently? Do you give them the same kind of um education and and nurturing?

**[23:50]:** Um and uh how do you treat them throughout their elementary and high school? Are you going to segregate them into different groups or is everybody going to be given an equal chance? Well, you might say it's our tradition in this country to give everybody equal footing in part because of a reaction to what happened in World War II in no small part. But what if the time comes when people say we need to be more efficient economically in this country and we need to devote our resource, we need to maximize um the investment uh uh the the the benefit we get from various investments. And so it's much more efficient to put kids in a certain genetic class in one school and kids who have another uh level of genetic uh uh giftedness in another school. Um of course much of this will be foolhardy because all of these genetic tests although they will give you probabilities of certain phenotypes they'll never at least for the foreseeable generation or two give you certainties.

**[24:50]:** No one will able to be able to predict with absolute total total certainty about the potentials of one or another um young person on the basis of of DNA tests at least not in the near future. Right now one can predict with um with total certainty that somebody has a certain alil they'll come now with Huntington's disease at the age of 30 or 40 or 50. There the predictability the penetrance is 100%. But what if somebody has an alil that says that with 60% likelihood they're not going to be very good at math? Is that already going to be enough to justify their segregation amongst a group of the mathematically less gifted? Let's say uh that they've gone through uh elementary and secondary education and high school and they've made it through college and they start looking for employment. Actually, there are jobs out here to be had in this economy.

**[25:42]:** you wouldn't know it, but there actually are people who can find jobs. And let's say one has now an employer who is evaluating a certain job candidate for um for employability. Maybe they'd like to have a nice medical checkup before they employ this person ostensibly to see whether this person is healthy enough to last for 10 or 20 or 30 years of employment. And maybe they'd like to include among that medical exam a peep at that person's DNA. just in case. And what if the DNA tells uh the employer that this individual is likely to get colon cancer in 18 years and has a slight susceptibility to mood instability and perhaps even manic depressiveness that this person uh is not one of those who can go to McDonald's and eat Big Macs with impunity but has a tendency to atheroscerosis. Think you can think of whatever possibilities you will.

**[26:37]:** Will that be therefore a ground to reject that person as an employee? Well, you say they really have no right to do that. But keep in mind that with increasing frequency in this society, medical benefits, medical insurance is paid by the employer. So, does the employer want to have a whole workforce of people who are in various stages of terminal disease? Or would this employer like to be able to pay the lowest possible health benefits because the employer has taken care to employ only people who have a really terrific genotype, whatever that is defined as being arbitrarily admittedly. Um, and what about marriageability? As my uh sister always says to me, uh, if you want to marry a man, the first thing you should do is look into his jeans. That's a double on tandra. Anyhow,

**[27:33]:** see, somebody finally got it.

**[27:41]:** Uh, the fact is the fact is that maybe uh certain people uh will will be deemed to be less desirable uh genetically. Well, the fact is we've been doing that for the last million years. If you if you're attracted to someone uh and you end up marrying them, then they have phenotypes which you think are in one way or another valuable consciously or unconsciously, you are practicing a form of eugenics. But obviously there could be a much more subtle form of eugenics where part of the marriage contract states that you want to see you want a sample of that person's buckle swab or some lymphosytes to check out what kind of um DNA he or she has. Now you say well that can never happen but it happens today regularly. uh there are um there are villages in Greece where there's a significant uh substantial percentage of people who have who carry the trait cickle cell anemia which as you may know is not so serious phenotypically in the hetererozygous

**[28:42]:** form but in the homozygous form is actually devastating and the reason they have cickle cell anemia is that those areas of Greece historically had high rates of malaria and as you may know cickle cell anemia actually protects uh in in the hetererozygous state actually protects one from the ravages of the malarial parasite. So about 20 years ago it became possible to do a simple genetic test to determine whether an individual was hetererozygous for cickle cell anemia and uh what happened is that somehow what were supposed to be confidential medical genetic tests got out. they became public and individuals young individuals in the population became known as carriers as hetererozygots for cickle cell trade even though phenotypically they were reasonably normal because the hetererozygous condition is not so devastating. So those individuals were soon ostracized to use an old Greek word. They were soon put to the side.

**[29:38]:** They were placed in the pool of the un unmarageable uh because nobody wanted to marry them. And so they then as a consequence began to marry amongst themselves. Remember what I told you about homozygosis at the cickle cell trade. But that's only one uh example of that. Among Orthodox Jews there is among Ashkinazi Jews between 2 and 3% of the population carries an alil for tay-ax disease which is phenotypically silent in the hetererozygous state but in the homozygous state is a devastating uh condition which leads to death in the first years of life. So now among the Orthodox Jews in New York be before uh two young people will get married they will do a a test to see whether they're hetererozygous for the tex alil and in fact it's no it's not limited any longer to orthodox Jews because if they're both hetererozygots their marriage to one another in spite of anything else they considered is strongly discouraged among those who don't live in such a closely structured society such people might

**[30:42]:** nonetheless decide to get married and then face the devast devastating possibility of one of their four offspring on on average be coming out as a homozygote and having an incurable um genetic disease which is going to lead to their early death. But um what about other other uh uh uh traits and and and at what at what time will this gen will these um will this genetic um discrimination where will it begin and where will it end? What if you find an individual who has a trait of manic depressiveness among uh relatives? Um and when will these genetic tests become public? When will they be private knowledge? Uh you say, well, they can all be kept private. But ultimately, there are already insurance companies which are demanding to determine whether an individual can be insured by looking at whether they have genes for certain kinds of disease-causing alals.

**[31:38]:** Uh after all, why should they uh insure somebody, give somebody life insurance if they are likely to come down with Huntington's at the disease at the age of uh between 35 and 40, which will surely and in inevitably lead them to an early grave. You'll say, well, we can't have genetic information like that become public or even become accessible. Maybe that's a solution. The problem is we've been talking about these pro these issues for 10 to 15 years in this society and we've not yet converged on any kind of solution and the solutions to these problems should not be left in the hands of molecular biologists because molecular biologists or biologically cognizant people by now like you are no more gifted and no more insightful to deal with these issues than anyone else is. They're intuitively obvious these issues. You don't need to know about um about snips to begin to understand the devastating potentially devastating impacts that the misuse of genetics can have on our society.

**[32:38]:** And what happens if one of these days people discover alals for certain aspects of cognitive function? chess playing ability, the ability to learn five different languages, the ability to remember strings of numbers, the ability to uh speak extemporaneously in front of a class for for what it's worth for 50 minutes several times a week. Um, whatever ability you want, valued or not so valued. What uh what if those alals begin uh to to come out? And here's the here's the worst part. What if somebody begins to look for those the frequency of those alals in different ethnic groups scattered across this planet? Now you will say to me, well, God has made all all his children equal. But the fact is, if you look at the details of human evolution, some of which I discussed with you uh a week ago, last week, um you'll come to realize that most populations in humanity are the modern descendants

**[33:41]:** of very small founder groups. remember about the the source of the fins. 70% of Finnish men carry the same Y chromosome. All modern fins, all modern most modern fins are uh all of them are likely to be the descendants of a small founder group that came into Finland uh two or three thousand years ago and and carry with them the peculiar set of polymorphisms that that founder group happens to have had. and arguments like that begin to persuade you that there'll be different alil frequencies in different populations of humanity. What if somebody begins to discover that Macedonians have um an enormously high rate of uh the ability to play chess because of a certain alil and here I'm talking very speculatively. I'm not literally meaning that. And and Tibetans have a very poor ability to construct software programs because of a genetic alil they carry.

**[34:36]:** I hope nobody's Tibetan here. I tried to choose two. Are there any Macedonians? All right, I succeeded. All right. Anyhow, so um the fact is the fact is it's inescapable that different alals are going to be present with different frequencies in different and uh inbreeding populations of humanity or populations of humanity that traditionally have been genetically isolated from one another. It's not as if all the genes that we carry have been mixed with everybody else's genes um freely over the last 100,000 years. Different groups have bred separately and have for reasons that I told you founder effects and genetic drift um acquired different sets of uh and different constellations of alals. So what's going to happen then? I asked you without wishing to hear an answer because nobody really knows. Then for the first time there could be a racism which is based not on some kind of virulent ideology not based on uh some kind of kooky versions of genetics because the eugenicists in the beginning of the 20th

**[35:43]:** century as well as the Nazis hadn't any idea about genetics. They were just using the word even though they knew nothing about the science of genetics as we understand it today. But what happens if now for the first time we i.e. You who begin to understand genetics begin to perceive that there are in fact uh different populations of humanity that are endowed with different constellation of alals that we imagine are more or less desirable. What's going to happen then? I don't know. But uh some people some scientists say well the truth must come out and that everything that can be learned should be learned and we will learn how to digest it and we will learn how to live with that. But I'm not so sure that's the right thing. And you you all have to wrestle with that as well. Uh and even even more insidious is the following uh notion.

**[36:36]:** Remember the story about the two gyms, the uh the two guys from Ohio who met one another u at the age of 39 after they'd been separated at 5 weeks of birth. That story begins to persuade you of something I said before, and that is that a lot of what you think you are isn't what you made of yourself, isn't what your parents made of yourself, isn't what your environment made of you and your experiences. Maybe it's all just in your genes. And if that's so, then maybe you can't take credit for any of the good things you've done. And conversely, maybe you're not responsible for all the bad things you've done. Maybe uh three years from now, somebody will begin to plead um that uh even though they were not criminally insane when they committed a a a string of serial murders, in fact, it wasn't really their fault because they

**[37:26]:** happen to have this particular genotype which is known to be correlated with a strong tendency to violence. And by the way, there is an alil which has a correlation, I forget which one it is, has a correlation with violent behavior. So what if one begins to write off everything that we do as not a reflection of our own free will, our own volition, but instead a consequence of the genes which our parents foisted on us. Of course, we can blame it on them. As a father of children, I can tell you that it's amazing how many different things can be blamed on the parents. Of course, the parents have their own out. The parents can blame it on their parents. So now it goes back to the grandparents back to the beginning of time. We laugh about these things uh and they are amusing but they are taking us on a collision course with some very difficult problems and you guys have to wrestle with them.

**[38:23]:** Uh and you guys have to explain to the people who haven't taken 7012 where the world of biology is taking us. And on that note, I want to tell you that Eric and I have enormously enjoyed being with you this semester. We wish you much luck and success your future lives. We hope some of you have become interested in biology and that you found this course a little different from what you took in um in uh high school. And have a wonderful winter vacation. See you.
