# Lec 11 | MIT 18.01 Single Variable Calculus, Fall 2007

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twzGBqPeW0M
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/twzGBqPeW0M

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 2:08 — Chapter 2 (2:08)
- 4:30 — Chapter 3 (4:30)
- 11:00 — Chapter 4 (11:00)
- 16:18 — Chapter 5 (16:18)
- 19:03 — Chapter 6 (19:03)
- 20:17 — Chapter 7 (20:17)
- 21:59 — Chapter 8 (21:59)
- 22:16 — Chapter 9 (22:16)
- 24:23 — Chapter 10 (24:23)
- 29:50 — Chapter 11 (29:50)
- 32:26 — Chapter 12 (32:26)
- 34:59 — Chapter 13 (34:59)
- 37:21 — Chapter 14 (37:21)
- 42:25 — Chapter 15 (42:25)
- 44:48 — Chapter 16 (44:48)
- 45:38 — Chapter 17 (45:38)
- 47:31 — Chapter 18 (47:31)
- 47:59 — Chapter 19 (47:59)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Common License. Your support will help MIT Open Courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT Open Courseware at ocw.mmit.edu.

**[0:22]:** Okay, we're ready to start the 11th lecture. We're still in the middle of of sketching and indeed one of the reasons why we did not talk about hyperbolic functions is that uh we're running just a little bit behind and we'll catch up a tiny bit today and then I hope all the way on uh Tuesday of next week. So let me pick up where we left off with sketching.

**[0:58]:** So this is a

**[1:03]:** continuation. All right. I want to give you one more example of how to sketch things and then we'll go through systematically. So the second example we did it one example last time is this. The function is x+1 over x +2. And I'm going to save you the time right now. This is very typical of me if especially if you're in a hurry on an exam. I'll just tell you what the derivative is. So in this case, it's 1 /x + 2 the quantity squared. Now the reason why I'm uh bringing this up this example up even though it'll turn out to be a relatively simple one to sketch is that uh it's easy to fall into a black hole uh with this problem. Okay, so let me just show you this is not equal to zero. Okay, it's never equal to zero. So that means there are no critical points.

**[2:08]:** Okay, at this point um students, many students who have been trained like monkeys to do exactly what they've been told suddenly freeze and give up because there's nothing to do. So this is the one thing that I have to train out of you. You can't just give up at this point. So what would you suggest? Okay. Can anybody get us out of this jam? Yeah.

**[2:47]:** Right. So the the the suggestion was to find the x values where uh f ofx is undefined. In fact, so now that's a a a fairly sophisticated way of putting the point that I want to want to make, which is that what we want to do is go back to our pre-calculus skills and just plot points. Okay? So instead, you go back to pre-calculus and you plot some points. That's a perfectly reasonable thing. Now, it turns out that the most important point to plot is the one that's not there. Namely, the value at x= -2, which is just what was suggested. Namely, we plot the points where the function is not defined. Okay, so how do we do that? Well, you have to think about it for a second, and I'll I'll introduce some new notation when I do it. If I evaluate two at this place, actually I can't do it.

**[3:49]:** I have to do it from the left and the right. So if I plug in minus2 on the positive side from the right, that's going to be equal to -2 + 1 / -2 a little bit more than -2 + 2, which is -1 / Now this denominator is -2 a little more than that plus two. So it's a little more than zero. All right. And that is well, we'll go we'll fill that in in a second. Everybody's puzzle. Yes.

**[4:30]:** No, that's the function. I'm plotting points. I'm not differentiating. I already differentiated. Okay. I already got something that was a little puzzling. Now I'm focusing on the weird spot. Yeah. Another question. Wouldn't it be a little less than zero? Wouldn't it be a little less than zero? Okay, so that's that's a very good point. And this is a matter of notation here and a matter of parentheses. So wouldn't this be a little less than two? Well, if it were if the parentheses were this way, that is 2 plus with a minus after I did the two plus, then it would be less. But it's it's this way. Okay. So the notation is you have a number and you take the plus part of it. That's that's the part which is a little bit bigger than all right and so this is what I mean. All right.

**[5:26]:** And if you like here I can put in those parentheses too. Yeah. Another question.

**[5:34]:** Why doesn't the top one have a plus? the the only reason why the top one doesn't have a plus is that I don't need it to evaluate this. It's going to and when I take the limit, I can just plug in the value. Whereas here, I'm still uncertain because it's going to be zero and I want to know which side of zero it's on, whether it's on the positive side or the negative side. All right, so this one it could I could have written here a parentheses 2 plus, but then it would have just simplified to negative one in the limit. All right. So now I've got a negative number divided by a tiny positive number. And so somebody want to tell me what that is? Negative infinity. Okay. So we've just evaluated this function from one side. And if you follow through the other side, so this one here, you get something very similar except that this should be Whoops.

**[6:32]:** What did I do wrong? I didn't want to I Yes, I mean I meant this. Okay, I want it minus two. The same base point, but I want to go from the left. All right, so that's going to be -2 + 1 same numerator and then this -2 on the left plus two and that's going to come out to be 1 / 0 minus which is plus infinity. All right. Or just plain infinity. You don't have to put the plus sign in. Okay.

**[7:09]:** Now, so this is the first part of the problem and the the second piece to get us ourselves started. You could evaluate this function at any point. This is just the most interesting point. All right. This is just the most interesting place to evaluate it. Now, the next thing that I'd like to do is to to pay attention to the ends.

**[7:32]:** And I haven't really said what the ends are. So the ends are just all the way to the left and all the way to the right. So that means x going to plus or minus infinity. All right. So that's the second thing I want to pay attention to. Again, this is a little bit like a video screen here. And we're about to discover something that's really off the screen in both cases. All right. We're taking care of what's happening way to the left, way to the right here. And up above, we just took care of what happens way up and way down. All right. So on these ends, I need to do some more uh uh analysis which is related to uh pre-calculus skill which is evaluating limits. And here the way to do it is to divide by x in numerator and denominator. Right?

**[8:23]:** is a 1 plus 1 /x 1 + 2 overx and then you can see what happens as x goes to plus or minus infinity it just goes to one right so no matter whether it's uh x is positive or negative when it gets huge these two extra numbers here go to zero and so this tends to one so if you like you could abbreviate this as f plus or minus infinity is equal to one all right So now I get to draw this and we draw this using asmmptotes. So there's a level which is y = 1 and then there's another uh line to draw which is um which is uh x = -2. All right. And now what information do I have so far? Well, the information that I have so far is that when we're coming in from the right, that's this uh uh to -2, it goes plunges down to minus infinity.

**[9:28]:** So that's down like this. Okay. And I also know that it goes up to infinity on the other side of the asmtote. And over here I know it's going out to um to the level one. And here it's also going to the level one. Okay. Now the there's an issue. I can almost finish this graph now. I almost have enough information to finish it. But there's one thing which is making me hesitate a little bit. um and that is I don't know for instance over here whether it's going to maybe dip below and come back up or not. So what does it do here? Can anybody see?

**[10:25]:** Yeah.

**[10:29]:** It can't dip below because there are no critical points. What a precise and correct answer. So that's exactly right. The point here is that because fprime is not zero. It can't double back on itself because there can't be any of these horizontal tangents. All right? It can't double back. So it can't can't backtrack.

**[11:00]:** So sorry if fprime is not zero f can't backtrack. All right. And so that means that it doesn't look like this. It just goes like this. All right. So that's basically it. That's practically the end of the problem. It goes like this. All right. Now you can decorate your your thing, right? You may notice that it maybe it crosses here the axis. You can actually evaluate these places and so forth. We're looking right now for qualitative behavior. In fact, you can see where these places hit. And it's actually a little higher up than I drew. Maybe I'll draw it accurately so that you can see it as we'll see in a second. All right. Anyway, so that's that's what happens to this function. Now, let's just take a look in a a little bit more detail by double checking.

**[11:56]:** So we're just going to double check what happens to the sign of the derivative. And in the meantime, I'm going to explain to you what the derivative is and also talk about the second derivative. So first of all, the trick for evaluating the derivative is an algebraic one. I mean obviously you can do this by the quotient rule, but I just point out that this is the same thing as this. All right. And now it has a whoops that should be a two in the denominator. And so now this has the form 1 - 1 over x + 2. So this makes it uh easy to see what the derivative is because the derivative of a constant is zero. Right? So this is derivative is just going to be uh switch the sign. This is what I wrote before. All right. And that uh explains it.

**[12:55]:** But incidentally, it also shows you that that this is a um this is a um a hyperola, right? These are just two curves of a hyperola. Okay. So now let's check the sign. It's already totally obvious to us that this is just a double check. We didn't actually even have to pay any attention to this. It had better be true. This is just going to check our arithmetic. namely it's increasing here. It's increasing there. That's got to be true. And sure enough, this is positive. As you can see, it's one over a square. So, it is increasing. So, we checked it. But now, there's there's one more thing that I want to just have you watch out about. So this means that f is increasing on the interval minus infinity x to minus2 and also from minus2 all the way out to infinity. So I just want to warn you, you cannot say don't say f is increasing on minus infinity infinity or all x.

**[14:12]:** Okay, this is just not true. All right, I've written it on the board, but it's wrong. I better get rid of it. There it is. Get rid of it. Okay. And the reason is so first of all it's totally obvious it's going up here but then it went zooming back down there and here this was true but only if x is not -2. So there's a break and you've got to pay attention to the break. So basically the the

**[14:45]:** the moral here is that if you ignore this place, it's like ignoring Mount Everest or the Grand Canyon. You're ignoring the most important feature of this function here. If you're going to be figuring out where things are going up and down, which is basically all we're doing, you'd better pay attention to these kinds of places, right? So don't don't ignore them. All right. So that's the first uh remark and now there's just a little bit of decoration as well which is uh the role of the second derivative. So we've written down the first derivative here. The second derivative is now -2 over x + 2 cubed. Right? So, so right I get that from differentiating this formula up here for the for the first derivative. And now uh of course that's also only works for x not equal to -2. And now we can see that this is going to be uh negative let's see where is it negative when this is a positive quantity.

**[15:58]:** So when um -2 is less than x is less than infinity it's negative and this is where this thing is concave let's see did I say that right negative right this is concave

**[16:18]:** down all right and similarly if I look at this expression the numerator is always negative but the denominator becomes uh negative as as well when x is less than -2. So this becomes positive right. So in this case it was negative over positive. In this case it was negative / negative. So here this is in the range minus infinity less than x less than two. And here it's concave

**[16:51]:** up. All right. Now again this is just consistent with what we already guess. And of course, we already know it in this case if we know that this is a hyperola that it's going to be concave down to the right of the vertical line, dotted vertical line, and concave up to the left. So, what extra piece of information is it that this is giving us? Did I say this backwards? No, I don't say backwards. Okay. So, what extra piece information is this giving us? It looks like it's giving us hardly anything. And it really is giving us hardly anything, but it is giving us something that's a little aesthetic. It's ruling out the possibility of a wiggle. Okay, there isn't anything like that in the curve. Okay, it can't shift from curving this way to curving that way to curving this way. All right, that doesn't happen.

**[17:43]:** So, so this is the these properties say there's no

**[17:50]:** wiggle in the graph of f. Okay. All right. So question

**[18:06]:** do we define increasing and decreasing based purely on the derivative or the more or the sort of more general definition of picking any two points and seeing because sometimes there can be inconsistencies between the two. Okay. Um so the question is uh in this course are we going to define positive derivative as being the same thing as increasing and the answer is no. We'll try to use these terms separately. What's always true is that if fprime is positive then f is increasing but the reverse is not necessarily true. It could be very flat the derivative can be zero and it still the function can be increasing. Okay. The derivative can be zero at a few places. Yeah. For instance, like a cubic, some cubics. All right. Uh, other

**[19:03]:** questions. All right. So, so that's as much as I need to say in general. I mean, in a specific case, but I I want to get you a general scheme and then I want to go through a more complicated example that gets all the features. of this uh kind of thing. So, so let's talk about a general strategy for

**[19:33]:** sketching. So, the first part of the strategy, if you like, uh let's see, I have it all plotted out here, so I'm going to make sure I get it exactly the way I wanted you to say it. Oh, okay. So I have it's plotting the plot thickens. Here we go. All right. So plot. What is it that you should plot first before you even think about uh derivatives? You should plot

**[20:07]:** discontinuities

**[20:11]:** especially the infinite ones.

**[20:17]:** All right, that's the first thing you should do. And then you should plot end points or ends or x going to plus or minus infinity if if there don't happen to be any any finite ends to the problem. And the third thing you can do is plot any any easy points. Uh this is this is optional and at your discretion. You might for instance on this example plot the places where the graph crosses the axis. All right if you want to. All right. So that's the first part and again this is all pre-calculus. So now in the second part, we're going to

**[21:15]:** solve this equation and we're going to plot the critical points and values. All right. In in the problem which we just discussed, there weren't any. So this part was empty.

**[21:38]:** All right. So the third step is to decide whether fprime sorry whether fprime is positive or negative on each

**[21:59]:** interval. Uh between

**[22:07]:** critical

**[22:11]:** points,

**[22:16]:** discontinuities. The direction of of the sign in this case, it doesn't change. It goes up here and it's also goes up here, but it could go up here and then come back down. So the the direction can change at every critical point. You can change at every discontinuity and you don't know. However, this particular step has to be consistent with one and two with steps one and two. In fact, it will never if you can succeed in doing steps one and two, you'll never need step three. All it's doing is double-checking.

**[23:01]:** Okay, so if you made an arithmetic mistake somewhere, you'll be able to see it. So that's maybe the most important thing and it's actually the most frustrating thing for me when I see people working on problems is they start with step three, they get it wrong and then they start trying to draw the graph and it doesn't work because it's inconsistent. And the reason is some arithmetic error with the derivative or something like that or some other misinterpretation. And then there's there's a total mess. If you start with these two steps, then you're going to know when you get to this step that you're making mistakes. People don't generally make as many mistakes with the first two steps. All right. Anyway, in fact, you can skip this step if you want, but that's at risk of not check double-checking your work. All right. So, what's the fourth step?

**[23:51]:** Well, we we take a look at whether uh fp prime is positive or negative. And so we're deciding on things like whether it's concave up or

**[24:06]:** down. And uh we have these points fprime uh of x is equal to zero which are called inflection points.

**[24:23]:** All right. And the last step is just to combine everything. All right. So this is this is the uh scheme the general scheme and let's just carry it out in in uh a particular case. Okay.

**[24:58]:** So here's the function that I'm going to use as an example. I'll use f ofx is x over log x and because the logarithm Yeah. Question. Yeah. Sorry. or uh the question is is this optional? So uh that's a good question. The is this optional?

**[25:31]:** Okay, so the question is is this optional? this this kind of question. The answer is uh it's it's more than just so so in many instances I'm going to ask you to do this. I'm going to ask you to find these things. In many instances I'm not going to ask you to. I strongly recommend that if I don't ask you to do it that you not try because it's usually awful to find the second derivative. Anytime you can get away without computing a second derivative, you're better off. So in many many instances, on the other hand, if I ask you to do it, it's because I want you to have the the the work to do it. But but basically, if nobody forces you to, I would say never do step four here. All right. Yeah. Other

**[26:25]:** questions? All right. So we're going to force ourselves to do step four. However, in this in this instance, but maybe this will be one of the few times. All right. So, here we go just for illustrative purposes. Okay. Now, so here's the the the function that I want to discuss and the range has to be x positive because the logarithm is not defined for negative values.

**[26:55]:** So the first thing that I'm going to do is I I'd like to follow the uh the scheme here because if I don't follow the scheme I'm going to get a little mixed up. So the first part is to uh find the singularities that is the places where f is infinite and that's when the logarithm the denominator vanishes. So that's f of 1 plus if you like. So that's 1 / log of 1 plus which is 1 / 0 with a little bit of positiveness to it which is infinity. And second we do it the other way and not surprisingly this comes out to be negative infinity. All right. Now the next thing I want to do is the ends. So I called these the ends and uh there are two of them. One of them is f of 0 from the right f of 0 plus.

**[28:08]:** So that is 0 plus / log 0 plus which is 0 plus / well log of 0 plus is actually minus infinity. That's what happens to the logarithm. It goes to minus infinity. So this is 0 over infinity which is definitely zero. There's no problem about what happens to this the other side. So this is the end. This is the first end, right? The range is this. And I just did the left end point. And so now I have to do the right end point. I have to let x go to infinity. So if I let x go to infinity, I'm just going to have to think about it a little bit by plugging in a very large number. I'll plug in 10 the 10th here just to see what happens. So if I plug in 10 the 10th into x log x I get 10 the 10th divided by the natural log of 10th which is 10th * 10 * log 10.

**[29:17]:** So the denominator this number here is about 2 something. All right 2.3 or so. So this is maybe 230 in the denominator and this is a number with 10 zeros after it. So it's very very large. I claim it's it's big. And that gives us the clue that what's happening is that this thing is infinite. So in other words, our conclusion is that f of infinity is

**[29:50]:** infinity. Okay. So what do we have so far?

**[29:57]:** for our function. We're just trying to build the scaffolding of the function and we're doing it by taking the most important points and from a mathematician's point of view, the most important points are the ones which are sort of infinitely obvious or the or the ends of the problem. So that's that's where we're heading here. We have a vertical asmtote which is at xals 1. right here. So this is x= 1 and we have a value which is that it's zero here. And we also know that when we come in from the uh sorry so we come in from the left that's f of one from the left we get negative infinity. So it's diving down it's going down like this. All right. And furthermore, on the other side, we know it's it's it's climbing up. So, it's going up like this. Maybe I'll just start it a little higher than that.

**[31:00]:** Right? So, so far, this is what we know. Oh, and there's one other thing that we know. Uh, when we go to plus infinity, it's going back up. All right. So, so far we have this. Now, already it should be pretty obvious what's going to happen to this function. So, there shouldn't be many surprises. It's going to come down like this. It's going to go like this. It's going to turn around and it's go back up. All right, that's that's what we expect. So, we don't know that yet, but we're pretty sure. All right, so at this point, we can start looking at the critical points. We can do our step two here. I'll leave a little bit more room here and see uh what's happening with this function. So I have to differentiate it and it's uh this is the quotient rule. So remember the function is up here x / log x.

**[31:55]:** So I have a log x^ 2 in the denominator and I get here the derivative of x is 1. So I get 1 * log x minus x * the derivative of log x which is 1 /x. So all told that's log x - 1 / log x^ 2. Right? So here's our our

**[32:26]:** derivative. And now if I set this equal to zero at least the numerator the numerator is zero when um x is equal to e the log of e is one. Okay, so here's our critical point and we have a critical value which is f of e and that's going to be uh e / log e which is e again because log e is one. So now I can also plot the critical point which is down here and there's only one of them and it's at e right that's kind of not to scale here because my blackboard isn't quite tall enough. It should be over here and then at slope one, but I dipped it down. All right. So, this is not to scale. And indeed, that's one of the things that we're not going to attempt to do with these pictures is to make them to scale.

**[33:24]:** The scale is a little squashed. All right. So, so far I have this critical point. And in fact, I'm going to label it with a C. Whenever I have a critical point, I'll just make sure that I remember that that's what it is. And since there's only one, the rest of this picture is now correct. That's the same mechanism that we used for the hyperola. Namely, we know there's only one place where the derivative is zero. So that means there are no more horizontals. So there's no more backtracking. It has to come down to here, get to there, and this is the only place it can turn around. Goes back up. It has to start here, and it has to go down to there. It can't go above zero. It's do not pass go. Do not get positive. It has to head down here. All

**[34:19]:** right. So that's that's great. That means that this picture is almost completely correct now and the rest is more or less decoration. We're we're pretty much done with the way it looks at least schematically. Okay. However, I am going to punish you as as I warned you. you know, we are going to go over here and do the step four and and and fix up the concavity. All right. And we're also going to do a little bit of that double

**[34:59]:** checking. Okay. So now uh let let's again just I want to emphasize we're going to do a double check this is part three but in advance I already have based on this picture I already know what has to be true that f is

**[35:23]:** decreasing on 0 to one f is also also decreasing on one to e and f is

**[35:40]:** increasing on e to infinity. All right, so already because we plotted a bunch of points and we know that there aren't any places where the derivative vanishes, we already know it goes down, down, up. That's what it's got to do. Now, we'll just make sure that we didn't make any arithmetic mistakes now by actually computing the derivative or staring at it anyway and making sure that uh it's it's correct. Okay, so first of all, we just take a look um the numerator. So f prime remember was log x -1 / log x^2 the quantity squared. So the denominator is positive. So let's just take a look uh at the at the three ranges. So we have 0 less than x less than one and on that range the logarithm is negative. So this is negative / positive which is negative. That's decreasing. That's good. And in fact that also works on the next range one less than x less than e.

**[36:52]:** It's negative / positive. And the only reason why we skipped one again is that it's undefined there. There's something dramatic happening there. And then at the last range when x is bigger than e, that means the logarithm is already bigger than one. So the numerator is now positive and the denominator is still positive. So it's increasing. So we've just double checked something that we already

**[37:21]:** knew. All right. So that's that's pretty much all there is to say about step three. So this is checking the uh positivity and negativity. And now step four there there is one small point which I want to make before we go on which is that sometimes you can't evaluate the function or its derivative particularly well. So sometimes you can't plot the points very well and if you can't plot the points very well then you might have to do three first to figure out what's going on a little bit. All right, you might have to skip. All right, so now we're going to go on to the second derivative. But first I want to use an algebraic trick to rearrange the terms. And I want to notice one more little point which I uh as I say this is decoration for the graph. So I want to rewrite the formula maybe I'll do it right over here.

**[38:22]:** Another way of writing this is 1 / log x - 1 log x^ squ. All right. So that's the another way of writing the derivative and that allows me to notice something that I missed before when I solved the equation log x -1 uh this is equal to zero here this equation here I missed a possibility I missed the possibility that the denominator could be infinity.

**[38:58]:** All right. So actually if the denominator is infinity as you can see from the other from the other expression there it actually is true that the uh derivative is zero. So also when x is equal to 0 plus the slope is going to be zero. Let me just emphasize that again. If you evaluate using this other formula over here, this is this is 1 / log 0 + minus 1 / log 0 + 2. That's 1 over minus infinity minus 1 over infinity if you like squared. Anyway, it's zero, right? So this is zero. The slope is zero there. That is a little piece of decoration on our graph. It's telling us here's a going back to our graph here. It's telling us that this is coming in with slope horizontal. So we starting out this way, right? That's just a little little start there to the to the graph.

**[40:01]:** It's horizontal slope. So there really were two places where the slope was horizontal. Now with the help of this second formula, I can also uh uh differentiate a second time. So it's a little bit easier to do that. If I differentiate 1 over the log, that's - log x^ -2 * 1 /x + 2 log x^ - 3 1/x. All right. And that if I put it over a common denominator is x log x cubed times uh let's see here I guess I'll take the 2 - log x. Okay. So I've now rewritten the formula for the second derivative as a ratio. Now to decide the sign, you see there are two places where the sign flips. Uh the numerator crosses when the logarithm is two. That's going to be when x is e^ squared. And the denominator flips when uh x is equal to 1.

**[41:22]:** That's when this uh the log flips from positive to negative. Okay. So we have a couple of ranges here. So first of all we have the range from zero to one and then we have the range from one to e squared and then we have the range from e^2 all the way out to infinity. So between 0 and 1 the numerator is well this is a negative number and this so minus a negative number is positive. So the numerator is positive and the denominator is negative because the log is negative and it's taken to the third power. So it's this is a negative number. So it's positive divided by negative which is less than zero. That means it's concave down. All right. So this is a concave down

**[42:25]:** part. And that's a good thing because over here this was concave down. So there are no wiggles. It goes straight down like this. And then the other two pieces are fp prime is equal to well it's going to switch here. The denominator becomes positive. So it's positive over positive. So this is concave

**[42:55]:** up and that's going over here. But notice that it's not the bottom where it turns around. It's somewhere else. All right. So there's another transition here. This is E squared. This is E. So what happens at the end is again the sign flips again because the numerator now when x is bigger than e^2 becomes negative and this is negative / positive which is negative and this part is concave

**[43:34]:** down and so we didn't quite draw the graph right. There's an inflection point right here which I'll label with an i. And it makes a turn the other way at that point. All right, so there was a wiggle. There's the wiggle. Still going up, still going to infinity, but kind of the slope of a mountain. All right, it's going the other way. All right, this point happens to be E^2 E^2 over

**[44:08]:** two. Okay, so that's as detailed as we'll ever get. And indeed uh the next game is going to be avoid being is to avoid being this detailed. So let me introduce the next sub subject which is um maxima and minima.

**[44:48]:** Okay. Now, maxima and

**[45:00]:** minima maximum and minimum problems can be described graphically in the following way. Suppose you have a function

**[45:11]:** All right, here it is. Okay, now find the maximum. All right.

**[45:23]:** Aha. And find the

**[45:29]:** minimum. Okay. So, this problem is done.

**[45:38]:** Okay, the point being that it is easy to find max and the min with the sketch. Okay, it's very easy. The goal, the problem is that the sketch is a lot of work. we just spent uh you know 20 minutes sketching something. We would not like to spend all that time every single time we want to find a maximum minimum. So the goal is to do it with So our goal is to use

**[46:24]:** shortcuts and indeed as I said earlier we certainly never want to use a second derivative if we can avoid it and we don't want to decorate the graph and do all of these elaborate subtle things which make the graph look nicer and really are aesthetically appropriate but are totally unnecessary. to see whether the graph is up or down. All right. So, let me just so so essentially this whole business is out which is a good thing. All right. And unfortunately the those early parts are the parts that people tend to ignore and which are typically are often very important. So let me

**[47:15]:** just first tell you the main point here. So the key

**[47:31]:** idea key to finding a

**[47:38]:** maximum. So the key point is we only need to look

**[47:49]:** at at critical

**[47:59]:** points. Well, that's actually what it seems like to uh in in many calculus classes, but that's not true. This is not the end of the sentence.

**[48:14]:** and end points and points of

**[48:33]:** discontinuity. All right? So you must watch out for those. If you look at the example that I just drew here, which is the the one that I carried out, you can see that there are actually five extreme points on this picture. So, let's switch. We'll take a look. There are five places where the max or the min might be. There's this important point This is as I say the scaffolding of the function. There's this point. There's down at minus infinity. There's this. There's this. And there's this. Only one out of five is a critical point. So there's more that you have to pay attention to on the function. And you always have to keep the schema the the the picture of the function in the back of your head even though this may be the most interesting point and the one that you're going to be looking for.

**[49:36]:** So, we'll we'll do a few examples of that next time.
