Transcript
everybody knows that a Malaysian airliner disappeared Into Thin Air on the evening of March 8th 2014 with 239 people aboard and that to this day the mystery remains unsolved what a lot of people don't realize is that the plane didn't just vanish once it actually vanished four times in today's episode of Deep dive MH370 we're going to break down the first phase of the flight from the totally normal taxi and takeoff right up until that first Vanishing we're going to look at what happened and how those first few Clues can already help us start to narrow down what might be the reason for the plane's disappearance hi I'm Jeff wise welcome to episode two two of Deep dive MH370 the first Vanishing this is a remake of the original episode that I produced with Andy tarnoff back in September of 2023 we were just starting the original season of the podcast we were just learning the ropes so the original version of the episode was Audio Only I don't have access to that original YouTube page Andy has gone his separate way so I'm creating an updated and remastered version of each episode of The Original season every week week okay let's get right into it starting with a departure from koala lmour International Airport the flight was a run-of-the-mill Redeye flight from K lumpor Malaysia to Beijing China the plane was a 12year old Boeing trip 7 airplane with 239 people aboard 227 passengers and 12 crew the captain 53-year-old zahari Ahmed sha was one of the most experienced captains Malaysia Airlines had with more than 18,000 hours of flight time his first officer fari Abdul Hamid was just getting started in his career he had just 2700 flight hours the flight was scheduled to depart at 12:35 a.m.
local time and actually took off from the runway at 12:42 so pretty much exactly on time so far everything was boringly normal the plane took off to the Northwest then turned to the East and had been cleared to fly directly to igari a waypoint at the very edge of the koala Lumar Air Traffic Control Zone beyond that lay the hoi Min control Zone that was operated by Vietnam from there it would pass over Eastern China on its way to Beijing on this night the weather was good there was very little other traffic around it was ideal flying conditions really no red flags no reason to be concerned 20 minutes into the flight zahari made a call that has attracted a fair bit of discussion he called up ATC and he confirmed that they were flying at 35,000 feet this was a totally unnecessary call he did not need to make it and some especially a YouTuber called Mentor pilot have made a big deal out of it he's he spent a lot of his his u YouTube video on the subject speculating on why he might have made the call listening carefully to the intonation asking if it was if it was a little tense if he seemed a little harried um personally I don't think we can really draw any conclusion it's it's slightly abnormal but Pilots are not machines they they might make unnecessary calls sometimes they might use sort of non-standard wordings sometimes it might mean something it might not we just don't have any evidence one way or the other and so I find it really hard to make a big deal out of it because it doesn't point us in one direction or another it's curious but there's a lot of curious things about this case things that are way more Curious actually okay so at 1:19 a.m.
local time when the plane is about 100 kilometers beyond the coast of the Malle Peninsula that had been flying over until that time the captain has an exchange with air traffic control basically the air traffic controller gives him permission to leave the zone that he's currently in and contact the next air traffic controller which is as we've said in hoim and in response uh this has all been settled now the captain says good night Malaysia 370 this is the last transmission that the plane made you have no doubt heard it many times it is very standard in the context in which it occurred as a plane flies from here to there it's constantly leaving one area of jurisdiction and entering another and getting a handoff then it leaves that area to enter the next one after that it's constantly saying goodbye to one area and saying hello to the next only to repeat the process when it leaves that next area so this is a very mundane thing that happens constantly all the time very familiar routine and it's so routine that as I said sometimes Pilots use non-standard language uh they might say hey thanks or have a good night something like that just a human interchange the important thing is not to clutter up the frequency sometimes if it's very busy people have to get their information across in a very concise way and you really can't have people just using any which any phraseology that they want they have to keep it tight but but at times like this when it's the middle of the night you can sort of be a little more Loosey Goosey this isn't particularly Loosey Goosey but he says you know good night Malaysia 370 a minute later the plane reaches that navigational Waypoint and this is the point this is the Waypoint that we mentioned earlier agari it's it's marked on aeronautical charts with the code name i g a r i and let me just explain a little bit about what that is all around the world there are these navigational waypoints that are marked on charts they have five letters and they generally are pronounceable they're they might be nonsense they might um have some local relevance for instance if you're flying near Disneyland in Anaheim and California you might see uh waypoints with names like Disney DS NE or Mickey mckk ye and you know a little bit of fun a little bit of uh you know local flavor for the pilots little kind of bit of touch of humor as it were but but a lot of times they just I don't know if agari means something in one of the local languages of Southeast Asia but it doesn't matter for the purposes of navigation it's just an easyto pronounce designator that um the pilots are given instructions to fly to and this particular one is the last Waypoint in the Malaysian controlled airspace so this marks the point at which the flight is entering a kind of transitional space it has just said goodbye to qua Lort air traffic control and for the time being nobody is paying attention to it standard procedure is for the captain of the plane or the whoever is flying the plane to then they've got three minutes to kind of get their act together make sure they have the right frequency to dial into the radio to call up oim Min in this case and say we're with you at at this certain flight level um and this is our flight designator and they then the air traffic control at the other end will say okay great and they'll keep an eye on them until they have to hand them over to the next air traffic controller but that didn't happen instead six seconds after the plane has crossed over agari it vanishes from radar screens it's not there and when I say vanish from radar screens Let Me Explain real quickly what I mean by that there are different ways that a plane electronically keeps in touch with the world around it um it's very important that planes not collide with one another so especially over busy airports you really don't want people just flying any which way they're kept under TI tight control by air traffic control which tells them where to go and when and what angle to fly out and so forth and in this case the the air traffic controller has been watching MH370 on the radar screens and you might be familiar with something called primary radar back in World War II they invented this idea that if you shine uh radio waves out into the out into space out into the atmosphere and it encounters a metal airplane it will reflect it like a mirror and if you have a big enough antenna you can catch that signal coming back and you will know more or less how far away it is and what direction it is that is not what air traffic controllers primarily use though they use something called secondary radar and what happens is the radar sends out a signal when the plane detects that signal it sends its own signal so it's an active transmission of of electronic energy essentially and this this response contains data in it it it tells air traffic controllers the altitude that the plane is at and it tells them who it is this is something that the plane has to actively transmit so one of the things that happens when the plane passes igari is that that system is turned off so when the radar Tower in Malaysia sends that that broadcast out nothing comes back well the signal just that's just passively reflected off the the the skin of the aircraft that will get received but air traffic controllers don't really pay attention to that they pay attention to a symbol that is on their radar screen that is generated by the computer system that runs the system that they're looking at and that symbol that says MH370 has now vanished it's not on the screen anymore now normally if they were actively paying attention to the aircraft and under their control they would certainly notice that that is a big deal for this plane to suddenly not be there anymore but remember they've said good night they've said goodbye it's not their problem anymore conversely hoim Min which is waiting for them to show up they haven't been on their radar screens they they haven't been there and hoim doesn't really know where they are they've been told by K limor that they're inbound but they haven't shown up and and the and the aircraft hasn't called them yet either so as far as they know they have no idea where this plane is maybe it hasn't left yet maybe they had problems getting the food truck up to the up to the plane there's a million Reasons Why Planes can be delayed so kalal lur has put it out of their minds hoim men is just cooling their heels waiting for something to happen nobody is paying attention to this plane so it's not on their screens anymore it's not broadcasting any other kind of information either it's not broadcasting over the radio which is just like uh you know I think that's pretty intuitive what a radio is it's like you know you you click on your mic and you say hey anybody out there want to talk to me you know we just we just saw the the pilot say good night Malaysia 370 so that's a radio transmission but after he stops doing that you don't have to turn off the radio you just don't transmit and nothing nothing will come out of the plane another way that a plane generates electronic signals is called AC cars and this originally started out as a kind of text message system that was used by Airlines to schedule their flights and pilot Duty time and so forth and they later added other kinds of information that you can send um you know if your wife or husband wants to send you a message they can do that over AC cars if there's a mechanical problem the system might automatically generate a sort of a health checkup to transmit to the operations center at the Airlines Headquarters so there's various kinds of bits and Bobs of data that can go over this automated system that will happen whether or not the pilot knows about it or not the pilot can also do things actively but that system was turned off we know because several minutes before it had sent its last automatic transmission and and no Transmissions were received after that so there's another system called adsb and this is something that had only started to be rolled out fairly recently it's a much newer technology than the other ones that we've mentioned this is a system that is designed to increase safety by basically transmitting freely and voluntarily the information about where you are in the sky so that the other planes can avoid you and um this is also used by flight tracking software if you use something like flight radar that uses basically the plane sends out these radio signals they're picked up by ground stations all around the world you can have one yourself if you want people can just kind of voluntarily take part in this network and doesn't work over the open ocean and so once you leave the proximity to land it eventually Fades out but when the plane was at agari it was still close enough to land that it was sending detectable adsp signals however 6 seconds after gari that system gets turned off too so acars is not transmitting adsb is not transmitting and the the transponder that connects with secondary radar is also not transmitting so this plane is not there now no one was paying attention so nobody noticed that all these systems went dark but later when investigators tried to figure out wait what happened to this plane a lot of all this data was not there so they they were really left with a scarcity of of evidence as to what happened so but the crucial thing to understand here is that nobody on the ground knew that something had started to go wrong only much later when when people looked at the data that had been recorded automatically did they see oh this thing had started to happen six seconds after agari but that only that was only discovered much later so what I've described is in some ways a little bit reminiscent of another incident that had happened just a few years before I'm talking about Air France 447 this was a flight that took off from Rio de Janeiro on June 30th of 2009 and it flew over the Atlantic Ocean and it was due to arrive in Paris the next day and it didn't and something very similar happened with MH370 where it took off in the middle of the night was supposed to arrive in a different city and it didn't and as time went by in the case of of both of these planes people gradually started to get more and more anxious about where is this plane in the case of airr 447 it too had left one area of air traffic control and was and there was a gap before it could talk to the next in the CA in that case because it was over over the middle of a large ocean there was several hours that were going to elapse before the next air traffic controller expected to hear from them so there was a much longer period of time in which something had gone wrong but nobody on the ground knew that something had gone wrong because there was no way for them to know it later signals from the acar system that had been recorded automatically were taken out of storage looked at and then people started to figure out that something had gone wrong but there were no alarms that went off there was no signal that woke somebody up and said hey look it something's gone wrong but this is a parallel it's not like this had never happened before where a plane in between air traffic control zones had just vanished in the case of Air France 447 something had gone wrong it's a very elaborate story but it had to do with both some system failures and some human errors which combined to have the plane hit the ocean and and everyone aboard died very soon after problems started to arise so when people on the ground on March 8th started to wonder why they hadn't heard from MH370 they obviously were going to get very worried increasingly worried as the minutes ticked by but the time the plane was supposed to land in Beijing it hadn't been seen anywhere calls were going back and forth between the various Air Traffic Control authorities everyone was was wondering maybe they you had an emergency and had to land somewhere else maybe they landed in Cambodia um maybe they had to divert somewhere else what could have happened but the longer a plane goes without being in contact the more worried people are going to get and the more and more it seems like this is a very bad situation and of course people are going to think about recent incidents that were similar they're going to think about air 447 and it's kind of a historical fact that when planes disappear it has it's usually an accident and and the accident in the case of a commercial airliner like this it's fatal and so as Dawn breaks on the morning of March 8th moods are very grim and the authorities start to send out search planes um and to try to see if they can find any trace of this plane maybe wreckage maybe maybe there were some rafts with people on them conceivably it could have landed I mean there there was a 737 flight a few years ago where they got um they had power failure in their engines during a storm and they wound up landing on a levy earn embankment so it is possible for planes that have mechanical problems even severe mechanical problems to land and for everyone to survive we remember the Sully Miracle on the Hudson case everyone survived it wasn't that it was hopeless but the presumption as these hours are starting to take by the presumption is that something very bad had happened the plane has probably crashed near its final transmission the reason why the transmission stopped was that the plane crashed that is your s of default scenario in a situation like this I remember when it happened I'd been writing about air crashes for a decade already I had had my Pilots license for a while I was a freelance journalist I remember thinking at the time when the news first broke that this plane hadn't arrived at its destination that it didn't seem particularly unusual but right off the bat there was that strange detail it was an uncanny piece of timing and this detail would come to seem more and more important as the days went on and we learned more jaw-dropping details about what had happened on that flight so we're GNA leave the tale here for now it's the end of day one the authorities are trying to figure out what happened to this plane that had disappeared off radar screens they have sent out search and rescue planes nothing has been seen but that is not so surprising when planes go missing it it takes a little while to find the debris can take a couple days but based on past experience like air friend 447 people thought the plane had come to some kind of grief near agari and most likely to crash in the ocean they're looking for pieces of debris floating on the surface if they can spot that um it's going to be pretty easy to find the rest of the wreckage at this point the case seems not that unusual potentially very tragic but not that unusual and fairly easy to solve of course none of that happened I'll leave you with that Cliffhanger for now join me next week for episode three of Deep dive m370 as the case continues uh its descent into the strange SL borderline impossible um as rumors spread it turns out that MH370 didn't crash into the South China Sea after all so I'll leave you with that um if you like the show Please Subscribe and I am very grateful for you're spending the time with me today I'll leave you with my words of wisdom which are don't stop looking and don't stop asking hard questions so long for now byebye