Transcript

Good morning. Morning. Yeah. All right. Good. Something to counteract the rainy days we have here. Um All right. Today we're going to make a very important transition. The transition goes back to this picture. Of course, what we want to do is understand biological function by taking our two favorite approaches. Understanding the organism minus an individual gene. Understanding an individual an organism minus an individual component and understanding the individual components minus the organism. Genetics and biochemistry. And as we know the geneticists went off on their route, finding mutants, doing mutant hunts, making crosses, making genetic maps, etc.

Didn't understand really what these genes had to do with anything specific in the organism other than they produced phenotypes when they were mutated. and the biochemists went off purifying enzymes, working out biochemical pathways, etc., etc. We began to see some connection when we talked a bit about the mutants that affect the ability to make arginine and the fact that they could encode different enzyatic steps. And in particular, I highlighted the work of Archbald Garrett, who really right at the start of the century recognized that somehow genetic mutations were responsible for somehow affecting the production of enzymes in important biochemical pathways.

That was sort of one connection of genetics into protein, but still a rather tenuous one. The real next step to connect these two would be to do the biochemistry of genes. So how would a biochemist approach heredity? A biochemist would grind up the organism, fractionate it in different components and attempt to find heredity. Purify hered get get like a pure um solution of heredity. That's nuts, right? the notion that you could purify heredity as a biochemical entity because like how would you know you had it? But of course that's exactly what happened. That is what happened was biochemistry developed sufficiently far that folks were actually able to purify substances not just that could digest a particular sugar or substances that might you know like slide by each other like actin and meosin do muscles but substances that were actually heredity and that began the real unification of those and that's the point of today and that is the field of molecular biology and we're going to cover tremendous territory in unifying these two different fields.

Okay. So, let's dive right in. So, the discovery of the transforming principle. It's a wonderfully oldfashioned kind of word. Nobody would use language like this today. The discovery of the transforming principle. So this starts, this shaggy dog story starts in about 1928 with the work of Griffiths. Griffiths had no particular interest in DNA or genetics or anything or biochemistry for that matter. DNA was interested in bacteria. He wanted to understand bacteria. And in particular, he studied numaccockus bacteria which could infect and kill mice. And he was very interested in the mechanisms by which these numacy could kill mice.

Now it turns out that the pumacus bacteria came in two different types. One, the bacteria when they grew on a petry plate produced a glistening smooth shiny colony. We'll call them smooth bacteria here. And these bacteria in addition to being smooth and glistening were virilent. That is if you inject into the mouse, these bacteria would kill the mouse. They're smooth because they have this encapsulating polysaccharide coat around them. And uh it's not uh necessarily the case that that's what makes them virulent, although it actually does have a role in that, but it's it is the case that they're smooth and they're virilent.

So you inject them in a mouse, mouse dies because the mouse is not resistant to these bacteria. By contrast, there were strains of pumacus that were rough. They did not have the same kind of a polysaccharide coat and therefore they had a very rough appearance. They didn't glisten and these were nonvirulent. If you inject these into the mouse, the mouse immune system was able to fight these particular rough bacteria. Okay, so Griffiths did the obvious experiment. So take some bacteria. We'll take some uh smooth virulent bacteria. We'll inject into a mouse and what will happen? Mouse will die. This is one of the easier assays in in uh the laboratory.

It's the feet up, feet down assay. You have a dead mouse. Okay. Number two, you know, assays are okay. Then take the rough bacteria inject into a mouse. What happens? Sorry, it lives. Mouse lives because these are nonvirolent. Okay. Now, let's just do some simple controls. Let's take the smooth bacteria and autoclave them. Heat them up to very high temperature to kill them. How will we know they're dead? They don't grow. You try plating them out, they don't grow anymore. So they're they're they're dead. So take heat killed and you can verify in the lab that they're killed. Heat killed smooth. Check that that uh they really were heat killed.

inject them into the mouse and what happens? Lives because I mean dead bacteria, right? Okay. Last of all, we take the utterly harmless rough bacteria plus the utterly harmless heat bacteria. We inject them into the mouse and what happens? it dies. That is a notable result because the rough bacteria alone will not kill this mouths and the smooth bacteria that have been heat killed will not kill this mouse but together they killed mouse. This is very puzzling. What was even more puzzling was when you autopsy the mouse, you can isolate from that mouse smooth, virulent, live bacteria, but you didn't put any in.

Very strange. So this actually yields live smooth virilent bacteria despite not having put any in there uh virilent bacteria. Somehow we were able to create smooth and virilent bacteria notwithstanding not having put any in here. So, of course, uh, Griffiths then attempted to say, well, what was it that allowed this to happen? So, he could try putting in dead rough bacteria with dead smooth bacteria. That doesn't do anything. You need to have something alive. So, you got to have live rough bacteria. You could then say, let me take the the dead virulent bacteria and start fractionating it biochemically and asking what fraction of that material from the dead bacteria uh allows us to recover to have this property of being able to now produce virilent bacteria that kill the mice.

Now, do you realize how utterly tedious and painful that experiment is? You take the dead bacteria, you fractionate it into lots of different biochemical fractions. For each fraction, how do you test whether it has the property? Got to shoot up a bunch of mice. This is a very tedious procedure. I mean, it's it is it's um you know, you you can't underestimate how important the assay is, how how important it is to come up with easy ways to do things in order to be able to accelerate progress. Griffiths tried hard and roughly began to purify fractions and get information about what the fractions were.

But in fact, this work really never did lead to a clear conclusion. But it did tell people that there was some material which got named the transforming principle. Um this is almost like an old alchemical kind of word. uh a principle being a an ent particular chemical uh composition of matter which you don't know it is you call it a principle living principle or something like that so what was this transforming principle well it really took work about 15 years later by Avery Mccardi Mloud to sort this out what Avery and Mccardi Mloud did was the same experiment basically except minus the mice.

What they found was you could take the dead bacteria, combine it the dead virulent bact, the dead smooth bacteria, combine it with the live rough bacteria, and by combining it in the right way in a test tube, you would be able to plate it out on a petri plate and see smooth bacteria come out son's mouse. So they didn't need the mouse. This dramatically accelerated work because if you were able to just take fractions of the dead bacteria, add it to the live bacteria and look for the presence of some smooth bacteria coming out of it, you would be able to work much more quickly. And they did. And they began purifying.

And they began purifying. And they tried to isolate the fraction that contained this new ability to make these bacteria acquire a new property. And they knew that they were transforming the heredity of this bacteria. They're transforming the traits of this bacteria. They were in fact transmitting heredity. And they purified and purified and purified and eventually testing many many fractions and making them pure and pure and pure and pure. They found that consistently the fraction that contained heredity was the fraction that contained DNA. Now it was a lot more work than that because no fraction is pure.

DNA is in multiple fractions that it but but you know they kept trying to purify it and it sure looked like the transforming principle the property of being able to transform was co-purifying along with the DNA fraction. And you know what the reaction to that was? Well, mostly it was that they must have goofed because all smart right-thinking people knew that DNA was an absolutely boring molecule because the interesting molecule at this time was proteins. Everybody knew there were zillions of there were 20 amino acids. They came in zillions of combinations. They had all sorts of different shapes and properties and hydrophobic ones and hydrophilic ones.

enzymes. And clearly anything as important as heredity was not going to be encoded in some utterly boring structural molecule that was just a long polymer of four virtually identical units. And so the sort of reaction was this is interesting, but there must be some trick. Something must be wrong in this experiment, give or take. Now, why did people think that DNA was so boring? Now, DNA had been known for a long time, since the 1860s. lots of molecules were known. But why was DNA boring and why were proteins kind of exciting? So for that we really do have to look some more closely at the structure of DNA.

I want to review the structure of DNA here because we're going to use it a lot. So DNA has three components as you undoubtedly know. It has first a sugar or almost sugar two prime deoxyibbos two prime deoxyibbos. So it's a pentos or almost it's a deoxy pentos and its structure and this is an important structure. In order to be a true sugar to be ribos, you would have a hydroxil here. Deoxyibbos just has a hydrogen there. And the way we number these carbons around this fivecarbon sugar are very important and we'll always talk about them. the one prime, twop prime, threep prime, fourp prime and fivep prime carbons of deoxy of of this deoxyibbos.

And you'll notice that it's the twop prime carbon that is deoxy. So that's the sugar. The next important component as we build up DNA is the base. Okay, the base is put here. Now I'm going to start simplifying our sugar base. So there are four kinds of bases that can go here and they are adinine, guanine, thymine, cytosine. So that's the second important part in building up DNA. The third important part in building up DNA is to make the monomers that are used to produce DNA, we need trios, we need to put on a triphosphate. And here we go. We'll take our sugar here. our base over here. And then off this carbon we have our phosphate.

And we have a triphosphate. There we go. So this is the monomer that is used to build up DNA. This guy here is called a nucleioide. Note the S. This guy here with the triphosphate on it is called a nucleotide. Okay, it's not usually written with such a big capital letter, but nonetheless, I point this out. And obviously, what is this triphosphate going to do for us? It's going to provide the energy to allow us to make DNA ch polymer chains. We're going to do a dehydration synthesis where we break two of those phosphates off and use it for the energy to be able to catalyze DNA chains to be made.

Okay. Now when you combine nucleotides into a DNA strand, you do so to create a sugar phosphate backbone. And you'll see for many molecules, I don't care that you know their structures terribly well, but for the basic structure of DNA, including its sugar phosphate background backbone, it's going to be important for all that we talk about. So what happens is we have a chain of DNA growing like this. We have our O here. We have our base here. And which carbon is this? Five prime. That's right. Okay. To the Which carbon is this? This one. Great. That's the three prime. Two prime. One prime. Great.

Okay. Um to this threep prime carbon we add this triphosphate breaking off two phosphates there. The diphosphate gets broken off the pyrophosphate and we get a single phosphate linkage to the next subunit of the chain. So here we go. phosphate, sugar, phosphate, sugar. And if we ignore these bases, which you know, who cares about the bases anyway, what we have is just phosphate, sugar, phosphate, sugar, phosphate, sugar, phosphate, sugar. Okay, the so it's very simple structure. There's nothing hard to remember about this. And the phosphate is always attached to the threeP prime carbon of the preceding sugar.

and to the fivep prime carbon of the next sugar. Okay, so we often speak of chains of DNA growing from the fivep prime end to the threep prime end. And that confuses non-molelecular biologists. No. And what are we talking about? Five prime ends and threep prime ends. This is what we're talking about. That the cat that the additions are catalyzed onto the threep prime carbon of that sugar. It grows at its three prime ends. So we have sugar phosphate, sugar phosphate, sugar phosphate. So that's it. We're all done. Um well there's the bases I guess too, right? So we'll mention these bases. The bases are they come in two types.

There are purines. Adinine and guanine are purines. And there are six membered rings with a five membered ring. And there's two bases that are called perramdines. They're smaller, the thymine and the cytosine. And they're six membered rings. And they have some carbon, some nitrogen, some oxygen, and some hydrogen. But you got to admit that compared to proteins, this is pretty boring. It's just one long sugar phosphate chain and two purines, slightly bigger things, two primitines, uh, slightly smaller things, very similar structures for these two. I haven't even bothered to focus on the difference.

And as compared to the richness of proteins, there's just no way anything interesting can happen with this. That was certainly the thinking at the time. You have to understand how important prior ideas, prior prejudice is to science. People look at it and say, "This must be some structural molecule. It's scaffolding. It's like the studs in the wall of of the house you're building or something like that. Not too interesting." So, uh, what happens? Well, you know, takes time to sort things out. people come back to this problem. Any any thoughts? I mean, I've given you one reason why this did not make a huge impact because it was, you know, DNA was kind of a boring molecule and people weren't really sure this was right.

Could be an artifact, right? Maybe maybe some important protein had come along for the ride with the DNA fraction, right? What's another reason why people might not have paid tremendous attention to this result? Sorry. It was just bacteria. Anything else? They couldn't imagine the link between couldn't imagine right how this DNA could encode the enzyme. Anything else date to the middle of the Second World War. Maybe people had more important things to do. Right. So, this is right in the middle of the Second World War. It's just worth noting that um that these guys are working in the middle of New York City at the Rockefeller Institute and it's the middle of the Second World War.

Anyway, war is over and some more work continues on this and the work takes a somewhat different tack. Um instead of working on bacteria, it now is there's work here on certain bacterial viruses. So instead, you see bacteria get their own here. Uh instead of using bacteria to infect mice, Hershey and Chase and others at the time used viruses to infect bacteria. So here the the the the bacteria is the victim. And people had found and had studied these amazingly interesting, really tiny things that could affect a bacteria and kill it. These particles that had these funny shapes were called bacteria.

What does fagee mean? To eat. bacteria eaters. Um, bacteria phagee were these little viruses. They were incredibly tiny. You could filter them through very small filters. And yet when you added them to bacteria, they would kill the bacteria. These were very simple things. I'm I'm reluctant to call them creatures. Are they alive? This was a favorite question people would like to debate. They say, "Are viruses alive?" And the answer is, who cares? I mean, it depends on what you want to define alive to mean. uh to me it's not alive and that it can't replicate on its own without a host. So, I won't call it alive, but anyway, I'll I'll I'll refer to them loosely as as these creatures that eat bacteria.

They were very simple and all they really had in them was some DNA in their capsid, this capsid up here, and some protein. But they could attach to a bacteria and after a certain amount of time cause the bacteria to burst open and produce lots of daughter fagee, lots of daughter bacteria phage. It could replicate within this bacteria. So somehow this while I might not want to call it alive certainly can reproduce itself or at least with the help of a bacteria can reproduce itself. Um when people first discovered these bacteria fagee what do you think they wanted to do with them? Sorry to kill bacteria.

Yeah. Where in humans? The first thought about what to do with bacteria phagee were a whole bunch of interesting Russians who wanted to make up large quantities of bacteria phage and have people drink them so it would kill all their bacteria. And this was the early ideas for antibiotics. um it didn't quite pan out that way, but you know, people have all these these very exciting ideas of, wow, I got something that kill bacteria. Let's pour it down a patient and see if that does something good for them. Um you know, that's why there are institutional review boards, too, to make sure that you you can't just do that uh right off the bat.

You somebody else has got to think about it. Also, it turns out not to be a great way to kill patient to kill sorry. No, it doesn't actually kill patients, but it doesn't also kill the bacteria so well in human beings. So anyway, um, so the question was, how is it that these viruses kill the bacteria? Somehow they inject something into the bacteria. Something causes something to happen which causes virus particles to be made. I don't put too fine a point on it because that's all you could really say at that point, but something goes in and something comes out. So what goes in? How could we tell what goes in?

Yep. By seeing what is left out. By seeing what's left out. How could we see what's left out? Just being really practical. How are we going to tell visually? Look, that turns out to be a terribly hard thing to do. You've got to have really good eyes to be able to say, "Oh, the the protein's still there, but not the DNA or the DNA." Because the the thought was if this thing is injecting its DNA then the DNA must be carrying the instructions to make fagee and then this would be hereditary material. So we want to show is that the protein stays out and the DNA goes in. But how's that going to how do you do that practically?

Radioactive labeling turns out to be the best way to do that. If we could label radioactively the DNA with one label and the protein with a different label, we could see which radioactive isotope goes into the bacteria. Any candidates for an element that we could use to label DNA that won't be in protein. Sorry. Sorry. Oh, who had one? Uranium. Uranium. Somebody's thinking World War II here, right? Need some spare uranium around. The problem with that is that DNA does not actually have uranium in it. And so when you put uranium in, it wouldn't still be DNA. We would like to label it with an element that's actually in DNA.

So the only difference is that it's a radioisotope. Phosphorus. Phosphorus. There's obviously phosphorus in that sugar phosphate backbone. Is there phosphorus in a typical amino acid? Any of the 20 amino acids? No phosphorus. Great. So we could use a phosphorus isotope. We could P32 label the DNA. How do you But how do you make live bacteria phage that that are labeled with with radioactive phosphorus? I What kind of fancy chemistry do you need to do that? Yes. Perfect. If you grow the bacteria in radioactively lab in in medium, if you grow the the virus and the bacteria in medium that has radioactive phosphate, the bacteria and the and the virus take care of it for for you.

The phosphate is automatically incorporated. So you don't have to do any chemistry. You just feed phosphate radioactive phosphate into the medium and the and the fage that are produced will be radioactively labeled purify them and use them in your experiment. Similarly, what are we going to label our proteins with? Carbon? No. Hydrogen? No. Oxygen? Nitrogen? No. Because the bases have nitrogen. Sulfur. We've only got sulfur. Where is sulfur going to be? So, for example, cyines, methionines, right? We got sulfur. Here's S35. So we can take bacteria and we can we can take um fagee and by growing them in the presence of radioactive DNA radioactive uh phosphorus p32 and growing them in the presence of radioactive sulfur S35 we are able to produce bacteria phage that are labeled.

Okay so P32 S35 now we infect bacteria with them. Let me take a big tube here. I'm going to add bacteria. I've got the fagee here. The fagee particles are attached to the bacteria and they're going to inject whatever they inject. Now, what do we have to do? We got to knock off the viral the the the bacteria phagee particles from the bacteria. I want to I want to knock them off and see what is uh staying with the viral particles and what goes into the bacteria. So, how do I get in there with tweezers and separate off peel off each virus from the bacteria? Washing turns out not to be strong enough to to you got to pretty violently get these things off.

So, you really need some incredibly strong agitation. And so, specialized devices were used to create intense agitation. What specialized devices are you aware of that do that? Blenders. kitchen blenders. The wearing blender turns out to be the perfect laboratory device for this experiment. And this is actually known as the wearing blender experiment. Um, you take the you take the bacteria with the with the fagee attached to it. You let them you let them uh attach and do whatever they're going to do. Inject their their DNA as we know it turns out it's the right answer. And then you press puree and and and the viral particles fall off.

So it's important to know how things really happen. So then what happens is the bacteria are separated from these particles. And it turns out these particles are the the viral particles are much lighter, much less dense than the bacteria. So how do we separate them? Centrifuge them. We centrifuge them. The bacterial particles are there up in the supernant turn out to be our fage capsids. And now what do we do? We take this stuff. We measure the radioactivity in the supernant that is the material that stays above and we measure the radioactivity in the pellet. And what do we end up seeing? Where does most of the P32 what shows up in the pallet?

Mostly P32 shows up in the pellet. Is there no S35 in the pellet? You know, in the textbook story, of course, there's no S35 because they want it to be nice and clean. But in reality, there's going to be some S35, but it was, you know, less than 1%, sorry, of the S35 ends up in the pallet. Most of the S35 stays up here in the supernant. Does all of the phosphorus go in? No, of course not. Some of the viruses didn't even attach and not everything goes in. So, there's still radioactive phosphorus up in the super natent. But the striking thing is that the pallet primarily has gotten the radioactive phosphorus, not the radioactive sulfate sulfur.

And therefore, we can conclude that what? Well, more DNA went in than protein. Are we therefore entitled to include the DNA as the hereditary material here? Why? Well, I mean, you know, suppose that 1% sulfate is tracking one minor protein that is the secret. You can't, it's very hard to rule out that there's no contaminants traveling along with the DNA. And if you really truly disbelieve DNA, you could be chirish and say, well, I just don't believe that that you've so purified it that you can completely rule out that some minor protein component is really conferring heredity. In fact, when you really look closely, Avery McCarti Mloud's biochemistry, I believe, was purer than the purity of this experiment.

But by this point, thinking had begun to shift toward DNA being a reasonable hereditary molecule. In addition, it was a second line of proof different from this from the Numacus using a different system both pointing to the same answer. And the intellectual tide shifted to recognizing that this probably was right. And the reason these experiments were pointing to DNA was DNA had to be the right answer. But of course, how was it the right answer? What was it about DNA that could confer these properties? This was still unclear in 1953, but not for that long. It became clarified relatively soon thereafter.

And of course, it became clarified with the understanding of DNA structure, the double helix. Nobody here has not heard of the double helix. Probably there's nobody, you know, no grown-up who doesn't know about the double helix and all that. But nonetheless, I want to stop and and think a little bit about it. Also, I'll say on a personal note, this is this is the first year I've taught this class after uh the first time I've taught this class. Um when Crick and Watson have not both been alive. Some of you may know that Francis Crick died just this this past summer which was very sad. He was an incredible person and uh you know as I've said Mendle was one of my heroes.

Francis Crick was also one of my heroes. He was just an extraordinary person. But uh Jim Watson is still alive and kicking um and still quite active. Um and so in any case you're not far removed. So I tell you a little bit about this stuff is history but this this history I'm telling you about these people are for the most part Francis's passing notwithstanding alive and kicking. Jim Watson is still quite alive. Actually, McCarti is still alive. Um, it's really uh Anyway, so 1953, just a year later, Jim Watson and Francis Crick are working in England. Um, Watson is a is a student from Indiana, former ornithologist, had his interest in ornithology originally, uh, and then studied more biology and came to England because he wanted to study the gene.

Francis Crick, a physicist who worked in the Admiral T during, uh, uh, during World War II. And of course what they did was on the basis of an awful lot of modeling and getting to see experimental X-ray defraction pictures of Rosalyn Franklin from London made a model and the model is this beautiful and I haven't drawn it to its proper proportions but this beautiful double helical structure fivep prime prime one chain of DNA running in one direction five prime to three prime and an anti-parallel chain of DNA going in this direction five prime to three prime it was a beautiful structure um Jim Watson has written a whole book about the discovery of the double helix structure um and uh we are only 51 years past that um it was anybody who hasn't read the double helix.

This book really should. It's one of the great u books of science literature and actually is on many people's lists of some of the great books of the 20th century. It's a wonderful competitive story of Crick and Watson racing against Lionus Pauling. Um it's you know someone came along uh and had lunch in Cambridge with Cric and Watson and they came away and and said this was before they discovered the structure about a year or so before and said these guys are idiots. They can't even memorize the structure of A and T and C and G and they're trying to find you know the structure of DNA. These guys are never going to get anywhere.

So this person who we'll come back to in a moment was wrong about this particular point because what Cricut Watson did was they played around with the models and what they ended up noticing was a couple of things. First off from Rosyn Franklin's pictures that this was helical. The X-ray defraction pictures could tell you at an at a glance that the structure was helical. They saw that. They then tried to make helyses. other people. Lionus Pauling knew something that DNA probably had to be helical and somehow he just got it totally wrong. He made a just a nutty model of DNA. Lionus Pauling's smartest chemist of of the century made a crazy model of DNA where he took the sugar phosphate backbones and he put all the sugar phosphate backbones in the middle and had three of them.

He had a triple helical model with sugar phosphates in the middle. And what can you tell me about the charge on these sugar phosphate backbones? Very negative. You going to stick a whole bunch of negative charges near each other in the middle? No way. Anybody could have known. This was Bush League mistake. But so Cric and Watson Pauling's got it wrong. They put together this model and the key to the model was the recognition of base pairing. the recognition of base pairing that if I take a thymine here and I take an addinine here. That these two groups would be pointing at each other in such a way as to make two hydrogen bonds with a certain characteristic distance.

And not just that, but cytosine and guanine could also be fit into that same distance. And they would have three hydrogen bonds. And here N H three hydrogen bonds and they would fit the what I got. Oh, whoops. Thank you. Good point. That's the problem. Yep. Well, it's a little messy, but anyway, the business end here is three hydrogen bonds and two hydrogen bonds, and they both fit into the same distance perfectly. So, this double helix here could have either A's and T's or G's and C's or C's and G's or T's and A's and they would all fit perfectly with each other. Now, there was an old observation, not that old, there was an observation floating around at the time that said when you analyze the amount of A's and T's in DNA, you always found out that the amount of A tended to be very close to the amount of T.

The amount of C tended to be very close to the amount of G, although these amounts could be different. This was due to a biochemist called charge and they're called this was called charg's rule or charge's law or charg's observation. Charge noted that the percentage of these amounts tended to be equal but didn't know what to make of it. This perfectly explained that. That's very good. Remember I said somebody came through uh Cambridge and said these guys were turkeys. Kirk and Watson were turkeys because they couldn't even remember the structure and all that. This was a very distinguished chemist who said this about Kirk and Watson.

It was Shariff. Charg came through and said these guys are turkeys. But it was Charge's rule that Charge had missed the importance of he was quite bitter about this through much of his life. And there's a very wonderful biting quote that Charg says when Cric and Watson become famous for the double DNA double helix. Um, see if I can get it right. Uh, he says that such pygmies should cast such giant shadows, referring to Cricen Watson, "That such pygmies should cast such giant shadows only shows how late in the day it is." Um, anyway, he was not happy. Um, so, uh, all right. Now, this was a big deal thing.

Cricen Watson knew this was very important. They raced to ex to to publish a paper about this. They sent it off to Nature. It's a gem of a paper. It's a page roughly in text. It's very short, very clear. Has this beautiful picture drawn by Francis Crick's wife, Odal, and it's it it is just a charming paper. They know that they've cracked the secret of life. Why do they know they've cracked the secret of life? Because the most important thing about this model here is not its structure per se, but that it explains how it is that a DNA molecule can be replicated. That somehow all it takes is for those two strands to come apart.

Who said who knows how? And that when they come apart, each can serve as a template for the other. Because since A's always match T's and C's always match G's, each strand has enough information for the other. That's how replication happens. You have two strands, each of which has sufficient information to encode the other. They somehow come apart. They each serve as a template for the other. And that's that. That is the secret of life. How life replicates itself. Not just that, we've explained replication. What about mutation? What's mutation? Sometimes gets it wrong. It sometimes screws up. So for one little biochemical model, we've explained replication and mutation.

It's pretty good. Now the thing is in writing this paper and getting this off to the journal, this was not an easy thing to get done quickly. You couldn't you just didn't have time to explain all these details. They wanted to stake their claim about this. So they wrote up the structure and instead of going to a long thing about how this explains replication and d's one sentence in the paper, the last sentence of the paper in which they just say it has not escaped our notice that this model explains replication and everything else. Basically the last sentence is oh and by the way it's not escaped our notice that this explains the secret of life.

Although it doesn't say it like that. It's the koiest sentence in the scientific literature. It's really just an amazing sentence there. And then they come back a couple minutes later and write a paper explaining what they mean and all that, but it's just a great sentence. So you will hear molecular biologists make the make reference use in their speech the phrase it has not escaped our notice that and it's always an homage back to this particular sentence in this paper of Cric and Watson. Okay. Now last thing. Yes. Jim Watson 25. Jim Watson was 25 and Francis was 35 when he did this. Um, yes, he was he was a 25-y old kid when he did this.

That's right. Um, pretty amazing stuff. Um, so last point I want to touch on and I'm not sure I'll get to get all the way there, but this model the meal. So this model here of DNA coming apart and each strand serving as a template for the other strand is called semicconservative conservative replic conservative replication. That is one strand is used as the template for the other strand. So there's an old strand and a new strand that's made. Now in theory you could imagine that DNA replication occurred not like this but instead somehow I can't imagine how but you could imagine and people were willing to imagine it that the old strands stayed together but somehow became a template for making a new double helix without actually using them.

This model of the strands actually serving as a template would predict that each new DNA double helix was in fact composed of one old and one new strand. If you could prove that, then you'd have real confirmation of this Cric Watson model of semiconservative replication. And so a young student, two young students, Matt Mezen, who's still working and is down the road at Harvard and wonderful person, and Frank Stall, who's still working in his organ, um, proved that the new DNAs that were made after each generation were in fact composed of one old strand and one new strand. Now, how could you possibly do that?

Sorry, radioactive labeling. But how do you radioactively label it so that you can see that it's that you've got a double helix that's half one and half the other? Old one's labeled with well with one isotope. It actually turns out to be nitrogen. The new one with a new isotope say N14. Uh you can do heavy nitrogen and and ordinary nitrogen. And if what you can do is grow up your DNA when you first grow it in normal nitrogen, then you shift to N15, heavy nitrogen. You could make DNA molecules that were half old, half new, and therefore half labeled with normal nitrogen, half labeled with heavy nitrogen.

And how would I prove that these DNA molecules were a 50/50 hybrid? What would be the property that I would be able to test? But radioactivity turns to be really hard to weight density. It turns out density if I could just measure the density of the DNA I would show that if the semiconservative model is true the molecules will now have intermediate density between all heavy and all light nitrogen. They had to work out a centrifugation technique so sensitive a salt gradient centrifugation where you could put DNA on it. you had a really fine salt gradient spun in a centrifuge and depending on where the DNA migrated you could measure the density of the DNA and they were able to show that in fact newly replicated DNA strands had this intermediate density that would be expected from the semiconservative model and so in fact by that point the semiconservative model I think is well established in some sense you would say the beauty of the double helix was almost one of these very rare scientific results where when you look at it you say It can't possibly be wrong.

It explains too much. It's too beautiful. But as we've discussed before, that's not enough. You need some proof so that it's real. And this Mezson stall experiment provided a real confirmation of that. On to next time.