Transcript
and after about 15 20 minutes sometimes with some of the witnesses that I've cross-examined the jury's kind of looking back and forth like oh my God this person is crazy as hell my name is Michael wadington and I am a criminal defense attorney most of my clients are men because I represent people in the military justice system and in state and federal court who are accused of false allegations in my years of experience dealing with false allegations I've come to one conclusion most people that make false allegations have a cluster B personality disorder one of the primary ones is borderline personality disorder many of the people I represent are involved in a relationship with people with borderline personality disorder or BPD for short I'm not going to get into the detailed criteria we have multiple videos on this topic that deal with mental health disorder such as BPD you can check out those videos for more information or check out the DSM 5 in the meantime this video is going to focus on cross-examining confronting and discrediting people who are making false allegations who also happen to suffer from borderline personality disorder as trial lawyers we Face challenging Witnesses in the courtroom and among the most difficult to cross-examine are those with borderline personality disorder these individuals can exhibit extreme emotional responses they engage in manipulation they often exaggerate and dist St facts and they tend to lie which makes them very dangerous in a court of law especially if your client is facing false allegations and they're in there trying to convince the judge and jury falsely that your client is guilty although some don't act with malicious intent although many of them do in my opinion their behaviors can derail a case if not properly handled during cross-examination today I'm going to walk you through some strategies that I've developed to effectively confront their lies and exaggerations to imp teach The credibility in other words to destroy the credibility and to control the narrative on cross-examination first you have to understand borderline personality disorder in witness behavior let's discuss the traits of borderline personality disorder that are relevant to cross-examination BPD is characterized by emotional instability intense fear of Abandonment impulsive behavior in a distorted sense of reality Witnesses with BP D May exaggerate events to gain sympathy tell half truths that align with their emotional perspective quickly escalate emotionally when they feel cornered and outright lie they're very manipulative and they're emotionally unstable and they tend to lie all the time so understanding these Tendencies allows us to anticipate how they might respond under pressure for example in a domestic dispute case a BPD witness might accuse the defendant of Outland landish Behavior turning minor disagreements into major allegations for example a BPD person may start an argument with their spouse falsely accuse them of something escalate it physically assault their spouse and then call 911 and Report their spouse and claim they were the one who was abused when that in fact did not happen I've seen that happen quite a few times over the course of my career your job is to cut through the exaggerations and establish the facts the truth not someone's perception of the truth but realistically what actually happened so what do we do we have to confront their lies and exaggerations and how do we do that when confronting lies or exaggerations Preparation is crucial it's key use their previous statements to trap them in contradictions for instance if the witness previously claimed they had no contact with the defendant but text records show otherwise calmly present the evidence you testified early that you hadn't spoken to the defendant since the alleged assault on April 15th get a yes out of that let me show you exhibit B A text exchange between you and the defendant from April 16th do you recognize this and then turn around and impeach them with that have them read the message particularly if it's a message with her asking to meet up again talking about how they met up that day or anything that disproves or discredits what she had previously said or that discredits or disproves the narrative the emo narrative the exaggerated narrative that they're pushing now these types of people again they rely on emotion lies and manipulation so they're going to tell a story and it's going to be emotional and it's going to be believable to someone that doesn't have experience with a person with BPD they're going to push back they're going to fight you they're going to be difficult but you must stay calm and unemotional people with BPD often escalate when they feel they are losing control again they can't control themselves emotionally they're they're all over the place up and down up and down it's like a roller coaster up and down up and down and they can't control it they often do wild things and say wild things when they're on this up and down roller coaster by remaining composed and keeping your demeanor calm you will magnify their emotional reaction and it highlights their instability to the jury and after about 15 20 minutes sometimes with some of the witnesses that I've cross-examined the jury is kind of looking back and forth like oh my God this person is crazy as hell they sounded very credible on examination when the prosecution had them up there with their coach testimony but on cross-examination it's like ripping off a Band-Aid that exposes a gaping wound exposes the severity of how problematic and messed up this person is and how much of a liar they are now let's talk about impeaching their credibility impeachment is a powerful tool impeachment like I said earlier is discrediting them Witnesses with BPD often provide inconsistent testimony because of their emot emotional reasoning I want you to remember that word emotional reasoning they reason based on emotion based on feelings if they're seeing a psychologists or psychiatrist their psychologist or psychiatrist will often allow them to talk and talk and talk about how they're feeling but what they're feeling may not be factually accurate it may be exaggerated it may be untrue it just might be wild exaggerations and emotional outbursts not based on reality in a court of law you're not a psychologist you're not a Psy iatrist you pin them down on the truth not on what their feeling and what their emotional reasoning is saying facts not feelings or what control a court of law use these inconsistencies to undermine the reliability if you're up there screaming yelling at they've been losing control as a lawyer you lost the battle you're going to look like a bully the jury's going to hate you the judge is going to hate you and the BPD person making the false allegations is going to win you have to be so nice so calm so professional it's okay if you seem exasperated at times but the jury has to believe that you are trying to get out the truth not that you're yelling at someone who's emotional and crying and all over the place because they're going to say oh my God this guy's a bully just like his client he's abusing her now I feel bad for her I'm going to find him guilty so you cannot fall into that trap if you don't get anything else from this video get this the lawyer must be calm professional even kind when cross-examining a person with BPD because it really contrasts the emotional instability versus the person who's just trying to get the truth who's trying to get the facts to the jury so they can make an informed accurate decision the jury can't get there if you're screaming and yelling and looking like an a-hole speaking of inconsistencies you want to pin them down and do your classic impeachment with a prior inconsistent statement acknowledge during court testimony bring up up in credit and build up their prior testimony with details and times and dates and then use transcripts or documents or depositions or whatever you have to show the inconsistency show it to them make them read it make the jury understand it this forces them to confront their own words and it exposes their distortions that's kind of the key exposing their distortions remember to them everything's emotional they're un aable so how do we control a witness when they're on the stand aside from using their prior statements control is essential when cross-examining individuals with BPD they will try to control the narrative they will try to pull it away from you and gain control for example they will often not answer the question and go off on a diet tribe about something that you didn't ask one of the techniques they'll use is when you ask a question that they don't want to answer they will turn to the jury and give some emotional Outburst about oh because he was raping me all these other times because he did all these other things to me we saw this in the Hamber herd case when she was confronted about the bottle that she allegedly was assaulted with and then she made up a whole new story about a bottle that she had never told anyone else it was a very exaggerated emotional story about Johnny Depp attacking her that she had never told anyone else and it got exposed again right there in court they're going to try to blurt things out I had a case once where I was pinning down a witness with a prior lie that was told and then she blurts out oh you think he's a good guy did you ask your client about the time he raped me in our honeymoon and the fact that I have a rape baby yeah ask him about that if you think he's such a good guy and I was simply just asking her a factual question based on something she said on direct examination and she made up this whole rape baby story in front of the jury and some of them were like what is going on here never brought it up before it was absolutely made up on the Fly and it was an emotional Outburst so what do we need to do to maintain control you're going ask short close-ended questions one new fact per question do not ask questions with multiple facts with adjectives or adverbs do not ask open-ended questions unless you're very very skilled at cross-examination and you know what you're doing it's a good idea to avoid open-ended questions because that'll allow them to ramble or emotionally manipulate the jury I sometimes do ask open-ended questions but I do it in a way where there's no good answer and I'm setting them up for a future impeachment it's like playing 10 games of Chess at the same time and you know how all the games are interacting I don't recommend that for a lawyer unless you probably tried about 50 jury trials and cross-examined dozens and dozens of these types of people when they don't answer the question redirect them back to the question and do not move on until you get an answer do not ask the judge to help you I don't like that I don't think that's effective you should be able to control the witness on cross-examination I have another video It's called The Nine techniques for controlling hostile Witnesses you could check it out it's an hour long course that I teach to lawyers it's an advanced cross-examination course it's free on YouTube if you want to check it out but in that course I teach lawyers how to control even the most hostile non-responsive Witnesses unless you're at that level stick with the basics one new fact per question always leading questions keep it short to the point and make them answer the question and don't just move on what do you do if the witness tries to take control of the situation using emotional outbursts or crying in the middle of your cross-examination which they will try to do if they have BPD people with BPD will very likely attempt to turn the courtroom into a stage where they're the star they're the Merill Streep they will try to escalate the situation using emotion it's all designed to gain sympathy so understand that don't lose your cool don't freak out and be like oh my God we're going down but most importantly do not engage emotionally if they cry or become defensive pause let the court observe don't go up there and start running up there and giving giving them tissues and apologizing for the fact that you had to question them just sit there let them cry when they realize that no one's coming to the rescue often the judge can see through this most judges can see through this the judge will just say okay you know give her AIT it you want tissue you want some water here you go you want five minute break and then we come back in we go back to the question that she started crying on you could say something like I understand this is difficult for you but let's go back to the question I asked before the break and then repeat the question your calm methodical approach will contrast with their volatility which juries notice in closing cross-examining a witness with BPD requires preparation precision and composure by exposing inconsistencies confronting exaggerations and maintaining control you can neutralize their influence while preserving The credibility of your case you must maintain as much credibility as possible if your client is being falsely accused by a PPD alleged victim that is so important you cannot be the villain in that courtroom and remember the jury is watching not just the witness but you your professionalism your patience and your focus will ensure that you maintain the upper hand and guide The Narrative effectively the key is to stay calm factual and in control if you're facing challenges with difficult Witnesses or want more tips on mastering cross-examination check out some of our other videos I'll be covering more advanced stratey IES and upcoming videos thank you for watching please like and hit subscribe below