# Why Narcissists Become More Cruel When You're Vulnerable

**Channel:** Jill Wise Narcissistic Abuse Recovery Coaching 
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n2T6CpubZu4
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/n2T6CpubZu4

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Why Narcissists Punish Vulnerability
- 3:13 — How Vulnerability Disrupts Control
- 10:33 — Dependency, Exploitation, and Control
- 15:00 — Performative Care and Hidden Cruelty
- 21:35 — What Real Love Looks Like

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** Hello everyone and thank you so much for joining me on my podcast all about surviving narcissistic abuse. I'm your host and lifelong survivor of narcissistic abuse myself Jill Weise and today we're talking about something I think is absolutely fascinating and frankly one of the most disturbing things about being in a relationship with a pathological narcissist. Why is it that some narcissistic individuals seem to become more cruel when you're at your most vulnerable? I'm talking about when you're sick, grieving the loss of someone you love, um struggling financially, dealing with a serious personal crisis or or going through something that has left you emotionally devastated. These are the moments when most of us would naturally expect the person who claims to love us to become more compassionate, more supportive, and more concerned about our well-being. But for some survivors of narcissistic abuse, the exact opposite happens.

**[1:08]:** The person they turn to for comfort becomes another source of pain. And if you've experienced this, you've probably wondered, "What in the hell is wrong with this person? Why would somebody treat me worse when I'm already suffering?" And I think what makes this so difficult to understand is that we're dealing with a complete reversal of what most people expect from a loved one. Because in a healthy relationship, vulnerability generally brings people closer together. When somebody you love is hurting, you want to help them. You want to make their burden a little lighter. But in some narcissistic relationships, vulnerability can actually trigger resentment, contempt, uh withdraw, or even punishment. And what's particularly disturbing is that this isn't always simply a matter of someone lacking empathy. There can be other psychological dynamics involved including uh threatened entitlement, resentment of dependency, discomfort with vulnerability, and the way some people use other people's weaknesses to reinforce their own sense of superiority.

**[2:26]:** Now, before we get into this, I want to make something very clear. Not every person with narcissistic traits behaves this way. And not everybody who struggles to provide emotional support is a narcissist. Some people are uncomfortable around illness and grief or or really strong emotions because they don't know what to say or how to help. But there's an enormous difference between someone who struggles to comfort you and someone who repeatedly makes your suffering worse. And today I want to explore some of the more disturbing psychological reasons that can happen because understanding these patterns can help survivors stop blaming themselves for needing support in the first place.

**[3:13]:** So let's start with something that I think is really revealing. Sometimes your vulnerability disrupts the role you've been assigned in the relationship. And I don't think that people talk about this nearly enough. In a controlling or narcissistic relationship, you may have gradually become the person who manages the other person's emotional needs. You're the one who keeps things running smoothly. You're the one who listens, who who reassures, who accommodates, who forgives, and who makes adjustments whenever something goes wrong. And over time, that arrangement can become so familiar that neither person even recognizes how one-sided it has become. But then something happens to you. You get sick. You experience a loss. You're overwhelmed. You need somebody else to take care of you for a change. And suddenly, the arrangement that has benefited the narcissistic person is no longer functioning the way they're accustomed to. You're not as available.

**[4:21]:** You're not as attentive. You don't have the energy to manage their moods or anticipate their needs. And instead of recognizing that you deserve support, they may begin experiencing your vulnerability as an inconvenience. Think about how disturbing that is for a minute. You're lying in bed with the flu and somehow the biggest problem in the household is that you're not doing enough for them. Apparently, even your immune system was supposed to consult their schedule before deciding to malfunction. And here's the deeper psychological issue. When someone has become accustomed to receiving care without providing much in return, your need for reciprocity can expose something about the relationship that was previously hidden. As long as you're functioning well and meeting their needs, the relationship may appear relatively stable. But the moment you require something substantial from them, you discover whether the emotional support actually flows in both directions.

**[5:31]:** And sometimes what looks like a sudden change in personality is really the first time the relationship has ever demanded something they were never willing to give. Another disturbing possibility is that your vulnerability can make you less useful to someone who primarily values relationships according to what they receive from them. And I know that says that sounds incredibly cold, but I think it's important to talk about in healthy relationships, people have inherent value beyond what they can provide. You don't become less deserving of love because you're sick or exhausted or grieving or temporarily unable to contribute as much as you normally would. But when somebody approaches relationships with a massive sense of entitlement, they may become resentful when the benefits they expect are interrupted. And this is where survivors sometimes experience something that feels almost transactional. When you're strong, productive, um, attractive, successful, emotionally available, and making their life easier, you may receive attention and affection.

**[6:48]:** But when you become ill, overwhelmed, or dependent, that attention begins disappearing, and you may find yourself wondering whether the person ever loved you for who you were, or whether they primarily appreciated what you were able to do for them. Now, that doesn't mean that every narcissistic individual consciously thinks this way, but the pattern the pattern can reveal a really disturbing imbalance in how the relationship operates. And I want you to think about something else. Sometimes the narcissist's cruelty during your vulnerability isn't simply about what they aren't receiving anymore. It can also involve what your suffering requires them to acknowledge. Because when somebody you love is in pain, responding compassionately requires you to recognize that their experience matters independently of your own. Their needs may have to come first for a while. Their emotions may deserve attention even when those emotions have nothing to do with you.

**[7:56]:** And for a narcissist who struggles to tolerate not being the center of the relationship, that can create resentment. This is why some survivors describe the narcissist suddenly developing a crisis of their own whenever the survivor needs attention. You're dealing with something really serious and somehow the conversation gets redirected towards their problems. Maybe they're exhausted. Uh maybe nobody appreciates what they're going through. Um maybe they're having the worst day imaginable and before you know it, you're comforting the person who was supposed to be comforting you. Now obviously two people can experience difficulties at the same time. But when this happens repeatedly, especially during moments when you're genuinely vulnerable, it can reveal a pattern in which your needs are consistently displaced by theirs. And here's where I think the psychology becomes really interesting. Some narcissistic individuals may experience another person's vulnerability as a threat to their own emotional stability because it confronts them with feelings they don't know how to manage.

**[9:18]:** So things like illness, grief, fear, dependency, all of those things are reminders that human beings are not always powerful, not always independent, or not always in control. And for someone whose self-image depends heavily upon strength, superiority, and invulnerability, being confronted with those realities can be really uncomfortable. But instead of recognizing and managing that discomfort, they may respond with irritation, contempt, emotional withdrawal, and the survivor can end up feeling as though they're perfectly normal human vulnerability is somehow offensive. You may be criticized for crying, um, accused of being dramatic, made to feel weak for needing help. And I think it's important to understand that another person's discomfort with vulnerability doesn't make vulnerability shameful. Human beings get sick. We experience loss. We become overwhelmed. We need support. And that's not a character defect. That's part of being alive.

**[10:33]:** Now, there's another psychological contradiction that I want to explore. And it's the way some narcissistic individuals seem to resent dependency even when they've spent years encouraging it. So think about that for a moment. A controlling partner may gradually undermine your independence, discourage outside relationships, um make you feel incapable of functioning without them. But once you actually become dependent upon them, they may begin treating that dependency with contempt. And there's something extraordinarily cruel about creating the very condition you later criticize somebody for having. This is where power and responsibility can become completely disconnected. They may enjoy the influence that comes from being needed but resent the obligations that come with actually being responsible for another person's well-being. They want the authority without the inconvenience. They want the importance without the sacrifice. And unfortunately, when the survivor becomes vulnerable, that contradiction can become impossible to ignore because genuine caregiving requires patience, consideration, a willingness to put somebody else's needs ahead of your own, at least temporarily.

**[12:04]:** And those qualities may be in very short supply. And I think this is one reason some survivors become afraid to ask for help, even when they desperately need it. They've learned that needing something creates an opportunity for criticism, resentment, or humiliation. So, they begin minimizing their pain. They insist they're fine when they're not. They apologize for being sick. They push themselves to function when they should be resting. And eventually they can become so accustomed to being punished for having needs that they stop recognizing those needs as legitimate. But there's another side to this that I think is extremely disturbing. And that's the possibility that some abusive individuals may actually recognize your vulnerability as an opportunity for greater control. Because when someone is sick, when they are grieving, when they are financially struggling or emotionally overwhelmed, they may have fewer resources available to protect themselves or challenge mistreatment.

**[13:15]:** Their energy is already depleted. Their attention is focused on surviving whatever crisis they're facing. And an abusive person may exploit that situation by becoming more demanding, more critical, and more controlling. And I want to be very clear here. I'm not suggesting that every narcissistic person consciously plans to take advantage of someone's suffering. But in some coercive relationships, vulnerability can absolutely be exploited. A person who might normally challenge unreasonable demands may be too exhausted to argue. Someone who's financially dependent may feel unable to leave. Someone who's grieving may be desperate for comfort and therefore more willing to tolerate mistreatment. And when another person recognizes those vulnerabilities and uses them to gain power, we're no longer simply talking about poor emotional skills. We're talking about exploitation. And this is why I think it's so important for survivors to pay attention to what happens when they're least able to defend themselves.

**[14:31]:** Does the other person become more considerate or more demanding? Do they respect your limitations or punish you for having them? Do they offer support without expecting something in return? Or do they use your need for help as an opportunity to remind you how much you owe them? Those patterns can tell you something important about whether this relationship is emotionally safe or not.

**[15:00]:** Now, I also want to discuss something that I think many survivors will recognize, and that's how some narcissistic individuals can become strangely competitive about suffering. You tell them you're exhausted and they're more exhausted. Uh you mention that you're sick and suddenly they've never felt worse in their life. You're grieving a loss and somehow their experience becomes the central tragedy. And while that may sound almost comical, it can be incredibly painful when you're genuinely struggling. Because suffering isn't supposed to be a competition. When somebody you love tells you they're hurting, the appropriate response isn't to establish that your pain is more impressive. But when someone is accustomed to organizing relationships around superiority and attention, even vulnerability can become another arena for comparison. And the survivor may eventually stop sharing their difficulties because they know the conversation will inevitably become about somebody else. And there's something else I want to point out.

**[16:13]:** Sometimes the narcissist may initially appear very supportive during a crisis, particularly when there are other people watching. They may make a public display of concern, tell everyone how much they're doing for you, or present themselves as the devoted partner who's making extraordinary sacrifices. But privately, the experience may be very different. You may be criticized for needing help, reminded repeatedly of everything they've done, or made to feel indebted for receiving basic consideration. And I think this is one of the more disturbing contradictions in narcissistic relationships. The person may enjoy being recognized as compassionate without consistently behaving compassionately when nobody is watching. And for the survivor, that creates yet another layer of confusion because other people may praise the narcissist for being so supportive while you know what actually happened behind closed doors. Sometimes the performance of caregiving becomes more important than the caregiving itself. Now, let's talk about what this kind of treatment can do to the survivor psychologically, because I think this is where the long-term damage becomes particularly serious.

**[17:38]:** When someone repeatedly responds to your vulnerability with criticism, withdraw, or punishment, you can begin associating having needs with danger. And that association doesn't necessarily disappear when the relationship ends. You may find yourself feeling guilty when you're sick, uncomfortable accepting help, or anxious about depending upon other people. And I think this is especially relevant for people recovering from complex PTSD because prolonged exposure to emotionally unsafe relationships can leave the nerves nervous system highly sensitive to signs of rejection or conflict. You may become hyperindependent not because you genuinely prefer doing everything yourself but because relying on someone else has historically come with consequences. And sometimes survivors are praised for being so strong and self-sufficient when the truth is that their independence developed partially because they learned that they couldn't safely depend upon anybody. And there's a difference between healthy independence and feeling that you're never allowed to need another person.

**[18:56]:** Healthy independence means you have confidence in your ability to function and make decisions. Traumad-driven self-reliance can involve believing that asking for help is dangerous, embarrassing, or likely to result in disappointment. And I think recognizing that distinction can be an important part of recovery because the goal isn't to become somebody who never needs anyone. The goal is to develop relationships where needing support doesn't put you at risk of being mistreated. And I want to say something else about vulnerability because I think it's particularly important for survivors who've been criticized for being emotional, sensitive, needy, or weak. Vulnerability is not the opposite of strength. In fact, the ability to acknowledge that you're struggling and ask for appropriate support requires a certain amount of emotional courage. What's unhealthy is not the need for connection. What's unhealthy is a relationship where one person's needs are consistently treated as legitimate while the other person's needs are treated as burdens.

**[20:13]:** And I think one of the clearest ways to evaluate the health of a relationship is to pay attention to what happens when life becomes difficult. It's relatively easy to be affectionate and attentive when everything is going well, but relationships are inevitably going to involve illness, grief, financial stress, disappointment, and periods where one person needs more support than the other. And the question isn't whether somebody handles every situation perfectly. Nobody does. The question is whether there's a genuine concern, mutual consideration, and a willingness to show up for each other when it matters. And if you've experienced someone becoming more cruel during your most vulnerable moments, I want you to understand that your behavior was not evidence that you were asking for too much. It wasn't proof that you were weak or difficult or undeserving of compassion. It may have revealed something about their limitations, their entitlement, or the unhealthy dynamics within the relationship.

**[21:26]:** And you don't have to minimize what happened simply because the person occasionally behaved differently when circumstances were easier.

**[21:35]:** And there's one final psychological point I want to leave you with. Sometimes the most revealing moment in a relationship isn't when somebody tells you how much they love you. It's when you're no longer in a position to make their life easier. When you're sick, exhausted, grieving, or struggling, and you have very little left to give. What happens then? Does a person still recognize your value? Do you do they still treat you with dignity? Do they still care about your well-being? Or does their affection begin disappearing the moment the relationship requires something of them? Because genuine love isn't simply about enjoying what another person brings into your life. It's about recognizing that the person has value even when they aren't able to pro provide those things. And if somebody's affection depends entirely upon your ability to remain strong and productive and accommodating and available, then what you're experiencing may have much more to do with convenience than love.

**[22:47]:** And I think this is one of the most important things survivors eventually learn. You don't have to earn compassion by being useful. You don't have to apologize for being sick. You don't have to justify grieving someone you love, and you don't have to prove that your suffering is serious enough to deserve basic human consideration. In a healthy relationship, those things shouldn't even be up for debate. So, if you've spent years wondering why somebody who claimed to love you became especially cruel when you needed them the most, I want you to consider the possibility that your vulnerability didn't create the problem, it may have exposed a problem that was already there. And while understanding the psychology behind that behavior can help you make sense of what happened, it doesn't excuse the cruelty or diminish the harm you've experienced. And if this episode resonated with you and you're struggling to understand narcissistic abuse, break a trauma bond, rebuild your self-rust, or recover from complex PTSD, I want you to know that you don't have to navigate this process alone.

**[24:03]:** I offer private one-on-one narcissistic abuse recovery coaching sessions where we can work together to help you understand what you've experienced and develop a personalized path towards healing. I also have a comprehensive online course covering the psychology of narcissistic abuse, trauma bonds, and the recovery process, as well as my private community, the recovery circle, where you can connect with other survivors who genuinely understand what you've been through. And you can learn about all three of these resources and schedule a private coaching session on my website at www.jill jillwise.com. And as always, thank you so much for spending this time with me. If you know someone who's been made to feel guilty or ashamed for needing support during one of the most difficult periods of their life, please consider sharing this episode with them. And I want to leave you all with one final thought. The people who genuinely love you won't always know exactly what to say or how to help when you're suffering.

**[25:13]:** Nobody is going to get it right every single time, but they won't consistently make your suffering worse simply because your needs have become inconvenient. Because real love isn't measured by how somebody treats you when you're making their life easier. Sometimes it's revealed most clearly when you're
