# Lecture 17: More on Central Potentials

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLe8YCnUed4
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/mLe8YCnUed4

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 0:52 — Chapter 2 (0:52)
- 3:54 — Chapter 3 (3:54)
- 11:09 — Chapter 4 (11:09)
- 14:19 — Chapter 5 (14:19)
- 17:01 — Chapter 6 (17:01)
- 18:47 — Chapter 7 (18:47)
- 21:45 — Chapter 8 (21:45)
- 25:42 — Chapter 9 (25:42)
- 31:04 — Chapter 10 (31:04)
- 32:36 — Chapter 11 (32:36)
- 40:09 — Chapter 12 (40:09)
- 41:37 — Chapter 13 (41:37)
- 43:41 — Chapter 14 (43:41)
- 44:27 — Chapter 15 (44:27)
- 48:31 — Chapter 16 (48:31)
- 49:30 — Chapter 17 (49:30)
- 50:55 — Chapter 18 (50:55)
- 52:00 — Chapter 19 (52:00)
- 52:36 — Chapter 20 (52:36)
- 53:52 — Chapter 21 (53:52)
- 56:02 — Chapter 22 (56:02)
- 59:06 — Chapter 23 (59:06)
- 1:01:17 — Chapter 24 (61:17)
- 1:10:03 — Chapter 25 (70:03)
- 1:13:23 — Chapter 26 (73:23)
- 1:14:54 — Chapter 27 (74:54)
- 1:17:38 — Chapter 28 (77:38)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT Open Courseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT Open Courseware at ocw.mit.edu.

**[0:24]:** All right. Should we get started? So, today, um, well, before I get started started, so, let me open up to questions. Do you all have questions from the last lecture where we finished off angular momentum?

**[0:45]:** Or really anything up to the the last exam.

**[0:52]:** Yeah. Um, so what exactly happens with the with the half L states? What happens with the half L states? Okay, great question. So, we're going to talk about that in some detail in a couple of weeks, but let me give you a quick pre-preview. So, remember that when we studied the commutation relations, uh, L plus or L uh, X L Y is I H bar L Z without using the representation in terms of derivatives with respect to a coordinate, without using the representations in terms of translations and rotations uh, along the sphere, right? When we just used the commutation relations and nothing else, what we found was that the states corresponding to these guys came in a tower with either one state corresponding to little L equals zero, or two states with L equals one half, or three states with little L equals one, or four states with L equals three halves, and so on and so forth.

**[1:53]:** And we quickly deduced that it is impossible to represent the half integer states with a wave function which represents a probability distribution on a sphere. We observed that was impossible and the reason is if you did so then you took when you take that wave function if you rotate by 2 pi in any direction if you rotate by 2 pi the wave function comes back to minus itself. But the wave function has to be equal to itself at the same point. The value of the wave function at some point is equal to the value of the wave function at some point. That means the value of the wave function must be equal to minus itself. That means it must be zero. So you can't write a wave function which is a probability distribution on a sphere if the wave function has to be equal to minus itself at any given point.

**[2:35]:** So this is a this is a strange thing we we sort of said well look these these are some other beasts. But the question is look these furnish perfectly reasonable towers of states respecting these commutation relations. So are they just wrong? Are they just meaningless? What we're going to discover is the following. And this is really going to go back to the very first lecture. And so we'll do this in more detail but I'm going to quickly tell you. Imagine you take a magnet. Okay, a little tiny bar magnet. Um in fact well imagine you take a little bar magnet with some uh little magnetization and you send it through a region that has a gradient for magnetic field. If there's a gradient so you know that a magnet wants to anti-align with the nearby magnet. North-south wants to go to south-north. So you can't put a force on the magnet but if you have a gradient of magnetic field then one end of a dipole one end of your magnet can feel a stronger effective torque than the other guy and

**[3:41]:** you can get a net force.

**[3:45]:** So you can get a net force. The important thing here is that if you have a magnetic field which has a gradient

**[3:54]:** So that you've got some large B here and some smaller B here. Then you can get a force and that force is going to be proportional to uh proportional to the mag- the how big your magnet is, but it's also going to be proportional to the magnetic field. And if the force is proportional to the strength of your magnet, then how far if you send this magnet through a region, it'll get deflected in one direction or the other. And how far it gets deflected deter- is determined by how big of magnet you sent through. You send in a bigger magnet, it deflects more. You want to go with that? Okay. Here's a funny thing. So that that's fact one. Fact two. Suppose I have uh a system which is um a charged particle moving in a circular orbit. Okay? A charged particle moving in a circular orbit.

**[4:45]:** Uh or better yet, well, better yet, imagine you have a sphere. This is a better model. Imagine you have a sphere of uniform charge distribution. Okay? Little gelatinous sphere of uniform charge distribution. And you make it rotate. Okay? So that's charge that's moving forming a current. And that current generates magnetic field along the axis of rotation. Right? Right hand rule. So if you have a charged sphere and it's rotating, you get a magnetic moment. And how big is a magnetic moment? It's proportional to the rotation to the angular momentum. Okay? So you determined that for a charged sphere, the it a charged sphere which is rotating with angular momentum, let's say L, has a magnetic moment which is proportional to L.

**[5:37]:** Okay? So let's put this together. Imagine we take a charged sphere, we send it rotating with some angular momentum, we send it through a field gradient, a gradient for magnetic field. What we'll see is we can measure that angular momentum by measuring the deflection. Because the bigger the angular momentum, the bigger the magnetic moment, but the bigger the magnetic moment, the bigger the deflection. Cool? So now here's the cool experiment.

**[6:03]:** Take an electron. Electron has some charge. Is it a little point-like thing? Is it a little sphere? Is it, you know, has Let's not ask that question just yet. It's an electron. It's the thing you get by ripping a negative charge off a hydrogen atom. So take your electron and send it through a magnetic field gradient. Why would you do this? Because you want to measure the magnetic You want to measure the the angular momentum of this electron. You want to see whether the electron is a little rotating thing or not. So you send it through this magnetic field gradient. And if it gets deflected, you will have measured the magnetic moment. And if you've measured the magnetic moment, you'll have measured the angular momentum. Okay? Here's the funny thing. If the electron weren't rotating, it would just go straight through, right? It would have no angular momentum and it would have no magnetic moment and thus it would not deflect.

**[6:51]:** Yeah? If it's rotating, it's going to deflect. Here's the experiment we do. And here's the experimental results. The experimental results are every electron that gets sent through bends. And it either bends up a fixed amount or it bends down a fixed amount. It never bends more, it never bends less, and it certainly never bends zero. In fact, it always makes two spots on the screen. Okay? Always makes two spots. It never hits the middle. No matter how you build this experiment, no matter how you rotate it, no matter what you do, it always hits one of two spots. What that tells you is the angular momentum, or rather the magnetic moment, can only take one of two values. But the angular momentum is just some geometric constant times the angular momentum. So the angular momentum must take one of two possible values. Everyone cool with that?

**[7:44]:** So, from this experiment glorified as the Stern-Gerlach experiment, from this experiment we discovered that the angular momentum LZ takes one of two values. L along whatever direction we're measuring, but let's say in the Z direction, uh L LZ takes one of two values. Plus some constant and you know, uh plus h bar upon two or minus h bar upon two. You just do this measurement. But, what this tells us is which state, which tower, which set of states describe an electron in this apparatus. L equals 1/2. But, wait. We started off by talking about the rotation of a charged sphere and deducing that the magnetic moment must be proportional to the angular momentum. And what we've just discovered is that this angular momentum the only sensible angular momentum here is the two-state tower which can't be represented in terms of rotations on a sphere. Yeah?

**[8:48]:** What we've learned from this experiment is that electrons carry a form of angular momentum demonstrably. Which is one of these angular momentum 1/2 states which never doesn't rotate, right? It always carries some angular momentum. However, it can't be expressed in terms of rotation of some spherical electron. It has nothing to do with rotations. If it can't we get this nonsensical thing with the wave function identically vanishes. So, there's some other form of angular momentum, a totally different form of angular momentum at least for electrons which again has the magnetic moment proportional to this angular momentum with some coefficient which I'll call mu naught.

**[9:31]:** But, I don't want to call it L because L we usually use for rotational angular momentum. This is a different form of angular momentum, which is purely half integer, and we call that spin.

**[9:44]:** And the spin satisfies exactly the same commutation relations. It's a vector Sx with Sy is equal to ih bar Sz. So, it's like an angular momentum in every possible way, except it cannot be represented S uh Z does not have any representation in terms of ih bar plan i dd phi. It is not related to a rotation. It's an intrinsic form of angular momentum. An electron just has it. So, this point you can ask me, "Look, what do you mean an electron just has it?" And my answer to that question is, if you send an electron through a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, it always hits one of two spots.

**[10:29]:** And that's it. Right? It's an experimental fact, and this is how we describe that experimental fact. And the legacy of these rotation of these little L equals 1/2 states is that they represent an internal form of angular momentum that only exists quantum mechanically, that you would have never noticed classically. That was a very long answer to it what was initially a simple question, but we'll come back and do this in more detail. This was just a quick intro. Yeah. So, for L equals 3/2, does that mean that there's four values of spin? Yeah, that means there's four values of spin. And so, there are plenty of particles in the real world that have L equals 3/2. They're not fundamental particles uh as far as we know. There are particles in nuclear physics that carry a spin 3/2. There are all sorts of nuclei that carry spin 3/2.

**[11:09]:** But uh we don't know of fundamental particle. Um if supersymmetry is true, then there must be a particle called a gravitino, which would be fundamental, and uh and would have spin 3/2 and four states. But uh that hasn't been observed yet. Other questions? Um was the ladder of seeing the successive states discovered first by the experiment, explained by the experiment. Oh, no. Oh, that's a great question. We'll come back to that at the end of phase. So, today we're going to do hydrogen among other things. Although I've taken so long talking about this, we might be a little slow. Um Uh we'll talk about that a little more when we talk about hydrogen, but it was observed and deduced from experiment before um it was understood that there was such a physical quantity. However, the observation that this commutation relation led to towers of states with this preexisted as a mathematical statement.

**[12:05]:** So, that was a mathematical observation from long previously. Um and it has a beautiful algebraic story and all sorts of nice things. Um but it hadn't been connected to the physics. Um and so the observation that the electron must carry some intrinsic form of angular momentum with one of two values, none none of neither of which is zero, uh was actually an experimental observation uh quasi-experimental observation um long before it was understood exactly how to connect this up. So, it wasn't I shouldn't say long. It was like within months, but whatever. Sorry. The the intent of the experiment wasn't to solve No, no. The the The experiment was this. There are um the spectrum Well, I'll tell you what the experiment was in a minute. Okay. Yeah. Um what was the Lz has to be plus or minus 1/2? Um what fixes the direction of the Z direction?

**[12:51]:** Excellent. Um the In this experiment, the thing that fixed the the fact that I was probing Lz is that I made the magnetic field have a gradient in the Z direction. So, what I was sensitive to since the the force is actually proportional to mu dot B. Yeah, really mu dot the gradient of B. So. We'll do this in more detail later. Um uh the gradient The direction of the gradient selects out which component of the angular momentum I'm looking at. So, in this experiment I'm measuring the angular momentum along this axis, which for fun I'll call Z. I could have called it X. What I discover is the angular momentum along this axis must take one of two values. But, the universe is rotationally invariant. So, it can't possibly matter whether I had done this direction the experiment in this direction or done the experiment in this direction.

**[13:32]:** What that tells you is in any direction, if I measure the angular momentum of the electron along that direction, I will discover that it takes one of two values.

**[13:43]:** This is also true of the L equals one states. LZ takes one of three values. What about LX? LX also takes one of three values, those three values. Is every state in the Is every system in a state corresponding to one of those particular values? No, it could be in a superposition, but the eigen values are these three eigen values. Regardless of whether it's LX or LY or LZ. Okay, it's a good thing to meditate upon. Anything else? One more, yeah.

**[14:19]:** Indeed. Indeed. Okay, since some people haven't taken the uh there will be a conflict if I'm later today, so I'm not going to discuss the exam yet. Okay, but very good observation and not an accident. Okay, so today we launch into 3D. We ditch our uh tricked out tricycle, and we're going to talk about real physical systems in three dimensions. And as we'll discover, it's basically the same as in one dimension, we just have to write down more symbols. But the content is all the same. So, this will make obvious the reason we worked with 1D up until now, which is that there's not a heck of a lot more to be gained for the basic principles, uh but it's a lot more annoying to write down the expressions. So, the first thing I wanted to do is write down the Laplacian in three dimensions um in in uh spherical coordinates.

**[15:12]:** And that is a beautiful abuse of notation. Um in spherical coordinates, uh and I want to note a couple of things. So, first off, this Laplacian, this can be written in the following form. Uh 1 over r uh dr r quantity squared. Okay, that's going to be very useful for us. Trust me on this one. Uh this is also known as uh 1 over r dr squared r. And this if you look back at your notes, this is nothing other than uh L squared except for the factor of h bar upon i, but if it's squared, it's minus 1 upon the h bar squared.

**[15:54]:** Okay. So, this horrible angular derivative is nothing but L squared.

**[16:02]:** Okay. And you should remember the d d theta is near these funny signs and cosines, but just go back and compare your notes. So, this is just an observation that the the uh Laplacian in three dimensions in spherical coordinates takes the simple form, a a simple radial derivative, which is two terms if you write it out linearly in this fashion, and uh one term if you write it this way, which is going to turn out to be useful for us. And the angular part can be written as 1 over r squared times the angular momentum squared with a minus 1 over h bar squared. Okay? So, and just to check, remember that Lz is equal to uh uh h bar upon i d phi. So, Lz squared is going to be equal to minus h bar squared d phi squared, and you can see that that's one contribution to this beast.

**[17:01]:** But, actually, let me uh I'm going to commit a capital sin and erase what I just wrote. So, I don't want it to distract you. Okay. So, with that useful observation I want to think about central potentials. I want to think about systems in 3D which are spherically symmetric because this is going to make this going to be a particularly simple class of systems and it's also particularly physical. Simple things like a harmonic oscillator in three dimensions which we solved in Cartesian coordinates earlier, we're going to solve later in spherical coordinates. Things like the the the isotropic harmonic oscillator, things like hydrogen where you don't where the system is rotationally independent, the force of the potential only depends on the radial distance all share a bunch of common properties and I want to explore those and along the way we'll solve a toy model for hydrogen.

**[17:49]:** So, the energy for this is P squared on 2M plus a potential which is a function only of the radial direct radial distance. But now P squared

**[18:04]:** is equal to - H bar squared times the gradient squared. But this is going to be equal to from the first term - H bar squared uh let me just write this out. Um uh uh do do do um do good. Um - H bar squared times R d r squared R and then from this term plus - H bar squared times - 1 over H bar squared L squared over R squared plus L squared over R squared.

**[18:47]:** Okay. So, the energy can be written in a nice form. This is - H bar squared 1 upon R d r squared R uh whoops, sorry, upon 2M cuz it's P squared upon 2M and from the second term L squared over R squared upon 2M plus 1 over 2M R squared L squared plus U of R. Okay, and this is the energy operator when the system is rotate is is rotationally invariant in spherical coordinates. Questions?

**[19:26]:** Yeah. So, this guy right here, is that the equal sign or minus like This? Yeah. Oh, that's an equal sign. So, sorry, this is just quick algebra, so it's useful to to note. So, consider the following thing, 1 over R DR R. Why would you ever care about such a thing? Well, let's square it. Okay. Cuz I did there. So, what does this equal to? Well, this is 1 over R DR R 1 over R DR R. These guys cancel, right? 1 over R times DR. So, this is equal to 1 over R DR squared R. But, why is this equal to DR squared plus two two over R times DR? And the answer is they're operators, and so you should ask how they act on functions. So, let's act how they ask act on functions. So, DR squared plus two over R DR times a function acting on a function is equal to f prime prime if this is a function of R plus two over R f prime.

**[20:24]:** On the other hand, 1 over R DR squared R acting on f of R Well, these derivatives can hit either the R or the f. So, there's going to be a term where both derivatives hit f, in which case the R's cancel and I get f prime prime. There's going to be two terms where one of the D's hits this, one of the D's hits this, then there's the other term. So, there are two terms of that form. One D hits the R and gives me one, one D hits the f and gives me f prime, and then there's an overall 1 over R plus two over R f prime and then there's a term where two D's hit the R but if two D's hit the R, that's zero. So, that's it. So, these guys are equal to each other. So, why is this a particularly useful form?

**[21:09]:** We'll see that in just a minute. So, I'm cheating a little bit by just writing this out and saying this is going to be useful form, but trust me, it's going to be useful form. Yeah. When you define P squared to be negative H bar R d r squared R, isn't that supposed to be 1 over R Oh shoot, yes, that's supposed to be 1 over R. Thank you. Thank you, yes, over R. Thank you. Yes, thank you for that typo correction. Excellent.

**[21:34]:** Thanks. Okay.

**[21:39]:** So,

**[21:45]:** So, anytime we have a system which is rotationally invariant, whose potential is rotationally invariant, we can write the energy operator in this fashion. And now you see something really lovely, which is that this only depends on R, this only depends on R, this depends on the angular coordinates, but only in so far as it depends on L squared. So, if we want to find the eigen functions of E, our life is going to be a lot easier if we work in eigen functions of L.

**[22:14]:** Because that's going to make this one E act on an eigenfunction of L, this is just going to become a constant. So, now you have to ask the question, well, can we? Can we find functions which are which are eigen functions of E and of L simultaneously? And so, the answer to that question is, well, compute the commutator. So, do these guys commute in particular with L squared? And well, does L commute with the derivative with respect to R, L squared?

**[22:40]:** Yeah, because L only depends on angular derivative, it doesn't have any L any R's in it, and the R's don't care about the angular variables, so they commute. What about with this term? Well, L squared trivially commutes with itself, and again, R doesn't matter. And ditto, R and L squared commute. So, this is zero, these commute, so we can can common eigen basis. We can find a basis of I of functions which are eigen functions both of E and of L squared.

**[23:17]:** So now we use separation. In particular, if we want to find a function, an eigen function of the energy operator E phi E is equal to um uh E phi E. It's going to simplify our lives if we take if we also let phi be an eigen function of um the L squared. But we know what the eigen functions of L squared are. phi E is equal to Let me write this of R is going to be equal to little phi of R

**[23:54]:** times YLM of theta and phi.

**[24:01]:** Okay. Now, quickly, because this is the angular the these are the eigen functions of the L squared operator. Quick, is little L an integer or half integer? Why? Yeah, cuz we're working with rotational angular momentum, right? And it only makes sense to talk about integer values of little L when we have gradients on a sphere when we're talking about rotations on a spherical coordinates. Okay? So little L has to be an integer.

**[24:31]:** And from this point forward in the class, anytime I write L, I'll be talking about the rotational angular momentum corresponding to integer values. And when I'm talking about the half integer values, I'll write down S. Okay? So let's use this Let's use this um separation of variables. And what does that give us? Well, L squared acting on YLM gives us H bar squared LL plus 1. So this tells us that E acting on phi E takes us a particularly simple form if phi E is proportional to spherical harmonic, then this is going to take the form minus H bar squared upon 2 M 1 over R dr squared R plus 1 over 2 mr squared L squared but L squared acting on the YLM gives us H bar squared LL plus 1 which is just a constant over R squared plus U of R.

**[25:42]:** phi E

**[25:53]:** Question? Yeah, don't you consider the states which are superpositions of YLM1 and YLM2? Absolutely. So we can we consider superpositions of these guys? Absolutely we can. However, we're using separation, so we're going to look at a single term and then after constructing solutions with a single eigenfunction of L squared we can then write down arbitrary superpositions of them and generate a complete basis of states. General statement about superposition separation of variables. Other questions? Okay. So here's our our our the resulting energy eigenvalue equation. But notice that it's now really nice. This is purely a function of R. We've we've removed all of the angular dependence by making it proportional to YLM. So this has a little phi YLM and this has a little phi YLM and nothing depends on the little phi. So I can make this just or depends on the YLM on the angular variables.

**[26:52]:** I can make this 5R.

**[26:57]:** 5R Okay? And if I want to make this the energy eigenvalue equation, instead of just the action of the energy operator, that is now my energy eigenvalue equation. This is the result of acting on phi with the energy operator and this is the energy eigenvalue. Okay? Cool. So, the upshot here is that when we have a central potential, when the system is rotationally invariant, it's invariant the the potential energy is invariant under rotations, then the energy commutes with the angular momentum squared, and so we can find common eigenfunctions. When we use separation of variables, the resulting energy eigenvalue equation becomes nothing but a 1D energy eigenvalue equation. Right? This is just a 1D equation. Now, you might look at this and say, "Well, it's not quite a 1D equation because if this were a 1D equation, we wouldn't have this funny 1/R and this funny R."

**[27:54]:** Right? It's not exactly what we would have got. Um and you know, it's got the - h-bar squared upon 2M. Um oops, and there's uh yeah, okay. There it's got these funny h-bar squared upon 2M. Um and it's got these 1/R Sorry, it's got the correct h-bar squared upon 2M, but it's got this funny R and 1/R. So, let's get rid of that. Let's just quickly dispense with that funny set of R. And this comes back to the sneaky trick I was referring to earlier of writing this expression. So, rather than writing this out, it's convenient to write it in this form. Let's see why. So, if we have that E phi of R is equal to uh h-bar squared upon 2M uh 1/R d squared uh R R uh plus and now what I'm going to write is Look, this is this is our

**[28:46]:** potential U have R. This is some silly uh radial dependent thing. I'm going to write these two terms together rather than writing them over and over and over again. I'm going to write them together and call them V effective. plus V effective of R where V effective is just these guys.

**[29:08]:** V effective Okay? Which has a contribution from the original potential and from the angular momentum, which notice the sign is plus 1 over R squared. So, the potential gets really large as you get up get to the origin.

**[29:24]:** phi of R

**[29:28]:** So, this R is annoying. This 1 over R is annoying, but there's a nice way to get rid of it. Let phi of R Well, this R we want to get rid of. So, let phi of R equal 1 over R um U of R. Okay? Then 1 over R squared or sorry, 1 over R dR squared R phi is equal to 1 over R dR squared R times 1 over R times U, which is just U. But, meanwhile, V on phi is equal to Well, V doesn't have any R derivatives. It's just a function. So, V on phi is 1 over R V on U. So, this equation becomes E on U because this also picks up a 1 over R is equal to minus h bar squared upon 2 m dR squared plus V effective of R U of R. Okay? And this is exactly the energy eigenvalue equation for a 1D problem with the following potential.

**[30:34]:** The potential V effective of R does the following two things. Whoops. don't want to drop that way. V effective of R. Suppose we have a potential which is um the Coulomb potential. So, let's say U is equal to - E squared upon R. Just as an example.

**[31:04]:** So, here's R. Here is V effective. So, U first. So, there's U. U of R. Let me draw this. V has another term, which is um H bar squared LL + 1 over 2 MR squared. This for any given value of L, this is a constant over R squared with a plus sign. So, that's something that looks like this. This is falling off like 1 over R. This is falling off like 1 over R squared. So, it falls off more rapidly. And finally, can R be negative?

**[31:44]:** No, it's defined from zero to infinity. So, that's like having an infinite potential for negative R. So, our effective potential is the sum of these contributions. Wish I had colored chalk. The sum of these contributions

**[32:01]:** is going to look like this. So, that's my V effective. This is my uh LL + 1 H bar squared over 2 M R squared, and this is my U of R. Question. Which U of R's are which? Good. Okay, so this is U of R, the original potential. Okay. Okay? This is 1 over L squared or sorry, LL + 1 over 2 MR squared.

**[32:36]:** Oh, shoot. Oh, I'm so I'm terribly sorry. I've I've abused notation terribly. Let's uh This is um uh uh uh crap. Sorry. Uh uh This is standard notation and in text, when I write this by hand, the potential is a big U and uh the wave function is a little U. So, let this be a little U. Okay, this is my little U. And so, now I'm going to have to Oh, jeez. This is horrible. Sorry. Um this is the potential, capital U with the bar underneath it. Okay, seriously. So, there's capital U with a bar underneath it. And um here's V, which is going to make my life easier, and this is the capital U with the bar underneath it. Capital U with the bar underneath it. Oh, I'm really sorry. I did not realize how confusing that would be. Um Okay, are Is everyone happy with that?

**[33:23]:** Yeah. W- Which one? Middle. Middle. Up. Up. That one. Where? The right there. Maybe I erase the one. Ah. So, this this is So, these are the wave function. I know. That That's the wave function. That is V. And uh uh It's there. You can erase the notation with the U at the end. Wait, if I erase it, how can I correct it? No, the middle equation on that board with the U and the area at the end. That's right. Yeah, there. Yeah. Excellent. So, the thing that isn't here would have a bar under it. Oh oh oh oh, sorry. Ah. You wouldn't think it would be so hard. Okay, good. And this is not the potential of the wave function. Okay, God. Oh, that's horrible. Um Sorry, guys. I That notation is not obvious. Um uh my apologies. Um Oh, there's there's an actual There's a better way to do this.

**[34:31]:** Okay, here's here's the better way to do this. Instead of calling the potential I'm sorry. I'm like your notes are getting destroyed now. So instead of calling the potential capital U, let's just call this V. Yeah. And then we have V effective. No, no, this is good. This is good. We can be careful about this. So this is V. This is V effective, which has V plus the angular momentum term. Oh, good lord. Um this is V effective. This is V. Uh V phi V U. Um good. This is V. There's no V underline. This is There's no V underline. It's not just uh V. Um V effective. Ugh. Good lord. Okay. Wow, that was an unnecessary confusion. It's top right. Top right.

**[35:20]:** U. Ugh. Is that V or V effective? That's V. Although it would have been just as true for V effective. So we can write V effective. It's true for both.

**[35:33]:** Cuz it's just a function of R. Ugh, for the love of god. Okay. Let's just Let's Let's check our sanity and walk through the logic. So the logic here is we have some potential. It's a function only of R. Yeah? As a consequence since it doesn't care about the angles, we can write things in terms of the spherical harmonics. Can do separation of variables. Here's the energy eigenvalue equation. We discovered that because we're we're working in spherical harmonics, the angular momentum term becomes just a function of R with no other coefficients. So now we have a function of R plus the potential V. This looks like an effective potential V effective, which is the sum of these two terms. So there's that equation. On the other hand, this isn't This is tantalizingly close to but not quite the energy eigenvalue equation for a 1D problem with this potential V effective.

**[36:18]:** To make it obvious that it's in fact a 1D problem, we do a change of variables. Phi goes to 1 over R U. And then 1 upon R D squared R phi becomes 1 over r d squared u, and v effective phi becomes 1 over r v effective u. Plugging that together gives us this energy eigenvalue equation for u, the effective wave function, which is a 1D problem. So, we can use all of our intuition and all of our machinery to solve this problem. And now we have to ask what exactly is the effective potential? And the effective potential has three contributions. First, it has the original v. Secondly, it has the angular momentum term, which is a constant over r squared. And here's that. Constant over r squared. And the sum of these is v effective. And this guy dominates cuz it's 1 over r squared.

**[37:05]:** This dominates at small r, and this dominates at large r if it's 1 over r. So, we get an effective potential that I'll check. There's the effective potential. Okay? Oi. And finally, the third fact is that r must be strictly positive. So, as a 1D problem, that means it can't be negative. It's got to have an infinite potential on the left.

**[37:33]:** Okay. So, So, as an example, let's go ahead and and think more carefully about specifically this problem, about this Coulomb potential and this 1D effective potential. Yeah. In your first term for EU, Yes. uh where does the 1 over r go? The 1 over r Good. So, the 1 over Remember that that d d r squared term gave us a 1 over r out front. So, from this term, there should be 1 over r here. From this term, there should also be a 1 over r. And from here, there should be a 1 over r. So, then I'm going to cancel the 1 over r by multiplying the whole equation by r. Yeah? Sneaky sneaky. So, anytime you see Anytime, this is a general lesson. Anytime you see an a differential equation that has this form, two derivatives plus one over R a derivative, you know you can play some game like this.

**[38:28]:** If you see this, declare in your mind a brief moment of triumph because you know what technique to use. You can do this sort of rescaling by a power of R. And more generally, if you have a differential equation that looks like um let me do the theory. If you have a differential equation that looks something like a derivative with respect to R plus a constant over R times phi, you know how to solve this. Right? Oops. Let me say plus uh dot dot dot phi. Uh you know how to solve this because it's DDR plus C over R means that phi, if there were nothing else, equals zero. If there were no other terms here, then this would say DDR plus C over R is phi. That means when you take a derivative it's like dividing by R and multiplying by C. That means phi goes like R to the minus C.

**[39:15]:** Right? But if phi goes like R to the minus C, that's not the exact solution to the equation, but I can write phi is equal to R to the minus C times U. And then this equation becomes DDR plus dot dot dot U equals zero. Okay? Very useful little trick. Um not really trick, it's just observation. And this is a second order version of the same thing. Very useful things to have in your back pocket um for moments of need. Okay? So, let's pick up um let's pick up with um with this guy. So, let me give you a little name for this. So, this term that comes from the angular momentum bit. This originally came from the kinetic energy, right? It came from the L squared over R, which was from the gradient squared energy. This is a kinetic energy term. Why is there a kinetic energy term?

**[40:09]:** Well, what this is telling you is that if you have some angular momentum, if little L is not equal to zero, then as you get closer and closer to the origin, the potential energy is getting very, very large. And this should make sense. If you're spinning and you pull in your arms, you have to do work, right? You have to pull those guys in that take you you speed up. You're increasing your kinetic energy due to conservation of angular momentum. Right? If you have rotational invariance, as you bring in your hands, you're increasing the kinetic energy. And so this angular momentum barrier is just an expression of that. It's just saying that as you come to smaller and smaller radius, holding the angular momentum fixed, your your velocity, your angular velocity must increase, your kinetic energy must increase, and we're calling that a potential term just because we

**[40:52]:** can. Cuz we've worked with definite angular momentum. Okay? This you did this you should have done this in classical mechanics as well. Um but um well, you should have done it in classical mechanics. So this is called the angular momentum barrier. Quick question. Classically, if you take a charged particle uh around in a Coulomb potential. Classically, it that system decays, right? It radiates away energy. Does the angular momentum barrier save us from decaying?

**[41:28]:** Is that why hydrogen is stable?

**[41:37]:** No one wants to stake a claim here? Is hydrogen stable because of conservation of angular momentum? No. Absolutely not, right? So first off, in your first problem set when you did that calculation, that particle had angular momentum. So um and it can radiate that away through electromagnetic interactions. So that didn't save us. Uh angular momentum won't save us. Another way to say this is that we can construct and we just explicitly see we can construct a state with which has little L equals zero, in which case the angular momentum barrier is zero over R squared. So it says nothing. Angular momentum barrier is not what preserve what keeps you from decaying. And the reason is that the electron can radiate away energy and angular momentum and so L will decrease and decrease. I can still fall down. So, we still need a reason for why the hydrogen system quantum mechanically is stable.

**[42:32]:** Why do things exist? So, let's answer that question.

**[42:38]:** So, what I want to do now is I want to solve Do I really want to do that way? Um Well, actually before we do it, um let's consider some last general conditions general facts for central potentials. So, let's look at some general facts for central potentials.

**[43:01]:** So, the first is regardless of what the potential the bare potential was, just due to the angular momentum barrier, uh we have this 1 over r squared behavior near the origin. So, we can look at this we can ask look what are the boundary conditions at the origin? What's What must be true of U of R near the origin? Near U of R or sorry, near R goes to zero.

**[43:36]:** What must be true

**[43:41]:** of U of R?

**[43:47]:** Okay. So, the right way to ask this question is not to look at this U of R which is not actually the wave function, but to look at the actual wave function psi sub E which goes near R equals zero like U of R over R.

**[44:05]:** So, what should be true of you?

**[44:10]:** Can you diverge? Is that physical? Does U have to vanish? Can it take a constant value? So, I've given you a hint by telling you that I want to think about there being an infinite potential, but why? Why is that the right thing to do?

**[44:27]:** Well, imagine U of R went to a constant value near the origin. If U of R goes to a constant value near the origin, then the wave function diverges near the origin. That's maybe not so bad. Maybe it has a 1/R singularity. All right, it's not totally obvious that that's horrible. What's so bad about having a 1/R behavior? So, suppose U goes to a constant.

**[44:58]:** Um so, phi goes to constant over R. What's so bad about this?

**[45:14]:** So, let's look back at the kinetic energy. P is equal to the kinetic energy is going to be minus H bar squared D squared. So, the energy is going to go like P squared over 2M D squared. But, here's an important fact. D squared, the Laplacian of 1/R Well, it's easy to see what this is at a general point. At a general point, D squared is D squared has a term that looks like 1/R D squared R R. So, 1/R D squared R D squared R times R on 1/R. Well, R times 1/R, that's just one. And this is zero. Right? So, the gradient squared of 1 over r is zero. Except can that possibly be true at r equals zero? No, because what's the second derivative at zero? As you approach the the origin from any direction, the function is going like 1 over r.

**[46:21]:** Right? So, it's growing. But, it's growing in every direction. So, what's its first derivative at the origin? It's actually ill-defined. Right? The first derivative is because it depends on the direction you come in. The first direction come in this way, the derivative looks like it's becoming this. From this direction, it's becoming this. It's actually badly divergent. So, what's the second derivative? Well, the second derivative has to go as you go across this point telling you how the first derivative changes. But, it changes from plus infinity in this direction to plus infinity in this direction. That's badly singular. So, this can't possibly be true what I just wrote down here. And in fact, D squared on 1 over r, and this is a very good exercise for recitation, uh is equal to delta of r. It's zero. It's clearly zero for r not equal zero, but at the origin, it's divergent, and it's divergent in exactly the way you need to get the the delta function.

**[47:22]:** Okay? Which is pretty awesome. So, what that tells us is that if we have a wave function that goes like 1 over r, then the energy contribution energy acting on this wave function gives us a delta function at the origin. So, unless you have a potential which is a delta function at the origin, nothing will cancel this off. You can't possibly satisfy the energy eigen value equation. So, u of r must go to zero at r goes to zero. Because if it goes to a constant, any constant, we get a bad divergence in the energy. Yeah? In particular, if we calculate the energy, we'll discover that um that the energy is badly divergent if it does not function divergent if we don't have uh U going to zero. So, notice, by the way, as a side note, that since phi goes like phi is equal to U over R, that means that phi goes to a constant.

**[48:31]:** This is good because what this is telling us is that the wave function, so it's true that U is vanishing, but the probability density, which is the wave function squared, doesn't have to vanish. That's about the derivative of U as you approach the origin from L'Hopital's rule. So, this is the first general fact about um central potentials.

**[49:01]:** So, the next one, and this is really the fun one. Good lord. Um is that note Sorry. Two. The energy depends

**[49:17]:** on L, but not on M.

**[49:30]:** Okay. Just explicitly, in the energy eigenvalue equation, we have the angular momentum showing up in the effective potential, little L. But little M appears absolutely nowhere except in the our choice of spherical harmonic. For any different M, and this was pointed out before, for any different M, we would have got the same equation. And that means that the energy eigenvalue can depend on L, but it can't depend on M. Right? So, that means for each M each M in the allowed possible values L, L minus 1 minus L and this is 2 L plus 1 possible values. For each of these M's, the energy is the same.

**[50:20]:** And I'll call this E sub L because um uh the energy can depend on L. Why? The degeneracy of E sub L is equal to 2 L plus 1.

**[50:47]:** Why? Why do we have this degeneracy?

**[50:55]:** Yeah, exactly. We get the degeneracies when we have symmetries. Right? When we have a symmetry we get a degeneracy. And so, here we have a degeneracy and this degeneracy isn't fixed by rotational invariance. And why is this the right thing? Rotational symmetry. So, why did this give us this degeneracy? Well, what the rotational degeneracy is saying is, "Look, if you've got some total angular momentum, the energy can't possibly depend on whether most of it's in Z or most of it's in X or most of it's in Y." It can't possibly depend on that, but that's what M is telling you. M is telling you what fraction is contained in a particular direction. So, rotational symmetry immediately tells you this, but there's a nice way to phrase this, which is the following. Look, what is rotational symmetry? Rotational symmetry is the statement that the energy doesn't care about rotations and in particular it must commute with L X and with L Y

**[51:48]:** and with LZ.

**[51:53]:** Right? So, this is rotational symmetry.

**[52:00]:** And I'm going to interpret these in a nice way. So, this guy

**[52:09]:** tells me that I can find common eigen functions. And more to the point, a full common eigen basis of E and LZ. Can I also find a common eigen basis of E, LZ, and LY?

**[52:29]:** Are there common eigen vectors of E, LZ, and LY?

**[52:36]:** No. How Are there common eigen functions of LZ and LY? No, cuz they don't commute. Right? E commutes with each of these. Okay, so I'm just going to say I'm going to pick a common eigen basis of E and LZ, but I could have picked LX, or I could have picked LY. I'm just picking LZ cuz that's our convention. But notice what are these two? Once I've chosen this, I'm going to work with a common eigen basis of E and LZ. What do these two commutators tell me? These two commutators tell me that E commutes with LX + ILY and LX - ILY, L plus minus. Right? So, this tells you that if you have an eigen functions of E and you act with a raising operator, you get another eigen function of E. And thus we get our 2L + 1 degeneracy cuz we can walk up and down the tower using L plus and L minus.

**[53:19]:** Cool? Okay. So, this is a nice example that when you have a symmetry

**[53:30]:** you get a degeneracy and and and vice versa.

**[53:36]:** Okay. So, let's do some examples of using these uh central potentials. Yeah.

**[53:52]:** Um it's zero. It's it's so E with LX is zero. E with LY So are you happy with that statement that E with LX is zero? Yeah. Good. Okay, and so this is zero because this is just LX plus I LY. So E with LX is zero and E with LY is zero. So E commutes with these guys. And so this is like the statement that L squared with L plus minus equals zero.

**[54:17]:** Cool. Okay, so let's do some examples. So the first example is going to be Actually, I'm going to skip the spherical well example. Um cuz it's just not that interesting, but uh It's in the notes and I you really need to look at it. Oh hell, yes, I'm going to do it. Okay, so spherical well. So I'm going to do it in an abridged form and maybe it's a good thing for recitation.

**[54:45]:** Thank you, recitation leader. Um so in the spherical well, what's the potential? So here's V of R. Not U bar and not U V effect, just V of R. Okay? And the potential is going to be this. So here's R equals zero. And if it's a spherical infinite well, then I'm going to say the potential is infinite outside of some distance L. Okay? And it's zero inside.

**[55:16]:** So what does this give us? Well, the the In order to solve the system, we know that the first thing we do is we separate out with YLMs. And then we rescale by one over R to get the function of U and we get this equation. Which is E on U is equal to minus H bar squared upon 2 uh dr squared and plus v effective well plus l l plus one uh over r squared with a 2m and an h bar squared uh and the potential is zero inside so we can just write this okay

**[56:02]:** so this is if you just only pull out the h bar squareds over 2m comes minus l plus one over r squared

**[56:16]:** okay so this is not a terrible differential equation and one can do some good work to solve it um but it's a harder differential equation that I want to spend the time to study right now so I'm just going to consider the case special case when there's zero angular momentum little l equals zero okay so in the special case of l equals zero e and I should call this u sub l u sub l e u sub zero is equal to uh h bar squared upon 2m and now this term is gone the angular momentum barrier is gone cuz there's no angular momentum dr squared ul which can be written succinctly as ul or sorry u zero prime prime cuz it's only a function of r so now this is a ridiculously easy equation we know how to solve this equation right this is saying that the energy a constant times u is two derivatives

**[57:11]:** times this constant so u zero can be written as a cosine of kx or sorry kr plus b sine of kr where h bar squared k squared on 2m equals E. And I should really call this E sub zero because it could depend on little L. zero Okay. So, there's our momentary solution. However, we have to satisfy our boundary conditions, which is that it's got to vanish at the origin, but it's also going to vanish at the wall. So, uh boundary conditions U of zero equals zero tells us that A must be equal to zero. And U of L equals zero tells us that um well, if this is zero, we've just got B, but sine of KR evaluated at L, which is sine of KL, must be equal to zero. So, KL must be a zero of sine must be n pi uh over uh it must be equal to n pi, a multiple of pi.

**[58:27]:** And so, this tells you what the energy is. So, this is just like the 1D system, right? It's just exactly like the 1D system. So, now to finally close this off what does this tell you what the the um uh the uh uh eigenfunctions are?

**[58:46]:** And let me do that here. So, therefore the wave function phi sub E zero uh of R theta and phi Oh god.

**[59:06]:** Jesus. This is so much easier in LaTeX. Um so, phi sub E zero of R theta and and phi is equal to uh Y L Y zero M, but what must M be? Zero because M goes from plus L to minus L. zero uh

**[59:31]:** I'm just not writing the argument. Y 0 0 * not U of R, it's times 1 over R times U. 1 over R times U of R. But U of R is a constant times sine of KR.

**[59:51]:** Sine of KR, but K is equal to n pi over L. n pi over L R. Okay, and what's Y 0 0? It's a constant. And so, there's an overall normalization constant that I'll call N. Okay. So, we get that our wave function is 1 over R times sine of n pi over LR. So, this looks bad. There's a 1 over R. Why is this not bad? At the origin, why is this not something I should worry about? Yeah, cuz sine is linear for small values of its argument. So, this goes like n pi over L times R. That R cancels the 1 over R. So, near the origin this goes like a constant. Yeah? So, U has a zero, but the wave function doesn't. Cool? Okay. So, um this has a very nice uh more general story for larger L um which uh uh yeah.

**[1:00:55]:** Which I hope you see in the recitation. Okay. Questions on this the spherical well? So, the whole point Oh, yeah, go.

**[1:01:17]:** Uh that's true. That's So, good. So, let me rephrase the question and tell me if this is the same question. So, this is strange. There's nothing special about the origin. So, why do I have a zero at the origin of my Is that the question? Okay. There's It's true. There's nothing special about the origin except for the two things. One thing that's special about the origin is we're working in a system which has rotational symmetry. But, rotational symmetry is rotational symmetry around some particular point. So, there's always a special central point anytime you have rotational symmetry. It's the point fixed by the rotations. So, actually the origin is a special point here. Second, saying that little U has a zero is not the same as saying that the wave function has a zero. Little zero little U has a zero, but it gets multiplied by 1/R.

**[1:01:59]:** So, the wave function in fact is not zero there. So, the physical thing is the probability distribution, which is the norm squared of the wave function, and it doesn't have a zero at the origin. That That satisfy? Yes. Okay. So, the origin is special when you have a central potential. That's where the proton is, right? Right. Okay. So, there there there is something special about the origin. Um wow, that was a really anti-Keplerian sort of argument. Um uh So, that Okay. So, that's where the proton So, So, there is something special about the origin, and the wave function doesn't vanish there even if U does. It may vanish there, but it doesn't necessarily have to. And we'll see that in a minute. Other questions? Yeah. So, what again was our reasoning for saying that the that U of R has to vanish at zero at R?

**[1:02:50]:** Good. The reason that U of R had to vanish at the origin is that if it doesn't vanish at the origin, then the wave function diverges um uh whoops, if phi goes to constant. Uh Oh, yeah. So, this implies phi. If the wave function If U doesn't go to zero, if it goes to any constant non-zero, then the wave function diverges, and if we calculate the energy, we get a delta function at the origin. So, there's an infinite contribution of energy at the origin. That's not physical. So, in order to get a sensible wave function with finite energies, we need to have the U vanishes because of the one over U. And the reason that we said it had to vanish at L was because I was considering the spherical well, spherical infinite well, where a particle is stuck inside a region of radius capital L, and that's just what I

**[1:03:35]:** mean by saying I have an infinite potential. Okay. Cool? Yeah. Others? Okay. So, with all that done, we can now do the hydrogen or the Coulomb potential. And I want to emphasize that we often use the following words when people often use the following words when solving this problem. We will now solve the problem of hydrogen. This is false. I am not about to solve for you the problem of hydrogen. I am going to construct for you a nice toy model, which turns out to be an excellent first pass at explaining the properties observed in hydrogen gases, their emission spectrum, and their physics. This is a model. It is a bad model. It doesn't fit the data, but it's pretty good, and we'll be able to improve it later, okay? So, it is the solution of the Coulomb potential. And what I want to emphasize to you, I cannot say this strongly enough, physics is physics is a process of building models that do a good job of predicting.

**[1:04:36]:** And the better the predictions, the better the model. But, they're all wrong. Every single model you ever get from physics is wrong. There are just some that are less stupidly wrong. Some are a better approximation to the data, okay? This is not hydrogen. This is going to be our first pass at hydrogen. It's the Coulomb potential. Okay. And the Coulomb Coulomb potential V of R is equal to minus E squared over R. This is what you would get if you had a classical particle with infinite mass and charge plus E, and then another particle over here with mass little m and charge minus e. And you didn't pay too much attention to things like relativity or spin or you know, lots of other things. And you have no background magnetic field or electric field and anything else. And if these are point particles and all of those things are false that I just said.

**[1:05:32]:** But if all those things were true, in that imaginary universe, this would be the salient uh problem to solve. So, let's solve it. Now, are they all those things that I said that were false? Uh proton a point particle, the proton is infinitely massive, there's no spin. Are those preposterously stupid? No. No, they're excellent approximations in a lot of situations. So, they're not crazy wrong, they're just not exactly correct. I want to keep this in your mind. These are going to be good models, they're not exact. So, we're not solving hydrogen, we're going to solve this idealized Coulomb potential problem. Okay, so let's solve it. So, if v is minus e over r squared, then the equation for the uh for the rescaled wave function u becomes minus h bar squared upon 2m u prime prime of r uh plus the effective potential, which is

**[1:06:24]:** h bar squared upon 2m uh l l plus 1 over r squared uh minus e squared over r u is equal to e sub l u. So, there's the the equation we want to solve. We've already used separation of variables and we know that the wave function is this little u times 1 over r times ylm for some l and some m. So, the first thing we should do anytime you're solving an interesting problem, the first thing you should do is do dimensional analysis. Okay? And if you do dimensional analysis, the units of e squared, well, this is easy. E squared must be an energy times a length. So, this is an energy times a length. Also known as P squared L, momentum squared over 2M two times a mass times a length. It's useful to put things in terms of mass, momentum, and lengths cuz you can cancel them out.

**[1:07:20]:** H bar has units of P times L. And what's the only other parameter we have? We have the mass, which has units of uh mass. Okay? And so, from this we can build two nice quantities. The first is we can build our knot. We can build something with units of a radius. And I'm going to choose the factors of two judiciously. H bar squared over 2M E squared. Oops. E squared. So, let's just make sure this has the right units. E squared has units of energy times a length. But H bar squared over 2M has units of P squared L squared over 2M. So, that has units of energy times a length squared. So, length squared over a length this has units of length. So, this is good. So, there's a parameter that has units of length. And from this, it's easy to see that we can build a characteristic energy by taking E squared and dividing it by this length scale.

**[1:08:17]:** And so, then the energy, which I'll call E knot uh which is equal to E squared over R knot is equal to uh 2M E to the fourth over H bar squared. Okay. So, before we do anything else, without solving any problems, we can immediately can do a couple of things. The first is if you take the system and I ask you, "Look, what do you expect This is a quantum mechanical a 1D problem in quantum mechanics with a potential and we know something about 1D quantum mechanical problems. I guess this guy. We know something about 1D quantum mechanical problems, which is that the ground state has what energy? Some finite energy. It doesn't have infinite negative energy. It's got some finite energy. What do you expect to be roughly the ground state energy of the system? Minus E naught. Yeah, right. Roughly minus E naught.

**[1:09:09]:** That seems like a pretty good guess. It's the only dimensionally sensible thing. Maybe we're off by factors of two. But maybe that's you know, maybe it's minus E naught. So that's a good guess. A first thing before we do any calculation. And if you actually take mu E to the fourth over H bar squared, this is off by unfortunately a factor of four. This is equal to four times the binding energy, which is also called the Rydberg constant. I want to make sure I get my factors of two right. Yep, I'm off by factor of four. I'm off by factor of four from what we'll call the Rydberg energy, which is 13.6 eV. And this is the observed binding energy of hydrogen. So before we do anything, before we solve any equation, we have a fabulous estimate of the binding energy of of hydrogen, right?

**[1:10:03]:** All the work we're about to do is going to be to deal with this factor of four. Right? Which I mean is important, but I just want to emphasize how much you get just from doing dimensional analysis. Immediately upon knowing the rules of quantum mechanics, knowing that this is the equation you should solve, without ever touching that equation, just dimensional analysis gives you this answer. Okay? Which is fabulous.

**[1:10:27]:** So, with that motivation, let's solve this problem. Oh, by the way, what do you think what do you think a naught is a good approximation to? Well, it's a length scale. What? Yeah, it's probably something like the expectation value of the radius. Or maybe the radius squared cuz the expectation value of the radius is probably zero. Okay. So, let's solve this system. And at this point, I'm not going to actually solve out the differential equation in detail. I'm just going to tell you how the solution goes because solving it is a sort of involved undertaking. And so here's the first thing. So we look at this equation. So we have this differential equation, this guy. And I want to solve it. So think back to the to the harmonic oscillator when we did the brute force force method of solving the hydrogen system. Okay? When we did the brute force method brute force method she sells seashells.

**[1:11:26]:** When the brute force method of solving what did we do? We first did we did asymptotic analysis. We extracted the overall asymptotic form at infinity and at the origin to get a nice regular differential equation that didn't have any funny singularities. And then we did a series approximation. Okay? Now, do most differential equations have a simple closed-form expression a solution? No, most differential equations have some you know, maybe if you're lucky it's a special function that people have studied in detail. But most don't have a simple solution like a Gaussian or a power law or something. Most of them just have some complicated solution. This is one of those miraculous differential equations where we can actually exactly write down the solution by doing a series approximation having done asymptotic analysis. So let's first off So the first thing we're doing dimensional analysis too, let's make these dimension let's make everything dimensionless.

**[1:12:20]:** Okay, and it's easy to see what what the right thing to do is take R and make it dimensionless by pulling out a factor of rho or of R not. So our pick our new variable is going to be called rho. This is dimensionless. Um and the second thing is I want to take the energy and I want to write it as minus E naught times some dimensionless energy epsilon. So these guys are my dimensionless variables. And when you go through and you do that, the equation you get is minus d rho squared um uh plus L L plus 1 over rho squared minus 1 over rho plus epsilon U is equal to zero. Okay? So, the form of this difference equation is Okay, it's not different in any deep way, but it's a little bit easier. This is going to be the easier way to to deal with this rather than to deal with any stupid constant.

**[1:13:11]:** And so now let's do the brute force thing. Three. Asymptotic analysis.

**[1:13:23]:** Okay. And here I'm just going to write down the answers. And the reason is First off, this is something you should either do in recitation or see a go through on your own, but this is just the mathematics of solving a differential equation. This is not the important part. So, when rho goes to infinity, which terms dominate? Well, this is not terribly important. This is not terribly important. That term is going to dominate.

**[1:13:49]:** And if we got that D rho squared plus U, rho goes to infinity, these two terms dominate. Well, two derivatives of it is a constant. You know what those solutions look like. They'll say exponentials with exponential being root with the power, the exponent, sorry, being root epsilon. So, U is going to go like E to the minus square root epsilon rho. For normalizability, I picked the minus. I could have picked the plus. That would have been divergent. Okay. So, as rho goes to zero what happens? Well, as rho goes to zero, this is insignificant and this totally dominates over this guy.

**[1:14:29]:** On the other hand, if L is equal to zero, then this is the only term that survives. So, you'd better make sure that that behaves gracefully. As rho goes to zero, asymptotic analysis is going to tell us that U goes like rho. Well, two derivatives, we pull down a rho squared. And so, two derivatives in this guy, we pull down an L then an L plus 1. So, this should go like rho to the L plus one.

**[1:14:54]:** There's also another term. Uh so, in the same way that there were two solutions to this guy asymptotically, one growing, one one decreasing, here there's another solution which is rho to the minus L that also does it because we get minus L, then minus minus L minus one, which gives us a plus L L plus one. But, that is also badly divergent at the origin. It goes like one over zero to the L. That's bad. So, these are my solutions. Okay. So, this tells us having done this analysis, we should write that U is equal to uh rho to the L plus one times e to the minus root epsilon rho times some remaining function which I'll call V little V. Little V of rho. And this asymptotically should go to a constant near the origin and something that behave that uh vanishes slower than uh uh than an exponential uh at infinity.

**[1:15:46]:** So, then we take this and we do our series expansion.

**[1:15:54]:** So, we take that expression, we plug it in. At that point, all we're doing is a change of variables. We plug it in and we get a re- resulting differential equation. Uh rho V prime prime plus two one plus L minus root epsilon rho uh V prime plus one minus two root epsilon L plus one V equals zero. So, this is the resulting difference equation for this little V guy. And we do an a series expansion. V is equal to sum over uh sum from J equals zero infinity of A sub j r to the j Plug this guy in here. Just like in the case of the harmonic oscillator equation and get a series expansion. Now um Okay, now let me write it out this way. um do do do Yes. um And the series expansion has a solution which is a sub j plus one.

**[1:17:05]:** This is actually kind of a fun process. So, if you, you know like quick little calculations, this is a sweet little calculation to take this expression, plug it in, and derive this uh recursion relation, which is root or two root epsilon times uh j plus l plus one minus one over uh j plus one j plus two l plus two uh a j

**[1:17:38]:** So, here's our series expansion. And in order for this to terminate terminate

**[1:17:48]:** we must have that some a j max plus one is equal to zero. So, one of these guys must eventually vanish. And the only thing that's changing is little j. So, what that tells us is that for some maximum value of little j root two epsilon times j maximum plus l plus one is equal to minus one. So, that gives us a relationship between overall j max, little l, and the energy. And when if you go through, what you discover is that the energy is equal to one over four n squared, where n is equal to uh j max plus l plus one. And what this tells us is that the energy is labeled by an integer n and an integer l and an integer m. Right, these are from the spherical harmonics, and n came from the series expansion, and it's equal to minus E naught over four n squared independent of l and m.

**[1:18:58]:** And so, by solving the differential equation exactly, which in this case we kind of magically can, what we discover is that the energy eigenvalues are indeed exactly 1/4 of E naught. And they're spaced with the 1/n squared, which does two things. Not only does that explain, so let's think about the consequences of this very briefly, not only does that explain the minus 13.6 eV, not only does that explain the binding energy of hydrogen as is observed, but it does more. Remember in the very beginning, one of the experimental facts we wanted to explain about the universe was that the spectrum of light for off hydrogen

**[1:19:43]:** went like E naught over four n squared.

**[1:19:51]:** This was the Rydberg relation.

**[1:19:56]:** And now we see that explicitly. So, we've solved for that expansion. But, there's a real puzzle here. On purely on very general grounds, we derived earlier that when you have a rotationally invariant potential, a central potential, every energy should be degenerate with degeneracy 2l + 1. It can depend on l, but it must be independent of m. But, here we've discovered, first off, we fit a nice bit of experimental data, but we've discovered the energy is in fact not just independent of m, but it's independent of l, too. Why? What symmetry is explaining this extra degeneracy? We'll pick there up next time.
