Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu okay so up until now uh in many ways we've uh thought about people as individuals we've you know how they see how they remember their personality uh things you can measure by IQ tests um uh uh if they have Psychopathology or not we we've primarily focused on people as sort of individual agents in the world and for this lecture for the next lecture we're going to flip over and think about people as they interact with other people and here's a all the way back from 1962 here's a sort of an example and you know so many from your so much from your life but of of how powerfully we're influenced by other people in our Behavior this is so this is a story of uh the rules elevator rules you guys know elevator rules right you get an elevator what are you supposed to be so you don't make other people uncomfortable or they don't make you yeah which way you're facing not too close in space right if there's only two of you and the other person huddles right next to you go hm H right okay so uh anyway here we go so I was a graduate student in brain and cognitive science and I got minimally exposed to social psychology I was actually a teaching assistant I must have heard something about it uh but it wasn't until I was teaching at Stanford which is full of famous social psychologists and I was hearing them give their introductory psychology lectures that I got a Amazed by what social psychologists have discovered about human nature uh and maybe because I was exposed to it in one shot it really changed for me personally how I try to think about people from that day forward so let's see if it does it for you right and in many ways we're going to do today the core core famous most famous things in Psychology the the Stanford uh zimbardo Prison Experiment The mgrm Obedience experiment and a theme you'll see is how funny we are as humans in our desire to want to fit in so what is social psychology the scientific study of the way in which our thoughts feelings and behaviors are influenced by the real or imagined presence of other people so it's how we relate to other people and to a certain extent you know if you compare to things like Linguistics or other or or or or other aspects of psychology it seemed social things have seemed you know weakish but uh people have been thinking in the last decade more or more that maybe many things that make humans humans have been pulled by powerful social relations that occur in groups of humans and so for example looking across primate species just across primates here's the average size of the social group here's the average size of the neocortex and it's a pretty good fit uh and so you can think back in the course of examples for example the infant who's willing to crawl across a dangerous visual Cliff if the mother has a positive facial expression you know risking uh injury at or more worse because you have a social cue that says it's okay and you're just an infant interpreting that so more and more is a thought that many of the abilities we have how we work together how we communicate together are driven by our fundamental social character and so we'll talk today about uh uh the power of the situation this is what's this is a big idea in social psychology is that people's behavior can be phenomenally altered by the situation they're in um and we'll talk about attribution how we decide whether a person behaves because a certain way because of their character or the situation they're in the fundamental attribution error uh Conformity compliance obedience and bystanders and I think every there's so many experiments here that amaze me uh uh and are still completely relevant today and I'll convince you of that so a thing we engage in all the time as humans is interpreting the actions and words of others why did somebody do something right that that fills our lives our families our teachers our friends our co-workers why did somebody do do something or say something why is that person looking at me friendly across the room right so the causal uh attribution you know what is driving that person's thoughts what's in their mind that's making them to behave that way and uh there's at least two kinds of of of explanations one of them is character so personality psychology is all about that the character of the person is making them behave that way because they're outgoing or because they're shy or whatever so Jeremiah helps the elderly person across the street because he's a really nice guy zven had a hard time solving the puzzle because he's kind of a dummy right to makeing money to the boy boy is she nice and generous right that's the personality predisposition interpretation um so that's that's the who she is or he is that or they're behaving that way because they're in a particular situation so Jeremiah helped the erly man across the street because his friends are breaking in to the apartment the guy's leaving behind okay or there's another person there he's trying to impress that person what a swell guy he is Spen had a hard time solving the puzzle because it was an impossible puzzle okay he didn't get nearly enough sleep the situation she gave money to the boy uh uh because that you know he's the drug dealer okay he he's a career running I okay whatever it's a situation okay so you know you pick it but you all of a sudden interpretation completely changes as to what's going on about character versus situation so where does the behavior come from the predis the dispositions of an individ idual or the situation they're in personality psychologists focus on this social psychologists focus on this and they will argue that this dominates everything this dominates everything um not the only thing but it dominates everything so let's consider then in one other way so uh let's say that you are late for an appointment with me so what do I start to think is I'm sitting there waiting for you and you don't email me you don't call me uh uh you might think well this person is a bit inconsiderate a bit disorganized a bit unmotivated it would not be a good idea for example to show up for a job interview late for your appointment right why because we don't want them to think we're disorganized and considered or unmotivated okay until we're hired um so that's the other person right like why aren't they here there something you know they're messing up and there's something not good about their character but imagine when you're late why are you late because you're disorganized inconsiderate and unmotivated no because something came up situation right the traffic was worse than you could have imagined right uh last minute it was an email you know that you had to respond to or your parent called or whatever some situation made you late and what I'm going to show you in a moment is that a very fundamental thing about people in fact called the fundamental attribution error is that we're biased to interpret the actions of others as revealing their character whereas we're biased to uh interpret our own actions as being driven by the situation we're in um so lot of this work Lee Ross was the one who came up with this term the fundamental attribution error the other person is driven by character we and that's how we interpret why they do things we give ourselves a break on the by the situation and so what they did is they ran experiments where they wanted to make it incredibly clear to Stanford undergraduate research participants incredibly clear that the situation was dominant and showed that even then even when you know for certain it's a situation and you know as much as you can possibly know you tend to ascribe character to people okay so they had students run in pairs and they were truly randomly flected to be a quiz master or a contestant two students at a time the quiz Master once and comes up with questions and the contestant has to answer so they could answer who were the two inventors of calculus and you know the answer might be it's probably You could argue some things about this right but look you know this is students it's sort of unfair that we get to ask you the question so I get to ask you something like what's the structure just in front of the hippocampus that's important for emotional memory and you might answer oh no oh no that was on the previous test it's not cumulative okay and you know I go it's the amigdala and I've worked in that field for 30 years and I feel pretty proud of knowing that little fact okay now uh I need a Student's Hand to go up to okay now you asked me a question that you think I might struggle on and believe me there's an infinite number outside the location of the amigdala pick one from physics or math or chemistry you're going to embarrass me but make it really hard so I don't look so bad there's what sorry a football match this weekend in England a football match this weekend in England between two of the top in the Premier League won Manchester no okay I just made that up okay no I don't know no here's the point if I ask questions I know the answer that I pick the question right and you may or may not know it if you pick if you create the question you know there's a pretty good chance I won't know it right okay so inherently when somebody is the quiz Master they're going to know the answer and the other person may or may not know it pretty good chance they don't as they make up questions you know that right logically you know that so uh the setup with and and the students were only correct 40% of the time not bad who were answering the questions spontaneously made up by the randomly selected quiz master so this is this is experiment knowing this does it tell you anything about the knowledge or intelligence let's call it just a easy label of the person asking the questions or the person answering the questions no right does that make sense they were randomly put into positions where one person gets to ask and one answer yet even seeing all this right in front of them then students were asked compared to the person in in general to the average student is the are the people up there the quizzer and the receiver are they less knowledgeable about average or more more knowledgeable than the average other St Stanford student and you know in a pure scientific sense used to say I have no idea because you created a situation where 1% had a hopeless Advantage compared to the other one right you saw you told me you were doing that I saw you do that but human beings can't help but say including the contestant says you know I guess I'm a bit dumb but that other person was really smart the one who knew about the soccer match in England right and other questions you know or the other person observing you know that quiz Master seems to know a lot that student and this other one the one who answering the questions not quite an average MIT student okay all right because people can't help but say no if I see Behavior it's because of the content of your character smarter or Dumber in this case even though I know logically em you can REM mind goes to that analysis of behavior in others by their character or disposition here's another one uh participants read essays that were in favor of Castro who was the leader of Cuba or Castro in the US were mostly against Castro uh the opinions expressing uses were presented as either chosen so the person could choose to speak what they wanted to speak or they were assigned by the experimenters so you were asked please give a proastro speech or please give an anti-castro speech you know that's your job here and then the people listening said okay how what's what do they really think about Castro what do they really think okay even in a situation where you're told they're going to be assigned that so what happens um here's how much they believe that the person the essay writer sorry was proastro or anti-castro uh in the case where they chose what to do but when they were given the assignment and now you know it's truly random it's not quite as much as this but they still believe that if you write a pro Castro essay even though you're told the person was assigned that essay as you read it you go this person seems to really believe it okay I think they're really for it because that's their predisposition you're told fully this is a situ that's a sign but humans can't help but think I see through this a little bit and that essay is just a little too well written a little too convincing for a person just to be randomly writing it okay so it's humans even when you give them all the information that it's 100% situational they can't help but interpret things as being built out of character or predisposition in a person so people have also thought that this idea of understanding another person's behavior in terms of the predispositions versus the situation uh that the dispositional one is made automatically reflexively that the situation information sort of follows in a controlled slow thoughtful way that takes energy to correct the humans on the whole first interpret automatically reflexively the behavior of others as their character and then second optionally can correct it thinking about the situation so the idea is you see something you immediately apply you decide what the person's character is and then you're Maybe maybe will slowly effortfully and consciously think about what the situation is that led to that so these are automatic and this is controlled thoughtful and deliberative so it may not happen and so the people to show this and it's a slightly complicated experiment but let me show you how they they wanted to prove that thinking about the situation Demands a lot of extra mental resources to overcome the initial interpretation so they had participants Watch Silent video clips they said it was silent because they wanted to preserve the privacy of the woman who was being video taped having a discussion with a stranger you just see the woman uh and she looks extremely anxious on some clips and not others the task is we want you to rate how anxious is this person basically rate your impression about in terms of their character are they an anxious type of person some of the research people who were the subjects were told the target was discussing uh what the topics were and then they also did one other thing which that some of the people were asked to just watch and rate and other people were told not only you watch and rate but we're going to test your memory for the content of what she said because of that they're trying to memorize what they hear and the idea is that you're filling up their attention with what they're memorizing they can't make the correction they're out of mental resources to make the situational correction so you're watching these films on anxious topics or relaxing topics uh so uh uh you know the relaxing topics might be these things tell me about a foreign film you like or favorite hobby or speak about your worst public humiliation a sexual fantasy you have a personal failure you had and of course these things in red you could expect a person talking about that to seem more anxious those are personal anxiety-provoking topics okay uh so so you so so you some of the so here's what happens so again the topics were either anxiety-provoking or not and you were either just watching the film or memorizing what you were hearing as well and the hypothesis is that uh this would happen so if you were doing one task and you were aware that oh this person and you were told what the topic is hasing a relaxing topic or an anxious topic you could separate out what the task is versus the person okay but if you were trying to memorize simultaneously what the content of the film was that difference disappears the rating is identical the people are not taking into account the topic that's being talked about because their mind is not because they're memorizing their mind is occupied with uh the content of the scene and they're not able to sort of correct the intuitive automatic reflexive habitual uh uh interpretation of a person's uh actions based on their character so in the news today as if it were organized for our course uh there's a fantastic debate about what pictures to release or not release from what yeah the the the the the killing of Osama bin Laden a huge debate uh going on about whether it should be released or not uh uh that's gotten the public attention one of the biggest reasons why among several but a big reason why there's such a huge debate is another set of pictures some years ago from Abu gra prison I'm going to show you those pictures and the consequences that were felt to follow from their release so this is one of the soldiers who was there private Lindy England who was said to have participated in maltreating and torturing detainees of the Abu gray prison so you know when the United States went into Iraq they very much had the thought that they were liberating the country from a uh from tyranny which in some sense everybody agrees I think just about they were in some sense uh but one of the goals was to convince the population of Iraq that the United States was not there to occupy and take over but to liberate and free the people of Iraq that was a big message the United States wanted to send to the world and to the Iraqis right okay regardless of whatever else you know uh or believe or have political opinion that was a message the United States wanted to send to everybody that was huge for them to do that were there to help free Iraqi citizens not to occupy and take over Iraq so imagine when these pictures came out some of of a very large prison that was run by Americans in Iraq and these pictures were put uh uh on the internet of uh various uh what looked like and probably were uh sort of torturous situations here's an here's an Iraqi person with this hood on their head with wires connected to the body here's this that Soldier holding a leash and here's a prisoner on the leash here's a picture a smiling picture with her and and another Soldier here's a a pyramid of naked prisoners piled up one onto top of the other in a humiliating position there's another picture of her thumbs up pointing at hooded naked uh prisoners genitals okay and then she was uh tried in court for these things it was devastating for the United States these pictures were devastating for the United States States because they were exactly the opposite of the picture the US wanted to present which is one of Liberation and friendliness and democracy and freedom and here's you know tyranny brutality uh and prison uh uh torture and um uh and that's what that's figures hugely in the mind of people in Washington now as are debating about these pictures and for the moment they decided not to release any picture the power of these pictures as they floated around to inflame and inight uh arguments and so here's two ways you can do it from the Viewpoint of social psychology the disposition attribution went you imagine you're a juror where she's being tried so you know the accuse knew what she was doing she was laughing and joking she enjoying participating all for her own sick humor so here's the crime you get angry and you're not very sympathetic because it's from controllable factors she should have controlled herself she's held responsible she should get a severe punishment or you could ask and we'll come back to this at the end of the lecture near theend you know were there uncontrollable factors well beyond what a person could reasonbly asked to uh control then you're not so angry at them if you think the situation was very problematic for example uh uh she she had a boyfriend who was the uh not only Superior to her uh militarily but also her uh uh was the linger she was a follower she was an individual was smitten she did whatever he wanted her to do uh somewhat more sympathy person not held responsible or and the punishment is is more about Rehabilitation than punishment so th those would be the two approaches she was found guilty of one count of conspiracy and four counts of maltreating dayanes one count of committing indecent act she was equit a conspiracy account so I'm going to come back to this in a little bit after we talk about the St Stanford Prison Experiment and ask you your thoughts about this individual from the information you have um so we'll come back to that a little bit thinking again about what is a person responsible for versus a situation so let's start to talk about social influence which is again a change in a person's Behavior or beliefs in response to the intentional or unintentional influences of others and we'll talk about three kinds Conformity which is changing your behavior or beliefs in response to explicit or implicit pressure from others that's the person turning in the elevator compliance changing one's Behavior to avoid conflict and obedience which is following uh beh uh the demands of more powerful people or organizations so Conformity uh I mean Conformity sounds like a bad word but we conform to implicit and explicit social rules it's pretty useful for social groups operating if everybody here was talking and walking in and out and stuff like that we couldn't talk you know have a class right I mean if we didn't conform in some ways we couldn't do very much that took more than one person to do uh and it's seen across peoples and lifespans and cultures it's how in certain ways we work together as people um now the Nal experiment on this came from a very perceptual effect uh participants reported for a study on visual perception uh research with Sharif they were seated in a dark room and saw a point of light appear then move and then disappear and they were asked to judge how far the light moved this is based on a on a perceptual illusion because if you stare at a light in a totally dark room uh you will start to interpret it moving even though it does not physically move uh it has to be a blacked out room you have to sit there for a while and then you start to get signals about movement that are incorrect and this perceptual illusion that a DOT is moving was called the autokinetic effect and that's okay you've seen Amazing Illusions and that would be another amazing illusion of a single dot of light in a dark room and you start to think it moves but what the astounding thing was this here's three individuals who were tested and their rating of how much it moved it didn't move so it's there's some differences now the three of them are tested together on day two on day three and day four and you can see that these three different people start to converge on The Identical imagined illusory movement as if the responses of the others were influencing one and another on such a simple thing and then this experiment was made even more Ridiculous by one of the most spectacular experiments just in Simplicity uh and power and replicability so from this is from Ash imagine that you walk into a room and your task is this now get ready because I'm gonna ask let me ask for a volunteer right now okay thanks get ready this is going to be pretty tough okay okay and everybody else will be nice to you because you volunteered all right you see this line here which of these three lines has the same length number one number one that looks good to you does that look like a really tough thing no okay thanks okay I was I was being a little fous all right thank you but you have to understand this is a gist of the experiment not such a tough thing okay pretty obvious here's what they did you were now you were brought into a room and there were six Confederates so that's the word in social psychology that's used for people who are in on the experiment okay they're not really subjects so you walk into a room you don't know what's going on there's six other students sitting there and they do exactly what we did now they show you a line like this and three other lines and say you pick it the six other people go first so you're sitting there imagine this and imagine the first some the first one says one you go okay and somebody goes H uh two you go hm and the next person says oh yeah two and by the time they get to you uh four of the six I said number two what do you do now to an astounding extent what you do is this you also say too okay and it's not like you're saying I'm just fitting in when they show you the pictures I Pi people are turning their head is there an angle is it the lighting thing you know why do I think it's number one when everybody else is pretty for such a simple thing pretty much so you know uh so TW you know there the Confederates are not always wrong but they're pretty often wrong and in a consistent way it's all a setup but you as an individual and here's one of these you see this person like okay if I look hard enough I'm going to figure out how did they figure out that line number one equals line number two so if you do it by yourself less than 1% errors obviously the only error you make is if you're not paying attention right okay all right with group pressure not every single time but all of a sudden 37 times more often you say it's the wrong line length and almost always the impression is you really believe it the people are really struggling they're really Heming and hawing okay they're not just uh and this varies you know not everybody's the same but only 25% give the correct answer throughout the experiment 75% of people at least once will give the obviously wrong answer because they feel the Conformity is H you know they need to respond to the other answers given by the other students around them such a simple thing as line length we cannot help but want to fit in and figure out a way to do that um what affects this Conformity well the more Confederates the more powerful it is that makes sense right uh so here's the group size effect so you know if only one person is making it you just figure they're not too Swift and you can get the line two people you're already moving up by the time you get to four people you know you're all the way up there four to uh 15 is about the same so four other people giving you obviously wrong answers you decide there must be something interestingly going on and you can figure it out like they did okay uh presence of an ally we'll come back to this a couple times all it takes is one person to break the Conformity and you're willing to break that too in these experiments that's set up the allies and one of the Confederates who's now told to give the right length so one Brave person can really change what you do but it's hard to be that brave person these allies are set up by the experimenter so what happens here we go here's the mistakes being made when all the other people are saying the long length and if one person is giving the right answers only occasionally still you do it sometimes but a dramatic difference from one person giving the right answer one to Center opens up your chance to go with the answer you know intellectually is correct uh embarrassment it's amazing the stuff we all do it's amazing the stuff we all do to avoid being embarrassed okay embarrassment is such a powerful thing for almost all of us there's some exceptions but for almost all of us so part of what's going on in Conformity is to not to be embarrassed to be different and so so here's the way they show you that they they have you arrive late you're not really arriving late they you know they tell you oh you should have been here we had a miscommunication all the other people are here they knew okay well because you arrived late why you just write down your answers you don't have to say them out loud because you know we can't have you mess up the experiment now then there's a still not perfect but people Reduce by a third the number of their incorrect answers okay because they don't have to tell other people what they saw okay it's not perfect but all of a sudden at least that and few other things it peaks in ninth grade uh women on average showed a bit more than men cultures that are more interdependent showed a bit more than cultures like the US that emphasized Independence but you know these are all variations on a relatively small thing fundamentally humans want to conform and they don't conform superficially they convince themselves there's something going on and then then the right thing to do is to conform um you know why do we conform there's all kinds of hypothesis we want to be right okay everybody else know that line length I want to be right uh and I want to be popular I don't want to be the weird person not doing this stuff um so anyway so let's come to compliance which is even more oppositional so uh you know this from your life if you have ever spent something money on something you didn't mean to because there's an effective salesperson it's called a foot in the door technique and here's an example here's what they did in 1962 in California Freeman and Fraser drove to homes random homes show a large unattractive sign that says drive carefully now we can all agree that's it's pretty non-controversial to drive carefully and they ask the person they knock on the door and they ask the person will you place this on your lawn now think if somebody you know somebody comes up to you knocks in the door and says would you place this large unattractive sign to drive carefully uh and less than 20% say yes okay that's not a shocking number right they're picking something that's like you know apple pie right and Mom I mean drive carefully who can be against that but still who wants a weird sign on your lawn right okay and they made it unattractive on purpose all right uh So 20% here's the other group they go they go up to your door they knock on the door and you say I have a petition here you've had that experience on the street or somewhere you know I have a PTI here will you sign up to support legislation to reduce traffic accidents okay and you think okay is there some gimmick here I mean who can be again who's for traffic accidents the person say yes says please he go okay I'm gonna sign that one right so a lot of people sign that one then you go back to that same house a few weeks later and you ask the sign it moves up to over 50% say yes for the sign that's the literally the foot in the door that once you've signed this petition then you're incredibly more likely to say yes for the sign and what we understand that to be as you know through other experiments we want to be consistent in our Behavior well gee if we're willing to sign a petition for fewer accidents why wouldn't we put a a sign on our lawn to further promote you know people not getting run over okay all right but once you make the small agreement then you're willing to do something way larger that by itself you would never do and I can't tell you from my own experience how much that when people end up doing something uh they really wish they hadn't done it often starts and you may know this in yourself with a small thing good or bad okay it seems small and then you did a little bit more and then you a little bit more and then all of a sudden you're surrounded by a SWAT team in your D dorm room right and you say like how did this happen right uh you it's amazing how often things good and bad start with small steps another small step and all of a sudden you know you're on a slippery slope to doing something you could never have imagined if it would have been posed uh as strongly as you ended up doing it does that make sense okay so this is compliance a little question little question all of a sudden you're doing something you would never do by itself um obedience now obedience we think well you know we're not we're not going to be that obedient we you know we to a certain extent obey our parents the police our bosses and firefighters again we a certain amount of obedience I think logically we think is necessary for social order and civilization so that we're all organized in some non-chaotic way uh and it varies across uh groups and times and so on but but we know there are horrible examples where obedience is associated with w w with genocide uh uh the defense of many Nazis in Germany was that they were simply following orders right and in genocides all over the world tragically tragically people say there why do they do that why would they end up if you opposed it that way to people why would you end up murdering you know many people innocent people defenseless people uh so often part of it is being obedient to some group um so now comes one of the all-time amazing experiments that we can't pull off although I'm going to tell you it was pulled off uh in a certain way recently from Stanley mgram so it works like this uh this is the actual flyer that mgram at Yale sent out person needed for a study of memory and they'll pay you $4 at that time that was something okay uh and he would come into Professor Stanley mgram in the department of psychology at Yale University uh and here was the gimmick it was a newspaper ad like that uh and you would come in and there'd be two people in the room one was a confederate and one was you who naively honestly just shows up to do an experiment they tell you they're here to help science improve learning and memory uh through punishment can we improve learning and memory uh through punishment and we're going to say that uh one of you will randomly become the teacher and one will become a learner and they make it look like a lottery that's sort hand out a piece of paper but it's all a setup you will become the teacher the other person will become the learner you will become the teacher um and you get sets of word pairs to memorize uh the teacher as a teacher you give a word and the student's supposed to give you the right answer you have the answer in front of you and you tell them whether they were right or wrong if if you get a if they give you the correct answer you're supposed to say good or that's right to encourage good learning if they give you the incorrect response you're supposed to press a button that delivers a shock uh here is the device they used and with every one of these buttons the voltage goes up and you as the teacher sample a 45v shock which I can tell you is moderately uncomfortable okay all right it's not terrible but you know it's not fun okay so you know that in case you had some illusion about that you know 45 volts is already pretty uncomfortable so you say that's how it feels okay okay now the other person goes into the room and you're sitting there as the teacher so here's the setup here you are getting your $4 doar here's the scientist in big in a white jacket telling you what to do uh the researcher here's the so-called learner but that's really a Confederate okay they're not really getting shocked in the other room but they're going to play act a lot um and you're sitting there in front of this device that goes from 15 to 450 volts in in small steps of 15 volts 30 switches across here 150 has a label that says strong shock 255 intense 375 danger severe shock at 435 and 450 there's no word left for the intensity shock they just put triple X all right initially the learner does well again it's a setup the learner knows what they're supposed to do and but then errors start to make the learner starts and with every error you're supposed to go one worse the learner complains that the shocks are starting to hurt as they move up to about a 100 then they scream and in the other room when you give the shock and the participants I can tell you they're just like you would think just like you would do you go like I really don't like this this doesn't seem right and the and the person running experiment says your job is to do the next thing okay and the people are suffering and like this can't be right and how's this happening at Yale and uh so which think what you would do um uh the learner complains about his or her condition in the other room more errors now uh the teacher is often begging the other person please listen and pay attention I don't want to shock you anymore do your come on and get it together I don't want to do it anymore uh then the person starts to scream from the other room you have no right to keep me here another shock I refuse to answer anymore you can't hold me here the person is shouting this from the other room my heart is bothering me at 300 volts the person says they refuse to answer you turn your head to the experimenter and you say the person's not even answering at 300 volts what do I do and the experiment and the scient the scientist in the white jacket says if there's no response that's a wrong response so you give another shock okay uh and at 350 volts a person is not even responding anymore as far as you know they're sort of dead okay I mean they're not you don't know what they're doing but you think something horrible has happened this is fully play acted and the people who went through this were miserable so much so that it's been almost impossible to do this ever since people think it's too dangerous for the naive research participant who thinks they're nearly shocking somebody to death um so how many people go all the way up and this person screaming begging saying their heart is starting to give out and finally going silent how many people go all the way up to 450 to all the way up long after the person has stopped responding and you get these incredibly bad signs so they asked experts and they said it would be about 1 to 3% that it's a good way to identify psychopaths in the world okay and you can certainly sit there you can say what I'm going to say like I would never do that and I'm going to convince you in a minute guaranteed in this room most of you would do that all the way guaranteed by any scientific evidence and all of us will say I would never do that power of the situation so how many people went all the way 2third went all the way two-thirds look at the round look to your left and to to your right if there's three of you two of you will go all the way while till you're I know no no not me not me not um so here's here's what you know experts said you know once you get to some intensity level practically nobody's going to do it here's the two-thirds of people who went all the way um and even uh so two-thirds went all the way uh but everybody went to 100 volts almost nobody stopped early on okay but onethird stopped around a third through two3 went all the way um so people have said oh that's in 1950s people were much more conformist and obedient okay that was before Vietnam before rock and roll before uh uh Watergate and you know all this stuff that has made us distrust Authority and you know before the internet we know what's going on you know all right so uh you know so now come on you guys should go like it's not us that's some you know sad 1950s people who were just following instructions we're independent people of the 21st century so they almost redid this experiment in some reduced way a couple years ago and it doesn't make a difference all right so in 2009 they one here's here's some things they did to get approval of this first of all they carefully even more carefully than before screened the subjects to make sure they were in good mental health they weren't breaking down people uh uh they were told three times they could stop and still get $50 for participating okay they were told multiple times you can stop you can stop you can stop uh after the experiment they were instantly told what the whole thing was about which wasn't that well organized before they have a clinical psychologist sitting there to to make sure that the person seems not too distressed okay uh and they said look since we know that pretty much everybody went 150 when other the way will stop at 150 volts you won't torture a person all the way through but 150 is pretty big you're doing it for quite a bit of time so what happens in 2009 uh for mgram 79% went to 150 volts in 2009 70% of undergraduates go to to that same length it looks pretty much the same and by the way in case you thought women were more merciful or not they're identical to men in these studies in 2009 okay uh it's stunning right and so so everybody who worries about situations in the world where people do horrible things to other people is incredibly impressed by this experiment where so little pressure as a voluntary experiment where you can stop any time and walk out it's not your boss it's not a general it's not your culture it's not your you know parents and schools just an experiment almost everybody goes all the way and that's to to in 2009 as well we're incredibly prone if we have the right situation to be obedient Beyond you know what our humanitarian Spirits suggest they would be so nobody really knows why we're so obedient although I'll show you some things that people have discovered does the status of the authority figure matter does it matter that the person seems like a scientist who knows what he or she is doing is a belief that the source of authority you know because they know what they're doing it must be okay uh how much does it Ma matter that you can't quite figure out how to get out of this situation and how much is a slippery slope like we talked about well if I can do five volts I can do 10 if I can do 10 I can do 20 if I can do 20 I can do 30 and somehow you know 5 by five you end up at 400 okay so these are all ideas so people have looked at this what if the person gives no instructions almost Nobody Does it if a person just says you know here's the experiment please do it and doesn't talk with you when you say you want to stop people stop all they have to say though is please continue and that's enough uh men and women aren't different if you do the experiment not a psychology here's the here's the Baseline the 70% to go all the way in an office building is less why do you think that people's interpretation of the situations is not quite as officially scientific right uh still you get a lot uh if the person in charge doesn't seem like they know what they're doing particularly know white coat does seem like an advanced scientist pushes way back the authority of the person if the experimenter isn't is is more formal but away from you so you don't see them they're talking to you over intercom or something that pushes you back uh to do it less likely if the victim is in the same room as you are uh that reduces it although still 40% go all the way uh if you have to touch the person while the person's being shocked that reduces it uh and if you have a Confederate who another person working with you on this who Rebels that also has a huge effect this idea again if there's one denter that frees you sometimes to follow your own ideas and thoughts but these one denters are set up you know who who becomes that one denter okay the famous uh Stanford Prison Experiment right same idea roughly speaking and unbelievably relevant to Abu grabe it's almost as if from the Viewpoint of psychologist they had rerun the Stanford experiment accept in Iraq with real prisoners and American soldiers so but in the Stanford Prison Experiment there was a social situ they where they basically told people that they would be either the prisoners or the guards Stanford undergraduates uh uh and uh they would put them in the basement of their psychology building and they would use various closets as the pretend cells but you were assigned to be randomly a guard or a prisoner to make it a little bit more realistic they surprised you when they picked you up you had signed up okay but they would run to your house and a guy would grab you and say you're coming now and you're the prisoner okay so there's a little play acting in this as well and what they found was that the guards the Stanford students who were randomly assigned to guards became so sadistic and the Stanford students who were the prisoners were so stressed that the study was stopped in six days they were going to do 24 days because people were sobbing people were doing horrible things to one another um here's pictures of the this reminds me the Abu gra right all lined up like that you know typical Stanford students who were dressed up and given a baton and they were just horrible horrible horrible horrible playing the role of the prison guards they became abusive and mean to a astounding degree um and uh uh so again this idea now uh we cly enough the only Authority here is the Phil zard the social psychology who said like your job is to be the guard and your job is to be the prisoner right so anybody could have stop sort of at anything but once they got playing these roles it only it took them only a few hours to really occupy the life of the sadistic guard and the life of the uh victimized prisoner so think of this thing in Abu gra where you had a a huge number of prisoners a very small number of American soldiers very few of the American soldiers had any training about how to think about being a guard it was almost as if you had rerun the Stanford Prison Experiment uh add to it fear on both sides of harm that's intended by the other groups add to it the cultural divisions between the Americans and the Iraqis uh so they you really felt like the other group was another group I mean you knew here at Stanford in the basement that these were your other students right half the room could be the guards here half the room could be the prisoners here nobody has been allowed to rerun this because the behavior was so horrible so fast that there's nobody that you're just simply not allowed to do an experiment like that again uh and here again it's a picture of the guards the students randomly chosen to be the guards and here's when the students randomly chosen to be the prisoner it looks just like Abu grave it's it's as if you know uh the Army should have heard about that experiment uh before that um and here's more pictures of the sort of abuse and you can find lots of videos online about that okay so I'm jump forward to this so again we could think again the more you know about this you know how free was this person to do the right thing and how situationally dominated were were they by Authority and by the situation that surrounded them if you think about the mgrm experiment who's your commander and in charge of you if you think about the zimbardo experiment you have the job of being the prisoner of the Guard okay uh uh and you know is she really a bad person or did you put her in a hopeless situation to do a good job so um the last thing I want to talk about oh let's talk about that for one second any thoughts how would you find her yeah what kind of abuse was in the prison well you know from one when reads and who knows how accurate exactly that is uh you know they one person did die not much of it was the torture of the sort of water boarding that you hear about it was it was more scaring the heck out of them and embarrassing them horribly you know taking a bunch of people having them all be naked and piling them up putting them on a leash okay I'm sure it wasn't physically nice it wasn't brutal in the most sense it was more taunting and humiliating um but there was some some pain involved as well it wasn't murderous you could say that limit you know um yeah ccum almost impossible the same thing with the milgrim they they redid it a little bit in 2009 with these limitations right the amazing thing is it looks just like in every as far as they took it just like the 1950s mgrm the Stanford experiment uh uh people now think ethically you can't do that because not only is the behavior of the guards abysmal but the people who were the prisoners were really depressed afterwards were really anxious afterwards it wasn't like stepping in and out of an experiment you know as were by the way the mgrm subjects who went all the way up they reported being haunted by this experience for many years to come so these kinds of things people would not do now because it's just too consider too risky for the participants yeah so um the Standford people like the students that were participating in it did they go on to live like noral oh what's the long-term damage that's a very good question I don't know if they've been followed up that's a very good question I know for months the people especially with the prisoners said they felt very very very bad but I don't know you know I don't know decades later they followed them not any that that would be an interesting question yeah psychology Psy yes it's not so much psychology I'd say you know I'm going to give you my impression because I don't have a good answer it's if you get the right kind of training so you're prepared for a situation you have a much better chance so remember earlier we talked about now it seems very academic compared to these experiments we talked about cognitive busyness that if your if your mind is not free to evaluate the situation you interpret in terms of disposition so if you're TR you know what does that mean in a scary complicated situation we go by our guts okay and our guts are you know the other person's different I'm I'm in charge of the them as the as the guard right uh if we're trained so that we have a second habit we can fall back on then we have a better chance of doing the right thing uh when the situation arises is this this is this is a general point but yeah just sending in people kind of unprepared it's not that they have to know psychology is that they have to be told again and again and again when you're the guard keep in mind that it's so easy to be abusive it's so easy to be humiliating uh that you have to guard against that in yourself does that seem okay yes it's training we think is uh but it's not it's not the intellectual knowledge is practice is practicing so that when the moment arises you're ready is I think what people believe is the right thing okay so the last thing I want to talk about a couple things is bystandard and helping and these are just amazing experiments and in many ways they're all about embarrassment and how embarrassment makes us incredibly less helpful and kind to others than we can imagine um so the most famous case uh that began a lot of This research was the murder in New York City of kitty genovesi and I'm GNA read to you just a minute about her murder it got a fantastic amount of newspaper coverage uh and this was the walk home she had to her apartment so at approximately 3:20 in the morning of uh March 13 1964 28-year-old Katherine Jovi was returning to her home in a nice middle class area of Queens from her job as a bar manager she parked her red Fiat in a nearby parking lot turned off the lights and started the walk to her second floor apartment um some 35 yards away she got as far as a street light when a man grabbed her she screamed lights went on in a 10f floor apartment building nearby so a lot of people she yelled oh my God he stabbed me please help me Windows opened in the apartment building and a man's voice shouted let that girl alone the attacker looked up Shrugged and walked off down the street Miss genovi struggled to her feet lights went back off in the apartment the attacker comes immediately back and stabs her again she again cries out I'm dying I'm dying again the lights come out the windows open in many of the nearby apartments the as salent again left and got into his car and drove away she staggers to her feet as a city bus Drives By it's 3:30 in the morning now the attacker returns again he finds her in the doorway at the foot of the stairs and he stabs her a third time this time with a fatal consequence it's 350 okay half an hour when the police received the first call they responded quickly and within 2 minutes they were at the scene she was already dead the only person with the one person to call was a neighbor who revealed that he had phoned only after much thought and an earli in phone call to a friend so he doesn't call the police he calls a friend and says hm I wonder what I should do here right who and he said I didn't want to get involved later was learned that there were 37 other witnesses to the stalking and stabbing over the half hour period Why did no one offer any help or call the police the story in question were Front Page News across the country Urban and moral Decay apathy indifference were some of the many off explanations this was one of these cases that people said this shows you how bad off we are especially in cities where people just don't care about other people okay they won't make a phone call uh to the police except one person Heming and haing his way for half an hour so the lack of the bystanders helping this woman you know is it because people are selfish uh nowadays you can bet you'd have a video of that on YouTube right there were a question that was what about the rest of it uh and unmit Mar life fear of getting hurt what would you have done now let me tell you the you'll see the punchline in a moment is the more people are around who could help the more certain you are that nobody's going to help the last thing you want uh to get help is a bunch of people okay uh the best chance you have is one person counterintuitively and against the math of multiple people so here we go so the most famous studies and I'll show you about three of them uh because they're just amazing about how we won't help people because if we not sure what the right thing to do is and there's other people there it's too embarrassing to do the most obvious humanitarian gesture so he talked they talked about did a serious of experiments most of them around Princeton looking at uh ideas about pluralistic ignorance let's say each witness is uncertain whether there's a real emergency they look around and the others not reacting this is probably part of the story decide it must not be a real emergency social evaluation of others what are they doing diffusion of responsibility each person fa that somebody else is going to get help so these are parts of the story but here's the experiments you arrive for an experiment to discuss personal problems you signed up you're a princeon undergraduate you show up there's one to four people put in different rooms over intercoms so it's one person sometimes alone or two on two different intercoms um one person the Confederate over the intercom dramatically enacts a person having a seizure all right so imagine you're a student dramat and one of these people who you believe is randomly another student starts to say I I think I need uh somebody here you know dramatically I can't do it well enough because there is I got one of the seizures coming on I could really use some help if somebody could help me somebody could help me choking sounds I'm going to die I'm going to die choking sound the intercom goes quiet what do you do well if there's two of you about 80% of the time you're going to do something if there's six of you only 30% of the time will anybody do anything yeah I think sometimes it's also like people can be really selfish I recently in the John's Hopkins examination like Le just a few months ago somebody started having a seizure in the middle of the exam not a single person stopped their test to help them neither is a ta so this is so let me c so you're saying people can be really selfish because John's Hopkins it was their exam they didn't want to stop they had an exam and somebody started having a seizure and neither the students nor the teaching assistant did anything to help the person for a long time for a long time okay so you're going to call it selfish and I'm going to agree in some sense that's true but I'm going to tell you it's amazing I didn't hear about the story it's exactly this thing everything and I'll show you three more I think three more examples every experiment shows that if if it's just you and one person you're incredibly more likely to help that person than if it's you among five people or 10 people the more people the more certain you are to do nothing and I'm going to tell you in a moment this is an amazing example why the exam matters too okay because these experiments will show you that this is deeply human unfortunately okay deeply human and it's not that we're I think it's not that we're more selfish it's that we're terrible at knowing this is a question about this we're terrible at knowing what to do under unusual circumstances and we're overcome by wanting to fit in so you you know you look at that person then under do anything they look at you you're not doing anything they look at that person and you guys are you're having a face off of not doing anything while the person's sort of you know sinking into their seizure okay and you could think it's all about selfishness and not helping but we think it's something weirdly about humans that in groups they don't know how to act if it's unusual they just don't know how to do it by themselves incredibly more likely to help so here's an example I'll show you a couple more was I hand yeah is this showing the this is a percentage of participants who help so you are you asking the math are you still better off like is this like the percentage of the time that the person received help yes this this is a percentage of help you're right that you're still better off with six but I'll show you that very often it doesn't play out that way okay but you're right you you have to do there's a TR off between the sheer number of people and the likelihood per person you're absolutely right that varies a little bit here's another one called lady in distress a subject walks alone or with a passive Confederate so the Confederate is set up to do nothing or with a friend a real friend you come as a pair uh and you you go into a room that's separated by a curtain the experimenter goes to the other room in this case they made it a woman at the time um turns on a tape recording of a huge fall much bigger than that boom okay she's around a curtain okay and she starts moaning a pre-recorded painful moan you're sitting on the other side of the curtain who gets up to go see what happened to the experimenter who sounds like they had a huge fall and are moaning with pain this is very much like example you said almost right okay what do the people do okay so here's what happens if you're by yourself uh 70% chance you'll go there you could wonder what's happening to the other 30% but okay that's so okay uh if the other Federate if the other person sits there who's set up to not do anything practically nobody ever goes and helps because you're sitting there and the other person's not doing it and you're going I don't know it's kind of a weird situation am I invading a person's privacy maybe that wasn't maybe that wasn't what I thought it was because the other person doesn't seem to be doing anything because they're set up if there's two people who are naive you're somewhere in between okay if you come with a friend somewhere in between but you here's the weird thing the more people the more you kind of trying to to figure out what's the right thing to do and you're not doing anything so I'm not going to do anything the other person is saying does that make sense okay every one of these the more people there are the more people don't know what to do and they do nothing because they don't want to do something weird and embarrassing like make trouble or not do what you're supposed to do here's another one where there's smoke there's fire subject filling out survey smoke enters through event alone you're doing this survey alone in a group of three or with two Confederates who notice but ignore the smoke or or a friend you bring with you so who leaves the room with in six minutes to go get help when smoke is billowing into your room okay all right now you could say as you sit there again this is like the mil exper you go well of course I would do it but amazingly people are sitting there trying to figure out like should I finish this first should I you know is this really a fire what's going on here alone 75% of the people get up within six minutes and go tell somebody there's smoke billowing into here with two passive Confederates so people set up to do nothing only 10% of the time does the individual get up and go tell anybody you look around the other two people are doing anything you figure well that must be the right thing to do uh two naive subjects then uh now that we're doing the math this way 12 uh percent by individuals so a third of the groups approximately do something okay that's still pretty low okay but if you go interestingly in with a friend that number goes up a person you really know and trust because what the interpretation is if it's somebody you know you're not going to be embarrassed you can say to that person well this is a little wacky but shouldn't we go tell somebody there's smoke here or somebody collapsed next door and and the friend goes yeah it's probably a good idea I don't know but maybe we should do that right but if you don't know the person you're not going to have that conversation so a friend is very powerful uh to release you from this but if you don't know the other people you yeah does it make a difference it's like a family like you your child I I don't know that they've done this so these are usually done with undergraduates so they just you just bring your roommate or your AAL okay yeah I don't know if it matters at other levels that's a very good question maybe people have looked at that I just don't know this is the last experiment okay and this is kind of the topper of all of this and this gets back to being in an exam situation I'm glad you brought uh because it's it's this is almost an ironic experimen in a deepest sense it's again darly at Princeton the Good Samaritan so what's the story of the Good Samaritan from the Bible for those who yeah somebody really injured on this road side of the road rights and people he's from Samaria okay I'm just telling you that's yeah yeah now I'm going to tell you one more thing and uh which is samarians were not the most affluent uh members of society of the time this matters for the story in a way you're about to hear okay so a Good Samaritan so they took students now think about this this is because they want to show you how absurdly weird it is when it is we're willing to step forward and help a person and I don't think it's about goodness it's about the weirdness of our minds and not embarrassing ourselves and how preoccupied we are with our other business okay so so social psychologist are going to tell you the reason the Good Samaritan stopped was not because he was such a good guy it's because he didn't have so much to do okay and here's the experiment they're going to tell you why okay uh it's very so these are students these are Seminary students studying to become ministers okay so this is this is the group they pick this group because they want to show you social psychologists get irritated by personality psychologists they say can you pick a nicer group Than People studying to be ministers okay that's the predis that's a disposition okay uh uh and they and they're they're uh uh they're filling out surveys about religious values in a room they're told that they're going to have to present a talk about the SE about either Seminary jobs or so this is careerism or a sermon on the Good Samaritan that's the that's one okay so you're sitting there going help people help people help people help people because that's okay all right all right they're pra that's their speech they're prepared okay uh then they're released to go give this talk in front of other faculty members and their students so they they want to do a good job job either they're sent to the building across the campus ahead of time plenty of time on time they have or they're late to go oh my gosh you didn't go over we told you you should be oh you're gonna be if you don't run you're going to be late okay you don't want to be late to give your practice sermon or speech to the faculty committee waiting for you right now as they and then here's one more thing to keep in mind some of you probably have visited Princeton New Jersey just to give you a sense of this this is even back in the 1960s but even now uh have so who's been to Princeton New Jersey Princeton University okay you have okay scary urban environment full of threatening noises the campus itself pastoral Place full of eating clubs and references to F Scott Fitzgerald I'm just adding in that Princeton is a pretty non-threatening place the campus itself okay I'm just I'm just adding this in because you got to keep this in okay so here's the Confederate it's a man slumped in a doorway moaning in obvious pain hunched over on the ground okay now on the path to giving the speech who stops to help anything they could measure about the personality these individuals made no difference whether you stop to help uh whether you are saying stop to help stop to help stop to help because you're going to give a talk about the Good Samaritan or going to talk about career paths okay doesn't make any difference at all so amazingly the people zooming by this in person are saying stop and help the person stop you know the guy's moaning in the in the doorway next to them uh as they walking sorry next to them say okay what counts as to who stops they're by themselves it's not a group thing now they're by themselves right it's if they're ahead of time if they have time because they know they could stop and help somebody and still make their talk on time 63% stop 45 if it's going to be a close call 10% if they're rushing because they're going to be late okay this is you know so this so they're taking the exam it's say the description you set up a big group of people taking an exam they're like this like they're pressured they're pressured they're pressured okay and there's a lot of us somebody's going to take care of this if they need to and I've got I've got things to do you know like take an exam or run over and explain how incredibly important it is morally to help those who are injured and around you right so it's you can have a more sort of a uh uh you know literary experiment showing you how weird it is uh when we stop and help people yeah this happened on campus I was walking back to one of the dorms and I walked by and I saw a feet sticking out of a bush like someone had collapsed into a bush they didn't quite believe it at first so I stopped next person and asked you know are there feet there that that's what I'm seeing um So eventually we called the police but the response for most of the people going by was I'm s I can't stop I'm late for Mido you know I have to I have to go PE set and all so a lot of people just went by and they saw okay so you're giving a Story in real life on the campus here where where two feet were sticking out from a bush all right no no no no this this is amaz this this is not a setup okay you're not a Confederate yeah yeah so first you want to ask somebody else and but this is really interesting I mean yeah yeah because that's the first thing right like yeah what do you think good idea to have a body here bad idea to have a body here and another person and say what we like your opinion before we do anything and the person says I can't stop there there's a you know I have things to do right I have I have homework yeah it's astounding so I you know I'll just stop by saying it makes you think you use the word selfish and and that no no I I don't mean to pick on you it's just weird how humans are like this you know you see this all the time for me personally the fundal attrib you know all of these things have really changed how I interpret situations and and you know how much I think a person's a crummy person because up until the fundamental attribution error although I always gave myself every break for doing everything wrong okay I always interpreted other people's failings as like deep character flaws right and it it has made me you know personally stop and think if somebody is not doing something I wish they did or I think would be better maybe from their perspective they're in a situation uh that's D compelling them uh to to to perform less well than I think they should or something like that so these are unbelievably fascinating things and very convincing uh and it's very sad you know when when they set up prisons not remembering these lessons that are so clear-cut and I think the huge thing to know about this as far as we possibly understand this is true of everybody you know all of us none of us think we would do this all of us are prone to do this through many many many experiments without any evidence to the contrary from a scientific Viewpoint it's about as convincing a story as you can possibly have all right thanks very much