Transcript
um bow out a little early uh so once again um I I appreciate everyone joining us this morning I think we have a really good uh webinar in front of us here some excellent speakers that I'm really excited to share with everyone um I want to just remind everyone for those uh who have just showed up um if you have questions there's a chat feature on the on the um within the app uh please use that chat feature for any questions comments anything uh we'll we'll look at those at the end and kind of address those questions as they come up and kind of a panel um and then we'll kind of take things from there but uh I'm gonna go ahead and Jump Right In thank you so what is it about additive manufacturing that I or or new materials I should say that really I think gets people excited um what what is it that I think draws people attention into new and strange and maybe mysterious materials like uh you know in pop culture we hear you know material is called vibranium and adamantium and they're typically completely indestructible or or uh lightweight and stronger than steel and we've kind of developed this Mythos around new materials and new um new products that that I think people wish existed but don't and so what is it that really captures the human imagination around these materials and what helps us Define kind of the the you know different stages of human development as part of those materials I mean if we talk in in history we look back and we say okay uh we have the Stone Age then the Bronze Age then the Iron Age Now with maybe the Silicon age that we're in now why is it materials really Define the different stages of human advancement and and what is it about that that that causes I think excitement in in humans I mean even in science we hear about some of these kind of mythical materials like like graphene that's a hundred times stronger than steel and and carbon nanotubes that that have a higher tensile strength than anything there that exists um why is it then that we don't have buildings made of these materials why is it that we don't you know make suits of armor that are completely impenetrable um and it really comes down to if you can't make it into something useful it doesn't really matter I mean if we go back to those pop culture references there isn't a pop culture reference that really talks about a material as just being a material they always talk about its properties and then where you use it um so you know adamantium I mean it's the clause for for uh that are completely indestructible that are you know infused with his bones um or the Valerian steel is stronger and can cut others um it it talks about the use and the application space and that's something that I think there's really a difference um between just being able to address new materials and talk about great new properties in a maybe lab setting versus actually having impact on the culture and having impact on humans and what we do and I think that's really where I'm excited about additive manufacturing and additive Manufacturing in particular I think is drawing and bridging that yeah hence the name of the series that we do here of Bridging the Gap between you know pure developmental science and real usable applications where you can actually go and take a component made of some brand new material that has properties that have never been seen before and you can put them into practice in a shorter period of time and in reality way faster than it's ever existed before and I think that's that's what personally gets me excited about new materials and additive Manufacturing in particular um is you know when I was doing research in in graduate school and and really developing new materials there it was so hard to control and to transfer that knowledge into something that would be useful for industry to whereas we're now developing materials where we're going from a development concept of a new material um and going into production on a component within two years which is an incredibly fast timeline compared to what has really happened within human existence in the past and and that's really where I get excited about you know the new materials that we're looking at I don't want it to elementums Horn too much a lot of you know who we are and what we do but you know I feel remiss if we don't talk about it a little bit but new high strength aluminum Alloys um and and not just Alloys based off of the Alloys that already exist but going beyond that and to materials that are competing with beryllium and and competing with some of these mythological materials that are very hard to produce or make or use um and then we go into other very difficult materials very high temperature nickel super Alloys for for all sorts of application spaces uh and then even in the refractory materials um like rhenium we've been printing uranium recently which uh if you had told me that we'd be making components out of renium and then hot fire testing them within um Within six months uh if you had told me that 10 years ago I would have probably told you you're crazy and so I think that's the really exciting part about additive manufacturing and the new materials that we're bringing to the table and that's why I'm really excited to introduce um the speakers that we have here today um a little bit about uh elementum's relationship with these different people elementum has a lot of relationships across the entire industry um but certainly we've been working with these gentlemen quite a bit um Jamie I mean we've been working with 6K products now for uh you know only about six months and really working on different things and and working with their the uranium that we've been printing was was with them if you saw that LinkedIn post so excited about um introducing Jamie Doug Hoffman was actually our first customer at elementum uh I'll back about eight and a half years ago um so that was a long time ago at JPL and then and Tim Smith certainly I think uh uh very little introduction is necessary for Tim Smith I think a lot of us understand the impact of drx810 and the excitement in the industry for new high temperature nickel super Alloys so with that um I'm gonna go ahead and hand things off to Jamie and he'll jump in and tell you about the great new materials that they have uh going on there at 6K So Jamie let me hand over the presentation to you perfect thank you Jamie okay um so uh good morning everyone um thank you for participation in the webinar and thank you Jacob and elementa for for setting this up this is a great opportunity to to discuss some of the the great things that we can do as uh as an industry in terms of additive manufacturing and and specifically with um with 6K additive uh where we might be able to fit into to bridging some of that that Gap um by providing some of the materials um that may not be readily available um I always frame this by saying 6K additive is uh we're um we're great at making materials um but we're not um we're not alloy designers or anything like that um so we always like to know what people want um and then we like to figure out how how we can make them so I think that that's where we really fit into this um and really fit into the additive world uh besides you know making some of the more common grades of tie and nickel that are that are very common and out of manufacture hearing we like to hear what people would like to do with it and what we think the technology can do as a whole um to to advance to your point to bring some of those things that that seem like they're off in the off in the distance uh to fruition um just a a little bit about um uh 6K additive in general um we are um we are part of a larger uh company called 6K Incorporated we generally have two two folks that um are two divisions that most folks know about that's the additive and then we also have the the um the other group which is the Energy Group which makes uh battery materials um of course this is focused a little more on the additive group so I'll focus a little more on that um we are about 75 employees uh we actually have four locations now um with our Global Center of uh manufacturing being close to Pittsburgh uh Pennsylvania as a group we have about 126 active patents um and um I think one of the things is besides the manufacturing uh portion of what we do we also have the an r d Center of Excellence which is located in North Andover which is part of the 6K Incorporated group so besides um leveraging our own manufacturing expertise we could also uh leverage a lot of R D um work from for from the North Andover Group which includes not only just design of materials and the processes but also design of equipment to facilitate those processes um we are a full service we are a full service power supplier I think the best way to to describe us is is probably like the fourth bullet down which is a wide spectrum of quality metal powders from sustainable sources uh but you but we also have that r d arm and there's a variety of different ways that we can approach making these materials um the really the core part of uh the the core technology that facilitates everything that we've built around these manufacturing processes is the unimel plasma system itself it's a microwave based plasma system which I'll talk about in the next couple of slides of why it's Unique but I think it's very it's always very important to understand and there's probably a large group of people on here that probably heard it before but I don't ever think everybody always completely understands our plasma we're not doing any atomization with our plasma we're simply doing spheritization so we're simply doing the the step that facilitates a morphology of powder that allows these things to be used in additive manufacturing now there are some benefits that come along with that in that we can you know improve cleanliness particularly interstitials for things like gases um but the the key thing is that we can take a lot of different types of materials and input it through the plasma and and melt each of those individual particles and allow them to become spherical and give us the properties um that are important to uh most of the additive manufacturing machines when it comes to uh you the utilization of powder so it's really it's a we call it a volume in volume out process very important to understand that in this process in that core process we're not doing any size change um it's only it's only uh shape change the microwave plasma itself is is sort of unique in that it um it it it is a little bit different than what what conventional and inductively coupled plasmas or some of the other technologies that exist out there because it's actually a little bit uh cooler uh plasma um and that affords us a couple of benefits so we say the core of our temperature is and it's the rub on our name is 6k it's 6 000 Kelvin is what the core plasma temperature is and that's a little cooler than what some plasmas run um but it also is a much uh it's a much larger density of of plasma and a much larger working Zone in in the plasma itself so a couple of things that a few things that that affords us it's highly stable it has a great temperature uniformity throughout the plasma itself um from the core outward and it also is um it also is highly energy efficient so a lot of so the the energy that you put into the plasma system the microwave couples and um the energy that from the microwave is about 85 percent efficient to the plasma uh what all that does is it gives us a really nice processing zone for a wide variety of materials so we have a pretty broad-based product offering and um it's facilitated by the fact that this microwave plasma is so controllable and that we can create a nice material processing Zone within the system itself okay sorry I'm just trying to advance the the slides okay here we are um so this is sort of a demonstration of um the breadth of the the power of the plasma um we always like to show this because it's um it it allows us uh or it shows that we can process a wide variety of uh materials that have a wide variety of melting temperatures so it within the plasma system itself we spheritize everything from um aluminum silicon so al10 uh very common in additive manufacturing all the way up to tungsten so a wide variety of of different melting temperatures and we can be successful with all of these because of that control that we have over the microwave plasma system and there's a few different there's a few different ways to control it we can control the power and we control the the space where we actually inject the material into the plasma but it'll what it allows us is it allows us uh again anywhere from a very low melting temperature material all the way up to a very high melting temperature material allows it to be process through through this system so again when you're thinking about um you know material design or alloy design or what are the things that we that can be done um this this gives you some some idea of the wide range of materials that we can process um on our system okay um total the uh the the capabilities of the of the uh system itself oops sorry um of the system itself so I I mentioned earlier that um you know we have we we do the core Alloys the nickel alloy fam or the nickel family of Alloys um stainless Steels um Titanium based um but you know we've also expanded out into into starting to commercialize some of those refractory uh those refractory Alloys and um well I won't go into the the whole capability Matrix you'll be able to look at that um you know through the recording um we can we have a a wide variety of options of raw material inputs that we can get to those spherical powers and so our some of our core uh focus is mechanically milled so we're taking uh particulate materials and making them the right volume via mechanical Milling um we can take irregular powder so whether it's from um um some other um atomization technique or a chemically reduced powders or even use powders also the also we have the ability to do high drive convertible solids you'll see a lot of that so for tantalum and and tungsten and iobion-based Alloys we can do that we also have the ability to mechanically alloy this so this is where a lot of the design stuff can really come into play which is where you can take a look at um you know what what are things that we could put together that might not be able to be conventionally put together and kind of agglomerate them together and then spiritize them in the unimount reactor but any of those feedstocks are good with to end up with a um us with a spherical material for additive Manufacturing foreign um so a little bit of the focus um in in the second half of this presentation is just the refractory Metals in particular I think this is a this is a space that's gaining a lot of momentum and I and and and I think we all believe that additive manufacturing is a really good space for for this um you know you have these very high melting temperature Alloys um they're a little more dense um and those the characteristics that make them so good for some of the applications that we're looking at also make them very difficult to handle in not only the production of the materials themselves but also the manufacturing techniques so I think that when we look at at this space in particular um added in manufacturing and and the unimelt process kind of kind of bridge that Gap to unlock the potential uh of of these materials and really get them into Parts into applications into a wider spread applications um some of the just some examples of some materials that that that we produce um on a commercial basis now we we actually make uh tungsten I think it's probably the most commonly printed uh refractory uh metal I think there's I think we see the most people doing uh working with it out in the industry uh now it's probably the most readily available just in general but there's a lot of different particulate feed stocks that you can that you can find in the tungsten in tungsten um and we have the ability again to spiritize that and get it to the to a place where it's it's useful for for out of manufacturing so all so correcting all the key components the flow the densities um to make it useful in most out of manufacturing applications um here's here's a an example of a of a a part a collimator uh this courtesy of 3D systems but you know you look at a part like this and probably not going to be very easy to manufacture anyway but uh via additive manufacturing uh so you think about the this this type of application um again additive really has a has a nice fit um in this in this space um another one this is from um a little bit different feedstock this is um a c103 so a niobium-based alloy um from the uh hydride dehydride process which creates a nice blocky kind of angular um feedstock but again not good for additive manufacturing um but again with the unimount we can convert that to a nice spherical powder and uh make it very useful for additive manufacturing again nice spherical powder particle good flow um good ad good tap density so again I'm just unlocking some of those those possibilities and I think most people probably know that this is a a typical in in hypersonics where you require high high melting point um these these parts of courtesy of casting on um low coefficient of thermal expansion you know all those things that are important for things that might move really really really fast um so uh again I'm unlocking some of those possibilities and again I I use these as examples but I always you know like to say we like the design and are very good at designing the processes to make the materials um but but you know we're always looking for for people with ideas of of what do we need to make and then we can we can figure out how to make it and um and and get get it into some of those apple locations the last thing that I I would be remiss in talking about is I think everything that we do at 6K additive is you know we think about um the environmental aspects of of things and I say that and and we've done a life cycle assessment on our process and um you know the the improvements over some traditional processes but I think even beyond that um we like to talk particularly in the AM World about making sure that we keep this eye towards sustainability and towards the environment um and that 6K additive has it looks very closely at being able to help the end users um recycle all the waste streams of this it actually ends up becoming a nice circular economy because you know whether it's spent powder or failed parts or builds um you know we we know that those are all issues that not only are have cost implications but also have implications to the total sustainability of the out of manufacturing process so I like to throw that out there and say that in the development of all these Alloys and and all these different techniques we like to think about ways to try to bring back um the materials that can't be used in the processes and make sure that we we have a place for them to go and that they don't just end up in landfills or or worse yet sitting on shelves for um you know decades and that it becomes somebody else's problem in the future so I'll um with that um turn it back to Jacob to to move the the webinar along um and um I'll be happy to fill questions you know at the at the end of the the webinar right yeah yeah I really appreciate that kind of overview and and certainly I think we see a number of application spaces where um you know how do you make the powder tends to be something that is a limiting factor so um again if you have questions please put them I think there's even a questions tab where you can submit questions to the panel and all of that as well and then we'll address them at the end so I appreciate it Jamie all right um I'd like to introduce our next presenter just one moment so I can introduce Doug so Doug from JPL um if you would give us a short introduction and then we're going to jump right into your presentation all right hi thanks Jacob I'm Doug Hoffman a senior research scientist uh and the section technologist for mechanical fabrication and test uh at JPL so let me share my screen all right well let's just get started here so that uh Tim has time to talk after me um I'm gonna be talking a bit about the you know 3D printing alloy development at JPL um everything I'm talking about is actually from before the pandemic when we're doing a lot of this work so we actually have several years worth of um you know additional work that we're kind of chewing through but this gave you kind of a snapshot in time from what we're doing up until um the beginning of the pandemic um I think uh you know out of manufacturing is playing a significant role in Flight projects and r d efforts at JPL this is just sort of a picture giving a snapshot of some of the things that we are uh working on just a wide variety of applications um as you probably know you know the jet propulsion laboratory where NASA's federally funded research and development center with a focus on robotic space exploration so we have a lot of very unique uh missions and a lot of one-off applications for for or materials in extreme environments so you can really see that flow down into the kind of parts that we're interested in manufacturing and the kind of materials that we need to be able to use in those applications so uh our additive manufacturing um a group is um is um joined with our materials Development Group so we have a group called the materials development and additive manufacturing group that focuses on conventional Metallurgy and alloy development computational thermodynamics as well as both metal and polymer additive manufacturing all with the objective of being able to produce uh parts to enable extreme environment uh exploration I should just mention um you know that we do have some slight Heritage with metal 3D printed Parts um so you know we've got some very unique challenges this is our our Mars rover perseverance um and we've we flew 12 3D printed Parts on perseverance I'll show in the next couple slides but uh here's the cad model of it as well as a picture I took of it of it being assembled so this will just kind of give you an example of um of the kind of applications that we have for Advanced Materials and for additive Manufacturing so the two infusion points that we had on perseverance um were in uh were in the Moxie experiment and in the um in the pixel instrument which you can see here on the Rover so the Moxie experiment as you may know was the first demonstration of planetary in situ resource utilization or isru it was a tech demo payload to demonstrate the production of oxygen from the CO2 atmosphere on Mars um and the pre-heater assembly um in Moxie was a pretty complicated part with internal features that we um that we decided um sort of late stage was a good infusion point for metal 3D printing um and then uh and then pixel is a spectrometer that you see on the right and in this case we were using additive manufacturing to produce a pretty complex housing that went uh over the pixel instrument so here's the uh you know images of the actual slight Hardware that we produced for um for Moxie and for uh pixel so Moxie was sort of an internally generated uh part that was printed on our own eosm 290 out of uh in Canal 625 and there were several parts of this preheater assembly that you can see uh printed here um one part in particular that had internal uh cavities in it that you can see with the CT scan on the right so this is a part that sort of was um a Pathfinder for being able to produce flight Hardware from design all the way through qualification and infusion uh the part at the bottom is the dust cover for Pixel which was a very complex part to manufacture out of sheet metal has sort of this hollow Rim that goes around it and then it has this thin walled Titanium cover that goes on the instrument so this was printed in ebm out of tie six four chemically etched and painted before it was installed on the Rover so two kind of different applications for additive uh both really demonstrating the utility of additive for for flight hardware and then I think this picture is just um um I guess you know my favorite uh this is uh the the 3D printed uh Thai six four uh dust cover for Pixel on the surface of Mars on the perseverance Rover so if you ever see a picture of the perseverance Rover you've got that big flat white panel right there you can point that out to people and say that is a a 3D printed part sitting on another planet so it's kind of a big success from our um infusion and it kind of demonstrates this trl9 um use of additive manufacturing of course this you know isn't the end of the story this was sort of our first um infusion of metal 3D printing all the way through a flight project and hopefully it'll be one of many in the future including hopefully some in the future that involve new materials that we are developing with ourselves and our partners so if you kind of look at some of our mission Concepts in the future these are missions that haven't flown yet but uh hopefully we'll slow uh will fly someday this is our um our eels uh concept for exploring the moon of Saturn Enceladus which is sort of this you know worm-like uh or eel-like Rover that will hopefully Crawl Through the vents on Enceladus to access the subsurface ocean to look for life but these are the kinds of environments that we are dealing with at JPL you know one day we're developing parts for Mars the next it's a lunar rover the next we're developing prototypes for a moon of Saturn or Jupiter so this kind of gives you a an idea of why we have to develop new materials and Manufacturing Technologies to access these um you know these extreme environments so here's um just to look at the eels uh Rover and you know some of the prototypes that have been built um where we have been using additive manufacturing for Proto typing not only for some of the joints but we've even 3D printed the screws on the eels Rover for going through snow using uh using our form Labs 3D printer these are tie six four parts that are printed on our m290 so you can kind of see that we you know work in both sides of the spectrum from flight applications down to uh down to prototyping and we work heavily with our robotics group you know Mobility for Rovers is a area where we see a lot of promise for additive manufacturing so we see here some compliant wheels for Rovers so we've been exploring how do you use additive manufacturing for Innovative Mobility systems so this is a cool example of a compliant wheel that was 3D printed in a single piece using later laser powder bed Fusion it's printed in a stack and then you remove the supports you compress the stack to pop open the um the mesh of the wheel bolt it together and you've got yourself a compliant wheel that can be made out of you know any material that you can get into a laser powder bed Fusion printer so this kind of gives us you know new and interesting capabilities for Mobility uh so moving on we've also spent a lot of time looking at the design for additive manufacturing uh we've got um you know scientists uh at JPL that work on design topology optimization um and um and hybrid manufacturing so this was a collaboration between JPL and Autodesk to Envision how design for manufacturing and topology optimization could be used for future uh spacecraft in this case this was a Europa Lander for the moon of Jupiter and this was you know you see sort of the organic looking frame this part was um you know designed for hybrid manufacturing that includes combinations of additives subtractive and castings all together to make a extremely low density um stiff topology optimized uh Lander this this is sort of was a Pathfinder for where could you take this technology if you are sort of agnostic about the manufacturing route but you look at the design that is enabled by computational methods and then you apply manufacturing constraints like additive casting and machining what can you do in terms of spacecraft design so this was a really cool Pathfinder part that hopefully will flow into some of our future missions as we try to reduce the mass which allows us to fly similar missions and smaller launch vehicles um so just to give you a snapshot of our added manufacturing this um this is our metal out of manufacturing center at JPL um I know you know most of most people this would not be that impressive because we've got just a small number of printers we've got two EOS m290s one EOS M100 and then an RPM 222 four Hopper DED but what's great about our out of manufacturing center is that we have a qualified manufacturing process compatible with the NASA 60 30 standard so we've got a flight qualified process for aluminum 6061 Ram 2 and for tie six four so that we can produce flight Hardware through this uh through this process using our additive manufacturing center so our team at JPL um you know spent a long time setting up this facility with the goal of being able to produce flight hardware for NASA using additive manufacturing this has been a multi-year effort to be able to stand and this up of course in the center we also have alloy development capabilities with our um our multi-hopper DED and our M100 and we partner with you know dozens of universities and National Labs and Commercial companies uh to do further uh development so some of the ongoing additive materials uh uh activities we have at JPL um you know we do magnetic materials for thrusters we're looking at you know high strength aluminum Alloys copper Alloys for CO2 reduction uh we printed amorphous Metals metal Matrix Composites Ceramics I'll show some Ultra hard cutting tools that we've been looking at for Excavating cryogenic ices and of course we've been working for over a dozen years now at this point on functionally graded Metals which we have identified a lot of beneficial applications for but it's very difficult to infuse those into missions because of the um the mixed metal compositions and functionally graded Metals so here is some work that we've been doing on our DED um this is some 3D printing of hyperco for some Thruster applications and so I'm sure the video is running choppy on your screen but it's a cool time lapse of printing um of one of these hyperco thrusters um so you know typically we can 3D print with our DED in to mirror net shapes and then we do finish Machining using um you know our machine shop which is right outside our additive Center and we can get really unique magnetic properties by controlling grain size in our DED if not by controlling composition just this week we printed another bimetallic magnetic part that takes this work even further by mixing um by mixing two materials together um moving on one of the things that we've been working on um is looking at how to develop cutting tools to cut through cryogenic ices if we land on Enceladus or Europa so one of the alloy development projects that we had starting back in 2017 was the development of 3D printing Excavating tools for robotic arms so this was a very difficult challenge because we don't have very stiff robotic arms that you would expect on a giant kooka or a drilling rig so we have to design robotic arms that can trench and excavate through ice on flimsy robotic arms using low power and they can't get stuck because otherwise the mission would be over so we spent a long time developing new designs and then fabricating these cutting tools out of different materials so we collaborated with pretty much anybody that could produce new materials for cutting tools so we printed some of these cutting tools out of zirconia in base metallic glass with heraeus and we worked with elementum on printing metal Matrix Composites and tool steel which you can see in the uh the image there um so what we're doing here as you see if the video um runs on this next slide we're trenching through some ice simulant using uh an amorphous metal cutting tool so we're measuring basically the mechanical specific energy of these cutting tools and looking at the cutting performance of these tools um as a function of their design and the material that they're manufactured out of so this really gave us a chance to sort of fix the design and then look at the effect of material on The Cutting performance so here you can see five different cutting tools made with various materials from you know in Canal metal Matrix Composites from elementum tie six four marriaging steel tool steel from elementum 316 and we have measurements of cutting performance in our stimulant for all of these cutting tools so this kind of gave us a good idea about how we drive this technology further we eventually went to tungsten carbide which is that curve right it there so we've been able to print tungsten carbide embedded in steel to get really impressive uh performance so some of the um you know alloy development things that we're really interested is developing metal Matrix Composites and so here's three examples of the metal Matrix Composites that we developed there's in situ where you know you can melt phases together and you can form dendritic phases that solidify from the liquid you can do hybrid Composites where you partially dissolve particles reprecipitate them and you've got you know three phases present we also look at ex-situ Composites where you have insoluble phases inside of a matrix and these can all be printed both with powder bed fusion and with DED for various applications we wanted to make this cutting tool out of a titanium carbide metal Matrix composite in Thai 6-4 so you know part of doing alloy development is trying to learn parameters so we worked in with elementum to try to develop um Thai carbide loaded chi64 and it didn't work very well in powder bed fusion with high loadings of titanium carbide which we're hoping to get you know 40 50 loadings so you know this is part of the process of doing alloy development is um is you know figuring out what works and what doesn't work based on the um the available parameters uh so we switched to DED to be able to try to do these tie carbide loaded tie Parts we're able to get up to about 30 percent loading of Thai carbide before we start getting significant cracks in the Thai 6-4 so we're able to do you know functionally graded tie to tie carbide Alloys and with DED you're able to control the Melt pool to partially or fully dissolve these Thai carbide particles to create metal Matrix Composites with really Innovative microstructures so here you see some micrographs of partially dissolved and re-precipitated titanium carbide in Thai 6-4 parts so this is kind of one of the most exciting things that we have developed with DED is multi-material metal Matrix Composites that combine titanium and titanium carbide and functionally graded ways so that you can produce Ultra hard titanium Alloys as well as you know very high melting temperature titanium Alloys that are loaded with um with picarbine so one of the things we demonstrated is we made cutting tool inserts out of these Thai Thai carbide parts and then we did the same experiments where we did cutting performance using these inserts to demonstrate that we could actually develop Thai carbide metal Matrix Composites that have pretty excellent cutting performance compared to tungsten carbide which was really surprising to us and the advantage of using additive is that you don't have to make inserts you can print these directly on your cutting tools so that you don't have to worry about bolts bonds or braces so um you know this is one of many of the areas that we're working on where we're trying to use Allied development to get us a new capability that hasn't previously existed and the reason we're doing it is because our unique missions require that we go to extreme environments and innovate with the design and operations of our spacecraft and Rovers so um I uh that's my last slide and I'll um if you guys would um are interested in emailing me reach out and I'll be done and turn it over to Tim great thanks Doug um sounded like Tim might be having a little bit of uh uh technical problems but we'll try and hand things over here you may have Frozen um so in the meantime while he's trying to get back in um why don't we go ahead and field a couple of questions and then we can kind of Dive In uh so one of the questions is about cost um you know generally there's a you know a concept of free complexity and we've talked a little bit about that and so um I want to talk and dive into you know that that difference in in new materials as well so generally what at least we found as being successful approaches to that you know question of cost really you know tends to be centered around well if you're trying to machine rename um there's very few places who will do it um and when you go to do it it costs something like 400 an hour and so there are quite a few materials and metal Matrix Composites I think are are very very much the same way a very difficult to machine I mean if you're up at 10 15 20 ceramic it can be very difficult to produce these in any other way and so particularly for new materials like these uh there's a different cost modeling of the performance difference here from these materials is significant enough that it would be almost impossible if not impossible to make these materials any other way any any I think comments on that Doug yeah I would totally agree I mean at least for our applications where we're sort of cost and variant um uh you know you can get away with um you know spending a lot on a one-off if it does something really unique so one of the things that has been a a struggle with additive is um you know commoditizing it out in commercial industry um being able to mass produce uh Parts um using additive even when there is a beneficial geometry um the you really have to be very selective about your additive Parts with the current makeup of the commercial landscape where the part really cannot be made any other way so you mentioned these refractory Metals um that would be impossible to machine otherwise you're talking you know extremely large rocket engines or nozzles would just be extremely difficult to machine conventionally these are great applications for additives um and you know where you're gonna see um the future is how do you take novel materials and apply them to additive where the benefit of using the novel material outweighs the additional cost of not only the qualification and the material production but also the manufacturing and post-production of the additive part so that's you're already kind of seeing that a little bit um all right there's Tim he's back hey excellent hey yeah uh yeah I want to address one more question before we get into Tim's presentation here because I think it's it's one that's that's relevant and sets up the next conversation as well as you know these new materials and adding new materials and additive Manufacturing in general is great but what happens if you need to like really qualify it for a crucial application space and again Doug I think JPL is kind of uh Paving the way for that and that you can't have a flaw that you discover when it's on Mars um so how do you address that how do you address qualification of additive manufacturing and that you know I think a lot of people are still afraid of additive even though there are I think quite a few examples of additive being used in trl9 or you know similar well I mean fortunately the NASA 60 30 standard is pretty robust if you haven't read it you can get a copy of it but uh it describes how to set up a qualified manufacturing process for a different class of of part um that would be used in um in a flight Mission so that involves everything from you know qualification of the powder the machine coupon level testing of parts that are printed as well as non-destructive testing on the part before it flies so doing CT scanning I'm doing proof loading on it so there is a whole process that you go through to assure that the parts that you produce with additive will you know work as intended and you don't have unexpected consequences you know it's interesting that you you put it that way too because I I think that additive is held to a higher standard than a lot of other manufacturing techniques because we're more comfortable with those other techniques and that that follows for me um but you know in particular CT scanning I was talking to someone in the federal government position um and I asked well you know the traditional part that's made has that been CT scanned and they're specifically saying no we won't go back and CT scan parts that have been made through castings because if we find a flaw then we have to ground the entire fleet even though they've been being used for 50 years um and so I think there's there's a sense of additive is being held to a different standard of um of quality control because it's a new and different and not and a technique that people just aren't as comfortable with yet and so I think there's some interesting aspects with that as well but um with that I'd like to uh hand things over to Tim and um I'll make you the presenter again here Tim right all right um all right do you see a full screen yes perfect all right uh yo thank you everyone for uh staying on while I figured out uh getting how to get back in the webinar but uh I you know want to present some of the work that we've been doing at Nasa Glenn uh my name is Tim Smith I've been uh researched here for about eight years and this is uh uh you know some uh overview of the high temperature alley development that we've been doing here at nestic life so a little bit of background on the application that kind of drove this research I came about through discussions with uh combustion researchers across the center who are trying to 3D print that uh combustor Dome that you uh see on this slide and they wanted to test it up to temperatures of 2000 degrees Fahrenheit or higher and uh the materials that they had been using um just weren't up to to Snuff really when they started uh hot fire testing uh their parts and so they came to us and said hey is there a material that we can buy off the shelf that we can 3D print these components with and operate at these really high temperatures um and you know we kind of came back and said you know we don't think so but we would really love to uh you know set up a project here where we kind of explored new Alloys uh that can operate these really extreme temperatures that are also amenable to the 3D printing process when you kind of look at the alloy systems that are available uh for you know temperatures of 1100 C or higher there really isn't that many material systems you can tap into um you know obviously refractory Metals uh you have your Composites and cmcs uh and then some other nickel based super alloy especially a Gammon Prime strength and alloys and a lot of these really have issues with one they're either not uh easily 3D printed or they have uh you know really uh Troublesome oxidation properties like refractory Alloys and since we weren't going to be able to pick up a coating uh project on the side for like something like refractor always we decided to not go with those instead we start exploring this other class of alloy system called oxidispersion strain analysis in fact you know back in the 70s 80s 90s a lot of research was done even here at Nasa Glenn on uh alloy development for oste dispersion strength and Alloys and really what an oxidispersion strength alley is is if you can incorporate nanoscale oxides through your bulk metallic part evenly dispersed uh really a multitude of high temperature properties gets significantly improved strength creep oxidation um and things like that the issue though is how do you get those Nasco oxides into your male component you can imagine with you know more conventional you know cast processes uh once that metal melts the oxidase immediately float to the top agglomerate and are not equally dispersed in your part anymore and so in the past they would do this very expensive mechanical alloying step uh and hot compaction and then your Machining to find get a finished product and really ended up being too economically costly to really see ODS always get you know take off um in within industry however we want to take a look at you know oxidative strength now is again with this new manufacturing you know technique of laser additive um you know at our disposal and you know see if we can kind of bypass these expensive processes of the past and make ODS Alloys just by printing them you know the issue though is always how do you get your NASCAR oxides with your metallic powder into your 3D printer and what we came up with was using this new high energy mixing technique called resin acoustic mixing what we can do is we can take that metal powder which in this case starting our research was nickel cobal Chrome uh equal Atomic it's a very meanable alloy to 3D print and kind of creates a really nice Foundation uh of this OES project moving forward so we took this nickel cobalt chrome powder and this nail scale yitria particles and we would mix it in these resin acoustic mixers and what happened was those NASCAR oxides would adhere and coat the metallic nickel cobal Chrome powder and you can kind of see some sem images on the bottom here uh and if you kind of look at you know the thickness of this type of coating it looks like about 250 nanometers thick roughly that would get adhered to the the metallic powders another way to look at it is the image on the left here is of an uncoated nickel coil Chrome metal powder particle and then you can see in the middle there you know what it looks like after we coat it what was really nice was that this process doesn't you know heavily deform uh metal powder you know with mechanical alloying you take very spherical powder and by the time you're done it's almost like uh flakes or plates uh and they don't flow very well and when you try to 3D print that type of powder you really introduced a lot of defects into the to the part because it's not a very spherical uh powder for um 3D printing in this case however we don't deform the metal uh powder particles and in fact what we have found is that the flow abilities appears to improve significantly after we coat it and so it's a process this coding process is really amenable to uh the 3D printing step so we would take this yitria coated Nick cobal Chrome powder and we would put in our printer into some trial near we were able to find you know a parameter sets that evenly disperse that coated nickel uh the coated yetria into our metallic build um the image SCM image on the lower left here you can kind of hopefully pick up these really fine black dots in the micrograph there those are not pores or prostate those are actually the Nasco oxides evenly dispersed into your your metal component there and you can see it doesn't really prefer grain boundaries or other locations it really does appear to be you know evenly and randomly dispersed throughout the the metal part so we kind of proved to ourselves at this point that hey we can make ODS Alloys with this coding step using 3D printing processes without you know mechanical alloying that's about right when the pandemic started and we all got sent home for a while um so a colleague uh Chris cantos and myself decided you know you know we have a lot of these thermodynamic modeling tools at our disposal you know we know we can make nickel Chrome ODS but there's nothing too special about that composition in terms of really optimizing high temperature properties and so we want to take that foundational nickel cobal Chrome uh composition and and alloy it to maximize its um high temperature properties and so we set out some goals for our modeling process which was you know maximize solid solution strengthening while maintaining it from you know operating temperature to melting temp uh to room temperature adding grain boundary carbides for strength all while maintaining printability of the alloy composition and so what we find is that you know a loose rule of thumb is that if your range between the liquidus and solidus temperatures would say it goes above 100 degrees Celsius you're more likely to run into 3D printing issues like microcracking and things like that and so we wanted to keep a narrow freezing range and then obviously avoid tcps or any inner metallic grains that might form on grain boundaries that would be detrimental and so we ran a ton of simulations uh and really uh came to this optimized composition that we're calling grx810 and CPL um we were able to take that powder successfully uh print it and start doing some characterization the microstructure some notable things that we found was uh we do see carbon segregation at the interface between the oxide and the metal Matrix we aren't sure you know if that really has anything any additional benefit to the properties but it was an interesting observation that we could see with some high resolution Dem analysis we also uh see the presence of niobium titanium Rich carbides which are those MC carbides we want to strengthen grain boundaries and so you know the simulations uh were successful there and we also see segregation of chromium and tungsten and uranium at the grain boundaries um with this alloy so we think that might help also strengthen and improve the oxidation properties of these grain boundaries and then just looking at the atomic lattice we show there isn't any Elemental ordering or segregation and we do have a a true solid solution Matrix with this album so we started to do uh tensile testing um through a wide range of temperatures uh notably it does have very decent cryogenic temperatures high strengths High ductility even with those nanoscale oxides incorporated into its its part um um but when we start to explore this alloy compared to your more conventional 7 18 625 and even Haynes 230 what we find is that by the time you get to 2000 degrees Fahrenheit you know you start to really see the benefit of these oxides uh have on the the tensile properties here and so you can see on that bar chart on the upper left you know almost a 2X Improvement in your tensile strengths with jx810 versus you know your your rot 718 a 625 albums so then we started to do creep tests um and so this is uh creep curves to rupture at 1100 degrees C almost 20 MPA so very high temperature low stress and that red curve there is nickel cobal Chrome nanoes so just us 3D printing that nipple Cobra Chrome powder that we had I see you get a handful of hours the strains very quickly and then it you know it breaks on you the brown curve is am 718 that was hit and heat treated almost the same strain rate as nickel cobal Chrome but you can see you know it does have some longer life uh and ductility better ductility but still in about 20 hours you know your parts failed the light blue curve is actually am 625 that's been hipped that's at an even uh lower stress so 14 megapascicles and so we had actually lower the stress to be able to put this curve on on this uh and chart here um you can see you know even by lowering the stress you still only get a handful of hours with it and then this purple curve here is your uh Haynes 230 raw alloy uh strain's about the same as 718 but you do get better ductility so overall you know all these nickel-based Alloys they really can't handle this type of high temperature and the part fails very quickly this blue curve here is one of our original ODS always that we produced which we were very excited about because you know hey we you know doubled the life uh uh compared to Haines 230 with this ODS alloy if I'm going to show the same curves now with jx810 and so you can see with this you know optimized composition with the nail scale oxides we've been able to significantly improve the high temperature uh creep properties uh for this class of Alloys um you know the hipped version lasted to almost 6 600 hours uh and we actually uh interrupted the as built jx810 sample at one percent cream strain at 2 800 hours um to uh to better understand the deformation that was undergoing and so if you look at an overview of you know creep rupture lives compared to jx810 uh on this long-scale map here was stressed on the y-axis you know you can see that you're more conventional high temperature Alloys rot Alloys 625 uh 230 233 they all are kind of grouped together where you get a handful of hours that these little stresses whereas gxa10 you can either significantly increase the stress of an application you get similar lives or you know get orders and make you longer life um at the same environment something that I also want to point out is that most components more or less have failed by the time you get to one percent uh strain um due to like part size constraints and so if we looked at time to get the one percent strain you know you're very you're really reduced on the amount of time that these Alloys are able to operate you know two hours for 7 18 five hours for Haines 230 and even our original ODS you know was nine hours but if we look at the asbell gxa10 it was you know 2 800 hours the hip version 21 100 hours and that is numbers are actually better than c103 in a high vacuum which was 1100 hours and so you know our hope is that jx810 can one replace 17 and 625 that are being used in these really high temperature applications but maybe even replace c103 that's being used in some of the lower temperature applications uh just because of how costly c103 is um we started to explore oxidation comparing again Jersey 10 to 718 at 1100 C uh you see about 2x Improvement between the two Alloys about 1200 C you know you see a significant uh Divergence in their oxidation properties uh 718 failed after three one hour thermal Cycles at 1200 C basically kind of crumbled into a pile of oxides whereas grx810 x a tendo is you know losing oxide uh maintains this structure and strength um and we were able to extend the test out you know for 100 hours on that one um uh we've actually recently we've been uh performing hot fire tests on grx10 injectors and nozzles at the Marshall space flight center um and so uh we'll hopefully have uh those results um you know published here soon um you know so far the tests have been very successful um I do want to talk about you know this coding process when we started we were coding about one kilogram per hour in our in-house lab scale mixers um we've been able to now get another mixer but also optimize the coding process so that we can more or less have a coding rate of 18 kilograms per hour and so we really do feel that this coding process that we've been using for uxj10 is very robust and uh you know can be further scaled to you know maybe introduce other oxides I you know I do want to say you know this is a I think a great case study of you know how additive can uh uh Infuse you know new materials uh much more quickly than conventional processes um we started printing jrc 10 for the first time less than two years ago and you know we're all ready to doing you know component hot fire tests uh at Marshall and so that's you know I don't think you would be able to do that type of rap development with any other manufacturing process uh I do want to touch on the fact that we are also doing refractory alloy uh development here at Nasa Glenn uh for you know a multitude of applications that most people are probably aware of hypersonics uh Fusion or fission uh Power um and we've also started uh coding refractory Alloys to explore you know types of improvements and properties that we might see here and so this is some early worked out uh colleagues my colleagues Justin Milner and Eric Rises have been doing on c103 and ODS c103 and what they've been able to find is that when we incorporate these uh dispersoids into c103 you're able to significantly improve its uh strength compared to uh non-ods versions and so if we look at you know these room temperature curves here from the left to the right look at those yellow dots you can see you know almost a 40 increase in its strength and so you know not only can these dispersoids improve nickel or nickel cobal Chrome based Alloys but we do think it can you know obviously improve a wide range of different alloy systems and then lastly I would like to just show that we uh uh we're able to 3D print that original combustor Dome that kind of kicked off this whole project and we actually just finished the first series of hot fire tests on that part uh and uh it did not fail uh the way that the other uh Parts have failed which was usually through cash drop the cracking and so we're hoping to also write that report up here um pretty soon and so I'd be happy to uh answer any questions and you know discuss am thank you great thank you Tim and uh I'd like to uh thank all of the panelists today and and um we have a couple of questions to jump into so I'd like to invite um uh Jamie and Doug back as well to join us for uh maybe addressing a couple of questions um and so to jump in a a first question um maybe for Jamie there's there's questions about um you know the environmental friendliness of powder production and that sort of thing you addressed it briefly um but is is there more you can kind of say about that or is there a place where people can go to look up and and learn more about um maybe this sustainability aspect yeah sure uh so the the full life the life cycle assessment that we did on your typical product processing is available on the 6K website um certainly can reach out to any any any of us here to to talk about it but I think the part of that life cycle assessment doesn't really take into account is the fact that we're we are trying to make sure that we team with all the folks that that are in the added manufacturing world we know that there are spent Potters we know that they're a waste we know that there are some waste streams that might be undesirable and that they're not always easy to get rid of or people just don't know really how to uh get rid of them so we we do like to you know partner with folks and we'll take a look at at what what you have and what you produce and figure out the best way to get the uh the the most environmentally friendly return which generally comes with the most value as well um anything you know anything is better than putting it into into a landfill and and that's really the Genesis of our manual factoring businesses is taking some really kind of not nice stuff and titanium uh grinding swarf particulate and and making it into something useful so uh we have a lot of options at our disposal besides even just going being able to get it back to powder there are some other options as well so foreign yeah great um let's see here and then I think that's that is an important aspect of recyclability and cost too it's not just for um environmental sustainability but also you know what do you do with the effluent if you have to spend to get rid of some of these strange materials um there's a cost to recycling as well so um addressing it is important um all right so we have some additional questions around uh qualification and and getting things through like FAA um uh standards certainly mmpds which generally um you know suggests framework for what testing needs to be done and how to test materials that's still ongoing the process to develop an mmpds um standard for for additive um I I think there's there's still aspects of that that uh um that um we we really should be addressing and I think are being addressed but there's a lot that goes into making sure that we're farthest along I would say NASA probably has one of the uh most robust standards that people typically look to um and I think part of that is because NASA started into additive earlier because there's a lot of applications within NASA that I think are are well suited to additive and and to new manufacturing techniques which is kind of the point of NASA as far as I'm concerned um of doing new things and approaching things in a new way before others do but we're actually seeing quite a bit of adoption outside of uh NASA and space applications now we're seeing um we have we have an application in one of our largest applications and is in F1 racing in their engines um it's it's actually quite high volume there's uh I would say we we end up having more scrutiny in F1 racing than we do actually in a lot of uh fly light Hardware which is um surprising but you know it is someone's life and there's a lot of eyeballs on that um so there's there's I think a range of different places and and ways that people are going about qualification and qualification of additive as a new technique I um don't know if anyone wants jump to in on that but we do have quite a few other questions so we'll move to the next one uh there's a question today uh before we go you know this is the NASA 60 30 standard it's the a it's available for um public it's released to the public so you can pick it up and it basically has you know your you know your um qualified manufacturing process for additive in here including all the testing characterization nde that needs to be done so I would encourage people to read this if they want to know about the gold standard for using additive parts although it you know it doesn't apply to all materials and out of manufacturing techniques I think that's also important to identify you can quickly push the boundaries of your materials and your manufacturing techniques and get outside of the NASA 60 30 standard but for laser powder bed Fusion it's fantastic yeah and and certainly I would say that it is an incredibly strict standard that goes above and beyond a lot of other standards and and other places that are putting things together and and maybe that's because it was the first um so it it is I think if you're looking to have everything locked down the NASA standard generally is uh above and beyond many of the other standards and maybe to its detriment is then hard to actually achieve uh but then if you are able to achieve the NASA standard I think there's a lot of um robustness behind it um one of the other questions that we get and actually as elements and we get this question a lot uh Tim but um can you talk to the dispersoids and the stability of the dispersoids during Printing and I certainly have comments about that as well yeah um you yeah know we we do know um that you know with the coated powder you have to make sure you uh print with parameters that allow for the dispersed voice to be evenly dispersed um you know issues that you have to pay attention to is you know you want to make sure that you're getting agglomerations um in your part that could be you know initiation sites for uh you know cracks to form um and so I think we have a pretty good grasp of that um with what we've been doing with jx810 I will say you know in terms of spill your box size on uh testing uh they're very stable after looking at you know microstructures after at 1100 C for 3 000 hours uh you know you see very little evolution of those oxides and so you know it's one that you know main reasons why you see such improvements uh in the mechanical properties is that you know they they don't evolve when we've got those temperatures and I think it's it's one of the key differences at least for the ram technology and again I don't want to get too far into the elementum products in this setting but um because of the formation in situ of the ceramic particles that is one of the advantages of that dispersion mechanism is the formation of the uh ceramic particles in situ but I found actually that the nanoparticulates such as what uh grx A10 is doing because of the steering attachment the nanoparticles onto the larger particles it is quite stable um and we found that reuse is generally you know that's everyone's first question generally is is quite stable well you know you know I when we started out we it was a very small project and so we got you know 100 pounds of powder and so all of those properties that you're showing you know you know wasn't done with you know the first use of the powder it was all done with recycled powder um and so uh you know we've recycled powder up you know 20 30 times and haven't noticed any issues in terms of you know lack of oxides dispersed or a big drop off in mechanical properties that being said we do want to do a very robust recycling study um you know in-house hopefully have some of those results here soon but nothing is you know shown up in our testing or characterization that would suggest there would be an issue there yeah um well I I think you know we we have quite a few more questions uh and I don't I don't know that we'll be able to get to all of them um but mainly take one or two more here if we have time Patrick um so I wanna want to dive into maybe the topical questions of um did the standards that um say exist with NASA or or exist around the the um you know standards for a specific alloy system do those stifle Innovation or do they actually support innovation Doug um well I mean that's a a good question uh I would say that like you said you know the standards are rigorous and they're designed for safety and Mission success so you know you you have to have standards that you follow to be able to you know have confidence in your parts um that being said you know when you're producing things you know like metal Matrix Composites or partially reacted Alloys functionally graded materials biometallic materials it's very hard to apply standards because you know how do you do a heat treatment regimen or tension and fatigue testing on a functionally graded alloy where you might have you know a hundred intermediate compositions that transition from one material to another so it is um you know the standards that we have they're very rigorously applied to powder bed Fusion parts um depending on what classification those parts are um but clearly moving forward as we go to Exotic materials multi-materials metal Matrix Composites functionally graded Alloys there's going to have to be new ways to qualify those parts for service that take into account the fact that they cannot be conventionally qualified using your standard coupon testing and that's something that we haven't you know yet figured out completely typically what we'll have to do is qualify a particular part for a particular application and it it may not be a part that is like a structural part it might be a part that's got magnetic properties so it will it will probably involve a lot of full system level testing on the part where you actually you know fabricate your part you make five of them and then you go through the qualification process for all five but you know does it stifle Innovation I mean uh you don't want to fly things that are unsafe so you want to have standards but at the same time having the standards then puts a somewhat of a barrier to infusion so that's what I'll say I I I'd say in in our experience as elementum and developing new Alloys we're actually almost craving some standard to at least be shooting for because I mean you could do so many things I mean we've printed probably over 150 different types of Alloys from tweaking different Alloys to different levels of ceramic to different base chemistries but ultimately we have to know well you know if we need to fit within a standard so that people actually use it and go into production that really is the gap that we're trying to cover right which it's it's not that you can make something cool that has properties that are great once like we had with stir casting and when I was doing my uh PhD you could get it once but not the next time with 3D printing and and really going after some of these standards if you can do something repeatedly and be able to develop a full data set that's really where it gives us something to shoot for and go for rather than it just being kind of blood everywhere so at least unfortunately if you're if you're dealing with powder bed fusion um you know the NASA 60 30 standard is a well-defined standard that you can apply you know any material and go through the whole process so that's one thing that we've been able to do is go through the whole qualified manufacturing process from Powder all the way through part and that can be applied to then any material that can fit in powder bed Fusion so at least with monolithic materials there is a process in place that is well defined and any material can go through that process and be stood up to flight qualification with that standard it's the you know the DED processes and the multi-material processes that are much harder to do yeah uh and and so final question um there's there's a question about you know post-processing and how do you develop materials with the entire process um I think we've seen a lot in the past where it's well here's a material that should work really well uh we can print it great and then you move on but what about the additional steps of how do you machine it how do you heat treat it how do you qualify different heat treatments and find the best heat treatment there's there's quite a bit to go down there and we found certainly with many of our Alloys is we're designing them with the most simple heat treatment possible and so it's that last statement of air qualifier as possible uh Tim have you found uh I mean a similar kind of Direction uh and and what are you using to dial in the heat treatment yeah so you know specifically on the ODS Alloys um you know uh allies like Jr say 10 or the nickel Chrome was nice as there aren't any precipitates that you have to age out to to get to the properties that you want so the fact is that your best properties are actually in the as built State um uh but you know obviously there's applications where you have to have a hip step to you know close up any defects that might have shown up and so uh we've done a few different hip Cycles just to make sure that you know you you always get a really nice uh uh you know closing of any porosity that might have shown up but beyond that uh there hasn't there isn't really uh much uh post-processing we are actually doing a machining study as well on the zods Alloys in-house so that you know hopefully soon we could say hey uh if you want to you know turn this material this is the what you can expect if you want to EDM it this is what you can expect and things like that so great um so I I know we have quite a few more questions and a bunch of people this is it's it's great response I I think you know and we could get down I think some rabbit holes on some scientific discussions but with the group we have here but uh I think um you know there's there's a lot to I think take further and I I want to make sure that we are recording this and we will share the recording um certainly the data for elementum products is on our website I expect that there's other places that they can find information about the products that uh you all shared here today um uh and then certainly we will be sharing I think uh contact information for for everyone here as well so if you have additional questions or want to follow up we'll make sure that everyone has um access uh to everyone here on the webinar but I'd like to take this time to say once again thank you to all of our panelists um and and I really appreciate it I think this is uh been a great webinar so um we'll continue this series of webinars of Bridging the Gap um our we'll do about three a year as we've been continuing to do now for the past years uh two and a half um and so uh please be on the lookout for the next one so thanks everyone thank you foreign