Transcript

We're live. Food for Thought Live is back. Uh, welcome wherever you're joining us from. Um, we, and I say we because we've seen to get straight into it this week. Sorry for the delay, um, the the length of time since we've done this, uh, but here we are with a cracker. Dominic Dyer, Philip Lymbery, gentlemen, good evening. Good evening. Nice to see you. Thanks so much for joining us, Philip. It's uh what a time for us to be having this kind of discussion and just for the folks who are who are tuning into this, as always, we really welcome your questions. So whether you're joining us on Facebook or YouTube or LinkedIn, I think not 100% sure you can ask questions on LinkedIn, but we will see and indeed share your questions as they come in.

So please feel free to ask any questions of any of us, but particularly excited to have Philip with us, the global CEO of Compassion in World Farming, responsible for some incredible work globally, um, that we can all be very very grateful for. And so if you've got any questions for Philip, please don't hesitate to put them in the chat and I'll, um, I'll put them on screen and we'll share them with Philip. And obviously the three of us were very firmly on Thomas Tuchel's England selection squad and we could have been playing for England against Croatia tonight, but we decided to be here instead doing this.

Um, gentlemen, nice to see you. Great seeing you. Thank you both for having us on. Not at all. I know Philip, me and you go back a long way, but I think Dan as well, you've probably known us both quite a long time. Absolutely. Yeah, and we've lived through significant change in that time, you know. We're it's we're in the making for good and for bad and I think that, um, it's really important that people who care about animals, whether they be wild or domestic, uh, speak up now louder than ever before because one of the things which really critical is that we show that being kind to animals is even more important today and into the future.

I know that very much coming from a farming background, talking about farmed animal welfare and we were talking before we went live about how climate change is impending. We're talking about how soils are declining, how ecosystems are are are in demise and what is the common thread in all of that? It's food and the way that we produce it and the way that we consume it. And a big part of that is how we're looking after the the animals that are farmed, the the cows, the pigs, the sheep, the the fish. And one of the big ways that we can fight the challenges facing humanity in the 21st century, climate, environmental collapse, soil decline is by moving away from cruel methods of farming, from moving away from cages, crates and confinement, moving away from factory farming.

What that tells us is that the future of humanity really is hinged on how kind we are to animals. And that's a very very important and timely message. Yeah, it is. It makes me think. So obviously we've got the climate change summit starting in Turkey this week and our Prime Minister was there today, Andy Burnham, and all credit to him because he's the only G7 leaders who actually turn up. I know the President of Brazil was there yesterday and obviously the President of Turkey is is playing a key role in all of this. But it just makes me think there's a lot of cynicism about these types of summits, you know, and you get the story straight away about people not being able to get into the exhibition hall and the transport systems not up to it and all the rest of it.

Put that aside and the cost of moving tens of thousands of people and the economic and environmental impact, it's clear that we've got to stay focused on global cooperation to to deal with what we're going through. You know, we're all of a similar age and generation, but we have seen such significant change on this planet. I know when I was born in 1970, I think there were 2.6 billion people on planet Earth. There's over 8 billion now. And if we go on the way we are, we have to feed more people the next, you know, 500 years next 50 years, sorry, then we would have to in the last 10,000 years combined.

If we look at the actual scale of the population and the need to provide them with protein and food to survive. And you're quite right, Philip. The problem that we have is that we're not changing those agricultural systems at all. You know, we're almost blind to it and allowing the cruelty in the intensive agriculture systems that we know cause so much danger to mankind and the planet to continue to expand. And it's literally devouring the planet, devouring our souls almost with the cruelty, but causing huge danger to everything, the ecosystem, our health and everything else. And I'm really, really appreciate having you on because you're one of those sort of tireless voices through your campaigning, advocacy and writing books to tell the world as you've been doing for the last 20 years about where we're going wrong.

But do you sometimes think no one's listening or not enough people are listening? Sometimes I do. Um but then I remember actually that things are starting to happen. People are starting to come together. And you made a great point about how the United Nations, for example, how multilateralism, how working together as as international governments is taking a real kick in certainly over the last couple of years led I I hate to say by by the the leader of the US of of America. Um but what I've been really clear about is that if we didn't have the UN, we'd have to invent it because we need global action.

We need to come together. We need to embrace solutions. And to picking up again on your point, Dom, about do I feel hopeless? Well, I started to feel hopeless. In the I felt that we needed to talk about not just incremental change in the way that we produce food and the way that we keep animals, but food systems transformation. And then in 2019, a fantastic individual called Antonio Guterres, who had taken over as General Secretary of the United Nations, he stood up and said, we need food systems transformation. And what he did was instigated a series of summits, food systems summits that would talking about food systems transformation and making this a new lexicon for governments.

160 odd governments came together in New York in 2021 and I was I was so proud to be appointed as a official champion of this system, of this of this series of summits. And they continued last the last one was in Ethiopia, but the key thing is that governments have started to realize that transformation of the food system is needed. What we need to do as people more in the know is enable governments to see what that transformation needs to look like. And what it needs to look like first and foremost is moving away from factory farming, getting animals out of cages, crates and confinement. Yeah, absolutely.

Gentlemen, I want to take a tiny little detour away from the topic, but something you both touched upon, which I think is so pertinent, so important and so relevant to so many of the people I know watch this because I get the messages and I'm sure you guys do too. You both talked about Dom, you you described it as, you know, being it's it's like it's damaging to our soul, we see going on. And Philip, you were just talking about the fact that you did go through that phase of losing hope. People go through that. People There's compassion fatigue. We all see so many things that we find almost unbearable, but we're absolutely determined to deal with them and we'll dedicate our lives to doing so.

And I know that so many people that follow all three of us and care deeply about the subjects we're talking about, they they come to me and I'm sure to you as well with that that very challenge that they're facing. And they do from time to time. What's what message do each of you have to folks just to keep things on an somewhat even keel? Cuz it's tough. What what would you suggest, Philip, to start off with in terms of what just anything, only one single thing that people can do to look after themselves in the in the process of looking after the animals and the environment? Well, the obvious thing is to seize the power of our plate three times a day and make sure that we're eating more plants, less meat and dairy, and making sure that any meat and dairy that we have comes from animals that are not factory farms.

They're free range, organic, regenerative, these kind of things, and looking at more plant-based eating. This is a great way of putting better quality food on your plate and making sure that animals and the environment are giving a better deal as well. So it's a win-win-win. It really is. And you know what I love about that as well is that folks who feel that when they step away from the let's call it the fight I'm somewhat reluctant to use the word fight because it it it just feels like a negative energy, but we're always fighting against these horrors that we that we stand against. And even And I know that when people take a step back from that, they feel like that's part of the problem.

They feel guilty that they're they're taking that time away from the fight, looking after themselves. And that's crucial to do. But while you're doing it, if you follow what Philip just said, every every single time you sit down to eat, you are still in the fight. You're still flying the flag for the animals and the environment. Dom, what what would you say one one tip for folks to be I think we live in a world of social media and connection that we we could never have imagined even just a few years ago. And in some ways it's very liberating. It gives us great power and influence, but it can also be very dark as well.

Mm. But I think in the positive way, just like we're doing here, we can set up a podcast and people can access and share this around the world. We can all connect with people that share our visions and our same goals and our same passions and then we can become a strong voice as a result of that. And I see that all the time like yesterday and unfortunate because like you guys I get invited to lots of different events and activities and opportunities to speak and engage because of the work we do. And yesterday I was in Parliament with Peter at an event they were doing looking at you know alternatives to animal testing.

And it was inspiring to hear from you know scientists and animal rights advocates and even some MPs one of which had been in the pharmaceutical industry before it became an MP and was talking about how he wanted to see an end to animal testing and how he was campaigning now he was in Parliament. And then I went in the evenings to an event the Sea Shepherd Global were were holding a screening of a film looking at what they were doing in Greece to to basically take on the octopus farmers, you know those who the octopus fishermen particularly the illegal fishing of octopus using plastic you know boxes effectively dropped into the ocean where the octopus come into them and then they just haul them up in in their tens of thousands and the the waste the killing the the eradication of these intelligent species is just horrendous.

But I think what they showed is that by working with local fishermen and by engaging with you know scientists and marine biologists they could bring life back to areas of the Mediterranean Mediterranean that have become you know effectively biodiversity deserts and that's something that's very close to my heart you know my partner's Turkish Cypriot. I remember spending time when we first met in Cyprus a lot. And the Mediterranean became very important to me but now if you go back to those places, there has been a huge eradication of of wildlife and marine life. And I think, you know, it's trying to support opportunities like that.

And and the lots of people in the room last night were volunteers, people that would go and volunteer on Sea Shepherd missions or were just donors and supporters just wanted to come along and talk. And yeah, we were talking about changing your eating habits and you know, looking at what was going on in in in the in the issues around marine life. Krill was another big discussion last night, you know, the extraction of krill, you know, by Chinese and Russian ships in the Arctic and the impact that's having. And one of the things that was amazing, they showed a film of just how the whales had returned to the Arctic, fin whales, in numbers unimaginable because, you know, we've had that moratorium on whaling in the Southern Arctic.

And whales have returned and they are, you know, in numbers that we could never have imagined we could have seen in years gone by with industrial whaling nearly pushed this species to the verge of extinction. But at the same time as those whales are appearing, the ships are there taking their food source away. So we stopped killing them, but we're almost killing them in another way. So we're not harpooning them anymore. We're actually sucking up their food source, which as we know is so important to the whole ecosystem of the planet. So I think it was just a challenging but also wonderful opportunity to bring people together.

And I think we've got to constantly do that, which I think why Philip in the books you do and all the campaigning and Dan, your film that you did looking at, you know, what was happening in intensive farming and food and you know, the move towards veganism, all of these things and what I can do are so important. But it's the people we can reach and bring together as a consequence of our actions because every one of those goes on and speaks to someone else and inspires someone else to care about this stuff as well. That's what keeps me going. I know it's what keeps you two going as well. Yeah, absolutely.

And I mean, it's you you know, you mentioned the whales and of course there's a downside as as per the krill, but I I do feel it's so important to celebrate the wins. And it seems that we're in a we work in a space where there's a bit of a tendency to focus on the the horrors. Of course we do because there's always those to deal with. But I think part of the the the methodology that I try to use to stay positive and stay hopeful and stay in the game, in the fight, is to is to celebrate those wins. You might have to seek them out. Maybe we should start sharing one on every one of these podcasts.

Speaking of which, you mentioned Octopus. Philip, am I right in thinking I cuz I see so much from you on on social media and I and I know that you were quite active in that fight against the planned octopus farm. What was the uh what was the latest on that? Well, the latest on that is a great victory for people who care about animals. We stopped plans for the world's first commercial octopus farm uh in Gran Canaria. When I say we, a coalition of fantastic animal welfare organizations, we got the plans withdrawn and it's just one of a number of fantastic victories that we've had this year. Getting the first commercial octopus farm stopped, uh getting Brittany Ferries to to pull out of to come out of the live animal export trade, taking calves from Ireland to France, which they hadn't been in for decades and then suddenly started again.

We've got them to stop. And this year we've also seen uh the UK government getting on with its animal welfare strategy uh and that includes um consultation on banning cages for laying hens and for pigs and a consultation on that is open at the moment and these people um get involved in it um a consultation on stopping the horrendous horrendous practice of killing pigs by lowering them into carbon dioxide gas chambers, something which 30 years ago scientists said don't do this. This is just beyond terrible. Yet it's taken off 90% of pigs from all different systems, whether it be factory farmed or or others, get killed in these ways.

But the government is looking at banning it. So please support the ambition by getting involved in the consultation consultation. So plenty to celebrate, but plenty yet still to do. Always. Always. Um speaking of consultations, one that springs to mind immediately is the I think it's now closed. And for anyone in in outside of the UK or unfamiliar with the process, we in Parliament here, they'll they'll talk about issuing a consultation in order to have a look at the situation related to something and then decide whether they'll change legislation or regulations and various or laws even. And one of them they're dealing with right now, which is very topical right now and which of course, as is the case every year, has gone mini viral on my page is my stance against fireworks.

And a government consultation that's taken place recently in regards to fireworks where we hope to God there's going to be some sort of at least a reduction in the noise level, which to me actually seems far too little. But we I know all three of us very much involved in that that fight against fireworks. And it's one that I don't know about you, gentlemen, but I find that I get so much the one of the reasons why people do sometimes find it exhausting to fight the good fight is the is what they run into in terms of resistance. And and I don't know I can that I can think of a greater example of of feeling sometimes feeling a little hopeless when you start to read the responses from people.

So you can lay out, for example, the fact that war veterans who suffer with PTSD will have flashbacks because of fireworks. You can demonstrate statistically provable demonstrations of the impact, negative impacts on wildlife, on domestic pets. 45% no less of dogs in the UK or dog owners say that 45% of the all of the dogs in the UK, which by the way is somewhere between five and six million dogs, show visible signs of fear and stress all the way up to injuring themselves or death. Um but of course those are the most extreme examples, but that many animals negatively affected, provably so. Not to mention horses, not to mention people with dementia, Alzheimer's, ADHD, not to mention the litter, the crime, the property damage, the fires, the the list goes on.

You can you can present all that and then find yourself faced with people saying you're the fun police. We should be able to enjoy our fireworks and do what we want and it's really important to us because it's tradition. It's What what are your thoughts on the fireworks thing, Philip? Because I I know you know you're a great lover of birds and um they're some of the most negatively adversely affected animals when it comes to fireworks, aren't they? They absolutely are and I think to answer your question, I think that that that we should follow the lead from the Netherlands and ban noisy fireworks, big showy noisy ones which cause abject panic and terror in animals, wild and domestic.

And they do so at a time when those animals are least able to do anything about it. The last thing you want to be doing is panicking when it's dark, when it's the middle of the night, when and where you can't see where you're going, where you're going to bash into the nearest tree. And the sheer terror of that was brought home to me, not so much from wild animals. I mean I've seen wild birds flicking around uh in uh fear in the bushes, not knowing what where to go next. But our uh previous uh dog, Duke, um the four-legged love of my life, uh he was terrified by fireworks to the point where he would shake uncontrollably and we would have to sedate him to get him through the firework night.

And and you make a really really important point there with your mention of firework night, because that's one of the other things that we see so often is people in defense of fireworks, which let's be honest, is it literally their causes the loud bang, which is kind of embarrassing, but in defense of fireworks and the loud bang and their right to hear it, they'll say it's only once a year, as if as if that's even vaguely true, because of course we all know that sometime prior to the 31st of October, it starts for Halloween. It goes all the way through from Halloween to the 5th of November, which great example this year, it fell on a Thursday, so we had fireworks on Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and lo and behold, what was on Sunday?

Diwali. So then we had Diwali. Now we're in the lead up to Christmas, then we'll have New Year, then we'll have Chinese New Year. And in each of those occasions, not only is it across a number of days or weeks even, but it's the the the school across the road will have a display and then the rugby club and then the neigh the neighbor doing it in their back garden and and and it's there's no end to it. It can start before it's even dark, Yeah. probably another good indication of just how stupid some of these people are. But it will go on for hours and hours well past the theoretical cutoff of 11:00 p.m.

So how are you supposed to sedate healthily, safely, sedate your your dog or your cat or your horse and prepare for that one night of the year when there's a local fireworks display at 7:00 p.m. on the 5th of November, and then you don't have to worry. It's nonsense. It's that's never the way it works. It is. I mean, it's like living for days, feels like weeks in a war zone. And looking after your your falling companion who you know the the first bang has them in absolute shakes. And having to after him day after day is is just incredibly difficult. And it just may always made me think, come on guys, think about your neighbors.

This has got to be seen as something that is unnecessary. And I hate to use the word, but selfish. 100% And it's it's an issue that's had massive massive public concern going back over the last decade. I think there's been three or maybe even four 100,000 petitions. We know how difficult they are to get government petitions for debates in Parliament on it. It's only now the government have been forced into the consultation that they've issued. And there's been lots of MPs to be fair of all parties have engaged with their constituents and put forward private members bills and issues like that. So I think all of that has helped.

But you still get the push back from the fireworks industry that if we do regulate too tightly, like you've seen in Ireland, it gives us an example where there is an outright ban on the private sale of fireworks that can only be used for displays. Then people are you know wandering around with vans at night selling them out the back of vans. And they say, well, that's what will happen if we do the same in England. Now there is a danger of that. But I think also we need to look to the future. The one thing I do like in the government's consultation having responded to it on behalf of Born Free was that you know, there is a sort of focus on on a new industry for silent fireworks for the use of drones where UK could become a leader, you know, as part of its broader sort of you know, entertainment industry, creative industries.

And I would like to see that. So I think it's a case where government can say we don't need to be importing, you know, cheap, dangerous fireworks from China and places like that that are being let off in the streets and are causing all this distress to animals and people. We could actually say we want to regulate more closely, you know, the decibel levels and lower the sound and we need to out, you know, make a lot of the big sort of air bomb type fireworks completely ban them and say that they have to go only for public display, the vast majority of fireworks. But then the better thing would be to to bring about a new industry in the UK.

You know, if you look at what drones can do visually, they're amazing. You know, we see examples of that around the world now. Incredible. And you don't get the noise, you don't get the smell, you don't get all the sort of flashing lights that cause all the distress that we've just been talking about. So I I just think we've got to think out of the box and change. And you know, I remember as a kid that the dangers of fireworks were horrendous. You know, those sparklers that you could get and you'd burn your hands and Yeah. you know, people letting off bangers in the streets. So we've come some way from that.

But the problem we have now is that I think fireworks are more accessible. They've been becoming more noisy and they're used, you know, for Diwali or for bonfire night or for New Year or whatever. And it goes on and on and on. And it's causing increased distress across society. And I think this does unite a lot of people, millions of people to want change. But I think government have to bite the bullet and say they'll take on some of those vested interests within an industry to say you have to change because that's what the public demand and that's what we need to see. We'll have to see the outcome of that consultation and what happens next.

We will. When is the When will we know the outcome? Do you either of you know? Well, government don't give timelines for responding to consultations and often they can sort of delay things if they don't, you know, particularly want to move on it. I think this one I hope they will respond to quite quickly with a, you know, a process of what they're going to do and try and build cross-party consensus in Parliament. But actually, that's what we need to see. But I think it's up to people then to be contacting their MPs and say listen, we want you to to get behind this. This is where parliamentary democracy is really important in that sense as well.

Indeed. Exactly. And that's what where you going back to your question Dom about how we can all get involved. Power of our plate three times a day was my instant response. My second response is always get get involved with organisations that are tackling these issues because going through their websites will give you the the portal if you like to get in touch with your MPs to make your your voice heard and to make change happen. So yeah, get involved with organisations, support them, get their newsletters. They'll be telling you when is the moment to respond to a consultation, to get involved and encourage your MP to vote the right way.

Indeed. I always get the impression that sometimes with with certain causes, specific causes such as fireworks and fireworks is a good example of it, is that people just think it's just not going to change. It's too widespread. It's too popular. And I'll just remind you guys if you're watching thinking that and we were Dom mentioned we're all of a similar age and we are so we all all remember the the the the advent of you can't smoke in public places anymore because we grew up. If you if when you went to a restaurant or a bar Yep. you would you'd need to have a shower because you unless you didn't mind stinking of smoke for the rest of the week because everything you were wearing your hair everything it was just absolutely vile and nobody I dare I dare say at the time nobody who smoked and wanted to continue smoking would have believed for a moment that that legislation would have got through and it did and it changed everything and now it's completely unheard of.

It's in fact it's bizarre when you go to a country that's still allowing that kind of thing you it's utterly utterly bizarre isn't it when you actually walk into a any any establishment and people are smoking indoors. It's like wow, it's like a trip down memory lane, but it's a pretty disgusting one. So I think that's a really good example of something excuse me, that was so widespread, so accepted, mainstream. But I don't see fireworks as being any different. No, I think it's a good example to use. And remember that you know, if you look back at the smoking debate at the time when the Labour government Tony Blair brought the ban in it was oh, should we have a phased ban?

Should we just have areas where people can smoke and where they don't smoke? And there was lots of debate. And in the end, no, actually we need a complete ban. Uh and that's what we got. And you look back at it now, most countries have replicated those bans. And like on planes and things, you remember you would have flown. I remember flying on airplanes where you had a smoking area and a smoking to come back. You know? Um so yeah, but it is a lot better. Wasn't it funny that the front of the plane was non-smoking and the back was smoking? As if as if there was any difference. And I think we've just cut you know, there are numerous consultations.

You know, and you were just talking about the the battery cages and you know, the situation with pigs and things. You work for years, you you know, fill up through the work you do both nationally and internationally to get change, be that European or a national level for example. And then you know, what is the legislation going to look like? How's it going to be enforced? What are all the vested interests that will try and push back and say we can't possibly do that? Um but I think at the center of what we're always trying to do, you got to think about what's the best interest of public safety and health, animal welfare, protection of the environment.

These are the fundamental principles that underpin all of what we're trying to do here, isn't it? Absolutely. Absolutely. And big change takes time and effort and people who care making their voice known. Uh there are plenty examples that I can think of where I've been told you'll never change that. You'll never bring that to an end. Classic one, live animal exports from the UK. In the 1990s it was a big deal. We had thousands of people out on the streets, at ports, airports, all around the country. But the basic message that I was hearing from people that were not so involved in in championing the cause in the debate was you'll never get that to stop.

Mm. We did. It took a while, but in 2024 we got it banned. And there we are. Yeah, it's it's about victories to celebrate and there's a huge one right there. And I realize I know we've had this conversation before, Philip, and no doubt we'll we'll continue to and have to because I know that there's a uh large swath of the vegan community and absolutely understandably so who feel that it's um it's not enough. You know, we it's that that to they I mean I know we're referred to as welfarists in that in that sort of swath of the let's call them the um the abolitionist community who feel that um that by saying, for example, let's ban live exports that we're saying listen, farms are fine, eating animals is fine as long as you tick these boxes.

That's not what it's about. It's important to to understand that because what we're saying is we we just recognize the reality of these things such as farms. And as long as they are a reality, let's make sure that welfare standards are as good and as tight as they can be. Needless to say, all of us here and probably everybody watching um would prefer there to be no need to have these conversations at all because we'd love it if there weren't farms. Just like I have the same conversation with Born Free and the clue is in the name of the the charity who who advocate for welfare standards in zoos.

It's not because they're saying zoos are okay or or or or anything along those lines. They're simply saying as long as they're a reality, let's ensure that the animals in those horrific circumstances are at least we're mitigating some of the suffering. And so that is a huge win. No live exports. I think that's a a great example. Yeah, you're absolutely right there that uh it's it's important that we don't let purity, the ambition for purity become uh the thing which prevents progress. Uh progress takes time. It it's doesn't always go in straight lines uh and and it it requires one change to build towards another change and a ripple effect.

And that's what we're we're trying to do and I'm always reminded um so Compassion in World Farming is 60 years old next year. I've been involved with the organization for 35 years. Can can you believe that? And uh I worked with founder of the organization who was formerly a dairy farmer. He gave up dairying and uh he went plant-based in his eating, started Compassion in World Farming. He also started a plant-based innovation company called Direct Foods that was bringing some of the first uh meat, plant-based meat, textured vegetable protein and you if if your memory is long enough you may also remember the packets of a burger mix sizzles and this was his company.

Um but his view was yes of course we need to go beyond um the the over consumption of meat. It would be great if people when when vegan but we can't just abandon the animals to suffering until that purity day comes when no one is eating meat ever again. That was his view. Uh that I took to heart. I met I him. I was I was a radical animal activist when I met him. I'm still a a radical animal activist, but of a different blend. And I took to heart that we cannot abandon the animals to suffering for decade upon decade upon decade, probably possibly even centuries uh until big change comes. Better to see the big change being hastened by every significant step change that we make.

And banning live exports is one of those. Stopping the the the world's first commercial octopus farm is another. And getting carbon dioxide gas killing of pigs stopped is another on top of that. I could go on. Cages, of course, is the spearhead to ending factory farming. Ending factory farming is the spearhead to major dietary change. But one thing which I absolutely believe is that by us keeping on, keeping on, as people who care, who feel it in our heart, we're the people who put animal kindness kindness to animals at the center of society where it needs to be. Can I bring up one issue that I think is important when we talk about the evolution of how we eat and produce our food, which I know you've been involved in the debate on, and that's cell-based meat production, the idea that we can produce meat protein effectively in a factory environment, taking cells from one animal, but we don't have to implicate, you know, millions of animals in this horrible factory destruction system that we're all too familiar with.

This technology has come a long way, hasn't it, in the last 10 years um and offers potentially not a a complete solution, but could make play a major role in altering the way we consume food without some of the significant environmental animal health suffering implications that that in intensive livestock system. Where are you on this now? Uh and where do you think we need to go to make this type of technology widely consumed in McDonald's and places like that that you know we we just take for granted we can get whatever we want from meat produced foods. Well cultivated meat, as cell based meat, lab grown meat as the media like to call it is a potentially a game changer.

We can take uh cells from animals using a harmless biopsy, grow them in uh in a bioreactor uh and hey presto we've got meat with a fraction of the environmental impact, a fraction of of the climate change impact. No slaughter, no factory farming uh and it can happen. In fact it is starting to happen. By pure chance or not this is a path of the world's first commercially available pet treat made from cultivated meat and our rescue dog I talked about Duke who sadly passed away uh but our rescue rescue dog now Bruce he loves these. Cultivated meat could be that game changer. It could give those who eat meat the thing that they want meat uh without the downside.

What do we need to get this going? Well we need to ensure the the the and we here is society needs to ensure that there is the investment, that there is the R&D, that we clear away the legal barriers because at the moment we're kind of in a bit of a catch 22 situation where these cultivated meat companies uh they're startups usually looking for investment. Uh they want entrepreneurs to put money in but who's going to put money in if there's no guarantee that there that that that the product can be sold because at the moment for example whilst this can be sold in the UK uh cultivated meat can't be sold to human consumers.

How strange is that? So who's going to put the money in if you can't get a guarantee that the products are going to get sold and you'll get a return for that money? That's the catch 22. So we need government. We need government to remove the barriers. We need the financial sector to get involved in this this part of food system transformation. And we can all get involved by speaking up and championing this new way forward. But do we think, you know, the point that interests me on a lot of this, having worked in the food industry and working in conservation wildlife protection these days, is that you're absolutely right, the government side of this is absolutely critical.

But if you look at say AI technology where governments are pouring huge amounts of money into data centers to say that we've got to have AI because it's fundamental to the future of our economy and our world, we're not seeing a similar debate to say actually we've got to have cell-based meat because if we don't have cell-based meat we're buggered effectively you know my my language. You know I used to work in the the soy food industry. I've been down South America. I've seen in Brazil and and and those parts of the world what industrial production of soy looks like. The scale of it is unimaginable.

The vast majority of it that has huge implications for how it's produced and harvested and the environmental impact is all going into meat primarily which is hugely wasteful as you know Phillip in terms of producing an end product. This is crazy. It's a system that can't go on. We were at almost at the end of what we can do with all of that. Never mind the suffering, never mind the zoonotic disease risks, never mind all the deforestation and pollution. We just can't go on doing that if we're going to feed as we said you know more people in the next 50 years than the last 10,000 combined which is what we have to do.

So we have to move to alternative proteins. Now there's plant-based proteins, there might be insect proteins, but cell-based meat is going to be a significant factor. What I don't understand is why there hasn't been a crisis summit where you bring you know industry and world leaders together saying, actually, we're going to do this now. We're going to invest billions and billions into producing the data centers of the world, which this will actually be cell-based meat production facilities. And we will industrialize this industry and we will start to produce first-rate tasting products that we will then legislate so actually McDonald's and all these companies have to use those products to feed people with.

Now you'll get lots of conspiracy theorists thinking this is like soil and green and we're all going to be, you know, industrial fed and done in. But ultimately you've got to make the case, haven't you? That if you don't do that, if you don't go down this route, we just can't sustain. The world just doesn't have enough resource to to to maintain this demand for protein. And our ecosystems are collapsing and we're increasing significantly the zoonotic disease risk and all the other things that we're familiar with. So I just think we're at a cutting point. The other thing, of course, is you've got to convince farmers of that.

And like there's farmers I know, you know farmers, I know farmers. This is an awful industry to work in if you have livestock. You know, you've rather got industrial livestock farms which are horrendous. And we got small livestock farmers just trying to make a living with all the muck and all the dirt and all that hard work. You know, most of the next generation of people aren't going to want to do that coming into farming. But if you gave them an opportunity to have some nice clean factory unit on their land that produce cell-based meat that goes off to McDonald's and on the other side they produce their cereal crops and things.

That's actually quite a nice business. You know, with all the modern technology and everything you've got with drones and everything, you can be you can be sitting right pretty making a lot of money, not really having to get your hands dirty very much in a very clean tech-based focused industry where there is no suffering, no disease risk. Right. That's the farming future that we have to have. But our governments are not doing that at all. What they're doing is they're in bed with industrial livestock farming systems and lobby groups that keep perpetuating this myth that we can't stop doing this, otherwise our whole system of food production will collapse.

And and our poor farmers will be done in. That's you know you know that, I know that, you know but I think the broader public is not maybe thinking enough along those lines and the urgency of this matter. You know we talk a lot about getting off fossil fuels and that has to be urgent. We need to get off industrial livestock just as urgently, just as urgently. Mm. But we're not getting anything like that. So you know there'll be hardly any discussion about any of that at the COP summit in Antalya. But actually it should be fundamentally part of it and it wasn't in the Prime Minister's speech this morning because my one put it in there because he wasn't going to say that the NFU would go mad.

You know what if he'd have just stood up and go by the way we're going to have to have cell based meat production. I'm going to say it now because it's really important and if you held up a bag of what you've just held up and go you know what I can feed this to my dog but I can't actually eat it. We've got to address that. That would make headlines around the world wouldn't it? But that's exactly what we're going to need to see. We are going to need to see that. So you know it's really important. You're absolutely right Dom and the great news is that there are innovations starting to bring farmers on board.

There is a fantastic organisation in the Netherlands called Respect Farms run by a brilliant woman called Ira van Eelen and it is about getting farmers on board and they're just opening the first on farm cultivated meat plant to do exactly what you're saying Dom to show that this is something that won't replace farmers, it will just replace the horrible hard work that they won't be wanting to do in the future and making it cleaner and easier, more competitive. This is the way forward. So Respect Farms in the Netherlands and Ira van Eelen is is a remarkable person. Her father is seen as the as the grandfather of cultivated meat.

He it was his vision that started humanity on this pathway of taking taking animal killing out of the the meat industry. We'll get there. I've no doubt, but we need to raise the voice a lot lot louder. That's a challenge to vegans as well though, Dan, isn't it? Because many vegans deeply opposed to the idea of cell-based meat as well. Where do you see that debate Um I think it it it's it kind of is absolutely fundamental part of exactly as I was talking about earlier on with regards to for want of a better expression the abolitionist movement whose view for anyone who's not familiar with it is that basically all of us should stop doing what we're doing in terms of things like the examples Philips given about welfare standards in farms or born free stopping the work to improve welfare standards in zoos and indeed stopping things like saying let's transition away from meat and dairy into these different alternatives with things like Veganuary or Meatless Monday.

The abolitionists are the folks who say we're actually causing more harm than good by focusing on those things and that we should all drop all thing all of our other focuses and just say to everyone around us go vegan now 100% and vegan not just being a diet of course it's a lifestyle. Um and it again it just comes down to a and I hate to say it because I'm not trying to be critical of anyone. I think there's a place for all of these different movements. I think there's a need for all of them in fact. There's no right or wrong because there's no single formula that will trigger and change the mind of a person because we're all individuals we're all different um but essentially we we are in a place now where you've got the abolitionists saying if we don't down tools in what with what we're doing and just focus on turning everyone vegan we're making things worse and I'll have conversations with those same people who were desperately upset at the fact that those closest to them, their family, their friends, their colleagues, the people who love and respect them the most in the world haven't made the transition away yet despite their best efforts, which in in in itself is is is indicative of just how unrealistic that approach is.

And so I think, Dom, to answer your question, there there is to some extent nothing that can be done about that mindset. But what can be done is to is to demonstrate that it's it has worked and it will continue to work. And a brilliant example of that I was reminded of when I was listening to you guys talk about it just now in terms of helping farmers transition away from meat into something else, which frankly they probably prefer to do. Although I'm sure some would would would take a different view on that, but I'm sure we you you guys both remember the incredible success that Humane Society International have had some years ago, now known as Humane World for Animals, who worked with rather than just berating and villainizing the the dog meat farmers in South Korea, which is just horrific to even say that sentence, dog meat farmers, because it's just a concept we can't get our heads around.

But for the for the likes of the vegan community, myself included, it's just as horrific to be pig, chicken, cow, sheep farming. They're all sentient beings that deserve a life and not to be exploited and killed. But Humane Society International, as they were called at the time, worked hand in hand with the dog meat farmers of South Korea to transition their business into things like blueberry farms. And the thing that was so powerful about that was that there was a an upcoming generation in South Korea that were in they they they felt about the dog meat trade the way that I feel and we we all feel about the the meat industry and the dairy industry.

They were horrified by it, and there's this really really deep stigma attached to that business that farmers had an opportunity to walk away from. They had an opportunity to now not not only to be more profitable because now they can sell something more widely. They can I don't know what the correct terminology is, Philip. I'm sure you can tell me where where they can have, you know, multiple crops throughout the year based on um making the best use of the the the resources available to them rather than just having a single crop a year, though we really are going to have to talk about this very soon.

Um and and they transitioned those farmers away from dog meat into things like blueberries, and those farmers have got a more profitable business and who who's up in arms about blueberries? No no one's fighting blueberries being being grown and sold as they are with things like uh in their case dogs, but in our case pigs, sheep, chickens, and everything else. So I think that the only thing we can do and and I I can't claim to know that it's going to work with everybody is to just keep on demonstrating that kind of success, that kind of win. That's huge and arguably much more difficult. If you think about the the the depth that those people had to be into the business they had in order to be willing to do that to dogs.

Um and it's some of the most horrific scenes any human being could ever possibly see, and these guys worked in that business, and now they are blueberry farmers. Yeah. But but I think also incentives, isn't it? You know, I think you're right. You know, what Humane Society did in South Korea is a good example of where you give incentives and give options to people to do different things. I think, you know, it was fascinating what you're saying, Philip, about what was happening in Holland, but what we need to see over the next 10 years is a new generation of cell-based meat farmers, don't they? We absolutely we need to see governments, just like at the moment they're trying to say to us, you want to give up your, you know, your internal combustion engine car for a for an electric car, and or we want you to have a heat pump, then we're going to, you know, incentivize you through various financial policies to do that.

Governments need to do that with farmers. They need to say, actually we are going to incentivize you to to to go into this type of farming. Exactly. Because actually it's going to reduce the burden on the state in terms of disease control and all the issues around meat production and all the pollution and you could come up with a whole list of public goods of taking a farmer from being a livestock farmer and putting them into a cell-based meat farmer where the taxpayer would benefit, less pollution in the river, less disease risk, bovine TB. I could give you a whole list in the UK which would save hundreds of millions of pounds.

Mm. So on that basis, of course the government should incentivize. And if that then brings a new generation of farmers into the industry, then that's a good thing because they become advocates for that. They become technologists. They become people that are using technology and innovation to create a new way of feeding the planet. They become environmentalists, which I think many farmers really are and want to be. And they they they they're in a future evolution industry which is not struggling to survive, that's actually moving forward. That's the type of excitement that brings the next generation in.

Whereas, you know, at the moment you have farmers struggling to survive, you're increasingly getting old and all the problems associated with it. I just think it's a win-win, but we need that sort of vision from government. And also we need the Elon Musks and and the others of the world at the moment that waste their money trying to go to Mars to become part of that. And actually the Bezos and other people is actually I'm going to start putting money into that as well so that we can back what government funds are going in. And we start to see hundreds, thousands, tens of thousands of cell-based farmers around the world, and then they become an industrial lobby group of their own.

They have their own unions and all and that's when everything changes. It does. That's when you reach tipping point. But you have to have a vision to set out to do that. What I'm I'm fearful of is that, you know, we can have this discussion here and we could lay out that vision. I I think in many government departments around the world that debate's not even starting, and within the farming industry largely, the industry that you try and influence through your writing and things, I don't think it's largely starting. But let's hope that as you were saying in places like Holland that it is beginning to change and we can do it.

Yeah, I think it is starting to change. I talked about the food systems summits, talking about food systems transformation. We've we've talked about respect farms. We've seen the upsurge of regenerative farming, groundswell being a major conference for example, the Oxford Real Farming Conference which is was started as a fringe meeting in opposition to the industrial farming conference across the world across the road that took place in Oxford every year. Still does. The real farming, the that fringe meeting in opposition is now bigger than the industrial one over the road. So things are starting to happen and I think where I absolutely would echo what you're saying, Dom, is that when we think about the food system that we've got now, which is dominated by factory farming, where animals are cage crammed and confined, where overconsumption of meat is is encouraged by the price signals, by the availability, by all sorts of things.

That didn't happen by accident. That happened by design. It was government policy decisions and funding, support way back in the middle of the starting in the middle of the last century, decades of government policy and and funding has gone into that. All sorts of other things as well, but the key point is it didn't happen by accident. What we now need, because we can see that the way that we're producing food, particularly farmed animals, because that's at the centre of the major challenges for humanity. It's a big thing for climate change. The livestock industry producing more greenhouse gases than all the world's planes, trains, and cars.

Industrial agriculture being the major reason why we're losing so much wildlife and environmental ecosystems around the world. And industrial agriculture also being the thing which is driving us to a future where if we carry on as we are, in 60 years time we may have no more soil. No soil, no food. Game over. So what we need is for governments to recognize that that food systems transformation they've started to talk about actually needs to be spearheaded by ending factory farming of animals. Not just because it's the right thing to do for animals, but because this is fundamental the future for us all.

Philip, that's such a great point you've made so beautifully again. And I say again because of course you made this point in Food for Thought, the documentary that you very kindly featured in that we released about 18 months ago. I mentioned that as a deliberate plug just before I plug Philip's book of the similar subjects to what he was just talking about. But Philip, I want to ask you to repeat a question or at least an answer sorry to a question that I gave to you in the documentary which has just come up from OPR Consulting. Great question here. Would food sorry would we be able to sustain food supplies if we trade if we stopped from dairy and meat?

And you're and it's and you're saying it's an uneducated question. It's not. This is this is a very very widespread belief which I'm sure Dom and I are clambering over ourselves to answer, but I know that Philip answers it beautifully with some statistics which will shock you. So the question being would we be able to sustain food supplies if we stopped eating meat and dairy? And of course what that comes back down to is that question around the amount of land, usable land space that's dedicated to growing crops and how much of that crop is used to feed animals which are then killed and eaten.

What are those statistics looking like these days, Philip? I know you covered this in food for thought but you'll you'll be able to cover it beautifully. You know the statistics are are this that our current food system occupies uh nearly half the world's habitable land surface and of that 80% of the agricultural land is devoted to producing animal products, meat and dairy. Those animal products from that 80% of that land uh deliver for humanity uh a a third of our protein, just over a third of our protein and less than a fifth of our calories. What that tells you is the 20% of the agricultural land in the world that is dedicated to plants for human consumption is actually providing the majority of our protein and the majority of our calories.

So could we could we uh feed the world without animal farming? Absolutely, much better on a fraction of the land. But if we wanted to go halfway house, let's just do that as a as an example and move away from factory farming which is predicated on uh feeding human edible crops, cereals and soya to incarcerated animals. If we moved away from that process, could we feed the world? Hell yes. We could actually feed an extra two billion people on the planet by simply moving away from factory farming and giving animals at the freedom that they deserve. I said he'd answer it beautifully, didn't I? Um, thank you for that, Philip.

It's uh it I hope that answers your question there, OPR Consulting, and it's a really important question and not a silly one. Um, and again, Philip, thank you for just for for clarifying those statistics so succinctly because I think that that's the sort of thing that people don't realize. You know, I mean it's the it's it's the go-to argument, isn't it, of the anti-vegan movement is well, where would I get my protein from? And you've just demonstrated that two-thirds of it comes from plants. And and actually to take it a step further, the only reality about animals is that they're a conduit for the protein that they themselves consume in the form of plants, which so essentially going vegan is just cutting out the middleman, which is an unfortunate animal that's sacrificed for a for the sake of concentrated protein.

It's kind of ridiculous and barbaric and and um to your point about you know, the resources available to the the the I think people think of the planet as a finite resource, at least they certainly did and and perhaps with with less ignorant these days, but for the for those of you who aren't familiar with this book, 60 Harvests Left, written by our our guest, Philip Lymbery, and and and published, if I'm not mistaken, Philip, you said 2022, so four years ago now. Yes. Could you just dis explain the concept of 60 Harvests Left and just what that actually means? Because I think this is another crucial point for people to understand in terms of the urgency of shifting towards plant-based food systems.

Well, the industrialization of agriculture has had many consequences. One of them is that it's depleting the world's soils. Uh and what I found was that um a a a leading professor called Professor Crawford had worked out that if we carry on as we are, destroying the world's soils by the practices we're using, then in 60 years time we will have no soil, and that will mean we won't be able to grow food. And and I've I I thought at the time, goodness, that's 60 years from now, but actually he worked that out in 2012. Time is running out. We need to take action. That is why we need the food systems transformation that moves away from factory farming, that gets takes away the walls from these farms, gets animals back out into the countryside, gives them decent lives, and a promotion of of a new more balanced consumption where we rein back the amount of meat and dairy that we're eating as a society.

And scientific evidence shows that we need to rein it back by half or more globally if we are to get back within planetary boundaries, a safe operating space that will ensure the future for our children. So there's a lot to be said for being kind to animals. Being kind to animals is absolutely being kind to ourselves and being kind to our children's children. So let's just do it. You see folks, this is why we have guests like Philip on. This is Thank you for that beautiful words as always. Dom, I'm going to I'm going to ask this question slowly because I can see you're chewing something. I just wanted to wanted to ask you to elaborate on before we went live we were having a conversation and I heard you talk about some of the latest statistics in regards to climate change and the temperature increase has was was feared and has now become a reality.

What was it you were saying on that? Cuz I think again and folks, just to be clear here, I think these things are important. The reason why I think these statistics are important to share is because it will compel people who don't know to take more action even if that is just making different choices of of the food they eat because we're running out of time to make choices. Sorry, Dom, go ahead and We are and I think, you know, as we can probably bring in this discussion to a close and it's been fascinating, but to do it justice, I think we we have to come back to what's being discussed in Antalya, you know, as we talk about the future of the planet in relation to climate change.

And this summer, you know, this summer in my view has been a life-changing experience for us all and a wake up to what the reality that we're going to face in the future and it could be the coolest summer we can experience into the future, which is absolutely terrifying, bearing in mind we were saying before we came on air that actually if you looked at temperatures in Britain this year and actually in Europe they were far worse, but in Britain they were terrible. Mm. It didn't actually drop below 20 degrees from late April all the way through to late October. Across this country the temperature was over 20 degrees from late April to late October to a large degree across the whole of the United Kingdom.

There were some areas where it cooled off more rapidly in Scotland and Northern Ireland and places, but the vast majority of the country was still topping out over 20 degrees into late October, which means you could wear your shorts and t-shirt effectively in Britain from late April to late October. Which is amazing. sort of Australian climate effectively or a southern Mediterranean climate or a North African climate almost. And that's happened. That's now with us. And if you look at what France went through this year, central France, southern France, parts of central Eastern Europe and other parts of Europe, over 40 degrees from May all the way through to late August, over 40 degrees.

Those are unprecedented temperatures, which we know have caused huge wildfires. We know as as Philip will be looking at and other people in the who look at farming the impact is going to have on crop yields and you know water and another issues relating to agriculture is significant. We've not really started to estimate the impact of that yet. We're beginning to see obviously global food prices and commodity prices rise alongside energy prices so food is becoming more expensive. You know I used to work in the plant science industry. I remember speaking to Sir John Beddington who was chief scientist at the time at dinner I went to.

Uh we had like a small sort of gathering of chief scientists including the American chief scientist who worked with Hillary Clinton as Secretary of State at the time in Brussels and it was one of those discussions where we'd all had a you know a few glasses of wine and we'd had a nice meal and um it was what keeps you up awake at night discussion. I remember John and one or two of the other people around the table saying it was all about this crunch in the food supply chain that actually it would only take some climatic moment like we've had this summer which led to you know droughts and wildfires combined with rapidly growing population combined with increasing living standards in India and China it was forcing more people into eating protein meat foods dairy foods which we know are causing all these problems and it just tips the world completely over Mhm.

and actually at any one time a lot of the commodities that keep the world moving are all on the sea on tankers moving from one place to the other. We've learned anything from the war with Iran is that you know the Gulf of Hormuz you know what we've seen there and the Straits of Hormuz and is an issue around oil. It's also an issue around fertilizers. A lot of the world's fertilizers coming through there too. So actually all this is integrated and it's all just in time delivery systems and it's moved through ports and it goes into systems to produce the food to enter the supermarkets and it won't take much to chip it over and I think we're getting very close to that and I think the government's telling us we should get our you know so many days of food supply and torches and wind-up radios is preparing us for what we all know is potentially going to happen and that is extremely scary.

Mhm. So I think what we're seeing in the climate, what we're seeing in the food security issues, the energy security issues are all combining. And you know, I've lived and breathed this stuff for many years as you have, Philip, and talked about it and spoken to politicians and industry leaders and others. But I'm at a point now where I'm thinking, my god, we're very close to that. We're very close to it. And I think this summer has pushed us even closer to that line. Can we come back from it? I hope we can. I think if we throw everything at it and we're prepared, we might get through the worst of it.

But it's going to be difficult. And I think taking for granted that we can just walk into a supermarket and just have the choice of food we want at the price we can afford and the availability, I think what we're getting close to hitting the buffers on that one to be honest with you. And I don't know, Philip, if you want to correct me in any of my assumptions there, but you know, yeah, I am increasingly worried about that because you're absolutely right. You've been a visionary to say what we need to do. And that's the frustrating thing about it is we do know what we can do. We know what we have to do.

But we're just not taking those steps. We're not doing it anywhere near quick enough. Indeed. And we we are, you know, we are praying for time, you know, to quote George Michael. I said to that in the House of Commons the other day just because it was going on about um you know, Listen Without Prejudice is an album that I loved as a you know, when it first came out in 1990 and that that song Praying for Time just still resonates with me. But we are praying for time and it's running out. It's running out. Absolutely. Yeah. It's a real thing, folks. It's a real thing. It is you know, we are running out of time and and that's why I think again, just to reiterate, because I hate the feeling that sometimes we we're having to share things that that I know are horrifying, some of which you'll already know and some of which you won't.

And I don't want you ever to think that that we we would ever share things with you just for shock tactics. It's other than the fact that that shock may inspire action, which brings me to uh that wonderful Joan Baez quote, which is my favorite in the world. Action is the antidote to despair. So if you do feel any despair, any horror at these statistics and these realities we're talking about and the very real fact that time is running out, take action because it's not too late. Philip, sorry, you were about to say something I'm sure. Um, you've said it so much better that future is ours to to embrace, to save, to make better and kinder and more compassionate than the present is.

Uh, it Is it an uphill battle? Of course it is. But then let's get going. Let's all hands to the pumps. Let's support the organizations on the front line. Let's seize the power of our plate three times a day. Let's put kindness to animals and to ourselves at the center of society for now, for the future, for always. Absolutely. That's a great note to end on I think. An optimistic Beautiful. Philip, thank you so much for joining us. It means the world not just to Dom and myself, but also to everyone watching I'm sure and we thank you and we can't wait to share more of these conversations with you.

You're an inspiration to us. Indeed. And thank you for blazing a trail and leading the way for us. Absolutely. It's a pleasure. Thank you Philip for all that you do. Thank you Dom, great to see you again. Folks, thank you for joining. Thank you for your engagement. I can see lots of comments coming in. Um, you're welcome. There's lots of thank yous to you gentlemen to us. It's we love having you on these um these podcasts and and the single most important thing or not not the single most important thing, but certainly something important that you can do to help spread the messages to just share this.

Get it out on your social media page. Of course this is live right now, but it stays up on our outlets, um Facebook, YouTube, LinkedIn. Um, share far and wide because you just never know what what might trigger someone to action. Um Philip, one more time, thank you, sir. Absolute pleasure. Always pleasure. Hopefully see you soon. Thanks for joining us, folks. We'll be back soon with another Food for Thought Live. Enjoy the rest of your evening. Take care, everyone.

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Food For Thought: Live! Philip Lymbery, Global CEO, Compassion in World Farming