Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu today's lecture in today's lecture I want to develop several more formulas that will allow us to reach our goal of differentiating everything so these are derivative formulas and they come in two flavors the first kind is specific so some specific function we're uh giving the derivative of and that would be for example uh x to the N or 1X those are ones that we did uh a couple of lectures ago and then there are General formulas and the general ones don't actually give you a formula for a specific function but uh tell you something like if you take two functions and add them together their derivative is the sum of the derivatives or if you multiply by a constant for example so um C * U the derivative of that is C * U Prime where C is constant all right so these kinds of formulas uh are very useful both the specific and the general kind uh for example uh they're needed so we need both kinds uh for pols and more generally pretty much any set of formulas that we give you we'll give you a few functions to start out with and then you'll be able to generate lots more by these General formulas so today we want to concentrate on the trig functions and so we have some we'll start out with some specific formulas and they're going to be the formulas for the derivative of the S function and the cosine function so that's what we'll spend uh the first part of the lecture on and at the same time I hope to get you very used to uh dealing with trig functions although that's something that you should uh think of as as a gradual process all right so in order to calculate these I'm going to start over here here and uh just start the calculation so here we go let's check what happens with the S function so I take sin x + Delta X I subtract sin x and I divide by sorry let's leave a little space there sinx and divide by Delta X all right so this is the difference quotient and eventually I'm going to have to take the limit as Delta X goes to zero and there's really only one thing we can do with this to simplify it or change it and that is to use the sum formula for the uh s function so that's this that's sin x cosine Delta X plus uh oh that's not what it is huh okay so what is it sin x s Delta X okay good you remember plus cosine no oh okay so which is it okay all right let's take a vote is it s s or is it sin cosine okay so is this going to be cosine all right all right you better remember these formulas all right okay it turns out that it's s cosine all right cosine sign so here we go no you got to do X here s Delta X all right so now there's lots of places to get confused here and you're going to need to make sure that you get it right all right so we're going to put those in parentheses here sin a plus B is sin a COS B plus cos a sin B all right now that's what I did over here except it was the letter X was a and the letter uh B was Delta X right now that's just the first part that's just this part of the expression I still have to remember the minus sinx that comes at minus sin and then I have to remember the denominator which is Delta X okay all right so now the next thing we're going to do is we're going to try to group the terms and the difficulty with all such arguments is the following one any tricky limit is basically 0 over 0 when you set Delta x equal to 0 if I set Delta x equal to 0 this is sinx - sinx so it's a 0 over 0o term here we have various things which are zero and various things which are non zero we must group the terms so that a zero stays over a zero otherwise we're going to have no hope if we get some one over zero term we'll get something meaningless in the limit so I claim that the right thing to do here is to notice I'll just point out this one thing is that the when Delta X goes to zero this cosine of 0 is one so it doesn't cancel unless we throw in this extra sign term here so I'm going to use this common factor and combine those terms so this is really the only thing that you're going to have to check in this particular calculation so we have the common factor of sinx and then that multiplies something that will cancel which is cosine Delta X - 1 / Delta X so that's the first term and now what's left well there's a cosine X that factors out and then the other factor is sin Delta X over Delta X okay now does anyone remember from last time what this thing goes to how many people say one how many people say zero all right all right it's zero that's my favorite number all right zero it's the easiest number to deal with so this goes to zero and that's what happens as Delta X tends to zero now how about this one this one goes to one my second favorite number almost as easy to deal with as zero and these things are are are picked for a reason they're the simplest numbers to deal with so Al together this thing as Delta X goes to zero goes to what I want a single person to answer Brave volunteer all right right back there cosine because this factor is zero it cancels and this Factor has a one so it's cosine so it's cosine X all right so our conclusion over here I'll put it in Orange is that the derivative of the sign is the cosine all right okay now I still want to label these very important limit facts here this one we'll call a and this one we're going to call B because we haven't checked them yet I promised you I would do that and I'll have to do that this time so we've we're relying on those things being true now I'm going to do the same thing with the cosine function except in order to do it I'm going to have to remember the sum rule for cosine so we're going to do almost the same calculation here we're going to see that that will work out but now you have to remember that cosine of a plus b is equal to cosine cosine no it's not cosine squared because they're two different quantities here it's cosine a cosine B minus here's the minus sign sin a sin B all right so you'll have to be uh willing to call those forth at will uh right now so okay so let's do the the cosine now so that's cosine x + Delta xus cosine x / Delta X okay there's the difference quotient for the cosine function and now I'm going to do the same thing I did before except I'm going to apply the second rule that is the sum rule for cosine and that's going to give me cosine x cosine Delta X x - sin x sin Delta X and then I have to remember again to subtract the cosine divided by this Delta X and now I'm going to regroup just the way I did before and I get the common factor of cosine multiplying cosine Delta xus 1 / Delta X and here I get um the sinx but actually it's minus sin x and then I have sin Delta x / Delta X all right the only difference is this minus sign which I stuck inside there well that's not the only difference but it's a crucial difference okay again by a we get that this is zero as Delta X tends to zero and this is one those are the properties I called A and B and so the result here as Delta X tends to zero is that we get Negative sinx that's the factor negative sinx all right so this guy is negative sinx I'll put a little box around that too all right now these formulas take a little bit of getting used to and um but before I do that I'm going to explain to you the proofs of A and B all right so we'll we'll get ourselves started by mentioning that now maybe maybe before I do that though I I want to show you how A and B fit into the proofs of these theorems so let me just make some remarks here so this is just a remark but it's meant to help you to frame how these how these proofs worked so first of all I want to point out that if you take the rate of change of sinx well let's start with cosine because it's actually a little less obvious if I take the rate of uh change of cos x so in other words this derivative at xal 0 then by definition this is a certain limit as Delta X goes to zero so which one is it well I have to evaluate cosine at 0 plus Delta X but that's just Delta X and I have to subtract cosine at zero that's the base point but that's just one and then I have to divide by Delta X and lo and behold you can see that this is exactly the limit that we had over there this is the one that we know is zero by what we called property a and similarly if I take the derivative of sinx at xal 0 then that's going to be the limit as Delta X goes to zero of sin Delta X Delta X and that's because I should be subtracting of 0 but s of 0 is0 all right so this is going to be one by our property B and so the remark that I want to make in addition to the to this is is something about the structure of these two proofs which is the derivatives of s and cosine at xal 0 give all values of d by DX sinx d by DX cosine X so that's really what this argument is showing us is that we just need one rate of change at one place and then we work out all the rest of them all right so that that's that's really the substance of this proof that's of course really then shows that it boils down to showing what this rate of change is in these two cases and a equals so now there's enough suspense that we we want to make sure that we know that those answers are correct right I think looks like the erasers are over here okay so let's let's um demonstrate both of them I'll start with B so I need to figure out property B now we only have one alternative as to a type of proof that we can give of this kind of result and that's because we only have one way of describing s and cosine functions that is geometrically so we have to give a geometric proof and to write down a geometric proof we're going to have to draw a picture and the first step in the proof really is to replace this variable Delta X which is going to zero with another name which is suggestive of what we're going to do which is the letter Theta for an angle okay so let's draw a picture of what it is that we're going to do now here's the circle and here is uh the origin and here's some little angle well I'll draw it a little larger so that it's visible here's Theta all right and this is the unit circle I won't write that down on here but that's the unit circle and now sin Theta is this ver vertical distance here maybe I'll draw it in a different color so that we can see it all okay so here's this distance so this distance is sin Theta okay now almost the only other thing we have to write down in this picture to to have it work out is that we have to recognize that when Theta is the angle that's also the arc length of this piece of the circle when measured in radians so this length here is also Arc Length whoops Arc Length Theta that little piece in there so maybe I'll use a different color for that to indicate it so there's orange and that's this this little chunk there okay so those are the two pieces now in order to to to um persuade you now that the limit is what it's supposed to be I'm going to extend the picture just a little bit I'm going to double it just for my own linguistic s so that I can tell you a story all right so that you'll remember this so I'm going to take a Theta angle below and I'll have another copy of sin Theta down here and now the total picture is really like a bow and it's bow string there all right so what we have here is uh a length of 2 sin Theta so maybe I'll write it this way 2 sin Theta I just doubled it and here I have uh underneath two whoops that's I got it backwards sorry about that trying to be fancy with the color chalk and I have It reversed here so this is not 2 sin Theta 2 sin Theta is the vertical that's the green so let's try that again this is 2 sin Theta all right and then in the denominator I have the Arc Length which is Theta is the first half and so double it is 2 Theta all right so if you like this is the bow and up here we have the bow string all right and of course that's we can cancel the twos that's equal to sin Theta / Theta and so now why does this T to one as Theta goes to goes to zero well it's because as the angle Theta gets very small this curved piece looks more and more like a straight one all right and if you get very very close here the green segment and the orange segment would just merge they would be practically on top of each other and they have closer and closer and closer to the same length so that's that's that's why this is true I guess I'll articulate that by saying that um uh short curves are nearly straight all right so that's the the principle that we're using or short pieces of Curves if you like are nearly straight so if you like this is the principle so short pieces of Curves all right so now I also need to give you a proof of a and that has to do with this cosine function here this is this is the property a and so I'm going to do this by flipping it around because it turns out that this numerator is a negative number if I want to interpret it as a length I'm going to want want a positive quantity so I'm going to write down 1us cosine thet here and then I'm going to divide bya there all right again I'm going to make some kind of interpretation now this time I'm going to draw the same sort of bow and arrow Arrangement but maybe I'll exaggerate it a little bit so here's the vertex of the sector but we'll maybe make it a little longer right all right so here it is and here was that middle line which was the unit whoops okay I think I'm gonna have to tilt it up okay let's try from here all right well you know on your pencil and paper it'll look better than it does on my Blackboard okay so here we are here's this shape now this angle is supposed to be Theta and this angle is another Theta so here we have a length which is again Theta and another length which is Theta over here that's the same as in the other picture except we've we've we've exaggerated it here and now we have this vertical line which again I'm going to draw in green the bow string but notice that as the vertex gets farther and farther away the curved line gets closer and closer to being a vertical line that's sort of the flip side by expansion of the the the zoom in principle the principle that that curves are nearly straight when you zoom in if you zoom out that would mean sending this vertex way way out somewhere um the curved line the piece of the circle gets more and more straight and now let me show you where uh this numerator 1us cosine Theta is on this picture so where is it it's well this whole distance is one but the distance from the vertex to the green is cosine of theta right because this is Theta so dropping down the perpendicular this distance down back to the uh origin is cosine Theta so this little tiny bitty segment here which is basically the gap between um the curve and the vertical segment so the Gap is equal to 1us cosine thet all right and so now you can see that as this point gets farther away if this got sent off to the state center you would hardly be able to tell the difference the bow string would coincide with the bow and this little gap between the bow string and the bow would be tending to zero and that's the statement that this tends to zero as Theta tends to zero right the scaled version of that yeah question down here the denominator also tend to zero though ah the the uh question is doesn't the denominator also tend to zero and the answer is is yes in my strange analogy here with zooming in what I did was I zoomed out the picture so in other words if you imagine so imagine you're you're you're taking this and you're putting it under a microscope over here and you're looking at something where Theta is getting smaller and smaller and smaller and smaller all right but now uh because I want my picture I I expanded my picture so the ratio is the thing that's preserved so if I if I make it so that this Gap is Tiny yeah let me say this one more time I'm afraid I've I've made life complicated for myself um if I simply let this Theta tend into zero that would be the same effect as making this closer and closer in and then the vertical would approach but I want to keep on blowing up the picture so that I can see the difference between the vertical and the curve so so that's very much like if you're on a video screen and you zoom in zoom in zoom in zoom in so the question is what would that look like that has the same effect as sending this point out farther and farther in this in that direction in the to the left and so I'm just just trying to visualize it for you by leaving the Theta at this scale but actually the scale of the picture is then changing when I do that so both Theta Theta is going to zero but I'm rescaling it so that it's of a size that we can look at it and then watching imagining what's happening to it okay does that answer your question my question then is that seems to prove that that limit is equal to 0 over 0 uh it proves more than it's equal to 0 over Z it's the ratio of this little short thing to this longer thing and this is getting much much shorter than this total length you're absolutely right that we're comparing two quantities which are going to zero but one of them is much smaller than the other in the other case we compared two quantities which were both going to zero and they both end up being about equal in length but here the the previous one was this green line here it's this little tiny bit here and it's way shorter than the than the two Theta distance all right or Theta yeah another question cos thet is the as cos Theta - 1 over so so here what I wrote is cine Delta xus 1 / Delta X okay and I claim that it goes to zero here I wrote of the minus that that is that is cosine Theta I I replaced Theta by a Delta X by Theta but then I wrote this thing so cosine minus Theta minus 1 - one is the negative of this all right and if I show that this goes to zero it's the same as showing the other one goes to zero another question uh so the question is what about this business about Arc Length so the word Arc Length that that shape that orange shape is an arc and we're just talking about the length of that Arc and so we're calling it AR length that's what the word arc length mean it just means the length of the arc why is this length Theta ah okay so this is a very important point and in fact it's the very next point that I wanted to make namely notice that in this calculation it was very important that we used length and that means that the way that we're measuring Theta is in what are known as radians all right so that applies to both b and a it's it's a scale change in a and doesn't really matter but in B it's very important the only way that this orange length is the comparable to this green length the vertical is comparable to the arc is if we measure them in terms of the same notion of length if we measured them in degrees for example it would be completely wrong we divide up the uh angles into 360° and that's the wrong unit of measure the correct measure is the length along the unit circle which is what radians are and so the only this is only true this is only true here if we use radians all right so again a little warning here that this is in radians so now here x is in Radiance and the the the formulas are just wrong if you use other units uh yeah okay so the second question is why is this crazy length here one um and the the reason is that what I did was the relationship between this picture up here and this picture down here is that I'm drawing a a a different shape namely what I'm really imagining here is a much much smaller Theta okay and then I'm blowing that up in scale so this scale of this picture down here is very different from the scale of the picture up there and if if the angle is very very very small then one has to be very very long in order for me to finish the circle so in other words this is this length is one because I that's what I'm insisting on so I'm I'm claiming that that's how I Define this circle to be of unit uh radius another question um I'm having a little difficult conceptualizing because that as get smaller and smaller The Rao don't okay um so the the question is uh it's hard to visualize this fact here okay so let me let me take you through um a couple of steps all right because I think probably other people are also having trouble with this visualization the first part of the visualization I'm going to try to demonstrate on this picture up here the first part of the visualization is that I should think of of the beak of a bird closing down getting narrower and narrower so in other words Theta has to be getting the angle Theta has to be getting smaller and smaller and smaller okay that's the first step so that's the process that we're talking about out now in order to draw that once Theta gets incredibly narrow in order to depict that I have to blow the whole picture back up in order to be able to see it otherwise it just disappears on me in fact in the limit theta equals z it's meaningless it's just a flat line that's the whole problem with these tricky limits is they're meaningless right at the Z 0 level it's only just a little away that they're actually useful that you get useful geometric information out of them so we're just a little away so that's with this picture Down Below in part A is meant to be it's supposed to be that that Theta is open a tiny crack just a little bit and the smallest I can draw it on the board with where you can visualize it is using the whole length of the Blackboard here for that so I've opened a little tiny bit and by the time we get to the other end of the Blackboard of course it's fairly wide but this angle Theta is a very narrow is a very small angle all right so so I'm trying to imagine what happens as this collapses okay now when I imagine that I have to imagine a geometric interpretation of both the numerator and the denominator of this quantity here and just see what happens now I claim the the numerator is this little tiny bit over here and the denominator is uh actually it's a half of this whole length here but a factor of two doesn't matter when you're seeing whether something tends to zero or not all right and I claim if you stare at this it's clear that this is much than that than that uh vertical curve there and I'm claiming so this is what you have to imagine is that as it gets smaller and smaller and smaller still that has the same effect of this thing going way way way farther away and this uh vertical curve getting closer and closer and closer to the green and so that the gap between them gets tiny and goes to zero all right so not only does it go to zero that's not enough for us but it also goes to Z faster than thisa goes to zero and that's what's over I I I hope the evidence is pretty strong here because it's so tiny already at this stage all right we are going to move forward and you'll have to ponder these things uh some other time so I'm going to give you an even harder thing to visualize now so so be prepared okay okay so now the next thing that I'd like to do is to give you a second proof because it really is important I think to uh to understand this particular uh fact more thoroughly and also to get a lot of practice with signs and cosiness so we're going to give you I'm going to give you a geometric proof of the formula for sign here for the derivative of sign so here we go this is a geometric proof of this fact this is for all Theta all right so far we only did it for theta equals z and now we're going to do it for all Theta so this is a different proof but it uses exactly the same principles all right so I want to do this by drawing another picture and the picture is going to describe Y which is sin Theta which is the uh if you like the um uh vertical position of uh some some circular motion so I'm imagining that some something is going around in a circle right some particles going around in a circle and so here's the circle here's the origin this is the unit distance and right now it happens to be at this location P all right maybe we'll put p a little over here and here's the angle Theta all right and now we're going to move it we're going to vary Theta and we're interested in the rate of change of Y so y is the height of P but we're going to move it to another location we'll move it along the circle to Q all right so here it is here's the uh the thing so so how far did we move it well we moved it by an angle Delta Theta all right so we we start at Theta Theta is going to be fixed in this argument and we're going to move a little bit Delta Theta and now we're just going to try to figure out how far the thing moves well in order to do that we've got to keep track of the the height the vertical displacement here so we're going to draw this right angle here and this is the position R and then this distance here is the change in y all right so the the picture is we have something moving around a unit circle a point moving around a unit circle it starts at P it moves to Q it moves from angle to angle plus Delta Theta and the issue is how much does y move and the formula for y is sin Theta so that's telling us the rate of change of sin Theta all right well so let's just try to think a little bit about about what this is so first of all I've already said this I'm going to repeat it here deltay is p r it's going from p and going straight up to R that's how far Y moves that's the change in y That's what I said up in the right hand corner there oops I said PR but I wrote PQ huh all right that's not a a good idea all right so Delta Y is p r and now I want to draw the diagram again one time so here's Q here's R and here's p and here's my triangle and now what I'd like to do is draw this curve here which is the piece of the Arc of the circle but really what I want to keep in mind is something that I did also in all these other arguments which is maybe I should have called this orange but I'm going to think of the straight line between so it's the straight line approximation to the curve that we're always interested in so the straight line is much simpler because that then we just have a triangle here and in fact it's a right triangle right so we have the geometry of a right triangle which is going to now let us do all of our calculations okay so now the key step is this same principle that we already used which is that short pieces of curves are nearly straight so that means that this piece of the circular Arc here from P to Q is practically the same as the straight segment from P to Q all right so that's this principle that that uh well let's put it over here is that PQ is practically the same as the straight segment from P to Q so how are we going to to use that well we want to use that quantitatively in the following way what we want to notice is that the distance from P to Q is approximately Delta Theta right because the Arc Length along that curve the length of the curve is Delta Theta so the length of the green which is PQ is is almost Delta Theta so this is essentially Delta Theta this this distance here now the Second Step which is a little trickier is that we have to work out what this angle is so our goal I'm going to put it one step below because I'm going to put the geometric reasoning in between is I need to figure out what the angle QPR is if I can figure out what this angle is then I'll be able to figure out what this vertical distance is because I'll know the hypotenuse and I'll know the angle so I'll be able to figure out what the side of the triangle is so now let me show you why that's possible to do so in order to do that first of all I'm going to trade the boards and show you where the line PQ is so the line PQ is here that's the whole thing and the key point about this line that I need you to realize is that it's practically uh perpendicular it's almost perpendicular to this to this Ray here all right it's not quite because because uh the distance between P to Q is nonzero so it isn't quite but in the limit it's going to be perpendicular exactly perpendicular the tangent line to the circle so the key thing that I'm going to use is that PQ is almost perpendicular to op all right the ray from the origin is basically perpendicular to that green line and then the second thing I'm going to use is something that's obvious which is that PR is vertical okay so those are the two pieces of geometry that I need to see and now notice what's happening upstairs on the picture here in the upper right what I have is the angle Theta is the angle between the horizontal and op that's angle Theta if I rotate it by 90 de the horizontal becomes vertical it becomes p r and the other thing rotated by 90 degrees becomes the green line so the angle that I'm talking about I get by taking this guy and rotating it by 90 de it's the same angle so that means that this angle here is essentially Theta that's what this angle is let me repeat that one more time we started out with an angle that looks like this which is the horizontal that's the origin straight out horizontally that's the thing that's labeled one that distance there and then I also have the my my that's my right arm which is down here my left arm is pointing up and it's going from the origin to uh the point P so here's the horizontal uh and and the angle between them is Theta and now what I claim is that if I rotate by 90 degrees up like this without changing anything so that was what I did the horizontal will become a vertical that's PR that's going up PR and if I rotate op 90° that's exactly PQ okay so let me even well I think I will draw it on there one time and see if you can let's do it with some arrows here so I started out with this and then we'll label this as uh let's see label this is orange okay so red to orange and then I wrote rotate by uh 90° and the red becomes this starting from p and the orange rotates around 90 degrees and becomes this uh this thing here all right so this angle here is the same as as the other one which I've just drawn all right different different uh or different Origins for the different vertices for the angles okay well I didn't say that all arguments were supposed to be easy all right so I claim that the conclusion is that this angle is approximately Theta and now we can finish our calculation because we have something with the hypotenuse being Delta Theta and the angle being Theta and so this segment here p is approximately the hypotenuse length to times the cosine of the angle all right and that is exactly what we wanted if we divide we divide by Delta Theta we get Delta y/ Delta Theta is approximately cosine Theta all right and uh that's the same thing as so what we want in the limit is exactly the Delta Theta going to Z Delta y over Delta Theta is equal to co sin Theta so we get an approximation on the on a scale that we can visualize and in the limit the uh formula is exact okay so that is a geometric argument for the same result namely that the derivative of s is cosine yeah uh you will have to do some kinds of geometric proofs sometimes uh when you'll really need this is probably in 1802 so you'll you you'll need to make reasoning like this this is for example the way that you actually develop the theory of arc length and dealing with Delta x's and Delta y's is a is a is a common tool all right I have I have one more uh uh thing that I want to talk about today which is some general rules and so I'm going to we took a little bit more time than I expected Ed with this so what I'm going to do is just tell you the rules and we'll discuss them in a few days so let me tell you the general rules so these were the specific ones and here are some general ones so the first one is called the product rule and what it says is that if you take the product of two functions and differentiate them you get the derivative of one time the other plus the othertimes the derivative of the one now the way that you should remember this and the way that I'll carry out the proof is that you should think of it as you change one at a time and this is a very useful way of thinking about differentiation when you have uh things which depend on more than one function so this is a this is a a general procedure the second formula that I wanted to mention is called the quotient Rule and that says the following that U / V Prime has a formula as well and the formula is U Prime V minus UV Prime / V ^ 2 so this is our second formula let me just mention and both of them are extremely valuable and you'll use them all the time this one of course only works when V is not zero all right so because we're out of time we're not going to prove these today but we will prove these next time and you're definitely going to be responsible for these kinds of proofs

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Lec 3 | MIT 18.01 Single Variable Calculus, Fall 2007