Transcript

okay welcome everyone to the rhetoric crash course this is part 2 I am gonna go over part 1 very very quickly if you are listening to this video and the part 1 stuff sounds unfamiliar or confusing or you just don't remember it it's going to be a really good idea for you at this point to go back to the week that had the initial rhetoric crash course and re-watch that video because we are building on that knowledge again I'm gonna review it very briefly here but it's really important that you understand all of that as well as the stuff that I'm going to add today ok so remember there are three goals of an argument to change the audience's mood mind willingness to act remember that the hardest of all of those is willingness to act it's very hard to get people to get up and actually do something but changing their mood and changing their mind is easier there's three kinds of rhetoric forensic rhetoric is that rhetoric of blame it's courtroom rhetoric demonstrative rhetoric is tribal rhetoric it's the rhetoric of praise and blame it is the rhetoric of Church and then there's deliberative rhetoric which is supposed to be the rhetoric of politics this is your future tense rhetoric with that there's a claim of fact that mostly goes with your forensic rhetoric claims of value are demonstrative and claims of policy are deliberative because it's about what we should be doing in the future all right then there's ethos which is argument by character and the initial video I went over decorum virtue practical wisdom and disinterest it's always that speakers or writers use to try to make themselves sound credible pathos is argument by emotion this is where our we're going to use emotional Appeals I want to make you laugh I want to make you cry any of that pity appeals to pity appeals to fear all of those are your pathetic tools next logos we talked about the logical syllogism the if and therefore statement the logic needs to follow so you have your major premise your minor present premise and that all leads to your conclusion okay and then we talked about Kairos which is seizing the moment right it's the right message at the right time with the right medium when I introduced this before I talked all about my dog and the problem with socks being left all over my house and I talked about when was the rhetorical best moment to try to change this behavior okay so that was the first set of information so again if none of that sounds familiar you're going to need to go back and get the much more in-depth involved presentation all right so now we're going to move on and talk about logical fallacies basically there are three questions so if you're reading an essay or listening to a presentation there are three guiding questions that you want to keep in mind as you listen does the proof hold up as you're listening does is it making sense does everything they're giving as their examples and their evidence is it all holding up in your head are you nodding going yep yep yep or are you going wait what right and so that's a really good test for that one am i given the right number of choices anytime someone tries to make give give you a categorical choice that is a problem does the proof lead to the conclusion that's what I just talked about logos you've got your major premise your minor premise leading to your conclusion which is your claim therefore statement so remember in rhetoric there are no rules in philosophy they don't want you to use any kind of fallacies that's why they're called logical fallacies because in logic it's really important that all the time every time the premise leads to the conclusion now in rhetoric the rule is you can do anything you want if you want to manipulate your reader by through pathos they say go for it if you want to reduce everything down to a ridiculous outcome they say go for it there are no rules in rhetoric the only rule at any time is don't stop talking rhetoric it's all about when you want to change their mood mind and willingness to act and in a way you just keep going till you do that so I know if you've ever been in an argument the most frustrating thing to happen is for the person that you're arguing with to put their hand up in your face and say we're done I'm not talking to you anymore at that point that's a rhetorical foul because again the rule in rhetoric is don't stop talking right you have to keep talking because if we keep talking then I can keep trying to manipulate you so that I win mood mind willingness to act or whatever my goal is so there aren't any rules now know that if I start using logical fallacies and you catch me then that is going to hurt my credibility and then all of a sudden my character suffers and I'm gonna probably lose so even though there are no rules and you can commit any fallacies you want in rhetoric you do have to be really careful about what you're doing because you don't want to get caught or you want to save yourself if you sense you're getting caught now the point of learning all of this is that if you can't spot them if you don't know all the different kinds of fallacies then you might use them unknowingly and that also can hurt your character because then you may not use it the best way that you can it might not be I guess fully manipulative so it's really important to know what you're doing and plan your fallacies out in advance I would also say it's really important to know the logical fallacies so that you can know when they're being used on you okay so here we go logical fallacies now Jay Heinrichs and the chapter that you read he he kind of boiled it all down to seven different fallacy types so I've grouped them here in the same way just so that it matches the reading that you have so the first grouping we have is the false comparison this is when an author is going to use two or multiple things in some kind of comparison that doesn't work so we're going to go through that list first the first one is the all-natural fallacy so you can see the definition there an ingredient belongs to the same group as things that are good for you so the ingredient is good for you when I was thinking about this one it made me think of the serial podcast part of the reason that everyone couldn't think that Adnan would kill hay is because you know he's this golden child he's a football star he's an EMT he goes to the magnet program so if all the kids in the magnet program are good kids with bright futures and college admissions then there's no way Adnan could be anything but good the all natural fallacy all right next is the appeal to popularity this is where your choice is legitimized because others have chosen it this is also called the bandwagon fallacy my favorite story for this one is the year that's true green lawn care came to my door I was making dinner they rang the doorbell and my dog is barking and dinner's burning and I'm looking at this guy and I'm going oh come on but you know I'm nice kind of so I answered the door and he says hello they're amiss we'd like you to sign up for true green lawn care we're gonna make your lawn look spectacular this summer do you know the hiders they live next door to you they signed up do you know the mixes they live down the street they signed up do you know the tolson's they live across from you they signed up do you know the Joneses they signed up to do you know all the people on this list all of them signed up don't you want your lawn to look just like all your neighbors so of course there at that moment I'm thinking yeah you're trying to sell me this by making me want to keep up you know with my neighbors and so I explained to him that this was a bandwagon appeal and then I went back to my dinner and said you know of course no thank you so that's the appeal to popularity everyone else is doing it so you should too all right the next one is reductio ad absurdum this is where you're reducing an argument down to absurdity I was looking online for some fresh examples of some of this stuff and I came across a Dilbert cartoon and this is from a while ago like I think it was in the mid 90s and an example of this kind of argument was in the car tune so Dilbert and his coworker Wally are at work and the boss comes in the room and he says all right I'm gonna rank all the engineers here from the best engineers to the worst and then I'm going to get rid of the bottom 10% well Wally is starting to panic in the cartoon because he's thinking oh crap I think I'm in the bottom 10% so then he's trying to reject or make the boss reject his argument right and so he reduces this down to absurdity by saying but boss your plan is flawed because there's always going to be a bottom 10% so you're just gonna keep firing until there's fewer than 10 engineers left and then you'll have to fire body parts and body parts and that's gonna lead to torsos and glands running around and blood and bile everywhere so as you see he reduced the argument down to something absurd so the results are the consequences of extending this line of argument so then the bosses position should be rejected I thought that was such a perfect example of this like he's really gonna fire body parts and chop people up because he can't fire whole people right so of course making that argument then while while he was hoping that the boss would say oh you're right this is a terrible idea I won't do it and so that is why that was trying to be persuasive so there you go reductio ad absurdum all right next is the fallacy of antecedent if it if it never happened before so it never will or it happened once oh it will never happen again this one I called the dog-bite fallacy in my head because I use this all the time I'm when I walk my dog she's this beautiful Samoyed she is so sweet and friendly and you know she loves little kids and little kids love her because she looks like this snow puffy cloud and she's always smiling and sweet and so she's always you know running up to kids and then the parents are always like oh does your dog bite and I'm always like oh she's never bitten she won't bite right and so that's the fallacy of antecedent how can I assume just because she's never a child that she never will write she's an animal how do I know that I don't but it's pretty persuasive and the parents always let their kids pet my dog now I've been really lucky so far but that is the fallacy of antecedent okay next is the false analogy it's where two things are being compared that are not comparable I have two examples for this one one when I first moved to Minnesota one of my first friends she was very religious and she called me one morning and she said Jan I'd like us to meet at the flagpole outside of the elementary school because we are going to I have a group of moms and their kids and we're all going to meet outside by the flood pool and we're gonna per say a prayer before school because you know saying a prayer before school is like eating cereal for breakfast they both get the day off to a good start and I said to her Kelly did you really just compare praying to frosted flakes because I don't think you can compare the two now I don't think I actually said that to her cuz generally people don't like other people that point out fallacies but you can see the idea don't compare to things that don't have any business being compared another example that I have for you is I had a student write a paper about it was arguing that video games were good for the brain and so this was the part of the paper during his counter argument where he was trying to acknowledge that too much of anything is bad right so that was his acknowledgment of the opposition so he said that first and then he said you know if humans drink too much water they can die now that is where he ended that part but I want you to think about it was he really comparing playing too many video games with drinking too much water what was I supposed to logically conclude that if I play too many video games I'm gonna die so you can see that that comparison does not work and I caught him and that impacted his ethos and therefore his credibility was shot okay next is the unit fallacy and this one for me is a little hard to talk about in terms of the kind of argument you'll be writing for this class because it's not really scientific argument so therefore I don't think you're really going to be speaking in units the one thing that I was thinking of when I thought of this one was in my read 960 course that I'm teaching this semester we're reading a book about archaeology and it's called the lost city of the monkey god and in that book they use airborne lidar which is basically just this really cool plane that shoots out all these lasers and can map out the ground and they use it to discover this archaeological find in Honduras and so when they first published the initial maps one of the critics of the project immediately publishes this huge arc about how much he hates the whole expedition and he actually criticizes it because he said he's looking at the lidar maps and he's saying oh look they just found something the equivalent of a city block they didn't find anything right and so he's comparing the map and what he saw to a city block when in reality he was reading the unit's wrong on the map and he didn't notice what the scale was right and so they're really the scale was times a thousand or something like that and really they found the equivalent of an entire city and so that was the point as he mistaked he committed a unit fallacy there so there you go that was the best example I could think of in like a rhetorical situation okay next you have the pathetic fallacy you can see the word there anthropomorphism I'm not sure if you know what that word means so I'm going to translate that for you in toward you do know which is personification any time we assign human characteristics to something that is not human so we do that to be manipulative right we do that so that we can make something that is not alive we can make it hurt or make it cry or make it funny and that is then attributing these human characteristics to it and then that's manipulative so that is like personification so there's your pathetic fallacy okay so the next fallacy type is the bad example and example you have there's two I think here the first one is misinterpreting the evidence where the examples don't support the conclusion and so I was thinking about that one because to me it sounds like a non sequitur which is where you have the premise not lead to the conclusion a non sequitur is Latin for it does not follow and so here I was thinking in a rhetorical situation you might see maybe an argument about global warming and they might talk about the ice caps and the violent weather patterns and things the disappearing of the polar bears they might use all of those examples to just say oh this is in global warming and so then the examples they're citing doesn't actually lead to the conclusion at all and you're left going wait what by the end which is a non sequitur meaning it does not follow next is a hasty generalization another name for this is stereotyping so it's reaching a vast conclusion with scant data so for example my dad used this on me once where he said I think I was having trouble with my car and one time in his life he had like this Volkswagen and he took it to a German mechanic near our house and this guy did a great job on his car so now he thinks that all Germans are good mechanics so when my I was having trouble with my car he said to me ok Janne well if you find yourself a German mechanic because they really know how to fix cars right which would be a hasty generalization he's making this huge broad generalization that all Germans are good car mechanics based on his one experience that's a hasty generalization or like I said another word for that is stereotyping next you have ignorant as proof there is a fallacy called that it's called the fallacy of ignorance what we can't prove doesn't exist so to say that what we can't prove the reason that the polar icecaps are melting and the polar bears are starving is because of global warming so therefore it doesn't exist there is an example or you could say people use this for religious also because they said well we can prove we can't prove that God is real so therefore he doesn't exist so there you go that would be your fallacy of ignorance okay the next type is circular reasoning this is where you might another name for this is obfuscation which means you're just talking in circles and trying not to make sense so the first example of that is literally what circular reasoning is is called a tautology where the premise and the conclusion conclusion repeat each other look at the example there if it's in stock we have it that's a tautology the conclusion and the premise are the same you should stop smoking because you shouldn't smoke proof proof and conclusion are the same that's a tautology all right the next one is all about choices and the number of choices that you have so the first one is many questions another name for this is making the question the classic example of this one is when did you stop beating your wife now you can see that my conclusion is based on an assumed truth the assumed truth is that you beat your wife and so therefore when I asked you when did you stop beating your wife it's based on my assumption that you are which is begging the question okay a false dilemma is when you're forced into a categorical choice this actually happened right after 9/11 george w bush was giving a really important political speech right after that happened and his famous line from that speech said you're either with us or with the terrorists that is a false dilemma there you go you could say that another name for that you might have heard this before it's called oversimplification reducing something to black and white like there is no gray area okay complex cause is when only one cause gets the blame for something that has many causes so again in global warming if you are going to say well global warming can all be blamed on too many cars on the road when really there's so many other things contributed to global warming so that would be an example of complex cause okay fallacy type six were on to the distraction so an ad attack is where you probably see these in political ads so you know during election season when all of a sudden all those political ads are on TV and all they do is attack each other and so I've given you the syllogism on the screen here you have person a says claim X right person B is looking at claim X and going whoa I don't know what to say about that so instead of actually dealing with claim X I'm just gonna call person B stupid and therefore what they said is wrong and so that's an ad hominem attack name-calling anything like that when you attack a person rather than the argument that's an ad hominem attack okay so next is a red herring a red herring the classic start of a red herring is well what we should really be talking about is and change the arguments direction so this is person a saying claim X person B coming along and going but I don't know what to say about X so I'm just gonna like distract you with Y because I can talk about Y and the sudden you're gonna forget all about X and therefore I'm gonna win so that's kind of how a red herring works I don't know if you know this but a red herring is actually a fish and we all know that fish smell really bad and so the idea of the red herring is that when they used to train dogs to hunt they and to track in the woods they would actually toss a red herring off the dog's path to see if the dog could kind of not pay attention to the smelly fish and still go after the Fox and so that's kind of where this idea of this fallacy came from it's all about distraction all right the straw man this one might be the most complicated of all the fallacies the straw man so I probably want you to close your eyes right now and build a straw man up in your head and then have a really strong wind come by and of course what happens to the straw man he's gone right he blows away and so that's the idea so you have person a saying claim X right person bigos well I don't know what to say about claim X so I'm gonna build this really silly argument that's kind of related and blow it down and then people will think that claim X is wrong that's the principle the idea of a straw man so I actually when I taught reading 1106 which is the college-level critical thinking class we read a book called nickel and dimed and it's by Barbara Ehrenreich and in that book she basically is claiming that the minimum wage in the US is way too low like you can't ever get ahead right and so she proves this by holding minimum wages jobs in three different states and failing miserably everywhere and that leads to her her conclusion so that's person acing claim X minimum wage in the US is too low and you can't ever make enough money to get ahead right okay so then this guy named Adam Shepherd then read her book in college and thought Barbara Ehrenreich I hate you so I'm gonna try to prove you wrong so then he takes 25 bucks and gets on a train I think and goes to Charleston South Carolina and starts out in a homeless shelter and his goal was in 6 months to have a furnished apartment a car and $5,000 in a savings account oh I'm sorry that was his goal in a year and he did it in 6 months and so then he said see Barbara you're wrong the American Dream is still alive now that is a much easier argument to prove because again he started at a homeless shelter he's also young and male and white and he had and he worked as a mover which isn't even a minimum-wage job and when people have too much furniture they give it to you so how easy is it to get a furnished apartment right and so and they get really big tips so all of that was a much easier argument to prove than a 50 mid-fifties year-old woman who was working as a maid right and she really did make minimum wage and so and she refused to be homeless so it's much easier when you have no overhead to start and start saving money so you can see that they're different arguments so Adam Shepard was trying disprove Barbara Ehrenreich but he made a much simpler argument for himself and then see Barbara you're wrong blow down the straw man so that's an example of a straw man okay the last type of fallacy is we have the wrong ending so for example first you have this slippery slope I by the way I love the cartoon here dude don't do it somewhere down the road it'll lead to chores love that because that's the idea of a slippery slope I always think of those Tom and Jerry cartoons where you know it's like snowing and Jerry pushes or I'm sorry Tom pushes dearie down the hill and he's going down this snowy hill and as he rolls down the hill he's getting bigger and bigger and bigger because he's picking up snow and becoming this huge snowball and when he hits the bottom of the hill he hits all these people and they all fall down right and so that's the idea of a slippery slope if we allow something to continue it's going to predict the doom and gloom of the entire civilization so for example one night I was sitting with my mother-in-law and this is a good cautionary tale of don't talk politics with your in-laws but the point is we were watching like an old episode of friends and it was one of the episodes where Ross's ex-wife I don't know if you remember this but she wasn't a same-sex relationship and so that was part of the episode and this was a couple years ago so it was during the whole merit right the marriage act stuff that was happening politically that was going to legalize same-sex marriage and so during that because I think that was on my mother-in-law's mind when she saw this at part of friends she said you know if we allow gay marriage to become legal pretty soon I'll be able to marry my dog and the entire institution of marriage will be ruined well that's a slippery slope argument right if we allow this one thing to happen pretty soon the entire doom and gloom of society will ensue there's your slippery slope okay then post hoc ergo propter hoc is after this therefore because of this so think about it for us a second it's the idea that be followed a so a caused B for example a couple years ago my uncle came to visit me and it was during that Vikash it must have been 2009 not that he hasn't been back since but this is the one I remember and he came and he was a few days at my house and my kids were little and they were sick I mean they were always sick little kids are sick right and so then he was going from my house to my sister's house in Virginia so he got unlike by the time he had left Seattle come to see me and then come to see my sister he'd been on like four or five planes right and he'd been at my house we had been out in the community so at restaurants and things he gets to my sister's house and he gets all sick and so he says Jan because I went to your house I'm sick right and so that's post-hoc that's a post hoc fallacy and it's funny because he's an education professor so I was kind of like a van hello this is a post hoc but I didn't say that to him because he was really sick and so I think it the reason I remember it was during the swine flu thing is because he thought he had h1n1 so anyway after this therefore because of this okay that's a post hoc argument all right so we're done with fallacies woo all right hopefully those made sense I would say if there's anyone of them that you're still feeling kind of muddy on I would recommend googling it because there's tons of examples of these things online and hopefully you can start to really understand them as you look at them online okay so Cicero's outline is a way to be the most persuasive it's like the way that classic oratory was always done so in classic oratory are really good speeches this was kind of the outline that these really good orators would use to tell the best speeches so you read about this in thank you for arguing too or they took Obama's Democratic National Convention speech and they broke it down into this outline and told you that because he organized it this way it was an amazing speech right and so we're gonna look at all of the different arguments that we analyzed and then when we create our own argument we're going to use Cicero's outline to help us be the most manipulative the most persuasive that we can possibly be so it moves from an introduction to a story we know that stories are the most manipulative thing that you do because our minds are wired for stories we love stories and so when someone's telling you a story you're engaged and you're with it and you're there with them and they might be making you laugh they might be making you cry and that's all full of ethos right so narration is such a good way to start now division is where they might present two sides they might say well we're here to discuss this issue so they're going to talk about the two sides but they're gonna do it in a way that divides the issue and helps you see that their side is better so it's like here I'm going to split this up and I'm going to tell you why this side of my side is the best one then they're gonna provide proof proof is all about giving all the reasons the examples the logic the facts the examples the studies all that stuff right the refutation is the counter-argument and there's a couple parts to the counter-argument first you have to acknowledge some people say bla bla bla right and then you either confute I'm sorry refute or you concede or you do both so you could say well yeah the other side has a point and then refute with facts and examples and authorities and things like that or you can acknowledge the opposition and then just refute it so just say why it's wrong so be careful you always want to make sure that there's an acknowledgment of what the other side is thinking first so some people say some might argue the other side says something like that usually introduces that refutation or counter-argument and then it's either conceded and or refuted and then a conclusion with the thesis statement so that's generally how Cicero's outline works okay so there's an example of this it is the happy secret to better work it's by shawn Achor it is one of my favorite TEDTalks like ever so i am so excited for you to listen to this i think you're really going to enjoy it and this is a mentor text discussion board that you're going to be doing after you listen to the TED talk now because this is a video the link doesn't work here so you're going to have to go back into this subfolder on d2l and click on the link and watch the TED talk and then do the discussion board it's going to ask you kind of to apply everything you've learned here to the TED talk that you heard and the TED Talks awesome so enjoy that all right now I did talk a little bit during Cicero's outline about the refutation so remember that another word for that as you can see here is the rebuttal counter-argument as another name you might see but again there's two steps you acknowledge the other side are you going to see the author acknowledging the other side and then they either concede saying yep the other side has a point and then they refute but or they'll just acknowledge some say and then they'll say however and move right into the refutation okay so acknowledging the other side and either conceding and refuting or just refuting alright and that is the end of rhetoric part 2 we're done make sure you email me with any questions because we're moving straight into applying all of this with our rhetorical analysis worksheet you've already learned how to do page 1 & 2 you might remember the everyone deserves a defense article and in praise of the guilty project we did those with the first two pages we're gonna loop back to everyone deserves a defense to show you how to do 3 & 4 and then there's two essays about prosecutors 1 I'll lead you through in a voicethread and have you practice and then one will be due for an assignment all right I hope that this all made sense please let me know if you have any questions and happy rhetoric

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Rhetoric Crash Course Part 2