Transcript
foreign good afternoon ladies and gentlemen it is my pleasure to welcome you to the IPS Northern lecture series by Professor wangong our 12th Sr Northern fellow for the study of Singapore today prop 1 will be delivering his first lecture titled cultures and civilizations following his lecture profile will take questions from the audience in a q a session the Q a session will be chaired by Professor kwakian Woon Vice Chancellor at University of the Arts Singapore before we begin please allow me to go over some housekeeping rules for the event thank you for joining us at the auditorium today please be reminded to switch our mobile phones to silent mode the lecture is being streamed live on Facebook it will also be recorded and uploaded onto our IPS website and our social media platforms later please submit your comments and questions at any time during the lecture through the Facebook comments for our audience members here at the auditorium today please set up to the mic during the Q a session to ask your questions we will try our best to answer as many questions as we can during the Q a we would also like to share our views on the event there will be a link in the feed at any of the lecture and also a QR code which you can click on or scan to submit your feedback our director of ips General Devon will now deliver his opening remarks director please ladies and gentlemen it gives me great pleasure to introduce our 12th Sr Northern fellow Professor Juan gang Wu a renowned historian and a scholar of rare distinction I said this before so I'll say it again we have a habit in Singapore of debasing language we call Scholars teenagers who managed to do so well in their a levels that we are watched without them award them prestigious scholarships Professor Wong is a different kind of scholar um his is a lifetime devoted to study anesthesis of Mind and Spirit a Perfection of art as much as a Perfection of life many years ago I chat a talk the professor Wong delivered I could see he was sitting next to me I could see he had a sheet of paper and he had scribbled just a few lines on the sheet of paper and then he held forth for 30 minutes and at the end of it I was filled with awe and envy because you could take down what he had said and they would all have made perfect paragraphs and there are very few people I know who can do that that is a scholar that is no more distinguished scholar in the humanities at any rate then Professor Huang on this island his lecture Series today um over the next few months actually is titled living with civilizations Reflections on Southeast Asia's local and National cultures in his first lecture today titled cultures and civilizations he will speak on the history of Southeast Asia's cultures and how they've been influenced by neighboring ancient civilizations among other things this will be followed by a second lecture on the 1st of December opening to the global maritime when he will discuss the effects of the rise of global Maritime trade on the Southeast Asian region his third lecture will examine among other things the role of Singapore as a port in the British Empire as well as the ancient civilizations various ancient civilizations losing control of their own terrains he will deliver his fourth lecture in March next year when you'll address how our region has lived with various civilizations after World War II I would like to thank my old friend Professor cockman Ken Woon the newly appointed Vice Chancellor of the University of the Arts Singapore for moderating today's q a the Sr Northern Fellowship for the study of Singapore was established in 2014 as you all know as a tribute to our sixth and longest serving president Mr Sr Nathan the fellowship aims to promote greater discourse on Singapore's public policy and current affairs I would like to thank individuals as well as corporations including those who give to IPS annually for their support and generosity in funding this scholarship and supporting IPS ladies and gentlemen our 12th Sr Northern fellow the incomparable Professor Wang Gang Wu thank you so much director ladies and gentlemen without further Ado I would like to invite Professor Wong to begin his first lecture titled cultures and civilizations Professor Wang please as you can see the IPS is a very considerate and thoughtful organization they've enabled me to sit down because I'm old thank you very much Canada well friends and colleagues ladies and gentlemen the SR Northern Fellowship has given me the chance to pursue my thoughts about Singapore as a new nation and share them with you those who gave the lectures before me included friends who have a deep and intimate knowledge of public policy and governance I do not have that knowledge and can only claim to be the oldest person to have given been given the privilege thank you I did share a worm's eye view of Singapore as a colony where Mr Northern and I were students staying at the dungeon road hostels also we briefly served at the time that when he was still self-governing I studied Singapore's place as the 12th state of the new Federation of Malaysia also during the brief period when he was in this alteration I served on a committee to examine the city-states contribution to the country's higher education after the separation my connection with Singapore were desultory until I came to work here in 1996 they were a mixed set of experiences with everything about the Republic seen from outside and from afar what was constantly in the news was the fact that this small state was in the middle of a newly defined region between two oceans most of the people were descended from immigrants from other countries who chose to settle here its leaders were nevertheless determined to create a national identity by incorporating parts of the several distinct cultures represented by its peoples the global city was determined to overcome its reputation as a cultural desert it was committed to being part of modern civilization while large portions of the population hope to retain the cultural heritage of their ancestors many were conscious that their Heritage came from ancient civilizations and that the three most prominent the indic and the Islamic are living civilizations living civilizations seeking to modernize together with their neighbors think of what was also reshaping a national culture within borders that had only recently been drawn up for them this was something I found fascinating and I was curious what this really meant for the country for decades I had romanticized about Singapore in Malaya as a colorful tapestry of local living uh and also a stick carpet that is woven with different strands of world history and there were moments when I had to stop painting these uh pretty pictures of Multicultural promise for example following the May 13 riots in Kuala Lumpur when the situation looked pretty precarious I had a personal perspective on racial and religious tensions having been brought having been through the Maria Hertel killings here in Singapore also I had briefly served on the committee set up to investigate the 1964 race riots in Singapore itself how can a new nation be built with such explosive ingredients as a student of History I was doing research on Chinese history but I also had an interest in the overseas Chinese these were the watch out in the nanyang that was the name an earlier name which was more or less the same as the region called Southeast Asia at the heart of that problem Beyond race and religion were political issues of Chinese Chinese nationalism and local nationalism intertwined with Imperial capitalism as well as anti-colonial socialism I was losing my political innocence at the time and while I was studying more history and encountering both ancient and modern modern civilizations before long I I saw the connection between local cultures and external influences that came to shape and Empower them what was more these influences often had Deep Roots depending on when the people first came to the region and how Dynamic and Powerful the neighboring civilizations were the records and artifacts that both the mainland and and Maritime peoples of our region did not they did not show the artifacts show that did not produce their own civilizations instead they chose what they wanted from those they were in contact with all of them ancient civilizations that have survived to the present there were the indexualization from the Indian subcontinent there was also the Sonic civilization in China coming from Overland as well as from the South China Sea and further west there was the Mediterranean civilization from across the Indian Ocean that Mediterranean was later identified with a monotheistic face that produced a profound division in that Civilization the arabic-based Islamic merchants reached out to our region early while the European Crusaders and trading companies arrived only after the 16th century all that changed after the 18th century when the Age of Enlightenment in Europe led the world to the idea of modern civilization a new Singapore emerged out of the imperialist rivalries that mapped the region at the end of World War II when the British call when the a new Singapore emerged out of the impurious rivalries that mapped a region at the end of the world war at the end of World War II that the British called Southeast Asia that region became one in which new nations were built and locally local cultures were being shaped into National cultures during the past 70 years many efforts have been made to trace the origins of the risk region that a region that did not have a name the search for Origins has been an intriguing Adventure and we know a great deal more about our region today but we're still trying to find meaning in the way our images of the past relate to present realities having lived through much of this period of discovery I offer my thoughts on why I believe that that past has something to offer our future let me Begin by stressing the difference between cultures and civilizations you'll be familiar with the literature and how various cultures during this past Century have been adapting to the task of modern nation building to do that we see each Nation dedicated to creating a national culture that could help frame a national identity they were doing that not only for their own security and self-respect they also want to be recognized as civilized in a modern world civilizations however civilizations however be ancient they might be did not doubt that they were civilized what concerned them was not to disappear along with those that are merely are now merely exhibited in modern museums in the following lectures I shall talk primarily about the civilizations that shape the history of the Southeast Asian region in which Singapore is located and of which it is the center my focus will be on the many cultures that were developed within the region and how the region had always been open to neighboring civilizations now this will include talking about those cultures that have kept themselves separate and have learned to select the ideas and institutions they needed to enable their cultures to shape their own distinctive identity a single voice no no exception it's just that we started later later than the others and given its commitment to staying up front with modernity is so so very strong it's a national identity it's less clearly defined it is interesting how all the new nations use their historical experiences to help them build new National cultures and how they expect to coexist with modern as well as modernizing civilizations in this context the Region's nation states have been engrossed with cultural adaptations together with problems of nation building also with regional Harmony and now also with superpower rivalry to understand how they dealt with the problems that they had faced and how they try to keep up with the world of rapid changes I think we need to examine the cultures that were developed here and the kinds of civilizations that they interacted with throughout the Region's history to try and do this I believe it is necessary to be to distinguish clearly between the words cultures culture and civilization but let me be clear these lectures are not about the history of Singapore or about Southeast Asia they are about how cultures of our region have lived with civilizations they're shaped and enriched their local identities and they also look at how different civilizations interacted here in borderless ways I use a historical frame to emphasize the processes of change and compare the different results the interactions have produced at different stages what do I mean by civilization how should it be distinguished from culture both are modern terms that came from Western Europe the concepts have been translated into various local languages and are now commonly used but the two are not always distinguished and when used in Translation they are often used interchangeable interchangeably I found it difficult to find satisfactory definitions of both words so I shall describe what I think they mean culture is what every group of people have shared because they developed it together and it's something that they identify as their very own the groups could be large or small they range from simple ones like isolated tribe to a sophisticated community that could establish strong States the cultures could be agrarian or pastoral settled or nomadic literate or non-literate they were likely to be ruled by Chiefs priests princess Kings even Emperors or elected leaders because they are people of all classes have lived together for long periods of time their cultures where they defined as ethnic or national or whatever were likely to be resilient and distinct civilization on the other hand stemmed from efforts by Visionaries prophets and teachers to explain the universe and to find the meaning of life on Earth from a set of first principles ideational and moral systems were constructed to uplift the life of everyone Beyond local cultures and identities when such Visions inspired the leaders of strong States and Empires those leaders could rise above the their local cultures and use the idea of a common Humanity to define a borderless civilization under their care each would then seek to bring local States and cultures under its wing and would act as agents to bring civilization to other peoples modern political discourse tells us that many of the early polities in Europe develop new ideas about the nature of their states these led them to identify sovereign states that could determine National borders for themselves the most powerful among them grew into National Empires which backed by a strong christianizing Mission claimed to be civilizing the unenlightened many local European cultures grew to become National cultures and they went on to represent an imperial civilization that reached out across the globe by the 19th century that modern civilization began to impact on all cultures in Asia that they encountered these included cultures Under the Umbrella of the ancient indic or sonic civilizations that were now relatively weak if not in Decline after advancing to dominate the world The credibility of this mission was diminished in the night in the 20th century by two world wars these were civil wars between rival National regimes that shared the same civilization but are determined to destroy one another however the commitment to being modern was not affected what emerged was a new world order created by the victors of the second World War and this was designed to bring an end to National Empires and replace them with a system of equal nation states the idea was to establish a single set of University accepted values but there was no agreement about what was Universal and this led to an ideological division that brought about the cold war between the United States and the Soviet Union when that ended the United States as Victor became the world superpower ready to spread its modern civilization to all of humankind he could choose whether to help the remaining ancient civilizations to modernize in order to survive or have them integrated into the only civilization there is modern civilization dominated all parts of our region during the 19th century before that however three ancient civilizations were influential until the 16th century when the fourth arrived and quickly connected all the world's oceans by Maritime power in my lectures I shall focus on southeast Asia its cultures and their relations with these their relations with these four civilizations I should begin by examining how the cultures had thrived were related to the ancient civilizations that impacted on our region I shall give special attention to the indig civilization that penetrated the region for more than a millennium my second lecture would take us to the Mediterranean where ancient civilizations of the three continents of Asia Europe and Africa had met I shall trace the Graco Roman civilizations transition to the two parts of an imperial monotheism and this will take us to how they bifurcated civilizations of the Christians and the Muslims came to interact in our region my third lecture will focus on the Revolutionary changes that made Singapore a key part a key port in an expanding British Empire by then the largest of the national Empires that extended modern civilization around the world I will also deal with the ancient civilizations that were losing control over their own terrains with Chinese merchants and coolies becoming dominant in Singapore I shall also refer to the Manchu Chinese Empire That Grew alongside the European expansion this is when Sonic civilization seemed to have peaked and was now struggling to be relevant in my last lecture I shall look at how our region lived with civilizations after the end of the second World War modern civilization was already dominant while three ancient civilizations were trying to modernize of the three China was rejuvenated after two revolutions in pursuit of modernity and that success has now made it a threat to American interests in our region Singapore has had to live with several civilizations when the city-state became independent it shows an exceptional path by declaring its commitment to what is going up a plural society nationhood and how it embraced modernization modern civilization in a world where ancient civilizations are modernizing has been a challenging experience and one whose future development deserves special attention I've now lived in Singapore for nearly 26 years and I've learned to care for some aspects of its exceptional governance style and social structure most of all I'd become fascinated by its people's links with many different worlds this does not qualify me to talk about the governance of Singapore I'm happy that the northern Fellowship committee has allowed me to go beyond that subject what has struck me is the way Singapore and the region have been living with different cultures and civilizations Singapore's experience is not unlike its neighbors in the region but the differences were significant many commentators have looked at this phenomenon described him and I've gained much from Reading their books all the books that I've read it has been a long learning process for me but let me begin with my personal background I was brought up as someone Chinese who failing to find home in China tried to become Malayan even Malaysian I then wanted off to be Australian in Canberra a capital city with a shorter history than Singapore where almost everyone I met came from somewhere else and only a tiny minority were actually born there my work then took me to Hong Kong before I came to work in Singapore again and everywhere I've been have been Multicultural to a greater or lesser extent so it probably is inevitable that my Outlook is filled with cultural concerns cultural anxieties you might say I found it remarkable that peoples of the region Had Each developed their distinct cultures while interacting with four civilizations that historical response has continued to the present even while a powerful modern civilization has been overwhelming the ancient civilizations elsewhere the peoples recognize that building new National cultures is in that tradition how they modernize their cultures is through development and change adaptation if you like well Singapore May seek its own path towards creating its National culture I believe that it found a Region's experience all the experiences of the region very relevant I first learned about Singapore as a student at the new University of Malaya now now the National University of Singapore nus I returned as a lecturer from 1957 to 59 before transferring to its Kuala Lumpur branch this is when we all thought that Singapore would become part of the Federation of Malia when Singapore is separated from Malaysia I had to observe its development from outside and 37 years later I came back to nus through one of its research Institutes I have thus had at least three layers of Singapore experience the first was as a site for Higher Learning the second as an experiment in Social Engineering seen from afar and the third as a state engaged with modern civilization two images for my first day have remained very strong in my mind one image came from the way the island was connected to the tip of the Malay peninsula I had seen that relationship captured by a name in some old maps that I found in the University Library the end most land that picture of a long stretch of land sticking out to the Sea Into the Heart of a huge archipelago has followed me for decades it led me every now and then to wonder about peninsulas and their role in history the other image came from my roaming the streets of Singapore I met many people who had come to the island after wandering around the region and was introduced to a minanchable practice that caught my imagination the word was mananto a kind of wandering what struck me was a marantou did not refer to traveling to a known destination The Wanderers after years of seeking experiences and opportunities expected to return home in fact many made a commitment to another land where they started a new life I found that word rich in meaning and closely linked to the peopling of this port city of Singapore those two images have resurfaced and they've led me to look afresh at the many unexpected connections that Singapore has had to separate Singapore's had to several worlds the connections reminded me how they had helped me understand the plural Societies in the region it made me look again at the many peoples who became accustomed to living with one another the idea of ujong Tana made me think about the gay the Genesis of cultures and civilizations and when I deal with people's confronting modernization a modern civilizations in this globalized world I shall come back to the idea of maranto as a history student I had always found the idea of ancient and modern civilizations very intriguing I recall trying to understand how modern civilization came from Europe to Asia what is happening led me to think that modern progress was desirable and ancient Pro ancient civilizations were backward if not dying the latter was painful to see but it seemed unavoidable the Europeans we met when I was young expected to be helpful to all those who wish to modernize and become more like them and as a matter of modern civilization I considered the university as one of its pillars I felt very lucky to be in a place where I could make myself modern however my professors also taught me that if becoming modern enabled an Asian state to challenge the West as the Japanese did in 1941 the great powers where they were ready to hit it hard and put that power down the lesson was it was all right to learn from them and even try to copy them outright but to think that the student could take on the master and drive him out of the region was unacceptable having studied Japan's ambition to to dominate China and Southeast Asia I thought that the outcome for Japan was deserved the name Tana linked me to my background in Malaya you may find that familiar because the island at the foot of the peninsula with people moving back and forth was very similar to my experience and I grew up in the peninsula side my neighbors including friends who went to the same school with a mix of peoples who came originally from several worlds our teachers too had come largely from China India and the Malay new santara world my parents both came from China and planned to return home as soon as they could my worlds had thus come to me from very different Origins two were linked to my English school in the state of perock the school regularly reminded me that we lived in Malay Muslim sultanate that traced its Origins back to Historic Malacca and the perak once had some kind of tributary relations with the kingdom of Siam but for reasons unexplained to us my school was named after one of the governors of the straight settlements a colony ruled by British Christian officials at the time I was not aware that no other school in Malaya was named in this way I realized later that it was an indirect and not too subtle way of telling us who was Modern both these worlds had little to do with the Chinese majority living in IPO town that Community consisted of nine young watch out from the southern provinces of China I recall now how the different dialects many Cantonese hakka and Hawken made me wonder whether there were more than one China on the edge of town were Malay kampongs where people saw themselves as the the Sultan's subjects while the Indians I met were openly resentful of the fact that their homeland of India was under British rule only later did I understand that I was living with people who had different cultures and some of their cultures were parts of ancient civilizations like the index of India Sonic that was developed in China and the Islamic and the Christian that originated from the Mediterranean region to my bafflement the relationship built on these worlds that I enjoyed as a child a suddenly changed in 1941 to 45 Japanese armies took over the town the new rulers did not trust the Chinese they claimed to side with the malays and won over many Indians to join them to drive the British out of India under Japanese tutelage we heard slogans like Asia for the Asians and had to bow to the emperor shawar we saw that a civilization like Japan with ancient Sonic roots could be modernized to fight back against those who claim to be superior but I recall the relief among most people in Nepal when the Japanese were defeated nevertheless there was great uncertainty as to what would happen when the British gave up the Empire and returned to their own country when I came to Singapore in 1949 I discovered that most of the people there had lived in Worlds not very different from mine hence the Delight I when I saw the maps where ujong Tana at the bottom of the Malay Peninsula I could identify with that it reminded me of Land's End Singapore was malayas Lands End I knew that was just Whimsy but there was a serious question there how did this island at the tip of the Malay peninsula fit into the region now called Southeast Asia I had just been made aware that southeast Asia was a it was a name for the region that never had its own identity few people realized today that this new University of Malaya was where the first books on southeast Asia were produced we were probably the earliest people today it was the earliest students anywhere to be taught that the region was of strategic interest to the Western Empires before the war ended British strategists had identified the region around Malaya as essential to their interests in Asia looking ahead they had seen the rise of nationalistic China as something inevitable and they knew that they would have to deal one day with an independent India with deep anti-british memories two of our professors were enterprising and produced the first textbook that textbooks that introduced this region to the world they were the geographer ESG Dobby who published Southeast Asia and the historian Brian Harrison who produced southeast Asia a short history I recall two of the discussions that followed the publication of their books the first centered on this large Peninsula between India and China that was nameless but unflatteringly known as Indochina the peninsula also had a long extension a narrow neck that led to a smaller peninsula and it's tip reached the island of Singapore that was to become the country called Malaya that was how I was taught the other discussion touched on the South China Sea this was seen as a half closed area a half close sea that was connected from ancient times to the Mediterranean on the one side of the other side of the Indian Ocean and the people in the west had names for our region like Savannah bhumi or the golden corcini casonis and so on and our region knew about the Mediterranean as the home of several ancient civilizations as this led some to suggest that the South China Sea could be considered Mediterranean of some kind was it not the meeting place of different ancient cultures and civilizations given that it had a huge Peninsula stretching South to the Malay peninsula in the middle of archipelagic new santara why did the cultures in this large area not gather their combined power and wealth and bind them together and create a civilization or civilizations I also wondered why the larger Peninsula did not have a name that everyone recognized today we refer to it often as mainland mainland of Southeast Asia no longer as Indochina it covers half our region and it consists of several major river valleys each of them home to an agrarian economy and a separate culture these divisions remain strong even after other peoples came south from the interior of the Asian continent as migrants and Invaders some Scholars did try to identify an ancient Khmer or accordion civilization that was lost and rediscovered however following Decades of research it was agreed that all the cultures developed on the peninsula were inspired by ancient indic civilization the historical historical artistic and Architectural records show their new ideas and institutions had come from various parts of the Indian subcontinent what was striking was that the peoples of our region had their local genius this enable enabled them to choose only what they wanted so that they could enrich and power their own cultures this brought me to another dimension of ancient local cultures the current Overland borders of Northern southeast Asia are misleading the tribal peoples further north in China known as the 100 year or the southwestern ye by the Chinese neighbors called him that were very similar to those of the peninsula they kept no records and were not clearly identified but from later research we know them as people who spoke three different families of languages the Osteo Asiatic the austronesian austronesian and the tibeto bourbon I was fascinated by these connections I even proposed that the original home in China south of the Yangtze River be called ancient Southeast Asian Southeastern Asia that would make it clear that the various rare and ye peoples not only included those who became Chinese but also those who were drawn South into Southeast Asia those closest to being sanitized were the Viet peoples of the river the Red River Valley their lands fell to the chinhan empires and they came on the Chinese rule for a thousand years and that was long enough for them to accept confusion legalist institutions and the social and ecstatic values of Sonic civilization but unlike the Chinese they were also attracted to India via Mahayana but sorry but like the Chinese they were also attracted to India via bahayana Buddhism and their version of index values brought those peoples closer together in that way the Viet peoples use Sonic civilization to shape their own National culture in short world before recorded history many osteoasiatic speakers came down the river systems of the Red River Mekong the menamerawadi the powerful born and Khmer peoples dominated the other four valleys and they establish close relations with index civilization their Elites were deeply inspired by Hindu Buddhist teachers and advisers from India from the Chinese records we learned that a kingdom called funan emerged at the on the Mekong Delta another called Jannah developed further inland and later the Khmer rulers built a remarkable Empire and dominated the lower reaches of both the Mekong and menam rivers for six centuries like funan and Jannah this Empire achieved its cultural Heights by embodying localized versions of index civilization there's no doubt that the indic prophets and teachers were the most dynamic and influential Visionaries for centuries there were two parts to the civilization there was a dravidian core and this was the indigenous civilization in the southern part of the subcontinent and he always had Maritime interests in our region and then there was a indo-aryan North they shared the Continental visions of the Indo-European speakers of Central Asia through the Hellenic and the Persian peoples who reached Northern India those ancient links produced a world of multiple gods that was comparable to that of the later Greco and Roman civilizations but unlike the peoples of the Mediterranean those of the index civilizations did not find the monotheism of the Semitic people's appealing indict civilization representative was represented by people later described as Hindus who deferred who offered a distinct road to rebirth rather than visions of Paradise in heaven they focused on developing original an esoteric insights about life that most people in our region found attractive and inspiring but the emphasis on Rigid cost divisions did not take root that is in fact a clear example of how our region was selective in what they adopted what they took over into their local cultures within India there were many local States and cultures that were free to choose among the many parts that were available to them the deep thinking teachers and priests debated fiercely among themselves about what was true there are numerous States fought one another frequently however the civilization continued to offer inspiration to those in our region who accepted what it had to offer is deep and Rich cultural Roots spread across the subcontinent and its Spirit of ideational and aesthetic inclusiveness enabled the civilization to withstand external threats first from the Islamic conquerors and later from the British Empire it is not clear what it was in the morning cultures that found index civilizations so attractive what we know is that when the Chinese first visited the earlier states on the mainland some 2000 years ago they recorded a strong presence of indic Institutions and a flourishing trade within Indian subcontinent what was noteworthy was that the early mon Khmer rulers worshiped the gods of the Hindu Pantheon adopted into government principle governance principles and embraced a wide range of India aesthetic values but their descendants and the Siamese successor States kept only the Buddhist Realms of index civilization something that I come back to later the scholars who first studied the so-called hinduized States as they called him at the time we're fascinated to discover that the new santara peoples of the archipelago were no less influenced by index civilization about the same time here the mix of deities the governance methods and the artistic artifacts and architectural monuments were influenced by different waves of influenced by in different ways by the indigenous cultures of the archipelago what was particularly striking was that when indic contacts weakened Buddhism did not survive in the archipelago among the new santara peoples the Hindu Faith was left mainly in eastern Java and Bali and contrary to what happened in India and among our Mainland States the archipelagic rulings Elites the archipelago people the new Sentara peoples eventually gave up much of their indic Heritage and turned to monotheistic Islamic civilization instead the maritime peoples of the archipelago had originated from different parts of the China mainland the peoples who spoke the austronesian languages arrived in the region from a different direction it is widely agreed that they moved out of southern China by sea most of them Island hopped from Taiwan to the Philippines and Beyond among them some turned West to the coast of central Vietnam there they followed the commands in accepting cultural inferences from index civilization and established their own river Rhine States these became known as the kingdom of linear or then Champa both kingdoms played a mediating role between the archipelagic cultures and those of the Mainland large numbers of these speakers also crossed the South China Sea and stopped at the neck of the Malay Peninsula south of the Khmer Empire and there they created a Frontier Zone between the continental and the maritime that is still significant for the region today the people of new centaura use their Island World in different ways and kept their Maritime trading activities distinct from that of the Earthbound Mainland States but both civilized about both but both sides continued to develop their cultures by sharing the best of the Hindu and Buddhist manifestations of index civilization neither the khmerce and their successes nor the archipelagic peoples produce Visionaries of their own with independent World Views that could have led to creating their own civilizations both sets of states were content to shape their own respective cultures by selecting what they wanted from index realization and discarding those they did not want and during the formative centuries of their development they seemed confident that what they picked from That civilization was sufficient to make them civilized and strong what is also worthy of note is that we learned of their centuries of immersion in Indian political religious and aesthetic values through Chinese records about the same time the Chinese had discovered that the Buddhist realm of knowledge and insights within index civilization was wonderfully attractive and convincing the expansion of their non-high trade in the South China Sea was largely based on the natural on the natural products collected by the Hindu Buddhist peoples for their commercial needs large groups of Buddhist Scholars from Sinai countries signic centers in China in Korea and in Vietnam studied in digitalization in the old capital of Sri Vijaya the Malay capital of Sri Vijaya then that palimba and they moved among the local monks of the singasari Realms of java and its mataram successor States like their counterparts in Southeast Asia the Chinese saw civilization as borderless and enriched their own cultures by choosing what to accept from another civilization this takes me to our Region's relations with early signic civilization a night with the indic and its Outreach across the Bay of Bengal the core of the signic civilization was in North China far away from the maritime world of the new santara peoples the Chinese themselves had first received their share of indic ideas and institutions from missionaries who came from Overland from Central Asia and from Northern India for them the Chinese one were won over by the subtleties of the Buddhist Dharma where relations are with our region was concerned it was not until large number large numbers of Chinese had migrated to the southern Coastal provinces that Maritime commercial activities quickly began to develop and after that the Chinese reached out for the sources of the India for the indic worldview both Overland through our Mainland States as well as by sea to the parts of the Arctic archipelago both merchants and officials profited from that going trade but for centuries it was a spiritual light of the western Heaven the sheet hand in India that Drew the Chinese to our region from Fashions records his travel accounts of the early 5th Century to Regions two volumes about those monks traveling to India via SRI Vijaya in the 7th century and there's enough testimony of the indic magnet that stimulated Chinese Maritime trade across the South China Sea in comparison the indig inspired to Santana States left no major writings to record their ties with India but only scattered inscriptions to show the extent of index influences on local literacy in any case monuments like borobudur from banan and many others speak louder than words walking around those great sites of develop devotion devotional architecture who can doubt the debts that index spiritual and political penetration had reached when Buddhism lost its importance in India China needed another kind of transformation to simulate its commercial interest commercial relations with our region this came with the decline of the tongue Empire and the second period of division in Chinese history from the 10th to the 13th century the Imperial State sought new sources of revenue and encouraged the enterprising people in the southern provinces to be more active in Maritime trade and this meant that trade now received official support we have more evidence of Chinese private trade pushing South to Luzon Island and the solo sea expanding commercial relations with Champa and the Khmer Empire and extending their interests further to the ports of java and SRI Vijaya we also have at the same time more and more Islamic sources of this period that confirm a growing trade involving Chinese and the merchants from the Red Sea and the Persian Gulf all of those who traded with Chinese with the Chinese learned to Value their manufacturers like Silk and Ceramics and some of their trading methods and technological skills but the Chinese had little the Chinese Merchants had little capacity to reflect the political and cultural values of Sonic civilization in any case it was clear that those values had little appeal to the new Sentara peoples who had a custom who had been accustomed to an increasingly open Multicultural environment by that time they were operating within the loose mandala system of State relations that they took from index civilization and with that serving as a model they had room to cultivate their own distinct local cultures for the first thousand years of recorded history our region was most responsive to index civilization and adopted many elements of that Civilization to shape a large numbers of distinct cultures in the region through a process that some have called syncretism each set of rulers and their Elites seem to have gained cultural and political confidence by their success in shaping their own local identity on the mainland the Khmer Amman the Thai and the Burmese Consolidated the indic Heritage to their respective versions of Buddhist Authority after that have been lost in India itself and when that and when they later became nation-state that internalized Authority provided strong foundations for developing modern National culture similarly the Vietnamese probably the first proto-nation one might call it one of the first Proto nations in our region were developing a distinct National culture drawing primarily from Sonic civilization people their openness to all three of their neighboring civilizations and enable the local cultures on different Islands as well as on the Malay Peninsula to retain their distinctive features this remains so even after most of the communities were later converted to Islam only those fathers to the east in the Philippines were later drawn into the Christian Mediterranean orbit but they too were inclined to maintain their own cultural features within that faith what began to make a difference was the growing importance of Maritime power from the 16th century onwards this power was shared between Britain and France during the 18th and 19th centuries by that time southeast Asia was experiencing the early capitalist qualities of modern civilization something that produced what has been called a decisive turn towards the idea of universal enlightenment the world was Singapore in all this I imagined that there were always people on this peninsula Island swimming in and out and sharing the index civilizational experiences of the other new Santana peoples around Singapore historians with the help of archaeologists have taken its history back to the end of the 13th century and you have seen artifacts that show the coming together of three civilizations that was no accident the century that is encapsulated in the Fort Canning park today saw important changes to the civilizational mix in the region the nomadic empires of Central Asia Persia and Afghanistan had invaded the heartlands of Sonic and indec civilizations with somewhat different results on the one hand Taco Mongol forces diminished indic influence at Sea and supported Islamic presence Indian Ocean on the other total Mongol Congress of China encourage Southern Chinese to advance their trading activities beyond the South China Sea to India and the Persian Gulf the temasek story linked the remnants of Malay Vijaya to an emerging Javanese majapahid Empire as well as the rule there's a rising Kingdom of cyan all three born out of localized Hindu Buddhist polities nothing before had prepared them for the naval Expeditions under the Muslim Admiral of Ming China that pushed Beyond Singapore to support the establishment of Malacca it has been suggested that the Moroccan ruler and that the Muslims so it has suggested that the Muslims who headed the Expeditions might have encouraged the Malacca ruler to convert to Islam but that probably was not it didn't matter that much because what was really mattered was that that moment of History Islamic and Sonic interests converged and that laid the foundations for the Malacca Empire to become the the base for Islamic Maritime expansions we know little about the rule of the role of Singapore during the centuries of transformation that followed the arrival of Europeans from time to time the new Santana peoples of The Straits and the archipelago tried to defend their interests from European expansion and for that they would have used the Island's Harbor and the rivers precisely what its place was among the contending Elites from malaka Johor they may not come out from Sumatra and the Bugis Maritime traders of solo wesi is unclear that probably mattered less than the fact that the island was strategically list situated when anglo-dutch rivalry led the two powers to separate their imputed interests once and for all in 1824.
by its very location it can be said that Singapore was complicit in affecting that change something important was about to take place the Port City was on the front line of national Empires the officials they were sent to run it believed that they were the standard bearers of modern civilization and what they set out to do would have massive consequences on the ancient civilizations that have so far been sustaining the region in my next lecture I said explore the conditions that began to pave the way for revolutionary change thank you thank you Prof Wang for those watching the lecture on Facebook please send me your comments and questions through the Facebook comment box for our audience members here please step out to the mic to ask your questions may I now invite Professor Vice Chancellor at the University of the Arts Singapore to start the Q a session thank you so much Prof Wang for starting your series on lectures by placing your own biography within the longer term historical context and indeed The Wider geographical canvas thank you for also sharing your own personal links with ujong Tana the endpoint tip of the peninsula your own maranta or wandering which has also led to the questions you have put before us today um and also for laying out the foundations and the scaffolding for addressing these questions over the next three lectures uh I would like to invite questions comments this is a precious opportunity and we have made enough time for a in-depth discussion I also have this iPad to look at questions coming in from our online source perhaps I would just make a quick observation Prof one that I think it's it's for me it's really good that the whole question of the concept of civilization which has often been met with suspicion uh by certain Scholars because of connotations about the superiority of any particular civilization over others including portraying others as being of a lesser State as sometimes as barbarians or even as Savages and so but by turning the concept of civilization to deeper spiritual intellectual philosophical resources that we can draw from today and that continue to resonate with our own uh our own maranta as we Face the Contemporary world I think that shifts the discussion in a very positive direction that would be my one comment Prof one but could I open up the discussion please yes Kishore professor mabumani foreign for that fascinating lecture you mentioned both in your lecture and the slides that the different parts of Southeast Asian the different Islands were able to retain their distinct cultures right and of course for me the most interesting Island in Southeast Asia is Java and the question in my mind is why is it that the Javanese were able to create their own very sort of unique culture which in a sense became the most successful culture within the new santara within the Indonesian fabric what is it that made them different and allowed them to dominate Indonesia in the way they do today what was special about them that made them different from the people in Sumatra in Borneo and elsewhere that's right for our questioners please speak a little louder too for the performance benefit I think was asking about the specialness of java where we see that it's it's centrality within the region and their special role in uh Kishore would you like to add a little more to that yeah yeah what makes yeah that that is a question that I've been asked again and again it has been the most puzzling question one of the most puzzling questions about our region I have uh no simple answer to this one I believe that the the most important reason is that those people who settle in Java very early had developed agriculture unlike elsewhere in all the islands we read about riverine States people never really went into the interior most of the people settled on the river by close to the Sea and concentrated their livelihood on using the sea either as fishermen Traders or Smugglers or Pirates or whatever they they essentially lived by the sea with the exception of java I mean there were lots of land in somata lots of land in Borneo but the river Rhine people did not go find the interior and the people in interior didn't do much like the diox or ibands and dozens in Borneo and even in Sumatra the Inland people did not go into agriculture as much as for example the Javanese did I recall one particular story I say when I was born in as you know I was born in Surabaya in East Java and one of the stories I was told was Java was different because if you poke a stick in the ground it will grow because of the fertility of the land the soil was volcanic I mean the fact that it was a and today we just read about the the earthquake in the in the sundown in the Sundar part in West Java and Java was a set of volcanic uh uh mountains which grew up regularly over Millennia and left behind such fertile soil that all you needed to do was just put something there and everything would go there was a story I grew up with and I've heard this from other people that things just grow so easily so when the maritime peoples arrived in Java unlike elsewhere where it was red the kind of red laterite soil that we find in Malay Peninsula or Sumatra or Borneo agriculture was not exactly appealing it was hard work whereas life in Java as a peasant was relatively easy this is my story I don't I don't offer it as a historical explanation but I suggest that the agrarian success in Java made it more responsive to the kind of agrarian society that created the index civilization in the first place what they brought for example when they went to the mainland of Southeast Asia index civilization was particularly successful it was among agrarian people even in China it was a gradient people who responded to Buddhism and it was in in Mainland southeast Asia and all the river and Big River states where they said what is Mekong very fertile and developed the agriculture very young very early and index standardization thrived in in all of them so there may be a connection between a gradient societies responding to the agrarian origins of index civilization much better the governance principles the ideas of those gods for example we pray probably they they had to reflect as it were a tremendous anxiety or desire to grow things to grow things fast and the deities help you keep the land fertile and keep the land rich where is the the sea Maritime people like the boogies or the Malay people generally who turn to the Sea and for example SRI Vijaya is a very good example we don't even have proper monuments of Sri Vijaya the people just moved around from Port to potty Victory which I had different capitals Right Round The Straits of Malacca and in the real linga archipelago and they didn't they didn't ever never really turn to the land it constantly changed their positions within the sea and did extremely well so even in the end when something like the Johor Empire began to revive itself it was by the Bugis who came from thousands of miles away from silhouetti again people who use the sea but never really were attracted to life as peasants on the land so I would simply say as a possible hypothesis for further Discovery research that The Agrarian fertility of java made the people who settled there found it so easy to become peasants that that had a different response and different uh way of absorbing and and taking over and taking all the richness of the index civilization so readily into Java thank you profan this is a hypothesis that is worthy of a few more PhD diseases yes please yes please could you also identify yourself okay my name is um I'm retired but previously associated with ntuc Enterprise and and now more Activity The Institute and faculty of actuaries yeah I'm a great admirer I'm a great admirer Professor Wang and thank you for such a wide scaffolding anchored in the last 1000 Years history I'm encouraged by the command to make by Professor called Ken Boon about civilization so I decided to ask two themes which I hear emerging from your lecture the first one was about Enlightenment and modernity yeah and the second word you used was pluralism but there was more in the context of Singapore I'm very curious about your views and that I'm going to write on professors quarks comments clearly enlightenment in the 18th century 17th century and his anchor on Industrial Revolution and the rise of science was compelling but it doesn't necessarily extend to the world of humanities ethics politics and how to live yeah although one could argue about the claims of democracy and individual Freedom there are alternative views about how to live here so I'm curious uh that simply in the last 200 years 100 years there is a sense that Enlightenment as anchored in science was Superior because it solves problem but a lie to that there are many issues which is now evident that the rise of science without the rise of ethics and humanity and how to live is problematic yeah problematic on today's terms yeah which brings us to the second question which is about pluralism not just of Singapore but the pluralism of civilizations yeah and hard to argue one is superior to the other so I'll be curious on your views how you view these questions which are Central to our times on how to relieve with each other as civilizations and your comments on the rights of science as incomplete we need a more holistic view of what a civilization means when it talks about enlightenment thank you Mr Tan Mr tandu remember we have three more lectures the enlightenment the rise of Science and is there really a lack or less development in the western Enlightenment in the area of humanities and ethics and and if so uh is there something that we need to address here well I I shall be talking about this in my in my next lecture so I will say more then but let me briefly say this that the major change that occurred was really after first of all after the fall of Constantinople something did fundamentally change and bring about a Renaissance Europe and that of course had its impact on on the uh the the power of the church and the power of states in Europe that led to the Reformation so the enlightenment is a particular product of a series of conflicts conflicts within Europe which were pretty pretty intense and very bloody and extremely cruel and brutal but in the in the course of it all they as they sorted out the the struggles one thing became clear there was a absolute rejection of the absolute authority of the church and that was a major turning point between what you call the Reformation period between the Catholic church and the Protestant world and from that plus the fact that the crusading wars of the Mediterranean against the Muslims in the Mediterranean finally ended when the Europeans reached out of the Mediterranean into the Atlantic and into the Indian oceans as I said my next station would be about the global Maritime and it was a global Maritime that created a different world and one of the first things to say about that was of course the opening of the Americas created a whole range of all kinds of possibilities came out of that the new wealth fantastic worlds and richness from the gold silver and then the trade in Asia which they which which became the secret of their success but out of it all together with the discovery of new worlds discovery of the new kinds of Florida fauna the new kind of living which uh which in the Europeans had never encountered before in the Americas as well as in Asia and elsewhere stimulated tremendous excitement in Europe and all this pulled together of the fact of the war against authority of the church and that led to war against the authority of the kings of the monarchs so you had those things followed one after the other in a way it was logical once you're opposed the authority of some some Pope or Catholic Church that was absolute once you reject that you open up tremendous opposite of opportunities to reject other claims to Authority including your claim to know the truth and the search for the truth the kind of scientific thought that emerged or not of that it's a longer story I I'll come to that later but you can see that that is a complete break and that is the beginnings of modern what we call Modern civilization but it was a very special set of circumstances that created that and it had something to do with the breaking out of the Mediterranean into the into the two oceans thank you Prof Wang so Mr Tan must stay tuned for the next three lectures uh yes sir please sir go ahead uh hi my name is Jahan I'm from Ministry of Home Affairs uh actually so thank you Professor Wong for the very enlightening lecture and I was thinking about the difference sorry the definition of culture and civilizations that you drew I wonder how you saw the digital or cyberspace that is growing like increasingly influence nowadays do you see this space as more of a culture or more of a civilization or how would you place the digital space in in your decorative space cyber space coaches and civilizations cyberspace today well that's that's really taking me way out of space I don't think I have an answer to you that is really something that into the future about modernism modern civilization has got one tremendous difference from from the the from the past is that modern civilization believe in the idea of progress I shall be talking about that but that idea itself is actually quite extraordinary no other civilization had had discovered the word in fact all other civilizations have always had a golden age in the past from which we have in fact deteriorated and we looked to the golden age to to give us guidance and so how to behave because the past is always better than us we have to be as good as in the past but the revolution came from this idea of progress you actually believe that the future is going to be better than the than the past never happened I mean even if even in the great religions we talked about the future there was always a day of salvation which the future is somewhere else not on this Earth it's it's end of the Earth in a way yes so the idea that you can material progress on this Earth is unending okay go on and on and on it's probably the answer to your thing will go on and uh whether whether where it's going to lead us to I have no idea thank you yes please yeah go ahead thank you Professor Wang for an exciting and you know inspiring lecture my name is Satya I work for a firm called KPMG uh yeah so um it's interesting about progress I hope uh the the better age on climate is definitely uh something we may want to go back to uh in the future at least on climate but my question Prof is really on the question of language you you laid out very beautifully how different civilizations have uh you know impacted southeast Asia at the cultural level uh can can I understand from you your perspective on how language has influenced southeast Asia through those ideas what language well I as as a as a historian we actually only begin when there was language when there was literacy we talk about records only after you had record so we have history so anything that was not written where we can only speculate and guess and we depend on archaeologists to do the work for us but the question of language is indeed very important but the language essentially is that rooted in cultures cultures and language are inseparable and as I defined as I describe what I mean by cultures everybody has culture even the most primitive tribe you can say has culture and anthropologists would argue even the most primitive tribe has culture it may not have civilization but it has culture everybody has it because what it means is that as a group you have something distinctive and what is distinctive is whatever you share together as a group and what you share together to start with is at least a spoken language so it's a language a speech which everybody had and this is as a humans and you gather together and what you shared in common in the language provides you with the basis for culture then when you have literacy you advance that to another stage when you can actually have memory recorded for for future reference and for to help you become better to learn about the pastor so you don't make the same mistakes once you've written it down all your inspired the things you can pass it down you can transmit it generation of the generation so literacy advances the the borders of your language and you can have a larger group you don't have to know each other you don't have to exactly speak the same dialect you can write it down and you can read it and that sort of thing so literacy adds another dimension but all these are still essentially part of cultures every culture depends on some means of communication and language is the basis of it literacy to me is of course fundamental because and you can say that if without literacy there's no question of even acquiring civilization very difficult very difficult how you communicate something like civilizations as far as I know all the all the successful civilizations that will communicate have at some point or another been dependent upon on literacy and even in index civilization in Southeast Asia we don't have many proper records of what happened in when indic civilization came here we have it in monuments aesthetic artistic music and dance which have survived those have survived and the literacy party comes in inscriptions here and there the people here did not have the tradition of writing it down as historical records but they did the literacy gave them something that we know the names of all the rulers of Encore or in bataram or or SRI Vijay we named some of the rulers because somewhere along the line there was some inscription which had it and all those inscriptions were in a script which came from India no script as far as we can tell if you can understand was invented in Southeast Asia the scripts all came from India the the speech may not have survived but the scripts have survived as the archaeologists have discovered them and as the script survive then you can relate the relation the connection can be made to reading the scripts for example we know some how old the Malay language was not by not to what we read today in Rumi or in a Javi but in actually in Sanskrit sanskritic scripts in index groups surviving in some of the inscriptions in in Sumatra so literacy then is essential to at least the transmission of civilizations cultures don't need that I mentioned earlier in non-literate cultures can be just as Rich too artistic and other aesthetic and and things you create with your hands and what you do with your your senses in terms of music and dance and so on there are many other ways of communicating culture but civilization I think ultimately depends on your ability to transmit a a sense of the true meaning of life the idea of Truth what is point of what what are we here for how do we become better people how to improve ourselves and so on these team at least required some degree of literacy and in the end the actual transmission does depend on literacy and all the civilizations that have survived to this day are highly literate civilizations I think that's not an accident but that language has a national language and so on that is a different thing and as I said and I'll come back to that later on about why I this difference difference between culture and civilization is so important even for Singapore you won't have a national culture but the national culture could be based on many layers of civilization and that I'll come back to later I have a couple of questions from online but I think since you're standing up please and I'll see whether it's related to the questions here too please okay my name is Wong sunfen I'm a Staff of nus associated with College of Alice and peterton and Richview Residential College okay I have a two questions but I'll try to keep it short but my main question is actually you mentioned in one of your slides that in the early Beginnings uh southeast Asia was a region with no identity right uh I think you said uh yeah a region with no identity so my question is after more than five Decades of six uh what do you see as the identity of Southeast Asia that's my question the second part to this question is with the introduction of inclusion of timolesstee uh will this identity change and how will it affect this identity of Southeast Asia yes well let me let me see since I am going to talk about later on about the nature of of Southeast Asia today since it was invented uh to begin with you you will not have Asiana it wasn't a place called southeast Asia and as I said the name was only invented in 1944 in 1944 44 43 in the in the office of some British strategic thinkers in the in you know in the middle of the war so that's a very recent thing this region didn't even have a name and this is what I find so absolutely fascinating about it it didn't even have a name and yet when you look at it they had so much in common and they had a deep Pace the basic which I identified as ending in origin tremendous variety of indic and origin including Buddhism of course and so on and then layer after layer of Islamic of Chinese in a different way cynic civilization and ultimately of this modern civilization which started as European Christian Crusaders civilization but eventually developing into modern civilization so the oldies have happened so this region was always there doing things differently from other places and located as I mentioned started to mention as a peninsula and an archipelago that didn't have a name didn't have a common name but they had common experiences and why they had all those common experiences nobody nobody bothered to give you the name this is quite interesting they they didn't even have a name for themselves I mean these are names which we are having to you know we've invent to to to to to to identify them and the scholarly research of the last half century has been extraordinary in trying to in to try and reconstruct the history of Southeast Asia which didn't have a history before we never saw it like that and now we see it like that and that itself is of great interest and I shall come back to that um I I just said perhaps just to acknowledge that we have questions online uh I think one question from one we could say for a subsequent lecture where the one of our listeners is asking your key concerns about modern day civilizations especially in the 21st century and with the rise of what has been called radical worldviews should we save that for another lecture it seems like I could I could start but I'm also tempted to say leave it to my later lecture okay I could say something because I think this is actually part of the part of the idea of progress that I mentioned earlier on once you have the idea of progress and progress becomes a marker for what is modern that modern has to be Progressive improving ourselves all the time advancing knowledge getting a better sense of what is true and what is not true to become more and more accurate about what we do to be able to handle the minusculest smallest things to the largest millions of billions of miles away in the in the in the atmosphere in the universe to be able to do all that is a fantastic Challenge and it just can go on and on and on as it were and once you once you've taken this idea of progress what we are facing today and what is I think probably beyond my capacity to understand at all is the way this Gathering speed I mean in my lifetime what I knew when I was young they what I learned later on took me decades to Fathom to work out in the technology that was available when I was young I was always very in fact almost boastful of the fact that I didn't know how to use a telephone until I was 19 years old because I had no telephone in my home nobody that I knew had a telephone I never used a telephone but now I can look at the world the world communicates how do we compare that and how do you measure the rate of the speed of change compared to say the speed of change in the thousand years before that in the thousand years before that that rate of speed that changes and now it's shrunk to a point of every second you can discover something new something new is happening around the world and they kind of communicate it to you this is on unimaginable in in my in my in my lifetime and yet this is going to go on will it come to a stop ever how how do you reach the point to come to an end when this kind of progress of science and technology that we have now the capacity to do I just can't imagine so I I honestly have no idea what it's going to be like but so but I what I do know what I do know is that what's the idea that we can progress and that being creative creative destruction as they were being creative being an Innovative constantly seeking to extend the frontiers of knowledge and so on at the speed that we're going that it's almost anything is possible given that given that fact that this is happening thank you and that's probably a partial answer to the earlier question about digital transformation um yes please sir hello Manoj Sharma I run a technology company but primarily I think because of these excellent IPS lectures of the years I've developed a fascinating interest in history Prof the last time you were here you made some comments about Empire today of course you've spoken and drawn our minds towards civilization and culture something that Prof Kishore mentioned earlier actually it's been my mind for quite some time and if you could lend some insights to it I'll be very delighted Prof Kishore brought up the idea of java and it was always in my mind we know that Raffles and faka were interested in bangka curry Moon and Singapore as potential places to have a settlement with all the wealth from java the malacca's islands the possibilities of Banker what was it about the Dutch civilization and culture post the 1824 treaty that did not allow them to succeed maybe in the way some of their competition did I hate to say this but there are other important words that I have not yet gone into and the word empire is one of them but even more important than I shall I shall come to that in in in very carefully and that is a one nation uh up to now I'm talking about cultures and civilization because they are all the always there but Empires came later and changed that many kinds of Empires and as I also we argue there are many kinds of Nations but let me say that to take the point of Empires and I'll deal only with this one tonight today and that is it imposes whenever one state becomes big enough and Conquer takes takes other people's SIDS it was already an Empire straight away it can be a very small Empire also very large empire they range all the way from an Empire which is no more than one state conquering in the next state all the way to the empires that are Global like like the British Empire was the first Global one that incorporated the sea where the Mongol Empire was one that nearly Incorporated all the land that was available in Eurasia so the the changing way you can control the power is grown in a way like like knowledge like progress you have capacity to take in more territory and all that becomes bigger but what did make a change is that all those empires in one way or the other were domestic Empires they're all ready to do with one king and how you the succession is also monarchies or Emperors and their children in the family it's a dynasty and you have to you have changing Dynasty change yeah from time to time the one by Dynasty Falls another takes over but dynastic Empires but the next stage in the stage that I think there's the beginning of what I call Modern civilization is when National Empires develop so it comes back to the word nation and that is a brand new word I mean the nation the word itself is not new but the way it is defined as a nation-state a state which is of the citizenry of the people of that state all of them are masters of that in that state there's no King The King doesn't it may be a constitutional Monarch but that's all but then the Empire like France or the United States in the 18th century when they became independent black is a completely new phenomenon and today this has become Universal everybody has Nations why because we've got the subjects of national Empires and we wanted to get rid of them we actually became Nations because that's what we we thought the way to do was to anti-colonial means you have your own nation and not mission a subject of a national Empire we want to be a nations in our own right so we took over the world nation and I I already giving you a hint what I'm going to say about it because of the problems of making ourselves nations are really immense and they vary from one country to another but they are tremendously difficult and much more complex than anyone realized all of us who started Our Lives as anti-colonials thought we were going to be great in building Nations we thought there was a job which all of us had to do and it was something we could all do if they can do it why can't we you know but actually he was so new to the whole of Asia and certainly to our region it was so new he's turned out to be an extremely difficult job and that comes to the fact that the nature of Empires changed and the empires became Nations and created a hell of a lot of headaches for all of us The Waiting answer we have we to be winding down because I see on the screen that my countdown timer says zero zero zero zero but uh profile by the way uh you might just have set yourself up for another lecture series on Empires and Nations I I think In fairness to those uh there there are two questions which I could collapse together and it's got to do with Prof one your idea of Southeast Asia and of course Singapore at the heart of Southeast Asia being the Confluence of civilizations you also spoke about mandalas there's a question asking about what are the implications of this Confluence especially from your Vantage Point it says here of your generation with this intertwining gender civilizations and Inter intersecting histories and you yourself of course were part of a generation that sought to create a national culture when Malaya was on the cups of Independence I note in your lecture you also spoke about some kind of loss of political innocence on your part and of course this also translated on into your your later work could you just say something general and leave us some thoughts so that we will come we will come and attend the next three lectures that's a big pile of questions out there yeah but let me let me try and use one one particular point which I think is it's a it's very important to me and I believe it is Central to many of our problems today and that is that my understanding of civilizations as being borderless how do I explain that it's borderless because if the quality of the ideas the Brilliance of the Discovery Med the methodologies discover new tools the inspiration of some spiritual or intellectual or even physical change that everybody aspires to and is impressed by all that is actually borderless if anybody can learn that you see it it's like the diffusion of knowledge once you have the knowledge you don't it does it's not that hard for you people to pick it up because it's more than nobody stops you what we're up against uh when you have things like Empires and Nations and particularly when you have Nations and it comes back to it because once you have borders when you say this is a border you cannot cross this is Sovereign you cannot touch you must respect and so and so forth then you you create a whole system which is absolutely necessary of course once you have these nations a whole system of laws regulations prohibitions and what is possible what is not and so on and then how to enforce it how to be willing to use violence to stop people from breaking the laws breaking the rules all these things add up and then everything is boarded and that restricts this question of civilization being borderless the that's the one thing that made as human beings as it were have really profited from Modern civilization has been the fact it has been borderless like ancient like the ancient civilizations modern civilization was borderless it was brought taken out by national Empires when they conquered the world they took it out to everybody but on the whole it was borderless in the sense that you can all learn from them I mean the Europeans who came out here were very happy to teach us if you want to be like them if you can in their eyes maybe they thought you may not be able to but if you can you're welcome to it and you're quite happy to do that because they were confident they were sure they were not afraid in fact very happy that you should learn your you show respect to them you actually admire them and therefore you want to learn from them they're very happy but then once they begin fearful that you can learn it and maybe even better it'd be better than them you get fearful you get frightened and then the story becomes different you can't afford to be borderless you have to say no no you can't learn that you can only learn this but you can't learn that and I can tell you what to learn and what you can't learn once you start talking like that and thinking like that you are actually moving away from civilization to my mind that is no longer civilization that is kind of national talk imputive Imperial nationalistic talk when you talk like that you want to remove once you've move away or you are frightened of being borderless then you are no longer talking about civilization you're talking about cultures National cultures fighting each other and so so I mean I'll try to use this word board that I I will be talking about that too but I think like you said to capture something that I think covers all the related problems that we face today thank you Prof Wang I'm I'm so glad I allow for a little more time but we've been indulging all of you this seems to me a very good place to end and with the concept of civilization and it the idea of borderlessness being on and transcending borders being in some ways liberating both intellectually as well as socially uh and and I I think one takeaway uh for me and I think for us is that we live on an island but we don't have to think like an island we can think in relation to the peninsula to the archipelago and to The Wider world and uh profuanga you said in at the end of the lecture that your next lecture will explore the conditions that pave the way for revolutionary change so you left us with a cliffhanger and we are all awaiting your next lecture with great anticipation thank you Prof Wang foreign for the excellent question answer session we've come to the end of today's lecture we would like to hear your views on the event and please click our links on the Facebook feed or scan the QR code up there to submit your feedback profile Second lecture title opening to the global Maritime will take place next week on 1st December details will be on our website and IPS Facebook page we hope to see you then thank you all for attending to this lecture have a good evening ahead foreign