Transcript
Neanderthals were around for a very long time. Somewhere near 400,000 years ago to about 40,000 years ago. Modern humans didn't show up in Europe until near the end of that, around 45,000 years ago. And so Neanderthals had the place to themselves for almost the entire run. And they were all over the place. Western Europe, the Middle East, Central Asia, down into Israel and Iraq, and east into southern Siberia. There's a cave in the Altai Mountains with 74 Neanderthal fossils in it. And so when people say the world Neanderthals lived in, there's actually not one. Over that stretch of time, the climate swung back and forth repeatedly from ice age cold to warmer than today and back again.
And every time it swung, the animals changed with it. So, let's start with the warm world. During the last big warm phase around 125,000 years ago, Europe was hotter than it is right now. Forests ran from Spain up into Scandinavia. Hippos, you know, actual hippos in European rivers. Lions on the ground where London sits today. Straight-tusk elephants, roughly twice the size of a modern African elephant, and up to 13 tons. Narrow-nosed rhinos, fallow deer, aurochs, the wild cattle that later got domesticated, standing up about to 6 ft at the shoulder. Britain is a weird case. It had the hippos and the lions during that warm phase, and Neanderthals were not there.
Site after site comes back with the animals and no stone tools, and the read on it is that the sea level rose and it cut the island off before anyone walked across. And so the hippos in the Thames were living in an empty Britain. On the continent, they were right there in it. Neanderthals in the same landscape as the elephants and the rhinos. And we know this because of the butchery sites. Then the climate turns and everything swaps out. Cold phase Europe is open grassland and steppe, dry and windy and freezing. The forests pull back south and what replaces them is a huge belt of grass running across the continent and it supported more large animals than anything in Europe today.
Woolly mammoth, woolly rhinoceros, about 2 tons with a flattened front horn that shows wear consistent with sweeping snow off the grass in order to get at what's underneath. Steppe bison, musk ox, Arctic fox, giant deer with 12-foot antlers. Oh, and reindeer in many numbers that are hard to picture. At one site in northern Germany, reindeer make up around three quarters of everything identifiable from at least 86 animals and perhaps as many as 140. The bones say autumn and they say adults because the young ones were being passed over. Somebody was showing up where the herds were going to be and then picking and choosing which ones to take.
So, the animals moved in and out as the temperature went up and down. And that happened over and over and over across Neanderthal history. Now, the predators. First up, we have the cave lion. Bigger than a modern African lion, close to 4 feet at the shoulder and up to about 880 pounds for a big male. It would range right across Europe and northern Asia and it shows up in cave art later on, painted over and over again, which should tell you what people thought about the animal because they thought about it a lot. There's a cave lion skeleton from Sigsdorf in southern Germany found by a teenager in 1975 about 48,000 years old.
It had cut marks on it which people already knew about and the assumption was that somebody had butchered it after it died. Then a team went back over it again and that's when they found a partial puncture wound on the inside of the third rib at an angle entering from the left side of the abdomen through the vital organs and striking the rib on the far side. The shape of that puncture, well, it matches lesions on deer bones known to have been made by Neanderthal wooden spears plus experimental wounds made with replicas. No tooth marks, nothing that suggests another predator did it. And so, somebody killed a lion with a wooden spear thrust into its gut probably while it was already down and the researchers line on this is that it's the earliest direct evidence of a large predator being killed by a human anywhere.
Then there's Unicorn Cave in Central Germany. Cave lion toe bones with cut marks on them at least 190,000 years old. The pattern of those cuts, well, it only makes sense if the animal was skinned in such a way that had kept the claws attached to the pelt. And those bones were not polished or shaped so they weren't exactly pendants. They were left there in the skin. Which means a Neanderthal was walking around wearing a lion. Next we have the cave bear around 30% bigger than a brown bear with the largest males pushing about a ton in the same weight class as a Kodiak and the chemistry of their bones says they were eating mostly plants.
Though that has been getting argued a lot lately because some populations show meat in the signal and the skull shape looks more omnivorous than people assumed. However, the reason they matter here is real estate. Cave bears hibernated in caves, Neanderthals sheltered in caves, you get the picture. Now, there are sites across Europe where the two turn up in the same deposits, layer after layer, and in some caves, there are thousands of bear bones. Not because there was a massacre, but because bears went into hibernate for tens of thousands of years and a certain percentage never came out. pulled more than 30,000 cave bear skeletons out of one cave in Switzerland alone.
Then, there's the cave hyena. At around 225 lb, it is noticeably bigger than the spotted hyenas that are alive today, living in clans and denning in caves. And the DNA, well, it's interesting because the Eurasian and African hyena populations split more than a million years ago. Far enough apart that some researchers want the cave hyena treated as its own species rather than a subspecies. This is the direct competitor. Both of them were going after large, prime-aged grazers, so the overlap is almost total. The same prey, same carcasses, same caves in the same places at the same time. There are sites where hyena tooth marks and stone tool cut marks show up on the same bones, sometimes with the hyena marks on top, which means people got there first and the hyenas cleaned up after.
Sometimes it was the other way around, and that means that Neanderthals were scavenging from hyena kills. So, it went back and forth, carcass by carcass, for tens of thousands of years. And Neanderthal bones turn up inside of hyena dens with gnawings on them. Make of that what you will. Leopards, yes, they were in Europe, too. So were wolves and brown bears, and those are all still around, so they don't get the Ice Age treatment. But the brown bears then were a different proposition. There was a large steppe form running as big as the biggest coastal brown bears alive today, and it was eating a lot more meat than a modern one does.
In Spain, they've actually tracked the shrinkage directly. From around 570 lb in the early Holocene down to oh, about 300 now. Now, Homotherium, the scimitar-toothed cat, lion-sized, long front legs, sloping back, flattened serrated fangs that look more like steak knives than the long curved daggers people picture on a saber-tooth. The build was telling people something for years because long front legs and a sloping back is not exactly an ambush body. In 2020, a team sequenced its genome, and the genes, well, they back it up. Adaptations for daylight vision, adaptations for strong bones and for the heart and lungs, the kit for endurance running, and the genes tied to complex social behavior.
And so the picture that comes out of that is a pack of them hunting in daylight, running something down until they stopped, which is not how anybody draws a saber-tooth. That same genome came back with high genetic diversity, which suggests there were a lot more of these around than the handful of fossils makes it look. And that matters because of where one of these actually turned up. It was a site with the oldest complete wooden hunting spears anyone has ever found in Germany, and excavators pulled its teeth and an arm bone out of the same layer as the spears. Two different cats, and the arm bone has impact damage on it consistent with somebody using it as a hammer.
So, the people who made those spears were in the same place as a saber-toothed cat and at least one of them picked up a piece of that cat and used it as a tool. The researchers who published it made the point that spears like those wouldn't only have been for hunting. Sometimes you're carrying a spear because of simply what's out there. And there's a second possibility raised, which is stealing. A cat makes a kill, a group of people show up, the meat changes hands. That works in both directions, though. How long this thing would last in Europe has been argued about. Every known fossil said middle Pleistocene, so that's where the extinction sat.
Then a jawbone dredged out of the North Sea by a Dutch fishing trawler got radiocarbon dated to about 28,000 years ago, which would put it in the last ice age alongside late Neanderthals and early modern humans. And of course, not everyone accepts that, and other researchers point out that no other European find supports survival being that late. So, one bone and a whole lot of argument. If you're a Neanderthal, well, you're living in a landscape where the large carnivores are not exactly rare. You're sharing caves with bears, competing with hyena clans for meat, and occasionally in the same valley as a big pride of lions that are more huge than anything alive today.
And you're doing it with wooden spears and stone points. That lion found in Germany? Well, it says something about how that went because at least once, somebody ended up winning. And that's what shifted over the last 20 years or so. The old picture had Neanderthals scraping by at the edge of a hostile world, mostly reacting to it. The evidence keeps pointing somewhere else. They were hunting elephant at Neumark Nord and killing lions in Germany and 190,000 years ago somebody skinned a lion in such a way they kept the claws attached, which is a decision about how something looks and not really about staying warm.
The animals that I've been talking about were their neighbors for hundreds of thousands of years. And most of them are now gone. So are the Neanderthals about 40,000 years ago, though not entirely since a few percent of their DNA is still walking around inside the people watching this and the person who's speaking it.