# Hinduism & Buddhism - Huston Smith

**Channel:** The Seeker
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=brVmYTg01KI
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/brVmYTg01KI

## Chapters

- 0:13 — Introduction to Huston Smith's Journey
- 4:55 — India: Art as Spiritual Technology
- 12:31 — Hinduism: What You Want and Liberation
- 21:53 — Tibetan Buddhism and Multiphonic Chanting
- 32:29 — Buddha Nature and Buddhism's Appeal
- 36:24 — Zen Training and the Koan Mu
- 48:02 — Zen Life and Farewell Gift

## Transcript

**[0:13]:** oh

**[0:55]:** dog

**[1:05]:** i'm bill moyers in his classic study of the world's religions houston smith says that a balanced view of religion would include not only its virtues but its atrocities human sacrifice and scapegoating fanaticism and persecution crusades and holy wars during his own lifelong exploration of religion houston smith has not lingered in those dark shadows he has tried to let the best in each faith shine through his concern is for the values they teach the metaphysical truths they reveal the vistas they spread before our eyes all the great religions invite us to read the world around us for meaning to look for signs of the sacred in our everyday lives that's what gives them their staying power wherever religion comes to life says houston smith it displays a startling quality it takes over i've been tracking houston smith's work for several years now anticipating this chance to talk to him about what he understands of religions hold

**[2:03]:** on the human heart a renowned scholar and popular teacher for 50 years houston smith strives to see the world's great faiths as their believers do from within the experience to grasp why and how these religions motivate those who live by them what does dharma mean he has shared his search with students at some of america's finest universities california at berkeley mit syracuse and washington university in st louis our time is up for tonight we'll take up at this point next time his classic text first published in 1958 and since translated into 14 languages has been read by millions he even introduced the world's religions to an american audience on national educational television in 1955. long before most of us had heard of the bhagavad-gita are the five pillars of islam

**[3:08]:** for firsthand experience he has traveled the world visiting ashrams in temples synagogues and mosques and studying with zen masters monks and swamis today's scripture reading is from the gospel of luke chapter 14 born of methodist missionaries in china he remains a methodist today but many of the spiritual practices and disciplines he encountered have become part of his own personal journey for houston smith all these different expressions he says all these faces of god are necessary to flesh out the human soul houston smith now lives near the campus in berkeley with his wife kendra still teaching and traveling and writing he has been called an ambassador to the world's religions i ask him to retrace some of the steps from this remarkable journey in our first hour we will travel with him from a tibetan buddhist monastery to his endo in japan but we begin in india houston smith first came here in 1957 the film he narrated from that experience carries us into the infinite vision of the east the cradle of two great religions hinduism and buddhism

**[4:55]:** everyone who has been to india agrees india is different i remember my first visit as if it were yesterday the long ride from the delhi airport it was the smells that were the strangest a blend rising from a half million cooking fires in the dusty evening air

**[5:20]:** what was it that made this place these people so different while at the same time making me think i know them i've always known a part of me seems to have been here from the beginning

**[5:41]:** the historian of religion can find almost anything he wants in india enacted with intensity what remains is to carry its insight back into everyday life

**[5:59]:** in india art is religion religion art her arts are strictly utilitarian their purpose is to inform and transform inform us of the way things truly are transform us into what we might truly be

**[6:24]:** you said in the film we saw that for india art is religion religion art help me to understand that clothiness said that the soul that beholds beauty becomes beautiful and the indians i think would agree with this we must realize that through the ages most indians were illiterate and that meant that their sacred texts were not in written words for the most part they were in sculpture painting dance temples with their beauty the truths came through not so much the mind with its cerebrations but through the eye through the ear and kinesthetically through the dance form

**[7:40]:** india never had the notion until our century of art for art's sake art was a spiritual technology and it is really very miraculous how art makes easy what otherwise would be difficult now what is otherwise difficult and the answer is to behave decently to one another sometimes that's easy but not always or the world wouldn't be in the shape that it's in but art as i say when it's great art and really working what it does is to transport us lift us to a different state of consciousness from which the world looks very different and from that different way in which the world looks we find spontaneously we want to behave decently if you go to a museum and just wash your eyes in just great beauty you go out in a different place the world looks differently and it is literally true that a mean a despicable act is just unthinkable well it happens to me more often with music to actually bring forth a will to do good or will to

**[9:19]:** be good that i can't explain well that seems i'm more audio than visual i've spoken of the visual museum but uh but i too can be transported by a melody at the the last two weeks it's been uh the magnificat from the eastern orthodox liturgy my soul magnifies the lord and my spirit rejoices and god my maker now never mind the word but the but the lilting tenderness of that aria uh it just uh puts one in a different state of life how do you explain this image of god out of the that's one of the hindu pictures in your book right that's a god so foreign to our idea that is this image of god has 10 arms well that's simply a symbol of omnipotence we're limited we've only got two but the divine uh power and capacity to do things just spread beyond so it has to do with the immense and incomparable

**[10:39]:** creativity of the divine everything in in india and they're exuberant in terms of numbers just uh it's it's more than we can conceive so god is everywhere looking omniscient is all these thousand faces are looking constantly and so all together aware but i would want to emphasize there is something in other people's religion that is incomprehensible uh wilfred smith a great deal and he said it seems that the egyptian thought that the sky was a cow and wilfred says you know i can't understand that i i cannot get my head into how anybody could think that the sky was a and we have to realize that these are not open books and there are esoteric regions in each one of us that we just have to admit well they meant obviously something to those people but beats us

**[12:31]:** this is shiva nataraj the dancing shiva a depiction of nature but what a difference between the way in which we in the west tend to think of nature as sidereal space spreading out on all sides this personalizes it in an art form the gracefulness the forearms indicate the prolificness of nature the circle of fire that rings it is the constant changingness of nature but the most important thing is the spirit of beauty and the word is little or play nature as the divine play now the secret might be overlooked namely the reason that nature can be seen in this graceful mood is that the lower foot is planted on a dwarf which symbolizes the human ego our in noisy clamoring demand that we have our way and only when that egoism is solidly subdued the foot planted solidly on it then our whole attitude towards the world that circles us and sustains it can be

**[14:17]:** changed from a blind mechanism into a dance of joy

**[14:32]:** is it impossible to state the essence of hinduism and what hinduism has contributed to the world it's so multi-splendored so many so many yes and one has to have some rubric some device to bring it into focus otherwise it just splatters out into a kind of chaos of everything and the device that i have found and lived with for decades now is the that there is an underlying motif to everything you see and that is the claim of hinduism that you can have what you want now that sounds good but immediately it opens on to what do you want and they move right in they say people want four things they want pleasure then they want worldly success which includes power wealth and fame and then a little more subtle they want to have behaved responsibly then finally we want liberation they put it in the negative term they don't put a positive what you

**[16:02]:** want because that's beyond all description they put it negatively liberation from any impediment that will hold you back from what will bring you your complete fulfillment and then they go on to different stages of life which they divide into childhood they don't count because no responsibilities there but youth where your chief obligation is to learn time is free so you can learn against the time when much will be expected of you then the householders stage where your primary concern is family and profession and community responsibility and then they go into the third stage which is retirement retirement for us we think of as rest and recreation but they think of retirement as the opportunity to really dig into your true adult education because up to this time you've been just too busy the clamor the demands but now before it's all over to turn your attention to an understanding of what life is all about

**[17:33]:** before you exit it what do you make of that hindu proverb there are realms of gold hidden in the depths of our hearts in the upanishads the philosophical versions and texts of hinduism there is a phrase that comes repeatedly like the clang of a gong

**[18:03]:** literally that thou art and what it means is the that which we seek in brahman the divine whatever you call it is right here within you you see they not only they begin by saying you can have what the what you want and that sounds very good but wait till you get to the climax and then you've already got it well why don't we doesn't feel like one god and they say well that's that's no problem there because the light of a lamp the shade can be covered with dust or soot or mud even to the point where the light does not shine through at all and that's our nature that are the divine which is completely present here has been shadowed by bad karma and so the object of life is to free those uh little grains and flecks of karma until the light can be not only shine before other people but can

**[19:26]:** be experienced within you somebody told me that you have written a poem about india that's about to be published it is i'm not a port but it is true this one i just woke up with it was almost formed oh i'm not well i'll see if i can remember the background was that i was looking at one of these many commissioned portrait of british viceroys to india and these were the lines that came to me who could have dreamed looking at this willful face that india touched him more than he touched her trains multiplied of course both baby booms of belching smoke and whistles whale english too improved as eaton's short pants broad white collar sprang up in unlikely places even the manly arts took hold as yogas vowed to bat and ball horses reel to mallets stroke while watched in printed flocked frocks but i've heard that his wife declared he mellowed through

**[21:13]:** the years listened more talked less grew more patient when a servant slipped and when the time to leave rolled around he knelt and kissed the parched red ground a tear met the dust in that waterless land that had known so well his heavy hand

**[21:53]:** in these mountains in northern india houston smith would encounter another culture and another religion that intrigued him after the chinese communist invaded tibet in 1949 and began to exterminate buddhist monasteries and customs tibetan buddhist monks brought their ancient ways across the himalayas to exile here in india

**[22:31]:** here are two young tulkus reincarnated llamas tibet is at their back it has been closed to them they are exiles and they're looking into the future which is totally unformed there is nothing that we see on that horizon and that depicted for me the future of humanity in its continuing odyssey so it was to india again that houston smith returned in 1964 to explore this endangered culture

**[23:21]:** he arrived at this tibetan buddhist monastery on the eve of an annual four-day ceremony where the llamas would chant 15 hours a day for four days

**[23:34]:** what he found inside these walls was a liturgy which used a sound he'd never heard a sound he described as lifting the human spirit to the level of the gods

**[23:55]:** the first hour they're chanting was nothing exceptional it was a very deep guttural rhythmic monotone and echoing out of centuries of unshaken belief it was sort of impressive but it was monotonous and it went on for an hour and i found myself actually dozing off in the course of the hour only to be brought to my consciousness with i it seemed like i was surrounded by angelic choirs because that monotone had splayed out into full blown chords

**[24:43]:** now i was trying to make sense out of that figuring out what is going on here when suddenly the choir cut out leaving it all to a cantor a single voice and here he was doing it all by himself

**[25:09]:** a first a third and a barely audible fit coming out of a single laryng

**[25:25]:** and then i must say my hair did begin to tingle when that tone first broke over my ears it was the holiest sound i had ever heard i remember my first thought was klaus leitmon will never believe me klaus being the music director back at mit i thought i've got to get evidence of this because the presumption had been that the human voice is not capable of doing that of doing that doing more than one tone exactly i i felt certain from the start that this is a phenomenon the west knows nothing about and so i excused myself beat the bushes went to the high school and finally found a little german recorder came back and said excuse me would you mind doing this all over again for me but they were very obliging and did and then when i went back to mit i asked who is doing the major voice on the acoustic work on the acoustics of the human voice and the name was kenneth stevens i called him asked if i can come over and if this was really

**[26:49]:** fun because you could just see the faintest smile on his face as he wondered what this philosopher had garbled in his account of what he had in the palm of his hand but when he put it on his his machine his player his expression changed dramatically and it is actually introduced a new word into the vocabulary of musicology namely multiphonic chanting

**[27:28]:** every song tone has overtone but it's too faint for us to hear as discrete notes but what they have learned to do is amplify those overtones so now we hear those overtone as discrete tones in their own right so that's the acoustics of it now what's the significance of that what's the point of all this what does it have to do with worship well this is obviously not art for art's sake it is more like spiritual technology

**[28:13]:** the purpose of worship is to shift from peripheral awareness to focal awareness the mystery and wonder of the world we sense that going on a lot but we do not have it in focus of our attention and the llamas they too take what is in peripheral awareness the overtones to faint for us to hear discreetly and elevate into our direct consciousness so they're doing with music exactly what worship is intended to do with the sacred move it from peripheral to focal awareness they tell me that at first it sounds like they are making the music the second step it's like the deity is making this music and they're just sort of riding the waves of that music and if their meditation reaches the climax then all distinction between deity llama and sound collapses and all there is is that one holy tone that holy tone has now been heard by ears around the world the monks houston smith first encountered in

**[29:58]:** 1964 have since toured the world three times first in the 1970s when they performed in london and again in 1988 when they stopped off in new york city to perform at the cathedral of saint john the divine

**[30:26]:** they came on a mission to alert the west to china's oppression of tibet they also sought to share their ancient culture with americans like this mandala

**[30:42]:** made of grains of colored sand which takes weeks to create and is destroyed in a flash

**[30:54]:** the sand is carefully collected and then scattered in a sacred ceremony symbolizing the impermanence of life

**[31:12]:** their most recent tour in 1995 included a stopover at the ranch of grateful dead drummer mickey hart in order to make a state-of-the-art recording in his studio hart also provided the monks with some needed rest and relaxation american style

**[31:41]:** houston smith was invited to attend the recording session it was here that he was reunited for the first time in 30 years with the monk he had met on that moonlit night high in the himalayas

**[32:02]:** that monk venerable lobsong tursing has been a chant master for three decades at the age of 60 he can still sing three tones simultaneously

**[32:19]:** he can still evoke what houston smith calls the holiest sound i had ever heard

**[32:29]:** it isn't the essence of buddhism to make us aware of the sacred within the eternal within the infinite within i mean those are just words the buddha nature what they call it but yes what is the buddha nature the buddha nature is our the core of our being which is the buddha it's a little bit like the realms of gold in hinduism that we were talking about it would be their name for that sacred center christians would call it the image of god that is within us

**[33:14]:** buddhism begins with a man in buddha's later years people came to him asking what he was not who are you but what are you buddha answered i am awake

**[33:38]:** one can detect a kind of androgynous quality in this figure is it male is it female as one gazes on this face one can sense what this space has been through the ups and downs the trials and the triumph and yet all coming through in the sense of serenity not just acceptance but affirmation at the face that has seen everything and yet comes out with affirmation

**[34:25]:** how do you explain the seemingly growing american interest in in buddhism well one i think clearly understandable point is that buddhism is probably the most psychological religion and we live in a psychological age has a lot of interest in psychology and i can be very personal kendrim our wife or whose husband i am is a psychologist and she has been four times to the uh buddhist vapasana retreat in berry massachusetts now that's three months three months of no talking no reading no writing and downcast eyes not looking in anyone else's face everything designed to turn one's attention inward we have a psychiatrist friend who has been to five of these and said his first three-month meditation retreat taught him more about the mind than his entire psychiatric training the reason he said is obvious in psychiatry we talk about other people's mind and in buddhist meditation we are looking intently at our own curious to

**[36:10]:** better understand his own mind houston smith traveled to japan to study with hiroshi or zen master

**[36:24]:** the rigors of zen training involving eight hours a day of silent meditation led him to write that entering zen is like stepping through alice's looking glass it is a world of bewildering dialogues obscure conundrums stunning paradoxes all designed to bring on a flash of wordless insight my supreme wish then was to make it into a zen monastery to undergo the training that the zen monks receive and little did i know at that time how what i was asking in terms of the difficulty because it would it's very easy to get into a zen temple but a zen monastery is another story because the roshi the zen master is working with in my case there were 30 students day in and day out to cultivate a very rare refined state of awareness basically in the 10th times about 15 hours a day of silent meditation and the plunk of gross westerner down into that is an

**[37:50]:** enormous distraction wonder how he's going to make it i wonder how long he will survive because you know all these become questions and the roshi's don't want it because it's a distraction the day after i arrived i was taken uh into the presence of the roshi only two at that time spoke english and he was one of the two i'm seated on my haunches there he is looking very stern in his robe and he gave me my koan koan is a meditation problem which in renzi's and the meditation focuses on now the beginning koans are like shaggy dog stories they're they make no sense the three standard ones this is the sound of two hands clapping what is the sound of one hand clapping the second standard one is what was the appearance of your face before your parents were born now the one i was given was the third standard one uh which is

**[39:03]:** a little bit longer a monk asked joshu he said joshua was a master back in china does a buddha does a dog have a buddha nature to which the master said mu which means no in japanese now every buddhist would know that the buddha had said even grass has a buddha nature presumably dog is on a higher scale of being than grass how can it be that grass has a buddha nature and a dog doesn't what i've just said he didn't tell me all he told me was does the dog have and the answer is no so i had a problem with anyone ding-a-ling-a-ling meaning it's all over for the day and so i had 24 hours with that problem on my mind somehow by redefining the word maybe by buddha nature you didn't quite mean that our dog didn't you know when you get a contradiction you fiddle with the terms so that they

**[40:13]:** will fit so i next morning the same routine i went back and uh he glared at me meaning what's your answer and so i gave him my answer and he said oh no no no no go back go back ding-a-ling-a-ling so i had another 24-hour and during that day i came up with an even more ingenious answer and when i went back the third morning he didn't even hear me out halfway through my answer he he roared at me he said you have the philosopher disease

**[40:58]:** then he softened a little bit and said you know there's nothing wrong with philosophy i happen to have a master's degree in philosophy myself from one of our better universities but philosophy deals with reason and reason can only work with the experience that it has to work with now you obviously have the reason you have do not have the experience for these we've put reason aside and go for the experience now the answer to these early quant is not a verbal answer it is an experience these are conundrums set up in such a way don't tell ask me how they work so uh the contra this is my theory i don't know if it's right my theory is that it presents you with a contradiction before which the reason feels helpless he would stress this word and he would say at times nothing but the whole universe nothing but and i found that it was

**[42:31]:** working like a kind of montram within me having as it were knocked out the logical rational process in this concentration on the issue at some point something gives and you enter into the deep mind and with a kind of detonative experience it's a mystical experience the most climactic moment of those eight weeks was when we came to the last week this intensive round-the-clock experience some would not sleep at all i i was 37 most of them were younger they let me sleep three and a half hours after the first night you're just sleepy after the second night you're bushed and then you just keep it keep going after that the net effect was i was worked up into a state my mind was in a state and this happens too i was furious i thought this kind of behavior to do this to a human being it's just human you know i'm not defending what

**[43:58]:** i was thinking but i was just irrational and at that time this climactic week final exam week so to speak we were going in twice a day and the second day before the end i went storming into that roshi and i was ready to let him have it to throw not just to throw in the towel on the whole business but to throw it right into his face and when i went in there in that utter rage so the usual routine you're sick sink down to your haunches you mechanically touch your forehead before him our eyes met and he said how's it going the word sounded like a taunt to me and i answered terrible and he said you think you're gonna get sick don't you and i yelled again yes i think i'm gonna get sick my throat was closing in on me so that i could hardly breathe and then all of a

**[45:09]:** sudden in the most objective quiet voice you can imagine he said what is sickness what is hell put them both aside and go forward and now i despair of communicating to you the effect of those words on me immediately with no thought i found bubbling up well by god he's right and the way sailing in with my anger with those words he just spun me around into a state of total tranquility and peace and i did my bow to the floor i got up leaving the room not only determined to finish the two days which i wasn't at all sure i was capable of doing but knowing that i could do it i have never experienced such a transfusion it seemed like the pipe from his aura to my horror in which the energy came into me when i said by god he's right the opposite sick sickness and tell when he said both are

**[46:49]:** irrelevant they came to the same thing and the union of the opposite in a normal state of mind i would never think of sickness and health as being identical but in that moment i could see that there really was no difference between them and i accomplished the union of opposites which they're gonna show putting the palms together symbolizes somehow you came to an acceptance of the dilemma the perplexity the contradiction and did not let yourself stay there you move beyond the contradiction then that's not the end that's only the first step in the real zen practice day after that day after day plodding footsteps after plotting footsteps to come to bring that glow and that glory of that experience into the daily life

**[48:02]:** this hall queen said my daily life is no different except that there is no conflict drawing water hewing wood in everything no obstruction this is the mysterious happening this is the wondrous incomparable

**[48:43]:** so it's to bring the other world into this world in the nitty-gritty of the daily life

**[48:55]:** when we came to the end of the incredible summer he gave us a farewell a little gathering and he spoke about then and he said all this colon all this training that you've been through that's not sin that is important as exercises but the zen life what is the zen life itself he says we can put it in a formula infinite gratitude towards all things past infinite service to all things present infinite responsibility to all things future that is zen and then the wonderful smile i'm glad you came have a safe journey home and he gave you a present didn't he this yeah this i know your wife was talking about this what is that i was uh just overwhelmed they call it a kakimono zen masters uh they feel that art is as important as anything in the zen training and this is a calligraphy that he himself painted for me personally and that

**[50:25]:** central character is the moo uh that i had been knocking my brains again all those weeks but now in this beautiful uh aspect i feel uh so ashamed of the contribution i gave him for his administration's patience towards me when he gave me a treasure as a farewell gift but have you decided if the dog has a buddha nature it needn't be determined definitively

**[51:11]:** next on the wisdom of faith with houston smith the son of missionary parents explores the complexity of confucianism the intertwining of the opposite looking to the east to become fully human using the discipline of yoga the days go better when i do it for his soul's sake to unite this human spirit to the ultimate spirit

**[52:22]:** so

**[52:39]:** you
