# Lec 14 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bihrpOS0qtY
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/bihrpOS0qtY

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 8:24 — Chapter 2 (8:24)
- 16:25 — Chapter 3 (16:25)
- 21:29 — Chapter 4 (21:29)
- 29:42 — Chapter 5 (29:42)
- 38:02 — Chapter 6 (38:02)
- 45:30 — Chapter 7 (45:30)
- 53:50 — Chapter 8 (53:50)
- 1:02:45 — Chapter 9 (62:45)
- 1:10:39 — Chapter 10 (70:39)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu

**[0:25]:** okay good afternoon good afternoon I want to remind you that a week from today is the second exam the format is identical to what you had 50 multiple choice questions thirty from the book chapters five to seven twenty from sacks and the lectures short answers okay so talking about tests you know why do we have tests we live that you live in a world of tests you know everything from SATs to on your horizons maybe GRE Zoar or MCATs or LSAT so so why do people have tests besides making it miserable to be under 30 as a revenge of the older people right okay why do people have tests

**[1:20]:** yeah yeah one of them is just you know yeah verify that you know something when people will call that sort of have you learned stuff right the test is a meant to be an estimate of what have you learned but a second form of testing that that's what people sometimes will call high-stakes tests in a slightly different way our ones about selection and prediction which sometimes involve achievement or aptitude things like SATs or GRE is right so achievement sirs are meant to be estimates of what you know how much math advanced placement tests how much math you know or physics content in a given area and sort of a broader sense of aptitude SATs or GREs now one thing that's different about today's lecture and intelligence it'll be a little someone we do personalities up until now to a first approximation most of the time we've talked about louis view as general principles of the human

**[2:17]:** mind and brain across everybody right how vision works across everybody memory across everybody thinking across everybody and now we're switching to a domain and it doesn't have to be this way but this is the way the world has done it where we emphasize differences between people right so when people take tests it's not to see that everybody took the test what they're going to do is you get an A or a B or a C or you get a high SAT or a medium SAT right and schools use the differences to think about you and so one question is you know from an empirical sense are these tests pretty good at predicting things and the answer is you know they're decent they're not terrific okay so the tests survive like SATs or GREs because there's correlations between these kinds of tests before you get to graduate school for example and how faculty rate students or

**[3:13]:** how productive people are in terms of researches or as a graduate student in this case or the GPAs or things like that so and the correlations are about you know 0.3 to 0.4 to give you an intuitive sense the correlation is between sex and height whether you're men or women and height is about 0.4 so of course lots of women are taller than lots of men an average men are taller than women that's a point for Coral so you know this is in that range right okay so tests are pretty good predictors everybody says that for things like predicting college performance or graduate school performance the combination of tests and grades are better the difference is grades take a lot of years to produce you know tests are one traumatic outing right so you know so they're you know tests are just a part of our life in selection processes so now what is intelligence

**[4:10]:** and it's it's it's a loaded word right I mean memory is kind of a neutral or detention is a neutral word intelligence is a loaded word I mean nobody wants to be low on intelligence right and so um you know psychologists have come out of this way but it's kind of funny because there's not going to be a really deep definition maybe it's a lot of different things and how they average up or something like that but people have said well it's something about the ability to solve problems to understand and learn complex material to adapt to the environment mental quickness those are all senses you might have of something that you think of as intelligence in a person but you know whether they are one thing many things it's very hard to pull that out and we don't know too much about that really and I also want to remind you of something we

**[4:55]:** talked about but it's especially important in this field we talked about an experiment versus correlations an experiment you have to have a dependent measure something you measure but critically and uniquely of an independent variable something that you vary that's what makes a study and experiment as opposed to correlation so studies of intelligence and of every kind are almost always correlational and almost never experimental that means they're always subject to lots of interpretation and many factors in the world and that's very important to keep in mind you know so and again they tend to focus on variation in people rather than what is intelligence itself and again here's this another correlation of height and weight you know that has a pretty stronger correlation right so where where did intelligence start with it's a fascinating story and by the way let me tell you the SAT story on the sidebar from moment so SATs nowadays do people

**[5:52]:** some people get ready a lot for SATs by courses you take and things like that I read about that okay when I when I took it people weren't that organized but but getting into college wasn't that competitive so you know and the original goals of SATs was what do you know it's really interesting because it ends up being things that they say well because people who are maybe under more supported circumstances more financially advantageous circumstances get more help to get ready for the SAT those things might amplify SAT differences in a way that's not really about the person to start with the original goal of the SATs was to the national test that was fair for everybody so that schools like Harvard for example attended to admit the same kind of students from the same small set of schools in the Northeast so now we have a test for everybody across the country and we

**[6:41]:** can admit people on their merit rather than a small social connectivity networks that make sense okay and yet SATs are now viewed as a suspicious tool in that regard it was originally meant to be democratizing saying everybody in the country takes the same test it's not whether you have a connection through a network to to our University IQs had the same story for good reasons and we'll talk about that IQ tests and interpretations of IQ are often sort of not don't have a good history but the original goal was pretty reasonable so in in France in 1904 they began Universal elementary education that every child goes to class and Albert Binet a physician wanted an objective way to identify children who needed extra help perfectly good idea child comes to school some children are ready to go some children need a lot of extra help because they have a difficulty so he gave developed a

**[7:33]:** set of tests where he probed many different abilities like copying and drawing repeating digits recognizing coins explaining why a statement did not make sense they wanted to probe different little areas of abilities so if a child is terrible at something or two things the teacher knows this child needs some extra help to get going so that's a you know that's a good use of testing I think by everybody's criterion but then testing you know sort of took off IQ testing but I I Q stands for intelligence quotient a test to give typical children they give it often for the most commonly used IQ tests at many different ages they'll test a large number of individuals and they'll compare what nowadays what they think of as your mental age to your chronological age right so your chronological age is how long you've lived your mental ages how well you score in a test the most famous

**[8:24]:** IQ test and most widely-used takes about two hours of testing comes from David wek so the Wechsler adult intelligence scale one for children and within that test what's within that test because when people talk about tests I think whatever kind of test it is it could only be about as good as the test design itself right to the extent that it's any good right a ridiculous test is a ridiculous test even if society gives it to you right but tests can be better than that and so what is inside the most widely used IQ test into especially in clinical environments so let's talk about one of them it has a bunch of little tests when is vocabulary they asked you to define words that similarities Alaska serious questions like how are an airplane and the car alike very simple map arithmetic operations digits pants how many digits can you remember information they'll give you a

**[9:15]:** series of questions like who is Martin Luther King jr. comprehension they'll ask you things about the world like why are their taxes and things like that and you give an answer somebody scribbles down what you say and they score you you know you got two points at one point we'll talk about that and then they add up these scores in the sub test what's in the soap none a non verbal test or the performance tests they'll show you a picture with a think missing have you did that as a kid I love those things you know what's missing in the picture stuff like that blocks they'll have you rearrange them into various geometric design picture arrangement you get a cartoon panels and you have to put them in the correct order to tell a story and they measure how accurately and quickly you do these things there's nothing amazing about any of these things they're probing a variety of little abilities that you have and

**[10:01]:** again that will take the mental age and chronological age divide it multiply by 100 and they'll standardize it so that 100 is the population mean in the United States do other countries do these things as well is that okay so I mean a test can only be possibly good as the content of it and what it measures it doesn't measure depends on the specific content of it they'll scale the scores out so you have a normal distribution you know with a peak in the middle the raw score is the number you get the standardized wanted to adjust it for your age and it's a pretty important concept because we'll come back to this in a moment right the raw scores your actual score but then they adjust it for your age right because you don't expect a five-year-old to do as well as a fifteen-year-old to do as well as you know peak 18 to

**[10:47]:** 23 year olds okay and then bad things happen as you get older you you know tell you a bit about that to a 2/3 of the people are plus or minus one standard deviation they set it for that more than two standard deviations up or down are about 5% on either end of the distribution of scores and they norm it by age again you don't expect a six-year-old to do something but you get some funny things not they have to worry about this in detail but let me just gives you a sense so imagine your five-year-old and you take the test on the last day you're a five-year-old or imagine you have your birthday today and you're six years old by moving from five to six from you know Wednesday to Thursday you've moved up a year for the scoring right because they go by year not by day so if you would have scored

**[11:34]:** 120 on the IQ test yesterday when they say what should you have scored for a five-year-old the very same test the next day you would score 100 okay now it's a bit of a that's the extreme case but you understand what happens right because you here's how well you did that might have been pretty good 120 is above the average for a five-year-old but the next day you're a six-year-old now for six-year-old is just average okay so age has a big effect on these things here's here's something sad for aging but good for you that your be smart now a 40 year old who scores average with what would be a what do you know undergrad right if I if I score like you know let me rephrase as if you were compared to 40 year old you would have a and that you have a hundred IQ you would have a 230 IQ because

**[12:25]:** age knocks down the score as well okay so things go up and and things go down okay in this problem and usually they think of a score below seventy as clinically concerning as this is not now and top two percent you get to join Mensa and do whatever it meant so people do which I don't know exactly but sounds interesting okay an important thing about tests of any kind are two huge concepts reliability and validity so reliability refers to the ideas that if you were tested more than once you would get the same score the better IQ tests work a fair bit to try to achieve that validity is you know the deeper question does a test validly measure what it's supposed to measure so if we had you flip a coin and said that's your IQ you'd say you know that's ridiculous it's not a valid test right we could measure your height that

**[13:13]:** would be extremely reliable measuring the same height today as tomorrow if we did a decent job that wouldn't be a valid measure of anything about any mental ability nevermind something like intelligence so those are two important concepts and testing but very different now why do people think IQ tests are interesting besides just this weird curiosity about intelligence because IQ tests correlate with GPA and high school and college job success salary stable marriages staying out of jail and how long you live alright again it's a correlation it could be many different things you know think I want to talk you out of is the idea that if you have you know a 200 IQ today you've got something stored up that will fend off disease right it's not that necessarily it's that there's lots of things in your life that got you to that score and all those things are likely to persist in your life

**[14:02]:** good health supportive education interest maybe in taking on challenging tasks you had those before you had them while you took the test you continued to have them after another way to think about it though which is you know both the plus and a minus being how you look at it IQ scores account for approximately 25 percent of the variation on these things so that's not huge that means there's many many many other factors besides whatever IQ is capturing but it's a it's about as big a chunk as you can get for a couple hours of testing and we know two other things like personality variation education culture all those things blend in and how a person will do an IQ all these outcomes so when we go back and forth because in one hand we say there's a lot of stuff besides IQ but IQ has some interesting this otherwise nobody would talk about it

**[14:48]:** and would just disappear from the world so on average on average what is 15 minutes 15 IQ points mean so an average a person with a hundred IQ in the US will go to high school in a year or two in a community college on average these are averages of a huge variety of people yet 15 more IQ points and on average you're likely to finish college and have a white-collar job have 15 fewer points and you're not likely to complete high school and you'd have to have a job that doesn't require education background so 15 points on averages correlate with things here's another one because we're all you know we're going to come everybody in the end is a little bit curious in your own life how much of you know what you're good at or not good at or any of us comes from our genes from our environment you know where does

**[15:33]:** that come from what what what are the things that support us or limit us so here's one study that's took women from the same family so they're all sisters from the same family okay they're trying to control a little bit of genetics because the shared genes within the family they're not twins but it and definitely shared environment they're in the same household so it's true okay and within those families they look at the IQ score so here's the average group above average well above average a little below average a lot below average and they say that in these these women all coming from the same households here's their average income and here's the average rate of illegitimate births which is one measure that people think is kind of a social an average not a desired outcome to have a child without a family supporting that's not going to help a person succeed in the world

**[16:25]:** to be a single mother and so you can see you know the salary pretty much moves with the IQ on average and the rate of village' births pretty much moves with that too so again it's an average but there's some relationship between these things now if you pick up the newspaper today and read about you know nuclear disasters in Japan and problems in the Middle East and other things like that you would say it's hard to say the world is getting smarter but you will you may or may not be surprised to hear of the so-called Flint effect this was kind of a surprise Minh was discovered which is basically this IQ scores where they're measured go up around the world all the time by IQ test scores it's as if the world is getting smarter all the time which is kind of an optimistic thing okay whether it's getting wiser right is a good

**[17:19]:** question but spike by IQ score smarter all the time so that's hidden for many years because every every few years these tests get re normed for the group so that makes sense okay so there you're given again hundred is the average and then given again and 100 is the average but if they ignore this averaging and just say across these tests that only change a little bit some of them only change a little bit if we just take the scores look at 1930 1940 and it just keeps going on so this is a Flynn is the person who discovered that the world is getting smarter by raw IQ tests and one of the tests a usable show an example this is another widely used test called Ravens progressive matrices IQs go up about three points every ten years so if you were born in 1930 you would you know first would have an IQ of

**[18:10]:** 100 their child 108 and their grandchild 120 with a standard deviation higher so it's like smarter smarter smarter now you will be I don't recommend to go home and tell your parents but any debate you have with them is pointless because you're smarter than they are but by the f you if push comes to shove ax you can look up the Flynn effect and have a discussion about that so somebody you know who has an IQ today let's flip it around the grandparent with if you have a hundred your grandparent you know would have a IQ of 82 by this reasoning people in 1900 would have a mean IQ of 70 by okay and and nobody knows why it's going up all over the world there's all kinds of ideas about maybe nutrition is going up maybe reasoning abilities are being Porsche maybe educational things I mean it's impossible scientifically to know why because it's

**[19:02]:** happening on such a global giant scale but some people have said the tests don't go up uniform across the test which gives us a hint about the way the world is changing and how intelligence tests in some way become a barometer of what mental abilities are increasingly prized by societies so there's relatively small gains across years in vocabulary or general knowledge or arithmetic whether our large gains are what you might call abstract thinking tasks like similarities so let's focus on that for a moment so a similarities question might be like this in what way are dogs and rabbits alike if you answer both mammals you get two points okay that's the best you can do and that's what we would call an abstract or taxonomic one whether you're abstracting across the two things or you could give an answer like you use dogs to hunt rabbits okay that's not a wrong answer that's considered a

**[19:58]:** one-point answer you kind of seem to know what a dog is you kind of seem to know where rabbit but you didn't give the best answer by this test criterion because it's a functional description of these things not a abstract conceptual one so let's think about different societies besides the Western industrialized one you know that we represent mostly in Liberia they ask people to sort baskets of food tools containers and clothing so most of us you know Western educated in a very broad sense would you know put the things of food together the things of tools together those are the abstract categories the people from this tribe put them in terms of functional pairings they put the potato next to the knife they used to peel the potato right and here's the fun thing in this study they said what would a fool do with this and they said oh well a fool would put

**[20:49]:** all the food things together and all the utensils together but that's pointless to do that because you know what are you to do all the food things over here when the utensils are over here do you understand okay it's what our society emphasizes as a useful way of thinking right so you could it's not completely arbitrary but it's not arbitrarily rewarded and prized in the world of Education that we live in here so intelligence tests attach value to at a specific time and specific test scores are changing over time different cultures are valuing different things it's constantly

**[21:29]:** renormalize it used to be for some number of years that 70 was used as the cutoff for estimates of broadly speaking mental retardation and why that matters is that a person for example would get certain kinds of medical services provided to them when a new version of the Wisc of the Wechsler test came out in 1991 so a

**[21:56]:** renormalize used that new test when it came out which they didn't quite but if they had the number of people rated as diagnosed as would have doubled in a single day because the renown the norms aren't pushing the numbers up okay so that the number of people call it you know scoring very poorly would have doubled in a single day because of the renormalize idea this is very important to realize that all these things what's really in the test was valued by a sort of society or culture and this norming things are really influencing a lot of how you get to these numbers so ideas about intelligence roughly in the in this field have come out of what are called psychometric analysis of subjects they give you this scatter of tests and the thing that struck many people is how for a given individual there's correlations among the tests a person who does one well

**[22:50]:** in one test tends to do well in another test and tends to do well on a third test and a researcher named Spearman gave this this correlation among tests the letter G the name G to Stanford general intelligence and asked for specific intelligence and then since then many people have said well really is there one broad sense of intelligence are there multiple separate kinds of intelligence and people debate that in the field and probably the some one that the answer is it depends what you're measuring for and the purpose of the measurement but in a good one to look at because it's very clear as a difference between fluid and crystallized intelligence so fluid intelligence is what we think of as novel problem-solving you have a situation you were never in before what do you do Christoph's intelligence are you know information you know so here's the conceptual idea that maybe general intelligence is you

**[23:44]:** know a thing and then it shows up on different tests with a different specific intelligences like maybe verbal or arithmetic so let me show the fluid and crystallized one so again fluid is processes so the fluid one we said we're first mental processes that are applied for novel situation and that declines a lot with age and adulthood so these lines going down here you know I'm about here and you're about here who should be grading who in this course you might ask okay all right the only reason the only reason that I get to grade you is because these lines keep going up here this is how many facts you know all right so the plus of living longer is that you get to know more stuff the risk of living longer is you don't use it as flexibly under novel situations all right so pretty strong this distinction at least with ageing between fluid

**[24:35]:** and soaked a fluid intelligent crystallized intelligence there's another study of exactly the same thing it's a striking ski slope of decline in fluid intelligence look at this all right from about 20 to 80 it just goes down relentlessly but when it comes to crystallized intelligence things like vocabulary that kind of hangs in there a puzzle you have some big health problem so at least those two kinds of seem to have a different basis and people have thought about different ways to think about intelligence and I'll just tell you that you can generally get positive correlations among the tests and so often people think about this general intelligence the correlation among the tests is a best single predictor okay now there's lots of responses to ideas about intelligence one of them is study of emotional intelligence Peter salivate is the researcher most involved in that you know and we know this in everyday life right we

**[25:31]:** know smart people what we might call book smart people who you know make who seem unwise and how they relate to people right how they perceive emotions how they facilitate with thought with emotion how they understand or manage their emotions how they relate to other people and so you know it's common sense to think that as something that varies across people it's very hard to measure that I mean part of the tyranny of tests is what can be measured gets measured what's hard to measure is hard to measure right it's very hard to measure in a laboratory in an hour a person's emotional intelligence people have tried it's just hard to do here's another area that's gotten a lot of attention from Howard Gardner at Harvard kind of fighting back against this idea of a single form of intelligence as captured by GE the idea of multiple intelligences and looking at things that dissociations in

**[26:23]:** patience development that you know we can talk about linguistic intelligence spatial intelligence music intelligence bodily intelligence at great athletes have great bodily intelligence intra personal or interpersonal it's kind of like emotional existential okay so he said there's all these different kinds of intelligence and you can each person is a profile of these you know you can be really strong in one a medium and another and not so strong in another the problem with this hall approach is yes it's true that people have a huge variety of facets of their humanity this whole course I feel like every lecture we do is we just turn a person a little bit to study another facet of their humanity right but it's hard as heck to measure you know interpersonal intelligence or naturalistic intelligence now maybe somebody will figure out how to do that it's just hard to measure those things even if it feels like something conceptually

**[27:11]:** that's there and so it's been hard so this idea which has had a lot of resonance to people not liking very simple-minded ideas of intelligence very unitary ones it's to still not gain much traction in practical use so let me talk a bit about some of the things that people said well if we talk about this intelligence what might be some mental mechanisms or neural mechanisms that support or underlie a so some things that go with it our mental speed and you know this right kind of quickness of thought okay not even big thoughts just quickness it feels like it helps a person solve problems so for example is a moderately high correlation between IQ complicated tests of all those tests and how quickly you push a button when the light comes on now we never say wow you know Sally or Fred is really smart they can push a button when the light comes

**[28:01]:** on really fast you know let's go to them and get the answers for the problem set okay because I'm you know it doesn't seem but that would go with the idea that simply being fast is kind of a useful thing for for acting on the world or how quickly people decide whether two lights two lines are the same length or different lengths very simple thing just speed and another idea is working memory capacity how much information you can hold in your head at any one time that's relevant to the problem or task in front of you so people try to explore these in certain ways I'm going to talk to you about a couple of brain studies that have tried to look at this so again we talked last time about frontal cortex different parts of it and especially the dorsal lateral prefrontal cortex is involved in thinking and so people have taken tasks and

**[28:47]:** said you know what happens when you think about them so here's one of easy item on the so-called cattell culture fair test so you know which of these things goes into here there's harder once okay so you you can okay or here's a sulli slightly adaptive version of the Ravens progressive matrices all you think about that for a moment I don't remember which is so you're told here's some rows and columns one of these eight answers logically fits in here and it's your job to figure out which one let's see how do we like three I like three two yeah is that threesome okay okay all right okay and they they get this is a medium hard item on this kind of a test and then they do these kind of map of results and they say this is the what's fun about the Ravens that's the item you just saw which is they they

**[29:42]:** sort of look at lots of other tests so specifically spatial tests specifically verbal tests specifically math tests and they said if we have to give you one test only one test only what test would best predict your performance on all the other tests and the answer is Ravens or IQ tests like that so of course if I give you a math test that better predicts your math performance if I give you a verbal test that better predicts your verbal performance if I give you a spatial test that better predicts your special performance but if I want to give you one test that gives me the best prediction of your performance and other tests it's things like these IQ tests that do that and that's that's just empirical that's not an argument about values or what intelligence is it's a lot of the people who work in this field they don't even care about these arguments

**[30:30]:** they just say I just want to test that predicts ok it's your job if you wanted to figure out why it is it's the genes environment education whatever I just want to test that predicts so from that perspective these tests are have a strong history and what turns on the brain when you solve this kind of a task well frontal cortex a lot parietal cortex but especially frontal cortex so it goes with our idea that thinking is very much tied to prefrontal cortical function here's another example of a study that said let's compare what happens in the brain when you have tests items that are hard which is the outlier one here they require a lot of G where items that are easy they require very little G we'll compare in the brain you know what happens when you turn on your G so to speak and again the prominent areas tend to be for

**[31:19]:** both spatial and verbal prefrontal cortex one more so n-back task we use that a lot where you job is letters come on and in this one the one back you say when do I see a letter that's the same letter as the one before so for exact sort so you see our rmx this is two back because an M occur two items ago three backs are really hard because the letter is going boom boom boom boom and what's hard about it is the letter in front of you you have to say does it match the one I saw three letters previously press remember that because it's going to be the target for the one that comes three after does this it's hard okay I can tell you it's hard you can be smart it's pretty hard and for this task in general the harder it gets the more you turn on dorsal lateral prefrontal cortex

**[32:05]:** and so they do this task with students in Washington st. Louis related it to performance on the Ravens and sure enough in the brain it's again prefrontal cortex alright so a bunch of studies has found all these tests you know involve a fair bit of the brain but they seem to really draw upon the capacities that you and I have in prefrontal cortex and one more note in brain imaging when we talk about things sometimes it's better to more activation and sometimes less activation and you have to know the behavior to know that so whenever you see somebody saying oh this person this group or whatever had more brain activity or less brain activity you don't know until you know the rest of the behavior whether more is good or bad sometimes when people get really good at something they use less of their brain because they can do it so efficiently okay so here's an example of people with lower and higher IQ doing an

**[32:57]:** end back task and you can see that the people with lower IQ have much more activation in the people at higher IQ so it's as if these people have to use all their brain resources to accomplish this and these people only have to use some it's as if it were that so you know here comes the you know when the classic topics of the fate of a human how much does your genes at birth and how much is the environment that you're in and if you were really to understand that in a deep deep scientific way we would know the genes that are related to intelligence the experiential factors in the world family education emotional support and so on how they interact all those things we know practically nothing about I'll show you one tiny example we know practically nothing about them in any depth at all so we mostly end up using twin studies

**[33:46]:** to make the best estimates we can because we which doesn't tell you what the factors are it just tells you how much is a twin who's identical more or less alike than a twin who's fraternal okay we'll come back to that but I do want to tell you a sort of exciting direction that's slightly getting at the genetic story of this so you may know many of you more than I do about genetics but single nucleotide polymorphisms our DNA variations these occur relatively commonly they're estimated to make up about 90% of human genetic variation and they're constant from generation to generation so people have studied a few of these variations among people and related them to performance so let me remind you of something from last lecture the Wisconsin card sorting task where you sort of these cards mysteriously and we said that if you have a frontal lesion you do poorly on this tasks

**[34:39]:** you get stuck with one kind of problem-solving or have it answer even when it's wrong in a new circumstance so what people have done is look at one particular gene that's related to this enzyme that modulates dopamine function in the prefrontal cortex so it's a risk factor for schizophrenia it metabolizes dopamine in prefrontal cortex it's a-you know we vary whether were which version of this gene we have and here's the performance on the card sorting task let me pick these these are healthy people if you have this version of the gene or this pairing or this pairing here's your card sorting task going up so this is kind of amazing that we're close to that where a single gene variant now the score doesn't go up a lot it accounts a small percent of the variance but it's one gene having an identifiable correlation with performance on a demanding task and you can do this

**[35:38]:** end back kind of task we just talked about and then you can look in the brain as people are performing this divided by which version of this gene they have and what you get is more activation in the people with with this compliment than this compliment sort of consistent with the idea other working harder there's the same group of people who are performing less well in the card sorting tasks so there are some genes that have been in a fight that are associated with what we call met called broadly intelligence but that one gene only counts for a tiny bit of the overall score on these kinds of things and we don't know much more about it than that so how do people even begin to think about nature and nurture and you know I like to think about this in two ways one way is narrowly IQ tests because there's been so much work

**[36:23]:** in that area but it's you know it's a deep question of how do we get to be who we are so again they mostly look at twin studies so-called behavioral genetics and estimated heritability how much of variation is due to genetics I'll come back to this height thing but to give you a sense height is thought to be 90% heritable in the US okay tall parents on average have love taller kids less tall parents less Hopkins and in twin studies they contrast monozygotic twins twins that are identical or have the same genes with dizygotic ones who share some genes but not nearly as many of course they share the same environment a lot have you guys seen the two twins talking to each other video on YouTube so that's all if you haven't seen it it's kind of fun the two twins are babbling but they're so demonstrative it's as if they were talking to

**[37:12]:** each other in babble right it's kind of fun if you haven't seen it's very cute okay all right anyway and this is you know the here's again is that the the the fraternal twins and here's the identical twins before they're born so here are this has been studied a fair bit here's the correlations between IQ scores and people of varying relations so let's just work down on that list unrelated persons reared together so perhaps an adopted person and his or her sibling or something they're correlated of about what point two okay foster parent and child it goes up a little bit parent and child living together so that's a biological parent a child living together that goes up a fair bit brother and sister reared apart back down brother and sister we're together so you could look at this as brother you know kind of shared genes right and that this might be something like

**[38:02]:** environment that makes sense intuitively okay that's assuming there's no interaction between genes and environment which we know must happen so when I do this I'm treating them as if they were additive and independent everything we know about genes and the environments are tremendously interactive okay we just don't have insight into that in any deep way in humans here's a really stunning one identical twins reared apart seventy point seven correlation identical twins reared apart that suggests a huge influence of genes identical twin ones we were together 90.9 okay so these this is the finding that stunned people so look at identical twins reared apart they're they're much more like each other than a brother and a sister we're together who share all the same environment of Education parental support and other things so you know I'm going to come back to this but as best people can estimate and these are you know these might be

**[39:00]:** radically replaced as we deepen our understanding of the actual genes and the actual environmental factors but people are estimating it's about half and half for IQ tests and we discussed the bit of arbitrariness in that so about half and a half let me show you a couple of environmental influences that have been identified and you know the first two months of specs has to do with on average with something about the healthiness of the environment the child is born into the third one is kind of fun just to talk about because you may wonder if you have a sibling or no sibling you know what does it mean that you were first born or second born or third born okay at least statistically okay so let's do the first two here's breastfeeding 3,000 people were followed from birth to young adulthood breastfeeding for at least six months correlate with a five to seven point IQ

**[39:49]:** game so we said 15 points really seems to mean something in educational outcomes the five to seven is you know half of that so that's something right so let's talk about for a minute you could say and I can tell you the as a parent who fairly recently uh had children you know all the mothers in the u.s. that I know of are going like I've got a breast feed and get that my kid to MIT Oh two more months of breastfeeding and this kid could go all the way to tenured faculty right all right so so I could tell you there's a lot of pressure on mothers if you don't know this not my mother I mean that but now mother's here you know do this for your kid do this for your kid do this for your kid all right because of results like these so one possibility is there something in breast milk that would be the direct mechanism that's making kids smarter give me another possibility that has nothing to do with

**[40:38]:** the breast milk yeah

**[40:43]:** it could be more nurturing sir children in many ways they could be mothers who can stay home and spend some time with the children versus being under very pressured economic circumstances that prohibit that right it could be a lot of things that seem does that make sense okay we don't know nobody has shown yet that it's the breast milk that goes into your brain and pushes up your brain okay in any sense it's just a correlation and of course if you're a parent you're going to say I'm not going to I'll take my I'll do the breastfeeding and let the scientist figure out in the future right alright here's another one there's the birth weight so again you could say the same thing I mean certainly you know having very low birth weight is a big risk factor for lots of things but at birth weight again goes with many factors in the environment that

**[41:24]:** are supportive for a healthy pregnancy versus not okay so it doesn't mean it is the birth weight it could be all the other things that were in the environment you know during the pregnancy at birth and continue on average in the environment of that child throughout their childhood and young educators that make sense okay if they're born in a very unsupportive medical environment they might have a low birth weight and unless our parents win the lottery or something they're likely to be in a difficult environment for all their educational years to come so people have tried to make clearer because it's so easy to get into sort of little mental traps on genes versus environments how genetic diversity affects heritability so there's a couple different ways to do it let's do this one so imagine you had cloned tomato plants that means they all have the exact same genes in this hypothetical example but somebody

**[42:14]:** has poor soil somebody has good soil well you get big differences and the heritability will be zero right environment can have huge influences but if you have genetically diverse plants you know then you're going to have an interaction so some plants will do okay even in poor soil some plants will do you know most spectacularly in good soil and less spectacular like environment by genes interactions and you can see that's in so many different ways so here's one example so we said height is 90% heritable within a society but Japanese men in the u.s. of people with Japanese extract our three inches taller than people in Japan okay so they still have weight whatever with Japanese genes are they have Japanese genes but in the u.s. getting the u.s. diet of McDonald's and that's pushing them up your 3 inches okay so so what do we mean by her so it just really know what do we fight is heritable but environment is a big part of the story

**[43:06]:** okay so it's just both I mean now here's a fun study and a reason that if you're a younger sibling I and you desperately want to IQ points you might knock off your older sibling all right I don't recommend this this is tongue-in-cheek all right but but it's a kind of a fun study just thinking about birth order more in a fun way well look at the whole thing we're talking about from 99 to 104 so it's five points we're talking about but whether it but in some countries they sort of test everybody going into the military and this was done and I think this is it on Denmark right and what they said is here's first person here's here's somebody who had these who are all children these are the IQ scores and this is the IQ scores if you if it you're that you would have but what happens if your older sibling

**[43:51]:** has passed away sadly you get those points and here's a here's a person who's older sibling and older sibling passed away and they move up those points that is if you're a younger sibling you have a few lower IQ points okay it's an average but kind of strikingly if your older sibling passes away sadly you seem to get those IQ points as you move up the birth order yeah yes yeah when you're young yeah it's too late sorry for all of you in here you know too late okay all right it's only a couple of points also but this guy did science because people are always wondering about there's an infused curiosity that birth order you know consequences so here's a person these are at least uh anyway okay so um but let's talk about a little bit about that birth order again because there's a second

**[44:45]:** really interesting point so uh here's Ravens score and here's if you if you're a lone child one of two that second of two children the third of three the fourth of four the eighth of eight the ninth of ninth you can see this course keep going down it's not dramatic but larger families and you can have a million ideas about why that would be alright about why it is larger your family and if the further you're down on the list you lose a few I quit you point for every sibling who's older okay so here's one idea from Robert science it was a very creative psychologist we're not sure that it's right but I think it's really fun to think about yeah so here here was this idea he said I'm going to make up an idea which is this the firstborn maybe's exposed only to adults the adults are talking to them about you

**[45:30]:** know the news of the day and all kinds of things the second-born has two adults let's say in a typical family but also has an older sibling right so the intellectual environment will be the average of two adults and a little child the next one and so on so he said you can do a kind of a formula which is like this pretend the two parents are each 30 and you're born will call your family intellectual stimulating environment 30 because we'll add up the ages and divide by the number of people in the family that make sense this is this is not meant to be a real formula okay it's just a conceptual playing out and then he said okay now you have the two parents and you have four-year-old sibling because you're the second born so now it's four of you we divide by four we'll say the average intellectual thing in the family

**[46:16]:** sixteen by the time the next child comes along a seven-year-old sibling three-year-old sibling divided by five and the average intellectual environment is fourteen here's the idea on average it's better for a child to have lots of interaction with a parent than with a little kid because a parent will stimulate more than a little kid a little sibling might be a lot of fun okay but in purely IQ land parent two parents talking to you about stuff is a more educational environment and two parents plus a sibling who's two years older than you because the two-year-old can't help no matter how smart he or she is they can't talk with you like an adult this is the thought and now here's the really fun observation and again we don't really know this is exactly right but but you know every year if you're around issues of Education there's test scores that different states have and in

**[47:11]:** this test test scores go up and you took you have taken high-stakes tests right in high schools and grade schools and stuff okay if the test scores goes up everybody goes oh you know reelect us we're awesome administration our test scores are going up we're doing everything right right if the test scores go down they go Oh throw the bubbles out of the administration their kids are watching too much MTV turn off that computer and so on right everybody gets a test scores and they figure out you know who's good and who's bad right you know parents teachers school systems politicians whatever science says and this is kind of an interesting thought he says no he can predict whether it's scores will go up or down simply by on average in a given year whether you there are more first Born's or second borns or third borns that if he just takes that population average

**[47:58]:** of every kid the moment they're born he can predict years later where the scores go and so here's the here's the scores in Iowa of the actual scores are going up and down so you can imagine scores are going down everybody's really upset about you know kids who don't study and teachers who don't teach and parents who don't parent write scores are going off and the kids are awesome the teachers are awesome the parents are awesome because that's who gets the credit right and he's saying ah this is my prediction here they simply on the number you know for a given birth year the average number of older children in your family okay that's it I'll look how well that tracks it's unbelievable right so it just makes you rethink that's so often when we get information about Society of what's going on this may or not be right or this may be right or

**[48:49]:** wrong but we don't really know what's going on you know there's all kinds of huge things out there in the world that aren't the easiest things to blame or give credit to right okay so there there's smart little small differences but they seem to track interestingly in the number of siblings you have who are older than you and at the same time this idea of parental exposure to language you know there's this Wiley study why decided study from Hart and Risley so they recorded for each month for two and a half years heroic recording one full hour of every word spoken at home between parents and children and 42 just 42 families but they categorize them as high medium or low socioeconomically so in terms of income and education okay and they're recording lots and lots of conversations verbatim and they code and analyze every utterance in thirteen hundred transcripts of thirty thousand pages all

**[49:44]:** right this is what the reason why this has not done a lot it's not very glamorous work to do alright you can imagine sitting down there but they're coding they recording lots of conversations at home and families who are better off medium off or poor and they're looking at what is the conversation like for an hour a day and here's what they find that variation in children's IQ and language abilities related to the amount of the appearance speak to their children and the academic success by age eight or nine or ten is related a lot to speech at zero to three now again you think causally because you think parents are talking to you at zero at 3:00 at nine and ten you're doing differential equations causally know the parents are talking to you a lot zero to three are talking to you at four or five and six a lot most of the time

**[50:30]:** okay so these things are not like you get an injection you're done many of the factors that we can measure continue on average for most people in their environment but it's very impressive how the environment altogether influences things by age three that cumulative act vocabulary is 1100 words in a professional family and a child was a child 750 in a working class and 500 and a welfare family and welfare families 600 words per hour working class 750 professionals 2153 by HD the vocabulary used by children and high SES homes is larger than the vocabularies by parents in the low SES by h3 larger vocabulary this is just telling you the incredible cumulative power of strong environmental influences because it's unbelievably multiplicative it's every day all day long if you're in an environment that's supportive or an environment that's not okay every it's not one shot it's every day multiply multiply multiply a 300 words more

**[51:33]:** per hour for professional no Offerman's extrapolate a year a child and professional family here's 11 million words versus 3 million a welfare family and strong correlation with IQ scores by age 9 so very huge differences in what children are exposed to at home and they correlate highly with disease things so there's an inch so the literature is that on average on average the IQ scores that children have around nine or ten correlate pretty well with ones that have for the rest of their lives before that it's extremely jumps around we don't know why but that's that's just a finding that time you're nine or ten whatever you have on average tends to hang in there you know if you're 100 at ten you'll tend to be 120 120 at ten you'll tend to be 120 or 20 so that makes sense okay you roughly so there's been a lot of interest in evidence about whether

**[52:23]:** you can change your IQ as an adult so here's one study that got a lot of attention because it was kind of interesting in that way so they they did it they did a complicated task like this where is this n-back task the simultaneous you hear letters and you see little spatial locations like this and every time something matched two items ago you would push a button so you're hearing them at the same time and if you hear a letter that was two letters ago you push a button or same spatial location you push one it's pretty hard they took 34 adults they trained them from 8 to 19 day so less than a month skipped weekends 25 minutes a day so only half an hour day to train on this and then they tested them on some of these widely used IQ types of measures here's a performance on the task itself getting better

**[53:10]:** and better okay that's not surprising and the more they practice the higher they got so if you practice really hard at something you get better at doing it that's that's not the thing they were interested where they were interested in this here's the IQ scores before they were trained the IQ scores they didn't practice the IQ test and here's the IQ ones afterwards this is the control group who did nothing this is a group that the de mental practice and you can see they pushed up their IQ scores not a lot but it was only 20 minutes a day for you know less than a month so these are these kinds of studies really intrigued people in two ways and the more training you got the more your IQ score went up more weeks you do this because a you know maybe we could push up IQ scores if that's important to push up this

**[53:50]:** is a big decision even when you're an adult you know what if you did more than 20 minutes a day for three weeks and B you know maybe we could push up everybody's IQ score who needed help in that with the right kind of training No at any age so a lot of interest in that so let me let me take a step now to sort of harder topics now one of the reasons that intelligence and IQ topics have gotten appropriately lots of concern is there's a terrible history of racism and sexism associated with IQ tests and the way people use that to argue basically inferiority of groups other than themselves so the US Immigration Act of 1924 the official government talked about biologically weak stocks at that time they were prejudiced against their focus their prejudice against Italians and Jews from Europe okay different societies different times as you know tragically have biases against

**[54:45]:** different groups in the world they're just unfortunately it's part of the world we live in you know and even though we know now with certainty that we're all almost identical genetically in any practical sense across racial groups race remains a powerful social category right it's very complicated topic you know the experience you've had as experience you've had but we know it's it's it's a it's a social category people identify to a certain extent with with that they recognize other people in that context we'll come back to that later in the course but it's a sort of a fact of life that we often think of ourselves as belonging to one racial group or another and somebody else's belonging to one racial group or another so I'm going to focus on one thing that's both trouble people and litsa to bad things but but has some interesting important aspects to think about so in the u.s.

**[55:35]:** when people compare African American and European American scores there's a gap scores that grows over time so an infancy to the extent you can test these kinds of things there's no difference by age four on average people who are European American will tend to score about four or five points higher in IQ tests and as the age goes up it continues to go up there's a gap on average the huge averages across many people so we're you know that across time as people get older in the US now we strongly believe for many many reasons empirically that this is an environmental influence and here's one example of many pieces of evidence so that children fathered for example but black American GIs and Germany brought up by German mothers have exactly the same IQs as white American GIs children and German mother said is in countries where stereotypes were not applied in general because partly because

**[56:30]:** it wasn't a history of for African Americans of Germany at that time the IQ scores are the same so we think it's you know overwhelmingly evident that it's an environmental effect but in the u.s. you know there's a lot of relationship between on average across the entire country on average between what group you're in and average income so here's the average income a few years ago depending on which group you identified yourself as belonging to so we talked earlier about the relationship between economic comfort or stability or support and things like the number of words a parent can speak to or it's time to speak to their child and how that seems to correlate with all kinds of advantages so here's an incredibly powerful and important idea Claude Steele is a researcher at Stanford who on you whose play a big part in this and here's the idea so it's called

**[57:21]:** stereotype threat it applies to all of us but but in some ways depending on the world we live in you know some of us can be more vulnerable than others in certain situations here's the idea so let me tell you the experiment and then the interpretation the experiment is that he'll bring people in and give Claude or students black and white participants college students and they say it's a laboratory experiment and they give them something like an SAT test and the group's perform just the same okay Stanford students black and white perform just the same that's the one group here comes the next group of black and white students who are told we're going to give you a test of intelligence now look what happens the scores of African Americans go down and it doesn't even have to be the phrase test of intelligence you can have people just tick off on a front page

**[58:09]:** what racial group they belong to and you get almost the same effect so what is this this is understood as stereotype vulnerability that is tragically in the u.s. there's a stereotype that African Americans are not as good academically as white Americans it's a pernicious stereotype is when we can decry more aliens it's a bad thing but it's out there there's another area where African Americans are thought of as phenomenal by stereotype which is sports in this country it's a weird thing right okay most of us you know so but it seemed but now the idea is that knowledge of these things even if you this is your real performance once that thought enters your mind that I'm doing something that some people say I'm not going to do such a good job down is enough to make you underperform compared to your true potential so the other area where this has been studied a lot it are as women in mathematics I think that's disappearing when I grew up everybody was worried that women weren't given as good an academic support as men or

**[59:18]:** girls and boys okay it's reversed okay in my lifetime it's reversed because now by every criteria women are outperforming men in the u.s. by every criteria but they societally the number who finished school you're beginning salaries everything okay so now they're worried that us boys are really being left behind okay so it's these things change because they're cultural inventions okay they're cultural inventions and cultural mores change and sometimes in good ways hopefully so stereotypes right is that that that others judgments are one's own actions will confirm negative stereotypes of one's group oh York's you should do badly on something we should do well on something so they studied on women that old people you know almost like athletic ability of course once the opposites the experiment was kind of fun they had a very athletic african-american instructor come up and start doing push-ups and all the white guys started - laps in their push-ups they got tired really fast compared to of an equally athletic white trainer came up to the front does that make sense okay good does

**[1:00:19]:** that make sense okay it's whatever whatever is the stereotype you have in your head you know if you say okay oh I'm not supposed to do good in this you underperform not everybody all the time of course but enough that we should we have to be concerned about that you know more for academic performance probably than push-ups but who knows all right so here's this achievement gap and here so here you know there's different scores between again at age between whites and blacks in the United States which we know shouldn't be there many factors are in it a huge variation among people of course he's a huge averages but one that you know everybody wants to get rid of in a just society where everybody has an equal opportunity so here's something unbelievable result it's so unbelievable that if it weren't for some subsequent results I wouldn't even show it to you even though it's

**[1:01:08]:** well done experiment but the message of it seems so incredible ok so here's what they did in this wealth control studying science and there's been some follow-ups that have exactly done this so they took on African American students and white students and they had them you know take these various tests but some of them at the beginning of the year wrote an affirmation they had they had to choose a value from a list and write an in-class essay about why the chosen value is important to you the controls chose a value from the same list and we're an essay about why the value might be important for somebody else you're writing a one time essay about why something matters to you or matters to somebody else so obviously what matters to you is more powerful for you right and by just doing that there's a 40% reduction in the African American students in the study

**[1:01:54]:** and their achievement grab their scores went up 40% because they wrote one essay at the beginning of the year about why values are important to them and related to education one essay did that okay unbelievable and just a reminder about how much one's attitude incredibly influences your performance you have a range of things you can do and what gets you to the top of your range that's in you or the bottom of your range has a lot to do with attitudes that can be moved around by a lot of things one essay overcame a tremendous amount of the concerns that on average African American students have about academic achievement and it's not just that so I'm you know in this course you only get a couple of tips of things that are useful to you for courses here's one okay it's the same principle but it seems to apply for everybody especially okay so here's

**[1:02:45]:** the experiment also published in science is really cool so I'm they brought in the brought in students and they said look look students often are worried about how they're going to do in a test especially if it's an area you think you're not so good in okay so they had to take a test on Gauss's modular arithmetic here's the pretest everybody did about the same then they said okay now they have to create pressure because of course if you take a test in an experiment that's not pressure right pressure is the grade you're going to get whether it lets you into medical school whether you get to become the head of the American Medical Association right okay that's pressure right all right so they say oh here's what we're going to do now we're going to give you another test everybody's scoring about the same but you can make a fair bit of money with

**[1:03:28]:** a partner who's down the hall we should tell you that partner has already done a really good job on the second version of the test so if you don't do well you don't get money and the partner down the hall doesn't get your money okay if you do well on the second test you're about to take now then everybody wins so they're trying to make you feel pressured oh man I want to win the money plus there's a guy down the hall who already did well and I'm gonna let it let us down right they're trying to make you feel as pressured as you might as much as they can in an experiment like you do in a regular test in a regular course alright so trying to create pressure and anxiety okay and then for 10 minutes the controls just sit there and think about it oh I hope you know I don't mess

**[1:04:03]:** up now the pressures on I don't meet the person if I don't do a good job down the hall all right okay an expressive group wrote an essay for ten minutes about their thoughts and feelings I wrote this back and this is a huge mistake this should be better okay I'll fix it up better better better I did it unrelated in writing so here's what happens the group that just sat there did nothing on their performance does it let me get this right the performance that wrote the expressive writing the score goes up everybody else's scores go down because here the users are beginning now they get pressured and they perform less well right the pressure is you know they're choking okay the group that wrote the essay their performance stays up and it's kind of ironic because there's a theme of comic of comedy it's frequently when they tell you whatever you do don't

**[1:04:59]:** tell somebody X and then by mistake you tell X have you seen that in a comedy show okay all right all right so you could have thought or writing an essay about my thoughts and feelings about how much anxiety and pressure I feel it's like the worst thing you can do it's like I don't want to face it you know I'd rather clear my mind right but it turns out that when people write this little essay about their thoughts and feelings about their anxiety their scores rise and if they don't write that kind of an essay the scores fall because you've introduced here the stress and anxiety that we think is a part of regular testing that makes sense I'll fix the slide I'm sorry about the typo all right okay so I'm a little afraid to give you advice because if somebody will write an essay to bet on the physics test and say

**[1:05:43]:** oh this is terrible I would have got an A but it seems like writing as a little essay about your thoughts and feelings actually pushes scores up I mean that's the scientific evidence but again it's just a reminder of how powerful feelings and attitudes are whether they're in us or visited on us by the world in how well we perform within the range of performance that we eat they're within us to start with I've two more points so we talked a little bit about entity versus growth you know people who believe that like I'm only so good at something I'm only so good at basketball only so good at math I'm only this programming I'm only so good at writing or whatever versus people who say the harder I work the better I'll get and that pretty much this work from Carol Dweck that many people tend to you know go for one thing or

**[1:06:29]:** the other or is it are we born with talents and that's pretty much the deal or the harder we work do we get more talented at doing something and so this is a kind of question there's a literally question so she gives students you have a certain amount of intelligence and you really can't change it you know I strongly agree that's that's this straight model or I disagree the harder I work the more I can smarter I can be so and what she did for example is give that kind of questionnaire to students and then follow them in the performance and a math course here's the ones who believed they could get better here's the ones who said they only have so much math ability and intelligence and look at the ones who thought they could get better it got better so that seems like a really good thing to have is also not only

**[1:07:08]:** the positive attitude but you know a real belief that the harder the work the smarter you'll get um all right last two slides so finally finally finally and we've had a couple of them but almost no a longitudinal random assignment study okay which sound doesn't sound usually exciting but that's the best science we can ever do randomly assign people to things and the follow them over time to understand how life works so one of the famous studies is which is for this Perry preschool so it followed into adulthood 123 children from low SES environments and around in Michigan and they were randomly andum we divided and there's no randomness right in life mostly you're not randomly given genes you're not randomly put into a household it's always the things are super correlated with each other and it's very hard to tease them apart but here they took kids who are from poor families and put

**[1:08:06]:** them randomly into two groups one group is a program group who received high-quality active learning preschool program and home visits to be supportive as well so they got help at home and help it's in preschool and an O program group who didn't get any of these I can tell you that when you do random assignment studies in real life like this some people said some people argue I don't agree this that it's unethical because you should help everybody all the time but if you don't do this you never figure out what helps people's okay so it's a little bit of a circuit you know you know you can't you can't figure out what really helps people okay so anyway and then in a really rare thinks that's random assignment they follow them ages three to eleven fourteen to fifteen nineteen twenty seven and forty okay like they follow you through most of your childhood and

**[1:08:50]:** adult life so what happens here's their IQ scores here's the program people in red at the no program people in blue and you can see that for a few years they separate by IQ but by age seven they're pretty much the same and when these kind of data came out there because now they of course after the preschool they go back to the regular local schools - pretty much the same schools okay so people have said after that they said well the Head Start as a kind of a program to help kids who are poor get a head start in education and support it's no good it doesn't do anything because once they get back into schools that are not very supportive the benefits of the program disappear you didn't do anything for the kid because unless you fix everything in their law is that one year just doesn't make a difference in the long

**[1:09:41]:** run okay so everybody said Head Start programs are just a sad lis a waste of resources because they don't do anything for these children over the longer term but here's the remarkable thing they kept following these kids and here's what they found for example in the number of arrests 36 had had five or more arrests in the program group but in that in the in the but all the way up to 55 for the no program group that's a big difference how often you're arrested that's a big outcome in life right earning 20,000 or more at age 40 program group sixty percent no program rule forty percent completed high school 45 to 65 twenty percent increase in completion of high school from one year of help before kindergarten basic achievement at age fourteen way up homework no willingness to do homework way up okay so so what's that's telling us is you know IQ is

**[1:10:39]:** a pretty interesting thing and we talk a lot about it is an interesting thing but there's something really deep in the ways you can help people that make them you know succeed in life you know not get in trouble avoid bad things make money finish school do your work okay that one year of school change these kids for the rest of their lives and on average you know and imagine if you had done two years or five years you know alright so and IQ in this case doesn't capture it at all there's something else in them that changed that made them more resilient in life and successful in the long run so there's a lot of pieces to who does well not well in ways we wish for everybody and IQs a piece of that story but there's a lot of pieces so thanks very much you

**[1:11:36]:** you
