Transcript

All right. Uh let's get started. Um we have uh 3 weeks left in the class and what we'll be doing for the next 3 weeks is really a series of applications of what we've learned so far uh to sort of help you understand how we add some richness to what we've learned and sort of take it to some more real-world applications. So, we're going to start that today by talking about something we've really ignored in the course so far, which is uncertainty. And how uncertainty affects your decision-making. So, what we've done so far in this class is we've sort of said, "Look, we've assumed whatever you make decisions, you make them with full knowledge and full certainty." But many, many decisions in life are made under conditions of uncertainty.

Okay? So, consider your decision to study for the final in this class. In our model so far you would you could optimize your studying across different units of the class. So, our model so far you'd know on the final which unit would be represented with what proportion and you'd optimize your studying appropriately. But of course you don't know that. You face uncertainty about what will be covered in the final and what proportion. You know the whole course is you're responsible for the whole class, but obviously allocate your time, you're uncertain about how to allocate your time across the different subjects on the test.

So, how do you make that decision? Nothing we need to bring our tools to bear on thinking about these kinds of decision-making under uncertainty uh situations. And this isn't just about the test. You know, I decide whether to bring my umbrella today. Okay, if I bring my umbrella there's a chance I'm going to lose it, but I don't want to get wet. I have to think about whether it's going to rain. It all depends on how certain I am it's going to rain, etc. There's decisions about um you know, uh whether to bet on a sporting event. That's decision uncertainty. And that's all the fun stuff in your life.

When you get to the anxiety-ridden adult life you've got things like whether to buy a 7-year mortgage or a 30-year mortgage, uh whether to buy health insurance, what school to put your kids in. All these things involve a huge amount of uncertainty. And we have not yet developed the tools to deal with this. What's really cool is that economics has a very useful tool to think about exactly these kinds of situations. That much like the other tools we've developed this semester is pretty easy once you understand it, but has a huge amount of power for explaining the world. And that's the tool of EXPECTED UTILITY THEORY.

AND THAT'S WHAT WE'LL FOCUS ON TODAY. That's what we'll learn today, the tool of expected utility theory. Okay. Now, I'm going to ask you a question. As always, I don't want you to try to outsmart me. I just want a quick gut reaction. Okay? I'm going to offer you a bet. Not really, but imagine I was. I'm going to flip a coin. Heads you get $125. Tails you give me $100. So, you win 125 versus lose 100. How many of you take that bet? Okay. So, yeah, you're a slightly more aggressive class than usual. About 40% of you taking the bet. Usually I get more about 20, 25%. Okay? Now, um yeah. Uh no, so one-time bet.

Um okay. So, basically um now, how do we think about this, whether it's a good idea or not? Now, those who raised your hand probably quickly did the math and did in your head what we call an expected value expected value calculation. What's the expected value of any gamble? The expected value of any gamble is the probability that you win times what you win plus the probability that you lose times what you lose. So, you did that calculation in your head. You said as long as he's not cheating and using a fair coin there's a 0.5 * 125 + 0.5 * -100. Okay? And that is an expected value of 12.50. So, those of you who raised your hand probably did that calculation quickly in your head and said, "Yeah, this is a positive expected value.

This is what we call in economics a more than fair bet." More than fair. A fair bet is one with an expected value of zero. So, a fair bet is one with an expected value of zero. So, a bet with a positive expected value is more than fair. And you in your head said, "I did that through. It's It's It's more than fair." Um uh and uh that's why some of you raised your hands, but many of you didn't. And that doesn't mean you were wrong. It just means this is not the right way to think about it. Okay? The right way to think about it is that what you care about is not dollars. What you care about is utility.

Dollars are meaningless. What you care about as a consumer is your utility. And ex- and so we don't want to think about expected value. We want to think about expected utility. Now, what is expected utility? It's the same kind of formula as this, but with one change. Expected utility is the probability that you win times your utility if you win plus the probability that you lose times your utility if you lose. And that is somewhat different than expected value. And the reason is because utility is not a linear weighting of dollars. Utility is a concave weighting of dollars. Okay? As such, because utility is a concave weighting of dollars, it exhibits diminishing marginal rate of diminishing marginal utility or diminishing marginal rate of substitution.

Diminishing marginal rate of substitution as we talked about ad nauseam in consumer theory. Okay? That means that the next dollar is worth less to you than the previous dollar. Okay? The next dollar is worth just like a diminishing utility. The next slice of pizza is worth less to you than the previous slice of pizza. Likewise, the next dollar is worth less to you than the previous dollar. As a result, losing a dollar makes you sadder than winning a dollar makes you happy. There's a non-linearity that comes from diminishing marginal utility diminishing marginal rate of substitution. So, for example, let's think about our typical utility function that we used previously in consumer theory.

Utility equals the square root of consumption. And let's just say you consume all your income as we always did. We've talked about savings the last couple lectures. Let's put savings aside again and just assume people consume all their income. Okay? And so, utility is a square root of consumption. Okay? And let's say you start your initial consumption C0 is 100. You start with $100 of consumption. Okay? Okay, your C0 is 100. So, your initial utility U0 is 10. Now, I give you I offer you this bet. What's the expected utility of this bet? Well, the expected utility of this bet is the probability you win 0.5 times utility if you win.

Well, utility if you win is the square root of your consumption if you win. What is your consumption if you win? If you win the bet, what is your consumption? So, raise your hand and tell me. Starting with 100. And I made this bet with you. Yeah. 225. 225. You started with 100 and you won 125. If you lose the bet what do you have? What do you have if you lose the bet? Zero. Okay? So, your expected utility is 0.5 times this utility of what what you get if you win times plus 0.5 times utility what if you lose. Now, if you do that math you will find that that is 7.5. Your expected utility of this bet is 7.5.

Which is less than your initial utility. So, you should not take the bet. Which is through the mechanism of psychology why many of you didn't. Okay? You should not take the bet. Okay? And the reason is because you are what we call risk and humans are what we call risk averse. That we that risk is inherently negative value to us. That a doll- a certain dollar is worth much more to us than an uncertain dollar. Just like a dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow. A certain dollar is worth much more than an uncertain dollar. To see why the best way to see intuition here is graphical. So, let's go to figure 20-1.

And just sort of slowly walk through this. It's a little confusing graph. On the x-axis is your wealth, your total consumption or money you have. You consume everything you have. So, it's wealth or alternatively consumption. On the y-axis of figure 20-1 is your utility. It's a graph of how much you consume against your utility. And as you can see, this is a concave graph. It is it's exhibiting diminishing marginal utility. Okay? Each dollar each dollar of wealth adds utility, but less and less over time. Just like each slice of pizza makes you happier, but less and less over time. Okay? You get that so the shape of this curve is true for any utility function that features diminishing marginal utility.

That's pretty much any utility function we have used this semester. Except we're trying to trick you. Okay? Has diminishing marginal utility. So as a result it has this shape. Okay? Now, with a utility function of this shape, let's evaluate the gamble I just gave you. You start with wealth of 100. So you see in the x-axis the 100 point. That corresponds to utility of 10. Right? So you can trace up that 100 to utility curve and then you go over to the y-axis. So that corresponds to utility of 10. Okay? Now, think about what the gamble does. What the gamble does is say, "Look, there's two possible outcomes with 50% chance each.

One is wealth of 225. That is the point all the way to the right. That leaves utility of 15. The other is wealth of zero. That's the point all the way to the left. That leaves utility of zero. What is the average of those two? Well, it's just a linear combination. All right? It's a 50% chance of each. So the average of those two is a wealth of 112.5, but an expected utility of 7.5. So you take you you draw a chord between those two points, between the zero point and point B. You find the midpoint of that chord. That's wealth of 112.5, but then you trace that over to utility function. And you see the expected utility is only 7.5.

And that's because it's we're not using a linear combination. We're using a non-linear combination. A non-linear concave combination, which means that moving up in terms of wealth makes you less happy than moving down in terms of wealth makes you sad. And you're really sad at zero. So it's going from 100 down to zero makes you way sadder than going from 100 up to 225 makes you happier. And that's all because diminishing marginal utility of income. So it's natural that this gamble would make you worse off, even though it's more than fair. Because yeah, you're somewhat happier if you win. If you win, utility goes up from 10 to 15.

That's great. But if you lose, utility goes down from 10 to zero. That's really bad. So you don't want to take this risk. Okay? Which is why, although you may not realize it, many of you uh wouldn't want to take that that gamble. So using this graph we can ask Okay, there questions about that? Yeah. So would we take the bet if the our gaining utility outweighs our loss utility or would we not take the bet if our loss utility Well, um you you've answered you that's it's the same the answers to the question are the same. It just depends on the probabilities. If the probabilities are 0.5 each, then those two answers two questions are exactly the same.

Because 0.5 each would be gain outweighing loss is the same as on net positive. But if the probabilities aren't 0.5, you want to use this equation. So you basically want to say is the weighted it's about the weighted average change in utility essentially, where the weights are these probabilities. Yeah. Is there any utility calculation in actually gambling? Like can someone dislike gambling Hold on. I'm going to come to that. We're going to come back to gambling. We talk all about the lottery at the end. Okay? So um Okay, but do people understand the basics of this graph? Okay. So using this graph, tell me the following.

How much Answer the following um answer the following question. Okay? Um How much Let's say This is a hard question. See if you can get this. Let's say that I said, "You know what, class? I'm going to force you to take this gamble. I'm going to come in here and I'm going to tell you I'm locking the door. You're not leaving without taking this gamble unless you pay me not to force you." So I'm going to offer you a more than fair bet. Would you be willing to pay me to get out of that bet? And how much would you be willing to pay me? Yeah. Would you be willing to pay you uh up to $2.50? Up to $2.50?

Your actual utility if you take the bet is expected utility if you take the bet. $2.50? I don't understand. Uh Well, okay. That's you you're You have $100 to start, right? Yeah, you have $100 to start. $25. Uh Okay, you're you're thinking about sort of right, but you're still thinking in a linear world, not a non-linear world. Look at the graph. Okay, yeah. Would it be $43.75? It would exactly $43.75. Why? Uh because right now the bet essentially gives me the utility of $56.25. Right. So your answer in the front was exactly right in a linear world. But in a non-linear world, you've got to account for the for the curvature.

So the way you think about it is right now your utility from that bet, if I force you to take it, it leaves you utility of $56.25. Okay? You can see that just go backwards from the 7.5 utility down to what level of wealth that's equivalent. What that means is you would rather pay me $43.74 than take that bet. Think about how crazy that is for 1 second. I'm offering you a bet that is more than fair and you will pay me almost half of your entire wealth to avoid taking that bet. And that's only with our standard utility function we always used. That's risk aversion. And the reason is because zero sucks so badly.

Okay? The reason is because you're so sad going to zero that you really don't want to be in that situation. And so you will actually pay me $43.75 to avoid a more than fair bet. That's what's crazy. Okay? So another way to see this, let me ask you another question. How large Let's say I offer you the same bet. Flip a coin. Tails you lose 100, heads you win X. How large would X have to be for you to take the bet? Tails you lose 100, heads you win X. Yeah. $300. 300? Why? Because then your expected utility is 10. Right, exactly. If it's 300, then I'm doing the square root of 400, which is 20, and the square root of zero.

You average those and you're going to get expected utility of 10. So for you to take that bet, I would have to say tails you lose 100, heads you win 300. I'd need to give you like a monstrously more than fair bet. And that is due to the principle of risk aversion. That basically because of diminishing marginal utility Risk aversion is something like made up. It's not some crazy concept. It just falls naturally out of diminishing marginal utility. Because making you sad um because losing because moving down makes you sadder than moving up makes you happier. Okay? Any question about that? Yeah. Uh I guess the next question is then like Right.

Okay, stop there. Let's go to the next section. Guys are way ahead of me as always. Let's go Let's talk about a couple extensions. Let's talk about a couple extensions. First extension. Change utility function. Okay? Suppose your utility function was of the form U = 0.1 * C. Now I've chose this particular form because the initial conditions are the same. With C0 of 100, U0 is still 10. So I'm starting from the same point as I was before. But now, would you take the bet and why? If that's utility function, would you take the bet and why? Just do the math. Do the math. What's your expected utility of that bet?

Your expected utility is 0.5 times your utility of 225. So it's times 0.1 times 225 plus 0.5 times your utility of of zero. So it's 0.1 times zero. Okay? And if you write that out and solve it, you get 11.25, which is greater than 10. So you would take the bet. Does anyone Any question about the math? I just did the expected utility evaluation. So you would take the bet. What's the difference? Why do you take the bet here? Yeah. Yeah, let me get Yeah, go ahead. This is a linear utility function, so If you're a linear utility function, what you care about is expected value. So you can see that Do I have that?

Yeah, in figure 22. This is the case we call risk neutrality. With a linear utility function, you're risk neutral. Because the linear utility Your linear utility function does not have what? Does not have diminishing marginal utility. As a result, you're you're just you just care about expected value. Okay? There's there's no difference between expected value and expected utility. It's all just Now, the number's a little bit different cuz the functional form, but it gives the same outcome. You'll always take a more than fair bet. And you reject a less than fair bet. So as people become move from risk averse to risk neutral, or as utility features less and less diminishing marginal utility, they'll be more and more willing to take gambles.

But it doesn't have to stop there. We can go further. Imagine that I wrote utility of the form utility was of the form C squared over 1,000. A weird utility function, but once again created so that if C0 equals 100, U0 equals 10. Now let's do the expected value calculation. Well, if you take the gamble, there's a 0.5 probability that you win. So then you would have utility B would be 225 squared over 1,000 and a 0.5 probability that you lose. So you just get zero. Okay? And the expected utility in that case is 25.3. The expected utility equals 25.3, which is way bigger than 10. So you take this gamble.

Why? Because now you're risk loving. Cuz what does this say about diminishing marginal utility of income? This actually says you have increasing marginal utility of consumption. A utility function like this says the next slice of pizza makes you even happier than the previous slice of pizza. So look at figure 20-3. This is the risk loving case where you actually have increasing marginal utility of consumption. Okay, we don't really talk about this case cuz it sort of doesn't make sense. But just to understand how this works, okay? Same calculations before you start at a point like A. If you win, you go to B.

If you lose, you go to zero. Well, this shape utility function going to B makes you way happier than going to zero makes you sad. So you love the gamble. Okay? In fact, you with this utility function, you would take an unfair bet. Okay? So for example, imagine I change the gamble to one where it's win 100, lose I'm sorry, win 75, lose 100. So I change the gamble now. Win 75, lose 100. I've made it an unfair bet. The expected value is negative. Okay? Well, this person will still take that bet. If you do the math, if if they win 75, they get 175. You do just replace this with 175 and you do the math, okay?

You're going to find that the expected utility in that case is 15.3. Which is greater than 10. So even an unfair bet, lose 100, win 75, will still leave these risk loving people better off than if they hadn't taken a bet. Yeah. Um so when we're doing the losses, when we set that to zero, we're assuming that they're starting off with the amount that they could possibly lose, correct? Oh, that's Okay, great. I'm going to come to that next. That's in these examples, but you've called me on an important assumption I'm making. Okay? These examples I have. Let's make sure we understand risk neutral and risk loving.

Do people understand that? Okay. So now let's um Now you actually have raised another issue. Let me ask a new question. Once again, forget everything you've learned. God and sticks. Here's the bet I'm offering you. Flip a coin. Heads, you win 1250, tails you lose $10. Who takes that bet? Raise your hand if you take that bet. Okay, that's backwards. More of you should take that bet, not less of you. Okay? And why is that? It's because of exactly what you just pointed out. It's because basically, if you think about that, um think about that bet. Think about Let's go back to your old utility function.

U equals square root of C. Okay? Let's think about that bet. So it's What's the expected utility? It's 0.5 times you win 1250. So it's square root of 112.5 plus 0.5 times you lose 10. Square root of 90. And that expected utility, okay? Is 10.5. Which is greater than 10. So you should take that bet. What changed? You're still risk averse. This is the guy who would have paid me 44 bucks to avoid the other bet is now happy to take this bet. Same person. What changed? What changed? Yeah. Smaller portion of the like the like total income. Right. And why does a smaller portion of the income change things here?

Cuz like if you do that little bit, it's less curved. Exactly. Because ultimately, infinitesimally, it's a linear curve. So if you go back to figure 21, at any given for any given epsilon change from point A, it's linear. So essentially, as you get small as gambles get smaller and smaller relative to your starting point, you become more and more risk neutral. Because Because yeah, you're a bit sadder than happier, but just a bit. And remember it's linear, you just take the So if I did a pen if I did 12 and 1/2 cents versus 10 cents, then unless you were crazy risk averse, you should take that bet.

Because essentially, you only care at that point it's so tiny relative to your wealth, you might as well use expected value. Okay? So as gambles become smaller relative to your income, the utility function becomes locally flatter. Okay, utility function becomes locally flatter. And as a result, you become more and more risk neutral. Okay. Question about that. Last point. Why did so many of you still not take that bet? Well, the answer is that even the model we've taught so far misses an important psychological phenomenon. So now I'm stepping out of standard micro and behavioral economics. Unfortunately, due to time semester, I'm not going to get to my lecture on behavioral economics.

But you guys want to learn I'll talk a little bit about it in the next few lectures. I'll sprinkle it in. But course 1113 is a fascinating course we offer here about how you build psychology into thinking about economics. And here's one example. Why is it that even with this gamble, even if I'd done the 12 and 1/2 10 cent gamble, a bunch of you still wouldn't have taken it. Why is that? That's because humans not only feature risk aversion, humans also feature loss aversion. Which is we have an irrational behavioral bias that losing by itself makes us sad relative to winning. Taking away something we have makes us sadder than getting something new.

So here's a standard experiment that's run. They take they make they get they get a bunch of like $5 mugs. Mugs worth about $5. They take people and randomly half of the people they ask, "How much would you pay for this mug?" And half the people they give them the mug and say, "How much would you sell your mug for?" Okay? Half people they say, "Here's a mug. How much would you pay for it?" Half people say, "Here's a mug, it's yours, but I want to buy it back. How much will you sell it to me for?" The average person will pay $3, but the average person wants $7 to sell it back. That makes no sense.

Either way, it's a mug it's trivial relative just a mug it's trivial relative to your wealth. It's just a mug, it doesn't really matter. But once people have it, they feel like, "No, that's already mine. I don't want to sell it." That's loss aversion. People are biased by their starting points. Okay? Your very starting point dictates your willingness to take a gamble. Which is not true in a standard economic model, but it's true in all laboratory experiments in psychology. So not only So the reason people don't like gambles are not only uh because they're risk averse, but even more they're loss averse.

So for example, there's great economic studies which show that there's a massive bias against selling your house for anything under the price you paid for it. That people sort of they're very sort of linear and they will sell a house above the price you paid for it, but there's this huge notch at the price you paid for it. They simply don't want to sell unless they paid for it. And that's this loss aversion idea. Okay, this comes up in many other contexts. So that's So there's two reasons why people are risk averse. People won't take gambles. The standard reason and the sort of extra psychological bias.

Now, this raises This leads us naturally to the next section I want to go to, which is to TALK ABOUT APPLICATIONS OF THIS THEORY AND WHY it's important. And the first application I want to talk about is insurance. Insurance is big business in America. Individuals in America pay individuals, forget about the government, just people spend $1.5 trillion a year on insurance products. Almost 10% of GDP. It's 10% of our entire economy is people buying insurance. Health insurance is the biggest, life insurance, casualty and property insurance, auto insurance, etc. Add it all up, it's almost a tenth of our entire economy.

Okay. Why? Because they're risk averse and also loss averse. I'm going to put loss aversion aside and just use the standard framework. That just strengthens the argument. But it's because they're risk averse. So let's let's do the math. Okay? Imagine you're a single 25-year-old male. I just I'm only being gender biased to you because there's no risk of pregnancy. Okay? So you're a single 25-year-old male in perfect health. So the only risk you face health wise is getting hit by a car. Okay? That's basically a risk. Otherwise, you're basically not going to go to the doctor. Okay? Um so essentially, um let's say your income is $40,000.

That's your income. And let's say that there's a 1% Since it's Cambridge, there's a non-trivial chance you get hit by a car. Okay? Let's say there's a 1% chance, probability is 0.01, you'll get hit by a car every year. And if you do, you're going to face $30,000 of medical bills. Okay? So you have a $40,000 income. There's a 1% chance you get hit by a car. And if you do, you'll face $30,000 of medical bills. And let's assume for the minute you'll still get to work. Your income will always be there. You're just going to have to face a bunch of medical bills. There's a separate issue about whether you might have to miss your job.

That makes this even worse. But let's ignore that. You can get to go to your job. You're just going to have to take a week and get patched up. And $30,000 is nothing, by the way, for a hospital bill. Okay? A typical, for example, heart attack hospital bill is well over $100,000. Okay? So $30,000 is pretty modest. Yeah. Would the person that hit the guy have to pay their insurance cover the medical bill? Well, let's let's ignore that for a second. Right now, we're talking about why you want insurance overall. We'll later get into who, you know, we can discuss later who's who should own that insurance, who should bear the risk.

But right now, it's just simply why you'd want insurance. Okay? So, the expected cost The expected cost of getting hit by a car, the expected value, or expected cost, cuz it's negative, is minus 300. So every year, there's going to be a $300 expected cost of getting hit by a car. And let's say your utility function is U equals square root of C. And let's assume there's no savings. You consume all your income. Okay? How much will this person be willing to pay for insurance? Well, we can solve that by asking at what insurance price would they be better off being insured versus uninsured? Well, let's So let's just do the math.

Okay? If they're uninsured, uninsured, what what's going to happen to them? Well, what's their expected utility? Well, there's a there's a 0.1% that they are going to get hit. And so their net income will drop from 40,000 to 10,000. Cuz they'll have to pay $30,000 of medical bills. So 0.1% chance their net income will be $10,000. And there's a 99% chance that their net income that their net income will be $40,000. Okay? That's utility without insurance. Okay? Add that up and you get 199. So their expected utility without insurance is 199. That's their expected utility. Expected utility with no insurance.

Now, let's do the expected utility with insurance, but with insurance with an uncertain price. Let's call the price X. Okay? What's the utility with insurance? Well, with insurance, there's a 0.1% chance that they get hit. 0.01. I'm sorry. It should be an 01. My bad. Wow, I can't believe you guys missed that. You guys a little tired today. 0.01. 0.01% chance that I get hit. Now, if I get hit with insurance, I don't have to pay my medical bill. But I do have to pay my insurance premium. So, what I have is I have 40,000 MINUS X, WHICH is my insurance premium. I always have to pay my insurance premium every year, no matter what.

If I don't get hit, THEN I GET MY 40,000, but I also have to pay my insurance premium. So basically, as these things are the same, so my expected utility is square root of 40,000 minus X. That's my expected utility. So how do I solve for the optimal X? Well, I ask at what X am I better off than being uninsured? So I set this equal to 199. I ask at what X would I be better off than being uninsured? And if you solve that, you get that the X star, the point at which you would rather be insured than uninsured, is a premium of $399. So you will pay You would rather have insurance at a cost of 399 than you would go uninsured.

Okay? Clear on that? You'd rather pay a premium of 399 than you would go uninsured. Now, think about what that means. Remember, the expected cost of this accident was only $300. That means that you have a $99 risk premium. You are willing to pay $99 to avoid bearing this risk. That is what you're willing to pay me before you're willing to pay me 4375 to get out of that gamble. That was your risk premium. It's how much you'll pay to get out of taking a gamble. Now, before I was offering you a gamble. But here's the thing. Being uninsured is a gamble. Being uninsured is like taking the gamble. So the example I had before I locked you in the room, and if you have to pay me if you want to avoid the bet, that's insurance.

You are locked in this life. You're locked into being in Cambridge. You're dealing with a 1% risk getting hit by a car always. So the question is, how much will you pay to avoid the at least financial cost, forget the trauma, the financial costs of being hit by that car? And the answer is you'll pay $99 above the expected damage it will do. And that is why insurance is big business. Because people will pay to avoid being put in risky situations. Okay? So insurance is a very profitable It's right now. In fact, of course, the insurance industry is like any other industry. There's a supply side and competition, and whether that will lead to profits and stuff like that, it depends on the whole supply side.

This is just the demand side. But the point is that there's going to be huge demand for insurance, and people will be willing to pay much more than the insurance cost the insurance companies. They're supposed to expect to pay $300 a year, and they're getting almost $400 a year in premium. So the insurance company makes that money. Okay? And basically, that's why insurance is big business. Now, here's a couple things I'd like you to show yourself in the, you know, when you're in your copious spare time. Okay? First of all, this risk premium should be bigger as the loss gets bigger. Why? Because you're moving away from that linear part towards the non-linear part of your utility function.

Similarly, this risk premium should fall as your income is higher. Why? Because once again, that makes you more towards the linear part. The bottom line is the bigger the risk is relative to your income, the more risk averse you become. The more you move from that linear part of the curve onto the non-linear part of the curve. Okay? So that's the key thing. Bigger risk relative What matters is risk relative to your income. That's going to determine your value your value you're willing to pay for insurance. So for example, let's think of your decision to go buy consumer electronics and the warranty.

And they always offer you a warranty. Now, those warranties are expected value negative. Okay? If you take the odds of your machine breaking, you're going to buy a new stereo. As if people don't buy stereos anymore. You're going to buy a car stereo. Okay? People still buy those. You buy a car stereo. Okay? You take the odds of that breaking times the cost it would take to fix it. Those multiplied are less than what they'll charge you for the insurance premium. It's a bad bet. But it's insurance. And so the question is, should you take that? Well, that depends on how wealthy you are. I should never take that.

Cuz my car radio cost is tiny relative to my income. Someone with low income might decide that's a large gamble relative to my income. I don't want to take that. So I'm going to buy the insurance offered by the manufacturer. Okay? So once again, it's all about the size of the risk relative relative to your income. Yeah. What if I What if I have an increased chance of breaking my phone? Well, that's a separate issue. We'll talk about that later. That's called moral hazard. Um you might uh That's not moral hazard. It's just What you're saying is there's heterogeneity, and you know that you're that you're actually that for you, it is a fair bet because you're a clumsy.

Well, then you should definitely take it. This is saying risk aversion works in favor of you taking it. Clumsiness further works in favor of you taking it. And we'll talk about that in a in a lecture or two when we talk about uh government provision of insurance. Okay? So that's So that's sort of the the first application, which is thinking about insurance and why it's such big business in America. And it is It is huge business in America. Okay? The second application is thinking about our friend, the lottery. Big news lately. We talked There was a huge couple of huge lottery uh payouts. So let's talk about Actually, let's do this.

Let's talk about the lottery. Now, the lottery is a total rip-off. Okay? The expected value of a lottery purchase is 50%. So every dollar you spend on the lottery, overall lottery options, for every dollar you spend, the expected payout is 50 cents. Is a much, much less than fair bet. Okay? And yet, lotteries are wildly popular. Actually, the beginnings of this country, the US were financed by a lottery. Much of money we government raised initially to set up America came from a lottery. And state lotteries are a huge source of public finance right now across America. Okay? Now, why do people play lotteries?

Well, there's basically four theories for why people play lotteries. The first is that people ARE RISK LOVING. IN FACT, that we're wrong people are risk loving and that's why they play lotteries. How do we know that theory is wrong? How do that theory is on its face wrong that people are risk loving? Yeah. The demonstration that you caused people didn't raise their hands. Well, that's that's that's one way we might know, but how do we know more more globally? You guys could be a weird bunch. How do we know more globally? Yeah. Because of diminishing marginal utility. Yeah, but that's a That's absolutely right theoretically, but that's theoretical right.

So, in the real world, what piece of evidence can you immediately point to that I recently pointed out that could show you this is wrong? Yeah. People buy insurance. People buy insurance. If they're risk loving, why they buying insurance? So, clearly people aren't risk loving. You wouldn't spend 10% of GDP on insurance. So, that theory is clearly wrong. Okay? That's theory one. Now, the second theory is a somewhat subtler version of this theory, which is quite interesting. Which is that people are both risk averse and risk loving. So, that risk aversion varies. Risk tolerance, let's call it, varies.

And then in particular, people are risk averse over small gambles, but risk loving over big gambles. So, let's look at figure 20-4. This is an example of what we call Friedman-Savage preferences. You don't need to know that. But, they had this idea that many people are are locally risk averse, but globally risk loving. Let's see what this Let's give you Let me explain this, okay? This is sort of complicated. So, imagine that I'm going to offer you a 50/50 gamble between W1 and W3. So, a gamble leads you to W1 and gamble leads to W3 50% chance. Okay? Well, if we look between W1 and W3, we're on the concave part of the utility function.

And as a result, I will not take that gamble. That gamble leaves me at point B, which is below B star. Okay? So, so basically, I will not take that gamble. That leaves me worse off than just having W1 + W3 over 2 with certainty. This is just if you hold your hand If you hold your hands between W1 W3, that's just the graph we saw before. You won't take that bet. But now, let's say once you get above W3, once you're rich enough, you're risk loving. So, let's say people are risk averse at first, but then get risk loving. So, if you started at if you said you were started at at W3 + W5 over 2, and I offer you a gamble between W3 and W5, then you might you're risk loving in that range, and you take it.

So, once you get rich enough, you start to get risk loving. So, I talked about before getting richer and getting more and more risk neutral as you get richer. What if it goes the other way? What if you actually get risk loving when you get richer? Well, then if you think about the whole Mega Millions thing, you could see that over the whole distribution from W1 to W5, people might want to take that risk. That you could actually be risk loving over the entire over these gambles over these giant gambles. And that is why people play may play Mega Millions. That over the giant gambles, they're risk loving, even if over more moderate gambles, they're risk averse.

You don't insure yourself for a billion dollars, you insure yourself for a few thousand dollars. Yeah. How was the size of the gamble we're talking about determined? We're talking about like small bets that were more linear. Is it based on what the the player puts in or what they get in return? Uh both. Both. It's basically about It's It's about expected utility calculations. Yeah, yes, it's true for Mega Millions, you put in $2, the chance of winning 1.6 billion. But, your probability is way, way lower than two and 1.6 billion. So, it's still unfair. Okay? So, the Friedman-Savage hypothesis is the only one you need to know the name.

Once again, this hypothesis is that what's happening is that people are first risk averse, but then risk loving. Well, how could we test and actually disprove this theory? Yeah. With scratch offs. Yeah, if this is true, people would love Mega Millions, but hate $10 scratch offs. In fact, the vast majority of lottery playing is not Mega Millions. It's $10 scratch off. Most money spent on lotteries are 10 and $20 gambles. Where you bet a dollar to win 10 or 20. That you should be risk averse over that or best risk neutral. You shouldn't be risk loving over those tiny gambles. And yet, that's most of what lottery players do.

Wouldn't not winning a scratch off be counted internally as not not getting money instead of losing money? Well, no, but you've lost the dollar you spent. And that dollar that I still offered you a gamble. Spend one, win 10 with a 0.05 probability. I mean, like in like in the loss aversion sense, I turned Well, we're not doing loss aversion. Loss aversion is sort of hard not to have to think about gambling. Loss aversion is more about losing. But, in the regular you could see you shouldn't do that unless you're risk loving, but even this theory would say you're not locally risk loving. So, this theory is out.

Which leaves us with two more theories. The first theory is that this is entertainment. That in people's utility function is not just consumption, but the thrill of finding out if they won. Okay? My wife, against my better judgment, went out and bought a Mega Millions ticket. Okay? And she got utility out of waiting for that number to come up. And it was pretty cheap utility. Cost her two bucks. So, in that sense, maybe you play the lottery a lot for entertainment. That's one theory. Unfortunately, the other theory is uh ignorance. That basically, you know, the saying is the lottery is a tax on the stupid.

Okay? That basically just don't understand what a bad deal this is. And the problem is we don't know which of these theories is right. And they have very different implications for government policy. Okay? If the If this theory is right, entertainment theory is right, then the government should support lotteries. Where essentially the government is essentially getting paid for providing entertainment. It's what the lottery is often called a voluntary tax. That I am basically giving the government money to go run our schools, and in return the government giving me the entertainment value of seeing whether my scratch off won.

That's great. That's welfare improving. Under this theory, okay? We should be uh discouraging lotteries. That all we're doing is taking a bunch of ignorant people getting to waste their money. Yeah. Is there not also a possibility that like there's there's a concept of having nothing to lose? Like if you're already like too poor to be able to afford your basic needs, then you might feel like I may as well try and win the lottery, and then I would be like all set. That is abs- That's not just be a tax on the stupid, but also a tax on the already really poor. That's exactly this. That wouldn't explain why I paid the $20 scratch off.

That's an absolute reason why I'd go ahead, even if I was starving, and play the Mega Millions. And that's the Friedman-Savage hypothesis, absolutely. But, that can't explain why, in fact, in some low-income communities, among some low-income groups, they'll spend as much as 20% of their income every year on the lottery. A net. Okay? They're losing huge amounts of money on scratch off tickets. So, the question is, is that a rational decision cuz they find it entertaining, or an irrational decision cuz they just don't understand uh what's going on? And unfortunately, uh we don't know the answer, but we do know it's very important.

It's important because there's big box and many in many low-income communities, it's a huge source of expenditure. So, I can't give you the answer today. I can just tell you it's an important question. I hope someday, you know, someone will figure out how to think about this cuz it's got very important implications. So, let me stop there. That's what I want to say about uncertainty, and we'll come back and do another topic on um on Wednesday.