# Lec 12 | MIT 18.01 Single Variable Calculus, Fall 2007

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YN7k_bXXggY
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/YN7k_bXXggY

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 1:26 — Chapter 2 (1:26)
- 5:24 — Chapter 3 (5:24)
- 6:44 — Chapter 4 (6:44)
- 9:54 — Chapter 5 (9:54)
- 11:04 — Chapter 6 (11:04)
- 13:08 — Chapter 7 (13:08)
- 15:26 — Chapter 8 (15:26)
- 17:32 — Chapter 9 (17:32)
- 19:07 — Chapter 10 (19:07)
- 20:35 — Chapter 11 (20:35)
- 22:39 — Chapter 12 (22:39)
- 25:35 — Chapter 13 (25:35)
- 27:12 — Chapter 14 (27:12)
- 29:37 — Chapter 15 (29:37)
- 30:10 — Chapter 16 (30:10)
- 33:50 — Chapter 17 (33:50)
- 34:29 — Chapter 18 (34:29)
- 36:11 — Chapter 19 (36:11)
- 39:59 — Chapter 20 (39:59)
- 42:23 — Chapter 21 (42:23)
- 44:10 — Chapter 22 (44:10)
- 47:09 — Chapter 23 (47:09)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at

**[0:21]:** ocw.mit.edu uh in the in the 12th lecture we're going to talk about we're going to talk about uh Maxima and Minima let us finish up what we did last time we really only just started with Maxima and Minima and then we're going to talk about related rates so right now I want to give you some

**[0:47]:** examples of Max Min problems and we're going to start with a with a fairly basic one so what's the the the thing about Max men problems the main thing is that we're asking you to do a little bit more of uh the interpretation of word problems so many of the problems are expressed in terms of words um and so in this case we have we have a wire which is length one cut into into two

**[1:26]:** pieces um and then then uh each piece encloses a

**[1:37]:** square sorry encloses a square and the problem so this is the setup and the problem is to find um the um the largest area enclosed

**[2:02]:** all right so here's the problem now in all of these cases in all of these cases there's a bunch of words and your job is typically to draw a diagram okay so the first thing you want to do is to draw a diagram in this case it can be fairly schematic here's your unit length and when you draw the diagram you're going to have to pick variables so th those are really the the the two main tasks to set up the problem so you're drawing a diagram this is like word problems of old in grade school through High School draw a diagram and um uh name name the variables so we'll be doing a lot of that today so here's my unit length and if I I'm going to choose the variable X to be the length of one of the pieces of Y and that makes the other piece 1 - x and that's

**[3:03]:** pretty much the whole diagram except that there's something that we did with the wire after we cut it in half namely we built two little boxes out of it like this these are our squares and their side lengths are X over 4 and 1 - x over 4 all right so so far so good and now we have to think well we want to find the largest area so I need a formula for area in terms of the variables that I've described and so that's the last thing I'll give the letter A as the label for the area and then the area is just the square of X over 4 plus the square of 1 - x whoops that's strange two got in there over four all right okay so far so good now the Instinct that you will have and I'm going to yield to that instinct is we

**[4:05]:** should charge ahead and just differentiate all right that's all right we'll find the critical points so we know that those are important points so we're going to find the critical points in other words we take the derivative we set the derivative of a with respect to x equal to zero all right so if I do that differentiation I get uh the uh well so the first one x^2 over 16 that's that's uh 8 sorry um that's X over 8 right that's the derivative of this and if I differentiate this I get uh well the derivative of 1 - x^2 is 2 * 1 - x * A-1 so it's minus 1 - x/ 8 all right so there are two minus signs in there I'll let you ponder that differentiation which I did by the chain rule all right hang on a sec okay just wait

**[5:13]:** until we're done all right so here's the derivative all right is there a

**[5:24]:** problem

**[5:28]:** uh right so there a 116th here this is x^2 over 16 and so it's 2x over 8 over 16 sorry which has an 8 all right okay that's okay all right so now uh this is equal to zero if and only if if and only if x = 1 - x that's 2X isal to one or in other words x is a half all right so there's our critical point so xal a half is the critical point and the critical

**[6:16]:** value which is what you get when you evaluate a at 1 12 is uh a half / 4 that's an e right so that's an e squar plus 8 s which is 1 32 all right so so far so

**[6:44]:** good but we're not done yet all right we're not

**[6:54]:** done all right so why aren't we done because we haven't checked the end points all right so let's check the end points now in this problem the end points are really sort of excluded the ends are between zero and one here that's the possible lengths of the uh of the cut and so what we should really be doing is evaluating in the limit so that would be the right hand limit as X goes to Z 0 of a and if you plug in X = 0 what you get here is 0 + 1 4^ squared which is 116th all right and similarly at the other end that's 1 minus one from from from the left we get A4 squar + 0 which is also a 16th so what you see is that the schematic picture of this function and this isn't even so far off from being the right picture here is that its level

**[8:10]:** here is a 16th and then it dips down and goes up right this is a half this is one and this level here is a half that this is a 1 over 32 all right so we did not find when we found the critical point we did not find the largest area enclosed we found the least area enclosed so if you don't pay attention to what the function looks like not only will you about half the time get the wrong answer you'll get the absolute worst answer you'll get the one which is the polar opposite from what you want all right so you have to pay a little bit of attention to the function that you've got and in this case it's just very schematic it dips down and goes up and that's true pretty much most function they're fairly simple they maybe only have one critical point they only turn around once but then

**[9:04]:** maybe the critical point is the maximum or maybe it's the minimum or maybe it's neither in fact so we'll we'll we'll be discussing that uh maybe some other time all right so what we find here is that we have the U least area enclosed enclosed is a 16 is sorry a 32nd right and this is true when um x = 12 so these are equal

**[9:42]:** squares all right and most when there's only one

**[9:54]:** square which is more or less the limiting situation if one of the uh one of the pieces disappears all right now so that's that's the the first kind of example and and I just want to make one more comment about terminology before we go on and I will introduce it with the following question what is the

**[10:28]:** minimum all right right so so what what what is the minimum

**[10:43]:** yeah right the lowest value of the function so the answer to that question is 1 over 32 okay now the problem with this question and you will so that refers to the minimum

**[11:04]:** value all right but then there's this other question which is where is the

**[11:15]:** minimum and the answer to that is xal a half okay so one of them is the minimum point

**[11:30]:** and the other one is the minimum value all right so they're they're two separate things now the problem is that people are sloppy and especially since you usually find the the critical point first and the value that is plugging in for a second people will stop short and they'll give the wrong answer to the question for instance now both questions are important to answer you just need to have a word to to to put there so this is a little bit careless when we say what is the minimum some people will say half and that's literally wrong they know what they mean but it's just wrong and when people ask this question they're being sloppy anyway they should maybe be a little clear and say what's the minimum value or where is the value achieved it's achieved at or where is the minimum value achieved where is min achieved would be a better way of

**[12:31]:** phrasing this this second question so that it it has an unambiguous answer and when people ask you for the minimum point they're also well so why is that we call it the minimum point we have this word critical point which is what x equals a half is in critical value and so I'm making those same distinctions here but there's another notion of a minimum point

**[12:59]:** and this is an alternative if you

**[13:08]:** like the minimum point is the point a half 1 over 32 right that's a point on the

**[13:24]:** graph it's the point well so I'll that graph is way up there but I'll just put it on there that's that's this point and you might say Min there and you might point to this point and you might say Max and similarly this one might be a Max okay so in other words so what this means is simply that um people are a little sloppy and sometimes they mean one thing and sometimes they mean another all right and you're just stuck with this uh because there will be some authors who will say one thing and some people will mean another and you just have to live with this little bit of annoying ambiguity all right yeah what is question okay so that's a good very good so here we go find the largest area in closed so that's sort of a trick question isn't it so there there are there are various uh that's a

**[14:25]:** that's a good thing to ask um that's sort of a question why because according to the rules we're trapped between the two Maxima at something which is strictly below so in other words one answer to this question would be and this is the answer that I would probably give is 116th but that's not really true because that's only in the

**[14:55]:** limit as X goes to zero or as X goes to 1 minus and if you like the most is when you've only got one square which It Breaks the Rules of the problem all right so essentially it's a trick question right but I would I would answer it this way because that's the most interesting part of the answer which is that it's 116th and it occurs really when you only when when one of the squares disappears to

**[15:26]:** nothingness all right so now uh let let's do another example here and uh I just want to illustrate the sort of the second the second uh style or the second type of question yeah I'm

**[15:50]:** wondering the question is um since the question was what was the largest area why did we find the least area the reason is that when we go about our procedure of looking for the least or the most we'll automatically find both because we don't know which one is which until we compare values and actually it's much more to your advantage to figure out that much both the maximum and the minimum whenever you answer such a question because otherwise you you won't understand the behavior of the function very well so the question we started out with one question we answered both we answered two questions we answered the question of what the largest and the and the and the smallest value was and also I'm wondering if we can check for the minimum whether it's a minimum or maximum yes one can also use the question is can we use the second derivative test and the

**[16:51]:** answer is yes we can in fact you can actually also stare at this and see that it's a a sum of squares so it's always um uh curving up it's a parabola with a positive second coefficient so you can differentiate this twice if you do you'll get an eighth plus another eth and you'll get a 16th so the second derivative is six is 1/16th uh is uh 1/4 and that's an acceptable way of of figuring it out I I'll mention the second derivative test again in this second example so let me talk about a second example

**[17:32]:** so again this is going to be oh another question you minimum or maximum you mean the question is when I say minimum or maximum point which will I

**[17:49]:** mean yeah so that that's the the qu I just repeated the question so the the question is when I say minimum Point what will I mean okay okay and the answer is that for the purposes of this class I will probably avoid saying that but I will say probably where is the minimum achieved just in order to avoid that if I actually said it I often am referring to the graph and I mean this and in fact when you get your little review for the second exam I'll say exactly that on the review sheet okay and I'll make this very clear when we're doing this however I just want to prepare you for the fact that in real life and even me when I'm talking uh colloquially when I say what's the minimum point of something I might actually be mixing it up with this with this other notion here all

**[18:47]:** right okay so let's do another

**[18:53]:** example so this is uh an an example to get us used to the notion of of constraints so we have so consider a box without a

**[19:07]:** top or if you like we're going to

**[19:12]:** find the box without a top with least surface

**[19:25]:** area for a fixed volume all right find the box without a top with least surface area for a fixed volume the procedure for for working this out is the following you make this diagram and you set up the variables right in this case we're going to have four names of variables all right we have four letters that we have to choose and we'll choose them in a kind of a standard way all right so first I have to tell you one more thing which is uh something that you'll that we could calculate separately but I'm just going to give it to you in advance which is that it turns out that the best box has a square bottom and that's going to get rid of one of our variables for us so it's got a square bottom and so let's draw a picture of it so here's our

**[20:35]:** box well I guess that goes down like this almost maybe I should do a little farther down all

**[20:48]:** right all right so here's our box let's correct that just a bit all right so now what about the dimensions of this box well this is going to be X and this is very foreshortened but it's also X the bottom is X byx it's the same dimensions and then the vertical Dimension is y okay so far so good now I have I to promised you two more letter names I want to compute the volume all right the volume is the base is x s and height is y so there's the volume and then the area the area is the area of the bottom which is X2 that's the bottom and then there are the four sides and the four sides are rectangles of Dimensions XY so it's

**[21:48]:** 4xy all right so these are the sides and remember there's no top so that's our setup so now the difference between this problem and the last problem is that there are two variables floating around namely X and Y which are not determined but uh there's what's called a

**[22:16]:** constraint here namely we fixed the relationship between X and Y and so that means that we can solve for um for y in terms of X so Y is equal to V /

**[22:39]:** x^2 and then we can plug that into the formula for a so here we have a which is x^2 + 4x * vx^ 2

**[23:04]:** question

**[23:14]:** yeah uh the question is will you need to know this intuitively no that's a that's something that I would have to give to you I mean it's it's it's actually true that that a lot of things the uh the correct answer is something symmetric in this Last Problem the minimum turned out to be exactly halfway in between because there were sort of equal demands from the two sides and similarly here what happens is if you elongate one side you get less it's it's it actually is a involved with a two variable problem namely if you have a rectangle uh and you have a certain amount of length associated with it what's the optimal thing you can do with that but I I won't in other words uh the optimal rectangle the the least perimeter rectangle turns out to be a square that's a little sub problem that leads you to this Square bottom but but

**[24:06]:** so that would have been a separate uh Max Min problem which I'm skipping because I want to do this slightly more interesting one all right okay so now here's our formula for a and now I want to follow the same procedure as before namely we'll look for the the critical point or

**[24:34]:** points so let's take a look so again a is x^2 + 4 VX and a prime is 2x - 4 V /x^2 so if we set that equal to zero we get uh 2x = 2 V /x^2 so 2x Cub uh well how did that happen to change into two interesting guess that's wrong okay right so this is uh X cubed is equal to to V all right and so uh X is equal to 2 1/3 V 1/3 all right so this is the critical

**[25:35]:** point so we are not done right we're not done because we don't even know whether this is going to give us the worst box or the best box from this point of view the one that uses the most air surface area or the least so let's check the ends right away to see what's happening so can somebody tell me what the ends what the end values of X are where do X range

**[26:04]:** from what's the smallest X be

**[26:11]:** yeah

**[26:15]:** because okay the the claim was that the largest X could be root a because somehow there's this x squ here and it and you you can't get any further path than that but there's a key feature here of this problem which is that a is variable the only thing that's fixed in the problem is V okay so if V is fixed what do you know about X yeah x z x is greater than zero yeah the lower end point that's safe because that has to do geometrically with the fact that we don't have any boxes with negative dimensions that would be refused by the post office definitely over and above the empty top which they wouldn't accept

**[27:12]:** either uh it's true that X is less than < TK of V over y so that's using this relationship but notice that Y is equal to vx2 so 0 to Infinity I just got a guess there over here that's right here's the upper limit so that this is really important to realize this is most problems most problems the variable if it doesn't have a limitation usually just goes out to infinity and infinity is a very important end for the problem it's usually an easy end to the problem too all right so there's the possibility that if we push all the way down to x equals z we'll get a better box it would be a very strange box a little bit like our Vanishing uh enclosure and uh maybe an infinitely long box also very inconvenient one might be the best box we'll have to see all right so let's just take a look at what happens so we're looking at a F0 plus right and that's x^2 + 4 V overx with X at0 Plus so what happens to that notice

**[28:27]:** right here

**[28:31]:** this is going to Infinity all right so this is infinite so that turns out to be a bad box all right let's take a look at the other end so this is x^2 + 4 v /x x going to infinity and again this term here means that this thing is infinite so the shape of this thing I'll draw this tiny little schematic diagram over here the shape of this thing is like this all right and so when we find that one turnaround point which happened to Be At This Strange point 2/3 of 2 to the 1/3 sorry V to the 1/3 that is going to be the minimum all right so we've just discovered that it's the minimum

**[29:30]:** which is just what we were hoping for this is going to be the optimal

**[29:37]:** box now uh since you asked earlier and and since it's worth checking this as well let's also check an alternative justification so an

**[29:55]:** alternative to checking in

**[30:01]:** ends is the second derivative

**[30:10]:** test I do not recommend the second derivative test I try my best want to give you problems to make it really hard to apply the second derivative test but in this example the function is simple enough so that it's perfectly okay if you take the derivative here remember this was uh whatever it was 2x minus uh 4 V over x^2 if I take the second derivative it's 2 + uh 8 V /x cubed and that's positive so this thing is concave up and that's consistent with its being the critical point is a min

**[30:59]:** is a minimum Point see now I almost said is a Min as opposed to minimum point so watch out yes so is this the answer to the problem or have to give Y and Y in ter you're one step ahead of me the question is is this the answer to the question or would we have to give Y and a and so on and so forth so again I want to this is this is something that I want to emphasize and take my time with right now because it depends what kind of real life problem you're answering what kind of answer is appropriate so so far we've found the critical point we haven't found the critical value we haven't found the dimensions of the Box okay so I I we're going to spend a little bit more time on this exactly in order to address these questions so first of all the value of y

**[31:51]:** so so far we have X is 2 the 1/3 V the 1/3 and certainly if you're going to build the Box you also want to know what the Y value is the Y value is going to be um uh let's see well it's it's vx^ 2 so that's V / 2 1/3 V 1/3 2ar which comes out to be uh 2 to the - 23 V 1/3 okay so there's the Y value on top of that we could figure out the um the value of a all right so that's also perfectly reasonable part of the answer depending on what one is interested in you might care how much money it's going to cost you to build this box this optimal box and so you plug in the value of a so a let's see is up here it's X2 + 4 uh V /x so that's going to be um 2 1/3 V 1/3 2ar

**[32:54]:** + 4 V / 2 2 1/3 V 1/3 all right and if you work that all out what you get turns out to be 3 * 2 1/3 V to 2/3 all right so so if you like one way of answering this question is is these three these three things that would be the the the minimum Point corresponding to the graph that would be the the the answer this question but the reason why I'm carrying it out in such detail is I want to show you that there are much more meaningful ways of answering this question so let me let me explain

**[33:50]:** that so

**[34:02]:** so let me go through some more meaningful answers here the the first more meaningful answer is the following sort of idea simply there what what are known as

**[34:23]:** dimensionless uh variables

**[34:29]:** so the first thing that you notice is the scaling law that a / V 2/3 is the thing that's a dimensionless quantity that happens to be 3 * 2 1/3 okay so that's one thing if you want to expand the volume you'll have to expand the area by the 2/3 power of the volume and if you think of the area as being in say um cubic uh sorry um Square in and the um the volume of the boxes being in cubic in then you can see that this is a dimensionless quantity and you have a dimensionless number here which is a characteristic independent of what a and v were the other uh dimensionless quantity is the ratio of Y to X or X to Y all right so again that's that's inches divided inches and it's 2 1/3 V 1/3 / 2 - 2/3 V to the 1/3 which happens to be two all right

**[35:36]:** so this is actually the best answer to the question and it shows you that the box is a 2: one box if this is two and this is one that's the good box and that is just the shape if you like and it's the optimal

**[36:01]:** shape and I certainly that aesthetically that's the that's the cleanest answer to the

**[36:11]:** question all right there was a question right here

**[36:20]:** yes could could you repeat that I couldn't hear I'm wondering if we'll be able to get the answer if we want told the square the question is could we have gotten the answer if we weren't told that the bottom was Square the answer is yes in 1802 with multivariable you would have to have three letters here an x a y and a z if you like and then you'd have to work with all three of them all right so I separated out into one there's a there's a separate one variable problem that you can do for the base and then this is a second one variable problem for this other thing and it's just two consecutive one variable problems that solve the multivariable problem or as I say in multivariable calculus you can just do it all in one step all right yeah X by y why did I divide X by y uh rather

**[37:14]:** than y byx or or in any so again what I was aiming for was dimensionless quantities so X and Y are measured in the same units and also the the proportions of the box so that's another word for this is proportions are something that's Universal independent of of the volume v it's something you can say about any box at any scale whether it be you know something by kristo in you know in the common maybe we'll get him here to do some fancy uh uh the proportions is with geometric problems typically when when when there's a scaling to the problem where the answer is the same at small scales and at large scales this is capturing that so that's why the yeah the ratios are what's capturing that and that's why it's aesthetically the nicest thing to ask okay I'm sorry what exactly does the ratio of the area to the volume rao3 tell us um it unfortunately this number is a

**[38:23]:** really uh is a really obscure number so it doesn't the question is what does this tell us the only thing that I want to emphasize is what's on the left hand side here which is the it's the area to the 2/3 power of the volume so it's a dimensionless quantity that happens to be this uh if you do this for example uh in general with planer diagrams uh circumference area is the is a is a bad ratio to take what you want to take is the square of circumference to area because the square of circumference has the same dimensions that is say inches squared to area which has which is in square in so again it's these dimensionist quantities that you want to to uh cook up and those are the ones that will have Universal properties there's a the the the the most famous of these is that the circle en is the encloses

**[39:10]:** the most area for its circumference and again that's only true if you measure a you you take the square of the circumference you you you do the units correctly all right okay anyway okay so we're here we we've got a uh a a shape we've got an answer to this question and I now want to do this problem well let's put it this way I wanted to do this problem by a different method I think I I'll I'll I'll take the time to do it so I want to I want to do this problem by a slightly different method here so here's example two by implicit differentiation

**[39:59]:** so the same example but now I'm going to do it by implicit differentiation and I now I I'll tell you the advantages and the disadvantages to this method here so the situation is you have to start the same

**[40:19]:** way so here was the starting place of the problem all right and we're taking the we're aiming the goal was the minimum of a with v constant so this was the situation that we were in and now what I want to do is just differentiate all right the function y is implicitly a function of X so I can differentiate the first

**[40:53]:** expression and that yields zero is equal to 2x y + x^2 y Prime right so this is giving me my implicit formula for y Prime so y Prime is equal to - 2x y / x^2 or in other words - 2 y /

**[41:18]:** X and then I also have the derivative of a with respect to X now you may notice I'm not using prime quite as much because I all of the variables are varying and so here I'm emphasizing that the differentiation is with respect to the variable X and uh this becomes 2x + 4 y + 4x y Prime so again this is uh using the product rule and now I can plug in for what y Prime is which is right above it so this is 2x + 4 y + 4x * - 2 YX okay and that's equal to zero and so let's get that gather that

**[42:23]:** together so what do we have we have 2x + 4 Y and then Al together this is 8 - 8 y = 0 so that's the same thing as 2x is equal to 4 y right the minus 4 y goes to the other side and so um X over Y is equal to

**[42:53]:** 2 so this I I claim well so you you you have to decide for yourself but I claim that this is faster all right it's faster and also it gets to the heart of the matter which is the scale invariant proportions which is basically also nicer so it gets to the nicer answer also so those are the those are the advantages that this has so it's faster and it gets to this I'm going to call it nicer and the dis Advantage

**[43:34]:** is um uh did not check whether this critical point is a Max Min or neither okay so we didn't quite finish the problem but we got to the answer very

**[44:10]:** fast Yeah question how would you check it well so it gives you a candidate uh the answer is so the question is how would you check it the answer is that for this particular problem the only way to do it is to do something like this all right so in other words you it doesn't save you that much time but with many many examples you actually can tell immediately that at the two ends the thing is is say zero and inside it's positive things like that so in many many cases this is just as good all right okay so now I'm going to change subjects here but the subject that I'm going to talk about next is almost is very very closely linked namely I talked about implicit differentiation now we're going to just talk about dealing with lots of variables and rates of change so essentially we're going to talk about the same type of thing so I'm going to tell you about a subject which is called related rates which is really just another

**[45:26]:** excuse for getting you used to setting up variables and equations so here we go related

**[45:38]:** rates and I'm going to illustrate this with one example today one one tomorrow so here's my example for today so you're again this is going to be a police problem but this is going to be a word prompt but and sorry I'm not don't want to scare you no police uh uh well they were police in the story but they're not present uh so but I'm going to draw it immediately with a diagram because because I'm going to save us the the trouble although you know the point here is to get from the words to the um to the diagram okay so you have the police and they're 30t from the road and here's the road and you're coming along here here in your um let's see in your car going in this direction here and the police have radar which is bouncing off of your car and what they read off is that you have that you're 50 ft away all right they also know

**[46:55]:** that you're approaching along the line of the radar at a rate of 80 ft per

**[47:09]:** second okay

**[47:15]:** now the question is are you speeding right that's the question so so when you're speeding uh by the way uh 95 ft per second is about 65 mph so that's the that's the uh threshold here so so what I want to do now is show you how you set up a problem like this all right this distance is 50 this is 30 and because it's the distance to a straight line you know that this is a right angle so we know that this is a right triangle and this is set up to be a right triangle which which is which is an easy one a 3 four five right triangle just so that we can do the computations uh easily all right so now the question is how do we put the letters in to make this problem work to figure out what the the rate of change is so now let me let me

**[48:13]:** explain that uh right now and we will actually do the computation next time so the first thing is you have to understand what's changing and what's not and we're going to use T for time in seconds okay and now an important distance here is the distance to this foot of this perpendicular so I'm going to name that X all right I'm going to give that letter X now X is varying the reason why I need a letter for it as opposed to this 40 is that it's going to have a rate of change with respect to T and in fact it's related to the question is whether dxdt is is faster or slower than 95 okay so that's the thing that's varying now there's something else that's varying this distance here is also varying so we need a letter for that we do not need a letter for this because it's never changing we're assuming

**[49:13]:** the police are parked they're not ready to Roar out and catch you just yet and they're certainly not in motion when they've got their radar guns aimed at you so you know sort of you need to know something about the sociology and style of of of police uh when they're okay so you need to know know things about the real world now the last bit is what about this this 80 here so this is how fast you're approaching now that's measured along the radar gun I claim that that's d by DT of this quantity here so this D is also changing that's why we needed a letter for it too so um next time we'll just put that all together and compute DX by DT
