# Lecture 7: More on Energy Eigenstates

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uk5DUtHY7LM
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/Uk5DUtHY7LM

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 5:14 — Chapter 2 (5:14)
- 8:41 — Chapter 3 (8:41)
- 11:49 — Chapter 4 (11:49)
- 19:26 — Chapter 5 (19:26)
- 22:27 — Chapter 6 (22:27)
- 26:11 — Chapter 7 (26:11)
- 27:36 — Chapter 8 (27:36)
- 28:10 — Chapter 9 (28:10)
- 29:06 — Chapter 10 (29:06)
- 29:39 — Chapter 11 (29:39)
- 31:26 — Chapter 12 (31:26)
- 33:26 — Chapter 13 (33:26)
- 35:20 — Chapter 14 (35:20)
- 36:59 — Chapter 15 (36:59)
- 38:00 — Chapter 16 (38:00)
- 40:06 — Chapter 17 (40:06)
- 45:34 — Chapter 18 (45:34)
- 47:27 — Chapter 19 (47:27)
- 48:15 — Chapter 20 (48:15)
- 49:25 — Chapter 21 (49:25)
- 51:17 — Chapter 22 (51:17)
- 54:36 — Chapter 23 (54:36)
- 57:00 — Chapter 24 (57:00)
- 57:46 — Chapter 25 (57:46)
- 1:00:30 — Chapter 26 (60:30)
- 1:06:44 — Chapter 27 (66:44)
- 1:10:40 — Chapter 28 (70:40)
- 1:14:23 — Chapter 29 (74:23)
- 1:15:49 — Chapter 30 (75:49)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high quality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at ocw.mit.edu

**[0:23]:** okay so I want to start out by reviewing a few things and putting putting some machinery together unfortunately this thing is sort of stuck we're going to need it later so I don't know I'll put it up for now so first just a bit of notation this symbol you should think of it like the dot product or the inner product it's just saying that bracket FG is the integral it's a number that you get so this is a number that you get from the function f in the function G by taking F taking its complex conjugate multiplying it by G and then integrating over all positions right so it's a way to get a number and you should think about it as the analog for functions of the dot product for vectors it's a way to get a number out of two vectors and so for example with vectors we could do V dot W

**[1:15]:** and this is some number and it has a nice property that V dot V we can think of as V squared it's something like a length it's strictly positive and it's something like the length of a vector similarly if I take F and take its bracket with F this is equal to the integral DX of F squared and in particular F could be complex so f norm squared this is strictly non-negative it could vanish but it's not zero at a pole it's not negative at a point it's the norm squared so this will be zero if and only if what F is zero F is the zero function right so same way that the vector if you take a vector and you take its dot product with itself take it the norm it's zero if and only if the vector is zero so this beast satisfies a lot of the properties of a dot product

**[1:59]:** you should think about it is morally equivalent we'll talk about that in more detail later second basic postulate of quantum mechanics to every observable is associated an operator and it's an operator acting on the space of functions are on the space of wave functions and to every operator corresponding to an observable in quantum mechanics are associated a special set of functions called the eigen functions such that when the operator acts on that function it gives you the same function back times a constant what these functions mean physically is they are the wave functions describing configurations with a definite value of the corresponding observable if I'm in an eigen function of position with eigenvalue x not awesome thank you AV person thank you so if if if your system is described by a wave function which is an eigenfunction of the position operator with eigenvalue X naught that means you can be confident that the system

**[2:54]:** isn't the configuration corresponding to having a definite position X naught right it's not a superposition of different positions it is at X naught similarly momentum momentum has eigenfunctions and we know what these guys are these are the Exponential's e to the ikx s they're the eigenfunctions and those are the wave functions describing states with definite value of the of the momentum of the Associated observable energy as an operator energy is an as described by an operator which has good which has eigenfunctions which I'll call Phi sub n with energy Z sub n those are the eigenvalues and if I tell you that your wave function is the state Phi sub 2 what that tells you is that the system has a definite energy e sub 2 corresponding to that eigenvalue cool and this is true for any physical observable but these are sort of the basic ones that we'll keep focusing on position momentum and

**[3:56]:** energy for the next while okay now a nice property about these eigenfunctions is that for different eigenvalues the Associated wave functions are different functions and what I mean by saying there are different functions that they're actually orthogonal functions in the sense of this dot product if I have a state corresponding to be it at X 0 definite position X 0 that means I'm an eigenfunction of position with eigenvalue X 0 and I have another that corresponds to being at X 1 an eigen function of the position operator the eigenvalue x 1 then these wave functions are orthogonal to each other ie we get 0 if X naught is not equal to X 1 let me call that now meanwhile not only are they orthogonal but they're normalized in a particular way the inner product gives me a delta function which goes beep once so that if I integrate against it I get a 1 same

**[4:45]:** thing with momentum and you do this this you're checking on the problem set I don't know if it was last one or this one and for the energies and energy one if I know the system is in state energy one and one let's say energy sub N and E sub m those are different states if N and M are not equal to each other and this inner product is 0 if n and M are not equal to each other and 1 if they are the properly normalized I recall that yeah

**[5:14]:** absolutely it is absolutely possible for two eigenfunctions to have the same eigenvalue that is certainly possible yeah good so um so here's a crude thank you this is a good technicality that I didn't want to get into but I'll go ahead and get into it it's a very good question so the question is is it possible for two different eigenfunctions to have the same eigenvalue could there be two states with the same energy different states same energy yeah that's absolutely possible and we'll run into that and there's nice physics encoded in it but let's think about what that means that the subsequent question is well if that's the case are they really still orthogonal and here's the crucial thing the crucial thing is let's say take a 1 function I'll call the function f 1 or Phi 1 consider Phi 1 and let it have energy e 1 so that e acting on Phi 1

**[6:02]:** is equal to e 1 Phi 1 ok and let there be another function Phi 2 such that the energy operator acting on Phi 2 is also equal to e 1 Phi 2 these are set to be degenerate degenerate doesn't mean you go out and trash your card degenerate means that the energies are the same there is yeah okay so what does this tell me this tells me a cool fact if I take a wave function Phi and I will call this Phi star in on R Street kulkarni so I've got this Phi star which is a linear combination alpha Phi 1 plus beta fi 2 a linear combination of them a superposition of those two states is this also an energy eigenfunction yeah because if I act on e on Phi star with E then that's its linear so e acting on Phi star is e acting on Alpha Phi 1 alpha Z constant doesn't

**[6:56]:** care Phi 1 gives me an e 1 similarly e acting on Phi 2 gives me an e 1 so this is equal to if I act II on this guy this is equal to from both of these I get an overall factor of u1 so notice that we get the same vector back times a constant a common constant so when we have degenerate eigen functions we can take arbitrary linear combinations to them get another degenerate eigen function cool so this is like imagine I have a vector and I have another vector and they share the property that they're both eigenfunctions of some operator that means any linear combination of them is also right so there's a whole vector space there's a whole space of possible functions that all have the same eigen value so now you say well look are these two orthogonal to each other no these two no but here's the thing if

**[7:43]:** you have a vector space if you have a space you can always find or THOG '''l guys and a basis for that space yes so while it's not true that they the eigenfunctions are always orthogonal it is true we will not prove this but we will discuss the proof of it later by pulling the mathematician out of the closet the proof will say that it is possible to find a set of eigenfunctions which are orthogonal in precisely this fashion even if there are degeneracies okay that theorem is called the spectral theorem and we'll discuss it later so it is always possible to do so but you must be alert that there may be degeneracies there aren't always degeneracies in fact degeneracies are very special why should two numbers happen to be the same something has to be forcing them to be the same and then that that's going to an important theme for us but

**[8:31]:** but it certainly is possible good question other questions yeah

**[8:41]:** yeah so using the triangular brackets it is al is a there's another notation for the same thing which is FG but this carries some slightly different weight it means something slightly you'll see this in books and this means something very similar to this but I'm not going to use this notation it's called Dirac notation we'll talk about it later in the semester but we're not going to talk about it just yet but you see this it means effectively it means the same thing as this this is sort of like dialect you know it's like French and québécois other questions my wife's Canadians other questions okay so given this fact given the fact that we can associate observables to operators operators come with special functions the eigenfunctions those eigenfunctions corresponding to have a definite value of the observable and they're orthonormal this tells us and this is really the statement of the spectral theorem that any

**[9:32]:** function can be expanded in a basis of states with definite values of some observable so for example consider position I claim that any wave function can be expanded as a superposition of states with definite position so here is an arbitrary function here's a set of states with definite position the Delta functions and I can write any function as a superposition with some coefficients of states with definite position integrating over all possible positions X not yeah and this is also sort of trivially true because e in it what's this integral well it's an integral DX not over all possible positions of this Delta function but we're evaluating at X so this only this is 0 unless X is equal to X naught so I just put in X instead of X naught and that gives me 5x sort of tautological we can do the same thing for momentum eigenfunctions I claim that any function can be

**[10:21]:** expanded in a superposition of momentum eigenfunctions where I sum over all possible values in the momentum with some weight right where this side tilde of K is just telling me how much amplitude there is at that wave number cool but this is the Fourier theorem it's a Fourier expansion so purely mathematically we know that this is true ok but there's also the physical statement any state can be expressed as a superposition of states with definite momentum there's math in here but there's also physics in finally this is less obvious from a mathematical point of view because Evan even told you what energy is any wave function can be banded in states with definite energy so this is a state my state en with definite energy with some coefficient summed over all possible values of the energy okay given any physical observable any physical observable momentum position angular momentum whatever given any physical observable a given

**[11:17]:** wave function can be expanded as some superposition of having definite values of that will it in general have definite values of the observable will a general state be an energy eigenfunction no but any state is a superposition of energy eigenfunctions will a definite state or a random state have a definite position certainly not you could have this wave function write superposition yeah

**[11:49]:** such that you can make an arbitrary state with a countable number of energy eigenfunctions rather than having to do a continuous excellent question so i mean a phrase that slightly differently it's an excellent question we'll come to that at the end of today's lecture so the question is this those are integrals that is a sum over discrete things why why is the possible values of position continuous possible values momentum continuous the possible values of energy discrete the answer to this will will become apparent over the course of your next few problem sets you have to do some problems to get your fingers dirty you to really understand this but here's the statement and we'll see the first version of this at the end of today's lecture sometimes the allowed energies of a system the energy eigenvalues are discrete sometimes they are continuous they will be discrete when you have bound States states that are trapped

**[12:41]:** in some region and aren't allowed to get arbitrarily far away they will be continuous when you have states that that it can get arbitrarily far away sometimes the momentum will be allowed to be a discrete value sometimes it will be allowed to be continuous values and we'll see exactly why subsequently but the thing I one emphasize is that I'm writing this to emphasize that it's possible that each of these can be discrete or continuous the important thing is that once you pick your physical system you ask what are the allowed values of position what are the allowed values of momentum and what are the allowed values of energy and then you sum over all possible values now in the examples we looked at yesterday or last lecture the energy could have been discrete as in the case of the infinite well or continuous as in the case of the free particle in the case of

**[13:29]:** a continuous particle this would have been an integral in the Katyn sorry in the case of a system such as a free particle where the energy could take any of a continuous number of possible values this would be a continuous integral to deal with that I'm often going to use the notation just shorthand integral sum because I which I know is a horrible bastardization of all that's good and just but on the other hand emphasizes the fact that it's a in some systems you will get continuous in some systems discrete and sometimes you'll have both continuous and discrete for example in a hydrogen in hydrogen we will find that there are bound states where the electron is stuck to the hydrogen nucleus to the proton and there are discrete allowed energy levels for that configuration however once you I envision the electron can have any energy you want it's no longer bound it can just

**[14:16]:** get arbitrarily far away and there are an uncountable infinity a continuous Vout set of possible States so in that situation we'll find that we have both the discrete and a continuous series of possible States yeah

**[14:31]:** yeah sure if you work on a lattice so for example consider the following quantum system I have an undergraduate and that undergraduate has been placed in one of 12 boxes ok now what's the state of the undergraduate I don't know is it a definite position state it might be but probably it's a superposition of an arbitrary superposition right a very impressive undergraduates at MIT so ok other questions yeah this is hole even changes overtime excellent question we'll come back to that very good question leading question okay so we have this the next thing is that energy eigenfunctions satisfy some very special properties right and in particular energy eigenfunctions have the property from the straining equation I h-bar DT on sigh of X and T is equal to the energy operator acting on sine of X and T this tells us that if we have sine X naught time t0 is equal to Phi n of

**[15:34]:** X as we saw last time then the wave function sine at X at time T is equal to Phi n of X and it only changes by an overall phase e to the minus I en T over H bar and this ratio en upon H bar will often be written Omega n is equal to en over H bar this is just the de briare relations okay I recall that so our energy eigenfunctions you know are how to say no to possible wave functions are no wave which is more morally good than another but some are particularly convenient energy eigenfunctions have the nice property that while they're not a definite position they don't necessarily have a definite momentum they do evolve over time in a particularly simple way okay and that allows me that and the superposition principle allow me to write the following if I know that this is my wave function at sy at

**[16:29]:** x times 0 okay so let's say in all these cases this is sine of X at time 0 how does this state evolve forward in time

**[16:44]:** it's kind of complicated how does this description how does sy tilde of K evolve for it in time again kind of complicated but when I express in terms of the energy eigenstates the answer to how it evolved forward in time is very simple because I know that this is a superposition a linear combination of states with definite energy states with definite energy involved with a phase and the Schrodinger equation is linear so solutions of the Schrodinger equation ad to become solutions of the Schrodinger equation so how does this state of all for it in time it involves forward the phase minus I Omega NT one for every different term in this some cool so we are going to harp on energy eigenfunctions not because they're more moral or more just or more good but because they're more convenient for solving the time evolution problem in quantum mechanics so most of today is going to be

**[17:34]:** about this expansion and qualitative features of energy eigenfunctions cool okay and just to close that out let's think of I just want to remind you of a couple of examples that we did that we did last time just get them on the board so the first is a free particle so for a free particle we have that our wave functions F Phi n are equal to ei well actually let me not write that down like so let me skip over the free particle because it's so trivial let me just talk about the infinite well okay so the potential is infinite out here and it's zero inside the well and it goes from zero to L this is just my choice of notation and the energy operator as usual is P squared upon 2m plus U of X you might say where did I Drive this and the answer is I didn't derive this I just

**[18:29]:** wrote it down it's like force in Newton's equations you just declare some force and then you ask what system doesn't model so here's my system it has what looks like a classical kind of of energy except these are all operators and the potential here is this guy it's zero out between zero and L and it's infinite elsewhere and as we saw last time the solutions to the energy eigenvalue equation aren't particularly simple Phi sub n of X is equal to root properly normalized to upon L sine of KX where kin is equal to n plus 1 pi where n is an integer upon L and these were chosen to satisfy our boundary conditions that the wave function must vanish here hence a sign and K was chosen so that it turned over and just hit 0 as we got to L and that gave us that the allowed energies were discrete because the e and

**[19:26]:** which you can get by just plugging to the energy eigenvalue equation was equal to H bar squared K n squared upon 2m so this tells us a nice thing first off in this system if I take a particle and I throw it in here in some arbitrary state at so that at time T equals zero the wave function x0 is equal to sum over n CN oh sorry let me write this as Phi n of X CN okay can I do this can I just pick some arbitrary function which is a superposition of energy eigenstates sure because any function is any function can be described as a superposition energy eigenfunctions and if I build the energy eigenfunctions jagan functions will automatically satisfy the boundary conditions all the good things will happen so this is perfectly fine an initial condition what is the system at time T

**[20:20]:** yeah we just pick up the faces in what faces this guy it's this e to the minus I Omega n T and when I write Omega n let me be more explicit about that that's en over h-bar so that's h-bar K n squared upon 2m T cool so there is our solution for arbitrary initial conditions to the infinite square well problem in quantum mechanics and you're going to study this in some detail on your problem set but just to start with a little bit of intuition let's look at the wave functions and the probability distributions for the lowest lying States so for example let's look at the wave function for the ground state what I will call sy Sub Zero and this is from 0 to L ok and I put these bars here not because we're looking at the potential I'm going to be plotting the real part of the wave function but I put these balls Wells here just to emphasize

**[21:26]:** that that's where the walls are at x equals 0 and x equals L so what does it look like well the first one is going to be sine of KX and a 0 KN is going to be PI upon L so that's again just this guy now what's the probability distribution associated with sy 0 where do you find the particle so we know that it's just the norm squared of this wave function and the norm squared here it's zero so it's quadratic SERO and it rises linearly cosine is linear small values that makes this quadratic the maximum and then quadratic so there's our probability distribution now here's a funny thing imagine I take a particle classical particle and I put it in a box okay and you put it in the box and you tell it okay it's got some energy so classically it's got some momentum so it's sort of bouncing back and forth

**[22:17]:** and it just bounces off the arbitrarily hard walls and moves around where are you most likely to find that particle

**[22:27]:** where does it spend most of its time it spends the same amount of time in any point it's got moving at constant velocity goes boom boom boom right so what's the probability distribution for finding it at any point inside classically constant classically the probability distribution is constant or just as likely to find it near the wall as not near the wall okay however quantum mechanically for the lowest lying state that is clearly not true you're really unlikely to find it near the wall what's up with that so that's a question that I want to put in your head and have you think about I'm we're going to you're going to see a similar effect arising over and over and we're going to see at the very end that that is directly related the fact that this goes to zero is directly related and I'm not kidding to the transparency of Dimond

**[23:20]:** not good okay I think it's pretty cool okay so look they're they're expensive it's also related to the transparency of cubic zirconium which I guess is less impressive but so so the first state again let's look at the real part of sy one the first excited state well this is now a sign with one extra with a two here two pi so it goes through zero okay so the probability distribution associated with sy one and I should say right this is the function of X looks like well again it's quadratic but it has a zero again in the middle so it's going to look like oops my bad art defeats me okay there we go so now it's even worse not only is it unlikely to be out here it's also very unlikely to be found the middle in fact there are zero probability you'll find in the middle that's sort of surprising but you

**[24:18]:** can quickly guess what happens as you go to very high energies the real part of sy and let's say you know ten thousand ten to the four what is that going to look like well this had no zeros this had one zeros and every time you increase n by one you're just going to add one more zero to the sign that's an interesting and suggestive factor fact so if it's size of 10,000 how many nodes are there going to be in the middle of the domain 10,000 and the amplitude is going to be the same okay I'm not going to be able to do this but you get the idea and now if I construct the probability distribution what's the probability distribution going to be probability of the 10,000th psy sub 10 to the 4 of X well it's again going to be strictly positive and if you are not able to make measurements on

**[25:08]:** the scale of L upon 10,000 let's just say like L over 3 because you know you have a thumb and you don't have an infinitely accurate meter what do you see you see effectively a constant probability distribution and actually shouldn't draw out there I should draw through the half because sine squared over two averages to one half Arcite sine squared averages to one half over many periods so what we see is that the classical probability distribution constant does arise when we look at very high energy states cool but it is manifestly not a good description the classical description is not a good description your intuition is crappy at low energies near the ground state where quantum effects are dominating because indeed classically there was no minimum energy quantum effects have to be dominating there and here we see that even the probability distribution is radically different than our intuition yeah

**[26:11]:** we keep working on it so so I want you all to think about what you're not gonna promise you unless you've already seen some quantum mechanics you're not gonna be able to answer this question now but I want you to have it as an uncomfortable little piece of sand in the back of your oyster mind you know what no offense what what what what is causing that zero why are we getting zero and I'll give you a hint in quantum mechanics any time something interesting happens it's because of superposition and interference all right so with all that said so any questions now over this story about energy eigenfunctions expanding into bases etc before we get moving no okay in that case get out your clickers we're going to test your knowledge Oh

**[27:17]:** channel 41 for those of you who have to adjust it

**[27:31]:** Wow

**[27:36]:** that's kind of worrying

**[27:42]:** aha

**[27:57]:** okay ready okay channel 41 and here we go

**[28:10]:** oops

**[28:16]:** okay so go ahead and start now sorry there was a little technical glitch there so so I'm going to cite or eigenstates they're non degenerate meaning the energies are different is a superposition so i1 plus i2 also an eigenstate

**[28:43]:** all right four more seconds all right I want everyone to turn to the person next to you and discuss this you've got about 30 seconds to discuss or a minute

**[29:06]:** possibly yet

**[29:16]:** this is it

**[29:29]:** I'm not sure the

**[29:39]:** all right yeah all right now I want everyone now that you've got an answer click again put in your current best guess oh wait sorry for some reason it's I have to start over again okay now click

**[30:02]:** this is the best I'm such a convert to clickers this is just fantastic so you guys went from okay so roughly y'all went from about thirty sixty ten to what are we now eight eight and end eighty-two and ten so it sounds like you guys are predicting answer B and the answer is I like the suspense there we go be good so so here's a quick question so it does anyone want to defend so why and the reason why is that if we have e on psy 1 plus I 2 this is equal to e on psy 1 + E on sigh - operator operator operator but this is equal to e 1 sy 1 plus E - psy - which is not if you want to need two are not equal which is not equal to e times so I want plus I 2 right not equal to e anything times I 1 plus I 2 and it needs to be in order to be an eigenfunction an eigenfunction of

**[31:17]:** the energy operator so yeah

**[31:26]:** does this only happen yeah okay that's a really good question so first off how do you measure an energy do you ever measure an energy let me more feel like do you ever measure a voltage the actual value of the scalar potential the electromagnetic scalar potential no you measure a difference do you ever measure the energy no you measure a difference in energy so the absolute value of energy is sort of a silly thing do you but we always talk about it as if it's not we said it's got energy 14 it's a little bit suspicious so to answer your question there's nothing hallowed about the number zero although we will often refer to zero energy with a very specific meaning what we really mean in that case is the value of the potential energy at infinity okay so when I say like energy usually what I mean is relative to the value infinity so

**[32:12]:** then let me ask your question again your question is is it possible to have energy 0 absolutely and we'll see that and it's actually gonna be really interesting what's true of states with energy 0 in that sense second part of your question though is how does energy being 0 fit into this well does that save us suppose one of the energies is zero then that says the EON sign 1 plus I 2 is equal to let's say e 2 is 0 well that term is gone so there's just the 1 e 1 are we an energy eigenstate no because it's still not over the form e times I 1 plus I 2 so it doesn't save us but it's an interesting question for the future all right next question for parts

**[33:06]:** so the question says X and P can you tie h-bar we've shown this is px equal to IH bar and is IP plus CX the same as CX plus IP

**[33:26]:** okay if you're really unsure you can ask the person next to you but you don't have to okay so this is looking good so everyone have an answer in you know

**[33:48]:** okay five four three two one okay good so ah the answer is C which most of you got but not everyone a bunch of you put D so let's talk through it so if X so remember what the definition of the commutator is X with P by definition is equal to X P minus P X if we change the order here P X is equal to minus this px minus X P okay it's just the definition of the commutator so on the other hand if you add things does 7 plus 6 equals 6 plus 7 yeah well of course 6 times 7 is 7 times 6 so that's not a terribly good analogy do operators do that do they does the map this is the order of addition of operators matter no so yeah yeah exactly exactly so it's slightly sneaky ok next question okay this one has five

**[34:54]:** ok F and G are both wave functions C is a constant then if we take the inner product C times F with G this is equal to what

**[35:20]:** three two one okay so the answer is so this one there's okay this one definitely discuss discuss with the person next year

**[35:54]:** all right and okay go ahead and enter your guess again or your answer again let it not be a guess okay ten seconds Wow okay fantastic that worked like a champ so what's the answer yes complex conjugation don't screw that one out it's very easy to forget but it matters a lot okay

**[36:27]:** cursor keeps disappearing okay next one a wavefunction sorry a

**[36:38]:** wavefunction has been expressed as sum of energy eigenfunctions here I'm calling the EU rather than Phi but same thing compared to the original wave function the set of coefficients given that we're using the energy basis the set of coefficients contains more or less the same information or it can be determined

**[36:59]:** okay five seconds

**[37:06]:** all right and the answer is C great okay next one so right now we're normalizing

**[37:21]:** okay all stationary states are all energy eigenstates have the form that spatial and time dependence is a spatial dependence the energy eigenfunction times the phase so that the norm squared is time independent consider the sum of two non degenerate energy eigenstates so I went in situ non degenerate means they're not energy they have different energies is the wavefunction stationary is a probability distribution time independent or is it time dependent

**[38:00]:** this one's this one's not trivial oh shoot I forgot to get it started sorry it's particularly untrue you can tend to your answer right so go ahead and enter your enter your answer

**[38:17]:** yeah this one always kills people

**[38:30]:** no chatting just yeah test yourself not your neighbor

**[38:37]:** you know it's fine to look deep into your soul don't look deep into the soul of the person sitting next to you

**[38:45]:** all right so at this point chat with your neighbor okay let me just let me just give you some presage the the pairwise strategy is probably not so good because about half of you got it right in about a half of you got it wrong so

**[40:06]:** all right let's uh let's vote again woods and hold on starting now okay vote again you've got ten seconds to enter a vote

**[40:23]:** Wow okay two seconds good so the distribution on this one went from thirty fifty twenty initially to now it is 1080 and ten amazingly you guys got worse the answer is C and I want you two to discuss with each other why it's C

**[41:27]:** all right so so let me talk you through it so the wavefunction we've said sine X and T is equal to u sine 1 or Phi 1 at X e to the minus I Omega 1 T and plus Phi 2 of X e to the minus I Omega 2 T all right so great we take the norm squared what's the probability to find it at X at time T the probability density the norm squared of this guy size squared which is equal to Phi 1 complex conjugate e to the plus I Omega 1 T plus Phi 2 complex conjugate e to the plus I Omega 2 T times the thing itself Phi 1 of X e to the minus I Omega 1 T plus Phi 2 of X e to the minus I Omega 2 T right and so this has four terms the first term is sy 1 norm squared the phases cancel right

**[42:30]:** you're going to see this happen a billion times in 804 the first term is going to be fine one norm squared there's another term which is Phi 2 norm squared again the phase is exactly cancel you do the minus I Omega 2 T to the plus I Omega 2 T plus Phi 2 squared but then there are two cross terms the interference terms plus Phi one complex conjugate Phi 2 e to the I Omega 1t e to the plus I Omega 1t I Omega 1 T and e to the minus I Omega 2 t minus Omega 2 so we have a cross term which depends on the difference in frequencies frequencies are like energies module and h-bar so it's the difference in energies and then there's another term which is the complex conjugate of this guy Phi 2 star times Phi 1 Phi 2 complex conjugate Phi 1 and the phases are also the Comets

**[43:17]:** conjugate to the minus I Omega 1 minus Omega 2 T of X of X of X of X so is there time dependence in this in principle yeah absolutely from the interference terms were we not in the superposition we would not have the interference terms time dependence comes from interference when we expand in energy functions cool however can these vanish when sorry Sagan great so when Omega 1 equals Omega 2 what happens time dependence goes away but eat obey gowanni is e 1 over H bar Omega 2 is e 2 over H bar we started out by saying these are non degenerate so if they're non degenerate the energy is a difference the frequencies are different so that doesn't help us how do we kill this time dependence yes if the two functions aren't just orthogonal in a functional sense but if we have the following suppose Phi 1 is like this it's zero everywhere

**[44:19]:** except for in some lump that's by 1 and Phi 2 is zero everywhere except here then any where Phi 1 is a nonzero Phi 2 is zero and anywhere where Phi 2 is nonzero Phi 1 is zero so this can point-wise vanish do you expect this to happen generically does it happen for the energy eigenfunctions in the infinite square well

**[44:44]:** sine waves now some of the Rodino they have zero it isolated points right there nonzero generically yeah so it doesn't work there what about for the free particle well those are just plain waves does that ever happen no okay so this is an incredibly special case we'll actually see it in one problem on a problem set later on a very special case so technically the answer is C and I want you guys keep your minds open on these sorts of questions when does the spatial dependence matter and when are there interference terms is there two different questions I want you to tease them apart okay cool yeah

**[45:34]:** that's a very good way to think about it that's exactly right so you've got an overall fit so let me that's a very very good question so the question can you let me let me say that subtly differently and tell me if this agrees with what you were just saying so look I can look at this wavefunction and I already know that the overall phase of wave function doesn't matter that's what it is to say stationary state is stationary is got an overall phase that's the only thing that norm squared it goes away so I can write this as e to the minus I Omega 1 T times Phi 1 of X plus Phi 2 of X e to the minus I Omega 2 minus Omega 1t is that what you mean so that's one way we could do this we could also do something else where you do e to the minus I Omega

**[46:19]:** 1 plus Omega 2 upon 2 T this is more I think what you were thinking of a sort of average frequency and then a relative frequency and then the change in the frequencies on these two terms absolutely so you can organize this in many many ways but the important thing is that your question gets at a very important point which is that the overall phase doesn't matter but relative phases in a superposition do matter so when does a phase matter in a wave function it does not matter if it's an overall phase but it does matter if it's a relative phase between terms in a superposition cool very good question other questions if not then I have some so consider a system which is in the state oh so I should give you five system is in a state which is a linear combination of N equals 1 and N equals 2 eigen States what's

**[47:17]:** the probability that measurement will give us energy e1 and it's in this superposition

**[47:27]:** okay five seconds

**[47:33]:** okay fantastic what's the answer yes see great okay everyone got that one so this one's a slightly this one's a more interesting question suppose I have an infinite well with width L

**[47:54]:** how does the energy the ground state energy compared to that of a system with a wider well

**[48:15]:** so L versus a larger L okay four seconds okay quickly discuss it amongst yourselves wait ten seconds

**[48:44]:** all right now click again yeah

**[48:55]:** all right 5 seconds 1 2 3 4 5 great ok the answer is a-ok great you because the energy of the infinite well goes like K squared K goes like 1 over L ok so the energy is if we make it wider the energy if we make it wider is going to be lower

**[49:25]:** and last couple of questions ok so at t equals 0 could the wave function for an electron in an infinite square well of with a rather than L be a sine squared of pi X upon a where a suitably chosen to be normalized

**[50:10]:** all right we've got about 5 seconds left and ok we are at chance we are even odds and the answer is not a superposition of a and B so I encourage you to discuss with the people around you

**[50:48]:** yeah great what properties had it better satisfy in order to you know be a viable way functional what properties should the wavefunction have so that it's reasonable yeah is is your at the ends good is it smooth yeah exactly and so you can write it as a superposition excellent so the answer is yeah

**[51:17]:** all right um vote again okay go I might have missed a few people so go ahead and start yeah okay five more seconds all right so we went from fifty fifty to seventy seven twenty three that's pretty good what's the answer eh why is this an energy eigenstate does that matter no what properties had this wave function better satisfied to be a reasonable wave function in this potential say again it's got to vanish at the walls it's got to satisfy the boundary conditions what else must be true of this wave function normalizable isn't normalizable yeah what else continuous is better not have any discontinuities is it continuous great okay is there any reason that this is a stupid wave function no it's perfectly reasonable it's not you know an energy eigenfunction but yeah cool yeah so right it is a superposition answer is like a ship or a time series yep

**[52:41]:** on this domain these are that and the signs are even right so this is actually odd but we're only looking at from zero to L right so I mean that half of it the signs are odd but we're only looking at the first peak so if you're just a well written that as cosine of the midpoint plus the distance for the midpoint cool this actually let me say that again because it's a it's a much better question than I just gave it shre if for so

**[53:09]:** so here's the question the question is look um this function in this business so sine is an odd function but sine squared is an even function so how can you expand sine squared and even function in terms of sines an odd function but this is we think about this physically here's sine squared in our domain and here's sine now what do you mean by even usually by even we mean reflection around zero but I could just as well have said reflection around the origin this potential is symmetric and the energy eigenfunctions are symmetric about the origin they're not symmetric about reflection around this point but they are symmetric about reflection around this point that's particularly natural place to call it zero so I was calling them signing so I was calling this here but I could have called a cosine if I called this zero cool for the same KX okay and indeed can we

**[53:56]:** expand this sine squared function in terms of a basis of these signs on the domain 0 to L absolutely very good question okay and lastly last clicker question oops River okay at equal 0 the particle is described by the wave function we just saw which is true the following which the Phong is true about the wave function at subsequent times

**[54:36]:** five seconds

**[54:41]:** oh okay in the last few seconds we had an explosive burst for a B and C so our current dissipation is eight sixteen ten and sixty-seven sounds like 67 is popular uh discuss quickly very quickly with the person next

**[55:12]:** okay and vote again

**[55:20]:** okay five seconds get your last vote in all right and the answer is D yeah okay and the reason is so let's think about the logic let's go through the logic here so as was pointed out by student up here earlier the wave function sine squared of PI X can be expanded in terms of the energy eigenfunction any reasonable function can be expanded in terms of a superposition of definite energy states of energy eigenfunctions so that means we can write sy at some time as a superposition CN sine of n PI X upon ei e to the minus I en T on H bar since those are in fact the eigenfunctions okay so we can do that now when we look at the time evolution we know that each term in that superposition involves with a phase the overall wave function does not evolve with a phase it is not an energy eigenstate there are going to be interference terms due to the

**[56:23]:** fact that it's a superposition so it's probability distribution is not time independent it is a superposition and so the wave function doesn't rotate by an overall phase however we can solve the Schrodinger equation as we did before the wave function is expanded at time 0 as the energy eigenfunctions time some set of coefficients and the time evolution corresponds to adding to each independent term in the superposition the appropriate phase for that energy eigenstate cool alright so the answer is D

**[57:00]:** and that's it for the clicker questions okay so any questions on the clicker aggression so far okay those are going to be posted on the website you can go over them and now back to energy eigenfunctions okay

**[57:23]:** so what I want to talk about now is the qualitative behavior of energy eigenfunctions suppose I know I have an energy eigenfunction what can I say generally about its structure so

**[57:38]:** let me ask the question qualitative behavior

**[57:46]:** so suppose that one hands you a potential U of X someone hands you some protection potential U of X and says you know look I've got this potential and maybe I'll draw it for you it's got some Wiggles and then a big wiggle and then it's got a big wiggle and then we won't do that yeah let's do that and the big wiggle and something like this and someone shows you this potential and they say look what are the energy eigenfunctions right well okay free particle was easy the infinite square well is easy we could solve that analytically but nets involve solving a differential equation so what differential equation is this going to lead us to well we know that the energy eigenvalue equation is minus H bar squared upon 2m v prime prime of X plus U of X 5x so that's the energy operator acting on Phi is equal to saying that it's

**[58:42]:** an energy eigenvalue says that started that it's an energy eigenfunction phi sub e says that it's equal to the energy operator acting on this eigenfunction is just a constant e phi so P of X and I'm going to work at moment in time so we're not going to drop all the T dependence for the moment so this is a differential equation we need to solve where u of X is this god-awful function right do you think it's very likely that you're going to be able to solve this analytically yeah probably not however some basic some basic ideas will help you get an intuition for what the wave function should look like and so and this is I cannot overstate the importance of being able to eyeball a system and guess the qualitative features of its wave functions because they that that intuition that ability to estimate is going to contain an awful lot of physics

**[59:34]:** so let's try to extract it so in order to do so I want to start by massaging this equation into a form which is particularly convenient so meticulous equation as Phi sub e prime prime so what I'm going to do is I'm going to take this term I'm going to notice this is two derivatives this has no derivatives S has no derivatives and I mean a move these this term over here and combine these terms into E minus U of X and I'm going to divide each side by 2m upon H bar squared with a minus sign giving me that v prime prime of e of X upon Phi e of X dividing through by this phi e is equal to minus 2m over H bar squared and let's just get our signs right we've got the minus from here so this is going to be e minus U of X

**[1:00:30]:** okay so you might look at that and think well why is that any better than what I've just written down but what is the second derivative of a function it's telling you not its slope but it's telling you how the slope changes right it's telling you about the curvature of the function and what this is telling me is something very very useful if I know so for example let's look at the function let's assume that the function is real although we know in general it's not well let's assume that the function is real for simplicity so we're going to plot the real part of Phi okay the vertical axis and this is X suppose the real part of Phi is positive okay at some point Phi prime prime if it's positive tells us that not only is the slope positive its increasing or no it doesn't tell us anything about somebody tell us whatever the

**[1:01:22]:** slope it's increasing if it's negative the slope is increasing as we increase X if it's positive its increasing as we increase X so it's telling us that the wave function looks like this locally yeah something like that if Phi is negative okay if I is negative then if this quantity is positive then Phi prime problem has to be negative but negative is curving down

**[1:01:49]:** so if this quantity which I will call the curvature if this quantity is positive it curves away from the axis so this is Phi prime prime over Phi greater than zero if this quantity is positive the wave function or the function curves away from the axis cool if this quantity is negative five prime prime upon Phi less than zero exactly the opposite this has to be negative if Phi is positive then Phi prime prime has to be negative it has to be curving down yeah and similarly if we're if Phi is negative then Phi prime prime has to be positive and it has to curve up so if this quantity is positive if the curvature is positive it curves away from the axis if the curvature is negative if this quantity is negative it curves towards the axis so what does that tell you about solution when the curvature is positive or negative tells you

**[1:02:49]:** the following it tells you that imagine we have a function where Phi prime prime over Phi is constant okay and in particular let's let Phi prime prime over Phi be a constant which is positive or sorry yeah let's say positive and I'll call that positive constant a constant Kappa squared and to emphasize that it's positive I'm going to call it Kappa squared this is a positive thing it's a real number squared okay what does the solution look like

**[1:03:21]:** well this quantity is positive if it's always give me curving away so we have solutions that look like this or solutions that look like this can it ever be zero yeah sure it could be an inflection point so for example here the curvature is positive but at this point the curvature has to switch to be like this what functions are of this form let me give you another hint here's one is this curvature positive yes what about this one yep those are all positive curvature and these are Exponential's and the solution to this differential equation is e to the plus e to the plus Kappa X or e to the minus Kappa X and an arbitrary solution of this equation is a superposition a e to the Kappa X plus B e to the minus capex everyone call that when this quantity is positive we get

**[1:04:17]:** growing and collapsing Exponential's yeah on the other hand if Phi prime prime over Phi is negative number ie - what I'll call K squared then the curvature has to be negative and what functions have everywhere negative curvature sinusoidal z-- cool and the general solution is a e to the I KX plus B e to the minus ikx so that differential equation also we're going to sign in co-sign cool so

**[1:05:15]:** putting that together with our original function let's bring this up so you want to think about the wave functions here but in order to think about the energy eigenstates we need to decide on an energy we need to pick an energy because you can't find the solution without fit in the Ender but notice something nice here so suppose the energy is e and let me just draw e this is a constant the energy is this this is a value here were drawing potential the function value potential this is the value of the energy just a constant it's just a number if you had a classical particle moving in this potential what would happen it would roll around so for example say you gave it this energy by putting it here and think of this as a gravitational potential you put it here you let go and it falls down it'll keep rolling until it gets

**[1:06:07]:** up here to the classical turning point and at that point its kinetic energy must be zero because potential energy is a total energy at which point it will turn around and fall back yes if you take your ball and you put it here you let it roll does it ever get here to this position no because doesn't have enough energy right classically this is a forbidden position so given an energy and given a potential we can break the system up into classically allowed zones and classically forbidden zones

**[1:06:44]:** cool now in a classically allowed zone the energy is greater than the potential and classically forbidden zone the energy is less than the potential let me call that but this tells us something really nice if the energy is greater than the potential what do you know about the curvature

**[1:07:14]:** yeah if we're in a classically allowed zone so the energy is greater than the potential then this quantity is positive there's a minus sign here so this is negative so the curvature is negative remember curvature is negative means that we curve towards the axis so in a classically allowed reason the wave function should be sinusoidal

**[1:07:42]:** what about in the classically forbidden regions in the classically forbidden regions the energy is less than the potential that means a magnitude this is less than this this is negative number minus sign the curvature is going to be minus times the - as a positive so the curvature is positive so the solutions are either growing Exponential's or shrinking Exponential's or superpositions of them and recall that so let's think about a simple example let's work through this in a simple example now let me give you a little bit more board space simple example would be a potential that looks like this okay and let's just suppose that we want to find an energy eigenfunction with energy that's e well this is a classically allowed zone and these are the classically forbidden regions now I want to ask what is the wave function look like and I don't want to draw it on top of the energy diagram because wave function is not an energy wave function is a different quantity so

**[1:08:50]:** it's got different axes and it one draw in a different plot so but as a function of X so just to get the position straight there is these are the bounds of the classically allowed and forbidden regions what do we expect well we expect that it's going to be sinusoidal in here we expected it's going to be exponential growing or converging out here X right but one last important thing is that not only is the curvature negative in here in these classically allowed region but the the magnitude of the curvature how rapidly it's turning over how big that second derivative is depends on the difference between the energy and the potential the greater the difference the more rapid the curvature the more rapid de turning over and fluctuation if the difference in between the potential and the true energy the total energy is small then the curvature is very small so the derivative changes very

**[1:09:47]:** gradually what does that tell us that tells us that in here the wave function is oscillating rapidly because of curvature the difference between e energy in the potential is large and so the wave function is oscillating rapidly as we get out towards the classical turning point the wave function will be oscillating less rapidly the slope will be changing more gradually and as a consequence two things happen we actually draw this slowly differently

**[1:10:16]:** so as a consequence two things happen one is the wavelength gets longer because the curvature is smaller and the second is the amplitude gets larger because it keeps on having a positive slope for longer and longer and it takes longer to curve back down so here we have rapid oscillations and then the oscillations get longer and longer wavelengths

**[1:10:40]:** until we get out to the classical turning point and at this point what happens yeah it's got to be exponential is now here we have some sign at some super positions of sine and cosines Exponential's and a particular it arrives here with some slope and with some value we know on this side we've got to get Exponential's and so this sum of sines and cosines at this point must match that sum of Exponential's how must it do so what must be true of the wave function at this point can it be discontinuous can its derivative be discontinuous no so it's do it the value and the derivative must be continuous so that tells us precisely which linear combination of positive growing and shrinking Exponential's we get so we'll get some linear combination which may do this for a while but since it's got some contribution of positive exponential it'll just grow exponentially off to infinity

**[1:11:36]:** and as the energy gets further and further away from the potential now in the negative sign what happens to the rate of growth it gets more and more rapid so this just diverges more and more rapidly similarly out here we have to match the slope and we know that the curvature has to be now positive so it has to do this so two questions first off is this sketch of the wave function a reasonable sketch given what we know about curvature and this potential of a wave function with that energy are there ways in which it's a bad estimate bed

**[1:12:18]:** okay excellent

**[1:12:24]:** absolutely could have crossed zero so I may have drawn this badly it turned out it was little subtle it's not obvious maybe it actually punched all the way through zero and then I diverge down negative that's absolutely positive so that was one of the quibbles you could have another quibble you could have is that it looks like I have constant wavelength in here but the potential is actually changing and the what you should chalk this up to if you'll pardon the pun is my artistic skills are limited okay so this is always going to be sort of inescapable that it's when you qualitatively draw something you know on a test I'm not going to value points on things like that that's what I want to emphasize but the second thing is there something bad about this wavefunction yes you've already named it what's bad about this wavefunction it's badly non-normalizable right it diverges off to

**[1:13:04]:** infinity out here and out here what does that tell you it's not physical good what else does it tell you about the system sorry excellent is this an allowable energy no if the wavefunction has this energy it is impossible to make it continuous assuming that I drew it correctly and have it converge is this wavefunction allowable no because it does not satisfy our boundary conditions our boundary conditions are that the wave function must vanish out here and it must vanish out here at infinity in order to be normalizable here we failed now you can imagine that so let's decrease the energy a little bit if we decrease the energy that we are trial energy just a little tiny bit what happens well that's going to decrease the curvature in here right we decrease bring the energy in just a little tiny bit that means this is a little bit smaller the potential stays the same so the curvature in the allowed region is just a little tiny bit smaller and meanwhile the allowed region has got just a little

**[1:14:11]:** bit thinner and what that will do is the curvature is a little less the region is a little less so now we have

**[1:14:23]:** oops sorry

**[1:14:28]:** get excited and if we if we tweak the energy what's going to happen what's going to right here a little bit sooner and let's imagine it's something like this and if we chose the energy just right we would get it to match to a linear combination of collapsing and growing Exponential's where the contribution from the growing exponential in this direction vanishes right there's precisely one value of the energy that lets me do that with this number of wiggles and so then it goes through and does its thing and we need it to happen on both sides now if I take that solution so that it achieves convergence out here and it achieves convergence out here and I take that energy and they increase it by epsilon by just the tiniest little bit what will happen to this wave function it will diverge it will no longer be normalizable when you have classically forbidden regions are the allowed energies continuous or discrete and that answers a question from earlier

**[1:15:37]:** in the semester Murli ER in the class and it also is going to be the beginning of the answer to the question why is this spectrum of hydrogen discrete see you next time

**[1:15:49]:** you
