Transcript

The first time that I personally experienced that there big differences between the working lives of men and women was when I was pregnant with my first child. Back then, I was doing research on gender equality and well-being. So, I was very well aware that there are big differences for men and women in terms of the gender pay gap. There's big underrepresentation of women in boardrooms, and also in families where both partners work, it's still the women that do most of the housework. So, in other words, I was a social scientist pregnant, and I was sort of the perfect case study for my own research.

The research that I was doing back then with my colleague looked at how people define quality of life for themselves. So, the questionnaires was asked, "What's important for your own quality of life?" And people often would mention things like their health, their income, friends, happiness, their family, their employment, things like that. However, what people mention what's important for their quality of life somewhat changes when they become parents. So, after people become parents for the first time, they're more likely to mention that family's important for their quality of life. At the same time, they're less likely to mention their friends and their finances and their employment.

Now, before you become a parent, you might not realize your priorities in life might change like this. Personally, I myself thought that my career aspirations would remain fairly constant once I have children, and I think most women do this. I thought that having children would have only a very modest impact on my career. After all, I had ambition and enthusiasm for my work. I had a fairly decent CV, a nice husband with very egalitarian views. So, how would children possibly impact my career? Well, I realize now that was a very naive point of view because children definitely will impact your life in many ways, and some of them definitely unexpected.

Overall, when we ask parents about children and their lives, you can see that after people have children for the first time, they will report that they have more of a sense of purpose and meaning in their life. But children impact their parents' lives in many different ways. So, most of you, even if you don't have children, you probably have heard of newborns not letting their parents sleep. Well, sleep deprivation and also fighting over who will change the next diaper is not really good for maintaining nice relationships. So, very often marital satisfaction goes down after people have children for the first time.

Parents have to reconcile their new identities as mothers and fathers. This often also means that they have to renegotiate at home who will work and who will do the housework and who will do the child care. In many countries, having children will be quite a big impact on your finances. Either one of the parents, usually the mothers, quits their job and takes care of the children, or parents have to pay for some sort of formal child care, which in many countries is quite expensive, not necessarily subsidized. Or maybe they're lucky enough and have free care from family member. But financial satisfaction is also often negatively impacted by having children.

Another area of life where children can really have a negative impact is when we talk about leisure time. So, quite often the realities of taking care of a small child will leave parents less time for their hobbies and their friends. Now, one I'm one area that I'm quite interested in is the employment area, and this is where children have a big impact on the work life for women. Now, why do I focus on women here? Well, of course, children might also have an impact on the employment and behavior of their fathers. But in most societies and most Western societies today, it is still the woman who will mostly cut back on her work.

This might be in the form of taking time term off to take care of the newborn, or she might cut back hours to work part-time, or completely drop out of the labor force. So, yes, let me just persuade you that it's mostly the woman who does take care of the children. Here, these are the results from a survey that was then conducted in 2004 across Europe, and I look with my colleague here at the percentage of dual-earner couples across a few countries. So, what you can see here that, well, since we're in Germany today, for example, in Germany in households where people don't have children yet, about 60% of those households are dual-earner couples.

And dual-earner couple means that both partners work more than 30 hours a week. Now, when there are children under the age of five in those households, this percentage drops quite a lot. There's also a big drop in dual-earner couples in the UK when people become parents. And now, when you look at France, there's much less of a drop. So, for French women, it's more normal to go back full-time when they have small children. But even if both parents work full-time, in most cases today, it's still the case that it's the woman who will take care of most of the household tasks and the child care. This is what sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild called the second shift.

So, the idea here is that women go to their work, often full-time, come back home, and then what then they will then take care of dinner, take care of the children, bring them to bed. I personally So, you can see that quite often the impact on work lives is really concerning women. Actually, I found on a personal level that the question of if and when to return to work after you have children is one where women are very good at judging each other. When I was on maternity leave with my first child, my son, quite often people would ask me about my plans for maternity leave. And then after saying what my husband and I had decided to do, quite often the question the person who asked me, usually a woman, would tell me about her own point of view.

So, one woman, for example, told me that she thought that staying home with a small child was incredibly boring. So, she just couldn't wait to get back to intellectual work. Another woman told me that she could not imagine going back to work because she couldn't imagine having strangers take care of her baby. So, although these comments and questions might be very well-intentioned, they certainly can make a new mother feel pretty guilty about her choices. Either she will feel guilty because she's neglecting her career and that's wasting what economists would say her human capital, or she feels guilty because she's potentially neglecting her baby.

But our opinions on what we consider is is appropriate for women and working when they have children depends to large extent actually on the culture that we're growing up in. So, this very cute little boy is my own little bundle of joy, and as you may guess from this picture, he's the result of a German-French collaboration. Well, I'm German, my husband is French, and we live in the UK. So, certainly when we discussed our child care arrangements, we were quite influenced by our own upbringing. So, I grew up in West Germany, and my mother, like most West German women in the middle class in her generation, did not work when she had children.

My husband's mother, on the other hand, in France had three children and always worked. And this was quite normal back then and is also quite normal today. Of course, things in Germany have changed. Now, you have a lot more mothers returning to work when they have children. But still, as I showed you earlier, in France, it's still more common that both parents work full-time once there are children in the household. But not only cultural preferences determine whether women return to work after they have children or not. Also, policy makers can influence those decisions. For example, whether a woman returns to work work and when depends quite a bit on the availability availability and cost of child care.

So, when a country offers high-quality child care that's maybe subsidized and affordable for parents, it's a lot easier for parents to actually work and combine child care with it. So, what's needed is really child care that's high-quality and parents can trust. Also, another important aspect is the length and the pay of parental leave. Of course, many families will need two incomes, and thus it might not always be a choice whether a woman stays home. But what we also found in our research that there are also other personal factors at play. So, one thing we looked at was women's job satisfaction before they have children.

And what we can see that women who are quite happy with their jobs before they have children, those are women that are more likely to return earlier to their jobs. So, for women that really didn't like their jobs, they might return later or they don't return. Another thing that's important for women's careers and maintaining career is whether their husbands, their partners, can work flexibly. So, in one study my students is conducting, we saw that women who have husbands who can be quite flexible in their own jobs, they perceive their careers to progress much better than other women do. And men's ability to be flexible in jobs, if they're able to do it, but also their willingness to contribute to household chores is quite important for families' work-life balance.

The opposite of work-life balance is work-life conflict or work-family conflict, and this might be describing actually a bit better what a lot of parents experience when they have children. So, we did a We did a study about work-life conflict in several European countries, and one of the really interesting findings we had there was that men who actually contribute more equally to household tasks report much lower levels of work-life conflict than men who let the women do all the work at home. So, this may sound a little bit counterintuitive or intuitive, but actually what we think is happening here is that one measure of work-life conflict is whether the partner complains.

And, well, if men don't really help in the household, they might receive a lot of complaints from their partners. So, this is my news my favorite newspaper headline that this study generated. So, this suggests that the prescription for men to have good work-life balance is to please do the dishes. Now, a lot of women try to achieve good work-life balance by working part-time, and does this actually work? Well, what we found in a study looking at seven European countries that indeed women who work part-time reported that they have lower levels of work-family conflict than women who work full-time or men.

But, although now in many countries women have the right to request part-time, there is just the right to request part-time. It's not necessarily that will be granted it. So, the employer has to consider their request. But, for many women that means they don't get the request granted, and if they really want to work part-time after having children, they might have to look for a new job. So, this can be problematic because quite often part-time employment is associated with lower hourly wages, also less opportunities for promotions, and quite often with lower skill levels. Now, what does this mean for women?

It can might mean a real downgrading in their jobs when they go and look for other part-time employment. So, this might then also have long-term financial consequences for her cuz if she now makes considerably less money per hour than she did in the previous job, then there will be not only more financial inequality in the couple, but also the woman will pay less into pensions and then have lower pensions later on. So, there might be long-term consequences of this. Now, what can policies do about this? Well, offering parental leave instead of just maternity leave might be a good way to let women and men balance their housework, their family life in better ways.

So, no matter in which country you leave, how satisfied parents are in certain areas of life depends to quite a large extent on how well they balance their paid work, their domestic tasks, and their child care. I don't want to ignore the large number of families and single parents that raise children on their own, but if both parents are present in a family, then the question of who does the paid work and who does the child care should not just be addressed to one person, but to both parents. This is a picture of my daughter when she was just learning to sit. So, you may guess from this picture here that she has a real can-do attitude, and my husband and I we like to joke that one day she'll be leading a large company.

But, no matter what her career choices may be, I just hope that if and when she decides to have children one day, that people will not judge her based on her decisions that she will make about her family and her work life. I actually hope that my my son and my daughter will receive exactly the same question when they announce that they will become parents, and this would really just simply be, "So, what do you and your partner decide to do about parental leave?" Thank you very much. Thank you very

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

Mothers, work and well-being | Anke Plagnol | TEDxBerlin