# 6. Costs

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSYNHb6YBEE
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/TSYNHb6YBEE

## Chapters

- 0:12 — Chapter 1 (0:12)
- 8:31 — Chapter 2 (8:31)
- 16:34 — Chapter 3 (16:34)
- 24:53 — Chapter 4 (24:53)
- 30:15 — Chapter 5 (30:15)
- 39:42 — Chapter 6 (39:42)
- 42:17 — Chapter 7 (42:17)

## Transcript

**[0:12]:** All right, why don't we get started? Um today we're going to continue our discussion of producer theory. Once again, to remember to put this in context, we the first few lectures were working consumer theory to help us derive a demand curve. Now working on producer theory to help us come up with supply curve. Uh we started last time by talking about how producers profit maximize. And the profit maximization implies cost minimization. Uh that if you want to maximize profits, you're going to want to produce as efficiently as possible. And basically to do that we need to understand how your costs vary with your output. If you're going to produce at an efficient level you need to understand how what your costs are are going to vary with your level of production. So essentially our goal of this lecture is to develop a cost curve. Develop a curve which tells you how the cost of your production varies with how much you produce.

**[1:10]:** And that's what we're after in this lecture. Okay? So we're going to start in the short with the short run and then turn to the long run. So start with developing a short run cost curve and then turn to the long run. Okay? And to make this lecture sort of mathematically coherent throughout the whole lecture we'll work with our favorite functional form, a production form of the function Q equals the square root of L times K. Remember, firms produce goods, little Q using two inputs, labor and capital. Labor is a variable input, that means you can change it in the short run and the long run. Capital is a fixed input which means that you can only change it in the long run. Okay? So in the short run we're going to have two kinds of costs. We're going to have fixed costs which are going to come from a fixed level of capital.

**[2:01]:** And we're going to have variable costs. We're going to have to come from our labor. So we're going to have two kinds of costs. Fixed costs, they're fixed cuz in the short run you can't change the level of capital and variable costs which are the costs of our labor of labor. And then we're going to have total costs are simply going to be fixed costs plus variable costs. Okay? So that's what we're thinking about costs. Think about any the cost of a firm's production in the short run is the sum of their fixed costs I either capital costs and the variable costs I either labor costs. Now, we're going to show you how you can turn a production function into a cost function. And to do so you simply need to recognize that costs the cost of firm's production are simply the amount of capital it uses, K bar, times the price of that capital which we'll call R plus the amount of

**[2:59]:** labor it uses times the price of that labor which we'll call W or the wage. Okay? This is the easy part. Think of the amount of hours of work you use times the wage per hour or the amount of workers times the salary per year. In any case, this is easy to understand. Every additional unit of labor comes with the cost that is the wage of that unit of labor. So think about an hourly model, every hour you work at your convenience store, they have to pay you the minimum wage for that hour. Okay, that's the cost of that hour of labor. Capital's harder. We call R the rental rate. And the reason is because we don't think of don't think of buying capital. Don't think of buying a machine. Think of renting a machine. The reason we do that is to make the periodicity work.

**[3:45]:** Okay? You don't buy a worker, thank God. You rent that worker and you rent that worker at a at a price W. So when the firm uses your time, they're renting your time an hour at a time at a price W. When we get machines, think of a firm as renting machines for a price R per machine per time period. Okay? So I understand firms usually don't do this. They usually buy machines and we'll come back to even if you buy a machine, how it effectively is like renting it. But for ease of thinking about this, we want to think about flows not stocks. So you have the firm's decision as renting a worker at the price wage at the price W or renting a machine the price R. Yeah. Can I like also be considered like the gas or electricity a machine can use it?

**[4:30]:** It it All that would be in there and we'll come back to that. That's right. This is a This is sort of the per period cost of using a machine. This is the per period cost of using a worker is the wage. This is the per period cost of using a machine which will include all the costs of running the machine as well as the cost of renting the machine itself. Okay? So later we'll talk about how if you own the machine and we'll we'll come back to the fact that you can actually this R representation is not bad. But for now just think of renting a machine or if it's a building, think of this as the year as the rent you pay on that building. Okay? Not the cost of building the building the building. Now, armed with our production function okay? And let's also say to make life easy, uh I did this wrong in my notes, so I hope my the other teachers figured it out.

**[5:18]:** Uh to make life easy let's say let's say that the rental rate R we're going to say is $10 and the wage rate W is going to be $5. Okay? Now armed with a production function if you simply have the production function and these two prices, you can derive the short run cost function. How do you do that? Well, just look at the math. We know that Q equals square root of L times K bar. Okay, in the short run. L times K bar. Okay? So inverting that simply means that L equals Q squared over K bar.

**[6:06]:** L equals Q Q squared over K bar. Okay? And that means that costs can be written costs can be written as 10 K bar the price the rental rate is 10. We have K bar amount of capital. Plus 5 Q squared over K bar. Okay, that's our cost function. Okay, I just plugged in for L and then I multiply I plugged that in for L and multiplied by the wage rate W which is five. Okay? So for example, for a fixed level of capital, this is cost. So for example, let's imagine our short run level of capital is one. Let's imagine we have one unit of capital in the short run just to make the math easy. Then that simply says that cost equals 10 plus 5 Q squared. And that's our cost function. 10 plus 5 Q squared. We've just derived the short run cost function.

**[7:13]:** 10 is the fixed cost component. That doesn't vary with the amount you produce. So there's no Q part of this. 5 Q squared is the variable component. That varies with how much you produce. So the cost function has a fixed part which comes from the fact of one fixed unit of capital. And a variable part which comes from the fact that the amount of Q that the amount of Q drives the amount of labor we need. Okay? Questions about that math. All right. Now, armed with this cost function, let's write that down again up here. So C equals 10 plus 5 Q K C equals 10 plus 5 Q squared. Okay, that's going to be our short run cost function we're going to work with. And remember, that short run cost function came directly from that production function. To derive this equation all I needed was that production function and those two prices.

**[8:06]:** And I derived this. Okay? Armed with that okay? We can define some of the key concepts that will drive our entire analysis of firms. And the single most important concept is marginal cost which is what it sounds like, the derivative of cost with respect to quantity. Okay? So in this the it's the marginal cost is delta C delta Q.

**[8:31]:** Okay? That's marginal cost. Okay? We'll also care about average cost which is just C over Q. Okay, it's very important in this class to keep our marginals different from our averages. The average is simply over the entire range of production. What was the average cost of producing each unit? The marginal is what's the cost of producing the next unit. And since production functions are non-linear, those will not be the same generally. Okay, average will not equal marginal in general because of non-linear function, delta C delta Q is not the same as C over Q. Okay? So we can actually graph these in figure 6.1. Figure 6.1 shows the cost curves for this cost function I just wrote down which comes from that production function. Okay? So you can see that the marginal cost as I said is delta C delta Q. Well, that's 10 Q.

**[9:28]:** So the marginal cost, the cost of producing the next unit rises with the number of units. Which makes sense. The cost has a Q squared term in it. So obviously the marginal cost is going to have a Q term in it. So basically the more you produce, the higher your marginal cost. The more units you produce, the more little Q, the higher your marginal cost. Average cost is this sort of funky shaped thing where it's which is 10 over Q plus 5 Q. I just divided this by Q. Okay? Where it's first declining and then increasing. Why is that? Why is average cost first declining and then increasing? What's the What just intuitively, why is that? Why in general in the short run would we expect that? Average cost first to fall and then increase. Anyone have ideas? Yeah.

**[10:25]:** Well, no, but it's falling first. So, why is it Why is it falling first? You're You're It's It's about that. Yeah. I think they're really high average or first fixed cost is not Right. the more you make, the lower that is. Right. The first units are paying off your fixed costs if you think about it. Well, the first units you sell, basically you start with this huge fixed cost. So, actually, by selling two units, yes, you get the variable cost second unit, but you get to pay off the fixed cost the first unit. So, look at here on this graph, we show average fixed costs and average variable costs. Average fixed costs are 10 over Q. If you only produce one unit, your average your average fixed cost is 10. You produce two units, it's five. With every unit you produce, your average fixed cost is falling.

**[11:06]:** You're paying off that fixed cost. Average variable cost rises. Every unit you produce, you're getting more and more variable cost. You put those together and you get a function that first declines and then rises. You first pay off your fixed costs, so your average costs are falling. Then your marginal cost Then you start to rise cuz you've got marginal costs that increase the quantity produced. And critically, the marginal cost intersects the average cost curve at the minimum of average cost. And that's just mathematical. Okay? If you have any function and you take the average, then the the minimum is going to be a derivative. Okay? That basically, before you get to here, 1.5 units, before 1.5 units, average cost is above marginal cost because you're paying off your fixed costs. Once you get beyond 1.5 units, average cost is below marginal cost. So, average cost hits marginal cost at the minimum average cost.

**[12:08]:** Yeah. Does that mean like a relatively large company eventually doesn't really have to worry about their fixed costs cuz like if they're having a lot more workers, their entire cost is going to be considered basically In the short run. It depends on this function. You said large, but large can be defined in two ways. But absolutely true. Certainly, if we take this very function, for large enough Qs, average fixed cost asymptotes to zero. Right? 10 over infinity is zero. So, for large enough Qs, the average fixed cost goes away. Okay? In the short run, remember we're in the short run with these fixed costs. Okay? Now, so other questions Good question. Other questions about that? So, that's our basic intuition the short run is that at first your costs are super high cuz you got to pay cuz you had to build the plant. Okay?

**[13:00]:** But then over time, that plant cost falls and then your only cost is based on the fact that you got to hire more workers if you want to produce more. Okay? Now, what we want to notice is that in the short run, there is a really close relationship. One of us the key relationship between marginal cost and the marginal product of labor, which we defined last time. Remember the marginal product of labor was dQdL. How much Remember digging a hole and diminishing marginal product that each additional worker for a fixed level of capital is less and less productive. Right? We talked about that last time. Well, the marginal cost of production is as I said equal to delta C over delta Q. Okay? Well, we know from last time that delta Q over delta L, we defined as the marginal product of labor. Right? Plugging those um and uh so, we know marginal cost is delta C delta Q.

**[14:05]:** Okay? And we can write this If you take the derivative of the cost function, so our general cost function up there, see the cost function at the top there? Take the derivative of that with respect to the amount of labor. Well, the first term drops out because it's fixed. So, you can rewrite delta C delta Q as W times delta L delta Q. Yeah. W times delta L delta Q. Right? I just rewrote delta C delta Q delta W God. It's brutal. Sorry, guys. W times delta L over delta Q. Okay? Little bit better. Okay, I read that cuz I just took the derivative of the cost function. Okay? First term drops out we take the derivative, second term I just took the derivative here or the discrete derivative. And I just said delta C delta Q is W times delta L delta Q. Well, we know the marginal product is delta Q delta over delta L.

**[15:04]:** So, we can rewrite marginal cost as W over the marginal product of labor. The marginal cost is equal to W over the marginal product of labor. And that makes sense. The marginal cost of the next unit will be higher the higher the wage and lower the more productive the worker. Making another unit with a super productive worker is cheap. Okay? Making another unit with a very unproductive worker is expensive. So, essentially, the more you pay them for each hour of work, the higher your marginal cost. But the less they get done each hour of work, the higher your marginal cost. So, that's why, roughly speaking, firms might want to pay a lot to people who are high-skilled. Okay? So, you might say, "Gee, why they paying my friend twice what I'm paying?" Well, maybe your friend's twice as productive as you. Okay? That would make or two and a half times productive as you and that would make sense.

**[16:05]:** So, we can't just say that it's a mistake to pay someone higher wages. We have to consider their wages relative to how productive they are. Okay? And that's a key relationship uh we will um we'll come back to. Okay? Questions about that? All right. That's the short run. Now, let's go to the long run. This gets a little more interesting. Actually, I always write on that side. I'll switch to this side today. Switch things up.

**[16:34]:** Guess if I do this side, I block you less probably. So, I think I should do this side. Okay. Long run cost curves.

**[16:43]:** Okay. Long run cost. Now, here what gets interesting is now K is no longer fixed. Now, we get to choose our input mix. Okay? And now our goal is going to be how do we choose our input mix to minimize costs? That's our goal here. How we're going to choose the mix of workers and machines to produce a given quantity most efficiently? Now, that optimal mix may change with the quantity. So, we're going to start We're going to do this in two steps. First, we're going to say, for given quantity, picked out of a hat, what's the right mix of labor and capital that minimizes the cost of producing that quantity given our production function? Then we're going to say, as the quantity varies, how does that change the optimal mix of L and K? And does it? Okay, so two steps. First, say for a given quantity, what's the right L and K to minimize cost of producing that quantity?

**[17:39]:** Then ask, well, as we vary the quantity, how does L How do L and K vary optimally? Okay? So, basically, we want to find the economically efficient combination of L and K, which is a combination that produces goods at minimum cost. Okay? And to do this, we are going to write down to derive this, we're going to write down what we call isocost curves. Isocost curves. Remember last time we did isoquants, which felt a lot like indifference curves? Isocosts are feel a lot like budget constraints. Okay? Isocost curves are essentially the firm's budget constraint. Okay? They're essentially mappings of the function C equals WL plus RK. They're essentially mappings for different amounts of K and L of the function C equals RK plus WL. So, if you look at figure 6.2, here we see our isocost lines. Okay? So, let's talk about this for a second.

**[18:41]:** So, for example, take the middle one, the $100 isocost. This is saying, what combinations of labor and capital cost you $100? Well, with a rental rate of $10 and a wage of $5, that means you could have 10 machines and no workers or 20 workers and no machines or some combination in between. Okay? This is just a budget constraint. It's just saying, given the amount of money you want to spend, given your cost, okay? How many machines or workers can you have? The difference is, we don't start I didn't start the example by saying your parents give you X dollars. That's why firm theory is harder than consumer theory. I pinned down the consumer theory problem much more easily by saying your parents give you X dollars, which told you which line to draw graph. I don't have that here. I haven't told you that here.

**[19:31]:** So, you have to graph the series of isocost curves cuz you don't know what the optimal cost is going to be. That's going to be pinned down later. That's what makes supply theory harder. Okay? You have to draw the series. So, you draw the series of isocost curves, different combinations that represent different amounts different totals of cost. And of course, the slope of that isocost curve is delta K delta L or minus W over R. Okay? That's the slope or in this case minus 0.5. Okay? Now, those of you thinking ahead, I know you guys are very insightful as a class. I'm sure some many of you thinking ahead might think, "Gee, that slope might not that slope might change as the number of workers and machines changes." Could you imagine the relative price of capital and labor changes in different cost? And it might and we'll put that aside for now.

**[20:25]:** For now, assuming for every relevant quantity these prices five and $10 are fixed. Let's ignore that where those prices come from. They're just given now. We'll come back to that later. Okay? Like I said, this course is sort of like peeling an onion. We raise things and we come back and go to the next layer of where that come from. Right now, we're we'll tell you where W and R come from. Right now, we're just going to take them fixed and we're going to assume they're always five and $10 regardless of the amount produced. Okay? Now, here's the question. You're a firm that must produce a certain amount of units. You have a production function and a cost function. How do you graphically figure out the right combination of capital and labor to use to produce a certain amount of units? Yeah. Is it the uh the tangent between the isoquant and the isocost curve?

**[21:18]:** That's exactly right. Just as I asked you, what is the right combination of pizza and cookies? And you told me that it was the tangency of the indifference curve and the budget constraint, it's the exact same logic here. The optimal mix of capital and labor comes from the tangency of the isoquant with the isocost as we see in figure 6.3. And ignore the like somehow that curve is sort of connected at the top. It's sort of a glitch of PowerPoint. Just ignore that. It's not a actually like a square or a trapezoid. It's just a curve. What would you call that? The curve in the two sides? Is that a That's not trapezoid. That's not That's a It's not a polygon. Okay? It's just a line. All right? Um so, basically uh is there a name for that? A curve and two lines? I don't think so.

**[22:07]:** It's just a polygon, right? Okay. So, it's not a polygon. It's just a curve. Okay? So, the curve is the isoquant for the square root of 12.5. What do I mean by that? I mean that is the combination of capital and labor that delivers square root of 12.5 units of production. Okay? So, what that curve is all possible combinations of capital and labor that deliver square root of 12.5 units. Okay? Just like the indifference curve is all possible combination of pizza and cookie that leads you equally happy, this is all possible combination of capital and labor that leads with a that leads you to a given production level. And as we said, the further out the isoquant, the more you can produce. So, you want to produce as much as you can given the prices you face in the market. Well, those prices you face in the market are delivered by the isocost curve.

**[23:01]:** So, the tangency is the best is the cost minimizing point. That's when you're producing the most you can given the cost you face in the market. The most you can given the cost you face in the market. Okay? And that tangency condition, once again, to continue our parallels to consumer theory, that tangency condition is going to deliver that the marginal product um is going to deliver that the marginal product of labor over the marginal product of capital, which we remember called last time the marginal rate of technical substitution. Okay? It's going to be equal to W over R. Actually, the negative of these is going to be equal to each other, but we'll just cross out the negative. So, the negative of MPL over MPK, which you call the marginal rate of technical substitution, is equal to the negative of W over R. The slope.

**[24:00]:** The optimal point is where the marginal rate of technical substitution equals the slope, which is the wage uh which is the wage to rental rate ratio. Alternatively, I don't know if anyone besides me likes this intuition, we can rewrite this as um MPL over W equals MPK over R. My bang for the buck formulation that I like. That the next dollar of wages, if you ask, "Should I spend the next dollar on wages or machines?" You should do it until the next dollar of wages delivers you the same return as the next dollar of machines. Okay? This is what you get for the next dollar of wages, MPL over W. This is what you get for the next dollar of machines, MPK over R. You want to continue to straight off machines and workers until that condition is true. Okay? So, let's actually now solve for this.

**[24:53]:** Okay? For our for our example, let's actually solve for that.

**[25:01]:** Okay? If we solve for this, we know that the marginal product of labor, which is DQ DL, okay? Is 0.5 * K over square root of K * L. And the marginal product of capital, which is DQ DK, equals 0.5 * L over the square root 0.5 * L over the square root of K * L. Okay? Just Just taking the derivative of the All I did was take the derivative of the production function. Okay? So, therefore, putting these together, we're going to we know that marginal rate of technical substitution in this example is equal to minus K over L. That's not a general formula. Okay? That's just this example. The marginal rate of technical substitution is equal to the negative of the ratio of capital to labor. We also know that the wage rate We also know we want to set this equal to the negative of the wage rate.

**[26:07]:** The I'm sorry, the wage the wage rental rate ratio. Okay? And we know that's negative a half. Then we know that's a half. So, cuz that's five and that's 10. So, we want to set the marginal rate of technical substitution to the wage rate rental rate ratio, which means we set minus K over L equal to minus a half. Or at the optimum, okay? That means that um your labor your capital at the optimum that means the amount of capital should be half as much as the amount of labor. In this example, we just solved for the efficient combination of inputs. The efficient combination is you should use K You should use capital to labor in a ratio of a half. You should use half as much capital as you use labor. Okay? So, let me pause there. And let's let's talk about where this is coming from.

**[27:01]:** Yeah. So, does that mean that at any given price of cost curve or your line, um that is the optimal point where it'll be tangent to Exactly. Exactly. That Right. That's the graphic intuition. Let's come to economics intuition. The economics intuition is the following. The production function delivers this relationship. That the marginal rate of technical substitution equals minus K over L. In other words, when you're producing goods given this production function, you're indifferent between the next machine and the next worker. That's just the way this production function worked out. That one more machine delivers you the same amount as one more worker. Okay? Now, I've just told you that one machine costs half of one more worker. So, what do you want more of? No. One machine delivers the same return as one worker. You want more workers. Workers cost half machines. They're equally productive.

**[28:01]:** So, you want more workers. So, the optimal amount of machines is going to be half as many as the number of workers. You want more workers because you're indifferent Look at that production function. You're indifferent. Okay? You don't give a about L versus K. They're the same to you. Okay? You're a hard capitalist, man. Machine or worker, you don't care. But, the market's telling you you can get a worker for half the price of machine. So, you as a good cost minimizing capitalist get take twice as many workers as machines. Okay? And that's the outcome that you get here. Questions about that? Okay? So, that's basically um what we do uh to to derive this. Now, what I want to do is take this and then derive our ultimate goal, which is what is the long-run cost function. That's sort of what we why we started this lecture.

**[29:04]:** What is the long-run cost function? Let's do the math. We'll do the math in five steps. Step one. Q equals square root of K * L. Okay? Step two. We know from up there that K over L equals W over R. We derived that. Right? Leading us to the conclusion that K This conclusion that K equals 1/2 L. Okay? We just derived that. Therefore, we can rewrite Q We can rewrite Q as the square root of 1/2 * L squared. Just substituting in cuz K equals 1/2 L. Therefore, we can solve for L is going to be square root of two over Q. And K is going to be square root of two over two over Q.

**[30:15]:** Okay? L is square root of two over Q. K is square root of two over two over Q. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. No, not not over Q. I'm sorry. That's my bad. Error. Error. Go back. Should always look at my notes. It's square root of two times Q. My bad. L is square root of two times Q. Okay? And K is square root of two over two times Q. Okay? Therefore, armed with this L and K, we can rewrite our cost function. So, step five is that the cost function given this stuff, the cost function equals R times square root of two times Q. I'm sorry. R times square root of two over two times Q. Plus W times square root of two times Q. I just plugged in the optimal L and K into my cost function. Okay? Now, I can plug in the 10 and the five to get C equals 10 times square root of two times Q.

**[31:38]:** And I'm done. I've just derived the cost function. This is what we came here for. This is what you got up this morning wanting to see. Okay? You got this morning you said, "I want to know how does the cost of a firm vary with the quantity it produces?" And I've just told you. This tells you how the the cost that you pay vary the quantity you produce. And I did that by by deriving the optimal mix of L and K you want to use. And then simply imposing the prices of those two, and I get a cost function. Yeah. I'm sorry. You'd be adding the two terms? Which two terms? Oh, it's Yeah, plus. I'm sorry. You're right. My bad. That's a plus. Thanks. This is the most math I'll do in a lecture all year, you can be pleased to know. It's why it's my least favorite lecture.

**[32:30]:** Yeah. So, is five generally true? Uh you mean this particular functional form? Yeah. No. This is all dependent on that production function I wrote down. What's generally true is this. Okay? Or or actually K wouldn't be What's generally true is just C equals In the long run, what's generally true is C equals WL plus RK. Okay? That's what's generally true. I just made But what I've showed you is given three things, a production All I gave you was a production function, a wage rate, and a rental rate. Given those three things, you can then derive the cost function. Okay? Given those three things, you can derive the cost function. In fact, given two things, you can derive the cost function. You could actually derive the cost function of given one thing, given just a production function, derive the cost function as a function of these input prices.

**[33:25]:** Okay? So, that is a lot of uh that's a lot of results from one function from one production function. Okay? Now, other question about this. Other math I got wrong. Sorry about that. Yeah. Sorry, could you repeat the three inputs that you're using? They're They're All I use Somebody Somebody tell me. What are the What do you need to get the magical cost function? What three things do you need? Yeah. W and R and then Q. Now, W, R, and What about Q? You need Q, but what about What do you need? W, R, and The production function. So, armed with a production function, that mathematical equation, this mathematical equation, W and R, I'm done. Everything I've done this lecture comes from those three things. The math is hard and annoying. We will have you practice it. You will not like it. Okay? It's just It's just kind of what you got to do.

**[34:21]:** All right? I don't like it. You're not going to like it. It's just what we got to do to get to the more interesting stuff. Okay? Yeah. What's the bar on the K? It's fixed in the short run. The bar on the It's It shouldn't see a bar on the K over here. That's all over here when I was doing the short run. Yeah. You need R and W in order to get to the fixed stuff like Yeah, I needed R and W. Well, in the sense that to simplify K equals 1/2 L. To K Oh, you're right. That's a good point. I needed R and W back here. You're right. It's a good point. It's a good point. But I still could have done this whole thing as a function of R and W if I wanted to. If I wanted to really, you know, screw up my math.

**[34:59]:** All right? Okay. So, now armed with this, let's talk about what happens when input prices change. We talked about with consumer theory what happens when the price of pizza and cookies changed. What happens when the price of labor and capital changes? What does that do? So, let's talk about changes in input prices. Okay? Let's go to figure 6-4. And let's look at with the same production function, square root of L times K. We're not changing our production function. We're going to change the wage rental ratio. So, a line the the the um We have our initial uh we have our initial line, our initial um wage rental ratio, which is that basically um you have a wage rate of this um but that but but but the budget constraint essentially that's flatter is our original budget constraint. The flatter budget constraint is our original budget constraint.

**[36:01]:** That's the budget constraint with a price of capital of 10 and a wage of five. And that intersects our isoquant at point X. So, we chose five units um uh we chose five units of labor. Now, we have a new We chose five units of labor and two and a half machines. Okay? That was our original This is sort of a messed up graph, but our original intersection was at point X. The cost-minimizing combination that got square root of 12.5 production was to have five workers and two and a half machines. Now, let's say the price of workers rises to 10. The wage rate rises to 10 bucks an hour. So, now workers and machines cost the same. What is now the optimal mix of workers and machines? Well, graphically, we know we still want to produce the square root of 12.5. So, we want to stay tangent to the same isoquant.

**[37:00]:** Okay? So, basically what we're saying is this is as if we said to consumers, "Keeping utility changed, change the price." What do we call that? Anyone remember what we called that? Keeping utility constant, changing the price? Anyone remember what we called that? This Who said that? All right, raise your hand next time. Be proud. Substitution effect. That's the substitution effect. It's the same idea here. We want to know for a given level of production, what happens as the price of the inputs change? And so, we shift along the isoquant from point X to point Y. And you'll see we choose a mix where we use fewer workers and more machines. And just as the substitution effect is always non-positive, this shift as this as the wage rate rise, the price of good on the X axis rises, you'll unambiguously use no more and almost certainly less workers.

**[38:03]:** Okay? And you can see that graphically, think about graphically, you're looking for the tangency between this curve and the line. The slope of the line just got steeper. Therefore, you must move to the left on the curve. It's the same proof as we used the substitution effect. Why the substitution effect was always non-positive. Okay? It's the same intuition here we use for why a rise in the wage rate will lead you to hire fewer workers and more machines. Guess what? You just entered the debate on the minimum wage. Anyone you follow the debate on the minimum wage, what do people say? Well, if you raise the wage you have to pay workers, they'll be replaced by machines. That's this. This is the math This is the mathematical and graphical intuition behind the debate on the minimum wage, which we'll get into later in the semester.

**[38:50]:** But the basic idea of that debate is, "Gee, if you force firms to pay more to workers, they're going to substitute towards machines." That's exactly right in theory. In practice, there's a lot of complications. But this gives you the theory of why people make that argument. Yeah. So, in this example, only like only the wage for workers changes, not the Not the machine. So, why would the the isocost like not have the same Y intercept? Ah, great point. Because here I'm drawing a new iso I am drawing the isocost that I would use while still producing square root of 12.5. So, that's It's just the substitution effect. I'm just I I'm not drawing the full set of isocosts at the new price. I'm just saying, "To produce the same amount, what's my new If I want to produce the same amount, what combination do I now have to use?

**[39:42]:** Okay? Yeah. So, how do you The total cost of production, let's see. It used Yeah, it has to be uh no. Uh let's see. No, total cost doesn't have to be the same. The total cost used to be five workers at five bucks an hour, that's 25. Then it used to be 50. Now, what is it? It's now it's 70. The total cost has gone up. Exactly. It's not like the budget constraint where your income is fixed. That's what's hard about producer theory. Because basically, the budget constraint was sort of asking, you know, keeping your budget fixed. This is like asking keeping your total production fixed. And so now you have to pay more to get to get that level of production. Okay? It's good questions. Okay. Now, ultimately, what does this lead to? This So So that gives us our changing input prices. Okay, other questions about that?

**[40:33]:** Now, remember I said at the beginning of the lecture, we're going to first going to solve for what is the cost-minimizing combination of inputs for a given quantity. We derived that up there. It's half as much Going back to our old prices, it's half as much capital as labor. Now, we want to ask, how does your cost change as the quantity changes? And we call that the long-run expansion path.

**[41:02]:** The long-run expansion path, which is how do your costs expand as you produce more? And we see that in figure 6.5. In figure 6.5, we show the particular case of a linear long-run expansion path. That's what you get in this example. It's a particular case. What this case says is at any given level of production, the optimal mix of labor and capital is the same. In other words, you always want to have given essentially given the price of labor is half the price of capital, you always want to have twice as many workers as machines. So, if you want to produce square root of 12.5, you want five workers and two and a half machines. If you want to produce square root of 50, you want 10 workers and five machines. If you want to produce square root of 112.5, you want 15 workers and seven and a half machines.

**[41:57]:** So, the long-run Given this production function, the long-run expansion path is linear. You always want the same ratio of workers to machines. Yeah.

**[42:17]:** This is what I tried to say. It's sort of I always say it every year, but it's hard. We have to come back to it. The reason producer theory is harder is because we're not given a fixed constant we are with consumers. Consumers, we're saying, "Look, you've got an amount You've got a resource. You've got a constrained maximization." We haven't constrained their maximization yet. There's another constraint we need. They have an extra degree of freedom relative to consumers. Now, in fact, consumers have that degree of freedom, too. When you grow up, your parents don't give you money. You decide how much to make. So, in reality, consumers you could do this will have the same degrees of freedom. But we started with the easy consumer theory case where you constrict We We We took away a degree of freedom. Now we're adding it back, which you can choose how much to produce, like you being able to choose your income as a consumer.

**[42:59]:** Okay? And that leads to the long long-run expansion path. Let me go on cuz I want to make sure I get through this stuff. Okay? Now, the long-run expansion path does not have to be linear. So, think about Look at figure 6.65B and 6.5C. So, 6.5B is a long-run expansion path for a production function such that capital becomes less productive the more you produce. I don't have the example of a production function, but you can write down production functions which have the feature that the more you produce, the less productive capital becomes. The less each additional unit of capital helps relative to each unit of workers. Okay? So, you know, we could think of this roughly as sort of like a a fast-food restaurant. That kind of, you know, each addition That basically, there's so much stuff to do where workers can efficiently share tasks and things.

**[43:50]:** Each just a worker that the marginal product of labor essentially diminishes less quickly than the marginal product of capital. Okay? On the other hand, in figure 6.5C, we have a long-run expansion path where where labor becomes less productive relative to capital. Think of this like heavy machinery. Where like basically all workers can do is run the machine. So, that second worker that Workers don't really do much but sit there and flip a switch. You need the worker to flip the switch. That's all they do. So, the second worker that you're already flipping the switch. So, really adding more machines is a more productive way to expand expand output. None of these is right or wrong. We're just saying that the shape of this expansion path can basically vary with how much uh with different production functions. Okay? But they're all the same idea. Now, so basically, that tells you um And the bottom But here's the bottom line that we want to come to.

**[44:49]:** That long-run expansion path is our long-run cost curve. So, ultimately, if you want to ask, "How do my costs vary with how much I produce?" This curve tells you. Because what it does is says, "For every level of production, I'll tell you the optimal combination of L and K." Given the price of L and K, that will tell you the costs. And so you trace out the costs with every level of production. This is your cost curve. This long-run expansion path tells you what the costs are for every level of production. And it tells you that cuz you've made You're doing the efficient level of production. Okay? That's what the long-run expansion path is telling you. Okay, this is hard. I'm about to make it harder. Which is we're now going to talk about the relationship between short-run costs and long-run costs. Okay? And the key insight is that long-run costs are everywhere lower than short-run costs.

**[45:51]:** Without looking at the figure cuz the figure doesn't help with this. Why does that make sense? Why are long-run costs Why if you can optimize over the long run, will you always have costs that are no higher and in general lower than optimizing in the short run? Yeah.

**[46:13]:** Because you have an extra degree of freedom. I think this Le Chatelier's principle, is that right for the chemists among us? That basically like essentially an extra degree of freedom means the more you can optimize over, the better you can do in optimizing. In the short run, you're constrained by the size of the building. In the long run, you can choose. So, let's to see that, let's go to figure 6.6. This is a confusing figure, so bear with me as I walk you through it. Okay? Consider a firm with three possible sizes of plants. They're going to build a plant. So, the capital here is the building. And there's three possible sizes, small, medium, and large. Okay? The small plant has the curve SRAC1. What does that curve mean? That means that the small plant I'm sorry, the small plant has SRAC1, the medium plant has SRAC2, and the large plant has SRAC3.

**[47:07]:** Compare SRAC1 to SRAC3. What this is saying is for small quantities of production, SRAC1 lies below SRAC3. Right? For small quantities of production, if you extend SRAC3 out, you see at levels of production like Q1 or even Q2, SRAC3 is way above SRAC1. When you go to level of production like Q3, SRAC1, if you extend that dash line out, it's going to be much much higher than SRAC3. So, the right And SRAC2 is in between. So, essentially, for different levels of production, these give the different optimal short-run cost curves. In the long run, you get to choose. So, the long-run average cost curve is the lower envelope of the short-run average cost curves. Because in the long run, you say, "Well, here's my production level. I know in the long run." So, if I know I'm going to build a lot of things, I choose SRAC3.

**[48:12]:** I choose I choose the biggest plant. If I might open my production's going to be low, I choose the smallest plant. But I can optimize in the long run by choosing the right size plant for my production level. This is hard, and I'm almost out of time, so let me end with an example that perfectly illustrates this. Tesla. Elon Musk, everybody's favorite guy these days. Okay? Tesla, when they came out, had to decide how big a plant to build. How many batteries to make. Batteries are the key input at Tesla's. Okay? And they expected to make to have demand for 20,000 cars by the year 2017. So, they built a plant like SRAC1. They built a plant that was the efficient plant to produce 20,000 cars. The problem is demand was for 200,000 cars. As a result, there's a three-year waiting list to get Teslas.

**[49:05]:** It turned out that was not the right size to produce. They lost money relative to the optimal. They made money. Musk is incredibly rich. But they didn't do what was most efficient given the underlying demand. But now, Musk can reoptimize. Now, he's saying, "Wait a second. People want way more cars. Well, producing them at the tiny plant was exorbitantly expensive. I had to run it over and over time, pay workers overtime, to produce 200K cars. That tiny plant just was exorbitantly expensive." That's if you take that dash line and extend it way the hell up. The SRAC1 line, they said it way the hell up, but incredibly expensive. So, what is Musk doing now? Building the largest battery plant in the world. In Nevada, he is building a battery plant that can produce batteries for 500,000 cars. So, we shifted from SRAC1 to SRAC3. He's now saying in the long run, I can more If I'm going to produce 200,000 cars, I can do that more efficiently with a giant battery plant.

**[49:58]:** And that's what he's doing. So, he's re-optimizing. Now, what if Musk is wrong? What if it turns out Tesla suck and people are like, I don't want them anymore. Someone else or you know, Chevy finally figures it out and makes a good electric car. Okay? Then what's going to happen is he's going to have made a mistake in the long run. Then in the third period, he'll go back to a smaller plant again. But he always can do what's efficient in the long run given the underlying demand. So, Tesla's an example of this sort of long run, short run dichotomy. Anyway, it's a lot of stuff for one lecture. We'll come back next time, talk more about costs, and then we'll start getting into competition.
