# Lecture 13: More on Scattering

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SsCeVABM4Mo
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/SsCeVABM4Mo

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 7:06 — Chapter 2 (7:06)
- 13:44 — Chapter 3 (13:44)
- 18:42 — Chapter 4 (18:42)
- 20:58 — Chapter 5 (20:58)
- 23:59 — Chapter 6 (23:59)
- 25:38 — Chapter 7 (25:38)
- 29:18 — Chapter 8 (29:18)
- 33:22 — Chapter 9 (33:22)
- 34:57 — Chapter 10 (34:57)
- 41:17 — Chapter 11 (41:17)
- 48:03 — Chapter 12 (48:03)
- 50:14 — Chapter 13 (50:14)
- 58:22 — Chapter 14 (58:22)
- 1:03:36 — Chapter 15 (63:36)
- 1:05:38 — Chapter 16 (65:38)
- 1:11:44 — Chapter 17 (71:44)
- 1:16:45 — Chapter 18 (76:45)
- 1:18:16 — Chapter 19 (78:16)
- 1:19:15 — Chapter 20 (79:15)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseware at ocw.mit.edu.

**[0:23]:** Uh any practical any questions from the last lecture from before spring break?

**[0:32]:** No questions? Nothing? Nothing at all? Are you all still on vacation? Thank you. Thank you. Yes. Yeah. Could you talk about the coherent states? Ah, okay. I Well, that's a great question. So, um so coherent states are um it Actually, how many people have looked at the optional problems? Nice. Okay, good. Um so, good. So, coherent states were a topic that we we touched on on the problem sets and on the um on the optional problems. And the optional problems um uh are mostly on the harmonic oscillator and and nice uh uh uh nice problems uh revealing some of the structure of the harmonic oscillator and it generalizes quite um quite broadly. But, here's the basic idea of coherent states. Let me just talk you through the basic ideas rather than do any calculations. So, what's the ground state of a harmonic oscillator? What does its wave function look like?

**[1:37]:** It's a Gaussian, exactly. It's minimum uncertainty wave packet. How does it evolve in time? Yeah, phase. It's an energy eigenstate. It's the ground state. So, it just evolves in time with a phase. So, if we look at the wave function for the ground state phi naught, it's something like e to the minus x squared uh over 2 a squared um with some normalization coefficient which I'm not going to worry about. Okay. And so, this is a minimum uncertainty wave packet. It's position on its position distribution is time independent cuz it's a stationary state and its momentum distribution, which is also a Gaussian, the Fourier transform, is a is time independent. And so, this thing up to its rotation of by the overall phase just sits there and and remains a Gaussian. Now, here's the question. Suppose I take my harmonic oscillator potential and I take my Gaussian, but I displace it a little bit.

**[2:31]:** It's the same ground state. But, I it's the same state, but I've just displaced it over a little. What do you expect to happen? How will this state evolve in time? So, we know how to solve that problem. We take this state, it's a known wave function at time zero. We expand it in the basis of energy eigen states. Each energy eigenstate evolves in time with a phase, so we put in that phase and redo the sum and recover the time evolution of the full state. And we've done this a number of times on the problem sets. Yeah. Would um would the Gaussian uh the displaced Gaussian evolve the same way um that is keep its width if it had any other initial width other than the one of the ground state? Uh let me come back to that cuz it's a little more precise question than Okay.

**[3:22]:** So, um So, we know how to solve this problem practically, algorithmically. But, here's a a nice fact. I'm not going to derive any equations, that's part of the point of the optional problems. But, here's a nice fact about this state. So, it's clearly a minimum uncertainty wave packet cuz at time zero because it's just the same Gaussian just trans- translated over a little bit. So, what we'd expect naively from solving is we expand this in Fourier modes and then uh we let the system evolve in time uh we let each individual Fourier mode uh or sorry, Fourier mode. We each let each individual energy eigenstate evolve in time, pick up a phase. And now, what we get is a superposition instead of sum over n at time zero, we'd have sum over n c n phi n of x. Now, as a function of time, we get e to the minus i omega n t.

**[4:13]:** And these phases are going to change the interference from summing up all these energy eigenstates. And so, the system will change in time because the way that the various terms in the superposition interfere will change in time. So, very naively, what you might expect if you just took a random function, for example, if I took a harmonic oscillator potential and I took some stupid function that did, you know, something like this, what would you expect it to do over time? Well, due to all the complicated interference effects, you'd expect this to turn into basically some schmutz, just, you know, some crazy interference pattern. The thing that's nice about a coherent state, and this is where it gets its name, is the way that all of these interference effects conspire together to evolve the state is to leave it a Gaussian that does nothing but translates in time.

**[5:02]:** A coherent state is coherent because it remains coherently a Gaussian as it moves along. It oscillates back and forth. And in fact, the peak, the center of this Gaussian wave packet, oscillates with precisely the frequency of the trap. It behaves just as a classical particle would have had you displaced it from the center of the harmonic oscillator trap. It oscillates back and forth.

**[5:30]:** Now, on the other hand, you know that its momentum is changing in time, right? And at any given point, as you've shown on the problem set that's due tomorrow, or you will have shown, um at any given moment time, the momentum can be understood as the overall phase. You can just change that momentum by the overall phase, so it's the spatial rate of change of the phase, e to the i k x. So, you know that the way the phase depends on position is changing over time. So, it can't be quite so simple that the wave function, rather than the probability distribution, is remaining a Gaussian over time. It's not. It's got all sorts of complicated phases. But, the upshot is that the probability distribution oscillates back and forth perfectly coherently. So, that seems a little magical. And there's a nice way to understand how that magic arises, and it's to understand the following.

**[6:18]:** If I take a state phi sub uh phi uh phi zero, but I translate it x minus x naught, okay? So, we know that the state phi zero of x was the ground state. What does it mean to be the ground state of the harmonic oscillator? How do I check if I'm the ground state of the harmonic oscillator? Well, look. I I walk up to you. I'm like, "Hey, I'm the ground state of the harmonic oscillator." You're suspicious. What do you do? Annihilate. Exactly. You act with the annihilation operator. Curse you. So, you act with the annihilation operator and you get zero, right? What happens if I act with the annihilation operator on this? Is this the ground state? No, I it's been displaced by x naught. And meanwhile, I told you that it oscillates back and forth. So, what happens if you act with the annihilation operator?

**[7:06]:** Should you get zero? No, what are you going to get? Some random schmutz, right? If you just take A and you act on some stupid state, you'll just get some other stupid state. Except for Gaussians that have been displaced, you get a constant times the same wave function, phi zero of x minus x naught. Aha! It turns out that these displaced Gaussians are eigen states of the annihilation operator. What does that mean? Well, it means they're coherent states. And so, the optional problems are working through of the study of the eigen functions of the annihilation operator, the coherent states. Is that cool? It's a state. It's a superposition. You can think about it like this. It's a superposition of the energy eigenstate, right? Any state is a superposition of energy eigenstates, and a coherent state is just some particularly special superposition of energy eigenstates. So, you can think about it literally as c zero phi zero plus c one phi one plus c two phi two, blah blah blah, right?

**[8:03]:** What does the annihilation operator do? What does the lowering operator do? It takes any state and it lowers it with some coefficient. So, a coherent state, an eigenstate of the annihilation operator, must be a state such that if you take c zero phi zero plus c one phi one plus c two phi two, you hit it with the annihilation operator, which will give you c one phi zero plus c two phi one divided by root two plus dot dot dot, or times root two divided plus dot dot dot. It gives you the same state back. So, that gave you a relation between the coefficients c zero and c one, c one and c two, c two and c three. They've all got to be suitable multiples of each other, and what you can show, and this is something you work through, not quite in this order, on the optional problems, what you can show is that doing so gives

**[8:49]:** you a translated Gaussian. Okay? So, physically, that's what a coherent state is. Another way to say what a coherent state is is it's as close to a classical object as you're going to get by building a quantum mechanical wave function. It's something that behaves just like a classical particle in that potential would have behaved in the harmonic oscillator potential. Did that answer your question? Okay. Anything else? So, Matt works with these for a living. Matt, would Do you want to add anything? All right. Um I like these. They they show up all over the place. This is like the spherical cow wave functions um cuz you know, it's awesome. It it's an eigen function of the annihilation operator. It behaves like a classical particle. Is there any easy way to define coherent states in potentials where you don't have nice operators like that? No, I mean, that's usually what we mean by a coherent state.

**[9:47]:** So, off So, the the the term coherent state is often used interchangeably to mean many different things, which in the case of the harmonic oscillator are identical. One is a state which is a Gaussian. Okay. So, in the harmonic oscillator system, that's a particularly nice state because it oscillates particularly nicely and it um it maintains its probability distribution as a function of time roughly by translating possibly with some phases. Um uh but people often use the phrase coherent state even when you're not harmonic. And it's useful to keep in mind that we're often not harmonic. Nothing is truly harmonic. So, um you had another question a moment ago though and your your question was about the width. Yeah. This just translates without changing its width. Exactly. With or without changing its shape at all. If the Gaussian were of a different width, would that still happen?

**[10:37]:** Yeah, it does. Although this the the details of how it does so are slightly different. So, that's called a squeezed state. And the basic idea of a squeezed state is this. Suppose I have a harmonic oscillator, okay? And this is actually how people build Well, this is one way people build squeezed states in labs. So, suppose I have a harmonic oscillator and put a system in the ground state. So, there's its ground state and its width is correlated with the frequency of the potential, right? Okay. Now, suppose I take this potential at some moment in time and uh you know, I control the potential. The potential is like so created by some laser field, for example, and you know, some annoying grad student walks over to the control panel and doubles the power of the laser. Right? All of a sudden I've squeezed the potential.

**[11:20]:** Okay? But my system is already in a state which is a Gaussian. It's just the wrong Gaussian. So, what does this guy do? Well, this is funny. The true ground state, once we've squeezed right? The true ground state would be something that's much narrower in position space. I didn't draw that very well, but it would be much narrower in position space. And thus its distribution would be much broader in momentum space. So, the state that we're that we've put the system in or we've left the system in has too much position uncertainty and too little momentum uncertainty. It's been squeezed compared to the normal state in the delta X delta P plane. Its uncertainty relation is still extreme. It still saturates the uncertainty bound because it's a Gaussian, but it doesn't have the specific delta X and delta P associated with that with the true ground state of the squeezed potential.

**[12:08]:** Okay? So, now you can ask, what is this guy doing time? And that's one of the optional problems, too. And it has many of the nice properties of coherent states. It's periodic. It evolves much like a classical particle, but its uncertainties are different and they change shape. Uh it's an interesting story. Anyway, that's the squeezed state. Yeah. Um do other potentials have coherent states that aren't Gaussian? Um it sort of depends So, um other potentials have states that behave classically. Yeah, they're generally um So, systems that aren't the harmonic oscillator do have very special states that behave at like a classical particle. Um but they're not as simple as annihilations uh by the um by the annihilation operator. Um Come to my office and I'll tell you about uh sort of analogous to ways for something called supersymmetric uh quantum models um where there's a nice story there.

**[13:00]:** Okay. Um I'm going to cut off coherent states for the moment and move on to where we are uh now. Okay. So, last time we um Last time we talked about uh scattering of a of a particle, a quantum particle of mass M against a barrier. And we made a classical prediction which I didn't quite phrase this way, but we made a classical prediction that if you took a particle of mass this particle of mass M and threw it against a barrier of height V naught, that the probability that it will transmit across this barrier to infinity uh is basically zero. So, this is the classical prediction.

**[13:44]:** It will not transmit to infinity until the energy goes above the potential. And when the energy is above the potential, it'll slow down, but it'll transmit 100% of the time.

**[13:58]:** Okay. So, this is our classical prediction. And so, we sought to solve this problem. We did. It's pretty straightforward. And the energy eigenstate took the form Well, we know how to solve it out here. We know how to solve it out here because these are just constant potentials, so it's just plane waves. Um Let's take the case of the energy is less than the potential. So, this guy. Then out here, it's an classically disallowed state, so it's got to be a exponential. If we want it to be normalizable, we need it to be a decaying exponential. Out here, it's oscillatory cuz it's a classically allowed region. And so, the general form of the of the wave function of the energy eigenstate is a superposition of a wave moving this way with positive momentum, a wave with negative momentum, a contribution with minus K. And out here, it had to be the decaying exponential.

**[14:47]:** And then by matching, we're requiring that the wave function was oscillatory and then exponentially decaying out here and requiring that it was continuous and differentiably continuous, that its derivative was continuous, we found matching conditions between the various coefficients and this was the solution in general. Okay?

**[15:07]:** Now, in particular, the wave the this term which corresponds to the component of the of the wave function moving uh towards the barrier on the left-hand side, uh has amplitude one. This term which has um which corresponds to uh a wave on the left with negative momentum, so moving to the left, has amplitude K minus I alpha over K plus I alpha where h bar squared K squared upon 2 M is equal to that's just the energy E. And h bar squared alpha squared over 2 M, that's all on this side, is equal to V naught minus E.

**[15:51]:** But this, notably, is a pure phase. And we understood that, so we'll call this parameter R. Because this is the reflected wave and this is an amplitude rather than a probability, so we'll call it little R.

**[16:06]:** And we notice that this uh the the probability that we that we get out um Good. So, if we want to ask the question of what is the transmission probability, the probability that I get from far out here to far out here, what is that probability?

**[16:22]:** So, if I consider a state that starts out as a localized wave packet way out here and I send it in, but with energy below the barrier, what's the probability that I'll get arbitrarily far out here, that I will subsequently find the particle very far out here? Zero, right, exactly. And you can see that because here's the probability amplitude. The norm squared is the probability density as a function of the position. And it goes like a constant times E to the minus alpha X. For large X, this exponential kills us. And we made that more precise by talking about the current. We said, look, the current that gets transmitted is equal to That's a funny way to write things. Um h bar um sorry, the current that gets transmitted, which is equal to h bar upon 2 M I um uh psi complex conjugate d x psi minus psi d x psi complex conjugate.

**[17:16]:** Uh on the right, so I'll put right right right right. This is just equal to zero. And the way to see that the easiest way to see that is you already showed on the problem set, the current vanishes or the current vanishes when the wave function can be made real up to a phase. And since this is some number, but in particular it's an overall constant complex number and this is a real wave function, we know that uh this is zero. So, the transmitted current out here is zero. The flux of particles moving out to the right is zero. Okay? So, nothing gets out to the right. So, that was for the energy less than the potential and we've now rederived this result, the the classical prediction. So, the classical prediction worked pretty well. Now, importantly, in general, we also wanted to define the transmission probability a little more carefully.

**[18:07]:** I'm going to define the transmission probability as the current of transmitted particles on the right divided by the current of transmitted of probability that was incident. And similarly, we can define an a probability that the particle reflects, which is the ratio of the reflected current, the current in the reflected beam, uh to the incident current.

**[18:33]:** Okay? And so, this is going to be the transmission probability and the reflection probability.

**[18:42]:** Yeah. Thank you.

**[18:50]:** Okay. So, let's do a slightly different example. In this example, I want to study the same system, the wall, but I want to consider a ball incident from the left. A ball, an object, a quantum particle incident from the left with energy greater than V. E greater than V naught. So again, classically, what do you expect in this case? You send in the particle, it loses a little bit of energy going up the potential barrier, but it's still got a positive kinetic energy and so it just keeps rolling.

**[19:21]:** It's like my car making it up the driveway. Just barely makes it. Um Okay. So, here again, what's the form of the wave function? Phi E can be put in the form uh on the left, it's going to be E to the I K X plus B E to the minus I K X. And that's over here on the left. And on the right, it's going to be of the form C E to the I uh K In fact, let me call this K1X and K2X, or sorry, K1X, which is on the left, h bar squared K1 squared upon 2M is equal to E. Um and on the right, we're going to have K2X because it's again a classically allowed region, it's going to be oscillatory, but with a different momentum, E to the I K2X plus D E to the minus I K2X. Okay.

**[20:15]:** Where um uh h bar squared K2 squared upon 2M is equal to E minus V0, which is a positive number, so that's good. So, here's our wave function.

**[20:32]:** Okay. Now, before we do anything else, I want to just interpret this quickly. So, again, this is like a this is like a wave that has positive momentum, and I'm going to say that it's like a a contribution, a term in the superposition, that is moving to the right. And the way to think that it's moving to the right, well, first off, it's got positive momentum, but more to the point, this is an energy eigenstate. So, how does this state evolve in time?

**[20:58]:** It's an energy eigenstate with energy. How does it evolve in time? It rotates by an overall phase, exactly. So, we just get this times an E to the minus I omega T, where h bar omega is equal to E, the energy. And that's true on the left or right cuz the energy is just a constant. So, this term goes as E to the I KX minus I omega T or KX minus omega T. And this is a a points of constant phase in this move to the right as T increases in order for the phase to be constant or for the phase, for example, to be zero, as T increases, X must increase. By assumption here, K is a positive number. On the other hand, this guy, that was a K1, the second term is of the form E to the minus I K1X. And when I add the um omega T minus I omega T, this becomes KX plus omega T, so points of constant phase, for example, phase equals zero, in order for this to stay zero, then as T increases, X

**[21:51]:** must become negative, X must decrease. So, that's why we say this corresponds to a component of the wave function, a a term in the superposition, which is moving to the left, and this is one which is moving to the right. Sorry, my right, your left. Sorry, this this is moving to your right, and this is moving to your left. Okay? It's a little Z2, it's harder than it seems. Um Okay. So, in this setup, we could imagine two different kinds of scattering experiments. We could imagine a scattering experiment where we send in a particle from the left and ask what happens. So, if you send in a particle from the left, what are the logical possibilities?

**[22:31]:** It could go through or reflect back. Are you ever going to get a particle spontaneously coming from infinity out here? Not so much. So, if you're sending it a particle in from the left, what can you say about these coefficients? D equals zero and A is not zero, right? Because D corresponds to a particle on the right-hand side coming in this way. So, that's a different scattering experiment. So, in particular, coming in from the left

**[22:58]:** means D equals zero and A not equal to zero. Coming in from the right means A equals zero and D not equal to zero by exactly the same token. Cool?

**[23:18]:** Okay. So, I want to emphasize this. A and B A and D, when you think of this as a scattering process, A and D are in guys. In. In. And C and B are out. This term corresponds to moving away from the barrier. This term corresponds to moving away from the barrier, just on the left or on the right. Okay? Out. And out. Everyone happy with that? Yeah.

**[23:59]:** Uh so, this is Well, that's so, this is the classical prediction. What I've written is classical prediction. Yeah. So, let me rephrase. The question was basically, look, that classical prediction implies that B must be zero in the other scattering process, and that doesn't sound right. So, is that true? No, it's not true, and we'll see it again in a second. So, very good intuition. Um that was good. Yeah, okay. Um

**[24:30]:** Good. So, in general, if we have a a general wave function, a general superposition of the two states with energy E, with A, B, C, and D all nonzero, that's fine. That just corresponds to sending some stuff in from the right and some stuff in Sorry, some stuff in from the left and some stuff in from the right. Yeah? But, it's of course going to be easier if we can just do what a simpler experiment. If we send in stuff from the left or send in stuff from the right. And if we solve those problems independently, we can then just superpose the results to get the general solution. Yeah? So, it will suffice to always either set D to zero or A to zero, corresponding to sending things in from the left or sending things in from the right. And then we can just take a general superposition to get the general answer.

**[25:11]:** Everyone happy with that? Okay. So, let's do that in this setup. So, here's our wave function. And you guys are now adept at solving the energy eigenvalue equation. It's just the matching conditions for A, B, C, and D. I'm not going to solve it for you. I'm just going to write down the results. So, the results, in fact, I'll use a new board.

**[25:38]:** The results for this guy, now for E greater than V, um are that um do do do What just happened? Right, okay, good. So, let's look at the case D equals zero, corresponding to coming in from the left. So, in the case of in from the left, C is equal to 2 K1 over K1 plus K2. And B is equal to K1 minus K2 over K1 plus K2.

**[26:12]:** And this tells us, running through the definition of J, the currents, and uh T and R, gives us that at the end of the day, the reflection coefficient is equal to K1 minus K2 upon K1 plus K2 norm squared. Whereas the transmission amplitude or probability is equal to uh 4 K1 K2 over K1 plus K2 squared.

**[26:45]:** Okay. And a good exercise for yourself is to rederive this. You're going to have to do that on the problem set um as a warm-up for a problem. Okay. So, at this point, we've got an answer, but it's not terribly satisfying because, you know, K1 and K2, what's the So, let's put this in terms of um more easily interpretable form. K1 and K2 are nothing other than code for the energy and the energy minus the potential, right? So, we must be able to rewrite this purely in terms of the energy and the potential E and V. And in fact, if we go through and divide both top and bottom by K1 squared on for both R and T, this has a nice expression in terms of the ratio of the of the potential to the energy. And the nice expression is 1 minus the square root of 1 minus V0 over E over uh 1 plus the square root of 1 minus V0 over E norm squared.

**[27:42]:** And similarly, the transmission amplitude has the form um 4 root 1 minus V0 over E over uh 1 plus the square root of 1 minus V0 over E squared. Okay. Um I don't remember which version of the notes I posted for this year's course. In the version from 2011, there was a typo that had here E over V, and in the version from 2012, that was corrected in the notes to being E over V0 over E. Um so, uh I'll check. But, let me just warn you about that at one on one or two pages in the notes at some point, these guys were inverted with respect to each other. But, the reason to write this out is now we can plot the following. We can now plot the quantum version of this plot. We can plot the actual quantum transmission as a function of energy.

**[28:37]:** And the classical prediction was that at energy is equal to V0, we should have a step function. But, now you can see that this is not a step function, and that's related to the fact that B was not actually zero. Right? As you pointed out. Hold on one sec. Um oh, sorry, was it quick? Then okay, the notes are wrong. Good. Thank you. Oh, that's great. Um okay, so the notes are wrong, so it should be uh V0 over E, not E over V0 um on the notes that are posted. Um we're in the process of teching them up. So, eventually, a beautiful set of nice notes will be available. Um

**[29:18]:** Extra elbow grease. Okay. So, uh so, what do we actually see? So, here we got for E less than uh E less than V0, we got indeed that the transmission probability was less than was exactly zero. So, that's a result for the quantum result. But, when E is equal to V0, what do we get? Well, when E is equal to V0, this is 1, we get square root of 1 minus 1, which is square root of zero, over square root of 1 plus square square of 1 minus 1, which is 0. Square root of 1 that's 0 over Okay, good. So that's that's not so bad except for this 1 over this e this is a little bit worrying. If you actually plot this guy out it does this. Where it asymptotes to 1. And to see that it asymptotes to 1 to see that it asymptotes to 1 just take e not gigantic.

**[30:14]:** If e not is gigantic this becomes v not over e which goes to 0. But if e is much larger than the potential. So this becomes square root of 1. And in the denominator this becomes square root of 1 1 plus 1 that's 2 squared 4 4 divided by 4 that goes to 1. So for large e much larger than v not this goes to 1. So we do recover the classical prediction if we look at energy scales very large compared to the potential height. Yeah? Okay. So that's nice. Another thing that's nice to note is that if you take this reflection probability and this transition probability this transmission probability then they sum up to 1.

**[31:01]:** This turns out to be a general fact and it's a necessary condition in order for those to be interpretable as reflection and transmission probabilities. The probability that it transmits and the probability that it reflects had better add to 1 or something is eating your particles. Right? Which is probably not what you're looking for. So um this turns out to be true in this case just explicitly but you can also on as you will on your problem set prove that from that definition of r and t it's always true. Just a check on the sensibility of our definition. If it weren't true it wouldn't tell you that quantum mechanics is wrong it would tell you that we chose a stupid definition of the transmission and reflection probabilities. So in this case we actually chose quite an enlightened one. Okay, questions at this point? Yeah. Does this analysis even hold for like classical particles?

**[31:47]:** We're talking about like the difference between like if I threw a baseball and I happened to throw it at a potential that that had height like 1 millionth of a joule less than the energy of the baseball would we observe this also? No. No? No. For the following reason. So uh So here's my classical system. Okay? Classical system is you know, literally some hill. So where I was growing up as a kid there was a hill not far from our house. I'm not even going to go into it but it was horrible. Um so if if you have if you have energy just ever so slightly greater than the hill he said from some experience. Um if you have energy that's ever so slightly greater Okay. I'm going to resist the temptation. So um One of these days. Um if you have energy that's ever so slightly greater than the hill.

**[32:36]:** Okay? And you start up here. What does that tell you? What does it mean to say that you have energy just ever so slightly greater than the potential energy at that point? Little tiny velocity. Okay? And I'm going to say I have a little tiny velocity this way. Okay? So what happens? We follow Newton's equations. They are totally unambiguous. And what they tell you is the with 100% certainty this thing will roll and roll and roll and then all hell will break loose and then if you're very lucky your car gets caught in the trees on the side of the cliff which is later referred to by the policeman who helps you tow it out as nature's guardrail.

**[33:22]:** I was young. It won't happen again. So with 100% certainty Newton's equations send you right off the cliff and for style points backward. So

**[33:39]:** So now I'm going to do the second thing. Newton's laws satisfy time reversal invariance. So the time reversal of this is this thing has this much energy and it shoots up the cliff and ever so slowly it just eventually goes up to the top where everything is fine. Okay? But does it ever reflect back downhill? No. And does it ever classically when you roll the thing does it ever actually not go off the cliff and hit the trees or but instead reflect backwards? I wish the answer were yes. But sadly the answer is no. Now if that car had been quantum mechanically small my insurance would have been much more manageable. Right? So but but sadly it wasn't. Okay? So this is a pretty stark and vivid this is a pretty stark difference between the quantum mechanical prediction and the classical prediction. Everyone cool with that?

**[34:33]:** Other questions? Yeah. I understand why it works out that r plus t equals 1 Yeah. I don't I'm not sure I understand the motivation to using the square for the ratio. Excellent. Okay. So the reason to do it so j so great. Excellent. Um How to say?

**[34:57]:** So when you calculate out uh when you calculate So here's one way to think about it.

**[35:08]:** We we know So the first thing we want is we want to define So this is a very good question. Let me repeat the question. The question is look why is it squared? Um why isn't it why isn't it linear? Um and um so let's let's think about that. Um uh ah ah ah

**[35:28]:** The reason it's squared is because of a typo. So let's think about Let's let's let's step back for a second and let's let's think Okay, it's a very good question. So let's think about what it should be. Okay, so let's let's for the moment put a put an arbitrary power there. Okay? And let's think about what it should be. Thank you so much for this question. I owe you like a plate of cheese or something. So that's high praise guys. I you know, French cheese. So um so should it be should it be linear should it be quadratic? What is that supposed to represent? What is t the capital t supposed to represent? Probability of transmission. Exactly. The wave function is the wave function at the value of the wave function at some point is that a probability? It's a Is it a probability density?

**[36:20]:** It is a probability amplitude. It is a thing whose norm squared is a probability. So we want something that's quadratic in the wave function. Right? Meanwhile a sometime before we wanted a definition of how much stuff is moving past a point at a given moment in time. Right? What's the probability density moving past a point at a given moment in time? And that's where we got the current j from in the first place. J was the probability density moving past uh a point uh at a given moment in time. Really more precisely well yes. So notice that j is quadratic in in the wave function. So it's how much stuff is moving past in a particular direction. Right? We chose it to be the incident to the reflected bit. Um at a moment in time. So it's a probability density. It's actually current. And it's quadratic in the wave function.

**[37:09]:** So it has the right units and the right structure to be a probability. If we squared that we would be in trouble because it wouldn't be a probability it would be a probability squared and in particular it wouldn't normalize correctly. So that typo was actually a bad typo. So what happened now thinking back to you have a video someday? So you can scroll back to What happened was I didn't put the square on the first I put the square on the second and then someone said square on the first like yes but the correct answer is no square on the second. So there are no squares. Thank you for the question. Very good question. In particular the thing that was so awesome about that question is it was motivated by physics. Right? It was like look why is this thing squared the right thing? That's two factors of the wave function it's already quadratic it should be like a probability.

**[37:51]:** Why are you squaring it? Very good question. Yeah. So in the transition probability why why do we know it's zero if the energy is less than v not? Is there any like Yeah. Okay, good. So um so we'll come back to that question in a little bit but let me just quickly say that we calculated it and we see explicitly that it's zero. Now you might say well look the true wave function has a little bit of a tail. Right? So you know, there's some finite probability you'll find it here if you do a measurement. But the question we want to ask in transmission is if you send it in from far away over here how likely are you to catch it far away over here? And the answer is you are not. That makes sense? Okay, good. Okay. So so much for that one.

**[38:34]:** Now here's a fun fact I'm not going to go through this in any detail. We could have done exactly the same calculation Okay? We could have done the same calculation sending something in from the right. Yeah. And sending something in from the right in on the right corresponds to d not equal to zero and nothing coming in from the left that's a equal zero. So we could have done the case a equal zero which is in from the left in from the right.

**[39:01]:** Okay? And if you do that calculation what you find is that c is equal to k1 minus k2 upon k1 plus k2 uh uh d and b is equal to um uh 2k1 um upon uh k1 plus k2 uh d. Okay? And this says that plugging these guys in the reflection and the transmission um are the same. In particular physically what does that mean? That means the reflection and transmission are the same uphill as downhill. Well downhill is uphill. Right? They're the same both ways. But that's truly weird. Right? What's the probability to transmit quantum mechanically if you have just a little bit of energy and you send the particle in. How likely are you to go off the cliff?

**[40:01]:** If we have energy ever so slightly greater than the potential and the transmission amplitude is the same downhill as it was uphill, how likely are you to fall off the potential? Never. Because if energy is just slightly greater than V naught, then the transmission probability is very, very low. Right? The transmission to go from here to here is extremely low if the energy is close to the height of the barrier. So had I only been on a quantum mechanical hill, we would have been just fine. Right? This is a really striking result. Though this thing, the the fact that you're unlikely to scatter uphill, that's maybe not so shocking, but you're really unlikely to scatter downhill. That is surprising. Okay. So I leave it to you to check that in fact um the transmission when we do it in from the right, the transmission and reflection probabilities are the same.

**[41:05]:** Recalling that transmission means going this way, reflection means bouncing back to the right. Cool? Yeah.

**[41:17]:** Uh Beca- Again, jeez, today is just a disaster because there's a typo. This should be times A. God. And the reason you know it should be times A first off is that these should have the appropriate dimensions. So A should be there should be a an appropriate power of A. And the second thing is that if you double the stuff in, you'd better double the stuff out. So if you double A, you'd better double C. So you know there had better be a factor of A here. And that's just a typo again. So I'm sorry. Today is a bad day at the chalkboard. Thank you for that question. Yeah. Is there a physical reason for why uh R and T in are the same and so different for what from what you would classically expect or is that just the way the math There is.

**[41:59]:** I want you to ponder that. And it's either at the end of today or at the beginning of tomorrow, we'll talk about that in more detail when we when we've done a little more technology. It's a it's a good question and you should have that tingling sensation in your belly that it's something is confusing and surprising and requires more explanation. And we'll get there, but I want you to just think about it in the background first. Yeah. Uh is there any physical experiment where R and T don't sum up to one? Nope. So the question is is there any experiment in which R and T don't sum up to one? And um there are two ways to answer that. So the first way to answer that is it turns out that R and T adding up to one follows from the definitions. Okay? So one of the things you'll do on the problem set is you'll show that using these definitions of uh the transmission and reflection probabilities, they necessarily add up to one.

**[42:51]:** Strictly, they have to. They follows from the Schrödinger equation. The second answer is let's think about what it would mean if R and T didn't add up to one. If R and T didn't add up to one, then that would say look, if you throw a particle in at a barrier at some feature in your potential, some wall, then the probability that it goes this way at the end versus the probability that it goes that way at the end if you wait long enough, um is not one. So what could have happened? Well, it could have gotten stuck in there. But that doesn't even conserve momentum, right? Not even approximately. And we know that the expectation of momentum is time independent. So uh for a free particle. So if this guy No, in in in between while it's actually in the potential, it's not actually time independent.

**[43:31]:** There's a potential, there's a force, but I mean, if you took a couple particles, can some of them get annihilated or something? Uh well, here Okay, so the So if you're talking about multiple particles and interactions amongst multiple particles, then it's a slightly more complicated question. The answer there is still yes, it has to be that the total probability in is the total probability out, but um but we're only going to talk about single particles here. But it's always true that for for for We're going to take this as an assumption that things don't just disappear. Okay. That the number of particles or the total probability is conserved. And there's a a third way to to say this. This really isn't independent from the first. Remember that this current These were defined in terms of the current. The current satisfies the current concept of probability conservation equation dT of rho is equal to the gradient minus the gradient of the current.

**[44:24]:** Right? So that the probability is always conserved. This The integral of probability density is always conserved. It's time independent. So it's by definition. Yeah, it's by construction, exactly. Okay. Yeah. Um looking at your expression for the transmission probability, Yes. I'm having trouble seeing how that works out to zero when V when E is less than V naught. Oh, this is only This expression is only defined when E is equal to V naught. Right? Because we we derived this Excellent question. We derived this assuming that we had an energy greater than V naught and then that the wave function had this form. You cannot use this form of the wave function if the energy is less than V naught. If the energy is less than V naught, you've got to use that form of the wave function. And in this form of the wave function, we derived that the transmission amplitude is zero because the current on the right, the transmitted current, is zero.

**[45:12]:** So this calculation is appropriate when E is less than V naught and this calculation is appropriate when E is greater than V naught. So you're absolutely correct. You can't use this when E is less than V naught. It gives you not the same answer. In fact, it gives you a complex It's kind of confusing, right? The factors can't, but so um so it's not really a probability at all. And indeed, this is just not the right quantity to use. All right, cool. Cool? All right. So um So there are a bunch of a bunch of nice things I wanted to deduce from what we've done so far. So the first is um look, I I I pointed out that this can be derived uh just explicitly and it gives the same results as before. That's not an accident. If you take the system and you just reverse the roles of K1 and K2, what happens?

**[46:01]:** Well, that just replaces E by E minus V naught. We could do that by doing this. Replaces E by E minus V naught and E minus V naught by E. It swaps the role of A and B and it gives you exactly the same things back. So if you're careful about that, you never have to do this calculation. You can just do the appropriate transformation on that calculation. It gives you exactly the same thing. So it's the same it's the same uh it's the same same algebraic steps. But the other thing that's nice is that you can actually do the same thing from here. So as long as you set the D equals zero. So there's another term here that we neglected, E to the plus alpha X. And we set we got rid of it. But you can analytically continue this calculation by noting that look, if we just set alpha we have want minus alpha equals i K2, then the algebra is all going to be the same.

**[46:49]:** We just have i K2 instead of minus alpha. So we can just replace alpha with minus i K2 everywhere in our expressions, uh being careful about exactly how we do so, being being careful to take care of factors of i and such correctly. Um and you derive the same results for both cases, which is a a nice check on the calculation. So often when you get a little bit of experience with these, you don't actually have to do the calculation again. You can just take what you know from a previous calculation and and write down the correct answer. Um so it's a fun thing to play with. Exactly how do you do that? So I invite you to think through that process while you're doing your problem set. Another thing is the reflection downhill thing, which is pretty surprising. But here's the thing that I really want to emphasize.

**[47:33]:** What this calculation shows you is not so much that is not just that reflection downhill is highly unlikely or sorry, uh transmission downhill is highly unlikely when the energy uh is very close to the potential the height of the potential barrier. That's true, but it's not the most interesting thing about this calculation. The most interesting thing about this calculation, to my mind, is the fact that from the detailed shape of the transmission as a function of energy,

**[48:03]:** we can deduce what the potential is. And let's think about what that tells you. If someone if you do an experiment, you have a a barrier and you want to know the shape of the barrier. Is it straight? Is it wiggly? Does it have some complicated shape? And how do you how do you measure that? Well, you might measure it by just looking. But imagine you can't for some reason. For whatever reason, it's in a box or you can't look at it. Maybe it's just preposterously small. How can you deduce what the shape of that hill is? Well, one way to do it is to send in particles as a function of energy, more and more energy, and measure the probability that they transmit. Okay? Now if you do so and you get this graph as a function of E, what do you deduce? You deduce that the barrier that you're scattering off of is a square step with this height V naught.

**[48:51]:** Everybody cool with that? So apparently, just by looking at the transmission amplitudes, the transmission probabilities, you can deduce at least something of the form of the potential. Which is kind of cool. If you didn't know the potential, you could figure out what it was. And this turns out to be a very general statement that you can deduce an enormous amount. And as we'll see, you can in fact deduce basically everything you want of the potential from knowing about the transmission probabilities as well as the phase shift, the transmission amplitudes. Okay, so this is the basic goal of scattering. And so the way I want you to think about it is imagine, for example, that someone ha- hands you an object, a a box, and the box has an import and it has an output. Okay? And they allow you to send in particles as a function of energy and measure transmission and reflection.

**[49:39]:** You measure transmission and reflection just as like I'm measuring transmission and off of your faces right now, from the light from above. So, suppose that you do so, put it on your test stand and you measure transmission, and you measure transmission as a function of energy, and you deduce and you observe the following: the transmission as a function of energy is uh small up until some uh some point, and then uh at some point which is maybe the minimum energy you can really meaningfully probe, you get something like this.

**[50:14]:** Okay.

**[50:19]:** So, here's the transmission as a function of energy. So, what can you say? If this is all the information you have about what's going on inside the box, what can you deduce about the thing inside the box? Well, one thing you can deduce is that it looks kind of like it looks kind of like a potential with height around V naught. It looks kind of like a potential step with uh with some height V naught. This is asymptoting to one. However, it's not because it has these oscillations in it. So, there's more to the potential than just a barrier of height V naught. What I want to show you is that you can deduce everything about that potential. And that's the point of scattering. So, let's do it. So, the goal here, again, to say it differently is what's V naught? Or what is V of X?

**[51:14]:** Not just the height, but the total potential. So, another way to say this, let me set up a precise version of this question. I want to be able to do the following. I want to take a system that has a potential which is constant up to some point which I'll call zero, and then uh oops. And then again from some point which I'll call L, is constant again, and inside I don't know what the potential is. Okay? So, in here there's some unknown potential V of X, which is some crazy thing, right? It could be doing anything, could be some crazy could have, you know, horns and whatever. It could be awful. But, the potential is constant if you go far enough away, and the potential is constant if you go far enough away. Good example of this is like uh uh hydrogen atom, right?

**[52:05]:** It's neutral, but there's a clearly an complicated potential inside cuz there's the proton and the electron, they're moving around in there in some quantum state anyway. And if you send something at it, far away it's as if it's not there, but close by you know there's strong electrostatic forces. And so, the question is what can you learn about those forces? What can you learn about the potential uh by throwing things in from far away from either side? Now, one thing we know already is that out here, the wave function always, because it's a constant potential, always takes the form E to the I K X plus B E to the minus I K X. And out here it takes the form C E to the I K X plus D E to the minus I K X. And again, this corresponds to moving in, D is in from the right, C is out to the right, B is out to the left, and A is in from the left.

**[53:00]:** And so again, there are basically four kinds of scattering experiments we can do. We can send things in from the right, which corresponds to setting A to zero. We can send things in from the left, which corresponds to setting D equals zero. And all of the information about what happens in V is going to be encoded in what's coming out, the B and C coefficients. Okay? And the way to make that sharp is just to notice that the transmission probability, if we compute for this system for this assuming this form of the wave function asymptotically away from the potential, the transmission amplitude is just C over A squared when you're sending in from the left, and the reflection is equal to uh B over A norm sorry uh norm squared. This squared is a squared. Wave function amplitude squared. Good. Okay. So, to learn about the transmission and reflection coefficients, it's enough, suffices, to compute, to know

**[53:59]:** B and C as a function of A and D. All of the scattering information is in those coefficients B and C for A and D. And here I'm assuming that I'm sending in a monochromatic wave with a single well-defined energy. Okay, I'm sending in a beam of particles with energy E. I don't know where they are, but I sure know what their momentum is. Right? So, it's some well-defined beam of momentum of particles with energy E. And these are the these probabilities are going to contain all the data I want. So, this is the basic project of scattering. Okay, questions? So, basically only depends on the transmission only depends on the edges? Well, it's not so much that Good question. The question is does the transmission depend only on what you do at the edges? And here's the important thing. The transmission depends crucially on what happens in here.

**[54:52]:** For example, if this is an infinitely high barrier, nothing's going across, right? So, the transmission depends on what's in here. But, the point is we can deduce just by looking far away, we can deduce the transmission probabilities and amplitudes just by measuring B and C far away. They're B and C far away. Okay? So, the transmission amplitude is something you measure when very far away. You measure if I throw something in from very far out here to the left, how likely is it to get out here very far to the right? And that, in order to answer that, if someone hands you the answer to that, they must have solved for what's inside. That's the point. So, knowing the answer to that question encodes information about what happened in between. So, I mean, I guess initially this was the your potential's going to associate with the stuff you did earlier.

**[55:39]:** Yeah. Here's what the potential drops down to the right of the box. Is that going to be problematic? Yeah, I'm going to for simplicity I'm going to assume that the potential always goes to zero when we're far away, because that's going to be useful for modeling things like hydrogen and yeah, exactly. Carbon, and we're going to do diamond later in this semester, then that'll be useful. Um but, we could repeat this analysis by adding an extra change in the asymptotic potential. It doesn't really change anything important. Yeah. Um it looks like even for just the simple step up or down, you can't tell from just the probabilities whether your step is going up or going down. Ah, excellent. Excellent. Excellent. So, there's got Good. Thank you for that question. That's really great. So, already it seems like we can't uniquely identify the the um the potential from the transmission probability if the transmission probability is the same for step up or step down.

**[56:31]:** Right? So, what's missing? Maybe the energy how it came out, you could probably tell. But, the but it we're working with an energy eigenstate, so the energy is just a global constant. We'll see what's missing, and what's missing is something called the phase shift. So, we'll we'll Very good question. Yeah. It looks like when we did the example for the step, that the T was something different than C over A squared. Yeah, it is because it's the ratio of So, that's why I wrote T as C over A here. So, T is the ratio of J over J I. And in fact, J T here, J T uh is equal to uh C squared times So, this is the probability density. So, it's probability density times the velocity. What's the effective velocity here? H bar K 2 over M. Whereas, J incident oops. J incident is equal to A squared, the probability density, times the momentum there or the velocity there, which is H bar K 1 upon M.

**[57:34]:** So, here are the ratio of J transmitted to J incident is C squared, norm C squared, K 2 over norm A squared K 1. Exactly. It's because it's not level. So, here they happen to be level, so the momenta factor cancel, and the only thing that survives is the amplitude. Good question. Yeah. Um for our black box examples, is it sufficient just to know what is reflected back from the whole situation? It It's not So, for for precision of this reason, it's not sufficient to know T. It's not sufficient to know T and R, but of course, once you know R, you know T, so you're exactly right that once you know the reflection probability, you know the transmission probability. But, there's one more bit of information which we're going to also need in order to specify the potential, which is going to be the phase shift.

**[58:22]:** But, see But, you're right, you don't need to independently compute B and T or R and T. You could just compute one. So, if you measure both sides of the box, is that my question? Um you don't need sensors on Well, you don't need sensors on both sides of the box, but you need to do more than just do the counting problem. We'll see We'll see that. Okay. So, let's take let's work out a simple example, the simplest example of a barrier of this kind. So, we want constant potential oops. We want a constant potential, and then ending at zero, and then we want it constant again and from L, and uh going off to infinity. So, it's the easiest possible thing we could do. Step step. We're just doing what we've done before twice. Okay? So, this is an example of this kind of potential.

**[59:06]:** It's sort of ridiculously simple, uh but let's let's work it out. So, we want to scatter in So, let's start out we could do either scattering from the left or scattering from the right. Let's start out scattering from the left, so D equals zero. Let's study this problem. So, what we know, do do do, and let's also note that we have two we have two choices or we have a choice to make. We could either study energy below the height of the potential or we could study energy above the height of the potential. And so, for simplicity, I'm also going to start with energy greater than the height of the potential V naught. And then we'll do E less than V naught afterwards. It'll be an easy extension of what we've done.

**[59:46]:** Okay, so this will be our first case to study. So we know the form of the wave function out here. It's A E to the I K X B E to the minus I K X. We know the form of the potential out here. It's C E to the I K X and D E to the minus I K X. The only thing we don't know is the form of the potential in here. And in here it's actually very simple. It's got to be something of the form I think I called it F and G my notes. I did. Um F uh E to the I K two K prime X. So I'm calling this K, so I'll just call this K prime X. Plus G uh E to the minus I K prime X. And the reason I chose K prime is because we were working with exponential or energy greater than the potential, so this is a classically allowed region.

**[1:00:25]:** It's an oscillatory domain, but with a different K prime. So here K squared uh H bar squared over 2 M is equal to E. And uh H bar squared K prime squared uh over 2 M is equal to E minus V naught, which is positive when E is greater than V naught. This analysis will not obtain when E is less than V naught. We'll have to treat it separately. Okay. So now what do we do? Well, we do the same thing we did before. We just do it twice. We'll do the matching conditions here, the matching conditions here. That's going to give us 1 2 3 4 matching conditions. We have 1 2 3 4 5 6 unknown coefficients, so we'll have two independent ones. That's great. We set D equal to zero to specify from that it's coming in from the left and not from the right.

**[1:01:08]:** That's uh five. And then we have normalization, which is six. So this should uniquely specify our wave function. Yeah? Once we fixed E. We have enough conditions. So I'm not going to go through the derivation cuz it's just an extension of what we did for the first. It's just a whole bunch of algebra. And let me just emphasize this. The algebra is not interesting. It's just algebra. You have to be able to do it. You have to develop some familiarity with it. And it's easy to get good at this. You just practice. It's just algebra. Um but once you get the idea, don't ever do it again. Once you get reasonably quick at it, learn to use Mathematica, Maple, whatever package you want and use computer algebra to check your analysis and use your physics to check the answer you get from Mathematica or Maple or whatever

**[1:01:52]:** you use. Always check against physical reasonability, but use Mathematica. So posted on the website are Mathematica files that walk through the computation of the transmission and reflection amplitudes and probabilities for this potential um and I think maybe another one. I don't remember exactly. Um but I encourage you strongly to use computer algebra tools cuz it's just a waste of time to spend 3 hours doing an algebraic calculation. In particular, on your problem set this week um you will do a scattering problem uh similar to the scattering problem you similar to the boundary problem you did last week, the quantum glue problem, which you may be doing tonight. Um the one due tomorrow, uh which is two delta function wells and find the bound states. So that involves a fair amount of algebra. The scattering problem will involve a similar amount of algebra. Do not do it.

**[1:02:36]:** Use a use Mathematica or computer algebra just to simplify your life. Okay. Um

**[1:02:46]:** Okay, so if we go through and and compute the find So what are we going to do? We're going to use the matching conditions here to determine F and G in terms of A and B. Then we'll use the matching conditions here to determine uh C D is zero C in terms of F and G. So that's going to give us an effective constraint relating A and B, leaving us with an overall unknown coefficient A, which we'll use for normalization. The upshot of all of which is the um the answers are that I'm not even going to write down. They're in the notes. Uh should I write this down? I will skip. So the upshot is that the transmission amplitude as a function of these K uh K and K prime, the transmission probability I should say, is one over Actually, I'm going to need the whole amplitude.

**[1:03:28]:** Shoot. So uh

**[1:03:36]:** The transmission probability is equal to and this is a horribly long expression.

**[1:03:51]:** Okay. The transmission probability, which is C over A norm squared, is equal to Okay. 4 K one K squared K prime squared cosine squared of K prime L plus K one K squared plus K prime squared sine squared of K prime L under 4 K squared K prime squared. Seriously. Okay. Um So we can simplify this out. So you can do some algebra. This is just what you get when you just naively do the algebra. And now I want to I I want to do two things. First off, uh this is horrible. There's a cosine squared, there's a sine squared. Surely we can all be friends and put it together. So let's use some trig. But the second thing, and the more important thing, is I want to put this in dimensionless form. This is horrible. Here we have K's and we have L's and these all have dimensions.

**[1:04:57]:** And they're, you know, inside the signs and the cosines is K L. That's good cuz it has units of one over length, this has units of length, so that's dimensionless. But let's put everything in dimensionless form. And in particular, what are the parameters of my system? The parameters of my system are well, there's a mass, there's an H bar, there's a V naught, and then there's an energy, and there's a length L. Okay? So it's easy to make a dimensionless parameter out of these guys. And a ratio of energies, a dimensionless ratio of energies out of these guys. So I'm going to do that. And the parameters I'm going to use are um coming from here, which uh

**[1:05:38]:** Okay. I'm going to define the parameters G naught squared, which is a dimensionless measure of the depth of the potential. We've actually run into this guy before. 2 M L squared V naught over H bar squared. Okay? So this is H bar squared 1 over L squared is K squared over 2 M, so that's an energy. So this is a ratio of the height of the potential to the characteristic energy corresponding to the length scale L. Okay? So the width, there's an energy corresponding to it because you take a momentum, which has one over that width. You can build an energy out of that H bar K squared over 2 M. And we have an energy, which is the height of the barrier. We take the ratio of those. Okay? So that's a dimensionless quantity G naught. And the other dimensionless quantity I want to consider is the ratio of the energy E to V naught, which is what showed up before in our energy plots.

**[1:06:30]:** So or in our transmission plot over there, E over V naught. So when we take this and we do a little bit bit of algebra to simplify your life, again, use Mathematica, it's your friend, the result is much more palatable. It's T for again, for the energy greater than V naught, is equal to still still long, but 1 plus uh 1 over 4 epsilon epsilon minus 1 sine squared of G naught square root of uh epsilon minus 1.

**[1:07:15]:** And upstairs is a 1. Okay? So remember, this is only valid for E greater than V naught or equivalently epsilon greater than 1. And I guess we can put an equal in.

**[1:07:32]:** So when you get an expression like this, this is as easy as you're going to make this expression. It's not going to get any easier. It's 1 over a sine times a function plus 1. There's really no simple way to great way to simplify this. So what you need to do when you get an expression like this is try to figure out what it's telling you. Useful thing to do is to plot it. So let's just look at this function and see what it's telling us. Let's plot this T as a function of epsilon. And for some fixed G naught. Okay? And keep in mind that this only makes sense for E greater than V naught or for epsilon greater than 1. So here's 1. And we're going to remain agnostic as to what happens below 1. And just for normalization, we know that the transmission probability can never be greater than 1, so it's got to be between 1 and 0.

**[1:08:15]:** So here's 0 and 0. Okay, so we're remaining agnostic about this for the moment. So let's start thinking about what this plot looks like. First off, what does it look like at 1? So when epsilon goes to 1, this is going to zero. That's bad cuz it's in a denominator. But upstairs, this is going to zero. And sine squared of something when it's becoming small goes like well, sine goes like that thing. So sine squared goes like this quantity squared. So sine squared goes like G naught squared. This goes like 1 over This is going like G naught squared epsilon minus 1 square root quantity squared, which is epsilon minus 1. So this is going to zero and this the denominator is going to zero exactly in the same way. Epsilon minus 1 from here, epsilon minus 1 downstairs from here. So the epsilon minus 1's precisely cancel.

**[1:09:01]:** From the sine squared we get a G naught squared. And from here we get a 4 epsilon. So we get 1 plus G naught squared over 4 epsilon. But 4 epsilon, what was epsilon here? 1, right? Cuz we're looking at epsilon goes to 1. So this is just a G naught squared over 4. So the height or the the value of T, so we're we're not looking in here, but at uh energy is equal to V naught or epsilon is equal to 1, we know that the transmission amplitude is not zero, but it's also strictly smaller than 1, which is good cuz if it were 6, you'd be really worried. So, g not squared if g not squared is zero, what do we get? One, fantastic. There's no barrier. We just keep right on going through it. Perfect transmission. If g not is not zero, however, the transmission is suppressed like 1 over g not squared.

**[1:09:49]:** So, what does this actually look like? Well, some value. Okay, and what is this value? It's just 1 over 1 plus 1/4 g not squared. Cool? Okay. And now what happens, for example, for very large epsilon? Well, when epsilon is gigantic, sine squared of this is Well, sine squared is oscillating rapidly, so that's kind of worrying. If this is very, very large, this is a rapidly oscillating function. However, it's being divided by roughly epsilon squared. So, something that goes between 0 and 1 divided by epsilon squared as epsilon gets large becomes zero. And so, we get 1 over 1 plus 0, we get 1. So, for very large values, it's asymptotic to 1. So, naively, it's going to do something like this. However, there's this sine squared, and in fact, this is exactly what it would do if we just had the 1 over epsilon uh times some constant.

**[1:10:44]:** But in fact, we have the sine squared, and the sine squared is making it wiggle. And the frequency of the wiggle is g not, except that it's not linear in epsilon, it's linear in square root of epsilon. So, as epsilon gets larger, the square root of epsilon is getting larger less than linearly. Yeah? So, what that's telling you is if you looked at root epsilon, you would see it with even period, but we don't have root epsilon. We're plotting this as a function of epsilon, so it's not even period, it's getting wider and wider. Meanwhile, there's a nice fact about this. For special values of epsilon, what happens to sine squared? It goes to zero. What happens when this is zero? Yeah, T is 1. So, every time sine is zero, i.e. for sufficient values of when root epsilon is a multiple of pi determined by g not, transmission goes to 1.

**[1:11:32]:** It becomes perfect. So, in fact, instead of doing Wow. So, in instead of doing this, instead of doing this, what it does

**[1:11:44]:** is it does this.

**[1:11:49]:** And so, let's check that I'm not lying to you. So, let me draw it slightly differently. So, to to check, so it's going to zero, and the period of the zero is getting further and further along. That's because this is square root, not squared. So, epsilon has to get much larger to hit the next period, right? And that's why it's getting larger and larger spacing. However, the amplitude it goes down from 1, that's when this gets largest. Well, at large values of epsilon, this is suppressed. As we get epsilon epsilon epsilon goes larger and larger, this deviation becomes smaller and smaller. Okay? So, that's what this plot is telling us. This plot is telling us a bunch of things. First off,

**[1:12:29]:** we see that at large energies, we transmit perfectly. That makes sense. This was a finite height barrier. Large energies, we don't even notice it. Tells you at low energies, well, we don't know yet what happens at very low energies, but at reasonably low energies, the transmission is suppressed. And if you sort of squint, this roughly does what we'd expect from the step barrier. However, something really special is happening at special values of epsilon. We're getting perfect transmission.

**[1:12:57]:** We get perfect transmission at these points. T is equal to 1. Perfect. Star. Happy with a big nose. I don't know. You know, this perfect transmission at all these points. So, this leaves us with a question of Look, why? Right? Why the perfect transmission? What's the mechanism making transmission perfect? But it also does something really lovely for us. Suppose you see a spectrum you see a transmission amplitude or transmission probability that looks like this. You may get crappy data. You may see that it's smudged out and you see all sorts of messy stuff, but if you know that there's perfect transmission at some particular epsilon 1, there's more perfect transmission at another epsilon 2, more perfect transmission at epsilon 3, and they scale, they fit to this prediction, what do you know? That you've got a finite height barrier. It's probably pretty well approximated by a square step.

**[1:13:51]:** Yeah? So, on your problem set, you're going to get experimental data. You're going to have to match to the experimental data. You're going to have to predict something about the potential that created a particular transmission probability distribution. And knowing where these resonances are, where these points of perfect transmission is going to be very useful for you. Yeah. Why couldn't there be another potential that will still create the periodicity of the ones? A very good question. So, let me I'm going to turn that around to you. Um can you orchestrate a potential that gives you the same thing?

**[1:14:24]:** That's an interesting empirical question. So, on the problem set, you'll study a double well potential. So, the the question was um uh how do I know there isn't another potential that gives me the same answer? And at this point, we don't know. Maybe there is another potential. In fact, you can do all sorts of things to make a potential that's very arbitrarily close that gives you an arbitrarily similar profile. But the natural So, if they're significantly different, how different do they look? So, on the problem set So, then the student said, "Well, I don't know. What about a double well potential?" So, in fact, we'll be doing a double well potential on the problem set. Okay. Um a good question, and we certainly haven't proven anything like this is the only potential that gives you this transmission amplitude. What we can say is if you get transmission amplitude that looks like this, it's probably pretty reasonable to to to, you know, say it's probably well modeled, right?

**[1:15:07]:** We seem to be reproducing the data reasonably well. So, it's not a proof of anything, but it's a nice model, and we're physicists. We build models. We don't tell you what's true. We tell you what are good models. If a theorist ever walks up to you and says like, "Here's the truth," punch him in the gut. Okay? It's not how it works. Experimentalists, on the other hand, well, just punch them, too, I guess. Um We build models. Okay. So, this leaves us with uh with an obvious question, which we've answered this in the in the in in the in the case of energy greater than the potential. Um Oops. What about the case of the energy less than the potential? So, we haven't filled out that part of the graph. Let's fill out that part of the graph. What happens if the energy is less than the potential?

**[1:15:59]:** And for this, I'm going to do the I'm going to use the trick that I mentioned uh earlier, that Look, if the energy is less than the potential, that just means that in the intervening regime, in here, instead of being oscillatory, it's going to be exponentially growing and damped because we're in a classically disallowed region. So, if the energy is less than V not, here we have instead of I K X, we have minus alpha X. And instead of minus I K X, we have plus alpha X. So, if you go through that whole analysis and plug in those values for the K's for for the K prime, the answer you get is really quite nice. We find that T for energy less than V not is equal to and it's just a direct analytic continuation of what you get here.

**[1:16:45]:** 1 plus uh 1 over 4 epsilon 1 minus epsilon. So, epsilon is less than 1 now. Uh 1 sinh squared of g not 1 minus epsilon under 1. Okay. So, now this lets us complete the plot.

**[1:17:13]:** And you can check, it's pretty straightforward, that because sinh again goes like it's it's argument at very small values of its argument, again we get g not squared 1 minus epsilon. Um sorry, this should be square root. 1 minus epsilon. Um really? Is it That a typo? Oh, no, it's in there. Okay, good. Um so, uh so, again we get g not squared 1 minus epsilon. The 1 minus epsilon cancels, and we get 1 over 4 g not squared, which is good because if they disagreed, we'd be in real trouble, right? So, they agree, but the sinh squared is just a strictly or that function is just a strictly decreasing function as we approach epsilon goes to zero. It goes smoothly to zero. So, this is what we see. We see an exponential region, and then we see oscillations with resonances where the period is getting wider and wider.

**[1:18:01]:** Okay? But this this should trouble you a little bit. Here, what are we seeing? We're saying, "Look, if we have a barrier, and we send in a particle with energy way below the barrier,

**[1:18:16]:** that's kind of troubling. If we send in a particle with energy way below the barrier, there's some probability that it gets out, that it goes across.

**[1:18:27]:** So, for E less than V not,

**[1:18:33]:** classically no transmission, we get transmission. Now, do we get resonances when E is less than V not? No, that's an interesting thing, and we'll talk about resonances and where they come from, and we'll talk about the more generalized notion of an S matrix in the next lecture. But for now, I just want to say a couple of things about it. So, I want to ask So, this is called tunneling. This transmission across the barrier, so across a disallowed barrier classically disallowed barrier.

**[1:19:15]:** So, this transmission across the classically disallowed barrier is called tunneling. And just a quick thing to notice is that if we hold e fixed

**[1:19:25]:** and we vary L, we vary the the width of the barrier, how does the tunneling amplitude depend on the width of the barrier? Right? At fixed energy, if we vary the width of the barrier, which is only contained in G naught, how does the transmission amplitude vary? And we find that for large L, very L much greater than one for typical scale in the problem, the tunneling amplitude goes like e to the minus two alpha L. Where alpha just depends on the energy in the potential. So, what we see is that the probability of transmitting, of tunneling through the through a wall, depends on the width of that wall. And it depends on it exponentially. The wider the wall, the exponentially less likely you are to tunnel across it. And this fits the simulation we ran, where we saw that tunneling the through a very thin wall was actually quite efficient.

**[1:20:17]:** And we also saw that tunneling across a wall can have resonant peaks at special values. It transmits perfectly. We saw that in the simulations. So, at this point, um I can't So, at this point I can't resist telling you a very short story. Um I have a very good friend, I have a very good friend who's not a physicist, uh but but who is a professor at MIT. Uh so, you know, a smart a smart person. And um very smart. She's one of the smartest people I know. Um and she uh she broke her ankle. Okay. She's always losing stuff. She's constantly losing stuff. And and she broke her ankle and she was going to the to the uh rehab place. And she parked her car right in front of the rehab place. And she parked her car right in front because she you know, she's got the broken ankle and she doesn't want to have to walk a long way to get the car and and she right in front.

**[1:21:04]:** She went in, she did her two hours of rehab, and she came outside and her car was gone. And you know, she's always misplacing her car, she's always misplacing her keys, she's always losing everything. But this time this time she knew where it was. And it wasn't there. And so, first she thought, "Oh, crap, my car's been stolen." Like this is just how annoying. I've got a broken ankle, my car. But she looks around and there's her car on the other side of the street pointed the opposite direction. And she's like, "Finally. Finally." And she was explaining this to me and a friend of mine who's also a physicist. She said, "Finally, I knew I had incon- I had just incontrovertible proof that quantum effects happen to macroscopic objects. My car tunneled across the street." At this point, of course, my friend and I are just like dying of laughter.

**[1:21:55]:** But she's saying, "My car tunneled across the street. And but here is the problem. I couldn't tell anyone because if I told anyone, they would know that I was crazy, right? Clearly I'm crazy because, you know, surely, you know, I I lose my stuff all the time, but surely it's just got misplaced. So, I went home and I got home and I was sitting down to dinner with my partner and our daughter and and and I was burning up inside cuz I wanted to tell them this crazy thing happened. I know quantum mechanics, it happens. And I couldn't tell them anything. So, I was just fidgeting and dying. And finally, my daughter said, "Mom, didn't you notice that we moved the car across the street?"

**[1:22:31]:** See you next time.
