Transcript
the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu today I'm going to continue uh the idea of setting up integrals and what we'll deal with is volumes by slices by slicing and it's lucky that this is after lunch maybe it's after breakfast for some of you because there's a the typical uh way of introducing this subject is with a food an ology there's a lot of ways of slicing up food and we'll give a few more examples than just this one but suppose you have well suppose you have a loaf of bread here so here's our loaf of bread and I hope that looks a little bit like a loaf of bread it's supposed to be sitting on the on the kitchen counter ready to be eaten uh and in order to figure out how much bread there is there one way of doing it is to cut it into slices now you probably know that bread is often sliced like this there are even machines to do it and with this set up here I'll draw the slice with a little bit of a more colorful decoration so here's our red slice of bread it's coming around like this and it comes back down behind all right so here's our our our bread slice and and what I'd like to figure out is its volume so first of all there's the thickness of the bread which is this Dimension the thickness is this Dimension DX here and the only other dimension that I'm going to give because this is a very qualitative analysis for now is the what I'll call the area and that's the area of the face of the slice and so the area of one slice which I'll denote by Delta V that's a chunk of volume is approximately the area times the change in X and in the limit that's going to be something like this and maybe the areas of the slices vary there might be a little hole in the middle of the bread somewhere maybe it gets a little small on one side so it might CH change as X changes then the whole volume you get by adding up so if you like this is one slice and this is the sum and you should think of it uh in a sort of intuitive way as being analogous to the remon sum where you would take each slice individually and that would look like this all right so that's just a superficial and uh intuitive way of looking at it now we're only going to talk about one kind of systematic slices already on your problem set you had an example of a slice of some region uh but we're only going to talk systematically about something called solids of revolution the idea here is this suppose you have some shape some graph which is maybe looks like this and now I'm going to revolve it this is the the xaxis and this is the y- AIS in this case I'm going to revolve it around the xaxis if you do that then the shape that you get is maybe like this if I can draw it a little bit it's maybe a football all right so that's the shape that you get if you take this uh piece of disc and you and you revolve it around if you had made this copy underneath it still would have been the same region so we only pay attention to what's above the axis here all right so that's the basic idea now I'm going to apply the method of slices to figure out the volume of such regions and give you a general formula and then apply it in a specific case I want to take one little slice of this this football maybe a football wouldn't work too well maybe it should be we should go back to a loaf of bread anyway the key point is that you never really have to draw a 3D picture and 3D pictures are of awful they're very hard to deal with and it's hard to visualize with them and one of the reasons why we're dealing with solids of revolution is that we don't have as many visualization problems so we're only going to deal with this and then you have to imagine from the the the two-dimensional cross-section what the three-dimensional picture looks like so we'll do a little bit of an exercise with the three-dimensional picture but ultimately you should be used to getting used to drawing 2D diagrams always to depict the three-dimensional situation since it's much harder to draw the first step is to consider what this slice is over here and again it's going to have width DX and we're going to consider what it looks like over on the 3D picture so it's it starts out being more or less like this but then we're going to sweep it around we're we're we're revolving around the xaxis so spitting around this way and if you take this and think of it as being on a hinge which is down on the x-axis it's going to swing down and swoop around and come back swing around and that traces out uh something over here which I'm going to draw this way it traces out a disc all right so it's hard for me to draw and I'm not going to try too hard maybe I I draw drew it more like a wheel looking like a wheel but anyway it's this little flat disc here and so the method that I'm describing for uh figuring out the volume is called the method of diss this is going to be our first method now I'm going to apply the reasoning that I have up on the the previous Blackboard here namely I need to get the volume of this chunk and the way I'm going to get the volume of this chunk is by figuring out its thickness and its area its cross-sectional area and that's not too difficult to do if this height so this height is what we usually call y y is usually a function of X it's varying this particular distance is y then the area of the face is easy to calculate because it's a a a circle or a disc if you like with this radius so its area is pi y^ 2 so that's if you like the uh one of the dimensions and then the thickness is DX so so the incremental volume is this so this is the method of Diss and this is the uh integrand now there's one peculiar thing about this formula and uh there more peculiar things about this formula but there's one peculiar thing that you should notice immediately which is that I'm integrating with respect to X and I haven't yet told you what Y is well that will depend on what function y equal F ofx I use so we have to plug that in eventually if we're actually going to calculate something we're going to have to figure that out there's another very important point which is that in order to get a definite integral something I haven't mentioned we're going to have to figure out where we're starting and where we're ending the picture which is something we dealt with last time in 2D pictures all right so let's let's deal with an example and uh we'll switch over from a football to a soccer ball I'm going to take a circle and we'll say it has radius a so this is zero and this is a and I'm putting it in this particular spot for a reason you can do this in lots of different ways but I'm picking this one to make a certain exercise that on your homework easier for you because I'm doing half of it for you right now all right yeah appreciated yeah I'm sure especially today it's appreciated so again the formula has to do with keeping track of these slices here and we're sweeping things around so the full region that we're talking about is the volume of the ball of radius a that's what what our goal is to figure out what the the volume of the ball of radius a is all right again as I say that the thing sweeps around uh coming out of the Blackboard spitting around on this on this x axis all right so the setup is the following it's always the same here's our formula and we need to figure out what's going on with that formula and so we need to solve for y as a function of X and in order to do that what we're going to do is just write down the equation for the circle this is the circle it's centered at a0 So that's its formula and now there's one nice thing which is that we really didn't need to find the formula for y we only need to find the formula for y^2 so let's just solve for y^2 and we won't have to solve a quadratic or anything take a square root that's nice this is a s - x^ 2 - 2 ax + a 2 the a s's cancel these two terms cancel and so the formula here is 2 ax - x^2 all right now that is what's known as the integrand well except for this factor of Pi here and so the answer for the volume is going to be the integral of Pi times this integrant 2 a x - x^2 DX and that's just the same thing as this but now there's also the issue of the limits which is a completely separate problem which we also have to solve the range of X is from this leftmost point to the rightmost point so X varies starts at zero and it goes all the way up to what what's the Top Value here 2 a and so now I have a completely specified integral again and this was the theme last time the whole goal is to get ourselves to a complete formula for something with an integrand and limits and then we'll be able to calculate now we're we're we have clear sailing to the end of the problem all right so let's just finish it off we have the volume is if I take the anti-derivative of that that's Pi * uh ax^2 whose derivative is 2 ax - x Cub over 3 that's the thing whose derivative is - x^2 evaluated at 0 and 2 a and that is equal to um Pi * let's see um uh 2^2 is four so this is 4 a cubed minus uh 8 a cubed over 3 right and so all told that is let's see 12/3 - 8/3 pi a cubed which is uh maybe familiar formula 4/3 pi a cub so it worked we got it we got it right let me just point out uh a couple of other things about this formula the first one is that from this point of view we've actually accomplished more than just finding the volume of the ball we've also found the volume of a bunch of intermediate regions which I can draw schematically this way if I chop this thing and this portion is X here then the anti-derivative here this region here which maybe I'll fill in with this region here which I'm going to call V of X is the volume of the portion of the sphere volume of um portion of width x of the ball and well the formula for it is that it's the the volume is equal to Pi ax^2 - XB 3 that's it so we've got something which is actually a lot more information for instance if you plug in x equals u a not surprisingly and this is this is a good idea to do because it checks that we've actually got a correct formula here so if you like you can call this a double check if you check check V of a this should be the volume of a half ball that's half way if I go over here and I only go up to a that's exactly half of the ball that had better be half so let's just see V of a in this case is pi and then I have a cubed minus a cub over 3 and that turns out to be pi times a CO total of 2/3 a cubed which is which is indeed half now on your problem set what you're going to want to look at is is this full formula here of this chunk and what it's going to be good for is is a a real life problem that is a problem that really came up over the summer and uh this fall at uh a couple of universities near here where people were trying to figure out uh a phenomenon which is well uh known namely if you have a a bunch of particles uh in a um in a fluid and maybe the size of these things is is uh is one micron that is the radius is one micron and then you have a bunch of other little particles which are a lot smaller maybe 10 nanom then what happens is that the particles the big particles like to hug each other they like to Clump together it's very they're very nice friendly characters so what what's the explanation for this the explanation is that actually uh they are not quite as friendly as they might seem what's really happening is that the little guys are shoving them around and pushing them together and they're they have sharp elbows the little ones and they're pushing them don't don't like them to be around and and and they're pushing them together um but there's actually another possibility which is that they also will stick to the sides of the container all right so so there are two things that actually happen here and if you want to get a quantitative handle on how much of this happens it has to do with how much space these things take up and so the issue is some kind of overlap between a band around one sphere and a band around the other sphere and this overlap region is what you have to calculate you have to calculate what's in here and you can do that uh using this this formula here it's not even difficult all right so this is this is if you just cut it in half turns out to be two of these guys and then you're you're on your way to figuring out this problem and the question is which do they prefer do they prefer to touch each other or do they prefer to touch the wall do they all cluster to the wall so you can actually see this in Solutions what they do and the question is to what extent do they prefer one configuration to the other all right so that's a real live problem which really comes up and came up just this year and frequently comes up and which is solved by our first calculation okay so now I have I called this method one for solids of revolution which is called the method of Diss and now I need to tell you about the uh other standard method which is called the method of shells uh all right so this is this is our second method I'm going to illustrate this one with a holiday themed example here this is supposed to be a witch's cauldron whoops witch witches well well maybe more than one Wich will will'll have this cauldron here all right so here's this shape and we're going to figure out how much how much liquid is in here I'm going to plot this maybe I'll put this down just a bit lower here and I'm going to make it a parabola this is y = x^2 and I'm going to make the top height be y = a all right so here's my situation and I want to figure out how much liquid is in here now the reason why I presented the problem in this form of course is really to get you used to these things and the First new thing that I want you to get used to is the idea that now we can also revolve around the Y AIS not just the X AIS so this one is going to be revolved around the Y AIS and that's what happens if you spin the parabola around you get this kind of shape this kind of solid shape here all right now I'm going to use the same kind of slicing that I did before but it's going to look totally different namely I'll draw it as in in red again I'm going to take a little slice over here and now I want to imagine what happens if it gets revolved around the Y AIS this time it's not a disc actually if IID revolved this around the other way it would would have had a hole in it which is also possible to do that's practically the same as the method of discs you'll maybe discuss that in recitation uh anyway we're going to revolve it around this way so again I need to sweep it around swing it around like this and I'll draw the shape it's going to sweep around in a circle and maybe it'll have a little bit of thickness to it and this is the thing that people call a shell right this is the shell so-called shell of the method I would maybe call it a cylinder and another way of thinking about it is that you can maybe wrap up a piece of paper and WR like this there there it is there's a there's a cylinder you can see very thin right very thin all right now the reason why I use the piece of paper as an example of this is that I'm going to have to figure out the volume of this thing its thickness as usual is equal to DX its height is what well actually I have to use the diagram to see that the Top Value is a and the bottom value is what we call Y so the height is equal to I'm sorry A minus y now again this is an incredibly risky thing here and I've done this before I pointed this out on the very first day of lecture the letter Y represents a lot of different things and in Disguise when I call this y I mean Y is equal to x^2 in other words the interesting curve I don't mean y equals a which is the other part in general you might think of it as being equal to Y top minus y bottom so there of course two y's involved in Disguise but we have a short hand and the sort of uninteresting one we call by it's we just evaluate immediately and the interesting one we leave as a symbol y all right now the last bit that I have to do I claim in order to figure this out is the circumference and the reason for that is that if I think of this thing as like this tube or or or piece of paper here in order to figure out how much stuff there is here all I have to do is unfold it it's its size it's the the whole quantity of paper here is the same whether it's rolled up like this or whether it's stretched out so if I unwrap it it looks like what well it looks like a kind of a slab right it looks like just a a slab like this and again the thickness is DX the height is a minus y and now we can see that the length here is all the way around it's the circumference all right so this is going to be the circumference when I unwrap it and in order to figure out the circumference I need to figure out the radius so the radius is on this diagram is right over there this is the radius and that distance is X so this length here is X and so this circumference is 2 pix and this height is is is still a a y a minus y sorry and the thickness is still is still DX right all right so in total we're just going to multiply these numbers together to get the total volume we have in other words words DV is equal to the product of the uh 2 pix Dimension the a minus y Dimension and the DX Dimension incidentally dimensional analysis is very useful and important in these problems you can see that there are three lengths being multiplied together so we'll get a volume in the end something cubic and we will be coming back to that because it's a quite subtle issue sometimes all right so here's the formula and let's simplify it a little bit we have 2 pi x * uh remember uh uh first I have to substitute otherwise I'm never going to be able to integrate and then I rewrite that as 2 pi ax uh minus X2 whoops X cubed DX better not get that wrong and now the last little bit here that I had better be careful about in order to figure out what the total volume is is the limits so the volume is going to be the integral of this quantity 2 pi ax - x Cub DX and now I have to pay attention to what the limits are now here you have to be careful X is possibly the the the the the uh you have to always go back to the the 2D diagram I went to it immediately but that's that's the whole point is that everything gets read off from this diagram here when you take this guy and you sweep it around you take care of everything that's to the left so we only have to count what's to the right we don't have to count anything over here because it's taken care of when we sweep around so the starting place is going to be xal 0 that's where we start and where we end is the farthest rightmost spot for X which is down here now you got to watch out about where that is in the Y variable it's up at yals a but in the X variable we can see that it's what it's the square root of a all right so these these limits but this is where you're gonna you're going to focus all your attention on the integrant and getting it just right and then you're going to lose your Steam and not pay attention to the limits they're equally important you have no hope of getting the right answer without getting the limits right right so this is the integral from 0 toare < TK of a again that's just because yal a uh and Y = x^2 implies X = < TK a that's that upper limit there and now uh we're we're ready to uh carry out this to evaluate this integral so we get two uh sorry we get 2 pi ax that's Pi ax^ 2 um now maybe I'll leave the the twoos in there 2 pi ax^2 is the anti-derivative of of this A2 over two and then here x 4 4 evaluated at0 and < TK of a and finally let's see what is that um that's 2 piun * um a^ 2 / 2 - a^ 2 4 which is a total of a fourth right 2 pi * a^ 2 over 4 which is um pi/ 2 a 2 yes question right so the question is why did I integrate only from the middle to this end instead of all the way from over here minus < TK of a all the way to the plus end and the reason is that you have to you have to look at what's happening with the rotation this red guy when I swept it around I counted the stuff to the right and the left so in other words I've if if I just rotate the right half of this I'm covering the left half so if I did it if I counted the stuff from minus squ of8 I would be doing it twice I would be doubling what I need right so it's too much another way of saying it is if if I wanted to take the whole region if I rotated around only 180° only Pi that would fill up the whole region if I did both halves and then instead of a a circumference instead of a 2 pix I could use a PIX but then and I would have double what I had so the there are two ways of looking at it the the same goes actually for the football case when I have that football I didn't count the bottom part because when I swung it around the x-axis the top part sufficed and I could ignore the bottom half yeah another question oh good question the question is when do you know uh how do you know when to take uh the rectangle to be vertical or horizontal so far we've only done vertical rectangles and I'm going to do a horizontal example in a second and the answer to the question of when you do it is this you can always set it up both ways one way may be a difficult calculation and one may one way may be an easier calculation yesterday we did it or sorry the last time yeah I guess it was yesterday we did it with with and the horizontal and the vertical were were quite different in character one of them was really a mess and one of them was a little easier so very often one will be easier than the other every once in a while one of them is impossible and the other one is possible in other words the difference in difficulty can be extreme so you don't know that in advance yeah another question the question is did we just find the volume when you when you rotate this green region around or did we find the volume when we rotate this whole region in other words just the right half or the or the right and the left half the answer is both the region that you get is the same you always get this cauldron whether you take this right half and you rotate it around or you take both and you rotate it around okay so the answer to both of those questions is the same and it's this yeah it it it so the if you rotated them both around and you only wanted to cover things once you would rotate halfway around if you only by 180 degrees that's true but you can rotate around as many times as you want you're still covering the same thing over and over and over over and over again okay okay so let's let's go on I have a I have a very subtle point that I need to discuss with you in order to go on to the next application here so so here's my and and I I do want to get to the point of of horizontal crosssections as well so let's let's uh continue here so the first thing that I want to point out to you now is I want you to beware of units there's something a little fishy in this problem and it can be summarized in the character of the answer which is just a little bit not clear namely it looks like it's a squared right and we know that a is in units and we should have gotten uh cubic units so there's something a little bit tricky about this question and so I want to illustrate the Paradox right now so suppose that a is 100 cm and suppose the units are CM then the formula for the volume isk / 2 * 100 squared and the units we must take are centim cubed despite the fact that you kind of want to square the centimeters but that's not what this problem says okay so this is the situation that we've we've got now if you work out what this is to figure out what the volume of this cauldron is what you find is that it's Pi / 2 time well uh 10 4th power is 10 * 1,000 cm cubed right and those are otherwise known as liters so this is approximately 10 pi over 2 L which is about 16 l so that's how much was in The Cauldron under this uh uh choice of units now I'm I'm going to make another choice of units now and we're going to make a comparison suppose that the units are 1 meter looks like it should be the same but if I calculate the volume it's going to be Pi / 2 and 1^ 2ar * m cubed right that's what the formula tells us to do and if you calculate that that out that's < / 2 * 100 um cm cubed and with this uh unit notation we really do want to cube the centimeters and Cube the 100 so we get pi/ 2 and here we get 10 6 cm cubed and that comes out to uh Pi over2 * 1,000 uh L or other words about 1,600 l so I I'd like to ask you first to contemplate this and this is a paradox and this is a serious Paradox if you really want to apply problems you actually have to understand what your answers mean so what do you think is going on here yeah yes right so the question is how could either of these make sense how am I dealing with the units in either case all right so now I'm going to explain to you uh the answer because this is really quite puzzling but it has a resolution the the answer to this question is that both answers are correct all right this is correct reasoning in both cases what's the matter is that you have to interpret the equation Y = x2 in two different ways two ways so let me explain what they are for instance you can take y = x^2 uh with uh in centimet so y = x^2 in cm in which case the picture looks like the following a is equal to 100 cm and this distance here which is the this is the this is the x value this is 10 all right this is 10 cm and that's what the relationship means so the top of the cauldron if you like this distance here is 20 cmers this is actually very badly drawn to scale it's actually very very deep this thing it's a rather skinny deep one okay so this is very much not to scale this picture the other picture the other picture is interpreting y x2 in met and that's more like what I had in mind actually I had in mind this big vat here and this distance here is is 1 meter and then the square root of one is one so this distance here is also 1 M and the top is 2 m all right now it's not that crazy and in fact it's easy to check that it's pretty reasonable in terms of scale that this thing has 16 lers in it and this guy has 1,600 lers in it all right so you actually have to know what your symbols mean when you're dealing with these kinds of Applied problems and if you're ever really going to do some some real consequences you have to know what what it is that what the units mean and the problem with the equation yal x^2 is that it's the one that violated scaling rules yeah no C okay um so uh the question is whether the formula V equals a half sorry Pi / 2 a^2 this is the correct answer to the problem but it is not consistent in units if you plug in a equals some number of centimeters some number of millimeters some number of inches and so on every single time you'll get a different answer and they're all inconsistent in other words this formula violates scaling ex if you interpret if you make if if you if you study each step correctly you will discover that these are the consistent and correct statements what I'm writing on the Blackboard and this makes sense in a unitless sense but then if you actually stick units on them one of them they both are correct and one of them describes this situation and one of them describes this situation and it's a mistake to think of this as being one meter and cubing The Meters all right that's that will be an error that will that will cause you problems all right this one is just unitless and then the meters cubed got converted all right so I I I encourage you to study this on your own so now I'm going to I'm going to introduce the next problem we'll have to solve it next time but the reason why I spend all the time on units is that otherwise it would be impossible for you to believe me when I do this next calculation all right because we're trying to get a real answer out of a real question and I'm going to make conversions between centimeters and meters back and forth and we have to get it consistent in order to have the right answer so there was a a reason for for uh illustrating this Pitfall so the second the next thing that i' like to do is I'd like to I'd like to boil the water in the uh in the witch's cauldron all right this is uh definitely seasonally appropriate since we're approaching Halloween and we'll work it out uh fully next time now I'm going to introduce another feature into the problem and this is the one that I want you to understand now we'll set it all up tomorrow but right now I need you to understand what the new main idea that we're going to we're going to get okay there's the new physical feature that I'm going to add to this problem is that if when you're boiling when the when witches are boiling this this water the temperature of the water is not the same at each level in the kettle at the bottom of the kettle where you're heating it up it's at its highest temperature so at the bottom it's going to be say 100° that is it's going to be totally boiling 100° C and at the top it's going to be say 70° uh right it's very cold outside in fact it's it's 0 degrees outside which is the the temperature at which all witches operate I think anyway so so so they're boiling their their their their stuff and the question that we're going to ask is how much heat how much heat do they need to do it now they don't the thing starts out at at 0° C and we're going to heat it up to this temperature configuration here but it's it's rising from 100 down here to 70 up here so the the temperature is varying in height and for Simplicity I'm going to make the formula for the temperature be um 100 at the top and 70 at the B uh sorry 70 at the b top and 100 at the bottom so it's going to be 100 - 30 y we'll we'll let the level be be one here uh sorry 30 I said three I wrote three but I meant 30 all right so this is the situation that we have now it's the the point about this problem is we're going to figure out the total temperature the total amount of heat that you need to add in order to heat this thing up that's going to be temperature times volume and but some places will count more than others these will hotter but there's less water down here there's this is wider up here so there's more water up here so there various things that are varying in this problem now the only way to set it up so that it works is to chop things up horizontally instead of vertically because it's on the horizontal levels that the temperature is constant so we'll have an easy calculation for how much it takes to heat up a layer a horizontal layer when we rotate this guy around the Y AIS that is which kind of shape it's a dis so actually this is going to be an easier problem this is going to be a dis problem not a shell problem but we're going to have to work things out with respect to the Dy variation in other words the integral will be with respect to Dy so we will do that next time we'll figure out how much heat it takes to uh boil the kettle