Transcript

the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT open courseware at ocw.mit.edu okay so we're going to pick up on our study of periodic potentials and our search for the explanation of the physics of solids uh and I want to quickly remind you of the logic of we went through last time this is one of the more subtle bits of logic in in the semester so um I'm going to do it again uh a little faster I'm also going to do it in a slightly different form I want to think for a moment about just a free particle but I want to use all the language and formalism we used for the periodic potential last time translation operators the block wave functions I want to use all of that for just a free particle so first let's just remind ourselves how the free particle Story Goes so for a free particle what by by which I mean the energy operator is p^2 upon 2 m and no potential plus zero we have a very important consequence um of being free that the energy can be written as just p^ s which is that the energy commutes with the momentum operator and what this tells us is that we can find a basis of IG functions which are common igen functions of e and P right we can expand every wave function any arbitrary fantastic thank you sir we can we can uh uh so is not to oh brilliant plan a thank you sir uh I don't know I that's an awful huge straw um pay no attention to the device beneath the table so um because you know it's quantum mechanics right bowl of water um so so the energy and momentum commute and as a consequence we can find a basis of V functions exists a basis of IG functions which are common igen functions of e e on f e uh and I'll label K by the IG value of K is equal to uh e f k and uh p on FK is equal to H bar k f e k you'll notice of course said I don't label by the value but I label it by something that's determined by the label the value is determined by the label as H bar K now here's the thing can we allow e and K to be any values we want independently can I make E3 and K 47 no I need to make there's a consistency relation which involves satisfying the energy value equation we actually have to find the solutions of these equations and once we find the solutions of those equations we will find relations between K and E and in particular for a free particle we find that the Rel that we need is e is equal to and I will write e sub K is equal to H k^2 upon 2 m this is also known as Omega is equal to H k^2 upon 2 m just to remind you the de e is H bar Omega Omega sub K that's not the thing I wanted to look at this is um and if we when we when we work this way we find that the energy G function or the energy gon values e okay as a function of K take a determined form and that determined form is quite simple it's a parabola everyone cool with that so if you know K you know e but if you know e it turns out it's doubly degenerate so if you know e you're one of two KS you could be either e to the IX um uh oh sorry and I needed to say that the um the function so from the solving the equation gave us that the energy functions F K are equal to uh sub normalization 1un 2 pi it's conventional e to the IX okay so if I tell you the energy you don't know which momentum I'm state I'm talking about but if I tell you the momentum you know the energy so there's a little degeneracy that degeneracy is coming from the parody symmetry of the system right and note that what we've done here did we have to write the wave functions in terms of these The IX is there another basis we could have used for the energy states yeah because these are degenerate we could have taken any linear combinations of e to the IX and e to the minus IX and we could have got for example sign and cosine that would have had the advantage that the energy igen functions would have been pure real which is something we proved was possible you can always choose pure real energy function however it would have had the disadvantage that these states would not sign and cosine or not I states of momentum right it's convenient to work with common I states of momentum and energy so we give up on having a real wave function and uh the that's the cost of finding shared IG functions of energy moment everyone cool any questions okay so this is the usual story for um for the free particle but we learned a couple things about it immediately just by looking at the by eyeballing the wave function we see that so some things to note note uh all states all igen functions F sub e which are of the form um e to the I KX and I'm going to add the time dependence in now minus Omega sub KT are extended right they uh they have equal probability density everywhere and the probability distribution does not fall off to zero as we go far away and so what this tells us we have to do is we have to build if we want to study real localized states that are localizable that are normalizable we have to build wave packets okay of the form s is equal to uh integral DK some overall momentum modes F of K uh e to the I KX minus Omega T sub K where this F we will generally take although we don't have to take to be a real function but but is peaked at some k okay so this is what we did and we studied the evolution of a wave packet of this form but in particular um such wave packets have a couple of nice properties the first property we've studied and if you're not totally comfortable with the idea of group velocity you really need to go over it again' be an excellent thing to show up in recitation for example stationary phase so the group velocity of such a wave packet as long as it's of this form and peaked around a single momentum value K not the group velocity uh is D Omega DK uh evaluated at kot at the peak value of the distribution and note I want to just quickly note that this is equal for the free particle to well Omega is H k^2 upon 2 m take a Dera respect to K the two cancels we get h k upon m h k upon M which notably is equal to the expectation value of the momentum over the mass everyall that so this gives us a nice way to by the way if you didn't know the mass but you could measure the system for example you can compute on average the momentum and you could compute the group velocity by watching wave packets move this is a Nifty way to compute the mass the mass can be given by well put the mass up here and divide by the group velocity measure the momentum and divide by the group velocity okay so I can take this and notice that this just exactly gives me the mass okay so this is a way to given a system with a with a um with a momentum and a Groove velocity I can compute an effective Mass which for the free particle is just the mass cool just a side observation but this is all a consequence of the fact that we have wave packets of this form there plane waves are at least things that have a phase times what could be a real although I could put an overall phase on the whole thing um a real function which is peaked at a particular value of K usual wave packet story any questions good so this should all be pretty familiar now here's the thing when we talk about a periodic potential what I want to do next is I want to talk about a periodic potential so now we have a system that has maybe steps and uh it's periodic with period L okay and then ditto it's going to be periodic um and I want to run through the same analysis I want to find the energy igen functions I want to organize them in a nice way and in particular I want to know the following if this is equal to V of x uh and V of X and I call the energy operator e and e sub G is equal to uh p^2 upon 2 M plus a coefficient G time um let me call it g subot just to make unambiguous times V of X notice that when G is zero this is just the free particle right I added a periodic potential times zero that is stupid but doable but as I slowly turn on G what's going to happen the energy igen functions are going to slowly change and the energy igen values are going to slowly change and the actual system we care about has some actual value of you not like seven or three or whatever but this is a way to connect the free particle to the to the particle in a periodic potential you know and if you just turn on a little weak potential you don't expect the system to radically change so one way to to organize the question of periodic potentials is what happens as you slowly turn on this periodic potential okay but here's the first thing I want to notice the first thing I want to notice is that it's no longer true that the energy commutes with the momentum so it would be silly to try to organize our wave functions in terms of energy igen functions which are also momentum igen functions because that will only be a sensible thing to do when the when this interaction term when this potential is zero right so instead I want to organize them in terms of energy igen values and any other operator that commutes with the energy igen function in particular this is not invariant under arbitrarily translations which it would have to be to be invariant under to conserve momentum but it is invariant under translations by L and as a consequence we have that the energy operator commutes with translations by L where translations by L takes a function and shifts it over by L and so because translations by L as you showed on a problems set long ago commute to the P squ because this is just an exponential of LP with coefficients with an i and an H bar and uh because the potential is invariant under shifting by L and so it commutes with TL this is zero so what this tells us is we can find common IG functions in fact a common igen basis of entl and here's the thing that's nice about this I could have made this argument whether the potential was zero or not for the free particle it's also true that the system commutes with translations by L it's free there is no potential it's sort of silly because I could have just used the momentum but let's see what happens if we use the translate by L operator everyone cool with that okay so we want to find common igen functions so as you guys showed on a problem set the igen functions of TL so in order to do this what are the IG functions of TL you said you showed that the igen functions of TL must take the form um sorry uh f subq of x is equal to e to the IQ x * U of X for some Q Where um Q is where U is a real periodic I don't really need the real but it's going to simplify my life so I'll take it to be real periodic uh function well let's drop real all together because we don't need that we use a periodic function and F of Q is this phase okay it times the periodic function so in particular fi is not periodic and as a consequence TL on fi Q is equal to e to the I ql F Q because this guy shifts and this is invariant periodic okay so this is the form general form of the igen functions of translate by L okay and periodic means that U of X Plus L is equal to U of X just be explicit okay so what this tells us is that the energy I functions can be put in a form can be organized as uh F sub e q such that e AC on F subq is equal to e f subq okay just like this line F subq and TL F EQ is equal to E to the iql by EQ it's just saying that we have common igen functions yeah with energy e and TL value q no because under translation by L um this x goes to X Plus l oh i' I've slightly changed notation from earlier in the course you're right I slightly switched so um ah good so yes so thank you so let's fix notation TL takes F ofx to uh f ofx minus L is what we've used previously right but I'm going to just switch notation and call this X Plus l so for the for for all the notes in here this is X Plus L um uh yeah it doesn't really make a difference you just have to be consistent and you're right I switched between lecture what was it eight and this one sorry about that um yeah good catch thank you for pointing that out okay so in which case this shifts by X to X Plus L and we get e the iql good catch um good so uh so again we have this property that we can find common ion functions however are can e and Q be specified independently we know on on General grounds that it's possible to find igen functions which are common igen functions because these guys commute um e and TL commute so we can find common IG functions and here they are and meanwhile we know that the form of these igen functions is of this form because any igen function of TL is of this form a phase times a periodic function that doesn't does that by itself tell us a relationship between the igen values e and Q no right just like e and K we're independent until we solve the actual I value equations right and required things like normal like um regularity no singularities so what we have to do at this point is solve the differential equations for continuity periodicity and solving the energy function energy value equations and when we solve the equations we'll get a Rel relationship between e and Q okay and in particular if we do that here whoops good uh here for so do you want to do it this way yes um so in particular for a let me write this in the following way for g equals 0 g not equals 0 which is a free particle we find e is equal to uh h^ 2 q^2 e sub Q is equal to h s Q2 upon 2m and um uh yeah and the wave functions are of the form f subq e are equal to some normalization 1un 2 pi * e to the i q X and the coefficient function U is just constant okay which is nice so times constant and so this this is reassuring because it's exactly the same form of the wave functions with exactly the same form of the energy but we're here the label the value Q is representing the possible value of um of uh uh the is controlling the value of TL so there was a question yes yes um so for the translation operator yes that eqx U of X will work for any complex q and any U with period out any periodic with period out yeah although if Q is complex then um this is badly non-normalizable because if Q has a an imaginary part then that function is going to diverge in One Direction or the other so Q would better be real but that's correct this works for this expression a function of this form a periodic function periodic with period L times an e to the iqx for any real value q and any periodic U will be a function it will be an igen function of TL translation no it's it's it's not just non heri it's not just it's in fact unitary I mean what what what exactly is your question sorry I misunderstood so so just the the translation operator has a a really really large number ofs indeed it does and that number is the same as the number of momentum functions because they're they can be both used as a basis they're both operators which whose igen functions form a basis that's exactly right so I think the difficult thing is to think that it that um we have a tendency to think that there aren't very many momentum IG functions for example but there's enough me function to be complete basis so if this seems like a vastly larger set then uh yeah then uh indeed okay so uh so when we do our analysis for the free particle of this form we get exactly the same story and I want to point out a couple of consequences for this working with this TL operation working with TL functions we have exactly the same properties our our igen functions are again extended we have to use wave packets and those wave packets move with a group velocity which is given by D Omega D DK on the other hand here um the I when we write uh superpositions our general wave function our general wave pack which I'm going to write here s is going to be of the form integral DQ um of e to the I QX U of x uh time some f ofx or sorry F of q u sub Q okay so um as long as this is a periodic function then the um oh and I should say minus Omega sub QT to get the time dependence in there as long as this is a nice periodic function especially for this case was when it's real and this is a sharply peaked function which is sharply peaked around some Q then we will find that the group velocity is again um V group is again D Omega now DQ evaluated at the peak value Q not and that's just a general consequence of this form of our wave packet as I encourage uh the uh recitation structures to uh review by stationary phase in the um in recitation and secondly um again we can find a nice this nice notion of a mass uh which is the expectation value of the momentum divided by uh the group velocity and again this for our simple free particle this is just a nice way of measuring the mass if you happen to want to do so uh for your uh for your free particle no one told you the mass everyone call that okay questions yeah but is that still the momentum when we have G is not equal to zero excellent question so now let's study the case with G not equal to zero okay so so far we looked at for G not not equal to or G not equal Z that was just this line but everything else was for General case of studying common functions of entl so now let's study the case for um an actual periodic potential so in particular uh repeat for G not equal to zero and this is the the analysis we did last time we did exactly this analysis and we looked for the common igen functions of e and translate by L right and we found that the common igen functions took the form EQ uh is equal to e to the i q of x uh time some U of X and now we need to find what's the relationship between e and Q are any e and any Q allowed and are do those give you IG functions from the free particle we should we expect that's certainly not the case on the other hand we have a guess as to what it should look like the um energy function for let me actually write this here oh whoops the energy IG functions uh and energy I can values more importantly of um the uh free particle organized in terms of Q we just immediately whoops we immediately see the energy is just h squ q s upon 2 m so the potential or sorry the um energy is a function of Q is again a parabola okay so here's q and here's the energy and this is for a free particle right free particle e = h^ 2 Q ^2 upon 2 m now I want to ask what happens as we slowly turn on the potential as we take G not not equal zero so we did this last time we turned on the potential we turned on uh a potential which is in fact Delta functions so now we in order to solve the differential equations we have to actually know what the potential is there's no getting around it and so we took a bunch of Delta functions with dimensionless strength G uh and spaced by L and what we found was an equation relating uh e and l which took the following form and for Simplicity I'm going to write e is equal to this is purely defin this has nothing to do with uh momentum although it looks like momentum I'm just going to write e formally as h bar^ s k script k^ squ upon 2m so K here should just be understood as root2 M over H bar squ which I hate writing out over and over again so let me actually write that the other way around script e k is equal to the square root of 2 m e upon H bar squ so when you see K think e when you see Lions think Lions okay um so so we found that the condition in order that we solve the differential equations the condition in order that e and Q label energy states which actually are energy functions common energy functions of the energy and the translation by L operator we found that there was a relation which was cosine of ql is equal to bless you cosine of KL plus G upon 2 uh KL s KL right so first off let's make sure that this agrees with what we found when G was equal to zero when G was equal to Z we found that e was equal to h s q^2 for any q and well when G is equal to zero this term goes away and we get cosine of ql is equal to cosine of KL and an example of a solution for that is ql is equal to K or Q is equal to K in which case e is equal to h squ k 2 m by plugging in that expression cool so this reproduces the free particle result when we need it to but in general it's not the same so what does it look like so let's take a look at that so here uh first off what I'm plotting here is um the is the the plot that we drew on the board last time only here I'm plotting it horizontally is the energy okay e and vertically is cosine of ql now for Q real number cosine of ql goes between one and negative one and so there's any value in here corresponds to a valid value of cosine or of Q sorry so any value any point between one and minus one uh is an allowable value of Q so for example this point right here corresponds to this value of Q okay just horizontal lines meanwhile this curve is the right hand side of that expression it's cosine of KL Plus or in this case it's cosine ofun 2me upon h squ l uh this right hand side plugged in here and I'm plotting it as a function of energy just to be explicit so this is energy or energy and the Q um and here's that curve so for g equals z which what I've which is what I've set it to here G is oops G is equal to zero that didn't work there we go when G is equal to zero we see that it goes between Z and this is just cosine of root e and there's cosine of root e it gets spread out because it's sare root of e rather than e everyone cool with that and so here's my question um what pairs of e and Q correspond to alloud energy functions how do you look at this diagram and decide which values of e and Q are good energy functions well the boundary on Q is such that of ql is between1 and one good all values are awesome so let me be explicit so how would I find that's exactly right let me rephrase that and be a little more explicit so take what we need is we need a solution of cosine ql is equal to the right hand side in this case cosine of root energy l so that means we need to find a horizontal line corresponding to a particular value of Q or particular value of cosine ql and a point on the curve uh cosine of root e l which is this guy so at any point where we are inside these two extreme values and this e will give us a value so for example for this point H I wish I could draw for for this point um that corresponds to a particular value of Q right where the coine of Q is equal to that vertical value and it corresponds to a particular value of e so each point here corresponds to a value of e an allowed value of e on the horizontal and an allowed value of Q such that cosine Q L is the is the vertical value everyone cool that so what yeah a lot of specific values of Q you have a lot of inters right yeah that's okay that's excellent okay so good so the the answer there are two ways of answering that that's a very good question so the question is look this is a slightly funny State of Affairs if we plot if we take a horizontal line corresponding to a particular value of Q it hits at various different values of the energy excellent observations so let me make two points about that the first point is that um the uh when we when we defined Q how did we Define q we said the translate by L on uh F EQ uh was equal to e to the iql F EQ but now suppose we take Q to Q Plus 2 pi upon L okay okay so if we take Q to Q to Q Plus 2 pi po we don't do anything to the value so so that's not enough to specify which function we're talking about because we change the value of Q and it doesn't change the so you can't just focus on the value there are two two ways of of of thinking about that one is look since q and Q Plus 2 pi upon L give you the same I value of TL we should just think of them as equivalent so one we should just look anytime you have q and you add plus 2 pi L you should just think of this as Q okay it's not different there's just you know Q now is valued periodic if you shift Q by 2 pi you're actually back at the same point so Q is now a periodic variable and um but that's not enough different values of these Q correspond to different values of the the same igen value so you're getting multiple Solutions as a consequence but there's another way to think about this um which is just in terms of this graph in terms of this graph uh if um uh if what we're specifying is cosine of ql but we're not specifying the of Q yeah so if we instead plotted this as a function of Q plot as function of q without assuming Q is equivalent to 2 pi Q + 2 pi upon L which we can do we're perfectly entitled to do that what do we get Q e what do you think you get for the free particle we know exactly what we get for the free particle a parabola and if you just take this and I'm going to give you guys Mathematica files for all these things uh if you just take this and re and and open it up instead of plotting in terms of cosine of ql plot in terms of Q that's exactly what you get a satisfying thing and I'm going to come back to that in just a minute but it was a really good question we'll come back to it okay other questions okay now let's ask what happens as we turn on G as we turn on G the solutions to this equation are going to be different because it's going to be a different equation so let's do it so here it is we have G we can tune it and I'm going to slowly turn on G and watch what happens to these curves and so now we see that the right hand side the yellowish curve is now exceeding one and minus one in various places right and why is it doing that let's put it some reasonable value down here so why is it doing that it's doing that because this can now be greater than one cosine is bounded between one and minus one but this is not right and so we overshoot in some places and what what does this tell us what is this really telling us what is really telling us is that there we go how do we find allowed values of e and Q such we have a good energy igen function which is simultaneously an igen function of e and of TL we need to find points where a horizontal line between 1 and minus one intersects the right hand side curve but for the energies between here this value of the energy and this value of the energy there is no such point right the energies in here any energy in here in order for those lines to intersect the line must be greater than one or less than minus one down here or here right so there's no allow pair Val there's no allowed value of Q such that there's a solution with energy between these two points everyone cool with that so that's telling us that there are values of energy there are values of energy where there are no energy I values with that corresponding energy because there simply aren't Solutions of this equation with for any value of Q with that energy on the other hand when the right hand side is between one and minus one we have allowed values of energy we have a value of q and a value of e that correspond to each other and that correspond to a solution of the energy I value equation and the TL I value equation okay so let's think about what that looks like in this presentation oh before I do I want to say one other thing about this um let's take this plot and let's use uh this periodicity so the periodicity is going to say that uh so here's Pi upon L here's minus Pi upon l let's see yeah good there's minus Pi upon L there's 2 pi upon L and 2 pi upon L if these guys are periodic then I could have just said look this point this is pi upon L and minus Pi upon l i could have said this point is the same as this point so I could have taken this whole bit of the curve and I could have moved it over here everyone cool with that because this value of Q is the same as this value of Q This value of Q is the same as this value of Q right so I could have written this and if we just take this over you can see it's per it's you know symmetric as a consequence we get and so we can write we can draw this entire Parabola fold it up into one region using the periodicity with Q is 2 pi upon L and when you fold it up into one region just using Q as periodic with Period 2 pi L and now noting that there are several solutions for every value of Q corresponding to how far out on the parabola you went now we have a much simpler way of presenting this where we don't need to see the whole Parabola this has a real Advantage when we plot things in this way these the structure of the the energy bands and energy gaps becomes considerably more simple so let me do that first let me set the G to zero okay so here is our free particle and let's look at that plot so here's the plot that I was just describing okay what you see here is the parabola and I've used the periodicity to box it up into one fundamental period between pi and minus Pi upon L okay and so the Blue Line corresponds to the the energy as a function of Q the allowed energy as a function of Q and what the green background represents is I'm going to put the horizontal section in green anytime there's an allowed energy with that so energy here is vertical and Q is on the horizontal going between minus pi over L and pi over L yeah I you might be getting this just now but is there a reason that uh as the energy increases the bands get broader and broader is that just matter of fact the ma is there a good physical yeah they they're both so um so the one way to think about it so just purely mathematically this is saying that cosine of ql is cosine of root eel so as we make the energy larger and larger some small variation in Q is going to correspond to a quadratic variation in E and that's what's making it stretch out if we plotted this as a function of K instead of e then it would have looked much more constant period okay so that's the the the mathematical answer the physical answer is this if we have some potential if I put you in a finite well so there you are you're in a finite well and you look at the ceiling damn it and so that's a that's frustrating right and it's deeply frustrating if it's a deep well but if it's a shallow well so it's not all that big a deal you climb out right the being in a deep potential being at low energy compared to the potential means that you're tightly bound right it takes a huge amount of energy to get out and as a consequence what you saw in your problem set is that the bands are quite thin but as you get closer and closer to the top or as you go to higher energy the thickness of that band grows as a measure of the fact you're less tightly constrained by the potential okay good so that's the physical intuition did that did that make sense good okay so yeah when you have g g to zero do you ever get to a point where always inside there's no ah good let's look let's look that's okay so let's answer that by looking so the question is basically look as you crank up G KN do you ever lose the bands entirely or or do the do the bands just disappear is that the question yeah you go to higher energies good so we we can answer that let me do that in two ways so the first thing I want to do is I want to um ask the first part of that question which is what happens as we turn on the potential here we have the free particle let turn on the potential we know what happens down here I want to ask what happens to the picture of the allowed values of Q and the allowed value sorry the allowed values of energy and their corresponding values of Q so here it's easy this particular point on the on the blue line corresponds to a value of the energy and a value of Q right what happens to those allowed pairs as we increase potential and as we increase the potential you can see on the left that the right hand side is exceeding one and minus one and correspondingly on the right here the Red Dot is what was the free particle Parabola and the blue line is the actual Solutions what you find is when you turn on the potential when you turn on the potential the actual solution moves away from the free particle line in a very particular way in particular for this value of energy in around 100 there are absolutely no allowed energy ion states there are no Solutions and so as correspondingly that area is not shaded green there are only solutions where you have this blue line everyone see that so we get these gaps and we get bands of continuously allowed energies and then gaps between those allowed bands and I'm going to post this uh this guy to play with uh on Stellar so now let's go up to very very large values of the interaction okay and let's see what happens when you go to large values of the interaction well one thing that happens is Mathematica sort of panicked down here so it lost an entire band which shouldn't happen let's try that there we go that's better okay so um uh there's a wonderful book on spectral methods in solving differential equations by a guy named uh Boyd uh and he's uh piy uh if someone degenerate and he uh he he says at one point the definition of an idiot is uh he says Idiot definition um someone who doesn't reproduce their numerics twice with different parameter values and so we could have just lost this band and written a paper ah bands disappear this is great never believe Mathematica until you've checked it so uh anyway so here here you see a band and another band and another What's happen is the bands become very thin but that makes sense from the earlier intuition we're making the potential much stronger we're more tightly binding particles into Wells and as a consequence the bands are very tightly restricted and that fits very much with what we saw on your fet simulations okay but hold on for one sec coming back to the question over here um yours uh coming back to that question if you look at higher and higher energy what you're going to find is that the bands get wider and wider and the gaps get thinner and thinner well that yeah as you go to that's a little more complicated than that depends on exactly what you're doing but the bands get wider the um gaps get wider but both of them don't NE don't get wider at the same rate um so this is actually something you'll look at on your problem side but the important thing you will find the important thing you will find is that the bands never disappear a band in 1D a band doesn't just close and disappear altogether and the bands don't overlap and here's an easy way to understand why the bands don't overlap let's look at what these states are so in particular I want to look at the states at at the uh bottom of each allowed energy band so let's go back down to small value of G okay so we have these big thick bands with a weak couple with weak potential we have big thick bands little tiny gaps and I want to look at the states at the bottom of the Gap let's make it maybe a little bit bigger okay so we want to look at the states at the bottom of the Gap and there's an optional problem in your problem set that works through the mechanics of this um but I want to look through it uh in some detail so what we're plotting here um uh did that work ah crap okay unfortunately this is yeah okay good um so here here what we have is the ground state of the lowest band zero interaction so here is G and it's 0.1 it's basically zero as I turn on the Delta function potentials what's going to happen to the lowest energy state which is the constant it has momentum zero what's going to happen to this guy well we saw from this guy that the lowest energy State got a little bit of a gap there right you there is no State at Zero Energy anymore there's now a state only at slightly positive energy away from what would have been the Zero Energy Zero momentum State everyone see that there's this little gap between zero and the bottom and if we make the interaction bigger we'll see that a little more obviously here's the red is the zero energy and it goes up to finite energy but has that lowest State developed any nodes does the lowest state in a 1D potential have nodes no right there's a node the zero nodes then one then two and do they ever switch orders does it ever go 0 to one no there's a note so what happens to these wave functions is all the wave functions continuously change as we turn on the potential but they don't switch order their ordering is completely fixed by the number of nodes so let's watch what happens to the actual wave functions so here's that lowest State and I'm going to turn on the potential what's going to happen well we're going to see the effect of the Delta function and there you see the effect of the Delta function turning on and as we tank crank up the potential you see that the wave function generates a kink uh where there is a Delta function and that state has zero nodes that's the ground state everyone cool with that okay similarly let's go to zero oops oh shoot don't give me infinite Expressions um you're not allowed to divide by zero um okay oh shoot uh um okay here's the uh the the second excited state this guy and let's look at what happens as we turn up the potential now exactly the same thing we see a little Kink we don't get new nodes uh but what we do get are Kinks at the potential this is for the special case of the delt function potential but it's illustrative of everything else so going back to the bands what's going on here is that these states are getting compressed they're getting pushed up together but they're not getting swapped in their order okay um and this was in the surface of a question that was asked what was the last question um okay I don't remember exactly which question I was answering I'm sorry but um sorry think it was if you lose the ah yeah if you lose so you know by the node theorem that you never lose States states with uh three nodes can't disappear that state with three nodes always has to be between the state with two thank you between the state with two nodes and the state with four nodes and they can't just disappear so those gaps never disappear and they never overlap because they never cross each other again by the node theorem all you get is things separating into bands and squishing together or spreading back apart and becoming the free particle Del fun you get indeed indeed so that's exactly right so the observation is look this was for the Delta function potential but we could have we didn't have to use Delta function barri we could have used little square barriers I could have used little you know goat shaped barriers I could have used whatever and there's going to be some answer and how is it going to change well the way it's going to change is where the bands are how wide they are and how wide the gaps are but the rest of the story goes over in exactly the same way the energy functions take the form me to the iqx time the periodic function cool okay and on your problem set what you're going to show one the things you're going to show and I love this result because it's it encapsulates so much physics you're going to show that if you have a potential a single potential barrier and you know the reflection amplitude and the transmission amplitude or really you just need to know one if you know the reflection amplitude if it's parody symmetric then you can write down the band structure entirely in terms of you can write down an equation for the allowed energies as a function of Q entirely in terms of the reflection amplitude in the phase shift which is an amazing fact so you know about reflection off of one barrier you make a an infinite lce of those barriers and you deduce the structure of the allowed energy bands and gaps which is cool so the scattering information as I kept promising contains a huge amount of the physics uh of of your system so we saw that it contains bound energies but it also contains these band gaps okay questions yeah so we make the um gen go to Infinity would that approach a single yeah exactly excellent so if we make G not go to Infinity so let's make G not um uh so first off let's look at what's happening as G not is getting so the question was what happens as G not goes to Infinity is it like getting single Wells so let's look at that it's a very good observation so here's a band between I really should put a line here but between here and here we have this band and that corresponds to um between here and here have this band as we make G not stronger the deviation from simple cosine gets larger and larger the amplitude gets larger and larger and those bands get steeper and steeper and steeper and the allowed energy bands get thinner and thinner and thinner in fact they get so thin that mathematical loses track some of them just the annoyance so here we have very very thin bands what happens is we take G very very large so let's make it 400 and you can see Mathematica doesn't like that it's totally lost the band so let's try something a little less uh extreme oh no still too big for Mathematica um eight you can do it little buddy ah there we go we've got keep track of one so what's happening is these bands are getting extremely thin what's happening you're erecting infinitely High barriers between each period and the laddish and if you have infin High barriers what are the allowed energy values it's the same as the energy values of the infinite well because it has to be zero at those infinite barriers right so all of the states all of the states in the band become degenerate and have the same energy the energy of the periodic well of the infinite well very good question okay so let's uh let mathematic relax a little bit again well done okay um and um so I want to quickly ask why do we have bands the first place why do we have gaps so what's going on why do we have gaps in the first place okay good this is a totally this is an excellent answer not the one I was looking for the answer is a good answer is because we did the calculation and that's what the calculation tells us right and that is a completely valid answer for a theorist right at the stage of writing down what your theory is and making a prediction but before you can write that paper publish and say aha I've discovered bands you must have an explanation to the following question um why how do you know your calculation was correct before you've done the experiment so one ANS of course you do the experiment it fits like a chant but it's not a very Illuminating experiment as you know you know you're going to find departures from your theory you want to improve the situation you want some intuition about why this works and you actually all know the physics behind this and we did it on the first problem set remember the the um uh the experiment that we studied on a problem set um the Davis and germer experiment where you send where you send plane waves onto a crystal and due to interference effects the transmission amplitude uh uh changes the transmission probability changes as a function of the angle and the reason it changed as a function of the angle was you had a crystal plane right so atom atom atom atom atom atom atom atom and the a plane wave sent in could scatter off of any of these scatterers right or it could transmit and Scatter off and further one down and if you look at the the scattering off different scatterers if the effect of those scattering so one down and then one much deeper down if those interfere destructively then that's going to suppress the reflection and if they interfere constructively it's going to enhance the reflection okay so usually we think about that Davis and gar experiment we think about it as a function of the angle of incidence either straight at or as a function of angle and we ask how does the probabil how does the transmission depend on those angles but there's another way to to phrase that question you can ask look on average how deep does that wave go does the wave propagate through the crystal or if it doesn't propagate through the crystal it's going to exponentially Decay with some wavelength with some uh with some um Decay length and what you find is that the the allowed uh the the um whether the wave propagates in or whether it decays exponentially depends on the energy and the lattice spacing of that Crystal and this is exactly the same thing we have a crystal in both directions we don't have empty air and we're sending in a plane wave now we have a plane wave can it propagate through well for some energies it'll propagate with continuous energy or it'll propagate continuously and for some energies it will damp out exponentially but if it damps out exponentially and it damps out exponentially in the other direction too then you don't get any solution at all it just completely dies so um what's really going on here is the fact that all of these scatters in this lattice are scattering centers and if you send a little wave packet in which you you should think of as an as a superposition of energy I can stat if you send a wave packet in the probability to get the probability amplitude to get from here to here is the probability amplitude to go from here to here plus to scatter through to transmit through and reflect back plus to transmit transmit reflect reflect um or sorry transmit transmit reflect transmit plus all the other crazy things you could do and you have to sum up all overall those terms right you have to sum the effect of how do you get from here to here every POS way to get from here to there all the two slid experiment some of overall possible paths where you bounce around scattering off each of these scattering centers and that's why the band structure is encoded in the Reflection amplitudes from an individual scattering Center because now it's just a combinatoric problems of how many different pads and summing up the phase that you get okay so it's just about coherent and incoherent uh scattering yeah Crystal and I have an electron I the electron to the crystal right just the right energy go through in some without saying excellent excellent so um so the question is under what conditions can you send in electron it'll just Cruise right on through the potential so let's let's answer that question that's exactly the right question so let's take off let's pick up from here and I want to ask what have we learned so what are the lessons for G not equal to zero okay so the first lesson is that the energy igen values uh e values are restricted to lie within a band it's in bands and the bands are separated by gaps okay two the energy igen states so this was I values the Energon states are all extended and we didn't even need we didn't need to uh to find the full solution of this equation to know that all we needed to know is that it was a solution of it was that the energy functions are IG functions of the translation operator as well and that tells us the probability of that form and that tells us that the probability distribution is which is the norm square of that guy is independent it's periodic and if it's periodic it can't fall off exponentially One Direction or the other Okay so we've seen that the igen functions are all extended and so as a consequence we have to we have to build wave packets so therefore we we must build wave packets and again the um the form of the wave packets s is equal to the integral DQ uh F of Q sorry uh I'll say fq KN uh sharply peaked around the point Q of Q um and then the wave functions e to the I QX minus Omega t uh times r u of x sub Q okay so we have to build wave packets so three this tells us that those wave packets move with group velocity by the same logic as for the free particle the group is equal to D Omega DK or DQ evaluated at Q okay where Q is where our wave packet is sharply peaked so that's already telling you something really cool look at this lowest band okay let's put make this a little more reasonable so let's look at this lowest band in particular I'm going to make this big okay so let's focus in on the lowest energy band here so there's the lowest energy band it goes from the top of the band to the bottom of the band it's just a little bit away from the free particle because we're looking at a relatively weakly uh perturbed system I I chose a small value of Q actually let's make it a little more exaggerated okay so there's the free particle curve the red one and the blue one is our actual B so that's the energy is a function of Q and let's make it even bigger this one goes to 11 um let's see okay and so what you can see is the following it looks again it looks sort of like a parabola at the bottom and at the top it curves over and actually goes to zero derivative and it has to because it's got to be periodic because Q is periodic with Period 2 pi L okay so what does that tell you about the velocity well let's look at the velocity V group velocity of wave packet with um whoops say here's zero um as a function of Q okay between uh minus 2 pi L and 2 pi l okay what is the group and here's what I mean what I mean is let's build a wave packet which has a reasonably well localized momentum say at this value of Q so I build a little wave packet it has a you know it's peaked here and and what does that wave function do well it has a group velocity and the group velocity is given by D Omega DQ and now we can't solve that equation analytically because it's transal but we can see just by eyeball what this does when Q is equal to zero What's the group velocity yeah it's the slope right d Omega DQ so what's D Omega DQ at the origin zero right because it's just horizontal so it's zero good what about uh at the uh what about a little bit to the right is here what if I give it a small positive Q wave packet localized with a small positive Q it's got a little bit of a slope now right little bit of a positive slope so it increases but then it reaches a maximum slope halfway through the uh halfway through the the domain so here it hits a maximum value and then the slope comes back down and if we went the other way if we made q a little bit negative the slope becomes negative and that's the velocity so that's a slightly strange thing as we increase Q it increases the velocity increasing Q increases the velocity for a while that's just like K and momentum momentum is H bar k so that would be increasing the group velocity for a free particle but now as we increase a q to a reasonably large value to two to um Pi upon l oh sorry this is uh Pi upon L and Pi upon l so if we do this to Pi upon 2 L or roughly to the middle we get to a maximum value and if we increase Q further what happens the velocity goes down right if we increase Q further the velocity goes this is strange for free particle if you had momentum H bar K and you increased K what happens to the expectation what happens to the group velocity if you increase the momentum what happens to the group velocity for a free particle it's going to increase right but not for our particles in not for our particle in the periodic potential the wave packet as you increase the crystal momentum Q past this maximum as you increase the crystal momentum you actually decrease the velocity and in fact if you keep increasing Q eventually the velocity goes to zero and you increase q a little more and it actually goes negative so this is a fun thing it's not behaving like normally you'd think of as a momentum and indeed is there momentum conservation in this system no we have a periodic potential there are forces at work is poent is momentum conserved no this is not a system that conserves momentum momentum can be exchanged between the particle and the potential Q is a good quantity it's the IG function of TL and that does commute with the energy operator so it's a perfectly reasonable quantity but the momentum itself p is not conserved so this Crystal momentum Q is not the momentum for all these reasons but it plays a lot of the same role especially near the bottom of the band near the top of the band it's a little bit funnier because if you increase Q you get a negative velocity if you decrease Q you get a positive velocity it's exactly the opposite of what you'd normally expect but let's let's hold on to that thought for a second okay so there's another sense in which the crystal momentum is like a momentum and you're going to show this on your problem set but it's very important in giving you some understanding some intuition about what the crystal momentum is on your problem set you'll show The Following suppose I induce a constant force for example imagine this particle in my periodic potential had a charge and I turn on a constant uniform electric field then that particle experiences a constant uniform driving force which I can write as a linearly increasing potential right so what you show in the problem set is that the force the expectation value the force is equal to for a wave packet sharply localized around some value Q the for it gives the time rate of change DDT of the expectation value of Q so if you turn on a force what happens is Q increases linearly thank you it's so hard it's just so obviously one um so uh so the force uh increas so if the force is constant then H bar Q increases constantly so Q just increases linearly in time yeah but that's fun well we'll come back to just how funny that is in just a Yeah question okay um well let's think about how funny that is let's let's let's tackle this right now so imagine we start with a wave packet which is well localized around zero Crystal momentum around Q equals Zer then what is that wave function doing in time how does that wave packet move what's its group velocity zero so it's just just sitting there it's just Little Wave packet slowly dispersing Quantum mechanically yeah but if we don't make it too tightly constrained in p and too tightly constrained in X the dispersion can be made quite slow so it's just a little wave packet localized around a POS particular position and localized around zero momentum and it's just sitting there cool now let's apply a force what happens as we apply a force a constant force with a positive sign Q is going to increase so the central value I should say uh yeah so the central value of our wave packet is going to go from zero to something slightly positive because Q is increasing what that means is that the velocity is increasing at first so the velocity is going to increase and in equal units of time it's going to March linearly along this way so the the particle is going faster and faster and faster and faster and that makes sense you're driving the system by putting on a constant force of course it accelerates the velocity accelerates linearly so the position accelerates quadratically so let's plot the position expectation value the position is a function of time okay at zero time it's at the origin it's some trivial position X notot as we increase time the velocity is increasing linearly for a while and the position is going to increase quadratically amone cool with that but eventually at some point time the velocity or the Q is going to get to the point where we're at the maximum allowed velocity and at that point what is the what is the curve for X going to look like it's going to have an inflection point okay and as we increase as we wait longer Q is going to continue linearly increasing which means the velocity is going to slow down so the thing slows down so it slope decreas increases until finally it's got zero velocity again there we go zero velocity DX DT and then what happens we keep forcing it it's a constant driving force but this is this by periodicity of Q and the thing as we increase Q further linearly in time as we increase Q further the velocity becomes negative so instead of continuing to accelerate the instead of continuing to move in a positive X Direction positive X Direction it starts going backwards that's weird you're putting a force in this direction and it's accelerating in that diretion that's a strange effect and as we continue eventually we get to a maximum negative velocity again an inflection point and uh at which point the velocity starts getting less and less negative or closer and closer to zero and we return and so in some period capital T which is determined by how big this constant driving force is the particle returns to its original position everyone see that yeah this is starting at it's starting well yeah let's get Q not equals z exactly so at the first point um so this is Q equal 0 this is oh sorry qal Z is the initial point and X is equal to X okay so this under this process the particle goes through an oscillation called a block oscillation it's named after the guy who invented the wave functions the block wave functions this is a deeply weird thing you take normally you think well look if I take a if I take a charg particle and I just put put it in empty space or in a box or whatever and they turn on electric field what happens to it it accelerates but if you put that charge particle in a periodic lattice like copper idealized copper here perfect uniform lattice and you turn on an electric field or con you put a capacitor plate across the thing that electron at first wants to behave like an electron in free space it wants to accelerate but then it finds out it's in a lattice and it goes backwards and it just oscillates back and forth cifi like you know I really want to get there oh crap if I really want to get there oh no I'm in a periodic potential and it just oscillates back and forth is there any conduction in this system due to the electromagnetic field that we've induced none that is a strange little beasti that is a strange strange property and yet copper conducts copper which is a uniform lattice of ions of potentials to which electrons are stuck in bands copper conducts the electrons don't do this block oscillation how come yeah it's not perfect and it's not perfect for a whole bunch of reasons so um so one reason it's not perfect is that um so first off in a lattice of say copper or whatever the ions have a finite Mass so what that means is they they're not stuck in place they also wiggle when the electron moves one of the ions move you know so the whole thing you should think of as a little wiggling piece of Jell-O and as a consequence it's not perfectly periodic this does a bunch of things one is these are no longer the exact energy ion functions you not have to deal with the oscillations wiggling of the lattice but more importantly here's something that can happen an electron can move along and it can kick one of these ions you can bounce off one of the ions and Scatter some of its momentum into the into the ion not into the rigid lattice but it can just make one of those ions wiggle so it's changed the structure of the lattice okay and what you can do then is you can have an electron that's accelerating and it hits something it stops and it accelerates and it stops accelerates and it hits something and it stops okay so when you have lots of disorder in your system when you can or when you allow the electron to bounce off things in the lattice you get this effective conductivity things start their block oscillation then they Collide and Scatter off their momentum and go back to zero momentum but they've moved over a little bit in their oscillation already they move up and they move so what that picture looks like is you accelerate and then boom you scatter and you fall back down to zero momentum by scattering off your momentum into something else same thing you move up and then now you have zero momentum again you move up you have zero momentum again you move up you have zero moment you move up you have zero momentum again and so you get this effective drifting of the electrons pointed out by guy named druda that gives you effectively a conductivity in a solid now there are a bunch of other effects that are important for conductivity normally we think of disorder as something that you know if you make things messy they're probably going to transmit less well right but disorder is absolutely essential for conductivity in real solids both for this reason because you scatter off of fluctuations but also when you have a Chuck of copper it's not a chunk of copper it's a chunk of copper but it's got you know here and there there's a little carbon atom that got stuck and maybe there's a bit of nickel and you know Palladium or you know berkum pretty unlikely but it could be there so you have all sorts of Schmutz sort of distributed around and again those are things that make the potential not periodic and so it will change the conservation of this Q okay yeah a little bit if you actually manage to put a an alternating current an alternating voltage at the right at the right frequen you could actually drive the electr from one side to the other in this fashion yeah think alternating Curren is that the electr really don't move at all that's a that's a very good observation it's it's a it's a little subtle so come to my office hours and ask me about that but there's an interest I for a very specific reason because it's easy and unambiguous I chose to look at the DC but you're right looking at the AC is really a very entertaining example so um yeah I'm not going to get into it there's a cool story with parametric resonance and there's a very nice story there come come to my office hours um because that is a particularly fun story okay um but I want to do one one last thing on this before we move on so in this process something very strange happened when we got to the top of the potential what we found was as we increase as we continue applying a constant positive force the velocity decreased yeah that is weird normally when I take a force and I take some object with some mass and I take a force and I apply it to the mass then the acceleration is the force divided by the mass in particular mass is always a positive thing so if I take my force and I divide it by the positive Mass I get acceleration in the same direction as the force but here we have an applied force and we get an acceleration in the opposite direction I thought our particle had a positive Mass didn't it have a positive Mass we started off with a positive Mass we should still have a positive Mass so what's going on here well we have a rule for calculating what the mass is we take the expectation value of the momentum and divide by the grp velocity so let's find out what the mass is for this guy I'll do that here so this is a slightly surreal moment with a nice little Coda so I'm going to write that expression for the mass slightly differently and you're going to show in your problem set P set you're going to show that that definition of the mass m star is p upon the groove velocity leads to the following expression you can write that as you can use that to derive that the the mass uh can be written as one upon H bar squ d^2 uh uh e D q^2 okay so the group velocity is the first derivative of the energy with respect to Q the mass or really one over the mass is proportional to the second derivative the curvature everone see that so this should not be an obvious equation unless you're breath takingly good at calculus your head um it's just chain rule but it does take a little bit of careful thinking because it's a physical argument it's not a rigorous mathematical argument you're can do it on your problem set so let's take this expression and let's see what the effective mass is is what is the mass of our particle now here when I say what is the mass of our particle I mean mean a very precise thing what is the mass of the object moving in this periodic potential that's what I mean what is the mass of this thing and we have a definition for it here it is and let's plot this one over Mass okay so let's plot this one over Mass oh that's not the way I want to drop yeah um okay do that yeah okay good so here oh shoot so um let's do it this way so I want to plot one over mass in the vertical as a function of Q and here's Q is equal to Z and here's one upon mass is equal to Z so at the bottom of the band and this is pi upon L and minus Pi upon L at the bottom of at the bottom of the band at Q equals 0 what is the mass well here's the velocity and there's the band so what's the the at the bottom of the band tell me properties about it is it zero yeah there's still some curvature it's a you know approximated by some Parabola right it's it's even and in fact you can well you can take that equation and derive properties of but it's some curvy thing you know you can see that it's more obvious if we look at a higher energy band so here's the minimum here's here's what it would have been if we didn't have a potential right but here's the minimum and it's nice and curvy and at the top again it's nice and curvy but it's got a second derivative there that's non zero everyone agree with that now here's the thing I want to ask is that second derivative um uh the same as it would have been if we had G arbitrarily small yeah not so much now if G was much lower the second derivative would be a bit different okay so in particular this is some funny value and I'm just going to give it a name it's going to it's going to have some value at zero and in particular it is positive ever agree with that but there's a point here there's an inflection point where this thing has zero second derivative and that inflection point is the same point where the velocity becomes a maximum because the velocity is a first derivative so when the velocity is at a maximum the second derivative has a zero right it's the derivative of the first velocity zero slope and so at that inflection point the velocity or the velocity is zero and um or sorry the velocity is a maximum and one upon the mass goes to zero and then if we increase Q further what happens 1 / M Star goes negative and it reaches a minimum at pi over L comes back and again repeats so whoops it's periodic I'm just artistically challenged so how can this possibly be right so first off what this is telling us is that we have a z a point where the mass is zero it's positive around the or where things normally behave intuitively it goes to zero one over the mass goes to zero which tells me that the mass m star is going to Infinity whenever the mass going to zero Mass must be going to Infinity what does that mean well what does it mean for something to be infinitely massive it means fals ma if it's infinitely massive then um let's write that as acceleration as force over M Star then that tells you that if you apply a force you get no acceleration but that's exactly what we saw we get to this point we keep applying our force and the velocity stays constant there's no acceleration yeah so the F defining this equation that's an external Force right it's an external Force exactly yeah purely external Force I put capacitor plate across my piece of metal so um the next question would be is it all that insane then because like you haven't calculated the net force on the object so to speak and so there is the potential and so yeah if the net force is zero sure you're applying a force but it's not going anywhere yeah that's a really that's that's that's a it it's not a complete answer to what's going on here but it's a very good observation um so uh let me let me rephrase that slightly so look I'm doing a slightly strange thing I'm apply I'm applying an external force and I'm not treating it quantum mechanically I'm treating this particle Quantum mechanically that's clearly stupid we should treat everything Quantum mechanically and derive the results in that fashion it turns out in this case that the negative effective Mass doesn't go away if we treat the electromagnetic field Quantum mechanically so you're absolutely correct but it's not enough to sort of make us comfortable with the result it doesn't change this result but you're absolutely correct that's an important thing to do if we want to be honest um but this is a perfectly good approximation uh for for for our purposes so so the mass goes infinite and then it goes negative one over the mass goes negative so that's ridiculous but that's exactly what we wanted the acceleration is the force divided by the mass but we found that when we apply a force in this direction we get an acceleration in this Direction that's a negative coefficient so in particular here's what I want to think about I want to ask the following question this value of the mass even around the bottom this is this should already be disturbing observation because this value of the mass is not the same as the mass of our original part particle and the way you can see that is if you go to very strong coupling then this band shrinks down and becomes very thin and the second derivative becomes arbitrarily small which means the mass becomes arbitrarily large so the mass is getting larger and larger as we crank up the potential the effective mass of whatever this thing is that's moving but this is strange the thing that's moving is our particle it has mass m everyone agree with that what is going on here and here I want to do experiment and my experiment so yeah the uh pong seamless pong ball company uh in recognition of my contributions to physics and $3 uh has given me uh a series of ping pong balls with which I'm going to do the following experiment okay here's the calculation I want to do the the lesson I want you to take away from this is that you've got got to be very careful what you mean by the mass of an object take one of these ping pong balls I'm not going to do the whole experiment for you but I'll tell you the setup take a pingpong ball and the first thing I want to do is I want to measure its mass well what do you mean by measure its mass well I'm going to take it I'm going to put in a vacuum you know we can take it to France to where they do the stand put then take the ping pong ball we're just going to turn that down okay can we kill that okay so okay so we take our ping pong ball and we put some Mass over here with a known mass and we put it on a scale and we wait until this goes to you know the vertical and we declare the mass and what we find is that the mass of our ping pong ball this is a you know not the greatest pingpong balls but by legislation this is supposed to be about 2.7 G uh where people getting fist fight so the mass of the ping pong ball needs to be about 2.7 gram and meanwhile the radius of this guy is about um 20 uh 20 20 millim so 2 centimeters yeah it's about right and um uh yeah so this is supposed morally it's supposed to be 2 cm and so if you go through this and you compute the density from these guys so this gives you a volume and uh if you compute the density the density is about 12.4 by regulation now I've done this experiment and I've done this measurement and I must have used very cheap balls because I got very very low density I got um oh sorry this is the wrong way to do it uh the density is equal to one in usual CGS units is one upon 12.4 um and I can write that as one upon 12.4 times the density of water okay now when I did this experiment I got one over 20 so I was probably using very cheap ping pong balls but by if you look up the regulations on Wikipedia this is what you're supposed to get um let's assume these are perfect so you do this there's the mass that is the mass that's what I mean by the mass you take a scale you weigh the thing right does anyone object to my definition of the mass it's an observational empirical process for determining the mass I take my mass okay and now I ask the following question if I take some water and I pull my pingpong ball and I put it under water and I put a spring scale here and I measure the force on this ping pong ball what will the force B well the force will be let's just call this 10 because the calculation going to be horrible otherwise well whatever let's call it 12 so the force um and another way to write this is that row water is equal to 12 row pingpong ball okay I did math there um so the force we know this from Archimedes the force is a combination of the of the weight of the pig POG ball down so it's going to be um the uh the density time the volume so the volume time row ping pong ball down uh so minus plus the volume times row water up because that's the weight of the water displaced right it's your weight down minus the weight of the water displaced everyone cool with that Archimedes it's pretty well known at this point so this is equal to the volume times uh row water minus row pingpong ball and I can write this as the volume time row water is 12 row pingpong ball so that's 12- 1 row pingpong ball that's 11 uh uh row pingpong Ball but this is equal to uh 11 times the weight of the ping pong ball um oh sorry 11 times the mass of the ping pong ball the volume times the density so Mass ping pong ball now there's an important thing that I forgot to add here what did I forget to add G right it's the forces is the mass times G okay G G and G so we get the force is equal to 11 M ping pong ball G everone agree with that I haven't done anything sneaky and so as a consequence what this predicts is that if I take the force and I divide it by the mass of the ping pong ball I get 11 times the acceleration of gravity and here's what that predicts that predicts when I let go of this thing what should happen it should accelerate upward through the water at n at 11 times the acceleration of gravity which is roughly 10 m/s squared so 110 m/s squar does that does that sound right just intuitively does that sound right if you pull something like a a ping pong ball or a beach ball or something underwater what happens when you let go of it well at this point I'm going to remind you that physics is an empirical science so let's see if we can do this um Okay now what's supposed to happen is this thing is supposed to shoot out at n times times the uh or 11 times the acceleration of gravity so it just shoot through this thing much faster than equivalently so which one's going to hit first should it come out or should it hit the ground first ping yeah the ping pong ball great that's all cool uhhuh so what's going to happen first is the pingpong ball going to hit the surface or is it going to come flying out of the water this is accelerating with the acceleration of gravity and this is accelerating up with 11 times the acceleration of gravity so let's do the experiment and this is what they pay me for oh this would be much more satisfying if we had a nice long um uh uh uh if we had a nice long um how do I want to phrase this um cylinder oh shoot stop yeah so it it's best done with a nice long cylinder but let's do this so which one wins gravity wins right and why intuitively why does this work I am neglecting the drag effects but I'm not really heating up the water all that much I mean it's not like the dissipation is all that significant the dissipation of the momentum which is drag the friction is not the most important thing for this for our purposes here that water hasn't heated up at all so what's going on the mass has changed moving through the water okay so here's here's the question has the mass of the pingpong ball my empty little ping pong ball changed so that's something like that has to be true but what's the right answer the right answer is this the thing that's moving is not the pingpong ball the pingpong ball is interacting with the fluid and as the pingpong ball accelerates it drags the fluid along with it and as it draag goes faster and faster it drags more and more of the fluid along with it and as it's dragging more and more of that fluid the effective mass of the entire object that's moving which is now the ping pong ball and it's all of its Associated Water is increasing and now if you take that Force which was constant and divide by this growing effective Mass you find that the acceleration rapidly falls off and you get a terminal velocity and you know this works if you blow a bubble underwater it doesn't shoot upwards with an infinite acceleration it goes glur glur glur and this idea this idea of the effective mass of a particle changing with its state of motion is is an idea called renormalization and it plays an essential role not just in particle physics but in all of modern condensed matter physics and we'll pick up at this point next time