# Lec 20 | MIT 9.00SC Introduction to Psychology, Spring 2011

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXzdOK_J-xE
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/SXzdOK_J-xE

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 8:48 — Chapter 2 (8:48)
- 11:13 — Chapter 3 (11:13)
- 19:26 — Chapter 4 (19:26)
- 28:00 — Chapter 5 (28:00)
- 32:42 — Chapter 6 (32:42)
- 40:13 — Chapter 7 (40:13)
- 49:03 — Chapter 8 (49:03)
- 50:41 — Chapter 9 (50:41)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** the following content is provided under a Creative Commons license your support will help MIT open courseware continue to offer highquality educational resources for free to make a donation or view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses visit MIT opencourseware at

**[0:26]:** ocw.mit.edu so so uh today and next time we're going to talk about uh Psychopathology people whose Minds brain and behavior are atypical uh more often than not but we'll talk about this in a moment uh these people face uh struggles difficulties and uh a huge goal is to try to help such individuals um so we'll talk a little bit about uh the history of ideas in Psychiatry and psychopathology a little bit about the ideas of diagnosis and labels and a little and I'll show you do a little film of patient with schizophrenia but there's an intuition in some places and some lives that are LED that that Psychopathology is rare that and so I'm going to least you know here's a list of not all psychiatric diagnosis but some of them schizophrenia bipolar disorder depression substance abuse drugs and alcohol anxiety panic disorder phobia developmental Al ones like autism ADHD and dyslexia obsessive compulsive disorder tomorrow I'm reviewing a lot of research grants for anorexia and bulimia so if we take

**[1:40]:** this list that you just saw and heard and ask how many of us in this room know somebody that we care about could be yourself could be a family member could be a friend know somebody who is touched by one of these diagnosis uh if you're willing to put up your hand who's touch and look around the room right an incredible number of people are touched by this and so it's a terribly important topic to understand and to help individuals and families who are struggling with these things and in fact it's estimated that we'll talk about these labels exactly that about half of all individuals at some moment in their life will qualify men or women at least for a brief period of meeting some psychiatric uh disorder uh it can be rare and devastating like schizophrenia 1% of the population worldwide but typically devastating in its consequences it can be potentially milder like depression

**[2:37]:** uh which ranges from very severe to somewhat moderate um and interestingly occurs considerably more often in women than men and we'll talk about that next time um there was a recent survey done a public health survey 5,000 young adults half of them in college like you half of them out of college they survey them and talk with them and about half qualified to have some sort of psychiatric disord uh disorder within the last year whether they were in or out of college didn't make a difference in this in the study but fewer than a quarter of those who met some criteria went and sought help um so how you know through recent history have people thought about people who behave differently who are so depressed they can't get out of bed who hear hallucinations who behave in agitated ways and bipolar disorder and you know it's as much a history story and a story of

**[3:32]:** culture and tolerance and intolerance as it is anything else and so uh you know unusual or mad behavior behavior is very disturbing and atypical now there's debates about all of this and uh so for example some people have argued that everything that we call psychiatric disorders is nothing but the labels we give to behaviors that we find uncomfortable or unproductive okay it's nothing about that it's just variation some people are taller and shorter some people like vanilla or chocolate ice cream and some people do or do not have bipolar disorder all right so it's it's a label that's given for just variation in human uh ability we'll talk about that or human performance and and and then there's many consequences of that others think that there's a humanitarian need to understand the disorders to help people um so as you think about these two sort of perspectives you can think that when people behaved very

**[4:29]:** unusually uh I'll show you a picture of this that we think some time ago that that people would literally tanate that is make a hole in the skull of individuals to attempt to let out the demons that was the interpretation of their time there's a thought that the witch hunts in the 16th and 17th centuries the Salem trials in the United States may have involved patients with things like Huntington or tourettes people didn't know how to interpret unusual behavior and so you know label it as possession or label it as witchcraft or something like that uh Insanity began to be understood as some sort of a disease but without any approach to treating it or helping individuals basically the process was to segregate individuals away and you would have very large you know pretty scary institutions with people literally chained uh and and living in filthy conditions there was nobody to care or protect for

**[5:20]:** them uh in a London Zoo you could go pay a penny and watch the humans in the cages uh and it wasn't they had not as many visitors as are in London now for the royal wedding but they had 96,000 in 1814 it wasn't a rare thing to go pay your penny and look at the scary people uh more recently we understand it is an organic illness and a psychological illness and we'll talk about all of that but all this is a huge point that how we understand unusual behaviors in people is tremendously influenced by the historical context that you're in um and we'd like to think we're making progress on this you know I think we are but uh you know a generation from now people might look back and say how sad you know that in 2011 people at MIT were teaching stuff like this right because if they were that wrong how

**[6:08]:** certain are we that we're that right so we just has to be a little cautious about very strong positions on these things I think here are skulls that were discovered with the tonation and some evidence that the person actually survived this kind of radical neurosurgery or right but you understand at the time when somebody behaved very very unusually you know people had Tred to explain what's going on and try to do what they can um here's you know pretty monstrous looking devices heads and boxes and things kind like this where people were trying to uh treat if you want to call it or control individuals having very unusual uh behaviors uh here's a huge hospital that had thousands and thousands the name of the hospital is bedum and that's what led to the word bedum now more generally used for sort of wildness or craziness um and point paintings like this from from from Goya

**[6:59]:** showing a mad house and you know it was it was because at that time don't forget when people there was no drug treatment no behavioral treatment people were behaving in scary ways and there was sort of put off to the side uh to be out of the range of disturbing other people now the first step towards teaching psychiatric diseases turns out to be a giant misstep but it took a long time for that to be understood as a giant misstep this is igas man who did something that all of us as scientists would be happy to uh have happened to us he won the Nobel Prize in physiology and Medicine in 1949 all right so the Pinnacle right of scientific respect uh throughout the world and he introduced uh what's now called frontal labotomy of prefrontal labotomy as a treatment for severe psychiatric disorders uh and then in the United States Freeman and Watts picked

**[7:53]:** it up and they went around the country taking basically ice picks going inside and making various cuts inside the skulls uh you know by 1942 there were 5,000 people per year worldwide documented probably more than that these were you know cases and don't and you know we now look at it as a terrible idea but at the time this is all they could imagine you know and that seemed better than putting people in boxes or cages was to attempt to treat it and and even kind of a a nent understanding that very unusual behaviors went with something to do with the brain um We Now understand these frontal aboto or prefrontal aboto surgical surgeons surgery to uh sever the connections of the frontal loes as not treating the disorder but simply uh uh sedating and controlling individuals that what you know when you made a person who was very agitated hard to deal with hard

**[8:48]:** to control hard to reason with uh you gave you gave a procedure like this all of a sudden they were easier to deal with for the doctors and nurses and family members and that seemed like progress and we Now understand that simply making somebody behave in a sedated controllable way is not what we mean really by treatment but we'll come back to this in a minute because many individuals who get medications don't like to take the medications uh some of you may have that experience and they feel they're dulled down in many cases not themselves anymore and so it's a really tricky issue at what level some medications you know start to approach that same issue of just making people behave in ways that other people find comfortable so um uh a nice example of this or a challenging example of this uh is from your book uh uh where there's a guy named Ry

**[9:42]:** he has Tourette's Syndrome so we classified that is a neurological disorder but it has a sort of psychiatric pieces you know Tourette's Syndrome from if if you don't know it from your own life somewhere or another you know it from movies and TV shows love Tourette Syndrome like law shows with courts because what do patients tette syndrome do they have involuntary physical ticks and part of what they have is they they often in during those ticks they curse in pretty horrific ways okay in an uncontrollable way uh uh so that's ideal for television plot lines it's unbelievably hard for the children and adults who have it uh because they're often perceived as being scary and dangerous uh if they're not in a in a controlled state so here's a guy named Ry who has ticks every few seconds since age four imagine if you haven't been maybe some of you have gone through this or

**[10:31]:** know somebody it's very tough on children to have that problem um tough on adults but really tough by the time he's an adult he he's a weekend drummer he loves to play pingpong but his uh not doing too well in terms of jobs he loses his jobs all the time and his home life is pretty miserable he's a pretty miserable life at work and at home um he tries Hal doll which is a drug uh that's uh can help with Tourette's and what happens to him is he instantly Cur of his ticks and the happiest person around if any of you glanced at this

**[11:13]:** yeah yeah it's slowing he feels slowed down exactly so he comes back with a black eye and a broken nose and now in a controlled voluntary way he curses at the doctor right and he says like just trying to go through a revolving door his timing is so off that he injures himself right because a drug has changed in some sense who he is and he feels that he's not himself anymore um he uh uh he stays on the drug for three years for for three months it starts to work uh over the next nine years he has a steady job his family relations improve he's successfully treated by sort of every objective measure happiness at home with your family you know holding a job that's sort of two practical things but he likes to live a life as two rays on the week K he likes to go off his medication and be himself

**[12:01]:** and be the fast drummer and ping pong player that he enjoyed for his early life and then he'll take the medication and be the sober slow somewhat sedated individual who is you know valued at the workplace and can work things out with his family more easily so it's always kind of you know it's always this interesting thing about how you're changing people uh in order to help them and then what's what's that line between changing them to fit in versus helping them so what is abnormal and we mean in a very statistical sense here just you know being at the tail end of distributions um you know some some some things we value abnormal you know being abnormal at one ended the distribution in terms of a success in life so what's a mental disorder it's a clinically significant Behavioral or psychological syndrome of pattern that occurs in a person and that is associated with

**[12:47]:** present distress or disability uh and with significant increase of suffering death pain disability important loss of Freedom so when I talk with psychiatrists and I collaborate a lot with them on Research they emphas excise again the functional consequence you know can you lead a happy personal life can you lead a a reasonably successful professional life and that's almost the most important thing beyond anything um and there's there's amazing stories that make you think about uh uh sources of of Madness apparent Madness or Insanity uh and and a powerful story for myth for me is the story of uh uh semil Weiss so uh he he noticed as a physician um in 1840s that the rate of death of childhood childbed fever in award served by physicians was four times as high as mothers in award in the same Hospital served by midwives at that time practically every physician was a male and every Midwife was

**[13:44]:** a female all right but you were four times more likely to die that's a big increase and his death if you were in award that Physicians served compared to midwives so he wondered what that was about um and he tended to know furthermore that the deaths tended to occur in women serially who were in one bed next to the other there were physical clusters of these and so he began to think well you know for example if the priest comes to gives a last right to this person does that psychologically you know discourage the next person um and he he also found out that that sort of didn't didn't seem to tell the story and then he asked was the same doctor going from bed to bed and the answer was yes of course it makes sense right bed to bed doctor the same doctor is going down the line of women and what he

**[14:29]:** began to notice is that the Physicians were reluctant to watch wash their hands now this sounds ridiculous uh but this is 1840 medicine uh and when he asked them why they didn't wash their hands which we would now would consider pretty fundamental in a medical environment right the basic response was that it was unmanly you know like men didn't wash their hands okay I'm a doctor I'm a man I don't wash my hands I'll come back to this in in a couple um so he asked them to wash their hands on a solution of chlorine and lime the deaths fell from 12% to to about 1% in 15 months all right many lives were saved because the Physicians simply washed their hand and did not carry infections from one person to another down the row of uh childbearing women right um 1848 there's a revolution in Austria he's fired from his job uh the doctors

**[15:20]:** immed you would You' think this would be better world but the doctors immediately are happy they no longer have to wash their hands and the death rid goes right back up uh Joseph liser in 1880 figured out formally lisine but liser uh you know what was going on in terms of cleanliness and sanitation saml Weiss in Austria becomes crazy tells he runs around to people in the street telling them to wash their hands and avoid Physicians and he dies in a mental institution in 1865 and imagine if you were walking here and sometimes when you do walk on the street you run into people who with psychiatric difficulties and it can be a bit scary right imagine somebody runs up to you right and tells you God's sakes you know avoid Physicians and please wash your hands most of us would shrink back a little bit it' be unusual slightly scary right but is he

**[16:09]:** who's the crazy person right uh and he's tragically feeling if he could just tell doctors to wash your hands you would save lives that day and into the future so you know uh more recently there's a compelling story for checklists I don't know if youve any of you seen this book so in emergency room you think okay that's 1840 but now we're Modern Day USA we know what we're doing and and doctors do and other professionals wash their hands more recently there's a a bestseller a couple years ago about checklists so what this is was done in emergency rooms and you may know that there's an unfortunately High rate of errors in hospitals even among highly skilled physicians in the best of academic hospitals there's just miscommunications between doctors and nurses changes of shifts and so on just mistakes happen and uh uh they began to use as an experiment a small checklist like five

**[16:59]:** items did you do the following five things about the catheter or replacing needles or so on and almost instantly there was opposition from the Physicians they said we're doctors and some of this was at John's Hopkins which is as you know is a famous Academic Place but I think it would apply at every hospital we're doctors now we're men and women doctors okay uh we don't need a checklist you know I went to college I went to medical school I did my residency I got my specialty in my boards I don't need a checklist you know that's for the intern right uh so they really opposed it but they got almost instantly far better results of safety and including saving lives almost instantly from the checklists uh uh but the Physicians still don't like it because it seems childish so even to this day it's a bit of a challenge to get uh professionals with

**[17:46]:** pride to do certain things that go against the grain even if it helps people's health so again we talked about that some people think that mental illness is nothing but labeling that which we find unpleasant or difficult non-conforming or deviant on the other hand there's two things one is again so many hands were up I I think if you around it you know that for many many psychiatric diagnosis it's there's a lot of misery involved for the patient for the family I mean it's not just a conceptual argument and there for many diseases like for schizophrenia for example in very different cultures around the world the rates are strikingly similar around 1% uh we'll talk about disorders like autism and ADHD where the numbers have gone up but in schizophrenia for as long as people have rough had a definition around the world is roughly 1% which is a lot one out of 100 for

**[18:33]:** a very very severe life altering disease so the challenges of diagnosis are huge because no brain disorder for all these neuros psychiatric disorders that affect so many people can be spotted by a blood test or a brain image nonone zero to this day everybody's working on it for many years and that corner may turn or or genetic test none so everything is a discussion between the physician and the patient and the family everything is a discussion like that and you know you can use your common sense and do a good job but there's risks so here's a famous study that psychiatrists get really mad about I'll tell you okay and you'll hear why in a moment so this is David rosenan a psychologist of Stanford and what he did is he and his graduate students became pseudo patients they pretended to hear voices which is one of the signal symptoms of schizophrenia to hear voices

**[19:26]:** telling you things the and of course of course if you go to an emergency room and say you're hearing voices telling to you to do things you get admitted you get a psych consult uh and then what they did is once they were admitted into a Psychiatry Ward they just became themselves again okay but now they had the label that they had had had a behavior at the check-in at the moment of admission that looked like schizophrenia seven of eight of these people were diagnosed with schizophrenia by The Physicians and nurses who saw them and it took them anywhere from 3 weeks to uh two months to be released um and every Behavior they did like taking notes because they were doing it for the research paper you know they were frequently interpreted as another sign of their disorder like you know abnormal writing Behavior okay uh schiz and if they got a little bit

**[20:18]:** better they would say schizophrenia but now in remission because you understand once you have that perspective on somebody then every Behavior can be interpreted as you know just a momentary abatement or if you're sitting there scribbling something unusual writing behavior um so one pseudo patient described that he had a close relationship with his mother but was rather remote from his father during early childhood during adolescence and Beyond his father became a close friend while his relationship cooled with his mother okay so that's you know that happens right uh his present relationship with his wife was characteristically close and warm apart from occasional angry exchanges friction was minimal the children had rarely been spanked this is what he told them this was the truth nothing's remarkable in the story right okay but because you're a health professional who's now trying to figure out why did this person hear voices the notes were this white 39y old

**[21:12]:** male manifests a long history of considerable ambivalence in close relationships which began in early childhood a warm relationship with his mother cools during his adolescence a distant relationship to his father's described as becoming very intense affective stability is absent his attempts to control emotionality of his wife and children are punctuated by Angry outbursts and in the case of children spankings you I mean this is human this is not okay because once you have a take on somebody you sort of look for you connect you keep connecting the dots and while he says that he has several good friends one senses considerable ambivalence embedded in those relationships also okay you understand that the interpret and you could say but this is just the problem of psychiatric diagnosis it's all discussion and interpretation um finally they were remitted patient resumes writing Behavior oral fixation it's a little too good to be almost true but there's some stories

**[22:08]:** where other patients were skeptical one patient said quote you're not crazy you're a journalist or Professor referring to the continual to note taking you're checking on up on the hospital as if to freed up patients now this is a little bit of a fable because this makes you know psychiatric disorders sound like you have you have a better sense of reality on the world and I don't think anybody thinks that in a deep way but uh but it it just shows you how how far off the health professionals were so you can you tell the story to a psychiatrist and they get really mad at you uh I mean it's a true story um it shows you the difficulty of diagnosis uh the psychiatrist I talk say well they could fake any disease they wanted to and go pretty far because if you know the medical symptoms and you go and tell a doctor those

**[22:47]:** things a non- psychiatric disease you could get pretty far in terms of treatment before they figure out something's not there right if you know what to say so they just think it's nothing specific about Psychiatry um but any case diagnosis so what are the CR criteria for Diagnostic categories signs are with the examiner sees and symptoms with the patient says and a syndrome is a cluster of signs and symptoms every neuros psychiatric disorder is basically a syndrome it's a cluster of things that tend to go together but individual patient individual patient individual patient shows a different picture than other people they want diagnosis that can be relatively reliably assessed consistently processed some sense that there's some validity to do this but all of this is sort of thinking things through and then finally all these thoughts are organized by experts meeting in you know hotel rooms around the country and conferences and they produce a

**[23:40]:** book called the diagnostic and statistical Manual of the American Psychiatric association DSM 4 dsm5 is about to come out in a in a little bit uh and they have this is the official list of diagnoses these are the lists that all doctors use school systems use Health insurers use you have to meet the criteria in this book to get a diagnosis it looks like that people like to point out that if you pile up the original dsms with each version the lists get bigger and bigger all of these lists uh uh are are debated uh in various ways um let me um give you a sense of a couple of the ones and you can see the ambivalence for so and the dangers of this so uh psychiatrists in the Soviet Union before the Soviet Union fell uh were thrown out of the worldwide psychiatric associations because they would regularly diagnose protesters in the Soviet

**[24:36]:** Union as being crazy and had to be put into mental institutions and given antis psychotic medications because only a crazy person would fail to recognize the correctness of marxist uh principles in the Soviet Union you and the incorrectness of all other Computing systems all right now that's we consider to be politically abusive in the worst sense um I think some of that has thought to go on a bit in China still and other countries but it was manifest in the Soviet Union so uh you know that we can throw out as really bad but it just shows you that you know the dominant powers in a culture can make these decisions about 20 years ago if you were homosexual you were had a diagnosis in this book as a psychiatric disorder um on a lighter side people not always Lighter Side maybe uh people have have debated whether video game addiction should count as a

**[25:29]:** real addiction people debate all the time you know what is the borderline between addictions that almost everybody agrees in terms of alcoholism or drug dependency count as fullscale addictions versus other things you know what what would it take for a person not to leave the room ever playing video games right to count as an addiction um uh there's debates now in autism spectrum disorders they're about to eliminate the separate listings of two two diagnoses uh one of them called um Aspergers which is sort of the milder form of of autism in general they're about to eliminate that distinction many patients and families with aspergers don't like that and also something called here's a bad label pdns pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified imagine if you have a child with difficulty and the doctor tells you your child has pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified that's a child basically who has two of the three components

**[26:27]:** of a diagnosis for for autism so why draw the line there and so psychiatrists I think reasonably saying we don't really understand the lines we're going to call all of these autism spectrum disorders uh but you can see these things are shifting over time these labels move as people think about things and there's no definitive evidence one way or the other besides best attempts by people to figure out what's going on and not everybody agrees also I'll talk about this next time when one DSM switched to another for example the number of children in Germany who qualified for ADHD diagnosis doubled overnight because the diagnostic criteria changed uh that doesn't mean that the which is the better one you couldn't even begin to prove which is the better one uh the original one or the one that had admitted more children into it so these are tough calls and you could say well it's all

**[27:16]:** kind of a little bit arbitrary and a bit subjective and it's true on the other hand you got to help people so why have these labels that there's all kinds of issues well first allocation of resources uh if a person usually needs needs such a diagnostic label to get services at school to get medical services in hospitals to have insurers support them and that's independent of the kind of uh medical service you have right uh second you know if you have a label that's somewhat useful for uh that helps you know what kind of services needed different services are needed for a child with ADHD versus an adult with depression or adult with obsessive compulsive disorder different things are needed a label is needed to even begin to figure out which way to go and then people also want to understand a little but what can they predict about the future course of that person

**[28:00]:** a little bit of treatment and they're fine a lot of treatment and monitoring needed you know you have to do something practical and the labels help you organize around that with all the risks of these labels so we're going to focus um a little bit on on schizophrenia and I'll describe it a little bit and then we'll see a film so sometimes the word schizophrenia is used in a kind of a medically incorrect way which is like multiple personality disorder that's not what schizophrenia is it was described by bler as a splitting of mental function functions disintegration of emotions thoughts and actions um about 1% worldwide another two to three have a percent have a partial version of schizophrenia practically for every disorder there's patients who meet the disorder and there's patients who come close okay and what that exact dividing line should be and what the value of it is is is is constantly

**[28:49]:** struggled with uh similar around the world a slight tendency from birth in Winter or spring people don't know why schizophr happens makes them think about a virus as part of the story patients with schizophrenia are defined as having psychosis and alteration in thoughts perception and Consciousness the thoughts are disconnected and loose they have unusual beliefs or delusions often of persecution uh somebody else Is possessing their thought they can have abnormal experiences in terms of auditory hallucinations mood disorders motor alteration you'll see in a movie with Restless purposeless uh overactivity can have impoved social function for a while people thought a really important distinction of schizophrenia was between what they called negative and positive uh symptoms so the negative ones were they did less of what a person typically does poverty of speech poor attention flat affect lack of motivation uh sorry that's the negative and the positive where active things that people don't usually do

**[29:45]:** delusions hallucinations bizarre or disorganized behaviors biologically has been hard to show that that's kind of a distinction that matters and so what happens with patients with schizophrenia um very mysteriously uh the clinical onset in most cases is late adolescence and early adulthood and nobody understands this um so very typically it's in your 18 20 22 24 how is it that such a psychiatric disorder awaits that long and not much longer in the vast majority of cases what what you know biological thing is ticking in a person that will lead to a psychotic break with reality a huge amount of research now is to try to look at individuals who are in their teens and you know step in and stop somebody before they have the psychotic episode the positive symptoms are most evident in in this acute schizophrenic episode negative symptoms often predominate in the long run huge variability from one person to the other

**[30:44]:** terms of outcome the outcome often responds positively to antic psychotic drugs it's estimated about a quarter of patients make a pretty strong recovery about a quarter remain very disturbed and about half are going back and forth uh uh fluctuating over the years so a picture that people will use is you know he's premorbid functioning and then somewhere in the late teens early 20s some dramatically bad thing happens and then some sort of stable uh condition with occasional relapses and and and a lot has to do with the challenge of individuals like this taking their medications partly being organized enough to take them partly again feeling like the real selves are often is not what the medicated self is um you may know the movie A Beautiful Mind with John Nash uh and it's just an example you know how how psychiatric disorders you know challenge people of every mental caliber um so he uh won

**[31:41]:** the 1994 Nobel prize in economics uh and if you've seen the movie although it's interesting if you've seen the movie also you could go up on YouTube and see him talking about the movie because he they sanitized him somewhat to make him more popular with the movie going public okay um uh because they made it you know a more Charming disorder than everybody says it was including himself uh but he was he he had a terrific aptitude for math went to Carnegie melon Princeton for his PhD uh famous for bargaining problem and non-cooperative games Theory uh came to n in MIT in 1951 as an instructor um and then after doing this fantastic work that won him the Nobel Prize developed acute schizophrenia so why don't we uh watch the movie tell do that let me do this so here's a fairly typical

**[32:42]:** patient yeah

**[32:50]:** sorry you know I I have no idea is there any different rate of schizophrenia people who

**[33:01]:** oh that's okay that's you know somebody who were deaf uh would they hear voices in their schizophrenia you know I I I it's a fantasting question I have no idea I've never thought about that that that's it's rare it's combination of the two are moderately rare you know just numbers wise but that'd be an interesting question yeah I don't know any other I saw another hand or no Okay so um so we know one thing that for every practically for every Neuropsychiatric disorder there's strong familial evidence uh that there's a genetic component to the disorder and a big one um so here are four I mean this is a very touching picture in a way these are identical quadruplets for girls who all grew up to have schizophrenia um not every identical twin will do that so if one twin has schizophrenia half the time the second Twin will have schizophrenia um uh uh if

**[34:04]:** it's diotic it's still higher than 1% but it gets down to 15 15% but I think people have rethought this because very often The Sibling or the or the uh twin if you look a little bit more carefully they won't meet the diagnostic criteria but they often have struggles of some kind as well the lifetime probability in a first-degree relative is 10% versus 1% % if you one parent is 13% two parents 50% so all this is you know lots of suggestions there's a genetic basis uh concordance rates for monozygotic twins for identical twins is almost identical whether the rear together or apart again suggesting a very strong genetic basis uh being adopted away from relatives does not reduce the risk having said that if it's not 100% concordance there's got to be something else going on besides the simple genes of birth right it is higher in urban areas areas that we think have

**[35:01]:** more stress in them uh people have noticed that when often times when people move cultures uh for example African communities in London of recent immigrat they kind of seem to notice a higher rate as well as if a big cultural move can put your risk so and so everybody pretty much agrees that there's what what people will call a multifactorial polyenic environmental threshold model that is there's a lot of different genes plus environmental stressors that come together in some way we don't understand um so uh and you would think that you know with a human genome decoded to a large extent and so on that we'd have some clarity on this uh it's been you can debate this uh and certainly identifying the genes that put you at risk for disease disorders is a hugely important topic the progress in identifying certain genes for any of these psychiatric disorders has been horrible okay uh genes

**[35:54]:** that are identified one year and the next five studies don't replicate it and so on so people the broad Institute across the street now say for them to believe that a gene is associated with schizophrenia they think you have to samples of 10,000 patients with schizophrenia and 10,000 people without it what does that mean that means there's nothing like a Smoking Gun Gene right 10,000 to have enough statistics to support a difference that means many many of the 10,000 don't have that Gene who have schizophrenia right okay if it were one gene one disorder you don't need 10,000 people to get a statistic you need five people so uh it's been a shock to people that there's been so slow progress given that all the things that can decode in the genome to find the genes that are at the heart of psychiatric diseases and that's true for practically all of them uh so we're

**[36:48]:** you know there's something complex about genes environment and people that far exceeds their understanding at the moment uh at every level and so people do models like this because it makes us feel better and there's something probably right about it you know there's an amount of stress in your life that can come up from how you're you know socioeconomic risk health problems family situations there's a predisposition that's genetically based and you know some combination of them determines whether uh you you manifest a disorder or don't so we said there's no definitive biological marker uh for schizophrenia as there is for every other psychiatric disease there's no blood blood test no brain test no nothing that definitively tells you if a person has a diagnosis but people have been studying uh things that are on average different EMB braines and I'll show you some of the most consistent findings uh about ventricles about hipocampal involvement pet

**[37:42]:** scans I'll show you this and I'll show you a few examples in schizophrenia so one thing people have noticed is uh that if they compare these are identical twins uh and you can see the ventricle the fluid filled space is somewhat larger than the twin with the diagnosis than without that's about the least specific brain marker we could ever have The ventricle just means that there's tissue missing around it okay it's just this fluid fill space there should be a bit more tissue it's very far from any specific biology of the disorder and here's the actual twin through their actual MRIs um so we don't think it's the size of the ventricle that makes no sense but that's somehow roughly correlated over the brain basis of the disorder is and then people have shown and these are relatively extreme examples postmortem samples uh here's the HPP campus and healthy individuals here you can see it's

**[38:30]:** somewhat shrunken in uh patients with the diagnosis of um schizophrenia and if you look at those pictures that are kind of picked you could say well that's easy you know give me the MRI you I I'll tell you who has it but statistically it doesn't work that way at all there's tremendous overlap in the size of the hippocampus between Health people without a diagnosis and people with schizophrenia so it's a statistical thing um people have also know this cellular organization sometimes look some how better in patients with schizophrenia uh the typical people than people with schizophrenia again a suggestion about a developmental history underlying this for the risk but without any kind of certainty uh when they've done studies looking at resting uh scanning uh metabolism you're just laying there this is a pet scan it's just where is the blood flowing uh you can see that this is a healthy person a lot of

**[39:21]:** our blood flows as we sit there to the frontal cortex and you can see it's kind of diminished in schizoph but again you cannot put a patient in and say this patient has schizophrenia because many patients will look like many controls um but the average can look like this here's a task now of a working memory task so people see in the easy condition letters are running along and every time there's an X they push a button that's the easy condition here letters are presented rapidly and every time the current letter is identical to the one you saw two letters ago you push a button so this is harder mental work harder working memory demands uh and then here's what you see uh in one data set um so you know people as they're doing this task they turn on a lot of frontal cortex working memory thinking you're used to that here's controls how

**[40:13]:** much they turn it on front of the brain viewed from the top here's relatives who don't have the diagnosis and here's patients who do have the diagnosis these are relatives of these patients uh and take a look at the you could see they're growing so this is this issue if it's more activation Better or Worse well it all depends the way we interpret this is uh for typical person here's how much they have to push you know the pedal to accomplish that working memory task if you're a patient you have to push it a lot more to do the task and you still make more mistakes if you're a relative without a diagnosis of schizophrenia you're somewhere in between and those relatives are as as accurate as controls but they perform somewhat more slowly this is a kind of interesting thing and practically every disorder if you take the relatives of people with a diagnosis

**[41:07]:** they often look like they have a kind of a milder version of that but they may have no problems in their lives they may be doing flourishingly well in every regard that you can think of but they Harbor some of the same genes to be a relative means to share genes and so that can make you know there's something about that happening here or in some subset of those individuals prac ially every study that's done if you take the relatives of people with a diagnosis there's some in betweenness compared to people picked in families without any history of that disorder um but what matters is the boundary right I mean this this difference doesn't matter if this person's doing well you know this difference is associated with something that really makes a big difference in the person's life the question about uh auditory hallucinations and the de this is kind of like that but this

**[41:55]:** is people hearing people but one of the things you can do with imaging is ask what some patients with uh schizophrenia have rapidly psyching auditory hallucinations most don't most it's every here and there but some have it pretty often so you can put them in a scanner and when they hear a voice they push a button and you can ask when they hear a voice as are auditory cortex active in at the level of the brain is it as if they were really hearing a voice and here's the auditory cortex active uh in the individuals at the moment they're experence exping the hallucination it's real to them because somehow it's engaging the auditory cortex that really hears the world that's why it's so powerful right and uh it's somehow engaging the very same tissue by which you really hear the world um how about treatment so uh we'll talk next session we'll talk a lot

**[42:49]:** about different kinds of treatment um neuroleptics are the most common treatment for schizophrenia they block I'll talk a bit about by this post synaptic dopamine receptors uh the drug is uh fully effective within hours but maximum clinical effect takes weeks uh and then remains after you stop the effect remains after the treatment stops a huge problem in schizophrenia are side effects of these kinds of drugs so early on uh you get you induce a bit of Parkinson's disease in patients who never had Parkinson's disease with these typical drugs there atypical drugs they have their problems I'll just focus on the typical drugs I'll tell you why in a minute and then later on this becomes n as cyia and about 20% of patients is a lot of patients this this is that you're producing by the drug abnormal and voluntary movement smacking of lips chewing and Drug uh protrusion uh and there's some drugs that

**[43:39]:** don't do it but they have other problems um and there there is evidence that behavioral therapy can be surprisingly useful in schizophrenia there's a you know most of us hardcore biologists we think that drugs got to be the deal I think there's more evidence than you would imagine that behavioral therapy or the combination of the two can be very helpful for people so you may know now you wouldn't know this I know this okay because I'm in constantly in the fundraising business as a researcher drug companies have almost stopped working on developing treatments for psychiatric diseases and they've almost stopped because it's been so unsuccessful the drugs that were found were almost always by happen stance drugs that were ran almost randomly tried for various disorders of various groups and worked uh none of them were rationally done in any biotech techology sense okay or molecular chemistry design sense uh they were all H practically

**[44:32]:** all of them were happen stance applications of quasy random drugs and then people noticed it helped individuals and so in the last 20 years where was much more rational development of drugs uh it's been spectacularly hard to develop new drugs for psychiatric disorders and so most pharmaceutical companies have basically stopped in the last couple years they just given up uh we know we remain optimistic uh everybody thinks they come back into the picture when some academics produce some things that look good uh but it's it turned out to be really hard and further many of the medications that are effective have all these side effects unes very undesirable side effects sometimes at the same time the fact that these drugs affected disorder has sort of promoted various theories so once people notice that anti- psychotic medications medications that diminish The psychosis of schizophrenia act on the dopamine system that led to the dopamine theory of

**[45:24]:** schizophrenia so they said well if the drug is pushing in down dopamine and that's helping people be less psychotic then maybe the real problem is that uh uh you know there's too much dopamine flowing in the brain of individuals with schizophrenia and that got supported by studies that if you give typical people overdoses of amphetamine you do something that looks a bit in a typical person like the paranoia of schizophrenia uh and so let's talk about this idea of drug action versus disease so if you have a headache what do you take to help yourself with the headache ibuprofen or aspirin or something like that does that mean the medical problem was you didn't have enough aspirin in your blood were you hypo aspiria no right the aspirin is doing something else to counteract the headache or the ibuprofen right it's not that you were short on Tylenol okay but it treats the the problem

**[46:18]:** so if a drug treats schizophrenia by acting on the dopamine system does that mean dopamine was the culprit and the answer is probably not as or it's hard to figure out but the original assumption that the way the drug Works gives you a direct insight into what the cause of the diseas is people have pretty much dismissed um uh but what drew them to it of course is still these antic psychotics the way they work is they block uh The receptors that take dopamine and therefore dopamine gets uh you know catabolized here and is not used in neurotransmission and furthermore amphetamine which produces a somewhat schizophrenic like uh uh schizophrenia like syndrome in some healthy individuals that accelerates the production of dopamine so that seemed to favor the story but again that's sort of not taken very broadly now again what favored the story was the more powerfully a drug bound to dopamine receptors the

**[47:12]:** less drug you had to give patients I mean all of that you could see make people think this is the story uh and it may be that dopamine is a part of the story but uh everybody understand that just because a drug acts on a disease does not mean it's treating the disease in the most direct way um and now why do patients get tardive discinesia why is an inadvertent uh consequence of treating um uh uh schizophrenia producing a verion of Parkinson's disease it's because the drugs are too non-specific so we know the ventral segmental area in the brain stem uh sends dopamine into the basil ganglia and into the prefrontal CeX conceptually what we understand we're trying to achieve with schizophrenia is something like diminishing something about this pathway but the drug can't just you know block this it also affects the basal ganglia and what Parkinson's disease is is a shortage of dopamine

**[48:09]:** in the basil ganglia in the case of Parkinson's disease is because of death of substantial nigral cells but you're producing a pharmacological version of uh Parkinson's disease in the effort to treat schizophrenia not in all patients not a sever as Parkinson's disease but a big side effect in many patients and there's other drugs they have their problems there's almost no drug uh uh that that that's that's completely successful and pure in any you know treatment sense for the patient despite that there's been a fantastic effect we talked about that when people were uh uh you know behaving very oddly and certainly schizophrenia is perhaps the scariest set of behaviors if you have to pick one disorder in that way um then uh you know once they began to have drugs that diminished the unusual Behavior people were leted out of uh state and government hospitals where they had been sort of secluded in many ways

**[49:03]:** and not helped in many ways and people view this as a tremendous success and I think it is to let people back into the community uh interacting in a sort of B typical way as opposed to being segregated in areas that were often not the best uh but there was a fantastic consequence which is now these people as you may know have no safety net they're back in the community and if they don't have people who care for them or follow them you know they're at risk for themselves so uh it's great to give a medication to let somebody out everybody agrees on that but then if you don't have a kind of a safety net of Physicians and family and so on a person's out on their own to stop taking the medication uh who's there to help them so it's a societal Challenge on top of that so next time I'm going to

**[49:45]:** talk about uh treatments for Neuropsychiatric disorders but for just one minute I'll ask you do you have any questions or thoughts about this whole topic yeah

**[50:11]:** there's a fantastic the question was uh why is there such a fantastically High rate of smoking which there is in patients with schizophrenia and bipolar you know so people will use phrases like they're self-medicating in some way uh but I don't think there's a you know you can make up a little bit of a story but it is very striking I I I I don't have I don't know a deeper story than that there might be but it's very

**[50:41]:** striking it it made the voices go away yeah I you know I don't know I mean there's but it's very there's a phenomenal High rate of smoking among patients like that um okay uh thanks very much for
