Transcript

Six months ago, I showed you the blood work of 50 carnivore patients, and one result in it changed everything, and they've now been eating this way for a full year. So, I tested them again. The result I meant was fasting insulin. It fell by more than half, and it's the first thing I looked for this time. I wanted to retest them because of the um warning that almost everyone gets when they tell their GP they've gone carnivore. The warning goes something like this. Um sure, it looks good for a few months, but give it time and it'll catch up with you. Now, a year is a fair point to check whether it actually did.

Now, 46 of the 50 came back, and the line risk for you worried about went up again, uh and I'll show you exactly how far. But when I looked at who it went up uh most in, uh they were the six patients with the lowest fasting insulin in the whole group. Now, that isn't the pattern that you would expect if this diet was slowly catching up with them. And I know what you're hoping I'll say, that a year in uh every number got better for every person. It didn't. And I'll show you the people it went the wrong way for, uh as well as the ones it went right for. So, that's 46 full panels, uh the same tests as last time, which comes to well over like 600 individual results.

Uh I went through them person by person, not just the averages. And if you're new to the channel, I'm Dr. Abs. I started out as a dentist, uh then went back to university to study in multiple fields like anti-aging medicine, metabolic medicine, and sports nutrition. Uh I've taught aesthetic and longevity medicine in almost 40 countries and treated over 10,000 patients. On that basis, I thought it was worth uh doing the thing almost nobody on either side of this argument does, which is going back and checking. So, we'll go through it marker by marker, uh the way we did last time, and I'll finish with whether it's even worth testing your own.

But thing that checking turned up isn't a blood result at all. Uh it's the four people who didn't come back. Uh because who drops out of something like this changes how you should read everything after they drop out. So section one, who came back? Now if I were watching this as a skeptic uh the first thing I'd want to know is who's missing out of that 50. And it's a very fair question. When people drop out of anything like this, the easy assumption is that they're the ones it wasn't working for. Now if that were true here, the 46 who came back would make carnivore look better than it really is.

So here are the four. Two of them moved abroad during the year and couldn't come back for their bloods. One is pregnant and pregnancy pushes blood fats up so much on its own that comparing uh her with the six month numbers will tell us nothing about the diet. And one stopped eating carnivore at about eight months. Uh she told me it wasn't her health. She just missed eating out with her family. Uh when she stopped her six month bloods were sitting right in the middle of the group. But a story about four people isn't proof, so I checked it a second way. If the four who left had been the ones doing worst, the 46 who stayed would have had uh much better six month numbers than the full 50.

But they didn't. Whenever more come back to show you the 46's six month averages are within a couple of percent of the whole groups. Uh losing those four didn't tidy anything up. And there's one more thing you should know before we look at a single number. Not all 46 were still eating the same way. Uh 41 stayed strictly carnivore for the whole year. The other five loosened up a bit mostly by bringing back some dairy or the odd pieces of fruit. Now you'll meet them properly later because they were most of the results that went the wrong way came from. The ground rules haven't changed since the last video.

Uh these are real patients, not a trial. Uh nobody was randomized. There is no control group, and every one of them agreed to have their results shown anonymously. So, treat this as what happened to 46 real people over a year, not as proof of what will happen to you. Which brings us to the number most of you came here for, cholesterol. 124% elastin gene expression increase, 51% reduction hair loss on pull testing, 8% increase in skin hydration, and multiple types of collagen made by your own body. These are just some of the reasons I've personally drunk Nutricost every day for five years. This channel has no sponsorships because I only recommend things I have personal or clinical experience in.

There's literally no product in the world that can do what this can. And you guys said to me you struggled to find somewhere to buy it and that it was expensive. So, in response, I made the labrate.com website, which is now the cheapest place in the world to buy it. The link is in the description below for all the literally unmatched clinical data and global patents on this product. Section two, cholesterol, a year in. So, total cholesterol and LDL both went up again by about 7% and here they are. I'm not going to dress that up. On most UK lab reports, those numbers would be printed in bold with a flag next to them because what's normally quoted as the normal range for LDL stops at about three.

Now, if you've been given the standard version of what that means, you're picturing something like grease going down a drain pipe. Uh the more of it there is in your blood, the more sticks to the walls until one day the pipe blocks. Um it's a reasonably understandable picture because it's the one most leaflets and most GP appointments give you, but it puts the wrong thing in the pipe. Uh LDL isn't cholesterol, okay? It's a particle that carries cholesterol within it uh along with fats and fat-soluble vitamins out to the cells that need them. So, think of it less like grease and more like a delivery lorry on a motorway uh or a highway.

So, counting LDL tells you how lorries are on the road. It doesn't tell you where any of them are actually crashing. On carnivore, there's a good reason for more traffic. When you stop eating carbs, your body runs mostly on fat. So your liver packs that fat into big lorries called VLDL and sends them out to your muscles. And as they drop their fat off, they shrink and what's left on the road is LDL. More fat being delivered means more of these lorries on the road at any one time. Now, I think back to the six patients I mentioned at the start. The six whose LDL rose the most this year were the six with the lowest fasting insulin in the whole group.

And five of them were also among the leanest. If the drain pipe picture were right, you'd expect the people whose LDL climbed most to be the ones whose health was slipping. Instead, they were the people with the best metabolic health in the whole group. And this isn't just my clinic, right? A team of researchers, they pulled 41 trials, I think, of low carb diets and found that the leaner people were when they started. Sorry, the the the leaner the people were when they started, the more their LDL went up. Now, people carrying a lot of extra weight actually came down slightly. There's a name for the lean fit people at the far end of that lean mass hyper responder as if it were a strange exception, right?

I put it the other way around. I don't think they're an exception at all. I think LDL was never the villain for anyone whose metabolic health is good. And the people with the most lorries on the road are simply the ones running most on fat. Now, the rest of the lipid panel moved the way you would want. Triglycerides are the number that climbs when climbs most when a diet is heavy in sugar and starch. They fell again by about another fifth. On top of the fall we saw at six months and HDL rose. Both should be on screen now. A quick correction from the last video while we're on HDL. Actually, one of the HCL numbers on the screen was converted into UK units wrongly.

Uh the right figure is 1.6 and it's on screen now. Now the number I actually watch from this part of the panel is the ratio of triglycerides to HDL because it tracks insulin far better than LDL does. Uh I'll give it in the American units I used last time because that's the scale my target is on. Uh the medium went from 1.1 at 6 months to 0.8 at a year. Uh I'd like to see it below one typically and the group is now comfortably under that as an average. But I want to be clear about what I'm not saying. Uh I'm not saying a higher HDL is a prize um or that anyone should be trying to get their LDL down.

I don't think we should be trying to push LDL or HDL up or down at all. Uh I think we should eat and live well and let those numbers be whatever they turn up to be. And in my view, the idea that less cholesterol is always better comes from misreading the science. The The trouble though is that most people don't give up on carnivore because they feel worse, at least in my experience. Uh they give up when they're sitting in front of a GP who's just seen an LDL of whatever, 6.4 and quite reasonably by the guidelines they're given wants to talk about a statin. Uh now that just so you know, that conversation is exactly what we prepare for in my school group and members post their blood work.

I go through it with them on our weekly live call uh and there are lessons in there on reading your own lipid panel so you walk into that appointment knowing what your numbers mean. Uh the link is in the description if you'd like to join us. Section three, sugar and insulin. So fasting insulin is a result I said I'd check first, so here it is. Last time it more than halved, uh which is the drop that changed everything for me. Uh at a year, it's fallen again to 3.5 and just under half the group are now below three. Uh this is the whole line from before they started to today. The prediction I hear most often about this goes the other way and there's a real lab finding behind it too.

So I want to give it a fair hearing. The argument is that if you eat nothing but and fat for long enough, you'll become insulin resistant. And it's true that if as someone who's been carnivore for a year has a big sugary drink in a glucose tolerance test, their blood sugar will often go higher and stay up longer than you'd expect. On paper that can look like early diabetes, of course. But that test is measuring the right thing at the wrong time. When you've had almost no carbohydrate for months, your muscles step back from using sugar, so the little sugar your liver makes is saved for your brain and red blood cells, which obviously need it.

So when a big dose of sugar suddenly arrives, your muscles don't let much of it in for a while. That's physiological insulin resistance, a protective setting rather than damage. And it reverses within days of eating carbohydrate again. The way to tell the two apart is fasting insulin. If fat really were damaging the way these patients handled sugar, their bodies would have to push out more and more insulin to keep their blood sugar set steady. And fasting insulin would would slowly creep up, whereas it actually did the opposite, it fell. Now there's a score called HOMA-IR that puts the two together into one number for how hard your body has to work to keep your sugar steady.

Now it fell again too, as you can see. And nearly, I think it was like nine in 10 of the group are now below one. So fasting glucose and HbA1c both edged down slightly and you'll see both of them here. There's barely a change and it doesn't need to be more because there wasn't much further for either to fall anyway. Then there are the two patients from last time who had type two diabetes. Their HbA1c were 65 and 68 before they started and both were below 37 within a month. A year on, there are 34 and 35. Whatever was supposed to catch up with them clearly hasn't. Yeah, now not everyone's insulin fell down no, went down though I should say, and I'll show you who it went up for later.

Insulin was the number I was most curious about the one I was most nervous about was actually inflammation because if a diet really were catching up with you as they say, that's where I'd expect to see it first. Section four, inflammation and the liver. So the marker I use for inflammation is high sensitivity CRP. Is a protein your liver releases into your blood when something in your body is inflamed. Now it already fallen by about two thirds in the first six months and at a year it's down by about another quarter. And and more than eight in 10 of the group are now below 1.5. You can follow it from start to finish on the chart that's on screen now.

So if you ask most people what eating red meat every day does to inflammation and they'll they'll say is it they'll tell you that it drives it up. Most of that idea comes from studies that ask large numbers of people what they ate and in those studies the people eating the most red meat also differed from everyone else in several other ways listed here on screen. And the studies can't fully separate the meat from everything that came with it. You know measuring CRP in people who eat meat without all of that is a more direct test and in this group CRP has now fallen twice in a row. Homocysteine which builds up in your blood when you're short of certain B vitamins also came down slightly.

There's the change you can see it. It's a small move but it's in the right direction and it makes sense because red meat is one of the richest sources of vitamins B12 and B6 that you can eat. I didn't show you liver numbers last time but I had them and I want to show you them now because there's a worry about the liver that I hear a lot. The worry usually goes something a bit like this. A diet this high in fat must be loading your liver with fat. The thing is when researchers traced where the fats in fatty livers actually comes from, only about I think it was like 15 % came straight from fat in the diet.

Most of it actually came from the person's own fat stores and about a quarter was made by the liver itself out of sugar. That was a small study though, there was only nine people, but every one of them had high insulin and that's the key. High insulin tells your liver to store fats. With insulin as low as it as low as it is in this group, the liver is far more likely to turn incoming fat into ketones and and then send it back out. ALT and GGT are two enzymes that leak out of liver cells into your blood when those cells are shall we say under strain. Both were already quite low and as the numbers are showing now, both came down even further.

So the place I was most nervous about turned out to be where the improvements were most consistent actually, which leads to hormones including the thyroid result that low carb critics point to more than any other I would say, at least in my experience. Section five, hormones. Now there's no kind of myth to take apart here with testosterone, so I'll just make it pretty simple. Last time average testosterone in the men rose by about a quarter. 29 of those men came back and at a year it has crept up a little further which is the last of these three readings. So most of the rise happened in the first six months and what matters at a year is that it held.

As last time SHBG barely moved so this is testosterone the body can actually use. Thyroid is where the argument starts though. Yeah, like last time I'm not going to average the thyroid numbers across everyone. A lot of these patients came in with either an underactive or an overactive thyroid, so an average would just hide more than it shows. Like it's it's a useless statistic here. What I can tell you is that every patient whose thyroid problem had resolved at six months is still resolved at one year. Now the argument you'll hear about the people whose thyroids were normal to begin with, it says that cutting out carbohydrate pushes down free T3, the active thyroid hormone, and that a lower T3 means your thyroid's starting to struggle.

Now the first half is right. In the people in this group who had normal thyroids, free T3 dipped slightly and there it is. You can see it. But the second half reads it, I would say backwards. When your thyroid generally can't keep up, your brain notices and pushes harder. And the signal it pushes with is TSH, which goes up. Now in this group TSH didn't budge. A lower T3 on low carbs is exactly what I'd expect and with a steady TSH it looks to me like a body that simply needs less of it, not a gland that's failing. And the way I settle it in clinic is the way I settle most of these numbers. I look at the person, not the number.

If someone's free T3 has dipped but they feel well on every count in this list, I'm not going to chase a number on the page, right? None of the 46 developed symptoms of an underactive thyroid this year. That leaves the people who didn't have a year like this, because they exist too, and I think we should show you them. Section six, the ones who went the wrong way. So seven of the 46 had at least one of the metabolic markers I've shown you go the wrong way this year. They're included in every average you've seen so far and I want to show you each of them because averages hide people like this. Now when someone's numbers go backwards a year into a diet, the natural assumption is that diet has stopped working for them.

It's what most people conclude and it's exactly the it catches up with you warning predicts. So it's worth looking at what actually changed for these seven for them from the five I told you about earlier, the one two loosened up. Their fasting insulin and triglycerides both went back You can look at the before and after here. All four had brought back milk or fruit or both, and milk in particular pushes insulin up more than its sugar content alone would would suggest or predict. Now, I know how that sounds. It didn't work because they didn't do it properly. That's the oldest excuse in the book.

But that's not quite what this is. These four people had good numbers at six months while they were eating strictly, and the numbers moved only after they changed what they ate and not before. Now, tested at the same lab before and after. I think it's a good control to have. And the fifth person who loosened up, who only brought back some cheese, barely moved at all. Now, two of the seven were strict the whole year and their CRP went up. One had a chest infection the week of a blood test, and when we repeated it a month later, her CRP was back down where it had been. The other had a tooth infection that he hadn't had treated yet.

Their CRP readings are on the card. CRP is a smoke alarm for the whole body and it goes off for a chest infection or a tooth infection just as readily as for anything you eat as well. Now, the last one I can't fully explain. He stayed strict, but his fasting insulin rose by about half. The only thing that changed in his life was a new baby and about Yeah, it's about five hours sleep a night and short sleep is one of the most reliable ways to push insulin up, but I can't prove that that's the reason, so not going to pretend I can. So, out of 46 people, four went the wrong way after changing what they ate.

Two had an infection at the time of the test and one I can't fully account for. So, this isn't a diet catching up with people. If it were, I expect to see it spread across the strict patients and getting worse with time, and that isn't what happened. You'll notice none of those seven went the wrong way on LDL. That's because I don't count a rising LDL as going the wrong way. If it's your own LDL that keeps climbing and you want the full reasoning behind that, I've made a a much longer video on cholesterol, statins, and and heart disease. I'll leave a link to it in the description below, and it's the one I'd want you to watch before you make any decision about your own.

And that raises the obvious question after a video like this. Should you be getting your own bloods done? Session seven, what a year will tell you. So, did it catch up with them? Well, for these 46 people over a year, it didn't. Here's a whole year on one screen. The results that went the wrong way could almost all be traced to something that changed rather than to a diet slowly turning on people. Now, that's still 46 patients from one clinic with no control group, so it isn't the final word. And I'd rather be corrected than be wrong for a bit longer. Now, planning to test them again maybe 18 months or two years.

If you want to see whether a second year looks like the first, that's a good reason to subscribe, I think. As for whether you should test your own bloods, my view hasn't really changed since the last video, to be honest. For most of you, I don't think it's that useful. If your fasting insulin comes back at, I don't know, six rather than three, the advice would still be the same. Read Eat you know, real animal food, build muscle, sleep properly. Where I think testing does help is if you're on medication, if you're managing a condition, or if a number on a report is the thing standing between you and a diet that's you know, possibly working for you.

Now, if that's you, the members post their results in my school group, and we go through them on the weekly call, and the link is in the description. Now, I'm also not saying that this is how you have to eat for the rest of your life. If it makes you miserable, what's the point of living longer, right? A treat now and then in sensible amounts isn't what moved the numbers in those four patients. What moved them was bringing something back every day without really noticing. The way your own balance sits is entirely up to you. It's not my decision to make. And if a year of these results keep pointing uh keeps pointing back to one thing, it's that a blood test is only measuring the foundations.

The first is sleep. That means you don't wake up tired, which the new dad in this group would tell you is easier said than done. Uh the rest uh I know sunlight on your skin and eyes, muscle that you continuously keep building even into your 50s and 60s if you can. Food that comes from animals rather than you know machines and factories. And people around you who notice if you aren't okay, you know social connections. Get those right and most of these numbers tend to look after themselves. You know if someone you know has been told that carnivore will catch up with them eventually, send them this video.

A year of real numbers might be more useful to them than just I don't know another warning.

Seek backward 5s ←
Longer seek (10s) Shift ←
Play Space Seek forward 5s →
Longer seek (10s) Shift →
0:00 Auto-scroll A Copy link at current time S

I Re-Tested 50 Carnivore Patients After A Year. How Many Were Harmed?