# Lecture 16: Eigenstates of the Angular Momentum Part 2

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4LyPVfGWtI
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/R4LyPVfGWtI

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 7:33 — Chapter 2 (7:33)
- 14:29 — Chapter 3 (14:29)
- 15:10 — Chapter 4 (15:10)
- 22:20 — Chapter 5 (22:20)
- 24:48 — Chapter 6 (24:48)
- 27:49 — Chapter 7 (27:49)
- 32:11 — Chapter 8 (32:11)
- 38:49 — Chapter 9 (38:49)
- 43:29 — Chapter 10 (43:29)
- 51:11 — Chapter 11 (51:11)
- 52:10 — Chapter 12 (52:10)
- 55:03 — Chapter 13 (55:03)
- 56:57 — Chapter 14 (56:57)
- 1:00:48 — Chapter 15 (60:48)
- 1:03:59 — Chapter 16 (63:59)
- 1:10:15 — Chapter 17 (70:15)
- 1:13:24 — Chapter 18 (73:24)
- 1:20:21 — Chapter 19 (80:21)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseware at ocw.mit.edu.

**[0:23]:** All right. Welcome everyone. Hi. So, um today we're going to pick up where we left off last time in our study of angular momentum and rotations in quantum mechanics. Um before I get started, let me open up for questions pragmatic and physics-related.

**[0:48]:** Yeah. Um so, when we were solving for the 3D harmonic oscillator, Yes. we um solved for the energy eigenfunctions, which was a product of phi x, phi y, phi z. Yes. And then you made an assumption where with an assumption that phi v was equal to phi sub n and m and s something like that. So, how did you get from Good. Good. So, what we had was that we had that the energy We wanted to find the energy of the 3D harmonic oscillator. And we wanted to find the energy eigen value eigen functions and eigen values. The way we did this was by saying, "Look, the energy of the 3D harmonic oscillator, which I can think of as a function of x and px and y and py and z and pz, has this nice form that we could write it as the uh energy operator purely in terms of x p squared over p squared x upon 2m plus m omega squared upon 2 x squared plus So, this is a single 1D harmonic oscillator

**[1:42]:** uh energy operator in the x direction plus e 1D in the y direction plus a harmonic oscillator energy 1D in the z direction. Yeah, so that was the first observation. And then we said that, "Look, our Given that this splits in this fashion, I mean, write my wave function uh my energy eigenfunction, I should say, phi of x, y, and z uh in separated form as a product phi x of x phi y of y and phi z of z. And we we used this and deduced that in order for this to be an eigenfunction of the 3D harmonic oscillator, it must be true that phi x of x was itself an eigenfunction of the x harmonic oscillator equals um uh with some energy epsilon, which I will call epsilon sub x, phi sub x of x, and ditto for y and z. And if this is true, if phi sub x is an is an eigenfunction of the 1D harmonic oscillator, then this is an eigenfunction of the 3D harmonic oscillator.

**[2:45]:** But we know what the eigenfunctions are of the harmonic oscillator. The eigenfunctions of the 1D harmonic oscillator, we gave a name. We call them phi sub n. Okay. So, what I what we then said was, "Look, um if this is an eigenfunction of the 1D harmonic oscillator in the x direction, then it must be uh le- it's labeled by an n. And if this one is in the y direction, it's labeled by an l. And if this one is in the z direction, it's labeled by a z. But on top of that, we know more. We know what these energy eigen values are. The energy eigen values corresponding to these guys are, if this is phi n, this is e e n. I simply write this as e n for the 1D harmonic oscillator. And taking this, using the 1D the fact that they're 1D eigen functions, and plugging into the energy eigen value equation for the 3D harmonic oscillator, tells us that the energy eigen values for the 3D case are of the

**[3:33]:** form e1 e1D x plus e2D or sorry, e1D in the y plus e1D in the z, which is equal to, since these were the same frequency, h bar omega times n plus l plus m from each of them a 1/2, so plus 3/2. Cool. Did that answer your question? Excellent. Other questions? Yeah. So, energy and angular momentum have to be related somehow, right? Yeah. I mean, of course, but because it's both Indeed. r cross p, right? Yes. is, so we have a ladder. Is there limits on them? Very good question. So, this is where we're going to pick up. See, let me rephrase this. This is really two questions. Question number one. Um look, there should be a relationship between angular momentum and energy, but we're just talking about angular momentum. Why? Second question. Look, we've got a ladder, but it is a ladder infinite?

**[4:29]:** So, let me come back to the second question. That's going to be the beginning of the lecture. On the first question, yes, angular momentum is going to play a role when we calculate the energy. But two two quick things to note. First off, consider a system which is spherically symmetric, rotationally invariant. That means that the energy doesn't depend on rotation. If I rotate the system, I haven't changed the energy. So, if a system is rotationally invariant, that's going to imply some constraints on the energy eigen values and how they depend on the angular momentum as we discussed last time. Let me say that slightly differently. When we talk about the free particle, 1D free particle. We've talked about this one to death. Take the 1D free particle. We can write the energy eigen functions as momentum eigen functions because the momentum commutes with the energy, right?

**[5:13]:** And so, the wave the eigen functions of the energy operator are indeed e to the ikx. They're plane waves. They're eigen functions of the momentum operator as well. Similarly, when we talk about a 3D system, it's going to be useful in talking about the energy eigen values to know a basis of energy eigen functions or sorry, of eigen functions of the angular momentum operator. Knowing the angular momentum operator is going to allow us to write energy eigen functions in a natural way in a simply in the same way that knowing the momentum operator allowed us to write energy eigen functions in a simple way in the 1D case. Does that make sense? It's We're going to have a glorified version of the Fourier theorem where instead of summing over e to the ikx's, we're going to sum over our angular momentum eigenstates. And those are called the spherical harmonics, and they are the analog of Fourier expansion for the sphere.

**[5:57]:** But you're right, we're going to have to understand how that interacts with the energy. And that'll be the topic of the next lecture. We're going to finish up angular momentum today. Other questions? Okay. So, from last time, these are the commutation relations which we partially derived in lecture and which you will be deriving on your problem set. Um it's a really good exercise. Commit these to memory. They're your friends. Um key thing here to keep in mind, h bar has units of angular momentum. So, this makes sense. Angular momentum, angular momentum, angular momentum, angular momentum. So, h When you see an h bar in this setting, um its job in some sense is to make everything dimensionally uh sensible. Okay. So, the important things here are that Lx and Ly do not commute. They commute to Lz. Can you have a state with definite angular momentum in the x direction and definite angular momentum in the y direction simultaneously?

**[6:50]:** No, because of this commutation relation. It would have to vanish. Can you have a state with definite So, this is uh say the x component of the angular momentum. Can you have a state with definite angular momentum in the x direction and total angular momentum L squared? Yes. Okay, great. That's going to be important for us. So, in order to construct the eigen functions, it turns out to be useful to construct these so-called raising and lowering operators, which are Lx plus iLy. They have a couple of nice properties, but the first is, since these are built up out of Lx and Ly, both of which commute with L squared, the L plus minuses commute with L squared. Okay. So, these guys commute. So, acting with L plus it doesn't change uh if if we have a an eigenfunction of L squared, acting with L plus does not change its eigen value.

**[7:33]:** Yeah. Similarly, L plus commuting with Lz gives us h bar L L plus or L minus with a plus or minus out front. This is just like the raising and lowering um uh uh This is just like the raising and lowering operators for the harmonic oscillator, but instead of the energy, we have the angular momentum. So, this is going to tell us that the um that the angular momentum eigen values, the eigen values of Lz, are shifted by plus or minus h bar when we raise or lower with L plus or L minus, just like the energy was shifted for the 1D harmonic oscillator, the energy was shifted um plus h bar omega a dagger, was shifted by h bar omega when we acted with a plus on an energy eigenstate. Same thing. Okay. So, our goal Two questions on the commutators before we get going.

**[8:24]:** In some sense, we're going to just ex- take advantage of these commutation relations and explore their consequences today. So, our goal is going to be to build the eigen functions

**[8:40]:** and eigen values

**[8:44]:** of the um angular momentum operators, and in particular, of the most angular momentum operators we can, a complete set of commuting observables, L squared and Lz. Now, you might complain, "Look, why Lz?" Whoops, I don't mean a commutator. I mean the set. Um you might say, "Why Lz? Why not Lx?" And if you call this the the z direction, then I will simply choose a new basis where this is called the x direction. So, it makes no difference whatsoever. It's just a name. The reason we're going to choose Lz is because it's it plays nicely that coordinate system plays nicely with spherical uh coordinates. It's just a conventional choice of spherical coordinates where theta equals zero is the up axis, but there's nothing deep about that. We could have taken any of these guys. Okay. So, this is our goal. So, let's get started. So, first, let So, we know, because of these commutation relations, we and in particular this one, we know that we can find common eigen functions of L squared and Lz.

**[9:37]:** Let us call those common eigen functions by a name, Y sub lm, uh where such that So, let these guys be the eigen functions, the common eigen functions of L squared and Lz. i.e., L squared Y L M is equal to Well, first off, units. This has units of angular momentum squared, H bar squared. So, that got rid of the units. And we want our eigenvalue L M. And I'm going to give a uh because I know the answer, I'm going to give instead of calling this a random dimensionless number, which would be the eigenvalue, I'm going to call it a very specific thing, L L plus one. This is a slightly grotesque thing to do, but it will make the algebra much easier. So, um Similarly, so that's what the little L is. Little L is labeling the eigenvalue of L squared and the actual value of that eigenvalue.

**[10:31]:** I'm just calling H bar squared L L plus one. That doesn't tell you anything interesting. This was already a real positive number. So, you know, this could have been any real positive number as well by tuning L. Okay. Similarly, um L Z uh Y L M. I want this to be an eigenfunction. This has units of angular momentum, so I'll put an H bar. Now, we have a dimensionless coefficient Y L M. And I'll simply call that M. Okay. So, if you will, these are the definitions of the symbols M and L, little L. And Y L M are just the names I'm giving to the angular momentum eigenvalues or eigenfunctions. Cool? So, I haven't actually done anything. I've just told you that these are the eigenfunctions. What we want to know is what's the what properties do they have and what are the actual allowed values of the eigenvalues?

**[11:18]:** So, the two key things to note are first that L plus and minus leave the an- leave the eigenvalue of L squared alone. So, they leave L alone. Right? So, this is the statement that L squared on L plus uh Y L M is equal to L plus on L squared Y L M is equal to uh H bar squared L L plus one. The eigenvalue of L squared acting on Y L M, whoops. L plus Y L M. And so, we have an L plus Y L M is just as much an eigenfunction of L squared as Y L M was itself. With the same eigenvalue. Two. So, that came from uh from Where are we? That came from this commutation relation. Okay. So, similarly, L plus minus raise or lower M by one. Okay. And the way to see that is to do exactly the same computation.

**[12:29]:** L Z on L plus, for example, Y L M is equal to L plus um Now, we can write the commutator um L Z L plus plus L plus L Z Y L M. But the commutator of L Z with L plus, we already have, is plus H bar L plus. So, this is equal to H bar L plus. And from this term L plus L Z on Y L M, L Z acting on Y L M gives us H bar M plus H bar M L plus Y L M. Is equal to pulling this out, this is H bar times M plus one times L plus H bar M plus one L plus Y L M. So, L plus has raised the eigenvalue M by one. This op- this state, what we get by acting on Y L M with a raising operator, is a thing with M greater by one.

**[13:27]:** And that came from the commutation relation. And if we'd done the same thing with minus, if you go through the minus signs, it just gives us this. Okay. So, um what does that tell us? What this tells us is we get a ladder of states.

**[13:44]:** And let's look at what they look like. Each ladder for a given value of L, if you raise with L plus and lower with L minus, you don't change L, but you do change M. So, we get ladders that are labeled by L. So, for example, if I have some value L1, this is going to give me a val- this is going to give me some state. I can uh label by M. I can Well, let me put the M to the side. I can raise it to get M plus one by L plus. And I can lower it to get M minus one uh by L minus. Okay? So, I get a tower. And if we have another value, a different value of L of L, I'll call it L2, we get another tower. Again, M, M plus one, M plus two, dot dot dot, minus one, dot dot dot.

**[14:29]:** So, we have separated towers with different value of L squared. And within each tower, we can raise and lower by L plus, skipping by one.

**[14:41]:** Okay, questions? So, that was basically the end of the last lecture, said slightly differently. So, now here's the question. So, this is the question that a student asked right at the beginning. Is this tower infinite?

**[15:05]:** Or does it end?

**[15:10]:** So, I pose to you the question, is the tower infinite or does it end? And why?

**[15:20]:** Okay, so it's tempting to say it's infinite in one direction because

**[15:27]:** Okay, so it's because there are no bounds to the angular momentum one can have. That's tempting. Um but at the same time, you when you act a raising or lowering operator on L, the eigenfunction the eigenvalue L squared remains the same. So, then if you keep you can't raise the Z component of the angular momentum above the actual length. Thank you, exactly. So, here's the statement. Let me restate that. That's exactly right. So, look, L squared is the eigenvalue of the total angular momentum. Roughly speaking, it's giving you an Precisely, in the state Y L M, it tells you the expected value of the total angular momentum L squared. That's some number, right? Now, if you act with L plus, you keep increasing the expected value of L Z. But if you keep increasing it and keep increasing it and keep increasing it, L Z will eventually get much larger than the square root of L squared.

**[16:19]:** That probably isn't true. Right? That sounds wrong. Right? That was the statement. Excellent. That's exactly right. So, let's make that precise. So, is the tower infinite? No, it's probably not for that for precisely that reason. So, let's make that precise. So, here's the way we're going to do it. This is a useful trick in general. This will outlive angular momentum and be a useful trick uh throughout quantum mechanics for you. Um I used it in a paper once. So, here's the nice observation. Uh suppose it's true that the tower ends. Just like for the raising and lowering operators for the harmonic oscillator in one dimension, that tells us that in order for the tower to end, the state must be zero once we raise it. The last state, so Y L, and I'll call this M plus, must be zero. There must be a max.

**[17:03]:** Oh, sorry. Let me actually, before I walk through exactly this statement. So, let me make first this the know slightly more obvious and precise. So, let's turn that argument into a precise statement. L squared is equal to, just from the definition, L X squared plus L Y squared plus L Z squared. Now, let's take the expectation value in the state Y L M of both sides of this equation. So, on the left hand side, we get H bar squared L L plus one. And on the right hand side, we get the expectation value of L X squared plus the expectation value of L Y squared plus the expectation value of L Z squared. But we know what the expectation value is of L Z squared is H bar squared M squared. But the expectation value of L X squared and L Y squared are strictly positive.

**[17:52]:** Because this is can be written as a sum over all possible eigenvalues of L X squared, which is the square of the possible eigenvalues of L X, times the probability distribution. That's a sum of pro- positive strictly positive numbers. These are positive guys. So, L L plus one is equal to positive plus positive plus H bar squared M squared. And in particular, that tells you that it's greater than or equal to H bar squared M squared. Right? I mean, maybe these are zero. Right? So, the least it can be is So, the the most M squared can possibly be is square root of L plus one. Or most M can be. Okay? So, M is bounded. There must be a maximum M. And there must be a minimum M because this is squared. The sign doesn't matter. Everyone cool with that? Okay, so let's turn this into now a precise argument.

**[18:42]:** What are the values of M plus and M minus? What is the top value of that of each tower? Probably it's going to depend on total L, right? So, it's going to depend on each value of L. Let's Let's check that. So, here's the nice trick. Suppose we really do have a maximum M plus. That means that if I try to raise the state Y L M plus, I should get the state zero, which is not you know, that ends the tower. So, suppose this is true. In that case, in particular, here's the nice trick. L plus Y L M, if we take its magnitude, if we take the magnitude of this state, the state is zero. It's the zero function. So, what's its magnitude? Zero. Okay, you might not think that's all that impressive an observation. Okay? But note what this is. We know how to work with this.

**[19:25]:** In particular, this is equal to I should have done this dot dot dot is equal to I'm not going to use the Hermitian adjoint and pull this over to the right hand side. The adjoint to L plus is L minus. So, this gives us Y L M L minus L plus Y L M. This also doesn't look like much of an improvement. Until you notice from the definition of L plus and L minus, that what's L minus L plus? Well, L minus L plus, we're going to get an LX squared. So, YLM We get an LX squared plus an LY squared. I'm going to get my sign right if I'm not careful. Um plus, well, let's just do it. Okay, so we have L minus L plus. So, we're going to get a LX ILY minus ILYLX. So, plus I commutator of LX with LY.

**[20:16]:** Okay? Good. So, that's progress uh YLM. But it's still not progress because the natural operators with which to act on the YLMs are L squared and LZ. So, can we put this in the form L squared and LZ? Sure. This is L squared minus LZ squared. YLM L squared minus LZ squared and this is Well, this is IH bar LZ. times I is minus H bar LZ. So, minus H bar LZ. Okay. YLM And this must be equal to zero. But this is equal to from L squared, we get H bar squared uh LL plus one. From the LZ squared, we get minus M squared H bar squared. And from here, we get minus H bar H bar M. So, minus uh M H bar squared. Notice that the units worked out. And all of this was multiplying YLM YLM, but YLM YLM, if it's a properly normalized eigenstate, which is what we were assuming at the beginning, is just one.

**[21:24]:** So, we get this times one is zero. Aha. And notice that in all of this, this was M plus. We were assuming we were working here with the assumption that L plus annihilated this top state. And so, grouping this together, this says therefore H bar squared times pulling out a common H bar squared from all of this times um L L plus one minus M M plus M plus M plus plus one is equal to zero. And this tells us that M plus is equal to L. And if you want to be strict, put a plus sign. Everyone cool with that? There's a very useful trick. If you know something is zero as a function, you know its norm is zero, and now you can use things like Hermitian adjoints. Very, very useful. Okay, questions about that? Yeah.

**[22:20]:** Good. Okay, so where the excellent. Where this came from was I was just literally taking L plus and L minus, plugging it taking the definitions, and plugging them in. So, if I have L minus L plus, L minus is just to write it out explicitly, L minus is equal to LX because it the angular momentum are observables and so they're Hermitian, so they're self-adjoint, minus ILY. So, L minus L plus gives it me an LXLX, it gives me an LXILY, it gives you a minus ILYLX, and it gives me an minus II, which is plus one LY squared. Cool? Excellent. I'm in a state of serious desperation here. I um Good. Other questions? Yeah.

**[23:04]:** This to here? Okay, good. So, here what I Sorry, this I jumped a step here. So, here what I said is look, I've got this nice set of operators acting on YLM. I know how each of these operators acts on YLM. LZ gives me an H bar M. Minus M H bar squared. LZ squared L squared. And then all over all that was uh just some number times YLM, which I can pull out of the inner product. Cool? Yeah. Good. The subscript plus meant that look, there was a maximum value of M. So, M squared had to be greater had to be less than or equal to this. There's a maximum value and a and a minimum value. Maybe they're different, I don't know. I'm just going to be ambiguous I'm going to be open-minded about that. Others? Yeah.

**[23:48]:** Yeah, awesome observation. Exactly. Okay, so we were going to get there in a little bit. So, I like that. That's exactly right. So, um So, let me let me go through one a couple more steps and then I'll come back to that observation. And and I promise I will say so. Okay. So, if we go through exactly a similar argument, let's think what happens if we did L minus on YLM minus just to walk through the logic. So, if this were you lower the lowest one, you get zero, then we'd get the same story L minus L minus. When we take the adjoint, we'd get L plus L minus. Okay? And L plus L minus, what changes? The only thing that's going to change is that you get this commutator the other direction, and there are minus signs in various places. The upshot of which is that M minus is equal to minus L.

**[24:35]:** So, this is quite parsimonious. It's symmetric. If you take Z to minus Z, if you know, if you switch the angular momentum sign of the angular momentum, you get the same thing back. That's satisfying, perhaps.

**[24:48]:** But it's way more than that. This tells us a lot about this about the possible eigenvalues in the following way. Look back at our towers. In our towers, we have that the angular momentum is raised and lowered by L plus. So, the LZ angular momentum is raised and lowered by L plus. L is remains the same, but there's a maximum state now, which is plus L. And there's a minimum state in here L1. Here, there's a minimum state minus L1. Similarly for the other tower, there's a minimum state minus L2 and a maximum state L2. So, how big each tower is depends on the total angular momentum. That kind of makes sense, right? If you've got more angular momentum and you can only step LZ by one, you've got more room to move with a large value of L than with a small value of L.

**[25:32]:** Okay. So, what does that tell us about the values of M? Notice that M um spans the values from the it's it's minimal value minus L to L in integer steps. In in unit steps.

**[25:57]:** So, if you think about M is L plus is L, then M is L minus one. And if I keep lowering, I get down to M is minus L plus one, and then M is equal to minus L. Okay? So, the difference in the LZ eigenvalue between these guys, the difference is 2L.

**[26:23]:** But the number of unit steps in here is one fewer because one dot dot dot to L minus one. So, this is some integer which is the number of states minus one. So, if these are N states and I'll call this N sub L states, then this difference twice L is N sub L minus one because it's unit steps. Cool? So, for example, if there were two states, so N is two, 2L uh is equal to Well, that's one, which is two minus one, the number of states minus one, also known as one. So, L is one half. Okay? And more generally, we find that L must be In order for this process to make sense, in order for the M plus and the M minus to match up, bless you. We need that L is of the form an integer N sub L minus one upon two.

**[27:17]:** Okay? So, this tells us that where NL is an integer. NL is just the number of states in this tower. And it's a positive strictly positive integer. If you have zero states in the tower, then that's not very interesting. So, this tells us that L is an integer an integer or a half integer. But nothing else. Cool?

**[27:49]:** So, in particular, if it's an integer if it's a half integer, that means one half, three halves, five halves. If it's an integer, it can be zero. There's nothing wrong with it being zero, but then one on.

**[28:06]:** Okay. So, that means we can plot our system in the following way. If we have L equals zero,

**[28:18]:** Yes, good. So, if we have L equals zero, how many states do we have? If little L is zero, how many states are there? What's the largest value of LZ? So, first off, if if Yeah, so good. What's the largest allowed value of LZ or of M if little L is equal to zero? Zero cuz it goes from plus zero to minus zero. So, it's pretty much zero. So, we have a single state with M equals zero and L equals zero. If L is equal to what's the next possible value? One half, then M can be either one half or we lower it by one, which is minus one half. So, there are two states. M equals one half and M equals minus one half. So, there's one tower. It's a very short tower. This is the shortest possible tower. Then we also have the state L equals one, which has M equals zero.

**[29:11]:** It has M equals one and it has M equals minus one. And that's it. And so on and so forth. State four states for M equals for L equals three halves with states three halves uh one half. This is M equals one half, M equals minus one half and minus three halves. Okay? The values of M span from minus L to L with integer steps. Minus L to L with integer steps. And this is possible for all values of L that are uh L which are of the form uh integer plus well, all integer or half integer

**[30:00]:** L's. Okay? So, for every different value of the total angular momentum, the total amount of angular momentum you have, you have a tower of states labeled by Lz's eigenvalue in this fashion.

**[30:14]:** Questions?

**[30:17]:** Does anyone notice anything troubling about these? Something physically a little discomforting about any of these? What does it mean to say I'm in the state L equals zero M equals zero? What is that telling you? Zero angular momentum, right? What's the expectation value of L squared? Zero. The expectation value of Lz? And by rotational invariance, the angular expected value expected value of Lx or Ly? That thing is not rotating. There's no angular momentum, right? So, the no angular momentum state is one with L equals zero M equals zero. So, this is not spinning. What about this guy? L equals one M equals zero. Is Does this thing carry angular momentum? Yeah. Absolutely. So, it just doesn't carry any angular momentum in the Z direction, but it's total angular momentum on average, it's expected angular momentum total angular momentum is L L plus one which is two times H bar squared.

**[31:12]:** Yeah? So, if you measure Lx and Ly, what do you expect to get? Well, if you measure Lx squared or Ly squared, you probably expect to get something non-zero. We'll come back to that in just a second. And what about the state L equals uh one M equals one? Your angular momentum got as much angular momentum in the Z direction as you possibly can, right? So, that definitely carries angular momentum. So, there's a state that has no angular momentum in the Z direction, there's a state that has some, and there's a state that has less, right? That makes sense, yeah? So, if M equals one and L equals one, Yeah. that means that the angular momentum in the Z direction is the total angular momentum? Is it? And then Lx and Ly are zero? That's Okay, that's an excellent question. So, um let's Let me come back to that Well, let me answer that now and then I'll come back to the point I wanted to make.

**[31:59]:** Okay? Hold on a second, let me just answer that question. Um oh, good. So, I'll work here. So,

**[32:11]:** So, here's the for the the crucial thing. Even in the state So, here we were talking about you you're asking about the state L equals one M equals one, and the question that was asked, it's a very good question, is look, does that mean all the angular momentum is in the Z direction and Lx and Ly are zero? Okay? But, let me just ask this more broadly. Suppose we have a state with angular momentum L and M is equal to L. Okay? That the most angular momentum you can possibly have in the Z direction. Same question. Is all the angular momentum in the Z direction? And what I want to emphasize to you is no, that's absolutely not the case. So, two arguments for that. The first is suppose it's true that Lx and Ly are identically zero. Okay? Can that satisfy the uncertainty relation due to those commutators?

**[32:51]:** No, there must be uncertainty in Lx and Ly because Lz has non-zero expectation value. So, it can't be that Lx squared and Ly squared have zero expectation value. But, let's be more precise about this. The expectation value of L squared is easy to calculate, it's H bar squared L L plus one. Right? Because we're in the state Ylm. This is the state Y L sub L or LL. The expectation value of Lz squared is equal to H bar squared M squared. And M squared now M is equal to L, so H bar squared L squared. Aha! So, the expected value of L squared isn't the same as Lx squared, but this is equal to the expected value of Lx squared plus Ly squared plus Lz squared.

**[33:39]:** Um which is equal So, therefore, the expected value of Lx squared plus the expected value of Ly squared is equal to Well, the difference between this and this. We just subtract this off. H bar squared L L plus one minus H bar squared L squared. H bar squared L. And by symmetry, you don't expect the symmetry to be broken between Lx and Ly, you can actually do the calculation and not just be glib about it, but both arguments give you the correct answer. The expectation value of Lx squared is equal to 1/2 H bar squared L. Okay? And ditto for Y. Okay, in this state. So, notice two things. First off, as we make the total angular momentum little L large, the amount we by which we fail to have all the angular momentum in the Z direction is getting larger and larger. We're increasing the crappiness of uh putting all the angular momentum in the Z direction.

**[34:31]:** However, as a ratio of the total angular momentum divided by L squared, so this divided by L squared, and uh this is H bar squared L L plus one. In particular, this is L squared plus L. So, if we took the ratio, the rational mismatch is getting smaller and smaller. And that's good because as we go to very large angular momentums, where things should start getting classical in some sense, we should get back the familiar intuition that you can put all the angular momentum in the Z direction. Okay? Yeah. Um why are we imposing the symmetry condition that the expectation values of Lx and Ly should be identical? Excellent. That's why I was saying this is a glib argument. You don't have to impose that That needs to be done a little more delicately, but we can just directly compute this and you're due to on your problem set.

**[35:15]:** Yeah. Why doesn't the existence of the L equals zero eigenfunction, where the angular momentum the where L squared is definitely zero, violate the uncertainty principle? Awesome. On your problem set, you're going to answer that, but let me give you a quick preview. This is such a great response. So, let me give you a quick preview. So, from that Lx Okay, this is a This is a really fun question. Let me go into it in in some detail. We don't We're doing Wow, I'm going fast today. Are you Am I going way too fast? No? A little little too fast? Okay, ask me more questions to slow me down. I'm excited. I didn't get much sleep last night. Um So, so yesterday um one of the great joys of being a physicist is working with other physicists. So, yesterday one of my very good friends and collaborator I really delight in talking with um came to visit and we had a late night dinner, and this led to me late at night not doing my work, but

**[36:12]:** reading papers about what our conversation was about. And only then at the very end, when I was just about to die, did I write the response to the reviewer on the paper that I was supposed to be doing by last night's deadline. So, I'm kind of tired, but I'm in a really good mood.

**[36:28]:** It's a really good job. Okay, so um

**[36:34]:** And now I totally lost my train of thought. What was the question again? Why the existence of the L equals zero state, where the the total angular momentum is definitely Excellent. And the uncertainty. Good. So, the question is, why don't we violate the uncertainty when we know that L equals Where am I? I just covered it. When we know that L equals zero and M equals zero, doesn't that destroy our uncertainty? Because we know that the angular momentum for Lz is zero, angular momentum for Lx is zero, angular momentum for Ly is zero. All of them vanish. Doesn't that violate the uncertainty principle? So, let's remind ourselves what the form of that uncertainty relation is. The form of the uncertainty relation following from Lx Ly is i h bar Lz, recall the general statement. The uncertainty in X or the uncertainty in A times the uncertainty in B squared squared uh is equal to Well, let me just write it as uh uh H bar upon two Oh, sorry.

**[37:23]:** 1/2 the absolute value of the expectation value of the commutator A with B. Right? Good lord. Okay. Um dimensionally, does this work? Yes. Okay, good. Cuz units of A, units of B, units of A, units of B. Triumph. Um And these are going to be quantum mechanically small because commutators have H bars. And commutators have H bars, why? Not because God hates us. Why do commutators have H bars?

**[37:55]:** What happens classically? In classical mechanics, do things commute? Yes. Why are there commuta- are there H bars in commutators of physical observables? Cuz we exist, right? Cuz there's a classical limit. Okay, so this is going to be quantum mechanically small, so we expect the uncertainty relation to also be quantum mechanically small. Okay? Just important intuition. So, let's look at the specific example of Lx, Ly, and Lz. So, the the uncertainty in Lx in any particular Remember that this is defined as the uncertainty in a particular state psi. In a particular state psi. And this expectation value is taken in a particular state psi. That same state. So, the uncertainty of Lx in some state Ylm times the uncertainty of Ly in that same state Ylm should be equal to Sorry, greater than or equal to 1/2 the the absolute value of the expectation value of the

**[38:49]:** commutator of Lx and Ly. But, the commutator of Lx and Ly is i h bar Lz. And i, when we pull it through this this absolute value, is going to give you just one. H bar is going to give me H bar. H bar upon two expectation value of Lz absolute value. Yeah? So, can Lx and Ly have zero uncertainty?

**[39:13]:** Can Lx and Ly have zero uncertainty? When? Lz expectation value of Lz is zero. So, that sounds good. It sounds like we could have uh Lz uh if Lz has expectation value zero, then we can have Lx and Ly definite. But, that's bad. L We Really? Really? Can we do that? Why not?

**[39:43]:** Bless you, my son. So, So, can can we have LX and LY both take definite values just because LZ Why? What else do we have to satisfy? What other uncertainty relations must we satisfy? There are two more. Okay? And I invite you to go look at what those two more are and deduce that this is only possible if LX squared, LY squared, and LZ squared all have zero expectation value. In fact, I think it's such a great question that I think it's on your problem set. Okay? So, thank you for that question. It's a really good question. There was something There was another question in here. Yeah. So, something that you said earlier, I just want to say I'm just not seeing it. Why? In this equation where you're sort of claiming that LZ is an integer or half integer. Yes. you're deriving this by like counting the number of equations and somehow assuming that What Why does Good.

**[40:47]:** Okay, great. So, the question is, wait, really? Why is L an integer or half integer? That was a little too quick. Is that roughly the right statement? I mean, I just don't understand the reasoning. Yeah, good. Excellent. So, let me let me go through the logic. So, the logic goes like this. I know that if I have I know that the YLMs if the YLMs are eigen functions of L squared and LZ and I've constructed this tower of them using the raising lowering operators. We've already shown that the largest possible value of M is L and the least possible value is minus L. And these states must be separated by integer steps in M. Right. Okay, good. So, let the number of Pick a value of L. Okay, a particular tower, and let the number of states in that tower be N sub L. Okay?

**[41:27]:** So, there's N sub L of them. Great. And what's the distance between these guys? Well, we haven't assumed L is an integer yet. We haven't assumed it yet. So, this N sub L is an integer cuz it's the number of states. And the number of states can't be a, you know, pi.

**[41:49]:** So, now let's count it. So, how many states are How many states are there? There are NL. But if I count 1 2 3 4, the total angular momentum down here is 2L. Okay? So, I had some pithy way of of giving this uh a a fancy name. Um uh but I can't remember what it was. Okay, so, the So, the length of the tower in units of h-bar, the height of this tower, is um is 2L. But the number of steps I took in here was N NL minus 1. And that number of steps is times 1. So, we get that 2L is N minus 1. There's nothing fancy here. I'm just saying if L is zero, we go from here to here, right? There's just one element. So, number of states is one, L is zero. So, it's that same logic just repeated for every value of L.

**[42:46]:** Other questions?

**[42:50]:** Okay. So, coming back to this,

**[42:57]:** something on this board should cause you some serious physical discomfort. So, we've talked about the L equals zero M equals zero state. This is a state which has no angular momentum whatsoever in any direction at all. Talked about the L equals one M equals zero state. It carries no angular momentum in the Z direction, but it presumably has non-zero expectation value for L squared, LX and LY squared. These guys are also fine. What about these guys?

**[43:29]:** Yes. That's disconcerting. Do I have to have angular momentum in the Z direction?

**[43:44]:** That should go on a shirt somewhere. Um uh Let me Let me ask the question more precisely um or or in a way that's a little less threatening to me. Do you have to have angular momentum in the Z direction? Okay? What I'm sorry, what's your name? Does David need to have angular momentum in the Z direction? Does this chalk need to have angular momentum Well, the chalk's a Okay, classically, no. Right? Okay, it can have some total angular momentum which is zero and it can be rotating not in the Z direction. It can be rotating in the ZY or the ZX plane. If it's rotating in the ZX plane, it's got angular momentum total angular momentum L squared is not zero, but it's angular momentum in the Z direction is zero. Its axis is exactly along the Y direction. Right? And so, it's got no angular momentum That's perfectly possible classically.

**[44:31]:** And that's perfectly possible when L is an integer. Similarly, when L is two, this is the particular tower that I love the most. 2 uh 1 0 -1 -2. The reason I love this the most uh is that it's related to gravity um which is pretty awesome. Um Yeah, that's a whole other story. Um so, but uh the uh I really shouldn't have said that. So, that's only going to confuse you. Um so, for any integer, it's possible to stand to have no angular momentum in the Z direction. And that means it's possible to rotate around the X axis or the Y axis orthogonal to the Z axis. That makes sense. But for these half integer guys, you are inescapably spinning. There is no such thing as a state of this guy that carries no angular momentum. Anything well described by these quantum states is perpetually spin rotating or spinning.

**[45:26]:** It carries angular momentum. Let me say it precisely. Perpetually carries angular momentum in the Z direction. Anytime you measure it, it carries angular momentum either plus a half integer or minus a half integer, but never ever zero. But in the classical limit where you have very large L, the M equals 1/2 state or the M equals -1/2 state is going to get arbitrarily small compared to the angular momentum. So, isn't it just like where we said, well, okay, you can never have your angular momentum only in the Z direction, but we don't care because you know, in the classical limit it gets arbitrarily close to there. See, one of the nice things about writing lectures like this is that you get to leave little landmines. So, this is exactly one of those. Thank you for asking this question. So, let me rephrase that question. Look, we all took high school chemistry.

**[46:14]:** We all know about spin. The nuclei have spin. They have some angular momentum. But if you build up a lot of them, you build up a piece of chalk. Look, as we said before, while it's true that the maybe it carries some uh there's some mismatch in the angular momentum in the Z direction for some large L state, it's not all the angular momentum. Some is in LZ LX and LY as well. It's preposterously small for a macroscopic object where L is macroscopic. It's measured the angular momentum in Planck units, in units of the Planck constant. 10 to the 26. I mean, something huge. Why would we even notice? But here's the real statement. The statement isn't just that this is true of macroscopic objects, but imagine you take a small particle. Imagine you take, you know, a single atom. We're deep in the quantum mechanical regime.

**[46:56]:** We're not in the classical regime. Okay? We take that single atom. And if it's described If it carries angular momentum and it's described by the L equals 1/2 state, that atom will never ever ever be measured to have its angular momentum in the Z direction or indeed in any direction be zero. You will never in any direction measure its angular momentum to be zero. That atom perpetually carries angular momentum. And that is weird. Okay? Well, maybe okay, maybe you don't find it weird. This is good. You've grown up in an era when that's not a weird thing. But I I find this deeply disconcerting. And the reason One reason you might say, well, look, you know, we never actually measure an atom. But we do. We do all the time because we measure things like the spectra of light as we'll study when we study atoms in a couple in a week or a couple of weeks because of the exam.

**[47:42]:** Um sorry, guys. There has to be an exam. Um as we will find when we study atoms in more detail or or indeed at all, we'll be sensitive to the angular momentum of the constituents of the atom. And we'll see different spectra. So, it's an observable property when you shine light on, you know, gases. This is something we can really observe. So, what this suggests is one of two things. Either these are just crazy, right, and ridiculous, and we should ignore them, or there's something interesting and intrinsically quantum mechanical about them that's not so familiar. And the answer is going to turn out to be the second, the latter of those. The latter of the That That was not intentional. Maybe it was subconscious. Okay, so, so I want to think about some more consequences of the structure of the YLMs and the eigenvalues, in particular of this tower structure.

**[48:39]:** I want to understand some more What other physics can we extract from this story? So, first, a very useful thing is just to get a picture of these guys in your head. Let's draw the angular the angular momentum eigen functions. Right? So, what does that mean? Well, so first, when we talked about the the eigen functions of momentum linear momentum in one dimension, we immediately went to the wave function. We talked about how the amplitude to be at a particular spot varied in space, right? And the amplitude was just e to the i k x. So, the amplitude was an oscillating, you know, the phase rotated, and the absolute value or the probability density was completely constant. Everyone cool with that? That was the 1D plane wave. So, the variables are we had an angular momentum eigenstate, and that's a function of the position. Or sorry, a a linear momentum eigenstate, and that's a function of position.

**[49:30]:** Angular momentum eigenstates are going to be functions of angular position. So, I want to know what these wave functions look like, not just the eigenvalues, but I want to know what is the wave function associated to eigenvalues little L and little M look like, Y sub LM of the angles theta and phi. What do these guys look like? So, how do we get them? So, this is going to be our goal for the next few minutes. So, the first thing to notice is that um we know that these got We know what the form of these of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are. If we act with LZ, we get h bar m back. If we act with L squared, we get h bar squared LL + 1 back. But, we also have other expressions for LZ and L uh and L squared. In particular, I wrote them down last time in spherical coordinates.

**[50:20]:** So, I'm going to work in spherical coordinates where um the declination from the vertical is an angle theta and the angle around the equator is an angle phi. Okay? And theta equals zero is going to be up in the Z direction. This is just a choice of coordinates. There's nothing deep. There's nothing even shallow. It's just definitions. So, we're going to work in spherical coordinates. In spherical coordinates, we we observe that this angular momentum, just following the definition from r cross p, takes a particularly simple form. Um That's a typo. h bar upon i uh d d phi. Okay? And instead of writing L squared, I'm going to write L plus minus because it's shorter and also because it's going to turn out to be more useful. So, this takes the form h bar e to the plus minus i phi

**[51:11]:** um d theta plus or minus cotangent of theta uh d phi. Okay? So, these are the expressions for LZ and L plus minus in spherical coordinates, in these spherical coordinates.

**[51:33]:** So, I want to know how YLM depends on theta and phi and it's clearly going to be easier to ask about the LZ eigen equation. So, let's look at that. LZ on YLM, sorry, LZ on YLM gives me h Oh, yeah. A- Oh, Jesus.

**[51:56]:** When I write letters by hand, which, you know, this is like basically when I write to my mom, all my h's are crossed. I can't help it. So, this is like the inverse. Um

**[52:10]:** It's been a long time since I made that mistake. It's usually the other. Okay. So, uh LZ acting on YLM gives me h bar m acting on uh YLM. But, that's what I get when I act with LZ. So, let's just write out the differential equation. So, h bar m YLM, where m is an integer or a half integer, depending on what whether L is an integer or a half integer. h bar m YLM is equal to h bar upon i uh d phi of YLM. Okay? Using the awesome power of division and multiplication, I will divide both sides by h bar and I will multiply both sides by i. Okay? And we now have the the equation for the eigenfunctions of LZ, which we actually wrote down last time, and we can solve this very simply. This says that, remember YLM is a function of theta and phi.

**[53:00]:** Here, we're only looking at the phi dependence because that's all that showed up in this equation. So, this tells us that the eigenfunctions YLM are of the form of theta and phi. Are of the form e to the i m phi times some remaining dependence on theta, which I'll write as P of theta, and that P could depend on L and M. Cool?

**[53:34]:** Now, already, before we even ask about the the dependence on theta, the P dependence, we learn something pretty awesome. Look at this wave function. Okay? Whatever else we know, its dependence on phi is e to the i m phi. Now, remember what phi is. Phi is the angle around the equator. So, it goes from zero to 2 pi and when it comes back to 2 pi, it's the same point. Phi equals zero and phi equals pi are two names for the same point. Yes?

**[54:06]:** But, that should worry you. Because note that as a consequence of this, YLM of theta zero is equal to well, whatever it is, but um sorry, theta theta of 2 pi is equal to e to the i m 2 pi times PLM of theta.

**[54:35]:** But, this is equal to Oh, now we're in trouble. If m is an integer,

**[54:43]:** this is equal to e to the i integer 2 pi one. Yes. Okay. You're supposed to cheer at that point. It's like the coolest identity in the world. So, e to the i 2 pi, that's uh that's one. So, if m is an integer,

**[55:03]:** then this is just um PLM of theta, which is also what we get by putting in phi equals zero. So, this is equal to YLM LM of theta {comma} zero. But, if m is a half integer, then e to the i half integer times 2 pi is minus one. And so, that gives us minus YLM of theta and zero. If m is uh a half integer.

**[55:37]:** Okay? So, let me say that again in the same words, actually, but let me just say it again with different emphasis. What this tells us is that YLM at zero as a function of the coordinates theta and phi, YLM, so, let's take m as an integer. YLM at theta and zero is equal to YLM at theta and zero. Right? That's good. But, if m is a half integer,

**[56:17]:** then YLM at theta and 2 pi, which is the same point as YLM at theta and zero, is equal to minus YLM at theta and pi at theta and zero. That's less good. What must be true of YLM of theta and zero? Zero. And was there anything special about the point zero? No, I could have just taken any point and rotated around by pi. So, this tells us that YLM of theta and phi is identically equal to zero if m is a half integer.

**[56:57]:** Huh. That's bad. Right? Because what's the probability density of being found at any particular angular position? Zero. Can you normalize that state? No. That is not a state that describes a particle. That is a state that describes the absence of a particle. That is not what we want. So, these states cannot describe these values of L and M, which seem like perfectly reasonable values of L and M, perfectly reasonable eigenvalues of L squared and LM,

**[57:29]:** they cannot be used to label wave functions of physical states corresponding to wave functions on a sphere. You can't do it. Because if you try, you find that those wave functions identically vanish. Okay? So, these cannot be used. These do not describe wave functions uh Let me draw that. These do not describe wave functions of uh of a particle in quantum mechanics. They cannot be used. Those values, those towers, cannot be used to describe particles moving in three dimensions. Every group So, questions about that? That is a slightly subtle argument. Yeah. You said something earlier about how um atoms like would never have a non-zero angular momentum. And so, the ones that have non-zero angular momentum, we just said they're not possible. So, Excellent question. I said a slightly So, the question is, look, earlier you were saying, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, atoms can have There are atoms in the world and they have half integer angular momentum and you can shine light on them and

**[58:32]:** you can tell and and stuff." Um but, you just said that you can't that you know, these can't exist. So, how can those two things both be true? And I actually Thank you for this question. It's a very good question. I actually said a slightly different thing. What I said was, states with angular momentum LM are half integers cannot be described by a wave function of the coordinates. We're going to need some different description. And in particular, we're going to need a different description that does what? Well, as we take phi from zero to 2 pi, as we rotate the system, right? As we take phi from zero to 2 pi, as we rotate the system, we're going to pick up a minus sign. So, in order to describe an object with L and M being a half integer, we can't use a wave function.

**[59:13]:** We need something that is allowed to be doubly valued. Right? And in particular, we need something that behaves nicely when you rotate around by 2 pi, we need to come back to a minus sign, not itself. So, it's some object that's not a function. It's called a spinner. So, we'll we'll talk about it later. We need some object that does that. So, it's there's this classic um a demonstration at this point, which is supposed to be done in a quantum mechanics class. So, at this point the lecturer is is obliged to do the following thing. You say, "Blah, blah, blah. If things rotate by 2 pi, they have to come back to themselves." And then you do this. Okay? I'm going to rotate my hand like a like a uh you know, I don't know, record um by 2 pi, and it will not come back to itself.

**[1:00:00]:** Okay?

**[1:00:04]:** And it quite uncomfortably has not come back to itself. Okay? But, I can do a further rotation to show you that it's a minus sign. I can do a further rotation by 2 pi and have it come back to itself. Right? And I kept the axis vertical. Yeah? Okay. So, at this point you're all supposed to go like, "Oh, yes. Uh-huh. Mhm. Yeah." Okay. So, so now that we've got that out of the way, I have an arm. Okay. So, so the story is a little more complicated than than that. This This is actually a fair demonstration, but it's a slightly subtle story. And if you want to understand it, ask your recitation instructor or come to my office hours. Yeah. USB sticks. USB sticks. Uh you insert them in here, they don't go in. You insert them the other way.

**[1:00:48]:** What about USB stick? You insert them this way, they don't work. You insert them this way, they don't work. But, if you do it again, then they do.

**[1:01:02]:** Okay.

**[1:01:06]:** That's pretty good. Okay. Um so, so for the moment, as long as we want to describe our system with a wave function of position, which means we're thinking about where will we find it as a function of angle, we cannot use the half integer LRM. So, if we can't use the half integer LRM, fine. We'll just throw them out for the moment, and we'll use the integer LNM. And let's keep going. Okay. Now, what we need to determine now is the P. We've determined the phi dependence, but we need the theta And we can get the theta dependence in a sneaky fashion. Remember when you solved the Remember that the the harmonic oscillator in 1D? When we wanted to find the ground state wave function, we could either solve the energy eigenvalue equation, which is a second-order differential equation, and kind of horrible, right? Or we could solve the ground state equation that said that the ground state is annihilated by the annihilation operator, which is a first-order difference equation, and much easier to solve.

**[1:01:56]:** Yeah? Let's do the same thing. We have an annihilation condition. If we have the top state, L plus on Y LL is equal to zero. But, L plus is a first-order differential operator. This is going to be easier. So, we need to find a solution to this equation. And um do I want to go through this? Yeah, why not? Okay. So, I want this to be equal to zero, but L plus Y LL is equal to Well, it's h bar uh e to the plus i phi d theta plus cotangent theta uh d phi on uh Y LL. And Y LL is e to the i uh L phi times P uh LM of theta. Cool. So, um d d phi on e to the i L phi, there's no phi dependence here. It's just going to give us a vector of i L. So, did I get the i Yeah.

**[1:02:46]:** Um so, that's going to give us an plus i L and no d d phi. Or i L. Plus. And then this e to the i L phi we can pull out. But, this has to be equal to zero. is equal to d theta plus i L cotangent theta uh P LM of theta. And this is actually much better than it seems for the following reason. D D theta Fine, that's d d theta. Cotangent of theta is cosine over sine. That's what you get if you take the derivative of lots of sine functions of a you know, sine to the L, say. Take a derivative, you lose a power of sine, you pick up a power of cosine. So, multiplying by cotangent gets rid of a power of sine, gives you a power of cosine, which is a derivative of of sine. So, P LM, noticing the L, and I screwed up an an i somewhere.

**[1:03:49]:** I think I wanted an i up here. Let's see. i

**[1:03:59]:** Do do do. Um

**[1:04:06]:** Sorry.

**[1:04:10]:** Yes, I want an i cotan- cotangent. Okay. That's much better. So, i cotangent and that Good. Good. And then the i squareds give me a minus L. Good. And this tells us that P LM So, if this is sine to the L, then d theta gives us an L sine to the L minus 1 cosine, which is what I get by taking sine to the L and multiplying by cosine, dividing by sine, and multiplying by L. So, this gives me P LM or sorry, P LL. This is for the particular state LL. We're looking at the top state, we're annihilating it. So, P LL is equal to some coefficient. So, I'll just say proportional to sine uh to the L of theta.

**[1:04:55]:** So, this tells us that Y LL is equal to some normalization sub LL just some number times from the phi dependence e to the i L phi and from the theta dependence sine to the L of theta. Okay. So, this is the form This is the form Oh, sorry. Go ahead. This symbol here? The Oh, this twisted horrible thing? It's proportional to. But, you know, it was a long night. Um so, uh so So, now we have the wave function explicitly as a function of phi and as a function of theta, completely understood. Uh for the top state in in any tower, right? This is for any L, the top state in any tower is e to the i L phi. Does that make sense? Well, L Z is h bar upon i d phi, so that gives us uh h bar is uh m is L.

**[1:05:51]:** So, that's good. That's the top state. And from the sine theta we just checked, we constructed that this indeed has uh uh the Well, if you then check, you will find that the the L squared eigenvalue, which you will do on the problem set, the L squared eigenvalue is h bar squared L L plus 1. Yeah. Um good question. Uh when we the expression we have for the L plus minus operators, how do we construct the expressions for LX and LY? Good. So, we it's much easier than you think. So, LX is equal to It's R cross L is R cross P, right? So, this is going to be um uh Y PZ minus ZPY.

**[1:06:25]:** Yeah. But, you know what What So, and this is equal to i i um uh h bar upon i Y d Z minus Z d Y. But, you know what Y is in spherical coordinates, and you know what derivative with respect to Z is in spherical coordinates, cuz you know what Z is, and then you know the chain rule. So, taking this and just plugging in explicit expressions for the change of variables to spherical coordinates takes care of it. Yeah. What is this description of the sine in case that sine to the power of Sorry. This is This is bad notation. It's um It's not bad notation, it's just not familiar notation. So, um it's notation that is used throughout theoretical physics. It means this. Sine theta to the L, the L power of sine. Yeah. Uh for typesetting reasons, we often put the power before the argument.

**[1:07:12]:** Yeah, no, it's a very good question. Thank you for asking, cuz it was unclear. I appreciate that. Other questions? Yeah. How do we come up with the L hat How do we come up with the L hat plus minus? That That was from this. Oh, okay. Yeah. So, it We know what the components of the angular momentum are in in Cartesian coordinates, and you know how to because you know, it's coordinates, you know how to change variables from Cartesian to spherical. So, you just plug this in for LX, but L plus is LX plus i LY. And so, you just take these guys in spherical form and add them together with the relative i. And that gives you that expression. Um David, this is for Could you just explain the distinction between Y sub LL and Y sub LM? Yeah, absolutely. So, Y sub LL it means Y sub LM where m is equal to L.

**[1:08:01]:** Oh, okay. But, it's just a generic energy It It's a It's a generic eigenfunction of the angular momentum with Okay. the angular momentum in the Z direction being equal to the angular momentum in the total angular momentum. So, at least it for the for these numbers. Okay. Cool. Good. So, now if we know this, how do we just as a side note, suppose we know Well, suppose we know this. We know this. We know what the top state in the tower looks like. How do I get the next state down in the tower? How do I get Y L L minus 1? Lower it. Lower it. Exactly. So, this is easy. L minus on Y LL, and we have to be careful about normalization. So, again, it's proportional to. Okay. Um but, this is easy. We don't have to solve any difference equations, we just have to take derivatives.

**[1:08:44]:** So, it's just like the raising operator for the harmonic oscillator. We can raise and lower along the tower and get the right wave function. Okay. So, to give you some examples, Yeah, let's do that here. So, let me just quickly give you an a few examples of the first few spherical harmonics. Oh, so I Sorry, I should give these guys a name. These functions Y LM of theta and phi, they're called the spherical harmonics. They're called these because they solve the Laplacian equation on the sphere, which is just the eigenvalue equation. L squared on them is equal to a constant times those things back. So, um do do do. So, just as to to tabulate a couple of examples for you concretely, consider the L equals zero states. So, Y the only What are the allowed values of M for little L equals zero? Zero.

**[1:09:34]:** So, Y zero zero is the only state. And if you properly normalize it, it's one over root four pi. Okay, good. What about L equals one? Then uh we have Y zero or Y one zero. And we have Y uh one minus one. And we have Y one one. So, these guys take a particularly simple form. Um root three I'm just I'm not even going to worry about the coefficient. They're in the notes. You can look them up anywhere. Um times cosine So, first off actually, let's look at Y one one. So non-linear today. So, Y one one is going to be some normalization and what is the form?

**[1:10:15]:** Right? So, it's just e to the i l phi sine theta to the l. L is one. So, this is some constant times e to the i phi sine theta. Y one zero. Well, it's got angular momentum zero in the Z direction. In in L Z. So, that means that how does it depend on phi? It doesn't. And you can easily see that because we're going to lose when we lower we get an e to the i minus i phi. Anyway, so this gives us a constant times no e to the i phi no phi dependence and cosine of theta. And it's easy to see you get a cosine theta. The d theta and the cotangent d phi both give you the same thing. And Y one minus one is again a constant times e to the minus i phi. So, it's got m equals minus one and sine theta again.

**[1:11:04]:** Notice a pleasing sort of parsimony here. Um the theta dependence is the same for plus m and minus m. Okay, and um So, what about Y two two? Some constant e to the i two phi sine squared theta. Uh dot dot dot. Y zero zero. And here it's interesting. So, here we just got one term from taking the derivative. They both give you cosine. But now there are two ways to act with the two derivatives. Um and this gives you a constant. Now, what's the phi dependence? It's nothing because it's got m equals zero. And so, the only dependence is on theta. And we get a cos squared Oops, there's a three. Three cos squared theta minus one. You mean Y two zero? Oh, shoot. Thank you. Yes, I mean Y two zero. Thank you. And then if we continue lowering to Y two minus two, this is equal to again a constant.

**[1:11:59]:** And the only going to be the same dependence on theta but a different dependence on phi e to the minus two i phi sine squared theta. Okay? Yeah. So, it's not normalized right? Why? Okay, good. So, quick question. So, let me turn that into a question. So, the question is are these normalizable? Yeah, okay. So, how would we normalize them? How What's the check if they're normalizable? Yeah, we integrate them norm squared over a sphere. Okay? Not over a volume, just over a sphere cuz they're only wave functions on the sphere. We haven't dealt with the radial function. We'll deal with that later. That'll come in the next lecture. Other questions? Yeah. Can you explain why Y of m equals zero doesn't Yeah, so why m equals zero doesn't have any phi dependence? Yeah, so if m equals if m equals zero had phi dependence, then we know that the eigenvalue of L L Z is what we get when we take a derivative with respect to phi.

**[1:12:56]:** But if if the L Z eigenvalue is zero, that means that when we act with d d phi we get zero. That means it can't depend on phi. Cool? Okay. Other questions? I want to show What I'm going to do next is I'm going to show you walk you through some of these angular momentum eigenstates graphically on the on the computer. Before we do that, any questions about the calculations so far? Okay. So,

**[1:13:24]:** So, here um

**[1:13:30]:** So, this this Mathematica package I'll post on the webpage. Um and at the moment I think it's doing the real part. So, what we're looking at now is the real part. Actually, let's look at the absolute value. Um Okay. Good. So, here we are looking at the absolute value of Oops, that's not what I wanted to do. Um Okay. So, what we're looking at in this notation is some horrible parametric plot. You don't really need to see the mathemat Oh, shoot. Sorry. Okay. So, you don't need to see the code particularly, so I'm not going to worry about it, but it'll be posted. Um So, here we're looking at the the absolute value, the norm squared of the spherical harmonic uh Y and the um the lower eigenvalue here lower coordinate is the L and the upper is M. Okay? So, when L is zero, what we get is So, what we're looking at So, here's what this plot is is indicating.

**[1:14:31]:** The distance away from the origin in a particular angular direction is the absolute value of the wave function. So, the further away from the origin the the colored point you see is, the larger the absolute value. Okay? So, and the color here is just to indicate sort of depth and position. It's it's not terribly meaningful. So, here we see that we get a sphere. So, the probability density or the norm squared of the wave function of the spherical harmonic is constant. So, that makes sense. It's spherically symmetric. It has no angular momentum. As we start increasing the angular momentum, let's take the angular momentum L is one M is zero state. Now, something interesting happens. Now, the the angle So, the total angular momentum is one and we see that there is two spheres. Let me sort of rotate this. So, there are two spheres and there's the Z axis passing through them.

**[1:15:20]:** And so, the probability is much larger around this lobe on the top or the lobe on the bottom and it's zero on the plane. Okay? Now, that's kind of non-intuitive if you think well, L Z is large, so it should be you know, Why is it Why is it along the vertical? So, why is that true? So, here this is the L L Z equals zero state. That means it carries no angular momentum along the Z axis. That means it's not rotating far out in the X Y plane. So, your probability of finding it in the X Y plane is very small because if it was rotating in the X Y plane, it would carry large angular momentum in L Z, but its L Z is zero. So, it can't be extended out in the X Y plane. Cool? On the other hand, it can carry angular momentum in the X or the Y direction.

**[1:16:05]:** But if it carries angular momentum in the X direction for example, that means the system is rotating around the Z Sorry, if it carries angular momentum in the X direction, it's rotating in the Z Y plane. Right? So, there's some probability to find it out of the plane uh in Y and Z. But it can't be in the X Y plane. Hence, it's got to be in the lobes up above. That cool? So, it's very useful to develop an intuition for this stuff if you're going to do chemistry or crystallography or any condensed matter physics. It's just very useful. So, I encourage you to play with these little applets and I'll post this um I'll post this Mathematica package. But let's look at what happens now if we let's crank up the angular momentum. So, as we crank up the L angular momentum, now we're getting this sort of lobby thing which looks like some sort of 50s sci-fi you know, apparatus.

**[1:16:49]:** So, what's going on there? So, now we see So, this is the two zero state. And the two zero state has a three cos squared theta minus one. But cos squared theta, that means it's got two periods as it goes from vertical to negative. And if you take that and you square it, you get exactly this. Okay? So, there you're seeing the cos squared as a function of the angle of declination from vertical. And it's zero it's m equals zero, so you're seeing no dependence on phi. It's Of course, that's a little cheap because the angular dependence on phi is just an overall phase. So, we're not going to see it in the absolute value. Everyone agree with that? We're We're not going to see the absolute Okay. So, and let's check that. Let's take L two and M two. So, now when L is two and M is two, we just get this donut.

**[1:17:34]:** So, what that's saying is look, all the angular We We've got some angular momentum. L is two. But all the angular momentum almost all of it anyway is in the Z direction. And is is that what we're seeing here? Well, yeah. It seems like it's most likely to find the particle the probability is greatest out in this donut around the plane. Now, if it were L Z is equal to L, it would be flat. It would be a strictly zero thickness pancake. But we have some uncertainty in what L X and L Y are, which is why we get this fattened donut. Everyone cool with that? And if we crank up L, and we make Yeah, right. So, you can see that you got some complicated shapes. Okay, but as we crank up L and crank up M, we just get a thinner and thinner donut.

**[1:18:13]:** And the fact that the donut is getting thinner and thinner is that L over L squared that we did earlier. Cool? It's still a donut, but it's getting relatively thinner and thinner even though it's by virtue of getting wider and wider. And um a last thing to show you is let's take a look now at um In fact, let's go to the L equals zero state. Um let's take a look at um the the real part.

**[1:18:39]:** So, now we're looking at the real part. And uh nothing much changed for the Y zero zero. But for Y two zero, well, still not much changed. For Y two zero, let's now uh Uh so, this is sort of disheartening. Nothing really has changed. But why? Cuz it's real. Exactly. So, for Y two zero, as long as M is equal to zero, this is real. There's no phase. The phase information contains information about the L Z eigenvalue. So, we can correct this by We can We can correct this by changing the angular momentum. Um let's Oh, shoot. How do I do that? Um I can't turn it off at the moment. Okay, whatever. So, so here we have large M. Here we have large M. And now we've got this very funny loopy structure. So, this is the Y22 which a minute ago looked rotationally symmetric.

**[1:19:34]:** And now it's not rotationally symmetric. It's this loopy structure. And where the lobes are Remember, we had previously we had a donut. Now we have these lobes when we look at the real part. How does that make sense? Well, we've got a sine squared of theta or sorry we Sorry, sine squared We've got an e to the i225. And if we look at the real part, that's cosine of 2 pi. And so we're getting a cosine function modulating the donut. And if we look at the real part, let's do the same thing. Let's look at Y22 and look at the imaginary part. And the imaginary part of Y20, we get nothing. That's good because Y20 was real. All right? That would have been bad. But if we look at the imaginary part of Y22, we get the corresponding lobes. The other lobes so that cos squared plus sine squared is 1.

**[1:20:21]:** Okay? Play with these. Develop some intuition. They're going to be very useful for us when we talk about hydrogen and the structure of solids. Uh, and I will see you next week.
