Transcript

Okay, so let's continue our discussion of welfare economics. Just to review where we are, the first set of lectures in the course are about positive economics, about understanding where supply and demand curves come from and what they mean. Now, last lecture we turned from positive to normative economics and actually making judgments about whether things are good or bad and we introduced the concept of welfare, economic welfare or well-being. And we talked about consumer surplus, which is a measure of how well-off consumers are made by a given exchange of goods and services and producer surplus, how well-off producers are made.

We're going to start our lecture by proving what's modestly called the first fundamental theorem of welfare economics, which is that competition maximizes welfare. So, this is basically taking our positive economics and a meeting our normative economics. That is we're going to talk about how the model we've derived so far, which is the equilibrium under perfect competition, happens to also be the outcome that delivers the maximum well-being to society. So, let's step back. Well-being we called welfare. How do we define the well-being of society? Well, we're going to start with a simple definition, which is we're going to safely say that social welfare social welfare, the total welfare of society, is simply consumer surplus plus producer surplus.

That is we're not going to put any different weights, we're not going to say we like somebody better than another. We're just going to say, look, surplus is produced by a transaction and we just care about the total surplus that's produced. And later we can come down to how we feel about consumers versus producers and we will. But right now, let's just say we care about the total surplus that's produced for society. How much benefit is produced by this transaction? Okay? Well, the benefits produced by this transaction is going to be the surplus derived surplus generated for consumers by that transaction and the surplus generated for producers by that transaction.

So, our total measure of social well-being is going to be the sum of consumer and producer surplus. And we are going to prove, as I said, we you don't need to know this, but it's in graduate economics called the first fundamental theorem of welfare economics, which is that under the assumptions we've made, which are many, okay, under the assumptions we've made, the competitive equilibrium, where supply equals demand, is the point that maximizes social welfare. That is the key insight is the point that the market naturally delivers, the equilibrium that's gained by the market naturally, happens to be the point that also makes society as well-off as possible.

A very profound result. Okay? That is the positive conclusion, which is that supply and demand will meet at a certain equilibrium, delivers a normative conclusion, which is that equilibrium is the point which maximizes social welfare. Okay? Now, the best way to see this is just graphically. So, let's go to figure 10-1. Okay? Figure 10-1 has supply and demand curve. Okay? Once again, whether these are curved or linear, these are just, you know, it's still the basic idea of supply and demand curve. So, a curved supply and demand curve are things which more are more sort of constant elasticity type curves, but that doesn't really affect the intuition.

Okay? We have here the triangles of consumer surplus and producer surplus. So, consumer surplus, give me the letter. Somebody raise their hand and tell me which letters on this diagram correspond to consumer surplus and why. Which which areas denoted by which letters correspond to consumer surplus and why? Yeah. R and V. And why's that? Um because the price is everything over the price, the area between the supply and the demand curve. Exactly. Everything above below the demand curve above the price consumer surplus, so R plus V. So, therefore, what's producer surplus? Same person. Um S plus T plus S plus T plus U.

Is producer surplus. So, consumer surplus R plus V, producer surplus is S plus T plus U. Okay? You can see, those of you are sort of graphically oriented, can immediately see the sum of those two triangles will be maximized at the intersection of the curves and nowhere else. Okay? So, for example, let's think about the case where I say, well, look, it's a shame the price is that high. We ought to make the price lower. Let's set a new price. Let's have the government mandate a new price at P2. Suppose the government intervenes and says we're going to set a price ceiling. We're going to say no one can charge more than P2 for their product.

And won't that be a good thing cuz consumers all be better off, they'll pay lower prices. Well, what does that do? That does What does that do to consumer surplus? Well, consumer surplus used to be R plus V. It instead becomes R plus S, which is bigger. Okay, consumer surplus rises. You lose the triangle V and you gain the E2, okay, at the price P2, um yeah, that becomes the new consumer surplus. The new producer surplus is what? At that price P2, what's the new producer surplus? So, raise your hand and tell me. Yeah. It's T. It drops to T. Producers just get below the price above the supply curve.

So, what has happened to total social welfare? It has fallen by the amount V plus U. Total social welfare has fallen by V plus B plus U. So, in some sense, two things have happened here. We set this price. The first is a transfer. We have transferred the rectangle S from producers to consumers. S used to be part of producer surplus, we're now giving it to consumers. First thing that happens is a transfer. That was probably the idea of this policy, make consumers better off. So, we've transferred what used to be producer surplus to consumers. That's the rectangle S. That's the first thing that's happened.

So, thing one that's happened is a transfer of S. But the second thing that's happened is we have created what we call a deadweight loss of U plus V. A deadweight loss of U plus V. DWL, deadweight loss. What is a deadweight loss? That is the net reduction in welfare from trades that are not made. The deadweight loss is a key concept. We'll come back to you, I don't expect you to know it in your sleep. Okay? Is a deadweight loss is the net reduction in social welfare from trades that are not made. The intuition here is that every trade that makes at least one party better off without making the other party worse off is a good trade to do.

Under the assumptions we've made so far, if you ever trade that increased consumer surplus or producer surplus or both, that's a good thing to have. Right? If my daughter has any song she wants to buy by Kendrick Lamar that she buys at more than a dollar, she gets them for a dollar. Anything which stops her from buying those songs is bad. She's losing surplus. Okay? So, basically, the key point is that deadweight loss is an inefficiency. Okay? We talked about how competition leads to maximally efficient production through cost minimization. Competition also leads to the maximum welfare outcome because that point is the point which makes society best off, defined as the sum of consumer surplus plus producer surplus.

Okay? But once again, I cannot highlight enough the depth of this insight. That this point, which before today you knew as the outcome, I showed you in the first lecture, this is what happens when you have supply and demand, you get to this equilibrium. That happens to be the very best place to be. And that's why we call it the first fundamental theorem. It's very important. Okay? Yeah. So, the idea of like since we're counting social welfare, even though consumers are better off, there is not as many trades because producers don't get as much out of it. So, so so let's I want to come to that.

Let's talk about that. Let's go to another example to talk about that. Let's talk about interventions. Let's do it Let's do Let's do an example. Let's That was just sort of to teach you the basic idea, but let's go on to more explicit example of a government intervention. Actually, I'll do it here. Let me do an explicit example of a government intervention that will and that will address the question which was just asked cuz I skipped over a sort of a key point here. That that um I'm always I'm always not sure whether the right order to teach these things. So, so let's ask let's take an example of a market.

Let's consider the market for gas. So, go to figure 10-2. This is a market talked about before, the market for gas. Imagine the market for gas is initially in equilibrium with supply curve S1 and a demand curve D. And it's initially in equilibrium at point little E1 with Q1 gallons of gas being sold at a price P1. That's the initial equilibrium. Now, imagine that there is an oil crisis because, for example, oil company decided it'd be a good idea to drill 8 mi underground horizontally and the it busts and there's spills everywhere, something like that, some random example like that. Okay? And there's a there's a there's a supply crisis.

What happens now is suddenly it gets more expensive to produce gas. So, the supply curve shifts upwards, we talked about this last time. Leading us to new equilibrium at point E2. And you remember we talked about the equilibrium works. First, initially there if we think about it in steps, initially you've created an excess demand because gas companies no longer want to supply uh Q1 gallons at a price P1 from the new supply curve. So, you move you shift along the demand curve to the new point E2, which is new equilibrium. And all's well and good. Okay, prices go up. That's what happened after Deepwater and things like that.

Okay? Now, imagine the government doesn't like that. Imagine the government says, "Well, we don't like that. We don't like the fact consumers have to pay more for gas. Consumers vote us out of office when they have to pay more for gas. So, we are going to solve this by imposing a price ceiling. We are going to announce the price of gas must remain at its old level P1. Okay? So, let's go to figure 10-3. Figure 10-3 shows what happens when the government imposed that price ceiling. Okay? Well, the first question is if the government imposed a price ceiling of P1, how much actually gets sold in the market?

This comes to the question which was just asked. Well, this is sort of a new thing this sort of a new thing we've looked at, which is we have the situation with excess demand. At the price P1, consumers still want Q little D. But suppliers are only willing to supply QS, Q little S. See? Consumers still are working off the same demand curve. If you use the government says we still want the price to be P1, they're like, "Great, we still want as much gas as we had before." Suppliers are like, "No way. We're not going to supply it. If you're going to keep the price at that level, we're going to produce less gas because we have a rising marginal cost.

So, if you're going to force to have that same price, we're going to work our way back down the supply curve and produce less gas. So, suddenly you have a situation of excess demand that doesn't get resolved. Remember last time we said excess demand got resolved by moving up the demand curve? Well, you can't here. You can't resolve that because the price is forced to be a P1. Okay? Now, what determines what actually gets sold when there's a price restriction? Here's the way I like to think of it. I like to think of the the actual quantity gets set by the constrained party. So, in this case, a price ceiling means that suppliers want are asked to supply more than they're willing to, so they just say no.

So, you actually get the ultimate quantity in the market is QS. It doesn't matter that demand is YQD. They can't buy stuff that's not produced. Likewise, we'll do examples later with a price floor where suppliers where where where consumers want less than suppliers want to provide, then it's consumers that decide what gets sold. So, basically whoever wants less gets to decide because you can't force the producers to produce more. We don't have a we have a private oil industry, gas industry. So, you end up with QS units of gas sold at a price P1. So, what the price ceiling does is move you from E1 to E3.

You would have moved to E2 without the government intervention, instead it moves you to E3. Okay? And as a result, you end up with consumers consumer surplus being A plus C, producer surplus being E, and relative to an unconstrained world, not relative to where we were before, but relative to where that government intervention, you have a deadweight loss of B plus D. Yeah. What do you think of that kind of government producing stuff yourself? Well, that's a very deep question to as I said, we don't have a nationalized gas industry, we just have private gas industries. There's a separate issue you know, a larger issue about whether private or public sector should be producing things and that's sort of beyond the scope of what we're discussing here.

But for now, assume the government just has a regulatory role, not a gas production role. The government, by the way, does have a little bit of gas production role because the government actually has something called the strategic oil reserve where they have millions of barrels they can actually release and release out in the market at certain times. The government does have a way to try to deal with this, but for now, let's assume they're not going to use the strategic reserve, just regulate price. Okay? So, they regulate price and what they've done is they've created a deadweight loss. Okay?

Um so, basically if we think about it, what are the costs and benefits of government intervention? The costs of government intervention are twofold. What are the costs of this price ceiling? There's two costs. Cost one is you've created an inefficiency. You've created uh you've created this deadweight loss. Because basically if you didn't restrict things, there are people who would have bought gas to the right of Q sub S and to the left of E2, those units between Q sub S and E2, where E2 intersects the x-axis. Those are units where the consumer surplus plus the producer surplus is positive, right?

You look at the unit right to the right of Q sub S. That's a unit that would have that consumers would have happily bought at the new higher price and producers would have happily sold to new higher price, but the government isn't letting it happen. So, that's a deadweight loss. So, that's an inefficiency. Okay? So, that's the first cost. The cost of to society of trades that don't get made. And we call this AN EFFICIENCY LOSS. BECAUSE THERE ARE EFFICIENT TRADES, trade things are efficient if they make the whole the joint surplus is positive. If I net people are better off, they're efficient trades which both sides were happy to make and they can't make and they can't make.

So, we call this an efficiency loss. Okay? But that's not the only cost to this policy. What's the other cost? This is a hard question. Yeah. Um you have to force the price to not be not be able to move it. Uh that's yeah, so there's enforcement. You have to like go around and send regulators around to gas stations, make sure they're not charging the wrong price. That's true. I I I sort of make say that small. I think more sort of a theoretical, not theoretical, but what's the other big source of What's Yeah. Is it like the loss of producers that they're not producing anything to innovate and stuff like that?

There's sort of a dynamic, but once again, the producers think this may be a short-run thing and once the you know, once the Deepwater Horizon gets fixed, they'll price will be back down or whatever. But what's the other miracle of the market that we lose here? We talked about this the very first lecture. Yeah. Is it like maybe the freedom of entering and exiting or No, it's the entry and exit, but that's once again, let's rule out entry and exit because it's just a short-run deal. Yeah. Uh is it like how do you ensure that the people who value it the most Yes, there's allocative inefficiency.

Remember, one of the things we talked about in the very first lecture, I think we did. Maybe not. Anyway, uh one of the most important benefits of the competitive equilibrium, it doesn't just deliver the right quantity, it delivers it to the people who want it the most. So, if you think about let's go back to figure 10-2, it's easy to see there. If you think about who gets gas at the initial equilibrium E1. Actually no, but let's go to 10-3, that's fine. So, let's say we hadn't interfered and we'd allowed the price to go to E2. Well, fewer people would have bought gas, right? Supply the quantity would have fallen from QD would have fallen all the way from E1 to E2.

But the people who dropped out would have been who? The people who valued gas the least. The people who got the lowest surplus from it. Okay? However, now suddenly you only have QS units of gas and you have QD people who want them. Well, now who decides who gets them? Before the market did the magic, the market made sure the people who wanted the units got them. Now of a sudden, something else has to decide. So, how do you resolve this? Well, we actually have an answer to this. We had a gas crisis in the 1970s and the government imposed a price ceiling. And how did it get resolved? How did we decide then who got the gas?

Does anyone know? Raise your hand and tell me if you know. Yeah? People waited in line. People basically sat in their cars and waited in line. Okay? Now, so essentially, if you think about it, we goods are going to get allocated somehow. If the market doesn't allocate them, there'll be another less efficient allocation mechanism. Okay? And basically, why is it inefficient that people waited in line for gas? There's actually two reasons, one sort of cute, but what's the main reason it's inefficient people waited in line for gas? Yeah? Um you're waiting in line not actually doing stuff. Yes, the opportunity cost.

Little point little one, you have the opportunity cost. Okay? You have the fact that that time I spent waiting in line, I could have been working or having fun. But certainly something I would have enjoyed more than waiting in line for gas. I think we can all agree that there's something we'd rather be doing with our time than waiting in line for gas. Okay, unless you really like the music in your car stereo you can't listen anywhere else. I don't I don't know what the story would be, but I can't imagine that many of us would prefer to wait in line for gas to do something else. So, there's the opportunity cost.

That's an inefficiency. Society is losing out because you are not using your time in the most productive way. In the way that maximize your welfare. Okay? So, there's that. What else? What's the other small other cost? Yeah. Yeah, people use gas waiting in line. So, there's literally the technical inefficiency. And remember, this is like back when cars got like 8 mi to the gallon. So, you'd like get to the front of the line, get gas, and then go back to the back of the line again. Cuz you use so much gas. Plus, not to mention the pollution and all that other stuff. So, basically, this is the inefficiency from a non-market allocation mechanism.

Okay? Which is that people could be doing more productive things and not wasting gas waiting in line. Yeah? Is the excess of demand Q S minus Q D or Q S minus like E2 No, Q D might because we fixed the price at P1. So, it's Q D minus Q. Since we fixed the price at P1, people want What's the demand at that price? Q D. What's the supply at that price? Q S. So, that's the excess demand. Okay? So, now, yeah. So, you mentioned how like the market makes sure people who want gas the most can get it, but isn't like the wanting or most like how much they're willing to spend on it? So, like does this market assume that all people make the same amount of income?

No, it doesn't. But, it does assume that basically the market, and this comes to the trade-off. What's the benefit of this policy? Which you've raised with your question, which is equity. Which is I've defined consumer surplus as simply being what the market delivers. So, basically, rich guys have more consumer surplus than poor guys. Okay? That might not seem fair to people. Okay? As a result, the benefit is equity, which is that if you that everyone gets gas at a lower price rather than the price rising, the people who drop out may actually not be the people who don't need to drive, the people who can't afford to drive.

So, they drop out. Remember, where does the demand curve come from? It comes to utility maximization. That's a constrained maximization. So, the people who drop out may may be people we want. Maybe they're people who have to lose their jobs cuz they can't drive to their jobs anymore. That's unfortunate. So, basically, the the benefit of this is equity, and that raises something we're going to come back to over and over again in this class, which is what we call the equity-efficiency trade-off. Okay? The equity-efficiency trade-off, which is there are many government policies which make society more equal, but along the way deliver deadweight loss.

And I'll actually tell you later in the class how to optimize across that problem. How to optimize across the trade-off between equity and efficiency. But, for right now, I just need you to understand that there's a that there's a trade-off. Okay? Yeah. Oh, so what like if it actually had something to do with equity like the consumer surplus like that the people who are who have like a bigger if there's no price ceiling, then the people who are able to pay the most money will Yeah, exactly. So, the point is, right, the people who What's your Morty or Yeah, but if there is like a price ceiling, then what just check the money and like people who have more time will get it.

Exactly. The it introduces a different kind of inequity. So, if you're worried about So, in some sense, the rich guy would say, "Well, that's not fair to me. Just cuz I've got a productive job I could be doing Yeah. and someone else has extra time, why should they get the gas instead of me?" So, you're right, there's always sort of an inequity. I guess when I say equity, that's a great point. When I say equity, I implicitly mean what we call That's actually a very important point. Whenever I say equity in this course, I implicitly mean what we call vertical equity. Vertical equity is rich versus poor.

Okay? There are other kinds of equity you might care about. Like who who has extra time versus who doesn't have extra time. Okay? But, and and that's a good point. But, for now, when I say equity, I'm going to think about rich versus poor. We think about government policy equity-efficiency trade-off, we really think about vertical equity. Okay? Other questions about that? Okay. So, let's do a couple more examples to drill this intuition home. Okay, let's do a couple more examples. Cuz this is a very important point. Okay? Example A, let's talk about ticket scalping. Okay? I love going to I go I love going to music concerts.

One of my 51st concert of the year last year. Um last night, sorry. Went to my 51st concert of the year. I love going to music concerts, so I know a lot about the music business. Um and ticket scalping at concerts is a big deal. For those of you who don't know the term, this is the idea of uh buying tickets essentially on a secondary market. So, let's use the example of Adele. So, Adele about 2 years ago went on tour for the first time in 4 years to back up an incredibly successful album. And folks really want to see her live cuz she had a big fan base. She was quiet for a while. She made an album.

People really want to see her live. She wanted to make sure her fans could afford to see her. So, what she did is she said, "I'm going to price tickets at many tickets for $40 and the highest tickets at 150." Which is really, really cheap. So, my daughter's going to see J Cole tonight, and she's paying like 150 for a mediocre ticket. Okay? So, 40 to 150 is really cheap. Okay? Uh but, she's saying, "I want to deliver consumer surplus to my fans. I want to make sure my fans can really enjoy this enjoy this uh get surplus." But, what happened? Well, what happened is that the tickets sold out instantly, like literally instantaneously.

And the major purchasers were what we call scalpers, who are essentially professionals who buy tickets and then resell them on what we call the secondary market. You might have heard of StubHub or other sites like that, where essentially go on and buy tickets to sold-out events. And the prices on StubHub were much higher. It was about $1,500 for a good ticket, about 10 times what she had set the price at. So, basically, who's getting the surplus? Not the fans. The scalpers. The people who were quick enough to get online, who set bots set up so that the second it went online, they went online and got the tickets.

They had thousands of bots set up essentially. Somehow they got around the click this if you're human box. I don't know how they do that. But, essentially, I'm sure it's smart programmers. You guys can probably do that in an hour as an extra credit project. Okay? They got around it, and they bought And so, essentially, Adele actually didn't create surplus for her fans. She created surplus for scalpers. Okay? Now, it didn't used to be this way. When I was a kid, we didn't have a secondary market. We waited online. So, when I saw my first concert in 1981, you guys believe that? 1981, I saw The Cars.

How many guys heard of The Cars? Oh, god. Anyway, I saw The Cars 19 I had to wait online for hours to get tickets. Because that was the that was the allocation mechanism. So, let's think about whether life is better or worse. Because on the one hand, scalpers get money. On the other hand, people don't waste time waiting online. So, it really comes out of the same equity trade-off we talked about before. Now, as a as a 16-year-old 1981, I could not have afforded to pay probably the secondary market price. So, I but I was 16. I had nothing to do with my time. So, I was happy to spend hours waiting online.

Okay? But, on the other hand, you could say someone who's very productive, who is a big fan, who is very productive and could be out inventing new products. If they weren't standing online, they might say, "That's really inefficient. I'm happy to pay 1,500 bucks and spend my time inventing new things rather than have to sit around waiting online." So, it's not clear which is the better or uh or or or the worse system. It's hard to say. Yeah. Doesn't that become like a market with the scalpers then? So, like the demand for the Adele tickets and like with all these different scalpers having all these different tickets, they'll be they'll be all like changing prices and all.

Well, no, but No, here's the point. This That's a great point. Which is that in some sense, what the scalpers do is undo Adele's action and create a truly efficient market. So, think of the scalpers as essentially undoing Adele's action, which distorted the market. So, you have a you have a market for Adele tickets, which is in equilibrium at $1,500. Adele tried to set a price ceiling at 150. Seemingly selfishly, saying, "Look, I'm going to give up my surplus Okay? Un for my for my fans." But, unfortunately, it didn't work out that way. What happened was the market re-equilibrated at 1,500, but that extra surplus didn't go to Adele.

The consumer surplus still remained above 1,500. The difference was that extra gap between 150 and 1,500 didn't go to Adele. It went to the scalpers. So, it's probably more efficient than waiting online because waiting online has an efficiency, whereas this instantaneous bidding is more efficient. But, it in some sense is delivering that the efficiency gain is being delivered not to consumers as Adele wanted. It's being delivered to scalpers. Okay? So, basically, now, there's another alternative. What could Adele have done instead? What what what what what What's What's another way Adele could have approached this?

Well, she could have auctioned her tickets online. She could have said, "Look, I know that I can't manage to deliver $40 tickets to my fans. I just can't defeat the scalping system. But, why should the scalpers have the money? I'm going to auction my tickets." And essentially, she could have set up an efficient market online, where people bid, and then you would have gotten the efficient outcome, and you wouldn't wait online, you would have bid. Now, it would have been inequitable outcome, but basically, the same fans would have gotten the tickets as in the end got them from the scalpers. But, instead of paying 1,500 to the scalpers, they'd pay 1,500 to Adele.

And probably that's a better outcome. I mean, you know, Adele doesn't need the money. But, at the At the of the day, if Adele's generating that amount of goodwill from her fans, it seems like she should get the money, not a bunch of scalpers. Okay? So, I guess probably I'd rather have her have it than the scalpers. Now, Ticketmaster has tried to set up auction systems recognizing this problem, and they're not really taking off. And it just it sort of speaks to the fact that people don't really like to think about economics. Okay? So, there was that basically people are like, "Yeah, but if you auction, that's ripping off the fans.

That's not fair." And Ticketmaster would say, "Well, you're getting ripped off anyway just by scalpers." And they said, "No, I can still get online first and get my ticket." And people just didn't like it. Thought it was unfair. Even though it's almost certainly a better outcome for society if you think Adele should have the money rather than the scalpers. Which speaks to the fact that, you know, morals matter in markets. Okay? We like to give these markets abstract amoral concepts, but morals do matter. Okay? And that basically it sort of matters, you know, uh you sometimes can't do the right thing because it might not be the thing that makes consumers willing to uh participate.

Okay? So, that's one example, scalping. Another example, food banks. Okay. Food banks are organizations which provide Oh, yeah, go ahead. Um what if you force um um that like everyone like when you buy something you have to put your name on the ticket so that only you can Yeah, I I I I've thought about that. So, in my if I could do anything I wanted in life, I'd be a rock star. And I thought if I was a rock star, it'd be cool. I'd like have a concert for like my mega fans where like they'd have to prove who they were and I'd have a bracelet and stuff. It just seems like it's too hard. Seems the technology is just too hard.

So, actually there's a really cool example of this. I was on the phone this morning with a with a with a rock and roll promoter who's doing a super cool thing. Um so, as the election approaches, I will nag you guys to vote. Voter turnout among the young is an enormous problem in the US. So, she is running a series of concerts around the country where if you show a picture of yourself outside a polling place, you get into the concert for free. To try to promote voting among young people. It's super cool. It's called I voted. You can look it up on the web. It's kind of a cool thing. There's a couple concerts here in Boston.

They're all over the country. Um so, you could think about things like that. The question is ultimately, you know, do people Photoshop the picture in front of the polling place? You know, it's all it's a just a question of enforcement. Okay. So, let's do our food banks. So, basically, um these are organizations that provide free food to the poor. And the biggest one is called Feeding America. Feeding America has food banks all over the nation, and they provide free food free food to the poor. Okay? Now, their goal then is they have to figure out where to send the food to get to people who need it the most.

Now, a market does this naturally. Basically, if people want more turkey in location A, then all of a sudden the price for turkey goes up. All of a sudden the store runs out of turkey. It says, "Wow, I can charge more for turkey." It raises the price, and it equilibrates the market. So, a market solves for sending the right food to where people want it. But, the problem with Feeding America is that they didn't have that market. So, they just had to decide where to send stuff, and they'd screw up. They'd like send potatoes to Idaho where like they're drowning in potatoes. Stuff like that. So, it was very hard for them to figure out where to send the food exactly where people want the most cuz they didn't have the market mechanism.

They wanted to give it away for free. They'd sort of defeat the purpose if they charged for it. But, they didn't really know they didn't have the market to tell them where folks wanted which foods. In the real market, if you want real foods, you bid the price up. In their market, you couldn't. So, Feeding America came up with a really clever solution. They made a virtual market. They said to each food bank, "We are going to give you a fake budget of X hundred thousands of dollars, and you bid for which foods you want based on what the people in your area want. And we'll then allocate it according to those bids." So, they got the market mechanism working without the food banks having to actually give any money.

Okay? So, in that way, they massively reallocated food. They suddenly said, "Hey, the one from Idaho is bidding really high for turkey and not all for potatoes. Maybe we should send them more turkey and send potatoes elsewhere." So, they essentially got market signals from a non-financial transaction. It was super cool idea. And the amount of And there was a huge benefit. They were able to effectively reallocate about 50 million pounds of food through this mechanism, making sure that food got to the folks that needed it. So, there's an example how you can use a market mechanism without actually while while not violating equity.

The food was always free. But, by setting up these virtual prices, they managed to get the food delivered to where people want the most. They let the market send its allocative signals. They let the market be allocatively efficient, send its signals of where people wanted the food without actually violating equity. Okay? Questions about that? Okay. Now, let's go to the hardest, but my favorite example, which is taxi medallions. This is a hard example, but it's a really cool one, and it ends with a great story. Okay. Taxi cabs. Now, let's cast your mind back pre-Uber. Okay? Go back 10 years. Or even I don't know what Yeah, about 10 years.

Taxi cabs were the only way you could get around town if you didn't have, you know, if you wanted to get from point A to point B in a car you didn't own one, you took a taxi. Okay? And this was a great example of an economist's perfectly competitive market in theory. It's an identical product. You want to go from point A to point B. Okay? It's very There could be lots of them riding around the streets. You can price compare because cabs are coming by all the time. Okay? It should have been a very effective, perfectly efficient, perfectly competitive market. Okay? But, it wasn't. Because every city limited the amount of taxi cabs that were allowed in their city.

Every city had a system where to be a taxi cab, you had to have what was called a medallion. Wasn't really a medallion. It's a piece of original medallion. It's just a piece of paper, actually. And they regulated the number of taxi cabs allowed in the city. They said we're only going to allow X many taxi cab drivers in the city, and every city did this. Now, we're going to do both a positive and normative analysis of this policy. Let's start with the positive analysis. What did this policy did policy do? Okay? Now, I'm going to go to figure 10-4. Figure 10-4 will be one of the most complicated figures to do in this class.

So, I'm going to go through it as slowly as I can, but please stop me if it's not clear. Okay? This one of these figures we'll go back and forth between the two sides. So, on the right-hand side is the market. On the left-hand side is a cab firm. We're going to start by assuming all cabs are identical. We assume all cabs are identical. So, one representative firm tells us about every cab firm. Okay? Now, we start with the market. We have an initial demand, which is D. The line D, the blue line, is the demand for taxi cabs. Okay? And initial supply curve S1. We're going to assume that essentially in a perfectly competitive market, you have a flat long-run supply curve.

You have perfectly elastic supply. Okay? Anybody can just grab a cab and start driving Once again, in a cab market without medallions, anyone could throw can throw a taxi sign on the car and start driving around picking people up. Okay? So, it's effectively perfectly entry and exit. So, it's a perfectly competitive long-run market. Therefore, flat supply at S1. So, initial equilibrium is at point big E1. Okay? Where you have Q1 rides, big Q1 rides per month. And that amounts to So, so you have Q That's the equilibrium. Now, how many firms are there? Well, we know how many firms there are cuz we say, "Okay, at that price P1, we go to the left." We know that firms will produce where marginal cost equals average cost, at the minimum of long-run average cost.

We proved that a couple lectures ago. Therefore, if the price is E1, we know each efficient firm will produce little Q1. If there's if each firm is producing little Q1, and the total amount of rides is going to be big Q1, then that implies little N1 firms. So, let me go through it again. Supply equals demand at big Q1. That gives you a price P1. Now, we shift to the left. At that price P1, we know that each firm will choose to produce little Q1 rides cuz that's where price equals marginal cost equals average cost. Now, we go back to the right. We know if there's little each firm is producing little Q1 rides, and you need big Q1, then there must be N1 firms.

Okay? Questions about that? That's the initial equilibrium. Okay. And at that point, there are long-run zero profits. Consumer surplus is A + B + both C plus C. C, by the way, is the gray area on either side of the dash line. A + B + C. We mark it twice cuz it's confusing with the dash line there. So, the blue area, the green area, and the gray area are the consumer surplus. And what's the producer surplus? What's the producer surplus? Raise your hand and tell me. Yeah. Zero because Yeah, there's no it's in long-run equilibrium, there's no profits. In long-run perfect competitive equilibrium, price Remember, profits are price minus average cost, but price equals average cost.

Okay? So, there's no profit. So, it's all consumer surplus. All well and good. Now, let's say the government comes in and says, "We're going to have a medallion system." Okay? Um So, let's So, let's say um we're going to we're going to have a system We're going to have a system where only little N2 cabs are allowed in the market. Little N2 are the only number of cabs allowed in the market. Okay, so what is the new market supply curve? Start on the right. What's the new market supply curve? Well, up to little N2 times Q1, nothing's changed. Each cab company used to provide Q what little Q1 rides at a price P1.

So, up to the point little N2 little Q1, we're on the same supply curve we used to be on. But, then things change. Why do they change? Because now let's say riders want more than little N2 Q1. Well, you can't deal with that by entry. You have to deal with that by the existing cab drivers working more. But, if they work more, supply curve is upward sloping. Because now marginal costs could be rising. Before the reason supply curve was flat is when you went to the right of little N2 little Q1. As you move to the right, you just got more entry and everyone still produce at their efficient level of little Q1.

Now, when you can't allow more entry, firms have to produce more and suddenly they're not at the cost minimizing point. They're riding up their marginal cost curve. So, the supply curve becomes flat to that point and then becomes upward sloping. And that's S2. S2 is the red line that is flat to the left of N little N2 little Q1 and then becomes very becomes upward sloping. And the new equilibrium is at point E2 with N2 firms by law you can only have N2 firms producing little Q2 rides each. Okay? And your new equilibrium is big Q2. And that new equilibrium price is uh the new equilibrium price is P2.

The new equilibrium price is P2. Okay? Now, P2 if you go to the old um P2 is the point if you look at the price is P2, but I forget the EC2 curve. Focus on the EC1 curve. Okay? Average cost The average cost function hasn't changed. It's still AC1. So, if the price is P2 and their average cost curve is AC1 they're going to produce where price equals marginal cost at little E2. Okay, so let me back up. You have a Let's go back to the right curve on the right. The equilibrium is now big E2. That's at a price little P2. Now, shift to the left. At a price of little P2, firms produce where price equals marginal cost, right?

Price equals marginal cost at a quantity little Q2. So, firms produce little Q2 cuz that's the point at which price equals marginal cost. They produce at little Q2. Well, if they're making little Q2 units at a price P2 they're earning profits of pi the shaded area. Because all they are producing units at price above marginal cost. And they're producing little Q2 units. So, every unit they produce they're earning profits on. So, the taxi medallion workers are the taxi companies are now making money. They're making profits. Okay? Questions about that? Yeah. The idea that if we allowed for people to more people to go in, profit would decrease.

Yeah, but we but we're not allowing them in. They're making profits. So, imagine where we started at E2 and allowed free entry. Then you'd see basically more firms would enter and you'd drive the price down to P1, but we don't allow that. So, there's profits. It's a barrier to entry which creates profits, which breaks us from our long-run flat supply curve. We talked about one of the reasons why that we won't be flat. So, now let's move to the normative. Is this a good idea or not? Well, let's look at the welfare implications. What's happened? What's happened is consumers used to have a surplus of A plus B plus C.

Now, their surplus is what? What's the new consumer surplus? Raise your hand and tell me. Yeah. Just A. Because it's the line below the demand above price is just A. Producers used to have zero surplus. What's their new surplus? Behind you. Yeah. B. Because it's the area above the supply curve below the price line. And C is what? The deadweight loss. Those are transactions no longer happening. Okay? The deadweight loss. Okay? So, basically normatively you can pose the problem as the following. Is it worth society losing the area C in order to transfer the area B from consumers to taxi cab drivers?

That's the way to think about this problem. Let me say it again, it's very important. Essentially, the government policy doing is saying, "I'm going to transfer B from consumers to producers even though it's going to cost me C in deadweight loss." That's what the government's saying. That's the government's position. Okay? Now, why is the government wrong? Why in fact is that not the proper statement of what happens? It's very complicated. What does the government miss? When it says, "Hey, look, I've made the drivers better off. Sure, I've created deadweight loss, but at least that I've made consumers better off.

At least I've made these drivers better off. They live terrible lives. There's articles in the paper all the time about suicides of taxi cab drivers. It's terrible." What did they miss? Yeah. The cost of taxi goes up. They've missed the fact that the taxi cab drivers have to buy the medallions. That the limited number of medallions aren't just given to taxi cab drivers. They're bought. And the taxi cab drivers, what is a taxi cab driver willing to pay for a medallion? They are willing to pay in the limit the total surplus they get from driving the cab minus a dollar. Or minus some amount, you know, that they need to eat.

So, if suddenly in a world with no restrictions with no taxi cab medallions, if you said we're going to give you a piece of paper so you can drive a taxi, but anyone can have it for free what would it be worth? Zero. But, in a world where you say, "You can If you have this piece of paper you can drive and drivers earn profits pi." What will the taxi cab medallion sell for? Pi minus some small amount. So, actually who wins? The taxi cab medallion owners. And who are they? They are random folks who happened to get these things in 1920 when they were issued. And their descendants and people who bought them.

Okay? So, this leads to my great story. The taxi cab medallion king of Long Island was a guy who happened to have a bunch of these taxi cab medallions and as they went through the roof, they got worth a lot. In New York a tax New York um had 12,000 permits. And that number did not change since they originally sold for $10 each in 1937. 1937, you could have bought it for $10 and they issued 12 12,000. They've never increased it. Right now, a taxi cab medallion in New York is worth $400,000. Okay? Well, the taxi cab king of New York is the guy who lives in Long Island who made so much money that he actually he actually for his kid's bar mitzvah not only had rented out a whole hotel a whole basketball themed bar mitzvah, but hired Nicki Minaj.

Okay? This was paid for by area B. Okay? This was paid for. So, in fact, IT'S NOT THE TAXI cab drivers that make out of this policy. It's the taxi cab king medallion king of Long New York. Now here's what happens. Okay? Here's what happens. What happens then when Uber comes in? Who's the big loser? Not the taxi cab drivers, the taxi cab medallion owners. So, everyone who tells you Uber's a bad thing cuz these poor taxi cab drivers are starving, taxi cab drivers were always starving. It was always a terrible life. The difference The difference is price of medallions is down like 50%. And I cry no tears for the for the Nicki Minaj hiring class of America.

Okay? So, basically when you think about people say Uber's bad, it steals jobs taxi cab drivers. No, it doesn't. Okay? It steals money from taxi cab medallion owners. And that is something we might be okay with. So, feel fine taking your Uber. Uh it's a great it's a great thing. So, let me stop there. Um I'm going to come back uh we'll we'll uh come back next lecture and we will start talking about monopoly. Uh the market structure not the game.