# Lecture 22: Metals, Insulators, and Semiconductors

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oq4OHT4hhJc
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/Oq4OHT4hhJc

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 7:22 — Chapter 2 (7:22)
- 14:20 — Chapter 3 (14:20)
- 19:16 — Chapter 4 (19:16)
- 22:58 — Chapter 5 (22:58)
- 25:09 — Chapter 6 (25:09)
- 27:07 — Chapter 7 (27:07)
- 29:20 — Chapter 8 (29:20)
- 30:21 — Chapter 9 (30:21)
- 34:37 — Chapter 10 (34:37)
- 36:29 — Chapter 11 (36:29)
- 38:59 — Chapter 12 (38:59)
- 39:47 — Chapter 13 (39:47)
- 46:42 — Chapter 14 (46:42)
- 52:28 — Chapter 15 (52:28)
- 54:37 — Chapter 16 (54:37)
- 1:01:03 — Chapter 17 (61:03)
- 1:07:56 — Chapter 18 (67:56)
- 1:16:32 — Chapter 19 (76:32)
- 1:26:05 — Chapter 20 (86:05)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseware continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseware at ocw.mit.edu.

**[0:23]:** Hi everyone. Um uh Spring has regrets. Um So, uh we have uh we're going to have a a guest at the end of lecture today, which should be kind of entertaining. Um just as a warning, if you see someone come in. Um So, questions before we get started.

**[0:49]:** No questions about anything? At all? Math? Nothing? Yeah. Can you explain the difference between the momentum and the crystal momentum? Yeah, okay. Let me go over that. That's a good question. So, the question is what's What again is the the significance of the crystal momentum? So, um So, let me answer that in a slightly backward way. So, this is a form of the explanation I haven't given you. So, it's going to be a slightly different one. Um let's step back and think about the momentum and ask what the momentum is. Now, you guys showed on a problem set um the following fact, that if you have a wave function, psi of x, such that the expectation value uh in the state psi of um of x uh in the state psi is equal to x naught, and the expectation value of p in the state psi uh is p naught, hat hat, then if you want to change the crystal the change the momentum increase the momentum by uh uh

**[1:58]:** h bar k, the way to do that is to take psi and and build a new wave function, psi tilde, um is equal to uh e to the i k x psi of x. And then, the expectation value of x is the same, psi tilde, still equal to x naught, because this phase goes away from the two complex from the wave function and complex conjugate when you take the inner product, but the expectation value of the momentum is shifted in the state psi tilde is shifted by h h bar k, p naught plus h bar k. So, all the intuition you have about momentum, you can translate into intuition about the spatial variation of the phase of the wave function. The Yeah? I have another question. Oh, okay, good. Okay, good. Good. Good. Good. So, um we we have a sneaky recitation instructor today. So, um So, the the information about the momentum can be encoded in the spatial variation of the phase of the wave function.

**[3:00]:** So, um one another way to ask to answer the question then of what is momentum apart from it's the thing that So, what are ways to answer the question, what is momentum? You could ask, well, what is momentum? It's the thing that commutes with p or with x by i h bar. That's one way to answer it. Another way to answer it is to say that translations by l can be expressed in terms of momentum as e to the minus i upon h bar um uh p uh l. Okay? So, these are both ways of describing what the momentum is, but another way of talking about the momentum is the momentum p governs

**[3:40]:** the spatial variation, the x dependence, of the phase of the wave function.

**[3:49]:** Let's try. Okay. So, these are all ways of of talking about what the momentum is. So, now let's turn this around and let's ask about the crystal momentum. Oh, and one last thing, a last defining property of of the momentum, um or uh uh it's a a central property from the Schrödinger equation is that the time variation d d t of p is equal to the expectation value of minus d the potential of x d x, right? Also known as the force. So, this is the Ehrenfest theorem statement that the the classical equation of motion p dot is equal to a the minus d v d x or minus the is equal to the force. Their Ehrenfest theorem tells us that the classical equations of motion are realized as expectation values. And equivalently, if there's no if there's no potential, if the potential is constant, this tells us that the momentum expectation value is time independent, right?

**[4:47]:** A familiar fact. So, these are all true, lovely, and uh things about the momentum. So, let's turn all of these facts around into the crystal momentum. So, let's talk about uh crystal momentum, which was the question, what is the crystal momentum? So, the crystal momentum is defined from beginning from the following property. If we have a potential v of x, which is invariant under shifting by one lattice spacing, by some l, this is v of x, then this tells us that the moment that the um the energy operator is invariant if we shift by l, if we translate by l, equals zero. And from this fact, we deduced via Bloch or Alla Bloch that the wave functions are really the energy eigenfunctions can be written in the form e q is equal to e to the i q x u of x, where u we're going to take to be a periodic function.

**[5:50]:** Okay? So, what is this parameter q doing? Q is governing the spatial variation of the phase of the wave function. Cool? So, in precisely this sense, in precisely this sense that uh p is that uh the the momentum governs the space of the wave function, here in the case of a periodic potential, the crystal momentum q is governing the spatial variation of the phase of the wave function. Okay? So, q is the thing that governs the phase as a function of x. Okay? Well, what about um uh another fact about the crystal momentum, which you show on your problem set, is that if you impose an external force, d q d t, and really d h bar q, d t, is equal to ah d d t of the time of the expectation value of h bar q uh is equal to minus uh the Sorry, the expectation value of the force, I'll just write.

**[7:05]:** Okay? So, again, this is a quantity, and this was assuming that we had a sharply peaked wave packet. So, this is for a wave packet sharply peaked

**[7:22]:** at oops at q naught. And so, then let me just write this as h bar q naught. So, the central value of your wave packet, so this is what you show on the problem set, that the central value of your of your wave packet, the peak of your wave packet, varies in time according to the external force. And so, in particular, if the force is zero, if we turn on no external driving force, your wave packet maintains its crystal momentum, it's time independent. So, the crystal momentum is something that's time independent unless an external force is applied, just like the momentum. And it's something that governs the phase of the wave function, just like the momentum. However, it's a different in a crucial way. It is not the eigenvalue p on uh psi sub e q is not equal to uh a constant p naught times psi sub e q.

**[8:12]:** Right? Because when we take when we act with p or we act with the derivative, we pick up a term from here, which gives us a constant, but we also have this overall periodic piece. And its spatial variation is generically nonzero. And if the potential is nontrivial, it's always nonconstant. So, when the momentum operator hits this guy, it will generically not give us zero. Then we'll get two terms, and we will not get an eigenvalue equation. So, q is not the eigenvalue, h bar q is not the eigenvalue of p. And what's the last important property of q that's different from the momentum?

**[8:52]:** It comes from the commutator, which tells us that um that the uh that the thing that's conserved is the expectation value of t l is really the precise statement.

**[9:06]:** And in particular, um what this um what this uh Sorry, let me phrase this slightly differently. What this tells us is that the eigenvalue or the eigenvalue of our wave function under translations by l is is uh is a quantity that can be determined simultaneously with knowing the energy. However, the eigenvalue of t sub l t l on this state is equal to e to the i q l, Okay? Which means that q is only defined for determining the eigenvalue up to 2 pi over l. If you have q, which is zero, and you increase it to pi over l, that value pi over l is effectively the same as the value minus pi over l. Okay? Because it leads to the same eigenvalue. But that's really strange, because that means that Q itself it's not strictly conserved. It's conserved mod 2 pi over L.

**[10:03]:** When you have momentum conservation, momentum is strictly conserved if there's no force. And even if there is a force it's increasing controlled by the by the force as you turn on a force it just constantly increases. For the crystal momentum that's not the case. You turn on a force, it increases according to the conservation law, but it's not increasing constantly. It's periodic. It's periodically defined. So it increases and then it ends up at a smaller value. It increases and ends up at a smaller value. Okay? So it carries many of the same properties. It governs the phase. It's time independent unless there's an external force applied. It's the eigenvalue controls the eigenvalue of an operator that commutes with the energy when when you have a periodic potential in the same way that the momentum commutes with the energy when you have no external force when you

**[10:51]:** have a constant potential. Um Did that Yeah. Help. Good. Okay. So developing an intuition for the crystal momentum I think is best done by just playing with examples and you'll do that more in the course on solids which I encourage you all to take cuz it's really beautiful stuff. But for for our purposes this is going to be the full set of ideas we'll need for 304. Other Yeah. Can you get something in lightning also probably in current perspective? Ah. Um So good. So Thank you. So this involves a slight subtlety which I've been glossing over in the entire story here which is the following. So is U of X a real function? Well from the from So when we started out asking what are the eigen functions of the translate by L operator, all we showed was that and I'm going to do this on a separate board just to make it

**[11:53]:** clear. Um can we leave this turns off cuz I kept bumping. Okay, cool. Um so when we started with translate by L and we constructed its eigen functions, we said that translate by L Q phi um I'll just say phi sub Q is equal to some some phase and this is unitary so it's got to be its eigenvalue must be an actual phase e to the I alpha of phi sub Q of X. And let's just suppose that this is true, then this tells us that phi sub Q times e to the minus IQL

**[12:25]:** uh equals U. So I'm just going to use this to define a new function U sub Q or just U. I'll use U sub Q, fine. Of X. So this is defined a new function U sub Q. I take an eigen function and multiply it by by some phase. Sorry, I mean e to the minus IQX. Okay? If we choose QL to be equal to alpha then acting on U sub Q by translate by L on U sub Q uh of X is equal to Well, if we act on phi sub Q with translate by L, what happens to phi sub Q? We pick up a phase e to the I alpha. What happens to e to the minus IQX? X goes to X plus L. We pick up a phase e to the minus IQL. So if QL is equal to alpha, those two phases cancel and we just get U back, U sub Q of X.

**[13:14]:** But translate by L of U sub Q by definition is equal to U sub Q of X plus L. So we've determined is that if we pick QL is equal to alpha, then phi sub Q, phi can now be labeled by its eigenvalue Q, can be written in the form e to the I QX U sub Q of X where this is periodic.

**[13:42]:** Everyone agree with that? Okay. So that's step one. Step two is to say, well look, since the eigenvalue of this guy under T sub L e to the IQ alpha e to the I Sorry, e to the I alpha is equal to e to the I QL. Since this is periodic under shifts of Q by 2 pi upon L, I can just choose to define Q up to 2 pi over L. So two Q I will take to be equivalent to 2 pi to Q plus 2 pi over L.

**[14:20]:** And the reason I'm going to do that is because it gives the same eigenvalue and if I want to label things by eigenvalues sort of redundant to give multiple values to the same eigenvalue. Now there's a subtlety here though. And the subtlety here is this. Suppose we have a free particle. Does a free particle respect translation by L? So if we have a free particle the potential is zero. That constant function is also periodic under shifts by L. Right? Cuz it's just zero. So it's stupidly periodic, but it's periodic nonetheless. So now I'm going to ask the following question. What are the common eigen functions of the energy and translate by L for the free particle? We did this last time. So the common eigen functions of translate by L and um and uh the energy are the wave functions phi sub Q comma E are equal to e to the I QX times some function U of X on general

**[15:16]:** grounds. But we know what these eigen functions are. They're just e to the IKX where K squared upon 2M is equal to E. H bar squared K squared upon 2M is equal to E. So we know that these are the correct eigen functions, but we're writing them in the form e to the IQXU. Now Now you say that's that's fine. There's nothing wrong with this. We just say U is constant and Q is equal to K. Right? Then that's these these functions Sorry, these functions are of this form, but they're of this form with e to the IQX being e to the IKX and U of X being constant. Right? There's nothing wrong about it. Does everyone agree? Perfectly consistent. However I thought we said that Q is periodic by 2 pi. If Q is periodic by 2 pi, then that would seem to imply that K is periodic by 2 pi.

**[16:02]:** But we know that's not true cuz any K is allowed for a free particle. So if we want to think about Q is periodic by 2 pi upon L then we cannot require that U is real. Because it must be the phase that makes this up. It must be So I can always write this as e to the I Q QX where Q is less than 2 pi upon L or sorry, Q is between 2 pi or pi upon L. And minus pi upon L. Right? So so that it's defined only up to this periodic thing. But times some additional phase e to the I K minus Q X. So this is trivially equal to e to the IKX. Right? But now U is not a real function. On the other hand, if we hadn't imposed the requirement that Q is periodic we wouldn't have needed to make U real.

**[16:56]:** We could have just taken Q to be equal to K for any value K and then U would be constant. U would be real. So this is This is important for answering the excellent question that our our fearless recitation instructor provoked me to to answer which is that So we'll come back to the the question in just a second, but I want to emphasize this that if we're going to take Q to be not periodic or sorry, if we're going to take Q to be defined only up to shifts by 2 pi over L, it's important that we allow U to be not real. It must be able to have an overall phase. But if we want Q to if we want U to be always real, we can do that. We just can't do impose this periodicity. Different values of Q mean different wave functions.

**[17:38]:** And this is really what's going on when you see those plots. Sometimes you see the plots as parabolas, the bands are represented by parabolas with wiggles, and sometimes they're folded up. And that's the difference. The difference is that when you fold them up you're imposing this periodicity and you're labeling the eigen functions by Q and the overall amount of the number of of K effectively of K phases that you're subtracting off. Yeah. So is this an arbitrary choice or does it automatically make Q periodic? Yeah, it I mean it How to say? It's um it's it's exactly akin to a choice of variables in describing the position of this particle. Should we use Cartesian coordinates or should we use spherical coordinates? Well, it can't possibly matter. And so you'd better make sure in any description of your system that changing your coordinates doesn't change your results.

**[18:26]:** And here that's exactly what's going on. Do we want to define our variable to be periodic by 2 pi upon L? Well, okay then, but U can't be real. Or we could take Q to be not periodic by 2 pi L and impose that U is real. It's just a choice of variables. But it can't possibly give different answers. But the point is this is a subtle little distinction that we gloss over and is glossed over into my knowledge every book on intro quantum mechanics that even covers periodic potentials. It can be very confusing. Anyway, the reason that I had to go through all this is that in order to answer the very very good question that Professor Evans posed I'm going to need to deal with this fact. So for the moment, let me deal with Let's work with U real and Q in Q an unconstrained real number.

**[19:09]:** Okay? So not periodic.

**[19:16]:** Everyone cool with that for the moment? Okay. So if we do that, then notice the following nice property of our wave function. Our wave function phi sub Q is equal to e to the IQX times U of Q or U of X which is real.

**[19:42]:** So when we construct the current, remember that J boils down to the imaginary part uh H bar over 2 m uh I uh well, H bar over m times the imaginary part of psi complex conjugate uh derivative with respect to x, which is the current in the x direction of psi. And we need this to be imaginary or we will get no current. You show this in a problem set. If you have a pure real wave function, for example, a single real exponential that's decaying, right? As on the wrong side of a barrier, then you get no current. Nothing flows. And that makes sense. It's exponentially decaying. Nothing gets across. So, we need the wave function to be real. So, if Q were zero, we would get zero. And what you can immediately do from this, compute from this, is that well, the derivative if the derivative doesn't hit e to the iqx, if it hits U, then the phase e to the iqx cancels.

**[20:40]:** And so, the contribution from that term vanishes. So, the only term that's going to contribute in here is when the derivative hits the e to the iqx. But then, this is going to be equal to uh H bar. Whoops. Oh, and did I get my um Yeah, no, I did. Okay, good. H bar Q. And we want the imaginary part, so that's going to eat the I. uh over m And then, we're left with uh U squared of x. Okay? So, this is the current. But we have to deal with We had to take advantage in order to for this to be sort of clean, we had to take advantage of U being real. Everyone cool with that? Now, there's one last twist on this, which is that if I have K If I have Q, this is a side note. Going back up here to this logic, if I have Q, um and I want I can always write it as um some Q naught plus uh n pi over L.

**[21:35]:** Right? And so, now what I want to do is I want to take sort of a hybrid of these two pictures, and I want to say phi sub Q is going to be equal to e to the i Q naught x where this is the value that's periodic by 2 pi. e to the i n pi over L x U. Okay? And so, now really what's going to What I'm doing here is I'm labeling Q not by a single number I'm labeling my wave function not by a single number Q, but by Q naught and an integer n. {comma} n So, Q naught and n. And so, now Q naught is periodic. It's defined up to shifts by 2 pi. n is an additional integer, and what it's telling you is how many times did you have to shift back to get into that fundamental zone between pi and minus pi?

**[22:25]:** And this fits nicely into this story because now all we're going to get here is Q, which is Q naught plus n pi. So, the current depends on both the the the part defined mod 2 pi over L and the integer, which tells you how many factors of 2 pi over L did you have to subtract off to get into that fundamental domain? Well, let's think back to our band structure. So, what is this n quantity? Let's think back to our band structure. In our band structure, we had something that looks like this.

**[22:58]:** Okay? And here's the value of Q. But am I plotting Q? No, I'm plotting here Q naught. I'm plotting the plot I'm plotting the part that's periodically defined up to 2 pi over L. So, this is pi over L. This is minus 2 pi over minus pi over L. Okay? And what we see is that there isn't a single energy, right? Cuz this is the energy in the vertical direction for these band pictures. There isn't a single energy for a given value of Q. In fact, the set of energy eigenvalue or the set the set of allowed states or energy eigenvalues for an allowed value of Q, let's say this particular value of Q naught, how many of them are there? Well, there are as many as there are integers. 1 2 3 4 count. So, to specify a state, I don't just have to specify Q naught, I also have to specify n.

**[23:43]:** Which one of these guys I'm hitting? And when you unfold this into the parabola picture, remember where these came from. These came from these curves came from shifting over. And the higher up you go, the more you had to shift over. And that's exactly the integer piece n pi over L. And so, we can write the current now in terms of H bar Q naught upon m U squared Oh, sorry. H bar Q naught upon m plus n pi uh H bar upon m U squared of x. So, we get a contribution from the crystal momentum and from which band we're in. Okay? So, it's sort of an elaborate story to to answer the phase question, but Yeah.

**[24:33]:** Good. So, here we had psi So, psi Oh, sorry. I should have done this for phi. But I meant this wave function, right? Okay. So, this is phi. This is phi Q Q. So, from from here, we're going to get the imaginary part So, we get the imaginary part of this wave function, which is e to the minus iqx U of x derivative of e to the iqx U of x. Now, the term that contributes is when the derivative hits the e to the iq x pulls down a factor of iq and these two phases cancel from these guys, leaving us with a U of x here and a U of x here.

**[25:09]:** Oh, sorry. This isn't the potential. Ah, good. That's the point. So, this isn't the potential. So, in in the statement that um what when we have uh this translation by x, so this is just some function. It has nothing to do with the potential. It's defined in terms of the wave function, the eigenfunction of translate by L. So, if we if we know So, the logic here goes, if we know we have a an eigenfunction of translate by L, then I construct a new function U, nothing to do with the potential, just a new function, which is e to the minus iqx times it. You can't stop me. You hand me a function, I will hand you a different function. And then, we pick Q felicitously so to show that U is periodic. So, U is just some periodic function, which is contained which is defined from the wave function from the energy from the eigenfunction of TL.

**[25:54]:** Did that answer your question? Okay. um So, here it just came from the fact that U is, you know, phi is e to the iqx U, and then there's a factor of U from each of these. Other questions? Yeah.

**[26:14]:** It's kind of awesome. um So, uh So, this picture when it's unfolded, first off, you know what it is for a free particle. So, we want the energy as a function of Q.

**[26:30]:** So, what is it for a free particle? Parabola. Yeah, exactly. Okay? Okay. And now, let's add in the And let's make this a This is a function of Q, not Q naught, but So, here's um pi over L. Here's 2 pi over L. Here's 3 pi over L. And I need to do this carefully cuz it's incredibly difficult to get this straight. Okay. uh Call that. And then, Okay.

**[27:07]:** My artistic skills are um not exactly the thing of legend. Okay, so um So, here's the parabola that would have been if we had not modded turned on a a periodic potential. As we turn on the periodic potential, we know that the energies the allowed energies change. And we So, in the first band, it's easy to see because from minus pi over L to pi over L, we don't have to do anything. pi over L minus. So, it looks exactly the same as the lowest band here. So, in particular,

**[27:37]:** Okay? So, what about the second band? Well, what I want to know what's the allowed at the other allowed energy at at say plus pi over L. So, at plus pi over L, it's going to be something greater than this value. But plus pi over L, we don't already know the answer from that diagram because the plus pi over L is the same as minus pi over L. So, what's the value over here? Well, the value over there for the second band is slightly above and then it increases and decreases. So, slightly above and then it increases.

**[28:06]:** Shift by pi over L. Whoops. uh Did I shift by pi over L? This is this guy. That's 1 2. um do do do Yes, I did. Good. Okay, and it goes the other way. So, just noting that it goes the other way from the top. um uh Let's see. I have a hard time drawing these things. Okay? So, for every value of Q, there's an allowed energy, but it's different than it would have been for the free particle. And then, we do the same thing for the next state. um And it looks like this.

**[28:47]:** And so, now imagine what happens. We take this and we fold it over once, twice. What we get is a band that looks that should look like this. That's That's what the second band should look like. Right?

**[29:00]:** Okay? And indeed, when we put it in the fundamental domain, this is what we get. This is what the first band and the second band together look like. And then, the third band, we'll move this over once and then twice, it's going to look like this. And this guy, move it over once, twice, looks like whoops.

**[29:20]:** Good? Yeah.

**[29:30]:** If we just wanted to If we wanted to plot Sorry, say again? E as a function of K instead of Q. Oh, yeah. E as a function of K is always going to look like that, but K is not a well So, what is K? K for is just defined as H bar squared K squared upon 2 m is equal to E. So, this doesn't tell you anything. Right? Cuz any loud K okay, sure any loud K is some valid value of E but this doesn't tell you which values of E are allowed. Only some values of E are allowed, right? There are no values of E, there are no energy I can states with energy in between here and here. Right? And so that tells you there are no allowed Ks because K is just defined it's just completely defined by E. So this doesn't tell you anything about which states are allowed it just tells you that a given an E there's some quantity I can define K.

**[30:12]:** This is a definition of K in terms of E. What this diagram is telling you is which Es are allowed.

**[30:21]:** Is sorry, say again. In An L? Um Yes. Yes, there should be a yes. Um let's see let's uh Q Um Uh sorry. Uh oh oh here. Yes. Yeah, you're absolutely right. Um um over L. Thank you. Excellent. That's exactly right. Yeah. Oh man, I made a dimensional mistake. Thank you. Jesus. Okay. Um Good. Yeah. Uh another question is can you like re-explain sort of like how imperfections in a lattice actually contribute to the conduction process? Yeah, I'm going to do that. So so that's a that's an excellent question. The question is could you explain again how imperfections in a lattice lead to actual conduction? As we talked about last time um when you have a perfect lattice there is actually no current flowing in response to uh an an applied electromagnetic field. If you put on a a capacitor plate across your perfect lattice you don't get any current.

**[31:23]:** The the particle the charged particle in your lattice just oscillates back and forth in a block oscillation running up the band and down the band up the band and down the band. So um how does that uh so Let me slightly change your question and turn it into two other questions. The first question is um given that that's obviously not what happens in real materials uh why don't we just give up on quantum mechanics and say it totally failed? Right? And so there this is a totally reasonable question and I want to emphasize something important to you which is the following. That model led to a prediction which is that if you put a capacitor plate across a perfect crystal then you would get no current flowing across you would just see that the electron wave packets oscillate all the block oscillations as discussed last time.

**[32:06]:** Um and that is manifestly not what happens with copper. But the experimentalist comes back and says look dude you that is ridiculous model cuz the copper isn't in fact perfect. It's messy. So how do you test the model? Well, there are two ways to test to to deal with the situation. One is you improve the model to incorporate properties that copper actually has and see if you can actually get the same conductivity that you see. But the other is you could improve the material instead of improving the theory. So let's make up let's can we actually build a perfect crystal? So this is actually something that I'm doing research on right now not on the building side but on the theory side cuz I'm a theorist and you should not let me in lab. Um uh But I I collaborate with experimentalists. So um they're nice people.

**[32:50]:** So very good physicists. So here's something you can do. You can build a system that has exactly a periodic potential. It turns out it's very difficult to do this with quantum systems but what you can do is you can do it with um lattices not of atoms but lattices of dielectric. So the equation here's a cool fact the equation for light going through a dielectric where the dielectric has different constant like wave guides you've got glass you've got air you've got glass you've got air that equation can be put in exactly the same form as a Schrödinger equation for the time evolution of a wave function. They're both waves and so it's not so surprising that these two wave equations are related to each other in a nice way. Meanwhile the index of the dielectric turns into the potential for the quantum mechanical problem. So if you have a periodic potential what do you want?

**[33:44]:** You want a periodic dielectric constant. Yeah? And so you can build a system which incredibly cleanly has a periodic dielectric constant and no disorder. And then you can put light into the system and you can ask what happens to this system. So here's the idea. I take a a system which is a periodic potential I'm going to draw the the potential here. Sorry the um the the so I'm going to draw the dielectric constant. So it's small large small large small large small large etc. Okay. But instead of having it be a one-dimensional lattice I'm going to make it a two-dimensional lattice. So now basically I've got a a set of wave guides or let me draw this slightly differently.

**[34:37]:** Okay.

**[34:41]:** So does everyone get the picture here? So literally what you have is you have glass glass with a different index glass glass with a different index. You can think of this as a line of glass fibers of optical fibers. And you shine in light that's reasonably well localized in both position and in phase variation or crystal momentum because you can control the phase of the light. So you send this wave packet in and you ask what happens. Well not a whole lot happens. It's a it's a wave packet. It's it's going through a a wave guide and but we haven't implemented an electric field. To implement electric field you need a the potential to be constantly varying. Aha. So let's add a linear ramp into the potential. Instead of making it just perfectly periodic let's make the index ramp just a little bit. This experiment has been done.

**[35:26]:** And this experiment so as the wave packet moves along what's discovered is that the position if I draw the X as a function of T and so now the role of T is being played by the distance it's moved along the wave guide what you find is it does this. It exhibits beautiful block oscillations. And uh this has been probed in a very small number of real honest quantum mechanical systems. Um the most elegant experiment that I know of was done by Wolfgang Ketterle who's here at MIT um and he got three data points because it was preposterously difficult and declared victory. So I I talked to him about this in the hallway one day he said yes this was ridiculous but we got three data points we got small we got large and victory. We we declared victory but it really needs to be done well.

**[36:11]:** So one of the one of the interesting questions in the in this part of the field right now we know that it's true but we want to see it we want to feel it. So um various people around the world are working on making a truly beautiful demonstration of this bit of physics. Yeah.

**[36:29]:** Is it a

**[36:34]:** Uh it's totally impractical cuz any any interferences just going to kill you. Yeah, unfortunately. So I mean you have to work ridiculously hard to make systems clean. So the the question is really a question about quantum computation which will come to you next week. Um but um uh the basic question is how robust is this and the answer is it's not robust at all. But which you can tell because everything in the real world has enough impurity that it conducts uh or is an insulator. Yeah. Um what plays sort of like the larger role in sort of like the perfection of a lattice like temperature or impurities? That's a very good question. So the question is what's the most important um uh property uh what's the most important disordering property that leads to conduction? And you know there's there's temperature fluctuations there are impurities in in the lattice um there are decohering effects which you know are is a more complicated story and that's actually it it depends on the situation depends on the

**[37:27]:** system and exactly how it depends is an open is is something that is an active area of research. Now there are many many ways to probe this physics. So we know that these block oscillations are true and we see them in all sorts of different systems that are analogous. Um so there's there's lots of experiments it's not like this is an ambiguous bit of physics. Um but it's one that turns out to be surprisingly difficult to tease apart. The reason I bring all this up is to emphasize the following. Our model made a prediction that disagreed explicitly with with the conductivity property of copper and other materials. So don't throw away the model observe that you've modeled the wrong system. If you find a system that fits your that that is uh that shares the assumptions of your model that's when you ask did it work and it worked like a champ.

**[38:09]:** Okay? So now let's talk about real materials. This is going to close up our discussion of bands in solids. Um and this is actually what I wanted to get to at the beginning of the lecture. But that's okay. There are lots of questions and they were good questions. Um so this is going to be extremely brief. But I want to ask you the following question. What happens uh in the following three systems? So first imagine we take uh imagine we take a um uh Imagine we take a system with a who built out of single wells which have uh some set of eigen of energy uh eigen states. Okay? And then we build a periodic array out of them. Okay? What do we expect and let me draw this bigger.

**[38:59]:** bounced bound state bounced What do we expect to see when we build a lattice? We expect that this is going to these states are going to spread out into bands of finite width. Yeah? And let's just talk about the one-D potential. So what we'll find is that this band turns into or sorry the state the single state turns into a band of allowed energy eigen states.

**[39:21]:** Okay. So this is now a plot of the energy. And similarly this state is going to lead to another band with some width.

**[39:37]:** And this state is going to lead to another band which is even wider.

**[39:47]:** Everyone cool with that?

**[39:51]:** Quick question, in 1D, do these bands ever overlap? No, by the node theorem, right? Okay, now let's take a single electron and let's put in let's let's take a single electron, let's put it in the system. What will happen? Well, if we put it in the system, what state will this single electron fall into? Yeah, one of the bands, but which state? Yeah, if you kick the system around, you let it relax a little bit, it's going to fall down into the ground state. You have to couple it to something else, like hydrogen has to be coupled to electromagnetic field to decay, but couple it, kick it, and let it decay, and it'll it'll settle down to its ground state. So, you get an electron down here in the ground state, and looking back at that band, we know that the band for that ground state looks like this.

**[40:33]:** This guy. So, here it is. There's our electron, it's sitting in the lowest energy eigenstate. Is it moving?

**[40:44]:** Well, it's in a stationary state. It's the ex- expectation value of the position changing in time. No, the expectation values don't change in time in a stationary state. That's part of what it is to be a stationary state, to be an energy eigenstate. Okay, great, it's not moving. Now, in order to make it move, what do you have to do? What kind of state corresponds to the position changing in time? Yeah, superposition, right? From the superpositions, we'll get interference terms. So, if we put it in a superposition of say this state and this state, which corresponds to different energies, if we put it in a superposition of these guys, then it's it's it's meaningfully moving. Yeah? It has some meaningful, well-defined time variation of its position expectation value. So, in order to induce a current, in order to induce a current of this system where the electron wave packet carries a little bit of momentum, is changing in time its position, what do I have to do to

**[41:40]:** the electron in the ground state? I have to excite it so that it's in a superposition of the ground state and the excited in some excited state, or more generally into a superposition of other states. Yes? In order to induce a current, I must put the the electron into a higher energy state, and in particular superposition of higher energy states. Everyone down with that? Here's why this is so important. Imagine each one of these wells is actually not some square well, but it's an atom. Okay. And let's say the atom is hydrogen, just for you know, you know, this doesn't actually happen, but just imagine. So, in particular, what I mean is it has the ion, the nucleus has charge plus one. And so, in order for the system to be neutral, I must have one electron for every well. So, if I have N wells, I must have N electrons in the system.

**[42:29]:** Everyone agree with that? In order to be neutral, otherwise the thing's charged and all sorts of terrible thing, you know, electrons will get ripped off of nearby cat. So, we must have an electron per well. How many states are in this band? For N wells. N, right? N states. Okay, so what if I put in the N electrons I need to neutralize the system, where do those N electrons go? Yeah, they fill up the first band. And if we let the system relax to its lowest lowest energy configuration, every state in this lowest band will be filled, and none of these states will be filled. Everyone down with that? So, now here's my question. When I've got that ground state configuration of this lattice of atoms with one electron per well in these distributed wave functions, filling out these bands, is anything moving? Why you guys are so quiet today?

**[43:23]:** Is anything moving? The system is in an energy eigenstate. In particular, it's in a completely antisymmetrized configuration because they're identical fermions. Okay. So, nothing is moving. If we want to induce a current, what do we have to do?

**[43:41]:** Yeah, we have to put them in a superposition. But where's the next allowed energy eigenstate? Next band. So, it's in the next band, it's the next allowed energy eigenstate. So, the configuration we have now is that these guys are all filled. These guys are all empty, but in order to take an electron from here and put it into this excited state, we have to put in a minimum amount of energy, which is the gap between those two bands. Right? So, now think about it this way. Suppose I take light and I send my light at this crystal. In order for the light to scatter off the crystal, you must have electrons in superposition states so that they can have a dipole and absorb and and radiate that energy. Yeah? But in order for that to happen, the light has to excite an electron across the gap.

**[44:35]:** It has to give it this macroscopic amount of energy. Well, it's not macroscopic, it's large. It's not infinitesimally small. That means that there's a minimum amount of energy that that incident light must have in order to excite the electron in the first place. So, very long wavelength light will never do that. Light of long wavelength will not have enough energy to excite an electron across this gap into the next band to allow there to be a current which could oppose the electric field. So, the only way for light to scatter off of this crystal is if the energy, which bar omega, of the light is greater than or equal to, well, let's just say greater than or approximately the band gap delta E. That cool? We've just discovered something. Crystals are transparent unless you look at sufficiently high frequencies. That's cool. Right? A crystal is transparent unless you look at sufficiently high frequencies.

**[45:34]:** If you look at low frequencies, your crystal should be transparent. Well, that's really interesting. In particular, we immediately learn something cool about two different materials. Consider diamond and copper. These are both crystals. They're solids made out of exact a regular array, perhaps not perfect, but extraordinarily good, regular array of atoms of the same kind. Arrayed in a particular structure, diamond and I think face-centered cubic, I don't remember. I really should know that. Anyway, copper is a lattice. So, um um that's embarrassing. I really shouldn't shouldn't know that. Um so, uh we have these two materials. Which one has the larger band gap? Diamond, cuz it's transparent at in the visible. So, the band gap delta E of diamond is much larger than the band gap for a copper. But in fact, this is a little more subtle because copper in fact, does it even have a band gap?

**[46:42]:** Ah, we're we made an important assumption here. So, I want to think about we're going to come back to copper in a second, but I want to point out the the nice thing here, which is that diamond has a very has to have a band gap. It's transparent. It must have a band gap. It must be such that when you fill up all the energies you all the electrons you need for it to be neutral, there's a gap to the next energy states, and that gap must be larger than visible wavelengths of light. Yeah? That's cool, and that must be true of all the transparent crystals that you see. Otherwise, they wouldn't be transparent. They would respond by having free electrons that could respond like a like a metal. Yeah.

**[47:25]:** Yeah. Is copper good or is are diamonds good conductors? No, they're terrible conductors. In fact, they're preposterously the the the if you compare the number of Well, okay, I'll get into this later, but yes, they're terrible. Uh that's a slightly more complicated story, which let me come back to. Hold on to that, and if I don't answer it today, ask me after in office hours cuz it's a little more What? Really? Wow.

**[48:01]:** Well, MIT. Okay, um it's all about the intellect. Um and everything else has to wait. Okay, so so this is pretty good, but but here's the thing. In one-dimensional crystals, the only thing that can happen is Look, if you have each band comes from an allowed energy state, and each energy state each each each each well comes with one electron or two electrons or three electrons, you will always have filled bands and then a gap and then filled bands and then a gap. Does everyone agree with that? You can't have a partially filled band if each band comes from a bound state in a single well, and each well comes with an integer number of electrons. You're just you're stuck. Yeah. Sp- I'm lying about spin, but spin in one spin in one dimension is a little I'm lying about spin. Okay. But do you really want me to get into spin?

**[48:56]:** Man, okay, so if we include spin and we have splittings between then it becomes a more subtle story. If we include spin, then there are two states for every allowed energy eigenstate of the potential. However, there are generically going to be interactions between the uh there are generically going to be magnetic interactions which split the energy of those two spin states. An electron with spin up and electron with spin down will generically have different energies. Now, in 3D, this isn't such a big deal because those splittings are tiny, and so the states can sort of overlap, but in 1D, they they can't. So, uh I mean, that that's also not exactly true, but it depends on exactly the detail. So, it depends on the details of the system is what I wanted to get to. So, uh So, let's Ah, curse you. So, let's So, let me talk about the same phenomena in an easier context where we don't have to worry about spin, which we haven't discussed in detail in the class, which is in three dimensions, where the story changes

**[49:47]:** in a dramatic way. Yeah. I have just a question. Yeah. Why isn't it true that the energy gap is always the same between changes? Oh, it's not. No, generically it's not. It will depend. So, you're just saying that it's like even in the second part you're just saying it's 5.5. Yeah, exactly. I'm just saying it happens to be the salient one. The salient Yeah, exactly. Yeah. That That's exactly right. No, the gaps are not the same. They They They do not remain constant. That's right. Okay. So, let's talk more about this system, but let's talk about it in three dimensions. So, in three dimensions, you guys did an interesting thing when you studied the You didn't know that this was about the structure of solids, but it really was. When you studied the rigid rotor. And when you studied the rigid rotor, you found that you had energy eigenstates and they were degenerate with degeneracy 2L uh or uh 2L + 1.

**[50:33]:** Right? The various different LZ eigenstates. Yeah? And then we turned on an interaction, which was the energy cost the energy penalty for having angular momentum in the Z direction, which added an LZ term to the energy. And what you found is that as a function of the as a as a function of the coefficient, which I think we called epsilon um of that uh that perturbation of that the energy, so that the energy was equal to uh uh um L squared over two uh I um plus uh epsilon LZ. What you found is that these guys split. So, this remained constant and this split whoops into uh So, this is degeneracy is L equals one, so the L equals zero, so this is one, this is three, this is five. So, the L equals zero state, nothing happens. The L equals one, there's one that changes, one that doesn't.

**[51:20]:** And then this guy has five, 1 2 3 4 5. Okay. And what we found here was that these guys could cross. States from different multiplets with different values of L had energies that could cross as a function of the strength of the deformation of your system. Right? The deformation here was you have a sphere and you stick out your arm. So, it's no longer a symmetric top. Um So, here we can have states crossing. There's no node theorem in three dimensions. So, as a consequence, when you have a three-dimensional uh material built out of atoms, so here's my sort of pictorial description of three-dimensional system built out of atoms. You have a potential well potential potential well potential well. Now, if the energy in one particular potential well is like this and like this and like this, then when we add in a lattice, we get bands again.

**[52:16]:** The structure is a little more intricate because the it depends on the momentum, but these bands now can overlap.

**[52:28]:** Okay?

**[52:33]:** Everybody see that? Because there's nothing preventing states from different uh in different multiplets from having the same energy in three dimensions. There's no node theorem that tells you have to keep the ordering constant as you turn on the potential. Now, we turn on the the multiple particle potential and they can interact. They can overlap. As a consequence, when we fill up Let's say we have two electrons per potential or per well, when we fill up those first two bands, well, there is the first uh so the first band is now filled. The second band and part of the first or part of the third band and most of the second band are going to be filled, but part of the second band is now available and much of the third band is now available. We filled in two n electrons, but we haven't filled up this band because it's really two bands jammed together.

**[53:21]:** Or really the bands from two different orbitals jammed together. They happen to overlap. One sec. So, as a consequence here, if this is the the energy of the last electron that you put in, how much energy do you have to give the uh the system do you have to add to the system to excite the energy or to excite electrons into excited states and in particular into superpositions so that the electrons can move? Yeah, a preposterously small amount. An amount that goes like one over the number of particles. Right? So, in the continuum limit it's zero. There's an arbitrarily nearby energy. So, how much energy does it take to excite an electron and cause a current that that opposes the the induced electric field? Nothing. Any electric field that you send in will be opposed by a by an induced current. And so, this behaves like a classical conductor.

**[54:11]:** You turn on an electric field and the charges will flow to oppose that externally imposed electric field. You get charges then building up on the walls of your capacitor plates. Cool? So, this is a system where we have a conductor

**[54:30]:** because there's an unfilled band.

**[54:37]:** And back here, we had an insulator

**[54:44]:** because we had filled bands separated by gap.

**[54:55]:** With a gap between the filled band and the next available band. Okay? This is actually called a band insulator cuz there's other ways of being an insulator, but um So, from this so far, just from the basic quantum mechanics of a particle in a periodic potential, we now understand why some crystals are transparent, why some materials conduct, why the materials that are transparent are also insulators, and the things that conduct are not transparent, right? Generally. Yeah. Why Why are there you not seeing band overlap in diamond? Like why would you Excellent. Excellent question. So, what's so special about diamond and different from copper? And so, the answer goes like this. So, what determined the exact band structure in for a 1D periodic potential? Two properties. One was L, the periodicity, and that came in the QL and KL, right? And the second is the the detailed shape of the potential.

**[55:56]:** Now, in three dimensions, the story is going to be a little more complicated. In three dimensions, the things that are going to determine the potential are not just the distance between atoms, but you have a three-dimensional lattice. And the three-dimensional lattice could have different shapes. It could be cubic. It could be hexagonal. You know, it could be complicated in all sorts of different ways, right? It could be bent, it could be rhomboidal, and and it could have all sorts of different crystallographic structures. So, that's going to go into it in the same way that L went into it, which is the only parameter in one dimension, the in the same way that L goes into it. So, the crystal structure the the shape of the lattice is going to determine. Secondly, the structure of the orbitals is different. Different atoms are different wells, so they'll give you different band structure.

**[56:32]:** So, different materials, for example, diamond versus copper are going to give you different bands of allowed energies because the potential is different, right? It has a different shape and So, when you solve the problem for the energy eigenvalues as a function of now the three different components of the crystal momentum, you'll just get a different set of equations. And working those out is not terribly hard um but uh it it does you know, it's a computation that must be done and it's not trivial. And so, one of the sort of I don't know if I'd say exciting, but one of the things that one does when one takes a course in solids is you go through a bunch of materials and you understand the relationship between the potential the the atomic orbital structure of the individual atom, the crystal structure, and the resulting band structure.

**[57:13]:** And there's some sort of nice mnemonics and then there's simple There're calculations that you do to get the answer. So, if you went up high enough, would you see overlapping bands a little far away from where the electrons are? Where the electrons where the states actually where the electrons are? Um you will almost always find overlapping bands in three dimensions at sufficiently high energy. Yeah, I I can't off the top of my head give you a theorem about that, but yeah, it's generic. Yeah. So, there is no such analog to a conductor in one dimension if you have these like look like reason like non-zero band gaps? Yeah, and and this is why Matt was barking at me. Um so, the answer the answer to that is yeah, there there are there are analog systems. Well, what would we need? What we need is we need one of two things.

**[57:54]:** We need either the the band gap coincidentally is ridiculously small. What's a good example of that? A free particle. In the case of a free particle, these band gaps go to zero. Right? And so, that's a conductor. Right? It's just a electron. Right? It conducts, right? Okay. So, that can certainly happen, but that's sort of stupid. I mean, it's not totally stupid, but it's sort of stupid. But a better answer would be Well, can you have a system where there are bands, but you didn't have one electron per per per potential well? And yeah, you can orchestrate that in lots of ways. Um now, in it involves orchestration. So, it's not the generic system that we were talking about here. But you can orchestrate it. So, spin is a useful thing that gives you a an extra If you have twice as many states per well, then you can have half a band filled.

**[58:41]:** Right? So, that's one way to do it. Um but then it becomes dependent on details of the system, which is what I didn't want to get into. But uh but yeah, you can orchestrate this. It's just not a generic thing from what we've done in Schrödinger after spinless systems. Um on the other hand, accidental um small gaps easy. That happens. That certainly happens. So, that brings me to the last thing I wanted to talk about before getting to entanglement, which is accidental small gaps. So, what happens to a system which is So, there are some systems that are neither conductors nor insulators. Um they are reasonably good conductors and reasonably bad insulators, but they're not perfect. Um How And these materials are called semiconductors. And I want to talk about why they're called semiconductors um and and what that what that means. So, this is going to be very brief, then I'm going to give you your the we're going to get into entanglement.

**[59:35]:** So, consider a system exactly using the same logic we've used so far, which has the following property. We have two bands, and the bottom band is filled because we've got just the right number of charged particles. Bottom band is filled, and this guy is empty, but the gap is tiny. Okay? Delta E is very small. Now, Delta E has dimensions, it has units, right? So, when I say small, that doesn't mean anything. I need to tell you small compared to what. So, what's a salient thing that controls an energy scale for a real material? Well, the temperature. If you have a hot piece of copper, then the lattice is wiggling around, and every once in a while an an ion can hit one of the electrons and excite it give it some momentum, and so the there's a there's a an available reservoir of energy for exciting individual electrons.

**[1:00:21]:** If you have it really hot, what happens? Every once in a while an electron will get nailed by a little thermal fluctuation in the system and get excited above the gap. And now it's in a super and generically it's going to be in a superposition state of one of these excited states, so it's in general going to be moving. It can radiate. It will eventually fall back down. But you're constantly being buffeted. The sea of electrons is constantly being buffeted by this thermal fluctuation. And as a result, you constantly have electrons being excited up, cruising around, falling back down. So, you end up with some population of electrons. And you can ask, and Boltzmann asked, although not quite in this language, how likely are you to get an electron up here? How likely is an electron to be to be excited up thermally? And those of you who are taking 8.044 will know the answer to this.

**[1:01:03]:** The probability goes as E to the minus um delta E over KT. So, let's think about where this is the Boltzmann constant. So, what does this mean? At very low temperatures, if the gap isn't zero, then this is zero. It doesn't happen. But at large temperatures, the denominator here is large. If the temperature is large compared to the width of the gap, then this is a small number, and E to the minus a small number is close to one. So, at high temperature, you're very likely to excite electrons up here. And now if you have electrons up here, you have a bunch of available states down here, also known as holes, and you have a bunch of available electrons up here with lots of available states. So, at high temperature, material with a small gap, or at least at temperatures high compared to the size of the gap, basically a conductor.

**[1:01:45]:** And at low temperatures, it's basically an insulator. This is called a semiconductor. And there are notes on um conductor There are notes on the Stellar web page um that discuss uh in a little more detail what I just went through and show you how you build a transistor out of a semiconductor. Uh and the important bit of physics is just this. Okay. So, that finishes this up for gap or for the band gap systems for periodic potentials. We've done something kind of cool. We've explained why um why diamonds are transparent. We've explained why they don't conduct. We've explained why copper does and it's opaque. And that's pretty good for 15 minutes of work, you know, it's not bad. Um but what along the way we also talked about the analogous system of photons of what are called photonic crystals, systems of periodic arrays of dielectrics, like wave guides.

**[1:02:38]:** And those have the same structure. They have uh bands of allowed energy and gaps of disallowed energies where no waves propagate through. So, you might think that's a little bit of a ridiculous example, so just to close this off, you've all seen a good example of a photonic crystal flying past you. You know that highly reflective at very specific frequency structure on the surface of a butterfly wing that makes it shiny and blue? It looks metallic. It looks like it's a crystal reflecting at a specific frequency at some sharp blue. And the reason is it's a photonic crystal. It is exactly of this form. It's if you look at it under a microscope, you see little arrays of protein which have different dielectric than air. And they form exact crystals, or not exact, but very good crystals, that reflect at very specific wavelengths. And as a consequence, they have a metallic sheen.

**[1:03:30]:** So, why would a why would a a butterfly put a photonic crystal on its surface? Well, it's extremely light. It's fairly rigid. It looks shiny and metallic without actually being shiny and metallic, and it's not a pigment, so it doesn't absorb light and decay over time. It's like the best thing you could ever do if you wanted to be a shiny fluttery flying thing. So, that's what Anyway, so there's an incredible amount of physics in this story of the band gaps um and the consider this an introduction to the topic. Okay. So, that's it for band gaps, and I want to move on to the remainder, the last topic of our course, which is going to be entanglement and quantum computation. And here I need to give you one quick observation and then move on to the punchline of today. The one quick observation is this.

**[1:04:15]:** We've talked about identical particles before, and we've talked about identical particles in funny states. So, for example, imagine I have two particles um described by a wave function, where the first particle could be in the state A, uh and the second particle is in the state B. And I can build this a wave function for the first particle being in state A and second particle in state B in the following way. So, let's say position A and position B. I can take a single particle wave function chi of A, uh and a single particle wave function is phi of B. And we've talked about what this tells us, and you've studied this on your problem set. What this tells you is that the probability that find the particle at point A is given by chi A squared, and we this is normalized, so when we integrate against it, we get one.

**[1:04:57]:** And similarly, the probability that we find the second particle at B is this thing norm squared, and it's independent of what A is. But we also studied in the So, this was called the distinguishable. We also studied the the symmetric uh configuration, which is equal to chi oops one over root pi root two chi of A phi B minus oh, symmetric plus uh chi of B phi A. And this tells us something totally awesome. What's the probability that I find the particle at at the I find the first particle uh uh at A? What's the norm squared of chi of A phi B, right? We integrate over all phi B, this is the norm squared integrates to one, so it's just fine. So, there's a factor of one half. We either find it at uh chi of A or chi of B. However, if I tell you that I've measured the first particle and I find it in the state chi, what can you say about the second particle?

**[1:06:00]:** It's in the state phi. If you know the first particle is in the state chi, the second particle is in the state phi because it's we measured it and it's not in the state the first particle is not in the state phi. So, measuring one particle tells you something about the second particle. And this is deeply disconcerting because I could have taken these particles, put them in this entangled state, and sent one particle, you know, off to a distant planet, and the second particle to my sister in DC, and my sister measures this second particle and determines what state it's in, and is immediately determined what state the particle is the second the first particle is in over in this distant planet Zorg, right? So, that's deeply disconcerting. And to those of us who have studied quantum mechanics up to this point, which we all in this room have, um to those of us who have studied quantum mechanics to this level of development and understand that it

**[1:06:48]:** is a correct description of many experiments, this should be yet another moment of serious discomfort. We've run into a bunch of these over the semester, but this one should be troubling to you because look, how can something here dramatically change the state, the configuration, the initial configuration of a particle arbitrarily far away? Isn't that deeply concerning? And if you think about relativity, this should be all the more deeply disconcerting because how does relativistic causality fit into this? So, there was a person at roughly this time, you know, a little earlier, who was troubled by this problem, and his name is Einstein. And so, one of the things that's kind of amazing is that he uh he created an experiment he created a thought experiment, which we're going to study in detail next week, called the EPR experiment. And it there's a beautiful historical story about the setting and the meaning and and uh and the particular person, and unfortunately, I'm not a historian, so I can't tell you that that story.

**[1:07:37]:** Um it sure would be nice if we had someone who wrote a biography of Einstein to tell you a little bit about that story. Oh look, it's Tom Levenson who wrote a biography about Einstein. SO, TOM IS

**[1:07:56]:** I NEED YOU, ALAN. OH, I NEED A MIC. YEAH. THIS WAY GOOD. SORRY.

**[1:08:04]:** SO, those of you who have taken courses in SHASS, and I'm sure that's all of you because of the GIRs, um no, this is larger than the usual SHASS class. So, I'm not used I'm very used to microphones, but not in this context. Okay. Is this Yeah, it's on. Can you hear me? All right. Um so, um there are lots of ways to slice the story of Einstein by the time he reaches the EPR experiment, which is Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen for the three people who actually wrote the paper. Um the you know, just to to to to dot dot the eyes and and cross the Ts on the paper itself, um Rosen is apparently the first person who first came to Einstein. Podolsky and Rosen were two young physicists um in Princeton after Einstein moved to Princeton. Einstein moved to Princeton in 1933, um about 3 weeks before uh I'm sorry, he moved to Princeton in '33.

**[1:09:05]:** He left Germany in 1932, December, about 3 weeks before Hitler took power. Um and he did so uh with decisiveness and dispatch and ahead of almost all of his In fact, I think all of his German Jewish physicist colleagues and those Germans for whom the German physicist for whom the Hitler regime was unacceptable. Which shows that Einstein really was smarter than most of his peers. It's one of the many different ways you can you can ascertain that. Um and so he came to Princeton in 30 he he did he actually went to Caltech before he went to Princeton uh on uh as part of an ongoing uh visitorship he had there. Came back to Europe. Hung with the Queen of Belgium who was a friend of his. Uh went to England. Um and then uh and then headed across the Atlantic and took up residency in Princeton at the Institute for Advanced Studies.

**[1:10:01]:** Uh where he stayed for the rest of his life. Um and over the course of the you know that was 33 he died in 55 I think. Uh I should know that but that's I think that's right. 22 years. Um he worked with a lot of different uh mostly younger physicists. Uh and Podolsky and Rosen were were early members of that chain. So Rosen is talking with him someday and and starts to frame this experiment. Einstein develops it. Uh the three of them talk about it. They write the paper and they and they put it out. And um I want to share with you actually a really lovely description of the way the problem was uh was um represented uh in a way by um uh in a by Dan by um I'm sorry. Um This is from a book that I recommend to all of you.

**[1:10:52]:** It's actually really it's it's hard to find. It's really Jeremy Bernstein uh who is a physicist. Uh he's sort of been around physicist and writer. He's he's in his 80s now. He lives in Aspen. Uh he worked at uh he worked with CERN for a number of years. He's always been an independent. He wrote for the New Yorker. Um anyway. So um you've all heard of the physicist Bell I assume. Bell's inequality? Okay. Um so Bell had a lovely way to describe um I'm trying to find I had this marked and then I lost my piece of paper in it. Um uh base I have I have already lost it. That's terrible. So Bell has this wonderful way of describing um uh this problem of entanglement and it's based on his description of an actual person. I was going to read you his actual quote and I'm just going to paraphrase it for you.

**[1:11:46]:** Uh he had a a friend named I think Berelstein. Or at least someone known to him. Um who had two quirks. Uh an unusual color sense and a and a taste for mismatched socks. Um and so Bell used to say if you saw Berelstein and you could only see one leg and that sock was pink you knew to a certainty you know that the other sock was not pink. There are he comes up I think I'm not I'm trying to remember who this is originally attributed to. Um same thing if you have a coin and you cut it in half down the down the you know um uh so you've got two coin shaped discs. You cut the disc in half not not and you have one side that's the head and the other side that's the tail. Um and they're separated you know they get handed to two different gamblers and one gambler tries to cheat the gambling establishment by tossing in his half coin and you see the head that you know somebody someone at some

**[1:12:49]:** other casino somebody else is cheating by tossing in the half coin that only has a tail on it. So there are lots of ways to represent this and and many physicists being very witty indeed have come up with different uh different uh little metaphors for it. Um So Alan just described for you um the basic claim in EPR. It's weirdness that you you have two particles that are entangled in some way and then go their separate ways. And um thus you have uh if you have knowledge of what's the state of one you have uh certain knowledge of the state of the other violating uh you know relativistic ideas of locality and just kind of making you queasy if you're sort of approaching it naively. Um what Einstein Podolsky and Rosen argued was actually something a little bit you know in fact the paper comes to an end on that note of queasiness.

**[1:13:51]:** But what they argued was a little bit more subtle. Cuz what they said is okay um you perform this thought experiment. You send the two particles off. Uh you measure position of one you know absolutely the position of the other. That has you you've conferred and the the paper turns on a discussion of the connection between a measurement and a a physical measurement and a property of physical reality. And they have a definition for what reality is. Uh and that is something whose um if you can perform a measurement you know that quantity absolutely. It's a it's you know I I don't have the mathematics to express that properly but that's that'll do for this hand waving experiment. And it says you can then do another experiment and measure a complementary property and you know that piece of reality. Which you can't do the so so on the one hand quantum mechanics says you can't know these uh you can't know physical reality to this level of of of precision and on the other hand um the the the

**[1:14:59]:** fact that you can do that measurement violates the relativistic um the relativistic picture of reality. Uh so you have what they claimed was a paradox. And you know this paper was published um and uh it received a a range of reactions from indifference by younger physicists who said we don't care that it's weird we're going to keep on doing quantum mechanics and performing experiments and making measurements and to see where this leads us. Remember this is happening in the mid-30s 1935.

**[1:15:35]:** One of these three books will tell me precisely in a moment. Um and uh you know the the quantum theory as it as it turned into quantum mechanics developed in its first period between 23 and 27 and by 35 you have you know enormous numbers of productive results and unexpected things and you know the prediction of the positron and then it's then it's uh observation and I you know I mean the the the theory is enormously dramatically excitingly productive. Uh so those who are really you know heads down doing the work are for the most part saying you know this is you know fine. You know we'll get back to it when we're old and retired and bored. Um and but that's that wasn't the uniform case and uh most notably Niels Bohr found this paper really troubling. And uh spent about uh six weeks apparently discussing this and trying to come up with a response to it.

**[1:16:32]:** And what he responded was essentially that you know um I mean in some ways it was the same reaction as his younger colleagues. Get over it. Uh but more precisely it was he said you can't there's no description of reality that excludes the measuring apparatus anymore. You can't uh you can't make statements about physical reality unless you include a description of the measuring apparatus. And you've said that we can measure this one quantity with precision and know the other thing and then we can subsequently in a separate observation measure a complementary quality and know the other other one. You still can't know them at the same time. Um it's still true that this that these complement that complementarity in essence means that once you know one part of the one one part of the picture you know some other part of the picture. Um and that's just the nature of of the quantum world.

**[1:17:27]:** Einstein had argued that the EPR paradox suggested that quantum mechanics was incomplete and Bohr essentially responded in effect that Einstein's description of quantum mechanical explanation was inadequate. And the important thing to remember and I want to just spend a couple minutes going back uh into the prehistory of all this um and then a couple minutes speculating on why Einstein reached the position he did and what that might tell you about the practice of science as a lived experience as opposed to one remember you know reflected in your textbooks. Um but the thing to remember is that there's nothing logically wrong with the EPR paper. Right? You know? It's it's you know it does what it says it does and there's no overt error in it. And there's nothing wrong with Bohr's response and in fact when the experiments were you know Bell formalized um the what what Bell's inequality really does is it formalizes the two arguments.

**[1:18:34]:** It says if Bohr is right you will observe this in the experiment and if Einstein is right you would have uh uh observe something different. The experiments were done and I imagine are still being done as as sort of demonstrations and they show that Bohr's interpretation was correct and that yes quantum mechanics produces results that are non-local just as Alan Alan described to you uh and that the world really is as strange as people first glimpsed in 1925 26 and 27. And um and the question of whether or not that strangeness is adequately explained whether or not the explanations that you're going to learn in this class and subsequent ones are quote complete or not. Completeness is a very funny very very tricky concept. But whether you know the question of whether or not you know, the framework of quantum mechanics um is somehow unsatisfactory in any kind of formal or technical sense uh is one that's at least partly dependent on your scientific

**[1:19:34]:** temperament, I think. So, um So, that's the that's the cartoon version of what happened in '35. Einstein with his two young colleagues proposes um a disc- I mean, really you should understand the EPR paper as a description in detail of a consequence of quantum theory as it was then expressed with the conclusion, and I just want to read you this thing. No reasonable definition of reality could be expected to permit such a result. You know? So, in fact you know, it's called a paradox, but it isn't. It's a complaint. You know, it's a memo to, you know, the Flying Spaghetti Monster that the universe shouldn't be this way if in fact experiments turn out to show that it is, and they have. Um So, the oddity here for a biographer of Einstein as opposed to physicist is, given what you know about Einstein between 1879 when he's born and say 1925 or so, when he completes the last of his really great

**[1:20:37]:** physics, um how could I mean, you know, it's it I actually keep you know, I've been working on Einstein off and on for years and years. I keep finding out new ways in which he's just s- you know, inconceivably you know, bright and on target and with a nose for the right problem and insightful and yet by the 1935, 10 years later, he's still a relatively young man. You know, he's in his 50s, um which being in my 50s I think is an extremely young man. Um You know, to just just 10 years after doing, you know, work that's right on the edge of the of, you know, of modern quantum mechanics that is essential to its foundation, that's, you know, I mean, really extraordinary. 10 years after that, he's saying no reasonable definition of reality should be, you know, should be permitted to to to behave this way.

**[1:21:30]:** How Where does that come from? Well, the first thing I want to tell you, again, this is all going to be a really cartoon version cuz there's not much time, I understand. Um Is it Einstein I mean, I I mean, how much of you are you aware of Einstein's role in the creation of the quantum theory? A lot I mean, a lot? None? Okay. Um Except, I mean, I I'm going to make a claim that except for Heisenberg, Schrödinger, maybe Bohr, maybe Born, maybe a couple of others, there's no one more important to the quantum theory than Einstein. And you can maybe even argue that from a sort of foundational point of view, that without Einstein rigorous thinking about the quantum mechanics would have taken much, much longer. I mean, he's really central to it. Uh Planck in 1900 uh publishes as an ad hoc solution to the blackbody problem um the first quantum theory.

**[1:22:28]:** Um in 1905 uh Einstein says it's not an ad hoc thing. If you look at the I mean, it's the photoelectric effect uh is is is the particular problem he's he's dealing with it with explanation, but that's really the the the behavior of the photoelectric effect is really presented as the confirmation of this idea that light exists as quanta with with particular kinds of behavior. And from 1905 on, he spends probably more time on quantum problems than he did on any other physics problem, certainly more than on relativity, though he spent, you know, enormous energy on special general relativity. Um One of the most amazing things about Einstein, in fact, is that despite the fact that, you know, he's seen and and and appears by 1935 to be this hidebound old guy who can't accommodate himself to the new world, is he had an extraordinary capacity to do what the Red Queen did in Alice in Wonderland and believe two impossible things before breakfast.

**[1:23:21]:** Just think of 1905. April, he publishes the quantum theory of light. June, he publishes special relativity, which treats light as a wave. And makes no mention of his revolutionary I mean, he called it revolutionary in a private letter in 1905. So, I mean, he knew what he had in the quantum theory of light. But in special relativity, go go read the special relativity paper. It's it's it's actually lovely reading. Um and you'll see it it He doesn't even nod in that direction. He doesn't say, you know, this is a heuristic I mean, this is nothing. So, he's he's capable of doing ex- I mean, there's a reason that year is called the Annus Mirabilis, the year the year of miracles. And in part, it's because Einstein is able to actually really focus on these things. And you know, I I realize class is almost over, so I'm there's several more steps in Einstein's quantum journey.

**[1:24:11]:** Um but, you know, what you should take away um is that I mean, Einstein's ability to deal with the problems of quantum pictures extends to the point he's the first person to suggest there might be a problem with causality in quantum mechanics. He does this in 1917, 8 years before quantum mechanics is invented, when he starts looking at what the the quote classical quantum theory tells you about um the emission of radiation from an excited atom. He realized you can't predict it precisely. Radioactive decay has the same problem. He says, "Well, you know, I don't want He writes in a letter, "I don't want to give up causality, but we may have to." So, you know, he's he's worried about these things. So, I see class is over now, 12:30? Yeah. Okay, sorry. So, I'll Just to finish up, the question here is why does Einstein give up on this?

**[1:25:02]:** And the answer, I think, is because in addition to his you know, as he started at the beginning of his career, he says, you know, with the quantum theory of light uh and with special relativity, ignore your physical pictures, try and look at the phenomena and explain those. And by 1935, that becomes very difficult for him because the phenomenology becomes too strange. One of the things that quantum mechanics does is it takes away the immediate visualizable visual- what the visualiza- uh the ability to visualize physical systems. There, English is my first language sometimes. Um And that's an aesthetic failure on Einstein's part. He had the intellectual capacity and explicitly said, "Quantum mechanics is a logically consistent theory that incredibly powerfully describes lots of problems." He said that in print. He nominated Schrödinger and Heisenberg for Nobel Prizes twice. I mean, he wasn't stupid. He was Albert Einstein.

**[1:26:05]:** But he was aesthetically incapable of pursuing this new physics in ways that were possible under the research you know, possibilities of the time. And that is what I would leave you with. Physics is an aesthetic as well as an intellectual pursuit. So, thank you all.
