# Lecture 4: Expectations, Momentum, and Uncertainty

**Channel:** MIT OpenCourseWare
**Source:** https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NN2txluv1PY
**Transcript page:** https://www.withtranscript.ai/video/NN2txluv1PY

## Chapters

- 0:00 — Chapter 1 (0:00)
- 1:05 — Chapter 2 (1:05)
- 3:17 — Chapter 3 (3:17)
- 5:16 — Chapter 4 (5:16)
- 7:29 — Chapter 5 (7:29)
- 8:23 — Chapter 6 (8:23)
- 8:43 — Chapter 7 (8:43)
- 14:44 — Chapter 8 (14:44)
- 16:01 — Chapter 9 (16:01)
- 18:40 — Chapter 10 (18:40)
- 27:08 — Chapter 11 (27:08)
- 31:56 — Chapter 12 (31:56)
- 35:17 — Chapter 13 (35:17)
- 36:54 — Chapter 14 (36:54)
- 38:14 — Chapter 15 (38:14)
- 46:55 — Chapter 16 (46:55)
- 48:45 — Chapter 17 (48:45)
- 51:04 — Chapter 18 (51:04)
- 53:52 — Chapter 19 (53:52)
- 54:21 — Chapter 20 (54:21)
- 58:34 — Chapter 21 (58:34)
- 59:16 — Chapter 22 (59:16)
- 1:00:03 — Chapter 23 (60:03)
- 1:04:06 — Chapter 24 (64:06)
- 1:05:59 — Chapter 25 (65:59)
- 1:08:27 — Chapter 26 (68:27)
- 1:12:24 — Chapter 27 (72:24)
- 1:12:51 — Chapter 28 (72:51)
- 1:15:07 — Chapter 29 (75:07)
- 1:17:05 — Chapter 30 (77:05)
- 1:18:28 — Chapter 31 (78:28)

## Transcript

**[0:00]:** The following content is provided under a Creative Commons license. Your support will help MIT OpenCourseWare continue to offer high-quality educational resources for free. To make a donation or to view additional materials from hundreds of MIT courses, visit MIT OpenCourseWare at ocw.mit.edu.

**[0:21]:** Anything lingering and disturbing or bewildering?

**[0:28]:** No? Nothing? All right. Okay, so the story so far

**[0:36]:** Important to get your coffee. The story so far is basically three postulates. The first is that the configuration

**[0:50]:** of a particle, whoops, config of a particle

**[0:58]:** is given by or described by a wave function

**[1:05]:** psi of x.

**[1:10]:** Yeah? So in particular, just to to flesh this out a little more, if we were in 3D, for example, which we're not, we're currently in our one-dimensional tripped-out tricycle, in 3D, the wave function would be a function of all three positions, x, y, and z. Um if we had two particles,

**[1:35]:** our wave function would be a function of the position of each particle, x1, x2, and so on. So we'll go through lots of details and examples later on, but for the most part, we're going to be sticking with single particle in one dimension for the next few weeks. Now again, I want to emphasize that this is our first pass through our definition of quantum mechanics. Once we've used the the language and the machinery a little bit, we're going to develop a more general, uh more coherent set of rules or definition of quantum mechanics, but this is our first pass. Two, the meaning of the wave function is that the norm squared, psi of x norm squared, it's complex, dx, is the probability of finding the problem of finding the particle

**[2:28]:** Um whoops, there's an n in there. Finding the particle in the region between x and x plus dx. So psi squared itself norm squared is the probability density. Okay? And third, the superposition principle. If I've If there are two possible configurations the system can be in, which in quantum mechanics means two different wave functions that could describe the system, given psi 1 and psi 2, two wave functions that could describe two different configurations of the system. For example, the particle's here or the particle's over here. It's also possible

**[3:17]:** It's also possible to find the system in a superposition, uh of the those two, psi is equal to some arbitrary linear combination alpha psi 1 plus beta psi 2 of x. Okay?

**[3:41]:** So some things to note. So questions about those before we move on. No questions? Nothing? Really? You're going to make me threaten you with something. I know there are questions. This is not trivial stuff. Hmm. Okay. Um So some things to note. The first is we want to normalize.

**[4:11]:** We will generally normalize and require that the integral over all possible positions of the probability density, psi of x norm squared, is equal to 1. This is just saying that the total probability that we find the particle somewhere had better be one. This is like saying if I know a particle is in one of two boxes, cuz I've put a particle in one of the boxes, I just don't remember which one, then the probability that it's in the first box plus the probability of the second box must be 100% or one. If it's less, then the particle has simply disappeared. And basic rule, things don't just disappear. So probability should be normalized. And this is our prescription. So a second thing to note is that all reasonable or non-stupid functions, psi of x, are equally reasonable as wave functions.

**[5:16]:** Okay? So this is a very reasonable function. It's nice and smooth. It converges to zero infinity. It's you know, it's got all the nice properties you might want. This is also a reasonable function. It's a little annoying, but there it is. And they're both perfectly reasonable as wave functions. This on the other hand, not so much. So for two reasons. First off, it's discontinuous, and as you're going to show on your problem set, um it discontinuities are very bad for wave functions. So we need our wave function to be continuous. The second is over some domain it's multi-valued. There are two different values of the function. That's also bad, cuz what's the probability? It's the norm squared, but if it has two values, two values for the probability, that doesn't make any sense. What's the probability that I'm going to fall over in 10 seconds?

**[6:00]:** Well, it's small, but it's not actually equal to 1% or 3%. It's one of those, right? So I just Hopefully it's much lower than that. So um all reasonable wave functions are equally reasonable All reasonable functions are equally reasonable as wave functions, uh and in particular, what that means is all states corresponding to reasonable wave functions are equally reasonable as uh as as physical states. There's no primacy uh in in wave functions or in states. However, with that said, some wave functions are more equal than others. Okay? And this is very This is important, and and coming up with a good definition of this is going to be an important challenge for us the next couple of lectures. So in particular, this wave function has a nice simple interpretation. If I tell you this is psi of x, then what can you tell me about the the particle whose wave function is this psi of x?

**[6:58]:** What can you tell me about it? What do you know? It's here, right? It's not over here. Probability is basically zero. Probability is basically Probability is large. It's pretty much here with with great confidence. What about this guy? Less informative, right? It's less obvious what this wave function is telling me. So some wave functions are more equal in the sense that they have, i.e., they have simple interpretations.

**[7:29]:** So for example, uh this wave function,

**[7:35]:** continuing on infinitely, this wave function doesn't tell me where the particle is, but what does it tell me? The momentum. Exactly. So this is giving me information about the momentum of the particle because it has a well-defined wavelength. So this one I would also say is more equal than this one. Uh they're both perfectly physical, but this one has a simple interpretation. And that's going to be important for us. Okay. Related to that is that any reasonable function Good. Any reasonable function, psi of x, can be expressed

**[8:17]:** as a superposition

**[8:23]:** of more equal wave functions.

**[8:29]:** Or more precisely,

**[8:35]:** uh easily interpretable

**[8:43]:** wave functions. Okay? We saw this last time in the Fourier theorem. The Fourier theorem said, "Look, take any wave function, take any function, but I'm going to interpret in the language of quantum mechanics. Take any wave function, which is given by some complex-valued function, and it can be expressed as a superposition of plane waves. Into 1 over root 2 pi in our normalization, integral dk, psi tilde of k, but this is a set of coefficients, e to the ikx. So what are we doing here? We're saying, "Pick a value of k. There's a number associated with it, which is going to be an amplitude and a phase, a magnitude and a phase. And that's the magnitude and phase of a plane wave, e to the ikx. Now remember that e to the i uh kx is equal to cos kx plus i sin kx, which you shall know, but just remind you, this is a periodic function.

**[9:36]:** These are periodic functions. So this is a This is a plane wave with a definite wavelength, 2 pi upon k. So this is a more equal wave function in the sense that it has a definite wavelength. We know what its momentum is. Its momentum is h bar k. Any function, we're saying, can be expressed as a superposition by summing over all possible values of K, all possible different wavelengths, any function can be expressed as a superposition of wave functions with a definite momentum. That makes sense? Fourier didn't think about it that way, uh but from quantum mechanics this is the way we want to think about it. Okay, it's just a true statement, it's a mathematical fact.

**[10:17]:** Questions about that? Similarly, I claim that I can expand the very same function, psi of x, as a superposition of states not with definite momentum, but of states with definite position.

**[10:34]:** So, what's a state with a definite position? Yeah, a delta function, exactly. So, I claim that any function, psi of x, can be expanded a sum over all of all states with a definite position, so delta of Well, what's a state with a definite position? x naught. Delta of x minus x naught. Okay, this is This goes bang when x naught is equal to x. Okay? But, I want to sum over all possible delta functions, that means all possible positions, that means all possible values of x naught. dx naught. And I need some coefficient function here. Well, the coefficient function I'm going to call psi of x naught.

**[11:13]:** So, is this true? Is it true that I can take any function and expand it in a superposition of delta functions? Absolutely, because look at what this equation does. This integral, remember delta function is your friend, it's a map from integrals to numbers or functions. So, this integral is an integral over x naught. Here we have a delta of x minus x naught, so it's This basically says the value of this integral is what you get by taking the integrand and replacing x by x naught. Set x equal to x naught, that's when delta is zero. So, this is equal to the argument evaluated at x naught is equal to x, that's just psi of x. Okay? Any arbitrarily ugly function can be expressed either as a superposition of states with definite momentum or a superposition of states with definite position. Okay? And this is going to be true, we're going to find that this is a general statement that any state can be expressed as a superposition of states with with a well-defined observable quantity for any observable quantity you want.

**[12:12]:** So, let me give you just a quick little bit of intuition. In 2D, this is a perfectly good vector, right? And here's a question I want to ask you. Is that a superposition?

**[12:25]:** Yeah, I mean, every vector can be written as the sum of other vectors, right? And it can be done in an infinite number of ways, right? So, there's no such thing as a state which is not a superposition. Every vector is a superposition of other vectors, it's a sum of other vectors. So, in particular, we often find it useful to pick a basis and say, "Look, I I know what I mean by the vector y y hat, so unit vector in this direction. I know what I mean by the vector x hat, so unit vector in this direction. And now I can ask, given that these are my natural guys, the guys that I want to attend to, is this a superposition of x and y, or is it just x or y?" Well, that's a superposition, whereas x hat itself is not. So, this somehow this is about finding a a convenient choice of basis.

**[13:16]:** But, any given vector can be expressed as a superposition of some pair of basis vectors or a different pair of basis vectors, right? There's nothing hallowed about your choice of basis. There's no God-given basis for the universe. It We look out in the universe in the Hubble Deep Field and you don't see somewhere in the Hubble Deep Field an arrow going x, right? So, there's no natural choice of basis, but it's sometimes convenient to pick a basis. This is the direction of the surface of the Earth, this is the direction perpendicular to it, right? So, sometimes particular basis sets have particular meanings to us. That's true in vectors, this is along the Earth, this is perpendicular to it, this would be slightly strange. I mean, maybe if you're leaning, um and similarly, this is an expansion of a function as a sum, as a superposition of other functions, and you could have done this in any good space of functions, we'll talk about

**[14:06]:** that more. These are particularly natural ones, they're more equal. These are ones with different definite values of position, different definite values of momentum. Everyone cool? Quickly, what's the momentum associated to the plane wave e to the i k x?

**[14:21]:** h bar k. Good. Okay. Um So, good. So, now I want to just quickly run over some concept questions for you. So, whip out your clickers. Okay, well, we'll do this verbally.

**[14:44]:** Okay. Um Oops. Oh. All right, let's try this again. So, how would you interpret this wave function? E. Solid. Yeah. All right. Um how do you know whether the particle is big or small by looking at the wave function?

**[15:04]:** Right? All right. Um two particles described by a plane wave of the form e to the i k x, particle one has a smaller wavelength than particle two. Which particle has a larger momentum? Think about it, but don't say it out loud.

**[15:21]:** Okay, and this sort of defeats the purpose of the clicker thing because now I'm supposed to be able to know without you guys saying anything. So, instead of saying it out loud, here's what I'd like you to do. Talk to the person next to you and uh discuss which one has the uh larger momentum.

**[16:01]:** All right, cool. So, So, which one has the larger momentum? How come? Right, smaller wavelength. p equals h bar k, k equals 2 pi over lambda. Solid? Okay. Smaller wavelength, higher momentum. If it has higher momentum, what do you just intuitively what do you expect to know about its energy? It's probably higher. Are you positive about that? No, you need to know how the energy depends on the momentum, but um but it's probably higher. So, this is an important little lesson that you probably all know from optics and maybe from quantum mechanics, shorter wavelength things, higher energy. Higher momentum for sure, usually higher energy as well. Um very useful rule of thumb to keep in mind. Okay. Indeed, it's particle one. Okay, next one. Um compared to the wave function psi of x, its Fourier transform, psi tilde of x, contains more information or less or the same or it's something but like Don't say it out loud, just Okay.

**[17:09]:** So, how many people know the answer? Awesome. And how many people are not sure? Okay, so there's still good. So, the people So, talk to the person next to you and convince them. Briefly.

**[17:43]:** All right. Good. So, uh nope. So, let's vote. A, more information. B, less information. C, the same. Yeah, okay, good. You got it. Yeah. All right. So, these are not hard ones. Um yay. Uh Okay. Uh this function, which is a sine wave of length L, uh zero outside of that region, uh which is closer to true? F has a single well-defined wavelength for the most part, it's closer to true. We this doesn't have to be exact. F has a single well-defined wavelength, or F is made up of a wide range of wavelengths. Mm. Okay, think it to yourself. Ponder that one for a minute.

**[18:40]:** Okay, now before before we get talking about it, hold on, hold on, hold on. I I want everyone since we don't have clickers, but I want to pull off the same effect, and we can do this cuz it's, you know, binary here. I want everyone close your eyes. Just close your eyes. Just for a moment. Yeah. Or close the person to close the eyes of the person next to you, that's fine. And And now And now I want you to vote. Okay, A is F has a single well-defined wavelength, B is F has a wide range of wavelengths. So, how many people think A, a single wavelength? Okay, close your close your or lower your hands. Good. And how many people think B, a wide range of wavelengths? Awesome. So, this is exactly what happens when we actually use clickers, it's 50/50. So, now you guys need to talk to the person next to you and convince each other of the truth.

**[20:23]:** All right. So, the the the volume sort of tones down as people I think come to resolution. Close your eyes again. Once more into the breach, my friends. So, um close your eyes and now let's vote again. f of x has a single well-defined wavelength. And now f of x is made up of a range of wavelengths. Okay, there is a dramatic shift in the field to B. It has a finite range or wide range of wavelengths, not a single wavelength. And that is in fact the correct answer. So, yay! Okay. So, um so learning happens. We've just That was an empirical test. Um So, um so does anyone want to defend this view that f is made of a wide range of wavelengths? Sure, bring it. Um so, the sine wave is an infinite and it cancels out past minus L over two and positive L over two, which means you need to add a bunch of wavelengths to actually cancel it out there.

**[21:15]:** Awesome. Exactly. Exactly. If you only had the the thing of a single wavelength, it would continue with a single wavelength all the way out. In fact, there's a nice way to say this. When you have a when you have a uh sine wave, what can you say about its uh we know that a sine wave is continuous and it's continuous everywhere, right? It's also differentiable everywhere. Its derivative is continuous and differentiable everywhere cuz it's a cosine, right? So, if you build if you take a superposition of sines and cosines, do you ever get a discontinuity? No. Do you ever get something whose derivative is discontinuous? No. So, how would you ever reproduce a thing with a discontinuity using sines and cosines? Well, you need some infinite sum of sines and cosines where there's some technicality about the infinite limit being singular. Like you can't do with a finite number of sines and cosines.

**[22:07]:** That function is continuous, but its derivative is discontinuous. Yeah? So, it's going to take an infinite number of sines and cosines to reproduce that little kink at the edge. Yeah. So, finite number of sines and cosines doesn't mean uh finite uh or an infinite number of sines and cosines doesn't mean infinite range of sines and cosines, right? Because over finite region, it's continuous itself. Uh that's true, but you need arbitrarily So, let's talk about that That's an excellent question. So, the the So, the question is as a very good question. The question here is Look, there's two different things you could be talking about. One is arbitrarily large and arbitrarily short wavelengths, so an arbitrary range of wavelengths. And the other is an infinite number. But an infinite number is silly cuz there's a continuous variable here, K. You can have an infinite number of wavelengths between one and 1.2, right?

**[22:55]:** It's continuous. So, which one do you mean? So, let's go back to this connection that we got a minute ago from short distance and high momentum. Okay? That thing looks like it has one particular wavelength. But I claim in order to reproduce that as a superposition of states with definite momenta, I need arbitrarily high wavelength. And why do I need arbitrarily high wavelength modes? Why do I need arbitrarily high momentum modes? Well, it's because of this. We have a kink. And this feature, what's the length scale of that feature? It's infinitesimally small, which means I'm going to have to be in order to reproduce that in order to probe it, I'm going to need a momentum that's arbitrarily large. So, it's really about the range, not just the number. But it's you need arbitrarily large momenta to to construct or detect an arbitrarily small feature.

**[23:50]:** You need arbitrarily large momentum modes. Yeah. Why do you phrase the definition that you need arbitrarily Why didn't you just say, "Oh, you need an arbitrarily small wavelength?" But why did you choose to phrase that I chose to phrase it that way because I want to emphasize and encourage I emphasize you to think and encourage you to uh to conflate short distance and large momentum. I want the connection between momentum and length scale to be something that becomes intuitive to you. So, when I talk about something with short features, I'm going to talk about it as something with large momentum. And that's because in a quantum mechanical system, something with short wavelength is something that carries large momentum. That cool? Great. Good question. Um so, earlier you said that like any reasonable wave function is like a a like a possible wave function. Yeah. Um does that mean it has to be Fourier transformable?

**[24:42]:** Yeah, that's usually a that's usually a a a condition. Yeah, exactly. What We don't We don't quite phrase it that way. And in fact, there's a problem on your problem set that will walk you through what we will mean uh what what should be true of the Fourier transform uh in order for this to be a reasonable wave function. And among other things, and your your intuition here is exactly right. Among other things, being able to have a a Fourier transform where you don't have arbitrarily high momentum modes is going to be an important condition. That's going to turn out to be related to uh the derivative being continuous. That's a very good question. So, that's the optional problem eight on problem set two. Okay. Um other questions?

**[25:21]:** All right. Cool. So, that's it for the clicker questions. Sorry for the technology fail. Um Okay. So, I'm just going to turn this off in disgust. Um Uh that's really irritating. Um so, So, today what I want to do is pick up what I want to start on is pick up on uh the discussion of the uncertainty principle that we sort of outlined previously. The fact that when we have a wave function with reasonably well-defined position, corresponding to a particle with reasonably well-defined position, it didn't have a reasonably well-defined momenta and vice versa. The certainty of the momentum seems to imply lack of under lack of knowledge about the position and vice versa. So, in order to do that, we need to define probability and in or define uncertainty. So, I need to define for you delta x and delta p. So, first I just want to run through what should be totally remedial probability, but it's always um it's always useful to to just remember how these basic things work.

**[26:25]:** So, consider a set of people in a room and I want to plot the number uh of people with a particular age as a function of the age. possible ages. So, let's say we have 16 people and at 14, we have one. And at 15, we have one. And at 16, we have three. Um and at 16, um and dot dot dot then at 20, we have two. Oops. And at 21, we have four.

**[27:02]:** And at 22, we have five.

**[27:08]:** And that's it. Okay. So, one one three uh two four five. Okay. So, what's the probability that any given person in this group of 16 has a particular age? I'll call it A. Okay. So, how do we compute the probability that they have age A? Well, this is easy. It's the number that have age A over the total number. Okay. So, note an important thing, an important side note, which is that the sum over all possible ages of the probability that you have age A is equal to one because it's just going to be the sum of the number with a particular age over the total number, which is just the sum of the number of with any given age.

**[28:03]:** So, So, here's some questions. So, what's the most likely age? If you grab one of these people from the room with a you know, giant erector set and pull out a person and let them dangle and ask them what their age is, what's the most likely age they'll have? 22. 22. Um on the other hand, what's the average age?

**[28:31]:** Well, just by eyeball, roughly what do you think it is? Yeah, somewhere around 19 or 20. It turns out to be 19.2 for this. Okay. But if everyone has a little sticker on their lapel that says I'm 14, 15, 16, 20, 21, or 22, how many people have the age 19.2? None, right? So, a useful thing is that the average uh need not be an observable value. This is going to come back to haunt us. Oops, 19.4. That's what I got. Um so, in particular, damn it. So, in particular, how did I get the average? So, let's just I'm going to define some notation. This notation is going to stick with us for the rest of quantum mechanics. The average age, how do I compute it? So, we all know this, but let me just be explicit about it. It's the sum over all possible ages of the number um of people of the number of people uh with that age times the age divided by the total number of people.

**[29:37]:** Okay?

**[29:40]:** So, in this case I'd go 14 14 16 16 16 20 20 21 21 21 21 22 2 2 2 2, right? And so, that's all I've written here. But notice that I can write this in a nice way. This is equal to the sum over all possible ages of A times the ratio of NA to N total. But the ratio of NA to N total, that's just the probability that any given person has a probability A. A times probability of A. So the expected value is the sum over all possible values of the value times the probability you get that value. Yeah? So I'm just going to This is the same equation, but we're going to box it. It's a very useful relation. And so again, does this have Does the average have to be measurable? No, it certainly doesn't. And it usually isn't.

**[30:29]:** So let's ask the same thing for the square of ages. What is the average of A squared? Square the ages. You might say, "Well, why would I ever care about that?" But let's just be explicit about it. So following the same logic here, uh the average of A squared, the average value of the square of the ages is Well, I'm going to do exactly the same thing. It's just A squared, right? 14 squared, 15 squared, 16 squared, 16, 16 squared. Um so this is going to give me exactly the same expression, sum over A of A squared probability of measuring A. Okay. And more generally, the the expected value or the average value of some function of A is equal This is something you don't usually do. It's equal to the sum over A of F of A, the value of F given a particular value of A times the probability that you measure that value of A in the first place.

**[31:27]:** Okay. It's exactly the same logic as uh averages.

**[31:37]:** Right? Cool. So here's a quick question. Uh is A squared equal to expect the expected value of A squared? Right. In general, no, not necessarily.

**[31:56]:** Right? So for example, um the average value So suppose we have a Gaussian centered at the origin. So here's A. Now A isn't age, but it's something I don't know. You include like infants and I don't know, whatever. It's not age. It's you know, happiness on a given day. So um what's the average value? Meh. Right? You know, it's sort of vaguely neutral, right? But on the other hand, if you take A squared, very few people have A squared is zero. Most people have A squared is not a zero value. And most people are sort of in the middle. Most people are sort of hazy on what the day is. Um So in this case, uh this is zero. Uh the expected value of A or the average value of A is zero, but the average value of A squared is not equal to zero.

**[32:43]:** Yeah? And that's because the square has everything positive. So how do we characterize This gives us a useful tool for characterizing the width of a distribution. So here we have a distribution where its average value is zero, but it's its width is non-zero. And then the expectation value of A squared, the expected value of A squared is non-zero. So how do we define the width of a of a distribution? This is going to be like our uncertainty. You know, how happy are you today? Well, I'm not sure. How unsure are you? Well, that should give us a precise measure. So the So let me define three things. First, the deviation. So the deviation is going to be A minus the average value of A. So this is just take the actual value of A and and subtract off the average value of A. So we always get something that's centered at zero.

**[33:29]:** Okay. I'm going to write it like this. Um Note, by the way, just a convenient thing to note, the average value of A minus its average value Well, what's the average value of seven? Seven, right? Okay, good. So that first term is the average value of A. The average value of A, and that second term is the average value of this number, which is just this number minus A. So this is zero. Yeah?

**[34:04]:** The average value of a number is zero. The average value of this variable is the average value of that variable, but that's zero. Okay. So deviation is not a terribly good thing on average because on average the deviation is always zero. That's what it means to say this is the average. So the deviation is saying how far is any particular instance from the from the average. And if you average those deviations, they always give you zero. So this is not a very good measure of the of the actual width of a system. But we can get a nice measure by getting the deviation squared. Okay. And let's take the mean of the deviation squared. So the mean of the deviation squared, mean of A minus uh the average value of A squared. Okay. This is what I'm going to call the standard deviation. It's a little odd cuz really you'd want to call it the standard deviation squared, but whatever.

**[34:54]:** We use funny words. And what does it mean if So now what does it mean if the average value of A is zero? Well, it means it's centered at zero. But what does it mean if the standard deviation of A is zero? Yeah, it's it's So if the standard deviation is is zero,

**[35:17]:** then the distribution has no width. Right? Because if there was any amplitude away from the average value, then that would give a non-zero, strictly positive contribution to this average expectation, and this wouldn't be zero anymore. So standard deviation is zero so long as there's no width, which is why the standard deviation is a good useful measure of width or uncertainty. Okay. And just as a note, taking this seriously and taking the square, so um standard deviation squared, this is going to be equal to the average value of A squared minus twice A times the average value of A uh plus average value of A quantity squared. But if you do this out, this is going to be equal to A squared minus two A average value of A average value of A, that's just minus twice uh the average value of A quantity squared. And then plus average value of A squared.

**[36:16]:** So this is an alternate way of writing the standard deviation. Okay? So we can either write it in this fashion or this fashion. And the notation for this is delta A squared.

**[36:32]:** Okay. So when I talk about an uncertainty, what I mean is given my distribution, I compute the standard deviation. And the uncertainty is going to be the square root of the standard deviation squared. Okay. So delta A, the the words I'm going to use for this is the uncertainty

**[36:54]:** in A given some probability distribution. Right? Different probability distributions are going to give me different delta A's.

**[37:09]:** So one thing that's sort of annoying is that when you write delta A, there's nothing in the notation that says which distribution you're talking about. When you have multiple distributions or multiple possible probability distributions, sometimes it's useful to just put given the probability distribution P of A. Um This is not very often used, but sometimes it's very helpful when you're doing calculations just to keep track. Everyone cool with that? Yeah, questions. Yeah, exactly. Of delta A squared, yeah. Yeah. Other questions? Okay. For Yeah. Yeah, it's just this is notation that's used typically, so I didn't put the parentheses around precisely to alert you to the stupidities of this notation. Yeah.

**[37:58]:** Okay. So uh any other questions for Good. Okay, so let's just do the same thing for continuous variables. Now for continuous variables.

**[38:14]:** Okay. I'm just going to write the expressions and just get them out of the way. So the average value of some X given a probability distribution on X, where X is a continuous variable, is going to be equal to the integral. Let's just say X is defined from minus infinity to infinity, which is pretty useful or pretty typical. Minus infinity to infinity, DX uh probability distribution of X times X. I shouldn't use curvy. I should just use X. Okay. And similarly, for X squared or more generally for F of X, the average value of F of X or the expected value of F of X given this probability distribution is going to be equal to the integral DX minus infinity to infinity the probability distribution of X times F of X in direct analogy to what we had before. But so this is all just mathematics.

**[39:08]:** Um and we define the uncertainty in X is equal to the expectation value of X squared minus the expected value of X quantity squared. Okay. And this is delta X squared. Thanks. If you see me dropping an exponent or a factor of two, please, please, please tell me. Um so thank you for that. Um so all of that is just straight-up classical probability theory. And now I just I to write this in the notation of quantum mechanics given this that the system is in a state described by the wave function psi of x. The average value, the expected value of x, the typical value if you just observe the particle at some moment is equal to the integral over all possible values of x. The probability distribution psi of x norm squared x and similarly uh for any function of x the expected value is going to be equal to integral dx probability distribution which is given by the norm squared of the wave function times f of x minus infinity to infinity.

**[40:25]:** Okay? And same definition for uncertainty. And again, this notation is really dangerous because this the expected value of x depends on the probability distribution. In a physical system, the expected value of x depends on what the state of the system is, what the wave function is. And this notation doesn't indicate that. So there are a couple of ways to improve this notation, one of which is um So this is again uh sort of side note. One way to improve this notation x is to write the uh expected value of x in the state psi. So you write psi as a subscript. Another notation that we'll come back you'll see why this is a useful notation later in the semester is this notation. psi And we will give meaning to this notation later, but I just want to alert you that it's used throughout books and all it means the same thing as what we're talking about the expected value of x given

**[41:17]:** a particular state psi. Okay? Yeah. To calculate the expected value of momentum, do you need to transform the Excellent question. Excellent excellent question. Okay, so the question is how do we do the same thing for momentum? If we need the if you want to compute the expected value of momentum, what do you have to do? Do you have to do some Fourier transform to the wave function? So this is a prob This is a question that um you're going to answer on the problem set and that we guess we made a guess for last time. But quickly, let's just think about what it's going to be purely formally. Formally, if we want to know the likely value of the momentum the likely value of the momentum, it's a continuous variable just like any other observable variable, uh we can write it as the integral over all possible values

**[41:58]:** of momentum from let's say it could be minus infinity to infinity uh the probability uh of uh having that momentum times momentum. Right? Everyone cool with that? This is tautology, right? This is what you mean by probability. But we need to know if we have a quantum mechanical system described by a state psi of x, how do we compute the probability that you measure p? Do I want to do this now? Yeah, okay, I do. Um the And we made a guess um question mark. We made a guess at the end of the last lecture that in quantum mechanics this should be dp uh uh minus infinity to infinity of the Fourier transform psi tilde of p up to an h bar factor. Um psi tilde of p the Fourier transform p p norm squared. Okay? So we're guessing that the Fourier transform norm squared is equal to the probability of measuring the associated momentum.

**[43:00]:** Okay? So that's a guess. That's a guess. And so on your problem set you're going to prove it. Okay? So exactly the same logic goes through. It's a very good question. Thanks. Other questions? Yeah. Does that mean the momentum itself represents probability? Good. So this is the probability of measuring momentum p and that's the the value p and we're summing over all p's. This is the probability and that's actually p. Okay? So the Fourier transform is a function of the momentum in the same way that the wave function is a is a function of the position. Right? So this is a function of the momentum, it's norm squared defines the probability and then the p on the right is this p cuz we're computing the expected value of p or the average value of p. Does that make sense? Cool. Yeah. Are we then multiplying by like p squared or doing all p's?

**[43:52]:** So we have like the dp times p for each value of Um no. So that's a very good question. So let's go back that very good question. So the question let me phrase in terms of position cuz the same question comes up. Thank you for asking that. Look at this. This is weird. X I'm going to phrase this as a dimensional analysis question. Tell me if this is the same question as you're asking. This is a thing with the with dimensions of what? Length, right? But over on the right hand side we have a length and a probability which is a number and then another length. That looks like x squared. Right? So why are we getting something with dimensions of length, not something with dimensions of length squared? And the answer is this is not a probability, it is a probability density. Okay, so it's got units of probability per unit length.

**[44:34]:** So this has dimensions of one over length. So this quantity p of x dx tells me the probability which is a pure number, no dimensions, the probability to find the particle between x and x plus dx. Cool? So that was our first postulate, our second postulate. Psi of x dx squared is probability of finding it in this domain. And so what we're doing is we're summing over all such domains the probability times the value. Cool? So this is the difference between discrete where we didn't have these probabilities where was it? Discrete where we didn't have these probability densities, we just had numbers, pure numbers and pure probabilities. Now we have probability densities per unit whatever. Yeah. How do you pronounce the last notation that you wrote? Uh uh How do you pronounce Good, that's a good question. The question is um How do we pronounce these things?

**[45:23]:** So this is called the expected value of x or the average value of x or most typically in quantum mechanics the expectation value of x. So you can call it anything you want. This is the same thing. The psi is just to denote that um that this is in the state psi and it can be pronounced in two ways. You can either say the expectation value of x or the expectation value of x in the state psi. Okay? And this would be pronounced one of two ways. The expectation value of x in the state psi or psi x psi. Yeah. No, that's a very good question. So um but they mean the same thing. Now, I should emphasize that when you know you can have two two ways of describing something that mean the same thing but they carry different connotations, right? Like I don't know.

**[46:08]:** Like you know, I have a friend who's like a really nice guy. He's a re He's a you know, he's a mensch, he's a good guy. And so I could say like he's a nice guy or I could say he's got ingioso. And they mean different things in different languages. It's the same idea but they have different flavors, right? So um you know, whatever your native language is, you've got some analog of this. This means something in a particular mathematical language we're talking about quantum mechanics and this has a different flavor. It carries different implications and we'll see what that is later. We haven't got there yet. Yeah. the iteration of psi Why is there a double notation of psi? double iteration Yeah. You'll we'll see later. Roughly speaking, it's because in computing this expectation value there's a psi squared. And so this is to remind you of that.

**[46:55]:** Other questions? Terminology is one of the most annoying features of quantum mechanics. Yeah. So it seems like this this big quantity variance is like a pretty convenient way of doing it. Yes. So how is it that the Heisenberg uncertainty works exactly like this with this definition of variance? Um That's a very good question. Um In order to answer that question we need to actually work out the Heisenberg uncertainty relation. So the question is Look, this is some choice of of uh uncertainty. Uh you could have chosen some other definition of uncertainty. Like we could have considered, you know, the expectation value of x to the fourth minus x to the fourth and taking the fourth root of that. So why this one? Um and one answer is indeed the uncertainty relation works out quite nicely. Um but there uh the I think the important thing to say here is that there are many ways you could construct quantities.

**[47:45]:** This is a convenient one and we will discover that it has nice properties that we like. There is no God-given reason why this had to be the right thing. Okay? I can say more but I don't want to take the time to do it. So ask in office hours. Okay, good. Um but we will The second part of your question was, you know, why does the Heisenberg relation work out nicely in terms of these guys? And we will study that in extraordinary detail. We will see that. So we're going to derive it twice um soon and then later. The later version is better. So let me work out some examples. Um Or actually you know what? I'm going to skip the examples in the interest of time. Uh they're in the notes and so they'll be posted on the web page. By the way, the first 18 lectures of notes are posted.

**[48:27]:** Um I had a busy night last night. Uh So um So let's come back to that to computing expectation values for a momentum. So

**[48:45]:** So I want to go back to this and ask us so you before I want to I want to make some progress towards deriving this relation. So I want to start over on the definition of the expected value of momentum. And I'd like to do it directly in terms of the wave function. So how would we do this? So one way of saying this is what's the average value of p? Well, I can phrase this in terms of the wave function in the following way. I'm going to sum over all positions dx expectation value of x squared from minus infinity to infinity and then the momentum associated to the value x.

**[49:23]:** Okay? So it's tempting to write something like this down and think there maybe there's some p of x. This is a tempting thing to write down. Can we? Yes. Are we ever in a position to say are we ever in a position to say intelligently that a particle that an electron is both hard and white? No, because being hard is a superposition of being black and white, right? Are we ever in a position to say that our particle has a definite position X and correspondingly a definite momentum P? It's not that we don't get to, it's that it doesn't make sense to do so. In general, being in a definite position means being in a superposition of having definite momenta for different values of momenta. Yeah? And if you want a sharp way of saying this look at these relations. I claim that any reason any function can be expressed as a superposition of states with definite momentum, right?

**[50:37]:** Well, among other things a state with definite position X naught can be written as a superposition 1 over root 2 pi integral DK I'll call this delta tilde of K e to the I K X.

**[51:04]:** And you'll if you haven't seen this, then you will on the problem set because we have a problem that works through great many details. But in particular it's clear that this is not this quantity can't be a delta function of K because if it were this would be just e to the I K X and that's definitely not a delta function. Meanwhile, what can you say about the singularity structure of sorry, the continuity structure of a delta function? Is it continuous? No, its derivative is in continuous. Its second derivative None of its derivatives are in any way continuous. They're all absolutely horrible. Okay? So, how many momentum modes am I going to need to superpose in order to reproduce a function that has this sort of structure? An infinite number. And it turns out it's going to be an infinite number with the same amplitude, slightly different phase.

**[51:53]:** Okay? So you can never say that you're in a state with definite position and definite momentum. Being in a state with definite position means being in a superposition of being in a superposition. And in fact, I'm just going to write down the answer here. e to the I K minus I K X naught Being in being in a in a state with definite position means being in a superposition of states with arbitrary momenta. And vice versa. You cannot be in a state with definite position definite momentum. So, this doesn't work. So, what we want is we want some good definition So, this does not work. We want some good definition of P given that we're working with a wave function which is a function of X. What is that good definition of the momentum? So we have a couple of hints. So, hint hint the first

**[53:02]:** So, this is what we're after. Hint the first is that a wave We know that given a wave with wave number K which is equal to 2 pi over lambda is associated according to De Broglie and according to the Davisson-Germer experiments to a plane to a particle. So, having a sorry, having a particle a a wave with wave number K or or wavelength lambda is associated to particle with momentum P is equal to H bar K. Yeah? But in particular, what does a plane with with wavelength lambda or wave number K look like? That's e to the I K X. And if I have a a wave a plane wave e to the I K X how do I get H bar K out of it? Okay?

**[53:52]:** Note the following.

**[53:56]:** The derivative with respect to X Well, actually let me do this down here.

**[54:07]:** Note that the derivative with respect to X of e to the I K X is equal to I K e to the I K X.

**[54:21]:** Yeah? I'm not you know, there's nothing up my sleeves, right? Um So, in particular, if I want to get H bar K I can multiply by H bar and divide by I multiply by H bar divide by I derivative with respect to X e to the I K X and this is equal to H bar K e to the I K X. That's suggestive.

**[54:49]:** And I can write this as P e to the I K X.

**[54:59]:** Okay. So, let's quickly check the units. Okay. So, what First of what are the units of H bar? So, here's the super easy to remember what the units of or the dimensions of H bar are. Delta X delta P is H bar. Okay? If you're ever in doubt, if you just can't remember H bar has units of momentum times length. It's just the easiest way to remember it. You'll never forget it that way. So, if H bar has units of momentum times length, what are the units of K? 1 over length. So, does this dimensionally make sense? Yeah. Momentum times length divided by length number momentum. Good. So, dimensionally we haven't lied yet. Okay. But so, this makes it tempting to say something like, well hell H bar upon I derivative with respect to X is equal in some question mark quotation marks P.

**[56:01]:** Right? So, at this point it's tempting to just say, look trust me P is H bar upon I D X. But I don't know about you, but I find that deeply deeply unsatisfying. So let me ask the question slightly differently. We've we've followed the De Broglie relations and we've been led to to the idea that and using wave functions that there's some relationship between the momentum, the observable quantity that you measure with you know, sticks and meters and stuff and this operator, this differential operator H bar upon I derivative with respect to X. By the way, my notation for DX is the partial derivative with respect to X. It's just notation. So, if this is supposed to be true in some sense what does momentum have to do with a derivative? Momentum is about velocities which is like derivative with respect to time, right? Times mass.

**[56:53]:** Mass times derivative with respect to time, the velocity. So, what does it have to do with a derivative with respect to position?

**[57:02]:** And this ties into the most beautiful theorem in classical mechanics which is Noether's theorem named after the mathematician who discovered it, Emmy Noether.

**[57:18]:** And just out of curiosity how many people have seen Noether's theorem in a class? Oh, that's so sad. That's a sin. Okay, so So, here's the statement of Noether's theorem. And it underlies an enormous amount of classical mechanics, but also of quantum mechanics. Noether, incidentally, was a mathematician. There's a whole wonderful story about Emmy Noether. Weyl went to her and was like, look I'm trying to understand the the notion of energy in this you know, this guy down the hall Einstein. He has this theory called general relativity about curved space-times and how that has something to do with gravity, but doesn't make a lot of sense to me because I don't even know how to define the energy. So, how do you define momentum and energy in in this guy's crazy theory? And so, Noether, who's a mathematician, did all sorts of beautiful stuff in algebra um looked at the problem and was like, I don't even know what it means in classical mechanics.

**[58:07]:** So, what does it really mean in classical mechanics? So, she went back to classical mechanics and from first principles came up with a good definition of momentum which turns out to underlie the modern idea of conserved quantities and symmetries. And it's had an enormous far-reaching impact um and you know, say her name with praise. Um so Noether tells us the following statement. To every symmetry

**[58:34]:** to every symmetry and I should say continuous symmetry, so to every symmetry is associated

**[58:44]:** a conserved quantity.

**[58:52]:** Okay? So, in particular, what do I mean by symmetry? Well, for example, translations. X goes to X plus some length L. This can be done for arbitrary length L. So, for example, a translation by this much or a translation by that much. Right? These are translations. To every symmetry is associated a conserved quantity. What symmetry is associated to translations?

**[59:16]:** Conservation of momentum. P dot. To time translations

**[59:24]:** T goes to T plus capital T. What's the conserved quantity associated with time translational symmetry, energy. Which is time independent. And rotations. Rotational symmetries.

**[59:44]:** X as a vector goes to rotations, oops, some rotation um times X.

**[59:54]:** What's conserved by virtue of rotational symmetry? Angular momentum. Rock on.

**[1:00:03]:** Okay. So, quickly, I'm not going to prove to you Noether's theorem. It's one of the most beautiful and uh important theorems in in physics and you should all study it, but let me just convince you quickly that it's true in classical mechanics. And this was observed long before Noether pointed out why it was true in general. What does it mean to have translational symmetry? It means that if I do an experiment here and I do it here, I get exactly the same results. Right? I translate the system and nothing changes. Cool? That's what I mean by saying I have a symmetry. You do this thing and nothing changes. Okay. So, imagine I have a particle, a classical particle, and it's moving in some potential, um you this is U of X. Right? Um and we know what the equations of motion are in classical mechanics from from uh from F equals MA, uh P dot is equal to the force, which is minus the gradient of U, minus the gradient of U.

**[1:01:01]:** Right? That's F equals MA in terms of the potential. Now, is the gradient of U zero? No. In this case, there's a force. So, if I do an experiment here, do I get the same thing as doing my experiment here? Certainly not. If the system is not translationally invariant, the potential breaks that translational symmetry. What potential has translational symmetry? Yeah, constant. The only potential that has full translational symmetry in one dimension is translation invariant, i.e. constant. Okay? What's the force? Zero. Zero gradient. So, what's P dot? Yep. Noether's theorem. Solid. Okay? Less trivial is conservation of energy. I claim, and she claims, and she's right, that if the system has the same dynamics at one moment and a few moments later, and indeed any amount of time later, if the laws of physics don't change in time, then there must be a conserved quantity called energy.

**[1:02:05]:** There must be a conserved quantity. And that's Noether's theorem. So, this is the first step, but this still doesn't tell us what momentum exactly has to do with a derivative with respect to space. We see that there's a relationship between translations and momentum conservation, but what's the relationship? So, let's do this. I'm going to define an operation called translate by L. And what translate by L does is it takes f of x and it maps it to f of x minus L.

**[1:02:38]:** Okay. So, this is the thing that effects a translation. And why do I say that's a translation by L rather than minus L? Well, the point the you if uh if you have some function like this and it has a peak at zero, then after the translation, the peak is when x is equal to L.

**[1:02:57]:** Okay? So, just to get the signs straight. So, define this operation, which takes a function of x and translates it by L, but leaves it otherwise identical. Okay. So, let's consider how translations behave on functions. And this is really cute. F of x minus L can be written as a Taylor expansion around the point x around the point L equals zero. So, let's do a Taylor expansion for small L. So, this is equal to f of x minus L derivative with respect to x of f of x plus L squared over two derivative squared, two derivatives of x f of x plus dot dot dot. Right? I'm just Taylor expanding. Right? Nothing sneaky. Let's add the next term actually. Uh Actually, let me do this on a whole new board.

**[1:04:06]:** All right. So, we have uh translate by L on f of x is equal to f of x minus L is equal to f of x. Now, Taylor expanding minus L derivative with respect to uh x of f plus L squared over two uh f I'm just going to write this as f Well, I'm not giving myself enough space. I'm sorry. f of x minus L uh is equal to f of x minus L derivative with respect to x of f of x

**[1:04:42]:** plus L squared over two two derivatives of x f of x minus L cubed over six. We're just Taylor expanding. Uh derivative cubed with respect to x of f of x and so on. Yeah? But I'm going to write this in the following suggestive way. This is equal to one times f of x minus L derivative with respect to x f of x plus L squared over two derivative with respect to x squared times f of x minus L cubed over six derivative cubed with respect to x plus dot dot dot. Everyone agree with that?

**[1:05:35]:** But this is a series that you should recognize, a particular Taylor series for a particular function. It's a Taylor expansion for the exponential. E to the minus L derivative with respect to x f of x.

**[1:05:59]:** Just kind of awesome. So, let's just check to make sure that this makes sense from dimensional grounds. So, that's a derivative with respect to x has units of one over length, that's a length, so this is dimensionless, so we can exponentiate it. Now, you might look at me and say, "Look, this is silly. You've taken an operation like a derivative and exponentiated it. What does that mean?" And that is what it means. Okay? So, we're going to do this all the time in quantum mechanics. We're going to do things like exponentiate operations. We'll talk about it in more detail, but we're always going to define it in this fashion as a formal power series. Questions? Can you transform operators from one space to another? Oh, you totally can. But let's We'll come back to that. We're going to talk about operators next time. Okay. Um so, here's here's where we are.

**[1:06:48]:** So, from this

**[1:06:54]:** what does the derivative with respect to x mean? What does the derivative with respect to x do? Well, a derivative with respect to x is something that generates translations with respect to x through a Taylor expansion. Okay? If we have L If we had L be arbitrarily small, right? L is arbitrarily small. What is the tran- What is the translation by an arbitrarily small amount of f of x? Well, if L is arbitrarily small, we can drop all the higher order terms and it's just the change is just L dx. So, the derivative with respect to x is telling us about infinitesimal trans- translations. Cool? The derivative with respect to a position is something that tells you or controls or generates infinitesimal translations. And if you exponentiate it, you do it many many many times in a particular way, you get a macroscopic finite translation.

**[1:07:46]:** Cool? So, this gives us three things. Translations in x are generated in this sense arg are generated

**[1:08:01]:** by the derivative with respect to x. But through Noether's theorem

**[1:08:10]:** translations uh in x uh are associated to conservation of momentum.

**[1:08:27]:** So, you shouldn't be so shocked. It's really not totally shocking

**[1:08:39]:** that in quantum mechanics

**[1:08:43]:** where we're very interested in the action of thing on functions, not just of positions, but on functions of position, it shouldn't be totally shocking that in quantum mechanics uh the derivative with respect to x is related to momentum in some particular way. Similarly translations in t are going to be generated by what operation? Derivative with respect to time. So, derivative with respect to time from Noether's theorem is associated with conservation of energy. That seems plausible. Derivative with respect to, I don't know, an angle. A rotation. That's going to be associated with what? Angular momentum. Okay? But angular momentum around the axis for whom this is the angle, so I'll call that Z for the moment. Okay? And we're going to see these pop up over and over again. But here's the thing.

**[1:09:52]:** We started out with these three principles today and we've led ourselves to some sort of association between the momentum and the derivative like this. Okay? And I've given you some reason to believe that this isn't totally insane. Translations are deeply connected with conservation of momentum. Translational symmetry is deeply connected with conservation of momentum. And an infinitesimal translation is nothing but a derivative with respect to position. Okay? Those are deeply linked concepts. But I didn't derive anything. I gave you no derivation whatsoever of the relationship between d dx and the momentum. Instead, I am simply going to declare it. I am going to declare that in quantum mechanics you cannot stop me. In quantum mechanics, P is represented by an operator. It's represented by the specific operator h bar upon i derivative with respect to x. And this is a declaration.

**[1:10:58]:** Okay? It is simply a fact. And when I say it's a fact, I mean two things by that. The first is, it is a fact that in quantum mechanics momentum is represented by a derivative with respect to x times h bar upon i. Secondly, it is a fact that if you take this expression and you work with the rest of the postulates of quantum mechanics including what's coming next lecture about operators and time evolution you reproduce the physics of the real world. You reproduce it beautifully. You reproduce it so well that no other models have ever even vaguely come close to the explanatory power of quantum mechanics. Okay? It is a fact. It is not true in some epistemic sense. You know, you can't sit back and say, "Oh, a priori starting with the integers, we derive that P is equal to No, it's a model.

**[1:11:43]:** But that's what physics does. Physics doesn't tell you what's true. Physics doesn't tell you, you know, what a priori did the world have to look like? Physics tells you this is a good model and it works really well and it fits the data. And to the degree that it doesn't fit the data, it's wrong. Okay? This isn't something we derive, it is something we declare. We call it our model and then we use it to calculate stuff and we see if it fits the real world.

**[1:12:09]:** Out. Out. Please. Please leave. Thank you. So

**[1:12:24]:** I love MIT. I really do. Um

**[1:12:31]:** So Uh Okay.

**[1:12:41]:** Okay, let's leave the So let me close off at this point with the following observation.

**[1:12:51]:** We live in a world We live in a world governed by probabilities. There's a finite probability at any given moment that two pirates might walk into your room. Okay? You just never know. You never know.

**[1:13:08]:** But those probabilities Those probabilities can be computed in quantum mechanics. And they're computed in the following ways. They're computed in the following ways as we'll study in great detail. If I take an a state psi of x which is equal to e to the i k x This is a state that has definite momentum h bar k. Right? We claim this. This was de Broglie and Davisson-Germer. Note the following. Take this operator and act on this wave function with this operator. What do you get? P hat Well, we already know cuz we constructed it to have this this property. P hat on psi of x and I'm going to call this psi sub k of x because it has a definite k is equal to h bar k psi k of x.

**[1:13:55]:** A state with a definite momentum has the property that when you hit it with the operation associated with momentum, you get back the same function times a constant and that constant is exactly the momentum we ascribe to that plane wave. Is that cool? Yeah. Just with the notation, what is the hat above the P about? Good. Excellent. So the hat above the P is to remind you that P is not a number, it's an operation. It's a rule for acting on functions. We'll talk about that in great detail next time. But here's what I want to emphasize. This is a state which is, you know, equal to all others in the sense that it's a perfectly reasonable wave function, but it's more equal because it has a simple interpretation. Right? The probability that I measure the momentum to be h bar k is one and the probability that I measure it to be anything else is zero.

**[1:14:43]:** Correct? But I can always put consider a state which is a superposition. Psi is equal to alpha Let's just do 1 over root 2 e to the i k x k1 x plus 1 over root 2 e to the minus i k x. Okay?

**[1:15:07]:** k2 Is this state a state with definite momentum? If I act on this state I'll call this psi sub s. If I act on this state with the momentum operator do I get back this state times a constant? No, that's interesting and so it seems to be that if we're If we have a state with definite momentum and we act on it with the momentum operator, we get back its momentum. If we have a state that's a superposition of different momenta and we act on it with the momentum operator, this gives us h bar k1. This gives us h bar k2. So it changes which superposition we're talking about. We don't get back our same state. So the action of this operator on a state is going to tell us something about whether this state has definite value of the momentum. And these coefficients are going to turn out to contain all the information about the probability of the system.

**[1:15:53]:** This is the probability when norm squared that I will measure the system to have momentum k1. And this coefficient norm squared is going to tell us the probability that we have momentum k2. So I think the current wave function

**[1:16:10]:** is something like a superposition of you know one you know over 10 psi pirates plus one minus one over 100 square root to normalize it properly. Psi no pirates.

**[1:16:39]:** Um And I'll leave you with pondering this probability. See you guys next time.

**[1:17:05]:** What in the lord? YOU CANNOT DISMISS THAT EASILY.

**[1:17:11]:** You called for Professor Alan Adams. Give it up. Within the chronicles of wasted time, I see descriptions of fairest rights. And I see lovely shows of lovely dames. And descriptions of ladies dead and lovely knights. Then in the bosom of fair love's depths of eyes of foot of lip of eye of brow I see the antique pens do but express the beauty that you master now. SO ARE ALL THEIR PRAISES BUT prophecies of this our time. All you prefiguring. But though they had but divining eyes I was wrong about the probabilities. BUT THOUGH THEY HAD BUT DIVINING EYES, they had not skill enough your worth to sing. For we which now behold these present days have eyes to behold

**[1:18:21]:** but not tongues to praise.

**[1:18:28]:** It's not over. Wait. Not marble with the gilded monuments of princes shall outlive this powerful rhyme. But you shall shine more bright in these contents that unswept stone be smeared with sluttish time. When wasteful war shall statues overturn and broils root out the work of masonry, nor Mars his sword nor war's quick fire shall burn the living record of your memory. Gainst death and all oblivious enmity shall you pace forth. Your praise shall still find room even in the eyes of all posterity. So till judgment arise, till you you yourself judgment arise you live in this and dwell in lovers' eyes.

**[1:19:23]:** BARELY HAPPY VALENTINE'S DAY UPON YOU. May your day be filled with love and poetry, whatever state you're in, we will ALWAYS LOVE YOU.

**[1:19:37]:** SIGNED, JACK FLORI AND JAMES E. TEDESCHI. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Now what?
