Transcript
apostles end up being self-appointed, but they claim that it's God appointed. And she invents squid spirits. And do you think that the NAR has to answer for like why is so much of this stuff coming out of the NAR? I think the NAR as a system on its own can hurt people without all the wacky practice. This is wildly dangerous because not only are you adding tons of people to this church, but it's an accountable church headed for a shipwreck. That framework is going to get people hurt. I hope that this helps people identify that they are inside of that ecosystem and to run. Everybody, welcome back to the wonderful world of Remnant Radio.
In this program, we're talking about the New Apostolic Reformation. Those online, the keyboard warriors who claim that everyone's NAR and the pastors who look like they're part of the NAR, but then they deny the title. It's going to be an interesting program. You guys stay tuned. Look guys, the New Apostolic Reformation, lots of people are claiming people are NAR that aren't, people are saying that they're not NAR when they clearly are. All this and more we're going to be talking about today. My name is Joshua Lewis and I'm here today with my co-hosts and partners in crime, Michael Miller on the left in Denver, Colorado and Michael Roundtree on the right in Oklahoma City.
Guys, let's let's set up this conversation. I'll tee it over to Roundtree first and then punt it over to Miller. Man, we've done a lot of content on the past on this. How's this episode any different? Well, I I think it's different because I think we're going to try to be even more clear in our definitions because no matter how many times we talk about it, it seems to still be unclear in people's minds. And the reason is that everybody's being accused of being NAR if they're just a charismatic on one side. And as you said, on the on the other side, it's people are denying that they're NAR when they're very clearly NAR.
And so some definitions that are clear in our minds might not be clear in other people's minds. And so and so we're going to try to really really shine some light on what the NAR is and isn't. And so I think I think just the degree and you a lot of times Josh we've done a lot of episodes on it but it'll tend to be focused maybe on a particular ministry like the the NAR inside of Robert Henderson's courts of heaven or the NAR inside of John Cooper's church and you know so we'll talk about a specific but I think we want to broaden it and just talk about the whole thing because I think you know if people aren't familiar with those individual ministries that we're saying yes that's NAR they can't they don't won't necessarily come away with as clear of a definition as what I think we're going to be able to offer today.
Miller do you have anything to add to that? Yeah I mean I think the reason we would do another episode that's geared towards this kind of information is because of how pertinent it is to today's conversation in church ecclesiology. I think you know I've been personally impacted by the new apostolic reformation though the pastor that I was under would never call himself part of the new apostolic reformation and you've got guys like Michael Brown who's saying it doesn't exist and that's because there is no formal organization called the new apostolic reformation. So it leaves people confused especially those who are actually pastoring churches that should be qualified NAR and those who have left churches that tend to be somewhat displaying the symptoms of NAR-like experience while maybe they actually aren't NAR.
So it's worth it's worth bringing the categories back up and clearly defining the terms as best as we can knowing that this also not a monolith. I've got a helpful story I think here. When when I started putting together notes for this show a story came to mind from man the 1990s but I was hanging out at kids camp hanging out you know in the mess hall line and when I was in line one of the kids behind me you know kind of leaned forward everyone's kind of snickering and laughing a little bit and one of them comes up to me and asks me hey are you a virgin and at the time as a child I didn't quite have context for this word and I said no I don't I don't think so and quite a few of the kids in the line started laughing and then I had to ask one of them what it meant to be a virgin.
And once they explained the category to me there at the Christian kids camp, uh I I went, okay, no, I can I can definitively say at that age I I was in fact a virgin, but I was unaware of the categories that they were using when describing a thing. And I think this is part of uh it's a hilarious story. I wish I could have seen that. Yeah. Roundtree was the kid who explained to me what a virgin was in that sense. similar story. Uh do you know if it's I can't remember what it was though. I I I don't know where you're going with that. Uh I don't remember, so I don't want to say cuz if I get the details wrong I can't remember if it's like your brother or you calling each other a name and uh Uh yeah, there was something like that and it would be completely not appropriate for the air.
Thanks for bringing it up. Okay, okay. All that to say all that to say that uh look, a category can exist that other people don't know that other people don't affirm. Like I wasn't a virgin because I pledge allegiance to virginity, right, in the holiness by which it stands. I didn't I didn't have to sign a membership card and like like vote something and it was a binary category that existed. You either were or you weren't. And you know, people out there are going to say that doesn't necessarily work with theology cuz theology isn't always binaries. And true enough, right? There are 50 shades between uh you know, what you've got as the patriarchalism and the egalitarian position and complementarian somewhere in between.
And each of those have 15 variations of of their own theological views. So you could say, oh, there's no such thing as a clear-cut binary view in theology. And I would just say that's not exactly right. Um another illustration that I've used and then I'm going to punt it over for some discussion after this is that if we walked into an evangelical church today, big mega church, pastor doesn't like to use big fancy theology, but he's just a decent communicator and wants to teach theology in a simple way without using big theological language. And I was to go up to someone and say, hey, are you a They would say, no, absolutely not.
Like I don't even know what that means. And then I go, okay, well, what do you believe about Israel? And they go, oh, there's two people of God. There's the church and then there's Israel. Um, okay, you know, do you think the Israel becoming a nation is super significant? They go, yeah, it started the prophetic time clock. Hey, do you believe in a pre-tribulation rapture? They say, yeah. You just go through the list of what dispensationalism is and they check every single box. Hey, they have this theological belief. They're in this category even if they don't realize they're holding those sorts of theological beliefs.
So I I bring all that up to say that there can be a category of theology that is a well-established theological category that people are using that other individuals can deny. Oh, I'm not that thing, but still be that thing because the nomenclature of that word has determined that well robust category. So those are all some embarrassing, some relevant, but illustrations that maybe can help us start navigating why we're having the problem that we're having today. Go ahead, Rafter. I think where the the difficult part of the difficulty in this, Josh is and Miller, is who gets to define what the NAR is.
Uh, because we naturally want to go back to see Peter Wagner who wrote extensively about this in the new apostolic reformation that was underway and we'll look at at the development of that over time. Uh, but the but the problem is that there there's a sense in which uh, even if his writings are used to define the movement in a in another sense, the categories do evolve over time. So to take another another example, for instance, like Calvinism. Calvin did not invent the tulip. If you're unfamiliar with the tulip, like T stands for total depravity, uh, U for unconditional election, L is for limited atonement, I is for irresistible grace, and P is for perseverance of the saints.
And so uh, so Calvin didn't come up with those. They're just characteristic of the Calvinistic system. And in fact, they were responses to uh, the Armenians who had characterized their system and why Calvinism was wrong and theirs was right based on five points. So the Calvinists said, oh, we've got five points. But the thing is, I mean, if you if you've ever read Calvin's Institutes before, he's a very careful theologian and when it comes to the five points, like he never signed off on that, but Calvinism developed as that. And a number of people, I mean, Wesley wasn't in love with any kind of denomination being named after him.
Same with Luther. Things develop over time. And so while the roots of the NAR could be traced to Peter Wagner, a lot has happened and a lot has evolved over time. And so it's like, who gets to define it? Does Peter Wagner, who started it in a certain direction? Do the modern charismatics who say different things about the NAR? So I think that's just a an interesting question for us to to kind of contemplate. Uh, you guys have any thoughts on that? I would imagine it'd be pretty frustrating for anybody who was early days NAR and then you've got Robert Henderson's book that comes out, Courts of Heaven, and everybody is now saying Courts of Heaven being equivalent with NAR because Robert Henderson was deeply impacted by C.
Peter Wagner. Um, so you I would imagine not all of those who are in the NAR are necessarily practicing the Gnostic practices of the Courts of Heaven. Um, so it creates a a problem if depending on who defines the terms, but then you've got on the other side of the spectrum those who do use the term and find it helpful overusing the term to the point where it no longer means anything because you just throw that term around as the bogeyman. Or, Josh, I think you used the example earlier of the boy who cried wolf. Like he to play a practical joke on people kept crying out wolf, wolf, and everybody in the town gets all in a in a tizzy tizzy trying to figure out where's this wolf and there's no wolf.
So the next time the boy cries out wolf when there's an actual wolf, nobody responds because the word ceased to mean anything to that community. I think the same thing is happening when it comes to the use of NAR language. You've got well, I mean sorry to say it, but the one who I think has written the best criticism on the NAR is also a bit guilty of typecasting and and what would be castigating would be the word I think casting aspersions on people who are actually not NAR and yet this person had no problem calling that person NAR. I'm thinking particularly of Holly Pivec in her book on the NAR.
She categorized Michael and I's mentor Jack Deere as being part of the New Apostolic Reformation despite the fact that Jack didn't teach any of the NAR practices nor did he teach any of the any NAR ecclesiologies. She said well, he once spoke at C. Peter Wagner's Institute. Well, that's a problem because just because he spoke there doesn't make him endorsing those beliefs and practices. No different than when I spoke at a New Age festival on the healing power of Jesus and his lordship over the powers of darkness, that doesn't make me New Age. And so we we've got these problems on each side of the spectrum, which is why we're taking the links we are to discuss this very problem.
What is the actual NAR? yeah, John Wimber spoke a lot in Peter Wagner's class at Fuller. And so there was kind of a partnership there in some ways, but then if you remember we went and interviewed Carol Wimber while she was still with us. Right. And asked her and asked her what she thought of Wagner's teaching on the on the NAR and all of that. I'm interested just because of the the kind of cultural context and the way that people will speak of the Vineyard. Well, because he was associated with C. Peter Wagner, this is part of the what they call the New Apostolic Reformation. Well, he didn't John didn't John didn't believe in any of that crap.
I want to maybe circle back a little bit to what Roundtree said because he was he was describing here the core of the movement is C. Peter Wagner and then there's the branches of the movement. I think if you're really going to do a good theology of this, what we can't do is like what said, look at the far fringes of the tree. If if if C. Peter Wagner is the the the stump of this thing, right? He's he is the the the core of this tree. He's got the roots of it all. And then out from that is a lot of the branches. At the very ends you got the leaves. That's a good illustration to keep in your head.
The guys on the outermost parts, I look at guys like a Robert Henderson. I I look at folks frankly like a Jennifer LeClaire and I go are these guys representative of all of C. Peter Wagner's beliefs? No. So it's not fair to say that like anyone who believes in a sneaky squid spirit is NAR, even though I think that's wild. Or anyone who believes that they should travel to heaven is NAR. And again that's crazy wild and it should be completely both of those things we should shun shun. But all that to say what is NAR is that we can say okay we need to familiarize yourself with the literature, read what C.
Peter Wagner said and then look at the connective tissue that goes all the way throughout the movement. So we shouldn't judge the center of C. Peter Wagner by the extremes and we shouldn't let the extremes determine everything that C. Peter Wagner believed. We should try to see the whole as what it is. Right now I would say that a lot of really big mainstream books such as culture of honor I think have been built upon a C. Peter Wagner's framework of anointing and authority, the undercover by John Bevere. Again I would say that there is a lot of nomenclature to use the proper pronunciation of of the honor culture.
No it's Like I said I I've heard it's not it's not binary guys. You can pronounce it both ways. It's nomenclature. I know I know I know I was messing around. The nomenclature of the day. How do you pronounce dyslexic? Lisdexic. So all that to say that the the the language of these books is greatly informed by this idea of apostolic authority, apostolic oversight that flows downhill from the apostle to others. That is an idea that I think we can trace back to Wagner. And I think when when you have an understanding of Wagner's beliefs, it's easier to identify something as as very NAR inspired or NAR adjacent.
So uh I think some of that can be helpful. And I do. I see a lot of the boy who cries wolf stuff out there um because if you if you're out there and you're like that guy's he spoke in tongues without interpretation. Well, that's NAR. Like they they want to they want to make every charismatic practice especially the bad ones as NAR, but they're not using the category appropriately and I feel like it loses all of its efficacy when we do this. Um round table pundit over to you. Yeah, Josh. I think I think that's all good point on Peter Wagner and tracing his argument. We're going to do that in just a second.
Uh but I also do want to affirm it is still important to pay attention to how it's evolved because that's the reality that many people are living with. A lot of people never heard of Peter Wagner nor of his teachings. And in the in the seed versions of that and in a lot of ways those aren't really around anymore. And so like the the mess that we are dealing with is what it's evolved into. So we are just so our audience knows we are going to talk about that too. But we just want to trace it from the beginning. Uh the other thing I I do want to say and I think I just want to make sure we say it on an episode like this cuz you talked about Holly Pivec a minute ago is uh is her partner Doug Geivett who also has written uh extensively about the NAR and they've tended to partner together.
Well, Doug Geivett is no longer with us. He's with the Lord. And uh so if you didn't hear that just want to let you know that and we we are thankful for Holly and Doug's work even though we haven't agreed on everything. I will say I have learned a lot about the NAR from their writings. So uh there's that. But let's jump into uh the just Peter Wagner and how this got started. Uh he he was a church growth guy at uh at Fuller and that's really how he and John Wimber uh got connected. John uh has you know had led churches, led tons of people to the Lord and so they kind of got partnered as a beautiful thing when when you read about kind of what happened in their classes with the gifts of the Holy Spirit and so on.
Uh but, but Wagner in 1998 he edited a book called the New Apostolic Churches. And as a church growth professor, he had really mostly just been focusing on what are the traits of the fastest growing churches in the world. And so he'd look at contemporary worship, church planting, in-house pastors, and the kinds of things that that like the churches that really grow a lot, what are they doing? Well, one of the things that he talks about in this book is quote the amount of spiritual authority delegated by the Holy Spirit to individuals. And uh and so in these churches he talks about how the pastor no longer worked for the board and that the office of the apostle was really back.
And so it functionally kind of went back to like a Moses model, which of course you don't actually have to be charismatic to go with the Moses model. What I what we mean by that when we when we say that is like one head dude and not really a plurality. There might be lip service to a plurality of of elders or to some kind of board, but it's one guy who's got the vision, runs with everything and and he's the mover and the shaker and and he's the leader and you can kind of not question him. And he's like, well, these are the fastest growing churches. Uh I don't know, it kind of makes me think of that African proverb.
I'll probably not cite it correctly, but it says something if like if you want to go fast, go alone, but if you want to go far, go together. And so he's tracking fast growing churches. Well, one dude at the top starts to lead it all and started applying the language of apostle to this suggested that God is now restoring proph uh apostles to the church. And so it's kind of like you know, in the reformation where the gospel sort of got dusted over through the centuries, you know, Martin Luther comes back and Protestant reformation and the gospel is restored and and and in a way like a true teaching office restored to the church, which that that's a crude representation.
There are obviously teachers in the church before that and they're anyway, we're not going to get into all that history, but very broad brushstroke. The gospel was restored and in a new way teachers were restored. And uh and here we have apostles being restored. And so that's kind of the the take that he took in this 1998 book. And then he started writing some more. Miller, you want to talk about that? Well, can I just give a quick thought on that last book, the one in 1998 Wagner edited The New Apostolic Churches. Just remember that is him as a church growth guy just trying to assess what he's seeing.
I'm just seeing these churches growing well. He wasn't saying this is what you should do. He's not saying this is the new vision for the church. He's just like this is their ecclesiology and he is describing it as apostolic. He even views non-charismatic churches in this initial work where he's trying to figure out what's going on in the body of Christ. I think that's important for people to remember because it's going to get more charismatic as time goes on. Well, so it's it's more like you've got CEOism or the Moses model uh with the guy at the top and that he's assessing this is where the fastest growth is taking place in these kinds of churches.
But he can also see the problem with the lack of accountability and so and you could see that he's now developing after assessing here's what works, which this is actually really fascinating when you think about it um because you you will see this be the process. It it boils down to pragmatism. It starts with him assessing what works and then creating a theology to support what works. So he writes a another book the next year or maybe was it a year later, I believe? He writes a book called Church Quake. And in this one he devotes two whole chapters to the apostolic office. And he says that there's these apostolic teams that you've got that you form and yet they all have to bend the knee to one final authority or one apostolic leader.
So you have elders, but those elders are really there to uh serve the pastor, who you know serve their vision that that um I guess senior apostles' vision and then he appoints them and can dismiss them at will. So Wagner sees a problem here and he shows that there's a problem and the main problem being is that well that apostolic leader doesn't necessarily have anyone to account to. Maybe they're just accountable to God. He he leaves it up in the air. The jury's still out to kind of figure this out. And then you also find that you see the spiritual covering language getting employed in this book as well as some recognition of dominionism taking place in some of these apostolic churches.
Not saying that he is endorsing dominionism at this point, but he does make mention of it being a common threat. Um I I don't think I'm leaving anything out, am I guys? No, that's right. That's right. I'll pick up on the next book in in 2000 C. Peter Wagner publishes a book about apostles and prophets. In this book he talks about apostles going to get revelation from God either directly or indirectly through other prophets and then the apostle makes that revelation known to the church and the church is then to go administer potentially this new strategy, this new idea, this new engagement of what God is saying to the churches, what the spirit of God is saying to the church in this present day.
Now Wagner does try to be careful here and say that this doesn't add to scripture, but for those who are looking on the outside in, if you're looking at new practices and new methods in order to accomplish God's purposes in the earth, that seems to function as an addition to scripture. One might say that the scripture says something like go take care of widows and orphans, take care of homeless people, care for your neighbor, and then a group of churches get together and go okay Lord, how do you want us to accomplish this in this region and go oh take care of veterans. You don't have enough resources to take care of all of these things at the same time.
They go great, we're taking care of veterans. That's not what he's saying here. You're going to see this begin to evolve into what we would see as strategic spiritual warfare in later publications where there is this new idea and new revelation that is being given down to the churches, but he's going to say in this argumentation that without apostles and prophets we don't have the ecclesiology or the the structure in which God will bless. So you start to see the beginnings of this kind of overflow language that if you don't have apostles and prophets, you're not going to have this kind of strategic power in your assembly to accomplish all that God wants you to do.
Um any comments on that? Yeah, but well I was just thinking before we go to the next publication that he comes out with, I'm just wondering, Josh, is it at this point you can start to see not just the potential practice for strategic level spiritual warfare, but also the endorsement of sort of new vision for a given area. It's like why my former church is one that I would say impacted me the upper room, they could say we are going to be a place of prayer. That's the vision God has given the apostolic leader. And so the primary focus is going to be prayer and that's how we're going to take the city.
Or you've got um well I don't know. Uh I'm trying to think of like a church that just serves really good coffee. Their vision is to be the Starbucks of all churches. Um I mean that's pretty I'm I'm making light of this little bit. not their tagline. Nah, but you do see stuff like this happen where it's like hey, we're doing this. There's other churches that are really good at that, but but this is what we are called to. Well I think that there you know there there is an assumption that not every church can do every single thing, right? Like my church in Ada has got 80 people in it, which isn't crazy to say that that is not the normal representation.
I say 70 to 80 people in it, but like that's like the normal representation of like churches in the first century. Weren't these giant mega churches? They had 100 200 people kind of going to a local assembly. And the idea that they were going to care for every single need of their community was kind of crazy, but the ethic of the message was to to point this in a certain direction. What they couldn't do is we're not going to be a church that really teaches the word. We're just not going to We're just going to focus on prayer and fasting. We're not going to do discipleship. We're not going to do evangelism.
Like you can't omit the things that scripture commands you to do, but you can direct in a specific way how you choose to do that thing. So discipleship in one community might be home groups, discipleship in another community might be one-on-one discipleship programs where you've trained people to train people who train people. Like the way you accomplish the mission, I think the Bible has wiggle room for the idea that you create your own mission and vision that is contrary to or in addition to the Great Commandment and the Great Commission allows you to take a title that that Jesus doesn't give his church.
You you're taking an authority over the church that Christ doesn't give us. And I don't I don't want to say explicitly he is saying that because he's speaking in these kind of broad terms. I think someone could have read this book, Apostles and Prophets, and come to that conclusion about their given mission and vision in the church. So I certainly see the early stages of what you're describing, Miller, in this in this you get a strategic strategy. Get something that God has given you, a strategic vision for that region. That's kind of what he's endorsing here. It's just now we're we're seeing today the application of what he was teaching.
Right. Yeah, I I liked Josh's qualifier because you know, when a when a pastor talks about having vision, I I just want to really understand what that pastor is talking about. Like when Tim Keller would talk about a theological vision of his church in the heart of the city, that was very different from a pastor like what you're talking about, Miller, who says, hey, we're going to do prayer and maybe we're just not really going to do discipleship and community. If we're going to be a church, we don't have permission to do that. We have to we have to do the things that the Bible commands as a church, and we can't pick favorites.
We have to do them all. And and yet at the same time, I think a church in the city such as Keller's is going to look different than a rural church. In different contexts, it can look different. And so like even in our church, like my church is a church of house churches. We we repeatedly say we don't think this is the only way to do it. We do see some precedent for this in the New Testament. So there's a visionary component to that, but it's more like theological vision, but we're still doing all the same things that say your more traditional churches are doing, where making disciples, doing evangelism, practicing prayer, doing the Lord's supper, centering on the word of God, etc.
So, how one defines the vision I think is is key there. But I want to come back to Wagner here and maybe Josh, were you trying to chime in? Yeah. What I'll do is I'll I'll just do a quick recap of the last three so people don't get lost in the sauce and let you do that fourth one if that's okay. 1998 Wagner releases the book New Apostolic Churches. In that book he is assessing what he's just seeing about growing churches. And one of the key features that would would kind of shock some people is centralized authority without accountability. In section two he talks about apostolic teams, the second book which we call a year later it's called Church Quake.
He's like apostolic teams report to one apostle, the senior apostle's up there. Well, who's accountable to that guy? He's like TBD. And then we see in 2000 he publishes Apostles and Prophets that talk about the spiritual overflow and this is the first book. I didn't mention this earlier. This is the first book where he calls himself an apostle. That's an important thing. But if you're going to get the blessing you've got to have the right alignment with this ecclesiology and have this specific strategy to reach your city. Okay, round two you want to pick up on our next one Apostles Today? Yeah, Apostles Today written in 2006 and so it begins as something of a of a reflection looking back to 2001 when the second apostolic age began.
And and so he talks about the restoration of apostles and and prophets in greater detail. And suggests based on Ephesians 2:20 that if you don't have apostles and prophets you're a church without a foundation, which is quite damning to any cessationist church like you just don't have a foundation because you don't have because you're not part of our charismatic movement. But apostles in this carried tremendous authority, extra authority and and the focus became on like changing history. The apostles were spiritual gatekeepers to a city and the responsibility of the people of God was essentially under that covering and submit and the blessings will flow to you and uh and if you are un if you are under their covering then God will use you and he will use your church to transform cities and to make history.
And so that's quite a nutshell version of Apostles Today 2006. When it it's probably important to note here that at this point by 2006 this kind of theology, the new apostolic reformation theology has begun to spread. It's no longer just C. Peter Wagner and and his institute that are now propagating these this kind of ecclesiology and this kind of belief system. It's now being pumped into second and third generations new apostolic reformation leaders. So you've got Harold Eberly who was a disciple of C. Peter Wagner at the Wagner Institute who then goes to Bethel and brings his um new wineskin or I think he calls it the complete wineskin, which is basically what Bethel built their ecclesiology off of and which uh Danny Silk then quite kind of rebranded in the book Culture of Honor um where they they attribute their success and all the miracles that they're seeing to having this structure.
This structure originally kind of crafted by C. Peter Wagner. So I think 2004 is a pretty pivotal time here and when it comes to history of this movement because Bethel becomes the charismatic brand that everybody is looking to worldwide and it's being propagated worldwide. Um I I know that's not necessarily in the next section Josh, but I thought that'd be important to note so people can kind of get the full grasp of how this thing made its way into the cultural zeitgeist of charismatic Christianity. Yeah, totally fair totally fair. In 2008 he writes a book called Dominion. In this book he kind of keeps doubling down on the content here and he starts talking about how the Great Commission and the Great Commandment are going to be fulfilled not just through the the spreading of the gospel, but the Great Commandment and Great Commission have a cultural aspect to them.
And this is where the Dominion uh theology that he had picked up on earlier is now really being implemented as a system where we get involved in the seven mountains of influence present day. I'm trying to think of all of the seven mountains. I I didn't list them here, but the seven areas of culture. We've talked on them on the show over and over again like media and finance and education and religion. I mean there's there's seven seven government family. There's there's these seven mountains that we're supposed to go and and Christianize. So in his view here in Dominion, he talks about sending people out to these specific spheres and Christianize politics and Christianize media and to get involved in these spheres of influence and to begin to Great Commandment, Great Commission, teach them to observe even if you don't teach them to believe, which is interesting.
I think it's a rather novel interpretation of the text here. And and I don't think it's bad. So people who are out there watching me and are like, hey, shouldn't I be salt and light everywhere I am? Absolutely. But I don't think it's only these seven and I don't think it's a strategic like plan of God that he has purposed before the foundations of time to take over media. I don't think media was a thing in the first century. I think we're just Christians. We're supposed to be salt and light in every place that we go. And to influence culture to the best of our ability as we are leaders in that said sphere of influence that we're in.
Outside of that, I'm not trying to Christianize politics. I'm trying to preach the gospel. Bunch of people get saved. Great. Anyway, but it is also in this book that he talks about strategic spiritual warfare where you're going to go out, you're going to do prayer marches and find the strongholds of the city, the spiritual powers that are ruling up in the heavenly places and then we're going to we're going to figure out what those are and then the apostle and prophet figure that out and then then we have to give prayer strategies of how to dethrone these powers over our region through great intercession, which again we've done great length of episodes on.
If I could, I'll just walk through the seven core tenets of what has been described thus far in C. Peter Wagner's work. We find at least seven that are here. It is the church governed by the fivefold ministry, uh primarily apostles and prophets, as a top-down leadership structure. And that when you have this fivefold organization, you get spiritual blessing. Uh those apostles are uh unquestionable uh to uh elders and deacons and boards of directors. They have this un um unquestionable kind of authority. I don't know the other word uh of posing there. Prophets find strategies from heaven and how to reach the cities.
Apostles then implement that plan from the prophets. Uh that's number four. Number five is churches that are set up under uh this structure will have supernatural overflow and spiritual blessing uh by submitting to the structures. Churches without the structure are robbed of foundational power uh that God intends to give his church. Number six is dominion theology targets the seven mountains of influence, family, religion, education, media, arts, entertainment, business, government, and attempts to Christianize these spaces with Christian influence. And seven, strategic spiritual warfare where apostles and prophets map out principalities and demonic powers of a city and through revelation and prayer are able to tear down those principalities.
Um which I think we can describe as a novel practice. So that is essentially the uh and I think what we've done is we've said this is C. Peter Wagner. This is the guy who influenced Cindy Jacobs. He's the guy who influenced Che Ahn. He's the guy who influenced Bethel. He established this thing. Lots of people believe in that general framework even if they deny being NAR. You go they've adopted this whole framework into their system. You go to Cindy Jacobs and ask her if she believes in strategic spiritual warfare. She's going to be like, yes, sir. Uh do you do you believe in apostles and prophets having authority that they kind of go find special revelation and the church should be established, you know, and run by fivefold ministry?
She's going to be absolutely uh you know, you you walk through those questions with a Che Ahn or a Cindy Jacobs. They're going to affirm it. And I think that there are quite a few charismatic congregations who can affirm this kind of doctrine even know even though they might not know where it comes from, C. Peter Wagner, or how to articulate it its proper category of the NAR. So, uh those are some thoughts. Who wants to take it from there? Maybe we can chat for a minute about why this is so important. I'll I'll maybe uh talk for a minute about this, Miller. I'll I'll tag you in and uh so I don't I don't want to monologue for too long, but uh I think so so why do why does this matter?
Not so that we can lambast people on social media. That's not that's not the purpose. Uh a few reasons I'll give. Uh number one, I think that it's really important that we distinguish between offices and gifts. In Ephesians chapter four, when it lists apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors, and teachers, it explicitly refers to these uh so that's verse 11 and verse seven it refers to these as gifts. And so it the reason that matters is because if you call these offices, then you give them a special status that is authoritative. And so when you pair that particularly with apostles and prophets, what you end up with is this authoritative position where we've seen them create essentially new doctrine, new practices that had been previously undiscovered.
We've repeatedly come back to the courts of heaven. It's egregious and it's sold millions of books. I wish every Christian would depart from the courts of heaven, go back and watch our videos over it, but it actually is rooted in this. It's rooted in this idea that special apostles and prophets get the special revelation that might involve a special novel teaching that people are supposed to heed and obey. Uh we don't like it. No, these are gifts to the church. Even uh even apostles, for instance, we would say these are these are missionaries. These are church planters. And while we do recognize it in the first century, the apostle Paul, the 12 apostles of Jesus had a unique and a special authority that did that was assigned to them.
There seemed to be categorically sometimes we'll talk about capital A apostles versus lowercase A apostles. Lowercase A might be like 2 Corinthians 8:23 where uh a lot of your modern translations will will uh render it as messengers to the churches. It's actually apostles. These were just messengers, people that were sent. They were given to travel. Uh and so apostle really means sent ones. And so I think missionaries, church planters fits that really well. We don't need to assign a special officer role to it. And really the officers that we see assigned like you see in Philippians uh 1:1 it's to the elders and deacons of Philippi.
And when you look at 1 Timothy 3 it's hey for elders look for this and for deacons look for that. We actually don't have a text where it's like hey here's what you look for to appoint an apostle. And that's part of the problem is apostles end up being self-appointed but they claim that it's God appointed and they self-appoint themselves to lead a church with their special revelation, special teaching, special practices and basically unrecognizable Christianity. So that that's one of it. And and one of the things that goes along with that is the lack of accountability. We saw early on in in Peter Wagner's development as he was just evaluating, watching oh the churches that are growing really fast are the unaccountable pastors.
And I'm like I don't I don't care how fast it grows. Maybe it's a bad thing how fast it grew. Like let's be accountable cuz this is wildly dangerous because not only are you adding tons of people to this church but it's an unaccountable church headed for a shipwreck. This is really bad. This kind of thing when when we establish the sort of hierarchy that uh Wagner and company establish where lack of accountability like to be able to write in print. I remember when I read this the first time in Wagner's writing to to see it in print where he's like we don't know about accountability for for apostles.
I mean I appreciate his honesty. But when it comes to accountability I don't want a TBD by it. I want like let's give give us the clear biblical texts. And so it it creates this special framework that uh that I think can be really dangerous but I've talked enough. Miller you want to follow up from there? Yeah I think one of the other components of it is sort of how it redefines what a prophet does. A prophet is now responsible for getting a vision for from God for an entire region, an entire group of people, an entire city and or town, rather than just edifying your average believer in a local church or a local community.
This person has to get some sort of strategic vision for a region. The problem is you just don't see that like anywhere in the text. And so this is why we at Remnant Radio keep advocating for the keep it local. I think Josh, you put out a really wonderful video of AI and me doing a dance where in the background it says keep it local. We we believe that that prophecy should be done on a local level and not necessarily on the YouTube osphere. It's the reason why every year you get these prophecies from what's the guy? Chuck Pierce up in Denton, Texas and Cindy Jacobs and James Goll, and they always have this prophetic round table where they're prophesying what's going to happen in the next year.
And it's all either vagaries or things that don't come to pass, things that can't be judged and no way to prove right or wrong or just things that patently are wrong. So that's a problem. Prophecy was meant to be done on a local level to edify the average attendee in church. Yes, there are prophetic things that take place that sometimes they look like signs. Sometimes it could be prophecies given to a region like when Agabus predicted a famine, but it certainly wasn't a strategic level spiritual warfare plan for the group. And I I think again one of the things that's not often highlighted is all of this boils down to pragmatism.
It's not so much recognizing that the growth well I think I think what happens with Peter Rigney is he just assumed the massive amount of growth that you saw in these areas makes it automatically good. That the ends justify the means. And that's why he then set out to create a theology that would then defend that problem of lack of accountability. Now it's true that on some level churches can make decisions that are advantageous for church growth really quickly. I know that anytime somebody comes to me with a new program, a new ministry they want to start at the church, I have to press pause on it until I have more information from that person and then I could submit it to the elders to talk about, hey, does this fit within our values?
Does it fit within the resources that we have available to get behind this? And that process of getting approval from the eldership plural, it takes time. It slows things down. But it also ensures the health of the community to where people don't quickly become cogs in a system and get discarded quickly. So that that slowing the process, it it works in both directions. It may slow down growth, but it also slows down harm, which I think is very important. And I think that's where a lot of this falls short. This is one of the big concerns that that I have in particular about the NAR, is when you have one person at at the top, yeah, you may get results, but that doesn't mean that the means you're using to get those results are good.
And it doesn't mean it won't lead to massive amount of harm. There are other results that we're now seeing with all of the new testimonies that seem to come out every week of some other person that was burned at a new apostolic reformation kind of church. So yeah, I've monologued long enough now, Josh. Why don't you step in? Yeah, yes, I will I will tag into the monologosphere. Okay, listen. A couple of things, you know, one, pragmatism isn't evil in itself. When every decision is driven by pragmatism, that's when we create room for destruction. So like imagine you have a group and their ethics is to teach the Bible.
They love teaching the Bible. It's like kind of their core values of who their church is. They love the scriptures. They want discipleship in their community. Uh they believe in teaching expositionally. They they want to teach the meaning of the text, the historical rootedness of the text, and someone comes along and says, hey guys, I'm not asking you to change your values at all. But the way that you're doing discipleship right now is your Sunday morning preaching. And I'll tell you, that's good. But you know what really works? What really works is when you are able to disciple people to do the thing that you're doing.
Teach them how to teach. That that is more effective. You'll reach more people. Now, what that has done is saying, hey, this is something that works. You should do that thing. And when we look at that against the value, which is the value is that you should be able to defend God's word. You should be ready in season, out of season. Uh right? We we need to know the truth. We need to we need to be able to communicate those truths. Teach them to observe all I've commanded, Matthew 18. I mean, you've got so many good biblical reasons to do this. You go, hey look, my values that have been informed by scripture and the method both coalesce in this beautiful moment that I can say, yes, that's a good thing.
Now, if the opposite were true and someone came to you and said, hey look, you're doing this big expositional thing, I don't know that it's that effective. People are getting bored in the sermon. You're diving really deep into this. I don't know that it's really changing people's lives. Maybe we should preach more topically. Maybe we should just kind of approach this and and really make it applicable to their lives. Teach them how to be better dads, better moms, better better husbands and and and spouses and and and kids and and teach them real practical things. Don't get too deep into the theology.
Don't get too far into the text. Just teach them how to live a moral life that'll make a better impact. What that does is that is a uh a pragmatism that reigns over the commands of scripture that says, hey, what you're doing is too complicated. Uh you need to dumb it down. You need to water it down. You need to focus not on what Christ has done for them, but what we have to do for Christ. Uh and it and it flips the gospel message and it inverts things into what is a moral therapeutic deism, big fancy word. You don't have to dive into it today. But all that to say that pragmatism isn't bad in itself as long as it lines up with those core values and missions of and visions that Christ has given his church.
And and and it is bad when it undermines those sorts of things. So that that's an important stipulation. The other thing I want to bring up is on uh the practices. This is where I I as much as I hate bad ecclesiology and I don't want people to get hurt. Like I'm actually deeply like concerned about the practices. Um you know I we're we're going to do a response at the time of this taping that video will already been out so you can go back and watch it. Um but we we read a book on defeating aquatic spirits um by Jennifer LeClaire. I think it's like a the longer title is spiritual warfare, how to defeat aquatic spirits, something something something.
Uh anyway we we read this book, did a response to it. She mentions courts of heaven. Uh she mentions apostles and prophets. She is all bought in to this new apostolic reformation and she invents squid spirits. You know like doesn't find them in the scripture, doesn't have a reason to believe in them other than some kind of prophetic revelation. She's teaching people how to engage with these squid spirits based on her own personal experiences. And why shouldn't she? If this is the framework that she has adopted that they that the apostles and prophets are supposed to give these new techniques to the church.
But what we do is we start building entire systems on speculation and mythology. You know we talk about the courts of heaven. You hear me dunk on it all the time. If you're new to the channel, that's where you're supposed to travel into heaven, find secret books that are written about you in heaven, plead your case before the judge who is Jesus uh and then to get all of the uh testimonies of voices in that courtroom like the blood of saints, the voices the voices of the martyrs, the voices of angels, the voices finances. finances because you've been giving your voice of finances up in the court of heaven.
So it's this crazy gnostic novel practice so that we can grant God the ability to answer our prayer. And yes I think the NAR as a system on its own can hurt people without all the wacky practice. But that is a natural trajectory of where that practice goes. And and I'm I'm deeply concerned because if Robert Henderson is willing to take it here, who comes after Robert Henderson, right? Origin had some weird ideas. Irenaeus took it further. Um you know Benny Hinn had some bad ideas. The guys who follow after him are going to go the the the Catherine Kuhlman of the world are going to go further. So I I'm concerned not in part by what it is, but I'm more concerned about what this will become if the church can't identify it.
Yeah. Yeah. Uh that that's really good. I like that you talk about trajectory there cuz I think Peter Wagner would probably look at what it's become today and probably I mean he would be more comfortable with it than we are, but I think even he would be uncomfortable with some of the things that like when they're practicing astral projection, I can't see him getting on board for that. And I do think that the NAR has to answer for like why is so much of this stuff coming out of the NAR? Why is it? I think we have to really answer for that kind of thing. I think what what I like to do cuz I I want to steal man the NAR.
We always try to do this on NAR on not just NAR when we're on on just Remnant Radio, we try as much as we can to represent the other side well because not everybody who's listening to this is like, oh yeah, I cast out squid spirits every Tuesday at 3:30. Not everybody's going to that place. And some of them are are thinking more like this. And I want you guys to try to respond to this. Okay? I'm going to pretend that I'm uh that I'm in that camp even if I don't necessarily own the label. Okay? Uh well well guys, what what would you say about this? I mean we we certainly want to have as much influence as possible in business and in government and the media, arts and entertainment, education, all of these things.
And I can tell you that like you know my pastor, he calls himself an apostle. I don't mind calling him an apostle. Uh he has a great teaching, but he has a board. And from everything I can tell, he's accountable to his board and he runs things through them. So he has a board and yes, he's the visionary of the church and he does get prophetic revelations for our city. But he invites us all to pray in and and man, we did this prayer campaign and we we prayed against the principality of greed over my city and and we just spent like like what could be wrong with praying? Like we spent a whole Friday night and into Saturday morning praying against the principality of greed and we went out and evangelized and it's kind of like you guys are saying like hey, stop evangelizing, stop praying and and yeah, I I know there's not like a direct Bible verse that says you know, pray against principalities, but I mean Paul does say our our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against principalities and it's in the context of prayer and he's going to later talk about praying, you know, pray at all times.
So like I don't see why it would be a problem to pray against these things, for somebody to have a revelation about these things and to go and try to be an evangelist out in the world and to use whatever gifts and callings and skill sets and talents that you've learned to enter into different spheres or mountains of society as we call them and I don't see what's wrong with trying to spread the gospel that way and and I feel like you're that you guys you you accuse Holly Pivec and Doug Geivett of broad brush stroke. Feels like you're doing that with me because you know, I'm not astral projecting, but I do enjoy the covering of my apostle and sorry guys, that part's weird to say.
And I'm trying. I I enjoy the covering of my apostle. he's really going with his illustration. I've been financially blessed and we do courts of heaven prayer and I have seen tremendous breakthroughs. So what are you it sounds like you guys are just against prayer and you say you're for apostles, it sounds like you're actually not. So help me understand. Jeez Louise, what an argument. that for a steel man, guys? I mean yeah, you did it. I I'm happy to poke at it. Miller, do you do you have anything you want to start with? Uh, well, the thing is not everything you said is stuff that we would be against, evangelizing the city being a case in point.
I don't think anybody is saying that if you're evangelizing the city that you're somehow uh bad. Um, I would say that strategic level spiritual warfare that idea um you may have received benefit of it from it, but I would question how you know you've received benefit from it. Uh, I I would ask like what metrics do you have by which to measure it because it's something that you can't measure. Um, so I I really don't know that your claim of it working makes it actually work, but then secondarily my bigger concern is where that leads because if you start incorporating certain practices that the scriptures don't advocate for, well then when does it stop?
You just gave justification for what Robert Henderson does with the Courts of Heaven. Um, and you just gave uh justification for what um Jennifer Claire does with squid spirits. Um, sorry. Just saying it. I'm not trying to mock her, but it is funny to me. Yeah. Yeah. Well, the the point is when you start saying yes to these practices, you then have a justification for saying yes to all of these other practices. Um, and and that 's where I and then I think the other part of it is when are you allowed to question the leader? Because it sounds like if you're questioning the leader, you're now being insubordinate and you're just not getting behind the vision that God has given them.
And so you de facto end up becoming a cog in someone else's wheel, uh not necessarily a servant bond servant of Christ, um but rather some particular individual's vision, and that vision may or may not be godly. So there's there's a lot there to that. The one of the illustrations that we've used on this program a lot I I want to give credit to Roundtree. I think he was the one who who first uh brought it up, but we've all we've all adopted Um just because it it's good doesn't make it right. Moses struck the rock and water came out. Um but he wasn't supposed to do this. Uh it angered the Lord and he wasn't able to enter into the promise because of it.
Um so I I think the question of oh it worked. Hey, I'm glad that you had that experience. I'll tell you an experience I had. Uh we prayed for some ladies at our church um who were practicing Courts of Heaven. They They was a very newly founded church at the time. Uh and they these folks didn't know that it was bad and we kind of walked through why it was bad. They were like, hey, do we need to burn this book? And I was like, probably. And they're like, do we need deliverance? And I was like, yeah, probably. Uh and we saw deliverance take place in the lives of people in our community because they were practicing Courts of Heaven.
That's That's one of the things that you you get into a kerfuffle here when you compare one experience uh and and you practice it on the basis of that experience. Can you also jettison the experience because of someone else's experience? No. I would not tell you you should not practice Courts of Heaven because I saw demonization as a result of Courts of Heaven. What I would tell you is don't go beyond what is written, which is what Paul tells the church of first uh the church of Corinth in the book of first Corinthians. He says, hey, don't go beyond what's written. Um he's applying truths to himself and to Apollos, um but he's saying, look, we are keeping ourselves restrained by what we can see in the scripture and we're not going beyond that.
And these are the guys who are writing scripture, instructing the church not to just build on novel interpretations, but the foundation that's been laid by Christ. Um I think that there is an expectation uh in the New Testament for believers to function under the normative means of grace that have been established by Jesus and the apostles and to say this is the formative way that you approach God through word, through prayer, through evangelism. If anyone who watched this program said prayer is wrong, they weren't listening. Um what I would say is nowhere in the Bible do we see Jesus, do do we see the apostles, do we see the prophets going throughout a region and engaging with principalities and powers?
Uh and in fact, we see in the book of Job, there are spirits that God explicitly says, you don't have the authority to deal with this. Now, some will argue that some of those beings in the book of Job are myths, which is fair, but I'm going to argue that this is probably a spiritual entity of some kind, which my NAR brothers and sisters would wholeheartedly agree with. And God says, look, you're not to you're not to deal with this. Only I can deal with this. We we see this in the book of Revelation. How do they overcome Satan from the heavens? By preaching the gospel, overcoming by the blood of the lamb and the word of their testimony.
They proclaim the good news in in Luke. They're proclaiming the good news. What happens in those accounts? Satan falls like lightning in Luke 10. So, do I think that we should do spiritual warfare? Absolutely. That's preaching the gospel. Should I think we should be praying without ceasing? Big fan, huge. I want to pray in tongues more than all of you. Like big fan. I want to do that. But the idea that we are to engage in prayer in this kind of gnostic, mystical sort of way because it works, that's bad because it opens the door for all kinds of things. People will say, necromancy is cool because, you know, it works.
I don't think Saul would make that argument. I got I got some good advice from my great grandpappy. So, necromancy works. Right? So, yeah, just cuz it's works doesn't mean it's good. I mean the Python spirit, it worked. She got fortunes, not good. Acts chapter 16. So, I also I over steel manned this. I don't know if you guys noticed, but I said, you know, we just pray against the principalities, but that's actually not what they do. They bind them and cast them down. So, they'll spend like hours long. They call it intercession and they call it prayer. Like that's how they'll talk about it. But what they actually do is they try to perform an exorcism over a region with a territorial spirit.
I believe territorial spirits are real. Daniel chapter 10, you have the prince of Persia and the prince of Greece. Uh and the Greek word used like for the Greek translation of that when you apply it in the New Testament describes uh like you know Satan is the ruler of this age like same kind of word. So uh I definitely believe those are demonic spirits and they're set in contrast to Michael and probably Gabriel but at least another heavenly being. So they're definitely demonic territorial spirits. Almost everyone agrees on that. So I believe they're a real thing but what we don't see Daniel doing is being like prince of Persia I cast you down in the name of Jesus.
In fact the whole spiritual battle is influenced because Daniel's praying about other other things. He's praying and mourning and fasting about Israel's spiritual and physical condition and he's grieved by it. So he's interceding for his people and that's what's influencing. So it's like we do have a model of exorcisms in the New Testament over individuals. We have absolutely no model for exercising a territorial spirit. And what this does is it represents a broader problem within NAR and and that is a a willingness to find things in the texts that aren't there. And Daniel 10 is is kind of a mysterious and honestly fascinating text and it has become rife with it's like almost charismatic conspiracy theory to the degree that to which we theorize on these things because where Peter Wagner would talk about territorial spirits Robert Henderson gets his marching orders from Daniel 10 or at least he claims to because he says ah see Daniel's prayer wasn't answered because uh Gabriel was or the angel was being held up by the prince of Persia and the prince of Greece and so you know they had a legal right to be there and so you have to remove that legal right and you'll get more answer to prayer and the subtitle of his book is granting God the legal right to fulfill his passion and answer your prayers.
Literally his theology is your sovereign and not God. It's right there in the subtitle of the book. That's how far the slippery slope goes. That's how uh far this trajectory extends, and it's extremely concerning. And what we don't see there in Daniel chapter 10 is we we don't see Daniel casting down some kind of or or identifying some kind of legal right by visualizing a New Age practice, himself entering into the courts of heaven so-called and hearing all these various voices so he can figure out exactly what the problem is and deal with it and get the answer to his prayer. No, like the Prince of Persia is going to dominate and keep the nation or the empire of Persia in power for the next two centuries.
Like he's going to be there. And he's going to outlast Daniel at least in terms of like Daniel's physical life. So it doesn't follow the arguments that they make out of this. And so that is our concern is it becomes a hermeneutic, a way of interpreting the scripture that leads to wild and insane practices that border on heresy and sometimes are heresy. So that would be our concern. Guys uh we're probably at the point of closing arguments. Is there anything else whether you want to comment on my what I just said or anything else that you guys want to say to kind of close this out? I mean I wrote these show notes just for the sole purpose of the two groups out there.
One group that's calling everything NAR that's not and another group that um refuses to acknowledge the NAR exist. To just to say there is a good logical category of New Apostolic Reformation that comes from a founder who has discipled thousands and thousands of people who are in leadership of churches today and they hold this framework. That framework is going to get people hurt. Please I hope that this helps people identify that they are inside of that ecosystem and to run. Then the other group to say hey chill, stop crying wolf because you're making it less effective when others are out there saying and I'm not saying don't use the word NAR, don't don't call people out for being NAR.
I'm just saying when you do it, do it correctly because people become numb to it, um because someone believes in prophecy, they're part of the new apostolic reformation. It's kind of like what happened with very popular uh heresy hunters who want to go after the word of faith. Everything's word of faith. Um well, when everything's word of faith, nothing is. You've got to have a categorical distinction for these sorts of subjects and say, hey, you know, if I call Michael Brown Tree word of faith because, you know, he believes speaking in tongues uh allows him to the spirit to pray through him, I go, well, that's not word of faith.
That's just what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 14. So like we need to we need to calm down with a lot of this language. One of the things that was said I love I love Jordan Cooper. I love the work that he's been doing recently. Uh I think he asked someone a question about like apostles, like um you know, ask your teachers if there's apostles today. I asked my guys, but they they said, yeah, there's apostles, but not like the 12. And then when I looked at their work, turns out they did believe in apostles like the 12. Because people can kind of snake around that language, if you're a part of a movement and you don't know if it's NAR or not, I think a great question would be, do we believe that there is spiritual blessing when we submit ourselves to apostles and prophets?
That would be a great question to ask. And if the answer to that is yes, it certainly means that at least there's a move toward the new apostolic reformation. I think that is some of the foundations for this whole movement's belief systems. Yeah, and and will I lose my blessing if I critique them in any way? There you go. There you go. Miller? do you have any thoughts? Uh I mean, I think the biggest detriment to this whole movement that I experienced is that people that there there is no way to hold that person accountable. And eventually everybody, whether they be a leader or a member, um become a cog in a system.
And so, you know, one of the ways that and I don't I think the NAR is one branch of CEOism. Uh it's one branch of pragmatism where the means are not justified uh eventually. Um but one of the symptoms that I see is common, not just with NAR, but CEOism, uh church, churches that now look more like a corporation than they do an an organization that's meant to care for those within the community, is there's a bigger vision than the people within the community. When your vision makes people expendable, um and those people are now there to serve this big purpose, um I I just I go I think you're building something else.
Um I'm I'm I I don't know if I'm flushing this out well, but I I don't think it just exists within the NAR. Um and I'm probably again just getting into the main reason for why this is this whole thing is important to me cuz I I worry about those who are told to die in a particular soil or who are told like, hey, we we're accomplishing this great thing for God, but in the midst of it, you just feel like you have no actual voice and no actual part to play. Um but you're just simply a means for someone else's ends. Uh and I worry about that. And I worry about the damage it does cuz I I find that all too many people end up denying Christ and denying the church as a whole because of their bad experience in these systems.
And so NAR is just I think one more flavor of uh a toxic system that is actually contrary to Christ's vision for the church. Yep. Praise God. That's good. Guys, thank you so much for tuning in this episode. We'll see you next time, Monday and Wednesday from 4:00 to 5:00 p.m. Central Standard Time. Peace out.