Transcript
You've heard a lot about the CBA negotiation in Major League Baseball. Let's talk about it. As you may have seen, Major League Baseball recently released a fiveinute video on social platforms explaining their salary cap proposal and all of the reasons they believe that it is necessary at this point. I took interest in this video. So today I'm going to go through it point by point and give you the reasoning why I think the things you're saying are either true, false, or possibly misrepresented. And as we all know, I am a player or was a player. And so I have a certain level of bias. I was on one of these sides.
That said, I'm going to do my best to be as objective and as unbiased as humanly possible. It's going to be hard. I am human, but I just want you to know that I'm trying my best. So, let's get right into it. This is Major League Baseball's salary cap proposal explained and fact checked. Major League Baseball's case for a salary cap. One thing I want to make sure we pay attention to as we move through this because there has been a lot of back and forth on the merits, and I will touch on some of that stuff uh as we go, whether or not the the things being said are actually important and and whether or not there's better ways to do it.
But what I want to really point out are the tactics being used here because I feel like that is the most important thing. A lot of times the tactics are the area that I have the biggest problem with, not actually what's being said. Here we go. Video opens by introducing us to Rob Manfred's right-hand man. Get used to this man's face cuz it's very likely that he becomes the commissioner when uh Rob moves on. This is also noticeable because frankly Rob doesn't have the greatest track record of speaking publicly. Morgan is much better at that. So, you're going to notice how well he communicates the message uh no matter how ambiguous that message can be at times.
We've spent the last couple of years making changes to the game based on fan feedback. So, the first point being made is we listened to the fans. we want to direct this towards the fans and we are trying to show them that they are the people that we are thinking about when we are making these decisions. He makes that case by talking about the pitch clock that was instituted in 2023 and the ABS that was instituted this year in 2026. As we know um both of these things in my opinion have been resounding success. I think it's up in the air whether or not they were fully fans, you know, idea and they were pushing so hard for they had no choice.
You know, as we know, the pitch clock shortens games. It fits games into a threehour window, which broadcasters really like. It's more predictable. So, pitch clock good. It's okay if both benefits happen. But to act like that's the only reason the games need to be shorter cuz the fans wanted it, not quite. That one was clamored for for the fans. I think them uh getting this done was a good idea, but also it shortens the games, too. So, there's some added benefits, but I I do will give them this that very likely was brought on by fans. He then goes on to point out the fans biggest gripes with baseball right now.
That is fairness, competitive balance, and blackouts. The ability to watch your team in the region that you live if you don't have the TV package or are paying for the distributors, uh however, however they're giving it to you, right? People hate Blackouts. They hate not being able to watch the their own team, but they can go on the app and watch other teams. That kind of defeats the purpose. And it's been a a point of frustration, especially with the number of streaming platforms there are now. So, they would love a one-stop shop. I think everyone would in every sport, but yes, that is a very big thing for baseball.
So, we're going to start from these are the two problems that we are solving. Let's find out if the proposed solutions solve them, shall we? In order to do that though, we have to find out how we got here. So, let's find out how we got here. According to Morgan Sword, payroll disparity, the biggest problem facing baseball, a point that I mostly agree with and I think needs to have uh something done to address it 100%. We have uh payroll disparity. The first thing they say is that big market teams have a huge amount of payroll or spend a lot more money than small market teams. Unfortunately, Morgan never defines a small market or a large market.
And I find that odd because it's hard to determine whether or not the rest of the arguments make sense or are true, especially when you're using hard data and numbers when we don't know what teams are being included into the buckets that you're talking about. You're going to notice this and it's going to come up a couple more times. just you wait that we never ever find out what those two things are definitively so that we can draw some accurate conclusions and in a couple cases we just full-on contradict ourselves. The big one they give which surprises absolutely nobody the biggest difference between the highest payroll and the lowest payroll or spending spending and payroll are a little bit different.
So let's say spending is seen here as $446 million. It doesn't say which team was the highest, which team was lowest, what year this is from. None of that exists. Judging by the context, this is 2025. This is the Dodgers being the top team, and this is the Marlins being the bottom team. But there is one key interesting thing happening here that is not disclosed, which is tactic number one, which I do not appreciate, and I think that it is obtuse on purpose, so I hate it. If you are anything like me, it's likely you don't sleep enough. Look, things get crazy. So, the least you could do is have the right bed to recharge you at night and have you ready to tackle the day.
That's where today's sponsor, Brooklyn Bedding, comes in. Brooklyn Bedding has been assembling top tier mattresses since 1995. That is a long track record of quality. Since switching to my own Brooklyn bedding mattress, I have noticed that I have been waking up more energized and more ready to get things done, which is big for me right now. I love a soft bed. Brooklyn Bedding has definitely delivered that. Choosing a mattress is a big decision. Brooklyn Bedding gets that. That's why they have a 365day trial night period, free returns, and a limited lifetime warranty. And shipping, you ask? That's also free for us customers.
So, just make your order and it will show up at your door. So, if you're looking to upgrade your sleep, head over to bricklandbedding.com/trevorme and use code trevorme for 30% off of your order at checkout. Thank you to Brooklyn Betting for sponsoring this video. Now, let's get back to the salary cap. The luxury tax payment that the Dodgers paid in 2025 was $169 million. And what they did was they included that into the spend to try to give the impression that it's payroll when in reality it's a fee that is paid into a revenue share for the rest of the league. So of that $169 million, zero of it is going to any player on their team outside of player benefits like pensions and things.
They have to pay pensions. It's a big pool of money. They have to pay for meal money. You know, all of these things, workers comp, like all of these things are in that pool. So, a portion of it goes there, but then the other portion goes to a revenue share with all the other teams, teams that don't receive as much money from their local TV networks currently. Of that 169, at least a couple dozen million dollars went to small market teams. So, to say that that is part of their disparity is disingenuous, but it does make it look worse, which might have been the point. Make of that what you will.
So, like I said, there was no source given, but it's probably the Dodgers and the Marlins, and that number is obviously bad. I agree that is bad. So, according to Morgan, it had been over a decade since a small market team won the World Series. Again, we don't know what a small market team is, and it is not defined again here. And the point was the Brewers are a small market team. The Brewers are 18th in payroll. Let's say they're the top. So the bottom 12 teams are small market teams. Let's take that logic over here and say, well, since we don't know what a small market team is, we can assume that in 2017 when the Houston Astros won the World Series, cheating non-withstanding, they had the 17th highest payroll.
As you can see here, according to Spot Track, 18th payroll is a small market or let's let's say market meaning the city that you live in. We're going to talk about what the difference between the market and the payroll is because just because they're 17 in payroll doesn't mean they're small market. But then that exposes another problem. Why is a team that is in one of the, you know, six biggest cities in the United States of America 17th in payroll? There's another question we should probably ask. We got to use Milwaukee being 18th because Milwaukee is a small market in terms of number of people that you can get money from.
It's also unclear when we're talking about payroll and when we are talking about market size because they are not one to one. We're going to be trying to figure out which one we mean the whole video as well. A lot of confusion happening. I don't know if you can pick up on that. Hey guys, editor Trevor here. There's two more things that I need you to keep in your mind as you move through the rest of this video. One, the idea that fan opinion doesn't matter about this whole situation is just not true. You absolutely do matter. If you do not like baseball and this gives you a bad taste in your mouth, that's a big problem.
And you should have power. You are the third party in this whole equation that is affected by it. You spend your hard-earned money on it. You give it your attention, which as we know is maybe the most valuable currency these days. You do matter and how you feel about it does matter. And number two, though I am hitting on a lot of these tactics and pushing back on the things said, trust is what I'm looking for here. It's important that you also have alternate solutions to the problem. Cuz right now, you are being given a solution. It's a bad solution in my opinion. I don't think it's grounded in anything other than additional money and manipulation opportunities in the future, but it is a solution.
So the next step is to get alternate solutions. In the comments, let me know anything that you believe could move us in the direction of getting more stars to be on more teams, giving all 30 teams the opportunity to sign some of the best talent so that there's more fun to be had for every fan base. Maybe it's a deferment thing. Maybe it's uh an update to the luxury tax where it's not just monetarily related. I want to know what you think because you do matter and we do need to figure this thing out because at the end of the day we all just want baseball. Okay, get back into it. Let's go over a kind of big claim that Morgan does kind of offhand.
I'll be honest, it's a little bit offhand. He says, quote, MLB has the widest payroll gap in sports, and it's not even close. We're going to go down a little bit of a selective data rabbit hole so I can show you the type of strategy you can employ if that is your prerogative. I can't help but notice that the word American doesn't come before sports. We're talking about all sports evidently. You got to be specific if you want to be specific. Even if he did mean in American sports, yeah, like that's obvious. All the other sports have salary caps. So like of course there's a small it's a smaller or a bigger gap.
That doesn't mean anything. That just means it exists. You like you you need to make the case that it's bad. Not that we're not just going to assume that it is bad. You know what I mean? There's a lot of things that we need to assume. We're playing off these assumptions that aren't really based in fact. They just feel true. So if he meant American sports, yeah, that like no, this is kind of just the everyone else is doing it argument all over again. But then what if he meant all sports in general, not just American sports? Have you heard of the Premier League? Now, we know Manchester City was cheating and doing a lot of crazy stuff, but even with the sanctions and even at a normalized payroll, they are still 5x what Coventry City is.
Like, no matter what they do, they're like these guys drop 50 million, they're still 4 1/2x of them. Like, it's not going to be even ever because they are uncapped as well. According to uh all the estimates I could find, the gap here is anywhere from 220 uh to 250 million pounds. That's 290 million to 330 million. Morgan said payroll. Remember, biggest payroll gap in sports. He didn't say spending. So, we can actually remove that luxury tax from the Dodgers because that is not payroll. It's associated with payroll, but it isn't payroll itself. Let's take the 515 million which the Dodgers had uh spent that year total and subtract 169 million which is $346 million.
That's their actual payroll. Let's subtract that's the Dodgers that is uh 68 million which is what the Marlins had that year and say that the gap is actually $278 million. If their gap is 290 million that is the Premier League at the lowest and MLB is 278 that is less. So, it's not the biggest gap and it's not by far. So, that's not quite a true statement. What did I just do there? I made a dumb selective argument. He is right. There is a huge gap, but I can make the same case for another league and we're just kind of spinning our wheels. It doesn't prove anything or move us in any direction. It's just wanting me to assume that that bad need to lower by any means necessary.
We still at this point haven't been told why it is bad. So, let's go do that. Now, back in the early 2000s, we implemented a luxury tax aimed at trying to solve this problem. But unfortunately, in the last couple of decades, it's only gotten worse. So, we're going to go to ratios. Now, I want to point out another tactic here. Ratios are important to notice just like percentages. That number being higher depends on the denominator. the the number on the bottom that is being divided by in this case the lower salary number. The lower salary number is what raises the higher number most effectively.
If you lower the bottom number uh cut it in half, it's going to double the high number. So the high number is going to go up a lot. So one number is getting a lot bigger with the other one getting a little bit smaller. It's very convenient if that higher number going up is beneficial to your argument. So just something to notice ratio of top five uh to bottom five payroll it was 3.2 and 95 to 96 and it's 4.7 and 2526 that going up is something to address. We agree that the discrepancy the the difference between these teams widening is a problem that is not up for debate. If you ask players straight up without you know the salary cap being put in if they agree they would say yeah these gaps getting bigger and bigger and bigger makes it so I am incentivized to go only to one or two places too and I don't want to do that I want to play near home and like we we we want to do other stuff it's not literally always about the absolute top money we can get it's always weighed around what's best for our families where we want to live being close to home our parents seeing us all kinds of stuff that weighs in it does if you can give us options where all 30 teams are on on the table I think players would appreciate that and enjoy it.
They would and I I can say from my experience I definitely would have I definitely would have loved that gaps are are uh uh growing but again small markets which we still don't know the definition of not raising their payroll as nearly as fast as the top are raising them is going to increase that as well. So again that lower number not increasing very fast but the top one increasing at a higher rate comparatively is going to raise that high number which is worse looking. So then we kind of make our conclusion here. If we are Major League Baseball, this shouldn't be something that happens only once a decade.
And that is that a small market team, which we still do not know what a small market team is, wins the World Series. We need a small market team to win World Series more than once a decade according to Morgan Sword. A very easy thing to agree with. There's a lot of easy things to agree with in this video. Another very, very effective tactic when you are trying to make an argument. But again, I have a question. Why is the 18th in payroll? Brewers considered a small market team, but the Astros are not a seven uh are not 17th in payroll. We're talking about market size, not payroll. But we've switched back and forth and kind of use them interchangeably.
And they are not. Astros have a very big market size. So when it is convenient, we say the Astros don't count because they have a big big city. Even though we're talking about payrolls being the problem, is the payroll the problem or is it the market size the problem? cuz they need to be executed differently or they need to be talked about differently cuz they're separate. Again, purposely confusing in my opinion. So then we move on again from the uh market size to the payroll, but these both have the biggest markets as well. So now it's confusing again. The case is made that Los Angeles and uh New York have spent more money than the other 28 teams.
Not combined, just more than they're the they're one and two in the list. more than the other 28 teams. It's worded in a way that maybe you can start to assume that maybe it means combined. That's not true. It's not combined. It's just individually they're one and two on the list. Since 1998, uh the bottom payroll average wins is 74 and since 1998 top payroll averages wins is 89. 15 game swing one way or the other is only about 10% of games in a 162g game season. That's a 10% swing. That's a 10% effect. You're telling me that 10% is the effect of payroll? That's not very high. It's something, but it's not everything.
There's another thing to notice here. We selectively chose 1998 as our starting year because what happened starting in 1998, the Yankees won three in a row and then lost the fourth one. So, it was the last time there was a three repeat where the Yankees dominated. So now that is the beginning of our uh time period that we're talking about because it's the best example if you if you cut it off before that of everything that was just said again. So we also see these time periods we're talking about a decade then we're talking about 28 years then we're talking about since 2000 then we're talking about 1998 again.
What are we trying uh to say here other than look at these two teams that both won backtoback World Series in this very specific time period. Isn't that so bad? Now, there are 12 teams in the postseason. 89 wins is a guaranteed playoff spot and 74 wins is only seven wins off of a playoff spot. Even the bottom five teams are within seven games of a playoff spot on average. Sounds pretty competitive to me. Now, if this were 100 and this were 60, we'd we'd have something to talk about here. Not saying it's not a problem. There is a problem. But is the correlation between money and wins very big? No, it's not very big.
It is part of it, but it is far from the most important variable in the equation. And according to uh an article done by Enoseris for the uh The Athletic and the New York Times, the link is real but weaker than implied. Payroll explains 8 to 17% of single season win variance. Sustain success over time is true. like you consistently are winning 8 to 17% more games if you spend a lot of money. But on any given year, you can make up for that that discrepancy in a bunch of ways. Uh as we just saw and as we see pretty regularly, it could but it could be adjusted a little bit more. It could be I think there is a little bit of tweaking to do.
There are some knobs to turn and get this thing done. They are correct in saying that this is a a problem to be addressed, but I am debating whether or not it is as big of a problem as they are making it seem. The Dodgers haven't had a losing season since 2010. The Yankees since 1992. We're talking about uh the Yankees not having a losing season since '92 and the Dodgers not having a season uh a losing season since uh 2010. If you really take that at face value, are we saying that they need to lose more? Are we saying that we need more losing seasons from them? Are we saying that they it's not possible for them to have a losing season because they spend lots of money?
That's a good argument to be made. I don't know if that's exactly what's being said, but this seems not like an argument for bringing up the people who don't have the resources, which is an argument also being made here, the small market teams per se, to have the opportunity to win more games. This is more of an argument that these these teams, if it were e even, would lose more. We can't just help the smart markets improve. We need the big markets to also be worse. He wants an emotional response here, right? This is the tactic. The emotional response is must be nice, right? Favorite f Pirates fans, they make the playoffs all the time.
Must be nice. They want you to be like, "Yeah, I don't like that." Which fair, fair, you shouldn't like it. But again, the proposed solutions here, we have to ask ourselves, are they going to produce an outcome that allows Pirate fans to feel that as well or maybe for those two teams to not lo win as much or be as quote unquote dominant? Over the last decade, teams from large markets represent 64% of the teams in the postseason, 75% of the teams that advanced to the LCS. Again, here we go. We're going percentage of teams, not not raw numbers, percentages, because percentages feel higher. 64% of the teams from large markets represent.
I thought large markets are going to have a little bit of an advantage because they do have more money. There being more money isn't a factor, but that's kind of something we also need to happen, right? They should be winning that much. Investing into your team should produce better results. like we we're not talking about removing those two things from each other, right? We're not that's not being proposed here. So, there's going to be some of this. And frankly, I don't know if 64% is not close to the balance. Maybe it's 60/40. Who knows? But there is going to be an advantage because you're supposed to spend money on your teams.
You're supposed to spend money on a business in order for that business to be successful. That's what businesses are. That's what businesses are supposed to do. So, this number is going to have to be over 50%. Or else something's broken the other way. And then 90% of teams from large markets represent 90% of World Series champions over the last 10 years, which is nine out of 10. So 90% sounds much more than nine. And then also, what's a large market? Who are the large market teams? Who are we talking about? I can go look at the list and like guess. And I think that's what he wants me to do. What's a large market team, Morgan?
What is it? Which ones are you talking about when you say that? That would be helpful. One other advantage to having a higher payroll is a margin for error. You can have a top player or multiple players go down with injury and you're going to be okay. But in the smallest markets, they lose those big stars, that could mean the end of your season. True. Absolutely true. I'm going to tip my cap to that one. That is uh that is a benefit of being able to afford more players. However, we've only just made it so that those players can't go to those cities. That doesn't mean they're not going to uh just group up other places.
I believe there are better ways to incentivize players spreading around the league uh the best players anyways than just capping pay. There's there's a lot of ways to do it. But I do agree having more of the better players that are tend to be paid more do hedge against injuries and that is a advantage. That absolutely is an advantage not only in baseball any sport. So that leads us to the proposal. One of the greatest movies of all time. Uh that's a lie. So what are they proposing? The first part of the proposal is a 50/50 revenue split. It's presented as a uh a split that will actually get more money to players than they are already getting.
But unfortunately, that's a misrepresentation as well. And this is one of the biggest lies by omission that I've seen so far. And I I feel very strongly about calling out. One thing we need to know before we do it is the definition of revenue. Revenue is the total amount of money a business brings in from selling its goods or services before any cost or expenses are subtracted before any cost or expenses are subtracted. That is the uh important phrase here. It's al often called the top line. So what the league is talking about here is not the top line. They are talking about revenues that they establish revenue streams.
If they just say a bunch of different revenue streams, then we can just call everything revenues. But in reality, it's profit. It's profit sharing. But they don't like using the word profit because remember, these teams aren't supposed to be profitable. This is according to reporting by Evan Drellic in the Athletic. MLB could take up to 17% of local revenues of the top off the top uh plus 20 22% of national revenues. Plus, some areas would have no expense cap such as construction and renovation costs for ballparks. I'm sure that won't be abused. uh including spring training facilities. Uh the league run TV station network would have no deduction limit either.
They can just deduct whenever they want and for 27 and 28 neither would cost any team's local broadcast. The league also wants unlimited deductions for what it broadly ter uh termed new ventures which has no definition too. That's not a 50/50 split. That is whatever they want to include into the pool that is then cut 50/50. uh but they want to exclude a very large portion of the total from the number that can be considered revenue even though revenue is the total number. That is what revenue is. So we're using a word that doesn't mean the thing that you're talking about. That is misinformation.
This is from the actual web website uh from MLB level the playing field how it works. And in this 50/50 splitter revenue there is no mention of any of these deductions. It's only uh only the ways everything's going to go up and the the similarities between all the other leagues NFL and NHL and NBA all of which have all these carveouts as well. So the the number you hear reported in Forbes is not the money percentage they're getting of they're not getting a percentage of that. They're getting a percentage of a much smaller number that has been determined by a bunch of collective bargaining and carveouts which is the same thing that Major League Baseball wants here too.
That is very important to notice and it's very frustrating when I see it not talked about very much. But again, I'm being unbiased. I've not done a good job of that so far in this video. Second, we implement a salary cap and a salary floor that will regulate what each team can spend on its team. Salary cap. They say it will bring eight teams lower in spending and 12 teams higher in spending. Remember, we're we got another one of these this number higher than that number. They also say that the total number will change, but again, they can't guarantee that because they don't know what all the carveouts are they're going to do for the revenue.
They're doing it based on the big number. The number they're using is not the number they would use to calculate revenue share. And then their final proposal is all media revenues will be shared equally. They could literally do revenue sharing amongst the teams at any time. Salary cap has nothing to do with this. They could just do this. This could just happen at any time. The players literally be like, "Okay, great job, guys." They could make it so everyone has the exact same amount of money if they want. Heck, we don't even have to have a range. Why don't just make every team spend $200 million flat?
Why? Why don't we do that? because we do want some sort of competitive advantage. So they are proposing revenue sharing amongst the teams attached to this deal which they could have done any time in the past. They could do this on their own. They could do it right this minute. But they want it to be a a thing that they're giving even though it's something that they want. Let's recap here. They want to reduce revenue disparity, address the blackouts by doing revenue sharing and then bringing everyone under the same broadcast deal for Major League Baseball. Basically, they would nationalize uh amongst all the teams the broadcast rights and then there would be a single subscription which would eliminate blackouts.
They would be able to set the price at whatever they want to set it and you would probably uh have to figure out a way to get just your team. That's a good thing in my opinion if they're able to do that and do it affordably. That said, they could do the revenue sharing anytime. So, they could do the blackouts. They could get rid of them without a salary cap. The blackouts have nothing to do with the salary cap or their proposal at all. It's being lumped in because they want you to think that, but it can be done without the seller cap. They are not linked at all. Players total pay increases. That is just false.
He has no idea if that's true. We have no idea if that's true because we don't know what the carvouts are and we don't know what New Ventures is. That number could be anything. Also, in that revenue share, the uh amateur draft money is included. So the money that you're able to spend in the draft, the teams are going to spend on drafting their own players, that is going to be part of the revenue, that 50% that the players get too. So it's going to take away that much more. That'll be deducted and that's about $500 million every year. And then player benefits is also included as a uh part of revenues, even though that has been collective bargained separately to salaries this whole time.
Now, it's suddenly going to be attached to salaries. So those two numbers combined are about a billion dollars in a in a league that made 12 total. So that's, you know, 9% off the top right out of the gate. The fans get a competitive game. Uh we do not know how things are more competitive at all. This video does not explain how competitive comes in. Like it's just going to be teams raising payroll. Teams the teams that are really trying hard can't try quite as hard. And so now everyone's closer together in money. So that 10% discrepancy kind of goes down and then everyone's mindset and their intentions for running their team are exactly the same.
Nothing changed. There's no way to know that either. Two things that are said with with the whole chest that aren't necessarily true and there's no way to tell. And then finally, we get to their final bit of evidence that this is the way to go. And that is the polls. Now, I talked about this last week on my Mayplaining podcast, but I'm going to talk about it again. We have 79% of baseball fans support a salary cap and floor source Morning Consult November 2025. I went and I checked that uh place for the poll morning consult. It does exist. It is a short article that surveyed 2200 people and it breaks down as such.
MLV fans support a salary cap strongly support is 59%. It's actually avid MLB fans that somewhat support and strongly support. The graphic says 79% of fans. That's misrepresented. It's avid MLB fans. We do not know according to this data how many of those 220 US adults were considered avid fans. It could have been 100 people. It could have been five people. Couldn't have been five people. The math doesn't uh even out, but you know what I mean. It's not all 2200. How how big is this subset of people and why is that not being represented on the graphic putting being put foot put forward? You if you notice one thing that is the most advantageous numbers when the other numbers on here are are saying a pattern 59% is a majority uh 69% on the other side of casual MLB fans and all respondents like these are real numbers.
They are important, but to only use the avid MLB fan subset of the small subset that was the total people pulled as your proof is uh disingenuous at best. Even from this data, I would say it still holds up pretty well. But they they even though it did say 59%. Some for some reason we're not using the more accurate number. We're using the other more advantageous number. It's like being that kid that wins a race by five feet and telling everyone you won it by 100. Like, why not just say you won? I think we know why. Some other issues I generally have with polls and I try to verify is how the questions are worded.
We don't know. It doesn't say anywhere in the article what how they ask the question. If they said salary cap and floor system, if they go, "Would you be in favor of a floor in parenthesis if it had a cap?" How do they how do they ask the question? Also, this company, Morning Consult, is a for-profit company that is often paid to run polls. It's possible that the poll was commissioned by Major League Baseball, but there is no evidence at this time to support that. Make of that what you will. Again, that's me right there trying to convince you that there could have been foul play here. Not a cool thing to do.
I am admitting that because I'm trying to use and illustrate the tactics of play here. All the other major US sports have implemented both a cap and a floor. And the reason is they go together. We want to have a floor and with that comes the cap. Yes, it has historically done that. Is that something that has to happen? Is it for fairness? Well, there's an argument to be made for fairness. It is not a foregone conclusion. It never has been and never will be because it's human beings and we make the decisions. So, I reject the premise that because something has been normalized and that a lot of other people have done it does not make it the best way to do things.
Not a law of nature. It's just a thing that you say. And then the last little tidbit is that players will make more money in the new system. a million dollars proposed minimum salary. That does not mean that players overall will make more money. That means a a lot of the young players who are at the bottom of the earning totem pole who MLB is hoping to speak to directly here will make some more money so that we can entice a group to split away from the leadership. But it is worth noting the minimum salary has gone up every CBA negotiation that uh I could uh find. um especially every single one under Rob Manfred.
This is a foregone conclusion. This is a small little uh nugget given to players in order for owners to move other things in. For example, the luxury tax system that they thought would benefit them uh and then ended up not benefiting them. This is it moving with the league. This is how this should work. It's like minimum wage in real life. It should move with the industry. That should just go up. Like this shouldn't be a this should be a thing that already happens and it does. So this isn't special. This isn't new. So, in conclusion, misrepresenting data and presenting opinions as truth are not characteristics of an organization that's negotiating in good faith.
This is something that's bothered me a lot because I watch, I listen, and then I see that it's not fully being explained the way that it should be if it were being done in fully good faith. And so then we have to wade through like some disingenuousness to get to the root of the problem. And that usually takes a long time. I know this is naive or I know this is too much to ask, but just say the thing that you want with your chest. If you did that, I would have respect for it and then we can argue on the merits. Just say it with your chest. Just say it and we'll be good. So, how'd I do? Was I unbiased?
I wasn't, was I? I think that that's never going to happen. At the end of the day, I want all teams to be able to compete. I want all teams to be able to sign players that want to play there and then pay them the wage that they deserve. And if that means there are some restrictions here or there around the circle to smooth out the edges of what this relationship looks like in order to make those things possible, I think that uh the players would be on board with that. We need to see what options there are outside of this option. That's all I have to say on that matter. That's a lie. I have tons to say on it and I'm probably going to keep saying stuff on it, but let me know down in the comments.
Do you agree? Do you not agree? What are your thoughts? What can we do both of the sides to make this just a better experience for all fans, not just some? And with that, that's all I got. This has been another edition of Baseball Explained. Drink your water, enjoy your baseball, and I'll see you next time on the Trevor May Baseball Channel. Hey.